You are on page 1of 6

SSPC-PA Guide 11

August 1, 2008

SSPC: The Society for Protective Coatings

Paint Application Guide No. 11


Protecting Edges, Crevices, and Irregular Steel Surfaces by Stripe Coating

1. Scope given area. The option of choice is usually determined by the


best cost/benefit ratio. Factors that enter into the cost/benefit
This guide discusses the technique called “stripe coating” analysis of edge protection include the severity of the exposure
or “striping” as a way of providing extra corrosion protection environment, interference with production during maintenance,
measures on edges, outside corners, crevices, bolt heads, and difficulty in accessing the structure to perform maintenance
welds, and other irregular steel surfaces, including optional painting. These factors are unique to each project.
surface preparation techniques for sharp edges to improve
coating performance. Some details, including the advantages 2.4 Sharp edges may be avoided at the prefabrication
and limitations of specific methods of obtaining additional stage or remedied by grinding after construction, but at a much
coating thickness, are described to assist the specification higher cost. When filing edges, care should be taken to assure
writer in assuring that the project specification will address that additional sharp edges are not created while modifying the
adequate corrosion protection. original edge. It is generally much less expensive and easier
to grind or chamfer edges in the shop than in the field.
2. Background
2.5 Additional coating thickness can be obtained by
2.1 Sharp edges, outside corners, crevices, and welds applying an extra layer of coating to the areas requiring addi-
are often sites where coating failures and corrosion begin due tional protection (the “stripe coat”). In some cases, the “stripe
to reduced coating barrier protection (see Figure 1). Reduced coat” may be followed by the application of a full coat of a
coating thickness on these surfaces can be a result of applica- coating with edge retention properties.
tion of inadequate amounts of coating, but the surface tension
of the wet coating or coating shrinkage during the drying/curing 3. Preparing Outside Corners and Sharp
process can also pull the film away from edges. Sharp edges Edges
resulting from cutting, burning, and shearing are especially
difficult to coat adequately. Bolt threads combine the adverse 3.1 Outside corners and sharp edges can be ground such
effects of sharp edges and crevices. that the edge is rounded to a 1.6 to 3.2 mm (1/16 to 1/8 inch)
radius. An alternative to rounding is to chamfer the edge to a
2.2 The solutions to this problem include (1) eliminating specified measurement, so instead of one 90-degree corner,
the irregularities by grinding, mechanical sanding, or filing; there are two 135-degree corners (see Figure 2). The width of the
(2) applying a thicker protective coating film to problem areas flat ground area, i.e. the distance between the two 135-degree
such as outside edges, pitted areas, and bolts; (3) applying a corners, is usually 1.6 to 3.2 mm (1/16 to 1/8 inch). Paint will
penetrating and/or good wetting coating to crevice areas and/ not pull away from a 135-degree corner as much as from a
or inside corners; or a combination of (1) and (2). In some 90-degree corner, resulting in more overall coating thickness.
cases, both grinding and stripe coating may be specified for a Further, subsequent abrasive blast cleaning provides some
radius to the 135-degree corners.

Coating

Chamfer
Poor Ideal

90 °
135 °

Figure 1. Schematic showing how coating Figure 2. Chamfering reduces a sharp 90° corner to
thickness is reduced at a sharp edge. two 135° corners.

1
SSPC- PA Guide 11
August 1, 2008

3.2 The increased performance resulting from rounding particular project. Sometimes only specified areas of outside
or chamfering edges depends on the service environment, the corners, edges, welds, and crevices are striped. Situations
generic type of coating and on the radius or size of the chamfer. where stripe coating is usually warranted are:
One research study1 showed that rounding or chamfering had
no measurable effect if an ethyl silicate inorganic zinc-rich • Immersion service (e.g., interiors of fuel or water
(IOZ) coating was applied over blast cleaned steel. Therefore, storage tanks; ship hulls)
there is no need to go to the added expense of grinding edges • Areas with high corrosion rates (e.g. cooling towers
if ethyl silicate IOZ coating is specified. However, the same and splash zones)
study indicated that rounding or chamfering edges before • Areas where access is difficult (e.g., towers, some
application of an alkyd or organic zinc-rich primer improved bridges).
the coating’s performance. Even with edge rounding or cham- • Built up members (e.g., lattice bars and boxes)
fering, it is necessary that proper spray application techniques
be used.2,3 The use of coatings with edge-retention properties Situations where stripe coating may not be cost effective
(see Section 4.7.3) may also minimize or eliminate the need are:
for edge grinding. • Non-critical components (e.g., interior wall in living
space on a ship)
3.3 Edge grinding is best done in the shop before blast • Mild exposure (e.g., SSPC environmental exposure
cleaning where the work is accessible. A sample statement zones 1A and 1B(1),5
in a specification may read, “All corners and edges shall be • Inside corners (can be adequately covered using
rounded to a 2 mm radius (1/16 inch) or ground to a 2 mm proper spray technique)
(1/16 inch) chamfer.” In addition to edges, rough surfaces are
ground smooth. Flame cut edges are normally ground over Areas that are usually stripe coated include:
their entire surface to remove the hardened surface layer • Crevices
resulting from flame cutting and permit creation of a profile. • Plate and sharp edges
For immersion service and other services where increased • Plate seams
corrosion can be expected, very rough welds should always • Back-to-back angle seams (built up members)
be ground because many coatings cannot adequately protect • Pitted steel
them. NACE Standard SP0178 "Standard Recommended • Bolt heads and nuts
Practice: Fabrication Details, Surface Finish Requirements, • Rivet heads
and Proper Design Considerations for Tanks and Vessels to • Welds
Be Lined for Immersion Service"4 provides guidance on finish • Other sharp discontinuities
requirements for welds. • Outside corners

4. Stripe Coat Application Stripe coating is most effective on edges that are either
rounded or chamfered by grinding (see Section 3).
A “stripe coat” is a coat of paint applied only to edges,
welds, outside corners, bolt heads and threads, and crevices, 4.2 How to Stripe
either before or after a full coat is applied to the entire surface.
These areas are difficult to coat due to coating shrinkage during 4.2.1 Brushing is the preferred method of applying stripe
cure. Shrinkage pulls coating away from sharp edges, resulting coats. Unless otherwise specified, SSPC-PA 1 requires brush
in low dry film thickness. Wet coating may flow over rather than application of coatings to cracks, crevices, blind areas of all
into crevices. This results in a temporary bridge over the crevice rivets and bolts, and all areas of limited access.(2),6 Brush
that disappears as the coating cures and shrinks, leaving the application provides the highest quality stripe coat on most
crevice interior unprotected. Both areas are susceptible to surfaces because it works the paint into the pores and crevices
premature corrosion. The practice of applying a “stripe coat” and allows the greatest control over the boundaries of the
to such areas is frequently referred to as “striping.” painted area. The coating should be allowed to dry to recoat
The project specification normally specifies the areas are according to the product data sheet before the full prime coat
to be striped, allowable methods of striping (brush or spray), in is applied. Coating manufacturers will usually provide guid-
what order to apply the stripe coat (before or after the full coat), ance on the amount of dry time required before application of
which coats are to be striped, whether tinting of the stripe coat subsequent coatings. Table 1 compares application of stripe
or use of another color of coating is required, and information coats by brush or spray.
on the drying/curing requirements between application of the
stripe and full coat (may defer to the coating manufacturer). (1)
SSPC Environmental Zone 1A–Interior, normally dry (or tem-
porary protection). Very mild (oil base paints now last six years
or more). SSPC Environmental Zone 1B–Exterior, normally dry
4.1 Areas to Stripe: The facility owner normally determines (includes most areas where oil base paints now last six years or
whether stripe coating is warranted for some or all areas of the more)4
(2)
SSPC-PA 1, Section 7.4.6.

2
SSPC-PA Guide 11
August 1, 2008

TABLE 1
COMPARISON OF APPLICATION METHODS
APPLICATION
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
METHOD

Brush • Best method to work paint into pores and • Most labor-intensive method
crevices • May pull incompletely cured paint from edge
• Most complete coverage of rivet heads, bolt
heads, nuts, and threads
• Best control of extent of area coated

Spray • Fastest method of application • May bridge (rather than penetrate into) pores and crev-
• Least labor-intensive method ices. Back-brushing needed to work wet coating into
• May be best method of applying coatings with pits, crevices, and angles.
edge retention properties, zinc-rich coatings • More likely to miss areas in tight spaces, resulting in
• Quick method for applying a stripe coat to holidays.
edges al-ready painted • Builds coating thickness on larger area (control of area
coated is difficult)
• More risk of overspray and dry spray

4.2.2 When applying a stripe coat, the brush strokes should be constantly agitated, unless otherwise recommended by the
run parallel to, not across, edges and crevices. Variations in coating manufacturer.
pressure of the brush during application can result in thin film 4.2.6 When striping with a multi-component thermosetting
on sharp edges and accumulation of coating on adjoining coating, the curing reaction will eventually progress to the point
perpendicular surfaces. To assure adequate film build on sharp where the coating fails to wet the surface and level adequately.
edges, multiple brush applications may be necessary. Bolt Since high temperatures often accelerate curing rates, this effect
heads and nuts should be striped in a circular brush motion. is most pronounced in hot weather. Heat of reaction (exotherm)
Striping should extend at least 3 centimeters (cm) (1 inch) from may also be generated when multiple components of thermo-
edges and other irregular surfaces. Round or oval brushes are setting coatings are mixed, so it may be more cost effective
generally considered most suitable for rivets, bolts, irregular to use smaller kits (e.g., 1-liter or 1-gallon units) rather than
surfaces, and rough or pitted steel. 5-liter or 5-gallon units. Note that most coating manufacturers
prohibit mixing of partial kits. Thinning should not be used to
4.2.3 SSPC-PA 1 does not permit rollers to be used to restore the flow properties of a multi-component coating that
apply coatings on irregular surfaces, such as rivets, bolt heads, has increased viscosity from partial curing.
crevices, welds, corners or edges unless otherwise specified.(3)
If the project specification permits the use of rollers for stripe 4.2.7 It is good practice for the stripe coat to be a different
coat application in these areas, PA 1 requires that the coating color from the adjoining full coats or the bare steel surface.
be brushed out to form a continuous and unbroken film over The color difference enables painters and inspectors to visually
these surfaces. verify there are no misses, skips, or thin spots in the stripe coat.
In addition, the application can be verified after the fact (as
4.2.4 Spraying the stripe coat can reduce the amount necessary) for thickness and proper coverage using a destruc-
of time spent in brush application, but the painter has less tive thickness gage (i.e., Tooke Gage), a holiday detector, or
control over the precise boundaries of the area being coated. (on some specialty coatings) ultraviolet light.
Spray may be the best method for applying stripe coats using
coatings with edge retention properties or zinc-rich coatings, 4.3 What Coats to Stripe: Usually, a stripe application is
or for applying a stripe coat to edges that have already been specified for the primer coating because of the importance of
painted. The applicator should spray the coating along the flat complete coverage. After a surface has received its first coat
surface, not directly at the edge itself, to prevent the atomiza- of paint, there is less probability of incomplete coverage of
tion pressure from pushing the coating away from the edge subsequent coats. Occasionally, multiple stripe coats may be
that is to be protected. required over rough hand welds. In critical areas, the specifier
may require that striping be done for two or more coats in a
4.2.5 When striping with a coating that is prone to pigment multi-coat system. Nevertheless, multiple coat striping is not
settling, such as zinc-rich primers, the coating in the pot should commonly specified.
(3)
SSPC-PA 1, Section 7.3.4.

3
SSPC- PA Guide 11
August 1, 2008

4.4 When to Stripe - Before or After Full Coat instructions in the coating manufacturer’s product data sheet
should be followed unless otherwise specified.
4.4.1 Many coatings professionals feel that the stripe
coat of the primer should be applied first to maximize corro- 4.6 Controlling Thickness
sion protection. For example, it is easier to work stripe coats
into crevices that have not been bridged by a spray-applied 4.6.1 The thickness of the stripe coat is difficult to control.
full coat. However, there are several reasons why the stripe Some contractors will measure thickness to assure the minimum
coat could be applied after the first full coat. If the stripe coat and maximum specified thickness limits have been satisfied,
is applied prior to primer application, there is opportunity for while others will make only a visual check for excessive build.
the surrounding clean, unprotected steel to deteriorate while For the most part, thickness is controlled by the skill of the
the stripe coat is drying/curing. Another reason is that stripe applicator and use of a wet film thickness (WFT) gage. However,
coating after application of the full coat (particularly an inter- notch gages cannot provide reliable WFT readings on irregular
mediate coat) will fill in pinholes and other holidays that have surfaces and should not be used on edges.
formed in the spray-applied coat.
4.6.2 Leeway on maximum thickness is usually allowed
4.4.2 If striping is specified for each coat in a multi-coat within 2 inches (5 cm) of an edge or 1 inch (3 cm) of a weld.
system, application of the stripe coat before the final finish Coatings may be tolerant of thickness beyond the specified
coat will result in a more uniform finish. upper limit. Near a striped area (2 inches [5 cm] from an edge
and 1 inch [3 cm] from a weld), the maximum thickness is
4.4.3 When painting a tank floor or other surface subject sometimes allowed to be twice the normal maximum. Designers
to foot or vehicle traffic, it may be wise to delay application of or specifiers should use coating manufacturer’s recommended
the final stripe coat over the welds to minimize erosion of the dry film thickness (DFT) ranges as guidance for required thick-
coating by foot traffic or air hoses being dragged across the ness of a stripe coat.
raised welds prior to the coating being put into service.
4.6.3 Conflicts can be avoided if thickness requirements at
4.4.4 The advantages and limitations of striping before or near the stripe coat and any allowed deviation from speci-
and after the full coat are summarized in Table 2. Final deter- fied minimum and maximum DFT thickness requirements are
mination of the best sequence of stripe coats and full coats will clearly stated in the project specification.
depend on the coating systems being used and the specific
requirements of each project. 4.6.4 Although thickness of the stripe coat can often be
measured in the immediate vicinity of an edge, it is very difficult
4.5 If the stripe coat is applied first, it is usually allowed to to measure thickness of a coating over the edge itself. Some
dry to touch (per ASTM D 1640) before the full coat is applied. electronic gages include very small tips (probes) to improve
However, there can be exceptions to this practice. The recoating the reliability of dry film thickness readings taken on an edge.

TABLE 2

ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS OF STRIPING


BEFORE VS. AFTER APPLICATION OF FULL COAT

TIMING ADVANTAGES LIMITATIONS

BEFORE • Better application and protection of irregularities • Rust-back of cleaned areas surrounding
• Better appearance the striped area may occur before full coat
• Holidays, light spots are more obvious can be applied
• Assists painter in monitoring progress

AFTER • Surrounding blast cleaned surface will not rust while • Damage to previously coated surfaces
stripe coat dries may occur during application of stripe
• Can sometimes apply by spray (brush-back usually coat
required) • Higher chance of incomplete coverage of
• Better coverage of pinholes and holidays irregularities
• Can visually ensure that stripe coat has been • Aesthetics (stripe coat may be more
applied properly visible)

4
SSPC-PA Guide 11
August 1, 2008

Notches in the probe tip aid in alignment of the gauge and thin
Measure paint thickness here (dft edge)
flexible shims can be used to verify the accuracy of the gauge
when measuring on an edge.

4.7 Coatings to Use for Striping


Measure paint thickness Measure paint thickness
4.7.1 Welds and crevices are best protected when striped here (dft flat) here (dftflat )

with a coating with good wetting properties. High build coat-


PA
ings are best for striping edges. However, it is impractical

E
IN

AT
T

T
IN

TR
to specify two different stripe coatings on a job with edges,

PA

BS
SU
crevices and welds. The paint should be of a consistency to
function on both surfaces.

4.7.2 The manufacturer should be consulted to determine


the appropriate coating to use for the striping. If the stripe coat
contains a zinc loading and is to be applied over a surface Figure 3. Diagram of edge retention test
already primed with inorganic zinc, an organic zinc primer (courtesy of MIL-PRF-23236C)
is used for the stripe coat, as inorganic zinc coatings do not The edge retention percentage is calculated as:
bond well over themselves or over organic zinc. High solids % Retention = dft (edge)/dft (flat) x 100
coatings may have a relatively short dry time and may not
possess good wetting properties, which is paramount to the procurement document. SSPC guides are intended to provide
success of the stripe coat. In this case, a compatible stripe coat consensus recommendations for best industry practice. They
with a slower drying time and improved wetting may be used are not written as requirements that may be cited in a contract.
with the high-solids coating. The coating selected for striping However, specifiers may incorporate information from an SSPC
should be designed for the service environment. guide into job-specific contract requirements.

4.7.3 Coatings with Edge Retention Properties: An 5.2 While every precaution is taken to ensure that all
alternative method for the protection of edges that may avoid information furnished in SSPC guides is as accurate, complete,
the need for grinding and chamfering is the use of a coating and useful as possible, SSPC cannot assume responsibility
that has edge retention properties. Typically these types of nor incur any obligation resulting from the use of any materials,
coatings are high-solids products that provide improved film coatings, or methods described herein, or of the guide itself.
thickness retention at the apex of an edge to improve protection
in these critical areas. A method for measuring the edge retention 5.3 This guide does not attempt to address problems
properties of a coating is published in MIL-PRF-23236C.7 This concerning safety associated with its use. The user of this
test method compares the film thickness of three specimens specification, as well as the user of all products or practices
cut from a sample of coating applied to a non-chamfered 90 described herein, is responsible for instituting appropriate
degree angle. The ratio of the film thickness at the apex vs. the health and safety practices and for ensuring compliance with
film thickness on the flat area is calculated and expressed as all governmental regulations.
the percentage of edge retention of the coating, as shown in
Figure 3. According to MIL-PRF-23236C, any specimen having References
less than 50 percent edge retention fails the test. An average
value of 70 percent edge retention for three test specimens 1. Corbett, W. D. “The Same Old Grind...An Investigation
measured using an optical microscope is required to qualify of Zinc-Rich Primer Performance Over Steel Corners.” Modern
a coating as having edge-retention properties. Steel Construction, Vol. 40, No. 6: p. 43-49.
Note that very sharp edges, or “knife” edges, are very 2. Graco Publications, Airless Spray Techniques. Minne-
difficult to protect even with coatings with edge-retention apolis, MN: Graco Inc., 1993. This document is available as a
properties. It is recommended that “knife” edges have their downloadable .pdf file from http://www.graco.com.
surface modified as described in Section 3 prior to coating to 3. Graco Publications, Air Spray Techniques. Minneapolis,
provide suitable corrosion protection. MN: Graco Inc., 1995. This document is available as a down-
loadable .pdf file from http://www.graco.com.
5. Disclaimer 4. NACE Standard SP0178 (latest edition); Standard
Recommended Practice: Fabrication Details, Surface Finish
5.1 This guide is designed to describe, review, or analyze Requirements, and Proper Design Considerations for Tanks
new or improved technology and does not meet the definition and Vessels to Be Lined for Immersion Service.” Houston, TX:
of a standard as defined by SSPC. A guide differs from a stan- NACE International (http://www.nace.org).
dard in that it is not suitable for referencing in a specification or

5
SSPC- PA Guide 11
August 1, 2008

5. SSPC, “How to Use SSPC Standards and Guides.”


Pittsburgh, PA: SSPC, 2008.
6. SSPC-PA 1 (latest edition), Shop, Field, and Mainte-
nance Painting of Steel. Pittsburgh, PA: SSPC.
7. MIL-PRF-23236C (latest edition); Coating System for
Ship Structures.Washington Navy Yard, DC: Naval Sea Systems
Command. This standard is available online at http://assist.
daps.dla.mil/quicksearch

You might also like