Professional Documents
Culture Documents
php/jpe
Abstract
The study aimed at attaining an overview on teaching experiences by means of guided inquiry
model of the scientific approach in order to inculcate the scientific attitudes among the students of
Luqman Al Hakim International Integrated Islamic Primary School Yogyakarta. The study was a
qualitative research using the ethnographic classroom approach. The subjects in this study were the
headmaster, the homeroom teachers of Grade 4A students, and the Grade 4A students. In collecting
the data, the researchers conducted interview, observation, and documentation. Then, the instruments
that the researchers employed were the interview guidelines and the observation guidelines. The data
in this study were analyzed using Lankshear and Knobel models and the analysis also included the
data that had been attained from both the observation and the interview. In order to test the data
validity, the researchers conducted the subject triangulation and the method triangulation. The findings
in this study thus revealed that the teaching activities that make use of the scientific approach consists
of seven strands of learning cycles and these strands include the spiritual, moral, intellectual, physical,
interpersonal, cultural, and social aspects. Each aspect has specific purpose and, as a result, by
implementing each aspect the students will have the scientific attitudes similar to those owned by a
scientist in solving their problems. The recounted teaching experiences, which made use of the
scientific approach, have shown similarities in that teaching activities become more meaningful if they
are conducted realistically with various learning activities both inside and outside the classroom. The
constraints in the application of the scientific approach are varying the teachers’ ability in
understanding the scientific approach, varying the learning styles and the learning abilities, and
varying the learning process for the students who need special assistance.
Keywords: scientific approach, scientific attitudes, Luqman Al Hakim International Integrated Islamic
Primary School Yogyakarta
How to Cite: Masithoh, D. (2018). Teachers’ scientific approach implementation in inculcating the students’
scientific attitudes. Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6(1), 32-43. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.21831/jpe.v6i1.14282
Permalink/DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21831/jpe.v6i1.14282
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -33
Dewi Masithoh
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -34
Dewi Masithoh
scientific approach and it becomes the main First-Grade students to the Sixth-Grade students
catalyst in the learning process. The scientific through a thematic integrative learning process
approach is believed to the golden bridge of that makes use of scientific inquiry approach.
students’ attitude, skills, and knowledge growth This elementary school even used to be a model
and development in any approach or any process for the implementation of 2013 Curriculum
that demands scientific criteria. throughout the Province of Yogyakarta Special
The previous learning process made use Region in 2013.
of scientific approach and scientific approach is Within the learning process, this
a combination of the learning process that has elementary school has made use of scientific
been focused on exploration, elaboration, and approach as the approach that trains the students
confirmation and the learning process that has to performing scientific reasoning as early as
been equipped with the activities of observing, possible. The students have been taught to be
inquiring, experimenting, reasoning, and little scientists through multiple learning
communicating (Kementerian Pendidikan dan methods and strategies such as Inquiry. In this
Kebudayaan Republik Indonesia, 2013). How- regard, the school has been implemented the
ever, some schools have developed a learning guided inquiry. The activities of guided inquiry
process that makes use of the activities of consist of observing, enquiring, reasoning, ex-
observing, inquiring, collecting data, processing perimenting, and communicating their findings
data, communicating, innovating, and inventing through a presentation in front of the class. Even
(Kemendikbud, 2013). Despite these last month the elementary school held a mini
differences, the objective of the learning expo as an event that expressed the students’
processes should be in the same corridor of the work. In addition, based on the results of an
scientific approach namely to emphasize interview with one of the Fourth-Grade teachers
learning process does not take place only inside the researchers found that the elementary school
the classroom but also outside the classroom has also made use of descriptive rapport as the
such as in the school environment and the report of the students’ holistic learning result
community. In addition, through such learning development. Completing the descriptive rap-
processes the teachers will only need to serve as port is certainly not an easy task. The teachers
a scaffolding when the students have difficulties should totally understand the background of
and the teachers will not only be sole learning each student in terms of their talent, interest,
source. Similarly, through these processes the characters, and capacity. The completion of such
scientific attitudes will not only be taught by descriptive rapport is interesting to study
means of verbal manner but also of example and because through the learning experiences that
role model. The results of several studies have have been attained by using the guided inquiry-
mentioned that there are significant differences model scientific approach the scientific attitudes
among the students before and after they have might be inculcated into the elementary schools.
attended the scientific inquiry-based learning Therefore, the researchers would like to conduct
process; the difference lies in the fact that the an in-depth review toward the learning
students’ have better scientific attitudes after experiences that have been attained by using the
they have attended the scientific inquiry-based guided inquiry-model scientific approach in
learning process (Ikaningrum & Gultom, 2013). inculcating the scientific attitudes toward the
With the presence of scientific approach in each students of Luqman Al Hakim International
learning process, the students will be habituated Integrated Islamic Elementary School
to performing scientific reasoning in solving the Yogyakarta.
problems that they should deal with so that the The meaningful learning experiences that
students will have scientific attitudes in drawing have been attained by using the guided inquiry-
conclusions from their problems. model scientific approach are expected to
Based on the results of observation expand the students’ knowledge in order to
toward the Luqman Al Hakim International prepare well-qualified future generation and
Integrated Islamic Elementary School, the human resources of Indonesian people. Due to
researchers found that this elementary school the statement, the learning process in the schools
has been implementing a learning process that should be the place for manifesting the four
inculcates the scientific attitudes toward their educational pillars (UNESCO, …) namely
students since 2008. The inculcation of these learning to know, learning to become him-
scientific attitudes has been conducted from the /herself, learning to do, and learning to live
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -35
Dewi Masithoh
together. By doing so, young mankind (students) In gathering the data, the researchers
are brought into the environment of their implemented the following techniques: obser-
adulthood in order to meet the true nature of vation, interview, and documentation.
human beings. In the same time, Indonesia The instrument in the study was the
might be in competition with other advanced researchers themselves. However, when the
countries in the domain of education. focus of the study had been clear the researchers
developed a simple research instrument that
Method
might complete and compare the data that had
The study was a qualitative research using been attained from both the observation and the
ethnographic classroom approach. A study of interview. The instruments that had been applied
ethnography might be performed in order to in the study were observation guideline, inter-
attain deeper understanding toward certain rules view guideline, documentation, and fieldnote.
that based the phenomena that had been Then, the techniques that had been
experienced or that had been possessed by a implemented in order to validate the data in the
group of people who had interaction in a socio- study were participatory extension, observation
economic, religious, political, and geographical persistence, and triangulation.
environment such as belief, language, values, On the other hand, the data analysis tech-
rituals, customs, and behaviors (Creswell, 2012, niques in this study were performed altogether
p. 473). In the context of education, a study of with the data gathering process. The process of
ethnography might be used in understanding the both the data analysis techniques and the data
pattern of interactional relationship between the gathering activities would be elaborated in the
teachers and the students in the school. The following sections.
ethnographic analysis was inductive and was
Data Processing
established based on the perspective of the
people who conducted the research. The data analysis in this study was
The study was conducted in the Luqman conducted directly after the researchers had
Al Hakim International Integrated Islamic gathered the data from each participant. After
Elementary School Yogyakarta. The elementary the data had been gathered, the researchers
school was selected as the research site after the conducted the process of intuiting, analyzing,
researchers had observed and had analyzed the and describing. The data processing activities
track records of the elementary school. Based on that had been conducted were documenting the
the results of both observation and analysis, the data that had been attained from the results of
researchers might conclude that the elementary observation, from the results of interview, and
school had been implementing the guided from the fieldnotes. The documentation was
inquiry-model scientific approach since 2008. conducted by replaying the results of the
The study took place from February until recording activities and by transcribing the
March in the second semester of the 2014-2015 speeches. Then, these data were encoded in
Academic year. order to ease the data analysis. The data should
The subjects in this study were randomly be encoded because the code would differentiate
selected. The subjects were selected based on the keywords of each participant.
the following criteria: the subjects should belong
Data Analysis
to the classroom that had been implementing the
guided inquiry-model scientific approach for at After the overall data had been gathered,
least three years and the subjects were the the researchers would conduct the data analysis.
teachers who had been experienced and who had In this study, the data analysis would be
understood how to inculcate the scientific conducted by implementing the techniques of
attitudes toward the students through the interview data analysis and of observation data
learning process. Both criteria should be met in analysis. The activities in the data analysis
order to ease the researchers in gathering the began with listening to the participants’ verbal
data around the Luqman Al Hakim International description from the observation results and
Integrated Islamic Elementary School. Then, the with reading repetitively the results of interview
subjects included: the principal, the Fourth- transcription. According to Lankshear & Knobel
Grade teachers, and the Fourth-Grade students. (2004), the stages of analysis should be as
follows: (a) preparing and organizing the
interview data and the observation data for the
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -36
Dewi Masithoh
analysis; (b) analyzing the code/category as the may serve as the students’ guide in dealing with
approach to analyzing the interview data and the their both present and future problems.
observation data; and (c) conducting domain and Based on the results of the observation,
taxonomic analysis. Afterwards, the researchers prior to implementing the 7M Learning Cycle
would compose the final description in a the teachers designed a unit plan. The steps that
narrative form as the composite description of the teachers conducted in designing the unit plan
the experience meaning and essence so that the would be provided in the following paragraphs.
researchers could display the picture of First, the teacher mapped the Competence
experiences in a single unit. Standards/Basic Competences. The mapping of
competence standards/basic competences was
Results and Discussions
conducted for each lesson that might be inte-
Results grated in order to see what themes that would be
The results of the study that had been suitable for serving as the main theme and
conducted in Luqman Al Hakim Integrated whether it would possible to integrate the com-
International Islamic Elementary School petence standards and the basic competencies of
Yogyakarta regarding the use of scientific each lesson under the main learning theme or
approach in inculcating the scientific attitudes not.
toward the Fourth-Grade students would be Second, the teacher designed the
elaborated in the following sections. questions. In this stage, the teacher would start
from fundamental questions. The questions
The Implementation of Learning Process could be such as: “Why should the students
The scientific approach within the learn certain topics?” “What are the benefits for
learning process of 2013 Curriculum is similar the students in the future?” “What is the
to the implementation of scientific learning relationship between the learning process and
stage within the elementary school. This learn- the real life that the students will encounter?”
ing stage is known as “7M Learning Cycle.” The Through these questions, the teachers would
7M Learning Cycle refers to the standards of involve the students in discussing certain
scientific learning process that has been matters in order that they would harness the
developed from the dimension of literacy within essence of the subjects that the students would
the curriculum of the elementary school and the study.
dimensions in this cycle are spiritual, moral, Third, the teacher designed a plan. In this
intellectual, physical, interpersonal, cultural, and stage, the teacher would define which content
social (Tim Kurikulum, 2012, p. 9). Then, the standards that he or she would discuss when
7M Learning Cycle itself consists of seven they answered the questions from the themes
stages that have been developed from the seven that had been defined. Through this activity, the
fundamental learning potentials namely: (1) teacher would involve the students in a process
mengagumi (admiring); (2) menghayati (con- of composing planning questions and of
templating); (3) meneliti (researching); (4) developing projects.
merealisasi (realizing); (5) mengkolaborasi Fourth, the teacher designed an activity
(collaborating); (6) mengaktualisasi (actualiz- schedule. Both the teacher and the students
ing); and (7) memberi (contributing). designed an activity schedule for the project
The implementation of each stage in this components. Then, they would define which
learning cycle has respective objective and standards that they should acquire. In this stage,
benefit. Multiple learning activities that the the teacher should pay attention that the activity
students conduct will be able to shape strong schedule should be made simple and in
personal characteristics within the students. In accordance to the age of the students.
addition, these activities are also able to Five, the teacher conducted monitoring.
inculcate the students’ scientific attitudes in the The teacher facilitated the process that the
form of curiosity toward scientific truths, critical students needed to carry out their projects. The
thinking toward the given assignments, teacher served as a mentor or a consultant within
diligence and persistence in searching the the learning process. In this stage, the teacher
information truth, teamwork, environmental could make use of criteria standards for
sensitivity, and alike. These scientific attitudes monitoring the students’ conductance.
Sixth, the teacher conducted assessment.
The teacher devised an authentic assessment
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -37
Dewi Masithoh
without various types of assessment. The the classroom administration, the inappropriate
authentic assessment would demand lots of project planning within the unit plan that led to
times and efforts from the students. the activity replacement so that the related
Seventh, the teacher conducted eva- project would be more appropriate to the learn-
luation. The teacher should devote their time to ing theme. On the other hand, the technical
reflect on the students’ work both in persons and problems were: the various students’ capacity,
in groups. The teacher should ask the students to the teachers’ replacement due to certain
express their various experiences and feelings. circumstances that occurred within the learning
Then, the teachers should also discuss which process, and different students’ learning styles.
matters that went well and which matters that The obstacles that came from the
should be improved. The students might also students’ party were covered the learning
share ideas that would lead to the new questions preparation problem and the learning activity
so that new projects could be created in the problem. The learning preparation problem was
future. the students’ neglectfulness in bringing the
objects that would be necessary for their projects
Learning Experiences
while the learning activity problem was the
Based on the data from the observation students’ difficulties in understanding certain
and the interview within the classroom, the materials; some of the students even disliked
participants expressed their teaching expe- certain subjects. Despite these obstacles, the
riences. There were several learning models that students still had high enthusiasm in reaching
had been implemented in the elementary school. their dreams because they gained good support
However, these models were collaborated in a from the environment.
container namely the project-based learning unit
Discussions
plan.
Each project in the unit plan also Based on the results of the study, the
contained other learning models such as researchers found that the Luqman Al Hakim
discovery learning/guided-inquiry learning and Integrated International School Yogyakarta had
problem-based learning that had been adjusted been developed into an elementary school that
to the activity of each stage within the 7M created the scientific based learning system and
Learning Cycle such as: understanding the verse atmosphere. The basis of this development was
of the Koran as the basis of a research, the religious values that had been in accordance
discussions, video playbacks, exhibitions/mini to the Koran, which had been fundamental since
expos, and alike. These multiple learning the establishment of the elementary school. The
activities provided direct experiences to the elementary school believed that each student has
children so that the knowledge that they grasped different potentials and characteristics.
would always be remembered. In addition, these Appropriate education may develop the
activities also trained the students to inculcate best potentials that the students have; as a result,
their scientific attitudes in encountering the such education may give birth to the perfect
problems in their life, to share from one to human beings. Therefore, educational objective
another, and to be aware of their surrounding should be defined more practically and
environment. systematically. Tauhidi (2001, p. 42) argued that
education should have certain objectives for
Obstacles within the Learning Process
developing 7 fundamental potentials that have
Implementation
been awared by God the Almighty. These 7
Also based on the data from the obser- fundamental potentials are as follows: spiritual,
vation and the interview within the classroom, moral, intellectual, physical, interpersonal, cul-
the researchers found several obstacles within tural, and social. The 7 fundamental potentials
the learning process implementation. These that have been developed by the elementary
obstacles came from both the teachers’ party and school into the 7M Learning Cycle that includes:
the students’ party. The obstacles that came mengagumi (admiring), menghayati (contem-
from the teachers’ party covered the planning plating), meneliti (researching), merealisasi
and the technical problems. The planning (realizing), mengkolaborasi (collaborating),
problems were: the different teachers’ capacity mengaktualisasi (actualizing), and memberi
regarding their understanding toward the (contributing).
scientific approach, the limited time in designing
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -38
Dewi Masithoh
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -39
Dewi Masithoh
association, and to conduct synergy as they are admiration might be attained through the signs
trying to find the solution for a problem. The (the verses) that they can identify and grasp
fourth reason is related to partnership/teamwork through their five senses. According to the
building. Through the partnership/teamwork scientific approach of 2013 Curriculum, this
building, the students are able to promote stage is known as Mengamati (Observing).
dialogue and negotiation and also to learn to
Second Stage: Menghayati (Contemplating,
cooperate. Last but not the least, the fifth reason
Moral Aspect)
is related to participation in decision-making
process. Throigh the participation in decision- Menghayati (Contemplating) is the
making process, the students are able to second stage of the learning cycle. In this stage,
empower each of their peers. the students are exposed to the facts that have
These characteristics certainly cannot be been in contary to the existing excellence and
attained in a passive learning process where the miracle. These facts show the opposites of the
students just sit and wait for the information that information that the students have attained in the
the teachers will provide. While the students’ “Mengagumi (Admiring).” The objective is to
skills cannot be shaped overnight, Anindyta & make the students aware of the fact that these
Suwarjo (2014, p. 220) has stated that the excellent or miraculous signs may change
students’ critical thinking skills will not be anytime. Human beings may also change these
developed immediately without the teachers’ signs into the better one or they may even
supports. Darmayanti & Wibowo (2014, p. 31) destroy these signs. From the activities that have
has also stated that in the context of character been conducted in this stage, the students learn
education habituation is created in order to to behave critically, to be humble, and to
enable the students to habituate themselves so understand the governing values in the real life
that they will behave according to the characters that surrounds them until the moral principles of
that have been inculcated and personalized from self-directed individual have been inculcated in
the through the intervention process. Therefore, their personality. According to the scientific
all skills should be trained since the beginning approach of 2013 Curriculum, this stage is
of the learning process and such training also known as Menanyai (Inquiring).
includes the attitudes of conducting scientific Third Stage: Meneliti (Researching, Intellectual
skills. Conducting these attitudes such as the Aspect)
scientists will take a long time in terms of
learning implementation so that the students will Meneliti (Researching) is the third stage
be habituated to conduct such attitudes in their of the learning cycle. The objective of this stage
daily life. is to demand the students to conduct research in
Based on the results of the study, the accordance to their age level. When the students
process of implementing the 7M Learning Cycle are children, they can be quite trained in
and of inculcating the scientific attitudes for conducting simple research. As the students
each stage will be elaborated as follows. grow up, they are demanded to conduct more
complex research. There are many things that
First Stage: Mengagumi (Admiring, Spiritual can be researched with regards to the signs
Aspect) (topics/themes) under study. This will depend on
Mengagumi (Admiring) is the first stage the perspective that bases the research plan of
of the learning cycle. This stage is ultimately both the teachers and the students. The more
important to complete because throughout this perspective that they refer to, the longer the time
stage the students will build their curiosity by of implementation will be. Therefore, the
conducting various interesting learning activities teachers and the students would select the
such as: listening to stories, watching videos, relevant perspective as the focus of their
outing to certain places, and alike. In this first research. In this stage, the students’ cognitive
stage, the emphasis will be highlighted to the knowledge has been improving as they are able
objective that the students admire the creation of to think critically, to be creative, and to be
God the Almighty. The objective of this stage is encouraged in making decisions. As a result, the
to develop the God-Conscious Spirit among the students will grow along with the complex
students. In this stage, the teachers will lead the thinking skills (complex thinker). According to
students to find their admiration toward the the scientific approach of 2013 Curriculum, this
signs (the verses) that He has made. This stage is known as Mencoba (Experimenting).
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -40
Dewi Masithoh
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -41
Dewi Masithoh
learning sessions. The scientific attitudes that participants’ scientific learning will be more
the 4th Grade students have developed are meaningful if they conduct the learning process
similar to those that have been developed by in actual manner. For example, by conducting
Harlen (1996, p. 12) namely: curious, respecting multiple activities both inside and outside
data, critical, persistent, creative and inventing, classroom such as understanding the Koran
open minded, cooperative to other people, and verses as the basis of a research, having dis-
environmentally sensible. Through the cussions, watching videos, outing, investigating,
possession of these scientific attitudes, it is verifying by experimenting, holding mini
expected that the students will have strong expo/exhibition, giving presentations, and alike,
characters as their capacity in dealing with the the students will be able gain more meaningful
rapidly changing century. experiences. With various learning activities, the
After completing all of the stages in the students will be encouraged to gain more
7M Learning Cycle, the teacher then will achievement and to improve their creativity and
conduct a learning evaluation, both the oral and also to pursue maximum learning. This is in
the written one, in order to measure the students’ accordance to the results of a study by
cognitive capacity and development. In this Abdelraheem & Asan (2006) which found that
evaluation, the teacher will assess the students’ learning process by means of inquiry-based
learning results by means of worksheet, energy- technology with the support of collaborative
efficient house display, and energy-efficient learning environment might improve the
monitoring record at the end of the learning students’ learning experiences. Similarly, the
process. For assessing the students’ learning results of a study by Machin (2014) showed that
process, the teacher will only score the students’ the implementation of scientific approach has
worksheet and display. Furthermore, in this positive influence toward the cognitive,
elementary school the researchers did not find affective, and psychomotor learning process and
any process nor attitude assessment as part of has achieved the classical cut score that has been
authentic assessment such as the one that has set. Thereby, attaining learning experiences by
been implemented by 2013 Curriculum. After means of guided-inquiry model scientific
crosschecking the data to the subjects, it turns approach might inculcate the scientific attitudes
out that the elementary school has not designed toward the students.
any scientific attitudes assessment in each Based on the results of interview with the
learning stage of 7M Learning Cycle. Therefore, teachers and the observation on the learning
the teachers in this elementary school should process within the classroom, the researchers
develop the instrument of process assessment has found that the obstacles of the learning
while the learning process is taking place so that process implementation come from both the
the assessment will not solely involve the teachers and the students. The obstacles that
cognitive one but also the affective one and the come from the teachers are as follows: the
psychomotor one. By doing so, the assessment teachers have different capacity in under-
that the teacher conducts will be authentic. The standing the scientific approach; the teachers
assessment process has a vital role in the suffer from limited time in designing the
scientific learning process because the assess- classroom administration; and occasionally the
ment has been intended to measure the students’ unit plan that has been designed contains
scientific attitudes. This statement has been inappropriate activities and consequently the
proven in a study by Putri, Candiasa, & teachers should replace these activities with the
Marhaeni (2014) which found that the Natural ones that are more appropriate to the theme. On
Science Subject scores from the students who the other hand, the obstacles that come from the
had been exposed to the assessment-based students are as follows: the students have
guided inquiry learning method were signi- various capacity; the students have different
ficantly better than the students who had been learning styles; and some of the students need
exposed to the conventional learning method. special assistance in attending the learning
With the presence of process assessment, the process. Despite these obstacles, the teachers
implemented scientific learning process will be always evaluate the learning process in order to
able to measure the students’ achievement on overcome these obstacles so that the obstacles
scientific attitudes. will not inhibit the students to keep pursuing
Based on the results of the study, the their aspiration with supports from the good
researchers would like to conclude that the environment.
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -42
Dewi Masithoh
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)
Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 6 (1), January 2018 -43
Dewi Masithoh
Copyright © 2018, Jurnal Prima Edukasia, ISSN: 2338-4743 (print), ISSN: 2460-9927 (online)