You are on page 1of 160

Automatic Control Systems 10e

CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Learning Outcomes
After successful completion of this chapter, you will be able to
1. Analyze transient and steady-state time response of a simple control system.
2. Develop simple design criteria for manipulating the time response.
3. Determine speed and position time response of dc motors.
4. Apply basic control techniques and look at the effects of adding a simple gain or
poles and zeros to the system transfer function.
5. Use MATLAB to study the time response of simple control system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-1. Basic time-domain test signals for


control systems. (a) Step function. (b) Ramp
function. (c) Parabolic function.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-2. Typical unit-step response of a


control system illustrating the time-domain
specifications.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-3. Unit-step response of a prototype


first-order system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-4. Pole position of the transfer


function, in Eq. (7-12), of a prototype first-order
system as the system time constant decreases.
Table 7-1. Motor Mechanical Time Constant
and Final Speed for Three Different Damping
Values
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-7. Speed response of dc motor in


Example 7-4-1 to a unit step input. (a) Solid line
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-8. Prototype second-order control


system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-9. Relationship's among the


characteristic-equation roots of the prototype
second-order system and σ, ζ, ωn, and ω.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-2. Classification of


Prototype Second-Order
System Based on
Damping Ratio
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-10. Step-response comparison for


various characteristic equation root locations in
the s-plane.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-11. Unit-step responses of the


prototype second-order system with various
damping ratios.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-12. (a) Constant-


natural frequency loci. (b)
Constant-damping-ratio loci. (c)
Constant-damping-factor loci.
(d) Constant-conditional-
frequency loci.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-13. Unit-step response illustrating that


the maxima and minima occur at periodic
intervals.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-14. Percent overshoot as a function of


damping ratio for the step response of the
prototype second-order system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-15. Normalized delay time versus ζ for


the prototype second-order system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-16. Normalized rise time versus ζ for


the prototype second-order system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure
7-18. Relationship's
among the pole
location and ζ, ωn,
PO, tr, and ts.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-19. Block diagram of a position-control,


armature-controlled dc motor.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-21. Position control response of dc


motor in Example 7-5-1 to a unit-step input for
three controller gain K values.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-4. Motor


Performance for Three
Values of Controller Gain K
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-5 System Time Constant and Steady-


State Speed Error for Three Different Controller
Gain Values – Given a Unit-Step Input
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-27. System time response for three


different controller gain values when Kt = 1.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-28. Block diagram of a system


undergoing disturbance.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-6. Summary of the Steady-State Errors


Due to Step-, Ramp-, and Parabolic-Function
Inputs for Unity-Feedback Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-34. Typical input-output characteristics


of an amplifier with dead zone and saturation.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-35. Typical input-


output characteristics of a
quantizer.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-36. Torque-angle curve of a motor or


closed-loop system with Coulomb friction.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-7. The Poles of the Closed-Loop System


in Eq. (7-129) when ωn = 1, ζ = 1 and Tp = 0, 1, 2,
and 5
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-37. Unit-step responses of the system


with the closed-loop transfer function in Eq. (7-
129): ζ = 1, ωn = 1 and Tp = 0, 1, 2, and 5.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-38. Unit-step responses of the system with


the closed-loop transfer function in Eq. (7-129): ζ =
0.25, ωn = 1 and Tp = 0, 0.2, 0.667, and 1.0.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-8. The Poles of the Closed-Loop System in


Eq. (7-130) when ωn = 1, ζ = 1 and Tp = 0, 0.5, 1, 2,
and 5
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-39. Unit-step responses of the system with


the closed-loop transfer function in Eq. (7-130): ζ =
0.5, ωn = 1 and Tp = 0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, and 4.0.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-9. he Roots of the Closed-Loop System in Eq.


(7-131) when ωn = 1, ζ = 0.5 and Tz = 0, 1, 2, 3, 6, and
10
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-40. Unit-step responses of the system


with the closed-loop transfer function in Eq.
(7-131): Tz = 0, 1, 2, 3, 6, and 10.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-41. Unit-step responses showing the


effect of adding a zero to the closed-loop
transfer function.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-42. Unit-step responses of the system with


the closed-loop transfer function in Eq. (7-135): Tz =
0, 0.2, 0.5, 2.0, 5.0, and 10.0.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-43. Control system with PD controller.


CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-10. The Roots of the Closed-Loop


System in Eq. (7-142) when Tz = 0.4 and KP
varies from 0 to 7
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-44. The root locus representing the


zero and poles of Eq. (7-142) for KP varying from
0 to ∞ and Tz = 0.4.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-45. Unit-step response of Eq. (7-142)


for Tz = 0.4 and three Kp values.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-46. Control system with PI controller.


CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-47. Pole-zero configuration of a PI


controller.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-48. Unit-step response of Eq. (7-149)


for three KI values, when KP = 1.25.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-49. Regions of dominant and


insignificant poles in the s-plane.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-50. Regions of dominant and


insignificant poles in the s-plane for design
purposes.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-52. Transfer-function block diagram of


the system shown in Fig. 7-51.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-53. Root loci of the characteristic


equation in Eq. (7-162) as K varies.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-11. Comparison of the Performance


of the Second-Order Position-Control System
with the Gain K Values
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-55. Root loci of the


third-order attitude-control
system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-56. Unit-step responses of the third-


order attitude-control system.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-57. Simulated no-load closed-loop


position response results for multiple KP gains.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-58. NXT motor no-load closed-loop


position response results for multiple KP gains.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-12. No-Load Closed-Loop Position


Response Performance Specifications
Comparison
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-59. Robotic arm with payload closed-


loop position response results for multiple KP
gains.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-13. Robotic Arm and Payload


Experimental Parameters
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Figure 7-61. Simulated robotic arm with


payload closed-loop position response results
for multiple Kp gains.
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-14. Robotic Arm Closed-Loop Position


Response Performance Specification
Comparison
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems
CHAPTER 7 Time-Domain Performance of Control Systems

Table 7-15. Fine-Tuned Robotic Arm and


Payload Experimental Parameters

You might also like