Professional Documents
Culture Documents
& issues
in crime and criminal justice
No. 374 June 2009
Methodological issues
Issue 1 is the considerable inconsistency between management staff in security should
The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) categories adopted in different reporting also be counted. There is also a case
census is conducted every five years periods. The category ‘guards and security for including public sector personnel in
across all Australian households. There officers’ was introduced into census reports various agencies involved in regulatory
are a number of core security employment only in 1986. Since then, the number of enforcement (a variant of ‘policing’),
categories in census reports that are security categories has been enlarged and including environmental protection and
readily included as part of the security modified. Indeed, it is also possible that the fair trading, but these persons are not
industry, such as ‘private investigator’ armoured car personnel count is inflated by captured by the census in a manner
or ‘crowd controller’. Other categories these definitional changes. useful for the current study.
(primarily ‘debt collector’), are more at the Therefore, while the census provides a
Issue 2
periphery of the industry and their inclusion record of the growing recognition of the
is contestable. For the purposes of this The second major source is the ABS
industry, it only provides indicative figures
study, debt collectors have been included, Australian Business Register (ABR).
over time regarding the number of people
given that their work is closely associated The category ‘Security and Investigative
doing security-type work. So the present
with that of private investigators and also Businesses’ provides data on the number
study analyses are, for the most part,
involves law enforcement, especially in of security firms by jurisdiction, the number
limited to the 10 year period from 1996
the area of recovery of assets and ‘skip of employees (within bands), income and
to 2006, which is the period that provides
tracing’ persons who are evading the financial turnover. The oldest comparable
the greatest consistency in categories.
law (Prenzler & King 2002). One limitation data are from 2003–04. The most recent
These data were obtained from the
with the census is that it only captures a data available, for 2006–07, capture all
ABS Consultancy Service, along with
person’s ‘main occupation’. This means businesses that had an Australian
accompanying data on age, sex, education
that secondary (primarily part-time) Business Number (ABN). In that year,
and income. The data have not been
employment is not included. The census an ABN was required for firms with
published before.
also does not capture persons in security an annual turnover of $50,000 or more.
By contrast, ‘police’ can readily be counted However, businesses which did not have
management and administration, and
from ABS census collections. However, an ABN could voluntarily report to the
security door and window installers, nor
the figures are for sworn officers only, and ABR. Consequently, smaller security
does it indicate if a person is working in
the public sector police services include firms might not be included.
private or public sector employment.
a large number of ‘unsworn’ staff. If these
Another problem for those relying upon staff are counted, then administrative and
the Australian census for accurate data
to have completed higher education than providers, including in critical areas such
Ownership police, they earn lower salaries and they as counterterrorism (Sarre & Prenzler
Findings from the IBISWorld (2007: 24) are more likely to be employed part-time. forthcoming). Moreover, there have been
report on the security industry highlight high The age of security providers also spans a number of high-profile conduct scandals
industry concentration. IBISWorld reported a wider range than police. in private security (Prenzler & Sarre
that in 2005, five companies accounted for forthcoming). Therefore, finding the model
The private contract security sector is of licensing most capable of ensuring
44.5 percent of ‘market share’ as follows:
characterised by considerable diversity, ethical conduct and competency is
Chubb 17.5 percent, Linfox 10.8 percent,
with a large number of small businesses of crucial importance.
ISS 8.9 percent, Tyco 4.3 percent and
and small number of very large businesses.
Signature 2.9 percent.
The industry itself appears to be fairly stable, Despite the general decline in crime
The report also found ‘there is a high with the larger sector characterised by in Australia, crime rates remain relatively
degree of foreign ownership of the major foreign ownership. high by comparison with the rest of the
companies in this industry’, with four of developed world, and some areas (such
the five companies being foreign-owned The influences identified in the background as fraud) are growing in magnitude (Rollings
(IBISWorld 2007: 20). In 2003, transport section of this paper will continue to dictate 2008). Notwithstanding the alleged
and logistics giant Linfox acquired Mayne change (van Dijk 2008: 129). Indeed, the omnipresence of security, research indicates
Logistics and Armaguard in a deal worth IBISWorld (2007) report describes a number that only around 45 percent of Australian
$250m. In the last few years, Chubb of industry-specific trends that are likely to households have basic security measures
Security Personnel, Chubb Mobile Services continue: in place, suggesting considerable scope
and MSS Security Group were taken over • significant continuing growth in electronic for a greater contribution from the industry
by the US corporation UTC Fire and Security. alarm and CCTV surveillance and to domestic crime prevention (ABS 1999;
In July–August 2008, the company then monitoring, as these are often seen to be 2005). It is clear from international research
sold these Australian holdings to an Indian more cost-effective than manned patrol that premises with security have significantly
company, Security and Intelligence Services, and guarding services lower rates of criminal victimisation than
growth of the industry and its regulation de Waard J 1999. The private security industry van Steden R & Sarre R 2007. The growth of
in international perspective. European journal on private security: trends in the European Union.
are essential for those arguing for greater
criminal policy and research 7: 143–174 Security journal 20(4) 222–235
professionalism and accountability of private
IBISWorld 2007. Security and investigative Wood J & Kempa M 2005. Understanding global
sector personnel and for those seeking a services (except police) in Australia. Melbourne: trends in policing: explanatory and normative
stronger partnership approach between IBISWorld dimensions, in Sheptycki J & Wardak A (eds),
Transnational and comparative criminology.
private security and police in crime Mayhew P 2003. Counting the costs of crime in London: Glasshouse: 287–316
prevention. Australia. Trends & issues in crime and criminal
justice no. 247. http://www.aic.gov.au/
publications/tandi/tandi247.html
www.aic.gov.au 6