a cura di

3F9: : .H?G9DIBG
VERIFICA DI CAPACITÀ PORTANTE DI
3F9: : 2>99JIDJ

commissione
FONDAZIONI DIRETTE IN FASE SISMICA
!IGEIBFJBH "H 7IDJ<JBH @J BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI @J <GF@H;JGFJ @JDIEEI JF <HAI AJA=JBH6 BG=I
visto da:
DJB4JIAEG @HCCI *.-//6 FIBIAAJEH C0H@G;JGFI @J G??GDE>FI <GD=>CI A7J8
3F9: : ): %0)<<DI=G C>??HEI H ?HDEJDI @H JF@H9JFJ A?IDJ=IFEHCJ I AE>@J EIGDJBJ B4I EIF9HFG BGF8
3F9: ,: G;;IEEJ EG @I9CJ I<<IEEJ @ICC0H;JGFI AJA=JBH A>C AJAEI=H EIDDIFG8<GF@H;JGFI:
Premessa
, BH>AH @ICCI <GD;I @J JFID;JH JF@GEEI @HC AJA=H FIC EIDDIFG HC @J AGEEG @ICCH <GF@H;JGFI @JDIEEH AJ
?> =HFJ<IAEHDI >FH DJ@>;JGFI @IC BHDJBG CJ=JEI: ,C =G=IFEG CH FGD=H FGF <GDFJABI IA?CJBJEH JF@JBH8
;JGFI A> &>HCI =IEG@G >EJCJ;;HDI ?ID CH 7IDJ<JBH @J BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI JF <HAI AJA=JBH6 CHABJHF@G @J8
ABDI;JGFHCJE+ HC ?DG9IEEJAEH: 3F CIEEIDHE>DH BG=?HJGFG @J7IDAJ =IEG@J EDH B>J J =IEG@J @J .HABGFI6
HGC>BBJ  IBID6 H>9IDJ I 2JB4HD@A B4I 7IDDHFFG EDHEEHEJ JF AI9>JEG:

Verifiche agli stati limite ultimi

"H FGD=HEJ7H @I<JFJABI @>I @J<<IDIFEJ H??DGBBJ ?DG9IEE>HCJ6 G9F>FG BHDHEEIDJ;;HEG @H BG=1JFH;JGFJ
@IJ BGI<<JBJIFEJ ?HD;JHCJ #H=?CJ<JBH;JGFI @ICCI <GD;I6 DJ@>;JGFI @IJ ?HDH=IEDJ @J DIAJAEIF;H I 9CG1HCJ'6
CHABJHF@G CH ABICEH HC ?DG9IEEJAEH A> &>HCI H??DGBBJG >EJCJ;;HDI:
 ,??DGBBJG 5
.G=1JFH;JGFI 5( ,5525
.G=1JFH;JGFI -( ,--2-
 ,??DGBBJG -( ,552
*IC BHAG AEHEJBG 7HC9GFG J BGI<<JBJIFEJ ?HD;JHCJ @J H=?CJ<JBH;JGFI @ICCI H;JGFJ I @J DJ@>;JGFI @ICCI DI8
AJAEIF;I DJ?GDEHEJ FICCI EH1ICCI :-:36 :-:336 ::3 @ICCI *. FIC BHAG AJA=JBG J BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J H=?CJ<J8

2%3*) %)!"3 3*!)!*)23 %)"", 23*.3, %3 2,

BH;JGFI @ICCI H;JGFJ AGFG ?GAEJ ?HDJ H@ 5 BGF Tabella 1 - Coefficienti parziali R per le verifiche agli stati limite ultimi
>F BGFAI9>IFEI H99DH7JG AI AJ >EJCJ;;H CH STR e GEO di muri di sostegno (tab. 6.5.I NTC2008)
BG=1: - @ICC0,??DGBBJG 5 JF &>HFEG GCEDI HCCH DJ8 Verifica Coefficiente Coefficiente Coefficiente
@>;JGFI @ICCH DIAJAEIF;H 9CG1HCI BGFEI=?CH CH parziale parziale parziale
DJ@>;JGFI @IJ ?HDH=IEDJ 9IGEIBFJBJ: (R1) (R2) (R3)
3F =IDJEG HC BGI<<JBJIFEI ?HD;JHCI 26 CI *.-// .H?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI
@JAEJF9>GFG EDH <GF@H;JGFJ A>?ID<JBJHCJ I <GF@H8 @ICCH <GF@H;JGFI 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:
;JGFJ @J =>DJ @J AGAEI9FG6 @I<JFIF@G @>I @J7IDAJ BGDDJ=IFEG 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:5
BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J AJB>DI;;H 2 ?ID CH 7IDJ<JBH @J BH8
?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI #EH1ICCH 5 I -': 2IAJAEIF;H @IC EIDDIFG H 7HCCI 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:
ID J =>DJ @J AGAEI9FG
?DI7JAEG >F BGI<<JBJIFEI
JF<IDJGDI B4I ?ID=IEEI >F @J=IFAJGFH=IFEG ?J Tabella 2 - Coefficienti parziali R per le verifiche agli stati limite ultimi
DIHCJAEJBG @ICCI <GF@H;JGFJ: di fondazioni superficiali (tab. 6.4.I NTC2008)
Verifica Coefficiente Coefficiente Coefficiente
Definizione dell’azione sismica secondo la parziale parziale parziale
(R1) (R2) (R3)
normativa vigente
.H?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5: 2 $ -:
,C ?HDH9DH<G :55:::5 *.-//6 A>CCH AJB>DI;8
;H @IC BG=?CIAAG <GF@H;JGFI8EIDDIFG6 AJ HB8 BGDDJ=IFEG 2 $ 5:/ 2 $ 5:5 2 $ 5:5
BIFFH HCCH valutazione della resistenza con ap-
procci pseudo-statici se la determinazione del-
le azioni discende da un’analisi pseudo- Altri metodi di calcolo della capacità portante
statica: "H .JDBGCHDI F: 5 @IC -// HC ?HDH8 di fondazioni dirette in condizioni sismiche
9DH<G :55:::5 EDHEEH JC EI=H @ICCI <GF@H;JGFJ %H HFFJ AGFG FHEJ 7HDJ =IEG@J ?ID 7HC>EHDI JC BH8
A>?ID<JBJHCJ JF BGF@J;JGFJ AJA=JB4I JFEDG@>BIF@G DJBG CJ=JEI <GF@H;JGFIEIDDIFG JF BGF@J;JGFJ AJ8
J EI=J @J JFEIDH;JGFI JFID;JHCI I BJFI=HEJBH @IC A=JB4I B4I BGFAJ@IDHFG C0I<<IEEG BJFI=HEJBG
AJAEI=H EIDDIFG8AED>EE>DH8ICI7H;JGFI( l’azione #<GD;I @J JFID;JH H9IFEJ A>C AJAEI=H <GF@H;JGFI8
del sisma si traduce in accelerazioni nel sotto- EIDDIFG' H9JDI FGF AGCG A>C BGI<<JBJIFEI * =H
suolo (effetto cinematico, Khk ) e nella fondazio- HFB4I A>CCI HCEDI BG=?GFIFEJ @ICCH <GD=>CH;JG8
ne, per l’azione delle forze d’inerzia generate FI EDJFG=JH @J BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI @J DJFB4 HF8
nella struttura in elevazione (effetto inerziale, AIF: HCJ =IEG@J6 HCB>FJ @IJ &>HCJ BGFAJ@IDHEJ
Khi ). >F0IAEIFAJGFI @J EHCI <GD=>CH6 BGFAJ@IDHFG @IJ
"H .JDBGCHDI &>JF@J @JAEJF9>I @>I BGI<<JBJIFEJ BGI<<JBJIFEJ BGDDIEEJ7J B4I EIF9HFG H??>FEG BGF8
AJA=JBJ GDJ;;GFEHCJ I @I<JFJABI JF <>F;JGFI @J BG8 EG @ICC0JFEIDH;JGFI BJFI=HEJBH EDH <GF@H;JGFI I
AH BHCBGCHDCJ( Khi BG=I DH??GDEG # ' I CI9H Khk EIDDIFG:
HJ 7HCGDJ @J FGD=HEJ7H A?IBJ<JBHEJ ?ID J ?IF@JJ I ,CB>FJ @J &>IAEJ =IEG@J BGFAJ@IDHFG HFB4I C0JF8
&>JF@J HC BGI<<JBJIFEI @J DIH;JGFI GDJ;;GFEHCI @IC <C>IF;H @ICCH BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI @HC BGI<<JBJIFEI
EIDDIFG kh B4I H A>H 7GCEH @J?IF@I @H A #BGI<<J8 AJA=JBG 7IDEJBHCI6 ?HDJ HCCH =IE+ @IC BGI<<JBJIFEI
BJIFEI @J DJ@>;JGFI @ICC0HBBICIDH;JGFI =HAAJ=H GDJ;;GFEHCI:
HEEIAH HC AJEG ?ID J ?IF@JJ' I @H H=H #HBBICIDH8 Metodo di Paolucci e Pecker
;JGFI GDJ;;GFEHCI =HAAJ=H HEEIAH HC A>GCG': 3C =IEG@G EJIFI BGFEG @I9CJ I<<IEEJ BJFI=HEJBG I
JFID;JHCI >AHF@G >F H??DGBBJG BJFI=HEJBG #FG8
EG BG=I yield design theory' I BGFAJ@IDH CH BH8
?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI JF BH=?G AJA=JBG ?DG@GEEG @IC
"H .JDBGCHDI ?DGAI9>I <GDFIF@G JF@JBH;JGFJ A>J 7HCGDI JF BH=?G AEHEJBG I @J EDI BGI<<JBJIFEJ <>F8
?HDH=IEDJ @H =G@J<JBHDI FIC BHCBGCG @IC BHDJBG ;JGFI @HC BHDJBG GDJ;;GFEHCI @IDJ7HFEI @HCCH AG8
CJ=JEI #?HDH9DH<G :55:::5': 7DHAED>EE>DH6 @HCC0JFID;JH @IC EIDDIFG I @HCC0IB8
Metodo di Cascone BIFEDJBJE+ @IC BHDJBG:
J1CJG9DH<JBH=IFEI6 JC =IEG@G B4I ?J AJ H77JBJ8
FH H &>HFEG @IABDJEEG FICCH .JDBGCHDI  &>ICCG @J
.HABGFI B4I IA?CJBJEH @>I <HEEGDJ BGDDIEEJ7J @H @G7I(
H??CJBHDI HC BGI<<JBJIFEI * @J BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHF8  BHDJBG GDJ;;GFEHCI @HCCH AG7DHAED>EE>DH(
EI AEHEJBG:

 effetto cinematico  JFID;JH @IC EIDDIFG @J <GF@H;JGFI(

 effetto inerziale
 

 IBBIFEDJBJE+ @IC BHDJBG(

.GF@J;JGFI FIBIAAHDJH ?ID >EJCJ;;HDI vi  B4I

 AJH kh<tan:
%H 7HDJI HFHCJAJ @IC =IEG@G6 AJ I7JFBI B4I C0I<8
<IEEG BJFI=HEJBG  =G@IAEG DJA?IEEG H9CJ I<<IEEJ
JFID;JHCJ @G7>EJ HCCI H;JGFJ AJA=JB4I EDHA=IAAI
@HCCH AG7DHAED>EE>DH:
Metodo di Maugeri
HCI =IEG@G  AEHEG GEEIF>EG @H >FH AIDJI @J
HFHCJAJ F>=IDJB4I BGF@GEEI BGF H??DGBBJG ?AI>8
@G8AEHEJBG BGFAJ@IDHF@G AJH C0I<<IEEG BJFI=HEJBG
B4I JFID;JHCI: >IAEI HFHCJAJ 4HFFG @IEID=JFHEG
J <HEEGDJ @J BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI AJA=JBJ ?ID G9FJ
BGFEDJ1>EG I DH??GDEHF@GCJ BGF J DJA?IEEJ7J 7HCGDJ
AEHEJBJ 4HFFG ?GDEHEG HCCH 7HC>EH;JGFI @IJ EDI
BGI<<JBJIFEJ BGDDIEEJ7J hgf, hcf, hqf @H H??CJBHDI HJ
<HEEGDJ @J BH?HBJE+ AEHEJBH AIBGF@G CH AI9>IFEI J9>DH 5(
<GD=>CH;JGFI( Dati iniziali per il dimensionamento della fondazione
nel caso in esame.

@G7I(
 <HEEGDI @J ABGDDJ=IFEG(

 <HEEGDI @J BGIAJGFI(

 <HEEGDI @J AG7DHBBHDJBG(

3 BGI<<JBJIFEJ 6 .6 %6 )6 I 3 AGFG <>F;JGFJ @J

tan:
J9>DH -(
Metodo di Richards Variazione della larghezza B della fondazione e del
!CJ H>EGDJ 4HFFG DJBH7HEG CI IA?DIAAJGFJ @I9CJ coefficiente di sicurezza FS in funzione del metodo
HF9GCJ ,) I  ) B4I @I<JFJABGFG CI ;GFI @J A?JF8 adottato nei due approcci considerati.
EH HEEJ7H I ?HAAJ7H FIC =IBBHFJA=G @J DHF@EC I
J BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J A?JFEH HEEJ7H I ?HAAJ7H ,) I  )
JF <>F;JGFI @ICC0HF9GCG @0HEEDJEG @IC EIDDIFG6
@ICC0HF9GCG @J HEEDJEG
EIDDIFG8?HDIEI I @ICCI HB8
BICIDH;JGFJ AJA=JB4I 7 I 4: 3 BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J BH8
?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI ?GAAGFG &>JF@J <GD=>CHDAJ BGF(

Esempio numerico
3F &>IAEG ?HDH9DH<G 7JIFI H<<DGFEHEG >F BHAG @J
?DHEJBH ?DG9IEE>HCI JFIDIFEI JC @J=IFAJGFH=IFEG
@ICCH <GF@H;JGFI @JDIEEH @ICCH A?HCCH @J >F AGEEG8
?HAAG6 BGF<DGFEHF@G J =IEG@J ?DIBI@IFEI=IFEI
J9>DH (
Confronto dei risultati ottenuti dall’applicazione dei
vari metodi nei due approcci considerati per la deter-
minazione della larghezza B della fondazione dell’e-
sempio in esame.

2%3*) %)!"3 3*!)!*)23 %)"", 23*.3, %3 2,

 

@IABDJEEJ6 >EJCJ;;HF@G CI AGCCIBJEH;JGFJ @IDJ7HFEJ
@HCCH BG=1JFH;JGFI - @ICC0,??DGBBJG 5 I @HCCH
BG=1JFH;JGFI @ICC0,??DGBBJG - @ICCI *.-//:
"0G?IDH ?DIAH JF IAH=I @I7I DIAJAEIDI AG?DHE8
E>EEG H A?JFEI GDJ;;GFEHCJ HFHCG9H=IFEI H >F
=>DG @J AGAEI9FG6 =H @I7I HFB4I EDHA=IEEIDI
CI H;JGFJ 7IDEJBHCJ6 EDHA=IAAI @HCC0J=?HCBHEG HC
EIDDIFG: ID EHCJ =GEJ7J AJ HAA>=I @J AI9>JEG B4I
C0G?IDH FGF ?GAAH A>1JDI A?GAEH=IFEJ I &>JF@J
JC = @J DJ@>;JGFI @ICC0H;JGFI AJA=JBH  ?GAEG
?HDJ H 5 #?HDH9DH<G :55::-:5 *.-//': ID CH
@I<JFJ;JGFI @IJ BGI<<JBJIFEJ ?HD;JHCJ J AJ <HD+ DJ<I8
DJ=IFEG HCCH Tabella 1 A?IBJ<JBH ?ID CI 7IDJ<JB4I
H9CJ AEHEJ CJ=JEI >CEJ=J 2 I !) @IJ =>DJ @J AG8
AEI9FG:
*ICCI EH1ICCI I FIJ 9DH<JBJ AJ DJ?GDEHFG J @HEJ
@ICC0IAI=?JG I J DJA>CEHEJ GEEIF>EJ H??CJBHF@G J
@J7IDAJ =IEG@J IA?GAEJ FIJ ?HDH9DH<J ?DIBI@IFEJ
HCCI @J7IDAI BG=1JFH;JGFJ6 BGFAJ@IDHF@G >FH
<GF@H;JGFI FHAEDJ<GD=I JC B>J ?JHFG @J ?GAH  H
56 = @HC ?JHFG BH=?H9FH: ID AI=?CJBJE+ AJ
@IDI JF BGFAJ@IDH;JGFI FIC BHAG AJA=JBG I
&>HCJ FG #H@ IAI=?JG J BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J JFBCJFH8
;JGFI @IC BHDJBG':
2J9>HD@G JC &>HDEG ?>FEG JF<HEEJ6 JFAIDIF@G CI
AGCCIBJEH;JGFJ JF <HAI AJ=JBH6 EIFIF@G BGFEG @IC8
CH ?HD;JHCJ;;H;JGFI @ICCH AI;JGFI6 @IJ BGI<<J8

BJIFEJ @J JFBCJFH;JGFI @IC BHDJBG6 @ICC0H11HEEJ8
=IFEG @IJ ?HDH=IEDJ =IBBHFJBG89IGEIBFJBJ @IJ
EIDDIFJ6 I @IJ BGI<<JBJIFEJ DJ@>EEJ7J ?ID JC BHAG AJ8
A=JBG6 AJ ?GEDI11I BGDDIDI JC DJAB4JG @J >FH @DH8
AEJBH I JDDIHCJAEJBH DJ@>;JGFI @ICCH BH?HBJE+ ?GD8
EHFEI6 BGF JC BGFAI9>IFEI AG7DH@J=IFAJGFH8
=IFEG @ICCI <GF@H;JGFJ:
3 =IEG@J ?DIAIFEJ JF CIEEIDHE>DH G<<DGFG <GD=>CH8
;JGFJ B4I @JABIF@GFG @H BGFBIEEJ I H??DGBBJ
?DG9IEE>HCJ AGAEHF;JHC=IFEI @J7IDAJ: 3F <>E>DG 
H>A?JBH1JCI B4I BGC ?DG9DI@JDI @I9CJ AE>@J @ICCH
9IGEIBFJBH AJA=JBH6 9DH;JI HCC0H>=IFEG @ICCH
BGFGABIF;H @IJ ?HDH=IEDJ @IC EIDDIFG I BGF C0>8
EJCJ;;G @J =IEG@J @J BHCBGCG AI=?DI ?J AG<JAEJBH8
EJ6 AJ 9J>F9H H@ >FH <GD=>CH;JGFI B4I FGF CHABJ
BGFAJ@IDH 7$/: #J99:56-6':
Conclusioni
%HCC0IAI=?JG DJ?GDEHEG I @H HCEDJ ?DIAIFEJ JF CIE8
EIDHE>DH6 DJA>CEH B4I H??CJBHDI CH <GD=>CH @J
DJFB48 HFAIF HC BHAG AJA=JBG AIF;H >CEIDJGDJ
7HC>EH;JGFJ6 ?GDEJ H >F @J=IFAJGFH=IFEG =IFG
BH>EICHEJ7G DJA?IEEG H@ HCEDJ =IEG@J B4I JF7IBI
JFBC>@GFG IA?CJBJEH=IFEI 9CJ I<<IEEJ @IC AJA=H:
3FGCEDI  I7J@IFEI B4I6 H ?HDJE+ @J =IEG@G6 C0,?8
?DGBBJG 5 BGF@>BH AI=?DI H @J=IFAJGFJ @J <GF8
@H;JGFJ =H99JGDJ6 G HC ?J >9>HCJ6 DJA?IEEG HC8
C0,??DGBBJG -:
%IEEG BJ6 FICCH ?DHEJBH ?DG9IEE>HCI6 J @>11J @IJ
?DG<IAAJGFJAEJ 7IDEGFG ?DJFBJ?HC=IFEI A>CCI AI8
9>IFEJ &>IAEJGFJ B4I DJ=HF9GFG E>EEGDH JDDJAGCEI(
5' CH ?GAAJ1JCJE+ @J >EJCJ;;HDI >F =IEG@G @J 7IDJ8
<JBH @J7IDAG @H &>ICCG HBBIFFHEG FICCH .JD8
BGCHDI B4I AJH 9J>AEJ<JBH1JCI I @J BG=?DG7H8
@J B>J HC % 5 9IFFHJG -//
 .H?JEGCG :
EH H<<J@H1JCJE+  .GCCIAICCJ :  HF;IFJ ,: #-/5'( HC>EH;JGFI
-' CH ?GAAJ1JCJE+ @J H11HEEIDI C0H;JGFI AJA=JBH
>EJCJ;;HF@G J BGI<<JBJIFEJ A6 1HAHF@G &>IAEH
: I=JFHDJG .3, IDGFH:
HAA>F;JGFI A> @HEJ EIGDJBG8A?IDJ=IFEHCJ B4I
G99J H??HJGFG BHDIFEJ #-/5-'( .HCBGCG @ICCH BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI JF ;GFH
' CH ?GAAJ1JCJE+ @J @J<<IDIF;JHDI I BGFEIAE>HCJ;8
;HDI J BGI<<JBJIFEJ @J AJB>DI;;H ?ID JC BHAG AJ8
:
A=JBG !,6 /8:
' CH ?GAAJ1JCJE+ @J 7HC>EHDI &>HCJ BGI<<JBJIFEJ DJ8
@>EEJ7J ?DIAIFEJ FICCH <GD=>CH EDJFG=JH ?DIF8
A?H;JG HJ @>11J HEE>HC=IFEI JF BGDAG: ,C =G8
=IFEG CH DHBBG=HF@H;JGFI  &>ICCH @J ?DI<IDJDI
<GD=>CH;JGFJ @J BHCBGCG A?IBJ<JB4I ?ID JC BHAG AJ8
A=JBG6 GEEIF>EI @H AE>@J ?J DIBIFEJ I @IEEH9CJH8
EJ:
ID >F0HFHCJAJ ?J H=?JH I H??DG<GF@JEH I ?ID
>F BGF<DGFEG EDH 7HDJ =IEG@J BGFGABJ>EJ ?ID JC @J8
=IFAJGFH=IFEG @ICCI <GF@H;JGFJ A>?ID<JBJHCJ JF
BGF@J;JGFJ AJA=JB4I #JF ?DIAIF;H @J EIDDIFJ AH18
1JGAJ' AJ DJ=HF@H HCC0HDEJBGCG @J DHFBIAB4JFJ :6
.HD1GFICCH 2:6 2JA?GCJ : #-/5-':
""#"#
 *>G7I FGD=I ?ID CI BGAED>;JGFJ @IC -//  .H8
?JEGCJ 8:
 .JDBGCHDI F:5-// 3AED>;JGFJ ?ID C0H??CJBH;JG8
FI @ICCI *>G7I FGD=I EIBFJB4I ?ID CI BGAED>;JG8
FJ
@ICCH BH?HBJE+ ?GDEHFEI @ICCI <GF@H;JGFJ @JDIEEI
I ?DG<GF@I JF BGF@J;JGFJ AJA=JB4I BGF =G@ICCJ
AI=?CJ<JBHEJ
 DHFBIAB4JFJ :  .HD1GFICCH 2:  2JA?GCJ :
AJA=JBH @J <GF@H;JGFJ A>?ID<JBJHCJ JF EIDDIFJ AH18
1JGAJ( HFHCJAJ @IJ ?DJFBJ?HCJ =IEG@J @J BHCBGCG6 DJ8
A7GCEJ FGD=HEJ7J I@ H??CJBH;JGFJ F>=IDJB4I

2%3*) %)!"3 3*!)!*)23 %)"", 23*.3, %3 2,