Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Abstract
Background: India has a large population using antiretroviral drugs (ARV) which has potential
therapeutic efficacy and high toxic properties resulting in diverse adverse drug reactions (ADRs).
Adherence to the ART is a crucial challenge to be addressed as it plays a major role in the success of HIV
management. Aim: To determine the prescribing pattern of antiretroviral drugs uses at an ART center
and the levels of adherence to the drugs and the associated adverse effects. Materials and methods: It is
a retrospective analysis of the clinical records related to HIV-infected adults who were receiving
treatment at an ART Center in Andhra Pradesh state. The main outcomes of the study are demographic
details of the patients, the pattern of ART combinations prescribed, adherence to the given ART, and
analysis of reported ADRs. Simple descriptive statistics and chi-square tests are the statistics used to
measure the outcomes. Results: A total of 430 HIV patients’ records were selected and
assessed. Tenofovir (TAF) + Lamivudine (3TC) +Efavirenz (EFV) (66.5%) were the most prescribed ARV
combination. The majority of 348 patients (80.9%) was good adherence and showed a significant
association with therapeutic outcomes. The most common clinical ADRs found in this study were
gastrointestinal disturbances (30.9%) followed by dermatological problems (20.4 %). Conclusion: Despite
drug toxicity, ART treatment bears potential therapeutic efficacy and is considered as the only means to
increase life expectancy in HIV infected patients. Detailed patient counseling and monitoring improve
therapeutic outcomes and patients adherence.
however, the prognosis of the diseases can be with ART in India; however there is paucity
controlled and prevented by effective in data from Andhra Pradesh state in India.
antiretrovirals (ARVs). By 2018, there are In this instance we aimed to determine the
62% of adults and 54 % of children receiving prescribing pattern of antiretroviral drugs
lifelong antiretroviral therapy (ART) in low- uses at an ART center. Also, we determined
and middle-income countries. Adherence to the levels of adherence to the drugs and the
the ART enables HIV patients to gain associated adverse effects.
potential for normal or near-normal life
Materials and Methodology
expectancy [1].
Study Design
Once initiated, the ART treatment should be
continued throughout the lifetime. Over a We retrospectively analyzed the clinical
period, there might be an instance of missing records of HIV-infected adults who were
doses and experience of side effects and receiving treatment at the ART Center, Old
ADRs. There are 6 classes of drugs used in Government general hospital, located in
combinations in ART include the Vijayawada city, Andhra Pradesh state in
nucleoside/nucleotide reverse transcriptase South India between January 2019 and
inhibitors (NRTIs), the non-nucleoside January 2020. The clinic is held every
reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs), Monday through Friday, where many AIDS
the protease inhibitors (PIs), the fusion patients around the state receive
inhibitors (FIs), the CCR5 antagonists, and antiretroviral therapy throughout the year.
the integrase strand transfer inhibitors
(INSTIs) [4]. This center maintains computer-based
clinical data of all the patients receiving ART
Positive therapeutic outcomes are possible which includes, demographic details,
only on 100 % adherence to the given medication history, patient response to the
treatment. Non- adherence may not only lead drugs, etc., The ARV (antiretroviral) drugs
to treatment failure but may also result in a are dispensed free of charge, monthly, to
fatal condition called antimicrobial about 4,000 registered HIV infected patients
resistance, which means the drugs can no including men, pregnant and non-pregnant
longer act effectively on the viral loads. In a women, and children from different parts of
study, it is said “all or nothing”, which means the Andhra Pradesh state.
it would be better to take no drugs at all than
to have adherence of less than 90% [5, 6]. Inclusion Criteria
Adherence was expressed in a study by Only adult patients (male and female) were
Arnsten et al. as the number of doses taken included in this study. Other inclusion
as a percentage of the total number of doses criteria were patients older than 12 years,
prescribed. For example, if the patient takes non-pregnant women confirmed HIV
28 doses out of 30 prescribed doses the infection with western blot test, patients with
adherence is 95%. Medication adherence can or without AIDS presentation according to
be said as all the prescribed drugs taken the criteria set out by the World Health
every day on prescribed time [7]. Organization (WHO) [8].
Given the rapid prevalence of HIV in India, The patient must have been enrolled on ART
there is a paucity of medical literature on only at the ART Center, Old Government
adherence to ART among HIV patients in general hospital, Vijayawada and they must
Asia. Despite showing potential therapeutic have used ARV drugs, at least once, after
effects, ART is associated with a wide range enrolment. Patient’s complete demographic
of mild to fatal ADRs leading to patient’s information and prescribed medications
non-adherence and treatment failure. Hence should be documented in the case files.
ADRs play a significant role in the success of Patients who died during treatment nor
the ART program. In developing countries stopped or changed treatment were also
like India, ADRs are not being properly included in the study.
reported are being overlooked until the
emergence of active pharmacovigilance Exclusion Criteria
activities in recent years. This made the
Children and pregnant women are a special
availability of ample literature on ADR
population group that was excluded.
reported among HIV patients treated
From Table 2, total 11 different for the treatment of HIV in 430 patients, of
Antiretroviral combinations were prescribed which Tenofovir (TAF)+ Lamivudine (3TC)
Generalized weakness 21 10
Others 0
Fever 37 17.61905
Hepatitis 1 0.47619
Pancreatitis 1 0.47619
Weight loss 5 2.380952
Anemia 15 7.142857
Total 210 100
Death 71
Discussion
The present study aimed to highlight the The most frequently prescribed combinations
most used ART combinations at an ART were Tenofovir (TAF) + Lamivudine (3TC)
center in Andhra Pradesh and the ADRs +Efavirenz (EFV). These combinations and
reported during their use. A total of 11 others prescribed are consistent with the
different ARV combinations are used, among guidelines of the WHO (2019). The same
them, Tenofivir + Lamivudine + Efavirenz combination TLE was majorly prescribed
(56%) was most frequently prescribed and (66.4%) in Allahabad [12]. While in a similar
these are consistent with the guidelines of study at an African country Nigeria, reported
WHO and the national guidelines for the use 23 different ARV drug combinations were
of ARV drugs in India [1, 10]. When prescribed, of which AZT-3TC-NVP followed
compared to prescribing practices in other by D4T-3TC-NVP where majorly prescribed
countries like Nigeria where 23 different [11].
ARV drug combinations have been used in a
single clinic, our study site was evident for Medication Adherence is the key to the
adhering to rational prescribing guidelines success of ART and in our present study 19 %
[11]. had poor adherence. A systematic review and
meta-analysis study done by Mhaskar et al
In our study female (51.2 %) patients were on adherence to ART in India showed the
slightly higher than men. The most pooled adherence rate was only 70% [13].
concerning issue is the majority of females When compared with the adherence rate
are in their reproductive ages and married reported in different studies across India,
with low educational status. This is evident this study shows analogous results [12]. Rate
that most of them are infected by unprotected of adherence is appreciable in the present
sex from the sexual partner due to a lack of ART center when compared with the result in
sex education. Even though many national other parts of Andhra Pradesh where 49.9%
HIV awareness programs are being executed, had poor adherence [14].In our study,
they may not have enlightened these people. Tenofivir + Lamivudine + Efavirenz (TLE)
(56%) accounted for the majority of ARDs thereby results in good therapeutic
followed by Zidovudine + Lamivudine + responses. In-country like India, ADR
Nevirapine (ZLN) (31.2%) regimen. This reporting by the patients is not an active
might be because TLE was a highly process, hence many considerable ADRs are
prescribed combination with a potential left unreported which have been indirectly
therapeutic efficacy and fewer toxicities being associated with patient's non-adherence and
reported than Zidovudine combinations. thereby treatment failure. Detailed
While in other studies, ZLN combination counseling before initiation of ART along
accounts for the majority of ADRs, with clinical and laboratory monitoring can
Zidovudine was responsible for the majority improve the condition.
of adverse events said in a study by Anita
shet et al., [15-17]. There are certain limitations in the study
like, surveillance data used in the study did
In our present study, a total of 210 ADRs not grade the severity of ADRs and there was
were reported among them, gastrointestinal no information on the medical history of the
disturbances (30.9%) followed by patient before initiation of ART. As it is a
dermatological problems (20.4 %) accounts retrospective study, re-challenges and de-
for the highest numbers. A similar result was challenge are not possible. Hence causality
observed in the study by Anita Shet et al., assessment is not being performed in this
were gastrointestinal disturbances (15.8 %), study. A further limitation of analysis
generalized fatigue (10.7 %), rash (6.3 %), includes, there was no data on co-
and anemia (10.3 %) [17]. While in another administered medication and treatments as
study, reported, Anemia (76.52%) was the well.
commonest ADR reported followed by skin
rash (11.36 %) [15]. Indian retrospective Conclusion
studies where similar regimens were used Despite drug toxicity, ART treatment bears
have noted ADR incidence rates of 34–53% potential therapeutic efficacy and is
[18, 19]. In our study, ADRs were observed considered as the only means to increase life
in patients who had baseline CD4 count < expectancy in HIV infected patients. Our
250 cells/μl. present study is a retrospective study with
certain limitations. Our present study does
Similar results were observed in a study from
not suggest discontinuation of treatment on
Kadapa, India that patients with a CD4
presentation of toxic effects or use safer
count of <250cells/μl was affected with more
alternative treatments. We would suggest
ADRs [19, 20]. Hence we suggest estimation
detailed counseling and monitoring improve
of ADRs based on the CD4 T- cell count at
the therapeutic outcomes and patients
initiation of therapy. This would aid in
adherence. Updating of national guidelines
accurate follow-up and decrease the chance of
with WHO guidelines can also result in good
ADR events, hence improve adherence and
therapeutic outcome.
References
1. HIV/AIDS (2019) Available from: update-2019-policy/en/. [Last assessed on
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact- 2019 Dec 06].
sheets/detail/hiv-aids. [Last assessed on
5. Sethi AK, Celentano DD, Gange SJ, Moore
2019 Dec 06].
RD, Gallant JE (2003) Association
2. National AIDS Control Organization. HIV between adherence to antiretroviral
facts and figures. Available from: therapy and human immunodeficiency
http://naco.gov.in/hiv-facts-figures. [Last virus drug resistance. Clin Infect Dis.,
assessed on 2019 Dec 06]. 37(8):1112-8.
3. Lewthwaite P, Wilkins E (2005) Natural 6. Cauldbeck MB, O'Connor C, O'Connor MB,
History of HIV/AIDS. Medicine, 33: 6. Saunders JA, Rao B, Mallesh VG, Kumar
NK, Mamtha G, McGoldrick C, Laing RB,
4. Update of recommendations on first- and
Satish KS (2009) Adherence to anti-
second-line antiretroviral regimens (2019)
retroviral therapy among HIV patients in
World health organization. Available
Bangalore, India. AIDS research and
from: https://www.who.int/hiv/pub/arv/arv-
therapy, 6(1):7.