Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fulltext PDF
Fulltext PDF
12, 1708–1715
1
Ege University, Faculty
Oxidation of Benzene to Maleic Anhydride
of Engineering, Department in a Fluidized Bed Reactor
of Chemical Engineering,
Bornova-Izmir, Turkey.
In this project, the selective oxidation of benzene to maleic anhydride (MAN)
was studied. Gas phase catalytic oxidation of benzene was carried out in a labora-
tory scale fluidized bed reactor on six different types of catalysts, which have dif-
ferent compositions. Effects of temperature, flow rates of benzene and air and cat-
alyst type on the reaction selectivity were investigated at atmospheric pressure.
The experiments were performed over a temperature range of 325 to 400 °C, a
space-time (W/FA0) range from 11.28 × 105 to 31.9 × 105 g s mol–1, and benzene/
air mole ratio changes between 0.0109 and 0.0477. It was seen that conversion of
benzene to MAN increased with increasing temperature for the catalysts sup-
ported by silica gel, aluminum oxide and titanium oxide. From the results it was
found that conversion increased with increasing flow rate of air. When the com-
parison of the catalysts were made, it could be said that catalysts supported by
silica gel showed higher MAN conversions. So it can be concluded that catalysts
supported by silica gel were more suitable catalysts for benzene oxidation to
MAN in a fluidized bed reactor.
The most widely used catalysts in the production of MAN 2 Experimental Section
include vanadium pentaoxide (V2O5), molybdenum trioxide
(MoO3) and sodium oxide (Na2O). Catalysts proposed in the 2.1 Catalyst Preparation
literature have difficult production processes and expensive sup-
ports such as aluminium, magnesium, zirconium, beryllium In this study, six different types of catalysts were prepared to
and titanium. It is seen that the catalysts supported by silica gel investigate the oxidation of benzene to MAN. The composi-
and superacidic catalysts can also be used in the oxidation pro- tions of them are given in Tab. 1.
cesses [6, 7]. The catalytic performances are sometimes affected
by the crystal phase of the titania support, anastase and rutile,
because of differences in the dispersion of vanadia and the for- 2.1.1 Catalyst 1
mation of reduced vanadium ions. The preparation methods
and conditions are the critical factors for the catalytic perfor- This catalyst is prepared by following the procedure in the pat-
mance and the structure of supported vanadium oxide. Impreg- ent by R. Marg [18]. Silica-gel is initially treated with 72 mL
nation, flash hydrolysis, chemical vapor deposition, grafting HCl, 14.4 mL HNO3 and 57.6 mL H2O in porcelain basin.
and chemical liquid deposition are preparation methods [8]. Secondly, V2O5 slurried with water and kept at around 80 °C
Polyoxometalates (POMs) are finding increasing use as cata- by heating on a hot plate. Powdered oxalic acid is added to the
lysts for the selective oxidation of several alkanes, aldehydes slurry in a small quantity (solution A). Ammonium molybdate
and acids. POMs are the most active and selective systems for is dissolved in water (solution B) and nickel nitrate is dissolved
oxidation reactions; however, yields achieved are not high in water (solution C). A 36 mL mixture of this solutions (pre-
enough to justify a commercial exploitation of the reaction. In pared by mixing of solutions A, B, and C) is kept on the sand
general, POMs having diavelent/trivalent transition metal cat- bath for 10–12 hour at 100 °C. After descending of the acid
ions in the secondary framework have been the subject of sev- from solution, water is drained off and the gel is dried in an
eral recent investigations, since the presence of these elements oven. The gel is then spread out in silica trays and left in a
may considerably affect catalytic performance [9–14]. muffle furnace. The temperature is gradually raised to 700 °C
The catalyst generally used for the selective oxidation of in 5 hours and maintained at this temperature for 2 hours.
benzene to MAN consists of vanadium-phosphorus-oxide
(VPO). The most important catalytic component in benzene
oxidation is V2O5. A catalyst for this purpose is usually modi- 2.1.2 Catalyst 2
fied by addition of MoO3. To improve the performance of the
catalyst, V2O5 and MoO3 have been combined with oxidized The second catalyst is prepared based on a receipt cited in the
forms of one or more metal oxides. These complex mixtures of literature [19]. Concentrated HCl, ammonium paramolybdate
oxides may be used as such in the form of powder, grains or and ammonium metavanadate are mixed perfectly stirred for a
agglomerates. In a fluidized bed, where the catalyst particles few minutes. The following solutions are prepared separately;
will continuously collide with each other and with the reactor first, a solution of 0.79 parts trisodium phosphate in 3.59 parts
internals, the catalyst must have a high attrition resistance. water; second, a solution of 0.64 parts bismuth nitrate in 1.28
Suciu et al. who, have been developing various methods to
enhance this attrition resistance of a VPO catalyst, for Table 1. Compositions of the catalysts.
instance, have found that treatment of the catalyst pre-
cursor with acid results in an agglomeration of catalyst Type of the carrier Cat. 1 Cat. 2 Cat. 3 Cat. 4 Cat. 5 Cat. 6
particles [15]. Another method to improve the attri- and % by weight
Silica gel Al2O3 No Titanium Silica gel No
tion resistance of VPO catalysts is the incorporation of
(72) (83.3) carrier oxide (91.34) (72) carrier
silica into the fluidized-bed catalyst by addition of a
colloidal silica sol. However, this method results in a CompositionsV2O5 53.6 63.99 – 100 53.6 36.263
decreased selectivity to maleic anhydride as well [16]. of active
Overbeek developed a preparation procedure which ingredient,
was cheaper and much more controllable than the wt %
preparation procedures of VPO catalyst. However, the MoO3 35.7 30.82 7.17 – 21.44 54.34
newly developed supported VPO catalysts did not
P2O5 – 0.92 – – 6.25 –
show reasonable catalytic performance (yield <20 %).
In general, titania-supported catalysts are much more NiO 10.7 1.15 – – 6.25 –
active than their silica counterparts. However, silica- Na2O – 1.2 – – 6.25 –
supported catalysts are much more selective, resulting
in better overall yields [17]. Bi2O3 – 1.92 – – – –
The aim of this study is to prepare catalysts by fol- ZrO2 – – 92.83 – – –
lowing the recommendations in the literature, to char-
acterize and to test them to investigate the influences B2O3 – – – – 6.25 –
of parameters such as catalyst type, temperature, space H3PO4 – – – – – 4.625
time and benzene/air mol ratio on the oxidation of
KNO3 – – – – – 4.772
benzene in a laboratory scale fluidized bed reactor.
parts water; and third, 0.71 parts nickel nitrate in 2.27 parts 2.1.5 Catalyst 5
H2O. These three solutions are then added to the hydrochloric
solution, and the mixed solution is stirred. 100 g of aluminum Catalyst 5 is prepared like Catalyst 1. The carrier is same as the
oxide is added to this solution as support. The coating opera- first catalyst but the active ingredients are different. A molar
tion is carried out by slow evaporation with continuous stir- ratio between V2O5, and MoO3 in 2.72 g silica gel is treated
ring of the solution. Finally, the catalyst is calcined at approxi- with 200 mL HCl, 40 mL HNO3 and 360 mL H2O in a porce-
mately 400 °C for 4 hours in a furnace. lain basin.
Solution A: 15 g V2O5 is slurried with 150 mL water and
kept at around 80 °C by heating on a hot plate. Powdered oxa-
2.1.3 Catalyst 3 lic acid (41.82 g) is added to the slurry in a small quantity with
stirring until the V2O5 is completely dissolved, giving a deep
Zr(OH)4 is impregnated with molybdic acid (H2MoO4) dis- blue solution. Solution B: 7.28 g of ammonia molybdate is
solved in 3.56 mL of ammonium hydroxide (25 %) and dissolved in 72 mL of hot water. Solution C: 6.153 g of nickel
26.7 mL of water followed by evaporating the water at room nitrate is dissolved in water. Solution D: 4.793 g of sodium
temperature, drying and calcining in air. The formulation and borate is dissolved in water. Solution E: 20.35 g sodium phos-
preparation technique of superacidic catalyst are proposed by phate is dissolved in water. Solutions A, B, C, D and E are
K. Arata [20]. mixed together and poured on to the silica gel previously pre-
pared. The mixture is kept heated on a sand bath at around
100 °C with frequent stirring. When the mixture dries to a
2.1.4 Catalyst 4 fairly loose powder, it is transferred to an air oven maintained
at 105–110 °C and heated until it becomes a fairly free flowing
V2O5/TiO2 catalyst is prepared by impregnation of TiO2 with powder (usually 5–7 h). Lastly, the impregnated silica gel is
a NH4VO3 solution according to the method described by Sat- transferred into a muffle furnace. The temperature is gradually
suma et al. [8]. NH4VO3 is dissolved in oxalic acid solution. raised to 500 °C in around 5 h and maintained at this level for
After addition of TiO2, the solution is evaporated with stirring 2 h.
until it becomes a pasty cake or a powder. The solid thus
obtained is dried at 110 °C and calcined at 500 °C for 7 h.
2.1.6 Catalyst 6
2.2 Apparatus
2.2.1 Air Supply Section Table 2. The powers of heaters and geometrical parameters of
the reactor.
Air stream used as reactant is obtained from the dry air cylin-
Reactor material AISI 316 SS
der. A valve and a rotameter are used to adjust the flow rate of
the dry air stream. First, the air stream is passed through a sili- Heater power supply 250 W
ca gel column to remove any water. Before the air is mixed Preheater power supply 300 W
with benzene, it is heated to 150–200 °C by passing it through
the electric preheater. HR 420 mm
DR 25.4 mm
A cooler is placed to cool the hot gas mixture leaving the reac-
2.2.3 Reactor tor. The gas contains MAN, unreacted benzene, by-products
and excess air. The cooler is a shell and tube type apparatus
A fluidized bed reactor with a 25.4 mm (1″) inside diameter and contains 14 tubes of 8 mm diameter and 500 mm length.
and 420 mm length is used for the reaction (see Fig. 2). It was Tap water is circulated through the shell side of the cooler.
made of AISI-316 SS. The catalyst is placed into the reactor
and two 300 mesh sieves are placed at the bottom and at the
exit of the reactor to support and to prevent the escape of the 2.2.5 Absorber Columns/Traps
powder catalyst. An electrical heater wound around the reactor
is used for heating. Glass wool is used insulating the reactor. The cooled stream leaving the cooler is passed through two
The reaction temperature is controlled through a PID temper- traps. One of these traps is filled with ice-salt mixture and the
ature controller connected to an iron-constantan type Cole- other is cooled with a circulating water-alcohol mixture. Traps
Palmer probe thermocouple. The powers of the heaters and are connected in series. The collected products are weighted
geometrical parameters of the reactor are listed in Tab. 2. and analyzed by using the gas chromatograph.
– The low rate of air is adjusted by the valve on the calibrated 4 Results and Discussion
rotameter and sent to the preheater and then the reactor.
– The effluent passes through the cooler, and then it goes In this study, by using six different type of catalysts, selective
through the traps. Flow rate of exit gas and CO2 % are mea- oxidation of benzene to MAN was studied in a fluidized bed
sured at specified time intervals. The uncondensed gas is reactor. During the experiments, effects of temperature, type
purged to the atmosphere. of catalyst, space-time, and benzene/air mole ratio on the reac-
– At the end of the experiment (after 2 hours), the pump is tion were investigated. Operating conditions are given in
switched off. Tab. 3.
– The preheater and reactor are cooled down. Air is passed for
a while and then it is stopped Table 3. Operating conditions in the experiments.
– The product mixture, which is obtained at each experiment
collected in the traps, are washed with 2 mL acetone and Parameter Range
then analyzed with a Hewlett Packard 5890 Series II Gas
Reactor temperature, TR (°C) 325–400
Chromatograph with flame ionization detector and HP inte-
–1
grator. Space time (W/FB0), (g s mole ) 11.28 · 105–31.9 · 105
Catalyst amount, (g) 13–94
x1
Total Selectivity (5) Figure 3. Temperature vs. conversion for nearly constant W/
xT FB0 = 18.38 g s molB–1 and benzene/air mole ratio is in the
range of 0.0109–0.0477.
Figure 8. The adsorption isotherms of fresh Catalyst 4. Figure 11. Pore size distribution of experienced Catalyst 4.
Figure 10. Pore size distribution of fresh Catalyst 4. Figure 13. Pore size distribution of experienced Catalyst 6.
MAN could be obtained. Pore size distribution of the experi- V [mL] volume
enced and the fresh catalysts are shown in Figs. 12 and 13. It is Vm [cm3/g] volume of catalyst
seen from Figs. 12 and 13 that pore size distribution of both X [%] conversion
catalysts are almost same. It is also easily seen from Tab. 4 that
adsorption volume of experienced catalyst is almost the same
as the fresh catalyst. References
When the comparison of all catalysts is made, it can be said
that Catalyst 1 had higher performance than the other cata- [1] Kirk-Othmer, Encyclopedia of Chemical Process and Design
lysts. In the experiments carried out over Catalyst 1, the high- Vol.14, Marcel Dekker, New York 1977.
est MAN conversions were obtained. It can be concluded that [2] http://www.vanadium.com.au/ScienceStuff/Chemistry/
Catalyst 1 is a more suitable catalyst for benzene oxidation to MaleicAnhydride.htm.
MAN in a fluidized bed reactor. The results also indicate that: [3] K. Lohbeck, H. Hafercorn, W. Fuhrmann, Ullmann’s Encyclo-
– V2O5 and MoO3 are essential active components. pedia of Industrial Chemistry Vol. A16, Wiley-VCH, Wein-
– SiO2 as a support is more suitable than Al2O3 and titanium heim 1992.
oxide. [4] H. R. Hakimelahi, R. Sotudh-Gharebagh, N. Mostoufi, Int.
J. Chem. Reactor Eng. 2006, 4, A23.
[5] J. Werther, Ger. Chem. Eng. 1983, 6, 228.
Symbols used [6] G. C. Bond, P. Forzatti, J. C. Vedrine, Cat. Today 2000, 56 (4),
329.
A [m2/g] surface area [7] http://www.cm.utexas.edu/academic/courses/Fall1998/
C [–] constant CH38/AlkaneCatalysis.htm
DD [mm] diameter of the gas distributor cap [8] A. Satsuma, S. Takenaka, T. Tanaka, App Cat., A 2002,
DR [mm] inside diameter of the reactor 232 (1–2), 93.
DGD [mm] inside diameter of the gas distributor [9] E. Etienne et al., App. Cat., A 2003, 256, 275.
F [mol/s] flow rate [10] N. K. Kala Raj, V. G. Puranik, C. Gopinathan, A. V. Ramas-
FB0 [mol/s] flow rate of benzene wamy, App. Cat., A 2003, 256, 265.
G.C. [–] gas chromatography [11] F. C. Jentoft et al., App. Cat., A 2003, 256, 291.
hR [mm] length of the reactor [12] J. C. Dillon, J. H. Holles, M. E. Davis, J. A. Labinger, Cat. To-
HD [mm] length of the gas distributor day 2003, 81 (2), 189.
HR [mm] length of the reactor [13] M. E. Davis, C. J. Dillon, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2002, 41 (5),
MAN [–] maleic anhydride 858.
M, m, wt [g] mass [14] A. S. C. Brown, J. S. J. Hargraves, S. H. Taylor, Cat. Today
MW [g/mol] molecular mass 2000, 59, 403.
n [mol] mole number [15] G. D. Suciu, G. Stefani, C. Fumagalli, UK Patent 2145010A,
P [atm] pressure 1985.
q [g/mL] density [16] H. Taheri, US Patent 5 011 945, 1991.
S.S. [–] stainless steel [17] R. A. Overbeek, Ph.D. Thesis, Utrecht University 1994.
t [s] time [18] R. Marg, India Patent 129962, 1971.
T [°C] temperature [19] A. Di Cio, A. Vitali, European Patent 0 037 020 B1, 1981.
TC [–] temperature controller [20] K. Arata, App Cat., A 1996, 1, 146.
W [g] mass of catalyst [21] http://www.refiningonline.com/EngelhardKB/crep/
W/FAO [g s mol–1] space-time TCR1_2.htm.