Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hans Günter Brauch, Adj. Prof. (PD) at the Free University of Berlin, chairman of AFES-PRESS, senior
fellow at UNU-EHS in Bonn and editor of this series; he publishes on security and environment issues.
Úrsula Oswald Spring, Professor at UNAM-CRIM, Mexico; first UNU-EHS chair on social vulnerability;
she writes on sustainability, development, gender, disaster, poverty and collaborates with peasants.
1
John Grin, Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Amsterdam; he publishes on societal
Environmental Change,
mental Law Research Centre, Nairobi; she writes on law, development, property, environment and gender.
Jörn Birkmann, Adj. Prof. (PD) at Bonn University, Head, Vulnerability Assessment, Risk Management and
Adaptive Planning Section, United Nations University, Institute for Environment and Human Security.
ISSN 1865-5793
Threats, Challenges, Vulnerabilities and Risks
ISBN 978-3-540-xxxxx-x
All chapters were anonymously peer reviewed. This is the third and
final volume of the Global Environmental and Human Security
Handbook for the Anthropocene (GEHSHA).
HESP / VOL 5 13
Contents
Forewords
Achim Steiner,
Executive Director of the United Nations Environment
Programme (UNEP) and
Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations V
Konrad Osterwalder,
Rector, United Nations University and
Under-Secretary-General of the United Nation VII
Jean-François Bureau,
NATO Assistant Secretary General for Public Diplomacy
Chairman, Science for Peace and Security (SPS) Committee IX
Joy Ogwu,
Permanent Representative of the Federal Republic of Nigeria
to the United Nations in New York XI
HRH Prince El Hassan bin Talal,
The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan XIII
Dedications XV
Acknowledgements XXVII
Prefaces 1
The Anthropocene: Geology by Mankind 3
Paul Crutzen, Nobel Laureate for Chemistry
Max Planck Institute for Chemistry
Department Atmospheric Chemistry
Connecting Inconvenient Truths: Urgency of Nuclear Disarmament in a World of
Pressing Problems 5
Amb. Jayantha Dhanapala,
Former UN Under-Secretary General for Disarmament,
President, Pugwash Conferences on Science and World Affairs
Living in and Coping with World Risk Society 11
Ulrich Beck
Population Prospects and the Challenges of Sustainability 17
Hania Zlotnik
Towards a Great Land-Use Transformation? 23
Christoph Müller, Hermann Lotze-Campen, Veronika Huber,
Alexander Popp, Anastasia Svirejeva-Hopkins, Michael Krause and
Hans Joachim Schellnhuber
xviii Contents
Part V Coping with Global Environmental Change: Climate Change, Soil and
Desertification, Water Management, Food and Health 689
40 Quantifying Global Environmental Change Impacts: Methods, Criteria
and Definitions for Compiling Data on Hydro-meteorological Disasters 693
Debarati Guha-Sapir and Femke Vos
Part VI Coping with Hazards and Strategies for Coping with Social
Vulnerability and Resilience Building 1101
68 Regulation and Coupling of Society and Nature in the Context of
Natural Hazards 1103
Jörn Birkmann
69 Differentials in Impacts and Recovery in the Aftermath of the 2004
Indian Ocean Tsunami: Local Examples at Different Scales in Sri Lanka 1129
Katharina Marre and Fabrice Renaud
70 Risks in Central America: Bringing Them Under Control 1147
Juan Carlos Villagrán de León
71 Economics and Social Vulnerability: Dynamics of Entitlement and Access 1159
Koko Warner
72 Social Vulnerability, Discrimination, and Resilience-building in
Disaster Risk Reduction 1169
Úrsula Oswald Spring
Section A: Scientific Research Goals and Strategies for Coping with Global
Environmental Change
73 Coping with Global Environmental Change: Need for an
Interdisciplinary and Integrated Approach 1193
G.A. McBean
74 Research Agenda and Policy Input of the Earth System Science
Partnership for Coping with Global Environmental Change 1205
Rik Leemans, Martin Rice, Ann Henderson-Sellers and Kevin Noone
75 The International Human Dimensions Programme on Global
Environmental Change – Taking Stock and Moving Forward 1221
Louise von Falkenhayn, Andreas Rechkemmer and Oran R. Young
76 DIVERSITAS: Biodiversity Science Integrating Research and Policy
for Human Well-Being 1235
Bruno A. Walther, Anne Larigauderie and Michel Loreau
77 The International Geosphere-Biosphere Programme’s (IGBP) Scientific
Research Agenda for Coping with Global Environmental Change 1249
Kevin J. Noone, Carlos Nobre and Sybil Seitzinger
78 Climate Information for Coping with Environmental Change:
Contributions of the World Climate Research Programme 1257
John A. Church, Ghassem R. Asrar, Antonio J. Busalacchi and
Carolin E. Arndt
xxiv Contents
Section B: Global Strategies, Policies and Measures for Coping with Climate Change
79 Key IPCC Conclusions on Climate Change Impacts and Adaptations 1273
Martin Parry, Osvaldo Canziani, Jean Palutikof and Clair Hanson
80 Options for Mitigating Climate Change Results of Working
Group III of the Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC 1283
Peter Bosch and Bert Metz
81 Global Climate Change, Natural Hazards, and the Environment:
an Overview of UNESCO’s Activities 1293
Walter Erdelen and Badaoui Rouhban
82 Climate Change and Development: UNDP’s Approach to Helping
Countries Build a New Paradigm 1303
Veerle Vandeweerd, Yannick Glemarec and Vivienne Caballero
Section C: Regional Strategies, Policies and Measures for Coping with Climate Change
83 EU Strategies for Climate Change Policy Beyond 2012 1319
Christian Egenhofer, Arno Behrens and Anton Georgiev
84 Coping with Climate Change in East Asia: Vulnerabilities and
Responsibilities 1333
Paul G. Harris
85 Strategies for Coping with Climate Change in Latin America: Perspective
beyond 2012 1341
Ricardo Zapata-Martí
86 Politics of Equity and Justice in Climate Change Negotiations in
North-South Relations 1355
Ariel Macaspac Penetrante
Section D: National Strategies, Policies and Measures for Coping with Climate Change
87 Climate Change: Long-Term Security Implications for China and the
International Community 1367
Yu Hongyuan and Paul J. Smith
88 Japanese Climate Change Policy: Moving Beyond the Kyoto Process 1381
Hiroshi Ohta
89 Implications of Equity Considerations and Emission Reduction Targets:
Lessons from the Case of Japan’s Mid-Term Target 1393
Norichika Kanie, Hiromi Nishimoto, Yasuaki Hijioka and
Yasuko Kameyama
Contents xxv
Abbreviations 1505
Bibliography 1521
Index 1765
52 Traditional Knowledge in Coping with Desertification
Pietro Laureano
52.1 Rural, Urban and Cultural inorganic components mix together, swarmed with
Desertification bacteria, worms, and other micro-organisms (Bennet
1939). The intense biological activity turns it into hu-
The misuse and the overexploitation of resources are mus, a colloidal compound saturated by organic sub-
the main causes of desertification which according to stances deriving from the decomposition of animal
the United Nations Convention is defined as: “deteri- and vegetable waste. It is the soil that makes plant life
oration of the lands in the arid, semiarid and semi hu- possible, the presence of which is so common in tem-
mid dry areas due to different factors including cli- perate areas that it is taken for granted. Life is instead
mate changes and human activity” (UNCCD 1994, the complex result of the continuous interaction be-
article 1a, 1995, 1995a). The definition highlights two tween chemical, physical, and above all biological fac-
fundamental aspects of desertification: a) desertifica- tors and, besides protecting the soil, it ensures its con-
tion is not the creation of a desert but of soil degra- stant regeneration. Vegetation, and in general all
dation; and b) human intervention is a fundamental biological activity related to the availability of water
factor besides the role of climate conditions. and to climate conditions, determine the soil features
Therefore desert and desertification are two very and constitute the prior conditions for the existence
different things. The desert constitutes a precise envi- of topsoil. Seeds can put down roots in the soil and
ronmental model that occurs in a specific climatic derive sustenance from it. For their part, plants pro-
context with its own laws, biological activities, and an tect the humus and ensure that it is constantly regen-
appropriate human use. Desertification produces an erated, thanks to dry cast-off plants. Surfaces which
environment in full decay and totally devoid of eco- are bare of vegetation are exposed to the harsh atmos-
logical balance. The difference lies in a specific varia- pheric agents, to the brutality of erosion which
ble: time. The natural establishment of the desert has crushes the rocks and produces sand. All of this in
followed the very long geologic times enabling the turn reinforces the erosion factors and worsens the
species to follow the changes with a process of trans- drought in that hard silicon particles are blown away
formation and evolution, and therefore allowing the by the wind, thereby becoming an abrasive force
creation of environments that in spite of the harsh cli- which can destroy even the hardest of rocks. Sand
mate are rich in adaptation and in the biodiversity of contributes to the disappearance of running surface
the species. water by settling in and filling up river beds, thus forc-
On the contrary, the processes of desertification ing the water to change its course and to become stag-
and the climate changes triggered by human interven- nant over vast surface areas where the water can evap-
tion are rapid. The biological and physical structure of orate or seep below ground.
the planet has not had time to adapt to them, result- This is how the constantly increasing degradation
ing in desolation and decay. A socio-economic and circuit of desertification is triggered. Soil, water, and
cultural degradation corresponds to the physical one. vegetation are interconnected in such a close way that
Poverty, emigration, and the loss of identity cause the the absence of any of these factors can cause the ab-
disappearance of the cultural heritage related to the sence of another factor with a multiplying effect. In-
knowledge and management of places. terfering with each one of these components triggers
In order to understand the desertification phe- the desertification process that may occur under all
nomena the key factor is the soil (Rubio 2002). In ge- climate conditions, but will variously develop depend-
ology what is commonly defined as soil is the superfi- ing on the ecosystems’ degree of vulnerability (Safriel
cial layer of the earth’s crust where the organic and 2007).
894 Pietro Laureano
Thus, it may be asserted that even the desert can natural factors trigger an environmental mechanism
undergo a process of desertification. Precisely in the of degradation which must therefore be ascribed to a
environments with a more critical and difficult bal- single factor: human intervention. The process affects
ance, characterized by a strong interaction between subtropical as well as temperate areas (Brandt/
the processes, each intervention from the smallest to Thornes 1996; Mairota/Thornes/Geeson 1998).
the most macroscopic one may produce lasting devas- While the traditional landscape with its small plots
tating effects. In the Sahara the traces left by vehicles of land surrounded by dykes and ditches, tree rows or
during the Second World War are still evident on the stone and mud walls, constitutes the optimal defen-
characteristic microvegetation of the soil that sixty sive device against weathering, the industrialization of
years later has still not recovered. In general the envi- agriculture based on heavy machinery needs vast ho-
ronment reacts to the roughness of the seasonal dif- mogeneous surfaces. The transformation into a mo-
ferences and to the cyclical climate alterations. Once noculture also involves the slopes, the marginal and
the period of crisis has passed, the environment has karstic areas where the natural harshness and vegeta-
the potential to return to its initial situation. Because tion provided shade, biological richness, and protec-
of overexploitation due to human action, which inten- tion from erosion. Chemical addictives like pesticides
sifies its destructive activity against the species and the and fertilizers transform the soil which becomes wa-
residual varieties just when the resources are becom- terproof. Maintaining the aquifers becomes impossi-
ing rarefied, any capability of recovery disappears ble and agriculture becomes increasingly dependent
even when the favourable conditions have been re-es- on artificial irrigation through the construction of big
tablished. hydraulic basins.
In the agricultural environment the process mani- The demographic growth, the abandoning of ar-
fests itself through the following phenomena: water chaic techniques and social habits even though they
erosion with the creation of cracks and fractures, loss were in harmony with the environmental potentials,
of fertility, alkalization and salinization of the soil; de- as well as the imposition of new crops according to
struction of the humus; disappearance of the plant the requirements coming from the world market and
cover; formation of sand, mud and calcareous layers; the dissemination of the monoculture, are only some
exhaustion of the aquifers and drought; decay of the of the causes of degradation. Above all, the settle-
slopes and landslides. The chemical and physical deg- ment of people gathered in small areas, according to
radation of the soil, induced by biological and physi- the necessity of the modern economies, causes the in-
cal mechanisms, reduce the vegetation and the origi- crease in energy demand, which is satisfied with a
nal bio-productivity disenabling any kind of use. In the massive devastation of the arboreal and forest herit-
Sahel zone in the Sub-Saharan area, these processes age. The wounds inflicted on the woods trigger proc-
start in a climatic area that receives more than 200 esses of continual and substantial collapse of the bio-
mm of rain per year, and also in a deeper strip in the logical variety, quality, and productivity. Animals and
south where the rains may reach 800 mm per year, i.e. plants are decreasing and the number of species is fall-
areas that cannot be properly defined as desert. It is ing so much that they are no more able to provide a
estimated that in these countries one million hectares genetic answer to the altered circumstances, and are
of tropical forests are destroyed and 100,000 hectares therefore destined to disappear.
of soil are irremediably covered every year with the Also the urban areas are affected by desertifica-
advance of the sands produced by wind erosion. In tion. In fact cities contribute both directly and indi-
Africa, altogether more than one billion hectares have rectly to the process. Directly, the massive urbaniza-
been damaged by this phenomenon. Millions of peo- tion may be considered in itself a form of
ple have been forced to emigrate elsewhere (Renaud/ desertification due to the spread of concrete over
Bogardi 2006: 24). In Mali and Burkina Faso one large natural surfaces; but also indirectly through the
sixth of the inhabitants have been forced to abandon absorption from the soil of the natural resources and
their villages. In Senegal two fifths of the population their destruction in the areas with a high demo-
of the upper valley of the homonymous river have graphic concentration. A close relationship between
been forced to emigrate. Mauritania is invaded by the urbanization and desertification may be found both in
sands. Here, the population established in the capital, the non-industrialized countries and in the most de-
Nouakchott, has increased from 9 to 41 per cent in veloped ones. In the first case, the process of decay is
twenty years, while the nomadic groups have fallen triggered and extends starting right from the areas un-
from 73 to 7 per cent (UNCCD 1995). Therefore, non- dergoing a modern and accelerated urbanization
Traditional Knowledge in Coping with Desertification 895
Figure 52.1: The traditional oasis ecosystem. Source: Pietro Laureano (2001: 372). The oasis is a self catalytic system in
which the first supply of water condensation and moisture is increased by the installation of palm trees
which produce shade, attract organisms, and form humus. The palm grove determines a humid
microclimate fed by hidden precipitations, water condensation, and underground drainage through the
underground passageways of the foggaras. The adobe habitat does not waste wood for firing bricks, it is
kept cool by the underground water passageway and provides waste to fertilize the fields. The system runs
the water resource in a cycle of use which is not only compatible with the renewable quantities available
but also increases them.
which impoverishes the surrounding territory. In the 52.2 The Knowledge of the Desert
advanced economies the spread of the process of de-
sertification is directly linked to the crisis of the his- The aridity of the desert is interrupted in specific
toric city centres and the traditional arrangement of cases that create niches and microenvironments that
the landscape. The building systems that have a strong contrast with the general situation. A slight depres-
natural component and low consumption of re- sion collects dampness, a stone shade and seed flour-
sources have been substituted with a model based on ishes. Thus, favourable dynamics develop: the plant
massive building operations that waste energy and generates its protection from sunbeams, concentrates
pollute the environment. water vapour, attracts insects, produces biological ma-
Thus, a process of physical and social desertifica- terial and the soil which nourishes it. A biological sys-
tion begins with the exodus of the population from tem used by other organisms bringing their contribu-
the ancient centres and the consequent disappearance tions is created, and a microcosm is generated as the
of the local systems. The impoverishment of the hu- result of their coexistence. By using these processes
man resources corresponds to the architectural decay people from the Sahara have developed oases. Origi-
and to the erosion of the mountain, hilltop, and slope nally, a single palm tree is planted into a hollow in the
systems. Emigration, the loss of identity and values, ground and surrounded by dry branches, which pro-
are associated with the socio-cultural aspects of deser- tect it from sand. As the time goes by, large tilled
tification. fields develop along terraced canyons or on green ar-
chipelagos among the dunes, thanks to complex and
896 Pietro Laureano
diversified techniques of water production, territory These in fact seek immediate effectiveness
arrangement, and microclimate formation. An oasis through a deep specialization of knowledge managed
can be defined as a “human settlement living in harsh by dominant structures capable of involving resources
geographic conditions and exploiting rare local re- external to the environment. Traditional knowledge
sources, to trigger a growing amplification of positive measures its functionality in the long run using a
interactions and fulfil a fertile and self-sustainable en- shared knowledge that was created and passed on
vironmental niche, contrasting with its hostile sur- from generation to generation through the social
rounding” (Laureano 1995: 24–25). practices, and uses internal renewable inputs. Thanks
Therefore not only the palm groves constitute the to modern technology, for instance, very deep wells
oasis but the entire landscape formed by the habitat have been dug out to pump water up to the surface.
and all the architectural and environmental compo- The results have immediately been visible, but have
nents. The organization of the ecosystem was realized dried up bordering resources, and sometimes by
by the people of the desert through the use of tradi- drawing water from fossil pockets, with time they
tional techniques that consist of: completely exhaust them. On the contrary, traditional
practical (instrumental) and normative knowledge con- knowledge uses systems for harvesting meteoric water
cerning the ecological, socio-economic, and cultural or exploits run-off areas by using the force of gravity
environment. Traditional knowledge originates from or water catchment methods, like the drainage galler-
people and is transmitted to people by recognizable and ies, allowing the replenishment and increasing the du-
experienced actors. It is systemic (inter-sectorial and rability of the resource.
holistic), experimental (empirical and practical), handed Modern technological methods operate by sepa-
down from generation to generation, and culturally
rating and specializing, whereas traditional knowledge
enhanced. Such a kind of knowledge supports diversity
and enhances and reproduces local resources (UNCCD operates by connecting and integrating. According to
2005: 109). the usual meaning of words such as forest, agriculture
and town, they are completely distinct from each
The way they are applied differs totally from modern other and meet similarly different needs: wood, food,
technologies (table 5252.1).) and housing. They correspond to specialized scien-
Table 52.1: Characteristics of modern and traditional tific systems: Silviculture, agriculture, and town plan-
knowledge. Source: The author. ning. Local knowledge does not make an artificial dis-
tinction within the world of plants between the forest
Modern Knowledge Traditional Knowledge supplying commercial wood and tilled land supplying
Specific solution Multifunctional
food (Shiva 1993a: 18). Forests, fields, and dwellings
are unitary ecological systems. Forests and other mar-
Immediate efficacy Functional over a long ginal apparently non-productive areas, such as steppes
period
and marshes, provide large quantities of food and wa-
Specialization Holism ter resources, and fodder and fertilizers for agricul-
Dominant powers Autonomy ture. They are also convenient to live in. The tradi-
Separation Integration tional town, in its turn, integrates with agriculture by
replacing the forest in desert areas, by collecting ferti-
External resources Internal inputs
lizers produced by the inhabitants’ organic waste, and
Confliction Symbiosis through its production of water collected on the
Monoculture Connection and complexity roofs. This principle is so close to the way in which
Uniformity Diversity nature works, where everything that remains of a sys-
tem is reused by other systems and the concept of
Inflexibility Flexibility
waste and the possibility of resorting to external re-
Costly maintenance Self-regulation and intensity sources do not exist. It has allowed human beings to
of work survive throughout history and is today proposed
Internationalization Consideration of the again by the modern theoreticians of sustainability
context (Pauli 1999).
Costliness Saving By this logic, to the strong cohesion among soci-
Attention to mere technical Symbolism and full of signi- ety, culture and the economy, also aesthetic and ethi-
details and rationalism ficance cal values are added. Traditional procedures operate a
Dependence Autopoiesis
harmonious fusion between the landscape and the tra-
Traditional Knowledge in Coping with Desertification 897
ditional aesthetic canons. A device for collecting or ekaran 1993; Tahoun 2003), have been asserted for
conveying water is never merely a technical structure many years at various levels. In the scientific field, re-
but also has its own beauty. Fields in the oases are sys- search on traditional knowledge has been imple-
tems of production and relaxing places for contempla- mented for more than twenty years with the specific
tion as well. Little agricultural fields in desert areas aim of overcoming the top-down approach to the
are called gardens, just as in Southern Italy, eliminat- transfer of technologies as well as the problem of
ing the separation between the vegetable garden and achieving a participatory relationship able to foster sus-
the pleasure garden. Often, the works and procedures tainability (Brokensha/Warren/Werner 1980). Many in-
have a deep symbolic meaning and are a continuous ternational bodies such as the International Labour
game of suggestions and analogies between tech- Organization (ILO) (Bhalla 1977; ILO 1985), the Or-
niques, art, and nature. Systems of water distribution ganisation for Economic Co-operation and Develop-
in the Sahara are reproduced in carpet drawings and ment (OECD) (Jequier/Blanc 1983), the Food and Ag-
in women’s hairstyles. They are part of a complex riculture Organization (FAO) (Saouma 1993), the
symbolism linked to life and fertility. Spiritual princi- United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
ples make rules sacred and guarantee their perpetua- Organization (UNESCO 1994, 1994a, 1994b), the
tion as in the case of the African sacred woods with United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)
their restricted access and of the whole set of taboo- (Dowdeswell 1993) and the World Bank (Vernon
objects, practices which guarantee the regeneration of 1989; Davis 1995) have declared its validity in research
forests, the saving of environmental resources and the and documents. The interest of the United Nations’
land as reserves for nature and human communities. conventions is clearly highlighted in the report enti-
Therefore, traditional techniques are an integral tled Building Linkage between Environmental Con-
part of a strongly consolidated network of links and ventions and Initiatives (UNCCD 1999).
relations, supported by a global framework of signs Despite this full commitment and interest, the
and meanings. They work within a socially shared cul- fields of application and the innovative dissemination
tural structure: the historical system of science and lo- of traditional knowledge are still below their real
cal knowledge. It is therefore wrong to isolate each potential, the reasons may be summarized as follows:
single technology, which is always highly contextual-
• The lack of awareness that environmental damage,
ized, not only linked to an environmental situation,
soil degradation, and desertification mostly result
but to a precise historical moment and a complex so-
from the loss of traditional knowledge;
cial construction. The totality of traditional practices
• The lack of information as to the validity and ben-
for managing resources constitutes the mediation
efits of traditional knowledge from the experts
through which a certain social form interacts with na-
responsible for national planning;
ture in realizing its technological dimension, an inte-
• The limited understanding of the role to be
gral part of its cultural complexity, and view of the
assigned to traditional techniques and their way of
world. Thanks to this knowledge populations are able
operating;
to gain greater resources from the environment com-
• The lack of communication and exchange of suc-
pared to the ones naturally offered. Both factors, the
cessful experiences;
cultural dimension and the environmental conditions,
• The unawareness of the innovative use of tradi-
change continually in time and from place to place,
tional knowledge.
thus creating and amplifying the cultural diversity.
It is necessary to clarify the modalities of use, the va-
lidity, effectiveness, the innovative force, and the pos-
52.3 Validity, Innovative Use, and sibility for integration of the traditional technologies
Integration with Advanced with the modern ones.
Technology
52.3.1 Multifunctional Use and Cultural
The validity of traditional knowledge and the use of Integration
practices derived from it, variously named as endog-
enous knowledge, appropriate technologies, local Traditional knowledge as an integrated learning or-
knowledge, indigenous techniques, nature-based ganization constitutes a complex system with multi-
knowledge, sustainable knowledge, folk knowledge, functional characteristics and an integral part of the
and cultural knowledge (Gupta 1989; Warren/Rajas- construction process of the collective identity as well
898 Pietro Laureano
as of social cohesion. The rice cultivations in the Phil- local knowledge system and the social categories,
ippines and Indonesia which cover the mountain sides mainly women. Within this framework, the case of
with an extensive system of terraces constitute a won- the irrigated perimeter of Ras Djebel in the north-
derful landscape created by the people. The beauty of eastern part of Tunisia, 30 km from Biserta, is a signif-
these terraces does not result from aesthetic choices icant example. Here a traditional kind of cultivation is
but depends on the harmonious application of the applied, following the oasis model and the Maghre-
traditional engineering techniques in order to organ- bian and Andalusian models of arboriculture and veg-
ize catchment areas, gather flowing waters and rain- etable gardens. Fields are divided into small plots ac-
falls, create terraces on which flows are channelled, cording to complicated procedures of inheritance and
and preserve the ground from washing away or erod- marriages that continuously divide and re-compose
ing. the properties. In this way, 2,000 hectares of land can
Traditional techniques relating to water manage- be divided into 4,500 plots. Traditional irrigation is
ment in the Ladakh region in India are another exam- carried out through harvesting subterranean waters by
ple. These enable fertile mountain oases to be created means of family-managed wells or irrigation, thanks
in otherwise arid lands. The techniques for using the to superficial channels running all over the agricul-
water resources provided by seasonal snow melting tural area. A project aiming at modernizing the system
are based on a system of rights and rules closely created a 15,000-m3 tank, fed by a lake located on a
linked to the social structure, to the norms regulating hill. The agricultural perimeter was then subdivided
the traditional division of work between sex and age into larger parts, each supplied by a modern water
groups, as well as to the ecological situation of each drawing system that irrigates large areas by sprinkling.
oasis village. The great social cohesion and spiritual Such a perimeter involved the removal of small prop-
motivation has enabled these people to apply modern erty boundaries. The peasants distinctly rejected the
techniques such as methods for using solar energy, in new division of the plots and the new methods of ir-
harmony with their ideals, and to reject others such as rigation on the basis of social, productive, and sym-
chemical fertilizers regarded as harmful for the soils bolical reasons which can be summarized as follows:
(Wacker 1997).
• The use of family wells enables each owner to
manage his own water independently. Such water
52.3.2 Technological Effectiveness and was previously free whereas there is a charge for
Productiveness the water provided by the project.
• The division of small land plots responds to ances-
Traditional technologies are not less competitive than
tral structures which extend the domestic space
modern ones. They achieve results differently and
into the agricultural one. In this way, women can
consider a series of contextual factors omitted by
work in the fields and at the same time feel at
modern techniques. The procedure is sometimes less
home.
immediate and needs more work. However, this is
• Irrigation through sprinkling is considered nega-
not a negative feature in many countries that face the
tive since it ‘favours the burning of the leaves and
problem of unemployment. Indeed, the application of
the appearance of new diseases’.
a technique determines effects both before and after
• Groundwater is commonly considered as ‘alive
the use of the necessary resources and has more gen-
since it originates from the earth and feeds the
eral consequences on the entire economic, social, and
plants’, in opposition to the water of the project
environmental model. These interactions are not
which is held as ‘a dead water coming from a stag-
taken into account in the application of a modern
nant basin and thus harmful to agriculture’.
technique based on specific and immediate yield crite-
ria. On the contrary, traditional techniques are se- Despite these oppositions, the project was carried out
lected and accepted through a process of environmen- with disastrous consequences. Indeed, after the
tal, historical and social considerations, appraised project was implemented, a 20-meter lowering of the
according to their validity in the long term, their con- water table as well as a 3 g/1 increase of salinity were
textual benefits, and their overall sustainability. verified (Bouayard-Agha 1997: 22–23).
Failure to evaluate these aspects has led to unsuc-
cessful projects for development cooperation which
have not taken into account the necessity of propos-
ing technologies that could be managed through the
Traditional Knowledge in Coping with Desertification 899
52.3.3 Validity and Application their land. They consider these waters as an advanta-
geous nutrient supply and not as something harmful
Traditional techniques are generally considered valid they should get rid of. At the same time, they provide
only for the less developed economies. This stance is an extraordinary contribution to the waste water
contradicted by the fact that situations in which tradi- drainage system of Calcutta completely free of charge.
tional technologies persist, and their role in the econ- In Liguria where in the Cinque Terre region there
omy and society is consolidated and stabilized, can be is one of the largest systems of terraced slopes in the
proved specifically in the more advanced countries. Mediterranean, this traditional practice that protects
The values of tradition, manufacturing practices, and the soils, and catches and channels the waters, has
the craftsmen’s skills are the basis on which the great been perpetuated through innovative agricultural
added value of economically important productions mechanization. Agricultural work on terraces is hard
for many advanced countries is founded. In particular due to tiring transport systems which are operational
the typical food production (oil, cheese, wine, etc.) only on foot. Traditionally there were techniques of
safeguards both the aesthetic and environmental qual- transport by means of sledges drawn up the hill by
ity of the landscape, since the old production systems ropes. Already at the beginning of the century these
are available thanks to the maintenance of traditional were substituted with mechanical funicular systems on
soil management techniques, as for instance is the rails. The same technique is re-proposed today with
case of the regions of Valais in Switzerland, the Loire appropriate monorail systems that enable the ascent
Valley in France, and Tuscany in Italy. Thus, it is of the slope without disturbing the landscape or the
wrong to consider traditional knowledge as marginal ecosystem.
compared to the great economic and technological In Burkina Faso zai is a particular traditional tech-
processes under way. Even from a quantitative point nique able to regenerate highly degraded soils. The
of view, their use still supports most of humankind soil is dug with holes that fill up with water in the hu-
which is distributed throughout the less industrialized mid season and are used as dump sites for rubbish
countries. Paradoxically, in these places where tradi- and manure in the dry season. This practice attracts
tional techniques are still used in a massive way, these termites that digest rubbish, thus its absorption by the
are considered by the modernist thought as a phe- plants’ roots. Furthermore, the tunnels dug by the ter-
nomenon of backwardness, whereas, in advanced mites increase the soil’s porosity. Seeds are then sown
countries, they create an image and provide added in the holes, giving very high crop yields. Innovative
value. Tradition is then a fundamental component of practices which promote original forms of symbiosis
successful modernity and creative industry. Tradi- between humankind and animals or micro-organisms
tional knowledge constitutes a dynamic system capa- are today re-proposed to rehabilitate degraded soils or
ble of incorporating innovation valued through local soils made suitable for human living in extreme areas.
wisdom: today’s appropriate innovation is tomorrow’s
tradition.
52.4 Knowledge from the Past for a
52.3.4 Paleo-technology and High Technology Sustainable Future
Traditional technologies do not have less technologi- The enormous hydraulic resources deriving from the
cal consistency than the modern ones. Sometimes river basins of the Nile, Mesopotamia, the Indus, and
they are the most refined technologies, other times river systems of China, determined the formation of
they are very simple but still more appropriate, that is the great empires that have been defined by Karl Au-
ecologically compatible and locally manageable. Fur- gust Wittfogel (1957) as hydraulic societies. The socio-
thermore, traditional knowledge is re-proposed economic model is the one of an increasingly expand-
through every possible innovative use that is in con- ing empire supported by a massive population growth
junction with modern technologies, which can oper- triggered by the agricultural potential and maintained
ate within the same logic. In the moist areas to the by an imperial conquest, the income coming from the
west of Calcutta, the traditional fishing and agricul- exploitation of a vast quantity of workers and by
tural practices cover approx. 10,000 ha of territory. spending resources on monuments or wars. The long
Here the world’s largest network of urban sewage wa- term results of this are the hypertrophy of the popula-
ter re-use is in use. Thousands of peasants convey mil- tion and of the territory, authoritarianism, state cen-
lions of litres of sewage water from Calcutta towards
900 Pietro Laureano
tralization, and the increasing destruction of the envi- new models of sustainability have to be based. The
ronment leading to an ecological catastrophe. historical settlements, the traditional landscapes, and
Within the great empires, in marginal areas with the local knowledge provide solutions to be safe-
scarce resources, or in the fringes of the empires in guarded and which can be re-proposed, adapted, and
protected areas, oases and cities were created in inac- renewed by means of the modern technology. It is not
cessible places and transformed into self-supporting a question of reapplying or transforming the single
centres. These autopoietic societies use the gathered procedures but rather of understanding the logic of
experience of traditional knowledge and become cen- those models which have allowed societies to posi-
tres of innovation for the amplification and proper tively advance their status and to make technical, artis-
use of local resources. This is the way the desert com- tic, and architectural implementations, fundamental
munities were organized and in general those socie- in the history of the civilizations. Knowledge about
ties often based on hydraulic systems, those which de- the most distant past can lead to the founding of new
veloped in harsh natural conditions (Laureano 2001). technological paradigms: the capability of enhancing
The geographical continuity of the desert areas, the inside resources and managing them at a local
extending from China to the Mediterranean and Af- level; the versatility and the interpenetration of techni-
rica through the three most ancient continents, fa- cal, ethical, and aesthetic values; the production not
vours the elaboration of appropriate solutions per se but for the good of the community and based
through the exchange and increase of knowledge. on the principle according to which each activity has
Complex ecosystems are created based on the use to start up another one without waste; and energy use
of the local resources, but which assume a larger di- based on cycles in constant renewal.
mensional scale by exploiting their position to control
the trade routes and convey huge economic incomes.
This is how the fantastic hydraulic and soil manage-
ment systems were realized in Petra (Jordan), and in
Marib (Yemen), ancient capitals of the Arabic desert
now only archaeological remains, and in the Saharan
oasis-towns such as Ghardaia that are still intact and
vital. The ever increasing effort to organize space de-
pended on the economic benefits ensured by the role
undertaken within an international exchange econ-
omy: the caravan gold routes in the Sahara, the in-
cense route in Arabia, the silk route in Palestine and
in the East.
The community’s acceptance of the necessary
tasks for preserving the geographic positions depends
on delicate environmental, economic, and cultural
equilibria. When even only one of the aspects of the
holistic conception of the world or a ring in the chain
of the resource management is missing, the entire sys-
tem is destined to collapse. This is the cause for the
collapse of various ancient civilizations, a current issue
today because of the menace represented for contem-
porary society by climate change (Mays 2007; Dia-
mond 2007a)
However, the knowledge is not completely lost. It
survives among the populations living in the appar-
ently undeveloped areas or the interstices of the ad-
vanced society and the places protected for their cul-
tural value. Knowledge is a great potential because the
local know-how, which improves under the harshest
environmental conditions, and the existence of intact
ancient structures are a valuable heritage on which
Hexagon Series on
Human and Environmental Security and Peace (HESP)
Edited by
Hans Günter Brauch,
Free University of Berlin, UNU-EHS and AFES-PRESS
Vol. 1: Hans Günter Brauch, P. H. Liotta, Antonio Marquina, Paul Rogers, Mohammad
El-Sayed Selim (Eds.): Security and Environment in the Mediterranean - Concep-
tualising Security and Environmental Conflicts. With Forewords by the Hon.
Lord Robertson, Secretary General of NATO, and the Hon. Amre Moussa, Secre-
tary General of the League of Arab States (Berlin – Heidelberg – New York: Sprin-
ger, 2003).
ISBN: 978-3-540-40107-0
Vol. 2: Hillel Shuval, Hassan Dweik (Eds.): Water Resources in the Middle East: Israel-
Palestinian Water Issues – from Conflict to Cooperation (Berlin – Heidelberg –
New York: Springer-Verlag, 2007).
Vol. 3: Hans Günter Brauch, Úrsula Oswald Spring, Czeslaw Mesjasz, John Grin, Pál
Dunay, Navnita Chadha Behera, Béchir Chourou, Patricia Kameri-Mbote, P.H.
Liotta (Eds.): Globalization and Environmental Challenges: Reconceptualizing
Security in the 21st Century (Berlin – Heidelberg – New York: Springer-Verlag, 2008).
Vol. 4: Hans Günter Brauch, Úrsula Oswald Spring, John Grin, Czeslaw Mesjasz, Patricia
Kameri-Mbote, Navnita Chadha Behera, Béchir Chourou, Heinz Krummenacher
(Eds.): Facing Global Environmental Change: Environmental, Human, Energy,
Food, Health and Water Security Concepts (Berlin – Heidelberg – New York: Sprin-
ger-Verlag, 2009).
Vol. 5: Hans Günter Brauch, Úrsula Oswald Spring, Czeslaw Mesjasz, John Grin, Patricia
Kameri-Mbote, Béchir Chourou, Pal Dunay, Jörn Birkmann (Eds.): Coping with
Global Environmental Change, Disasters and Security - Threats, Challenges, Vul-
nerabilities and Risks (Berlin - Heidelberg - New York: Springer-Verlag, 2011).
Vol. 6: ThanhDam Truong, Des Gapter (Eds.): Transnational Migration: The Migration -
Development - Security Nexus. Hexagon Series on Human and Environmental
Security and Peace, vol. 6 ( Berlin - Heidelberg - New York: Springer-Verlag, 2011).
Vol. 7: Úrsula Oswald Spring (Ed.): Water Resources in Mexico. Scarcity, Degradation,
Stress, Conflicts, Management, and Policy. Hexagon Series on Human and Envi-
ronmental Security and Peace, vol. 7 (Berlin - Heidelberg - New York: Springer-Ver-
lag, 2011).
In Preparation
Vol. 8: Jürgen Scheffran; Michael Brzoska; Hans Günter Brauch; Peter Michael Link;
Janpeter Schilling (Eds.): Climate Change, Human Security and Violent Conflict:
Challenges for Societal Stability. Hexagon Series on Human and Environmental
Security and Peace, vol. 8 Berlin - Heidelberg - New York: Springer-Verlag, 2011).
Vol. 9: Czeslaw Mesjasz: Stability, Turbulence or Chaos? Systems Thinking and Security.
Hexagon Series on Human and Environmental Security and Peace, vol. 9 (Berlin -
Heidelberg - New York: Springer-Verlag, 2012).
Authors or editors who would like to have their publication project considered for inclu-
sion in this series should contact both the series editor:
PD Dr. phil. habil. Hans Günter Brauch, Alte Bergsteige 47, 74821 Mosbach, Germany
Phone: 49-6261-12912 FAX: 49-6261-15695
Email afes@afes-press.de
http://www.afes-press.de and http://www.afes-press-books.de/html/hexagon.htm
___ copies Brauch (Eds.), Coping with Global Environmental Change, Disasters and Security, HESP 5, ISBN: 978-3-642-17775-0 € 299.00
___ copies Brauch (Eds.), Facing Global Environmental Change, HESP 4, ISBN: 978-3-540-68487-9 € 249.99 / $ 379.00 / ₤ 226.50
___ copies Brauch (Eds.), Globalization and Environmental Challenges, HESP 3, ISBN: 978-3-540-75976-8 € 259.99 / $ 359,00 / ₤ 233,00
{ Please bill me
{ Please charge my credit card: { Eurocard/Access/Mastercard { Visa/Barclaycard/Bank/Americard { AmericanExpress
Number Valid until
Name
Available from
Dept.
Springer Springer
Order Department Customer Service Center GmbH Institution
PO Box 2485 Haberstrasse 7 Street
Secaucus, NJ 07096-2485 69126 Heidelberg
USA Germany City / ZIP-Code
Call toll-free 1-800-SPRINGER Call: + 49 (0) 6221-345-4301
Country
8:30 am – 5:30 pm ET Fax: +49 (0) 6221-345-4229
Fax your order to (201) 348-4505 Web: springer.com Email
Web springer.com Email: orders-hd-individuals@springer.com
Email orders-ny@springer.com Date Signature
All € and £ prices are net prices subject to local VAT, e.g. in Germany 7% VAT for books & journals and 19% VAT for electronic products.
Pre-publication pricing: Unless otherwise stated, pre-pub prices are valid through the end of the third month following publication,
and therefore are subject to change. All prices exclusive of carriage charges. Prices and other details are subject to change without notice.
All errors and omissions excepted. 02