Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Orita
G.R. No. 88724, April 3, 1990
Medialdea, J. / KMD
SUBJ!" MA""R#
MA""R# !ri$i%al lia&ili'() *'a+e* o -o$$i**io%) *pe-ii- elo%ie*) rape
!AS SUMMAR#
% eople . ri'a, ri'a a* -o%i-'ed o r*'ra'ed rape, 5oeer '5e S! rled '5a' 5e *5old &e
-o%i-'ed o -o%*$$a'ed rape &e-a*e ri'a a-'all( a''ai%ed 5i* prpo*e a%d, ro$ '5a' $o$e%' al*o
all '5e e**e%'ial ele$e%'* o '5e oe%*e 5ae &ee% a--o$pli*5ed, '5* -o%*$$a'ed. "5e S! al*o rled
'5a' ll pe%e'ra'io% i* %o' e**e%'ial i% '5e -o%*$$a'io% o rape. ' i* al*o 5ardl( -o%-eia&le 5o '5e
r*'ra'ed *'a+e i% rape -a% eer &e -o$$i''ed.
D!"RNS#
AR". 336 When and how rape is committed
committed Rape i* -o$$i''ed &( 5ai%+ -ar%al %oled+e o a o$a%
%der a%( o '5e olloi%+ -ir-$*'a%-e*#
1. B( *i%+ or-e or i%'i$ida'io%)
2. 5e% '5e o$a% i* depried
depried o rea*o% or o'5eri*e
o'5eri*e %-o%*-io*) a%d
a%d
3. 5e% '5e o$a% i* %der
%der 'ele (ear* o a+e, ee% '5o+5
'5o+5 %ei'5er o '5e -ir-$*'a%-e*
-ir-$*'a%-e*
$e%'io%ed i% '5e 'o %e:' pre-edi%+ para+rap5* *5all &e pre*e%'.
AR". ; Consummated, frustrated, and attempted felonies !o%*$$a'ed elo%ie* a* ell a* '5o*e 5i-5
are r*'ra'ed a%d a''e$p'ed, are p%i*5a&le.
A elo%( i* -o%*$$a'ed 5e% all '5e ele$e%'* %e-e**ar( or i'* e:e-'io% a%d a--o$pli*5$e%' are
pre*e%') a%d i' i* r*'ra'ed
r*'ra'ed 5e% '5e oe%der
oe%der peror$* all '5e a-'* o
o e:e-'io% 5i-5 old
old prod-e '5e
elo%( a* a -o%*e<e%-e &' 5i-5, %eer'5ele**, do %o' prod-e i' &( rea*o% o -a*e* i%depe%de%' o '5e
ill o '5e perpe'ra'or.
"5ere i* a% a''e$p' 5e% '5e oe%der -o$$e%-e* '5e -o$$i**io% o a elo%( dire-'l( &( oer' a-'*, a%d
doe* %o' peror$ all '5e a-'* o e:e-'io% 5i-5 *5old prod-e '5e elo%( &( rea*o% o *o$e -a*e or
a--ide%' o'5er '5a% 5i* o% *po%'a%eo* de*i*'a%-e.=
A!"S#
• !o$plai%a%', !ri*'i%a S. A&a(a% a* a 19(ear old -olle+e *'de%' i% Boro%+a%, a*'er% Sa$ar
5ile appella%' a* a 5ilippi%e !o%*'a&lar( >!? *oldier.
• % '5e earl( $or%i%+ o Mar-5
Mar -5 20, 1983, -o$plai%a%' *' arried a' 5er &oardi%+ 5o*e ro$ a
par'( 5e% *o$e&od( 5eld
5eld 5er a%d poed a %ie 'o 5er %e-. Ce ordered 5er 'o +o p*'air*
p*'air* a%d
5e% '5e( rea-5ed '5e *e-o%d loor, 5e -o$$a%ded 5er 'o loo or a roo$. Upo% e%'eri%+ '5e
roo$, 5e '5e% ordered -o$plai%a%' 'o 'ae o 5er -lo'5e*. S-ared, *5e 'oo o 5er " *5ir'. "5e%
5e plled o 5er &ra, pa%'* a%d pa%'(, Ce '5e% $o%'ed 5er appella%' &' -old %o' ll(
pe%e'ra'e 5er *o 5e -o$$a%ded 5er 'o $o%' 5i$, alloi%+ o%l( a *$all par' a+ai%E o 5i* pe%i*
'o pe%e'ra'e i%'o 5er a+i%a.
• !o$plai%a%' da*5ed o' o '5e roo$ %aed a%d dar'ed r'5er 'o '5e $%i-ipal &ildi%+. a'.
Do%-era* a%d o'5er poli-e$e%, 5o ere i%*ide '5e &ildi%+ ope%ed '5e door a%d o%d
-o$plai%a%' %aed *i''i%+ o% '5e *'air* -r(i%+. "5e( &ro+5' 5er 'o '5e a*'er% Sa$ar roi%-ial
Co*pi'al 5ere *5e a* p5(*i-all( e:a$i%ed &( Dr. A&de, 5ile '5e re*' e%' 'o '5e &oardi%+
5o*e a%d *a *o$e&od( r%%i%+ aa(.
• Ba*ed o% '5e p5(*i-al e:a$i%a'io%#
o a'ie%' -a$e i% i% a *'a'e o *5o-
o -ir-$*-ri&ed 5e$a'o$a a' a%'erior %e-
o li%ear a&ra*io%* &elo le' &rea*'
o $l'iple pi%poi%' $ar* a' '5e &a-, a&ra*io%* a' &o'5 %ee*
o %o i*i&le a&ra*io%* or $ar* a' '5e peri%eal area or oer '5e la) er('5e$a'o* area*
%o'ed *rro%di%+ a+i%al orii-e, 'e%der) 5($e% i%'a-') %o la-era'io% >re*5 a%d old?)
e:a$i%i%+ i%+er -a% &arel( e%'er a%d i'5 dii-l'() a+i%al -a%al 'i+5') %o di*-5ar+e*
%o'ed.
"5e a--*ed a* -5ar+ed i'5 '5e -ri$e o r*'ra'ed rape &eore '5e Re+io%al "rial !or', Bra%-5 ,
Boro%+a%, a*'er% Sa$ar, a%d *e%'e%-ed 'o a% i$pri*o%$e%' o 10 (ear* a%d 1 da(, ri*io% Ma(or, a*
$i%i$$ 'o 12 (ear* ri*io% Ma(or, $a:i$$) 'o i%de$%i( !RS"NA S. ABAAN 5 4,000.00,
i'5o' *&*idiar( i$pri*o%$e%' i% -a*e o i%*ole%-(, a%d 'o pa( -o*'*.
"5e a--*ed a**ail* '5e 'e*'i$o%ie* o '5e i-'i$ a%d a'. Do%-era* &e-a*e '5e( *5o re$ara&le a%d
i'al i%-o%*i*'e%-ie* a%d i'* i%-redi&ili'( a$o%'i%+ 'o a&ri-a'io% a%d '5ereore -a*'ed do&' 'o i'* -a%dor,
'r'5 a%d alidi'(.
SSU/S#
1
)WON t
het
ria
lco
urte
rre
dindi
sre
gar
dingt
hes
ubs
tant
iali
nco
nsi
ste
nci
esi
nthe
t
est
imo
nie
soft
hewi
tne
sse
s.
2
)WON t
het
ria
lco
urte
rre
dinde
cla
ringt
hatt
hec
rimeo
ffr
ust
rat
edr
apewa
scommi
tted
byt
heacc
use
d.>S?
CFDNG#
1. No, '5e t
rialc
our
tdi
dno
ter
rindi
sre
gar
dingt
hes
ubs
tant
iali
nco
nsi
ste
nci
esi
nthe
t
est
imo
nie
soft
hewi
tne
sse
s. '5e alle+ed i%-o%*i*'e%-ie* reealed '5a' '5e( reer 'o 'riial
i%-o%*i*'e%-ie* 5i-5 are %o' *i-ie%' 'o &lr or -a*' do&' o% '5e i'%e**e*@ *'rai+5'orard
a''e*'a'io%*. ar ro$ &ei%+ &ad+e* o a&ri-a'io%, '5e i%-o%*i*'e%-ie* i% '5eir 'e*'i$o%ie* $a( i%
a-' &e *'iia&l( -o%*idered a* $a%ie*'a'io%* o 'r'5l%e** o% $a'erial poi%'*. "5e*e li''le
deia'io%* al*o -o%ir$ '5a' '5e i'%e**e* 5ad %o' &ee% re5ear*ed. "5e $o*' -a%did i'%e**e*
$a( $ae $i*'ae* *o$e'i$e* &' *-5 5o%e*' lap*e* do %o' %e-e**aril( i$pair '5eir i%'ri%*i-
-redi&ili'( >eople . !a&a'o, G.R. No. F 37400, April 16, 1988, 1;0 S!RA 98?.
"5e -or' o%d %o -o+e%' rea*o% 'o depar' ro$ '5e ell*e''led rle '5a' '5e i%di%+* o a-' o
'5e 'rial -or' o% '5e -redi&ili'( o i'%e**e* *5old &e a--orded '5e 5i+5e*' re*pe-' &e-a*e i' 5a*
'5e ada%'a+e o o&*eri%+ '5e de$ea%or o i'%e**e* a%d -a% di*-er% i a i'%e** i* 'elli%+ '5e
'r'5 >eople . Sa$*o%, G.R. No. 66620, A+*' 26, 1989?.
2. e*, '5e -5ar+e *5old &e rape, i%*'ead o r*'ra'ed rape. !learl(, i% '5e -ri$e o rape, ro$ '5e
$o$e%' '5e oe%der 5a* -ar%al %oled+e o 5i* i-'i$, 5e a-'all( a''ai%* 5i* prpo*e a%d,
ro$ '5a' $o$e%' al*o all '5e e**e%'ial ele$e%'* o '5e oe%*e 5ae &ee% a--o$pli*5ed. No'5i%+
$ore i* le' 'o &e do%e &( '5e oe%der, &e-a*e 5e 5a* peror$ed '5e la*' a-' %e-e**ar( 'o
prod-e '5e -ri$e. "5*, '5e elo%( i* -o%*$$a'ed. % a lo%+ li%e o -a*e* >eople . *-ar, 48
5il. 627) eople . Cer%a%de, 49 5il. 980) eople . Ro(era*, G.R. No. F 3188;, April 29,
1974, 6; S!RA ;;;) eople . A$ore*, G.R. No. F3299;, A+*' 21, 1974, 68 S!RA 606?, '5e
-or' 5ae *e' '5e %ior$ rle '5a' or '5e -o%*$$a'io% o rape, pere-' pe%e'ra'io% i* %o'
e**e%'ial. A%( pe%e'ra'io% o '5e e$ale or+a% &( '5e $ale or+a% i* *i-ie%'. %'r( o '5e la&ia
or lip* o '5e e$ale or+a%, i'5o' rp're o '5e 5($e% or la-era'io% o '5e a+i%a i* *i-ie%'
'o arra%' -o%i-'io%.
Ne-e**aril(, rape i* a''e$p'ed i '5ere i* %o pe%e'ra'io% o '5e e$ale or+a% >eople . "a(a&a, ;2
5il. 669) eople . Ra&ada%, e' al., 63 5il. ;94) U%i'ed S'a'e* . Gar-ia, 9 5il. 434? &e-a*e %o'
all a-'* o e:e-'io% a* peror$ed. "5e oe%der $erel( -o$$e%-ed '5e -o$$i**io% o a elo%(
dire-'l( &( oer' a-'*. "ai%+ i%'o a--o%' '5e %a're, ele$e%'* a%d $a%%er o e:e-'io% o '5e
-ri$e o rape a%d ri*prde%-e o% '5e $a''er, i' i* 5ardl( -o%-eia&le 5o '5e r*'ra'ed *'a+e i%
rape -a% eer &e -o$$i''ed.
Decision of the Regional Trial Court is hereby MODIFIED. The accused Ceilito Orita is hereby
found guilty beyond reasonable doubt of the crie of rape and sentenced to reclusion perpetua as
!ell as to indenify the victi in the aount of P"#$###.##.