Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spe 112411 Pa
Spe 112411 Pa
Fig. 2—Typical setting curve for the RSM system using a Chandler consistometer (at 181°F).
field is the largest and most important field in Mexico and the In addition, the enormous conductivity originated by the presence
second-largest in the world. It was estimated that the original oil of vuggy high-permeability streaks favors water production even
in place was approximately 37 billion std bbl. The main pay zones more. The OCP/RSM system has been implemented effectively in
in Cantarell are highly fractured, vuggy-carbonate formations from Mexico, with more than 30 jobs showing successful results. Three
the Jurassic/Cretaceous. Formations are hydraulically continuous case histories are presented here.
and have an average thickness of approximately 4,000 ft. The oil A common practice in this field is that when the water/oil contact
produced is approximately 22°API oil. Typical total porosity is 8%, moves up closer to the perforations and water production becomes
and up to 35% of it is secondary porosity, fractures, and vugular significant, the producing interval is abandoned and the well is
areas. Matrix permeability varies from 1 md to 6 darcies. Average reperforated a few feet farther up. In 2003, the operator started to
bottomhole static pressure is approximately 1,400 psi, and average abandon intervals either mechanically or chemically. One of the ini-
bottomhole temperature is 200°F (93°C). Currently, this field is tial alternatives attempted was to perform squeeze-cementing jobs to
being produced with a pressure-maintenance program by nitrogen abandon the perforated interval. Limited success has been achieved
injection and gas lift (Rodriguez et al. 2004). with this technique when the wells exhibit water-coning problems.
For instance, Well A was diagnosed with water-coning problems and
was treated with a standard squeeze-cementing job (Vasquez et al.
Case Histories 2006). Water cut before the treatment was approximately 22% and
Over the past 3 years, undesirable water encroachment in the increased to 55.4% immediately after the treatment. The attempt
Cantarell field has caused many wells to be shut down because of to reduce water production was unsuccessful because the squeeze-
the lack of capacity for hydrocarbons and water-handling facilities. cementing job did not provide a barrier deep inside the matrix of
The initial depth of the water/oil contact when the reservoir started the formation. This well was abandoned 7 months after the squeeze-
production was 10,500 ft; it has moved up to a depth of 8,560 ft. In cement job because of excessive water production. Similar results
fact, the water/oil contact has an estimated move-up rate of 74 ft/yr. have been obtained with expandable liners or packers.
Fig. 4—Typical compressive-strength vs. time curve for the RSM system. (It develops more than 4,000 psi in less than 3 hours,
at approximately 200°F).
Fig. 5—Water-cut history of Well 1 before and after the OCP/ Fig. 6—Water-cut history of Well 2 before and after the OCP/
RSM treatment. RSM treatment.
Because of the vertical communication between the interval to the matrix of the formation, and the RSM system was successful
be sealed and the future perforated interval, it has been necessary at the near-wellbore region. Water production for these wells was
to place a barrier between these two intervals to keep the water/oil decreased substantially following the OCP/RSM treatment and the
contact from reaching the new perforations so that the life of the perforation of the new intervals, as Figs. 5 through 8 illustrate.
treated wells could be extended. For these wells, high-permeabil- These wells are currently producing at a water cut that the facilities
ity streaks and water-coning problems were addressed using the can handle after the conformance treatment.
combination of the OCP and the RSM systems. To achieve this
objective, it was necessary to obtain a deep penetration into the Case History: Well 1. Well 1 (Fig. 9) was perforated originally
formation (with the OCP system) to completely seal the current from 8,265 to 8,429 ft measured depth in 1999. This well pro-
producing interval. Another risk associated with the placement of duces from a Lower Cretaceous formation. The characteristics of
the water-shutoff treatments was the low pressure exhibited by the reservoir are: 70% dolomite, 25% calcite, and 5% limestone;
most of these formations. In most of these cases, the conformance porosity of 9%; permeability of 1,710 md; water saturation of 10%;
system in the near-wellbore region was jeopardized by the possibil- reservoir temperature of 225°F; and bottomhole static pressure of
ity of overdisplacing the treatment and leaving the near-wellbore 1,735 psi. Once the gas/oil ratio (GOR) increased significantly, the
region untreated. The risk associated with this problem was mini- interval had to be abandoned and it was decided to reperforate a
mized using the RSM system because of its right-angle set in a lower interval (JSK) to drain the remaining reserves. In this case,
matter of minutes at the vicinity of the wellbore. the water/oil contact was originally 656 ft (200 m) below the tar-
The rigid sealant has proved successful at shutting off perfora- geted interval. This zone was abandoned because of its high water
tions. The placement of the RSM has to be executed with extreme cut. A water-shutoff treatment was performed in May 2006 at 9,872
care to avoid premature setting or overdisplacement of the system. ft (9,105 ft vertical depth), seeking theoretical radial penetration
In summary, the OCP system provided an effective seal deep into of 9 ft with the OCP system. This treatment included 20 m3 of
OCP/RSM
treatment
Nov. 2004
Fig. 7—Water-cut history of Well 3 before and after the OCP/RSM treatment.
Fig. 8—Water-cut history of Well 4 before and after the OCP/RSM treatment.
seawater to cool the formation, 50 m3 of OCP system, and 1.6 m3 performed in January 2005, leaving the producing intervals at
of RSM (1.74 g/cm3) using a gel spacer to avoid contamination of 9,594 to 9,643 ft and 9,676 to 9,774 ft in an inferior Cretaceous
both systems. Seawater was used as the displacement fluid. All of formation. General characteristics are as follows: 85% dolomite,
these stages were pumped at 5 bbl/min with a maximum pressure 10% calcite, and 5% limestone; porosity of 7%; permeability of
of 280 psi, observing suction after shutdown. After the preventive 2,512 md, predominantly vuggy; water of saturation 12%; reser-
treatment, the 9,282- to 9,462-ft interval was perforated in the voir temperature of 222°F; and bottomhole static pressure of 2,076
Jurassic formation. Production was increased by an additional psi. The gas/oil contact was at 8,859 ft (8,550 ft vertical depth).
1,325 BOPD and maintained at this level for 1 year; the well was Because the water/oil contact was at 9,282 ft vertical depth at
then closed because of the increasing GOR. It is important to men- the middle of the producing interval and water cut increased from
tion that the upper original interval was abandoned in a mechanical 1.5 to 6%, it was decided to repair the well, with the main objec-
manner, using two permanent packers, without the application of tive of abandoning the current producing intervals because of water
any treatment to preclude the gas communicating down to the coning or high-permeability streaks. The selected technique was
producing interval. to combine the OCP and RSM systems with a theoretical radial
penetration of 12 ft, then perforate an upper interval in the same
Case History: Well 2. Well 2 (Fig. 10) was perforated in August formation. According to the log interpretation in the anisotropy
2001 and completed in January 2002. Its last workover was track, it was possible to identify a fracture train contributing to
64% of the production; thus, the major volume of treatment was shale; porosity of 3%; average permeability of 2,620 md; water
focused on this interval. saturation of 10%; reservoir temperature of 266°F; and bottomhole
With the use of a 95⁄8-in. cement retainer at 9,512 ft, the treat- static pressure of 2,194 psi. During March 2002, the well started to
ment was pumped; it consisted of 15 m3 of seawater for cooling show water influx that varied from 0.2 to 0.5%, and it increased in
down the formation, 50 m3 of OCP system, 1 m3 of linear gel to 2004 to 2%. By the first quarter of 2004, water cut reached 5%, and
avoid contamination of fluid systems, 2.94 m3 of RSM (1.74 gr/ the operator decided to repair the well. It is important to mention
cm3), and a displacement volume of 37.5 m3 of seawater. All stages that, at that time, there were no facilities to dehydrate oil flow. A
were pumped at an average rate and pressure of 3.5 bbl/min and production rate of 7,687 BWPD with 5% water cut could not be
250 psi, respectively. After the treatment, the 9,124- to 9,223-ft handled properly offshore.
interval was perforated and stimulated. After this treatment, the According to log examination, the formation is not highly frac-
new interval produced 12,800 bbl of water-free oil, indicating that tured in this field. However, the main fractures give 2,620 md of
the zones causing water production were shut off. average permeability. The treatment performed was 50 m3 of OCP
system for a radial penetration of 12 ft and 1.5 m3 of RSM sealant.
Case History: Well 3. Well 3 (Fig. 11) was perforated in March In this case, it is probable that most of the treatment had sealed
2000 and completed in June 2000. Its most recent workover was one or two main fractures that allowed the water to enter the well.
performed in December 2004, with producing intervals 10,643 to In these cases, treatment-volume determination becomes crucial,
10,692 ft in a Cretaceous brecciate formation (BTPKS). Charac- but the more the better. Currently this well produces water-free
teristics are as follows: 75% dolomite, 20% limestone, and 5% from the same interval.
liner
liner
liner
Case History: Well 4. Well 4 (Fig. 12) was completed in April References
2005 in the interval of 10,072 to 10,171 ft. After it was perforated, Albonico, P., Bartosek, M., Malandrino, A., Bryant, S., and Lockhart, T.P.
an acid stimulation was carried out by pumping hydrochloric acid 1995. Studies on Phenol-Formaldehyde Crosslinked Polymer Gels in
(HCl) (15% wt). Production shown after stimulation reflected Bulk and in Porous Media. Paper SPE 28983 presented at the 1995 SPE
constant water cut of 11%. Water/oil contact was determined to be International Symposium on Oilfield Chemistry, San Antonio, Texas,
at 495 ft below the base of this perforated interval, so the decision USA, 14–17 February. doi: 10.2118/28983-MS.
was made to perform a water-shutoff treatment and then perforate Barklay, D., Lawson, K., Mullins, B., and Cardono, B. 2006. Standalone
an upper interval 206 ft above the top of the isolated one. Coiled-Tubing Water Shutoff Operations Reinstate Well on a Normally
The formation is a carbonate formation with only 5% shale, Unattended Installation. Paper SPE 100132 presented at the SPE/
having a porosity of 6%, bottomhole static temperature of 220°F, ICoTA Coiled Tubing Conference and Exhibition, The Woodlands,
and an average permeability in the range of 5,000 md. It was fur- Texas, USA, 4–5 April. doi: 10.2118/100132-MS.
ther decided to treat this well with 40 m3 of OCP and 1.83 m3 of Bartosek, M., Mennella, A., Lockhart, T.P., Causin, E., Rossi, E., and Pas-
RSM sealant. A new zone perforated at 9,646 to 9,754 ft was acid succi, C. 1994. Polymer Gels for Conformance Treatments Propagation
stimulated with HCl (15% wt). The entire treatment was performed on Cr(III) Crosslinking Complexes in Porous Media. Paper SPE 27828
through a cement retainer. presented at the SPE/DOE Symposium on Improved Oil Recovery,
Water production (less than 2%) came back right after the treat- Tulsa, 17–20 April. doi: 10.2118/27828-MS.
ment and has remained less than 2% for almost 21⁄2 years following Conformance Technology Manual, Pub. F-3373. 1996. Houston: Hallibur-
the treatment (Fig. 8). ton Energy Services.
Over the last 2 years, the operator has performed preventive Hardy, M., Botermans, W. and Smith, P. 1998. New Organically Crosslinked
water-shutoff treatments using the combination of the OCP and Polymer System Provides Competent Propagation at High Temperature in
RSM systems rather than squeeze-cementing jobs as a result of Conformance Treatments. Paper SPE 39690 prepared for presentation at
the initial success observed with this technique. Previous publica- the SPE/DOE Improved Oil Recovery Symposium, Tulsa, 19–22 April.
tions have documented the success of conformance technology Lockhart, T.P. and Albonico, P. 1994. New Chemistry for the Placement
in Mexico with these systems (Ortiz Polo et al. 2004; Vasquez et of Chromium(III)/Polymer Gels in High-Temperature Reservoirs. SPE
al. 2006). Prod & Fac 9 (4): 273–279; Trans., AIME, 297. SPE-24194-PA. doi:
10.2118/24194-PA.
Conclusions Moradi-Araghi, A. 1994. Application of Low-Toxicity Crosslinking Sys-
1. The combination of the OCP and RSM systems has proved tems in Production of Thermally Stable Gels. Paper SPE 27826 pre-
successful in controlling water production in the Cantarell field sented at the SPE/DOE Symposium on Improved Oil Recovery, Tulsa,
and other fields in Mexico. 17–20 April. doi: 10.2118/27826-MS.
2. The OCP system is capable of penetrating deep into the matrix Ortiz Polo, R.P., Monroy, R.R., Toledo, N., Dalrymple, E.D., Eoff, L., and
of the formation to provide a more effective seal, particularly for Everett, D. 2004. Field Applications of Low Molecular-Weight Polymer
water coning and high-permeability streaks. On the other hand, Activated with an Organic Crosslinker for Water Conformance in South
the RSM system was used as a tail-in because of its fast-setting Mexico. Paper SPE 90449 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Confer-
properties and its capability to stop gas migration. Conventional ence and Exhibition, Houston, 26–29 September. doi: 10.2118/90449-MS.
squeeze cement techniques have yielded negative results in the Prada, A., Civan, F., and Dalrymple, E.D. 2000. Evaluation of Gelation
Cantarell field. Systems for Conformance Control. Paper SPE 59322 presented at the
3. RSM in depleted zones has proved effective as a tail-in of the SPE/DOE Improved Oil Recovery Symposium, Tulsa, 3–5 April. doi:
main treatment because it is controlled, fast setting, and mainly 10.2118/59322-MS.
to avoid overdisplacement of the OCP system. Rodriguez, F., Sanchez, J.L., and Galindo-Nava, A. 2004. Mechanisms and
4. The volume design of the OCP is crucial for the success of the treat- Main Parameters Affecting Nitrogen Distribution in the Gas Cap of the
ment (the more volume injected, the better the results). This volume Supergiant Akal Reservoir in the Cantarell Complex. Paper SPE 90288
becomes even more critical when the problem to be corrected is a presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition,
combination of water coning and highly fractured formations. Houstons, 26–29 September. doi: 10.2118/90288-MS.
5. Recently, the temperature range of the OCP system was Sydansk, R.D. 1993. Acrylamide-Polymer/Chromium(III)-Carboxylate
expanded by the introduction of a retarder for high-tempera- Gels for Near Wellbore Matrix Treatments. SPE Advanced Technology
ture applications and a new base polymer for low-temperature Series 1 (1): 146–152. SPE-20214-PA. doi: 10.2118/20214-PA.
applications. The current temperature range of the OCP system Vasquez, J., Jurado, I., Santillan, A., and Hernandez, R. 2006. Organi-
is from 80 to 350°F (27 to 177°C). cally Crosslinked Polymer System for Water Reduction Treatments