Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10
After reading this chapter, you should be able to:
! Explain why religion has existed in all societies
! List the five great religions of today and summarize their beliefs
! State the problem that fundamentalist religious views pose for the The more I study science,
state the more I believe in God.
! Discuss the role of religion in society —Albert Einstein
From A.D. 1095 to 1272, Europeans went to war to recapture territory which had traditionally
been controlled by Christians from the Muslims. The Crusades, as those wars were called,
changed the nature of society. As evidenced in today’s problems of worldwide terrorism and
fighting in the Middle East, religion is still leading to wars and still changing the nature of
society. The importance of religion to society cannot be overemphasized.
If we think of religion as including all beliefs in supernatural powers, conceived of as
controlling people’s lives, and including various types of spirits and gods, then religion probably
had its beginnings in some of the earliest human societies. The findings of archaeologists and
anthropologists suggest that from time immemorial humans have sought explanations of their
existence and of natural phenomena that went beyond the range of what they could learn from
the ordinary experiences of life or from observation of the natural world.
An aspect of life that from very early on troubled people was the inevitability of death, and
religion often promised them a life beyond death. Also, as cultures and civilizations developed,
people longed to find purposes and satisfactions in life that would transcend the needs and
desires of everyday living and thus give human existence greater dignity and meaning.
Religion helps satisfy this longing because of the concepts common to all of its forms: the
incorporation of a code of ethics; the use of myths or stories; the organization of intellectual
doctrine; the display and comfort of ritual; the fostering of community and regard for others;
and the hope of some intense, personal experience such as the answering of prayer.
That religious beliefs, institutions, and rituals have been a major element in the cultural
patterns of most societies cannot be doubted. Even in modern industrial societies many of our
oldest values and traditions are rooted in religion. In our own country, evidence of religious
influence is rich. It includes the millions of people who attend religious services; the thousands
of houses of worship; the celebration of holidays (holy days) such as those associated with
182
Religion 183
Christmas, Easter, Passover, Yom Kippur, and Ramadan; and those ceremonies that are both
private and official, such as weddings and funerals, and rites such as baptisms and bar
mitzvahs.
In this chapter, our purpose is not to show the truth or falsehood of the doctrines of any
particular faith. Rather, it is:
! To describe the nature of religion and the general character of certain major religions of
the past and present
! To give some attention to the role that religion has played in the development of human
societies, not only to integrate and stabilize them but also, at times, to create conflicts
! To consider the present-day influence of social change on religion and, conversely, the
influence of religion on social change.
The inscription expresses the views of many different religions. The Great Sphinx and the Pyramid of Khafra.
broadest sense, as the relationship between man and the superhuman power he believes in and
feels himself to be dependent upon.” Such a relationship is expressed in various ways,
including feelings of trust or fear, legends, myths, prayer, rituals, and the application of
religious precepts to the conduct of life.
What religions the earliest human beings practiced is a matter for speculation, but there
are some tribal groups today, such as African bushmen, whose way of life is, or has been until
very recently, so removed from modern technology that it is tempting to liken their beliefs to
prehistoric ones. A graphic example can be seen in the classic film The Gods Must Be Crazy. In
the first fifteen minutes of this film, Kalahari bushmen are seen living a life that we feel must
have been unchanged for thousands of years. Suddenly, a Coke bottle is tossed out of a plane
passing overhead and lands among them. The bushmen view the bottle as a gift from the gods,
but it causes changes, including tests of faith, which themselves celebrate the imagination of
the primal human spirit. Ultimately, the bushmen decide they want to get rid of this “new
technology” in order to preserve their way of life.
Other 4% Protestant
Jewish 6%
2% Ch
ris
Buddhist t
ian
None 7% Roman
24% Catholic
Roman 17%
Other Other
Catholic
7% Christians
21%
9%
Hindu None
Other Protestants 15% 16%
Christian 46% Muslim
3% 23%
ist ia n
C hr
(a) U.S. population (b) World population
Figure 10.1
(a) Religious identification of U.S. population; (b) Religious identification of world population. (Source: Pew Research
Center)
do not attend services more than once a year, the total number of people in the United States
classified in the “none” category would rise to more than 50 percent, which is a substantial rise
over past decades.
Whether Confucianism and Taoism in China and Shintoism in Japan should be included
in the great religions of today is questionable. Since the current regime, the status and future of
China’s ancient religions are uncertain. Furthermore, Confucianism often is said to be more a
philosophy than a religion. Shintoism is the ancient religion of Japan but has had strong
competition from Buddhism. In 1868 reformed Shintoism was made the official religion of
Japan, but after World War II religious freedom was declared. However, some calculate that
millions of Japanese still retain their faith in Shintoism. It is a mixture of nature, ancestor, and
emperor worship and is closely associated with Japanese nationalism, although the concept of
the emperor’s divinity was officially abolished in 1945.
Hinduism
Hinduism is the religion and social system of the Hindus, the majority of whom live in India.
Since ancient times, it has had a strong hold in India, and even today it dominates the lives of
the majority of its people. A minority of Indians have been converted to foreign faiths such as
Christianity or Islam, or to religions such as Buddhism, Jainism, or Sikhism, all three of which
developed out of Hinduism itself.
Unlike many religions, Hinduism has no founder, no distinct set of creeds, and, although
it has many clear-cut paths to salvation, no unique path. It holds that the soul inhabits suc-
cessive bodies in its journey through the universe, and thus all life, including insect and plant
life, has a soul. All beings, even the gods, must die and be reborn in an endless cycle. Some
believe that this cycle can be escaped through asceticism, in which personality is lost and the
believer becomes one with the Absolute. Although Hinduism claims to be monotheistic, its
High God has many forms, of which the two best known are Vishnu the creator and preserver
and Shiva the destroyer. There are thousands of lesser gods. No one attempts to remember all
of them, but each has its place in folk affection; the believer will tell you, “They are all the
same god.”
186 Institutions and Society
In Hinduism all life is sacred because all life has a soul. The sacrifice
of living creatures, a characteristic of some Hindu ceremonies, is
explained by precisely this: Because life is sacred, its sacrifice to the gods
is vitally meaningful. Today, however, partly because of the economic
value of animals, sacrifices are almost always represented by flowers and
food (the gods eat the spiritual portion of the food; the material portion
is consumed by the givers). Many animals are sacred: The cow is revered
because she represents Mother Earth. She is never to be injured or killed
(sick and starving cows roam the countryside and crowded city streets;
they have been known to attend the movies in Calcutta). Other sacred
creations are monkeys, snakes, the banyan tree, the herb known as basil,
all mountains and rivers, and rocks of unusual shape.
Hindus are divided into four castes: (1) scholars and priests
(Brahmans, a word meaning “source of life,” or “expansive force”);
(2) administrators of the state; (3) commercial and agricultural entre-
preneurs; and (4) workers who perform the tasks the three higher classes
shun—for example, sweeping floors, cleaning bathrooms, and repairing
shoes. This caste system, in which individuals are differentiated in the
jobs they can have, is hereditary, and although it has been officially
outlawed for decades, it has proved almost impossible to eradicate, and
to transfer to a higher caste is very difficult.
There are hundreds of kinds of Hindus, of which the Sikhs form one
Shiva, a Hindu god. of the most important in the modern world. Sikh is derived from a Hindi
word meaning “disciple,” and Sikhs are disciples of a group of gurus
whose tenets are most easily expressed by naming principles to which they are opposed: the
caste system, the priestly hierarchy and ritual, and idolatry. Sikhs are skilled farmers and
shrewd businesspeople, and they are considered among the world’s finest soldiers. They
subscribe to such Hindu beliefs as birth and rebirth and the transmigration of the soul. In
India, intense religious hatred exists between Sikhs and followers of the dominant Hinduism,
and this enmity is fortified by political and regional rivalries. In 1984, after the Indian Prime
Minister Indira Gandhi had ordered a military attack on the sacred Sikh temple of Amritsar
(which resulted in many Sikh deaths and great damage to the edifice), she was assassinated on
the grounds of her official residence; Sikhs are widely believed to have been responsible. Since
then there has been ongoing tension in the Punjab region of India, where the majority of Sikhs
reside.
An outward sign of Hinduism is its concentration on counting and classifying, creating
categories into which to fit individual manifestations. This usually is explained as a method of
imposing order on a complicated world, but it can also be seen as a means of imposing
disorder, or of proving, by the endlessness of the effort, that the world cannot be categorized.
This characteristic enables Hinduism to incorporate diverse and even contradictory prin-
ciples if Hindus find them good.
Hinduism has been gaining popularity in the West under the auspices of movements such
as Hare Krishna. Many Americans have become disenchanted with modern-day society and
the principle of rationality on which it is based. They argue that rationality has led us into the
mess we are in and that it is time to turn to faith and mysticism.
Buddhism
Although Buddhism, for the reasons outlined in this section, is now rare in India, it remains
important in the Eastern world. It teaches that by right thinking and self-denial its followers
can achieve nirvana. It developed out of early Hinduism, and one of its chief objectives is to
free people from the endless cycle of reincarnations that is part of Hindu doctrine. Buddhism
was founded more than 500 years before Christ by a young Nepalese prince, Shakyamuni
Religion 187
Judaism
We now turn to the three major monotheistic religions (religions with one god)—Judaism,
Christianity, and Islam—which all share a common history. We begin with Judaism, which,
although it has played an important role in world history, has a relatively small number of
adherents. In 2015, the entire Jewish population of the world was probably only about 13.9
million, compared with about 2.2 billion Christians and 1.6 billion Muslims.
Judaism developed out of the religion of the ancient Hebrew tribe. According to the Bible
story, a great leader of this tribe, Abraham, put his trust in a single God to guide him and his
people in their migrations. During their wanderings, the Hebrews, or Israelites, as they came
to be called (after Jacob, or Israel, the grandson of Abraham), moved into the fertile Nile delta
to escape famine. There they were eventually enslaved by the Egyptians.
During the period of their slavery, probably sometime between 1450 B.C. and 1400 B.C.,
there arose a great leader, Moses. He led the Israelites to freedom, as God had directed him,
and came to be commonly regarded as the real founder of Judaism. After the escape of the
Israelites from Egypt, Moses ascended Mount Sinai, where God appeared to him and through
him made a sacred covenant with what were by then the twelve tribes of Israel. That covenant
required that the Israelites acknowledge “the God of Israel” as ruler of the world and creator of
heaven and earth. In return, God recognized the people of Israel as his chosen followers.
Moses had been instructed by God to call him Yahweh, or as it is sometimes translated,
Jehovah. When Moses came down from the mountain, he brought with him two stone tablets
on which were inscribed Yahweh’s Ten Commandments. These were later amplified into the
many commandments and prohibitions set forth in the Torah—the Pentateuch, or the Five
Books of Moses—which is part of both Jewish scriptures and the Christian Old Testament.
Judaism has several unique characteristics. First, though it makes claims to universality, it
was and still is primarily the religion of a group of people who can, with qualifications, regard
themselves as descendants of the ancient Israelites. Jews believe that they were chosen by God,
but they do not believe that being chosen by God makes them special. They do not understand
why they were chosen, and they regard it as a burden as much as a blessing. In fact, in the Book
of Exodus, God suggests to Moses that perhaps he should begin again with a less fractious
tribe. According to Jewish theologians, God chose the Jews simply because he had to begin
somewhere. They do not see it as an honor or as a sign that they are superior, attitudes that are
attributed to them by some non-Jews.
Second, Judaism has preserved much of its essential character for more than 3,000 years.
It has done this in spite of the fact that for more than 1,900 years, ever since their last major
rebellion against Rome was crushed by the Emperor Hadrian in A.D. 135, Jews have been a
widely scattered and often persecuted minority among alien peoples. Finally, and most
important, Judaism was the first great religion to develop a clear and unequivocal concept of a
single God as the creator and ruler of the universe.
Although some Jews believe in the resurrection of the dead and that people must account
beyond the grave for their good and evil deeds, unlike some other religions Judaism is a world-
affirming, not a world-denying, faith, and it requires that Jews enjoy this life and use their
abilities for the service of humankind. It looks for the coming of the Messiah—the expected
deliverer of the Jews—and for a messianic age in which the kingdom of eternal peace will
prevail and all evil impulses will be removed from the human heart. But it rejects the Christian
belief that the Messiah has already come with his message of salvation.
From the Middle Ages to early modern times, the rights of Jews in Europe were greatly
restricted, and they were forced to live in special sections of the cities called ghettos. The
French Revolution and Napoleon did much to free Jews from the ghettos. But later there was a
backlash, and it was not until after the social upheavals of 1848 that in most countries Jews
received full rights of citizenship on a more or less permanent basis. This, however, did not end
their troubles, for the very success that many of them soon enjoyed in their professions stirred
up new waves of anti-Semitism, or feelings of hatred and dislike toward Jews.
Religion 189
Christianity
Christianity, the principal religion of the Western world, developed from Judaism, and the
greater part of the Christian Bible (the Old Testament) still consists of Jewish sacred writings.
The ancient Jews believed that at his chosen time God would confound their enemies and set
up a new Jewish kingdom under a Messiah (deliverer) descended from King David. Later,
some came to believe that the Messiah would come
down from heaven at the end of the world, at the
time of the resurrection of the dead, and would
carry out the last judgment.
Jesus of Nazareth, the founder of Christianity,
was born in Bethlehem, about A.D. 1. This date in
itself is an example of the power of religion. In
Western cultures, events that took place before the
birth of Christ are dated “B.C., ” meaning “Before
Christ.” For instance, in Chapter 3, we said that
humans first appeared in China about 20,000 B.C.
The term “A.D.” stands for the Latin words anno
domini, which literally translated mean “in the year
of our Lord.” This term is used to begin numbering
all over again, with A.D. 1 as the year of Christ’s
birth. The year A.D. 2000 means the two thousandth
Pope in front of a large crowd.
year after Christ’s birth.1
© imageBROKER/Alamy Stock Photo
1
Twentieth-century scholarship indicates that Christ actually was born about 4 B.C. There will be no attempt to
renumber dates, as that task would be impossible, and the Western world’s dating system will continue to use A.D. 1
as a reference point. An alternative, secular, way of designating A.D. and B.C. is C.E. (Common Era) and B.C.E. (Before
the Common Era).
Religion 191
At some point in Jesus’ life, he became convinced that he was the Messiah, or Christ, and
the divine son of God. Often he is called Jesus Christ, which simply means Jesus, the Messiah.
Soon after he started his ministry, at about the age of thirty, he gathered around him the
Apostles, the twelve close associates who were to be his chief aides and who were to carry on
his ministry after his death.
Our knowledge of Jesus’ teachings comes to us indirectly. He did not write them down but
depended on his disciples to preach from memory what he had taught. Our chief sources are,
first, the Gospels of the New Testament and, second, the Epistles. But these were prepared long
after Jesus’ death. The four Gospels are thought by historians to have been written between A.D.
65 and about A.D. 100. Presumably, they were based on documents in which some of his
followers had recorded his sayings as they remembered them. But how accurately his sayings
and the events of his life were recorded, or how much was changed or added by successive
copiers or revisers of the Gospels, historical scholarship cannot tell us with any certainty.
Jesus never doubted the reality of God or of his own special relationship to God. But he
knew he had not been sent, as some of his hearers hoped, to deliver the Jews from Rome by
reestablishing the earthly kingdom of David. Rather, he had been sent by his Father to show all of
humanity, Jews and Gentiles alike, the way to heavenly salvation. Like many Jews of his day, he
believed that the long-foretold messianic kingdom of God would come rather soon, but for him
it was a kingdom in heaven, which was only for those who would believe in him, who would truly
repent of their sins, and who would surrender to the will of God before it was too late.
Jesus taught that the most important things are to believe in God, do His will, and believe
in Jesus as the son of God. God is utterly good: supremely righteous and just, but also forgiving
and merciful. Therefore, people should trust him completely and regularly seek spiritual aid
through prayer. Jesus also taught that God demands we love one another, friend and foe alike,
and this has been one of the most difficult teachings for devout Christians to interpret and to
apply as a practical guide in daily conduct. In addition, Jesus taught his disciples to obey the
Ten Commandments, which God transmitted to Moses on Mount Sinai, and to follow the
golden rule. The latter states, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.”
Jesus’ success in drawing crowds in Galilee soon attracted the attention of the leaders of the
two principal Jewish sects, or parties, in Jerusalem—the Sadducees and the Pharisees. They had
their own differences, but both became enemies of Jesus because his teaching and his actions did
not always follow the dictates of either Judaic law or tradition. After he had been preaching for
three or four years, Jesus decided to go to Jerusalem at the time of the Passover, when Jews from a
wide area would be assembled for the great annual festival. This gave the enemies of Jesus an
opportunity to stir up ill feeling against him among the people. Finally they seized him, made
accusations against him, and denounced him to the Roman governor, Pilate, on the ground that
he claimed to be king of the Jews. Pilate doubted Jesus’ guilt, but when the crowd demanded
death, the governor acquiesced and ordered Jesus’ crucifixion at Golgotha.
Three events reported in the Gospels and the Epistles are of crucial significance for
Christianity: (1) the Last Supper of Jesus with his disciples on the evening before the crucifixion,
(2) his crucifixion, and (3) his resurrection on the third day after his death. Even before coming
to Jerusalem, Jesus had foretold his death and resurrection to the twelve apostles. A key belief of
the Christian religion is that Jesus died to redeem the sins of humankind and thus opened for
them the way to salvation. In the sacrament of Communion, or the Eucharist, which was first
celebrated by Jesus with the twelve disciples at the Last Supper, devout communicants believe
that they enter into a special relationship with Christ. The wine they drink and the bread they eat
symbolize, or in Catholic doctrine actually become, the blood and body of Christ. The com-
municant is thus strengthened in his or her attempts to achieve salvation by the redemptive
power that Christ achieved through his death and resurrection.
The Early Christians. The spread of Christianity after Jesus’ death was relatively rapid, but
the early Christian groups, or churches, were only loosely linked. By the end of the first century,
however, administrative organization had begun to develop in Rome and elsewhere, and
192 Institutions and Society
except Quebec, Protestant settlers from northwestern Europe were in the majority. In other
areas, as in practically all of Latin America, settlers came largely from overwhelmingly
Catholic countries such as Spain, Portugal, and Italy. Christianity was also carried to other
parts of the world by the strong missionary movement that developed in the nineteenth
century, but in most non-Christian countries missionaries succeeded in converting only a
small fraction of the people.
Islam
Islam, like Judaism and Christianity, is a religion based on divine revelation, and its mes-
senger, Muhammad, like Moses, made no claims to divinity for himself. He believed only that
he had been chosen by God, or Allah, to receive from the angel Gabriel revelations of Allah’s
will. These revelations, which became frequent, he repeated in full to those who would listen,
and shortly after his death they were assembled by his friend Abû Bakr to form the Qu’ran, the
holy scriptures of the Muslims. Abû Bakr became the first successor, or caliph, to carry on
Muhammad’s work. The Qur’an begins as follows:
In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful.
All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds.
The Beneficent, the Merciful.
Master of the Day of Judgment.
Thee do we serve and Thee do we beseech for help.
Keep us on the right path.
The path of those upon whom Thou hast bestowed favors. Not [the path] of those
upon whom Thy wrath is brought down, nor of those who go astray.
The Qur’an is accessible on the Web in formats that are easily searchable for specific topics,
and, given the importance of Islam to modern world affairs, browsing through it is definitely a
worthwhile activity.
Muhammad was born about A.D. 570 at Mecca, in the western part of what is now Saudi
Arabia. According to tradition, he was orphaned and became a ward first of his grandfather and
then of an uncle, both of whom were prominent members of the Koreish tribe. Later he was a
merchant, and at about the age of 25 he became the business advisor to a rich widow, fifteen
years his senior, whom he eventually married. Meanwhile, he had come into contact with the
Arabian religion of his time, which was a mixture of animism and polytheism. Muhammad had
also learned something about Judaism and Christianity from his acquaintances in Mecca who
were followers of both religions. His contacts with Jews and Christians may have contributed to
his dissatisfaction with the beliefs and practices of his fellow Arab tribesmen.
Though Muhammad himself initiated the religion of Islam, he was greatly influenced by
Christianity and Judaism. He considered that he was completing and perfecting the work
194 Institutions and Society
of Moses, Jesus, and other heavenly messengers whom he recognized as his forerunners.
But Muhammad denied the Christian doctrine of the Trinity and the divinity of Christ.
According to the Qur’an, God is one and God is eternal. He neither begets nor is begotten.
In Arabic, Islam means “submission,” and Muslims are submitters to the will of God. The
devout Muslim’s goal is fairly simple: It is to perform one’s duties as outlined in the Qur’an and
as exemplified by the acts of Muhammad in his lifetime. For devout Muslims, the Qur’an
is infallible.
The so-called Five Pillars of Islam state the indispensable religious duties of a believer:
1. Acceptance and frequent repetition of the creed, “There is no God but Allah and
Muhammad is his messenger.”
2. The performance five times a day of prescribed rituals of prayer and devotion
3. The giving of alms to the needy
4. The fast during Ramadan, the month when the angel Gabriel appeared to Muhammad
5. The pilgrimage to the Kaaba stone at Mecca once in a lifetime by those who can afford it
From the seventh century to the eighteenth century, Islam spread as far west as Spain and as
far east as the Philippines. It was able to do this through its access to trade routes from its
original home in Arabia and through military conquest. Islam’s influence ebbed and flowed,
but by the end of World War I in 1918 it had reached a low. By the second half of the twentieth
century, however, with political independence and national consciousness, Islam was
enjoying a resurgence and again extending its influence. Today its principal distribution is in
the Arabian peninsula, North and West Africa, the Middle East, Turkey, Afghanistan and the
Indian subcontinent, parts of the former USSR, and Indonesia. In both the United States and
Europe, the number of Muslims is growing, and some authorities predict that there will be
more Muslims than Jews in the United States in coming decades.
One of the reasons for the growing number of Muslims in the U.S. and Europe was the
conflicts in Syria, Libya and Afghanistan, which displaced millions of people, and led Europe
to classify them as political refugees. This classification made them eligible to emigrate,
whereas had they been classified as economic refugees–refugees who are moving for economic
reasons, they would not have been eligible. In 2015 Germany took in over one million
migrants, most of whom were Muslims.
The Denominations of Islam. After Muhammad’s death, Islam split into two factions: the
Shiites (the sectarians, followers of Ali, cousin to the Prophet), who believed that Ali was the
legitimate successor to Muhammad, and the Sunnis (the traditionalists), who believed that Abû
Bakr, the oldest companion of Muhammad, was the legitimate successor. Today Sunnis constitute
about 85 percent of all Muslims and Shiites constitute about 15 percent. There are also smaller
sects of Islam, including the Sufis and the Wahhabis, and
though they are small in number, they can play important
roles in the interaction between the Islamic world and the
Western world.
The difference between Sunnis and Shiites concerns
who should be seen as the legitimate religious authority in
society. Shiites follow a system of Imamah. They believe
that the existing Imam is the true leader of Muslims, and
that all true Muslims must submit to his rule. Imams are
appointed by existing Imams, which means there is a line
of succession that always assumes a living Imam as ruler.
Because Imams carry enormous power among believers to
tell people what to do, Imamah can, and often does, come
in conflict with governments, which also claim the right to
tell people what to do. An example is Iran, which has a
The Qur’an is the Holy Book of Islam. Shiite majority. Iran has both a religious authority—the
Religion 195
Imam—and a democratically elected government, and there is often confusion about which
authority is in charge.
Sunnis do not follow a system of Imamah. This means that Sunnis generally are more
content with having a secular ruler as long as that secular ruler does not interfere with the
spiritual dimension of religion. In Iraq there are both Sunnis and Shiites, with the Shiites in the
majority. However, Iraq had never been a democracy, and until 2004 the Sunnis were in
charge. It was in part to keep the Shiite majority out of power that the United States had earlier
supported Saddam Hussein in his war with Iran.
After invading Iraq in 2003, the United States struggled with setting up a democratic
government, which the United States stated was one of the goals of the invasion, in a country
with a Shiite majority whose beliefs often put religious rule by an Imam above secular
democratic rule. The type of problem the Shiite sect presents today was the kind of problem
that led Rousseau early on in his discussion of democracy to despair of the relationship
between religion and government, and to call on government to set up a civil religion that
avoided the conflict.
Islamic Fundamentalism. In recent years, there has been much discussion of what is
sometimes called Islamic fundamentalism and its connection to terrorism and jihad.
In Arabic, jihad means “striving,” but it is commonly used by the Western press to denote a
sacred war against the Western world. As with all fundamentalist religious groups, there is
much dispute about what is meant by fundamentalist Islam and whether some groups should
be considered as fundamentalist Muslims. According to the dictionary, fundamentalism
consists of “strict maintenance of ancient or fundamental doctrines.” The problem is that
there is generally ambiguity about what those doctrines are, and the issue comes down to who
is interpreting them. For some fundamentalists, such as Al Q’aeda and ISIS (the Islamic State
Iraq and Syria) the empowerment of Islam, which they see as God’s plan for humankind, is a
sacred end, and it can be achieved only through the establishment of an Islamic state. They
interpret these doctrines as requiring Muslims to fight against the Western world and to
reestablish an Islamic state, regardless of the costs to society and humanity. This interpret-
ation of Islam had led to justification of terrorist attacks and wars in Islamic countries to
replace existing governments with fundamenalist Islamic governments.
Other Muslims interpret them quite differently; many simply want to be left alone to
follow their spiritual beliefs, leaving secular matters to government. Their concern is with
religion, not government. For them, religious fundamentalism is simply strict adherence to
the Five Pillars. The difference between the two views of fundamentalism has sometimes been
called the difference between revivalists, who want to be spiritually devout, and fanatics and
extremists, who exploit this devotion for political ends.
Ayatollah Khomeini, who led the Islamic revolution in Iran, combined fundamentalism
with the Shiite belief in the role of the Imam and argued that because Islamic government is a
government of law, and because a knowledge of law is necessary for anyone to rule, the person
who should rule is the person whose knowledge of the law surpasses all others. Under this
interpretation, it is appropriate to revolt against existing secular governments and replace them
with rule by Islamic clerics, such as himself. This perspective fit Shiite views much better than it
fit Sunni views, which posited a separation between religion and secular government. Khomeini
also claimed that the West was on a crusade to eliminate Islam from the world and that Western
ways were evil. In so doing he portrayed the United States in particular as the great Satan,
claiming that good Muslims would reject U.S. technology and way of life.
More recent Islamic scholars such as Hasan alt-Turai and Sayyid Muhammad Husayn
Fadlallah have argued that the problem is not that the West is on a crusade to eliminate Islam,
but instead that the West has dispossessed Muslims. Unlike Khomeini, these scholars argue
that Islam could selectively borrow technology and institutions from the West. These debates
are still going on in Islamic society, and the outcome will play an important role in the peace of
the world.
196 Institutions and Society
This is not the case, however, with Islam, and Islamic fundamentalism poses the threat of
religion to secular government that Rousseau foresaw. How those theological decisions play
out will make a significant difference to the future of both the Middle East and the world.
Key Points
! Humans have always been troubled by the inev- ! Modern religions face serious questions. Disputes
itability of death and the meaning of life; their arise both within religions and among religions.
interest in these issues has led them to religion. ! Religion has played a central role in society for
! The five great religions of today are Hinduism thousands of years and is likely to do so for thou-
Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. sands of years in the future.
! In current society, religion is a source of moral ! Religion presents a potential problem for secular
values, and it significantly influences all aspects of government if religion extends its influence beyond
life. the spiritual realm.