You are on page 1of 13

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp.

1–13, 2005
Ó 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Printed in Great Britain
doi:10.1016/j.emj.2004.12.005 0263-2373 $30.00

Using the Internet to


Enhance Global
Strategy
GEORGE YIP, London Business School
ANNA DEMPSTER, Birkbeck College, University of London

How does the Internet affect globalization and glo- v Which aspects of website design and functionality
bal strategy within firms? How should multina- affect global strategies?
tional companies re-evaluate their global v Does using the Internet improve the performance
strategies to best take advantage of the Internet? of multinational companies?
Both managers and researchers have assumed that
a correct and appropriate use of Internet technolo-
gies by companies speeds up globalization of
industries and enables firm use of global strategies. The Internet as a Driver of Globalization
This paper provides empirical evidence on the
exact uses of the Internet by global companies, What characteristics cause some industries to make
how their use affects key globalization drivers more use of the Internet? Observing the more suc-
and how they believe this, in turn, affects perfor- cessful applications, commentators and researchers
mance. We derive ten lessons on how companies have suggested a number of industry characteristics
can use the Internet to enhance their global which promote Internet use (Andal-Ancion et al.,
strategies. 2003): digitizability of the end product (e.g., most
Ó 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. information-based products such as directories and
encyclopedias), time sensitivity of the end product
Keywords: Internet, Globalization, Global strat- (e.g., airline travel), high search costs (e.g., books),
egy, Multinational companies potential for customization (e.g., clothing retailers),
insufficient matching of buyers and sellers (e.g., busi-
ness-to-business exchanges and consumer-to-con-
Can companies use the Internet to enhance their glo- sumer auction sites), and a tradeoff between
bal strategies? Both in the sense of expanding their richness and reach (e.g., retail brokerage, Evans and
geographic scope, and in the sense of globally oper- Würster, 1999). We propose an additional industry
ating more-integrated strategies, the ubiquitous nat- characteristic—globalization—that also increases
ure of the Internet (and its application in the World use of the Internet by firms.
Wide Web) should make it easier for companies to
globalize (Govindarajan and Gupta, 2001; Yip, One of the main difficulties in assessing the effects of
2000). This paper provides a framework for thinking the Internet per se is that it has come at a time of other
about this issue and provides evidence from a survey significant developments in the global economy
of 115 multinational companies, primarily based in (Nadler and Tushman, 1999). The various drivers
Europe. We address the following questions: of globalization that have blurred geographical
boundaries for business have also introduced global
v Does industry make a difference? Which indus- opportunities as well as increasing operational
tries offer more potential for using the Internet complexities. However, taken as a whole Internet
to enhance global strategies? technologies have in many cases accelerated global-
v Does use of the Internet make it easier for compa- ization processes through a number of key techno-
nies to implement global strategies? logical characteristics that have made it particularly
v Which aspects of Internet use help most with suitable for driving the globalization tendencies of
implementing global strategies? multinational firms:

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 1
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

v Designed as a decentralized network with no central the Internet and its repercussions on multinational
control, no single body or person can dictate what firms are only just emerging (Bakos and Brynjolfsson,
goes in, comes out, or how it is used (although 1999).
some national governments increasingly try to
selectively block or monitor Internet access and
use). Companies and sub-units can use and adapt
the Internet according to their specific needs. A Framework for the Internet and
v The effect of this decentralization of transactions and Globalization
information transfer raises major questions about
the role of bodies which would have traditionally Our framework for the Internet and globalization
had functions of control, such as governments and builds on extensive previous research on the relation-
regulatory institutions. In terms of transferring, ship between industry characteristics, particularly
accessing information, companies are now much industry globalization drivers, and global strategy
less dependent on local infrastructures. (Porter, 1986). Exhibit 1 illustrates the core compo-
v As a technology, the Internet is designed with dis- nents of our framework. Industry globalization driv-
regard for established boundaries such as geographi- ers, such as globally common customer needs or
cal, political and legal. global scale economies (outlined in detail in the next
v Borderless communications mean that distance in no section), encourage firms in specific industries to use
way hinders communications. International man- various global strategies—such as global market par-
agement teams who use the Internet are not lim- ticipation, global products, global activity networks,
ited by geographic scope. global marketing, and global competitive moves
v As an interactive medium, the Internet can be used (Path 1). There is also a direct effect between these
for collaboration and identity building across a industry globalization drivers and Internet use (Path
dispersed community such as those in a global 2). Firms using global strategies are likely to make
firm. more use of the Internet to exploit the latter’s global
v Cost and speed advantages are also substantial. The capabilities (Path 3). In turn use of the Internet fur-
Internet is a much less expensive way to send ther enables the implementation of global strategies
information, and this information can be received (Path 4). Lastly, Internet-enabled global strategies
in real time anywhere in the world. For global contribute to improving the global performance of
businesses this has massive implications for the a firm (Path 5).
possible scale and scope of operations and rede-
fines the traditional trade-off between richness To investigate our questions and to test our frame-
and reach, allowing both to be achieved for rela- work we designed a questionnaire and had it com-
tively little cost. 1 pleted by 115 multinational companies from
v Nomadic/mobile computing has become a reality as Europe and other parts of the world. We also con-
the Internet, the World Wide Web, and their ducted follow-up interviews with a selection of par-
accompanying technologies, such as WAP and ticipating firms. Appendix ‘Research Methodology’
3G, continue to evolve. describes our methodology in detail.
So it seems that the Internet is at least highly comple-
mentary to the already powerful trends that are forc-
ing companies to become global, and at most a key
driving force of the continued globalization of exist-
How much should a Company use the
ing companies. Internet?

While the Internet seems all pervasive in daily life, How much of its business should a company expect
research on its dominant effects on globalization is to book over the Internet? During the Internet
limited and empirical work on the precise use of bubble, commentators and promoters expected tradi-

Industry Use of Enabling of Improved


Globalization Global Use of Internet Global Global
Drivers #1 Strategies #3 #4 Strategies #5 Performance

#2

Note: (#) indicates Path numbers as discussed in text.

Exhibit 1 Overall Framework of Globalization and Internet

2 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

Sales Service and Customer Information (both at 4.3),


Worldwide Revenues Booked Over the Internet
and Marketing (4.2).
Industry Sector % of Industry % of Firm
Lesson 1: Don’t worry about booking huge percentages of
Chemical/Pharmaceutical 5.0 3.6 your revenues over the Internet but make sure that nearly
Construction/Capital Goods 6.5 2.0 every activity takes the Internet into consideration.
Energy/Resource 5.2 6.2
Financial/Property 4.8 3.5
Logistics/Transport 6.2 4.4
Retail/Grocery 10.2 7.6 Does Industry Globalization Affect
Technology/Media/Telecommunications 9.6 7.0
Average 6.8 4.9
Use of the Internet?
n = 115 companies
Industries differ in their globalization potential and
Exhibit 2 Use of the Internet by Industry in their degree of Internet use. How are the two
related?
tional companies to rapidly shift the bulk of their
business to the Internet or die. This credo was
typified by General Electric’s ‘‘destroyyourbusi-
ness.com’’ initiative. We found that only 6.8% of Market Globalization Drivers
industry revenues and 4.9% of firm revenues were
booked over the Internet. But there were, of course, Market globalization drivers depend in particular on
differences by industry sector. Two sectors scored globally common customer needs and tastes, which in
notably higher than the others did. Both the Re- turn allow multinational companies to sell products
source/Support and Technology/Media/Telecom- (goods or services) with a high degree of global stan-
munications sectors had much higher levels of dardization. The higher the degree of global com-
revenues booked over the Internet at both the indus- monality in an industry, the easier it is for
try and firm level (Exhibit 2). These industries were companies to use the Internet and the Web to offer
particularly well suited to take advantage of the var- information and transactions to customers around
ious characteristics and cost benefits of the Internet the world. Examination of the two ends of the spec-
and adopted it much more quickly. trum makes this point clear. At one extreme, compa-
nies in an industry in which all customers around the
However, it was clear that managers in all industries world want only one globally standardized product
made sure that the Internet was taken into consider- could reach and sell to these customers with the sim-
ation in nearly every individual activity. We found plest of websites, and these websites should have a
that most individual activities of the majority of com- high degree of global standardization. At the other
panies made some use of the Internet (Exhibit 3). The extreme, companies in an industry in which custom-
greatest use at the time of the questionnaire was for ers in different countries want nationally unique
R&D, Customer Information, and Marketing (all at products would have to provide far more complex
3.1 out of 5.0). Most companies reported they would websites, and these websites should need a high de-
greatly increase each activity’s use over the next gree of local customization, not just in their content
three years, with the greatest predicted uses for After but also in their format.

3.1
research and development 3.9
2.0
production 3.0
2.6
distribution / logistics 3.9
3.0
marketing 4.1
2.3
selling 3.7 Now
2.3 In Three Years
after-sales service 3.8
1.8
billing and collection 3.6
3.1
customer information 4.3
2.6
supplier information 4.0
2.5
OVERALL ACTIVITIES 3.8

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0

Exhibit 3 Firm Use of the Internet by Activity

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 3
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

We measured market globalization drivers in terms and transportation for sourcing efficiencies; energy
of the extent to which customers have globally com- and resources; and retail and groceries for cost differ-
mon needs and tastes. We found this measure to ences; and technology, media and telecoms for new
have a large positive correlation (.27) with expected product development costs.
future use of the Internet, measured as average of
all individual activities (even though it did not have
a significant relationship with use of the Internet
now). This finding implies that in industries where Government Globalization Drivers
companies have customers with more globally com-
mon needs and tastes, firms are more likely to in- Government actions affect industry globalization by
crease their use of the Internet across various value raising inter-country trade and investment barriers
adding activities (as listed in Exhibit 3). Industry sec- or, in some cases, by providing inducements. The
tors (see list in Appendix on Research Methodology) existence of trade and investment barriers should
which rated high in our survey of globally common encourage the use of the Internet as ways to bypass
needs and tastes include: chemicals and pharmaceu- them, particularly import duties and taxes. Unless a
ticals; technology, media and telecoms; logistics, dis- government is actively engaged in monitoring and
tribution and transportation; and energy and censoring Internet traffic, as is the case of a few
resources. This list matches those found in other authoritarian regimes, most governments find it
studies (Morrison, 1990; Johansson and Yip, 1994). impossible to track or tax services delivered over
the Internet. For goods and services ordered over
the Internet but delivered physically across borders,
governments should, in theory, be able to tax these
Cost Globalization Drivers at the frontier. In practice, however, most govern-
ments miss significant proportions of the increasing
Key cost globalization drivers include global econo- number of relatively low value items.
mies of scale or scope, global sourcing efficiencies,
cost differences in producing in different countries, Other government globalization drivers include glo-
and high product development costs. Each of these bal standardization of technical standards and global
spurs MNCs to implement global strategies such as commonality of marketing regulations. Differences
global factories, global production networks, global in technical standards among countries affect the ex-
buying, relocation of activities to low cost countries, tent to which products can be globally or regionally
and development of global rather than national prod- standardized. Industries moving to global technical
ucts. Each of these strategies is made easier by use of standards should generally make more use of the
the Internet: including to coordinate a global network Internet as ways to make these standards more acces-
of production sites, to coordinate global buying both sible and transparent, which in turn should encour-
in terms of internal customers and external suppliers, age adoption of global standards. Differing
and to coordinate national needs in the development marketing regulations affect the extent to which uni-
of global products. form global marketing approaches can be used. Mar-
keting across borders over the Internet is easier in
We measured cost globalization drivers in terms of: industries with globally common regulations.

(a) the importance of global scale or scope economies, We measured government globalization drivers in
(b) potential savings from global sourcing efficiencies, terms of:
(c) extent of cost differences in producing in different
countries, (a) level of favorable global trade and investment policies,
(d) ratio of new product development costs relative to (b) global standardization of technical standards,
expected lifetime revenues. (c) global commonality of marketing regulations.

We found that new product development costs had a We found that level of favorable global trade and invest-
significant and positive correlation (.22) with current ment policies had a significant positive correlation
uses of the Internet although the others did not. All (.22) with current use of the Internet at the time of
four measures, however, have large positive correla- the questionnaire, although the other measures did
tions (from .18 to .27) with expected future use (the not. But all three measures had a large positive corre-
average of all individual activities.) This finding im- lation (from .19 to .25) with expected future use (aver-
plies that companies in industries which have stron- age of all individual activities). This finding implies
ger cost globalization drivers are more likely to that companies in industries that have stronger gov-
increase their use of the Internet across their various ernment globalization drivers are more likely to in-
value adding activities (as listed in Exhibit 3). Indus- crease their use of the Internet across their various
try sectors that rated high in our survey on cost glob- value adding activities (as listed in Exhibit 3). Indus-
alization drivers include: logistics, distribution and try sectors that rated high in our survey include:
transportation; and chemicals and pharmaceuticals none in particular for favorable trade and investment
for scale/scope economies; logistics, distribution policies; energy and resources; technology, media

4 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

and telecoms; logistics, retail and groceries; and dis- competitive globalization drivers are more likely to
tribution and transportation for standardization of increase their use of the Internet across their various
technical standards; and technology, media and tele- value adding activities (as listed in Exhibit 3). Indus-
coms for commonality of marketing regulations. tries that rated high on the average of all the global-
ization drivers in our survey include: technology,
media and telecoms; and distribution and trans-
Competitive Globalization Drivers portation.

Globalization requires companies to be particularly Lesson 2: Most companies in more globalized industries
sensitive to competitive actions and reactions. The make more use of the Internet in order to better exploit
Internet heightens this global rivalry in several ways. globalization potential. The competitive implication is that
First, ‘‘Internet time’’ accelerates the necessary speed companies in such industries need to carefully monitor
of moves and countermoves. Second, the Web creates how rivals are making use of the Internet, and lead or
a public forum for signaling, making it easier for match rivals’ activities.
competitors to communicate with each other. Third,
comparison of competitors becomes much easier for
potential customers, particularly in terms of price
transparency—the Web allowing for both cross-com- Global Strategies and Use of Internet
petitor and cross-border comparisons. Fourth, the
Web makes it easier for companies with a given com- The previous arguments and analyses show that
petitive advantage to transfer and leverage that companies in more globalized industries should
advantage globally in a variety of ways discussed make more use of the Internet. It is also well estab-
above (such as by reducing the amount of physical lished that companies in more globalized industries
investments needed). Fifth, for existing industry should and do make more use of global strategies.
leaders or incumbents, the Internet era has created These strategies include global market participation,
the phenomenon of ‘‘born global’’ rivals—via the globally standardized products and services, global
Internet these companies have global reach from activity networks, global marketing, and global com-
the day they put up a Website (such as Amazon petitive moves (Yip, 1992). So the next question is
and eBay). whether companies that make more use of global
strategies should make more use of the Internet,
We measured competitive globalization drivers in and conversely, whether use of the Internet actually
terms of the average of all the individual industry helps them to implement global strategies.
globalization drivers listed above. We found this
measure to have a significant positive correlation Overall, we found that the average use of global strate-
with both current (.25) and expected future (.45) gies was positively correlated (.22) with the average
Internet use (average of all individual activities). In use of the Internet in firm activities, and also with the
a further test, we ran a regression of average activity use of the Internet for two individual activities:
use of the Internet now against average industry global- after-sales service (.23) and customer information (.24).
ization drivers. The result showed a significant slope However, these findings do not imply causation. It
of 0.31, meaning that a 1.0 unit increase in the could be either that greater use of global strategies
strength of industry globalization drivers results in leads to more use of the Internet or that greater use
an average .31 unit increase in the use of the Internet of the Internet leads to more use of global strategies.
in company activities (Exhibit 4). This finding im- The truth is probably both. A related finding does
plies that companies in industries that have stronger provide evidence that the effect flows from use of
the Internet. We asked about the extent to which
use of the Internet made it easier for the companies
to implement various global strategies. We found that
5.0
use of the Internet had at least a moderate effect
(2.5 or higher on 1 to 5 scale) on all global strategies,
with the greatest effects for operate global activity
4.0
networks and co-ordinate globally dispersed activities
Average
Slope = 0.31
(Exhibit 5).
Activity 3.0
Use of
Internet We found further support for this enabling effect on
2.0 global strategies of use of the Internet by conducting
some correlation analysis. We found that greater use
1.0
of the Internet, as measured by the average use of the
1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 Internet in firm activities was positively correlated
Average Industry Globalization Drivers with every measure of the extent to which the Internet
made it easier to implement global strategies (detailed in
Exhibit 4 Effect of Industry Globalization Drivers on the next sections) and with the average of these mea-
Use of Internet sures (correlation of .39).

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 5
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

participate in foreign markets 2.6

globally rollout new products and services


2.6
quickly

offer standardised products or services 2.5

offer localised products or services 2.6

locate activities outside home country 2.8

operate global activity networks 3.2

co-ordinate globally dispersed activities 3.1

have a globally uniform marketing 2.6

use global competitive moves 2.6

Mean 2.7

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0


Score

Exhibit 5 Internet Effects on Implementation of Global Strategies

Internet Effects on Global Market Participation eign markets (path 4): production (.30), distribution/
logistics (.20), marketing (.20), selling (.40), after-sales
By substituting for or supplementing physical activ- service (.45), billing and collection (.48), customer infor-
ities, the Internet makes it easier for companies to mation (.32), and overall activities (.34). Hence, current
participate in foreign markets. The advent of global use of the Internet in various activities is starting to
strategy in the 1980s meant that companies started make it easier to participate in foreign markets, with
to pull back from smaller or non-strategic markets powerful implications for the future.
in order to reduce costs. The Internet makes it more
economically feasible to once again serve these
For the other measure of global market participation
non-core markets. Ironically, the Internet is allowing
we found that to globally roll out new products and ser-
companies to return to the multinational era when
vices quickly was significantly correlated with use of
companies sought a presence in as many countries
the Internet in overall activities (.22) and with many
as possible. Today, companies can participate in core
individual activities such as selling (.23), after-sales
countries with physical presence supplemented by
service (.32), billing and collection (.25), customer infor-
Web activities. At the same time, they can participate
mation (.27), and supplier information (.20). The differ-
in non-core countries with a Web presence supple-
ence between (a) participate in foreign markets is not
mented by some physical activities.
surprising, as the former reflects prior activities,
while (b) globally roll out new products and services
We measured global market participation in terms of
quickly, clearly reflects current activities. So compa-
the extent to which companies:
nies using this latter strategy are more likely to use
the Internet to enhance it. We also found that the
(a) participate in foreign markets,
use of the Internet in many activities was correlated
(b) globally roll out new products and services quickly.
with making it easier to implement the strategy of
globally roll out new products and services quickly (path
We found that participate in foreign markets was not
4): including selling (.23), after-sales service (.32), billing
significantly correlated with any measure of current
and collection (.25), customer information (.19), and over-
use of the Internet (path 3 in Exhibit 1). As participa-
all activities (.19). Hence, current use of the Internet in
tion in foreign markets typically takes years, even
a large range of activities is starting to make it easier
decades, to build up, this finding implies that compa-
to globally roll out new products and services
nies have not yet responded in their Internet activi-
quickly.
ties to their existing patterns of foreign market
participation. However our survey found implica-
Lesson 3: Use of the Internet enables global market partic-
tions for current efforts to expand foreign market ipation, particularly if a company uses the Internet in mar-
participation. We found that the use of the Internet keting related activities, including: distribution/logistics,
in many activities was correlated with making it marketing, selling, after-sales service, billing and collec-
easier to implement the strategy of participate in for- tion, and customer information.

6 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

Internet Effects on Global Products and Services global and local products shows that the Internet
helps solve one of perhaps the greatest dilemmas in
Global products and services are seldom totally stan- globalization: how to be both global and local at
dardized worldwide, but they are designed with glo- the same time. This dual capability of the Internet
bal markets in mind, and they have as large a for globalization parallels its other dual capability
common core as possible. Some industries and cate- of increasing both reach and richness simultaneously
gories, such as personal computers and air travel, (as discussed earlier).
allow the potential for a very large common core,
while others, such as furniture and legal services, Lesson 4: Use of the Internet enables both globally stan-
allow for less commonality. Deciding on the extent dardized and locally customized products and services.
of global standardization poses a major dilemma Companies can now use the Internet to lessen the global-
for MNCs. Use of the Internet and websites eases this ization tradeoffs they have had to make in regard to prod-
dilemma by making it easier to offer an array of glo- ucts and services.
bal, regional, or local products, and local customiza-
tion options for standard core products. While the Internet Effects on Global Activity Location
same can be done through traditional media (bro-
chures or sales calls), the Web provides more options The Internet helps to solve the long-time dilemma
and the interactivity of the Internet provides for cus- facing multinational companies—how much of their
tomization by the customer (as in Dell Computer’s value chain to recreate overseas? In earlier eras of
ordering system). poor transportation and communications, the solu-
tion generally required the foreign location of a lot
We measured global products and services in terms of expensive assets and activities. In the global era,
of the extent to which companies: beginning in the 1980s, many companies found that
they could reduce duplication by operating physical
(a) offer globally standardized products or services, networks with specialized nodes. As an electronic net-
(b) offer locally customized products or services. work, the Web, through both intranets and extranets,
completes this process of de-
Of the different measures of cur- duplication. Many down-
rent Internet use, we found that
customer information and overall
The Internet helps solve stream and support activities
lend themselves well to Web-
activities had significant positive based replacement for local
correlations (.20 and .23) with one of perhaps the greatest di- physical presence. Globalizing
the measure of (a) offer globally R&D operations has been a
standardized products or services. lemmas in globalization; how key objective of global compa-
We found that offer locally stan- nies. But centralization at one
dardized products or services was to be both global and local at location has been the tradi-
not correlated with any measure tional strategy to achieve the
of current Internet use. the same time needed scale in R&D. The
Web now enables virtual
We found, however, that use of R&D teams that concentrate
the Internet in many activities and pool expertise and re-
was correlated with making it easier to implement sources from separate locations, so that companies
the strategy of (a) offer globally standardized products can both tap into local expertise and achieve global
or services (path 4): production (.22), selling (.28), scale. The Web can also be used to co-ordinate glob-
after-sales service (.38), billing and collection (.47), cus- ally dispersed production activities. Many compa-
tomer information (.26), supplier information (.18), and nies now handle their global after-sales service
overall activities (.32). Hence, current use of the Internet through their Websites.
in various activities is starting to make it easier to
offer globally standardized products or services. We measured global activity location in terms of the
Interestingly, the effects were even more extensive extent to which companies:
for the strategy of (b) offer locally standardized products
or services : production (.24), distribution/logistics (.25), (a) locate activities outside home country,
marketing (.19), selling (.27), after-sales service (.24), (b) operate global activity networks,
billing and collection (.28), customer information (.22), (c) co-ordinate globally dispersed activities.
and overall activities (.33).
First, we found that operate global activity networks
The above findings imply that on the one hand com- was significantly and positively correlated with cur-
panies are not yet making much use of the Internet rent use of the Internet for after-sales service (.19), cus-
relative to globally standardized or locally custom- tomer information (.27), and overall activities (.25). We
ized products. But on the other hand companies are also found that co-ordinate globally dispersed activities
finding great potential from Internet use for enabling was significantly and positively correlated with cur-
both these strategies. Also, the applicability for both rent use of the Internet for production (.18) and overall

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 7
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

activities (.24). However, we found that locate activities of current Internet use (path 3 in Figure 1). On the
outside home country was not significantly correlated other hand, we found that use of the Internet in some
with any measure of current Internet use (path 3 in marketing-related activities was correlated with mak-
Figure 1). These three findings imply that just the ing it easier to implement the strategy of have a glob-
act of locating activities overseas does not in itself ally uniform marketing mix (path 4): after-sales service
spur Internet use. But operating global activity net- (.28), billing and collection (.34), and customer informa-
works and coordinating globally dispersed activities, tion (.25). These findings imply that companies have
which both require a degree of global integration, do not yet made much use of the Internet to help with
require use of the Internet for appropriate activities. the strategy of having a globally uniform marketing
mix, but those who do are finding it useful.
When we looked at how use of the Internet might en-
able these global strategies, we found many effects. Lesson 6: Use of the Internet helps companies to have a
We found that use of the Internet in many activities globally uniform marketing mix, especially if a company
was correlated with making it easier to implement applies the Internet to customer-related activities.
the strategy to locate activities outside home country (path
4): selling (.22), after-sales service (.36), billing and collec-
Internet Effects on Global Competitive Moves
tion (.21), customer information (.20), and overall activi-
ties (.21). For the strategy of operate global activity Perhaps the hardest element in global strategy is that
networks, the enabling activities were after-sales service of making globally coordinated competitive moves,
(.19), customer information (.24), and overall activities such as monitoring competitors globally and making
(.25). For the strategy of co-ordinate globally dispersed cross-country counter-parries (Porter, 1986). The
activities the enabling activities were after-sales service Internet and Web provides additional tools, such as:
(.29), customer information (.27), and overall activities
(.28). Interestingly, use of the Internet for the production v using the Web to monitor competitors more
activity was not correlated with the enabling of these closely
three strategies. These findings imply that firms found v responding more quickly via Web offerings
it is more important to use the Internet for customer- v using deep linking, metatags and other techniques
related activities, than production-related activities, to hijack potential customers from competitors’
in order to support strategies of global activity loca- websites
tion. This may not be surprising if we consider that a v choosing the right mix of competitive and co-
primary role of the Internet is to reduce distance, operative behavior with rivals and other partners
and there is usually a greater distance between a com- v establishing global standards to limit or pre-empt
pany and its customers than within a company. competition

Lesson 5: Use of the Internet enables the global location of We measured global competitive moves in terms of
activities, especially if a company applies the Internet to the extent to which companies use such moves. We
customer-related activities.
found that to use global competitive moves was signifi-
cantly and positively correlated with current use of
the Internet for after-sales service (.23), billing and collec-
Internet Effects on Global Marketing tion (.18), and customer information (.27). Also, we
found that use of the Internet in most activities was cor-
Research on global marketing shows that different
related with making it easier to implement the strat-
elements of the mix need to have different degrees
egy of use global competitive moves (path 4): research
of global uniformity (Syzmanski et al., 1993), with
and development (.21), production (.20), selling (.29),
brand names and packaging having the most unifor-
after-sales service (.44), billing and collection (.38), cus-
mity, pricing, advertising and distribution moderate
tomer information (.33) and overall activities (.25). These
uniformity, and selling and promotion the least (Yip,
findings imply that companies are currently using the
1997). Hence even global marketing involves a com-
Internet in mostly selling and customer-related activ-
bination of global and local elements. The Internet
ities to help with the strategy of global competitive
should make it easier for MNCs to provide such
moves. But companies are also finding that Internet
combinations—Websites can easily provide local
use in other activities such as R&D and production
adaptations around core elements. Conversely, glo-
also helps enable global competitive moves.
bal marketing on the Web requires some specific
choices: whether to provide Websites in different for-
Lesson 7: Use of the Internet helps companies to make glo-
eign languages, whether to have a globally common bal competitive moves.
look for different country Websites, and whether to
have a globally common content.

We measured global marketing in terms of the extent Nature of Multinational Firm Websites
to which companies have a globally uniform marketing
mix. We found that to have a globally uniform marketing In addition to examining the effects on globalization
mix was not significantly correlated with any measure of use of the Internet, we also investigated the effects

8 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

2.7
different foreign
languages
3.8

Now
2.6 In Three Years
globally common
look
3.7

2.3
globally common
content
3.4

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0

Exhibit 6 Languages and Commonality of Websites

of Website design in regards to: languages used, glo- planned use in three years’ time, these two remained
bal commonality, transactional capability, and spe- the top items, although provides detailed product infor-
cific functionality. mation overtook provides advertising and marketing.
The lowest uses were for offers competitor comparisons
online and monitors online customer satisfaction.
Languages and Global Commonality
We also investigated whether these different func-
There are many arguments that multinational com- tionalities helped with the implementation of various
panies should maintain their websites in different global strategies (by looking for significant and posi-
foreign languages, in order to better serve foreign tive correlations between each functionality and each
customers. A separate argument, independent of lan- global strategy). We found that many website func-
guage, is that multinational companies should main- tionalities help to enable many global strategies. Cer-
tain a globally common look for different country tainly, none hurt.
websites, or even globally common content to
strengthen branding. We found that the companies, Lesson 9: The more multifunctional a company website,
on average, made only moderate use of these three the more it enables globalization.
aspects, but planned to greatly increase their use
over the next three years (Exhibit 6).

We also investigated whether these three aspects of


website design made any difference to the imple- Effects of Internet Use on Global
mentation of global strategies. We found that having Performance
different foreign languages helped companies to par-
ticipate in foreign markets, and that having a glob- Our fifth and last research question was whether use
ally common content or a globally common look of the Internet improves a firm’s global performance.
each helped to implement a globally uniform mar- We used several measures of performance and asked
keting mix and to use global competitive moves. about the effects of Internet operations on the firm’s
global performance in terms of each measure. Exhibit
Lesson 8: Having foreign languages and a globally com- 8 shows that the overall effect was positive, though
mon content or look helps with some global strategies. moderate, at a mean of +.66 in a possible range from
2.0 to +2.0. All measures were on average positive,
with brand awareness and brand image enjoying the
Functionality of Websites greatest positive effects. Profitability enjoyed the
least positive effect at +.25, market share enjoyed a
Beyond being transactional, other aspects of website below average gain of +.43, while sales enjoyed an
functionality might affect globalization. We investi- average effect of +.65.
gated several aspects and found that the companies
in our sample currently make the most use of provides Lesson 10: Use of the Internet improves all aspects of global
advertising and marketing, followed by provides detailed performance, but more for brand and customer measures
product information (Exhibit 7). When asked about than for profitability.

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 9
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

collects data on 1.2


consumer 3.7
offers competitor 1.5
comparisons online 2.5
monitors customer 1.6
online satisfaction 3.6
1.8
offers online support 3.9
offers accounting 1.9
online 3.1 Now
2.1 In Three Years
offers booking online 3.2
offers purchasing 2.3
online 3.7
provides detailed 3.2
product information 4.4
provides advertising 3.4
and marketing 4.2
2.1
AVERAGE 3.6

1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0

Exhibit 7 Nature of Multinational Firm Websites

brand/company image 1.1

brand/company awareness 1.1

customer satisfaction 0.7

customer retention 0.6

channel relationship 0.6

customer gain 0.5

market share 0.4

profitability 0.3

AVERAGE 0.7

-2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

Exhibit 8 Effects of Internet on Global Performance

Conclusions and Implications work Economy at London Business School for the
funds that supported this study.
Our Study confirms that using the Internet does in-
deed help companies to globalize and to implement
global strategies. We have drawn eleven lessons for
managers from our findings. Perhaps the most
Appendix
important lesson is that the Internet helps companies
be both global and local at the same time. Web de- Research Methodology
sign is also important, which means that managers
responsible for globalization need to include Web Our main research method was to collect data from
designers on their global strategy teams. Competing large multinational companies in Europe and else-
in Internet time also means competing in Internet where worldwide using a specially designed
global space. questionnaire.

Acknowledgment Questionnaire
The authors thank the Vice Chancellor’s Office at the A two-page questionnaire was developed on the fol-
University of Cambridge and the Centre for the Net- lowing items:

10 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

v The strength of specific globalization drivers for a The additional questionnaires were reliably filled out
designated industry in which the firm by willing participants and had the benefits of increas-
participates. ing sample size and providing a late responses sub-
v The percentage of industry and firm revenues sample that could be compared with the earlier ones.
now booked over the Internet.
v The extent to which various firm activities make
use of the Internet, now and in three years time. Checking for Non-response Bias and Nationality
v The extent to which the firm uses various aspects Differences
of global strategy.
v The extent to which the Internet makes it easier We checked whether responding companies might
for the firm to use the same aspects of global be significantly different from non-responding ones
strategy. by comparing the responses of the sample that re-
v What the firm’s website does, now and planned sponded to the first mailing and the sample that re-
for three years’ time. sponded to the reminder, a standard technique for
v Whether the website offers foreign languages, inferring the differences between respondents and
and whether it has a globally common look or non-respondents. To the extent that there is a re-
content. sponse bias, we should assume that our sample rep-
v Effects of Internet operations on the firm’s global resents companies who make greater use of the
performance in terms of: revenue growth; profits; Internet and/or have more interest in it. Therefore,
market share; channel relationships; customer any bias will be to report higher levels of use, etc.,
satisfaction, gain and retention; and brand/firm than might be the case in the total population of large
awareness and image. international companies.

The questionnaire was pre-tested on ten MBA stu- We found no significant differences in means at the
dents of several nationalities in a leading UK-based 95% confidence level between early and late respond-
business school. Based on the students’ comments ers in terms of firm size, percent international, or use
we made various amendments. of the Internet (% of industry revenues booked over
the Internet, % of firm revenues booked over the Inter-
net, and overall firm use of the Internet for various
Sample value-adding activities. Therefore, we can conclude
there is unlikely to be significant non-respondent bias.
The targeted population was the 1000 largest interna-
tional companies in each of the UK and Continental Similarly, we found no significant differences be-
Europe, and the 500 largest companies in the United tween the European and non-European samples in
States. Given their size, these companies can all be con- terms of the percent of industry revenues booked
sidered incumbent firms, i.e., not Internet start-ups. over the Internet (European 6.5% and non-European
6.7%), in terms of the percent of industry revenues
The questionnaire was mailed to firm CEOs with re- booked over the Internet (European 4.3% and non-
quests to pass it on to the head of International Busi- European 4.8%), or in terms of overall firm use of
ness if necessary. All returned questionnaires were the Internet for various value-adding activities. This
filled out by senior managers: largely by CEOs, pres- lack of differences allowed us to combine all the
idents, VPs, heads of strategy or heads of e-business observations in one larger sample.
who specified their position.

A number of the mailings were returned as undeliv- Sample Characteristics


erable (55 for the United Kingdom, 73 for Continental
Europe, and 47 for the United States). A total of 79 Firm Nationality
completed surveys were received from the first mail- Most of the sample comprised companies headquar-
ing. A postcard reminder was sent two months after tered in Europe (85%), as follows:
the first mailing and a further 26 surveys were re-
ceived. After deducting the undeliverable addresses, Home Country of Firm Number of Respondents
our response rates were as follows: 4.1 % for the Uni-
ted Kingdom, 5.5% for Continental Europe, and 1.8% UK 42
for the United States. Germany 15
Switzerland 9
Ten extra questionnaire replies were collected Portugal 7
through an executive education program held at Lon- Belgium 5
don Business School in March 2001. All ten responses Italy 4
were collected after the original deadline of the ques- Finland 3
tionnaires and therefore classed as ‘late’ responses. France 3
The respondents came from a number of regions Netherlands 3
including those outside Europe and the United States. (continued on next page)

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 11
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

(continued ) Firm Interviews

Home Country of Firm Number of Respondents To complement the questionnaire data, we con-
ducted interviews with the heads of Internet strategy
Spain 2 of four large UK-based companies that had com-
Sweden 2 pleted the survey: HSBC Group (banking), Royal &
Austria 1 Sun Alliance (insurance), and TBWA/GGT Direct
Denmark 1 (advertising and media), and part of the TBWA
Norway 1 group and Corus group (steel). We also reviewed a
TOTAL EUROPE 98 = 85% case study on a fifth firm (British Airways) that
had participated in the survey (Anderson et al.,
USA 10 2001).
South Africa 3
Argentina 1
China 1
India 1 Analysis
Israel 1
We used various analytical techniques, including
TOTAL USA & OTHER 17 = 15% multiple regression and structural equation model-
ing. We report in this paper only the bivariate analy-
TOTAL SAMPLE 115 = 100% ses such as correlations (significant at the 5% level,
two-tail), but all the significant relationships have
Firm Size been confirmed in multivariate analyses.
The size in annual revenues of the companies ranged
from $0.5 million to $50 billion with a mean of $6.4
billion and a median of $2.0 billion. There was some
variation in firm size by nationality. Non-UK Euro-
Note
pean respondent companies reported the largest
mean annual revenues ($9.3 billion) followed by US
1. Evans and Würster (1999) argue that, unlike traditional bricks-
companies ($6.5 billion), UK ($3.1 billion), and Other and-mortar companies, for very little money an e-business can
($2.4 billion). provide a wide base of customers (reach) with access to a broad
range of products (also reach), and detailed complete informa-
Percent International tion about each product (richness). It can also collect huge
amounts of information about each customer (richness again)
On average, international revenues accounted for and use it to sell more products and services.
52.9% of total firm revenues, with a standard devia-
tion of 26.2%.
References
Industry Sectors
The sample firms participated in a wide variety of Andal-Ancion, A.A., Cartwright, P.A. and Yip, G.S. (2003)
The digital transformation of traditional businesses.
industry sectors according to their own response Sloan Management Review 44(2), 34–42.
descriptions and external follow up investigation. Anderson, J., Parks, T. and Earl, M. (2001) British Airways:
As most large global firms may be players in more Transitioning to e-Business. London Business School.
than one industry, respondents were asked to specify Bakos, Y. and Brynjolfsson, E. (1999) Bundling Information
the key industry for their firm activities. We then clas- Goods: Pricing, Profits and Efficiency. Management
Science 45(12).
sified these industries using 2-digit Standard Indus- Evans, P. and Würster, T.S. (1999) Getting real about
trial Classification (SIC) codes, combining some virtual commerce. Harvard Business Review 77(6),
sectors where the sample was too small. The sample 84–95.
split as follows: Govindarajan, V. and Gupta, A.K. (2001) The Quest for
Global Dominance. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, Chapter
9.
# % Johansson, J.K. and Yip, G.S. (1994) Exploiting globaliza-
tion potential: US and Japanese Strategies. Strategic
v Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals 13 11.3 Management Journal 15, 579–601.
Morrison, A.J. (1990) Strategies in Global Industries: How US
v Construction and Capital Goods 17 14.8 Businesses Compete. Quorum Books, Westport, CT.
v Energy and Resources 15 13.4 Nadler, D.A. and Tushman, M.L. (1999) The organizations
v Finance and Property 22 19.1 of the future: Strategic imperatives and core compe-
v Logistics, Distribution and 17 14.8 tencies for the 21st century. Organizational Dynamics
Transportation 28(1), 45.
Porter, M.E. (1986) Changing patterns of international
v Retail and Groceries 12 10.4 competition. California Management Review 28(2), 9–
v Technology, Media, 19 16.5 40.
and Telecoms Syzmanski, M., Bharadwaj, S.G. and Varadarajan, P.R.
(1993) Standardization versus adaptation of interna-
TOTAL 115 100.0

12 European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005
USING THE INTERNET TO ENHANCE GLOBAL STRATEGY

tional marketing strategy: An empirical investigation. Yip, G.S. (1997) Patterns and determinants of global
Journal of Marketing 57, 1–17. marketing. Journal of Marketing Management 13,
Yip, G.S. (1992) Total Global Strategy: Managing for World- 153–164.
wide Competitive Advantage. Prentice-Hall, Englewood
Cliffs, NJ.

GEORGE S. YIP, Lon- ANNA M.


don Business School, Sus- DEMPSTER, Birkbeck
sex Place, Regent’s Park, College, University of
London NW1 4SA. E- London, Malet Street,
mail: gyip@london.edu London WC1E 7HX. E-
mail: a.dempster@ bbk.ac.
George S. Yip is Lead Fel- uk
low of the UK’s Advanced
Institute of Management Anna M. Dempster is
Research and Professor of Lecturer in the School of
Strategic and International Management, Birkbeck
Management at London College, University of
Business School. A prolific London. Her research is
author, his most recent book is Total Global Strategy II broadly concerned with strategic innovation, including
(2003), an updated and prize—winning book from the evolution of Internet ventures in the UK, role of
1992. He has won both research and best teaching corporate announcements and real option evaluation of
awards. disclosure strategies.

European Management Journal Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 1–13, February 2005 13

You might also like