Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Impact of Architectural Spaces' Geometric Forms and Construction Materials On The Users' Brainwaves and Consciousness Status
The Impact of Architectural Spaces' Geometric Forms and Construction Materials On The Users' Brainwaves and Consciousness Status
net/publication/323540071
CITATIONS READS
5 1,972
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Adapting Strategic Environmental Assessment into Egyptian Urban Planning System in Egypt View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Ibrahim Rizk Hegazy on 01 May 2018.
*Corresponding author: Received 8 April 2017; revised 15 November 2017; editorial decision 20 November 2017; accepted 27
i.hegazy@ymail.com November 2017
................................................................................................................................................................................
interacts with the energy of forms to provide spaces with the the architectural space and the user’s brainwaves and conscious-
balance required for their users’ comfort [1]. ness, which may affect the quality of architectural design process.
In December 2011, a study investigating the effect of a build- This study is based on linking brainwaves to geometric form of
ing with a pyramid form (Maitreya Buddha Pyramid, Bengaluru, architectural spaces by using a computational method in order to
India) on a number of meditators’ brainwaves was conducted [2]. identify a scientific measuring tool that can use the frequencies of
An effort was made to investigate the cerebral electrical activity resonance in predicting and identifying the impacts of the archi-
of fifteen meditators that are recorded by electroencephalograph tectural spaces on the user’s mental status and consciousness. This
(EEG). The EEG is a physiological electrical signal recorded may support architects and designers in identifying appropriate
from the scalp to study the brain function. EEG is recorded geometric forms to meet the required uses and functions that
before and after meditation inside and outside the pyramid. In need particular consciousness statuses.
this study, 13 meditators had an increase while 2 meditators had
a drop in alpha waves. The amplitude of theta parameters for 14
meditators showed an increase while 1 meditator showed a 2 THE HUMAN BRAIN AND STATUSES
decrease. In addition, the amplitude of delta shows an increase OF CONSCIOUSNESS
of 11 meditators and a decrease of the others. This increase in
the alpha and theta waves showed the suggestive of relaxation The brain is the most important part of the human nervous
after meditation. system. It gathers and analyzes information, and controls most
With the same methodology, another study published in of the body’s organs and systems. The brain is mainly com-
2014 [3] aimed to measure the impact of staying inside a his- posed of three areas that are cerebrum, cerebellum and brain
toric building space with a vault ceiling shape (El-Sultan stem. The cerebrum cares about cognitive, sensory and mental
Hassan mosque, Cairo) on the users’ consciousness status, by functions of the human body. The mind is not a part of the
recording the brain electrical signals (EEG) of a number of brain, but it is the process of the activities and functions, in par-
volunteers inside and outside the building. The results showed ticular, those functions in which the human being aware of
that 14 of the volunteers showed an increase while 8 volunteers such as personality, thinking, controversy, memory, intelligence
showed a drop in alpha activity. The amplitude of theta/beta and even emotion. Hence, the mind is what distinguishes
ratio for eight volunteers showed a decrease while three volun- between the human and the animal, not the brain [5].
teers showed an increase. This increase in the alpha and
decrease in theta/beta waves showed the suggestive of relaxation
and calm awareness after staying for 20 min inside the building.
2.1 Brainwaves
Brainwaves are very accurate electrical signals reflecting the
Haberakn et al. [4] argued that it is hard to separate the
changes which occur in the frequency of brainwaves during dif-
human behavior and the form of spaces that human lives in. In
ferent mental statuses. Studying brainwaves has a key role in
this regard, architecture can affect negatively on human as it
understanding how the human brain and mind work and the
could be shown in the monotonous repetition which leads to
relationship between the neurological functions the main brain
weariness and boredom and thus leads to a status of depression
parts. The electrical activity of the brain is actually defined as
and social confusion, leading to the prevalence of psychological
the collection of all activities of brain cells. While each brain
diseases and behavioral deviations. This supports the point of
cell has its own frequently wave, but what we can measure is
view that the building starts with an ideology and a philosophy
the combined activities of all brain cells [6].
of a designer and then turns into influential in human relations
that take place either positively or negatively in our communi-
ties. Hence, the trend which aims to revive the social side in 2.2 Types of brainwaves
contemporary architecture arises, because the spatial behavior Brainwaves are classified into five major types, as follows
is a form of social interaction resulting from an individual’s life (Table 1):
in the environment and community.
Karim [1] argued how critical it is to recognize the significance ▪ Delta waves
of building to human health inside a building. Consequently one ▪ Beta waves
can locate power spots, anciently used as healing places, where ▪ Theta waves
concentrations of healing powers appear. This is one of the key ▪ Gamma waves
principles of building timeless architecture. These features cause ▪ Alpha waves
buildings to be considered of great effect on human health on
the physical, psychological and spiritual levels. This classification based on the frequency of brainwaves. It
The main problem is the lack of the scientific measuring instru- was noticed that certain patterns of brainwaves related to cases
ments used to identify the impact of the geometric form of the of consciousness, such as alertness, relaxation, sleep and deep
architectural space on the users’ bioenergy through their brain- sleep. The following table shows each of brainwaves characteris-
waves and consciousness. In this sense, this research attempts to tics and its relation to the status of consciousness as well as the
identify the scientific relationship between the geometric form of shape of the waves [7].
Delta 0 4
Associated with the deepest levels of relaxation and restorative, healing sleep
Theta 4 8
Involved in daydreaming and sleep
Alpha 8 12
Bridges the gap between our conscious thinking and subconscious mind
Beta 12 40
Conscious thought, logical thinking, and tend to have a stimulating effect
Gamma 40 100
Higher processing tasks as well as cognitive functioning
2.3 The effect of brain frequencies on statuses When the session progresses, the frequency rate of these pulses
of consciousness is changed gradually, thus changing his brainwave patterns and
Table 2 presents the effects of frequencies in each band on the guiding his mind to several useful mental statuses [12].
human brain statuses of consciousness [8]. Since we live in built spaces all time, the functional efficiency
of the architectural space affected by the user’s psychological
and mental status. Some activities need special mental statuses
2.4 Brainwave entrainment as relaxation in residential buildings, attention, and activity in
Brainwave entrainment (pronounced ‘ehn-TRAIN-mint’) refers educational buildings,…etc. This section concludes that brain-
to the brain’s electrical response to rhythmic sensory stimula- waves control the human consciousness and mental status.
tion, such as pulses of sound or light. When the brain is Moreover, the human brain has shown its ability to respond to
exposed to a stimulus, through the eyes, ears or other senses, it external effects and the possibility to enter required conscious-
produces an electrical charge in response, called a cortical ness brain status.
evoked response (CER) (Figure 1). These electrical responses
are carried throughout the brain to become what you ‘see or
hear’ for example. This activity can be measured using sensitive 3 EXPERIMENT EXPLANATION
electrodes attached to the scalp [9].
When the brain is exposed to a rhythmic stimulus, such as a In this section, the experiment is explained according to two
drum beat, for instance, the rhythm is reproduced in the brain main axes:
in the form of these electrical impulses. If the rhythm becomes
fast and regular, it can start to resemble the natural internal The first axis discusses the experiment aim and concept, the
rhythms of the brain, called brainwaves. When this happens, meaning of resonance, and the principle of the octave as a
the brain responds by synchronizing its own electric cycles to way to understand the impact of the high-frequency range to
the same rhythm (Figure 2). This is commonly called the the low-frequency range of the human brain.
Frequency Following Response (FFR) [10, 11]. The second axis explains the simulation software ‘CST Microwave
FFR could be valuable since brainwaves are very much Studio’, the inputs and outputs of the simulation environment,
related to mental status. For instance, a 4 Hz brainwave is asso- and identifying how to analyze the experiment outputs.
ciated with sleep, so a 4 Hz sound pattern would help reproduce
the sleep status in the brain. The same concept could be imple-
mented to many other mental statuses, including meditation, 3.1 Experiment aim and concept
relaxation and concentration. If a person listens closely during Practical experiments which carried out on a number of the
a music session, he will hear small, quick pulses of sound. buildings’ users indicate a significant change of 70–95% of the
other hand, the frequency domain solver of CST is, like the the S-parameter value increases this represents the resonance,
transient solver, a general purpose tool. It provides electromag- as shown in Figure 5.
netic near and far fields as well as S-parameters. The frequency
domain solver is the better choice for small structures.
The simulation environment settings include units, proper- 4 SIMULATION PROCESS
ties of surrounding environment, frequency range and bound-
ary domain conditions. As shown in Figure 4. The process of simulating the resonance frequency of the
As the simulation process aims to identify the resonance fre- selected geometric forms steps can be summarized in the steps
quency, the simulation output is the S-parameter chart. When shown in Figure 6.
Square L = 1.57 1
W = 1.57
Circle R=1 1
Square L=1 1
Circle R=1 1
Figure 6. Experiment methodology. materials. This is presented in a form of a graph of the param-
eter value with the range of the frequency. Since the results
4.1 Inputs vary depending on the geometric form, as well as construction
A set of basic geometric of six basic geometric forms (cone, pyra- material change, it could be argued that the impact of the geo-
mid, cube, cylinder, dome and vault) is examined in the current metric form should not be overlooked in the case of resonance,
research (Table 3). All with the same volume and in the natural in addition to, the impact of the construction material. The
air environment. Every form will be examined with four materials S-parameter of all tested forms is presented in Table 4.
(wood, steel, concrete and glass) in order to identify the effect of
changing building form and materials on user’s brainwaves.
5 DISCUSSION
4.2 Results Table 4 and Figure 8 summarize the simulation results with
Figure 7 shows the results of S-parameter—which indicates the transforming octave equivalent to the range of brain frequencies
case of resonance—for the form of pyramid case with different and the emotional status represented by those frequencies.
S-parameter (resonance) Units Equivalent freq. (Hz) Wave type Consciousness status
(with steel, wood or glass materials), or in a steel or wooden the resonance frequency occurring inside these forms, which
dome. In addition, this case may be attained if the user stays in may cause changes in the users’ brainwaves and consciousness.
a space with a vault form made of concrete, steel or glass.
Alpha waves that help in moderation and mental stability,
learning and improving the status of general mood may be
REFERENCES
occurred during staying in a square space made of concrete or [1] Karim I. Back to a Future for Mankind. CreateSpace Independent
glass materials. This is also obvious in the cases of wooden Publisher, Florida, 2010.
cone and vault as well as the concrete cylinder. [2] Vijayalakshmi K, Tanya M, Nagaraj Y. Analysis of neuro cognitive effects
In case of need to change the user’s consciousness to atten- on meditation. Int J Comput Appl 2011;36:6–9.
tion, concentration or conscious thinking, the brainwaves need [3] Essawy S, Kamel B, Elsawy M. Timeless buildings and the human brain.
to be guided to be beta waves that may be occurred if the user Int J Archit Res 2014;8:133–42.
stays in a cone space made of concrete, steel or glass. In add- [4] Haberakn J, Mignucci A, Teicher J. Conversations With Form: A Workbook
for Students of Architecture. Oxon: Routledge, 2014.
ition, this case may be attained if the user stays in a space with
[5] Makeig S, Gramann K, Jung T et al. Linking brain, mind and behavior. Int
a wooden square or a glass dome.
J Psychophysiol 2009;73:95–100.
Finally, this study identifies that there is an obvious relation- [6] Lee I. Brainwave Vibration, 2nd edn. Best Life Media, 2010.
ship between the geometric forms of architectural spaces and [7] Michael K, Cornwell A, Zoe M. Gamma and beta neural activity evoked
their construction materials and the users’ consciousness. Each during a sensory gating paradigm: effects of auditory, somatosensory and
geometric form resonates with a specific resonance frequency. cross-modal stimulation. Clin Neurophysiol 2006;117:2549–63.
The resonance occurred causes a change in the human brain- [8] Alsan K, Bayraktaroglu E, Gurvit Z et al. Comparative analysis of event-
waves which guides his consciousness to a particular status. related potentials during Go/NoGo and CPT: decomposition of electro-
Depending on the research results, it is evident that there are physiological markers of response inhibition and sustained attention. Clin
different effects related to the geometric forms and construction Neurophysiol 2006;1104:114–28.
materials of the architectural spaces on the users’ brainwaves [9] Huang T, Charyton C. A comprehensive review of the psychological effects
of brainwave entrainment. Altern Ther Health Med 2008;14:38–49.
and consciousness. This may assist architects and designers in
[10] Nyström S. Effects of photic stimulation on neuronal activity and subjective
identifying appropriate which geometric form is the most suit-
experience in man. Acta Neurol Scand 1966;42:505–14.
able for their designs in order to suit the required uses and func- [11] Smith J, Marsh J, Greenberg S et al. Human auditory frequency-following
tions that need particular consciousness statuses. There is no responses to a missing fundamental. Science 1978;201:639–41.
doubt that there is a need for more studies and investigations on [12] Cahn B, Polich J. Meditation statuses and traits: EEG, ERP, and neuroima-
this subject, in particular, the possibility to study the effect of ging studies. Psychol Bull 2006;132:180–211.
geometric forms which are constructed from more than one [13] CST Microwave Studio. Workflow and Solver Overview. CST Computer
materials, as well as the effect of the geometric multi-forms on Simulation Technology AG, 2014.