You are on page 1of 3

DEALINGS S.

304(1) of NLC
Form 14A is not effective to vest until a
- Transfer memorial has been made on the RDT
- Lease
Frazer v Walker
 TRANSFER “indefeasibility” gives the immunity from
attack by adverse claim to the land or
Persons capable to deal with land? interest in respect of which he is registered,
S.205 of NLC which a registered proprietor enjoys.
- Alienated land
- Interest in alienated land  LEASE AND TENANCIES
Characters of Lease and Tenancies
What may be transferred? 1. Exclusive possession
S.124(1)(a) of NLC - The lessee can enter into posession of the
- The whole part of alienated land land and take posession of it
- They can exclude all other person
S.124(1)(b) of NLC including the landlord from the land.
- The whole part of undivided shares in land - They have control over the premises.
(co-proprietor)
Woo Yew Chee v Yong Yong Hoo
Restrictions on powers to transfer? There was a written agreement allowing
S.214(2) of NLC the respondent to occupy the premises for
- Any limitation imposed by the NLC or any 10 years with a monthy rent. Repsondent
other written law was to share with the appellant (landlord),
- Any restriction in interest to which the the kitchen, bathroom and toilet. The
land is subject landlord held the key.
- Subject to any conditions imposed in any Held : The agreement was in the nature of a
lease, charge and tenancies lease and not a license.

Form and effect of transfer Addiscome Garden Est v Crabbe


S.215(1) of NLC Addiscombe Garden Estates (AGE) entered
Form 14A is to be used to trasferland an agreement with Crabbe and his fellow
trustees of a tennis club under which the
S.215(2) of NLC trustees could enter, use, and enjoy a
Only when Form 14A has been used in a clubhouse and tennis courts in return for a
proper manner, then only the title of the monthly fee. The agreement was stated on
transferor shall pass and vest in the its face to be a license. At the expiry of the
transferee together with the benefit of agreement period, the trustees remained in
registered interest attached to the land occupation claiming to hold a secured
tenancy. AGE sought an order for
S.215(3) of NLC possession.
The transferee shall hold the land subject to
any registered interest, condition and RIN Held : The agreement was held to be a
and all other matters appearing in the RDT lease. On its true construction, the
document created the relationship of
Indefeasibility of title : landlord and tenant, even though it was
- S.92 of NLC described as a license. The arrangement
- S.340 of NLC satisfied the legal requirements of a
tenancy, and the parties could not alter the
substance of an agreement by labelling it a
license. The club amounted to a business

1
for the purposes of the statute, and they Effects of unregistered lease
were entitled to security of tenure. - S.206(3) of NLC
Unregistered lease is void as lease, it is still
2. Intention to create a lease/tenancy good and valid as an agreement under
Inferred from the written agreement or contract for a lease.
conduct of the parties
Margaret Chua v Ho Swee Kiew
Errington v Errington Although the agreement for a lease for 25
A father made his son and daughter-in-law years was void for lack of registration, it
a unilateral offer to his son and daughter in was valid as an agreement for a lease
law that they could remain in the house if enforceable in equity.
they paid off the remaining mortgage
instalments. Siew Soon Wah & Ors. v Yong Tong Hong
They proceeded to do this, however before An unregistered written agreement for a
the mortgage was paid off, the father died lease stated to be “as long as the tenant
The father’s wife inherited the house. wishes to occupy” is valid as an equitable
Held : No removal, claim failed. Although a lease for 30 years.
unilateral contract can only be accepted
once its conditions have been performed,  Creation of tenancy
the mother was estopped from revoking S.213(1)(a) & S.223(1) of NLC
the offer as there was a collateral contract Tenancy exempt from registration (TER) is
to keep the offer open until its conditions granting for a tenancy or sub-tenancy for a
had been met period not exceeding 3 years.

3. Granted for a specified period or the S.213(2)(a) & S.223(2) of NLC


term is capable of being ascertained Shall be created orally or written

Tan Swee Hoe v Ali Hussein Brothers S.213(2)(b) & S.206(2)(a) of NLC
The appellants had orally agreed to allow If written not required to comply with the
the respondents to occupy the premises for requirement under S.2017-212 as to form
as long as they wished upon payment for
tea money. The written tenancy S.223(1)(a) of NLC
agreements were later executed by the TER can be created by a registered
parties and the appellant sued for vacant proprietor of any alienated land
possession.
Held : The trial judge dismissed the S.213(3) & S.316 of NLC
appellants’ claim and ordered them to TER is effective to bind any person or body
register a lease in favour of the claiming the rights under the tenancy onlu
respondents for a term of 28 years. upon endorsement of the claim on the RDT
of the title affected
 Creation of lease
S.221 of NLC S.316 & S.317 of NLC
Can be created by RP over any alienated Application for endorsement of the claim
land for the period exceeding 3 years. for tenancy to be made to the Registrar by
Form 15A must be used to register a lease. the tenant

S.227 of NLC Registrar shall note the words “EXEMPT


Upon registration of a lease, all interest in TENANCY CLAIMED” on the RDT and shall
the land shall vest in the lessee. signed and sealed

2
Effect of absence of endorsement
The purchaser of the land or registered
interest can evict the tenant from the land
before expiry of the tenancy period.

Than Kok Leong v Low Kim Hai


Notice of the existence of the tenant before
the transfer is not important in absence of
such endorsement pursuant to the
requirements under S.213(3) of NLC.

Hotel Ambassador Sdn Bhd v Seapower


Tenancy would not bind R until tenancy has
become protected by endorsement prior to
the date of registration of the certificate of
sale.

You might also like