Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Lesson Introduction................................................................................................................2
2. The External Environment of the Firm....................................................................................2
3. The PESTEL Framework...........................................................................................................2
4. PESTEL Analysis: Tesla Motors Case Exercise..........................................................................4
5. The Structure-Conduct-Performance Model..........................................................................5
6. Introduction to the Porter Five Forces Model........................................................................7
7. Porter Five Forces Model- Part 1............................................................................................8
8. Porter Five Forces Model- Part 2............................................................................................9
9. Porter Five Forces Model- Part 3..........................................................................................11
10. Porter Five Forces Model- Tesla Motors Case Exercise.....................................................12
11. Looking Inside the Firm for Competitive Advantage.........................................................12
12. The Resource-Based View of Competitive Advantage......................................................13
13. VRIO Analysis....................................................................................................................14
14. The Value Chain Framework.............................................................................................16
15. Ratio Analysis and Benchmarking.....................................................................................17
16. SWOT Analysis..................................................................................................................19
1. Lesson Introduction
Porter, more so than Mintzberg, suggests that strategy be formulated on a foundation
of analysis.
Both the traditional model strategy development and the scenario based model stressed
this and are consistent with Porter's thinking.
Strategists' plan emergence is aligned with Mintzberg's thinking.
Analysis consists of developing a better understanding and gaining insights into both the
firm's external and internal environments.
In strategy development, the purpose of studying the external environment is to identify
future opportunities for business growth, as well as potential threats that must be
mitigated.
The purpose of studying the internal environment is to assess organizational strengths
and weaknesses relative to the opportunities and threats that were identified in
external analysis.
A PESTEL analysis helps management identify the external forces that could impact their
market and analyze how they could directly impact their business.
Switching Cost:
Switching costs are the costs that a consumer incurs as a result of changing
brands, suppliers or products. Although most prevalent switching costs are
monetary in nature, there are also psychological, effort- and time-based
switching costs.
Switching costs can be embedded in products to discourage a customer from
switching to a different product or service provider by having that customer
incur an opportunity cost.
Strength of substitutes:
A substitute is an alternative product that serves a similar purpose.
A few examples:
Email is a substitute for express mail;
Plastic is a substitute for glass;
Coffee is a substitute for tea;
bio-fuel is a substitute for gasoline;
used cars are substitutes for new cars; and
The more substitutes a product has and the greater propensity for a buyer to
substitute, the more elastic the demand curve will be for a competitors
product.
Elasticity is just a measure of the sensitivity of a product’s demand to that
products price. The relationship is inverse and the higher the price the lower the
demand.
Many strategists have started using a sixth force in developing a Porter Model. The
sixth force identifies products that complement the products the industry competitors
sell.
Complements are products or services that stimulate demand for an industry's product.
For example, video games made by EA Sports, such as Madden NFL Football, or first
person shooter games, like Battlefield or Call of Duty, can stimulate demand for gaming
consoles made by Sony and Microsoft.
A company is complementary to your company if your customers value your firm's
product more when they are able to combine it with the other company's product.
A complement becomes a competitor if your firm chooses to also develop the
complementary products itself.
The stronger the force in the Porter model, the more likely the downward pressure on
industry margins will be high; for complements the effect is exactly the opposite. The
more complements for an industry’s product, typically the greater the demand and the
higher the profits.
Using the sixth force, we can construct a slightly different model of firm structure. In this
model there are three distinct pairs of forces:
entry/exit barriers
supplier and buyer power
substitutes and compliments
Some ways companies can mitigate structural impediment to firm profitability”
Increase product differentiation
Diversify product lines
Introduce or strengthen switching costs
Continually innovate to increase product value
Alter bargaining relationships between the industry competitors and buyers and
suppliers
Build barriers to entry to keep new competition out
Develop complements or build strategic partnerships with complement
providers
Resources can be tangible: land, equipment, technology, and other physical assets, or
intangible.
Tangible resources can easily be bought in the market, they confer little advantage to
companies in the long run, because rivals can just as easily acquire identical assets.
Intangible assets are everything else that can still be owned by the company. Brand
reputation, trademarks, intellectual property are all intangible assets.
To stress that point again, intangible assets are much more likely to create a sustainable
competitive advantage than are tangible assets.
The two critical assumptions of the resource-based view are that resources must also be
heterogeneous and immobile.
The first assumption is that skills, capabilities, and other resources that
organizations' possess differ from one firm to another. If organizations had the
same quantity, quality, and mix of resources, they could not employ different
strategies to out-compete each other.
Resources are also considered to be immobile or “sticky”: at least in the short
run, resources do not move from company to company. Due to this immobility,
companies cannot replicate rivals’ resources and implement the same
strategies.
The resource-based view assumes that companies achieve competitive advantage by
using their specific bundles of resources effectively in creating either a differentiation or
cost advantage in the marketplace.
For a resource to be at the basis of a competitive advantage, it must be valuable, rare,
costly to imitate and organize to capture value. The acronym VRIO.
13.VRIO Analysis
VRIO is an acronym for Valuable, Rare, Costly to Imitate, and Organized to Capture
Value.
This framework assumes that a firm can only gain a sustained competitive advantage if it
has the resources and capabilities that satisfy VRIO requirements.
For a resource to be the basis of a competitive advantage it must be valuable, rare,
costly to imitate, and the firm must be organized to capture value.
Valuable:
Resources are also considered valuable if they help a firm increase the
perceived value of the firm's products.
For instance, does the resource in some way lead to an increase in product
differentiation or decrease the cost of the product?
The resources that cannot meet this condition, that is, help increase
differentiation or reduce cost, lead either to competitive parity or a competitive
disadvantage.
Rare:
Resources that can only be acquired by one or very few firms are considered
rare.
Rare and valuable resources grant at least a temporary competitive advantage.
The situation when more than one company has the same resource, or uses the
same capability in a similar way, results in competitive parity.
Even though competitive parity is not a desired position, a firm should not
neglect the resources that are valuable but common.
Costly to imitate
If firms that don't have the resource can't imitate it, buy, or substitute for it at a
reasonable price.
There are three key reasons why resources can be hard to imitate.
Historical condition. Resources that were developed over a long period
of time are often costly to imitate. Brand reputation is the best
illustration of this condition.
Causal ambiguity. In some cases, competitors may not be able to
identify the particular resource or resources that are the cause for a
competitors’ competitive advantage.
Social complexity. Resources and capabilities are interwoven into the
fabric of the firm's culture and interpersonal relationships. Two or more
social and business systems interact or combine, creating many and
complex possibilities.
Organized to capture value:
The O in the VRIO is referring to how the firm is organized to exploit the full
competitive potential of its resources and its capabilities.
A firm that has valuable, rare, and costly to imitate resources can, but not
necessarily will, achieve sustained competitive advantage. The resources
themselves do not confer any advantage for a company if the firm is not
organized to capture the value from them.
In order to fully realize competitive advantage, the organization needs to have
appropriate organization structure, management controls, and compensation
policies.
VRIO analysis
If the resources are not valuable the firm should consider eliminating or
outsourcing them. In these cases the focus should be on becoming more cost-
efficient.
If the resource or resources are valuable, but not rare, the firm is in a
competitive conformity. This means that the firm is not worse than its
competitors, but it's not better either.
If the resource is valuable and rare but it is not expensive to imitate, the firm
will have a temporary competitive advantage. When competitors imitate it, the
competitive advantage will be lost. If possible, firms can use trade-secret type
protections here to prolong the competitive advantage.
If the resource is valuable, rare, and is expensive to imitate it, but the firm itself
is not organized to take advantage of it, the resource may become an
unnecessary cost. Institutional changes will be required to exploit the potential
advantage.
If a resource is valuable, rare, expensive, or difficult to imitate, and organized to
capture value, the firm can expect to enjoy a sustained competitive advantage.
VRIO can be applied to capabilities as well as to specific assets. Some firms are able to
achieve competitive advantage by developing unique capabilities to manage relatively
common, tangible assets.
14.The Value Chain Framework
Value chain analysis helps strategists understand how a firm creates value for its
customers.
A value chain is the full range of activities a firm performs to bring a product from
conception to delivery. A value chain may include design, production, operations,
marketing and distribution, as well as other activities.
Business activities are put into two categories: primary activities that create value, and
support activities, that help enable the primary activities.
Primary activities generally include the following:
In-Bound Logistics. In-Bound Logistics can either be narrowly defined as simply
transportation or more broadly defined as supply chain management. For many
firms these activities are outsourced to service providers like Federal Express
and UPS. BTW any activity that is outsourced cannot be a source for competitive
advantage since the activity and the capability supported will not be VRIO – the
activity is not rare.
Manufacturing and assembly, this is the stage where raw materials and other
inputs are turned into final product. For industrial and consumer products
companies, this would be manufacturing. For service-related organizations'
operations here are the processes that directly support the creation of the firms'
value proposition.
Distribution or outbound logistics, this is the distribution of the final product to
customers.
Marketing and sales, this stage involves activities such as advertising,
promotion, sales force organization, selecting distribution channels, pricing and
managing customer relationships.
Post-sales support, this refers to the activities that are needed to maintain the
product's performance after it has been produced and sold.
The indirect or support activities enable and support the primary activities. Several key
support activities are as follows:
Research and Development. R&D involves researching the firm’s market and
customer needs and developing new and improved products and services to fit
these needs.
Information Systems. Technology can be used across the board in the
development of a product; including in the research stage; in product design,
and in production automation. Technology also includes the design and
development of firm’s networks, network security, databases, and database
security. Finally, information technology systems are designed and developed to
facilitate managerial decision making and the efficient running of the
administrative processes of the enterprise.
Human Resource Management, these are the activities involved in hiring and
retaining employees; and ensuring that employees are placed in the right jobs.
Firm infrastructure refers mainly to the management of the firm’s physical
infrastructure including the assets of the firm.
Accounting, Finance, and Planning are administrative functions that support
many of the planning and control functions of the organization.
Planning is the primary function of management and essential to the
performance of a business.
Accounting provides controls for financial aspects of the business as
well as reporting for management other stakeholders of the firm.
Finance activities include the management of the firms cash flow and
cash positions, as well as obtaining the capital necessary for running the
organization.
16.SWOT Analysis
A SWOT is essentially a two by two matrix that forms a set of quadrants.
The x-axis of a SWOT represents a positive assessment at one end and a
negative assessment at the other.
The y-axis is usually labeled Internal at one end and External at the other.
The four quadrants are labeled:
STRENGTHS, which are positive internals
WEAKNESSES, which are negative internals
OPPORTUNITIES, which are positive externals
THREATS, which are negative externals