You are on page 1of 20

International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

www.elsevier.com/locate/ijhydene

Review
Metal hydride materials for solid hydrogen storage: A review夡
Billur Sakintuna a,∗ , Farida Lamari-Darkrim b , Michael Hirscher c
a GKSS Research Centre, Institute for Materials Research, Max-Planck-Str. 1, Geesthacht D-21502, Germany
b LIMHP-CNRS (UPR 1311), Université Paris 13, Avenue J. B. Clément, 93430 Villetaneuse, France
c Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung, Heisenbergstr. 3, D-70569 Stuttgart, Germany

Received 31 July 2006; received in revised form 21 November 2006; accepted 21 November 2006
Available online 16 January 2007

Abstract
Hydrogen is an ideal energy carrier which is considered for future transport, such as automotive applications. In this context storage of
hydrogen is one of the key challenges in developing hydrogen economy. The relatively advanced storage methods such as high-pressure gas
or liquid cannot fulfill future storage goals. Chemical or physically combined storage of hydrogen in other materials has potential advantages
over other storage methods. Intensive research has been done on metal hydrides recently for improvement of hydrogenation properties. The
present review reports recent developments of metal hydrides on properties including hydrogen-storage capacity, kinetics, cyclic behavior,
toxicity, pressure and thermal response. A group of Mg-based hydrides stand as promising candidate for competitive hydrogen storage with
reversible hydrogen capacity up to 7.6 wt% for on-board applications. Efforts have been devoted to these materials to decrease their desorption
temperature, enhance the kinetics and cycle life. The kinetics has been improved by adding an appropriate catalyst into the system and as well
as by ball-milling that introduces defects with improved surface properties. The studies reported promising results, such as improved kinetics
and lower decomposition temperatures, however, the state-of-the-art materials are still far from meeting the aimed target for their transport
applications. Therefore, further research work is needed to achieve the goal by improving development on hydrogenation, thermal and cyclic
behavior of metal hydrides.
䉷 2006 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Hydrogen storage; Review; Mg-based hydrides; Complex hydrides; Intermetallic compounds; Ball-milling; Kinetics; Storage capacity; Operating
temperature and pressure

Contents

1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1122
2. Mg-based metal hydrides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1123
2.1. Improvement on surface properties and mechanical ball-milling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1123
2.2. Cyclic stability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1127
2.3. Catalyst effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1128
2.4. Chemical composition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1129
3. Complex hydrides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1129
3.1. Sodium alanates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1130
3.2. Lithium and potassium alanates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1131
3.3. Lithium nitrides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1131
3.4. Lithium boro- and beryllium hydrides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1132
4. Intermetallic compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1133
5. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1135
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1136
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1136

夡 The work was carried out in LIMHP-CNRS.


∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +49 (0) 4152 872673; fax: +49 (0) 4152 872670.
E-mail address: billur.sakintuna@gkss.de (B. Sakintuna).

0360-3199/$ - see front matter 䉷 2006 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2006.11.022
1122 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Nomenclature P–C pressure-composition


Pabs hydrogen absorption pressure
BCC body centered cubic Pdes hydrogen desorption pressure
BM ball-milling Tabs hydrogen absorption temperature
Cyc. cycle Tdes hydrogen desorption temperature
DOE US Department of Energy tabs hydrogen absorption time
H/M hydrogen atoms per metal atom tdes hydrogen desorption time
Mm misch metals XRD X-ray diffraction

1. Introduction safety perspective such that some form of conversion or energy


input is required to release the hydrogen for use. A great deal
Hydrogen is the ideal candidate as an energy carrier for both of effort has been made on new hydrogen-storage systems, in-
mobile and stationary applications while averting adverse ef- cluding metal, chemical or complex hydrides and carbon nanos-
fects on the environment, and reducing dependence on imported tructures.
oil for countries without natural resources. Carbon materials such as activated carbons, carbon nan-
Hydrogen storage is clearly one of the key challenges in otubes, and carbon nanofibers have been the subject of intensive
developing hydrogen economy. Hydrogen can be stored as (i) research. The research on hydrogen storage in carbon materials
pressurized gas, (ii) cryogenic liquid, (iii) solid fuel as chemical was dominated by announcements of high storage capacities
or physical combination with materials, such as metal hydrides, in carbon nanostructures. However, the experimental results on
complex hydrides and carbon materials, or produced on-board hydrogen storage in carbon nanomaterials scatter over several
the vehicle by reforming methanol [1]. Each of these options orders of magnitude. The hydrogen-storage capacity for car-
possesses attractive attributes for hydrogen storage [2]. bon materials is reported between 0.2 and 10 wt% [7,8]. The
Available technologies permit directly to store hydrogen experiments to date claiming very high values could not inde-
by modifying its physical state in gaseous or liquid form in pendently be reproduced in different laboratories. In view of
pressurized or in cryogenic tanks. The traditional hydrogen- today’s knowledge although they have good reversibility prop-
storage facilities are complicated because of its low boiling erties, carbon nanostructures cannot store the amount of hydro-
point (−252.87 ◦ C) and low density in the gaseous state gen required for automotive applications [9].
(0.08988 g/L) at 1 atm. Liquid hydrogen requires the addition Hydrogen forms metal hydrides with some metals and alloys
of a refrigeration unit to maintain a cryogenic state [3] thus leading to solid-state storage under moderate temperature
adding weight and energy costs, and a resultant 40% loss in and pressure that gives them the important safety advantage
energy content [4]. High-pressure storage of hydrogen gas is over the gas and liquid storage methods. Metal hydrides have
limited by the weight of the storage canisters and the potential higher hydrogen-storage density (6.5 H atoms/cm3 for MgH2 )
for developing leaks. Moreover, storage of hydrogen in liquid than hydrogen gas (0.99 H atoms/cm3 ) or liquid hydrogen
or gaseous form poses important safety problems for on-board (4.2 H atoms/cm3 ) [3]. Hence, metal hydride storage is a
transport applications. Designs involving the use of methane safe, volume-efficient storage method for on-board vehicle
as a hydrogen source require the addition of a steam reformer applications.
to extract the hydrogen from the carbon which adds weight, There are two possible ways of hydriding a metal, direct dis-
additional space requirements, and the need for a device to sociative chemisorption and electrochemical splitting of water.
sequester CO2 [1]. These reactions are:
The US Department of Energy (DOE) [5] published a long- x
term vision for hydrogen-storage applications considering eco- M + H2 ↔ MHx , (1)
2
nomic and environmental parameters. The predicted minimum
x x x
hydrogen-storage capacity should be 6.5 wt% and 65 g/L hy- M + H2 O + e− ↔ MHx + OH− , (2)
drogen available, at the decomposition temperature between 60 2 2 2
and 120 ◦ C for commercial viability. It was also predicted low where M represents the metal.
temperature of hydrogen desorption and low pressure of hydro- Metal hydrides compose of metal atoms that constitute a host
gen absorption (a plateau pressure of the order of a few bars lattice and hydrogen atoms. Metal and hydrogen usually form
at room temperature) and nonthermal transformation between two different kinds of hydrides, -phase at which only some
substrates and products of decomposition as reported by Schulz hydrogen is absorbed and -phase at which hydride is fully
[6]. Furthermore, the cost of a storage medium and its toxicity formed. Hydrogen storage in metal hydrides depends on differ-
properties need to be carefully considered for the realization of ent parameters and consists of several mechanistic steps. Met-
the set goals. als differ in the ability to dissociate hydrogen, this ability being
Storage by absorption as chemical compounds or by ad- dependent on surface structure, morphology and purity [10].
sorption on carbon materials have definite advantages from the An optimum hydrogen-storage material is required to have the
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1123

following properties; high hydrogen capacity per unit mass and desorption temperature and to fasten the re/dehydrogenation
unit volume which determines the amount of available energy, reactions. These can be accomplished to some extent by chang-
low dissociation temperature, moderate dissociation pressure, ing the microstructure of the hydride by ball-milling (mechan-
low heat of formation in order to minimize the energy necessary ical alloying) with elements which reduce the stability of the
for hydrogen release, low heat dissipation during the exother- hydrides and also by using proper catalysts to improve the
mic hydride formation, reversibility, limited energy loss during absorption/desorption kinetics [61].
charge and discharge of hydrogen, fast kinetics, high stability
against O2 and moisture for long cycle life, cyclibility, low cost 2.1. Improvement on surface properties and mechanical
of recycling and charging infrastructures and high safety. ball-milling
Hydrogen-storage as metal hydride has been the focus of in-
tensive research. The hydrogen-storage systems have been re- A critical factor for hydrogen absorption by metals is
ported in numerous studies [11–17]. The light metals such as Li, the metal surface, which activates dissociation of hydrogen
Be, Na, Mg, B and Al, form a large variety of metal–hydrogen molecules and allows easy diffusion of hydrogen into the bulk.
compounds. They are especially interesting due to their light Diffusion is not the limiting step initially because no material
weight and the number of hydrogen atoms per metal atom, has been reacted and there are sufficient active sites available
which is in many cases at the order of H/M = 2. Heavier [62], but chemisorption is the slowest step for pure Mg at this
ones may enter the multiple component system only as a low- point [63]. As the reaction progresses, hydrogen diffusion takes
abundant additive, most likely for alteration of properties or as place and the hydride layer grows, producing a nearly imper-
a catalyst. There is enduring research both on modifying and meable layer. Diffusion through this hydride layer becomes
optimizing the known hydrogen-storage materials, and new re- the rate-limiting step in the hydride formation process [63].
sources. The studies are conducted on finding optimum solid In addition to formation of a compact hydride layer, exposure
hydrogen-storage system [18]. In this review, we briefly men- to oxygen also lowers absorption rates due to the formation
tion about hydrogenation properties, advantages and disadvan- of a highly stable oxide layer [25]. Andreasen et al. [64] have
tages of different metal-hydride systems such as Mg-based reviewed the kinetics in terms of apparent activation energies
metal hydrides, complex hydrides, alanates and intermetallic and apparent prefactors of Mg-based hydrides. It was suggested
compounds. A brief review of state-of-the art is reported on that variations in apparent activation energies correlate with the
metal hydrides. This work will serve to evaluate solid fuel presence of MgO surface layer inhibiting diffusion of hydrogen.
hydrogen store for industrial on-board hydrogen storage tank Thus, oxidized samples show large apparent activation energies
design. and well activated samples show smaller activation energies.
The ball-milling creating fresh surfaces during processing is
2. Mg-based metal hydrides an economic process that is widely applied to metal hydrides
to achieve good surface properties [15]. The main effects
There is considerable research on magnesium and its alloys of ball-milling are increased surface area, formation of mi-
for on-board hydrogen storage due to their high hydrogen- cro/nanostructures and creation of defects on the surface and
storage capacity by weight and low cost [15]. Besides, the Mg- in the interior of the material. The induced lattice defects may
based hydrides possess good-quality functional properties, such aid the diffusion of hydrogen in materials by providing many
as heat-resistance, vibration absorbing, reversibility and recy- sites with low activation energy of diffusion. The induced
clability. In recent years, therefore, much attention has been microstrain assists diffusion by reducing the hysteresis of hy-
paid to investigations on specific material properties of Mg al- drogen absorption and desorption [30]. The increased surface
loys for the development of new functional materials. contact with catalyst during ball-milling leads to fast kinetics
Magnesium hydride, MgH2 , has the highest energy density of hydrogen transformations. It is possible to control proper-
(9 MJ/kg Mg) of all reversible hydrides applicable for hydrogen ties of the store material, according to specific applications.
storage. MgH2 combines a high H2 capacity of 7.7 wt% with the These include changing the alloy composition, surface prop-
benefit of the low cost of the abundantly available magnesium erties, microstructures and grain size by ball-milling without
[19–22] with good reversibility [23,24]. the additional cost of catalyst and with minimal loss of stor-
The main disadvantages of MgH2 as a hydrogen store is the age capacity [58]. It is used for production of nanocrystalline
high temperature of hydrogen discharge, slow desorption kinet- magnesium with superior powder morphology that gives re-
ics and a high reactivity toward air and oxygen [25,26]. Ther- markable improvement of kinetics and surface activity for
modynamic properties of the magnesium hydride system have hydrogenation [21,25]. The crystalline Mg2 Ni alloy obtained
been investigated. The results showed high operating tempera- by ball-milling has excellent surface properties compared with
ture which is too high for practical on-board applications [27]. those prepared by a conventional metallurgical method [65].
High thermodynamic stability of MgH2 results in a relatively Huot et al. [58] investigated the structural difference between
high desorption enthalpy, which corresponds to an unfavorable milled and unmilled MgH2 . The specific surface area is de-
desorption temperature of 300 ◦ C at 1 bar H2 [15,20]. creased by milling 10-fold. Faster hydrogen desorption kinetics,
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of recently stud- reduction in activation energy and enhanced kinetics observed
ied Mg-based hydrides are summarized in Table 1. Many efforts for the milled MgH2 compared to the unmilled one are seen in
has focused on Mg-based hydrides in recent years to reduce the Fig. 1. The activation energies for desorption were measured
1124
Table 1
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of Mg-based hydrides

Material Method Temperature (◦ C) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max wt% of H2 Ref.

MgH2 –5 mol% Fe2 O3 BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 2–15 tabs: 20 No data 1.37 [28]
30 wt% Mg–M mNi5−x (CoAlMn)x BM Tabs : 15 Pabs : 6 tabs : 83 No data 2.30 [22,29]
Mg–5 wt% FeTi1.2 BM Tabs and Tdes : 400 Pabs : 30 No data 9 cyc.: stable after fourth cycle 2.70 [30]
Pdes : 1
MgH2 –5 mol% V2 O5 BM Tabs : 250 Pabs : 15 tabs : 1.6 No data 3.20 [28]
90Mg–10Al BM Tabs and Tdes : 400 Pabs : 15 tabs : 2.7–19 No data 3.30 [31,32]
Pdes : 12 tdes : 0.5–5.8
Mg–50 wt% ZrFe1.4 Cr 0.6 BM Tabs : 250–350 Pabs : 20 tabs : 1 2 cyc.: stable 3.40 [33]
Tdes : 300–350 Pdes :1 tdes : 5
Mg–10 wt% CeO2 BM Tabs and Tdes : 300 Pabs : 11 tabs : 60 5 cyc.: not stable 3.43 [34]
Pdes : 0.5 tdes : 60
Mg–20 wt% Mm (La, Nd, Ce) BM (pellet form) Tabs : 300 Pabs : 10 tabs : 10 No data 3.50 [35]
Tdes : 480 Pdes : 1 tdes : 5
Mg–40 wt% ZrFe1.4 Cr 0.6 BM Tdes : 270–280 Pdes : 1 tdes : 15 2 cyc.: stable 3.60 [36]
La2 Mg17 –40 wt% LaNi5 BM Tabs and Tdes : 250–303 Pabs and Pdes : 4–7 tabs : 0.45 20 cyc.: not stable 3.70 [37,38]
tdes : 4
La0.5 Ni1.5 Mg17 Hydriding combustion Tabs and Tdes : 280–400 Pabs : 2.21–11.34 tabs : 15 Not stable 4.03 [39]
synthesis
Pdes : 1.62–15.48 tdes : 5
Mg–50 wt% LaNi5 BM Tdes : 250–300 Pabs and Pdes : 10–15 tabs : 3.33 Not stable 4.10 [40]
MgH2 –2LiNH2 BM Tabs and Tdes : 200 Pabs : 50 tdes : 60 4 cyc.: stable after 2nd cycle 4.30 [41,42]
Pdes : 10
Mg2 CoH5 Mixing Tabs : 450–550 Pabs : 17–25 No data 1000 cyc.: stable 4.48 [43]
MgH2 –5 mol% Al2 O3 BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 15 tabs : 67 No data 4.49 [28]
1.1MgH2 –2LiNH2 BM Tabs : 200 Pabs : 30 Tabs : 30 9 cyc.: stable 4.50 [44,45]
Mg–20 wt% TiO2 BM Tabs : 350 Pabs : 20 bar tabs : 2 No data 4.70 [46]
Tdes : 330–350 Pdes : 1 tdes : 10
Mg–30 wt% BM (hexane medium) Tdes : 300–550 Pdes : 2 tdes : 30 No data 5.00 [47]
MmNi4.6 Fe0.4
MgH2 –5 wt% V BM Tabs and Tdes : 300 Pabs and Pdes :1–3 tabs : 2 2000 cyc.: stable 5.00 [48]
tdes : 10
Mg–Fe–Mg2 FeH6 Mixing Tabs : 473–552 Pabs : 77–85 tabs : 90 600 cyc.: stable 5.00 [43]
MgH2 –Mg2 FeH6 Mixing Tabs and Tdes : 350–525 Pabs and Pdes : 3.6–93.7 tabs : 90–1440 600 cyc.: stable 5.00 [49]
MgH2 –5 at% Ti BM Tabs : 200 Pabs : 10 tdes: 3.33 No data 5.00 [50]
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Tdes : 300 Pdes : 0.15 tabs : 0.83


MgH2 –5 at% Ni BM Tabs : 200 Pabs : 10 tdes : 5 No data 5.00 [50]
Tdes : 300 Pdes : 0.15 tabs : 16.7
Mg–30 wt% LaNi2.28 BM Tabs : 280 Pabs : 30 tabs : 1.6 3 cyc.: stable 5.40 [51]
MgH2 –5 at% V BM Tabs : 200 Pdes : 0.15 tdes : 3.33 No data 5.50 [50]
Tdes : 300 Pabs : 10 tabs :1.66
Mg–10 wt% Fe2 O3 BM Tabs : 320 Pabs : 12 tabs : 60 3 cyc.: stable 5.56 [52]
tabs : 10
Mg–30 wt% CFMmNi5 Mixing and Tabs and Tdes : 500 Pabs and Pdes : 3–10 tdes: 40 No data 5.60 [53]
encapsulation
Mg–10 wt% Al2 O3 BM Tabs and Tdes : 300 Pabs : 11 tabs : 60 5 cyc.: not stable 5.66 [34]
Pdes : 0.5 tdes : 60
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1125
[54]

[34]

[43]
[50]

[55]

[56]
[57]

[58]

[59]
[26]

[20]

[60]
 7.60
5.80

5.87

6.00
6.00

6.40

6.50
6.70

7.00

7.00
7.00

7.30
5 cyc.: not stable

2 cyc.: not stable


1000 cyc.: stable
800 cyc.: stable
No data

No data

No data

No data

No data
No data

No data

No data
tdes : 50 (unmilled)
tdes : 12.5 (milled)
tdes : 10–35
tabs : 13.33
tdes : 8.33

tdes : 150

tabs : 420
No data

No data
tabs: 4.2

tdes: 1.5
tdes : 33
tabs : 60
tdes : 60
tabs: 90

tabs : 6

tabs : 2

tabs : 1
tdes: 6

Fig. 1. Hydrogen desorption curves of unmilled MgH2 (solid symbols) and


ball-milled (hollow symbols) MgH2 under a hydrogen pressure of 0.15 bar
[58].
Pabs and Pdes : 4.0–1.4

Pabs and Pdes : 1–2

as 120 and 156 kJ/mol for the milled and unmilled powders,
respectively. It has been found that ball-milling of Mg2 NiH4
vacuum

vacuum
3–10

substantially decreases the desorption temperature. Depending


Pdes : 0.15

0.15
Pdes: 0.15
Pdes : 0.5

8.4

8.4

0.6
Pabs : 10

Pabs : 11

Pabs : 10

No data
1

on the ball-milling conditions, the shift of the onset of desorp-


Pdes :
Pabs :
Pdes :
Pabs :
Pdes :
Pdes :
Pabs :
Pdes :
Pabs :

tion temperature can be as large as 100 ◦ C for MgH2 and 40 ◦ C


for Mg2 NiH4 [66].
Hydrogenation properties are very sensitive to these surface
modifications. The ball-milled powders do not require activa-
Tabs and Tdes : 300

Tabs and Tdes : 300

Tabs and Tdes : 300

Tabs : 300 (milled)


Tdes : 350 (milled)

Tabs andTdes : 300

tion compared to the conventional methods. For all nanocrys-


Tabs : 230–370

Tdes : 150–250

Tdes : 140–190

Tdes : 335–347
Tdes : 50–150

talline hydrides investigated, the grain boundary does not


Tabs : 200
Tdes : 300

Tabs : 200
Tdes : 300

Tabs : 180

dramatically affect the pressure–composition (P–C) isotherms.


This describes the thermodynamic aspects of hydride forma-
tion which is more visible in the Van’t Hoff plots that illustrate
the relationship between equilibrium pressure and changes in
enthalpy and entropy. The pressure for hydrogen desorption
cyclohexane medium)
Wet-chemical method

of the unmilled MgH2 is lower than that of the milled one, as


BM (benzene and

seen in Fig. 2.
Aoyagi et al. [67] proposed that ball-milling of the alloys
under inert environment leads to reduction in powder size and
Mixing

creation of new surfaces, which are effective for the improve-


BM

BM

BM

BM

BM
BM

BM

BM

BM

ment of the hydrogen absorption rate. Hydrogen absorption


rate of Mg-based alloys also increases with the milling time.
Liang et al. [30] proposed that ball-milling of Mg–5 wt%
MgH2 –0.2 mol% Cr 2 O3

MgH2 –1 mol% Cr 2 O3
Mg/MgH2 –5 wt% Ni

FeTi1.2 produces fine powder with nanometer-sized grains and


Mg–0.5 wt% Nb2 O5
Mg–10 wt% Cr 2 O3

3Mg(NH2 )2 –8LiH
MgH2 –2 mol% Ni
MgH2 –5 at% Mn

large microstrain, which results in an increase in the hydrid-


MgH2 –5 at% Ge
MgH2 –5 wt% V

MgH2 –1 at% Al

ing and dehydriding rates. The high absorption rate is due to


the large quantity of phase boundaries and the porous surface
MgH2

structure [40]. Nanocrystalline hydrides enhanced the hydro-


genation kinetics, even at relatively low temperatures. These
1126 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Fig. 3. Desorption curves of magnesium catalyzed with 0.1 mol% Nb2 O5 and
milled for 2, 5, 10, 20, 50 and 100 h, at 573 K and vacuum [75].

with 5.56 wt% H2 absorption, by facilitating nucleation by cre-


ating defects on the surface of Mg particles and reducing the
particle size of Mg and thus by shortening the diffusion dis-
Fig. 2. Pressure–concentration–temperature curves of the unmilled and
tances of hydrogen atoms. By using the same method, it was
ball-milled MgH2 at 623 K [58]. proposed recently that the presence of nickel lowered the onset
temperature of MgH2 desorption to 225 ◦ C by ball-milling un-
der hydrogen atmosphere [71]. Tessier et al. [70] synthesized
structures can be obtained by means of local change in the Mg2 Ni with the same method. Furthermore, Orimo et al. [73]
stable atomic positions into the metastable configuration. found that ball-milling of Mg2 Ni under hydrogen resulted in
Ball-milling of LiNH2 /MgH2 results in low dehydrogenation a significant facilitation of hydrogen desorption. Alloying time
temperature (200 ◦ C) but with markedly slow kinetics and has a significant effect on hydride properties of Mg2 Ni. Ab-
lowered hydrogen uptake capacity [41]. Wagemans et al. [68] dellaoui et al. [74] proposed that absorption capacity changes
investigated the quantum chemical perspective of MgH2 . Small with alloying duration. Barkhordarian et al. [75] investigated
MgH2 clusters have much lower desorption energy than bulk the effect of milling time on the magnesium hydrogen sorp-
MgH2 , hence enabling hydrogen desorption at lower tempera- tion reaction. Reaction kinetics is enhanced by increasing the
tures. The hydrogen desorption energy decreases significantly milling time, as shown in Fig. 3. Ball-milling is generally used
when the crystal grain size becomes smaller than 1.3 nm. A to produce powders in the range of 60.100 m [25,76] to cre-
MgH2 crystallite size of 0.9 nm corresponds to a desorption ate more active sights for hydrogen penetration. Smaller parti-
temperature of only 200 ◦ C [68]. Particles with nanocrystalline cle sizes also eliminate the formation of hydride layers greater
structure with grain size of 10 nm or less, increase the density than 50 m [25].
of grain boundaries, resulting in easier activation [69]. Although extensive work has been done on hydrogen storage
In another approach, a hydrogen-absorbing material can be in bulk materials as thin film hydride is an emerging field of
hydrogenated during ball-milling [70]. It was shown that ball- research. Research performed on thin films of pure magnesium
milling under hydrogen atmosphere is a convenient method for concluded that the thinner the magnesium sheet, the faster it
the formation of metal hydrides which causes simultaneous hy- achieved complete formation of MgH2 . It was found that hy-
drogen uptake and mechanical deformation resulting from ball- drogen penetrated to an average depth of 30 m and stopped
milling. Huot et al. [71] produced MgH2 under H2 atmosphere [77]. Mg portions of the film have converted totally into MgH2
by ball-milling. This method improved the hydride formation at temperatures not higher than 200 ◦ C [78]. Hydrogen-storage
kinetics. Chen et al. [72] studied also the formation of metal properties of nanocomposite three-layered Pd/Mg/Pd films
hydrides under H2 atmosphere. The results indicated that pul- have been previously investigated. After hydrogenation under
verization and deformation processes occurring during high- a hydrogen gas pressure of 1 bar at 100 ◦ C, Pd layers contain
energy ball-milling play a major role in the hydriding reaction. only 0.15–0.30 wt% H2 , whereas the Mg film contains 5.0 wt%
It is concluded that ball-milling is a simple and inexpensive hydrogen [79]. Pd/Mg films with different degree of crystal-
method of producing high hydrogen content metal hydrides. lization in the Mg layer are prepared in different sputtering
Mg–10 wt% Fe2 O3 is synthesized by mechanical grinding conditions [77]. The dehydriding temperature decreases with
under H2 atmosphere [52]. It increases the H2 -sorption rates decreasing the degree of crystallization in the Mg layer in
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1127

Table 2
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of Mg–Ni-based hydrides

Material Method Temperature (◦ C) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max wt% of H2 Ref.

Mg2 Ni–1 wt% Pd BM Tabs : 200 Pabs : 15 tabs : 27 4 cyc.: stable 2.50 [86]
Mg2 Ni BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 29 5 cyc.: not stable 3.20 [87]
Mg2 Ni BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 11.6 tabs : 10 4 cyc.: stable 3.50 [86]
Mg2 Ni BM Tabs and Tdes : 280 Pdes : 1–2 No data No data 3.53 [74,88]
Mg–Mg2 Ni BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 12 tabs : 83 2 cyc.: not stable 3.60 [89]
Mg2 Ni BM Tabs and Tdes : 280–330 Pabs : 1–15 tabs : 1 No data 4.10 [82]
Pdes : 1–2 tdes : 1
70 wt% Mg–30 wt% LaNi5 BM Tabs and Tdes : 350 Pabs : 10 tabs : 30 10 cyc.: stable 4.66 [90]
Pdes : 1.5 tdes : 10 [91]
65 wt% MgH2 –35 wt% Mg2 NiH4 BM Tdes : 220–240 Pdes : 0.5 tabs : 10 20 cyc.: stable 5.00 [66]

Pd/Mg films. The lowest crystallization of films absorb 5.6 wt% dehydriding temperature is 250.300 ◦ C at desorption pressure
of hydrogen and all hydrogen desorbed at a temperature lower of 2.1–3.0 bar [22,66,74,84,88]. High hydrogen capacity of four
than 190 ◦ C in a vacuum [77]. hydrogen atoms per Mg2 Ni, combined with the small specific
Mechanical alloying can be preformed in the presence of or- weight of the alloy is the most important advantage of Mg2 Ni
ganic solvents such as benzene, cyclohexane or carbon materi- over other magnesium hydrides [93].
als [80,81]. Nanosized MgH2 ball-milled with benzene showed There are numerous publications regarding the upgrade of
reversible hydriding/dehydriding with high capacity under 1 bar hydrogenation properties of Mg2 NiH4 . Their hydriding prop-
hydrogen pressure. It was proposed that the organic additives erties are thought to be strongly affected by their nanometer-
of benzene or cyclohexane are essential for decisive character- scale structures by means of thermodynamic and kinetic
istics of the resulting magnesium to sustain nanosized magne- aspects. MgNi2 prepared by ball-milling is found to react with
sium with high-degree of dispersion [20]. Wet milling in the hydrogen even at room temperature, whereas polycrystalline
presence of toluene leads to hydrogen and carbon pick up in the material needs hydrogenation temperature of 250.350 ◦ C and
powder, and also require much longer milling times [82]. Hy- pressure of 15–50 bar [84]. Haussermann et al. [92] inves-
driding properties of Mg-based composites which are prepared tigated the structural stability and bonding properties of the
by mechanical milling of magnesium powder and graphite or Mg2 NiH4 using ab initio density functional calculations. Par-
graphite supporting 5 wt% Pd in the presence of various ad- ticular changes of the hydriding properties of the nanostruc-
ditives (tetrahydrofuran, benzene or cyclohexane) have been tured Mg2 NiH4 have been also reported [19,22,25,73,94].
studied [80]. In particular, the presence of tetrahydrofuran in The nanocrystalline Mg2 Ni intermetallic compound formed
the milling process strongly affected the hydriding and dehy- by mechanical alloying of Mg and Mg2 Ni can absorb hydro-
driding kinetics of the resulting composites [80]. There is a gen rapidly without activation. The Mg + Mg2 Ni composites
synergetic interaction between Mg and aromatic carbon atoms need activation, but once activated, they absorb hydrogen more
of graphite containing charge transfer to some extent. rapidly than Mg2 Ni at low temperature of 150 ◦ C under 12 bar
It has been found that the hydrogenation properties of Mg, with high capacity of 4.2 wt% [89]. Nanoparticles of Mg2 Ni
such as hydrogenation/dehydrogenation temperature and hy- leads to superior hydrogenation behavior including easy acti-
drogenation rate, can be more or less improved by forming vation and hydrogen uptake in the first cycle itself compared to
composite structures. Zhu et al. [22,29] reported that the hy- the conventional crystal phase [86,87]. Nanocrystalline Mg2 Ni
drogen sorption properties of Mg and Mg–Ni-based alloys can with Pd exhibits much faster absorption kinetics at 200 ◦ C than
significantly be improved by forming composites having proper the as-ball-milled samples (reaction halftime of 2 and 33 min,
microstructural feature. respectively) [86].
Mg2 NiH4 attracts wide interest for being a promising hydro-
gen store material due to its relatively high capacity, low cost, 2.2. Cyclic stability
light weight and low-toxicity [83] and for its unusual struc-
tural and bonding properties [84,85]. The hydrogen absorption Cyclic stability is one of the major criteria for applicability
and desorption properties of Mg–Ni-based alloys are listed in of metal/metal hydride systems for reversible hydrogen storage.
Table 2. Mg2 NiH4 forms eagerly by hydrogenating the alloy Depending on the nature of the additives, cycling temperatures
Mg2 Ni [92]: and starting microstructures, various structures and intermedi-
Mg2 Ni + 2H2 → Mg2 NiH4 . (3) ate phases can be obtained. Song et al. [34] synthesized magne-
sium hydrides with additives of Cr 2 O3 , Al2 O3 and CeO2 . All
Upon hydrogenation, Mg2 Ni reacts with 3.6 wt% of hydro- the samples absorb and desorb less hydrogen at the fifth cycle
gen and transforms into the hydride phase, Mg2 NiH4 , and the than at the first cycle due to the agglomeration of the particles
1128 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

2.3. Catalyst effect

Catalysis is one of the critical factors in the improvement


of hydrogen sorption kinetics in metal hydride systems that
enables fast and effective dissociation of hydrogen molecules
[21]. Effective catalysts, even added in small amounts enhance
the formation of a hydride in reasonable extent. There is in-
tensive research about finding a proper catalyst to enhance the
hydriding properties. It was reported that the rate of absorption
is controlled by the following factors: the rate of hydrogen dis-
sociation at the surface, the capability of hydrogen to penetrate
from the surface which is typically covered by an oxide layer
into metal, the rate of hydrogen diffusion into the bulk metal
Fig. 4. Cyclic stability of chemical Ni-doped Mg at 503–643 K and 4.0 bar, and through the hydride already formed.
time for one full cycle 3 h [43].
Palladium is a good catalyst for hydrogen dissociation re-
action. The hydriding properties are enhanced by catalysis
during hydrogenation/dehydrogenation cycling. Misch metals through nanoparticles of Pd located on magnesium surface
(Mm) such as Ce, La, Nd and Pr, are used to increase the cyclic [25]. The reactivity of palladium after exposure to oxygen is
stability [95,35]. However, the increased concentration of Mm recovered during exposure to hydrogen because of the easy
in the samples has an adverse effect on hydrogen-storage ca- decomposition of palladium oxide [93]. However, high cost
pacity and their reaction rate [35]. Gross et al. [37] have re- of palladium is the main disadvantage for the industrial ap-
ported formation phase changes, segregation and disintegration plications [15]. Zaluski et al. [86] have also reported on the
of La2 Mg17 + 40 wt% LaNi5 during cycling at temperatures presence of Pd as a catalyst in nanocrystalline Mg2 Ni, LaNi5
up to 350 ◦ C. It was also reported that hydrogen capacity of and FeTi systems, enhance the absorption rates even at lower
La0.5 Ni1.5 Mg17 decreases with cycling [39]. temperatures and maintain less sensitivity to air exposures.
There are few publications regarding high number of cyclic Hydrogen molecules have a strong affinity for nickel and
tests. Reiser et al. [43] investigated the behavior of Ni-doped readily dissociate and adsorb onto surface-layer nickel clusters
Mg and Mg2 CoH5 . They indicated that they are almost stable [101,102]. Through the addition of 1 at% of nickel to magne-
even after 800 cycles with small fluctuations in the hydrogen ca- sium, Holtz and Imam [76] achieved a 50% increase in hy-
pacity, as shown in Fig. 4. The cyclic stability of MgH2 –5 wt% drogen capacity, a decrease in the temperature for the onset of
V is studied by Dehouche et al. [48] up to 2000 cycles. They hydrogenation from 275 to 175 ◦ C, and a lowering of the de-
concluded that there is no change in isotherms and no disinte- hydrogenation onset temperature from 350 to 275 ◦ C.
gration of the materials even when hydrogen content reached In addition to Pd and Ni, Ge can be used for the catalysis
5 wt%. Also the cyclic stability of MgH2 + 0.2 mol% Cr 2 O3 is of hydrogenation kinetics [60]. The presence of Ge decreases
previously examined at 1000 cycles. Although desorption time the hydride decomposition temperature in a range from 50 to
is increased, an increase of H2 storage capacity is reported by 150 ◦ C, depending on the catalyst amount. But the catalytic ef-
about 8% between the first and the 500 or 1000 cycle due to fect of Ge disappears after few hydrogen absorption/desorption
structural relaxations and crystallite growth [55]. Friedlmeier cycles [60]. Vanadium also acts as a catalyst for the dissoci-
et al. [96] observed a decrease in the kinetics of hydrogen ab- ation of hydrogen molecules. It was also reported using V as
sorption after 4300 cycles, but no loss in the hydrogen capacity a catalyst, hydrogen capacity can be increased up to 5.8 wt%
of Mg–2 at% Ni alloy. However, to achieve the same storage while the thermodynamic parameters of MgH2 were not altered
capacity, the system temperature had to be increased. Neverthe- [54], as shown in Fig. 5.
less, Dehouche et al. [97] showed 15% decrease in hydrogen Titanium and vanadium block the oxidation of the alloy sur-
capacity after 2100 cycles with a starting material of nanocrys- face, and therefore, increase the discharge capacity over mul-
talline Mg2 Ni. This was attributed to the formation of the non- tiple cycles [103]. A nanocrystalline Mg1.9 Ti0.1 Ni alloy shows
hydride forming MgNi2 phase, during the cycling process. good absorption kinetics at room temperature [104]. The Ti de-
The resistance of metal hydrides to impurities is one of the creases the kinetic barriers of absorption while the Ni protects
critical issues for on-board applications in order to maintain the alloy from deactivation due to oxide layer formation.
performance over the lifetime of the material. The effects of The poor kinetics of MgH2 are greatly improved by addition
N2 , O2 , CO2 and CO on a pure magnesium powder have been of different oxide catalysts that enhance hydriding properties
studied [98]. Both O2 and N2 slowed the rate of hydrogen ab- at relatively low temperature, such as V2 O5 [28] and Cr 2 O3
sorption, while CO and CO2 entirely prevented the uptake of [34,55]. The oxide particles may operate as a milling ball dur-
hydrogen [98,99]. The performance of MgH2 .V.Ti was eval- ing high-energy ball-milling that creates many defects in the
uated after 1000 cycles under a H2 atmosphere containing Mg powder. Defects provide hydrogen an easy path to Mg [28].
101 ppm moisture. Hydrogen-storage capacity increased 5% but It was also proposed that Cr 2 O3 yields fast hydrogen absorp-
desorption properties deteriorated due to surface modification tion, whereas V2 O5 and Fe3 O4 cause the most rapid desorp-
of the particles [100]. tion of hydrogen [57]. The addition of TiO2 also resulted in
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1129

Wang et al. [33,36] combined both the catalytic and milling


effect in a system of fine ZrFe1.4 Cr 0.6 particles covering
Mg particles that resulted in an enhancement in absorp-
tion/desorption rates. ZrFe1.4 Cr 0.6 dispersing homogeneously
on the particle surfaces and in the interior of the material played
an important role in promoting the decomposition of MgH2 .
That probably could account for the decrease in activation en-
ergy. In another study [51], mechanically alloyed Mg–30 wt%
LaNi2.28 reported to have good hydriding properties with
5.40 wt% hydrogen storage under 30 bar hydrogen pressure.
With energetic ball-milling, the solubility limit of magne-
sium in lithium slightly increased [106]. Luo [44] developed
LiNH2 /MgH2 system by partial substitution of Li by Mg which
has a storage capacity of 4.5 wt% at 200 ◦ C and 30 bar. Me-
chanical alloying of Mg with some elements such as Zn, Al,
Ag, Ga, In or Cd resulted in reducing the stability of magne-
sium hydride. Indium and cadmium gave the best results [107].
Bogdanovic et al. [49] and Reiser et al. [43] considered the
Mg2 FeH6 –MgH2 systems. The maximum amount of stored hy-
drogen is 5.0 wt% which is one third less than magnesium dihy-
dride with 7.7 wt%, but the Mg2 FeH6 .MgH2 system possesses
numerous advantages including the low price of starting mate-
rials, the free choice and constancy of the heat delivery temper-
Fig. 5. Hydrogen desorption curves of mechanically milled MgH2 –5 at% V ature by controlling the applied hydrogen pressure and absence
composite (hollow symbols) and MgH2 (solid symbols) under 0.15 bar [54]. of heat losses with time. The intermetallic hydride Mg2 FeH6
shows the high volumetric hydrogen density of 150 kgH2 /m3 ,
which is more than double of liquid hydrogen [108].
a markedly improved hydrogenation performance of Mg, rapid Nanocomposites of MgH2 and 3d transition metals, Ti, V,
kinetics, low working temperature and excellent oxidation re- Mn, Fe and Ni, have been investigated intensively [48,50,109].
sistance [46]. Liang et al. [40] suggested that La showed a cat- The composites containing Mg–Ti and Mg–V exhibited the
alytic effect on Mg–50 wt% LaNi5 nanocomposite. rapid absorption kinetics such as absorption time of 2–5 min.
In addition to catalyst type, the amount of catalysts used Formation enthalpy and entropy of magnesium hydride is dis-
has a significant effect on hydrogen absorption behavior. torted by milling with transition metals. Furthermore, the acti-
Oelerich et al. [57] investigated different amounts of oxides vation energy of desorption for magnesium hydride is reduced
for catalysis but it is shown that only 0.2 mol% of the cata- at 200 ◦ C.
lyst is sufficient to provide fast sorption kinetics. The effect
of Nb2 O5 concentration on the kinetics of magnesium hydro-
3. Complex hydrides
gen sorption reaction at 300 ◦ C is studied. Fastest kinetics are
obtained using 0.5 mol% Nb2 O5 with a 7.0 wt% of hydrogen Another class of light-weight storage materials is com-
capacity [26]. plex hydrides. Complex hydrides are known as “one-pass”
In the search for efficient and inexpensive catalysts for hy- hydrogen-storage systems which mean that H2 evolves upon
drogen sorption reactions, a new type of catalytic compounds contact with water. Sodium, lithium and beryllium are the only
is developed [105]. These catalytic complexes demonstrated re- elements lighter than magnesium that can also form solid-state
markable enhancement in sodium alanates and magnesium, as compounds with hydrogen. The hydrogen content reaches the
well as in hydrogen generation through hydrolysis [105]. value of 18 wt% for LiBH4 . Use of complex hydrides for
hydrogen storage is challenging because of both kinetic and
2.4. Chemical composition thermodynamic limitations.
Intense interest has developed in low weight complex hy-
The type and the chemical composition of the metal alloy drides such as alanates [AlH4 ]− , amides [NH2 ]− , imides and
is one of the most important factors in the metal–hydrogen borohydrides [BH4 ]− . In such systems, the hydrogen is often
system [21]. Bouaricha et al. [31] prepared Mg/Al alloys by located at the corners of a tetrahedron. The alanates and borates
high-energy ball-milling. The measured hydrogen capacity of are especially interesting because of their light weight and the
the material decreases with Al content, from H/M = 1.74 for capacity for large number of hydrogen atoms per metal atom.
pure unmilled Mg, to 1.38 for Mg:Al (90:10), and then to 1.05 Borates are known to be stable and decompose only at ele-
for Mg:Al (75:25). But it improves the kinetics. Ball-milling has vated temperatures. Alanates are remarkable due to their high
a possibility to combine two or more phases having different storage capacities; however, they decompose in two steps upon
hydrogenation characteristics [21]. dehydriding.
1130 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

3.1. Sodium alanates Moreover the surface of sodium alanate is damaged by the
catalyst which causes decreasing the cyclic capacity.
Sodium alanates are complex hydrides of aluminum and The dry-doping TiCl3 catalyst is investigated by the same
sodium. Sodium tetrahydroaluminate–NaAlH4 and trisodium group [123]. It largely eliminates the high catalyst weight,
hexahydroaluminate–Na3 AlH6 have been known for decades. low capacity and contamination problems noted above for the
Sodium aluminum hydride, NaAlH4 , would seem to be a alkoxide catalysts [116]. Both the hydriding and dehydriding
possible candidate for application as a practical on-board rates increases by doping [123]. Under the same rehydrogena-
hydrogen-storage material due to the theoretically reversible tion conditions, the amount of evolved hydrogen from the
hydrogen-storage capacity of 5.6 wt%, low cost and its avail- Ti-doped NaAlH4 is about 50 times as much as that of the
ability in bulk. undoped NaAlH4 . This clearly indicates that the addition of ti-
Although they have good hydrogen-storage capacity, com- tanium species enhances kinetically not only the dehydrogena-
plex aluminum hydrides are not considered as rechargeable tion, but also the rehydrogenation reaction of NaAlH4 [118].
hydrogen carriers due to irreversibility and poor kinetics. With 2 mol% TiN as a doping agent, cyclic storage capacity
However, by using appropriate transition or rare-earth metals of 5 wt% H2 is achieved after 17 cycles. However, decrease in
as catalysts, the complex hydrides can be made reversible. hydrogenation rate with number of cycles is observed [122].
Bogdanovic and Schwickardi [110,111] demonstrated upon Zirconium doping is also used for the same purpose. The dehy-
doping with proper titanium compounds, the dehydriding of driding kinetics of NaAlH4 is significantly improved. Although
aluminum hydrides could be kinetically enhanced and main- effects of zirconium are poorer than titanium as a catalyst for
tain reversibility under moderate conditions in the solid state. the dehydriding of NaAlH4 to Na3 AlH6 and Al, it is a superior
Unlike intermetallic hydrides, these complex-based hydrides catalyst for the dehydriding of Na3 AlH6 to NaH and Al [119].
release hydrogen through a series of decomposition reactions Sun et al. [124] examined the details of the doping role
as described in two equations below, for the dehydrogenation of titanium and zirconium on NaAlH4 with XRD. Significant
reactions of NaAlH4 : changes occur in the lattice parameters of sodium alanates upon
doping. Hence the enhancement of dehydriding kinetics is as-
NaAlH4 ↔ 13 Na3 AlH6 + 23 Al + H2 , (4a) sociated with dopant induced lattice distortions rather than the
catalytic effect [124]. Phase transitions and crystal structure
Na3 AlH6 ↔ 3NaH + Al + 23 H2 . (4b) modifications of doped-NaAlH4 were also observed by Gross
et al. [125]. Contrary to Sun et al. [124], they proposed the cat-
Theoretically, NaAlH4 and Na3 AlH6 contain large amounts alytic effects of doping materials in the enhancement of kinet-
of hydrogen, 7.4 and 5.9 wt%, respectively. However, the re- ics of NaAlH4 . It was earlier reported that the presence of Ti is
lease of hydrogen does not occur in a single-step reaction. not enough rather a particular local arrangement is required for
NaAlH4 first decomposes evolving molecular hydrogen and the dehydrogenation reaction [126]. Ti-cluster-doped NaAlH4
form an intermediate compound, Na3 AlH6 and metallic Al. is investigated [122,127]. The hydrogenation and dehydrogena-
This intermediate phase then decomposes to NaH with ad- tion measurements indicate that the state of the precursor is of
ditional metallic Al formation and hydrogen evolution. The even greater importance than the simple amount of Ti in the
reversibility of these two reactions is a critical factor for the material. The small size of the Ti clusters seem to be responsi-
practical applications. ble for the increase of the reaction rate [127].
Stoichiometrically, the first step consists of 3.7 wt% H2 re- Although titanium has positive effects as a catalyst, kinet-
lease and the second step 1.9 wt%, for a theoretical net reaction ics is not fully enhanced. The hydrogen desorption can last
of 5.6 wt% reversible gravimetric hydrogen storage [111,112]. up to 4200 min in some cases [123]. To improve the kinet-
The process is characterized by slow kinetics and reversibility ics Thomas et al. [128] investigated the effects of mechanical
only under severe conditions. The operating temperatures are ball-milling on the microstructural character of NaAlH4 in the
between 185 and 230 ◦ C, and 260 ◦ C for the first and the sec- presence of catalyst. Fracture and fragmentation of particles
ond reaction, respectively. Finally, the decomposition of NaH are observed in particle morphology. The direct synthesis of
occurs at a much higher temperature, with the total hydrogen Na3 AlH6 and Na2 LiAlH6 by energetic mechanical alloying was
release of 7.40 wt%. For hydrogen storage, only the first two also investigated earlier [129]. The milled NaAlH4 or Na3 AlH6
reactions need to be considered, because the decomposition of exhibited great improvement of the kinetics of absorption and
NaH occurs at too high temperature of 425 ◦ C for practical desorption. The addition of carbon in the milling process im-
storage systems. proved their performance as well [120]. Mechanically alloyed
Previously Jensen et al. [113] reviewed the catalytically en- Na3 AlH6 exhibits faster kinetics than Na3 AlH6 obtained from
hanced sodium aluminum hydrides. Recently, numerous stud- the decomposition of NaAlH4 [130]. Moreover, the hydrogen-
ies are being carried out to enhance the hydriding properties of storage performance of NaAlH4 was found to be highly de-
NaAlH4 as listed in Table 3. pendent on the milling time which increases with time [117].
The effects of liquid alkoxides Ti(Obun )4 + Zr(OPr i )4 on Consequently mechano-chemical synthesis method which in-
hydriding properties of sodium alanates were investigated volves simply ball-milling of the appropriate reagents at high
by Sandrock et al. [116]. The liquid alkoxides contribute energy, is applied to prepare Na3 AlH6 [114]. It can desorb the
to hydrocarbon contamination of the released hydrogen. same amount of hydrogen at 200 ◦ C within only 150 min and
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1131

Table 3
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of sodium alanates

Material Method Temperature (C◦ ) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max Ref.
wt%
of H2

Na3 AlH6 Mechano-chemical Tdes : 200 Pdes : 1 tdes : 150 No data 2.50 [114]
synthesis
Na2 LiAlH6 BM Tabs : 211 Pabs : 45 tabs : 100 No data 2.50 [115]
NaAlH4 –2 mol% BM Tabs and Tdes : 125–165 Pabs and Pdes : 101–202 tabs : 60 5 cyc.: not 3.00 [116]
Ti(Obun )4 –2 mol% tdes : 180 stable
Zr(OPr i )4
NaAlH4 –4 mol% Ti BM Tabs : 120 Pabs : 120 tabs : 60 8 cyc.: not 3.30 [117]
Tdes : 150 Pdes : 1 tdes : 600 stable
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Ti BM Tdes : 25–160 Pabs : 20–120 tabs : 300–720 No data 3.80 [118]
Tabs : 25–193 Pdes : 1 tdes : 40
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Mixing Tabs : 120 Pabs and Pdes : 60–150 tabs : 1020 25 cyc.: not 4.00 [111]
(Ti(Obun )4 Tdes : 180–260 tdes : 120–300 stable [112]
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Mixing Tabs : 135–120 Pabs and Pdes : 150–130 tabs : 330 33 cyc.: not 4.00 [110]
Ti(Obun )4 Tdes : 180–160 tdes : 90 stable
NaAlH4 –2 mol% TiCl3 BM Tdes : 125–100 Pdes : 83–91 tdes : 20 5 cyc.: not stable 4.00 [116]
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Mixing Tdes : 200 Pdes : 1 No data 3 cyc.: stable 4.00 [119]
Zr(OPr)4 3 after second cyc.
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Mixing Tabs : 104 Pabs : 88 tabs : 1020 3 cyc.: stable 4.00 [113]
(Ti(Obun )4 ) after second cyc.
NaAlH4 Mechano-chemical Tabs and Tdes : 80–180 Pabs and Pdes : 76–91 tabs : 120–300 2 cyc.: not 5.00 [120]
synthesis tdes : 300 stable
NaAlH4 –2 mol% Mixing Tdes : 200 Pdes : 1 No data not stable 5.00 [121]
Ti(Obun )4 -C
NaAlH4 –2 mol% TiN BM Tabs : 104–170 Pabs : 115–140 tdes : 30–1200 25 cyc.: stable 5.00 [122]
after 17th cycle

without a catalyst, giving reaction rate about 10 times faster very high temperatures of above 680 ◦ C [114]. Therefore, the
than conventionally produced, non-catalyzed hydrides [114]. commercialization of lithium-based compounds is hindered
by their slow kinetics and high temperature absorption and
3.2. Lithium and potassium alanates desorption.
The reversible hydrogen decomposition of KAlH4 has been
A survey of important studies on lithium-based hydrogen- studied previously [138]. The hydrogen capacity was above
storage compounds are summarized in Table 4. It shows clearly 3.5 wt% under 10 bar of hydrogen in a temperature range of
high capacities of stored hydrogen as weight percent material. 250–330 ◦ C, the reversible reaction smoothly proceeds without
In theory, lithium alanates are very attractive for hydro- any catalyst, which is different from the reactions of NaAlH4
gen storage, because of their high hydrogen content. The to- and LiAlH4 [138].
tal hydrogen content is 10.5 and 11.2 wt% for LiAlH4 and
3.3. Lithium nitrides
Li3 AlH6 , respectively. Unfortunately, LiAlH4 has an extremely
high equilibrium pressure of hydrogen, even at room temper-
Lithium nitride is usually employed as an electrode, or as a
ature. LiAlH4 is in fact an example of an unstable hydride,
starting material for the synthesis of binary or ternary nitrides.
which decomposes easily, but which cannot be re-hydrogenated
Although the temperature required to release the hydrogen
[114]. The desorption of LiAlH4 occurs in two steps:
at usable pressures is too high for hydrogen-storage appli-
3LiAlH4 → Li3 AlH6 + 2Al + 3H2 , (5a) cations it was suggested that the metal–N–H system could
prove to be a promising route for reversible solid hydrogen
Li3 AlH6 → 3LiH + Al + 23 H2 . (5b) storage [45].
The idea of hydrogen storage in lithium compounds goes
The hydrogen released in the two reactions shown, corre- back to 1910, when Dafert and Miklauz [139] reported the
sponds to 5.3 wt% from the decomposition of LiAlH4 and reaction between Li3 N and H2 to Li3 NH4 . In fact Li3 NH4 has
2.65 wt% from the decomposition of Li3 AlH6 at temperatures been proved to be the product of the following reaction, which
between 160 and 200 ◦ C. After completion of the reactions, was proposed by Ruff and Georges [140]:
2.65 wt% of the total hydrogen content in LiAlH4 remains
unreleased in form of LiH which can be desorbed only at Li3 N + 2H2 → LiNH2 + 2LiH. (6)
1132 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Table 4
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of Li-based hydrides

Material Method Temperature (◦ C) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max wt% Ref.
of H2

LaNi3 BH3 Arc melting Tabs : 25 Pabs : 4 tabs : 30 2 cyc.: not stable 0.84 [131]
Li2 NH Mixing Tabs and Tdes : 230–200 Pabs : 7 tabs : 10 15 cyc.: not 3.10 [132]
Pdes : 1 tdes : 300 stable
LiNH2 –LiH–1 mol% BM Tdes : 150–250 Pabs : 30 tabs : 30 3 cyc.: stable 5.00 [133]
TiCl3 Tabs : 180
Li2 O–Li3 N Partial oxidation Tabs : 180 Pabs : 7 tabs : 3 6 cyc.: stable 5.20 [134]
Li2 MgN2 H2 Mixing Tabs and Tdes : 180 Pabs : 90 tabs : 60 No data 5.50 [42]
Pdes : 1 tdes : 60
Li3 N Mixing Tabs : 50 Pabs : 0.5 tabs : 20 No data 6.00 [135]
Tdes : 240–270 Pdes : 1
Li2 NH Mixing Tabs and Tdes : 255–285 Pabs : 10 No data No data 6.50 [45]
Pdes : 1.5
Li3 BN2 H8 BM Tdes : 250–364 Pdes : 1 tdes : 228 No data 10.00 [136]
LiBH4 - 21 MgH2 –2 mol% BM Tabs and Tdes : 315–450 Pabs : 4.5–19 tabs : 240 3 cyc.: not 10.00 [137]
TiCl3 Pdes : 2–3 tabs : 240 stable

Consequently, Li3 N can theoretically store 10.4 wt% hydro- storage capacity of above 10 wt%, however, reversibility is lack-
gen. Li3 N has two plateaus in the P–C isotherm. Desorption ing. Although desorption conditions seem to be advantageous,
isotherms cannot return to the origin. Under P–C isotherm con- irreversibility stands as an important problem for use of these
ditions, about 55% of hydrogen can be desorbed at tempera- materials to be utilized as storage medium. Authors reported
tures above 230 ◦ C. More important for hydrogen storage, is their attempts to rehydride the decomposition product by heat-
that this mixture could decompose to release hydrogen gas upon ing at 8 MPa but without success.
heating, according to the following reaction: A proposed way for lowering the hydrogen desorption
temperatures of Li-based complex hydrides is partial cation
LiNH2 + 2LiH → Li2 NH + LiH + H2 . (7)
substitutions using different valence cations with larger elec-
Hydrogen storage leads to the formation of LiNH2 and LiH. tronegativities. It was predicted that the dehydriding reactions
Theoretically 7 wt% of hydrogen can be reversibly stored in of LiNH2 with partial Mg substitutions are useful as hydrogen-
Li2 NH [45]. storage materials for fuel–cell applications [142]. The starting
A critical potential issue regarding this N-based storage ma- and ending temperatures for the hydrogen desorption reac-
terial is the generation of NH3 , which consumes some H2 and tion from LiNH2 are lowered about 50 K by the partial cation
also poisons the downstream processes. Hu et al. [141] demon- substitution of Li by Mg [143,144].
strated that NH3 produced via the decomposition of LiNH2 is
completely captured by LiH. This ultrafast reaction between 3.4. Lithium boro- and beryllium hydrides
NH3 and LiH inhibits NH3 formation during the hydrogenation
of Li3 N [141]. The importance of boron for hydrogen-storage technologies
Hu et al. [135] studied the temperature-programmed hydro- have been reported [145]. LiBH4 has a gravimetric hydrogen
genation and dehydrogenation of Li3 N and reported a reversible density of 18 wt%. The compound was first synthesized by
hydrogen capacity of 6 wt%, within 240–270 ◦ C temperature Schlesinger and Brown [146] in an organic solvent. Accord-
range. Another study of the same group was to investigate the ing to the work of Stasinevich and Egorenko [147] hydrogen
fast kinetics of LiO2 /Li3 N mixture for hydrogen storage [134]. desorbs from LiBH4 at temperatures greater than 470 ◦ C.
They improved the activation characteristics of Li3 N with the Despite its great storage capacity, all attempts to synthesize
hydrogenation–dehydrogenation pretreatment, partially oxidiz- LiBH4 from the elements at elevated temperatures up to 650 ◦ C
ing the surface layer. They reported a maximum of 5.20 wt% and pressure of 150 bar H2 failed to date [108,148]. Moreover,
hydrogen capacity with very fast kinetics such as 3 min for LiBH4 is an expensive compound [15].
desorption. It was found that the compound releases hydrogen in
A catalytic study of Ichikawa et al. [133] reported a 5.50 wt% different reaction steps and temperature regimes. The low
storage with high reaction rate after three cycles, with the uti- temperature desorption releases only a small amount (0.3 wt%)
lization of TiCl3 catalyst during ball-milling of the LiNH2 and of hydrogen. The high temperature phase releases up to
LiH mixture. Recently Hu et al. [132] reported a reversible hy- 13.5 wt% of hydrogen. A total of 4.5 wt% of the hydrogen
drogen capacity of 3.10 wt%, that increases with the number remains as LiH in the decomposition product.
of cycles, due to improved porous structure of the material. Vajo et al. [137] show that LiBH4 can be reversibly store
Another study on a different class of solid hydride has been 8–10 wt% hydrogen at temperatures of 315–400 ◦ C by addi-
done by Pinkerton et al. [136], reporting an extraordinarily high tion of MgH2 including 2–3 mol% TiCl3 . Formation of MgB2
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1133

stabilizes the dehydrogenated state and destabilizes the LiBH4 The early studies on LaNi5 as hydrogen-storage material has
[137]. However, the kinetics is too slow with the absorption been reported by Aoyagi et al. [67]. The effect of ball-milling
time up to 6000 min hinder practical applications. on hydrogen absorption properties has been investigated, and
Besides alanates, nitrides and borohydrides, lithium–beryllium maximum hydrogen content has been reported as 0.25 wt%. It
hydrides are a new group of metal hydrides for hydrogen stor- is concluded that activation treatment is necessary for LaNi5
age. They show high reversible hydrogen capacity with more to be useful for hydrogen-storage applications. Kaplan et al.
than 8 wt% at 150 ◦ C. The reaction of hydride formation is [181] have investigated the hydrogen absorption in pure LaNi5
fully reversible. Since lithium and beryllium are the lightest both theoretically and experimentally. The group reported that
hydride-forming metals, reversible hydrogen capacity in these LaNi5 has 1.28 wt% hydrogen-storage capacity for 8.3 min hy-
complex compounds is higher than in any other known hy- driding process. They characterized the hydriding process by
drides [149]. On the other hand, the Li3 Be2 H7 is a highly toxic exothermic reaction between LaNi5 and H2 that leads to rapid
material [15]. temperature increase. These supported the results from theoret-
ical calculations.
4. Intermetallic compounds With different stoichiometric addition of other metals, LaNi5
compounds were shown to be enhanced for hydrogen-storage
Research on intermetallic compounds for hydrogen storage by the works of Chen et al. [182], Corre et al. [175], and Lu et al.
was already attempted more than 20 years ago. The discovery [174]. They achieved hydrogen-storage capacities with differ-
of hydrogen absorption by LaNi5 [150] and FeTi [151], opened ent stoichiometric LaNi5 samples such as 1, 1.44 and 1.32 wt%,
new possibilities for industrial developments. However, for on- respectively. Chen et al. [182] applied chemical coating by cop-
board storage, they remained at the stage of prototypes due per and achieved kinetics and cycling behavior during hydro-
their weight penalty and low hydrogen-storage capacity [152]. genation /dehydrogenation process. By CO surface treatment,
The different families of intermetallic compounds classified 1.44 wt% hydrogen capacity is achieved in LaNi5 . Lu et al.
on the basis of their crystal structures, such as AB2 type (Laves [174] processed the LaNi5 using a twin roll process in order to
phase), AB5 type phases and Ti-based body centered cubic, achieve uniform nanocrystalline structure with 1.32 wt% stor-
BCC, alloys are well known as hydrogen-storage materials. age capacity.
Intermetallic compounds are often obtained by combining an Apart from the above reported works, a few important stud-
element forming a stable hydride with an element forming a ies in the literature are worth mentioning. Liu et al. [183], Wang
nonstable hydride. As for the metallic hydrides, the dissociative et al. [184], and Suda et al. [185] reported on the fluorination of
chemisorption of hydrogen is followed by hydrogen diffusion hydriding alloys and its effects on properties. The aim of these
into the interstitial sites. experiments was to form a Ni-rich layer in order to improve
The hydriding properties of these compounds are summa- the initial activation and impurity tolerance. There are also
rized in Tables 5 and 6. For practical applications at ambient theoretical studies found in the literature, on LaNi5 utilization
temperature and pressure, their low energy density per unit for hydrogen storage, tank design and optimization. Kikkinides
weight is an important critical disadvantage. For instance, et al. [186] showed the direct relation between hydrogen-
the hydrogen capacity of the most popular LaNi5 -based al- storage performance and optimization in LaNi5 systems.
loys operating at moderate temperature does not exceed Storage time could be improved by 60% through optimization.
1.4 wt%. The mechanism of hydrogen diffusion in LaNi3 BHx is inves-
Among the AB5 type alloys, due to their low working tem- tigated. The results suggested that hydrogen occupies sites co-
perature and pressure, metal alloys containing high amounts of ordinated by lanthanum and nickel only, while the basal La–B
LaNi5 have been studied as hydrogen-storage materials by var- planes act as barriers to hydrogen diffusion along the hexag-
ious research groups around the world [176–180]. Some of the onal axis. Boron has an adverse effect on the hydrogen sorp-
studies were carried with pure compounds, while others stud- tion properties of intermetallic compounds because it acts as
ied blending of the material with various metals through melt- a barrier for hydrogen diffusion and favors localization of the
ing or mechanical alloying techniques. Important results from hydrogen atoms in the metal matrix away from the boron atom
these studies are represented below. sites [131].
The parent compound LaNi5 absorbs about 1.0 H/LaNi5 The AB2 type compounds are derived from the Laves phases
(1.5 wt%), however, its cost is relatively high and the plateau crystal structures. The potential AB2 types are obtained with
pressure is low. The P–C diagram shows a flat plateau, low Ti and Zr on the A site. The B elements are represented mainly
hysteresis, but unfortunately the hydrogen capacity is de- by different combinations of 3d atoms, V, Cr, Mn and Fe. The
graded after a few cycles. Therefore, these materials are still hydrogen-storage capacity can reach up to 2 wt% in Laves phase
far from meeting the US DOE goal of 6.5 wt% reversible V–7.4%Zr–7.4%Ti–7.4%Ni [166]. The Laves phase series of
hydrogen capacity. Due to their potential for commercial appli- compounds has attracted large attention in the last decade due
cations, researchers have been studying the effects of milling, to their good hydrogen-storage capacity. Most of Laves phases
mechanical alloying or melting with other metals and surface show relatively high capacities faster kinetics, longer life and a
treatment techniques such as carbon monoxide treatment. relatively low cost in comparison to the LaNi5 -related systems
Table 6 presents the major outputs from a number of studies [155]. However, their hydrides are too stable at room temper-
on AB5 type compounds for hydrogen storage. ature [187]. In general the AB2 type compounds seem to be
1134
Table 5
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of intermetallic compounds

Material Method Temperature (◦ C) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max wt% Ref.
of H2

MgS BM Tabs : −196 Pabs : 50 No data No data 0.50 [153]


La0.90 Ce0.05 Nd0.04 Pr0.01 Ni4.63 Sn0.32 Melting Tabs and Tdes : 100, 25 Pabs : 5–10 tabs and tdes : 6.6 No data 0.95 [154]
Pdes : 0.24
Zr(Cr0.8 Mo0.2 )2 Induction melting Tabs : 120 Pabs : 30 No data No data 0.99 [155]
Ml0:85 Ca0:15 Ni5 RF melting Tdes : 25 Pdes : 10 tdes : 60 100 cyc.: stable 1.10 [156]
LaNi4.8 Sn0.2 Arc melting Tdes and Tabs : 80 Pdes : 3–4 No data 1000 cyc.: stable 1.16 [157]
La0.55 Y0.45 Ni5 Induction melting Tdes : −20 Pdes : 3.5 No data 5 cyc.: stable 1.30 [158]
Ti0.9 Zr0.15 Mn1.6 Cr0.2 V0.2 RF melting Tdes : 25 Pdes : 10 tdes : 60 100 cyc.: stable 1.30 [156]
MmNi4.6 Al0.4 Melting Tabs and Tdes : 25 Pdes : 25 tdes : 5 11 cyc.: stable after ninth cycle 1.30 [159]
MmNi4.6 Fe0.4 Melting Tabs and Tdes : 25 Pabs : 35 tabs : 15 11 cyc.: stable after ninth cycle 1.44 [159]
Ml0.75 Ca0.25 Ni5 RF levitation melting Tabs : 20 Pabs : 100 No data No data 1.45 [160]
Pdes : 6.8
80 wt% TiCr1.1 V0.9 –20 wt% Melting + BM Tabs and Tdes : 30 Pabs : 17 No data No data 1.50 [161]
LaNi5 Pdes : 0.5
Ti0.97 Zr0.03 Cr1.6 Mn0.4 RF levitation melting Tabs : 20 Pabs : 100 No data No data 1.55 [160]
Pdes : 81
La0.7 Mg0.3 Ni2.65 Mn0.1 Co0.90 Melting Tabs and Tdes : 30 Pabs : 5 No data No data 1.56 [162]
Pdes : 0.33
Zr0.75 Ti0.25 Cr1.5 Ni0.5 Arc melting Tabs : 40 Pabs : 47 No data No data 1.75 [163]
Ti1.1 CrMn Arc melting Tabs and Tdes : 23 Pabs : 33 tabs : 1 1000 cyc.: stable 1.80 [164]
Pdes : 1 tdes : 5
FeTi BM Tabs : 25 Pabs : 100 No data No data 1.92 [165]
V–7.4%Zr–7.4%Ti–7.4%Ni Arc melting Tabs : 40 Pabs : 10 No data 10 cyc.: not stable 2.00 [166]
Pdes : 1
V0.375 Ti0.25 Cr0.30 Mn0.075 Arc melting Tabs and Tdes : 30 Pabs : 50 No data No data 2.20 [167]
Pdes : 0.2
Ti45 Zr38 Ni17 BM Tabs : 300 Pabs : 80 tabs : 1200 No data 2.23 [168]
Quasicrystal powders Tdes : 427
Ti–V–Cr Arc melting Tabs and Tdes : 40 Pabs : 100 No data No data 2.80 [169]
Ti–10Cr–18Mn–27V–5Fe Magnetic levitation melting Tabs : 60 Pabs : 30 tabs : 8.3 No data 3.01 [170]
Pdes : 1
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Ti–10Cr–18Mn–32V Magnetic levitation melting Tabs : 60 Pabs : 30 tabs : 8.3 No data 3.36 [170]
Pdes : 1
TiCr1.1 V0.9 Melting + BM Tabs and Tdes : 30 Pabs : 17 No data No data 3.50 [161]
Pdes : 0.5
Ti43.5 V49 Fe7.5 Arc melting Tabs : −20 Pabs : 100 tabs : 20 50 cyc.:stable 3.90 [171]
Tdes : 300 Pdes : 10
Ti–V–Cr–Mn Magnetic levitation melting Tdes : 247–472 Pabs : 30 No data No data 3.98 [172]
Pdes : 0.03
La1.8 Ca0.2 Mg14 N13 BM Tabs and Tdes : 27–327 Pabs : 40 tabs : 15 6 cyc.: not stable 5.00 [173]
Pdes : 1 tdes : 10
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1135

Table 6
Hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of LaNi5 compounds

Material Method Temperature (◦ C) Pressure (bar) Kinetics (min) Cycling stability Max wt% Ref.
of H2

LaNi5 BM Tabs : 20 Pabs : 20 tabs : 1.6 8 cyc.: not stable 0.25 [67]
La0.59 Ce0.29 Pr0.03 Ni4 Co0.45 Mn0.45 Al0.3 Twin-rolling Tabs : 60 Pabs : 10 No data No data 1.27 [174]
Pdes : 0.6
La0.9 Ce0.1 Ni5 CO surface Tabs : 0–100 Pabs : 50 tdes : 1.8 20 cyc.: stable 1.40 [175]
treatment after fifth cycle
Tdes : 25
LaNi5 CO surface Tabs : 0–100 Pabs : 50 tdes : 13.6 20 cyc.: stable 1.44 [175]
treatment after fifth cycle
Tdes : 25

more sensitive to gaseous impurities than the AB5 type com- mance, hydrogen absorption–desorption plateau pressure, hy-
pounds. Thus, a small amount of oxygen can be a poison for drogen desorption capacity and reduce the hysteresis of hydro-
the AB2 s, while, for the AB5 s, it acts as a reactant, reducing the gen absorption–desorption plateau, and the cost of alloy [170].
storage capacity slightly. CO is a poison for both types of com- The quasicrystals have a new type of translational long-range
pounds, although capacity recovery is possible by recycling in order, display non-crystallographic rotational symmetry. They
pure hydrogen [188]. contain high amounts of interstitial sites. The quasicrystalline
Hydrogen absorption of FeTi powders has previously been Ti45 Zr 38 Ni17 has 2.23 wt% storage capacity [168]. The sorp-
extensively studied. FeTi is a well-known hydrogen-storage tion of hydrogen between the layers of the multilayered wall
compound with a total hydrogen capacity of around 1.90 wt% of nanotubular TiO2 was studied in the temperature range of
with inexpensive elements. Hydrogen capacity of FeTi can be 195–200 ◦ C and at pressures of up to 6 bars. Hydrogen can in-
accomplished to 1.90 wt% by the catalytic effect of 1 wt% Pd tercalate between layers in the walls of TiO2 nanotube [189].
addition [165]. However, the activation process of FeTi is trou-
blesome due to the formation of titanium oxide layer. Both 5. Conclusion
high-pressure and high temperature are required to achieve a
reproducible absorption/desorption of the maximum amount of Hydrogen storage is a key issue in the success and realiza-
hydrogen in the compound [151,187]. tion of hydrogen technology and economy. According to US
New BCC solid solution alloys have been reported to ab- DOE, the hydrogen-storage capacity target for commercializa-
sorb more hydrogen than the conventional intermetallic com- tion is 6.5 wt% at the decomposition temperature between 60
pounds. In recent years, study of Ti-based BCC phase alloys and 120 ◦ C with high cycle life. Although pure water contains
has been studied in several laboratories because of their remark- 11.1 wt% of hydrogen, its decomposition requires much ther-
able hydrogen capacities. However, the high cost is one of the mal, electric, or chemical energy [15].
critical drawbacks limiting their successful practical applica- Since the conventional hydrogen fuel storage methods of
tions. Ti–10Cr–18Mn–27V–5Fe and Ti–10Cr–18Mn–32V has pressurized H2 gas and cryogenic liquid H2 pose safety and per-
hydrogen-storage capacities of 3.01 and 3.36 wt%, respectively meation problems along with high cost, they do not meet future
[170]. Increasing the V content is effective in accelerating hy- on-board applications goals set for hydrogen economy. Solid
drogen absorption, enhancing the hydrogen absorption capacity state hydrogen fuel storage either absorption in the interstices
and flattening the hydrogen desorption plateau, while decreas- of metals and metallic alloys or adsorption on high surface area
ing hydrogen desorption plateau pressure. The maximum and materials such as activated carbons gain the attention for pos-
effective hydrogen-storage capacities of Ti–V–Cr–Mn alloys sible future hydrogen applications. The present article reviews
are 3.98 and 2.51 wt%, respectively [172]. the hydrogen-storage materials for transport applications which
It is well known that vanadium is expensive; therefore, de- require research into further aspects of tank technology, heat
creasing of the vanadium content is another goal of the investi- management and solid fuel recycling. The work is carried out
gations. In Ti–V–Cr–Mn compounds, increasing the Cr content in an attempt to facilitate prospectus material choice for further
and the addition of Mn is necessary to increase the effective hy- tank design aiming at on-board vehicle applications.
drogen capacity by increasing the plateau pressure, but also to Hydrogen can be stored in metal hydrides under moderate
decrease costs by decreasing the vanadium content. The BCC temperature and pressure. Metal hydrides are the promising
phase solid solution of V0.375 Ti0.25 Cr 0.30 Mn0.075 exhibited an candidates due to their safety advantage with high volume-
effective hydrogen capacity of 2.20 wt% [167]. efficient storage capacity for on-board applications. Intensive
In order to improve the hydrogen-storage properties and re- research has been recently conducted on the metal hydrides for
duce the cost of Ti–V-based BCC alloys, the effect of Fe substi- improving adsorption/desorption properties based on hydrogen-
tution in Ti–10Cr–18Mn–32V alloy is also investigated [170]. storage capacity, kinetics, thermal properties, toxicity, cycling
It was reported that Fe addition increases the activation perfor- behavior and cost.
1136 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

Group of Mg-based hydrides is a promising candidate for [5] DOE: US Department of Energy. Website: http://www.doe.gov.
competitive mobile hydride storage with the reversible hydro- [6] Schulz R, Huot J, Liang G, Boily S, Lalande G, Denis MC. et al.
Recent development in the applications of nanocrystalline materials to
gen capacity of up to 7.6 wt%. However, slow kinetics and high
hydrogen technologies. Mater Sci Eng A 1999;267:240.
hydrogen desorption temperatures up to about 300 ◦ C reduce [7] Darkrim FL, Malbrunot P, Tartaglia GP. Review of hydrogen storage
the efficiency and applicability in vehicles. Although much ef- by adsorption in carbon nanotubes. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2002;27:
fort has been devoted to those materials in order to decrease 193–202.
their decomposition temperature, enhance the kinetics and cy- [8] Hirscher M, Becher M, Haluska M, Zeppelin F, Chen X, Dettlaff-
Weglikowska U. et al. Are carbon nanostructures an efficient hydrogen
cle life by using appropriate catalysts and production method
storage medium?. J Alloys Compds 2003;356–357:433–7.
of ball-milling, further research is needed. [9] Hirscher M, Becher M. Hydrogen storage in carbon nanotubes.
The complex hydrides released hydrogen by the step reac- J Nanosci Nanotech 2003;3(1–2):3–17.
tions unlike the metallic hydrides. Although the storage ca- [10] David E. An overview of advanced materials for hydrogen storage.
pacities of complex hydrides are theoretically high, there is a J Mater Process Technol 2005;162–163:169–77.
[11] Zhou L. Progress and problems in hydrogen storage methods. Renew
big difference between the theoretical and the presently practi- Sustain Energy Rev 2005;9:395–408.
cal attainable hydrogen capacities. Repeated hydrogenation cy- [12] Schlapbach L, Züttel A. Hydrogen-storage materials for mobile
cles need to be applied for the potential applications to ensure applications. Nature 2001;414:353–8.
the reversibility of these materials. Moreover, the slow kinetics [13] Zuttel A. Materials for hydrogen storage. Mater Today 2003; 24–33.
[14] Zhou L, Zhou Y, Sun Y. Studies on the mechanism and capacity
problem is a significant obstacle for practical on-board applica-
of hydrogen uptake by physisorption-based materials. Int J Hydrogen
tions. The intermetallic compounds do not satisfy the require- Energy 2006;31(2):259–64.
ments for mobile storage for the reason that their low storage [15] Grochala W, Edwards PP. Thermal decomposition of the non-interstitial
capacities up to 2 wt% for available use and along with high hydrides for the storage and production of hydrogen. Chem Rev
costs. An alternative application may be seen in effective use 2004;104:1283–315.
[16] Eberle U, Arnold G, Helmholt RV. Hydrogen storage in
as thermodynamic devices [188]. metal—hydrogen systems and their derivatives. J Power Sour
There is no perfect choice of hydrogen store material to 2006;154(2):456–60.
meet the set US DOE goals for transport applications. Although [17] Latroche M. Structural and thermodynamic properties of metallic
some results are encouraging, such as improved kinetics and hydrides used for energy storage. J Phys Chem Solids 2004;65:517–22.
lower decomposition temperatures for metal hydrides, further [18] HyTRAIN: Hydrogen Storage Research Training Network, EC-MRTN-
CT-2004-512443. Website: http://www.imr.salford.ac.uk.
research is needed to develop materials satisfying the needs for [19] Zaluska A, Zaluski L, Ström-Olsen JO. Structure, catalysis and atomic
technical applications. In the light of the achievements, there is reactions on the nano-scale: a systematic approach to metal hydrides
high potential in developing better hydride materials with high for hydrogen storage. Appl Phys A 2001;72:157–65.
reversible hydrogen capacity at ambient temperatures. In ad- [20] Imamura H, Masanari K, Kusuhara M, Katsumoto H, Sumi T, Sakata Y.
High hydrogen storage capacity of nanosized magnesium synthesized
dition, technological improvements in vehicle design and sys-
by high energy ball-milling. J Alloys Compds 2005;386:211–6.
tem integration along with cost efficiency will determine the [21] Zaluski L, Zaluska A, Ström-Olsen JO. Nanocrystalline metal hydrides.
on-board applicability of the selected material [2]. The success J Alloys Compds 1997;253–254:70–9.
and realization of hydrogen economy using hydrogen stored [22] Zhu M, Wang H, Ouyang LZ, Zeng MQ. Composite structure and
solid fuel technology will be dependent on the meeting of hydrogen storage properties in Mg-based alloys. Int J Hydrogen Energy
2006;31(2):251–57.
above goals. [23] Wiswall R. Topics in applied physics. Hydrogen Met II 1978;29:209.
[24] Fukai Y. The metal–hydrogen system, basic bulk properties. Springer
Acknowledgments series in materials science, 1993.
[25] Zaluska A, Zaluski L, Ström-Olsen JO. Nanocrystalline magnesium for
hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 1999;288:217–25.
Support for this work was provided by the EU FP6 RTN [26] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Effect of Nb2 O5 content on
Project HyTRAIN; Hydrogen Storage Research Training Net- hydrogen reaction kinetics of Mg. J Alloys Compds 2004;364:242–6.
work. Figs. 1–5 reprinted from indicated references with kind [27] Bogdanovic B, Bohmhamme K, Christ B, Reiser A, Schlichte K, Vehlen
permission of the Elsevier and International Journal of Hydro- R. et al. Thermodynamic investigation of the magnesium–hydrogen
gen Energy are acknowledged. system. J Alloys Compds 1999;282:84–92.
[28] Jung KS, Lee EY, Lee KS. Catalytic effects of metal oxide on
hydrogen absorption of magnesium metal hydride. J Alloys Compds
References 2005;421(1–2):179–84.
[29] Zhu M, Zhu WH, Chung CY, Chea ZX, Lia ZX. Microstructure and
[1] Ogden JM. Developing an infrastructure for hydrogen vehicles: a hydrogen absorption properties of nano-phase composite prepared by
Southern California case study. Int J Hydrogen Energy 1999;24(8): mechanical alloying of MmNi (CoAlMn) and Mg. J Alloys Compds
709–30. 1999;293–295:531–5.
[2] Dogan B. Hydrogen storage tank systems and materials selection [30] Guoxian L, Erde W, Shoushi F. Hydrogen absorption and desorption
for transport applications. ASME Conference PVP2006- ICPVT-11, characteristics of mechanically milled Mg–35 wt% FeTi1.2 powders.
Vancouver, Canada, July 23–27, 2006, Conference Proceedings CD, J Alloys Compds 1995;223:111–4.
Track: Materials and Fabrication, Session: Materials for Hydrogen [31] Bouaricha S, Dodelet JP, Guay D, Huot J, Boily S, Schulz R. Hydriding
Service, Paper No. 93868, pp. 1–8. behavior of Mg–Al and leached Mg–Al compounds prepared by high-
[3] Weast RC, Astle MJ, Beyer WH. CRC handbook of chemistry and energy ball-milling. J Alloys Compds 2000;297:282–93.
physics. 64th ed., Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 1983. [32] Bououdina M, Guo ZX. Comparative study of mechanical alloying
[4] Trudeau ML. Advanced materials for energy storage. MRS Bull of (Mg:Al) and (Mg:Al:Ni) mixtures for hydrogen storage. J Alloys
1999;24:23–6. Compds 2002;336:222–31.
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1137

[33] Wang P, Wang A, Zhang H, Ding B, Hu Z. Hydriding properties of [55] Dehouche Z, Klassen T, Oelerich W, Goyette J, Bose TK, Schulz R.
a mechanically milled Mg–50 wt% ZrFe1.4 Cr 0.6 composite. J Alloys Cycling and thermal stability of nanostructured MgH2 –Cr 2 O3
Compds 2000;297:240–5. composite for hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 2002;347:319–23.
[34] Song MY, Bobet J-L, Darriet B. Improvement in hydrogen sorption [56] Hanada N, Ichikawa T, Fuji H. Catalytic effect of nanoparticle 3d-
properties of Mg by reactive mechanical grinding with Cr 2 O3 , Al2 O3 transition metals on hydrogen storage properties in magnesium hydride
and CeO2 . J Alloys Compds 2002;340:256–62. MgH2 prepared by mechanical milling. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:
[35] Tran NE, Lambrakos SG, Imam MA. Analyses of hydrogen sorption 7188–94.
kinetics and thermodynamics of magnesium–misch metal alloys. [57] Oelerich W, Klassen T, Bormann T. Metal oxides as catalysts for
J Alloys Compds 2006;407:240–8. improved hydrogen sorption in nanocrystalline Mg-based materials.
[36] Wang P, Zhang HF, Ding BZ, Hu ZQ. Direct hydrogenation of Mg J Alloys Compds 2001;315:237–42.
and decomposition behavior of the hydride formed. J Alloys Compds [58] Huot J, Liang G, Boily S, Neste AV, Schulz R. Structural study and
2000;313:209–13. hydrogen sorption kinetics of ball-milled magnesium hydride. J Alloys
[37] Gross KJ, Spatz P, Züttel A, Schlapbach L. Mechanically milled Compds 1999;293–295:495–500.
Mg composites for hydrogen storage: the transition to a steady state [59] Leng HY, Ichikawa T, Isobe S, Hino S, Hanada N, Fujii H. Desorption
composition. J Alloys Compds 1996;240:206–13. behaviours from metal–N–H systems synthesized by ball milling.
[38] Gross KJ, Chartouni D, Leroy E, Züttel A, Schlapbach L. Mechanically J Alloys Compds 2005;404–406:443–7.
milled Mg composites for hydrogen storage: the relationship between [60] Gennari FC, Castra FJ, Urretavizcaya G, Meyer G. Catalytic effect of
morphology and kinetics. J Alloys Compds 1998;269:259–70. Ge on hydrogen desorption from MgH2 . J Alloys Compds 2002;334:
[39] Li Q, Chou K-C, Xu K-D, Jiang L-J, Lin Q, Lin G-W, Lu X-G, 277–84.
Zhang J-Y. Hydrogen absorption and desorption characteristics in the [61] Reule H, Hirscher M, Weißhardt A, Krönmuller H. Hydrogen desorption
La0.5 Ni1.5 Mg17 prepared by hydriding combustion synthesis. Int J properties of mechanically alloyed MgH2 composite materials. J Alloys
Hydrogen Energy 2006;31(4):497–503. Compds 2000;305:246–52.
[40] Liang G, Boily S, Huot J, Neste AV, Schulz R. Hydrogen absorption [62] Holtz RL. Basic user’s guide for NRL 6323 hydrogen storage system,
properties of a mechanically milled Mg–50 wt.% LaNi5 composite. 1996.
J Alloys Compds 1998;268(1–2):302–7. [63] Friedlmeier G, Groll M. Experimental analysis and modeling of
[41] Chen Y, Wu C-Z, Wang P, Cheng H-M. Structure and hydrogen storage the hydriding kinetics of Ni-doped and pure Mg. J Alloys Compds
property of ball-milled LiNH2 /MgH2 mixture. Int J Hydrogen Energy 1997;253–254:550–5.
2006, in press. [64] Andreasen A, Vegge T, Pedersen AS. Compensation effect in the
[42] Xiong Z, Wu G, Hu J, Chen P. Ternary imides for hydrogen storage. hydrogenation/dehydrogenation kinetics of metal hydrides. J Phys Chem
Adv Mater 2004;16(17):1522–5. B 2005;109:3340–4.
[43] Reiser A, Bogdanovic B, Schlichte K. The application of Mg-based [65] Chen J, Dou SX, Liu HK. Crystalline Mg2 Ni obtained by mechanical
metal-hydrides as heat energy storage systems. Int J Hydrogen Energy alloying. J Alloys Compds 1996;244:184–9.
2000;25:425–30. [66] Zaluska A, Zaluski L, Strom-Olsen JO. Synergy of hydrogen sorption
[44] Luo W. (LiNH2 –MgH2 ): a viable hydrogen storage system. J Alloys in ball-milled hydrides of Mg and Mg2 Ni. J Alloys Compds 1999;289:
Compds 2004;381:284–7. 197–206.
[45] Chen P, Xiong Z, Luo J, Lin J, Tan KL. Interaction of hydrogen with [67] Aoyagi H, Aoki K, Masumoto T. Effect of ball milling on hydrogen
metal nitrides and imides. Nature 2002;420:302–4. absorption properties of FeTi, Mg2 Ni and LaNi5 . J Alloys Compds
[46] Wang P, Wang AM, Zhang HF, Ding BZ, Hu ZQ. Hydrogenation 1995;231:804–9.
characteristics of Mg–TiO (rutile) composite. J Alloys Compds [68] Wagemans RWP, Lenth JHV, Jongh PE de, Dillen AJV, Jong KP de.
2000;313:218–23. Hydrogen storage in magnesium clusters: quantum chemical study.
[47] Davidson DJ, Raman SS Sai, Srivastava ON. Investigation on the J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:16675–80.
synthesis, characterization and hydrogenation behaviour of new Mg- [69] Hong T-W. Dehydrogenation properties of nano-amorphous Mg2 NiHx
based composite materials Mg–x wt% MmNiFe prepared through by hydrogen induced mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds
mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds 1999;292:194–201. 2000;312:60–7.
[48] Dehouche Z, Djaozandry R, Huot J, Boily S, Goyette J, Bose [70] Tessier P, Enoki H, Bououdina M, Akiba E. Ball-milling of Mg2 Ni
TK. et al. Influence of cycling on the thermodynamic and structure under hydrogen. J Alloys Compds 1998;268:285–9.
properties of nanocrystalline magnesium based hydride. J Alloys [71] Huot J, Akiba E, Takada T. Mechanical alloying of Mg–Ni compounds
Compds 2000;305:264–71. under hydrogen and inert atmosphere. J Alloys Compds 1995;231:
[49] Bogdanovic B, Reiser A, Schlichte K, Spliethoff B, Tesche B. 815–9.
Thermodynamics and dynamics of the Mg–Fe–H system and its [72] Chen Y, Williams JS. Formation of metal hydrides by mechanical
potential for thermochemical thermal energy storage. J Alloys Compds alloying. J Alloys Compds 1995;217:181–4.
2002;345:77–89. [73] Orimo S-I, Fujii H. Effects of nanometer-scale structure on hydriding
[50] Liang G, Huot J, Boily S, Nestea AV, Schulz R. Catalytic effect of properties of Mg–Ni alloys: a review. Intermetallics 1998;6:185–92.
transition metals on hydrogen sorption in nanocrystalline ball milled [74] Abdellaoui M, Cracco D, Percheron-Guegan A. Structural
MgH2 –Tm (Tm5 Ti, V, Mn, Fe and Ni) systems. J Alloys Compds characterization and reversible hydrogen absorption properties of
1999;292(1–2):247–52. Mg2 Ni rich nanocomposite materials synthesized by mechanical
[51] Fabing L, Lijun J, Jun D, Shumao W, Xiaopeng L, Feng Z. Synthesis alloying. J Alloys Compds 1998;268:233–40.
and hydrogenation properties of Mg–La–Ni–H system by reactive [75] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Kinetic investigation of
mechanical alloying. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006, in press. the effect of milling time on the hydrogen sorption reaction of
[52] Song MY, Kwon IH, Kwon SN, Park CG, Park HR, Bae J-S. Preparation magnesium catalyzed with different Nb2 O5 contents. J Alloys Compds
of hydrogen-storage alloy Mg–10 wt% Fe2 O3 under various milling 2006;407:249–55.
conditions. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31:43–7. [76] Holtz RL, Imam MA. Hydrogen storage characteristics of ball-
[53] Raman SS Sai, Srivastava ON. Hydrogenation behaviour of the new milled magnesium–nickel and magnesium–iron alloys. J Mater Sci
composite storage material Mg–x wt% CFMmNi5 . J Alloys Compds 1999;34:2655–63.
1996;241:167–74. [77] Higuchi K, Kajioka H, Toiyama K, Fujii H, Orimo S, Kikuchic Y.
[54] Liang G, Huot J, Boily S, Neste AV, Schulz R. Hydrogen storage In situ study of hydriding–dehydriding properties in some Pd/Mg thin
properties of the mechanically milled MgH2 –V nanocomposite. J Alloys films with different degree of Mg crystallization. J Alloys Compds
Compds 1999;291:295–9. 1999;293–295:484–9.
1138 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

[78] Akyildiz H, Özenbaş M, Öztürk T. Hydrogen absorption in magnesium [102] Bloch J, Mintz MH. Kinetics and mechanisms of metal hydride
based crystalline thin films. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31(10): formation—a review. J Alloys Compds 1997;253–254:529–41.
1379–83. [103] Iwakura C, Nohara S, Zhang SG, Inoue H. Hydriding and dehydriding
[79] Higuchi K, Yamamoto K, Kajioka H, Toiyama K, Honda M, Orimo S. characteristics of an amorphous Mg2 Ni–Ni composite. J Alloys Compds
et al. Remarkable hydrogen storage properties in three-layered 1999;285:246–9.
Pd/Mg/Pd thin films. J Alloys Compds 2002;330–332:526–30. [104] Liang G, Huot J, Boily S, Neste AV, Schulz R. Hydrogen storage
[80] Imamura H, Sakasai N, Kajii Yi. Hydrogen absorption of Mg- properties of nanocrystalline Mg1.9 Ti0.1 Ni made by mechanical
based composites prepared by mechanical milling: factors affecting its alloying. J Alloys Compds 1999;282:286–90.
characteristics. J Alloys Compds 1996;232:218–23. [105] Zaluska A, Zaluski L. New catalytic complexes for metal hydride
[81] Shang CX, Guo ZX. Effect of carbon on hydrogen desorption and systems. J Alloys Compds 2005;404–406:706–11.
absorption of mechanically milled MgH2 . J Power Sources 2004;129: [106] Huot J, Swainson IP, Shulz R. Neutron diffraction study of lixiviated
73–80. nanocrystalline Mg–Li compound. J Alloys Compds 1999;292:292–5.
[82] Vija R, Sundaresan R, Maiya MP, Murthy SS. Comparative evaluation of [107] Liang G. Synthesis and hydrogen storage properties of Mg-based alloys.
Mg–Ni hydrogen absorbing materials prepared by mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds 2004;370:123–8.
Int J Hydrogen Energy 2005;30:501–8. [108] Züttel A, Wenger P, Rentsch S, Sudan P, Mauron Ph, Emmenegger Ch.
[83] Han SS, Goo NH, Lee KS. Effects of sintering on composite metal LiBH4 a new hydrogen storage material. J Power Sources 2003;118:
hydride alloy of Mg2 Ni and TiNi synthesized by mechanical alloying. 1–7.
J Alloys Compds 2003;360(1–2):243–9. [109] Kyoi D, Sato T, Rönnebro E, Kitamura N, Ueda A, Ito M. et al.
[84] Orimo S, Fujii H. Materials science of Mg–Ni-based new hydrides. A new ternary magnesium–titanium hydride Mg7 TiHx with hydrogen
Appl Phys A 2001;72:167–86. desorption properties better than both binary magnesium and titanium
[85] Sato T, Blomqvist H, Noreus D. Attempts to improve Mg2 Ni hydrogen hydrides. J Alloys Compds 2004;372:213–7.
storage by aluminium addition. J Alloys Compds 2003;356–357:494–6. [110] Bogdanovic B, Schwickardi M. Ti-doped NaAlH4 as a hydrogen-
[86] Zaluski L, Zaluska A, Ström-Olsen JO. Hydrogen absorption in storage material—preparation by Ti-catalyzed hydrogenation of
nanocrystalline Mg2 Ni formed by mechanical alloying. J Alloys aluminum powder in conjunction with sodium hydride. Appl Phys A
Compds 1995;217:245–9. 2001;72:221–3.
[87] Singh AK, Singh AK, Srivastava ON. On the synthesis of the Mg2 Ni [111] Bogdanovic B, Scwickardi M. Ti-doped alkali metal aluminium
alloy by mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds 1995;227:63–8. hydrides as potential novel reversible hydrogen storage materials.
[88] Abdellaoui M, Mokbli S, Cuevas F, Latroche M, Guegan A Percheron, J Alloys Compds 1997;253–254:1–9.
Zarrouk H. Structural, solid–gas and electrochemical characterization of [112] Bogdanovic B, Brand RA, Marjanovic A, Schwickardi M, Tölle J.
Mg2 Ni-rich and Mgx Ni100−x amorphous-rich nanomaterials obtained Metal-doped sodium aluminium hydrides as potential new hydrogen
by mechanical alloying. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31(2):247–50. storage materials. J Alloys Compds 2000;302:36–58.
[89] Liang G, Boily S, Huot J, Neste AV, Schulz R. Mechanical alloying [113] Jensen CM, Gross KJ. Development of catalytically enhanced sodium
and hydrogen absorption properties of the Mg–Ni system. J Alloys aluminum hydride as a hydrogen-storage material. Appl Phys A
Compds 1998;267:302–6. 2001;72:213–9.
[90] Terzieva M, Khrussanova M, Peshev P, Radev D. Hydriding and [114] Zaluski L, Zaluska A, Ström-Olsen JO. Hydrogenation properties
dehydriding characteristics of mixtures with a high magnesium content of complex alkali metal hydrides fabricated by mechano-chemical
obtained by sintering and mechanical alloying. Int J Hydrogen Energy synthesis. J Alloys Compds 1999;290:71–8.
1995;20(1):53–8. [115] Genma R, Okada N, Sobue T, Uchida H-H. Mechanically milled
[91] Terzieva M, Khrussanova M, Peshev P. Hydriding and dehydriding alanates as hydrogen storage materials. Int J Hydrogen Energy
characteristics of Mg–LaNi5 composite materials prepared by 2006;31(2):309–11.
mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds 1998;267:235–9. [116] Sandrock G, Gross KJ, Thomas G, Jensen C, Meeker D, Takara S.
[92] Haussermann U, Blomqvist H, Noreus D. Bonding and stability of the Engineering considerations in the use of catalyzed sodium alanates for
hydrogen storage material Mg2 NiH4 . Inorg Chem 2002;41:3684–92. hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 2002;330–332:696–701.
[93] Zaluski L, Zaluska A, Tessier P, Ström-Olsen JO, Schulz R. Catalytic [117] Wang P, Jensen CM. Method for preparing Ti-doped NaAlH4 using Ti
effect of Pd on hydrogen absorption in mechanically alloyed Mg2 Ni, powder: observation of an unusual reversible dehydrogenation behavior.
LaNi5 and FeTi. J Alloys Compds 1995;217:295–300. J Alloys Compds 2004;379:99–102.
[94] Aymard L, Ichitsubo M, Uchida K, Sekreta E, Ikazaki F. Preparation [118] Sun D, Srinivasan SS, Kiyobayashi T, Kuriyama N, Jensen CM.
of Mg2 Ni base alloy by the combination of mechanical alloying and Rehydrogenation of dehydrogenated NaAlH4 at low temperature and
heat treatment at low temperature. J Alloys Compds 1997;259:L5–8. pressure. J Phys Chem B 2003;107:10176–9.
[95] Tran NE, Imam MA, Feng CR. Evaluation of hydrogen storage [119] Zidan RA, Takara S, Hee AG, Jensen CM. Hydrogen cycling behavior
characteristics of magnesium–misch metal alloys. J Alloys Compds of zirconium and titanium–zirconium-doped sodium aluminum hydride.
2003;359:225–9. J Alloys Compds 1999;285:119–22.
[96] Friedlmeier G, Manthey A, Wanner M, Grollm M. Cyclic stability [120] Zaluska A, Zaluski L, Ström-Olsen JO. Sodium alanates for reversible
of various application-relevant metal hydrides. J Alloys Compds hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 2000;298:125–34.
1995;231(1–2):880–7. [121] Jensen CM, Zidan R, Mariels N, Hee A, Hagena C. Advanced titanium
[97] Dehouche Z, Djaozandry R, Goyette J, Bose TK. Thermal cyclic charge doping of sodium aluminum hydride segue to a practical hydrogen
and discharge stability of nanocrystalline Mg2 Ni alloy. J Alloys Compds storage material. Int J Hydrogen Energy 1999;24:461–5.
1999;288:312–8. [122] Bogdanovic B, Felderhoff M, Kaskel S, Pommerin A, Sclichte K,
[98] Pedersen AS, Larsen B. The storage of industrially pure hydrogen in Schüth F. Improved hydrogen storage properties of Ti-doped sodium
magnesium. Int J Hydrogen Energy 1993;18:279–300. alanate using titanium nanoparticles as doping agents. Adv Mater
[99] Bouaricha S, Huot J, Guay D, Schulz R. Reactivity during cycling of 2003;15(12):1012–5.
nanocrystalline Mg-based hydrogen storage compounds. Int J Hydrogen [123] Sandrock G, Gross KJ, Thomas G. Effect of Ti-catalyst content on the
Energy 2002;27(9):909–13. reversible hydrogen storage properties of the sodium alanates. J Alloys
[100] Dehouche Z, Goyette J, Bose TK, Schulz R. Moisture effect on Compd: s 2002;339:299–308.
hydrogen storage properties of nanostructured MgH2 –V–Ti composite. [124] Sun D, Kiyobayashi T, Takeshita HT, Kuriyama N, Jensen CM. X-ray
Int J Hydrogen Energy 2003;28(9):983–8. diffraction studies of titanium and zirconium doped NaAlH4 elucidation
[101] Baer R, Zeiri Y, Kosloff R. Hydrogen transport in nickel (1 1 1). Phys of doping induced structural changes and their relationship to enhanced
Rev B 1997;55(16):952–74. hydrogen storage properties. J Alloys Compds 2002;337:L8–L11.
B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140 1139

[125] Gross KJ, Guthrie S, Takara S, Thomas G. In situ X-ray diffraction [153] Goo NH, Hirscher M. Synthesis of the nanocrystalline MgS its
study of the decomposition of NaAlH4 . J Alloys Compds 2000;297: interaction with hydrogen. J Alloys Compds 2005;404–406:503–6.
270–81. [154] Iosub V, Latroche M, Joubert J-M, Percheron-Guégan A. Optimisation
[126] Chaudhuri S, Muckerman JT. First principles study of Ti-catalyzed of MmNi5−x Snx (Mm = La, Ce, Nd and Pr, 0.27 < x < 0.5)
hydrogen chemisorption on an Al surface: a critical first step compositions as hydrogen storage materials. Int J Hydrogen Energy
for reversible hydrogen storage in NaAlH4 . J Phys Chem B 2006;31:101–8.
2005;109(15):6952–7. [155] Bououdina M, Soubeyroux JL, Rango P de, Fruchart D. Phase
[127] Fichtner M, Fuhr O, Kircher O, Rothe J. Small Ti clusters for catalysis stability and neutron diffraction studies of the Laves phase compounds
of hydrogen exchange in NaAlH4 . Nanotechnology 2003;14:778–85. Zr(Cr 1−x Mox )2 with 0.0 < x < 0.5 and their hydrides. Int J Hydrogen
[128] Thomas GJ, Gross KJ, Yang NYC, Jensen C. Microstructural character- Energy 2000;25:1059–68.
ization of catalyzed NaAlH4 . J Alloys Compds 2002;330–332:702–7. [156] Chen Y, Sequeira CAC, Chen C, Wang X, Wang Q. Metal hydride beds
[129] Huot J, Boily S, Güther V, Schulz R. Synthesis of Na3 AlH6 and and hydrogen supply tanks as minitype PEMFC hydrogen sources. Int
Na2 LiAlH6 by mechanical alloying. J Alloys Compds 1999;383:304–6. J Hydrogen Energy 2003;28:329–33.
[130] Kircher O, Fichtner M. Kinetic studies of the decomposition of [157] Dehouche Z, Grimard N, Laurencelle F, Goyette J, Bose TK. Hydride
NaAlH4 doped with a Ti-based catalyst. J Alloys Compds 2005; alloys properties investigations for hydrogen sorption compressor.
404–406:339–42. J Alloys Compds 2005;399:224–36.
[131] Filinchuk YE, Yvon K. Boron-induced hydrogen localization in the [158] Challet S, Latroche M, Percheron-Guegan A, Heurtaux F.
novel metal hydride LaNi3 BHx (x = 2.5.3.0). Inorg Chem 2005;44: Crystallographic and thermodynamic study of La0.55 Y0.45 Ni5 .H2 ,
4398–406. a candidate system for hydrogen buffer tanks. J Alloys Compds
[132] Hu YH, Ruckenstein E. Hydrogen storage of Li2 NH prepared by 2005;404–406:85–8.
reacting Li with NH3 . Ind Eng Chem Res 2006;45(1):182–6. [159] Muthukumar P, Maiya MP, Murthy SS. Experiments on a metal
[133] Ichikawa T, Isobe S, Hanada N, Fujii H. Lithium nitride for reversible hydride-based hydrogen storage device. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2005;30:
hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 2004;365:271–6. 1569–81.
[134] Hu HH, Ruckenstein E. Highly effective Li2 O/Li3 N with ultrafast [160] Wang X, Chen R, Zhang Y, Chen C, Wang Q. Hydrogen storage alloys
kinetics for H2 storage. Ind Eng Chem Res 2004;43:2464–7. for high-pressure suprapure hydrogen compressor. J Alloys Compds
[135] Hu YH, Ruckenstein E. H2 storage in Li3 N. Temperature programmed 2006;420(1–2):322–5.
hydrogenation and dehydrogenation. Ind Eng Chem Res 2003;42: [161] Santos DS dos, Bououdina M, Fruchart D. Structural and hydrogenation
5135–9. properties of an 80 wt% TiCr1.1 V0.9 –20 wt% LaNi5 composite material.
[136] Pinkerton FE, Meisner GP, Meyer MS, Balogh MP, Kundrat MD. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2003;28:1237–41.
Hydrogen desorption exceeding ten weight percent from the new [162] Liu Y, Pan H, Gao M, Li G, Sun X, Lei Y. Investigation on the
quaternary hydride LiBN2 H8 . J Phys Chem B 2005;109:6–8. characteristics of La0.7 Mg0.3 Ni2.65 Mn0.1 Co0.75+x (x = 0.00.0.85)
[137] Vajo JJ, Skeith SL, Mertens F. Reversible storage of hydrogen in metal hydride electrode alloys for Ni/MH batteries. Part I: phase
destabilized LiBH4 . J Phys Chem B 2005;109(9):3719–22. structures and hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compds 2005;387:147–53.
[138] Morioka H, Kakizaki K, Chung S-C, Yamada A. Reversible hydrogen [163] Bououdina M, Enoki H, Akiba E. The investigation of the
decomposition of KAlH4 . J Alloys Compds 2003;353:310–4. Zr 1−y Tiy (Cr 1−x Nix )2 –H2 system phase composition analysis and
[139] Dafert FW, Miklauz R. Uber einige neue Verbindungen von Stick-stoff thermodynamic properties. J Alloys Compds 1998;281:290–300.
and Wasserstoff mit Lithium. Diese Sitzungsberichte Bd. CXVIII, July [164] Kojima Y, Kawai Y, Towata S-I, Matsunaga T, Shinozawa T, Kimbara
1910. p. 981–96. M. Development of metal hydride with high dissociation pressure.
[140] Ruff O, Georges H. Uber das Lithium-imid und einige Bemerkungen J Alloys Compds 2005, in press.
zu der Arbeit von Dafert und Miklauz: Über einige neue Verbindungen [165] Zaluski L, Zaluska A, Tessier P, Strörn-Olsen JO, Schulz R. Effects of
von Stickstoff und Wasserstoff mit Lithium. Anorganischen und relaxation on hydrogen absorption in Fe–Ti produced by ball-milling.
elektrochemischen Laboratorium der Kgt. Techn. Hochschule Danzig, J Alloys Compds 1995;227:53–7.
February 13, 1911. p. 502–6. [166] Kuriiwa T, Tamura T, Amemiya T, Fuda T, Kamegawa A, Takamura H.
[141] Hu YH, Ruckenstein E. Ultrafast reaction between LiH and NH3 during et al. New V-based alloys with high protium absorption and desorption
H2 storage in Li3 N. J Phys Chem A 2003;107(46):9737–9. capacity. J Alloys Compds 1999;293–295:433–6.
[142] Orimo S, Nakamori Y, Kitahara G, Miwa K, Ohba N, Noritake T. [167] Seo C-Y, Kim J-H, Lee PS, Lee J-Y. Hydrogen storage properties of
et al. Destabilization and enhanced dehydriding reaction of LiNH2 : an vanadium-based B.C.C. solid solution metal hydrides. J Alloys Compds
electronic structure viewpoint. Appl Phys A 2004;79:1765–7. 2003;348:252–7.
[143] Nakamori Y, Orimo S-I. Destabilization of Li-based complex hydrides. [168] Takasaki A, Kelton KF. Hydrogen storage in Ti-based quasicrystal
J Alloys Compds 2004;370:271–5. powders produced by mechanical alloying. Int J Hydrogen Energy
[144] Nakamori Y, Orimo S. Li–N based hydrogen storage materials. Mater 2006;31(2):183–90.
Sci Eng B 2004;108:48–50. [169] Okada M, Kuriiwa T, Tamura T, Takamura H, Kamegawa A.
[145] Fakioglu E, Yürüm Y, Veziroglu TN. A review of hydrogen storage Ti–V–Cr B.C.C. alloys with high protium content. J Alloys Compds
systems based on boron and its compounds. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2002;330–332:511–6.
2004;29:1371–6. [170] Yu XB, Yang ZX, Feng SL, Wu Z, Xu NX. Influence of Fe addition on
[146] Schlesinger HI, Brown HC. J Am Chem Soc 1940;62:3429. hydrogen storage characteristics of Ti–V-based alloy. Int J Hydrogen
[147] Stasinevich DS, Egorenko GA. J Russ Inorg Chem 1968;13(3):341–3. Energy 2006;31(9):1176–81.
[148] Züttel A, Rentsch S, Fischer P, Wenger P, Sudan P, Mauron PL. [171] Nomura K, Akiba E. H2 Absorbing–desorbing characterization of the
et al. Hydrogen storage properties of LiBH4 . J Alloys Compds Ti–V–Fe alloy system. J Alloys Compds 1995;231:513–7.
2003;356–357:515–20. [172] Yu XB, Wu Z, Xia BJ, Xu NX. Enhancement of hydrogen storage
[149] Zaluska A, Zaluski L, Ström-Olsen JO. Lithium–beryllium hydrides: capacity of Ti–V–Cr–Mn BCC phase alloys. J Alloys Compds
the lightest reversible metal hydrides. J Alloys Compds 2000;307: 2004;372:272–7.
157–66. [173] Gao L, Chen C, Chen L, Wang X, Zhang J. et al. Hydriding/dehydriding
[150] Vucht JV, Kuijpers FA, Bruning H. Philips Res Rep 1970;25:133. behaviors of La1.8 Ca0.2 Mg14 Ni3 alloy modified by mechanical ball-
[151] Reilly JJ, Wiswall RH. Formation and properties of iron titanium milling under argon. J Alloys Compds 2005;399:178–82.
hydride. Inorg Chem 1974;13(1):218–22. [174] Lu D, Li W, Hu S, Xiao F, Tang R. Uniform nanocrystalline AB5 -type
[152] Reilly JJ, Sandrock GD. Hydrogen storage in metal hydrides. Sci Am hydrogen storage alloy: preparation and properties as negative materials
1980;242(2):118–9. of Ni/MH battery. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31(6):678–82.
1140 B. Sakintuna et al. / International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 32 (2007) 1121 – 1140

[175] Corre S, Bououdina M, Fruchart D, Adachi G-Y. Stabilisation of high [182] Chen Y, Sequeira CAC, Chen C, Wang X, Wang Q. Metal hydride beds
dissociation pressure hydrides of formula La1−x Cex Ni5 with carbon and hydrogen supply tanks as minitype PEMFC hydrogen sources. Int
monoxide. J Alloys Compds 1998;275(277):99–104. J Hydrogen Energy 2003;28:329–33.
[176] Broom DP, Kemali M, Ross DK. Magnetic properties of commercial [183] Liu FJ, Suda S. Properties and characteristics of fluorinated hydriding
metal hydride battery materials. J Alloys Compds 1999;293–295: alloys. J Alloys Compds 1995;231:742–50.
255–9. [184] Wang XL, Suda S. Surface characteristics of fluorinated hydriding
[177] Joubert J-M, Cerny R, Latroche M, Percheron-Guegan A, Schmitt alloys. J Alloys Compds 1995;231:380–6.
B. Hydrogenation of LaNi5 studied by in situ synchrotron powder [185] Suda S, Sun Y-M, Liu B-H, Zhou Y, Morimitsu S, Arai K. et al.
diffraction. Acta Mater 2006;54:713–9. Catalytic generation of hydrogen by applying fluorinated-metal hydrides
[178] Joubert J-M, Latroche M, Cerny R, Percheron-Guegan A, Yvon K. as catalysts. Appl Phys A 2001;72:209–12.
Hydrogen cycling induced degradation in LaNi5 -type materials. J Alloys [186] Kikkinides ES, Georgiadis MC, Stubos AK. On the optimization
Compds 2002;330–332:208–14. of hydrogen storage in metal hydride beds. Int J Hydrogen Energy
[179] Joubert J-M, Cerny R, Latroche M, Leroy M, Guenee L, Percheron- 2006;31(6):737–51.
Guegan A. et al. A structural study of the homogeneity domain of [187] Bououdina M, Grant D, Walker G. Review on hydrogen absorbing
LaNi5 . J Solid State Chem 2002;166:1–6. materials—structure, microstructure and thermodynamic properties. Int
[180] Joubert J-M, Latroche M, Cerny R, Bowman RC, Percheron-Guegan J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31(2):177–82.
A, Yvon K. Crystallographic study of LaNi5−x Sn2−x (0.2 < x < 0.5) [188] Dantzer P. Properties of intermetallic compounds suitable for hydrogen
compounds and their hydrides. J Alloys Compds 1999;293–295:124–9. storage applications. Mater Sci Eng A 2002;329–331:313–20.
[181] Demircan A, Demiralp M, Kaplan Y, Mat MD, Veziroglu TN. [189] Bavykin DV, Lapkin AA, Plucinski PK, Friedrich JM, Walsh FC.
Experimental and theoretical analysis of hydrogen absorption in Reversible storage of molecular hydrogen by sorption into multilayered
LaNi5 –H2 reactors. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2005;30:1437–46. TiO2 nanotubes. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:19422–7.

You might also like