Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AND EVALUATION
Session-1
Monitoring & Evaluation Course (Part I)
15TH -17TH JULY 2020
URUGUAY GHANA
DEMONSTRATION OF TEAM WORK
INTEREST GROUPS IN THE GHANA VRS URUGUAY
GAME
INTEREST GROUP INTEREST, RESPONSIBILITIES
1.Playing body or the team Win the game and progress further
2.Referee Compliance with the rules of the game
3.Lines men Compliance with the rules of the game
4.Coach Selection of players to execute game
plan, technical direction etc
5.The FA Ensure efficient football administration
6.Sport Ministry initiate and execute policies, programmes and
projects to ensure the development and
promotion of Sports
7.Office of the President Ensure equal development of all sectors of the
(Government) national economy
8.FIFA (Organizers) Ensure constant improvement of global football
9.Supporters Union Provide entertainment during games
10.The Media Provide information on the game to the general
public
12.Sponsors Provide funds and logistics to support the game
Breaking down
the “M” and the “E”
• MONITORING • EVALUATION
1. Looking 1. Appraisal
2. Observing 2. Assessment
3. Watching 3. Review
4. Tracking 4. Enquiry/ Inquiry
5. Checking 5. Interpretation
6. Policing /Patrolling 6. Comparison
7. Following 7. Introspection
8. Inspecting 8. Judgement
9. Supervising 9. Analysis
10.Overseeing 10.Probe
11.Invigilating 11.Investigation
12.Viewing 12.Study
REQUIREMENTS FOR
M&E
1. Policies, Goals and Objectives
2. Plan, Programme or project
(ongoing or completed)
3. TIMEFRAME – it could be
seconds, minutes, hours, days,
months or years
MAPPING M&E
1. SELECT A PROJECT
2. VIDEO
What is MONITORING?
• The Development Assistance Committee (DAC) of the
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
(OECD) defines monitoring as a continuing function that
uses systematic collection of data on specified indicators to
provide management and the main stakeholders of an on-
going development intervention with indications of the
extend of progress and achievement of objectives and
progress in the use of allocated funds
Systematic collection and analysis of information as a project or a
programme progresses
Aimed at improving the efficiency and effectiveness of a project or
organization
It is based on targets set and activities planned during the planning
phases of the intervention
Keep work on track, and can let management know when things are
going wrong
What is MONITORING?
Establishing indicators of efficiency, effectiveness and impact;
Setting up systems to collect information relating to indicators;
Collecting, recording and analyzing information
Using information to inform day-to-day management.
Is an internal function in any project or organisation
Types of Monitoring
• Financial Monitoring- Tracks revenue, disbursements and cash
flow to assess cost efficiency and the correct use of funds
• Diagnostic Monitoring: Examines methods used to implement the
intervention, identify problems that causes delays, affect quality or
make it difficult for the intervention to achieve its objectives and
provides solutions
• Compliance Monitoring: Assess the compliance of donor
regulations and expected results, grant and contract
requirements, local government regulations, laws and ethical
standards
• Beneficiary Monitoring: Tracks beneficiary perceptions of a
project or a programme. It include tracking beneficiary satisfaction
or complaints, their participation, treatment, access to resources
and their overall experience of change
• Performance Monitoring: Tracks the use of inputs, the progress of
activities and the delivery of outputs. Examples include
supervision, inspection, review of progress reports, administrative
records and audit reports
Example of Financial Monitoring
FINANCE
What to monitor Information to be collected Sources of information Use of information
Budget and Expenditure by project / programmes Invoices and Predict expenditure for budgeting
expenditure Expenditure by budget head vouchers Compare costs of different project
Balance of budget remaining this year Budget break down Identify areas of excessive
Regular recurring items of expenditure Analysis of budget expenditure
, e.g., rent and expenditure, e.g., Identify any savings
Previous year’s budget and using computer Compares costs with project
expenditure spreadsheets achievements to assess cost –
Rates of inflation News papers effectiveness
Exchange rates Bank
Staff salaries Salaries Staff records Ensure staff are paid according to
Tax, insurance, etc. Pay slips pay scale reflecting nature of job
Final pay * Salary records and length of service
Other payments: e.g., health Ensure other payments are made
allowance, staff loans according to correct procedures
Ensure all staff know what
benefits they are entitled to
Cash flow analysis When is cash needed for project? Cash record system To ensure sufficient but not
Where will cash from? (might include excessive cash is available
loan repayments, community
contributions, etc.)
What and when are cash outgoing?
(regular and irregular) supply
Order quantities
Steps to Conducting Monitoring
1. Prepare for monitoring
• Review existing information related to project or programme
• Identify the purpose and scope of the monitoring (e.g. check on-going
works and activities, goods and service delivered, immediate and
intermediate outcomes, etc.)
• Establish the time schedule for monitoring (e.g. the first Tuesday of
every month)
• Determine who must be involved in each monitoring exercise with due
consideration to age, gender, disability and other social factors
• Organize a meeting or workshop with stakeholders before field
monitoring
• Determine specific projects and expected results and/or components to
be monitored as well as cross-cutting themes and success factors to be
applied
• Assemble the necessary materials that will be used in the field (e.g.
cameras, rain coats, hats, flip chart with stand, markers, masking tape,
needed documents, etc.)
• Prepare a big chart on the wall or billboard to present the field findings -
pictures, data tables and graphs, etc.
Steps to Conducting Monitoring
2) Construct or select and prioritize the indicators
3) Determine baselines and targets for each indicator
4) Determine which categories of staff will be responsible for the
collection of data on each indicator
5) Develop a timetable for frequency of monitoring
6) Develop or strengthen the M&E information system for data
capture, storage, analysis, retrieval and presentation
7) Develop other monitoring instruments, such as questionnaires
8) Conduct monitoring activities - field visits, supervision,
inspection, administrative records, rapid assessments, review of
audit or progress reports,
9) Analyze the monitoring data collected
10) Write monitoring reports
11) Make recommendations
12) Implement recommendations
13) Identify new indicators based on the recommendations
14) Modify the monitoring system if necessary
WHAT IS EVALUATION?
• The Development Assistance Committee
(DAC) of the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development (OECD)
defines Evaluation as the systematic and
objective assessment of an on-going or
completed project, programme or policy,
its design, implementation and results in
relation to specified evaluation criteria.
Comparison of actual project impacts against
the agreed plans
Classification of Evaluation
1. Purpose- Evaluation can be grouped according to
the main objective. Two types are observed under
this categorization: Formative and Summative
Evaluation
2. Timing of the Evaluation- there are four types of
evaluation if time is used to categorize them: Ex-
Ante Evaluation, Mid-Term Evaluation, Terminal or
Final Evaluation and Ex-post Evaluation
3. Technical Specification and Scope-these are
evaluations based on their technical specification
and scope
4. Who is Conducting the Evaluation- Two main
categorization is observed under this criteria:
Internal or Self evaluation and External Evaluation
Who Conducts the Evaluation
More Informed
Policies and
Decisions
M & E STANDARDS AND PRINCIPLES
• Independent (There Should not be Restrictions on the Scope, Content and Recommendations of any Evaluation Report)
• Transparent (The Rationale for Evaluation should be Clear from the Onset)
• Ethical (The Evaluation must not Reflect Personal Interests. Evaluators must Respect the Rights of Institutions and Individuals)
30
What is
M&E System it
?
Assessing
Needs and Data Collection
Conditions
Stakeholders Indicators, Matrix,
Analysis Calendar & Budget
Other Studies
& Evaluations
M&E PLANS AT ALL
LEVELS
M&E Plans Body Responsible
NDPC
MDAs
RPCUs
DPCUs
Project Managers
Risks or challenges
of any M&E System
Session-2
Monitoring & Evaluation Course (Part I)
OUTLINE
• Session objectives/Introduction
• Lessons learned
37
The Needs of the Community or country
DESIRED
RESULT (Better!)
LATER
Policy /
Programme
SITUATION
NOW
(Challenges)
The Logic Model/Result Chain
Impact Long-term widespread
improvement
External
factors
Immediate to medium-
Outcomes term effects of the
outputs
Tasks undertaken to
Activities
Assumptions
Inputs
Financial, Human and
Material
What is LOGIC MODEL?
•A recommended method for program design
and development of M&E strategies
• A depiction of the processes and targeted
outcomes of the intervention
•It helps the organization to specify strategic
objectives, identify what resources are needed,
develop indicators to measure progress and
proposed results, and communicate the
interventions’ potential value.
40
What is LOGIC MODEL?
• Defining the logic model of a development intervention
is the first step in M&E
• It can take a variety of forms, for example:
a result chain in the first row of Logical Frameworks
a diagram of objectives, flow charts or a result tree
a diagram of expected effects
a narrative description of outputs, outcomes and
impact
41
Components of the Logic Model
• NEEDS
• INPUTS
• ACTIVITIES
• PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
• EXPECTED OUTPUTS
• EXPECTED OUTCOMES,
• EXPECTED IMPACTS,
• ASSUMPTIONS
• EXTERNAL FACTORS
42
Developing Indicators
Session- 4
Monitoring & Evaluation Course
(Part I)
43
Outline of the Session
• Introduction of session
• Session’s Objectives
• concept of indicators
• Classification of indicators
• Steps involved in developing indicators
• Development of Monitoring Matrix
• Group Discussion
44
7/23/2020
Session Objectives
At the end of the session, participants will be
able to:
• Explain the concept & essence of
indicators in the conduct of M & E
• Explain the criteria for developing
indicators
• Develop indicators for M&E
45
7/23/2020 Michael Marfo Ohene
The Needs of the Community or country
DESIRED
RESULT (Better!)
LATER
Policy /
Programme
SITUATION
NOW
(Challenges)
INDICATORS
LATER
INDICATORS
NOW
An Indicator
48
Classification of Indicators
• Financial, human, and material resources (Input
INPUTS indicators)
Easy to Simple to
Availability
Measure Understand
Cost
Robust Time Bound
Effective
54
Well-defined
55
EXAMPLES OF INDICATOR DEFINITIONS
AGENDA FOR JOBS INDICATORS DEFINITION RESPONSIBI
LITY
Upper West 79.4 79.2 128 363 207 2,514 2,451 2,755
Northern 86.34
North East 78.3 70.6 297 570 170 3,565 3,439 3,097
Savannah 73.0
Bono 78.8
Ahafo 74.8 53.4 237 262 217 10,129 11,242 10,428
Bono East 55.4
Ashanti 76.9 78.2 500 489 603 33,207 35,142 35,428
Greater Accra 78.9 87.9 37 240 202 91,527 100,941 106,427
Eastern 75.2 77.4 106 349 226 15,814 16,079 17,646
Average
Total Average 63.3 1,971 3,385 2,606 201,936 213,436 224,221
77.6
Trend of crime incidence in regions, 2017-2019
120,000
100,000
80,000
Number
60,000
40,000
20,000
0
Western Volta Central Upper East Upper West Northern Brong Ahafo Ashanti Greater Accra Eastern
Region
1000
800
reported case of crime
600
400
200
0
Wester Central Greate Volta Eastern Ashanti Brong- Northe Upper Upper
n r Accra Ahafo rn East West
Murder 60 50 97 30 47 107 52 39 10 8
Defilement 151 226 722 180 153 232 122 57 24 22
Robery 13 59 244 50 55 63 42 37 14 7
Rape 82 234 1021 48 150 143 38 71 33 99
Region
Regional Trunk Road Surface Condition Mix 2018/2019
80
70
60
50
Percentage
40
30
20
10
0
Western Central Greater Volta Eastern Ashanti Brong Northern Upper East Upper
Accra Ahafo West
Regions
2019 2018
Updates on Health and Sanitation Core Indicators 2019
Region Proportion of Institutional Institutional population with Proportion of Recorded
the population Maternal under five access to basic the cases of
with valid NHIS mortality ratio Malaria Case drinking water population child
Card (%) Fatality Rate sources with access trafficking
to improved and abuse
Rural Urban sanitation
Western 38 106.1/100,000 0.09 59.54 76.25 20.0 0.0
Western 33 34.9/100,000 0.07
North
Central 34 105.2/100,000 0.07 64.2 59.04 19.0 4
Greater 34 139.7/100,000 0.19 64.2 59.04 25.0 34
Accra
Volta 36 131.6/100,000 0.19 64.4 31.15 14.0 16
Oti 36 54.9/100,000 0.11
Eastern 41 139.1/100,000 0.11 56.45 30.74 30.0 4
Ashanti 38 155.8/100,000 0.05 58.25 64.28 23.0 4
Bono 62 70.3/100,000 0.17 66.11 19.34 20.0 7
Bono East 52 105.3/100,000 0.24
Ahafo 49 97.23/100,000 0.06
Northern 33 144.0/100,000 0.12 60.95 43.94 12.0 9
North East 46 59.9/100,000 0.15
Savannah 44 50.4/100,000 0.07
Upper East 57 79.2/100,000 0.01 65.89 23.04 8.0 0
Upper West 57 74.8/100,000 0.14 74.37 14.21 15.0 4
Total 40 117.5/100,000 0.1 62.06 61.29 21.0 82
Regional distribution of Jobs created under GSFP
2018/19
1800
1600
1723
1400
1200
1151
1000
960
Number
400
200
0
Ashanti Brong Central Eastern Greater Northern Upper East Upper Volta Western
Ahafo Accra West
Regions
Monitoring and Evaluation
MATRIX
Session-6
Monitoring & Evaluation Course (Part I)
66
SESSION’S OUTLINE
• Session objectives
• M & E matrix
• Components of M & E matrix
• Essence of M & E matrix
• Class exercise
• Lessons learned
• Summary and closing
67
Session Objectives
At the end of the session, participants will be
able to:
• Explain the component of M&E Matrix
• Identify the essence of M&E Matrix
• Develop M&E Matrix for their field survey
based on the agreed common area
68
ESSENCE OF M & E MATRIX
• Provides the linkage of every project and M & E to
the overall national policy plan
• Targets
• Data Sources
• Monitoring frequency
• Responsibility
71
THE M&E MATRIX
72
CLASS EXERCISE
73
LESSONS LEARNED
session
in your fieldwork
74
ARE WE ALL ON BOARD?