You are on page 1of 4

Journal of Advances in Information Technology Vol. 7, No.

1, February 2016

The Influence of Culture on Instagram Use


Ali J. Al-Kandari
Gulf University for Science and Technology/Mass Communication, West Meshrif, Kuwait
Email: Alkandari.j@gust.edu.kw

Ahmed A. Al-Hunaiyyan and Rana Al-Hajri


Public Authority for Applied Education and Training (PAAET)/ Computing Department, Shuwaikh, Kuwait
Email: {aa.alhunaiyyan, ra.alhajri}@paaet.edu.kw

Abstract—Instagram, the photo and video-sharing social with what they see by pressing the “Like” button or
medium, is rapidly gaining popularity. The State of Kuwait provide comments to express their opinions on the posts.
presents an excellent case for exploring the influence of The State of Kuwait presents an excellent case for
culture on Instagram use. Like other Arab countries, the exploring the influence of culture on Instagram use. Like
traditional culture of Kuwait greatly affects the attitudes
other Arab countries, the traditional culture of Kuwait
and behaviors of its People. It is interesting to examine the
influence of gender on Instagram use activities. In Kuwait, greatly affects the attitudes and behaviors of its People. It
the culture, besides security reasons, inhabits females from is interesting to examine the influence of gender on
disclosing contact information. The central theme of this Instagram use activities. In Arab countries, females have
research paper is to understand gender differences on been subjugated by a cultural conservatism. The status of
Instagram use by Kuwaiti higher education students. This Arab females has improved; yet, variations between
study confirms that males are more likely than females to genders still exist because of “local traditions and social
post their personal pictures on Instagram, more likely to customs” [3] which “has always been a marked
disclose their personal information and more likely to have preference for boys over girls” [3]. This paper begins
public accounts unlike females who are more likely to have
with literature review, hypothesis, method, results, then
private accounts than males. 
discussion and conclusion.
Index Terms—social media, gender differences, cultural
differences, media and culture, usability, Instagram II. LITERATURE REVIEW
Wherever Females compose the majority users of
many Social Networking Sites (SNS) [4], Facebook [5],
I. INTRODUCTION
MySpace [6], Twitter, Bebo, Flickr [7] and Pinterest [8].
Instagram, the photo and video-sharing social medium, Conversely, males make up the majority of Google’s
is rapidly gaining popularity and preference with more users (71%) [8], Digg, YouTube and LinkedIn [6]. These
than 200 million users [1] and 13% of the total users of surveys confirm that the nature, functions and design of
social media placing it fourth in rank after Facebook, social media determines their users and effects. Females
Twitter and Pinterest [2]. It is a social media application prefer Facebook, Myspace, Twitter, and Pinterest because
that allows people to share with others their daily life they are interpersonal and discussion-oriented while
activities, lifestyles, habits and interests in pictures and males favor Google, Digg, YouTube and LinkedIn
videos. Instagram is easy to operate, and it only requires because they are information and content-oriented [9]-
downloading, choosing a username and password, and [11]. We also argue that females prefer social media more
finally posting pictures that others see. People can either than males because these media are primarily social in
upload posts taken instantly or stored ones from their their nature and this nature is similar to the social makeup
mobile phone gallery. of females.
Like other social networks, Instagram is built on Instagram use by males and females will not eschew
having followers like family, friends or strangers who from those uses of other social media. Females use it to
follow the updates of Instagrammers’ life via posted socialize and provide opinion while males use it to collect
pictures and videos. Created profiles include personal information and pass time. Both will use it to present
information and a picture to identify the account. People their daily life to others, however, the culture and
either create public, directly accessed, accounts or private traditions of Kuwait may mediate such use. Females will
ones that require seeking permission from the be more reserved about presenting themselves to others in
Instagrammer before viewing the posts. Once following personal pictures because the “social attitudes have
Instagrammers, followers can view the pictures and remained relatively constant” [3] in the conservative Arab
videos’ timelines. People viewing the posts can interact and Muslim culture. In many times, “The Koran is far
more protective of women’s rights and status than is the
case with more recent social practices” [3]. This cultural
context is enforced by the Arab patriarchal kinship
Manuscript received August 8, 2015, revised November 22, 2015.

© 2016 J. Adv. Inf. Technol. 54


doi: 10.12720/jait.7.1.54-57
Journal of Advances in Information Technology Vol. 7, No. 1, February 2016

system, which expects males to protect the family and information such as telephone numbers, emails and home
financially provide for it and females to have greater roles addresses on their SNS profile accounts [22]. Females
at home and in raising children [3]. feel more worried about providing such information [4].
In addition, among the Arabs, family honor, which has About 20% of them say they will share their location
roots in the sexual conducts of females, is an important details in comparison to 65% of males. Also, 55% of
value that has to remain unsoiled. If not bounded by males will share their email contact while only 42% of
marriage, such conducts bring shame to family and females will do so [21].
“blacken its face”. It is difficult to erase or restore a In Kuwait, the culture, besides security reasons,
dishonor. To prevent such conducts, many Arab countries inhabits females from disclosing contact information.
segregate between the two genders in places [12]. This culture assumes that “the inherent personalities
Furthermore, many families force their daughters to wear between men and women are vastly different” [3].
Hejab because it communicates an image of a decent Females who display contacts will be perceived as flirty
female. Thus, many families will think that posting and frivolous. Displaying contact information will reveal
personal pictures of females show them as having playful males flirty and wanting to contact females too, but the
and unrestrained character that seeks relations with males. culture is less critical to males. It gives them more
This is to avoid giving “rise to false impressions or freedom in behaving and movement than females. It also
unfounded gossip” [3]. To the Arabs, “Guarding a forbids interaction between males and females who are
woman’s image is neither a personal nor a family choice; strange to each other [3]. Generally, it is indecent if a
it is imposed by the culture” [3]. Therefore, even if male and female stay behind closed doors or go out on a
females post personal photos, they have to appear sober date. That is why there is a separation between males and
and modest in them and not reveal much of their bodies. females in social gatherings, schools and many
Also, females who have public accounts will avoid workplaces in Kuwait.
posting their personal pictures in favor of pictures of
materials they own or places they go. III. HYPOTHESIS
A. Privacy Settings The central theme of this research paper is to
More females believe that there is risk online. They understand the influence of culture on Instagram use by
report more about privacy concerns [13] and are more Kuwaiti higher education students. The following
likely to read privacy statements [14]. This interest in the research questions are posited: Accordingly, this study
online privacy issues by females is perhaps because they tries to answer and confirm three hypotheses:
are more likely to be victims of online abuse. According Hypothesis 1: Males are more likely to post their
to the Working to Hold Online Abuse Organization [15], personal pictures on Instagram than females?
73% of the 2500 online harassment and stalking cases Hypothesis 2: Females are more likely to have private
from 2000 to 2008 are for females. To maintain their Instagram accounts than males.
privacy, they create private accounts [16], support Hypothesis 3: Males are more likely to reveal their
privacy policies and provide false information [17]. personal information on their profile accounts than
Kuwaiti females will probably be more likely to create females?
private accounts on Instagram due to safety and more
importantly cultural reasons. Many fathers, brothers and IV. METHODS
husbands will reject that females have stranger male The sample of this study includes university students
followers because it communicates a negative impression in Kuwait. This segment is chosen because it uses
or create bad reputation about the females. Conversely, Instagram more often that other age groups. About 539
having a private account may communicate that a female university students participated in a questionnaire that
is moral and well-mannered. More likely, males will have took about 10 minutes to fill out. It was distributed to
public accounts and followers from the opposite sex students who were enrolled in general education courses
because “The misbehavior by women is believed to do to guarantee a sample representing diverse body of
more damage to family honor than the misbehavior of students from different fields. Such courses were like
men” [3]. The Arab culture treats males more favorably. Introduction to Politics, Introduction to Physical
Males can go out with anyone and come back at any time Education, Principles of Psychology, principles of
while females are restricted. Thus, they will limit their Business…etc. The questionnaire was originally in
Instagram’s relationships only to family and friends. English and translated to Arabic to control language from
Even in the United States, 52% of females say that their being an artifact. It took about 15 minutes to fill out.
social media profiles are set private so that only friends Subjects were told that there information will be
view them [18]. confidential.
B. Information Disclosure
Females are extroverted and reveal more information V. RESULTS
about themselves on MySpace [19] and Facebook [20]. This study seeks to confirm its three hypotheses. To
This personal information includes their relationships, confirm them, independent t-test procedures were used to
preferences, jobs, and religious affiliations [21]. However, find out the differences between males and females. The
more often than females, males provide their contact first hypothesis stated, Males are more likely to post their

© 2016 J. Adv. Inf. Technol. 55


Journal of Advances in Information Technology Vol. 7, No. 1, February 2016

personal pictures on Instagram than females. The t-test “blacken its face” of the family [12]. “Guarding a
revealed that males (M = 1.82; SD = .38), more than woman’s image is neither a personal nor a family choice;
females (M = 1.49; SD = .50), posted personal pictures it is imposed by the culture” [3].
on Instagram (t(522) = 8.00, p = .001). This finding This is also similar to having public accounts by
confirms the first hypothesis. females. Families are more likely to reject that their
The second hypothesis stated that Females are more daughters to allow other stranger males to follow them.
likely to have private Instagram accounts than males. The Having males followers may shows a female who is a
t-test statistical procedure confirmed this hypothesis. playful. Such image is because “The misbehavior by
Males (M = 1.21; SD = .41) are more likely than females women is believed to do more damage to family honor
(M = 1.10; SD = .30) to have public accounts (t(520) = than the misbehavior of men” [3].
3.54, p = .001). Future studies might compare between Arab and
The last hypothesis which stated that Males are more Western females on the use of Instagram. Using a cultural
likely to reveal their personal information on their profile perspective might further highlight the influence on
accounts than females. The t-test revealed that More culture on the use of various social media. Future studies
frequently than females (M = 2.92; SD = 1.77), males (M might also examine age as a factor influence usage of
= 3.68; SD = 2.01) disclose their personal information Instagram in issues related to privacy settings, disclosure,
(t(527) = 4.49, p = .001). The third hypothesis is types of pictures posted, and level of involvements, etc.
confirmed. Table I bellow shows types of information,
each gender disclosed with percentage. REFERENCES
[1] A. Smith. (2014). The numbers: 85 interesting Instagram
TABLE I. TYPES OF INFORMATION, EACH GENDER WITH %
statistics. Digital Marketing Rambling. [Online]. Available:
Information Males Females http://expandedramblings.com/index.php/important-instagram-
Disclosed Freq. Rank % Freq. Rank % stats/#.U_jjTtgcSt8
Real name 152 1 78 206 1 59 [2] M. Duggan and J. Bernner. (2013). The demographics of social
Personal media users—2012. The Pew Research Internet Project. [Online].
140 2 72 126 3 37 Available: http://www.pewinternet.org/2013/02/14/the-
pictures
Preferred demographics-of-social-media-users-2012/
77 3 40 175 2 51 [3] M. Nydell. Understanding Arabs: A Guide for Modern Times,
saying
Boston: Intercultural Press, 2006.
Age/
57 5 29 101 4 29 [4] A. Acquisti and R. Gross, “Imagined communities: Awareness,
Birthday
information sharing, and privacy on the Facebook,” in Privacy
Major/school
57 5 29 92 5 27 Enhancing Technologies, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, G.
of study
Danezis, E. Golle, Ed. Heidelberg, Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 2006.
Contacts 47 6 24 42 9 12 [5] A. N. Joinson, “Looking at, looking up or keeping up with'
Interests and people? Motives and uses of Facebook," CHI 2008 Proceedings,
46 7 24 67 7 19
hobbies pp. 1027–1036, 2008.
Gender 36 8 19 68 6 20 [6] A. Lenhart, “Adults and social network websites,” Pew Internet &
Nationality 34 9 18 52 8 15 American Life Project, February 20, 2009.
Job title 24 10 12 17 11 5 [7] J. Goudreau. (2010). What men and women are doing on
Place of Facebook. [Online]. Available:
18 11 9 16 12 5
living http://www.forbes.com/2010/04/26/popular-social-networking-
Marital status 18 12 9 22 12 6 sites-forbes-woman-time-facebook-twitter.html
[8] E. Shubin. (2012). Gender differences in social media usage.
[Online]. Available:
VI. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION http://www.commcreative.com/blog/2012/09/gender-differences-
This paper sought to find out the influence of culture social-media-usage
[9] D. Williams, M. Consalvo, S. Caplan, and N. Yee, “Looking for
on Instagram use between males and females. The gender (LFG): Gender roles and behaviors among online gamers,”
Kuwaiti, as an Arab culture, can dictate the use of Journal of Communication, vol. 59, pp. 700–725, 2009.
emerging social media. This study confirms that males [10] R. E. Guadagno, N. L. Muscanell, B. M. Okdie, N. M. Burk, and T.
are more likely than females to post their personal B. Ward, Even in virtual environments women shop and men
build: A social, 2011.
pictures on Instagram, more likely to disclose their [11] R. E. Guadagno and R. B. Cialdini, “Persuade him by email, but
personal information and more likely to have public see her in person: Online persuasion revisited,” Computers in
accounts unlike females who are more likely to have Human Behavior, vol. 33, pp. 999–1015, 2007.
private accounts than males. Such findings confirm what [12] R. Patai, The Arab Mind, Red Brick Press, 2007.
[13] M. Hoy and G. Milne, “Gender differences in privacy-related
the literature discussed about the status of Arab females. measures for young adult Facebook users,” Journal of Interactive
Such culture has always preferred males over females [3] Advertising, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 28-45, 2010.
and this is why males are more likely than females to post [14] R. Milne, George, and J. M. Culnan, “Strategies for reducing
their personal pictures or disclose their personal online privacy risks: Why consumers read (or don't read) online
privacy notices,” Journal of Interactive Marketing, vol. 18, no. 3,
information on Instagram. The image of a female is part 15-29, 2004.
of the image of the entire family or clan. Father, brothers [15] Working to Hold Online Abuse organization (WHOA). (2008).
and husbands probably will allow females to have Comparison statistics 2000-2009. [Online]. Available:
Instagram accounts, but would probably not prefer that http://haltabuse.org/resources/stats/Cumulative2000-2007.pdf
[16] J. Fogel and E. Nehmad, “Internet social network communities:
their sisters, wives and daughters to post their personal Risk taking, trust and privacy concerns,” Computers in Human
pictures especially if they have public accounts or Behavior, vol. 25, pp. 153-160, 2009.
disclose personal information. Such conduct might

© 2016 J. Adv. Inf. Technol. 56


Journal of Advances in Information Technology Vol. 7, No. 1, February 2016

[17] K. B. Sheehan and C. Doherty, “Re-weaving the web: Integrating Dr. Ahmed A. Al-Hunaiyyan is a faculty
print and online communication,” Journal of Interactive member of the department of Computer and
Marketing, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 47-59, 2001. Information systems at the College of
[18] The Demographics of Social Media Users. (2012). [Online]. Business Studies, PAAET, Kuwait. He earned
Available: www.pewresearch.org his PhD. Degree in the field of Computer
[19] P. Norris, Digital Divide: Civic Engagement, Information Poverty, Science, specializing in Multimedia interface
and the Internet Worldwide, New York: Cambridge University design, from Hertfordshire University, United
Press, 2001. Kingdom. As of working experience, he
[20] E. A. Kolek and D. Saunders, “Online disclosure: An empirical participated in various academic
examination of undergraduate Facebook profiles,” NASPA Journal, institutions,in and out of Kuwait. Now Dr. Al-
vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 1–25, 2008. hunaiyyan is a research associate at the faculty of computer science at
[21] Examiner (2012). Gender differences arise in social media use. University of Malaya, Malysia. His research interest is Human
[Online]. Available: http://www.examiner.com/article/gender- Computer Interaction (HCI), software Usability, Designing Educational
differences-arise-social-media-use Multimedia Interfaces and social media.
[22] Z. Tufekci, “Grooming, gossip, Facebook, and MySpace,”
Information, Communication & Society, vol. 11, no. 4, pp. 544–
564, 2008.

Dr. Ali J. Alkandari is an associate professor Dr. Rana Alhajri is a faculty member in the
of mass communication in Gulf University for department of Computer Science at the Higher
Science and Technology, Kuwait. He was the Institute of Telecommunication and
director of research and development and dean Navigation, which belongs to The Public
of admission and registration at the university. Authority for Applied Education and Training
His research interests include social media use (PAAET) in Kuwait. She earned her PhD.
and effects. Degree in the field of Computer Science,
specializing in e-learning, from Brunel
University, United Kingdom. Her research
interest is Hypermedia, Individual Differences,
HCI, Usability, Multimedia Interface design in education in software
use and social media.

© 2016 J. Adv. Inf. Technol. 57

You might also like