You are on page 1of 117

F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 FO R T U N E .

C O M

For Business • For the Economy • For the Battle Against COVID-19
E N G I N E E R E D TO
A H I G H E R S TA N D A R D

C L I M AT E C O N C I E R G E

S H I AT S U M A S S A G E

H E A D - U P D I S P L AY

THE HUMAN
S TA N D A R D

Adjusts the temperature before you even realize you’re cold.

Seven different massage settings to give you one moment of peace.

Gives you more than a glimpse—prepares you for what’s ahead.


THE NEW LS —THE GREATEST EXPRESSION OF LEXUS
lexus.com/LS | #LexusLS

Options shown. ©2020 Lexus


Travel confidently with the personal
M2
security of private aviation.
More certainty. More protection. More peace of mind. Our
diverse jet portfolio lets you move with comfort and security.
Put your worries to rest and let our aircraft carry you forward.
CJ3+
A SOLUTION FOR EVERY SKY. txtav.com/jets

CJ4

XLS+

LATITUDE

SOVEREIGN+

LONGITUDE

© 2020 Textron Aviation Inc. All rights reserved.


CONTENTS FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 3

Features February/March 2021


VOLUME 183 • NUMBER 1
HEARTBREAK IN THE
HEARTLAND: Battered grain
bins in Luther, Iowa, in the
wake of an Aug. 10 derecho.

42
Cold-Blooded
Elon Musk is not about
to let a few endangered
reptiles throw a wrench
in Tesla’s ambitious
plans for a German Giga-
factory—and European
domination.
BY VIVIENNE WALT

WHAT 49 52
COMES
Now the Hard The Most
Work Starts Prepared Woman
NEXT
BY BRIAN O’KEEFE
What lies ahead for
in Washington
BY NICOLE GOODKIND
99
business, the economy, & GEOFF COLVIN The World’s
and the battle against Trailblazing Treasury Most Admired
Secretary Janet Yellen
COVID-19.
must stabilize a COVID-
Companies
Fortune’s annual ranking
ravaged economy—and
of corporate reputation.
that’s just the beginning
BY SCOTT DECARLO
of her ambitious agenda. & MATT HEIMER
A F P V I A G E T T Y I M A G E S ; I O WA : D A N I E L A C K E R — G E T T Y I M A G E S

62 70 80
COVER , ORIGINAL PHOTO (BIDEN): ANGEL A WEIS S—

After the Busted Hawkeye Elegy


SolarWinds Hack Stagecoach BY ERIKA FRY
BY DAVID Z. MORRIS BY REY MASHAYEKHI A brutal storm struck
& ROBERT HACKETT Iowa, already reeling
Can Wells Fargo CEO
How America Charlie Scharf— from COVID-19 and
can untangle its or anyone—fix the political discord. What
cybersecurity mess. beleaguered bank? will it take to rebuild?
Cover image by
NICOLAS ORTEGA
4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 CONTENTS

Departments

Foreword
WHAT OUR
6 Making Time for EDITORS
Deeper Understanding ARE UP
TO NEXT
BY CLIF TON LE AF

FORTUNE
The Brief BRAINSTORM
Senior writer
15 Is America Giving Up
Michal Lev-Ram
on Working Women?
BY MARIA ASPAN &
and deputy
EMMA HINCHLIFFE
editor Brian
O’Keefe explore
21 T-Mobile’s New CEO how tech is
Answers the Call disrupting
BY A ARON PRES SMAN our world and
reshaping our
22 Book Review: lives. fortune
In the Hot Seat With .com/podcasts
Former GE CEO Jeff
Immelt BY GEOFF C OLVIN
TRAILBLAZERS
24 COVID Clobbers Nobody starts
Commercial Real out in the
Estate, and Banks C-suite. Mem-
Feel the Fallout bers of Fortune’s
BY L ANCE L AMBERT
Most Powerful
29 Can Peloton Keep Up The Conversation Women com-
munity recount
Its Pandemic-Era Pace?
BY ROBERT HACKET T how they navi-
8 ALBERT BOURLA gated corporate
32 The Overlooked After developing the world’s first COVID-19 vaccine, the Pfizer CEO America to
Tech Portfolio: has his eye on the next impossible task. INTERVIE W BY CLIF TON LE AF reach the top.
The Pros Expect a fortune
Different Cohort of .com/videos
Market Winners This
Year BY JEN WIECZNER
EASTWORLD
Find expert
Passions The Cartographer insights weekly
on what’s domi-
106 Land Mark: The 112 The Economic nating business
New Land Rover Impact of COVID-19 in Asia. fortune
Defender Proves Lockdowns Worldwide
Worthy of Its Name .com/newsletters
BY BRIAN O’KEEFE
BY DANIEL BENTLE Y & NIC OL AS R APP

Fortune (ISSN 0015-8259) is published monthly, delivered in combined issues in February, April, June, August, October, and Decem-
ber, by Fortune Media (USA) Corporation, Principal Office: 40 Fulton Street, New York, NY 10038. Periodicals postage paid at New
York, NY, and additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send all UAA to CFS. (See DMM 507.1.5.2). Non-Postal and Military Facilities:
Send address corrections to Fortune magazine, P.O. Box 37508, Boone, IA 50037-0508. Canada Post Publications Mail Agreement
#40069223. BN# 888381621RT0001. ©2021 Fortune Media IP Limited. Printed in the U.S.A. Customer Service and Subscriptions: For
24/7 service, please use our website: www.fortune.com/myaccount. You can also call 1-800-621-8000 or write to Fortune magazine,
P.O. Box 37508, Boone, IA 50037-0508. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is strictly prohibited. Your bank
may provide updates to the card information we have on file. You may opt out of this service at any time.

PHOTOGRAPH BY MACKENZIE STROH


Our advisors listen, so you
know you’ve been heard.
When you talk to a Dell Technologies Advisor, they’re focused on
you — to provide tailored solutions on everything from laptops
to the cloud, to keep your Small Business ready for what’s next.

Call one today at 855-341-5261


Dell.com/SmallBusinessPartner

Vostro 15 5502 with up to an 11th Gen Intel® Core™ i7 processor


Starting at $799

Intel and the Intel logo are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries. Copyright © 2021 Dell Inc. or its subsidiaries. All Rights
Reserved. Dell Technologies, Dell, EMC, Dell EMC and other trademarks are trademarks of Dell Inc. or its subsidiaries. Other trademarks may be
trademarks of their respective owners. 390685
6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 FOREWORD

Worth the Time

IT IS SOMETIMES HARD to fathom, in That’s what you’ll find, I believe, in the


collection of stories we’ve assigned for this
our era of instantaneity, how long the issue’s cover package. Together, they try to
timeline can be for putting together a print answer a question that has taken several
magazine. Our story in this issue on the patient weeks to figure out: What comes
next? As a new President presides at the
striking SolarWinds hack (which begins on Resolute desk, as a new Congress dithers
page 62)—by David Z. Morris and Robert and perhaps even begins to deliberate,
as a slate of challenges from COVID-19
Hackett, two of the most seasoned and to climate change to the collapse of civic
sophisticated writers on cybersecurity that kindness grow ever more urgent, what
lies in wait just over the horizon?
I’ve ever read—got its germination shortly I’m happy to say that the answers, con-
after this jaw-dropping breach was scientiously reported by my colleagues, do
shed light. They offer thoughtful guid-
reported in mid-December. ance for anyone who hopes to navigate
an uncertain landscape for business, the
Viv Walt, our senior special correspon- economy, and life during a pandemic
dent in Europe, began reporting on Elon that won’t seem to fade. One extra note
Musk’s controversial Gigafactory in Ger- of comfort, as political correspondent
many (see “Cold-Blooded,” on page 42) in Nicole Goodkind reveals, is that the U.S.
the days before Thanksgiving, when she economy has a steady hand at the tiller in
heard the brouhaha building in Berlin. If new Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen—a
my email archive is to be believed, writer woman who has proved to be an assidu-
Rey Mashayekhi first pitched his feature ous steward in every previous role she’s
on Wells Fargo (“Busted Stagecoach,” held (page 52).
page 70) way back in June, after gather- This issue also marks another change
ing string on the troubled bank in several in Fortune’s now-91-year history—and I
other stories. And Erika Fry’s simply mes- believe it is a welcome one. We are now
merizing tale of her home state in crisis, publishing our print magazine every
“Hawkeye Elegy” (page 80), got its start other month. That move will not only
shortly after she was born—or at least free up our reporters to break more news
that’s my guess based on the sheer depth and offer urgent commentary on Fortune
and expertise of the reporting. .com, it will also help ensure that the sto-
That long, deliberate timeline is a fea- ries you do read in these pages are always
ture, not a bug. To be sure, we are proudly worth your time.
digital first at Fortune—eager as any flock
of ravenous reporters to take flight with a
breaking story. And I hope, dear reader,
you’ll return to Fortune.com again and
I L L U S T R AT I O N B Y S A M K E R R

again to see what we’ve uncovered. Yet


for all of the virtue of speed in this end-
lessly streaming information age, there is
wisdom—perhaps even the irreplaceable
CLIFTON LEAF
kind—to be found in the slow-but-steady Editor-in-Chief, Fortune
act of feature-writing. @CliftonLeaf
Empowering
Employees
Professionally
and Personally
At GEICO, success is led by our employees, from the way
we talk about insurance to the way we support our
customers to the way we evolve our culture.

By amplifying voices with our Employee Resource


Groups, expanding our reach in local communities,
conducting implicit bias training, and more, we aim
to ensure every employee – current and future – feels
seen, heard, included, and represented.

Make Your Mark


at geico.com/careers

Some discounts, coverages, payment plans, and features are not available in all states, in all GEICO companies, or in all situations. GEICO is a registered service mark of Government Employees Insurance Company,
Washington, DC 20076; a Berkshire Hathaway Inc. subsidiary. GEICO Gecko® image © 1999–2021. © 2021 GEICO 20_608541397
MAN ON A MISSION:
Albert Bourla,
vet-turned-CEO of
the Fortune 100
pharma company, has
overseen the delivery
of over 50 million
doses of Pfizer’s
COVID-19 vaccine.
FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 9

The
Conversation
ALBERT BOURLA
As the pandemic took hold last spring, scientists at Pfizer set out to, in the words
of CEO Albert Bourla, “make the impossible possible.” Now, on the heels of
achieving just that—developing the world’s first COVID-19 vaccine with breakneck
speed—the leader of the 172-year-old drugmaker talks about the clash of science
and politics, drug prices, and his next impossible task. INTERVIEW BY CLIFTON LEAF

T H I S E D I T E D Q & A H A S B E E N C O N D E N S E D F O R S PAC E A N D C L A R I T Y.

GOING ALL IN ON SCIENCE continue to work with in making


vaccines for other diseases. We had
In early March, 2020, barely a year recombinant proteins, you name
into your role as CEO, you made a it. But my team [led by head of

“This is why near-instant decision to put some


$2 billion of Pfizer’s money at risk to
vaccine research Kathrin Jansen]
went through each technology, and

I was put in develop a coronavirus vaccine. What


drove you to make that giant wager?
said our recommendation is to go
with mRNA, which could be scaled

this position: BOURLA: It was a massive bet, but


it was a very necessary one. There
up very quickly once it was devel-
oped. It’s true that there had been

to be able are not many companies that have


the kind of end-to-end capabilities
no vaccine made before with mRNA
technology—but if we are successful,

to take the in vaccines that Pfizer has—ones that


can start from early research and go
then ours would be the first.
My team wanted to get started

right risk… all the way into not only manufactur-


ing, but also distribution, which is
very fast. And BioNtech [CEO Ugur
Sahin, who had reached out to Jan-

not to be challenging. So the question in my


mind was, “If not us, then who?”
sen in a March 1 phone call] also said
they wanted to do it very fast. So we

conservative There are a slew of proven ways


started investing, and they started
sharing their data with us—without

and not for constructing vaccines, but you


chose to go with mRNA 1 , a tech-
even a contract.

move when nology that had never before pro-


duced an approved vaccine. Why?
The need for speed was one reason
to go with an mRNA vaccine. An-

the world I knew that we were working with


mRNA in flu [through our partner-
other benefit is that you can change
the genetic recipe for the vaccine

needs us.” ship with German firm BioNTech].


We had adenoviruses that we
on the fly—something that may be
necessary as the virus continues to

PHOTOGRAPH BY M
F IA
RCST
K ELN
AZS ITENSATM
REO H
1 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

Your day job, of course, BET WEEN


THE LINES
The current coronavirus variants
that have emerged are causing
is to find solutions at alarm. How effective is Pfizer’s vac-

Pfizer, where you’ve


cine against these mutant strains?
(1) Message
received: We are quite confident right now
been trying to jump-start Unlike traditional
vaccines that use
that we can neutralize these variants.

growth. You’ve projected


We have proved that in the lab—and
part of a disabled this experiment that we did in our
or dead virus to
annual revenue growth illicit an immune own labs has been already replicated
in multiple labs in universities and
will reach 6% soon. That’s
response, these
vaccines use mes- hospitals. Right now we are cover-
well above where the senger RNA to in-
struct cells to make
ing both of the new variants [that
have emerged in the U.K. and South
company has been for a harmless protein
associated with the Africa]. I think the fundamental

the last couple of years . 2


virus—which, in
turn, alerts immune-
question is, What are the chances
that a new mutation that will not
Are you still confident in system defenders. be covered by the vaccine emerges?

that trajectory? (2) Annualized


trailing five-year
Theoretically, it’s a very possible
scenario. If you protect a very big
I’m very confident now. And also, revenue growth:
part of the population, and if there
I want to say the projection is for Pfizer’s strong is a strain that emerges that can use
biopharma business this [vaccinated] pool of population
“at least 6%” revenue growth. The has been dragged to replicate while the current strains
6% is not the ceiling, it’s the floor. down by other units.
cannot, obviously this will overtake
And I’m very confident—excluding BRISTOL-MYERS the original. So it’s not a certainty,
anything coming from the COVID-19 SQUIBB but it is now, I believe, a likely sce-
vaccine—that the remaining nario. But that proves even more the
case for an mRNA vaccine—because
segments of the business will deliver 19.0%
now you can very quickly develop a
these numbers. And to that we need new version of the vaccine that either
to add whatever the final impact adds to the current immunogenicity
of the COVID vaccine will be. We ABBVIE or creates a very different one that
haven’t released any projections for can cover the new mutations as well.
13.2%
that—though I believe on revenues, How quickly is “quickly”?
we will be higher than $3 billion. That will depend on multiple factors.
MERCK One of them, it is the regulatory
framework. But I believe we will be
3.6%
able within two months to have it.
mutate and more variants emerge. And, of course, we would still likely
Exactly. Speed was of the essence JOHNSON & JOHNSON have to manufacture at risk.
and flexibility was of the essence. 3.3%
This was exactly the reason why Speaking of risk, you made a sec-
we’ve chosen this for flu. 3 Flu has ond big bet not to take any govern-
the same characteristics. Every year ELI LILLY ment money to develop the vaccine,
is a different flu. So every year the 3.3% as some of your competitors did.
vaccines that we’re getting for flu The government said, “We can
are different from the year before. ASTRAZENECA finance this.” But when the offer
[With other technologies] each came, I thought a little bit what
takes months to develop. The RNA 0.7% would happen if we take the money
vaccines could disrupt that, because because it was the easiest thing to
PFIZER
you can do in weeks what you’d take. I realized that if the govern-
need months to do in the other 0.3% ment gives you money, there’s no
cases. SOURCE: S&P GLOBAL way that they will not want a seat at
TH E C O N V E R SATI O N — A L B ERT B O U R L A

the table. “How are you going to do (3) Dream team: increase the vaccination rates. And
it?” they’ll ask. “How will you use Before COVID-19, then, if they do that, we may have a
the money? Give us a report.” Within Pfizer and BioNTech period that we are the bottleneck and
were working on
a massive company like Pfizer, we developing a flu we need to produce much more, and
have a lot of bureaucracy to deal vaccine. “Right now, we are preparing for that. We an-
with. I was betting that I would take flu vaccines, in many nounced recently that we are increas-
control, so as the ultimate decision cases, have less ing our expected production this year
than a 50% efficacy,”
maker in the company I would waive says Bourla. With
from 1.3 billion to 2 billion doses.
all bureaucracy. My goal was to say, the success of their
“You talk to me directly. I’m replacing coronavirus vaccine, EVERYTHING IS POLITICS
all governing bodies. I’m making the he expects the
decisions.” But I couldn’t do that if I partners “to bring As complex as the task of making
a vaccine that will
was taking the government money. have almost ultimate and distributing this novel vaccine
I knew that we’ll never be able to efficacy of more has been, you’ve had to deal with
make the impossible possible if we than 90% against something even more challenging
didn’t do that. Keep in mind that we the flu.” over the past year: politics. That
started much later than Moderna 4 , came the moment you suggested
for example. But also we didn’t need (4) Booster bene- your vaccine might be available
factors: Several
the money. I’m sure Moderna needed this past October and you found
U.S. agencies helped
it. Now, if we failed, was it going to Moderna, a much yourself at the center of a bruising
be very painful? Absolutely. But if we smaller company presidential campaign fight.
failed, was that going to be the end of than Pfizer, finance It was a whole different game—com-
Pfizer? Absolutely not. This is why I the development pletely different than what I was
of its mRNA-based
was put in this position: to be able to coronavirus vac- expecting. And let me clarify some-
take the right risk—not to be reckless, cine. The Moderna thing. The October timeline was the
but also not to be conservative and vaccine received one I’d set in March with my team
not move when the world needs us. emergency use when I pushed them to go as fast as
authorization from
the FDA one week
they possibly could. I was thinking
For all the logistical feats you’ve after Pfizer’s. that October is the flu season—with-
pulled off 5 , there has been wide- out even thinking, of course, that
spread frustration with the vaccine (5) From lab to in November we have elections.
rollout in general. What’s gone logistics: Pfizer has Suddenly it became the biggest
wrong? delivered more than political issue. It was shocking when
Look, there are two phases. There is 50 million doses to I heard the first presidential debate
more than 10,000
the phase that I was worried about vaccination points and COVID and the vaccine were
a lot, where Pfizer is sending the around the world. being discussed in political rather
vaccine to vaccination centers in than in scientific terms. This is when
every country that has asked. That (6) By the dash- I made the statement the next day
is our responsibility and fortunately board light: The that some people want us to go faster,
we were able to do that very difficult figure is not an some people want us to do it slower.
estimate. Pfizer
logistical step quite successfully. tracks its actual suc-
I’ll tell you, we’ll go at the speed of
We were able to see almost 99.99% cess rate in shipping science. And so be it. And then, the
6 successful shipments—on time vaccine through a vaccine ended up coming a little bit
without any issues with the qual- real-time dashboard after the November election. And
ity, because we were monitoring the that monitors the now, what for some had been “too
location (by GPS)
temperatures on every single box that and temperature of early,” for others became “too late.”
we sent. But a lot of the countries, each box. Well, what can we do? I tried hard
including the U.S., were not ready to to navigate this political minefield.
distribute those vaccines. They didn’t And one of the reasons why we
have enough capacity in the vaccina- didn’t take the government money
tion centers. I’m sure—and I hope— in the first place was that. Because
that all of them will get their act if you take governmental money,
together. They will change their plans then everything that you do be-
and they will be able to dramatically comes even more politically charged.
1 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 TH E C O N V E R SATI O N — A L B ERT B O U R L A

There’s a new administration in the You began your professional career


BET WEEN
White House and a new Congress. THE LINES as a veterinarian 7 and now spend
Sounds like a good time to push for most of your time focused on hu-
some long-term solution on drug man disease. Has studying animal
(7) Animal spirits:
pricing—an issue that continues to health helped you see things in your
Bourla, who holds
dog your industry. a DVM and a Ph.D., current role that others might not?
Let me first say that I’m a very strong practiced veterinary I believe everything that is a little
believer that reform is needed. The obstetrics at a bit out of the ordinary helps bring
current status quo is not sustain- university hospital different perspectives. As you say,
in Greece for five
able and it’s not desirable. The vast years, specializing in I’m a veterinarian and that lets me
majority of my peers are already in in vitro fertilization, understand the science so I can
this column as well. Everybody says artificial insemina- better communicate with our drug
that we need to make changes. But tion, and embryo development teams. I also worked
transfer.
those changes, I believe, have to have in the animal health group of Pfizer
two fundamental pillars: They need [since spun off as Zoetis], and when
(8) Greek trag-
to be pro-innovation and pro-patient. I moved to the human health side—
edy: “In my city of
There is of course a major debate in Thessaloniki,” says 11 years ago—I realized that Big
the U.S. over drug pricing. But there Bourla, “there were Pharma, at the time, was very much
are two different aspects to drug 55,000 Jews and brand focused. It was the brand
prices: One is the cost of medicines only 2,000 survived that mattered. That was never the
the Holocaust. And
to the system, for example, to Medi- then actually many case in animal health. There, it was
care, the federal budget. The second of them left. So the customer who mattered—it was
is, what is the cost of medicines to eventually, when I the owner and the dog; it was the
individuals—the person who goes to grew up, we had a veterinarian.
community of 700
the pharmacy and has to pay some- Also, I think coming from a small
or 800 people in a
thing out of his pocket? Those two city where we once country like Greece—one with
are very different. The first one [how made up half of the glorious history, but which in the
much the system is paying for medi- population.” current reality doesn’t have a very
cines] represents 12% of the overall big seat at the international table—
health care cost. So by definition, it has brought some perspective. You
cannot be the “big” problem, okay? learn how to fight, [you know] it’s
But when it comes to patients—the not going to be easy. Being Jew-
people who buy their medicines—this ish in a country where the Jewish
is by far their biggest challenge. Be- population was almost extermi-
cause right now, Americans are pay- nated during the Holocaust taught
ing for their medicines as if they don’t me to be adaptive, and to be much
have insurance—even when they more flexible in society so you can
do. They pay a huge amount out-of- survive. My mother was arrested
pocket. That needs to change. Now, to and survived. My father was hiding
move costs out of the patient’s hands, and survived. But it was not the
then someone has to pay, because it’s same with their families. So broth-
not a zero sum. We are willing to take ers, parents, they were extermi-
over a very big part of out-of-pocket nated. That gave me an identity. 8
costs for the patients right now. I The fact that in my career in Pfizer I
don’t say—and I don’t think anyone lived in eight different cities in five
would say—that it’s fair that we take different countries has also made
all of it. But we are willing to take our me appreciate the power of diver-
fair share and even more. But this is sity and how every culture is unique
where the money should go. I don’t and brings things to the table. My
think that the money should go to own experience taught me to be
cover the black hole of federal bud- very sensitive to that. All of that
gets that will grow and grow. But in gave me perspectives that have
any case, we must find a solution and helped me become who I am, and I
we must find it now—this year. think everything helped.
JON RIMANELLI

Founder and CEO, ASX.US

“ W E AR E
D E SI G NI NG
T HE FU T U R E
I N M I CH IG A N.”

Innovation. Resilience. Agility. It’s how Michigan businesses continue


to build the future. Tech companies, engineering talent and innovators
in manufacturing are all coming here for a reason. Our expertise,
talented workforce and proven adaptability are making a difference
now and shaping the future. Join us and make your mark
where it matters.

Put your plans in motion by visiting


michiganbusiness.org/pure-opportunity
We’re here for better.
At Truist, our purpose is to inspire and build better lives and communities. And every day, the pursuit
of better drives us—to empower clients with more choices, teammates with more fulfillment, and
communities with more hope. We boldly believe in the power of what we can achieve together.

Truist.com
Truist Bank, Member FDIC. © 2021 Truist Financial Corporation. Truist, the Truist logo
and Truist Purple are service marks of Truist Financial Corporation.
FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/M A R C H 2 0 2 1 1 5

THE BRIEF BUSINESS. DISTILLED.

EM P LOY M EN T

Is America Giving Up on Working Women?


The female workforce has borne the brunt of COVID-19’s economic devastation.
What will it take to put women’s careers back on track?
BY MARIA ASPAN AND EMMA HINCHLIFFE

PHOTO ILLUSTRATION BY SELMAN DESIGN


1 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

In early 2020, just before the first U.S. employment is likely


to endure beyond the
patient was diagnosed with COVID-19, pandemic’s eventual end.
women crossed a major employment milestone. Women who have lost
jobs or left the labor force
The labor market was booming. Health care, are missing out on future
education, and other service sectors largely retirement and Social
Security income as well as
staffed by female workers were racing to hire current wages and savings.
more people. And for a few shining months in Ultimately, some econo-
mists predict, the crisis
early 2020, government data showed that women will increase the gender
outnumbered men in the U.S. paid workforce. wage gap by five percent-
age points. And women
who try to return to the
Then “the whole house burned the most damage to the labor force in the future
down,” says Michael Madowitz, a Black and Latina women will do so with a yawning
labor economist at the Center for who were already the most hole in their résumés.
American Progress. economically vulnerable. “Whether women
It’s been almost a year since “We’ve lost so much regain their footing in the
COVID-19 closed the schools and ground. It’s astronomi- post-pandemic economy
day cares working mothers rely on cal,” says C. Nicole Mason, depends on whether
for childcare, and battered many of president and CEO of employers recognize the
the service-oriented businesses with the Institute for Women’s reason for those gaps or
majority female workforces. And in Policy Research. penalize women for a
that time, the pandemic has set work- The numbers are shock- reality they had no control
ing women back by more than three ing: 5.4 million women’s over,” says philanthropist
decades—to levels of labor force par- jobs gone since last Febru- Melinda Gates, whose
ticipation last seen in 1988. The re- ary—55% of all net U.S. Pivotal Ventures fund
sulting employment conflagration has job losses in that time focuses on gender equity.
spread across race, age, and industry, period. Almost 2.1 million
from low-paid essential workers to women vanished from the “THERE HAVE definitely
“knowledge” employees in remote- paid labor force entirely. been days where I’m like,
friendly corporate roles—although By September, three work- ‘Maybe I should give up,’ ”
it has, predictably and awfully, done ing mothers were unem- says Julia Pollak, labor
ployed for every father economist for online job
who had lost his job. marketplace ZipRecruiter
Then, early this year and a mother of two
CHANGE IN LABOR PARTICIPATION RATE came perhaps the bleakest young children. Their
1% statistic yet: In December, schools have been remote
the U.S. economy shed since March, so Pollak is
0 a net 140,000 jobs, the scheduling her paid work
first such downturn since around the kids’ Zoom
–1 April. Jobs lost by women calendars. But at least her
account for the entirety job’s flexibility allows her
–2 MEN of that number. While to “make up for lost time
–2.5% individual men became during the day” by work-
–3 unemployed during that ing 8 p.m. to midnight,
period, men as a group when the kids are in bed.
–4 –3.4% gained 16,000 jobs for the “It’s lower-wage women,
WOMEN month. But women as a who have to leave the
–5%
group—especially women house to go to a grocery
of color—lost 156,000. store or a warehouse, who
DECEMBER 2019 APRIL 2020 DECEMBER 2020 The damage to women’s have no choice but to leave
SOURCE: BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS (SEASONALLY ADJUSTED DATA)
THE BRIEF — EMPLOYMENT

the labor force entirely,” women struggle to stay in


Pollak says. “It really is their workforces. Others
mothers who are bearing said they have expanded
the brunt of the crisis.” paid leave or pandemic-era
The fact that moms— bonus pay. Target offered
rather than dads—are the most concrete plan,
shouldering the bulk of saying it is providing all
family obligations became U.S. employees with un-
vividly obvious in Septem- limited company-paid in-
ber, when schools resumed. home or day-care “backup
With classrooms remote, care” through May.
“hybrid,” or some unpre- Telecom titan Verizon
dictable mix, 865,000 offers another potential
women dropped out of the example of how to support
labor force in that month Online ed: When schools started up in September, women essential workers with
dropped out of the workforce at four times the rate of men.
alone—four times the childcare obligations.
number of men who left. When lockdowns closed
“Bringing everyone back it includes child tax credits LaMoreaux, chief HR 70% of Verizon’s stores,
into the house exposed the for low-income families officer for IBM. Beyond the company retrained the
wound of gender inequal- and $25 billion to support expanding some employee 8,000 affected workers—
ity,” says Misty Heggeness, the country’s flounder- benefits, the enterprise- including many women—
a principal economist with ing childcare providers. tech giant is widening to do at-home tele-sales or
the U.S. Census Bureau. The Biden administration eligibility for a “return- other remote jobs. Verizon
“For women with children proposals also include an ship” program that hires allowed some of those
in their households, the expansion of paid leave; and trains women who workers to remain remote
struggle has been real in an increase in vaccine have taken a break from or go part-time even as
a way that women haven’t rollouts, which could help the workforce. “This is not stores reopened—and
experienced for decades.” schools and day-care cen- a sprint,” she says. “This is expanded its paid childcare
Heggeness points out ters reopen more quickly; going to be a marathon for benefits for all employees,
that men—as fathers and and a federal minimum female employees—and offering to reimburse up
business leaders—could wage of $15 per hour, an for their employers.” to $15 per hour and $100
do “a lot more” to take on increase that advocates say But while tech compa- per day.
childcare responsibilities would directly benefit the nies are known for their “For a lot of parents,
and “to actively encour- women of color dispro- rich benefits, the industry this broke their work/
age change in other men’s portionately working in writ large has a shoddy life infrastructure,” says
behavior.” But any systemic low-wage service jobs. track record of hiring Christy Pambianchi, the
fixes will require federal All of these policies are women. Instead, some company’s chief HR officer.
policy, including legislation expensive, of course, and of the biggest private She credits these expanded
that centers on mothers the Democrats’ razor-thin employers of women are benefits with a lower-than-
and the affordable child- hold on Congress will com- retail companies, which normal turnover at Verizon
care infrastructure that plicate President Biden’s largely rely on their work- last year—and says the
would enable more women efforts to enact them. In ers showing up in person. not-insignificant price was
to remain in the workforce. the interim, some private When Fortune asked eight worth it.
President Joe Biden’s employers are trying to of the largest brick-and- “It is expensive,” Pam-
AL SEIB—LO S ANGELES TIMES/GE T T Y IMAGES

proposed $1.9 trillion make a significant, if non- mortar retailers about bianchi says, though she
COVID-19 relief plan systemic, difference. how they are supporting declines to share the exact
would be a good start, “The lasting impacts of their female workers, the cost of Verizon’s pro-
several economists and this are going to be far- response was mixed. Some grams. “But on the other
policy experts tell Fortune; reaching,” warns Nickle said they haven’t seen hand, turnover has a high
expense. And we think

100%
it’s really important that
WOMEN’S SHARE OF THE 140,000 our employees know, and

U.S. JOBS LOST IN DECEMBER


society knows, that we’re
here for them.”
Content by the Buzz Business

CHANGE AGENTS

SAUDI ART STAR

To celebrate Saudi
Arabia’s return to
the Venice Biennale,
celebrated land artist
Zahrah Al-Ghamdi Part of a dazzling new wave of Saudi artists, art fair, has emerged as one of the brightest
created a stunning Zahrah Al-Ghamdi is delighting internation- stars in the fast‑developing art world of Saudi
site‑specific al audiences with her poetic and sensitive Arabia and the Middle East. Exploring the
installation in 2019. meditations on memory, loss, and identity. impact of globalization and cultural change
on traditional lifestyles, and making sensitive
In her sensitive The Venice Biennale had never seen any‑ and imaginative use of natural materials,
and personal work, thing like it. Overrunning the floors, pillars Al‑Ghamdi’s handcrafted work is intensely
Al‑Ghamdi uses and ceilings of an ornate 500‑year‑old personal. She is preoccupied with memory, with
natural materials arsenal, more than 50,000 pebbles, rocks, the passing of time, and with finding meaning in
to explore the lumps of clay, and scraps of burnt leather the past and in her own childhood experiences.
poetics of the past transformed a Renaissance‑era depot into
and the changing a stunning simulacrum of the ancient life‑ “I like my work to be authentic,” she says. “An
nature of village life style of the people of the Saudi deserts. artist’s work should reflect their identity
in Saudi Arabia. and culture. For art to have feeling, an
Evoking the landscape, architecture, artist must put their soul into it. That is
Exhibiting across and culture of village life in Saudi Ara‑ why I use materials related to my culture,
the Middle East and bia, this extraordinary organic artwork, my environment. and the homes and
Europe, she is one of After Illusion, was the creation of Jed‑ architecture of the places where I grew up.”
the brightest stars in dah‑based artist Zahrah Al-Ghamdi.
a new constellation Al‑Ghamdi says that the continuing changes in
of Saudi artists. In recent years, Al‑Ghamdi, who was chosen Saudi Arabia have helped unlock the potential
to represent her country at the 2019 Biennale of a new generation of artists, especially women
Content by the Buzz Business

Q&A

a magical, beautiful place. It used to


be a crossroads of many different
civilizations. I chose to install 6,000
tin cans traditionally used for storing
dates, in many different colors and
sizes. I filled the metal containers
with reflecting mirrors andw various
shades of sand. The idea was to
show how people of different races
Al‑Ghamdi’s work is inspired by the culture and landscape of the desert villages where she grew up. and backgrounds can come together
in this one stunning landscape. I
artists, to express themselves and Saudi Arabia did not make it possible called it Glimpses of the Past.
create works that resonate across society. for me to go professional. Changes
in the art world here have opened What advice do you give to your
A faculty member of the Art and Design vnew doors for me, not only locally, students who are beginning
department at Jeddah University, but even internationally. The Ministry their lives as artists?
Al‑Ghamdi is on a mission to help other of Culture is now developing major I am passionate about teaching art. I
artists find their way in the art world. events and supporting Saudi artists. always try to teach my students that
These changes have made it possible to make art, you need to combine
“New opportunities are opening up for me to make a living from my art. ideas, feelings, and skills.
for creative Saudi art students to Some Saudi students are very shy about
develop their skills, display their What is it like making installations expressing how they feel or think. I see
work, and fulfill their ambitions,” in the deserts of Saudi Arabia? it as a success if I can push my students
she says. “It is an inspiring time I have always wanted to take my art out of their shyness and make them
to be an artist in Saudi Arabia.” pieces outside the walls of the gallery. braver about expressing themselves
This dream became possible with the with their art. I encourage them to
What inspires you most as an artist? Desert X project at Al‑Ula, supported display their work outside college. And
I grew up in southwestern Saudi Arabia, by the Ministry of Culture. Al‑Ula is I teach them that art is limitless.
surrounded by traditional domestic
architecture. All my art reaches back to
the memory of these spaces and that
culture. I am inspired by history, by stories,
and by memories of places related to my I WANT MY ART TO BE
SOMETHING YOU CAN FEEL,
childhood. Identity, loss, and storytelling
are all important to me. I focus on the loss
and extinction of traditional architecture.
NOT JUST SOMETHING YOU
I want my work to inspire intense feelings
and emotions. Like other land artists, I
CAN SEE.
use raw materials such as sand, clay, rock, —
and leather to express my feelings and
bring out strong reactions in the viewer. ZAHRAH AL-GHAMDI,
How is the Saudi art world changing?
ARTIST
When I started out, my art was just a Al‑Ghamdi’s stunning installation After Illusion was
hobby. The arts scene at that time in one of the highlights of the 2019 Venice Biennale.
Room For Days,
and nights, and working... with a view.

BR-21 BELGARD ROOMS


Open Air Office Natural Collection | Gray Tones

Browse, pick and click for your perfect outdoor office with
the new Belgard Rooms portfolio. Simply take our quiz or choose your own
inspiration, then customize and share your ideal design. To start planning your
home addition, visit Belgard.com/rooms and design your outdoor room today.
T-Mobile CEO Sievert
worked side by side with
John Legere, then took
the reins in April.

T-Mobile’s subscriber
base, analysts say there’s
still more opportunity for
Sievert, especially as con-
sumers are only starting
to seek the benefits of 5G
networks where T-Mobile
is well positioned to lead.
“Worst-to-first stories are
rare enough in American
business, but in telecom
they’re almost unheard
of,” longtime industry
analyst Craig Moffett at
MoffettNathanson Re-
search gushes. With lower
prices than AT&T and
Verizon plus a potentially
better network, “that’s a
powerful recipe for contin-
ued share gains,” he adds.
The reason T-Mobile is
considered the leader in
T EL EC O M
5G comes down to airwave
spectrum, the precious

T-Mobile’s New CEO


dad vibe to the party, he but limited commodity
also possesses top-notch of the wireless industry.

Answers the Call marketing chops honed at


some of America’s leading
Thanks to the Sprint deal,
T-Mobile has vast swaths
After taking over from the legendary brands. of underused spectrum in
John Legere in April, Mike Sievert has a plan To be sure, history shows the 2.5 GHz band, which
that following a star exec is is well-suited for send-
to dominate 5G—and dial up big gains. no easy task. Tim Cook has ing speedy 5G traffic to
BY AARON PRESSMAN successfully extended Steve subscribers on the go or in
Jobs’ trailblazing path at homes and businesses. Ver-
IT’S ONE THING to take over from Apple, but whether it’s izon and AT&T don’t have
a successful CEO. It’s quite Craig Barrett taking over anything like it available
another to follow in the footsteps at Intel for Andy Grove or and have been bidding like
of a larger-than-life, brash-talking, Jeff Immelt following Jack mad at the most recent fed-
Twitter-fueled leader like T-Mobile’s Welch at GE (see story on eral airwave auction to try
John Legere, who also happened to the opposite page), the to catch up. But those new
transform the company into the No. 2 Fortune 500 is littered with airwaves won’t be online
carrier and the dominant player in succession stories that do for a year or more.
5G, and quintupled the stock price not go as planned. The challenge is convinc-
C O U R T E S Y O F T- M O B I L E

over his eight-year tenure. But by his And though Legere’s ing sticky cell phone cus-
side the whole time was Mike Sievert, glorious run included tomers at AT&T and Ver-
who as of April won the top job upon adding more new custom- izon that T-Mobile’s 5G is
Legere’s retirement. While Sievert ers than all his competi- enough of a game changer
brings a decidedly suburban Seattle tors combined to triple to switch allegiance. All
2 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE BRIEF — TELECOM

three carriers have mud- increasing responsibilities In 2018 FortuneÕs Geoff Colvin delved into the decline
died the waters with forget- across corporate America, of GE; the article in part spurred Immelt’s book.
table ads so far that in joining IBM’s personal
some cases had to be pulled computing unit for a few
after the ad industry’s years before the lure of the
watchdog pegged them for dotcom bubble drew him
exaggerations. T-Mobile’s to E*Trade in 1998, where,
recent ad starring Bill at not yet 30 years old, he
Nye, the Science Guy, got was named chief market-
dinged for promising the ing officer and helped de-
“most reliable” 5G network, velop the broker’s memo-
while Verizon had to pull a rable Super Bowl ads.
Super Bowl ad claiming its Then came lead marketing
5G network was built for roles at AT&T Wireless in
first responders and drop 2002 and at Microsoft.
its claim it had the “most From there, missing a
powerful” 5G. “hypercompetitive market
Still, Sievert may be like wireless,” he found his mind in 2018; an article I
ideally suited to design way to Sprint’s Clearwire wrote played an indirect
role. He decided to tell
the message that wins unit, and ultimately, in
the story of why he did
the 5G era as firmly as 2012, to T-Mobile. what he did, to own up to
Verizon’s “Can you hear me Sievert helped de- mistakes, distill what he
now?” campaign helped it velop Legere’s “Uncarrier” had learned, and defend
dominate the 3G and 4G strategy that did away himself against criticism
he considers unmerited.
periods. “We’re going to with two-year contracts, He does it engagingly and
create some real FOMO overage charges, and other candidly, emphasizing his
among people carrying annoyances. Loyal custom- successes while admit-
around AT&T and Verizon ers were rewarded with B O O KS ting to errors of judgment
and action. After years
phones,” Sievert wagers. free pizza promotions and
of refusing to criticize
He first learned the “Netflix on us.” T-Mobile, his celebrated predeces-
business sitting at the in fourth place in 2012, HE WROTE sor, Jack Welch, Immelt
kitchen table listening to passed Sprint in 2015 and THE BOOK blames him for leaving
behind messes that had
his dad, a marketing guru is now ahead of AT&T by ON GE to be cleaned up. Yet
for IBM and other com- some measures and aiming JEFF IMMELT OPENS he writes that he called
panies, craft campaigns. to pass Verizon. UP ABOUT WHAT WENT Welch for advice in the
After graduating from “The opportunity we WRONG AT ONE OF financial crisis—a period
AMERICA’S GREAT so traumatic for Immelt
the Wharton School in have in front of us is like COMPANIES (AND THAT that, he reveals, he briefly
1991, he joined Procter & nothing we’ve ever had,” GE TATTOO). planned to resign after
Gamble, where he oversaw he says. T-Mobile’s fast 5G BY GEOFF COLVIN being forced to cut GE’s
brands including Crest already covers where more dividend for the first time
and Pepto-Bismol. The than 100 million people WHY WOULD Jeff Im- since 1938. He confirms
stomach-calming Pepto live and will double that by melt write a book about that he was pushed out of
his troubled tenure as his job suddenly, after a
team sat with the Metamu- year-end. AT&T and Ver- General Electric’s CEO disastrous performance
cil team, leading to some izon cover a tiny fraction from 2001 to 2017? He before a group of Wall
hilarious co-marketing op- of that with their fastest confronts that question Street analysts. He also
portunities, at least inside 5G. Also in Sievert’s sights on page one. “My tenure explains why GE’s famous
had ended badly,” he round logo is tattooed on
P&G’s walls. A T-shirt with is completing Legere’s
acknowledges in the first his left hip.
both product logos read, effort to take on the cable paragraph of Hot Seat: Immelt’s story is not ul-
“With friends like these, market. “It’s a $100 billion What I Learned Lead- timately a happy one. The
who needs enemas?” “P&G industry dominated by ing a Great American hard fact remains that GE
didn’t have quite the same companies customers don’t Company. “My legacy today is a mere remnant
was, at best, controver- of what it was when he
swag game as T-Mobile,” love,” Sievert says. sial … Maybe it would be became CEO. This book is
Sievert jokes now. Sounds like a great better not to write a book his telling of what the hell
From P&G, Sievert won call. at all.” He changed his happened.
2 4 FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE BRIEF

Some buttoned-down Bank of America and


R E A L ESTAT E
bankers could soon share JPMorgan Chase, CRE
his pain. As the pandemic makes up only 6% and 15%

First Bars, Then Banks?


wears down bars, gyms, of all loans, respectively,
hotels, and other busi- according to Morningstar.
COVID has clobbered small businesses— nesses, it runs the risk of But that figure is 38% at
causing a commercial real Buffalo-based M&T Bank
and the ripple effects could create big estate (CRE) tenant crisis, and 37% at Texas’s Cullen/
headaches for lenders. BY LANCE LAMBERT which could put billions of Frost Bankers—which
dollars’ worth of loans in in January conducted its
FLOOR-TO-CEILING, the interior jeopardy. Neel Kashkari, first layoffs in nearly two
of Tattooed Mom is covered president of the Federal decades. Banks like these
in graffiti. The bar, which has been Reserve Bank of Minne- are bracing for defaults: In
open for 23 years on South Street in apolis, tells Fortune that 2020, M&T increased its
Philadelphia, doesn’t stop its hipster CRE is the most vulner- provision for credit losses
patrons from getting crafty. But even able financial sector—with to $800 million, up 355%
with its faithful clientele transition- the potential to cause from the prior year.
ing to takeout, Tattooed Mom has a shock to the system. Any crisis could take
problems that can’t be painted over. “Thousands of small busi- years to brew. Outside of
It’s unprofitable, and sales remain nesses have already or will hotels, distressed sales of
down 70% from pre-pandemic levels. go under … That rolls up commercial property aren’t
Robert Perry says his bar will survive, into the commercial real abnormally high to date.
but many of its neighbors won’t. estate market and rolls up But Greg Gleason, presi-
“Within a one-block radius there are into the banking sector,” dent of real estate private
six restaurants that are already gone,” Kashkari says. equity firm Corigin, says
he says. “Every week you read about Small to midsize banks more such sales loom, as
new closures, and it breaks my heart.” face the greatest risk. At banks and owners unload
vacant assets. Through
2022, analytics firm CoStar
forecasts $126 billion in
40%
BANKS’ EXPOSURE TO COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE (CRE) LOANS
distressed CRE sales, with
CRE LOANS AS A
the total rising to over
% OF ALL LOANS $320 billion by 2025. The
35
outlook could be grimmer
if work-from-home trends
CULLEN/FROST BANKERS M&T BANK
30 outlast the pandemic,
creating trouble for of-
JPMORGAN CHASE WELLS FARGO fice buildings. As of now,
25
75% of companies plan
to use less office space in
CITIGROUP ZIONS BANCORPORATION
20 the future, according to a
Fortune survey of CEOs in
KEYBANK December in collaboration
15 KEY: 10,000 with Deloitte.
Still, Kashkari says the
50,000
FIFTH THIRD BANCORP CRE risks should be man-
10
ageable if banks are vigi-
U.S. BANCORP 100,000
C H A R T S O U R C E : M O R N I N G S TA R

lant about their portfolios.


5 PNC FINANCIAL SERVICES Keep an eye on the vaccine
150,000 rollout, he advises: The
TRUIST FINANCIAL LOANS
BANK OF AMERICA
longer it takes to tame the
0 virus, the more businesses
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400% will close—and the shakier
CRE LOAN ASSETS AS A % OF EQUITY CAPITAL AND RESERVES some banks will look.
CON T EN T F ROM B A SWA RE

TREND 1. Artificial intelligence (A.I.) and


machine learning will accelerate innovation
One of the core facets of AP automation
is the elimination of paper invoices and the
ability to receive quality data electronically. The
once-standard optical character recognition
technology relies on mapping each field from
every new invoice. A.I. and machine learning have
completely revamped that model. Basware’s
SmartPDF AI, for example, uses machine
learning to convert data from PDF invoices into
an electronic format with a high level of data
accuracy and gets smarter over time, making
invoice processing faster and less wasteful
without manual eff ort.

WHAT THE FUTURE


“Transforming an unstructured PDF invoice
into a structured e-invoice, agnostic of lan-
guage, sounds easier than it is,” Andersen says.

HOLDS FOR AP
“In a few years, we’ll move toward increased an-
alytical capabilities leveraging A.I. and machine
learning. But for 2021, a lot of businesses can
make great gains with just the data visibility.”

AUTOMATION TREND 2. E-invoicing legislative mandates will


spread to more regions
Historically, the private sector has instigated
AP automation. But recently, government-
The pandemic has brought AP transformation mandated invoicing standards in places like
into sharp focus, proving that automated Germany and India have increased, and Andersen
expects that trend to accelerate.
payables processes are key for cash flow “Right now, there’s a lot of variance between
management, saving time, decision-making— countries,” Andersen says. “The pandemic is ad-
vancing the conversation about how legislation
and enterprise success. can standardize the AP process and help protect
against tax and IT fraud, among other benefi ts.”

TREND 3. The AP professional’s role will evolve


THE MODERNIZATION AND AUTOMATION OF As automation solutions give AP profes-
accounts payable (AP) was on track to become sionals more bandwidth and data, their role is
“THE PANDEMIC
mandatory in many countries even before the quickly evolving, says Andersen.
HAMMERED HOME
COVID-19 pandemic. But global shutdowns “They’ve historically been operators, in
THAT ORGANIZA-
accelerated AP digital transformation, and com- principle, ensuring things are flowing through
TIONS NEED NOT
panies relying on manual payables processes the system,” he says. “With AP automation,
ONLY FULL VISIBILITY
struggled to maintain operations. they can focus on just the exceptions, freeing
INTO THEIR SUPPLIER
“The pandemic hammered home that orga- them up to help guide the business in terms of
UNIVERSE BUT ALSO
nizations need not only full visibility into their ‘Here’s what’s going on, and here’s where we
TRUE BUSINESS
supplier universe but also true business continuity can improve.’”
CONTINUITY THAT’S
that’s independent of physical office locations,” Specifically, Andersen adds, AP profession-
INDEPENDENT OF
says Klaus Andersen, CEO of Basware, a global als will increasingly need to interpret data and
PHYSICAL OFFICE
cloud-based procure-to-pay and e-invoicing translate it into business analyses, then com-
LOCATIONS.”
KLAUS ANDERSEN solution headquartered in Finland. municate actionable insights to the C-suite for
CEO, Basware AP automation is essential for a success- enterprise success.
ful enterprise, Andersen says—for cash flow And that’s the kind of next-level, data-backed
management, saving time, data-backed decision- decision-making that AP transformation can
making, and more. He predicts three major trends enable—powering the innovation that will help
for 2021. companies thrive in 2021 and beyond. ■
CONTENT FROM PGA TOUR

DURING THE PANDEMIC, GOLF


FACILITIES, SUCH AS TPC SAWGRASS
(PICTURED), IMPLEMENTED HEALTH
AND SAFETY MEASURES THAT
ALLOWED PEOPLE TO CONTINUE
PLAYING THE GAME.

After a partial shutdown,


golf is now on a hot streak.

On the Upswing
GOLF HAS ALWAYS BEEN A GAME THAT REQUIRES, and facilities while communicating to players and
rewards, improvisation and resilience. Even PGA staff that thoughtful, enhanced personal safety
TOUR superstars hit a bad shot once in a while— measures had been enacted. Back2Golf provided
amateurs, a little more often—and part of the three phases of guidelines, reviewed by the Centers
game is learning to shake off a less-than-perfect for Disease Control and Prevention, which included
lie and find a way back toward the hole. Given this limiting cart ridership to a single player, mandating
need for resilience, it’s not surprising that despite social distancing, providing new means of remov-
recent challenges to the world of professional ing balls from cups without touching the pin, and
sports—and to every aspect of our lives—the game more.
of golf has not only survived but also thrived. These efforts proved fruitful, and suddenly, it
seemed, everyone was a golfer, or a golfer in the
Playing Through a Pandemic making. Despite losing two months of play, total
In March and April of 2020, more than half rounds completed in 2020 were up 13% year over
the nation’s golf courses—54%—closed due to year (YOY) through November, according to Golf
the COVID-19 pandemic. But with some foresight Datatech. And per the National Golf Foundation,
and quick action, the game waged an incredible the industry expected to add 500,000 new junior
rally with a widespread reopening in May. The PGA golfers in 2020, a 20% YOY gain. Equipment sales
TOUR helped lead a group of industry stakeholders rose with this tide. Golf Datatech reported that July
on “Back2Golf,” a cohesive framework to reopen 2020 saw almost $389 million in sales, the highest
WE GET TECHNOLOGY
THAT CAN HELP YOU
ADAPT TO ANYTHING.

At CDW, we get that “disruptive” doesn’t begin to


describe the challenges you’re facing today. Even aside
from the shift to large-scale remote work, it’s been an
uphill battle to remain productive. And that’s why just
any old laptop isn’t enough.

Our experts can assess your distributed workforce,


then orchestrate a solution with Dell Latitude 9000
series laptops. Each device is preconfigured to your
unique needs and will learn and adapt to individual users Dell Latitude 9000
with Dell Optimizer — built-in, AI-based software that
analyzes and adjusts critical functions to deliver a more
seamless experience.

We get there’s so much out of your control right now.


But with devices that make your day a little easier,
you’ll have more bandwidth for everything else.

For innovations that keep you productive, you need


TM
Dell Technologies and IT Orchestration by CDW¨.

CDW.com/DellClient
© 2021 CDW® , CDW•G ® and PEOPLE WHO GET IT® are registered trademarks of CDW LLC.
CONTENT FROM PGA TOUR

ever tracked by the organization in a single overall for charity in 2020, despite the truncated
month, while August’s $331 million in sales schedule.
was a 32% YOY increase that surpassed that
month’s prior sales record by $44 million. New Faces, New Numbers
What may be even more remarkable is that Last year also ushered in a compelling wave of
the sport has experienced a boom in popular- young new stars. Collin Morikawa, at age 23,
ity in 2020. When professional play resumed, captured the first major post-shutdown title,
engagement with and consumption of the and his second professional victory, at the 2020
PGA TOUR also experienced a boom. From PGA Championship at San Francisco’s Harding
the TOUR’s first official return event in May, IN MARCH AND APRIL Park, highlighted by a dramatic late eagle to
the Charles Schwab Challenge, through the OF 2020, 54% OF break from a crowded pack. Two other charis-
TOUR Championship in September, broadcast matic young twentysomethings, Matthew Wolff
household ratings on partners CBS and NBC THE NATION’S GOLF (21) and Viktor Hovland (23), also enjoyed great
rose 23%, while cable household ratings on COURSES CLOSED success in 2020, and experts believe each of
the Golf Channel surged 50%—in a year when DUE TO THE these three men will reach superstar status
all other major sports saw decreased ratings.
Average weekly cross-channel engagements on
COVID-19 PANDEMIC. sooner than later.
If the PGA TOUR’s numbers are all up, includ-
television, streaming services, and digital and BUT WITH ing the Q-rating of its rising stars, it is partially
social media increased 52%, with streaming SOME FORESIGHT attributed to the quality of its data. ShotLink
subscribers to PGA TOUR Live rising a whopping AND QUICK ACTION, technology, powered by CDW, has tracked and
68%, with the average user watching 50 min- recorded every single TOUR shot struck, in real
utes more per week. Average weekly PGA TOUR
THE GAME WAGED time, since the technology’s debut in 2001, us-
app and website visits were up 28%, and social AN INCREDIBLE RALLY ing lasers and recently added high-speed video
media engagements were up 68%. WITH A WIDESPREAD cameras around each putting green. The cam-
That golf was visibly, actively engaged in REOPENING era system, known as ShotLink Plus, produces
raising money for the fight against COVID-19 advanced statistics and metrics that promise
likely helped the sport earn additional goodwill. IN MAY. to grow even more focused and specific in the
The industry rallied to support relief efforts to near future.
the tune of more than $40 million via a variety One example on the horizon: ball-in-motion
of undertakings. Among the first and most statistics, which show not only where a ball
high-profile charity sporting events were a pair ended up but also how it got there (by landing
of PGA TOUR–backed televised endeavors fea- on the green before spinning back four feet, for
turing superstars Dustin Johnson, Rory McIlroy, instance). This technology will soon produce
Phil Mickelson, and Tiger Woods, among others. statistics that break down a player’s likelihood
The TOUR, its players, tournaments, and part- of making putts of various lengths, while factor-
ners raised more than $30 million to support ing in their success rates when those putts
COVID-related relief efforts during the sport’s break left to right or right to left. Hard-core fans,
shutdown from March to May; and when the gamers, and bettors want to know everything
TOUR returned, it inspired fans with thoughtful they can about these kinds of details so they
gestures both big and small, such as includ- can engage more deeply with the game, and
ing the names of local frontline workers on the ShotLink Plus will bring them one step closer.
backs of caddies’ bibs (alongside the player’s It’s yet another sign of a game on the upswing.
name). And the TOUR generated $160 million —EVAN ROTHMAN
THE BRIEF FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 2 9

A FEW DAYS after pro-Trump riot- movement and sweat and


E X ERCISE
ers storm Congress, I mount my resilience and tenacity to
trial Peloton bike to let off steam. get us through and process

Can Peloton Keep


Curious about the company’s all of that emotion, okay?”
handling of the chaos, I select a Rigsby sermonizes, legs

Up the Pace? 30-minute “high-intensity interval


training and hill ride” recorded on
whirring in sync with an
electro-house jam.
The fitness-tech company’s Jan. 6, while law enforcement cleared Sweat drips. Endor-
business sprinted ahead the Capitol. I clamp on my clip-in phins course. As I pedal
shoes and join the cycling session’s harder, Peloton—a busi-
during the pandemic. Now it Adonic trainer, Cody Rigsby, who ap- ness I long dismissed from
faces a pack of new rivals. pears on an attached tablet screen. the sidelines as a frivolous
BY ROBERT HACKETT “What we’re gonna do is use luxury—begins to make
sense. Something is bub-
bling up within me—a
frisson. It’s the feeling
that John Foley, Peloton’s
cofounder and chief execu-
tive, refers to when he tells
me he wants his exercise
equipment and classes “to
feel like a warm hug.”
Perhaps no one is feel-
ing more snuggled than
Peloton and its inves-
tors right now. During
the COVID lockdowns
that began last year, the
connected-bike maker
quickly became one of the
pandemic’s biggest win-
ners. Millions of suddenly
O R I G I N A L P H O T O S : C O U R T E S Y O F P E LO T O N ; N I C K V E A S E Y— S C I E N C E P H O T O L I B R A R Y/ G E T T Y I M A G E S

gym-less people scrambled


to satisfy their fitness fixes
with Peloton’s at-home
gear and workout app. In
response, the company’s
shares have soared. Since
going public in September
2019, Peloton’s stock price
has sextupled to $157.14.
But Peloton is about to
face its most challenging
incline yet. With more
people getting vaccinated,
more gyms are poised

Peloton’s exercise
bikes have given it a
major foothold in the
market for at-home
fitness equipment.

PHOTO ILLUSTRATION BY
ARMIN HARRIS
3 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

PEDAL TO THE METAL


In just a few years, Peloton has built an exercise empire, and the pandemic has only helped to accelerate its sales and profits.
Wall Street has taken notice, sending the company’s shares surging despite misgivings from some analysts.

STOCK PRICE GROWTH 510.0% PELOTON QUARTERLY REVENUES QUARTERLY PROFITS Q3 2020
$69.3 M.
500% $700 million Q3 2020 $80 million
$757.9 M.

600 60
400
500 40
300
400 20

200 300 0

200 -20
100
100 -40

0
0 -60

SEPT. 26, 2019 JAN. 25, 2021 2018 2019 2020 2018 2019 2020
NOTE: DATA DISPLAYED AS CALENDAR YEAR. PELOTON FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2020. SOURCES: S&P GLOBAL; BLOOMBERG

to reopen, which could temper the prescient. Both compa- ton’s board after leading
home workout craze. Meanwhile, nies started with pricey, a funding round in 2018,
drafting off Peloton’s lead, a host premium hardware and an should know. An early in-
of competitors, from Apple to ambition to reach main- vestor and longtime direc-
NordicTrack-maker Icon Health & stream customers. The tor of Netflix, he compares
Fitness, are muscling into the market. fortunes of both businesses Foley’s ambitions to those
It’s a pivotal moment for Peloton to soared during the pan- of Netflix CEO Reed Hast-
prove it’s got momentum, that it can demic as poster children of ings. Many peers wrote off
be more than just a stay-at-home fad. a tech rally reminiscent of these founders as “crazy,”
In 2014, a couple of years after the dotcom craze. but Hoag believed in their
Peloton’s founding, Foley and Tom The math of Peloton’s vision, feeling “there was
Cortese, Peloton’s cofounder and valuation—it has a market something magical about
chief operating officer, set up shop capitalization of $46 bil- all of it,” he says.
in a mall in Short Hills, N.J. Situ- lion—is difficult to justify Not everyone is en-
ated near an Apple store and a Tesla unless one believes the chanted. Simeon Siegel,
dealership, the two hoped to tap company will become an analyst at BMO Capital
those brands’ high-end allure while a tech-media titan. Jay Markets, is Peloton’s iciest
enticing passersby. Hoag, a venture capitalist bear. “Humanity, by na-
The Tesla connection would prove with TCV who joined Pelo- ture, is lazy,” he says. Siegel
argues that Peloton’s
market opportunity is lim-
ited: Most people prefer

IT HAS LONG BEEN OUR THESIS THAT FITNESS to plant butts on couches
than glutes in saddles.

IS MOVING TO THE HOME.


JILL WOODWORTH, PELOTON’S CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER
Merciless in his appraisal,
Siegel says Peloton’s stock
is “detached from reality”
THE BRIEF — TECH

and should trade at $33, on workout tech of their FITNESS FIGHT On a mid-January day,
or nearly 80% lower than own. In April, 45-year-old I tour a new Peloton R&D
where it is today. Icon started offering Plan- Peloton is facing off facility that opened as the
Whichever the case, et Fitness’s then 15 million against a growing pandemic struck. Here,
Peloton’s business is grow- members access to iFit, its list of rivals. Here are Peloton tries to improve
ing quickly. The company catalog of streamed fitness some of them. its products and dream up
saw $1.8 billion in sales classes. In June, clothing new types of torture racks
during its fiscal year ended retailer Lululemon paid APPLE for its customers.
June 30, 2020, doubling a half-billion dollars for At one point, cofounder
CEO Tim Cook says
from the year before. Most Mirror, the maker of a Cortese lets me peek in-
Apple’s greatest
of that money came from smart screen for workouts. contribution to man- side a room that contains
selling bikes, which cost And in December, Apple kind will be in health. equipment undergoing
up to $2,500. But the debuted Fitness+, a sub- Apple Fitness+, a testing. Near the door-
company is also focused scription service for online workout app intro- way, a bicycle hooked up
duced in December, is
on adding to its 1.8 million exercise classes. a key part of that push.
to a computer is pedal-
digital subscribers, who Meanwhile, Nike, ing away with no one
pay up to $39 monthly for Under Armour, and Strava ICON HEALTH & in the seat, as though a
virtual classes. are revving up their own FITNESS ghost is riding it. On the
For most of its history, fitness apps. other side of the room,
The fitness equip-
Peloton has hemorrhaged Will any of these, in- ment maker pitches I glimpse something I
money. During the pan- cluding Peloton, have stay- iFit, its eight-year-old doubt I’m supposed to
demic, however, with the ing power after the virus fitness software, as a see. It’s a long-rumored
influx of new customers, subsides? “It has long been Peloton alternative. follow-up piece of equip-
The company plans to
it finally switched gears our thesis that fitness is ment that the company
go public soon.
into profitability—nearly moving to the home,” says has never officially con-
$160 million in the past Jill Woodworth, Peloton’s PLANET FITNESS firmed: a rowing machine.
two quarters combined. chief financial officer. “We When I ask about the
Still, Peloton has found don’t think that’s going The gym franchiser, machine later, a Peloton
which has lost legions
itself on the defensive to abate when COVID of members because
spokesperson says the
lately. During the mad- is over.” of the pandemic, company “often reviews
ness of the pandemic, Foley puts it another beefed up its app in and tests all kinds [of
a spike in customers way: “We sell people ef- April with content tech], but that doesn’t
from Icon’s iFit.
inconveniently coincided fectively a Trojan horse.” mean we plan to pursue
with a crippled supply He means that buyers of LULULEMON
any of those particular
chain. Quarantined ships, Peloton’s equipment get product areas.”
jammed-up terminals, and hooked on subscribing to Known for its athlei- By the time I com-
closed warehouses stalled Peloton’s classes, and are sure wear, Lululemon plete my own post-riot
in June paid $500 mil-
the import and distribu- therefore unlikely to defect lion for Mirror, a
workout, I’m panting and
tion of Peloton’s bikes and to rivals. maker of a $1,500 perspiring. The class is
treadmills from Taiwan, Peloton is extending its wall-mounted device cathartic, and the trainer’s
its main manufacturing hooks too. In December that streams video soothingly anodyne com-
base. Customers, strung it shelled out $420 mil- of vinyasa flows and mentary assuages the
kickboxing.
along and disappointed by lion for Precor, a maker recent terror of insur-
continual delivery delays, of exercise equipment for EQUINOX GROUP rection.
vented on social media. hotels and gyms. That At the end of the ses-
Foley ultimately apolo- business will enable Pelo- The gym chain started sion, pop singer Lizzo
offering $2,500
gized for the problem and ton to follow its devotees croons during the cool-
SoulCycle bikes last
promised to do better. The on business trips and year. Its spin classes down phase, “Baby, how
company expects to clear vacations. Crucially, the are available through you feeling?” I wipe the
its backlog by spring. acquisition also expands Variis, an Equinox- sweat from my brow and
While Peloton whips Peloton’s manufacturing owned app that kick my heels from their
features content from
itself into shape, competi- footprint beyond Asia to Equinox subsidiaries
foot clamps as the chorus
tors are angling to steal the U.S., alleviating some including Blink Fit- arrives. “Feeling good
the lead by doubling down logistical challenges. ness and Pure Yoga. as hell.”
3 2 FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE BRIEF

ingrained part of our lives.”


Besides Amazon, Kalra
has recently bought more
of big tech companies
including Apple, Alphabet,
and Facebook. Those four
stocks, plus Microsoft,
are the “FAAMG” com-
panies, which went on a
tear in 2020 that left them
accounting for almost a
quarter of the market cap-
italization of the S&P 500
by year’s end.
Still, with most FAAMG
companies valued at up-
wards of $1 trillion apiece,
the math just makes it
harder for them to con-
tinue delivering the multi-
bagger returns investors
G LO BA L O U T LO O K strive for. That’s why
growth-oriented investors
are now looking for gains
The Overlooked Tech Portfolio from a younger generation
of companies that are sim-
During the pandemic, investors have flocked to Tesla, Zoom, ilarly promising to change
and the “FAAMG” stocks. But the pros expect a very different the way we live and work,
cohort of market winners in tech this year. BY JEN WIECZNER from finance to entertain-
ment. Starting from a
smaller base than the tech
IF THERE WASanything in 2020 Lippert. giants, these companies in
that went better than expected, It’s a lesson that has the U.S. and abroad have
it was the stock market. Mike Lippert increasingly been borne more potential to get a lot
can attest to that. The manager of the out in the past decade: bigger—but in many cases,
Baron Opportunity Fund remembers Many tech companies have their stock prices haven’t,
feeling in April the bleak dread of proved they are much less shall we say, zoomed quite
recession. Instead, his fund returned sensitive to downturns as much over the past 12
roughly 90% last year—his best than anyone thought, months.
performance to date and perhaps, while any company that’s Indeed, with many tech
Lippert thinks, his best ever. “I am not on a digital trajectory stocks already trading
very realistic that it’s a career year,” puts its investors at risk. at all-time highs, money
he says. Put another way: If you managers are looking past
But Lippert doesn’t owe his out- want to make money in valuations and prizing
size returns to any major dip-buying today’s market, why own solid balance sheets over
back in March, during the blink- anything but technology bargains—particularly as
and-you-missed-it bear market. stocks? “A lot of these risks abound with much
Rather, his best bets had been years technology companies of the economy (notably,
in the making—including stakes in have become the con- travel and hospitality)
Tesla (up 743% in 2020), Netflix, sumer staples of today,” still in tatters. “Pretty
and of course Zoom. “We were says Sonu Kalra, man- much every good company
investing in mostly digital trends, ager of the $48.4 billion trades at a high valuation
and they became must-haves, must- Fidelity Blue Chip Growth today,” says Lippert. Rath-
ILLUSTRATION BY
NICK LITTLE dos during the pandemic,” explains Fund. “They’ve become an er than reshuffling their
The best time for
your organization to
respond to change
is in real time.
Thrive during change with a finance, HR, and planning system
built to provide real-time data, actionable insights, and what-if
scenario modeling. Because in order to thrive in a continuously
changing world, your business must quickly adapt.

Workday. For a changing world.™

© 2021 Workday, Inc. All rights reserved. Workday, the Workday logo,
and “Workday. For a changing world.” are trademarks of Workday, Inc.,
registered in the United States and elsewhere.
3 4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE BRIEF — GLOBAL OUTLOOK

portfolios for an economic recovery four years as corporate valuing it at $60 billion,
in 2021, investors are wagering on spending bounces back. but “you can kind of get
continued growth of innovative com- “I’m not arguing these are this feeling that we’re just
panies (which may still accelerate as cheap companies,” he says, scratching the surface,
the coronavirus wanes). “We believe “but I believe we can make now that this digital rela-
winners can keep winning for a very double-digit long-term tionship has been estab-
long period of time,” says Rebecca returns.” lished,” says Tu.
Irwin, comanager of the PGIM Jen- Alan Tu, manager of the Likewise, Fidelity’s
nison Focused Growth Fund, which $8.8 billion T. Rowe Price Kalra thinks certain quar-
was up more than 67% last year. Global Technology Fund, antine-inspired behaviors
Lippert of Baron Opportunity has which returned more will last even when people
been paring his highest-fliers while than 75% last year, has go back to offices. That’s
building up positions in other stocks been sorting out “COVID why he recently stocked
that have gone relatively overlooked. winners” from what he up on Wayfair (W, $294),
“We love Zoom Video, but they’re calls “COVID impostors”— the online furniture and
not going to grow as fast in 2021 companies whose success decor retailer. “My sense
as they did in 2020; it’s literally will fade with the corona- is that my appreciation
impossible,” he says. Lately he’s been virus. In the winning camp for my house will con-
buying cloud companies, includ- he puts Twilio (TWLO, $393), tinue post-pandemic as
ing Guidewire Software (GWRE, $126), the company behind those well,” he says. Those new
which is digitizing the property and text messages alerting you homeowner habits, shared
casualty insurance industry. Guide- when your Uber is outside, across the white-collar
wire and some other enterprise tech your takeout order is ready workforce, are fueling
companies lagged the sector last for pickup, or it’s time to other changes at Wayfair:
year as their clients put big software vote for your candidate. The e-commerce company
deals on hold. But Lippert thinks Twilio’s stock price more turned its first profit in the
such stocks will thrive over the next than tripled in 2020, second quarter of 2020

MORE ROOM TO RUN


The economy’s most tech-heavy sectors had a blistering 2020, but their share-price valuations aren’t far out of line with
the rest of the stock market.

CUMULATIVE TOTAL RETURNS SINCE JANUARY 1, 2020 S&P 500 P/E RATIOS
INFORMATION
50% JANUARY 20, 2021: TECHNOLOGY
45.5% SECTOR
40 S&P 500
COMMUNICATION
SERVICES
30 S&P 500 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INDEX SECTOR
25.8% 35.7
S&P 500 COMMUNICATION SERVICES INDEX S&P 500
20
30.2
21.5%
10 27.9

S&P 500 INDEX


0

–10

–20

–30

JANUARY 2020 APRIL JUNE SEPTEMBER JANUARY 2021


SOURCES: BLOOMBERG; S&P DOW JONES INDICES. P/E RATIOS BASED ON TRAILING 12-MONTH EARNINGS AS OF 1/19/21
Free Financial Tools
Wealth Management

“Keep abundance in your


thoughts and focus on
financial well-being.”
-Deepak ChopraTM, MD
Founder, Chopra Global

Author Deepak Chopra has a mission to empower


personal transformation. A healthy, abundance-filled
life begins with healthy habits. That’s why he’s working
with Personal Capital to help people reduce stress and
find financial confidence.

Start today by using our powerful, free financial tools


to see where you stand—now, and for your retirement.

Find financial peace of mind.


FREE FINANCIAL TOOLS AVAILABLE ON WEB & MOBILE
Download free financial tools today at
personalcapital.com/fortune

All product names, logos, and brands are property of their respective owners. Featured individuals are paid spokespeople and not clients of PCAC and do not make any
endorsements or recommendations about securities offerings or investment strategy.

Advisory services are offered for a fee by Personal Capital Advisors Corporation (“PCAC”), a registered investment adviser with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Investing involves risk and you may lose money. All visuals are illustrative only. Visit PersonalCapital.com. PCAC
is a wholly owned subsidiary of Personal Capital Corporation (“PCC”), an Empower company. PCC is a wholly owned subsidiary of Empower Holdings, LLC. © 2021 Personal
Capital Corporation. All rights reserved.
3 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE BRIEF — GLOBAL OUTLOOK

A LOT OF THESE COMPANIES HAVE BECOME THE


and has continued the
streak since.

CONSUMER STAPLES OF TODAY. THEY’VE BECOME


Other companies that
survived the pandemic

AN INGRAINED PART OF OUR LIVES.


with minimal damage
will likely also get a
boost as normality re-
turns. Natasha Kuhlkin,
comanager of the PGIM
Jennison Focused Growth the burger joint’s locations describes his focus as “the together, the benefits of
Fund, is fond of Match remain closed. Even if picks-and-shovels way e-commerce are actually
Group (MTCH, $148), which online ordering shrinks to play this, as opposed greater in China,” he says.
owns more than 40 online to half its current propor- to trying to bet on which Besides shopping giant
dating communities serv- tion once people can dine miner will hit gold” by Alibaba (BABA, $265), he’s
ing demographics that out again, “it’s going to be buying pharmaceutical been buying lesser-known
range from Gen Z through 30% of a company that’s companies. He owns Mas- Pinduoduo (PDD, $171),
senior citizens. While growing really rapidly,” says sachusetts-based Repligen a growing e-commerce
roughly 40% of hetero- Chung. (RGEN, $217), whose equip- seller in China’s midsize
sexual couples now meet Underpinning restau- ment is used to produce cities. (Pinduoduo, whose
online (up from 5% two rants’ and other shops’ and test biologic drugs, share price nearly quin-
decades ago), according ability to shift so quickly to as well as Minneapolis tupled last year, in August
to a 2019 Stanford study, e-commerce are the digital firm Bio-Techne (TECH, replaced venerable Silicon
that share is still increas- payments companies. But $357), which supplies Valley data-management
ing. Kuhlkin estimates e-commerce payments are antibodies and reagents company NetApp in the
Match’s revenue grew just one part of the busi- to pharmaceutical labs. Nasdaq 100.)
nearly 20% last year, ness at Square (SQ, $227). “We sometimes call these For a counterpart in
despite the damper that Irwin of PGIM Jennison is compounders,” Chung Latin America, Irwin
masks and contagion excited by the explosion in says. “This isn’t going to favors the region’s largest
put on dating (thanks in use of Square’s Cash App, be the fastest-growing e-commerce player, Argen-
part to new in-app video which enabled people company in the universe, tina-based MercadoLibre
features). There should be to receive their stimulus but we think it’s going (MELI, $1,984), which
even more potential when checks digitally as well as to continue to be a nice, has also built a fintech
romance reverts to being trade stocks and Bitcoin steady growth company business for paying and
a less dangerous under- on their phones. “I don’t for a number of years.” lending that’s flourishing
taking: “We do expect think you’d see us own- For other steady-growth in places like Brazil.
some reacceleration,” says ing a traditional financial tech companies, look T. Rowe’s Tu, mean-
Kuhlkin. institution—they just don’t no further than China, while, is betting on
Eventually, couples will have the growth prospects the only major economy Singapore’s Sea (SE, $233),
want somewhere to go on that really intrigue us,” she that managed to expand a major e-commerce force
dates again, which is one says. in 2020. The pandemic in Southeast Asia that also
reason why Dan Chung, With the world’s gaze on sped up the shift to makes a viral video game
CEO and chief investment vaccines, no tech portfolio e-commerce even more akin to Epic’s Fortnite,
officer of Alger, sees op- would be complete without acutely there, where a lack as well as (what else?) a
portunity in restaurants, technology-driven health of major chain retailers digital payments business
particularly those that care companies. Alger’s combined with a dearth that has taken off during
have leaned into online or- Chung is investing in a of storage space in small the pandemic. There’s a
dering. Digital orders now handful of companies that homes has long neces- reason the NYSE-listed
make up nearly 60% of supply the tools and ma- sitated more frequent stock is now Tu’s top hold-
sales at Shake Shack (SHAK, terials to develop mRNA- store runs—a particular ing, right above Amazon.
$108), where overall sales based drugs, a therapeutic inconvenience given “A company like Sea has
were actually 4% higher in technology rich with heavy traffic congestion elements of Amazon in
the final quarter of 2020 research potential after the and then, the virus, says its earlier years,” says Tu.
than the year earlier—de- success of vaccine mak- Fidelity’s Kalra. “So when Investors would be smart
spite the fact that many of ers like Moderna. Chung you put all those things to own both.
CONTENT FROM LEIDOS

SECURING THE FUTURE OF AIR TRAVEL


Automated and manual pat-downs and false
alarms. But in the near future,
artificially intelligent growing leaps in artificial
security systems are intelligence (A.I.) and
helping aviation leaders automation being pioneered
by companies like Leidos will
fast-track growth also increasingly allow
and innovation. passengers to self-identify
and self-screen, without even
stopping at security check-
FAST, FRICTIONLESS SECURITY points.
solutions that maintain high “Airline leaders are
threat detection while increasingly looking for ways
speeding people and goods to before the pandemic, which Top security providers like to decrease operating costs
their destinations are the has only served to accelerate Leidos are already helping while improving security, just
future of transit. Underscoring this ongoing trend,” says Jim speed up this transition by as passengers are putting an
the industry’s growing push Moos, president of the Civil offering automated passenger- ever-growing premium on
toward smarter airports, the Group at leading technology screening capabilities, accessibility, safety, and
Transportation Security and security provider Leidos. hyper-accurate computed convenience,” says Moos. “By
Administration (TSA) has “Going forward, it will only tomography (CT) image scans leveraging A.I. and machine-
ramped up technology become more important for for baggage scanning, and learning capabilities to quickly
deployments by more than transportation leaders to fully sanitized automated han- screen passengers and
270% since March 2020 alone. embrace digital transforma- dling of antimicrobial trays. optimize productivity, our
“The aviation industry was tion by making travel Innovations like these simplify systems offer all of the pieces
already embracing seamless experiences more touchless, airport traffic patterns and needed to deliver a seamless
and contactless solutions automated, and intuitive.” workflows while minimizing air travel experience.” ■

Transforming global security and detection


SAFEGUARDING PEOPLE AND COMMERCE
Leidos delivers fast, frictionless, and fully-integrated technologies that make travel safer, healthier, and more
efficient. With more than 24,000 products deployed across 120 countries, we offer solutions for aviation, ports
and borders, and critical infrastructure customers globally.

Leidos is securing the movement of people and commerce around the world.

leidos.com/security-detection © Leidos. All rights reserved. An equal opportunity employer/disability/vet.


SPONSORED CONTENT

THE CORONAVIRUS PANDEMIC PLUNGED


America into the worst public health and
Since March, Tito’s has
produced and donated economic crises in living memory. As
more than 1,155 tons businesses large and small shuttered,
of hand sanitizer to
communities across or transformed in record time to stay
the country. afloat, hospitals became overcrowded,
supplies dwindled, and millions of
people retreated to mandated isolation,
corporations in every industry confronted
the enormity of the situation.
This demanded a great deal of
introspection from corporate leaders.
How could they ensure the safety of
employees and customers in this new
world? How could they help their
communities and the people on the
front lines of the pandemic? For many,
it came down to a simple tenet: Do good,
wherever you can.
“When doing good is something that
is ingrained in the culture, something
that the team feels empowered to do,
it’s amazing to watch not only the col-
lective good that comes from that, but
the meaning and purpose it brings to
the team—especially now,” says Amy
Lukken, joyologist and head of philan-
thropy at Austin, Texas–based vodka
brand Tito’s Handmade Vodka.
Across the nation, the philanthropic
responses to COVID-19 have shown
corporate America at its best. In fact,
seven in 10 U.S. corporate funders in-
creased their charitable contributions in
response to the coronavirus pandemic,

LEADING BY
according to a recent report from the
Charities Aid Foundation of America.
From local giving and food drives to
the development of diagnostics and

EXAMPLE
vaccines to pivoting production lines to
make personal protective equipment,
corporate philanthropy and action have
been widespread and agile.
In March, as the world scrambled to
find ways to prevent the spread of the
In 2020, corporate America let its virus, the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and
core values guide its strategy, and Trade Bureau authorized the produc-
tion of ethanol-based hand sanitizers
made a real impact in people’s lives. by permitted spirits distillers. Tito’s
stepped up to redeploy a portion of its
distillery production lines to manufac-
ture a much-needed supply, as well as
to distribute it to communities in need.
To date, the company has donated more
Austin through and through.
1995. After no one would invest in Tito’s idea, he put it all on credit
cards and built his own distillery in this shack on twelve Austin acres.
We’re still in the same spot today.
Rooted in Texas for over twenty years.
SPONSORED CONTENT

ventilators for immediate use in

7 in 10
Central Texas.
Another firm that made a
significant impact in 2020 is
Wesley Financial Group, LLC,
a Franklin, Tenn.–based con-
U.S. sumer advocate that special-
corporate izes in timeshare cancellation
and timeshare debt elimination
funders for individuals and families.
increased Founder and CEO Chuck
their McDowell named the company
for John Wesley, the founder
charitable of the Methodist Church, after
contributions one of his quotes stuck with
in response him: “Do all the good you can,
by all the means you can, in
to the all the ways you can, in all the
coronavirus places you can, at all the times
pandemic. you can, to all the people you
can, as long as ever you can.”
“That quote is pretty much
how and why we do what we
RIGHT: Volunteers do,” McDowell says. “It’s a
from Wesley Financial
Group delivered food personal thing for me, and I try
and toys at the annual to make it a personal thing for
“Christmas on Monroe”
event in Nashville—a than 1,155 tons of hand sanitizer to critical all of our employees too.”
community hit hard frontline workers in 48 states and to the public Putting those words into action, in 2020
by tornadoes and the
pandemic last year.
via community giveaways. McDowell personally donated more than half
“Within the first few days of announcing pro- a million dollars directly to families and local
duction, thousands of organizations reached out churches in Tennessee. And he set an example for
to us in need,” says Taylor Berry, vice president the rest of the company; employees managed to
of brand marketing at Tito’s. “We would call, tell raise tens of thousands of dollars for local chari-
them we could get them whatever they needed, ties and people in need through individual efforts
and then we’d hear joy and relief on the other end and corporate initiatives. Wesley Financial Group
of the line. It was extremely meaningful for our also stepped up its charitable work significantly
entire team to be able to help in that way.” in the wake of the pandemic. The firm took on pro
In addition to a plunge into hand sanitizer bono cases for 114 families to help them get out
production, the company donated millions of of timeshare commitments they could no longer
dollars to nonprofit organizations, like Children of afford. They increased their support of nonprofits
Restaurant Employees (CORE), the United States like the Jason Foundation, Inc., which is dedicated
Bartenders’ Guild, Southern Smoke, World Central to the prevention of youth suicide. According
Kitchen, and the National Restaurant Association to McDowell, supporting the organization was
Educational Foundation, that provided assistance even more important this year because of the
to service industry workers as well as hundreds of widespread depression that has resulted from job
local nonprofits in communities across the coun- loss and isolation. McDowell is also establishing
try assisting with COVID-19 relief efforts. a foundation that will raise money to help small
Tito’s donated $1 million to the Baylor College businesses weather this economic storm, with a
of Medicine to research a low-cost, global vaccine jump-start from a personal donation of $500,000.
for COVID-19, which is currently in phase II of The global pandemic created an opportunity
safety trials in India; gave a $2.5 million grant to for companies to put their core values on display
the University of Texas at Austin COVID-19 Model- for the world to see, and much of corporate
ing Consortium, which is working to help map the America stepped up to the challenge. Now, as
spread of COVID-19 and improve preparedness for we continue to create a path forward, it’s clear
future pandemic threats; and put $400,000 toward that the purposeful leadership spurred by the
funding the development and production of 500 pandemic is here to stay. ■
We Cancel Timeshare for You
Many people believe their timeshares cannot be canceled, but
they often can be. Our founder and CEO, Chuck McDowell, has
successfully fought in federal court for the right to help timeshare
holders — like you — out of their “binding” agreements. Whether
you were misled or pressured you may have an easy exit.

How Does the Cancellation Process Work?


• Start with a FREE consultation to discuss your needs.

• If we see that the circumstances of your agreement qualify


you to exit the timeshare, you’ll be assigned a specialist to Don’t think for another minute
walk you through gathering documentation. that you are stuck with this.
What we do is help you cancel
• Our Resolution Department then works quickly to have your your timeshare along with all of
timeshare and related fees permanently terminated. the debt and fees associated
with it. Guaranteed.
Rest assured that you will pay nothing if we don’t successfully
cancel your timeshare.

We are able to help most timeshare holders that contact us. You
could be one phone call away from complete peace of mind. Chuck McDowell
Founder & CEO

Get your free information kit and see if you qualify:

CALL 855.705.0223
or visit www.WesleyFinancialGroup.com

“Wesley Financial delivered on everything they promised.


The feedback, customer service and prompt attention was amazing... Based on over 450 reviews
I would highly recommend them to anyone!”

-Mark & Vickie—Wesley Financial Group, LLC clients


4 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

COLD-
I
N LATE 2019, TALKS WERE BREWING in Berlin over a multi­
billion­dollar deal so secret it needed its own code name—
one that evoked the cloak­and­dagger espionage of the
city’s old Communist days: Project Anushka. “Everyone

BLOODED
thought it must be related to Russia,” says Axel Vogel,
Minister of the Environment for the state of Brandenburg,
L I E S A J O H A N N S S E N - KO P P I T Z— B L O O M B E R G / G E T T Y I M A G E S

home to the German capital.


As it turned out, no Russians were involved. Instead, in
November of that year, Germans finally learned who was behind
ELON MUSK IS NOT ABOUT the biggest investment the country had seen in decades: none
TO LET A FEW ENDANGERED other than Elon Musk.
REPTILES THROW A WRENCH “We’ll see you more often in Berlin,” Musk gushed that No­
vember night as he took the stage to accept an industry award,
INTO TESLA’S PLANS FOR A
and then stunned the audience by announcing a massive new
GERMAN GIGAFACTORY— factory in the city. “I love Berlin. It’s great!”
AND EUROPEAN DOMINATION. Project Anushka was a reference to an old Soviet biplane
in which German officials had whisked the Tesla CEO over
BY VIVIENNE WALT the proposed site for the company’s newest Gigafactory. The
flyover was an edgy, stylish touch aimed at winning over an
GO BIG OR GO HOME: Tesla’s massive new Gigafactory going up in Grünheide, Germany, sprawls over more than 4.8 million square feet.

exec known for his edgy style. “Giga gest by far in Europe, and one of the Yet not all locals were thrilled.
Berlin” as Musk calls the factory, will biggest in the world,” he says. Public hearings in October drew an­
be the living embodiment of that No less important is the flood of gry testimony, with a transcript that
persona. “It will be cool and fun,” he new jobs the factory will bring to runs to 1,233 pages. Tesla’s fourth
told Fortune in a long interview in the region, beginning with “at least factory, after California, Nevada,
late January, wherein he laid out his 20,000 people,” he says, and rising and Shanghai, sits on 750 acres in
vision for a huge push into Europe. over time to about 50,000 hires. Grünheide, an exurb of Berlin with a
“I’m aiming to have it be a real gem.” But as Musk has learned, the population of 9,000, amid pine trees
German officials had strong mo­ smallest of details can complicate local authorities planted in the 1940s,
tivation for wooing Musk: His plan the biggest of deals—and trip up hoping to sell them as lumber. Vogel
is epic. In a largely forgotten area of even a man who has sent rockets says the area is now home to “people
former East Germany, about 20 miles (and his company’s stock price) into who want to spend quiet retirement
from the capital, Musk is racing to the stratosphere. or raise their children in natural ar­
finish a vast facility capable of turning As construction began on the fac­ eas,” many of whom feel their lifestyle
out, beginning as early as this sum­ tory last June, many living nearby is “threatened” by Tesla’s arrival.
mer, European­built Teslas—at a pace expressed huge excitement that one But the greater threat has been
he expects will reach 500,000 cars a of the world’s most valuable compa­ to creatures far less visible: two
year by 2023. Musk also plans to add nies had handpicked their backyard endangered species, the sand lizard
a battery factory that will be “the big­ to launch its big move into Europe. and the smooth snake. For decades,
4 4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

MUSK’S WILD LIFE: An endangered sand lizard (left). Musk holds court with journalists outside the Gigafactory site in September.

the animals have burrowed in the For all the controversy, there ap-
woodlands around Grünheide, an in- pears to be no stopping Tesla’s Giga-
creasingly precious respite from the factory. “The total investment is very,
encroaching human world. Imme- very substantial,” Musk says. “And we
diately after Musk’s 2019 announce- will continue for quite some time.”
ment, environmental groups sued Tesla’s building application estimated
Tesla for endangering the reptiles, as the factory construction would cost
well as the rare western barbastelle a billion euros. And for politicians,
bat. All are protected under strict the influx of new jobs is crucial for
nature conservation laws, which pro- a region that suffered a disastrous
hibit construction that might harm brain drain after the collapse of Com-
listed wildlife. Musk admits he was munism. “Almost a whole generation
amazed there were reptiles on the left from East to West,” Branden-
site. “I think this is not a fun place for burg’s Economic Affairs Minister
a snake or lizard,” he says. “They will Jörg Steinbach tells me. Thanks in
be very, very cold. Frozen!” part to Tesla’s arrival, he says, “we are
In February of last year, a court turning the wheel around 180 de- vantages,” says Christiane Schröder,
order mandated that Tesla suspend grees.” Musk says he intends to make managing director in Brandenburg
building until it had a plan to save the the factory a tourist site, a “beautiful” for the Nature and Biodiversity Con-
wildlife on the land and relocate the tech showcase heavily powered by servation Union, one of the organiza-
lizards and snakes. Tesla offered to wind and solar. Being on the edge tions that sued Tesla for endangering
plant three times the number of trees of Berlin is crucial, he says, to luring the animals.
it was planning to obliterate, but the thousands of top engineers: “We are Rescuing the reptiles from Tesla’s
legal challenges persisted. In Decem- recruiting from across Europe.” bulldozers has required months of
ber Tesla was twice ordered by judges But to environmentalists, offi- painstaking planning. “It is very, very
to stop felling trees, because it could cials have simply traded nature for difficult,” says Jens Frayer, a profes-
kill reptiles still alive on the site. As of business interests. “They saw all the sional lizard catcher for German
late January, work was continuing. advantages and ignored all the disad- conservation company Natur und
Text, which is searching for animals
living on the company’s land.
Even in the best of times, Germa-
ny’s indigenous Coronella austriaca
MUSK’S EUROPEAN TOUR snakes and Lacerta agilis lizards
Tesla dominates the worldwide electric-vehicle market, with about 18% of total sales.
But the company’s primacy is slipping in Europe.
wage an all-out battle against the
elements. Those that survive the cold,
wet weather are often eaten by crows;
NEW REGISTRATIONS FOR ELECTRIC* PASSENGER CARS IN WESTERN EUROPE an eight-year life span is rare. These
ANNUALIZED are hardly the best of times. As Tesla
VOLKSWAGEN 173,402
began its frenzied build-out, so Frayer
150,000 scrambled to save the reptiles, a task
135,111
he says requires immense patience
and well-honed skills. “Both the
RENAULT/
NICOL AS ARMER—PICTURE ALLIANCE/GET T Y IMAGES

NISSAN/ TESLA snakes and the lizards have camou-


100,000 MITSUBISHI/ flage,” he says. “First we have to train
96,018
96,362
people to see them. And then we have
to train people to catch them.”
69,564 The railway tracks on Tesla’s land,
50,000 HYUNDAI/KIA PSA which sit atop piles of small rocks,
42,618 are a favorite and frustratingly effec-
40,115 tive hiding place for the creatures.
“The snakes can hear and feel when
DAIMLER
BMW
you’re near,” Frayer says. “You will
0
never see them.” In the end, the
2019 2020 2021 team built black plastic boards to
* WITHOUT SECONDARY SOURCE OF PROPULSION SOURCE: SCHMIDT AUTOMOTIVE RESEARCH, 12-MONTH MOVING AVERAGE, 18 NATIONS COVERED
T I T L E — C AT EG O R Y

“AN EMPTY PLAYING FIELD. NOW


TESLA ENTERED THE EU AGAINST
soak up the sun, coaxing the animals
out as they searched for warmth.
After 28 days of work, the team of
four trackers caught just 17 lizards

THE COMPANY HAS COMPETITION.”


and 14 snakes.
Dozens are still hiding. “We don’t
know how many are still there,”
Frayer says. “We will have to con-
tinue in the spring.”
By then, Musk says, the factory
will be almost ready to roll out its
first German Teslas—engaging in says Matthias Schmidt, an industry properly seeing to their needs.” Birgit
its own high-stakes battle against analyst in Berlin. “Now they have Dietze, Brandenburg director for the
the country’s cherished auto indus- much greater competition.” IG Metall industrial union, which has
try. German automakers, including Musk insists he is delighted by the 2.4 million members, says she expects
BMW, Daimler, and Volkswagen, growing rivalry. “The mission of Tesla Tesla to abide by Germany’s labor
together produce about 5 million is and always has been to accelerate laws, including a minimum of 24
vehicles a year and hire more than sustainable energy,” he says. Even vacation days a year and guaranteed
800,000 people, representing the so, to maintain its position as the overtime pay.
country’s single biggest industry. world’s leading electric-car maker For all that, Musk sees a key op-
Taking on that entrenched power- (now controlling about 18% of the portunity in the EU’s single market of
house will not be easy, even for Musk. global market), Tesla will need to win about 450 million people. He says he
So far, Tesla has benefited from the in Europe. Musk believes that long- will also open a car-design center in
slowness of German competitors to term success requires a stronghold in Berlin, tapping into the country’s deep
electrify their fleets en masse. But in North America, China, and Europe. experience. “The best cars are made
2020, Volkswagen finally sold more Without all three, he says, “you simply in Germany. Everyone knows that,” he
battery-powered vehicles in Europe cannot achieve economies of scale.” told the Berlin audience that night in
PAT R I C K P L E U L— P I C T U R E A L L I A N C E / G E T T Y I M A G E S

than its upstart competitor. While Also ahead are likely battles with 2019. He went on to recall the skepti-
Tesla’s software capabilities remain the powerful auto unions. Under cism when Tesla launched in 2003 as
superior, the Germans have spent de- German law, union officials occupy the world’s first maker of all-electric
cades building out giant factories and seats on auto companies’ supervi- cars. “Everyone thought we were huge
delivery systems, which Tesla is now sory boards—a jolting contrast from fools,” he said, laughing. “I thought we
creating there from scratch. What’s the U.S., where Tesla has fought off were fools too, frankly.”
more, the old-style automakers are workers’ attempts to unionize. Today, no one is laughing. Begin-
under increasing EU pressure to shift Musk seems reluctant to change his ning this summer, sleepy Grünheide
away from fossil fuel. “Tesla did a ter- stance at Giga Berlin. He says workers will bring another huge expansion to
rific job entering the EU market, but would want to unionize “only if we are Tesla. Less clear is whether the lizards
it was against an empty playing field,” doing something wrong and I am not and snakes will fare as well.
CONTENT FROM MOODY'S

DK Bartley
Chief Diversity Offi cer
Moody's

MAKING DIVERSITY
A pivotal moment for the global risk assessment
firm Moody’s took place at a companywide town
hall meeting following the racial unrest this past

AND INCLUSION spring. One of Moody’s Black managing directors


shared her own story about having “the talk” with
her children. While she had achieved a great deal of

A BUSINESS success at her job, she said, it hadn’t insulated her


and her family from the dangers of systemic racism
in America.

IMPERATIVE “I think it opened up a lot of employees’ eyes,”


says DK Bartley, Moody’s chief diversity officer. “At
Moody’s, we provide a safe space and see each other
How Moody’s is listening, as equals. But the minute you step [outside these]
doors, society may not care if you work at Moody’s.”
looking forward, and adapting The solutions to the complex racial challenges
facing this country are neither simple nor quickly
in order to thrive. achievable—and the first step toward making real
progress is acknowledging that. At Moody’s, an
understanding of the nuances involved has led to
a multipronged, ongoing effort to promote greater
diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). This work is
FOR MOST BLACK PARENTS, HAVING “THE TALK” motivated both by a sincere desire to do the right
with their children about how to interact with thing—and an understanding that it’s a necessity
police officers is an unfortunate, yet necessary, for responsible business.
coming-of-age moment. It doesn’t matter where According to Jinny Jeong, manager, Chief
you live, what your job is, or how much money you Executives for Corporate Purpose (CECP), 2019
make. While Black families have been dealing with data from CECP’s Giving in Numbers 2020 Edition
this issue for years, the killings of George Floyd, report shows that 93% of companies say that their
Breonna Taylor, and Ahmaud Arbery last spring measurement practices for DEI were either steady
brought the issue to the forefront for millions of or on the rise. When CECP asked similar questions
other Americans on a scale that no one—including in a pulse survey of affiliated companies in spring
businesses—could ignore. of 2020, 73% of companies said that they expect
CONTENT FROM MOODY'S

their DEI budget for next year to increase. These numbers are proof (MLT) Black Equity at Work Certification, which provides an objec-
that Moody’s mission reflects a larger trend in the corporate world. tive third-party assessment of employers’ efforts to move toward
But Bartley stresses that Moody’s efforts also address an even bigger achieving Black equity.
picture. The MLT certification road map helps companies achieve the
“For us, diversity and inclusion are a business imperative. It’s not same results-oriented success in Black equity as they do in other
just something that’s nice to have; it is a must-have,” he says. “We aspects of their business. Focusing on the three P’s—People,
want to show our authentic commitment to advancing Black culture, Purchasing, and Philanthropy—the program provides actionable
and show how focusing on Black talent is an asset to our organiza- benchmarks, best practices, and insights that companies can use
tion globally.” to achieve genuine racial equity across all levels of their corporate
To Bartley’s point, Moody’s has partnered with the Executive structure.
Leadership Council, the premier organization for developing Black “As we go on this journey, we’re providing a level of transparency,
executives in America, to launch the Raymond McDaniel Scholar- and putting a level of certification around it, to say what you’re doing
ship Program for college students. The five-year, $1 million program, is the gold standard,” says Bartley.
named for Moody’s recently retired CEO, will offer recipients an For Moody’s, supporting Black employees is a cornerstone of its
internship at Moody’s beginning their sophomore year and, upon effort to support diversity and inclusion among everyone who works
graduation, a job that allows them to rotate between different sec- for the company. For example, the Raymond McDaniel Scholarship
tors within the company. After two or three years, they will be evalu- Program can serve as a model for future DEI-related initiatives that
ated for a permanent role. will improve the company’s talent pipeline among other underrepre-
This program will help young Black talent find professional op- sented groups, such as women, veterans, and people with disabili-
portunities at Moody’s—and it will also help Moody’s find promising ties, as well as in the LGBTQ+ and Latinx communities.
and diverse new talent. The hope is that when scholarship recipients “There is this very continuous, purposeful, and engaging con-
return to their campuses, they will tell their peers about the culture versation around not just the Black experience but diversity at all
of inclusivity at Moody’s, which will help diversify Moody’s applicant levels,” Bartley says. “DEI is in our corporate DNA.”
pool in the future. As a company built on data and analysis, Moody’s is used to
Moody’s also understands the importance of community initia- finding objective, actionable ways to address complicated issues.
tives. In June, the company announced a $1 million commitment to Corporate DEI is no different.
support equal justice and the advancement of Black communities “Just like we train employees on a skill set or a methodology,
over the next five years. The effort was launched with a $100,000 we’re training them on diversity and inclusion,” Bartley says. “We
donation to the Equal Justice Initiative (EJI), which is committed to believe that by doing that consistently, we will deliver exponential
challenging racial injustice in the United States. And to ensure that benefits.” ■
Black voices within the company are heard, donations will be made in
consultation with Moody’s Black Inclusion Group.
Additionally, Moody’s has joined some of the world’s largest com-
panies as a participant in the Management Leadership for Tomorrow

In 2020 Moody’s Black Inclusion Group (B.I.G) hosted a series of events to


educate employees and celebrate Black History Month.
FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 4 9

WHAT

HERE’S WHAT’S AHEAD FOR BUSINESS, FOR THE ECONOMY,


AND FOR THE BATTLE AGAINST COVID-19.
T H E EC O N O M Y C Y B E R S EC U R I T Y BANKING THE HEARTLAND

TAKING THE THE HACK TURNING HAWKEYE


LEAD AT THAT SHOULD THE WELLS HEARTBREAK
TREASURY CHANGE STAGECOACH Iowa was already stagger­
Former Fed chair Janet EVERYTHING AROUND ing from a combination
Yellen has an ambitious of COVID­19 and political
After the massive Wells Fargo CEO Charlie
agenda at the Treasury discord when a massive
SolarWinds breach, the Scharf believes that the
Department. A look at storm tore across the
U.S. needs a new approach beleaguered bank is ready
her top priorities. state, leaving devastated
to untangle its cyber­ to leave its troubled history
PLUS: Meet the rest of farms and communities
security mess. Here are behind. Investors have
the Biden team’s new in its wake. What will it
four ways to fix the system. their doubts. PLUS: The
economic power players. take to rebuild?
outlook for big banks.
5 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

WHAT COME S NEXT BY B RIAN O’KEEFE

Coping With the New


Normal. Are you feeling
optimistic, or anxious?
If the answer is ‘both,’
you’re ready for 2021.
You’ve heard the phrase roughly 10,000 times comes next—for business, the economy, and our collec-
by now. There’s no doubt the expression has been pop- tive battle against COVID-19—is more urgent than ever.
ping up in your inbox regularly. It’s very likely, in fact, that And the key to understanding may lie in this insight: After
you’ve said it yourself more than once: “The New Normal.” the turmoil of the past 12 months, some things are now
Sure, it’s catchy and alliterative. And it taps into the permanently New; some things are still Normal; and the
sense of dislocation that we all feel after a year of uncom- challenge is to recognize and navigate between the two.
mon upheaval, sacrifice, and, for many, forced isolation. For a case in point, look no further than the election
But what, exactly, does it mean? of President Joe Biden. He’s a lifelong centrist, a self-
“There is this almost religious fervor with which we talk consciously traditional pol who might as well have “Normal”
about the new normal,” says Amy Webb, the founder and silk-screened on his hygienic face masks. But the fact that
CEO of the Future Today Institute, a management con- the Democrats now have narrow control of both houses of
sulting firm. “And I’ve been curious for a while now: What Congress for at least the next two years is undoubtedly New:
is driving us to seek that out? And I don’t actually think It’s a power shift with ramifications for Wall Street, global
the answer is that people want to know what the future trade, and our relationship with China. That it follows the
is so they can plan for it. I think, instead, that desire to most contentious election in contemporary times, marked
know the new normal is really our collective desire to have by the outgoing President’s desperate attempt, through
things stop changing so much.” misinformation, to reverse the results of an election he lost
The psychological imperative to slow down and normal- definitively, only adds to our anxiety about this New moment.
ize the path forward is a perfectly understandable response The reboot in Washington is absolutely top of mind for
to the jarring turbulence of the past year. Most disruptive Ian Bremmer’s clients. The founder and president of the
of all, of course, has been the SARS-CoV-2 virus, which has Eurasia Group, a political risk consulting firm, says that
already infected some 100 million people around the world every customer wants to know, “How different is Biden?
and taken the lives of more than 2.1 million. The pandemic How much can he govern? Is the U.S. actually facing some
has exacted an enormous economic toll, but it has also ac- structural challenges that are deeper than we thought?”
celerated the development of new technologies and trans- Wall Street appears to be betting that life under Biden
formed the dynamics of how we work and live, introducing will be the best kind of Normal. From Election Day through
variables that are hard to predict long term. Biden’s inauguration on Jan. 20, the S&P 500 rose 14.3%.
As much as we might like to hit “pause,” however, it’s not In fact, the Biden boost was more than twice as strong as
really an option. If anything, the need to understand what the Trump bump from four years ago, when the S&P rose
FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 5 1

6.2% in the same span. For now, it seems the market is


shrugging off any concerns about onerous new regulation THEY’RE BIGGER;
or tax increases. Meanwhile, it almost appears as if the big
banks are competing to issue the most bullish GDP fore-
WE’RE BITTER
ONCE A SOURCE OF PRIDE, THE ROARING GROWTH OF
cast: JPMorgan Chase predicts the U.S. economy will grow
TECH’S “BIG FIVE” HAS BECOME FOR SOME A SYMBOL OF
5.8% in 2021. Morgan Stanley sees 6.4%. And Goldman ECONOMIC INEQUITIES AND AN UN-LEVEL PLAYING FIELD.
Sachs is forecasting 6.6%. That’s a lot of pent-up demand, a
belief that consumers will get Normal with a vengeance.
BIG TECH AS A SHARE OF THE S&P 500 INDEX
Much of the confidence, of course, stems from the early
5 COMPANIES’ AGGREGATE: 23.1%
rollout of highly effective vaccines—developed, in a New 25%
way, at record speed—to counter COVID-19. (For insight
into Pfizer’s successful effort, in partnership with BioNTech,
see “The Conversation” in this issue.) After a bumpy start, 20
the vaccination distribution effort in the U.S. is picking up FACEBOOK
speed, even as the virus mutates and becomes more infec-
tious. President Biden first announced a goal of distributing 15
100 million doses of vaccine in his first 100 days in office; by
late January, he was pledging the U.S. would have enough ALPHABET
doses for 300 million Americans by the end of summer. 10
In international relations, the New Normal may in fact AMAZON
resemble the Old Normal. The Biden administration will
move quickly to smooth over ruffled relationships with 5 MICROSOFT
key allies. A return to a less disruptive style of diplomacy
in trade negotiations and the restoration of a globalist
mindset in the White House add up to a predictability APPLE
0
that business can embrace. 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 ’21
Still, there are stiff challenges ahead: The pandemic SOURCE: BLOOMBERG
has only deepened and highlighted the problem of income
inequality in the U.S. And it has further disrupted the eco-
system of business, as thousands of small enterprises have 1-YEAR RETURNS FOR TECH STOCKS
closed even as corporate behemoths, particularly the tech APPLE 81.2%
giants on which we’re increasingly dependent, have surged.
AMAZON 76.9%

Technology has been our salvation as we’ve MICROSOFT 40.6%

muddled our way through the pandemic. During lock- ALPHABET 29.2%
downs, it has allowed us to Zoom with colleagues, to binge- FACEBOOK 27.6%
SOURCE: BLOOMBERG
watch, to shop our looks online, and to socialize in isolation. S&P 500 INDEX 19.1% (TOTAL RETURNS FROM 1/24/20 THROUGH 1/25/21)
But to many, this New doesn’t feel Normal. Regulators,
elected officials of both parties, and consumers are getting a
little uncomfortable with Big Tech’s heft and sway. In Janu- AMERICANS’ OPINION ON TECH FIRMS
ary, a Fortune and SurveyMonkey poll found that 64% of OPINION ON CONSOLIDATION AMONG TECH FIRMS
U.S. adults would like to see the federal government investi- NOT SOMEWHAT VERY DON’T KNOW/
gate at least one large tech company for antitrust violations. CONCERNED CONCERNED CONCERNED NO ANSWER
18% 26% 41% 15%
(Google and Facebook are already on the docket.)
Bremmer believes that the actions of the social media
companies to “deplatform” President Trump in his final,
dark days in office add an unexpected dynamic to the RESPONDENTS WHO SAY THESE COMPANIES SHOULD BE BROKEN UP
debate. In the eyes of Republicans, he says, tech regulation FACEBOOK 35%
is now a partisan battle. “The tech companies are suddenly AMAZON 27%
all in on the Democratic side, whether they like it or not,”
ALPHABET 24%
says Bremmer. “I can’t remember a time when the most
APPLE 22%
important companies in the U.S. economy were going to be
in such a partisan battle with one political party.” It may not MICROSOFT 19%
be Normal, but it’s definitely New. NONE OF THEM 45%
SOURCE: JANUARY 2021 FORTUNE/SURVEY MONKEY POLL
5 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

WHAT COMES

JUSTIN CHIN—BLO OMBERG/GE T T Y IMAGES


W H AT C O M E S N E X T

THE ECONOMY

NEXT BY NICOLE GOODKIND

The Most Prepared


Woman in
Washington
T R A I L B L A Z I N G T R E A S U RY S E C R E TA RY JA N E T Y E L L E N I S R E N O W N E D A M O N G P E E R S FO R
H E R M E T I C U LO U S R E S E A R C H A N D R E L E N T L E S S FO C U S . A S T H E B I D E N A D M I N I S T R AT I O N ’ S
EC O N O M I C P O I N T P E R S O N , T H E FO R M E R F E D E R A L R E S E R V E C H A I R I S N O W C H A R G E D W I T H
S TA B I L I Z I N G A N D S T I M U L AT I N G A N EC O N O M Y R AVAG E D BY T H E PA N D E M I C . A N D T H AT ’ S
J U S T T H E B EG I N N I N G O F H E R A M B I T I O U S AG E N DA .

Janet Yellen is an icon waiting to happen. she’ll be a business-oriented leader at Treasury and a
With her signature silver bob, single-strand pearl neck- friend to markets. That confidence is only bolstered by the
lace, and seemingly infinite supply of jewel-toned jackets fact that Yellen collected more than $7 million in speak-
(collar popped, always), it’s easy to imagine the new ing fees from the likes of Goldman Sachs and hedge fund
Treasury secretary’s image emblazoned on T-shirts and Citadel since leaving the Fed two years ago—a revelation
her silhouette outlined on inspirational Instagram posts. that stirred a bit of controversy among Democrats.
She’s a natural fit as an emblem of the #Girlboss move- Progressives like to think of Yellen as an advocate for
ment that has so finely boiled down modern feminism underrepresented Americans. They see her as someone who
into a shallow yet marketable vestige of unadulterated will push for a higher minimum wage, more regulation of
capitalism—a conceit used to describe the relentless shadow banking, and new legislation in the mode of Dodd-
rise-and-grind schedules of business leaders like Marissa Frank to protect consumers. To liberals, Yellen is someone
Mayer and Sheryl Sandberg, and to help sell “Notori- who will at last put the guardrails on Wall Street.
ous RBG” merch to young women. Yellen’s Q score with But no matter what persona is projected onto Yellen—
Gen Y should soon be on the rise. feminist hero, Wall Street savior, progressive darling—the
On Wall Street, meanwhile, Yellen is seen as a known magnitude of her new day job dwarfs all of them in conse-
quantity. The former Fed chair is someone who doesn’t quence. As Treasury secretary, she is running point for the
make surprise decisions—who says what she’s going to Biden administration’s efforts to stabilize a teetering U.S.
do and then does just that. Big Finance is optimistic that economy that has been rocked by the COVID-19 pandemic.
5 4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

FEDERAL DEBT HELD BY THE PUBLIC AS A SHARE OF GDP FEDERAL FUNDS TARGET RATE
150% 7%

GREAT COVID-19 6
RECESSION PANDEMIC
5
100
4
JAN. 21, 2021
3 0.25%

50
2

PROJECTED
1

0 0

1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2001 2005 2010 2015 2020
SOURCE: CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE SOURCE: FEDERAL RESERVE

Her decisions over the next few months will have a pro- mountain range of firsts. Yellen was the only woman in her
found impact on how quickly the economy can rebound. class to earn an economics Ph.D. at Yale University, and she
The challenges facing Yellen and the rest of President was then (for quite some time) the sole female economics
Joe Biden’s economic team are daunting. Though the U.S. professor at Harvard University. She served under Presi-
unemployment rate has fallen from its COVID peak of dent Bill Clinton as chair of the Council of Economic Advis-
14.7% last April, it plateaued at 6.7% in the final months ers (a rare non-first moment; she was the second woman to
of 2020, nearly twice as high as a year earlier. The Federal serve in that role). In 2014, she was confirmed as the first
Reserve has already taken rates down to near zero. Thou- female chair of the Federal Reserve, under Barack Obama.
sands of small businesses have closed for good during the Now, under President Biden, she’s achieved yet another
pandemic, which continues to ravage the country. And there title: the first woman secretary of the Treasury.
is rising concern in Washington about continued borrowing Her new job also makes Yellen the first person—of any
to stimulate the economy. The U.S. national debt grew by gender—to complete the holy trinity of the U.S. finance
a stunning $7.8 trillion over the past four years under the circuit: Council of Economic Advisers chair, Fed chair, and
Trump administration, driven in part by Trump’s signature Treasury secretary.
2017 tax cuts and the $3 trillion in stimulus funding Trump Yellen has hit the ground running, working with Biden to
signed into law last year. Some Republicans are now using get his COVID-19 relief bill passed by Congress quickly. In a
the specter of further debt to push back against President conversation with Fortune, she underscores the new admin-
Biden’s proposed $1.9 trillion stimulus bill, dubbed the istration’s top priorities: a successful distribution of at least
“American Rescue Plan.” 100 million doses of vaccine within 100 days; reopening
Yellen is also taking the reins at a Treasury Department schools; making sure Americans are able to remain in their
that has been greatly reduced in size and capacity under homes without fear of eviction; and providing a $1,400
her predecessor, Steven Mnuchin. Between 2016 and 2019, stimulus check to a majority of Americans and emergency
the Treasury’s main offices, including domestic finance, funding for state and local governments. “It’s a priority to
economic policy, and international affairs, saw staffing help get us through the pandemic, to get our economy func-
drop by about 25% as budgets fell. Those departments tioning again,” she says of the stimulus legislation.
control responses to the economic recovery, financial The new Treasury secretary also echoes President
policy, and grant programs. Mnuchin operated without Biden’s calls for both parties to dial back politics in the
a deputy for two years and left the division of domestic interest of problem-solving. “I hope very much that we can
finance without an official leader. Yellen will have to bring work in a bipartisan way, Democrats and Republicans, to
in a number of people, and quickly, to fill empty positions. get beyond this sort of stalemate that has been around for
But it’s hard to imagine a leader with more sparkling cre- a number of years now,” says Yellen. “I think that many
dentials—or a better demeanor—for the work at hand than people agree on both sides of the aisle. We need to invest
the 74-year-old Yellen. Each career peak on her résumé in our people and our infrastructure. We need to solve our
has been seemingly followed by another, higher summit—a competitiveness.”
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E E C O N O M Y

The business world may be comfortable with Yellen is centered wholly around work and shoptalk. She
Yellen, but she’s no businessperson herself. Unlike Hank often remarks that people would be bored if they joined
Paulson or John Snow, Wall Street execs turned Treasury her family for dinner, as she and her husband, George
heads, Yellen is a career economist. And the direction of Akerlof, who won the Nobel Prize in economics in 2001,
the stock market is not her North Star. Yellen’s perspective, usually engage in rigorous work-related discussion. Her
says Ben Bernanke, the former Federal Reserve chair and son is also in the family business; he received his Ph.D. in
now distinguished fellow at the Brookings Institution, isn’t economics from Harvard University in 2009 and teaches
to please any particular interest group. Rather, it’s “how do at the University of Warwick in England.
we get the economy going, and how do we make sure the Bernanke is quick to point out that Yellen prefers to
benefits are spread as widely as possible?” prepare for meetings very, very far in advance. She’s
If Mnuchin was the Beltway’s “most eager man,” as he’s known for showing up to airports hours before her flight;
been called, the Brooklyn-born Yellen is Washington’s she says that she uses the extra time to read. Adds Ber-
“most prepared woman.” She certainly won’t be arrang- nanke: “She’s a meticulous, cautious, thoughtful person.
ing photo ops with sheets of money, as her predecessor She speaks quietly. She’s well prepared, and she’s done all of
did. “She’s got a whole new set of issues that she’s going to the analysis. But she’s not a shrinking violet, and she’s not
have to dig into, and she will,” says Bernanke. “I mean, she afraid to speak up. Sometimes the quietest person in the
won’t be satisfied until she understands exactly why every room is the person you most want to listen to.”
particular line in the tax code is as unintelligible as it is, Yellen prefers to read from notes rather than speak off
what it means, and how to fix that.” the cuff. As director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal and
Indeed, Yellen is legendary for her focus. Her colleagues Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution, David Wes-
past and present emphasize that their relationship with sel has worked closely with Yellen and has seen her speak

TACKLING TAKING ON CHALLENGING REBUILDING


INCOME CLIMATE CHINA ON CAPACITY AT
POLICY INEQUALITY CHANGE TRADE TREASURY

STRAIGHT Yellen believes it’s


critical to address
Expect a renewed
focus on the
We need to reset
the relationship
The Treasury
budget over the
FROM THE the economy’s
structural imbal-
environment from
the Biden team.
with China, says
Yellen, and in
past four years
has been “cut
SECRETARY’S ance. “We have an
economy where
“Climate change
is a big priority.
order to do so
effectively the
enormously,”
says Yellen.
MOUTH the typical high
school–educated
It’s going to be
very clearly in
U.S. will have to
work with allies
There has been
a reallocation of
YELLEN OUTLINES FOUR OF worker is barely focus,” says Yel- to address com- personnel toward
HER TOP PRIORITIES. seeing any wage len. In the past, mon challenges activities ranging
increase for the she’s supported instead of operat- from monitoring
last 50 years, a carbon tax that ing unilater- terrorism and
and we need to would charge ally as the Trump other national
change that and polluters for administration security concerns
make sure that emissions and preferred. “China and away from
The push for a $1.9 tril- those workers redistribute funds is a very strategic economic security
lion COVID-19 relief get the kind of to U.S. house- competitor,” she at home. While the
package is the Biden pay they de- holds through says, noting that former are “im-
administration’s chief serve,” she says. dividends. the U.S. needs to portant things for
That will happen Last fall, Yellen “use an array of us to preserve,”
focus now. But true to by investing in cochaired a com- tools” to address says Yellen, “in
form, Secretary Yellen infrastructure mittee on how to a number of the process, other
has already outlined her and R&D, and by achieve net-zero disruptive actions areas of the Trea-
tenure at the Treasury educating workers emissions. Rec- taken by China, sury have really
so that they have ommendations such as “dumping been depleted.”
and identified what else
the skills to utilize included shifting products, erecting She will be staffing
she wants to accom- modern technol- incentives for trade barriers, up Treasury with
plish. Here is what lies ogy. Yellen also companies to and giving illegal people dedicated
at the top of her list. plans to focus on prioritize sustain- subsidies to cor- to her overarching
small-business ability and using porations.” Those mission of ad-
loan programs markets to speed actions are “hurt- dressing struc-
to help boost the transition ing our economy,” tural economic
job creation. from fossil fuels. she says. changes.
5 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

ECONOMIC HARDSHIP DURING THE PANDEMIC inequality, she said, were near their highest levels in the
People who say they were unable to pay for basic necessities like food, past 100 years, and the trend concerned her. And then, in
heat, or rent
an un–Fed chair (and un-Yellen) way, she editorialized just
WHITE 10% a little. “I think it is appropriate to ask whether this trend
BLACK* 31%
is compatible with values rooted in our nation’s history,
LATINO 26%
among them the high value Americans have traditionally
People who say they used up all or most of their savings** placed on equality of opportunity,” she said.
Yellen knew that reporters were there to cover the talk,
WHITE 16%
BLACK* 38%
but she believed her remarks were relatively benign.
LATINO 49% Apparently, she misjudged. Neil Irwin of the New York
Times called her words “downright radical.”
* WHITE AND BLACK DATA DO NOT INCLUDE LATINOS SOURCE:
** EXCLUDES THOSE WHO REPORTED NEVER HAVING HAD SAVINGS THE COMMONWEALTH FUND “No, that wasn’t Elizabeth Warren, or the editor of The
Nation, or Paul Krugman,” began the New Yorker story

more times than he can count. He describes her unique


procedure for answering audience questions. First, she
writes out her response and commits it to memory. Next,
she rips up the paper. And finally she speaks.
But Yellen also possesses a rare charisma. Mary C. Daly,
president of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco,
says Yellen is especially skilled at making people feel seen.
“I feel like we’ve met another Eleanor Roosevelt in Janet,”
says Daly, who calls Yellen a mentor and a friend. “There
can be a room of thousands of people, but when she walks
up to the stage, everybody goes quiet, and all eyes are on
her. I’ve never seen that happen with anybody else.”
She also makes a habit of asking colleagues for their
opinions, even when it’s likely that she already knows
what she’s going to do, says Wessel. Yellen may be genu-
inely curious, but soliciting input also offers colleagues a
quick ego rub. And massaging egos is a skill that certainly
doesn’t hurt Yellen, who has made a career of being the
only woman in rooms full of well-venerated men.
The people sitting around the tables at the G7 and G20 As director of the National Economic Council,
and the IMF like Yellen but also respect her, says Wes- Brian Deese, 42, will help set the agenda.
sel. “Her stature will give her substantial influence in the

Meet the
administration.” That influence will extend to the Oval
Office, he predicts. “When she chooses to use it, she’ll have
something close to veto power over big economic policies.”

Economy’s
But how exactly she wields that power remains to be
seen. Yellen has spent the majority of her Washington
career working at the Federal Reserve, an independent

New Power
agency charged with keeping monetary policy decisions
K E N C E D E N O — C N P/ B L O O M B E R G / G E T T Y I M A G E S

at arm’s length from political influence. As a result, she


has been careful about revealing her personal leanings, or

Players
much about herself at all.

One event sticks out in Wessel’s mind as a


moment when Yellen gave a rare glimpse of her political
stripes. It was 2014 and Yellen was nearly a year into her ALONG WITH TREASURY SECRETARY YELLEN,
role as Fed chair when she gave a speech on the inequal- THESE KEY BIDEN APPOINTEES WILL HAVE A
ity of economic opportunity to a room full of her peers at MAJOR IMPACT ON DRIVING POLICY.
the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. Income and wealth BY GEOFF COLVIN
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E E C O N O M Y

about the event. business to be,” scolded future Trump chief of staff Mick
“Everyone [in the government community] knows Mulvaney, then a Republican representative from South
that Yellen is a liberal Democrat, but that really shouldn’t Carolina. Rep. Sean Duffy, a Republican from Wisconsin
influence her job as Federal Reserve chair,” commented and former cast member of MTV’s The Real World, ac-
N. Gregory Mankiw, former economic adviser to George cused her of political bias.
W. Bush and then-chair of the Harvard economics depart- A visibly rattled Yellen defended her position. “I am not
ment, to the Harvard Political Review. making political statements,” she said. “I am discussing a
Months later, Yellen, who appears to skew much closer significant problem that faces America.”
to the center of the political spectrum than the far left, She didn’t see what she was saying as anything but data-
reported to Congress to deliver her semiannual monetary driven analysis. And anyway, “it had been a topic I’d ad-
policy report. But she found that Republicans were still dressed on a number of occasions before,” she tells Fortune.
focused on her remarks in Boston. Yellen experienced a rare setback in 2018 when then-
“You’re sticking your nose in places that you have no President Donald Trump essentially axed her and replaced

“PERSONNEL IS policy,” think he will be that person.” them will play important than ideology. “If Elizabeth
says a Washington maxim Jared Bernstein, member roles in executing Biden’s Warren or Bernie Sanders
invoked at the dawn of each of the Council of Economic economic policies. Two of the had become President, they
new administration. The Advisers. Bernstein’s power most important: would still have to deal first
point is valid; you don’t re- is greater than his title sug- Assistant Attorney Gen- and foremost with just crisis
ally understand policy until gests. He won’t outrank other eral for Antitrust. The Trump management,” says Veuger.
you know who’s creating it CEA members, but he’s al- Justice Department was more Beyond the pandemic, the is-
and executing it. President ready one of the administra- active on antitrust than many sues at the top of the team’s
Biden’s economic team, still tion’s most influential figures would have expected under to-do list are infrastructure,
being assembled, reflects because of his long and close a Republican President. climate, inequality, and
the forces shaping today’s relationship with Biden. In The Biden administration raising taxes. Biden and the
Democratic Party. “The staff- the Obama administration could be even more active. team will pursue an activist
ing really runs the gamut he was chief economist to Candidate Biden said the agenda based on their view
from very centrist Democrats then–Vice President Biden. tech giants wield too much that today’s ultralow interest
to people who come much Bernstein is decidedly left power, a view with bipartisan rates—negative after infla-
more from the left,” says Stan of center but not over on the support. The Trump DOJ last tion—present “a once-in-a-
Veuger, a Washington-based Bernie Sanders fringe. year sued Google on antitrust generation opportunity to
economist at the American Rohit Chopra, director grounds, joined by 14 states, make huge public invest-
Enterprise Institute and an of the Consumer Financial both red and blue. Biden’s ments that will pay off in
economics lecturer at Har- Protection Bureau (pend- choice of an antitrust chief higher living standards for
vard. In addition to Treasury ing Senate confirmation). will signal what’s ahead for the next generation,” says
Secretary Janet Yellen, here Amped up regulation of the Silicon Valley and potentially Wessel.
are top power players on financial services industry other industries. That view fits well with a
Biden’s economic team. looks to be a significant trend Comptroller of the Cur- broader, deeper view of how
Brian Deese, director in the Biden administration. rency. A low-profile post, it’s to strengthen the overall
of the National Economic Treasury Secretary Janet crucially important in the economy. Wessel says, “If
Council. Just 42, and not a Yellen has said she thinks regulation of national banks, you got all the economic
trained economist, Deese the Dodd-Frank law doesn’t including the biggest ones: team of the Biden adminis-
nonetheless held high-level go far enough, and Chopra’s JPMorgan Chase, Bank of tration in a room and asked
economic posts throughout record suggests he’ll be an America, Citigroup, and Wells them, ‘Do you think that
the Obama administration, energetic regulator. Attorney Fargo. If increased financial investments in pre-K educa-
including deputy director of Lucy Morris, who served regulation becomes a Biden tion and more aid for young
the Office of Management with Chopra at the CFPB priority, as many expect, children and low-income
and Budget and deputy direc- in its early days, writes, “I the holder of this job will be families can increase not only
tor of the National Economic anticipate that he will be at highly influential. their prospects of moving
Council, which manages the least as aggressive as former As for the policy that the into the middle class, but can
President’s economic deci- director [Richard] Cordray, Biden economic team will also increase the productivity
sion process. “If you have if not more,” a prospect that be executing: At its highest growth of the United States?’
a strong White House, the may chill the blood of Wall level, it’s driven partly by the I think they would say yes.”
person who organizes the Street executives. Since May circumstances of the mo- Having hit the trifecta of
meetings, the presentations, 2018 Chopra has been on the ment and partly by shared controlling the White House
and what will be presented Federal Trade Commission. deep beliefs. The most plus both houses of Con-
to the President has a lot of Other top power positions immediate imperative, man- gress, Biden, his team, and
power,” says the Brookings haven’t been filled as of this aging the pandemic crisis, their party now have a rare
Institution’s David Wessel. “I writing, but whoever takes is more about competence opportunity to test that belief.
5 8 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

“When she chooses to use it,” says the Brookings Institution’s


David Wessel of SECRETARY YELLEN, “she’ll have something
close to VETO POWER over major economic policies.”

Yellen speaking
in December
after President
Biden announced
her as his pick to
run the Treasury.

her as Fed chair with Jerome Powell. “She was disap- Bush Terminal, a group of docks in South Brooklyn. He
pointed,” says her friend Wessel. “She thought that Trump worked on the teeth of union workers. At the end of the
liked her and that she had a shot at being reappointed.” day, he’d discuss their lives with young Janet. If they had
Still, she was happy that Powell, a peer she respects, was lost a job, he would tell her about their financial and family
nominated to do the job. problems, their inability to afford health care, their loss of
It’s still unclear exactly why Trump got rid of Yellen. self-worth.
Some speculate that he just didn’t want an Obama ap- Those lessons stuck with her “so much so that I became
pointment at the Fed. Trump told the Washington Post an economist because I was concerned about the toll of K R I S T O N J A E B E T H E L—T H E N E W Y O R K T I M E S / R E D U X P I C T U R E S
that he thought she was too short to run the Fed. Wessel unemployment on people, families, and communities,” she
remembers her joking about the story. The Post said she said in her speech.
was five-three when in reality she’s barely five-feet even. But entering a male-dominated field was not without
She wasn’t going to call in a correction, Yellen told Wessel, challenges. “The sexual harassment was ever present,” says
but somebody else could feel free to. Sylvia Ann Hewlett, who received her Ph.D. in economics
from the University of London in the early 1970s before
In December, Yellen stood next to President- teaching at Columbia University. The idea of focusing on
elect Biden in Wilmington, Del., as she accepted his nomi- gender pay gaps and wealth inequality, as Yellen came
nation for Treasury secretary. There, in a speech that was to do in her career, was risky at the time, especially for a
uniquely candid for the reserved economist, she offered a woman, says Hewlett. “Women had two choices—either
window into how she became the person she is today. they joined the dominant group and didn’t write about it,
Her father, she said, was a dentist who began his busi- or you were seen as a sore thumb.”
ness during the Great Depression, setting up shop near In that context, it took chutzpah for a female economist
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E E C O N O M Y

to step out of line and raise questions about the accepted CHANGE IN HOUSEHOLD INCOME BY INCOME GROUP
wisdom in the field. But Yellen downplays that narrative,
300%
and describes her work as a natural evolution.
“When I first went into macroeconomics, the view that I TOP 1% EARNERS
250
had and had learned in graduate school was that a gener-
ally strong economy with a low unemployment rate would
200
benefit workers across the income spectrum—that a so-
called rising tide lifts all boats,” Yellen tells Fortune. “But
sometime in the mid-’80s that really began to change, and 150
it became no longer true that when the economy was do- TOP 20%
ing well overall that everybody benefited.” 100
Yellen came to realize that while full employment was
still important, it wasn’t enough to address long-term 50
BOTTOM 20%
declines in income for the majority of Americans. “And so
I have focused for many years on understanding what the 0 MIDDLE 20%
forces are that have been making it so difficult for workers
1979 1990 2000 2010 2017
to succeed,” she says. “And because such a large share of
SOURCE: CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE NOTE: INCOME AFTER TAXES AND TRANSFERS
the workforce hasn’t been able to get ahead, income and

$68.1
When she met again with Congress in 2016, she took a
markedly different tone. “It is troubling that unemploy-
ment rates for these minority groups remain higher than
for the nation overall, and that the annual income of the
median African-American household is still well below
the median income of other U.S. households,” she said.
Around the same time, Yellen created a task force to di-
B ILLION versify hiring practices within the Federal Reserve itself.
Now Yellen is bringing that same perspective to the
Treasury. David Clunie, executive director of the Black
U.S. trade deficit with China in November, a 14-year
Economic Alliance and the executive secretary of the
high. Despite tariffs imposed under President
Department of the Treasury under President Barack
Trump, the $61.2 billion in consumer goods imported Obama, has been working with Yellen to ensure that the
from China to the U.S. was the highest on record. department is focused on racial inequality while work-
ing through COVID-relief programs. Recent surveys
found that Latino and Black Americans have experienced
wealth inequality has been the theme.” economic hardship during COVID-19 two to three times
In 1998, under Bill Clinton, Yellen took the lead on a as great as that of white Americans. The pandemic has
landmark study, “Explaining Trends in the Gender Wage also had a disproportionate effect on women compared
Gap.” It proved to be a pivotal moment in her career. The with men. (See “Is America Giving Up on Working
paper concluded that women earned 25% less than men, Women?”) “I’ve been encouraged by what I’ve seen," says
and it was published just as America was celebrating the Clunie. “She seems to have a new freedom to speak in
35th anniversary of President Kennedy’s signing of the much more outward terms about what this means to her
Equal Pay Act. The resulting media attention elevated her personally.”
profile and eventually helped boost her into her next major Yellen tells Fortune that at the Treasury she will fight
role as president of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Fran- publicly to address inequality. But, perhaps thinking back
cisco in 2004. to that contentious 2014 hearing, she has a message for
While at the Fed, Yellen’s views on racial justice and her Republican friends in Congress. “The wage gap and
the economy evolved. In July of 2015, Yellen received income inequality should not be politicized,” she says.
some blowback from testimony she gave to Congress that “They’re facts that everyone recognizes.”
seemed to imply that there was little the Federal Reserve It’s also a fact that her new job is more overtly political
could do to improve disproportionately high Black unem- than any she has held before. Yellen brings to it a distaste
ployment rates. Progressive groups and senators pushed for politics as usual and a reverence for data. And that
Yellen on the topic. She listened. might be just what the economy needs.
BUILDING BETTER LEADERS
WITH PURPOSE

LEARNING
Curriculum focused
on purpose-based leadership
and inclusion

CONTENT
Fortune Conferences on demand
and executive sessions with CEOs

EVENTS
Facilitated discussions, Fortune-
moderated editorial conversations
with experts and provocateurs,
and group coaching sessions

COMMUNITY
Peer-to-peer networking,
brainstorming, and
meetups

OFFICIAL
KNOWLEDGE
PARTNERS
ª

Join the new


purpose-driven
leadership
community
from Fortune.
FORTUNE.COM/
CONNECT
6 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

WHAT COMES

LEL AND BOBBE—GET T Y IMAGES


W H AT C O M E S N E X T

CYB ERSECURIT Y

After SolarWinds:
Untangling
America’s
Cybersecurity Mess T H E S O L A R W I N D S H AC K E X P O S E D D OZ E N S — M AY B E
H U N D R E D S — O F U . S . C O M PA N I E S TO H AC K E R S ’ S P Y I N G E Y E S .
I T A L S O U N C OV E R E D D E E P - R O OT E D F L AW S I N T H E WAY T H E
C O U N T RY A P P R OAC H E S CY B E R S EC U R I T Y. H E R E ’ S W H AT W E N T
W R O N G, A N D H O W B U S I N E S S A N D G OV E R N M E N T C A N F I X I T.

NEXT DAVID Z . MORRIS


& ROB ERT HACKETT

In early December, the cybersecurity firm Fire- and its methodical, long-simmering information-gathering
Eye disclosed that it had been hacked, by miscreants who approach suggested a nation-state was behind it. By early
had taken copies of powerful tools used by the company’s January, U.S. intelligence agencies were blaming Russia,
security testing teams. As it investigated, the company and “SolarWinds” had become shorthand for a hacking
soon found that the attack was part of something much catastrophe. (See “Timeline of a Cybercrime.”)
larger. FireEye’s systems, it turned out, had been compro- “It’s certainly going to be the worst cyberattack in United
mised using spyware implanted via the IT management States history thus far, and I don’t believe people under-
and security platform Orion, a top-selling product of an stand its magnitude,” says Tom Bossert, a former homeland
Austin-based IT software firm called SolarWinds. security adviser for President Trump who is now president
Five days after the initial disclosure, FireEye alerted of cybersecurity startup Trinity Cyber. “It’s primarily so
the public to what it had discovered, triggering a broader troubling because of its alarming scope—the scale of this is
search that revealed a threat of staggering scale and terrify- breathtaking.”
ing subtlety. The compromised Orion software had not only That includes the scope of the potential damage to
reached thousands of SolarWinds’ corporate customers, but business. While many high-profile hacks target customer
it had also exposed systems at the U.S. Treasury, the State data, such as credit card numbers and addresses, the
Department, and the Department of Homeland Security. SolarWinds attackers appear to have focused on much
The attack had apparently begun more than a year earlier, higher-value internal information. Their objectives appear
BEARS’ LAIR?
The Moscow
headquarters of the
SVR intelligence
agency, whose
“Cozy Bear” cyber
unit is one suspect
in the SolarWinds
hack.

TIMELINE OF A CYBERCRIME
SECURITY EXPERTS RANK THE SO-CALLED SOLARWINDS HACK AMONG THE TWO OR THREE MOST SERIOUS CYBER
ESPIONAGE INTRUSIONS IN U.S. HISTORY—AND IT MAY BE THE ONE THAT REACHES DEEPEST INTO CORPORATE AMERICA.
HERE’S WHAT WE KNOW SO FAR ABOUT HOW IT UNFOLDED.

SEPT. 4, 2019 MARCH–JUNE 2020 publicly reports reported that 44% JAN. 5, 2021 fected agencies
the hack. of the escalation reportedly include
SolarWinds, SolarWinds be- targets it detected A group of the Department of
an Austin-based lieves that 18,000 DEC. 19 were in the IT U.S. intelligence Homeland Secu-
software company, Orion customers sector, 18% were agencies issue a rity, the Treasury
is compromised. downloaded a FireEye reports in government, statement saying Department, and
Engineering done software-update that more than 19% were NGOs or that “an Advanced the State Depart-
for SolarWinds patch that included 1,000 infiltrated think tanks, and 9% Persistent Threat ment. Microsoft
by subcontrac- the Sunburst back- systems have been were government (APT) actor, likely email accounts
tors in Eastern door during this pinging a com- contractors. The Russian in origin,” at the Depart-
Europe is one pos- period. Because mand-and-control follow-on attacks is responsible for ment of Justice
sible source of the this download is server operated appear to have the attack. Some are compromised,
breach. part of a trusted by hackers, giving mainly targeted experts suspect though the DOJ
The hackers process, there is them the option to email systems; the SVR, the Rus- says there’s no
implant malware nothing to alert penetrate further their full extent is sian foreign intel- indication that
into an update even vigilant by stealing internal unknown. ligence service classified systems
for Orion, an IT security teams that users’ credentials associated with the were breached.
and cyberse- anything is amiss. that give them DEC. 31 Cozy Bear hacking
curity manage- access to more team. Russia de- JAN. 12
ment dashboard DEC. 11 systems. Microsoft nies involvement.
D I G I TA L G L O B E / S C A P E WA R E 3 D / G E T T Y I M A G E S

product made by Microsoft says announces that Email secu-


SolarWinds. This The hackers, about 40 of its own the SolarWinds JAN. 10 rity firm Mimecast
malware, dubbed using stolen cre- customers were at- hackers accessed reports that it has
“Sunburst,” is a dentials, attempt tacked. An Amazon the internal source The Cybersecu- also been compro-
so-called backdoor to register a new internal report later code that under- rity and Infra- mised by Orion. It
that allows hackers device for multifac- pegs the total of lies some of its structure Secu- says about 4,000
to monitor and tor authentication. impacted firms and software. To date, rity Agency says of its customers
potentially further This action tips off agencies at more there’s no indica- “fewer than 10” were “potentially
infiltrate networks the cybersecurity than 250. Those tion anything was federal agencies affected,” but only
it is installed on. company FireEye reports have not tampered with or were impacted by a “low single-digit”
to the intrusion; named the victims, that customer data the compromised number of custom-
two days later, it but Microsoft was stolen. Orion patch. Af- ers were targeted.
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CY B E R S E C U R IT Y

to have included penetrating email systems and accessing


corporate secrets—among them, the source code underly-
ing Microsoft’s software. Cisco, Intel, Nvidia, and Deloitte
are among the other giants who say they were exposed
STRIKING BACK
to the Orion patch. No company has admitted to being
seriously impacted yet, but IT departments are bracing for HOW THE BIDEN
the worst: theft of assets and intellectual property, leaks
of internal data and deliberations, and the vast expense of WHITE HOUSE
scrubbing or even rebuilding their compromised systems. SHOULD RESPOND
Just as frightening as the scope is how smoothly the at-
tack circumvented government and private-sector cyberde- TO SOLARWINDS
fenses. Some see the attack not as a failure by one software
vendor, but as an indictment of U.S. cybersecurity itself.
“The United States created the Internet,” says Katie Mous-
souris, founder of Luta Security and a pioneering cyberde- THE EPIC HACK HAS UNDERSCORED THE
fense pro at Microsoft and Symantec. But in cybersecurity, DISORGANIZATION THAT UNDERLIES
“we are losing our lead.” Whatever its consequences turn AMERICA’S CYBERSECURITY POLICY.
out to be, the SolarWinds hack has exposed major flaws in HERE ARE FOUR WAYS THE NEW
the patchwork public-private partnership we’ve relied on to ADMINISTRATION CAN CHANGE THE
keep our information technology safe, drawing attention to SYSTEM FOR THE BETTER.
just how ill-coordinated and permeable it can be. NOW THAT JOE BIDEN has taken office, he’s got to figure
In the traditional defense supply chain—think the mak- out how to dig the country out of a spectacular, smoldering
ers of fighter jets or Coast Guard cutters—private contrac- crater.
tors submit to strict oversight and rigorous standards in ex- For about as long as the coronavirus pandemic ravaged
the United States, another sinister invasion was taking
change for long-term, high-value government contracts. In place—except in secret. This incursion was an audacious,
cybersecurity, in contrast, a handful of midsize government silent cyberattack that infiltrated, ransacked, and subverted
agencies work with a vastly larger constellation of private at least 10 government agencies and potentially hundreds
software developers, cybersecurity contractors, and their of corporations.
The President is inheriting a mess, to put it mildly. “It’s
customers, offering relatively few guidelines and imposing
not Pearl Harbor. It’s not an act of war,” stresses Mark Mont-
only loose oversight. gomery, head of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission, a
Most experts in the industry view the decentralized, federal cybersecurity task force. “But it was a brutal act of
market-driven structure of U.S. cybersecurity as a source espionage that is going to cost us a lot of money”—many,
of agility and innovation. But in the SolarWinds debacle, many billions, he says—”to recover from.”
Biden is entering the fray with no illusions, if little clarity,
they also see the system’s weaknesses on full display. In this about the magnitude of the challenge he faces. “There’s
mega-breach, the industry’s flawed financial incentives, a still so much we don’t know, including the full scope of the
lack of transparency, underinvestment in training, and old- breach or the extent of the damage it has caused. But we
fashioned cost-cutting each played a role. know this much; this attack constitutes a grave risk to our
national security,” the then President-elect said in Decem-
These failures encapsulate the challenge of fixing Amer-
ber after the hack’s discovery. Echoing Biden’s avowal, a
ica’s cybersecurity structure. The encouraging news is that National Security Council spokesperson tells Fortune the
corporate and public-sector reformers are already respond- administration will be “elevating [cybersecurity] as an
ing with repairs and countermeasures; the less good news imperative across the government from day one” and will
is that many of those repair efforts are in their earliest days. “hold accountable those responsible for attacks.”
Toward that end, Biden’s team has earmarked $10 bil-
(For more about those efforts, see the accompanying story.) lion of pandemic relief for additional IT spending. Assum-
ing Congress approves it, more than two-thirds will go to
When FireEye went public with its SolarWinds the Homeland Security Department’s top cyber outfit to
news, neither the National Security Agency, the Penta- improve incident response and network monitoring across
government. Biden has already made a number of calcu-
gon’s Cyber Command, nor any other U.S. intelligence or
lated appointments to deal with the situation, including
cyber agency had detected the attack, even though it had plucking Anne Neuberger, an NSA honcho, for a new cyber
likely been underway for months. That notion is troubling advisory role on his National Security Council, and the lat-
enough: Even more stunning is the fact that FireEye est defense legislation gives him some powerful new tools.
wasn’t legally obligated to inform anyone—publicly or If America is going to pull out of the ever-widening gyre
that is the SolarWinds hack, the new Commander-in-Chief
privately—about its discovery. has to stay focused. On the following pages, you’ll find four
There are a growing number of legal requirements for policy recommendations, sourced from public- and private-
firms such as retailers or banks to report hacks involving sector cybersecurity experts, that should top his list.
6 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

1. RALLYING BEHIND
A NATIONAL
CYBER DIRECTOR

ON JAN. 1, Congress agencies. An elevated


passed the $740 billion “cyber bureau” at the State
National Defense Autho- Department would be a
rization Act (NDAA) for key accompaniment: To-
2021, overturning a veto by gether, the two could more
President Trump. In addi- persuasively corral allies,
tion to approving the Pen- exert influence abroad,
tagon’s annual budget, the and push for bright, red
hefty piece of legislation “do not cross” lines on the
contains some profoundly Internet—like no plunder-
significant cyber policy ini- ing of intellectual property,
tiatives. Most notably, the interfering with elections,
law approves the creation sabotaging public utilities,
of a new executive branch or harming civilians.
role: the Office of the Na- Michael Daniel, Presi-
tional Cyber Director. This dent Obama’s cyber czar CHRIS KREBS, founding director of a key
office, with a staff of up to and now head of the indus- cybersecurity agency, has been hired by SolarWinds
75, is set to be the Presi- try group Cyber Threat Al- to address its post-hack mess.
dent’s “principal adviser” liance, says the U.S. needs
and policy coordinator on to be more consistent and
all cybersecurity-related explicit if it is to establish
matters. international rules of the
theft of customers’ personal data. But the U.S. does not
Of more than two dozen road in cyberspace. As require independent research firms to share their findings
Solarium Commission rec- for SolarWinds, he says, about cyberthreats with government agencies, even if they
ommendations adopted in America and its allies need constitute a potential national security threat.
the NDAA, the directorship to signal to the perpetra-
In a $170 billion industry in which many companies are
may be the most signifi- tors that “anything that
cant, says Solarium’s Mont- goes beyond espionage beholden primarily to private-sector clients, this gap in the
gomery. In cyberdefense, that we find”—like data law can create troubling incentives. Because their business
as in many other policy destruction or physical models are often based on selling exclusive warnings and
arenas, a spaghetti-tangle damage—“we reserve the defense strategies to clients, cyberthreat intelligence firms
of agencies have overlap- right to escalate.”
ping responsibilities. Of course, the U.S.
don’t have a direct financial inducement to share their find-
The hope is that the conducts espionage too, ings publicly. Charles Carmakal, the FireEye investigator
new office can give federal Daniel acknowledges. But who led its probe of the SolarWinds attack, notes that pri-
policy the cohesion it has there should be no toler- vate firms might hoard information about a novel cyberat-
lacked. The President ance for other nations’
tack “to use it as a competitive differentiator.”
doesn’t have time to drop operations that “get too
in on the Small Business big, too bold,” he says. To be sure, many cybersecurity firms do share their
ANDRE W HARRER—BLO OMBERG VIA GE T T Y IMAGES

Administration to check on At press time, the findings widely, and it’s unlikely that any firm would have
its cybersecurity efforts, rumored top contender for stayed quiet about a threat as dire as SolarWinds. But
or to manage relationships director was Jen Easterly, executives across the industry cite the lack of uniform ex-
between municipal water head of resilience at Mor-
authorities and the EPA, gan Stanley and a former
pectations around disclosure as a pitfall that may let some
Montgomery says. “In the NSA official who helped attacks go unpublicized. Imagine if Boeing, in mid-1941,
end, you need someone establish the U.S. military’s had discovered the plan to bomb Pearl Harbor, then taken
who is accountable.” Cyber Command. Whom- time to weigh the costs and benefits of informing the Navy.
To be effective, the ever Biden puts in charge
Private-sector dominance of software design contrib-
cyber director will need to will set the tone for all that
work in concert with other follows. utes to another serious cybersecurity risk that the Solar-
Winds attackers exploited.
The malicious code at the core of the attack was deliv-
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CY B E R S E C U R IT Y

2. STRENGTHENING
CISA , THE WHITE
HOUSE’S LIAISON
TO BUSINESS

SHORTLY BEFORE the Such exercises would help


SolarWinds’ hacking revela- big companies and cyber-
tion, Trump ousted Chris security firms plan for, say,
Krebs, founding director of what to do if Iran hacks
the Cybersecurity and In- a utility to poison local
frastructure Security Agen- water supplies, the Kremlin
cy, or CISA, the agency that causes citywide blackouts,
serves as the government’s or China fries our roughly
primary cyber-focused three-dozen GPS satellites.
interface with private “Bodies like CISA matter
industry. Krebs, a veteran because they’re trying to
of Microsoft, had earned develop the philosophies
plaudits for building CISA, and the methodologies
and for his role in keeping and practices that we need
the 2020 elections free of share” to increase our col-
ANNE NEUBERGER, a veteran of the National Security foreign interference. He lective defenses, says Vasu
Agency, is the top cybersecurity expert in President lost his job in a dispute over Jakkal, Microsoft’s chief
Biden’s inner circle. the President’s baseless security marketer.
election fraud allegations. The NDAA boosts the
The two-year-old CISA authority of CISA in other
was already fighting to be ways as well. Crucially,
ered via a “supply-chain attack” that was fiendishly hard “invited to the adult table in CISA will be permitted to
to detect. Once attackers compromised SolarWinds and intelligence discussions,” hunt down threats on fed-
inserted spyware in a trusted “patch,” or update, it became says Kiersten Todt, manag- eral networks, where who
nearly invisible to routine cyberdefense measures. ing director of the nonprofit knows how many hackers
Cyber Readiness Institute. are crawling. The Solar-
This vulnerability is especially dangerous because, in part
Krebs’s dismissal would fur- Winds hack ought to be
for the sake of cost savings, most software reuses a variety ther handicap the agency viewed “as a long-term pen-
of third-party components, such as open-source code. One most responsible for etration of our most valu-
compromised component can become a foothold for attack- helping companies recover able networks,” says Dmitri
ers to access or corrupt other systems, potentially turning from hacks. (Krebs has Alperovitch, founder of
since been hired by Solar- Silverado Policy Accelera-
it into a backdoor master key to any software built using Winds to help the company tor, a security-focused think
it. Yet there is no widely accepted standard for tracking or with its unenviable attempt tank. Staffing up a squad
reporting what components and interactions make up a to bounce back from its of top-notch search-and-
piece of software, much less any regulation requiring such eponymous hack.) destroyers “is something
But even as it absorbs they need to start leverag-
tracking. In the SolarWinds attack, this may have added ob-
its loss, CISA has gained ing literally on day one,”
stacles, as thousands of private and government customers new powers under the says Alperovitch, also a
scrambled to understand the threat posed by the corrupted NDAA. For one, the agency cofounder and former tech
Orion patch. got clearance to create chief of the cybersecurity
There is growing awareness that effective cybersecu- a “cyber planning office” company CrowdStrike.
that will more closely and Word is that Biden
rity must be built into software and networks from the
P H I L L I P FA R A O N E — G E T T Y I M A G E S

proactively coordinate with intends to tap Rob Silvers,


ground up, including through “zero-trust” software that the private sector. That a former Obama official
would limit hackers’ movement between systems. But includes creating play- who helped negotiate a
there’s little market incentive to build software that is so books for how to respond major trade-secret–stealing
to big hacks, putting in truce with China in 2015,
robust, and governments don’t have much leverage to
place economic continuity as CISA’s new leader. If he’s
require it. “You see an increasing reliance on commercial plans, and running tabletop confirmed, he’ll be a close
and even off-the-shelf technology in even very high-end exercises with corporations partner to the national
[government] system spaces,” says Eric Wenger, a tech- on code red situations. cyber director.
6 8 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

nology policy director with Cisco Systems. That’s why the


SolarWinds attack impacted public agencies and private
3. SETTING companies alike: Using the same software exposes them

BETTER to the same attacks.

STANDARDS SolarWinds can boast of an achievement that


few of its rivals can match: Between 2010 and 2019, its
profit margins tripled. The company was able to keep wid-
ening those margins, in part, by outsourcing work on its
Orion product to less expensive software engineers in East-
ern Europe. What seemed like a savvy business move may
TOO OFTEN cost- Thornton-Trump also turn out to be the company’s undoing: As of this writing,
conscious companies nick proposes requiring com- investigators were pursuing the possibility that hackers
cybersecurity from their panies spend a certain compromised SolarWinds through its Eastern European
budgets first. share of their revenue operations. But in outsourcing its engineering, SolarWinds
Ian Thornton-Trump on security controls. A
says he experienced just 2019 study by Deloitte was reacting rationally to market forces (not to mention
that agony firsthand when and FS-ISAC, a security- following the lead of many of its software peers).
the digital defense advice focused consortium for the The underlying problem is that the U.S. has a severe
he gave to SolarWinds— financial industry, found shortage of cybersecurity talent. A recent survey by the
whose widespread network that financial firms spend
labor analytics firm Emsi found that the U.S. has less
monitoring tool Orion on average 10% of their IT
became ground zero for budgets, or about 0.6% of than half the qualified cyber professionals it needs, across
the hackstravaganza—went their revenue, on cyber- the public and private sectors—a gap that has resulted in
ignored a few years ago. security. That’s roughly hundreds of thousands of unfilled jobs. That helps make
(A SolarWinds spokesper- $2,150 per employee. While existing talent more expensive: The median cybersecurity
son said, “We believe our there’s no one-size-fits-all
investment in security has approach—and compliance salary in 2019 was $99,730, according to the Bureau of
consistently been appropri- doesn’t equal security, any Labor Statistics, about 15% above the median salary for
ate for a company of our worth-their-salt security software engineers. And that extra cost gives firms in the
size” and that the com- pro will tell you—the figure industry another incentive to take production offshore.
pany is now “fortifying and is not a bad rule of thumb.
In a sense, the problem starts in our universities, and
implementing additional Similar standards-
security practices.“) setting is underway in the some reformers think the solutions should begin there
Thornton-Trump, now government. The Depart- too. A 2016 review found that of the top 10 computer
chief information security ment of Defense asks its science programs in the U.S., none required cybersecurity
officer at cyber firm Cyjax, suppliers to comply with coursework to graduate; three of those 10 didn’t have a
believes companies should a “cyber maturity model
keep up to snuff when it certification” that aims to cybersecurity program at all. Some companies have been
comes to certain basics, assure some basic level of stepping up efforts to train entry-level cyberdefenders.
he tells Fortune. That could data safeguarding. Frank Cilluffo, a former adviser to the George W. Bush
include requiring busi- Solarium’s Montgomery administration on counterterrorism and cyber issues, rec-
nesses to perform regular hopes the government
ommends thinking even bigger: “We need the equivalent
audits and penetration will establish a nonprofit
testing, which gauge how bureau of cyber statistics— of an educational moonshot around cyber issues, which
permeable a company’s similar to Underwriters will require federal funding,” he says.
systems might be to a hack. Laboratories, which tests New cohorts of cybersecurity graduates won’t help
He looks to the cyber- and grades consumer much, though, if they’re working within a dysfunctional
security standards set by products. That hypothetical
the New York Department organization could become system. Restructuring that system is core to the work of the
of Financial Services, which an essential source of data Cyberspace Solarium Commission, a task force commis-
came into full effect in 2019 for the nascent cyber insur- sioned by Congress to help reform U.S. cybersecurity. “Our
and apply to financial firms ance industry, a key lever focus [is] on making the market more effective at driving
operating in the state, as a for pushing the private
good behavior,” says commissioner Suzanne Spaulding, a
solid precedent. sector to adopt better
(Reaching for carrot cybersecurity practices. senior adviser for cybersecurity and counterterrorism at
over stick, Thornton-Trump It could also eventually the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “If the
suggests that the govern- rate software and software market isn’t performing the way it should, why isn’t it?”
ment offer tax rebates to components based on their The commission spent the past year drawing up a wide-
companies that perform cybersafety—a grading
third-party attestations system that could nudge ranging list of recommendations, and in January, 26 of
proving they’ve abided by sloppier tech companies to them became law as part of the 2021 National Defense
the rules.) step up their game. Authorization Act. The NDAA creates a White House–
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CY B E R S E C U R IT Y

level Office of the National Cyber Director and grants


new private-sector threat-response powers to the federal
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency—signif- 4. FEWER SECRETS:
icant changes that commission members hope will prompt
closer collaboration between government and industry on PASSING A
security standards. “A lot of the recommendations, some DATA BREACH
of us have been making for years,” says Cilluffo, who’s also
a commissioner. “But the political will was not where it NOTIFICATION LAW
needed to be. Now, we don’t need any reminders.”
Solarium’s mandate has been extended for at least
another year, and its next round of advocacy and recom-
mendations will focus more squarely on the private sector. IN THE U.S. at present, SEC guidance now, and
The goal: creating better incentives for building secure companies have to disclose the cottage legal industry
software and sharing intelligence about cyberthreats. breaches only when they that’s formed around it is
On the engineering side, Solarium is pushing for a compromise certain types doing nobody any good,”
of data, like people’s says Robert Knake, an ex–
national cybersecurity certification authority—something personal information. Most National Security Council
like a Better Business Bureau that would grant its seal of electronic break-ins— member.
approval to safer software. Such certification would likely including ones featuring The trick is to make
involve tracking software manufacturers’ defenses against high-stakes stolen trade sure stronger disclosure
secrets, financial losses, or requirements don’t stop
well-known attacks, which make up a growing share of worse outcomes—therefore companies from rooting
breaches. Increasingly, rank-and-file cybercriminals barely go unreported. out intrusions in the first
code at all, and instead use prepackaged tools sold by That’s got to change, place, a possible negative
more skilled malefactors. Standardized defenses against cybersecurity experts say, outcome Knake says is like
this sort of simple, repetitive attack, Cilluffo says, could and the bar for public dis- taking “an ostrichlike ap-
closure must be lowered. proach.” Companies might
help free up cyberdefense teams to focus on fighting more A national data breach prefer to stick their heads in
subtle, innovative, and dangerous attacks, such as those disclosure law, akin to what the proverbial sand rather
from state-backed adversaries. Europe requires, would than spend money looking
Other reformers back a so-called Software Bill of force companies to report for hacks they’ll have to tell
any significant network the world about.
Materials: Such a bill would require U.S. tech companies intrusions to the govern- Companies that special-
to catalog the various third-party modules, open-source ment. If CISA can get a ize in cyber “threat intel”
components, and library code they used to build a piece of clearer picture of wide- are also wary about rules
software—addressing the industry’s transparency prob- spread hacking campaigns, that might require them
lem. Such an inventory would make it easier to alert devel- it can better help coor- to disclose the hacks they
dinate responses. Down unearth—in part because
opers and customers to software in which security flaws the line, obliging publicly their business models are
were discovered, just as an auto manufacturer can issue a traded companies to file often based on selling
recall if, say, a brake shoe turns out to be defective. cybersecurity-related met- warnings exclusively to
The more urgent advocacy will be around the sharing of rics to the Securities and clients. Suzanne Spaulding,
Exchange Commission, as a cybersecurity expert and
information about cyberassaults. Spaulding says that new they already do in account- a member of the Solarium
rules could include enhanced threat reporting require- ing, will let stakeholders Commission who supports
ments for “critical infrastructure companies”—a category better assess risk. such rules, says, “The con-
that might include private cybersecurity firms. If there’s “less of a scar- cern over the years from
Proposals like these elicit understandable wariness from let letter around a breach companies has been, if I’m
and a greater willingness to a good actor, and I disclose,
industry. Complying with a Software Bill of Materials, for talk about them,” says Amit but my competitor finds a
instance, could be cost- and labor-intensive for companies, Yoran, CEO of cybersecu- way to hide it, that’s a com-
and could even create new risks by providing detailed rity firm Tenable Networks petitive disadvantage.”
information to attackers. Intelligence-sharing mandates, and former president of For the broader busi-
RSA, then “you’ll have more ness community, stronger
too, face opposition from many cybersecurity firms, which informed investors, and, disclosure rules might have
see them as eroding their competitive advantages. Cisco’s as a nation, we’ll have a bet- to go hand in hand with for-
Wenger worries, for example, that such rules could deter ter understanding of how malized audit and pene-
investment in cybersecurity, by reducing how much private many of these breaches tration-testing guidelines.
firms can benefit financially from their research. are actually occurring and Because if more hackings,
what the cost is.” like SolarWinds, can be
The question ultimately may be whether the cost of “It’s too easy for com- brought out of the shadows,
cooperation is greater than the cost of the next Solar- panies to argue their way then sunlight can work its
Winds—or the one after that. out of disclosures under disinfecting magic.
7 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

WHAT COMES

“WE MADE A
BUNCH OF
MISTAKES”:
Scharf at a Wells
Fargo office in
Palm Beach.
Federal penalties
against the bank
have limited its
options.

PHOTOGRAPH BY ERIKA LARSEN


W H AT C O M E S N E X T

WELLS FARGO

Busted Stagecoach:
Can Charlie Scharf
—or Anyone—
Fix Wells Fargo?
H O B B L E D BY T H E A F T E R M AT H O F I T S PA S T S C A N DA L S , W E L L S FA R G O
T U R N E D TO A T W O -T I M E FO R T U N E  5 0 0 C EO TO H E L P I T G E T B AC K O N T R AC K .
T H E PA N D E M I C S H O O K U P H I S T U R N A R O U N D P L A N S . N O W T H E 1 6 9 -Y E A R- O L D B A N K
A N D I T S L E A D E R FAC E A N E V E N S T E E P E R C L I M B .

NEXT BY REY MASHAYEKHI

Charlie Scharf, the CEO of America’s third-largest pandemic-afflicted year, this house has been the hub from
bank, is a man enamored with the potential of the company which Scharf has tackled one of the toughest turnaround
he leads. He sounds almost awestruck as he enumerates assignments in business. Scharf oversees an enormous,
the forces at his disposal. There’s the commercial bank that multifaceted bank with more than 260,000 employees and
serves millions of small businesses. There’s a consumer- some 70 million customers. It’s a company emerging from
lending platform that accounts for more mortgages than the most tumultuous period in its nearly 170-year his-
any other major bank. There’s a wealth management tory, one in which it got caught—on multiple occasions—
division that has helped countless customers expand their flagrantly abusing the trust of those customers.
affluence. “The core franchise, and what we do for consum- Wells Fargo continues to pay for those sins with a
ers and businesses, is extraordinary,” Scharf says. tarnished reputation and through the lingering impact of
He pauses before adding, matter-of-factly: “But we severe fines and sanctions. The most damaging of those
made a bunch of mistakes.” is a Federal Reserve–imposed, $1.95 trillion cap on the
It is mid-October, the day before Scharf ’s first anniver- bank’s assets. As the economy reels from the impact of the
sary at the helm of Wells Fargo. The CEO is sitting in an coronavirus, all banks are feeling the effects of ultralow
elegant, wood-paneled study at his home on New York’s interest rates that clobber their profit margins. But unlike
Long Island, speaking via a Zoom video link. For much of a its rivals, Wells can’t offset the impact by rapidly stepping
7 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CA N A N YO N E F IX W E LL S FA RG O ?

up lending volume or attracting capital reserves—the meaningful cultural change. “It takes a long time to turn
asset cap prevents it. Wells Fargo’s revenue has steadily around such a big ship,” says Jason Goldberg, a senior
declined since 2017 and dropped another 15% in fiscal equity research analyst at Barclays. “He’s learning that.”
2020, to $72.3 billion. Profits have shriveled, too, and Scharf, for his part, sees a chance to restore the bank to
its shares, which fell 44% last year, have consistently un- its rightful place. “I came in with a clear understanding
derperformed those of other big banks since the scandal that the core franchise continued to be this great oppor-
erupted. “This company is a damaged company, and all tunity,” he says, “but that there was a tremendous amount
strategies have to be put on the table to bring it back to of work to do.”
a level of profitability that investors will find acceptable,”
says Gerard Cassidy, head of U.S. bank equity strategy at Scharf grew up in Westfield, N.J., a New York
RBC Capital Markets. suburb crowded with financial professionals like his fa-
When he took the gig, Scharf, now 55, stepped into one ther, a stockbroker. By age 13, Charlie was working back-
of the most closely scrutinized positions in finance. It’s office jobs at Manhattan brokerages. As an undergrad at
his third CEO stint at a Fortune 500 financial services Johns Hopkins, he initially had designs on becoming a re-
company, and an extremely well-compensated one. He can search chemist—until he had a sophomore-year epiphany.
earn up to $23 million annually, depending on stock in- “I was in physical chemistry, locked in a lab, when I said
centives. It also ranks among the toughest chief executive to myself, ‘I really don’t want to spend my life in a place
jobs in America. Given Wells’ status as one of the biggest without windows,’ ” he recalls. In business, he realized,
“Main Street” lenders, its overall health has implications “you could create something in a very different way.”
As fate would have it, a relative of Scharf ’s knew the

6,400
father of a banker named Jamie Dimon, the young chief
financial officer of Baltimore-based lender Commercial
Credit. Dimon brought the recent grad on board in 1987—
the start of a working relationship that would span more
than 20 years. Scharf played a variety of roles under Dimon
and Sandy Weill as they grew Commercial Credit into what
eventually became Citigroup. When Dimon landed the top
POSITIONS ELIMINATED IN Q4 2020 job at Bank One in 2000, he tapped Scharf as CFO. After
Bank One merged with JPMorgan Chase in 2004, Scharf
took the helm of Chase’s sprawling retail banking business.
With more than 260,000 employees, Wells Fargo has
Dimon recalls Scharf as able to “handle just about any-
one of the nation’s biggest workforces. More job
thing” Dimon threw at him: “He got stuff done; he had a
cuts are likely, however, as the bank repositions itself. good nose for cracking through the bull.” Scharf acquired
the seasoning that came with ever-larger roles; he also saw
Dimon’s job evolve as he led ever-larger companies. Of
for the broader economy too. Scharf ’s longtime mentor, what he learned from Dimon as a leader, Scharf says, “He
JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon, tells Fortune that stands in front. He doesn’t hide behind people. He doesn’t
the task Scharf signed up for is a challenge “too big to look at others when something goes wrong.”
walk away from,” adding, “It’s better for the country and Scharf would put those lessons into practice in 2012,
for the banking industry that they succeed.” when Visa tapped him as CEO. Visa was still grappling with
For now, Scharf is concentrating on creating a leaner, its 2008 transition from a private entity, owned by an asso-
more focused institution—shrinking the bank in order ciation of card-issuing banks, to a publicly traded company.
to save it. If he succeeds in shepherding Wells Fargo out At Visa’s San Francisco headquarters, Scharf found what he
of regulatory purgatory, he may restore the luster of one describes as an “insular” business that “didn’t really engage
of the grand old names of American banking. Should he with the technology community.” He aimed to rectify that,
fail, Wells could be permanently relegated to afterthought establishing relationships with fintechs like PayPal and
status among its blue-chip rivals. Stripe that expanded Visa’s footprint in digital payments—
Fortune spoke with Scharf and top Wells Fargo execu- a focus that proved prescient. Says current Visa president
tives—as well as analysts, critics, industry rivals, and Ryan McInerney, a JPMorgan alum who followed Scharf to
former colleagues of Scharf ’s—to capture the state of Visa: “A lot of the foundation he laid, especially as it relates
the turnaround, some 15 months into the CEO’s tenure. to digital commerce, you’re seeing the results now.”
It has been an eventful time that has featured sweeping Scharf left Visa in 2016, seeking to be closer to his
organizational changes—along with high-profile missteps family on the East Coast—and leaving behind a company
that fueled skepticism about whether Scharf can institute whose share price more than doubled during his tenure.
NEIGHBORHOOD
FIXTURE: Wells
Fargo has about
5,000 branches
nationwide.

Even amid lockdowns, Wells Fargo had “1 MILLION


CUSTOMERS A DAY COMING INTO OUR BRANCHES,”
says consumer banking head Mary Mack.

His experience there, as well as a subsequent stint as CEO tors also held Wells’ leadership accountable: Former CEO
of custodian bank BNY Mellon, taught him how all- John Stumpf, who stepped down after the scandal emerged
encompassing the chief ’s role was. “There’s no job that’s in 2016, was eventually handed a $17.5 million fine and a
comparable,” Scharf says. “The whole organization looks to lifetime ban from the banking industry. His successor, Tim
you for the wins and the losses, for setting the tone and the Sloan, resigned under political pressure in March 2019.
culture … Some love it, and some don’t love it.” Scharf falls In a report last year, the House Financial Services Com-
into the first category. mittee slammed Wells Fargo’s board and management for
Around the time he was leaving Visa, another San continually failing to address the company’s shortcomings,
Francisco–based company was reckoning with a scandal even years after the misdeeds came to light.
of tectonic proportions. Wells Fargo had been one of the few American banks to
The details of Wells Fargo’s fake-accounts fraud debacle emerge from the 2008 financial crisis with its reputation
are well documented: Driven by a hyperaggressive sales intact. As rivals stumbled, Wells grew stronger, as evi-
TING SHEN—BLO OMBERG/GE T T Y IMAGES

culture, employees opened accounts for and sold financial denced by its $15 billion mid-crisis acquisition of Wachovia.
products to millions of customers—without their approval. Now, it finds itself the bête noire of the banking sector. “We
The problems were endemic across the company, with were growing while everyone else was focused on running
similar sharklike misconduct surfacing in Wells’ mortgage, themselves better,” says Jon Weiss, a 15-year Wells veteran
auto lending, and wealth management businesses. who now leads the corporate and investment banking divi-
The fallout proved devastating. From 2016 through sion. “We were to some degree victims of our own success,
2018, federal regulators hit Wells with five consent orders and maybe we could have used a bit more introspection.”
laying bare the institution’s mismanagement—along with By spring 2019, Wells’ board was searching for a CEO
sanctions that included the constraining asset cap. Regula- who could lead the company in a long, hard look in the mir-
74 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

ror. Six months after Sloan stepped down, Scharf got the TOTAL RETURNS FOR THE ‘BIG FOUR’ BANK STOCKS
job. Solving the bank’s regulatory issues, Scharf said shortly CUMULATIVE FROM DEC. 31, 2015, TO JAN. 20, 2021
after his appointment, would be “clearly the first priority.”
150%
138.7%
For the first meeting of Wells Fargo’s oper- JPMORGAN
CHASE
ating committee under the new CEO, its leaders gathered
in a windowless conference room in St. Louis to address 112.0%
100
BANK OF
the daunting business of turning the bank around. “Char- AMERICA
lie brought in a legal pad—not a PowerPoint presentation,
not 40 pages of colored pictures the way that an invest-
ment bank would present—with a page and a half of 50
notes, line by line, that he wanted to go through to explain 36.9%
the way he does business,” Weiss recalls. “It was a disarm- CITIGROUP
ing, casual, but very focused discussion with no baloney.”
Matter-of-factness and a “no frills” demeanor are com- 0
mon threads in descriptions of Scharf; his directness can
be as striking as his trademark shock of white hair. But –29.4%
WELLS
plainspokenness can also be an asset for a chief executive FARGO
–50%
with bad news to deliver and tough problems to solve.
The biggest problem Scharf identified at Wells Fargo was 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
an exceptionally decentralized organization—one lacking SOURCE: BLOOMBERG
the clear lines of accountability that might have prevented
the fake-account fraud. The bank also lacked risk-and-
compliance safeguards that most banks of comparable size
already had. “We did have a relatively siloed organization, unveiling, the Justice Department announced that Wells
where you had intact businesses that were running a bit would pay $3 billion to settle criminal charges related to
independently,” says Mary Mack, who has been with Wells the accounts scandal. The consensus was that this would
for 26 years and now leads its consumer and small-business be Wells’ last major penalty, but it offered another stark
banking division. “I don’t think we did a very good job of example of the scandal’s erosion of the bank’s profits. An-
stepping back and saying, ‘Could that condition or set of other sign of the lingering cost: In 2020, Wells Fargo spent
weaknesses actually exist across the entire company?’ ” $6.7 billion on “professional/outside services”—more than
Scharf began a major overhaul, starting with turnover at 9% of total revenue—the lion’s share of which reflects legal
the top. Nine of the 17 people now serving with Scharf on and consulting fees related to the post-scandal cleanup.
the bank’s senior leadership committee are new hires. Prior Meanwhile, the pandemic forced Wells Fargo to put daily
to last year, the role of chief operating officer didn’t exist at emergencies ahead of long-term reforms. Scharf, still in
Wells Fargo. Scharf created it and recruited Scott Powell, the early days of meeting Wells’ workforce, found himself
a former colleague at Citi and JPMorgan, to fill it. Powell confined to his Long Island home office. Keeping the bank’s
most recently served as CEO of Santander’s U.S. business, thousands of branches open was essential—even amid
where he helped that bank cope with regulatory sanc- lockdowns, Wells had “1 million customers a day coming
tions of its own. Several other new executives are also past into our branches,” says Mack—but keeping them safe, and
colleagues of Scharf ’s: CFO Mike Santomassimo had the transitioning nonbranch employees to remote work, was a
same role at BNY Mellon; Mike Weinbach and Barry Som- logistical obstacle course.
mers, who now head Wells’ consumer lending and wealth COVID-19 also triggered a mini-scandal that echoed the
management divisions, respectively, are JPMorgan alumni. bank’s past misdeeds. After the government enacted mort-
In February 2020, Scharf unveiled a reorganization gage relief measures to help people who couldn’t keep up
plan that redrew the company’s business lines across five with payments, no fewer than 1,600 borrowers complained
distinct divisions. Just as important was a reconfiguration that Wells Fargo had placed their loans in forbearance with-
of Wells’ risk-management system: Each of the five divi- out their consent—an act that could actually harm the bor-
sions now has its own dedicated risk officer—a structure rowers’ credit ratings and prevent them from refinancing.
designed to ensure no unit of the bank is cutting corners. “We were erring on the side of trying to help customers in a
Analysts hailed Scharf for bringing Wells Fargo in line very difficult time,” Scharf says of the snafu, which the bank
with other banks’ best practices. But subsequent events scrambled to correct. “Every institution makes mistakes.”
offered persistent reminders of the work that remains to The bank also entangled itself in difficult questions
be done. Last February, just days after the reorganization’s around diversity. No incident from his first year at Wells
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CA N A N YO N E F IX W E LL S FA RG O ?

Fargo proved more threatening to Scharf ’s reputation than pany’s goal of doubling Black representation in its senior
comments he made in a June memo announcing new diver- ranks over the next five years, as well as its plan (announced
sity initiatives, in which he cast doubt on the depth of talent in his June memo) to tie some of executives’ compensation
available for top jobs at the bank. “The unfortunate reality to the diversity of their business lines. He also seems acutely
is that there is a very limited pool of Black talent to recruit aware that the hire-who-you-know approach that he has re-
from with this specific experience,” he wrote. lied on for years has also perpetuated inequities. “When you
With nationwide awareness of structural racism honed to look at the representation inside this company—and this
a sharp edge by the killing of George Floyd just a few weeks is true of most financial institutions—there’s a tremendous
earlier, the comments were particularly tone-deaf. They need to do things differently,” he says.
upset many employees and drew widespread condemna-
tion from critics outside the bank. They also highlighted the January 15 at first glance seemed like just another
whiteness and maleness of the ranks of former colleagues dreary day for Wells Fargo. Disclosing earnings for the
from which Scharf had recruited many of his lieutenants. fourth quarter of 2020, the bank reported revenues that
While his nine hires on the leaders’ committee include a missed analysts’ estimates, and shares fell nearly 8% on
woman and two Black men, the highest-ranking ones, the day. The general gloom obscured the fact that Wells
including the COO and CFO, are white men. “What we’ve Fargo also revealed substantial details about its future—as
seen is that he’s replaced one insular group with another,” a leaner institution doubling down on what it does well.
says Nick Weiner of the financial industry labor group Recapping some moves and unveiling others, Scharf ’s
Committee for Better Banks. team listed a series of asset sales that would extract the
Scharf quickly apologized for the “limited pool” com- bank from “noncore” businesses. On their way out are
ments, saying they reflected “my own unconscious bias.” Wells Fargo’s $10 billion student loan portfolio and its
Wells has since created a diversity, representation, and Canadian equipment-financing business. The bank is
inclusion group: Its chief, Kleber Santos, who joined the also looking to off-load its asset management arm, which
company in November from Capital One, sits on the senior oversees more than $600 billion for institutional clients.
leadership committee. Months later, Scharf is solemn and “The businesses that we’re exiting are perfectly good busi-
cautious as he discusses the gaffe. He points to the com- nesses,” Scharf said on the earnings call. “The question is,

REORGANIZATION
CONSUMER AND WEALTH AND CORPORATE
SMALL-BUSINESS INVESTMENT AND INVESTMENT
BANKING MANAGEMENT BANKING
DIGGING AND LENDING

SMALLER, 2020 REVENUE 2020 REVENUE

DEEPER 2020 REVENUE


$34 BILLION
$14.5 BILLION $13.8 BILLION

WELLS HEADS
HEAD
BARRY SOMMERS
HEAD
JON WEISS
MARY MACK AND
TO SURVIVE ITS CURRENT MICHAEL WEINBACH Wells Fargo managed This division includes a
WOES AND KEEP $2 trillion in total assets at $110 billion commercial
SHAREHOLDERS HAPPY, Wells Fargo has one of the the end of 2020—though it real estate portfolio and
A BIG BANK PLANS TO largest home mortgage plans to sell its $600 billion a big stake in “C&I” loans
DOWNSIZE. businesses in the U.S., institutional asset manage- (financing for businesses
and this division is Wells’ ment business, the better buying equipment and ma-
biggest business segment to focus on individuals. chinery). Overall, the bank’s
by far. Falling interest rates Wells’ wealth manage- loans are split nearly 50/50
WITH REGULATORY sanc- have hurt the division’s ment team has historically between commercial and
tions limiting its ability revenue as of late. But the served “mass affluent” consumer lending. While
to grow, Wells Fargo has bank’s $400-billion-plus and middle-class custom- it’s not a household name
been shedding “noncore” consumer loan portfolio ers as well as richer ones. in the field, Wells Fargo
units to focus on its most also includes strong auto- Scharf sees the division is still the ninth-biggest
promising businesses. financing and credit card synergizing with consumer investment bank in the U.S.,
Here are the units that businesses that command lending: “Huge numbers of according to Dealogic, and
CEO Charlie Scharf hopes higher interest rates and customers who come into Scharf’s team sees that as
will help the bank thrive should perk up as the our branches have money a business in which it could
again in better times. economy improves. to invest,” he says. win market share.
7 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : CA N A N YO N E F IX W E LL S FA RG O ?

OUTLOOK: UNCLEAR

WILL LIFE GET BETTER FOR BANKS?


BANKS HAVE BEEN SLOW TO RECOVER FROM THE COVID RECESSION —AND THE ROAD AHEAD LOOKS ROCKY.

FINANCIAL FIRMS, banks A SLOW, UNEVEN ROCK-BOTTOM NEW MANAGEMENT


included, had a rough 2020 RECOVERY INTEREST RATES IN WASHINGTON
that wasn’t reflected by
the country’s soaring stock
markets. (The S&P 500’s Some key indicators for The Fed returned rates to Bank leaders won’t miss
financials sector lost 4% banks, including mort- near zero to deal with eco- the volatility and unpre-
in 2020, compared with a gage demand and deposit nomic fallout from the pan- dictability of the Trump
16% gain for the broader growth, have remained demic, and it has signaled administration, but they
market.) The coronavirus strong. A resurgent bull that they could remain may find themselves feel-
pandemic forced America’s market has driven trad- there for years to come. ing nostalgic for some of its
largest financial institutions ing revenues, and more That puts a ceiling on the policies. President Biden
to retool on the fly, leaving economic stimulus seems rates banks can charge will likely seek a reversal
them scrambling to sup- likely. But high unemploy- customers and reduces of Trump’s pro–Wall Street
port their commercial and ment and lingering woes “net interest income,” a deregulatory agenda, as
consumer borrowers, and for small businesses remain key driver of revenues. (It’s well as the undoing of
undermining the income burdensome headwinds, the difference between some tax cuts for corpora-
they made from interest with no clear end in sight what banks earn on loans tions and high-net-worth
rate spreads. Though senti- until COVID-19 abates. In and what they pay out on individuals. Look for banks
ment has improved, 2021 the short run, big banks will deposits.) In the near term, to team up with regulators
looks like it will be far from emphasize their profit- expect banks to step up to lay ground rules for new
a stroll. able—and thus far, rela- loan volume to make up developments in fintech
tively pandemic-proof— for what they’re losing in (like cryptocurrencies and
wealth management interest, especially in the digital payments) and capi-
and investment banking mortgage space. tal markets (such as direct
businesses. listings and SPACs).

are they best housed within Wells Fargo?” until it can satisfy regulators that it has fully reformed.
In Scharf ’s vision, that housing is reserved for bread- The bank and its regulators refuse to comment on a
and-butter businesses that Wells has dominated for de- timeline for the removal of the asset cap, citing legal
cades—including consumer banking and personal wealth constraints. “I understand people’s desire to hear exactly
management—as well as for investment banking, where what the company can look like when we get beyond these
the company believes it can rise in the ranks. things,” Scharf tells Fortune. But until his risk-control re-
To sustain profits while it pivots, Wells Fargo will keep gime impresses the authorities, “beyond” will have to wait.
cutting. The company has identified more than $8 billion in Some 20 years ago, while living in Chicago as CFO at
long-term cost savings, of which job cuts are part and par- Bank One, Scharf began taking guitar lessons. During the
cel: Wells reduced headcount by 6,400 in the fourth quar- pandemic lockdown, he reconnected with his old instruc-
ter, and more cuts are expected this year. The bank plans to tor, and Scharf now studies with him over Zoom once a
dramatically reduce its real estate footprint, scaling down week, playing blues and rock. “It’s creative,” he enthuses.
its office space by up to 20%. A downsizing of its branch “The idea that you can pick up [a guitar] and make some-
network is well underway. Wells Fargo had about 5,000 thing out of it, differently than someone else who you hand
branch locations at the end of 2020, down from 6,600 in the same device to, to me is just an extraordinary thing.”
2009, and it plans to close 250 more this year. Scharf is committed to coaxing something new and harmo-
Ambitious as it is, the plan will likely leave Wells Fargo nious out of Wells Fargo. But it’s going to take quite a while
running in place insofar as overall growth is concerned— longer to get the instrument back in tune.
99 Tips to Help Make
Your Retirement
More Comfortable
Exclusive Offer—Call Now!
Get these must-have retirement tips for FREE by calling 888-442-2072
or texting* “Info” to 68658 or visiting FisherFreeGuide.com/Info

Tip #40 Tip #44 Tip #85


How can you How can you simplify How can you spend less
plan for taxes in Social Security? without changing your
retirement? lifestyle?

Whether you’re already retired or planning to retire soon, you need answers to your pressing retirement questions on money,
health, family and more. Learn ways to improve your finances and retirement lifestyle without making major sacrifices in our
FREE guide, 99 Retirement Tips.

If you have an investment portfolio of $500,000 or more, please call to get 99 Retirement Tips now. Millions of people have
requested Fisher Investments’ free guides—they combine 40+ years of financial advice and tips from successful retirees,
so you can get better outcomes for your retirement.

Call Toll-free 888-442-2072


Text* “Info” to 68658 or Visit FisherFreeGuide.com/Info

*Terms and Conditions at . Message and data rates may apply.


Please see our Privacy Policy at .

©2021 Fisher Investments. 5525 NW Fisher Creek Drive, Camas, WA 98607.


Investments in securities involve the risk of loss. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns.
C O N T E N T F R O M R E D W O O D TA X S P E C I A L I S T S

BILL HALL
CEO and Cofounder,
Redwood Tax Specialists, LLC

BRINGING INSTITUTIONAL
TAX SAVING TO THE SMALL
BUSINESS OWNER
“Big Four” accounting firms, working as a strategic tax
Redwood Tax Specialists offers consultant for Fortune 500 companies. He had been

innovative solutions for reducing involved in dozens of highly technical tax-reduction


strategies and implemented tax savings to the tune of
tax burdens on business owners hundreds of millions of dollars.
But it wasn’t until after Fedyshyn left the Big Four
and high-net-worth individuals. and ultimately owned his own CPA firm in Shelby, N.C.,
in 2014 that he first experienced a sense of the chal-
lenges faced by more traditional CPA firms.
“Endless legislative changes, commodity services
with high competition, pricing pressures, and technol-
ogy changes were just a few of the challenges I worked
BECAUSE OF COMPLICATED RULES, FEAR OF THE with then—and problems that CPAs are faced with
Internal Revenue Service, and the generalized today,” Fedyshyn says. “I quickly realized that CPAs
knowledge of most certified public accountants have to be nimble and wear many hats.”
(CPAs), many businesses just follow a standard tax This realization would lead Fedyshyn to start push-
plan. But a customized plan can help increase tax ing long-held boundaries within the CPA industry. His
savings—something that Cornelius, N.C.–based firm began partnering with other CPAs, including sev-
Redwood Tax Specialists brings to the table for CPA eral of his prior colleagues at the Big Four, rather than
clients every day. viewing them as competitive threats. Fedyshyn formed
long-term relationships with dozens of profession-
A Storied History als with niche tax expertise and began to implement
By the time Scott Fedyshyn, lead strategic tax planner tax plans more like a project manager than a CPA.
and cofounder of Redwood Tax Specialists, established Ultimately, this allows Fedyshyn to assemble a team
the firm along with Bill Hall in 2019, he’d already had of professionals for each tax plan he implements and
17 years of experience, including tenure at two of the offer his clients multiple strategies simultaneously.
C O N T E N T F R O M R E D W O O D TA X S P E C I A L I S T S

“THE BIGGEST
STRATEGIC ADVANTAGE
WE HAVE AT REDWOOD OVER
OTHER SERVICE PROVIDERS
OUT THERE IS OUR ABILITY TO
BRING HUNDREDS OF STRATEGIES AT
ONCE TO ANY GIVEN CLIENT.”
SCOTT FEDYSHYN, CPA, CFP®
Lead Strategic Tax Planner and
Cofounder, Redwood Tax Specialists, LLC

In short, Fedyshyn’s outside-the-box thinking with a network of managing directors all across
allowed him to be flexible—a skill that ultimately the country. Within a year, Redwood had grown to
drives his position at Redwood Tax Specialists. include almost 300 managing directors.
“Early on, I realized that the traditional model Hall explains that Redwood’s tax-reduction
just doesn’t allow for the necessary time and plans aren’t designed to replace the existing
monetary investments in strategic tax-reduction relationship between a client and their advisors;
services,” Fedyshyn says. “Tax planning is the rather, they can be utilized by CPAs in addition
number one service requested by clients, but it to a client’s current strategy. Redwood’s turnkey
takes a tremendous amount of resources to do it advisory service, aimed at tax compliance firms,
right, keeping this service out of reach for most provides an opportunity for those firms to fully
CPA firms. Ultimately, the demand from clients outsource tax planning, and avoid the intensive
and CPAs alike is what led to the creation of education and investment requirements neces-
Redwood and our back-office tax planning team, sary to expand into these technical areas.
and the expansion of strategic partnerships with “The biggest strategic advantage we have at
advisors.” Redwood over other service providers out there is
Leveraging the expertise he’d gained by work- our ability to bring hundreds of strategies at once
ing on tax-reduction strategies at the Big Four, to any given client,” says Fedyshyn. “We customize
Fedyshyn began implementing the same strate- each strategy for every client in order to achieve
gies on a smaller and more affordable scale at his very specific outcomes, and we offer a complete
firm. Some of his clients began realizing a 30% implementation team. Nobody else is doing this
to 50% overall tax reduction, and Fedyshyn’s firm with the level of competence that our team has.”
flourished. Even when the COVID-19 pandemic hit and
workforces went fully remote, Redwood’s col-
A Fortuitous Meeting laborative approach meant that it had a fortuitous
As Fedyshyn’s firm and its innovative approach head start, as the team was already using digital
became more widely known within the industry, technologies to connect with directors and CPAs
Fedyshyn eventually crossed paths with financial from coast to coast. Hall even points out that
services professional and coach Bill Hall. Hall Redwood’s remote service model can almost be
had spent most of his 38-year career helping regarded as the new industry standard.
high-profile financial advisors and CPAs grow their “The results we’ve seen at Redwood have
businesses by utilizing comprehensive tax strate- been spectacular,” Hall says. “This kind of col-
gies. Hall’s extensive professional network and laboration with deep-dive tax experts, along with
industry connections were a perfect complement our ability to maintain existing relationships, is
to Fedyshyn’s more technical tax foundation. a breath of fresh air to the industry. We’re remov-
They decided to start Redwood Tax Special- ing barriers and delivering unmatched client
ists with a dedicated focus on tax reduction for service, and we’re fully prepared to take every
business owners and high-net-worth clients. Out opportunity presented to us in regard to tax
of the gate, their plan was to work collaboratively benefits under any administration.” ■
8 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

A drone’s-eye view of the damage


to bins at the Heartland Co-Op grain
elevator in Luther, Iowa, on Aug. 11,
the day after the derecho.

WHAT COMES

DANIEL ACKER—GET T Y IMAGES


W H AT C O M E S N E X T

THE HEARTLAND

Hawkeye Elegy
L A S T S U M M E R A M O N S T E R S TO R M O F U N P R EC E D E N T E D V I O L E N C E TO R E AC R O S S I O WA ,
L E AV I N G B I L L I O N S O F D O L L A R S I N DA M AG E D FA R M L A N D I N I T S WA K E . I T WA S A B R U TA L
B LO W TO A N EC O N O M Y A L R E A DY R E E L I N G F R O M A N U N FO R G I V I N G PA N D E M I C A N D A S TAT E
D I V I D E D BY P O L I T I C S L I K E N E V E R B E FO R E . W H AT W I L L I T TA K E TO R E B U I L D A N D R E U N I T E ?

NEXT BY ERIK A FRY

The weather report showed a slight risk of But nothing—not that work, not his Ph.D. and two me-
thunderstorms, and in the early hours of Aug. 10, Justin teorology degrees, nor his storm-chasing experience in the
Glisan, Iowa’s state climatologist, was feeling hopeful Midwest—prepared him for what so suddenly material-
about that. The land was dry and crying out for a good ized over Iowa that day. He saw it coming from the deck of
soak. On a call with field agronomists that morning, he’d his Des Moines home, a wall of dark-as-night clouds that
exchanged wishes that the storm line making its way sent him scuttling to his basement. He was only halfway
across Nebraska would hold together over Iowa. there when a tree limb hit his house and ripped out a gas
Despite coming off two of the state’s wettest years on main. The security alarm went off the moment he lost
record and ideal planting conditions in the spring, the power—precisely four seconds past 11 a.m.
summer months had been warm and windy, and by Au- Over the course of the next two hours, the “monster”
gust, severe drought had taken hold in West Central Iowa. storm Glisan witnessed ripped across the state of Iowa
Glisan is attached to Iowa’s Department of Agriculture with increasing intensity and devastation, leaving in its
and Land Stewardship, and on field visits, he had observed wake felled trees, downed power lines, overturned semis,
the telltale signs that crops were experiencing physiologi- crumpled grain bins, flattened crops, and mangled homes
cal stress: The corn had started to “fire,” its lower leaves and businesses. By the time the storm petered out in Ohio,
turning a brittle yellow as the plant shut down to conserve at the end of its 14-hour, 770-mile run, it had caused some
water; the leaves of soybeans, meanwhile, were flipping $11 billion in damage, making it the most costly thunder-
during the day to keep in what moisture they could. storm in American history, according to data from the Na-
All summer long, Glisan had watched storms approach tional Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
the region, and just fizzle out as they hit dry air. The state’s At its peak, the wind gusts that day are thought to have
farmland desperately needed rain. exceeded 140 miles per hour in Iowa, such an anomaly in
Before he became state climatologist in 2018, Glisan the middle of the country that NASA and Glisan are study-
worked as a research atmospheric scientist at Iowa State ing photos of damage to make sense of the storm.
University, building regional climate models and study- Even in a state full of weather-conscious farmers, the
ing the fluid dynamics of the atmosphere. Every day, event—which many Iowans still describe as an “inland
he thought about the acts of Mother Nature in terms of hurricane”—seemed completely alien and unworldly,
systems and parameters. like nothing they’d seen before. In fact, it was a derecho

A grant from the NIHCM Foundation generously helped fund reporting for this story.
8 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E H E A RTL A N D

(pronounced deh-REY-cho), a term coined in the 1880s Ben Olson, a fourth-generation farmer in Benton
by Iowa’s first official weather observer, Gustavus Detlef County, was out hauling manure; Willie Fairley, a Cedar
Hinrichs. A cantankerous, polymathic professor who had Rapids restaurateur was picking up supplies for his rib
a hand in developing the periodic table, Hinrichs believed shack; Steve Shriver, a Cedar Rapids business owner, was
there should be a term to distinguish Iowa’s straight-line grabbing lunch with his mom; Maria Gonzalez, a social
wind events from rotational ones (a.k.a., tornadoes). worker in Marshalltown had just gone out with her dog,
He settled on the Spanish term “derecho” (meaning and her husband had run to the bank.
“straight”), which is defined today as a windstorm that Father Craig Steimel, the pastor at five Catholic parishes
travels at least 240 miles with sustained winds over in rural Benton Country, returned from running errands
58 mph. Though such storms occur about every two years in the Cedar Rapids area just as the sky turned dark. His
in Iowa, the term was not widely known in the state. Even home in Norway is adjacent to St. Michael’s Church, and
DuWayne Tewes, the veteran disaster coordinator based in the next thing he knew a garbage can flew by his window
FEMA’s Kansas City office who led the agency’s response and then St. Michael’s 110-foot, 140-year-old steeple
in Iowa, conceded he’d never heard the term before. landed in his yard. As the storm raged for another 30 min-
Tornadoes are of course the common disaster of the utes, he wondered if his house would collapse. Would the
plains—terrifying and devastating, but short-lived and church blow over? “It was just ungodly,” he says.
limited in their path of destruction. Derechos tend to The storm was a trauma. But it was also more than that.
be longer and more sweeping affairs, and this one was It was a collision of disasters—this extreme weather event
especially so. The storm essentially traveled due east along hit America’s heartland in the middle of an economy-
Highway 30—the old Lincoln Highway—and Inter- bruising pandemic and a summer of bitter polarization.
state 80, cutting a swath of the state 90 miles wide that For many, the derecho layered on more hardship and stress
includes valuable farmland, a handful of meatpacking when they could least afford it. For local health officials, the
towns, Iowa’s two largest university campuses (Ames and storm complicated the already challenging task of managing
Iowa City), and Iowa’s two largest cities (Des Moines and a raging virus. For leaders, it piled another few Jenga pieces
Cedar Rapids). on the COVID-19 socioeconomic balancing act.
They were all caught, like Glisan, more or less un- It’s not fair to reduce Iowa’s very real disasters to sym-
prepared. Derechos are especially complex, impromptu bol, but on Aug. 10, with its flattened fields and exploded
storm systems, making them hard to forecast with much barns, Iowa looked like America felt.
lead time. Most impacted Iowans started their day with
a standard August weather report and went about their
activities, with no inkling that they’d have to shelter from When the rest of the country thinks of Iowa,
100 mph winds in a few hours, let alone live a week or they almost certainly conjure up long, flat stretches of
more without power. cornfields and farms; flyover country populated almost
exclusively by white people. But the state today is far more
complex and diverse than the old stereotype suggests—
like anywhere in America, it’s a place in flux, full of ten-
THE STORM’S PATH OF DESTRUCTION sions and contradictions.
COUNTIES DECLARED DISASTER AREA AFTER THE AUGUST 2020 DERECHO One of the nation’s top producers of corn, hogs, and
soybeans, Iowa’s economy remains driven by agriculture
MINNESOTA
WISCONSIN and related manufacturing. But as those industries have
MASON CITY shed labor, Iowa’s growth has shifted to more populated
urban areas, powered by sectors like banking, insurance,
business services, and health care.
MARSHALLTOWN
FT. DODGE Iowa has one of the nation’s highest labor participation
rates—it’s a quirk of the Plains states that many middle-
AMES CEDAR RAPIDS aged and older women work—but there aren’t enough
TAMA
MADRID HIGHWAY 30 job opportunities to match the number of highly skilled
IOWA CITY workers the state supplies. Indeed, Iowa exports a lot of
NEB.
DES MOINES the talent it develops. “We educate the hell out of Iowans,”
OMAHA says Dave Swenson, an economist with Iowa State Univer-
IO WA sity. “But the way our economy is configured with its heavy
OTTUMWA
ILLINOIS loading, production, manufacturing, and agriculture—all
50 MILES of that talent we educate, we can’t use it.”
MISSOURI
Over the past decade, 70 of Iowa’s 99 counties lost popu-
SOURCE: FEMA
Scott and Jenni Birker on
their farm near Garrison,
Iowa. The couple were
already struggling with
the pandemic when the
derecho destroyed their
barn and damaged tractors.

lation. That includes many rural counties but also—and The picture it reveals, while distinctly Iowan in some
more troubling, says Swenson—the semi-urban ones that ways, is one that, from a distance, looks fundamentally
are home to “micropolitans,” the manufacturing-dependent American in 2021. It reveals a society struggling to grapple
cities of 10,000 to 50,000 that have been shedding jobs and with a series of complex, interlocking issues at once—a novel
now have physical footprints larger than their economies. coronavirus and climate change; an economy and demogra-
It’s a dynamic that plays into the state’s deepening urban phy in flux; a public bitterly polarized by politics. Sitting as
and rural divide, which has been increasingly visible in the it does in the geographic middle of the U.S., Iowa functions
traditionally purple state’s politics. In 2016 and 2020, Iowa naturally as a microcosm of the broader nation. And the
supported Trump, but in 2020, more of that vote was in questions it’s wrestling with echo those at the heart of our
rural parts of the state. As is the case across the country, current circumstances: How do you balance public health
Iowa’s red communities have gotten redder, and its blue and the economy? Personal freedom and the greater good?
communities bluer. At a high level, red is winning: Today, Fear and science with blind certainty and belief?
Iowa’s governor, both of its senators, and three of its four In short, what can Iowa show us about our way forward?
representatives in Congress are Republican.
Going into 2020, Iowa’s overall economy was flat. “It
wasn’t growing at all,” says Swenson. Unemployment spiked Like many people, I spent a lot of 2020 wor-
like it did everywhere at the start of the pandemic but has rying. Catastrophizing is something I’ve always been good
since fallen to 3.6%. Swenson says that’s less good news at, and so early last year, when the esteemed infectious dis-
than it appears: Iowa didn’t gain jobs during the year, it ease expert Michael Osterholm told me that he expected a
lost workforce. Swenson suspects the dropouts are largely novel coronavirus in China to spread like the wind, my mind
women shouldering childcare responsibilities or people instantly went to my parents, both of whom are in their
who retired early for pandemic-related safety concerns. seventies and one a lifelong smoker, in Cedar Rapids.
Not surprisingly, how Iowans weathered the past year When I told my colleagues I was worried about my par-
and all of its unanticipated catastrophes depends on ents getting the virus, they chuckled. In Iowa? That’s the
where you look and whom you ask. And so this accounting safest place you could be. This was the frenzied month of
is a mosaic of many different individual stories, told as the February when we lacked such imagination that the U.S.
derecho blew, from west to east. government was spending millions to evacuate American

PHOTOGRAPH BY DANNY WILCOX FRAZIER—VII/REDUX PICTURES


8 4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

citizens from foreign countries, as if one could outrun the


virus and that U.S. borders would protect them.
The coronavirus did of course reach Iowa. The first
known cases were in early March—an adventurous group
of senior travelers had contracted it in Egypt while on
a Nile cruise—though it was probably spreading in the
Hawkeye State already.
In the beginning, Iowa reacted to the coronavirus like
much of the country, with the abrupt closure of schools,
theaters, churches, bars, indoor dining, barbers, and
tanning salons. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds, a conservative
Republican in her fourth year on the job, issued a state
public health emergency because of the virus on March 17.
But she did not issue a shelter-in-place order, one of the
few governors to not do so, leaving Iowa more open for
business than most states.
I sent my parents N95 masks as well as a pulse oximeter,
which I asked them to use regularly with the strong, and
surely annoying, suggestion that they report their readings
back to me. (They didn’t.) We did weekly Zooms, which
lifted spirits and provided some peace of mind.
Iowa, with a population of 3.2 million, is not a par-

“These people, they must have FLUNKED SCIENCE ,”


says the mayor of Marshalltown about his citizens who
won’t wear face masks. “They just DON’T GET IT.”

ticularly dense state—it ranks 35th in the U.S. in density. euthanize them.
But in the early weeks of the pandemic, the state had an The state’s curve hadn’t flattened much before Iowa
alarming number of cases, most of them linked to meat- reopened in mid-May, and since then the picture has gotten
packing plants and nursing homes. The virus was hitting much, much worse. There were plenty of things, brought to
the essential and the infirm. “The tradeoff in Iowa was we light by local media and the public health community, that
were more than willing to maintain our economy, at the did not inspire great confidence in the state’s response—
expense of the health and well-being of our workforce,” like, for instance, the fact that the state’s main testing infra-
says Swenson, the Iowa State economist. structure was provided by an inexperienced Utah startup
That Faustian deal led to community spread and that won a no-bid contract seemingly due to its connections
punished other businesses too. Ben Olson, the farmer in to Ashton Kutcher, Iowa’s favorite celebrity son.
Benton County, had 200 beef cattle lined up, ready for Most of all, Reynolds was absolutely insistent, press
delivery at a nearby Tyson plant on March 31. Together conference after press conference, that the best approach
they represented hundreds of thousands of dollars and the to the pandemic was to put it in Iowans’ responsible hands.
seven-month investment in raising them from 800 pounds The state didn’t need to order its citizens about what to do
to their precisely desired sale weight—1,500 pounds. He because she trusted them to do the right thing. She wouldn’t
got a call 12 hours before go time: There was an outbreak issue a mask mandate, nor would she give mayors in her
at the plant; he’d have to wait. The same thing happened state the power to do so.
two weeks later. He sold his oversize cattle a month late, At the time, my father was still holding out hope that
for a bad price. Pig farmers across the state faced similar there would be Iowa football games to attend in the fall,
dilemmas; some, with no market for their hogs, had to and the prospect of him in a stadium with the mask-less
Kimberly Elder (left), the emergency
management coordinator for Marshall
County, is a one-woman disaster relief
department. Restaurateur Alfonso
Medina’s slogan, “No love, no tacos,”
went viral in October.

masses was among my worst COVID fears at the time. on what had happened beyond mention of a wind event
Then, in the middle of the afternoon on Aug. 10, my in Chicago. Cedar Rapids hadn’t been blown off the map
mom sent a group text that began, “We are safe [prayer exactly, but it, along with hundreds of other communities,
hands emoji] …” There was a series of photos that were had blown off the grid.
barely recognizable as their backyard. “Tornado!?” My All of the Cedar Rapids metropolitan area, some
sister texted. My brother, who lives a block away from 132,000 people, lost power in the storm. (Across the
my parents, wrote “land hurricane.” They didn’t have the state, 680,000 customers did.) With cell towers toppled,
power or cell reception to communicate much beyond some lost communications too. For a 51-hour period, St.
that, and for the next 48 hours it was as if Cedar Rapids Luke’s Hospital, one of two medical centers in downtown
had been blown off the face of the earth. Cedar Rapids, was a complete island—losing Internet,
There were a few video clips of the intense storm circu- electronic medical records, the landline, and service from
lating on social media, but it was hard to find much news all three of Cedar Rapids’ cell carriers. At the same time,
Eastern Iowans who had been injured in the storm or
debris-cleaning efforts were pouring into the emergency
RATE OF DAILY NEW CASES OF COVID-19 room. The hospital saw twice its normal volume in the 24
150 CASES PER 100,000
hours after the derecho. “It was probably the scariest time
I’ve had as a hospital administrator,” the hospital’s CEO,
HIGHEST: Michelle Niermann of UnityPoint Cedar Rapids, tells me.
NOV. 15, 2020
146.5 Assessing the scope of the damage was especially chal-
100 lenging in Cedar Rapids, which—beyond the loss of power
and communications—was initially almost untraversable
because of all the debris and fallen trees. (As a “Tree City
IOWA USA,” Cedar Rapids a lost an estimated 65% of its canopy
50 in the storm.)
It’s hard not to think of the derecho as a blatant spec-
U.S. tacle of climate change, particularly when the city it hit
hardest, Cedar Rapids, is not long recovered from the
0
freak 500-year flood that destroyed much of its downtown
MARCH 9, 2020 JULY SEPT. NOV. JAN. 2021 and a good chunk of its affordable housing in 2008.
SOURCE: CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION, 7-DAY AVERAGE

PHOTOGRAPHS BY DANNY WILCOX FRAZIER—VII/REDUX PICTURES


8 6 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

As climatologist Glisan told me, it’s difficult to link Anti-mask protesters inside the rotunda of the Iowa Capitol in
a single extreme weather event to climate change. But Des Moines on Jan. 11, 2021. Marshalltown Mayor Joel Greer (at
left, in suit) with Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds (in jeans). The governor
there’s plenty of subtle evidence that Iowa’s weather is
didn’t issue a mask mandate until late in 2020.
changing and increasing the odds of damaging storms like
the derecho. Much of Glisan’s job is helping farmers adapt
to that reality—like preparing for more frequent heavy landscape were reflecting their whole year’s experience
rainfall. (The probability of receiving more than three back at them.
inches of rain in a 24-hour period in Iowa has tripled over
the historical rate in the past 30 years.)
In the 2020 Iowa Farm and Rural Life poll, 81% of The derecho wreaked havoc everywhere
farmers said they believe climate change is occurring, up it hit. In Madrid (pronounced MAD-rid), 30 miles north
from 68% in 2011. That’s a much greater percentage than of Des Moines, the storm peeled the roof off the four-floor

F R O M L E F T: K E L S E Y K R E M E R —T H E R E G I S T E R / U S A T O D AY N E T W O R K / R E U T E R S ;
across Iowa’s general public, of whom 67% believe global Madrid Home, a senior living center, where six coronavirus
warming is happening. (The rate is 72% nationally.) patients were in isolation and receiving treatment on the
I didn’t get to speak much to my parents during the 10 facility’s top floor. Kris Hansen, CEO of Western Home
days they were in the dark, dealing with the derecho. Most Communities, which runs the site, was in a virtual meeting
O L I V I A S U N —T H E R E G I S T E R / U S A T O D AY N E T W O R K / R E U T E R S
attempts to call were met with understandable frustration when he got the panicked call from his executive director
about draining their phone battery. I know it was tough in Madrid.
on them. My mom is still sometimes moved to tears when For Hansen, who was an hour to the northeast, in a part
she talks about the volunteers—friends, family, and total of the state where skies were still clear, it was an unthink-
strangers—who came with their chain saws to help them able twist. With 10 senior-living communities in the state
out. My family was lucky in that the trees that fell on their of Iowa, the pandemic had been a real test for Western
houses did not cause significant damage. My parents got a Home—for all the reasons familiar to long-term-care
new roof, which was covered by insurance; my brother will facilities across the country (a lack of PPE, a shortage of
get one in the spring. workers), and for reasons more specific to Iowa.
I got the sense from them and others in Cedar Rapids, “I got frustrated with the governor a few times for not
and I felt it myself when I visited in December, that one coming out stronger with a mask mandate,” he says, add-
of the hardest things post-derecho was inhabiting a world ing that it felt like the state had chosen the economy over
of such obvious and inescapable physical loss, as if the protecting seniors. “Why would we put anybody at risk if
W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E H E A RTL A N D

we don’t have to? Our employees are still out in the com- was everywhere, hitting rural counties especially hard.
munity. They don’t have a choice.” Despite growing cries from the public health community
Western Home effectively guarded its sites against a to do more, Gov. Reynolds again just asked Iowans to be
COVID-19 outbreak until late July, when it experienced responsible. As the curve climbed, the governor herself ap-
its first one in Madrid. The virus had slipped in during a peared on stage with President Trump and without a mask
visit from one of the facility’s contracted therapists. Over at an outdoor rally attended by thousands of his support-
the course of a few days, six patients and three staff on the ers in Des Moines.
home’s first floor tested positive for COVID. It was tough In November, health facilities around the state began an-
on morale. “They were beating themselves up because nouncing that they were at or near capacity—they lacked ei-
they felt like they had failed,” says Hansen, who, like other ther the staff or beds to handle more COVID patients. The
health and long-term-care providers across the country, governor responded with a set of complicated rules aimed
has been contending with a serious shortage of workers. at controlling the spread: no more than two spectators per
The fall brought scary and unspeakable tragedy to some child at an athletic event; face coverings should be worn at
of Western Home’s properties. The company had some indoor gatherings of 25 or more, or outdoor gatherings of
managed-care facilities where nearly 100% of residents over 100. Finally, the week before Thanksgiving, Reynolds,
tested positive, and where workers, also positive, took in a tone that begged forgiveness—“No one wants to do
care of them. “It just scares the crap out of you,” he tells this … I don’t want to do this”—issued a statewide mask
me. “[My employees] have got families too.” The biggest mandate, albeit one with some exceptions.
challenge has been controlling the virus in dementia units.
At one small facility in Cresco, Iowa, eight of 24 residents
were lost to COVID. “We see what the results of this are,” The mask rule couldn’t have come soon enough
he says of the state’s lax approach to the virus. for Marshalltown Mayor Joel Greer. A lawyer by day,
When I spoke with Hansen in mid-January, his staff Greer had watched COVID stress his community since
and residents were still awaiting vaccines. Says Hansen: early spring. Marshalltown, a city of 28,000 smack dab in
“It’s not rolling out nearly as fast as we had hoped.” He the middle of Iowa, is a meatpacking town, and like other
didn’t blame the state but the federal government, which Iowa cities it had had an early outbreak at its pork pro-
is running the rollout in long-term-care facilities with cessing facility and largest employer, JBS. Dozens tested
the private sector. “It’s just not well-coordinated enough. positive for the virus in April, and one local employee died
We’ve got folks, quite honestly, that are going to die be- a week before retirement in May.
cause of this, because of exposure that continues on.” It had just gone on from there. For Greer, it was a
Hansen remains frustrated by the dynamics around source of frustration and heartbreak that his county had
the virus in Iowa. He noted that the day before we talked at times been one of the most hard-hit in Iowa, while Iowa
there had been an “Informed Choice Iowa” rally involving was one of the most hard-hit states in the country.
hundreds of unmasked Iowans in the rotunda of the Iowa Greer Zoomed periodically with a group of mayors
state house (where state legislators are not required to in central Iowa. Many wanted to issue mask mandates,
wear masks, and many don’t). The group was calling for something they technically didn’t have power to do. Some
an end to COVID mandates. “I don’t know what happened went ahead with it anyway. Unwilling to exceed his legal
to common sense in the middle of this whole pandemic,”
says Hansen. “It’s just crap that this thing turned out to be
as political as it did.”
CUMULATIVE EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
15%
Naturally, I didn’t stop worrying about U.S.
COVID when the derecho hit. I worried more. As Iowans
10
will tell you, they come together in disasters. I imagined
the virus spreading with all the goodwill.
Cedar Rapids did see cases peak slightly after the 5
derecho and the immediate recovery, says St. Luke’s Hos-
IOWA
pital’s Niermann, but the situation wasn’t as bad as she
feared it would be. “Masking went way down,” she told 0
me. “Honestly, people had to work on a different level of
hierarchy of needs.”
–5%
Far worse was yet to come. For much of the fall, Iowa
was one of the nation’s COVID chart-toppers. The virus 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020
SOURCE: BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS
8 8 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

authority, Greer issued a mayoral proclamation requiring Medina prayed his staff wouldn’t all get sick at once and
face coverings, with the caveat it couldn’t be enforced. It require him to shut down. The restaurant has actually done
didn’t really catch on. very well during the pandemic—he credits takeout alcohol
In October, Greer walked into a local bar to pick up a sales for the fact that La Carreta had its best-ever Cinco de
takeout order. The place was crowded, and while the staff Mayo in 2020. And Medina says he was lucky to have gotten
were wearing masks, he was the only customer wearing the virus himself during the quiet Thanksgiving week, at a
one. The other patrons began making derogatory com- time when his business could handle his 10-day absence.
ments about him and questioning his manhood. “These Most of his employees had mild cases like his, and all
people, they must have flunked science,” Greer tells me. eventually recovered, but nearly everyone on his team has
“They just don’t get it.” lost someone to COVID: Medina’s 52-year-old uncle in
Ohio; his parents’ 30-year-old physician in Mexico; his
chef ’s father; the grandfather of two servers; loyal custom-
Service workers in Marshalltown were among ers. “Death has been all around us,” he says.
those who paid the price for the divide over mask-wearing. Medina was born in Roanoke, Va., and he spent his early
childhood traveling around the country with his parents,

1.34
immigrants from Mexico, as they built a growing business
of Tex-Mex restaurants. They arrived in Iowa when he was
5 years old and later moved to Marshalltown, which he
loved for its diversity, the good education he got, and the
kindness of people generally. “It was a good place to grow
up. You know, ‘Iowa nice,’ you really do see that,” he says.
When the pandemic began, Medina noticed many
MILLION CUB IC YARDS high-demand items—sanitizer, rice and beans, toilet pa-
per—were available from his bulk suppliers. He made large
orders and started reselling things locally; at one point, he
Amount of storm debris hauled away by debris was providing local nursing homes with gloves. Through-
management companies in Iowa since the derecho, out the pandemic, he’s donated staples for local food-drive
equal to about 24,000 dump trucks, or 133,000 tons efforts and organized fundraisers for families who have lost
members to COVID.
But Medina is probably best known for a slogan—“No
Alfonso Medina, the 31-year-old proprietor of La Carreta love, no tacos”—that he promoted on a billboard in front of
Mexican Grill, a popular Tex-Mex restaurant in the city, his restaurant, and on merchandise this fall. After the kill-
came down with COVID during the last week of Novem- ings of George Floyd and other unarmed Black citizens by
ber. He lost his sense of taste and smell, a symptom that, police last summer, Medina felt a responsibility to use his
by that point in the year, he estimates 80% to 90% of his platform as a local business owner to be vocal about his val-
17-person staff had already experienced. Since March, his ues. He experimented on social media and got good feed-
team had tried to distance in the restaurant and take pre- back, so he placed a yard sign in front of La Carreta. It had,
cautions. They had worn masks, but few customers did. what seemed to him, nuggets of unimpeachable common
“It was very frustrating that customers didn’t have to sense: “Black lives matter”; “Human rights are women’s
wear them because it was almost causing this, to a point,” rights”; “Science is real.” But the sign prompted an angry,
Medina told me in early January. “We could all be wear- handwritten note on a receipt one day; the customer called
ing masks, but we knew it’s just a matter of time before the sign un-Christian. Medina posted a photo of the receipt
someone gets sick.” on his personal Facebook page with his own note: “No love,
While a couple of big-box stores in Marshalltown— no tacos.” He also set up a website and online clothing store
Menards and Walmart—started requiring face coverings under that banner, advocating for fairness and equality and
early in the pandemic, without a state mandate and as a that Election Day be made a federal holiday to ensure all
minority-owned business, Medina thought it would be dif- can vote. Profits from the site went to a local scholarship
ficult to enforce a mask policy at La Carreta. His employees, fund Medina had previously established.
particularly those in high school who worked part-time, As things do, his message went viral, especially after he
weren’t comfortable confronting customers. He wished his was featured by CNN in October in the run-up to the elec-
patrons would just be responsible. “If you’re coming here tion. Orders for “No love, no tacos” hats and shirts poured
to eat because this is your favorite restaurant, why wouldn’t in from around the world, and as people posted photos of
you just wear one?” (Since the governor issued the state- themselves voting in November, many hashtagged them,
wide mandate, he says, almost everyone wears them.) #NoLoveNoTacos. The effort funded 14 scholarships to
The backyard of a home in Cedar Rapids damaged by the felling the courthouse’s clock tower and ransacking the
derecho. Designated as a “Tree City USA,” Cedar Rapids lost an historic district and downtown businesses, before damag-
estimated 65% of its canopy in the storm.
ing a number of homes in one of Marshalltown’s low-
income neighborhoods. That made the derecho a surreal
and especially cruel sequel of sorts.
Marshalltown’s community college. Much of the burden of responding to these disasters
Medina says he received at least one letter that was far has fallen on the shoulders of Kimberly Elder, emergency
nastier than the note that had kicked off everything. I management coordinator for Marshall County. She’s been
asked him if COVID and the current political climate had in her role since 2003, and every year, it seems, there are
made Iowa less nice. He said he and his employees don’t more disasters and fewer resources to deal with them. For
talk politics in the restaurant for a reason. much of 2020, she worked out of an office full of boxes.
“There’s people in Marshalltown with way different Some of them are filled with PPE, the county’s stockpile
J O S E P H C R E S S — I O WA C I T Y P R E S S - C I T I Z E N / U S A T O D AY N E T W O R K / R E U T E R S

points of view, and I respect everybody’s point of view,” that she herself distributes to nursing homes and emer-
he says. “I have clientele here that have different party gency responders. Others are file boxes, brimming with
affiliations than mine. They walk in with whatever gear or paperwork—the long tail of administrative business that
whatever their shirt says, and I tell my employees, ‘We give follows a disaster. Elder hasn’t had a vacation in more than
them the same five-star service as anybody else.’ ” two years, and, as a one-woman shop, her biggest fear is
getting sick with COVID. Says Elder: “If I’m in the hospital,
like some of these people are, what are they going to do?”
Mayor Greer has found that type of neutral Elder isn’t the only one mired in the process of recovery.
ground increasingly hard to preserve. He laments how polit- Some in the community have struggled more than oth-
icized the pandemic has become in his city. He’s taken heat ers to get timely relief from insurers and state agencies.
over COVID—in emails, texts, and a whole lot of comments As Iowa cities go, Marshalltown is uniquely diverse, with
lobbed at his mayoral Facebook page—from both sides. a population that is 30% Hispanic, according to recent
“Half the people are mad as hell that school’s in session, the census data. Students in the Marshalltown school district
other half are mad that it’s not. It’s been pretty ugly,” he says. are native speakers of more than 40 different languages;
Three years in, Greer’s tenure has involved dealing with kindergartners in the district are 70% nonwhite. The
one catastrophe after another in Marshalltown. One July meatpacking plant helped give rise to this multicultural-
day in 2018 a tornado literally traveled down Main Street, ism because its jobs have drawn different populations to
9 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E H E A RTL A N D

the city over time, including most recently Burmese and public and canceled the annual powwow and other cultur-
Congolese refugees. ally important ceremonial gatherings.
In navigating the recovery process, language barriers are But there were limitations to the effort. Many of the set-
one issue; the other is time. The city’s immigrant popula- tlement’s residents work in nearby towns like Tama, Toledo,
tion makes up a large part of Marshalltown’s essential and Marshalltown, and everyone has to leave the settlement
workforce, employed in jobs that often don’t offer flexibility to get groceries and other supplies. The Meskwaki’s efforts
to deal with things like lining up an insurance adjuster. to stop the spread of the virus could only be as good as the
efforts in those surrounding communities.
“The state of Iowa was one of those states that didn’t
For some on the Meskwaki Settlement, the take the virus too seriously,” says SpottedBird, who moved
8,000 acres of Tama County that is home to the Sac & Fox from Seattle to take his job in May (he’s not a tribal mem-
Tribe of the Mississippi in Iowa—east of Marshalltown— ber). “So safeguards were kind of lackadaisical, loose, and
displacement because of the derecho came with another people were generally not wearing masks for a long time.”
brutal cost: COVID. Like many health professionals in the state, Papakee
Iowa’s only federally recognized tribe, the Meskwaki has been frustrated greatly by Gov. Reynolds’s response to
purchased the land in 1857 after resisting banishment by the pandemic. He would tune into her press conferences
the federal government to a reservation in Kansas. Over the on the virus only to be dismayed each time by her continu-
years the tribe expanded its holdings, and the settlement, ing insistence that she trusted Iowans to make the right
where 1,200 or so tribal members currently reside, has its decisions. “Obviously you could not, because our numbers
own health clinic, court, and school. In 1992 the Meskwaki continued to soar,” he says.
opened a hotel and casino on the property—advertised as He admits some of the same challenges exist on the settle-
having “the loosest slots in Iowa”—which today provides ment; there are those in the community who bristle at being
about 70% of funding for tribal operations. required to wear masks or being told how to conduct their
The derecho damaged 271 of the settlement’s 350 social lives. At one Christmas gathering on the settlement, a
homes, and in the storm’s aftermath, the generator- single person exposed 25 others. The casino, which provides
powered hotel was the obvious place for those affected the tribe with important revenue, reopened in July with a
to go. Seven hundred tribal members “jam-packed” new nonsmoking policy, temperature checks, and masking
into the hotel, some five or six to a room, says Lawrence and social distance requirements—a combination of mea-
SpottedBird, the settlement’s executive director. People sures that Papakee says have been effective but not perfect.
found themselves in proximity to people from whom Vaccinations have started on the settlement, but Papa-
they’d been socially distanced for months. kee had no idea when the next shipment was showing up,
“We were interacting more closely and working more making things hard to plan. The community’s elders were
closely,” says SpottedBird. “We had to drop our guard to do anxiously awaiting their turn.
that. The result was our cases spiked.” Reflecting trends seen across the country with Native
The settlement, in some ways, had taken an opposite American populations, the Meskwaki have been more
approach to the state’s in handling the pandemic. Rudy impacted by the virus than other groups. When I spoke
Papakee, health director at Meskwaki Tribal Health Clinic, with Papakee, roughly a quarter of the settlement’s tribal
learned of the community’s first COVID case in March. A population—301 people—had so far tested positive for
tribal member had sought care at a hospital for breath- COVID; five had succumbed to the virus.
ing problems and tested positive for the virus. Soon the
individual’s family members and their contacts did too.
Several of the cases were severe, involving hospitaliza- Outside the settlement, Shannon Zoffka,
tions, and one elder who contracted the virus died. CEO of Tama County Public Health and Home Care,
“We were a little epicenter, at first,” says Papakee. He leads the area’s pandemic response. She has lived in the
knew many in the population were vulnerable, either as small, rural county of 17,000 all her life, but the past year
elders or individuals with health conditions, like diabetes has been eye-opening. “There’s definitely a large percent
and high blood pressure, that put them at greater risk. of the population in the county that don’t believe in
Tribal leadership responded almost immediately with a masks. They think that the vaccine is unsafe; they think
shelter-in-place order, shuttering the casino and other that COVID is a hoax,” Zoffka tells me one afternoon in
operations on the settlement. They continued to pay em- early January.
ployees and asked them to stay home. They had a robust That resistance to reality persists despite the county’s
and accessible testing infrastructure, thanks to the Indian nursing home and meatpacking plant outbreaks, and the
Health Service. When the tribe opened back up in early fact that Tama ranks in the top 4% of counties nationally
summer, it did so conservatively: It required face masks in in deaths per capita due to COVID. There was also a spike
TIGER INVITES YOU TO

WATCH LIVE FEBRUARY 18-21


RIVIERA COUNTRY CLUB | PACIFIC PALISADES, CA

© 2021 PGA TOUR, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PLAYER APPEARANCE SUBJECT TO CHANGE.
9 2 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E H E A RTL A N D

in cases after the derecho; the county had made commu- become somewhat obsessed with Tama County Public
nity meals and cooling stations available to residents dur- Health’s Facebook page. The information was clear and
ing the weeklong period they—and Tama County Public the posts impressively transparent; the office regularly up-
Health—went without power, making cases especially dated case numbers and explained why they were higher
complicated to trace. than the state’s (the state’s data was behind). Following the
But things got really ugly at the start of the school posts, you could also sense a growing, desperate pleading
year, as quarantines that were prescribed after known behind them: Wear a mask! Wash your hands! Protect
COVID-19 exposures started to affect sports. “People were your grandparents!
very angry,” says Zoffka, who says her office’s attempts You only had to read the comments to get a sense of
to investigate contacts or inform people of exposures to what the office was up against. While there were plenty
the virus were often met with verbal abuse. “People think of supportive and thankful followers, comments often
they have the right to call you names and yell and scream enough devolved into heated arguments between citizens
and threaten.” about why there were so many cases in the county. Others
Soon she noticed people taking a different but equally argued the whole thing was overblown.
bad-faith approach to her office’s outreach. “People got Even though her team tries mightily to push out facts
smart very fast when the definition of a close contact over their own Facebook page, Zoffka largely blames social
changed to being within six feet of someone for consecu- media for the misinformation that has spread within the
tive 15 minutes.” People said to the case investigators, community about COVID, and for the harsh, bullying tone
“Well, you don’t have a tape measure or a stopwatch. You in which many discuss the virus, both online and increas-
ingly in person. She expects hurt feelings and memories

$11
of the animosity that has emerged during COVID will
linger, and that the doubters will remain. “I think people
who don’t believe are never going to believe until they’re
affected directly,” she says with some resignation.
When I spoke with Zoffka, her staff was working their
way through administering its supply of Moderna vaccine
doses. The logistics had been a challenge, particularly
through the holidays, but it was going all right. She hasn’t
B ILLION had a lot of time to process what stage of the pandemic
journey she’s in, or think much about the future. She’s
Estimated total damage caused by the derecho just been responding—to questions about the virus, or the
after its 14-hour, 770-mile run across Iowa and vaccine, or cases that need investigating, or all the other
through much of the Midwest, making it the most things that land on her desk. She’s hopeful that a lot of
costly thunderstorm in American history people will get vaccinated, and that maybe life will start
inching its way back to normalcy by the end of the year.
“I’ve kind of had it in my head that 2021 is going to be
don’t know.” Or: “You can’t prove that we were there.” similar to 2020 in a lot of ways.”
While Zoffka’s team has had good support from part-
ners like the school system, local business, law enforce-
ment, and the Meskwaki Settlement, such attitude from When the state climatologist Justin Glisan
community members was a disillusioning blow: “I don’t went out on his first trip to survey the derecho-impacted
think we expected that early on. Our thought was, ‘We fields, the scene was staggering—acres and acres of corn
want to keep people safe. People want to keep other blown flat, snapped off, or tipped so far over that it was
people safe.’ But then once [public health efforts] really not salvageable. Some of it had been further damaged by
affected their personal lives after some of the restrictions hail, shredded, as if it had taken on machine-gun fire.
have been lifted, it got kind of rough.” “To stand in a field and to be able to look across it and
Given that, Zoffka says it was hard to stomach the realize I can see things I should not be able to see be-
governor’s continuing reliance on Iowans to “do the right cause the corn is just flat, it’s devastating” says Meaghan
thing” to control the virus. Beyond slowing the spread of Anderson, a field agronomist with Iowa State University
disease, Zoffka says, a mask mandate would have sup- Extension and Outreach. She choked up for a moment,
ported businesses in the community who were trying to then added, “I have a job where I get a paycheck every
encourage safe behavior and often getting pushback. two weeks. I don’t put hundreds of thousands of dollars
In studying how the pandemic was playing out in upfront to plant something in April and then hope that,
Iowa—before I spoke with Zoffka—I had come across and come September or October, I can harvest it and make my
“ INVESTING IN TODAY’S MARKETS?
I’LL NEED SOME GOOD PEOPLE
WORKING ON THAT!”
GUIDANCE ON MUNICIPAL BONDS FROM HENNION & WALSH
You’ve worked hard for your money. And, in today’s unstable economy,
it’s vital to protect what you’ve built and keep planning for your healthy
leisure years of retirement. How? By looking for income sources that
are as secure as possible. Our long-term experience with tax-free
municipal bonds, which offer historically low risk, is likely to be just
what you need right now. In August of 2019, Moody’s Investor’s Service
found that rated investment-grade municipal bonds had an average
cumulative 10-year default rate of just 0.10% between 1970 and 2018.
Therefore, they can be an important part of your portfolio.
Hennion & Walsh is built on the classic American values of integrity
and one-to-one service. These time-tested values drive us and the
investment solutions we design for our clients.
We’ll use our expertise in retirement income investments to help you
plan for and generate income – whether you’re already in retirement
or just looking ahead. And given the historically low risk and income
they offer, tax-free municipal bonds can be an option to react to
today’s market instability.
Straight-talking and no-nonsense, we’re the hard-working investment
company for hard-working Americans who want to navigate these
uncertain times.

CALL (800) 316-2804 TODAY


to get your copy of the Hennion & Walsh Bond Guide.
It’s FREE and WITHOUT OBLIGATION.
In the Bond Guide, you’ll learn:
• The benefits and risks of municipal bonds
• Strategies for smart bond investing
• Municipal bond facts every investor should know

© 2021 Hennion & Walsh Inc. Securities offered through Hennion & Walsh Inc.
Member of FINRA, SIPC. Investing in bonds involves risk including possible loss
of principal. Income may be subject to state, local or federal alternative minimum
tax. When interest rates rise, bond prices fall, and when interest rates fall,
bond prices rise. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
9 4 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 W H AT C O M E S N E X T : TH E H E A RTL A N D

money back. That’s an incredible show of faith.” the state that didn’t get hit by the derecho or drought,
Farmers that were hit didn’t lose just crops but also a yields were good in 2020 and corn prices have risen nicely
lot of their infrastructure—the expensive equipment, the since summer. Federal assistance in the form of trade
barns and grain bins. “We’re going to be dealing with this payments and COVID relief have provided a generous
for years to come,” says Anderson. cushion and were a good part of the reason that farmer
Crop and other insurance covered much of the damage, incomes, on average, increased in 2020.

“People think they have the right to call you names and
YELL AND SCREAM AND THREATEN,” says one public
health official trying to limit the spread of the virus.

but many, like Jenni and Scott Birker, still faced significant In Cedar Rapids, as elsewhere, the recovery
losses in 2020 because of the compound effect of the pan- continues. There is plenty of evidence—in the form of
demic and the derecho. In recent years, the couple, who debris piles, dented fences, and tarped roofs—that the
live in Benton County and raise beef cattle, watched their city is still being put back together. But mostly there’s
margins slim to almost nothing. “I’ve changed from being great satisfaction in how the community came together
a cowboy basically to being a businessman. We’re picking and some lingering wonder at all they went through.
up pennies and nickels every day out here,” Scott says. The mayors of both Cedar Rapids and Marshalltown
But 2020 was a new type of challenge. Starting in touted big investment projects they have underway—
February, with virus fears rattling markets, the Birkers developments that have nothing to do with rebuilding
weren’t able to secure their usual put option to ensure from disasters, but rather just boosting the strength of
they covered the cost of their cattle. Then outbreaks start- their cities.
ed shuttering the state’s packing plants. Given the backlog Since the pandemic began, the state has recorded a
of cattle waiting to be sold, the couple made the decision total of 313,907 cases of COVID and 4,448 deaths due
to modify their animals’ rations—“basically we put them to the virus—ranking it eighth among states in terms of
on a 60-day diet”—to prolong the period before they took cases per capita, and 17th in terms of deaths per capita
them to market. “We had to pay for that extra feed cost over the course of the pandemic. After Iowa’s scary,
with no insurance on the cattle, which we thought was hospital-straining battle with the virus in November, the
the right move at the time,” says Scott. “We didn’t have a situation is much improved: The state’s case numbers
clue what to do.” have nose-dived. It might have been the mask mandate;
And then the derecho hit. The Birkers lost their barn, it might have been Iowans being responsible.
chicken coop, miles of fence, and much of their corn crop, A spokesperson for Governor Reynolds said in a state-
and had multiple tractors damaged. As they emerged ment: “The governor had a very targeted and balanced
from their basement after the storm, they found their approach to mitigating the COVID-19 pandemic. The
five-dozen chickens and laying hens scattered among the focus was protecting lives, livelihoods, preserving hospital
wreckage. Their cattle were all alive, but wandering free in resources, and bringing kids back to school safely. A mask
the pasture. When they finally sold the cattle in October, it is one layer of protection and she emphasized all of them
was for a loss. In all, it was a terrible year, but they have no on a near daily basis.”
plans to quit. For those I interviewed, the new year has almost univer-
Others have had it even worse. And Anderson and sally come with a sense of hope—because of the vaccine, or
others worry about the potential for farm bankruptcies to the rising price of corn, or the stronger community spirit,
come as well as mental health issues among the agricul- or just the turn of the calendar away from 2020.
tural community. (She knows of one farmer who commit- My parents are fine. They’re thinking about new trees
ted suicide after the derecho.) Ag giant Cargill does too; it and alternative ways to provide shade in a yard that lacks
has sponsored some of the work the ISU extension service them. Their pulse oximeter remains virtually untouched,
is providing for farmers and their families. in its box. And they got vaccinated for COVID as I was
The bleak outlook is far from universal. For those who finishing this story. I still worry about them and the virus,
managed to harvest their crops, or who lived in a part of but then I probably always will.
WATCH LIVE MARCH 4-7
B AY H ILL C LUB & LODGE | ORLAN DO, FLORIDA

© 2021 PGA TOUR, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PLAYER APPEARANCE SUBJECT TO CHANGE
C O N T E N T F R O M R AY T H E O N

security became more vulnerable than ever, leading


to a 400% uptick in cybercrime reports, according to
the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
“We’ve seen an increasing prevalence of ransom-
ware attacks as the world has become more virtual,”
says John DeSimone, vice president of cybersecu-
rity, training, and services at Raytheon Intelligence
& Space, a leader in developing advanced sensors,
training, and cyber and software solutions. “Digital
technologies that address ransomware attacks
are even more of a priority, as those attacks have
increased in sophistication.”
Raytheon employs more than 3,000 cybersecurity
experts globally to help public- and private-sector
clients protect critical assets. “Everyone wants to be
cyber secure,” DeSimone says. “But keeping up with
increasing digital threats is a challenge: Hiring and
retaining highly skilled in-house cyber experts for
around-the-clock protection is usually not afford-
able or practical.” And there is a lot at stake. What
used to be individual networks managing distinct
services, such as data, video, and voice, are quickly
converging. Meanwhile, the IT components con-
nected to those networks are proliferating in data
centers, throughout supply chains, and especially on
far-flung connected devices. That may help auto-
mate business, but it also creates weaknesses.
“All of these systems are now interconnected,
and therein lies the additional cyber vulnerability
exposure,” says DeSimone. “Any time access to criti-
cal business systems and networks goes unchecked,
there’s more inherent vulnerability.”
In response, companies are deploying new tools,
such as machine learning for more accurate and

A CRITICAL TIME FOR


faster cyber threat hunting or smart sensors for
advanced analytics. Raytheon offers these services
to clients without the in-house overhead. Critical

BUSINESSES AND
asset protection helps companies secure their most
important assets without overspending by offering
everything from managed detection and response to

CYBERSECURITY
advanced threat hunting according to need.
“Trust no one” may be a warning common in
cinematic thrillers, but it’s also become something of
a mantra in cybersecurity. Zero-trust architectures

Cybercrime has accelerated during the operate on the principle of “never trust, always
verify” and treat all users as potential threats—
pandemic. Here’s how to fight back. giving only authenticated users access to sensitive
data. These architectures can provide another key
tool for establishing data resilience, by helping
maintain operations after a disruption.
LAST YEAR, BUSINESSES ACROSS SECTORS STRUGGLED In short, if 2020 was the year many companies
to keep their doors open. But the economic reper- became aware of new cyber vulnerabilities, 2021
cussions of the COVID-19 pandemic were not the is providing a chance to address them. “The
only corporate disruption in 2020. With consumers cyber-threat landscape is constantly changing,”
spending more time online and businesses struggling DeSimone cautions. “And so are the opportunities for
to support suddenly distributed workforces, network companies to fight back.” ■
Attack
the hack
Combining decades of expertise
with commercial partnerships
that enable us to advance cyber
solutions, we focus on optimizing
existing infrastructure and rapidly
neutralizing threats — so you can
focus on your mission.

RTX.com/cyber

©2021 Raytheon Company, a Raytheon Technologies company


FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/M A R C H 2 0 2 1 9 9

AFTER A YEAR in which humanity leaned more heavily than ever on tech giants—to connect, entertain, and even
feed us in a time of isolation—it’s fitting that Apple, Amazon, and Microsoft hold the top three spots in Fortune’s
ranking of corporate reputation. Apple, the premier personal-tech provider, tops the roster for the 14th year in a
row, based on our poll of some 3,800 corporate executives, directors, and analysts. Elsewhere on our All-Stars
list, companies that became even more essential during the pandemic were among the biggest movers. Stream-
ing juggernaut Netflix returned to the top 10. Big-box giant Walmart (No. 11) and Target (No. 17) earned their high-
est rankings since 2011 and 2008, respectively. And chipmaker Nvidia, medical supplier Abbott Laboratories, and
fintech pioneer PayPal each made their Top 50 debut. (FOR MORE DETAILED RANKINGS, VISIT FORTUNE.COM.)


1 0 0 FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1

THE 50 ALL-STARS THESE COMPANIES WON ADMIRING


VOTES FROM INSIDE AND OUTSIDE THEIR INDUSTRIES.

1 APPLE 18 36
BLACKROCK 26† USAA VISA 45† BANK OF
AMERICA
1* COMPUTERS AND COMMUNICATION 25 FINANCIALS 24 FINANCIALS 36 FINANCIALS N.R. FINANCIALS

2 AMAZON 10 COSTCO
WHOLESALE 19 HOME DEPOT 28 UPS 37† MERCK 45† NESTLÉ

COMPUTERS AND STORES AND STORES AND NATURAL CONSUMER


2 COMMUNICATION 9 DISTRIBUTORS 21 DISTRIBUTORS 33 TRANSPORT 49 RESOURCES 39 PRODUCTS

3 MICROSOFT 11 WALMART 20 AMERICAN


EXPRESS 29 NORDSTROM 37† NVIDIA 47 LOWE’S

COMPUTERS AND STORES AND STORES AND STORES AND


3 COMMUNICATION 18 DISTRIBUTORS 14† FINANCIALS 20 DISTRIBUTORS N.R. PRECISION N.R. DISTRIBUTORS

4 WALT DISNEY 12 SALESFORCE 21 PROCTER &


GAMBLE 30 UNILEVER 39 PEPSICO 48 PUBLIX SUPER
MARKETS
MEDIA AND COMPUTERS AND CONSUMER CONSUMER CONSUMER STORES AND
4 ENTERTAINMENT 10 COMMUNICATION 23 PRODUCTS 31 PRODUCTS 43 PRODUCTS 48 DISTRIBUTORS

5 STARBUCKS 13 NIKE 22 COCA-COLA 31 TOYOTA MOTOR 40 ADOBE 49 SAMSUNG


ELECTRONICS
STORES AND CONSUMER CONSUMER COMPUTERS AND
6 DISTRIBUTORS 13 PRODUCTS 12 PRODUCTS 30 TRANSPORT 47 COMMUNICATION N.R. PRECISION

6 BERKSHIRE
HATHAWAY 14 SOUTHWEST
AIRLINES 23 DELTA
AIR LINES 32 CVS HEALTH 41 IBM 50† PAYPAL
HOLDINGS
CONTRACTED COMPUTERS AND
5 FINANCIALS 11 TRANSPORT 19 TRANSPORT 38 SERVICES 35 COMMUNICATION N.R. FINANCIALS

7 ALPHABET 15 JOHNSON
& JOHNSON 24 3M 33 ACCENTURE 42 ABBOTT
LABORATORIES 50† UNITEDHEALTH
GROUP
COMPUTERS AND NATURAL NATURAL COMPUTERS AND CONTRACTED
7 COMMUNICATION 26 RESOURCES 29 RESOURCES 34 COMMUNICATION N.R. PRECISION N.R. SERVICES

8 JPMORGAN
CHASE 16 FEDEX 25 MARRIOTT
INTERNATIONAL 34 SINGAPORE
AIRLINES 43 MASTERCARD
*LAST YEAR’S RANK
MEDIA AND N.R.: COMPANY NOT RANKED
8 FINANCIALS 14† TRANSPORT 17 ENTERTAINMENT 28 TRANSPORT 42 FINANCIALS
LAST YEAR
A TIE IN RANK

9 NETFLIX 17 TARGET 26† GOLDMAN


SACHS GROUP 35 BMW 44 CHARLES
SCHWAB
DROPPED OUT OF THE TOP 50:
ADIDAS (RANKED 40 LAST
YEAR), CATERPILLAR (44),
EXXON MOBIL (50), LOCKHEED
MEDIA AND STORES AND MARTIN (46), L’ORÉAL (45),
14† ENTERTAINMENT 22 DISTRIBUTORS 27 FINANCIALS 32 TRANSPORT 37 FINANCIALS AND MCDONALD’S (41).

T H E 5 0 A LL- S TA R S BY CAT E G O RY

COMPUTERS AND COMMUNICATION FINANCIALS PRECISION


CONSUMER PRODUCTS MEDIA AND ENTERTAINMENT STORES AND DISTRIBUTORS
CONTRACTED SERVICES NATURAL RESOURCES TRANSPORT
THE WORLD’S MOST ADMIRED COMPANIES — THE LIST 2021

INDUSTRY STANDOUTS HOW WE DETERMINE THE LIST

AS RANKED BY THEIR PEERS AS WE HAVE in the past, Fortune


collaborated with our partner Korn
Ferry on this survey of corporate
CLOSELY WATCHED AND HIGHLY ESTEEMED In addition to the overall All-Stars reputation. We began with a uni-
list, the Most Admired Companies verse of about 1,500 candidates:
SHEER SIZE CAN CREATE a virtuous survey tracks 52 industry groups— the 1,000 largest U.S. companies
cycle that in turn gets reflected in the and among those, some winning ranked by revenue, along with
non-U.S. companies in Fortune’s
scores of Fortune’s Most Admired streaks rival or even eclipse Apple’s. Global 500 database that have
Companies survey. The scoring Berkshire Hathaway, for example, revenues of $10 billion or more.
system favors companies that excel at has topped the property and casu- We winnowed the assortment to
multiple facets of management (see alty insurance group for 23 years the highest-revenue companies
in each industry, a total of 670
the adjoining column for more on in a row. Walt Disney has been the
in 30 countries. The top-rated
our methodology). And the bigger a No. 1 entertainment company for 18 companies were picked from that
company is, the more likely its peers straight years. And in a year when it pool of 670; the executives who
and competitors are to avidly seek devoted vital resources to the search voted work at the companies in
information about how and why it’s for a COVID-19 vaccine, Johnson & that group.
To determine the best-regarded
succeeding, and to keep that infor- Johnson finished first in the pharma- companies in 52 industries, Korn
mation at the top of their minds. ceutical industry for the eighth con- Ferry asked executives, directors,
That phenomenon may help secutive time. (Berkshire and J&J join and analysts to rate enterprises in
explain the perennial top status Microsoft, Coca-Cola, and Toyota in their own industry on nine criteria,
from investment value and quality
of Apple, which is not only one of another elite category: Those compa-
of management and products to
the world’s largest companies, with nies have appeared on our All-Stars social responsibility and ability to
$275 billion in revenue in fiscal list every year since 1998.) attract talent. A company’s score
2020, but also one of the most closely Still, while continuity is common, must rank in the top half of its
followed by the tech community it isn’t the rule. Fresh names reached industry survey to be listed. (For
complete rankings, visit fortune
and business media. We ask survey the top in several other industries, .com.)
respondents to rate companies on including mining and crude oil Results were not published in
nine criteria: This year, Apple ranked production (where miner Newmont the following categories because
in the top 10 in eight of those, earning won); trucking, transportation, and of insufficient response rates:
cable and satellite providers;
the highest scores of any company in logistics (where top honors went to
petroleum refining; pipelines; U.S.
the “quality of products” and “sound- Denmark’s Maersk); packaging and energy.
ness of financial position” categories. containers (International Paper); To select our 50 All-Stars, Korn
Target earns similar respect from and financial data services (S&P Ferry asked 3,820 executives,
its peers, also cracking eight out of Global). In consumer foods prod- directors, and securities analysts
who had responded to the industry
nine top rankings. After a year when ucts, PepsiCo ranked first this year, surveys to select the 10 companies
the big-box retailer hired tens of ending a 15-year run by Nestlé—and they admired most. They chose
thousands of employees and vastly capping a year in which Pepsi drew from a list made up of the compa-
expanded its curbside pickup and as much attention for its stances on nies that ranked in the top 25% in
last year’s surveys, plus those that
online shopping, respondents gave race and social justice issues as it did
finished in the top 20% of their
it the survey’s highest scores for for its global brand portfolio. industry. Anyone could vote for
“management quality” and “wise use And in life and health insurance, any company in any industry.
of corporate assets.” E-commerce New York Life took the No. 1 spot The difference in the voting
and cloud titan Amazon, meanwhile, for the first time. In its biggest acqui- rolls explains why some results
can seem at odds with each other.
captured top 10 scores in six cat- sition ever, the 175-year-old company For example, Lockheed Martin fell
egories, with best-overall rankings cemented its status as America’s off the All-Stars list this year but
in “innovativeness” and “value as a largest mutual life insurer in 2020 by ranked No. 1 within the aerospace
long-term investment.” (The latter acquiring several business units from and defense category when votes
from only those in that industry
honor is almost an understatement: Cigna. The takeaway: Sometimes
were counted. —S.D.
A $100,000 investment in Amazon your good repute can scale up along
10 years ago would be worth more with your business.
than $1.6 million today.) —Matt Heimer and Scott DeCarlo
1 0 2 FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE WORLD’S MOST ADMIRED COMPANIES — THE CEOs

UNDERRATED / OVERRATED

S O U R C E P H O T O S : N A D E L L A : A B D U L H A M I D H O S B A S — A N A D O L U A G E N C Y/ G E T T Y I M A G E S ; B A R R A : PAT R I C K T. FA L L O N — B LO O M B E R G / G E T T Y I M A G E S ; C O O K : R O Y R O C H L I N — W I R E I M A G E / G E T T Y I M A G E S ; M C M I L LO N : R I C K T. W I L K I N G — G E T T Y I M A G E S ;
WHICH CEOs DESERVE MORE ATTENTION,
AND WHICH GET TOO MUCH? FORTUNE ASKED
EXECUTIVES AND DIRECTORS FOR THEIR VOTES.

Z U C K E R B E R G : J O S H E D E L S O N — A F P/ G E T T Y I M A G E S ; B E ZO S : E L I F O Z T U R K— A N A D O L U A G E N C Y/ G E T T Y I M A G E S ; M U S K : YA S I N O Z T U R K— A N A D O L U A G E N C Y/ G E T T Y I M A G E S ; D I M O N : G I U L I A M A R C H I — B L O O M B E R G / G E T T Y I M A G E S
MOST UNDERRATED CEOs BASED ON 5,250 RESPONSES

SATYA NADELLA MICROSOFT 328 VOTES

NADELLA’S PEERS HAVE NOW VOTED HIM “most underrated” five years in a row—an indication,
perhaps, of his ability to steer the company through a major reinvention while generating
shockingly little drama. Tech analysts believe (though Microsoft won’t confirm) that the
Azure cloud business Nadella has championed now accounts for as much revenue as the
Windows software that turned the company into a behemoth a generation ago. The suc-
cessful absorption of LinkedIn and software development site GitHub have demonstrated
the 53-year-old CEO’s ability to win on multiple fronts, as has the Xbox’s sustained cred
in gaming circles. Microsoft’s share price, meanwhile, has more than quintupled during
Nadella’s seven-year tenure—a sign of investors’ long-term confidence in his big bets.

MARY BARRA TIM COOK DOUG MCMILLON


GENERAL MOTORS APPLE WALMART
151 VOTES 146 VOTES 135 VOTES
Last spring, GM was making PPE The pandemic barely slowed Walmart has been a bulwark
for health care workers; by fall, it Apple’s rollout of new phones, against COVID, keeping
was posting healthy profits. watches, and services. stores open and hiring widely.

MOST OVERRATED CEOs BASED ON 4,489 RESPONSES

MARK ZUCKERBERG FACEBOOK 445 VOTES

FACEBOOK IS HARDLY THE ONLY ONLINE PLATFORM to have struggled to curb the spread of
misinformation. But over the past year, with COVID-19, the killing of George Floyd, and
the presidential election each spurring waves of algorithmically amplified falsehoods
and hate speech, Zuckerberg’s company came under unprecedented scrutiny—and an
expanding circle of critics faulted the CEO and cofounder for doing far too little, years too
late. Advertisers began voting with their dollars in meaningful ways, pulling back and even
pulling out, as revenue growth slowed. An antitrust suit by the Federal Trade Commission,
meanwhile, seeks to undo Facebook’s acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp—taking
aim at some of Zuckerberg’s signature accomplishments.

JEFF BEZOS ELON MUSK JAMIE DIMON


AMAZON TESLA/SPACEX JPMORGAN CHASE
407 VOTES 294 VOTES 280 VOTES
Amazon's hypercompetitive Fortune’s Businessperson of Some bank analysts think
culture inspires as much criti- the Year for 2020 remains JPMC has been too compla-
cism as admiration of late. profoundly polarizing. cent in the fintech race.

I L L U ST R AT I O N S BY S A M K E R R
OUR
PLEDGE
RUNS
D E E P.
Sustainability is at the
core of everything we do.

DellTechnologies.com
© 2021 FORTUNE Media IP Limited All rights reserved. Used under license. FORTUNE and FORTUNE Media IP Limited
are not affiliated with and do not endorse products or services of Dell Technologies.
PASSIONS
TIME WELL SPENT

AUTOS

Land T
HE NATURAL INCLINATION when getting behind a
completely reengineered vehicle like the Land
Rover Defender is to compare it to its predecessor.

Mark
In this case, that earlier model was an icon: an overlander
that went largely unchanged from the Land Rover Series 1
of the 1940s until 2016, when the long-in-the-tooth
Defender could no longer keep up with modern require-
ments for safety and emissions.
By focusing on off-road fundamentals, That Defender provided decades of admirable service
the new Land Rover Defender proves to be for those heading off-pavement, whether it be UN peace-
COURTESY OF L AND ROVER

worthy of its name. BY DANIEL BENTLEY keepers in Rwanda or a sheep farmer in Wales, and it won
a rabid fan base who still keep them rolling over muddy
hillsides today.
Among those fans, this writer included, the 2019 unveil-
ing of the new Defender raised eyebrows. It is big—very
big—and swaps flat-sided steel panels for bulbous alumi-
FO R T U N E F E B R U A RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 1 0 7

and a metal-lined trunk


that are begging to be sul-
lied by muddy boots and
dirty gear. This is a utility
vehicle with a capital U.
So while it has impec-
cable road manners, to re-
ally see what the Defender
can do, you need to give it
some unforgiving terrain.
Thankfully the New York
weather cooperated during
Fortune’s review, serving
up snow, sleet, and freez-
ing rain. Driving through
2 that mess on gravel and
dirt demonstrates what
BUILT ON makes the Defender spe-
LEGACY cial in the indistinguish-
[1] The new Land
Rover Defender able landscape of SUVs.
earns its badge Even though Land
with superlative Rover has equipped the
off-road Defender with various se-
performance. [2]
lectable terrain modes for
Luxury materials
meet rugged snow, gravel, and sand, its
utilitarianism in normal ride mode, paired
the Defender’s with optional off-road
cockpit. [3] tires, is more than capable
Queen Elizabeth II
and the Duke of on loose and slippery
Edinburgh with ground. And while Fortune
their Land Rover didn’t have the chance—or
Series IIa. the nerve—to test it, JLR
says the Defender can
wade through water of up
1 3
to three feet, no modifica-
tions required. All this,
along with its superb
visibility and command-
num. Yes, if you squint, you engine (U.S. buyers are The Defender suc- ing presence, inspires a
F R O M T O P : C O U R T E S Y O F L A N D R O V E R ; PA I M A G E S / G E T T Y I M A G E S

can see the “design DNA” denied the diesel options cessfully walks the line level of driver confidence
of the original, but the new available in Europe). That between providing the that few of its competitors
Defender is definitely not power plant, which JLR luxury expected of such an can provide.
more of the same. It was a dubs its Ingenium engine, expensive vehicle and be- It’s in this realm that
big risk for struggling par- packs quite the party trick: ing appropriately rugged. the new Defender earns
ent company Jaguar Land Its electric-powered su- The ride is plush, thanks to its badge. It may look
Rover (JLR), but one that percharger near-instantly adjustable air suspension, different. It may drive
just might pay off. spins up when the throttle and the tech is cutting- like a luxury SUV on the
Fortune reviewed the is applied. The result is edge—the rearview mirror highway. But Land Rover
Defender in its top-of- snappy acceleration with uses a camera when visibil- has imbued the Defender
the-line four-door 110 X plenty of low-end torque ity is obscured, and there’s with the uncompromised
package, priced at $85,750, that gets you to 60 mph in an excellent touch-screen off-roading chops of its
which comes with a just under six seconds—in entertainment and control ancestor. And that has
395-horsepower, three- a vehicle weighing over system. But the Defender given the purists plenty to
liter mild-hybrid gasoline 5,000 pounds. Crikey. also has rubber floor mats smile about.
1 — LEARN MORE AT FIVESTARPROFESSIONAL.COM
4
YEAR
WINNER
11 2 FO R T U N E F E B R UA RY/ M A R C H 2 0 2 1 THE CARTOGRAPHER

YEAR-OVER-YEAR GDP GROWTH FOR SELECTED COUNTRIES STRINGENT NATIONWIDE CONFINEMENT*

10%

0
AMERICAS

-10

-20

BRAZIL CANADA MEXICO U.S.


-30%

10%

0
EUROPE

-10

-20

FRANCE GERMANY SWEDEN U.K.


-30%

10%

0
ASIA

-10

-20

CHINA INDIA JAPAN SOUTH KOREA


-30%

JAN. 1, 2020 JAN. 10, 2021 JAN. 1, 2020 JAN. 10, 2021 JAN. 1, 2020 JAN. 10, 2021 JAN. 1, 2020 JAN. 10, 2021

THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF LOCKDOWNS


ONE BY-PRODUCT OF THE GLOBAL PANDEMIC has been to speed up tech-driven innovation in a range of areas—including economics.
Data scientists have long sought to improve real-time GDP estimates. And the challenge has become more urgent as policymakers try to
balance the COVID-19 health crisis with the toll of lockdowns. So Nicolas Woloszko, an economist at the OECD, developed a system that
uses Google Trends data and machine learning to provide weekly snapshots of GDP in 46 countries with a high degree of accuracy. Here,
we’ve overlaid Woloszko’s GDP numbers for the past year with data from the University of Oxford on strict lockdowns in 12 major econo-
mies. One conclusion: With a virus as devastating as SARS-CoV-2, there is no universal policy blueprint for success. —BRIAN O’KEEFE

INFOGRAPHIC BY *INDEX VALUE ABOVE 70 ON THE OXFORD SOURCES: GDP WEEKLY SIMULATION BY NICOLAS WOLOSZKO FOR THE OECD WEEKLY TRACKER OF
NICOLAS RAPP CONFINEMENT STRINGENCY INDEX (0–100) ECONOMIC ACTIVITY; CONFINEMENT DATA FROM THE OXFORD COVID-19 GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TRACKER

You might also like