Professional Documents
Culture Documents
189–196
www.elsevier.nlrlocatersensorb
TiO 2 thin films by a novel sol–gel processing for gas sensor applications
C. Garzella a,) , E. Comini a , E. Tempesti a , C. Frigeri b, G. Sberveglieri a
a
Department of Chemistry and Physics for Engineering and Materials and I.N.F.M., UniÕersity of Brescia, 25100 Brescia, Italy
b
Instituto CNR-MASPEC Parco Area Delle Scienze 37 r A, 43100 Parma, Italy
Abstract
Novel thin films of titanium dioxide dispersed in a polymeric matrix have been prepared by a chemically modified sol–gel technique.
Nanostructured films of pure TiO 2 in the anatase form are obtained after annealing at 5008C. SEM, TEM and TGrDTA are used for the
structure characterisation of TiO 2 films. The role of the polymer in controlling the microstructure is confirmed. The first application of
this technique in gas sensor field is presented in this work. Ethanol and methanol sensing properties are tested and reported. TiO 2 sensors
can detect very well concentration required for breath analysers. q 2000 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction air. By using this method, the TiO 2 deposition has the
same microstructure and crystallographic orientation as
There is widespread interest in TiO 2 thin films for
TiO 2 powders.
applications such as ultraviolet filters for optics and pack-
A further improvement has been recently found by
aging material, antireflection coatings for photovoltaic cells
using a chemically modified alkoxide method, which yields
and passive solar collectors w1x, photocatalysts for purifica-
a characteristic microstructure w5x Ža so-called nanostruc-
tion and treatment of water and air w2x and thin ceramic
ture. of nanosized crystallites and nanosized spaces be-
films or membrane with controlled porosity w3, Chap 14x.
tween the crystallites with excellent photocatalytic activity
Thin, transparent TiO 2 films have been made previously
for the decomposition of aqueous acetic acid w6x.
by various vapour-phase methods including chemical
We would like to report now a novel application of the
vapour deposition, reactive evaporation, electron beam
so-called Achemically modified sol–gel techniqueB in the
evaporation and sputtering w1x. Films made by these pro-
gas sensor field. The possibility to control the porosity of
cesses tend to be crystalline and nonporous.
films is of particular interest for gas sensor application
Alternatively, TiO 2 films derived from alkoxides using
since the number of gas molecules that interact with the
sol–gel process require considerably less equipment, re-
semiconductor surface increases with films surface area.
sulting in generally lower processing costs. A major advan-
The peculiarity of this technique to maintain good surface
tage of sol–gel processes over the vapour-phase methods
properties at high temperatures is also important since the
is the ability to control the microstructure of the deposited
response towards gases usually implies working tempera-
film, i.e. the pore size, pore volume and surface area w3,
tures higher than 4008C.
Chap. 8x. In this regard, an innovative sol–gel processing
The films made by the procedure described in the
has been described for the preparation of ceramic thin
present paper have the following advantages: Ž1. a wide
films as novel materials for integrated humidity sensors
w4x. The prototype sensors were prepared by depositing choice of substrate is available since the films are made in
the absence of any acid or base catalyst Žimpurities., which
metal alkoxide solutions onto Al 2 O 3 substrates with
may be corrosive; Ž2. the film properties do not change
comb-type Au electrodes, by dip-coating and heating in
with time as the TiO 2 precursor is fully hydrolysed and
condensed prior to film formation; Ž3. crack-free films are
)
Corresponding author. Tel.: q39-30-3715769; fax: q39-30-3715788. produced in relative easy terms; and Ž4. film properties can
E-mail address: garzella@bsing.ing.unibs.it ŽC. Garzella.. be controlled by varying the TiO 2rpolymer weight ratio.
0925-4005r00r$ - see front matter q 2000 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 2 5 - 4 0 0 5 Ž 0 0 . 0 0 4 2 8 - 7
190 C. Garzella et al.r Sensors and Actuators B 68 (2000) 189–196
obtained by mixing the gas from certified bottles with the electrical properties due to variations of the atmosphere
synthetic air. All the measures were made under controlled have been registered with the Volt Amperometric tech-
humidity ŽRH 30%. and the temperature of the chamber nique, applying a constant potential of 3 V to the sensing
containing the sensors was set at 208C. The changes in the layer and registering with a picoammeter the conductance
Fig. 2. SEM micrographs of films obtained via sol–gel chemically modified Ža. TiO 2 –HPC film as grown and Žb. TiO 2 film annealed at 5008C Žbar: 500
nm..
192 C. Garzella et al.r Sensors and Actuators B 68 (2000) 189–196
variation as a function of time. Either the gas flow or the The crystal phase has been identified as TiO 2 anatase, as
electrical parameters were controlled by a PC, which also confirmed by microRaman analysis. The TEM micrograph
registered the conductance change of the sensors. with more details have been reported by the authors else-
where w10x.
A complete scanning of the films surface was per-
3. Results and discussion formed by microRaman analysis. The microRaman spec-
trum ŽFig. 1. was obtained by subtraction of alumina
3.1. Microstructure absorption and presents an intense band at 144 cmy1 and
three less intense bands at 400, 515 and 640 cmy1 , which
3.1.1. Structural characterisation are characteristic of the anatase form w11x.
The microstructure and the crystal phase of the an-
nealed samples have been investigated by TEM analyses, 3.1.2. SEM analysis
selected area diffraction ŽSAD. and microdiffraction pat- Fig. 2a and b reports two scanning secondary electrons
terns of single crystallites. The deposited layer appears images of TiO 2 –HPC films as grown and after annealing
nanostructured with particle sizes between 3 and 30 nm. at 5008C, respectively. The polymer-oxide composite ap-
Fig. 3. SEM micrographs of TiO 2 thin film obtained by classical sol–gel technique and annealed at 5008C Žbars: Ža. 5 mm and Žb. 500 nm..
C. Garzella et al.r Sensors and Actuators B 68 (2000) 189–196 193
Fig. 6. Dynamic variation of the current flowing through the TiO 2 thin
Fig. 4. TGArDTA analyses of TiO 2 thin film as grown obtained with film when 100 ppm of methanol are introduced in the test chamber at two
chemically modified sol–gel technique. different working temperatures Ži.e. 4008C and 5008C. at 30% RH.
194 C. Garzella et al.r Sensors and Actuators B 68 (2000) 189–196
Fig. 8. Ratio Ž Qs SrS w . of the response of the sensor deposited with Fig. 10. Response as a function of CO and NO 2 concentration of the
the new technique and the standard sol–gel as a function of the concen- TiO 2 sensors at 4008C.
tration of ethanol and methanol at a working temperature of 4008C and
5008C, and 30% RH.
of gases as the NO 2 and CO in the concentrations ranges
from 0.5–4 to 100–300 ppm, respectively, at a working
tween the two layers become more pronounced as the temperature of 4008C. The response to these possible
temperature increases; at the working temperature of 5008C interfering gases, in high concentration with respect to the
the ratio Q rises, increasing the alcohol concentration. The alarm level for indoor and outdoor conditions, is more than
highest value is reached for 600 ppm of ethanol at 5008C, one order of magnitude lower than the response to the
as reported in Fig. 8. alcohols. This sol–gel deposited material is well suited for
It has been highlighted that the morphological charac- the alcohol presence detection.
teristics of the TiO 2 can be related to the more pronounced
sensing properties.
4. Conclusions
3.2.6. Cross sensitiÕity Thin composite films of TiO 2 and polymer HPC have
The influence on the response amplitude of relative been made via the chemically modified sol–gel technique
humidity of the environment atmosphere has been tested by dip-coating onto alumina substrates. Sintering the sam-
for the target gases. Fig. 9 plots the different responses to ples at 5008C in air results in the complete burnout of the
300 ppm of ethanol at 5008C and at two different values of HPC and the formation of an anatase film. The deposited
RH Ž30% and 50%.. The response in the two ambient layers are uniform and present a characteristic nanostruc-
varies about 15%, which is less than 100 times the varia- ture with particles size between 3 and 30 nm. Films made
tion due to the presence of 100 ppm of ethanol. in the same condition via the classical sol–gel procedure
In Fig. 10, the response Ž DGrG for reducing gases and imply a cracked surface and larger particle size.
D RrR for oxidising gases. is reported for two other kind The new role of polymer in the sol–gel process for
TiO 2 thin film growth has been confirmed: it acts as in situ
steric stabiliser preventing particle sintering and film
cracking during the annealing treatment.
The temperature stable nanostructured TiO 2 films pre-
sent interesting surface properties for gas sensors applica-
tions. The TiO 2 thin films deposited via the chemically
modified sol–gel technique show a response towards alco-
hols that is always enhanced Žfrom 10 to 60 times. relative
to the film grown via the classical sol–gel technique.
The TiO 2 layers show a better surface interaction with
gas molecules; this behaviour can be tentatively ratio-
nalised assuming that nanosized particles imply higher
surface areas and porosity. The response and recovery
times for ethanol are particularly interesting for possible
applications such as control food analyses, wine identifica-
Fig. 9. Kinetic variation of the current flowing through the TiO 2 thin film
tions, electronic noses and medical devices. As noticed, the
when 300 ppm of ethanol are introduced in the test chamber at two response is very high at concentrations well below the
different values of RH at 5008C. limit imposed for breath analysers and the responses to-
196 C. Garzella et al.r Sensors and Actuators B 68 (2000) 189–196
ward possible interfering gases are always two order of Elisabetta Comini was born in 1972. She received a graduate degree in
magnitude lower than the responses of alcohols. physics at the University of Pisa in 1996. She is presently working on
chemical sensors with particular reference to deposition of thin films by
PVD technique and electrical characterisation of MOS thin films. She is
now finishing the PhD in material science at the University of Brescia.
References
Ezio Tempesti was born on the 26th of October 1943. He obtained his
degree in 1968 at the Pavia University. At the Politecnico di Milano, he
w1x H.A. Macleod, Thin Film Optical Filters, 2nd edn., Macmillan, New
was an assistant from 1968 to 1969 then he became Assistant Professor
York, 1986.
until 1982 and Associated Professor from 1982 to 1986. Full Professor at
w2x I. Paz, Z. Luo, L. Radenberg, A. Haller, Photooxidative self-clean-
the University of L’Aquila until 1990, he left for the University of
ing transparent titanium dioxide films on glass, J. Mater. Res. 10
Brescia where he is now the Director of the Department of Chemistry and
Ž1995. 2842–2848.
Physics for Engineering and Materials. He has been involved in several
w3x C.J. Brinker, G.W. Scherer, Sol–Gel Science: The Physics and
research projects, e.g. with S.N.I.A., Montedison, SNAM Progetti, I.C.I.,
Chemistry of Sol–Gel Processing, Academic Press, New York,
Euratom, Elf Atochem, etc. He has been project leader of the Italian
1990.
Ministry of Scientific Research, C.N.R., E.N.E.A. and European Commu-
w4x E. Traversa, G. Gnappi, A. Montenero, G. Gusmano, Ceramic thin
nity. He is a member of Assne. Italiana di Ingegneria Chimica, Fedn.
films by sol–gel processing as novel materials for integrated humid-
Europeenne du Genie Chimique, N.Y. Academy of Sciences.
ity sensors, Sens. Actuators, B 31 Ž1996. 59–70.
w5x K. Kato, K. Niihara, Roles of polyethylene glycol in evolution of Cesare Frigeri has obtained his degree in solid state physics at the
nanostructure in TiO 2 coatings, Thin Solid Films 298 Ž1997. 76–82. University of Bologna. For 8 years he was a Research Scientist in Agip
w6x K. Kato, Y. Torii, H. Taoda, T. Kato, Y. Butsgan, K. Niihara, TiO 2 Nucleare where he performed researches in the field of sintering of
coating photocatalysts with nanostructure and preferred orientation ceramic materials and the relationship between mechanical properties and
showing excellent activity for decomposition of aqueous acetic acid, crystalline textures in metal alloys. In 1982 he joined the CNR-MASPEC
J. Mater. Sci. Lett. 15 Ž1996. 913–915. Institute in Parma where he is a Senior Scientist. Since then, his activity
w7x V.J. Nagpal, R.M. Davis, S.B. Desu, Novel thin films of titanium has dealt with the study of extended defects by electron microscopy, their
dioxide particles synthesised by a sol–gel process, J. Mater. Res. 10 interaction with point defects and their correlation with growth parame-
Ž12. Ž1995. 3068–3078. ters in both bulk and epitaxial III–V compound semiconductors, as well
w8x V.J. Nagpal, R.M. Davis, J.S. Riffle, In situ steric stabilisation of as with the development of SEM and TEM methods for defect analysis in
titanium dioxide particles synthesised by a sol–gel process, Colloid such compounds. He is the author of 85 publications in international
Surf. 87 Ž1994. 25–31. journals and proceedings with international refereeing committee. He has
w9x G. Sberveglieri, L.E. Depero, S. Groppelli, P. Nelli, WO 3 sputtered given six invited talks in international conferences and is member of the
thin films for NO x monitoring, Sens. Actuators, B 26–27 Ž1995. scientific or steering committee of two international conferences.
89–92.
w10x C. Garzella, E. Comini, E. Tempesti, C. Frigeri, G. Sberveglieri, Giorgio SberÕeglieri was born on July 17, 1947 and received his degree
13th European Conference Solid-State Transducers ŽEurosensors in physics from the University of Parma in 1971 with his research
XIII., The Hague, Nl, September 12–15, 1999, pp. 431–432. activities on the preparation of semiconducting thin film solar cells. He
w11x E. Haro-Poniatowsky, R. Roodriguez-Talavera, M. de la Cruz Here- has been appointed Associate Professor at the University of Brescia in
dia, O. Cano-Corona, R. Arroyo-Murillo, Crystallisation of nano- 1987. In the following year, he established the Thin Film Laboratory,
sized titania particles prepared by the sol–gel process, J. Mater. Res. afterwards called Gas Sensor Lab., mainly devoted to the preparation and
9 Ž1994. 2102–2108. characterisation of thin film chemical sensors; he has been the Director of
w12x G. Sberveglieri, M.Z. Atashbar, Y. Li, M. Wlodarsky, E. Comini, G. the GSL since 1988. In 1994, he was appointed Full Professor in Physics,
Faglia, M.K. Ghantasala, Nanocrystalline TiO 2 thin films prepared formerly at the Faculty of Engineering of the University of Ferrara and
by the sol–gel process for alcohol sensing, Transducers ’99, Senday, then in 1996 at the Faculty of Engineering of the University of Brescia.
Japan, June 7–10, 1999, pp. 1690–1693. He is referee of the journals AThin Solid FilmsB, ASensors and ActuatorsB
w13x T. Brousse, D.M. Schleich, Sprayed and thermally evaporated SnO 2 ASensors and MaterialsB and other journals and member of Scientific
thin film for ethanol sensors, Sens. Actuators, B 31 Ž1996. 77–79. Committee of Conferences on Sensor and Materials Science. During his
25 years of scientific activities, Giorgio Sberveglieri published more than
140 papers on international reviews; he presented more than 50 oral
communications to international congresses and numerous oral communi-
Biographies cations to national congresses.
Carlotta Garzella was born on June 14, 1972. She received a graduate
degree in chemistry at the University of Milan in 1997. She is now a PhD
student in Materials Science at the University of Brescia and is working
on chemical sensors with particular interest on the sol–gel technology for
oxide thin film deposition and the chemico–physical characterisation of
the oxide surfaces.