Become An Insider Login

#Views (/views) #Opinion (/Views)

A Wrinkle in Time
Scott McLemee explores a series of essays on working from home during the pandemic.

By   Scott McLemee // August 28, 2020

 

(https://www.insidehighered.com/sites/default/server_ les/styles/large/public/media/work-from-
home-businesswoman-vector-id1213186222.jpg?itok=ZYeK4I-c)
ISTOCK.COM/SORBETTO

I had a dream come true last weekend, quite literally. For the rst time in about six months, I was able to
browse in a bookstore (one in my neighborhood that's reopened with sanitary and social distancing
protocols clearly posted) while wide-awake. In the past, leaving the store without buying anything had felt
like a triumph of willpower, but this time it involved some guilt. Only one other person was in the store during
my visit, a clerk, and it only seemed fair to her to purchase something. Next time, for sure.

To be clear, I am not exactly wanting for reading material, but the element of wish ful llment is intense even
so. Likewise with my spouse, who reports having theater dreams. She has attended at least one play a
week, on the most conservative estimate, throughout her entire adult life -- or did until this spring.
Performances by excellent companies are livestreamed now, and she has been able to take theater classes
online. But there’s more to going to theater than seeing a play -- a ritual-like aspect that can’t be broadcast.
Browsing indulges curiosity and involves a degree of chance. The hunger is not for content but for certain
qualities of experience, in part communal, that are lost or on hold for the duration.

The possibility of turning crisis into opportunity comes up in one of the essays on working from home that
appears in the latest issue (https://www.utpjournals.press/toc/jsp/51/4) of the Journal of Scholarly
Publishing. “How many of you,” asks Erika Dyck, a history professor at the University of Saskatchewan, “have
dreamed of pressing pause on the work treadmill? I am talking about a genuine freeze-frame, reset, and
rethink, or a chance to read something that isn’t directly related to a task with a deadline.”

But think again: “Let’s not kid ourselves; working from home during a pandemic is not that.” Before the
pandemic, Dyck had what seemed like a modus vivendi that balanced parental responsibilities and
academic work, including her role as a co-editor of the Canadian Bulletin for Medical History. “Now,” she
Become An Insider Login
writes, “despite being relatively isolated or even hiding in a home o ce, I consistently feel tired and am
unable to focus on anything, especially when it comes to writing … My mind has constantly wandered,
whether drifting toward the contents of the fridge and the looming prospect of dinner, or more often
enveloping me in a fog of wondering whether any of the work we do as academics really matters, or
whether we will still have academic institutions in a post-COVID world.”

Dyck’s is the most confessional of the essays and, no doubt for that reason, the one that made the most
impression on me. At some point her trouble writing it became integral to what she had to say -- in
particular, to acknowledging the trouble with “feeling like we need to be productive while people are dying,
losing jobs, hungry and scared.”

The other four contributors to “A Compilation of Short Takes on Working from Home
(https://www.utpjournals.press/doi/full/10.3138/jsp.51.4.05) ” recount different levels of di culty in
adjusting to the disruption. Bryan Birchmeier, an intellectual property coordinator at Michigan Publishing and
the University of Michigan Press, frames it as a less physically grueling version of the phase known as “tear-
down” or “total control” that he went through as in boot camp: “It’s meant to break down any barriers recruits
may have to adjusting to a military schedule and to military procedures … We have had to create or adjust to
a new schedule and new procedures because so much about our daily routine is different …”

At the other extreme is the experience of Olivier Lebert, the manager for two Canadian journals for 15 years,
who has telecommuted for 11 of them -- and from France for the past 10. It sounds like the pandemic has
not called for that much change in routine, and he can sum up best practices very clearly: establish a
schedule. Stick to it. Meet deadlines. Outside your set working hours, relax: “stop responding to professional
calls or emails.”

Lebert’s recommendations are sensible, and they line up closely with the advice offered in the same
symposium by Sarah Buhler, an associate professor at the University of Saskatchewan College of Law, and
by Kathie Porta Baker, described as “a self-employed manuscript editor, proofreader, and production
assistant living and working in Northern Virginia.” But for Lebert, the boot camp-like transformation took
place quite a while ago. Work at home has become second nature, though he does not indicate how long
that took.

We are coming up on six months since the familiar broke. Marking the anniversary of a change sometimes
helps to put it in perspective. In this case no commonly accepted date is available to punctuate time into
before and after. (March 10 seems a little early, while March 15 is probably too late.) The turn was sudden,
sharp, yet a blur. We make adjustments that seem to nudge things a little closer to normal, but with an
uneasy awareness that there is so much more loss still to come.

Read more by   Scott McLemee

 Become An Insider Login

(/print/views/2020/08/28/essay-
pandemic-and-time)

Be the rst to know.

(https://www.insidehighered.com/content/sign-
inside-higher-eds-newsletters)
Get our free daily newsletter.
(https://www.insidehighered.com/content/sign-
inside-higher-eds-newsletters)

Work/School Email* Job Title*

I have read & agree to the terms of

Keep Me Informed ▶ Inside Higher Ed’s Privacy Policy.*

We have retired comments
(https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2020/06/24/change-inside-higher-eds-policy-

!
reader-comments) and introduced Letters to the Editor. Letters may be sent
to letters@insidehighered.com (mailto:letters@insidehighered.com) .
Read the Letters to the Editor  » (https://www.insidehighered.com/views#letters-to-the-
editor)

Inside Higher Ed Careers

Hiring? Post A Job Today! (https://shopcareers.insidehighered.com?utm_medium=editorial-
site&utm_source=ihe&utm_campaign=edtocareers&utm_content=article-end)

Faculty (#tab- Administrative(#tab- Executive Jobs

(#tab-
Jobs facultyjobs) Jobs administrativejobs)
Administration Outside (#tab-
executiveadministrationjobs)
Jobs Higher jobsoutsidehighereducatio
Education

Browse Faculty Jobs

Arts & Humanities Education

(https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/arts- (https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/education/
and-humanities/)
Engineering & Mathematics
(https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/engineerin
 and-mathematics/) and-technology/)
Become An Insider Login
Health & Medical Social Sciences
(https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/health- (https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/social-
and-medical/) sciences/)

Professional Fields Technical & Vocational Fields

(https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/professional- (https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/technical-
WANT TO ADVERTISE? CLICK HERE (HTTPS://WWW.INSIDEHIGHERED.COM/ADVERTISE)
elds/) and-vocational- elds/)

Science & Technology

COLLEGE PAGES
(https://careers.insidehighered.com/jobs/science-

College Name SEARCH

Featured college pages

(/college/muskegon-community-college)

(/college/moraine-park-technical-college)

POPULAR RIGHT NOW

U of Florida suspends professor blamed in student's suicide

(http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2021/03/03/u- orida-suspends-professor-blamed-students-
suicide)

Inside Higher Ed's News (http://www.insidehighered.com/news)

Inside Higher Ed | Kean University (http://www.insidehighered.com/college/185262/kean-university)

10 strategies to support students and help them learn during the coronavirus crisis (opinion)
(http://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2020/03/17/10-strategies-support-students-and-help-them-learn-
during-coronavirus-crisis)

How professors can and should combat linguistic prejudice in their classes (opinion)
(http://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2021/01/27/how-professors-can-and-should-combat-linguistic-
prejudice-their-classes-opinion)

Advice for students so they don't sound silly in emails (essay)

(http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2015/04/16/advice-students-so-they-dont-sound-silly-emails-
essay)

Inside Higher Ed | University of North Georgia

(http://www.insidehighered.com/college/482680/university-north-georgia)
Wellness and Mental Health in 2020 Online Learning (http://www.insidehighered.com/digital-
Become An Insider Login
learning/blogs/online-trending-now/wellness-and-mental-health-2020-online-learning)

Scholar studies metaphors used in Britain and Turkey for academics

(http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2021/03/05/scholar-studies-metaphors-used-britain-and-turkey-
academics)

Opinions on Inside Higher Ed

(/views/2021/03/05/resources-avoiding-self-plagiarism-are-scarce-and-problematic-opinion)
Self-Plagiarism, Fraud and iThenticate: A Complicated Relationship
(/views/2021/03/05/resources-avoiding-self-plagiarism-are-scarce-and-problematic-opinion)

(/views/2021/03/04/administrators-can-help-students-know-how-get-support-campus-opinion)
Talk to Us, Please! We Really Are Here to Help! (/views/2021/03/04/administrators-can-help-
students-know-how-get-support-campus-opinion)

(/views/2021/03/04/federal-government-should-rectify-how-it-handles-international-students)
Dropping the Ball (/views/2021/03/04/federal-government-should-rectify-how-it-handles-
international-students)

Inside Higher Ed’s Blog U

Confessions of a Community College Dean (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean)
Followup on Fall Planning (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean/followup-fall-planning)
Just Visiting (/blogs/just-visiting) Become An Insider Login
An Ultra-Sophisticated Language AI Shows the Way Toward Better Writing Assessment
(/blogs/just-visiting/ultra-sophisticated-language-ai-shows-way-toward-better-writing-assessment)

Tackling Transfer (/blogs/tackling-transfer)

Systems Can -- and Must -- Build Better Pathways to Prosperity (/blogs/tackling-transfer/systems-
can-and-must-build-better-pathways-prosperity)

Confessions of a Community College Dean (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean)

Cabin Fever (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean/cabin-fever-0)

Learning Innovation (/blogs/learning-innovation)

3 Questions for Swati Carr, Research Fellow at Extension Engine (/blogs/learning-innovation/3-
questions-swati-carr-research-fellow-extension-engine)

Confessions of a Community College Dean (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean)

Planning for Fall (/blogs/confessions-community-college-dean/planning-fall)

BACK TO TOP

News & Views

Admissions

Student Voice

Teaching & Learning

Diversity

The Key Podcast

Careers

Find a Job

College Pages

Career Advice

Job Alerts

Post a Job
 Events Become An Insider Login

In-Person Events

Editorial Webcasts

Vendor Webcasts

Reports & Data

Special Reports

Surveys

Booklets

AAUP Compensation Data

Quick Takes Views Blog U Letters to the Editor Audio Topics Sponsored Content

keyword

News & Opinion

search

Free Newsletters Contact Us About Us Hire Faculty & Staff Advertise Work For Us
Testimonials Rights and Permissions Privacy Share our content

Copyright © 2021  •  Inside Higher Ed  •  1150 Connecticut Avenue NW Suite 400  •  Washington, DC 20036  •  
Ph: 1-202-659-9208  •  Fax: 1-202-659-9381
Do Not Sell My Personal Information