Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Vision of 6G Wireless Systems: Applications, Trends, Technologies, and Open Research Problems
A Vision of 6G Wireless Systems: Applications, Trends, Technologies, and Open Research Problems
Abstract—The ongoing deployment of 5G cellular systems is a mirage. Although the 5G systems that are currently being
continuously exposing the inherent limitations of this system, marketed will readily support basic IoE and URLLC services
compared to its original premise as an enabler for Internet (e.g., factory automation), it is debatable whether they can
arXiv:1902.10265v2 [cs.IT] 21 Jul 2019
bps/Hz/
Joules/m3
and THz
5G Beyond 5G 6G
End-to-End Delay
5 ms 1 ms < 1 ms
Requirements
Radio-Only Delay
100 ns 100 ns 10 ns
Requirements
End-to-End Reliability
99.999% 99.9999% 99.99999%
Requirements
maps (Trend 6). These short-term AI-enabled 6G functions and CubeSats to provide backhaul support and additional wide
will be complemented by a so-called “collective network area coverage. Integrating terrestrial, airborne, and satellite
intelligence” in which network intelligence is pushed at the networks [10] and [11] into a single wireless system will be
edge, running AI and learning algorithms on edge devices essential for 6G.
(Trend 7) to provide distributed autonomy. This new edge AI 6) Energy Transfer and Harvesting: 6G could be the
leap will create a 6G system that can integrate the services cellular system that can provide energy, along with 3CLS
of Section II, realize 3CLS, and potentially replace classical (Trend 6). As wireless energy transfer is maturing, we foresee
frame structures. 6G base stations providing basic power transfer for devices,
5) Integrated Terrestrial, Airborne, and Satellite Net- particularly implants and sensors (Trend 7). Adjunct energy-
works: Beyond their inevitable role as 6G users, drones can centric ideas, such as energy harvesting and backscatter will
be leveraged to complement terrestrial networks by providing also be a component of 6G.
connectivity to hotspots and to areas with scarce infrastructure. 7) Beyond 6G: A handful of technologies will mature
Meanwhile, both drones and terrestrial base stations may along the same time of 6G and, hence, potentially play a
require satellite connectivity with low orbit satellites (LEO) role towards the end of the 6G standardization and research
Broadband
LL
eMBB
Reliability (1-10y)
-1
-5
-7
1000
Mobile
100 -9 Broadband
1 URLLC Reliable
0 0 0.1 1 10 100
Latency (ms)
Data rate (Gbps)
Fig. 2. MBRLLC services and several special cases (including classical eMBB and URLLC) within the rate-reliability-latency space. Other involved, associated
metrics that are not shown include energy and network scale.
process. One prominent example is quantum computing and the co-existence of THz, mmWave, and microwave cells
communications that can provide security and long-distance across all layers, building on early works such as [13].
networking. Currently, major research efforts are focused on 3) 3D Networking: Due to the integration of ground
the quantum realm and we expect them to intersect with 6G. and airborne networks, as outlined in Section III, 6G must
Other similar beyond 6G technologies include integration of support communications in 3D space, including serving users
RF and non-RF links (including optical, neural, molecular, and in 3D and deploying 3D base stations (e.g., tethered balloons
other channels). or temporary drones). This requires concerted research on
various fronts. First, measurement and (data-driven) modeling
IV. 6G: R ESEARCH AGENDA AND O PEN P ROBLEMS of the 3D propagation environment is needed. Second, new
approaches for 3D frequency and network planning (e.g.,
Building on the identified trends in Section II and the where to deploy base stations, tethered balloons, or even
enabling technologies in Section III, we now put forward a drone-base stations) must be developed. Our work in [10]
research agenda for 6G (summarized in Table III). showed that such 3D planning is substantially different from
1) 3D Rate-Reliability-Latency Fundamentals: Funda- conventional 2D networks due to the new altitude dimension
mental 3D performance of 6G systems, in terms of rate- and the associated degrees of freedom. Finally, new network
reliability-latency tradeoffs and SEE is needed. Such analy- optimizations for mobility management, routing, and resource
sis must quantify the spectrum, energy, and communication management in 3D are needed.
requirements that 6G needs in order to support the identified 4) Communication with LIS: As per Trend 3, 6G will
driving applications. Recent works in [7] and [12] provide a provide wireless connectivity via smart LIS environments that
first step in this direction. include active frequency selective surfaces, metallic passive
2) Exploring Integrated, Heterogeneous High- reflectors, passive/active reflect arrays, as well as nonreconfig-
Frequency Bands: Exploiting mmWave and THz in urable and reconfigurable metasurfaces. Open problems here
6G brings forth several new open problems. For mmWave, range from the optimized deployment of passive reflectors and
supporting high mobility at mmWave frequencies will be a metasurfaces to AI-powered operation of LISs. Fundamental
central open problem. For THz, new transceiver architectures analysis to understand the performance of smart surfaces, in
and propagation models are needed [8]. High power, high terms of rate, latency, reliability, and coverage is needed,
sensitivity, and low noise figure are key transceiver features building on the early work in [9]. Another important direction
needed to overcome the very high THz path loss. Once these is to investigate the potential of using LIS-based reflective
physical layer aspects are well-understood, there is a need to surfaces to enhance the range and coverage of tiny cells and
develop new network and link-layer protocols to optimize the to dynamically modify the propagation environment.
use of cross-frequency resources while taking into account 5) AI for Wireless: AI brings forward many major re-
the highly varying and uncertain nature of the mmWave and search directions for 6G. Beyond the need for massive, small
THz environments. Another important direction is to study data analytics as well as using machine learning (ML) and AI-
TABLE II
S UMMARY OF 6G SERVICE CLASSES , THEIR PERFORMANCE INDICATORS , AND EXAMPLE APPLICATIONS .
Communication &
Information
AI/Machine learning Data analytics Theory
foundations
Intelligence Communications
foundations foundations
Game Theory Electromagnetics
Autonomy Large
and sensing intelligent surfaces
foundations foundations
Control Theory 3D Stochastic
Geometry
Risk 6G System Networking
foundations foundations
Network Science
Microeconomics &
Statistics Physics Optimization
foundations foundations
Human Computing
Physics and QoPE foundations Stochastic
foundations Optimization &
Optimal Transport
Psychophysics
& Physiology
based SSNs (realized using reinforcement learning and game services) or from a control system (for CRAS) is an important
theory), there is also a need to operate ML algorithms reliably 6G research area, especially in light of new, emerging devices
over 6G to deliver the applications of Section II. To perform (Trend 7). This requires both real-world psychophysics ex-
these critical application tasks, low-latency, high-reliability periments as well as new, rigorous mathematical expressions
and scalable AI is needed, along with a reliable infrastructure for QoPE that combine QoS, QoE, and human perceptions.
[1] and [3]. This joint design of ML and wireless networks is Theoretical development of QoPE can be achieved using
a key 6G research area. techniques from other disciplines such as operations research
(e.g., multi-attribute utility theory (see [14])) and machine
6) QoPE Metrics: The design of QoPE metrics that in-
learning (see [2]). 6G will be the first generation to enable a
tegrate physical factors from human physiology (for HCS
new breed of applications (wireless BCI) leveraging multiple This greatly improves spectrum efficiency and network ca-
human cognitive senses. pacity, and helps the integration of imaging and wireless
7) Joint Communication and Control: 6G needs to communication. How to realize holographic radio is a widely
pervasively support CRAS. The performance of CRAS is gov- open area.
erned by real-world control systems whose operation requires An overview on the necessary analytical tools and funda-
data input from wireless 6G links. Therefore, operating CRAS mentals related to these open problems is shown in Fig. 3.
over 6G systems requires a communication and control co-
design, whereby the performance of the 6G wireless links is V. C ONCLUSION AND R ECOMMENDATIONS
optimized to cater for the stability of the control system and
This article laid out a bold new vision for 6G systems that
vice versa. Due to the traditional radio-centric focus (3GPP
outlines the trends, challenges, and associated research. While
and IEEE fora), such a co-design has been overlooked in
many topics will come as a natural 5G evolution, new avenues
5G. Meanwhile, prior works on networked control abstract the
of research such as LIS communication, 3CLS, holographic
specifics of the wireless network and cannot apply to cellular
radio, and others will create an exciting research agenda for
communications. This makes the communication-control co-
the next decade. We conclude with several recommendations:
design a key research topic in 6G.
8) 3CLS: The idea of joint communication and control • Recommendation 1: A first step towards 6G is to enable
must be extended to the joint design of the entire 3CLS MBRLLC and mobility management at high-frequency
functions. The interdependence between computing, commu- mmWave bands and beyond (i.e., THz).
nication, control, localization, sensing, energy, and mapping • Recommendation 2: 6G requires a move from radio-
has not yet been fully explored in an end-to-end manner. Key centric system design (à-la-3GPP) towards an end-to-end
questions range from how to jointly meet the performance of 3CLS co-design under the orchestration of an AI-driven
all 3CLS services to multi-modal sensor fusion for reconstruct- intelligence substrate.
ing 3D images and navigating in unknown environments for • Recommendation 3: The 6G vision will not be a simple
navigating robots, autonomous driving, etc. 3CLS is needed case of exploring additional, high-frequency spectrum
for various applications including CRAS, XR, and DLT. bands to provide more capacity. Instead, it will be driven
9) 6G Protocol Designs: Owing to all trends discussed in by a diverse portfolio of applications, technologies, and
Section II-B and their challenges, compared to 5G, 6G will techniques (see Figs. 1 and 3).
require radical new protocol designs. For instance, 6G must • Recommendation 4: 6G will transition from the
introduce new, AI-driven protocols for signaling, scheduling, smartphone-base station paradigm into a new era of smart
and coordination that can replace conventional 5G protocols surfaces communicating with human-embedded implants.
that rely on pre-determined network parameters and rigid • Recommendation 5: Performance analysis and opti-
frame structures. These new 6G protocols will, in contrast, mization of 6G requires operating in 3D space and
continuously adapt to the current and projected state of the moving away from simple averaging towards fine-grained
wireless environment. As 6G evolves, there will be a need analysis that deals with tails, distributions, and QoPE.
for new, dynamic multiple access [15] protocols that can
dynamically change the type of multiple access (orthogonal R EFERENCES
or non-orthogonal, random or scheduled) used depending on [1] M. Chen, U. Challita, W. Saad, C. Yin, and M. Debbah, “Artificial neural
the needs of the applications and the network state. Moreover, networks-based machine learning for wireless networks: A tutorial,”
IEEE Communications Surveys and Tutorials, to appear, 2019.
novel handover protocols must be designed to account for the [2] A. Taleb Zadeh Kasgari, W. Saad, and M. Debbah, “Human-in-the-loop
3D nature of the 6G system and the presence of different wireless communications: Machine learning and brain-aware resource
management,” IEEE Transactions on Communications, to appear, 2019.
types of mobile devices. New protocols for authentication and [3] J. Park, S. Samarakoon, M. Bennis, and M. Debbah, “Wireless network
identification will also be needed to handle the new breed intelligence at the edge,” arXiv preprint arXiv:1812.02858, Dec. 2018.
[4] P. Zioga, F. Pollick, M. Ma, P. Chapman, and K. Stefanov, “Enheduanna
of wireless devices that include drones, vehicles, as well as a manifesto of falling live brain computer cinema performance: Per-
embedded and implanted devices. Finally, all 6G protocols former and audience participation, cognition and emotional engagement
using multi brain BCI interaction,” Frontiers in neuroscience, vol. 12,
must be distributed and able to leverage datasets distributed pp. 191, April 2018.
across the network edge. [5] Y. Li, J. Liu, B. Cao, and C. Wang, “Joint optimization of radio and
10) RF and non-RF Link Integration: 6G will witness a virtual machine resources with uncertain user demands in mobile cloud
computing,” IEEE Transactions on Multimedia, vol. 20, no. 9, pp. 2427–
convergence of RF and non-RF links that encompass optical, 2438, Sep. 2018.
visible light communication (VLC), molecular communica- [6] G. Durisi, T. Koch, and P. Popovski, “Toward massive, ultrareliable, and
low-latency wireless communication with short packets,” Proceedings
tion, and neuro-communication, among others. Design of such of the IEEE, vol. 104, no. 9, pp. 1711–1726, Sep. 2016.
joint RF/non-RF systems is an open research area. [7] M. Bennis, M. Debbah, and H. V. Poor, “Ultrareliable and low-latency
wireless communication: Tail, risk, and scale,” Proceedings of the IEEE,
11) Holographic Radio: RF holography (including holo- vol. 106, no. 10, pp. 1834–1853, Oct 2018.
graphic MIMO) and spatial spectral holography can be made [8] Y. Xing and T. S. Rappaport, “Propagation measurement system and
approach at 140 GHz-moving to 6G and above 100 GHz,” in Proc. of
possible with 6G due to the use of LIS and similar structures. IEEE Global Communications Conference (GLOBECOM), Abu Dhabi,
Holographic RF allows for control of the entire physical space United Arab Emirates, United Arab Emirates, Dec 2018.
[9] S. Hu, F. Rusek, and O. Edfors, “Beyond massive MIMO: The potential
and the full closed loop of the electromagnetic field through of data transmission with large intelligent surfaces,” IEEE Transactions
spatial spectral holography and spatial wave field synthesis. on Signal Processing, vol. 66, no. 10, pp. 2746–2758, May 2018.
TABLE III
S UMMARY OF R ESEARCH A REAS