You are on page 1of 7

Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Psychology of Sport and Exercise


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/psychsport

Olympic athletes back to retirement: A qualitative longitudinal study


Miquel Torregrosa*, Yago Ramis, Susana Pallare
s, Fernando Azo
 car, Clara Selva
noma de Barcelona, Spain
Universitat Auto

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Objective: In this qualitative longitudinal study we assess the retirement process of Olympic athletes. We
Available online 17 March 2015 aim to evaluate the influence that following a dual career or being exclusively focused on sport can have
in this process. We compare athletes' prospective views before retirement (Torregrosa, Boixado  s,
Keywords: Valiente, & Cruz, 2004) with their retrospective accounts ten years later. This allows us to assess athletes'
Qualitative longitudinal study accuracy in predicting the process and its outcomes in relation to the trajectory followed.
Elite athletes
Design: We designed a qualitative longitudinal study (Epstein, 2002) conducting semi-structured
Dual career
interviews.
Transitions
Retirement from sport
Method: Fifteen Olympic athletes were interviewed twice. Thematic analysis was performed on the
qualitative data comparing prospective views and retrospective accounts of: (a) retirement planning, (b)
voluntary termination, (c), multiple personal identities, (d) availability of social support, and (e) active
coping strategies.
Results: Ten athletes reported positive transitions related to their favorable approach to the five cate-
gories above. Most athletes reporting positive transitions followed dual careers (i.e., parallel or conver-
gent trajectories). Five out of fifteen athletes reported unexpected difficulties in the transition. Four of
these followed a linear trajectory during their sporting career. A clear view of retirement in the pro-
spective interviews also facilitated retirement for an athlete following a linear trajectory. While a diffuse
view of retirement in the prospective interview signaled future difficulties.
Conclusion: Results from this qualitative longitudinal study suggest that promoting dual careers in elite
sport and working on the prospective view of retirement can facilitate retirement from elite sport and
the transition to an alternative professional career.
© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction vein, this work presents a qualitative longitudinal study of retire-


ment, providing a unique insight into the dynamics of retirement as
Exploring retirement from sport has been a subject of interest in a process. Here we focus on a group of 15 elite athletes, com-
sport psychology from pioneering work in the late sixties (e.g., plementing their prospective view on sport retirement given in the
Mihovilovic, 1968) to current times (e.g., Park, Tod, & Lavallee, early 2000s (Torregrosa, Boixado s, Valiente & Cruz, 2004), with
2012). Indeed, studies on career termination, and more generally their retrospective accounts of the same process ten years later.
on career development and transitions, have increased substan- This approach enables us to comment on factors conditioning both
tially both in quantity and quality since the end of the1980s the fulfillment of athletes' initial expectations regarding retirement
(Stambulova, Alfermann, Statler, & Co ^te, 2009). However, according and the effectiveness of initial strategies and decisions taken, from
to Park, Lavallee and Tod (2012) in their systematic review, avenues a long term retrospective position. In particular, by taking into ac-
for research still remain. In particular, these authors propose that, count different trajectories in terms of athletes' career compatibi-
as retirement occurs over time, employing longitudinal designs lization, we could study the way in which following dual careers
could minimize the limitations of cross-sectional studies. In this can affect the retirement process.

Retirement from competitive elite sport


* Corresponding author. Departament de Psicologia Ba sica, Evolutiva i de l'Edu-
, Edifici B, Universitat Auto
cacio  noma de Barcelona, 08193 Bellaterra, Barcelona,
Spain. Tel.: þ34 935813153. Factors involved in athletic career termination have been
E-mail address: miquel.torregrosa@uab.cat (M. Torregrosa). extensively discussed by Stambulova et al. (2009), in the ISSP

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2015.03.003
1469-0292/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56 51

Position Stand on career development and transitions. In this Related to the concept of dual careers, in the context of a semi-
comprehensive review, these authors pointed out three major professional sport Pallare s, Azo
car, Torregrosa, Selva, and Ramis
shifts in stance concerning athletes' career transitions: (a) transi- (2011) proposed three different types of trajectories followed by
tion being interpreted now as a coping process rather than as a Spanish elite water polo players during their sporting career. Based
phenomenon; (b) other transitions being included, instead of on content analysis of the interviews, they defined: (a) a linear
focusing almost exclusively on athletic retirement; and (c) a shift trajectory when the athlete is only focused in his/her sporting
from considering athletes' transitions exclusively in their sporting career giving almost 100% dedication to sport and having an almost
career to a “whole person” lifespan perspective. Stambulova et al. exclusive athletic identity; (b) a convergent trajectory in which sport
draw 6 conclusions concerning key features of the transition pro- is prioritized but is compatible with an alternative job or with
cess: (a) the multi-causality of career termination, (b) the great education, resulting in a more balanced multi-personal identity;
inter-individual differences in the reactions to career termination, and (c) a parallel trajectory in which sport and higher education or
(c) the key role of the subjective feeling of voluntariness in the work are almost equally prioritized and the athlete shows a
process of adaptation, (d) the importance of making timely plans balanced multi-personal identity. This proposal of trajectories has
for life after an athletic career, (e) the importance of the resources been explored later in other sports and cultures (e.g., Azo car, Pe
rez,
available for athletes, and (f) the fact that approximately 15e20% of s, & Torregrosa, 2013) providing a frame to interpret the
Pallare
elite retired athletes need psychological assistance. As a conse- quality of adaptation to career transitions. In the present study this
quence, in their statements and recommendations the authors model of trajectories has been used, with dual career illustrated by
emphasize that retirement planning, voluntary termination, mul- both the convergent and parallel trajectories. We have found the
tiple personal identities, availability of social support and active trajectory followed to be highly relevant in an athlete's handling of
coping strategies facilitate athletes' adaptation to post-career life. the retirement process.
These are aspects we have taken into account in our longitudinal
study. Note also that failure in coping with retirement is often
followed by negative consequences such as psychological pathol- Qualitative longitudinal studies
ogies or alcohol and drug abuse (McPherson, 1980; Wylleman,
Rosier, & De Knop, 2015). The quality of adaptation to a post- A distinct feature of this study is its longitudinal nature,
sport career determines its success and we explore the relevant including the prospective and retrospective view of retirement,
issues involved. We next present key findings from our initial spanning a period of ten years. Epstein (2002) proposed three types
prospective study and background on models of trajectories to of approaches for qualitative longitudinal studies: (a) continuous
contextualize the work. research in the same small society, (b) periodic studies at regular or
irregular intervals, and (c) return after a lengthy interval of time has
Main results on the prospective view of retirement from elite elapsed since the original research (p.64). Our study follows the
athletes third approach and with a ten year gap between interviews, pro-
vides a particularly long term view of the retirement process. At the
In 2004 we interviewed 18 active Olympian athletes on their time of the second interview all athletes were retired from elite
prospective view of retirement from competitive sport (Torregrosa sport and had already passed through the adaptation process
et al., 2004). Using a grounded theory approach we identified three following the transition. The qualitative longitudinal approach has
different stages along which active athletes gradually build an been used to study transitions in different life spheres such as
image of retirement from sport (i.e., initiation-training, maturity- educational research (e.g., Gordon & Lahelma, 2003), or the tran-
performance and the anticipation of retirement). In addition we sition from education to work (Kuhn & Witzel, 2000). However it
found that some of the aspects valued by retired athletes in other has been less used in sport psychology in general and in career
studies were also important for active athletes. These included the transition research in particular. In a recent systematic review of
definition of retirement as a process rather than a moment, and a 126 studies on athletes' career transition out of sport, Park, Lavallee,
preparation period for retirement. The aspects we identified in our et al. (2012) identified 113 cross-sectional studies, but only 13
study are in line with those proposed by Stambulova et al. (2009) in (10.3%) with a longitudinal design. Six are qualitative longitudinal
the ISSP Position Stand, mentioned in the previous section (i.e., studies assessing transition processes on small samples of different
retirement planning, voluntary termination, multiple personal competitive levels, interviewed at least twice, four of them retro-
identities, availability of social support, and active coping strate- spective, and the longest, (Douglas & Carless, 2009), spanning six
gies). These issues were revisited in the longitudinal study. years. In this study we conduct a qualitative longitudinal study with
a sample of high achieving Olympians over a longer period
Models of trajectory and the concept of dual careers providing their prospective view of retirement before making the
decision to retire and the retrospective view ten years later.
A relevant indicator of potential problems during and after
retirement from elite sport is an athlete being exclusively focused
on sport, and having a strong and unidimensional athletic identity. Purpose
This derives from anecdotal evidence on elite athletes having se-
vere problems after retirement from elite sport and research in The purpose of this qualitative longitudinal study is to evaluate
career transitions (see Park, Lavallee et al., 2012). Thus, policy the influence that following a dual career or being exclusively
makers on different parts of the world aim to provide preventive focused in sport can have in the retirement process of Olympians
resources in order to balance an athletic career with education, with excellent sporting achievements. The opportunity of having
work and other life skills (EU Expert Group, 2012; USOC, 2012). In their prospective view of retirement investigated in our previous
Europe, the Expert Group promoted by the European Union pro- research (Torregrosa et al., 2004) allows us to assess their accuracy
posed a set of guidelines to promote dual careers for talented in predicting the process when we compare it with their retro-
athletes. The objective of the dual careers approach is to avoid spective accounts ten years later. This accuracy can be related to
situations in which the talented athlete is forced to choose between their trajectory, including pre-retirement attitudes to critical as-
sport and education or work. pects which bear relevance to post-career life.
52 M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56

Methods Procedures

Participants Athletes participating in the previous study (Torregrosa et al.,


2004) were localized, if possible. All those who were able to be
Fifteen athletes (10 male and 5 female) from the sample of 18 in contacted agreed to participate in the follow up study. Athletes
the prospective study (Torregrosa et al., 2004) were contacted and were informed of the purpose of the study, and three experienced
agreed to participate in the follow-up. The three other athletes interviewers conducted the sessions at each participant's chosen
were living abroad during the period of the retrospective in- location, in the athlete's preferred language (Spanish or Catalan).
terviews and it was not possible to contact them. The interviews were first recorded (lasting from 45 to 60 min) and
Table 1 summarizes the characteristics of the sample. All of then transcribed verbatim. At the end of the investigation, all par-
them were already retired from Olympic competition. Eight ath- ticipants were sent a personalized letter thanking them for their
letes competed in individual sports and 7 in team sports. From the collaboration, giving them a summary of the main findings, and
first step of the thematic analysis (See Table 2) athletes were clas- inviting them to contact the research team for further feedback or
sified regarding the type of trajectory mainly followed during their counseling, if so desired.
sporting career: four athletes followed parallel, 5 convergent and 6
linear trajectories. The number of participations in Summer Data analyses
Olympic Games of each athlete ranged from 1 to 5 and medals from
0 to 2. Age at retirement ranged from 25 to 40 and time since Data analysis was conducted using thematic analysis with a
retirement to the retrospective interviews ranged from 2 to 10 deductive approach to the content (Braun & Clarke, 2006). This
years. Thirteen athletes were retired both from Olympic and in- analysis organizes and describes data in rich detail (Sparkes &
ternational competitions. The remaining athletes, two competitive Smith, 2014). In order to conduct the thematic analysis proposed
sailors, had retired from Olympic events but were still participating by Braun and Clarke (2006), we followed six steps (see Table 2).
in international competitions. Software Atlas.ti 7 was used as an assistant to organize data codi-
fication and interview analyses.
Instruments We ensured descriptive validity (e.g., interviews were audio-
recorded, transcript verbatim and proofread by a different
For the follow up study a semi-structured interview guide was researcher) and theoretical validity (e.g., the authors met and dis-
designed by the research team divided into two parts: (a) a shared cussed the categorization of each code in relation to the theoretical
part for all athletes, and (b) an individualized part for each athlete. framework) in order to guarantee the rigor of the results (Maxwell,
The shared part included: (a) a review of the sporting career 2002). All five authors participated in the thematic analysis and the
since the first prospective interview until retirement from process of triangulation.
competitive sport; (b) an analysis of the retirement process inves-
tigating if it was planned or unplanned; (c) a review of the transi- Results
tion period looking into its length and assessing how the athlete
coped at the sporting, personal, relational and vocational levels; (d) The process of analysis consisted in the comparison between the
the situation at the same levels in the period of the retrospective prospective views and retrospective recalls of athletes regarding (a)
interview; and (e) the institutional support received or not during retirement planning, (b) voluntary termination, (c) multiple per-
the period of transition. sonal identities, (d) availability of social support, and (e) active
In the individualized section the participant was prompted to coping strategies. The main type of trajectory followed during the
recall his/her view of retirement from elite sport given in the pro- sporting career was observed as a factor modulating the experience
spective interviews. That vision was then compared with the situ- in each dimension.
ation they experienced during the process of retirement.
Similarities and differences between the prospective view and the Retirement planning
retrospective accounts at different levels were discussed between
the athlete and the researcher and are presented in the paired The athletes that followed parallel (27%) or convergent (33%)
quotes of the results section. trajectories (dual careers) were aware in the prospective interviews

Table 1
Description of participants.

Participant Gender Sport Type of trajectory Olympic participations (Medals) Age at retirement Years retired

Athlete 1 Female Individual Parallel 2 (0) 25 7


Athlete 2 Female Individual Linear 4 (2) 35 2
Athlete 3 Female Individual Convergent 2 (0) 36 6
Athlete 4 Female Individual Convergent 1 (1) 25 9
Athlete 5 Female Team Parallel 2 (0) 34 5
Athlete 6 Male Individual Convergent 5 (0) 40 10
Athlete 7 Male Individual Parallel 1 (0) 28 8
Athlete 8 Male Individual Linear 1 (0) 37 6
Athlete 9 Male Individual Linear 3 (1) 34 10
Athlete 10 Male Team Linear 4 (2) 33 4
Athlete 11 Male Team Convergent 5 (2) 38 7
Athlete 12 Male Team Linear 4 (2) 35 7
Athlete 13 Male Team Convergent 4 (1) 37 10
Athlete 14 Male Team Linear 1 (1) 33 10
Athlete 15 Male Team Parallel 2 (2) 33 10
M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56 53

Table 2
Description of the steps followed in the thematic analysis.

Steps Description

1. Familiarization with the data and allocation of athletes Transcribe interviews, reread transcriptions, detect main ideas, and allocate athletes to trajectory type.
to the type of trajectory
2. Creation of the initial codes based on the purpose Define concepts according to the literature “retirement planning, voluntary termination, multiple
of the study personal identities, availability of social support and active coping strategies”. Find examples in data
and specify when concepts can be used or not. Systematically code most relevant features of the data.
3. Grouping of the codes in main themes Compile and classify relevant information concerning each raw code. Generate visual representations
in order to facilitate code classification into main themes.
4. Refinement of the themes Analysis of the themes at two different levels. First we checked if they made sense in relation to the
code extracts. Second, we checked whether the themes fitted to the data both in the prospective and
retrospective interviews.
5. Definition and designation of the themes Analysis and clear definition of each theme. Moreover, an informative name was chosen for each theme
(see Table 3).
6. Producing the report Selection of relevant quotations representing good examples for each theme in the study at the moment
of the manuscript development.

(P) that planning retirement in advance would make the transition me to continue, although the federation supported me. [ … ] Then I
easier. As a team sport player said “There are people who dedicate came back [ … ] and in 2008 a new federation board arrived and
what they earn to business. But I have chosen the way I think is sacked me” (A8R).
better, which is studying and having academic training. It will Voluntary termination is not always possible in sport. Injuries
facilitate my entering into the labor market, contacts are not are common triggers of retirement. This was the case for two ath-
enough” (A15P). Ten years later the same athlete reported, in the letes in this study regardless of the type of trajectory they followed
retrospective interview (R), a vital experience of an easy and fast (parallel and linear). In a prospective interview one of these ath-
transition to an alternative professional career, to some extent letes following a parallel trajectory predicted “I know that it will
attributed to luck “I'm lucky because I studied sports sciences. I finish one day. It is a period of my life that one day must finish, but I
planned to live from sport and I did it. I work in the city hall as head want to be the one deciding to stop” (A1P). In a similar way a team
of the sports planning service” (A15R). Similar experiences were sport player following a linear trajectory stated “I think that it is
reported by most of the athletes following parallel or convergent important to know when to retire. It is important to be able to
trajectories and only one of the athletes of this group reported choose the moment. It is very sad to see how some athletes drag
severe difficulties in spite of retirement planning (see the quotation themselves on the fields” (A14P). However, in both cases it was an
of A3R in the synthesis and specificity of results). injury that made them decide to retire: “It was unexpected because
In the prospective interviews, athletes' following a linear path the year before the Olympics I injured my back, I pushed for the
(40%) were not planning retirement and saw sport as almost their Olympics but after that I quit” (A1R). “I stopped for one year
only possibility of an alternative professional career. As expressed because of a knee injury, then I changed to a lower club, but the
by a male athlete from a team sport “Some days I would like to knee was still hurting. I did not finish as planned” (A14R).
follow my career in sport, by being a coach. Some other days I think
that I'll be burnt-out. I would also like to be a PE teacher in a school. Multiple personal identities
For this reason I also like sport sciences” (A10P). The lack of plan-
ning in the prospective interviews was manifested in stress and In the prospective interviews all athletes following parallel and
difficulties during retirement, reported in the retrospective in- convergent trajectories mentioned more than one personal identity
terviews by all the athletes following linear trajectories (n ¼ 6). The “I go to the classes in the morning and you meet completely
same male athlete from a team sport stated “When I left the na- different people that never speak about sport. Moreover you have
tional team I began to have this need. All the alarms rang in my to dress like a person because I'm all day in my jocks” (A5P).
head and I tried to look for an attractive way out” (A10R). Whereas most of the athletes in linear paths (five out of six) had a
very strong and almost one-dimensional athletic identity focused
Voluntary termination only in their results as athletes “I think that I'll be always sailing. I
don't know if competing or not, but sailing. It is my world, I always
In the prospective interviews all athletes expressed the belief lived in it, I like it and I will not leave it. I need the sea” (A2P).
that in the future they would be able to choose their moment or In the retrospective interviews athletes with multiple personal
period for retirement. It was expressed by athletes in parallel and identities (n ¼ 10) reported easier transitions and adaptation pro-
convergent trajectories (60% of the sample). “When I'll see that this cesses. This was true, even in those cases when what was planned
is not good for me I'll knock on another door, I'll have another job” did not always happen in the end. “What I did ok was to study,
(A6P), as well as by athletes in linear trajectories (40% of the sam- regardless of the fact that I'm not working in what I studied. In this
ple) “While I have competitive life I'll try to keep competing [ … ] way if I would not be working at the federation, I could be working
my intention is to keep living from sport. We will see at what level, in any other thing” (A5R). On the other hand, athletes in linear
in the ministry of sports or any interesting thing” (A8P). In the trajectories and with a one-dimensional identity reported more
retrospective accounts voluntary termination had become true for difficulties and a lack of security in the transition period “When you
those athletes in parallel and convergent trajectories that had are in this world you are in a bubble in which you feel safe, if you
planned retirement in advance. The same athlete expressed “I have to get out you feel insecure” (A2R).
stayed because I wanted and I left when I wanted to. It is similar to
changing a job. It is not that I was fed-up but the benefit was not Availability of social support
enough, so I left and I left happy” (A6R). This was less true for most
of the athletes (five out of six) in linear trajectories “I left Olympic Athletes in parallel and convergent trajectories (n ¼ 9) reported
competition because this man [the Federation Chair] did not allow in the prospective interviews that they perceived social support
54 M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56

available at different levels. For example, a male from a team sport parallel and convergent trajectories perceived a high degree of
expressed “It was easy to find a job because here all people from our social support in the prospective views. This was confirmed in the
sport are like a family. We all know each other, and I had people in retrospective interviews, referring to both during and after retire-
the club that offered me a job and I started working in a printing ment from elite competition. These athletes showed a sense of
office” (A13P). However, those athletes in linear trajectories, not autonomy in decision making during the prospective interviews
planning for retirement and with a one-dimensional athletic and reported a lack of severe problems related to the transition
identity (n ¼ 4) reported in the prospective interviews the lack of during and after retirement from elite sport.
social support available “My parents are 3000 km away, we keep In contrast, most of the athletes following linear trajectories in
contact on the phone, I don't have a partner nowadays [ … ] and my sport (n ¼ 6), reported a lack of retirement planning in the pro-
friends are those from the sport world” (A8P). spective interviews and multiple possibilities which were poorly
In the retrospective interviews most of the athletes in parallel defined, and focused only in sport. In the retrospective interviews
and convergent trajectories (eight out of nine) reported a high they acknowledge a late awareness and consciousness of the need
perception of social support available both during and after the for planning retirement that made the transition slow and very
transition “I feel very comfortable in public relations. If I can give a difficult. Voluntary termination was also a strong belief for those
hand I always think about it, and if someone offers something I athletes. But they admitted in the retrospective interviews that in
always listen and then I evaluate its viability” (A13R). On the other their situation the voluntariness was not real in the end, in one case
hand the athletes in linear trajectories with one-dimensional ath- because of an injury, and in all other cases due to the lack of al-
letic identity (n ¼ 5) perceived a lack of social support and in some ternatives to elite sport. Athletes in linear trajectories perceived a
cases (n ¼ 2) other derived problems such as alcohol or drug abuse lack of social support in the prospective interviews that made them
“I feel that I've passed a period of loneliness in family, sporting, and feel alone trying to cope with everything. This recognition of lack of
other matters [ … ] in the last months I went to bed after six drinks social support was confirmed during and after retirement and re-
every other day and three years ago it was everyday” (A8R). ported in the retrospective interviews. Finally, during the pro-
spective interviews athletes following linear trajectories reported
Active coping strategies reactive coping strategies and a sense of being always behind.
Those athletes reported more difficulties than their colleagues
Referring to active coping strategies, in the prospective in- following dual careers and in some cases (n ¼ 2) severe adaptation
terviews, some athletes in parallel and convergent trajectories problems during and after retirement from competitive sport. In
(n ¼ 7) reported a sense of autonomy in decision making and a general, although the type of trajectory (i.e., linear, convergent and
balance between different life spheres (i.e., sport, family, work/ parallel) is related to the way in which the athletes experience
studies) “For my professional future my nine years working helped retirement from sport, being typically easier for those following
me a lot. I think that this is very important” (A11P). On the other dual career (i.e., convergent and parallel trajectories), this is not
hand, athletes in linear trajectories (n ¼ 6) reported the use of always the case. While showing trends our qualitative methodol-
reactive coping strategies. Decisions were made ad hoc when ogy allowed us to pick up specific cases which did not follow the
events happened, rather than being premeditated. “I'm studying general pattern. We found an athlete following a convergent tra-
but I don't know if I will finish. If I don't I'll ring the bell and ask if jectory, having been forced by circumstances and not convinced,
they have something to offer me, and I'll decide if I want what they who had a very diffuse image of retirement in the prospective
offer me” (A12P). In the follow-up retrospective interviews athletes interview. This individual had severe problems during and after
in convergent and parallel paths that previously reported active retirement. “I asked to work only part time to be able to train better
coping strategies, reported less adaptation problems during and [ … ] although my dream would be to be able to live only on sport
after the retirement process both in personal and professional sit- and not to worry about other issues” (A3P); “You hit rock bottom, I
uations “When I was 24 I started working while playing. While didn't expect it, because I thought I had my life solved with my
others went to the beach or to rest I put on my tie and went to studies and everything [ … ] when you face it you feel disoriented”
work” (A11R). On the other hand, athletes in linear trajectories who (A3R). On the other hand, one of the athletes following a linear
described reactive coping strategies in the prospective interviews trajectory reported an accurate image of retirement in the pro-
reported severe adaptation problems both at personal and profes- spective interview. With multiple personal identities he had an
sional levels during and following the retirement moment. “I could easy and fast transition to an alternative career “I miss very much
have taken advantage of the transition moment to study something my hometown, when I will retire I don't want to move every year.
or work, but I was personally bad, hooked on alcohol and drugs and We had a daughter this year and I don't want a nomad life. If it is
I changed the national team for wild parties all summer” (A12R). possible I would like to coach children in a team in my hometown”
(A14P); “The year after retirement I started coaching. Now I am a
Synthesis and specificity of results coach in third division and I don't want to go anywhere, I had offers
to move to better teams but I'm very happy here with my wife and
Table 3 shows a synthesis of the results based on the themes the children. I'm very comfortable in my hometown “(A14R).
identified as a result of the thematic analysis. Athletes in parallel
and convergent trajectories (n ¼ 9) were aware and conscious of Discussion
the importance of retirement planning and offered some possibil-
ities richly described in the prospective interviews. In the retro- This qualitative longitudinal study shows that athletes that
spective accounts they acknowledge retirement planning as a key followed dual careers (including convergent and parallel trajec-
aspect that made transition faster and easier in most cases. tories) shared a profile characterized by retirement planning,
Voluntary termination was a strong belief in the prospective in- voluntary retirement, multiple personal identities, availability of
terviews that became true in the retrospective interviews, except social support and active coping strategies. These factors tended to
for one athlete having to retire due to an injury. They showed facilitate the process of retirement from elite sport and the tran-
several personal identities in the prospective interviews that sition to an alternative professional career. On the contrary, athletes
facilitated transition and opened up different possibilities, some that followed linear trajectories showed a pattern of lack of
expected and some unexpected. Most of the athletes (n ¼ 8) in retirement planning, involuntary termination, one-dimensional
M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56 55

Table 3
Defined themes derived from the thematic analysis.

Theme name Parallel/convergent trajectories Linear trajectory

Prospective interview Retrospective interview Prospective interview Retrospective interview

Retirement Awareness and consciousness Key aspect Lack of planning Late awareness and
planning Some possibilities richly Made the transition fast and not very difficult Multiple possibilities poorly consciousness
defined defined and only focused Made transition slow and
in sport very difficult
Voluntary Strong belief Became true in most cases Strong belief It was not real due to the lack
termination of alternatives
Multiple personal Several personal identities Facilitated transition and opened different possibilities Single personal identity as Made the transition much
identities athlete more difficult
Availability of Strong perception of social Social support confirmed during and after retirement Lack of social support Lack of social support
social support support perceived confirmed during and after
retirement
Active coping Sense of autonomy in Lack of severe problems related to the transition Reactive coping strategies Severe adaptation problems
strategies decision making during and after retirement from sport sense of being always behind during and after retirement
from sport

athletic identity, lack of social support and reactive coping strate- the prospective interviews. The retrospective interviews with the
gies which made this transition more difficult. same athletes confirmed that their initial view bore close resem-
In the prospective interviews of athletes that followed dual ca- blance to reality, for most of the athletes following convergent and
reers we observed a pattern of awareness and consciousness of parallel trajectories. However, we evidenced that the prospective
retirement planning, a strong belief in voluntary termination, view of retirement was less accurate and quite distant to what
several personal identities, a strong perception of social support, happened later for most of the athletes following linear trajectories.
and a sense of autonomy in decision making. This pattern and the Inviting participants to provide their thoughts and views related
expectations that derive from it, were confirmed in the retrospec- to retirement from elite sport before, and a considerable time after
tive interviews with the same athletes. On the other hand in the taking this step provides valuable accounts from athletes regarding
prospective interviews of elite athletes in linear trajectories we the process experienced and does not merely give a snapshot of a
typically found a lack of retirement planning, a strong belief in a moment or only a retrospective report of a process. Thus, the use of
voluntary termination, a one-dimensional personal identity as an a qualitative longitudinal study as proposed by Epstein (2002) gives
athlete, a lack of perceived social support, and a reactive coping a more complete view of career transition and retirement, over-
style that gave them a sense of being always behind external coming one of the limitations in knowledge in the field highlighted
events. In the post-retirement interviews we found evidence that by Park, Lavallee, et al. (2012).
the unrealistic expectations of these athletes were not met. Nevertheless, this study also has constraints that should be
Specifically, related to this congruence between the prospective mentioned. First, the sample of participants comprised a very
and retrospective interviews, we have found that athletes following specific group of elite Olympic athletes competing in Summer
dual careers (i.e., parallel and convergent trajectories) were more Olympic Games, some of them winning medals and having very
accurate in anticipating the complexities of the retirement process. successful sporting careers. Thus, the generalization of the results is
In contrast, those in linear trajectories were less realistic about their limited. Second, the qualitative longitudinal study was based only
ability to cope with retirement. As dual career athletes had devel- on two interviews in a ten years period. Although different authors
oped different identities they had more resources to deal with non- (e.g., Epstein, 2002) indicated that this is enough for qualitative
athletic spheres. On the other hand, athletes on linear trajectories longitudinal designs, we think that at least a third interview would
only felt comfortable in the athletic domain and at the moment of improve the quality of the data obtained. This third interview could
retirement used poor coping strategies such as avoidance or denial. be planned in a time frame (i.e., five years after the first one) or even
In our results we have found examples of loss of athletic identity as better on a conceptual frame (i.e., during actual retirement stage).
anticipated by previous studies (Park, Lavallee, & Tod, 2012). And in For further studies, it would be interesting to complement the
some cases problems of substance abuse like those reported by qualitative results of this study with quantitative data on motiva-
McPherson (1980). tion, basic needs satisfaction, coping strategies and other psycho-
Our results confirm the findings in the review by Stambulova logical variables from a point of view which allows a holistic and
et al. (2009) referring to multi-causality of career termination, developmental perspective on the pre-retirement career stages
great inter-individual differences in the reactions to retirement, which athletes will face (e.g., Wylleman, Reints, & De Knop, 2013).
and the need of some athletes for psychological assessment. As It would be also interesting to use theoretical frameworks from
shown in this study, encouraging dual careers can help to minimize other fields of psychology as Park, Tod et al. (2012) have done,
the proportion of athletes needing psychological support. Retire- applying the trans-theoretical model to career termination, to
ment planning, voluntary termination, multiple personal identities, career transition in general and dual careers in particular.
the availability of social support and active coping strategies make In summary, from this qualitative longitudinal study we
the transition to an alternative professional career easier, especially conclude that promoting dual careers and working on the pro-
for athletes in parallel and convergent trajectories. However, not spective view of retirement can facilitate retirement from elite
taking into account all these dimensions makes retirement more sport and the transition to an alternative professional career.
difficult particularly for those athletes following linear trajectories.
Torregrosa et al. (2004) proposed that active athletes had a view Authors note
of retirement that became clearer and more accurate as they were
aging and advancing in their sporting career. The present study This research was supported in part by grant Ministerio de
adds new information and checks the accurateness of the view in n (DEP2010-15561).
Ciencia e Innovacio
56 M. Torregrosa et al. / Psychology of Sport and Exercise 21 (2015) 50e56

Acknowledgments McPherson, B. P. (1980). Retirement from professional sport: the process and
problems of occupational and psychological adjustment. Sociological Sympo-
sium, 30, 126e143.
Andrea Perez collaborated in data collection and transcription. Mihovilovic, M. (1968). The status of former sportsmen. International Review of
Rosemary Thwaite provided language help in writing this article. Sport Psychology, 3, 73e93.
s, S., Azo
Pallare  car, F., Torregrosa, M., Selva, C., & Ramis, Y. (2011). Modelos de
The authors want to thank their collaboration.
trayectoria deportiva en waterpolo y su implicacio n en la transicio
n hacia una
carrera profesional alternativa [Athletic Career Models in Water Polo and their
References Involvement in the Transition to an Alternative Career]. Cultura, Ciencia y
Deporte, 6, 93e103. http://dx.doi.org/10.12800/ccd.v6i17.36.
Azocar, F., Perez, A., Pallare
s, S., & Torregrosa, M. (2013). Foreign football players Park, S., Lavallee, D., & Tod, D. (2012a). Athletes' career transition out of sport: a
adaptation to Spanish leagues: untangling non-normative transitions. In systematic review. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 6,
M. Torregrosa, & A. Vilanova (Eds.), Transitions and strategies in top level sport. 22e53. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2012.687053.
Symposium conducted at the XVIII ECSS Annual Congress of European College of Park, S., Tod, D., & Lavallee, D. (2012b). Exploring the retirement from sport
Sport Science, Barcelona, Spain. decision-making process based on the transtheoretical model. Psychology of
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Sport and Exercise, 13, 444e453. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Research in Psychology, 3, 77e101. http://dx.doi.org/10.1191/ j.psychsport.2012.02.003.
1478088706qp063oa. Sparkes, A. C., & Smith, B. (2014). Qualitative research methods in sport, exercise and
Douglas, K., & Carless, D. (2009). Abandoning the performance narrative: two health. From process to product. Abingdon: Routledge.
women's stories of transition from professional sport. Journal of Applied Psy- Stambulova, N., Alfermann, D., Statler, T., & Co ^te
, J. (2009). ISSP Position stand:
chology, 21, 213e230. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10413200902795109. career development and transitions of athletes. International Journal of Sport
Epstein, T. S. (2002). Mysore villages revisited. In R. V. Kemper, & A. P. Royce (Eds.), and Exercise Psychology, 7, 395e412. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/
Chronicling cultures: Long-term field research in anthropology (pp. 59e80). 1612197X.2009.9671916.
Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira. Torregrosa, M., Boixado s, M., Valiente, L., & Cruz, J. (2004). Elite athletes' image of
EU Expert Group. (2012). EU guidelines on dual careers of athletes. Brussels. retirement: the way to relocation in sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5,
Gordon, T., & Lahelma, E. (2003). From ethnography to life history: tracing transi- 35e43. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1469-0292(02)00052-3.
tions of school students. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 6, USOC. (2012). Athlete career, education and life skills working group (pp. 1e26).
245e254. Wylleman, P., Reints, A., & De Knop, P. (2013). A developmental and holistic
Kuhn, T., & Witzel, A. (2000). School-to-work transition, career development and perspective on athletic career development. In P. Sotiaradou, & V. De Bosscher
family planning e methodological challenges and guidelines of a qualitative (Eds.), Managing high performance sport (pp. 159e182). New York, NY:
longitudinal panel study, Forum. Qualitative Social Research, 1(2). http://www. Routledge.
qualitative-research.net/index.php/fqs/article/view/1086/2376. Wylleman, P., Rosier, N., & De Knop, P. (2015). Transitional challenges and elite
Maxwell, J. A. (2002). Understanding and validity in qualitative research. In athletes' mental health. In J. Baker, P. Safai, & J. Fraser-Thomas (Eds.), Health and
A. M. Huberman, & M. B. Miles (Eds.), The qualitative researcher's companion (pp. elite sport. Is high performance sport a healthy pursuit? (pp. 99e116). Oxon, UK:
37e63). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Routledge.

You might also like