Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Christianity began as a renewal movement within Judaism that sought to encompass Judaism.Yet it
did not initially define itself over and against Judaism as it’s opposite. It did no seemingly reject
Judaism and its entire tenets. Christianity, as it would later become, was originally a positive
movement within Judaism1. This movement began with Jesus Christ. His followers remembered
much about that brief period and facts about him can be recovered by a close study of the gospels
and of the historical background. However, as a strong movement in the history of the world,
Christianity took off only after his (Jesus) death and then it had to survive great hostility.
According to the history, there were several sects in the Jewish religion. Some of them include:
Pharisees, Sadducees, and Zealots but also other less influential sects, including the Essenes. The
first century BC and first century AD saw a growing number of charismatic religious leaders
contributing to what would become the Mishnah of Rabbinic Judaism. A central concern in 1st
century Judaism was the covenant with God, and the status of the Jews as the chosen people of
God. Many Jews believed that this covenant would be renewed with the coming of the Messiah.
1
David L. E. (1997), Christianity the first Two Thousand Years (London, Cassell Wellington House)
Page1.
2
Sanders E.P. et.al (1998) Jesus and Judaism and The Historical Figure of Jesus. (Duke University).
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jesus// retrieved 5/12/2020.
1
than one year, during which he attracted considerable attention. Sometime between AD 29 and AD
30, he went to observe Passover in Jerusalem, where his entrance, according to the Gospels, was
triumphant and infused with eschatological significance. While there he was arrested, tried, and
executed. The most certain and well attested fact about Jesus of Nazareth is that he was tried,
sentenced and executed by the Roman procurator Pontius Pilate on a charge of high treason. This
does not make him unique. Many thousands of Jewish rebels and revolutionaries were crucified by
the Roman rulers of Palestine during this era. The Jews on the whole were opposed to Roman rule,
and some of them, as we have seen, were intent upon overthrowing the Romans and restoring the
kingdom of Israel. Jesus was found guilty of being involved in some such conspiracy and,
moreover, of claiming to be the rightful king of the Jews, the heir to the throne, or what the Jews
would have called the Messiah.3 According to his disciples, he resurrected and they very much
convinced that he still lived and had appeared to them (Jn. 20:19-30). They converted others to
belief in him, which eventually led to a new religion, Christianity.
In fact, Jesus was capable as the advancement in the historical backdrop of humankind. He rose
above all that had ever been said also, done previously. He was all around a definitive, the last
word. He was on a standard with God. His statement was God’s assertion. His Soul was God’s
Spirit. His emotions were God’s sentiments. What he represented was actually equivalent to a big
motivator for God. No higher assessment was possible. To trust in Jesus today is to concur with
this evaluation of him.
3
Albert N. (1976), Jesus before Christianity (South Africa, David Philip, Publisher (Pty) Ltd) Pg 113.
2
monotheism. Some of the passages in the Hebrew Bible quoted by the Christians depended on the
Septuagint, a translation into Greek which was to be replaced by a more accurate version. 4
Insofar as they began to separate or be separated from Judaism, which did not accept Jesus as the
Messiah, the earliest Christians expressed certain ideas about the one on whom their faith focused.
As with other religious people, they became involved in an exceedingly way looking for truth.
God, within the very nature of things, was necessarily the ultimate truth. In a reference preserved
within the Gospel consistent with John, however, Jesus refers to himself not only as “the way” and
“the life” but also as “the truth” (Jn 14: 16).This is exactly what he replied to Thomas when he
claimed of not knowing Christ. From the start there have been Christians who might not have seen
Jesus as being the truth or as a singular participant within the reality of God.
6
Ehrman, B.D (2012) Christianity in the 1st century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki// retrieved
11/12/2020.
4
As earlier affirmed Christianity began as a movement within Judaism at a period when the Jews
had long been dominated culturally and politically by foreign powers and had found in their
religion (rather than in their politics or cultural achievements) the linchpin of their community.
Jesus did not found an organization; he inspired a movement. It was inevitable that the movement
would quite soon become an organization but in the beginning there were simply people, scattered
individuals and groups, who had been inspired by Jesus. There were the twelve, the women, his
family (Mary, James, Jude), many of the poor and the oppressed who had been put on their feet by
him; there were disciples in Galilee and disciples in Jericho (e.g., Zacchaeus) and Jerusalem (e.g.,
Joseph of Arimathaea and Nicodemus) (Acts 6:7; 15:5). There were Greek speaking Jews like the
seven Hellenists who were inspired by what they had heard about him (Acts 6:1-6) there were even
Pharisees and priests who joined the community that had been formed in Jerusalem.
In Jesus’ earthly mission, he ministered to the spiritually and physically hurting people of Israel
(and nearby regions).He promoted a purist, personal faith based upon absolute love of God and
neighbor, and he challenged the corruption/oppression of the political and religious elite. Socially,
this led to controversy and conflict with the ruling powers in Jerusalem, Judea, and Roman
demesnes. Eventually, Jesus was arrested, tried, and convicted by the Sanhedrin under Caiaphas,
the Jewish High Priest, and for treason in the Roman courts under Pontius Pilate, the Roman
governor of Judea (although Jesus’ Jewish enemies wanted him convicted of blasphemy).
Jesus’ teaching began to manifest following his words as recorded in the gospel “Go therefore and
make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the
Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I commanded you; and lo, I am with you always,
even to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:19–20). Consequently, the followers of Jesus began
sharing the good news of the resurrected Messiah.
7
Leonel L. M. (1977), The Meaning of Ritual, (Harissburg, Morehouse Publishing), Pg. 39.
8
Catechism of the Catholic Church (2013), The Revised Edition. (Ibadan, St. Paul Publication)
n.1096.
9
Will, H. (1953) Judaism and Christianity: Their Unity and Difference. Vol. 21, No. 2 (Apr., 1953),
(Published By: Oxford University Press) pp. 67-78
6
Furthermore, the two religions see man as a unitary, self transcending, dynamic, responsive, and
responsible creature, in contrast to both the mystical idealists and naturalist views of man.
Still based on the similarities and differences of the both religion, they see man as original in order
of creation ordained to God and therefore at one with world and himself. They both see this primal
harmony upset and all creation “spoiled” by man’s sin which essentially self-will in rebellion
against God, the idolatrous diversion of ultimate allegiance from God to something that is not God.
Christianity’s center of attention is found on “The Original Sin” which is the sin that was
committed by Adam and Eve while they were in the Garden of Eden and continues on from that
generation to this generation we are living today .While Judaism’s center of attention on “Sin”
connotes the continuous sins committed after a person is born, thus proving that at birth a person is
with no sin. This divergence of doctrine is seen in both religions’ interpretation of the fall.
According to the Christian perspective, when Adam and Eve sinned, the glory of God in them was
taken away, thus making the whole creation perverted (Gen 3:19.). While in Judaism, when Adam
and Eve sinned, God made them to suffer the consequences by only chasing them out of the
Garden of Eden but never meant that sin will follow their forthcoming generation (Gen 3: 23).
Christianity’s element of redemption that is meant to return the glory of God which was lost after
Adam and Eve sinned in the garden of Eden is only through Jesus Christ who is claimed to be God
in the flesh and a part of the Holy trinity, cleanses the sins of the whole world for those who accept
this redemption. The Judaism element of redemption is done through prayer which cleanses the sin
impartially, and full cleansing is done after they ask for forgiveness from the people.
According to Jews, Jesus was just a good man and was not reincarnation of God into mankind. He
has no powers to save souls as Christians perceive and believe it to be. Again he never resurrected
from the dead. Judaism has never approved Jesus as the Prince of Peace and the Messiah. They
claim that the Prince of Peace shall rule the world later and peace shall dominate this whole world.
Christianity believes Jesus as the Prince of peace and the promised Messiah and all who accept this
divinity have peace in their minds and souls.10
Furthermore, Judaism continues to state that God is one. God cannot be made of three parts which
are termed as the Holy trinity as Christians profess. They claim that this can be compared to
pagans who worship many gods and that the capacity of claiming that God is in three parts
diminishes the preeminence of his power. Therefore, it has no room for Jesus ascribing a position
10
UK Essays (2018). Similarities Between Judaism And Christianity Religion Essay.
https://www.ukessays.com// retrieved from 28/11/20.
7
of being God the Son. This is opposed by Christianity since according to the Bible which claims
that “In the beginning there was the word, and the word was with God and the word was God. The
word became flesh and dwelt among us in this world” (John 1:1, 14). As much as there are
differences and similarities, only time can tell since Christianity is based on faith. There is no
religion that can be placed above the other.
11
Richard A.H. (2009) Early Christian movements: Jesus movements and the renewal of Israel, (USA;
University of Massachusetts, Boston) n. 3
8
Finally, it very difficult to say that, the very existence of similarities merely exacerbated the
conflict. For the Christians, the similarities were further proof that they were the fulfillment of
everything that was valid in the “Old Covenant,” and that the Jews preserved nothing but an empty
shell, a degenerate and corrupt form of a misunderstood reality. For the Jews it became impossible
to see the Christians as merely a strange and completely alien religion, since they appeared as
claimants to the Israelite heritage, bent on dispossessing the Jewish people of the validity and
authenticity of its religious existence. In due course the Jewish Christians were included in the
category of those sectarians whom the Jewish community rejected and anathematized. Hence, the
New Testament describes Jesus as engaged in violent polemics against the “Scribes and
Pharisees,” and especially against the interpretation of Torah and Judaism which they represented.
REFERENCES
Albert N. (1976), Jesus before Christianity. South Africa, David Philip, Publisher (Pty) Ltd.
Catechism of the Catholic Church (2013), The Revised Edition. Ibadan, St. Paul Publication.
9
David L. E. (1997), Christianity the first Two Thousand Years. London, Cassell Wellington
House.
Ehrman, B.D. (2012) Christianity in the 1st century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki// retrieved
11/12/2020.
Leonel L. M. (1977), The Meaning of Ritual, Harissburg, Morehouse Publishing.
Omoregbe, J. (1999), Comparative Religion: Christianity and other World Religions in Dialogue,
Lagos: Joja Press Ltd
Richard A.H. (2009) Early Christian movements: Jesus movements and the renewal of Israel, on
Theological Studies 62(4) 10.4102/hts.v62i4.410 USA; University of Massachusetts.
Rodney S. (1997), The Rise of Christianity. Harper San Francisco, Princeton University Press.
Sanders E.P. et.al (1998)Author of Jesus and Judaism and The Historical Figure of Jesus. Duke
University. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jesus// retrieved 5/12/20200.
The New Community Bible, (2015), Second Edition for Africa. Ibadan, St. Paul Publication.
UK Essays (2018). Similarities Between Judaism And Christianity Religion Essay.
https://www.ukessays.com// retrieved from 28/11/20.
Will, H. (1953) Judaism and Christianity: Their Unity and Difference. Vol. 21, No. 2 (Apr., 1953),
Published By: Oxford University Press
10