Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Stephanie M. Llop & George N. Papaliodis (2018) Cataract Surgery
Complications in Uveitis Patients: A Review Article, Seminars in Ophthalmology, 33:1, 64-69, DOI:
10.1080/08820538.2017.1353815
Uveitis and Ocular Immunology Service, Department of Ophthalmology, Massachusetts Eye and Ear, Harvard
Medical School, Boston, MA, USA
ABSTRACT
Uveitis is a leading causes of blindness worldwide, and the development of cataracts is common due to both the
presence of intraocular inflammation and the most commonly employed treatment with corticosteroids. The
management of these cataracts can be very challenging and often requires additional procedures that can
compromise surgical results. The underlying disease affects a relatively young population at higher risk of
complications. Preoperative control of inflammation/quiescent disease for at least three months is generally
accepted as the minimum amount of time prior to surgical intervention. Phacoemulsification with intraocular
lens is the preferred method for surgery, with some studies showing improvement in visual acuity in over 90% of
patients. The most common postoperative complications include macular edema, posterior capsule opacification,
recurrent or persistent inflammation, glaucoma, epiretinal membrane and IOL deposits, or dislocation. Despite
the potential complications, cataract surgery in uveitis patients is considered a safe and successful procedure.
Keywords: Cataracta complicata, cataract complications, cataract extraction, phacoemulsificationuveitis
Correspondence: George N. Papaliodis, M.D., 243 Charles St., Boston, MA 02114, USA. E-mail: george_papaliodis@meei.harvard.edu
64
Cataract Surgery Complications in Uveitis Patients 65
Type of Surgery: Phacoemulsification vs. Small had a slightly lower incidence of cystoid macular
Incision Cataract Surgery (SICS) edema and persistent uveitis.22 Many factors play a
role in the development of macular edema; this
One reason it is difficult to compare previous studies is makes it difficult to compare studies and accounts for
because of older surgical techniques compared to such a large variability in the published data. The
modern phacoemulsification surgery. A study by etiology of the uveitis has a big impact on the risk of
Suresh et al. performed phacoemulsification via either developing postoperative macular edema, being more
a 5.5 mm scleral tunnel, or a 3.2 mm clear cornea prevalent in intermediate uveitis and very rare in her-
approach with IOL insertion and an overall immediate petic infections. This is shown, for example, in studies
improvement of two or more lines of Snellen VA was specifically on patients with pars planitis, where post-
seen in 91% of the eyes and maintained until the latest operative macular edema has a higher impact, affect-
follow-up in 87% of cases.18 In another study of 242 ing up to half of the cases, related to a higher
eyes with uveitis that underwent phacoemulsification preoperative incidence of CME.5 The preoperative con-
surgery, 59.9% of eyes had a visual acuity of 20/40 or trol of inflammation is key in predicting recurrent
better by their last postoperative visit; 68.18% had inflammation after cataract surgery and, consequently,
anterior uveitis, 7% intermediate, 7% posterior, and the development of macular edema. Bhargava et al.
17.76% panuveitis.23 Ram et al. found improvement showed that there was a statistically significant reduc-
in 91.6% of patients after phacoemulsification.24 tion in the rate of macular edema in patients preopera-
Estafanous et al. reported 87% of patients with visual tively treated with oral corticosteroids (P < 0.001).9 In a
acuity of 20/40 or better.19 A study that compared study of patients with JIA, all eyes had chronic ante-
phacoemulsification versus small incision cataract sur- rior uveitis (45 inflamed eyes) at the time of cataract
gery (SICS—a form of extracapsular cataract extrac- surgery; despite ongoing immunosuppressive therapy,
tion) showed comparable results with corrected 44% developed CME.28 Eventually, chronic macular
distance visual acuity (CDVA) of 20/60 or better in edema can result in atrophic macular changes that
90.0% of patients who had phacoemulsification versus could affect vision permanently.14
88.3% in the SICS group.22 Data from Hazari et al.
comparing extracapsular cataract extraction (ECCE),
ECCE with posterior capsule intraocular lens Posterior Capsular Opacification (PCO)
(PCIOL), and phacoemulsification with PCIOL in uvei-
tis patients showed no statistically significant differ- Another common complication after cataract surgery
ence in the visual acuity at six months between the is posterior capsule opacification, leading to symptoms
three groups.3 These facts seem to be irrelevant in our of glare or blurred vision, reduced visual acuity, or
modern era of advanced phacoemulsification, but, impaired posterior segment exam.20 Some studies
unfortunately, there are still countries that do not would consider PCO as clinically significant if it
have open access to this technology. requires yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) capsulot-
omy. The incidence of PCO varies among studies, in
part due to the definition given or criteria for diagno-
COMPLICATIONS sis. Factors that are critical in the development of PCO
include surgical technique, and preoperative/post-
Cystoid Macular Edema operative control of uveitis; it is more likely to occur
in eyes with persistent inflammatory activity.10 Kosker
Cystoid macular edema (CME) is the most common et al. had the lowest PCO rate of 12.7% in a study that
complication of cataract surgery in the general popula- only included quiet eyes (at least three months prior to
tion. Because of the different definitions and diagnostic surgery) with a diagnosis of anterior uveitis,21
criteria, the incidence has been reported to be between although Okhravi et al. reported that the prevalence
1% and 30%, with 1%–2% of patients having no risk is higher in patients with anterior uveitis compared to
factors. Although, in most cases, the macular edema is posterior.10 Hazari et al. reported PCO in 14.92%3 of
self-limited, in rare cases it can lead to long-term visual patients; Bhargava et al. in 16.67%9 of eyes that under-
deterioration that is difficult to treat.25 went SICS, and comparing SICS vs phacoemulsifica-
In patients with uveitis undergoing cataract sur- tion, the incidence was 15% vs 16.7% respectively. In
gery, the reported incidence ranges from 2% by both groups, YAG laser capsulotomy was performed
Suresh et al. to 33% by Estafanous et al. following in 20 eyes (15.9%) after a quiet postoperative period of
phacoemulsification.3,4,6,9,14–20,24,26 Severe uveitis was three months.22 In one of these studies in patients who
associated with an increased incidence of macular had SICS, there was no statistically significant correla-
edema. One study published a prevalence of up to tion between PCO and increased postoperative inflam-
56% of CME when longer follow-up was observed mation (P > 0.05).9 In a large cohort of 242 eyes by
(mean 81.4 months).27 Comparing phacoemulsification Yamane et al., PCO was documented in 19% of
vs. SICS, patients in the phacoemulsification group patients after phacoemulsification.23 PCO requiring
YAG laser capsulotomy was reported in 18.3% by eyes that underwent phacoemulsification and PCIOL
Yoeruek et al.,16 28.70% eyes by Ram et al.,24 and in implantation were associated with significantly lower
31% of eyes by Estafanous et al.19 Other studies have a incidence of increase inflammation (chi-square test;
higher incidence, ranging from 37.5% to 58% of eyes, P = 0.047).3 Bhargava et al. found a rate of persistent
including a study with 42.3% PCO in patients who uveitis in 16.7% of patients who underwent SICS vs.
only had intermediate uveitis.4,13,15,27 13.6% after phacoemulsification.22 Studies exclusively
When comparing IOL materials (polymethyl metha- on phacoemulsification in uveitis patients report an
crylate [PMMA], silicone and acrylic), PCO after sur- incidence of 21.8% by Elgohary et al.20 and 30.16%
gery occurred in 23.7% of eyes, but significantly less by Yamane et al.23 Abela-Formanek et al. showed
frequently in patients with an acrylic IOL than in that there were no significant differences in inflamma-
patients with IOLs of other materials (P < .001).6 tion after implantation of foldable IOLs in uveitic eyes
Suresh et al. compared PMMA, heparin surface- (foldable hydrophilic acrylic, hydrophobic acrylic or
modified and acrylic IOLs, and PCO was seen in silicone).29
53%, 45%, and 24%, respectively.18 Lower rates were
seen in patients who were given systemic corticoster-
oids preoperatively.20 PMMA lenses have demon- Epiretinal Membrane
strated the highest incidence of associated PCO in
normal eyes, so their use is not recommended in Epiretinal membrane is another complication after cat-
patients with uveitis who are predisposed to increased aract extraction in uveitic patients. The etiology of the
inflammation.10 A study by Elgohary et al. using a Cox uveitis and the diagnostic modality (clinical exam vs.
multivariate regression model revealed that YAG cap- use of OCT) may explain the large variability in the
sulotomy was required at a higher rate in patients who incidence of this complication, which ranges between
had hydrogel IOLs and in patients <55 years old.20 4.47% and 56%.3,9,16,19,20,22,23,27
Fogla et al. also described a higher prevalence of
PCO in younger patients <40 years old.15 In a recent
study of cataract surgery in pediatric uveitis (mean age Glaucoma
10.9 years), the percent of PCO was 15/21 eyes or
71%.26 The coexistence of uveitis and ocular hypertension is
common, and previous studies have found that
increased IOP leads to glaucoma in 9–20% of
Recurrent or Persistent Inflammation patients.30 It is then expected that postoperative devel-
opment of persistently elevated IOP is another com-
Some authors clinically define postoperative uveitis as mon complication of cataract surgery. There are many
any inflammatory episode within three months after etiologies for uveitis and some are inherently more
surgery that required additional intensive antiinflam- associated with glaucoma than others.
matory (topical or systemic) or immunosuppressive Older studies, including a review of the published
treatment in the presence of anterior chamber flare data on Fuchs heterochromic iridocyclitis (FHI),
and/or cells. Studies with lower recurrence of uveitis reported that the incidence of glaucoma ranges from
have stricter preoperative steroid application and, in 10% to 32% in the years prior to modern phacoemulsi-
some cases, additional immunosuppressive fication surgery. This particular subset of patients with
treatment.16 As little as 8.3% of patients developing FHI also have a higher frequency of hyphema;5 Suresh
recurrent inflammation has been reported, but a very et al. observed the Amsler’s sign in 20/34 eyes with
short follow-up period is noticed in that study FHI.18 Studies in juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA)
(4–8 weeks postsurgery).16 Other studies have shown patients show that eyes with active inflammation
an incidence of 12.5% in one month,4 approximately developed secondary glaucoma in 50% of cases.28 In
13% in six months,6,21 and 30% recurrence in the Fox et al. group, 3/16 eyes with glaucoma preo-
12 months.11 When longer follow-up is provided, the peratively developed loss of visual acuity postopera-
true incidence might be higher, as suggested by the tively because of complications of chronic glaucoma.31
findings of Krishna et al., where 53% of eyes devel- A raise in IOP is usually followed by complete
oped clinically significant recurrence or exacerbation resolution, but sometimes a reasonable number of
of inflammation.27 In those with anterior disease, patients require glaucoma surgery. In a study by
severe uveitis in the first week postoperatively was Yoeruek et al., a rise in IOP occurred in 41 eyes
found to be associated with an increased incidence of (22.8%), but 19 of these eyes had borderline pressure
macular edema, and visual acuity less than 6/12 at before cataract surgery. Of these, 2.2% (four eyes)
six months’ follow-up.10,13 required glaucoma surgery.16 Similarly, Okhravi et al.
When comparing ECCE with ECCE + PCIOL, there reported 13.3% eyes (12 of 90 eyes) with raised IOP
was no statistically significant difference in postopera- and two required surgery. Findings were similar for
tive inflammation, noted in 27.4% of eyes. However, phacoemulsification and SICS.22
Seminars in Ophthalmology
Cataract Surgery Complications in Uveitis Patients 67
Low IOP or hypotony is an uncommon complication Other complications that occur less frequently but
after cataract extraction. Older studies on patient have been reported include corneal edema, corneal
with JRA showed higher incidence of hypotony scars, corneal neovascularization, corneal perforation,
that is mostly seen in the immediate postoperative band keratopathy, iris atrophy, anterior synechia, pos-
period. Possible explanations include cyclitic mem- terior synechia, rubeosis, hypopyon, anterior capsular
branes, ciliary body detachments, or severe opacities, IOL explantation, IOL capture, vitreous opa-
inflammation.5 cities, vitreous hemorrhages, macular holes, optic disc
edema, optic disc atrophy, retinal detachments, chor-
oidal detachments, enucleation, evisceration, and
IOL Deposition pthisis.23
Seminars in Ophthalmology
Cataract Surgery Complications in Uveitis Patients 69
30. Gregory AC, Zhang MM, Rapoport Y, Ling JD, Kuchtey RW. 32. Murthy SI, Pappuru RR, Latha KM, Kamat S, Sangwan VS.
Racial influences of uveitic glaucoma: Consolidation of cur- Surgical management in patient with uveitis. Indian J
rent knowledge of diagnosis and treatment. Semin Ophthalmol. Ophthalmol. 2013;61(6):284–290. doi:10.4103/0301-
2016;31(4):400–404. doi:10.3109/08820538.2016.1154169. 4738.114103.
31. Gm F, Flynn HW Jr, Davis JL, Culbertson W. Causes of 33. Ganesh SK, Sen P, Sharma HR. Late dislocation of in-the-
reduced visual acuity on long-term follow-up after cataract bag intraocular lenses in uveitic eyes: An analysis of man-
extraction in patients with uveitis and juvenile rheumatoid agement and complications. Indian J Ophthalmol. 2017;65
arthritis. Am J Ophthalmol. 1992;114:708–714. doi:10.1016/ (2):148–154. doi:10.4103/ijo.IJO_938_16.
S0002-9394(14)74049-8.