Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CLOSING THE
DATA SKILLS GAP IN
THE COVID-19 ERA
AND BEYOND
Preface
W
elcome to the NTUC LearningHub Data Skills
Report 2020!
The unprecedented COVID-19 pandemic has drastically
transformed the future of work and life, and we are now
entering a New Normal. Within a short span of time,
the way we live, communicate, and conduct business
have transformed drastically. Companies will be thrusted
into a new era of transformation, prompting employers
to actively reassess the workforce they need in order to
navigate the new economy. The COVID-19 storm is not
over and business leaders must reflect on their strategies in
weathering the turbulent period ahead.
In this complex business environment, intuition and
guesswork alone are not sufficient and I would posit that
business leaders will have to be supported by data to
improve their chances of success in any business innovation
or business venture.
To help us understand the importance of data and the role
it plays in keeping businesses viable and competitive, we
embarked on this research. This report aims to provide
a view from the ground about the degree of data usage
in Singapore, the general perception about the data-
related skillsets of Singapore’s workforce, hiring trends
and preferences of businesses in Singapore, and actions
taken to close skills gaps in order for businesses to remain
competitive. We hope that through this report, more
business leaders will understand how to plug the data skills
gap and appreciate the reasons behind the possible inertia
of encouraging more employees to embrace data. It is also
written with the intention of getting more workers to gain insight into
the overall market demand and identify gaps in their current skillsets to
determine how they can adapt.
Let me share a few snippets about what the report has unveiled. For a
start, it is heartening to see employers recognizing the power of data. In
our research, we have found out that four in five (79%) business leaders
found that data literacy of their employees is more important now than
ever before. By a similar measure, 80% of them have agreed that using
data and business intelligence tools will increase the chances of their
companies surviving this downturn. We also found that the majority of
business leaders (94%) and employees (88%) are using data more often
to make business decisions now than before.
Looking forward, in a Volatile, Uncertain, Complex and Ambiguous
(VUCA) environment like the COVID pandemic that we are facing
now, the importance of data will be here to stay to help us declutter
the complex and ambiguous environment that we all face. What do
we do from here? Here in Singapore, we are fortunate that we have
a well-educated workforce and that provides a good springboard
towards building a highly data literate workforce. We want to work
with more businesses and organisations to invest in Data Analytics,
Data Interpretation for Decision Making in Business and last but not
least, Data Protection & Risk Management. While data literacy was
considered a new skill last decade and only for a select few, we want to
make data literacy a basic skill for Worker 4.0 — our future workers.
Here at NTUC LearningHub, we are committed to this journey and
we are more than happy to work with any like-minded organisations to
collectively move the needle in this data revolution.
Table of Contents 4
Conclusions 28
94% 88%
with a resounding “yes”.
EMPLOYERS EMPLOYEES
Industry clusters such as Professional Services, Trade & Connectivity and Lifestyle top
the list when it comes to experiencing increasing use of data in the workplace to drive
business decisions.
97%
EMPLOYERS
93%
EMPLOYEES
important or important for
their employees to understand
data well in order for their
companies to be successful.
89%
say that they would face
challenges at work if
Employees have also they were not good at
expressed the challenges understanding data.
and pitfalls of not possessing
data-related skills
The types of challenges they would face at work if they were not proficient in
understanding data include:
Not able to measure the results of my work 59%
06
Becoming outdated on modern business practices 56%
Not being able to do my job well 55%
Taking longer to get my work done 50%
Not being able to communicate efficiently with my boss/management 45%
Higher probability of making mistakes 37%
87%
are concerned that their careers
will be affected if they were not
proficient in understanding data.
Many employers
report a lack of
1in3
employers have expressed that their workforce
data literate staff do not have the necessary data-related skills
that are relevant to their business.
90%
employers express keen
interest in hiring employees
66% 82%
of all the employers indicate that they would
be willing to pay more for someone who is of employers indicated that they would
data literate for a role that did not require hire between 1 to 4 employees for roles
data specialisation. that specialise solely in data related work.
The data specialist roles that this group of employers intend to hire for include the
following:
Data Analysts / Business Analysts 71%
Data Scientists 51%
Data-Driven Decision Makers / Managers 36%
Data Systems Developers 34%
Data Protection Officers 33%
Data Visualisation Executives / Dashboard Creators 31% 08
Computing / Coding experts 28%
Data Protection Executives 26%
Of this group of employers who would like to hire employees that specialise
solely in data-related work, these are the levels they are looking to hire for:
Middle (manager/senior manager) 71%
Junior (below manager) 51%
Temporary/Contract based 36%
Senior (director and above) 34%
76%
report an interest to hire between one to three
employees for roles that are not specialised in
data-related work.
10%
indicate an interest to hire at least 10 employees
who are not specialised in data-related work.
66%
of all employers indicated that
they are currently keen on hiring
52%
employees who are not specialised intend to hire majority (more than 50%) of
in data-related work. employees who are data literate, even if their roles
do not require any specific data specialisation.
Key Trends
64%
employers report that their
companies currently do not have
training programmes in data literacy
for their employees.
09 The obstacles faced by the employers to upskill their team to be more data literate
include the following:
There is no time to train them 46%
My employees are reluctant to pick up such skills 34%
There is a lack of data know-how within my company 32%
There is a lack in government funding 27%
57%
employers are aware that the government
has subsidies for data literacy courses
91%
recognise the
importance to
upskill themselves
in data literacy to
do their job well. 91%
indicate that they intend to
upskill themselves in data
literacy in the near future.
Employees who mentioned that upskilling in data is important, but who did not
intend to, rate the following are reasons for not pursuing training:
There is a lack of training support available in my company 38%
I do not have time 33%
Courses are too expensive for my budget 26%
I don’t know which course is relevant to my job 24%
I don’t see a need to upskill myself 17%
I have not come across one that I like 12%
10
There are too many choices and I don’t know where to start 10%
47%
employers feel that
companies should be
responsible for ensuring
the data literacy of their
workforce. The rest are of
the opinion that employees
should be responsible for
ensuring they are data
literate to stay relevant to
their company. 56%
employees feel that companies should be
responsible for ensuring that the workforce is
data literate. On the other hand, the rest are
of the opinion that the onus is on themselves
in ensuring that they are data literate to stay
relevant to their company.
CONTEXTUALISING
SINGAPORE’S DATA
SKILLS GAP
A
mid the COVID-19 outbreak, businesses have had to swiftly adapt to
changing environments and exploit available business intelligence to react in
unprecedented times. The capabilities of real-time data processing have enabled
companies to quickly analyse and handle the irregular demand for their products.1
Business leaders and employees alike increasingly recognise data literacy as a key
competency, with a large majority (79%) of business leaders in Singapore saying that
data literacy of their employees is more important now than before the pandemic. To
a similar degree, four in five business leaders (80%) ‘agree’ and ‘strongly agree’ that the
use of data and business intelligence tools will increase the chances of their company
surviving through this economic downturn*.
The spotlight on data analytics is certainly not new. According to a spokesperson from
the Economic Development Board (EDB), Singapore contributes at least SGD1 billion
each year to the data analytics industry. In addition, the National Research Foundation
(NRF) has set aside SGD150 million to boost Singapore’s artificial intelligence (AI)
capabilities.2 These investments establish an enabling environment for businesses in
Singapore to thrive and maintain their position are at the forefront of Industry 4.0.
However, as the Singapore government press on with its digitalisation push to combat
the coronavirus crisis, and as businesses are thrust into a “must transform” mode, a
skills gap persists. And until that gap is plugged, companies will not be able to harness
the power of data to survive and compete in a fast-changing world.
1 The Straits Times. 2020. Some industries may grow even as Singapore heads for recession. [Accessed 16 June 2020]
2 Economic Development Board. 2017. Grab pushes digital innovation to stay ahead of the game. [Accessed 16 June 2020]
MORE RELY ON DATA TO MAKE BUSINESS
DECISIONS NOW, AS COMPARED TO A YEAR AGO
The use of data in the workplace has proliferated evidently as compared to last year.
87%
of business leaders report
94%
indicated that their companies
that they currently use data are using data more often to
to make business decisions. make business decisions now
as compared to a year ago.
88%
of employees have similarly stated that
their team at work makes more data
driven decisions now than ever before.
97% 12
business leaders.
93%
employees.
Business leaders’ votes for the data related skills necessary for their employees to have
Contextualising Singapore’s Data Skills Gap
69%
of employees say that 64%
translating data into of them say that
insights is the top skill to translating those
propel a business forward. insights to business
actions is another
top skill to propel a
business forward.
93%
understand that
44% 49%
stating it is stating it is
being data proficient very important. important.
is pertinent to a
company’s success.
Despite appreciating
the importance of data 92%
of them admit that they would
13 to business, employees
be able to carry out their job
are not confident of more effectively if they could
their own data abilities. understand data better.
On their company’s leadership, about a third of the employees were not confident
in the ability of their senior management to improve business performance by
leveraging data. For leaders to instil more confidence in their employee on using
data, they need to first lead by example by upskilling and using data effectively
in the workplace. Additionally, they must have a better grasp of the data related
challenges employees are facing at work.
89%
of employees expect to encounter
challenges at work if they were not
proficient in understanding data.
In this group, over half of the respondents identified with the following challenges:
59%
unable to measure
50%
spending more
work outcomes. time to complete
their work.
56%
becoming outdated
55%
unable to do
on current and future their jobs well.
business practices.
45% 37%
of employees identified having
difficulties communicating
efficiently with their management.
! said they had an increased
likelihood of making mistakes.
The need for transformation is inevitable as employees fear that their quality and
productivity in work might be compromised due to their data incompetency.
14
With the lack of data skills posing
challenges to their daily work potential,
87%
of employees have
there is a perceived consequential effect cited that their data
on their long-term career prospects. incompetency will affect
their career development.
When further enquired on the potential ways data incompetence would hinder
their career development, many employees cited the following concerns:
With retrenchment looming over heavily affected businesses, workers need to take
action to keep themselves resilient and equipped with relevant data skill sets.
HOW IBM FOSTERS A DATA DRIVEN
CULTURE AMONG ITS LEADERS
IBM has always been a leader in the data space, priding themselves on how
closely they embrace and utilise data in their workplace. These are some ways
that IBM cultivates a data driven culture across verticals in its organisation,
according to Andrew Campbell, Senior Partner of Talent and Transformation.
42%
Data Analytics
67%
28%
Data Visualisation
42%
16%
Advanced Statistics Techniques
27%
17%
Data Science Engineering
23%
Business leaders’ votes for the data related skills that are necessary and lacking in their employees.
Contextualising Singapore’s Data Skills Gap
When turning to employees to get their perspective on this issue, the results
came out quite similar. Data Analytics, Data Interpretation for Decision Making
in Business and Data Protection and Risk Management remained the top 3
necessary skill sets that were seen as important but lacking among themselves.
21%
Data Visualisation
41%
20%
Advanced Statistics Techniques
28%
13%
Data Science Engineering
18%
Employees’ votes for the data related skills that are necessary and those which they lack.
The findings highlight a congruence between the data skills that both business leaders
and employees feel are valuable to have. Interestingly, both parties understand that
there is a fundamental mismatch between skills needed and skills possessed among
employees. This only underscores the need for improving data literacy through
training and readiness for future disruptions. With Singapore progressively reopening
the economy and society, businesses could use this downtime as an opportunity to
close the data skills gap within organisations, emerging stronger and better prepared
for the uncertain and volatile environment ahead.
A common understanding among business leaders and employees has been
established about the importance of data to improve work decisions and business
growth. There is a prevalent skills gap in the workforce to meet the demand in data
competencies to keep pace with the rapid transformation of businesses. This lack
of data competency, coupled with what is perceived to be a weak adoption of data
analytics and BI from the top, has rippled into affecting employees work and increased
anxiety on potential career development roadblocks.
18
TRANSFORMING &
MOVING FORWARD
W
ith a better ground level perspective on data literacy in Singapore, we
will further build on how businesses can transform their workforce and
improve data training as we move forward into this post pandemic era.
At a time where business intelligence is key to navigating an uncertain world, not
knowing how to leverage data effectively could be costly and unproductive. A Qlik
survey of 9,000 employees around the world found that companies lose an average of
more than 43 hours a year on each employee. These lost days due to procrastination
and sick leave stem from stress around information, data and technology issues, and
equate to around USD3.7 billion loss of productivity in Singapore.3
Taking a deeper dive into data talent attraction, workforce training, and the state at
play, could elucidate some of the barriers to closing data skill gaps.
3 Qlik. 2020. New Research from Accenture and Qlik Shows the Data Skills Gap is Costing Organisations Billions in Lost Productivity.
[Accessed 25 June 2020]
EMPLOYERS ARE WILLING TO PAY A PREMIUM
WHEN HIRING EMPLOYEES WITH DATA-RELATED
COMPETENCIES
Business Leaders’ Data Literacy Demand in Non-Data Specialised Job Roles
90%
of business leaders were 33%
keen on hiring data literate were willing to pay up to 20%
employees, regardless of more for someone who is data
their team size or job role. literate for a role that did not
require data specialisation.
48%
of business leaders were willing
to pay up to 10% more.
52%
of business leaders
would prefer more than
half of their workforce
27%
of them would prefer all 20
to be data literate. of their workforce to be
data literate.
This shows how being data competent has transcended its typically specialised job
scope. Changing expectations among business leaders require everyone, even those in
non-data related jobs, to widen their knowledge on applying data to their work.
36%
specialist roles are:
71%
data analyst/
data driven decision
makers/ managers.
business analyst.
51%
data scientists.
Transforming & Moving Forward
1in3
business leaders have expressed that their workforce do not have
the necessary data-related skills that are relevant to their business.
When asking business leaders how likely they were to send their employees for data
literacy courses, majority of them said likely (58%) and very likely (26%).
These valuable insights show the common understanding between both parties on
the importance of data literacy and wanting to upskill. However, this issue on the lack
in data literate employees continues to persist. To truly close this skill divide and get
to the root of the problem, we need to dig deeper into the barriers, obstacles and
underlying motivations of these employees that stop them from upskilling.
70%
of employees.
64%
of business
report that their companies
do not have any data literacy
training programmes.
leaders
ADVOCATING DATA AND AI INCLUSIVITY
AT SOFTBANK ROBOTICS
SoftBank Robotics is debunking the general misconception that data can only be
analysed and utilised by data scientists and specialists. Using SoftBank Robotics
solutions will enable workers of all profiles to make use of data to streamline their job
responsibilities to drive a more efficient work environment.
Though the automation of mundane tasks, SoftBank Robotics envisages that robotics
will be able to improve the lives of not only specialised data professionals, but for
workers of all backgrounds, regardless of their industries. This can be done by
enabling the workforce with the relevant skills and knowledge in both data analysis
and AI. SoftBank Robotics observed that it is important to empower users with the
implementation of data-driven operation workflow to foster a collaborative working
relationship. Non-data specialists usually do not possess the know-hows or tools
to apply the correct model in their data analysis and are often overwhelmed by the
quantity of data which could hamper their data analysis process.
This includes worker profiles such as facility maintenance operators and cleaning crew
as they learn to incorporate data-driven operation workflow in their day to day tasks.
One solution that SoftBank Robotics has produced is Whiz, a robot aimed to foster
collaborative working relationships between AI and cleaning teams. They interact with
tools such as Whiz Connect and SoftBank Robotics’ fleet management platform along
with the guidance of SoftBank Robotics Customer Success team, that offers actionable
workflow advice. This allows cleaning crew members to maximise the benefits of data
to increase productivity.
Our team is taking the lead in applying data analytics to improve our
partners’ workflow, aiming to refine solutions and deriving data-driven
operation insights to enable our partners to be able to to conduct
analysis independently and improve on their service delivery of hygiene
and cleanliness to their service buyers. We believe employers should also
play their part by providing adequate training as well as inculcating the
data-driven decision mindset to staff who are non-data specialist in their
current job when looking to implement a data-driven workflow,
says Eric Lim, Sales Director of SoftBank Robotics Singapore Pte Ltd.
TRAIL BLAZING BUSINESS-WIDE DATA
TRANSFORMATION
At a time where businesses need to adapt quickly to disruptions arising from the
pandemic, Qlik has ramped up its efforts in providing solutions that enable businesses
to leverage data across verticals. It provides easy access to data on a single platform,
which is enhanced with conversational analytics, allowing people to intuitively ask
questions and chat with their data to get the answers they need quickly.
Qlik has a firm ethos that data should no longer be confined to traditional data
specialist roles like data scientists or data architects but extend its use to normal
everyday people. One example is how Singapore Management University has
successfully integrated Qlik’s data and analytics platform into virtually every part
of the campus located in Bras Basah; from the lifecycle of its students to facilities
management, staff scheduling and even predicting academic learning patterns.
People that you least expect would use data are applying it in
very unusual ways - it is showing us that data is being valued
as an asset with tremendous latent value to functions that are
well beyond finance and IT. Whether it is HR, facilities, security
personnel, healthcare workers or procurement, this crisis has
shown the benefit of everyone in the organisation receiving
accurate, real-time information from a single analytics platform.
Apart from helping clients lead their business with data, they pride themselves on
championing a highly prolific data literacy cause at a global scale. As founders of the
Data Literacy Project and its countless data initiatives like developing the “Human
Impact of Data Literacy” Report together with Accenture, they have created a vibrant
online community who are dedicated to making our society proficient in harnessing
data to bring business value.
2in5 43%
business leaders.
were not aware of
training funds and
27%
business leaders felt
that the government
schemes. funding is sufficient.
59%
of the employees.
76%
of business leaders
companies have started
to place more emphasis
on data literacy training
over the past year.
88% 81%
of business
felt that these training
programmes were
of employees.
leaders.
sufficient. 24
Although more companies are starting to recognise the need for data literate
employees, more should be done to push the importance of data and extend the
required resources and training support for employees to hone their skills. Business
leaders play a critical role in enabling change in the company and raise the need for
restructuring training programs if necessary. Employees need to take a proactive stand
to improve themselves, in response to the significant reconfiguration of needs in the
economy and job market.
When shedding light on the obstacles faced in upskilling their team in data literacy,
business leaders attribute the fact to not having time to train them (46%), employees
reluctance to pick up such skills (34%) and a lack of data know-how within the
company (32%).
WHILE UPSKILLING DATA LITERACY IS
IMPORTANT TO THE EMPLOYEES, THE
TOP REASON FOR NOT DOING SO WAS
ATTRIBUTED TO THE LACK OF TRAINING
SUPPORT FROM THE BUSINESS LEADERS
Of the minority who recognised that upskilling in data literacy is important but were
not intending to upskill, the top three reasons for not pursuing training in data literacy
were the following:
38%
lack of training support
in their company.
26%
lack of affordable
33%
training courses.
lack of time.
These are salient points that business leaders should be aware of when making training
more accessible to employees.
From these findings, we see how both business leaders and employees face problems in
25 upskilling. A common reason tops both party responses – not enough training support
is given to the employees who require them. Employees reluctance to pick up the skills
also came in second on reasons why they do not upskill. A concerted effort is required
by both parties for improving data literacy in the workforce.
While employees and business leaders understand the importance of data upskilling,
there is room for improvement for both parties to overcome barriers and place more
emphasis on data literacy. Moving forward, Singapore would require the collaboration
of both business leaders and employees to close the data skills gap and boost her
ability to thrive in today’s data-driven economy.
CONCLUSION
CLOSING THE DATA SKILLS GAP
With businesses pivoting and the pandemic forcing companies to change the
way they work, there is a common understanding among business leaders and
employees on the importance of data to improve work decisions and business
growth. Almost all (97% of business leaders and 93% of employees) believe it is
important to understand data well in order for the company to be successful.
In NTUC LearningHub’s recent skills survey, 40% of employers felt that data
analysis was important in keeping their business viable during this COVID-19
period, and 79% responded that data literacy of their employees is more
pertinent now than ever before. However, among the employees, there was a
lack of confidence in their data competency, with 92% admitting that they could
do their job better if they understood data more. This illustrated a prevalent
skills gap among employees to meet the data skill demands while keeping up
with the rapid transformation of businesses. As workplaces have evolved into
using data in almost all aspects of their business, companies need to exude a
culture of being data driven, as well as create a strong infrastructure to build
a data literate workforce. This would serve as a competitive advantage, and
enable them to harness the multitudinous benefits of becoming a data driven
company. Being data incompetent has raised challenges to employees at work
and for businesses, a loss in productivity and growth. With the perceived
negative consequences linked to being data illiterate, employees and business
leaders need to join forces in closing the skills gap and preparing for their
future.
In a larger context, data literacy is the foundation for Singapore’s future success
and action needs to be taken to ensure we do not get left behind amidst these
uncertain times.4 Singapore needs to be forward looking, adapting to data skills
and technology to emerge stronger and more prepared to thrive in future
calamities.5 As Mr Iswaran, Minister of Communications and Information has said
in an interview with The Straits Times “The current situation has presented an
opportunity for Singapore to double down on its push towards a digital future.”6
With the government support, funding, and guidance in place, it is up to business
leaders and employees to enable the change and pursue their own path to data
upskilling.
4 Singapore Business Review. 2019. Singapore workers need to be data literate to thrive in today’s business climate.
[Accessed 22 June 2020]
5 The Straits Times. 2020. Covid-19 pushing firms towards digital economy: Minister. [Accessed 22 June 2020]
6 The Straits Times. 2020. Ministerial Committee set up to guide digital adoption, create jobs in digital economy.
[Accessed 22 June 2020]
RECOMMENDATIONS
FOR BUSINESS LEADERS
Business leaders must take charge in harnessing the power of data and champion
data literacy in their workforce to do so. While it may take a considerable amount
of planning and time investment, fostering a data-driven culture will prove to reap
rewards in the long run.
Employees who want to boost their employability could leverage data to show their
higher ups that they mean business. Employees can take small steps and use simple
ways to apply data-backed rationalisations in their daily work.
33
Our Courses
In line with the additional national measures announced in response to COVID-19,
NTUC LearningHub has quickly transitioned to virtual classes, adjusting our delivery of
training to make it accessible even in the midst of this pandemic.
PROFILE OF RESPONDENTS
Business Leaders
34%
Out of the total of 200
respondents that completed the
62%
employer online survey
were aged 45
and older.
were male.
63%
respondents were between
the ages of 16 to 44 years old.
17% Manufacturing
15% Built Environment
13% Essential Domestic Services
11% Trade & Connectivity
5% Lifestyle
25%
respondents
had their monthly personal
income fall between
SGD$6000 to SGD$7999.
40%
department.
held a director
position or higher.
60%
had a manager or
senior manager
job role.
Employees
Out of a total of 500 respondents
that completed the employees
online survey
52% 34%
were aged 45 and older.
were female.
67%
respondents were between
the ages of 16 to 44 years old.
15% Manufacturing
14% Essential Domestic Services
12% Built Environment
7% Trade & Connectivity
7% Lifestyle
38%
respondents
had their monthly personal
income fall between
SGD$2000 to SGD$3999.
Majority of respondents (76%) work in the private sector and slightly more than
half of the respondents (54%) had less than 10 years of work experience.
66% 84%
of the respondents
held a job position worked in an office
below managerial level. environment.
16%
worked in jobs that
involve manual labour.
About
NTUC LearningHub
NTUC LearningHub was corporatised in 2004 with the vision of transforming
Workplace Safety & Health, Security, Human Resources and Foreign Worker
Training.
achieved over 2.5 million training places across more than 500 courses with a
AT A GLANCE >400
certified trainers
>500
courses
39
Across
Worked with over 5 Training Centers
21,000 organisations
since 2004
with
2.5million
training places since 2004
© Copyright NTUC LearningHub 2020. All rights reserved. The reproduction and transmission
of logos, marks or any original design of all or any part of this work is restricted without a written
permission of their respective owners. The commission of any unauthorized act may lead in civil
and/or criminal action.