Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Profesora:
Mercedes Gómez
It is proved that the food we eat reacts chemically with our blood type, and by choosing the right food
allows the stomach to digest and absorb the right nutrients that we need. Aramark has created a new
strategic business unit, to test a new concept of healthy restoration. We want to provide a catering
service to the private Hospital in Madrid called Hospital de Montepríncipe. The menus will be made
based on patients’ blood type with the intention that this will help in their recovery. In addition, the
hospital will be a pioneer in Spain within the health sector.
But this project will not be complete without the appropriate technology of blockchain. The era of
encrypted information, cyber contracts, security and agility is the future. For that reason, we will
implement it with the main objective of protecting patient information, expanding competitive
advantage and optimize operational processes with the cost savings that this entails.
The total cost of the 7 months’ project is 306.222,00€ that is expected to be recovered in only 7
months after its implementation. The risks of the project are very low considering the great experience
of Aramark in the catering sector and the professionalism of the assigned team. 19 people dedicated
100 per cent of their time to the project will be responsible for the execution of the milestones in time
and manner.
As a result, the hospital will be a pioneer in Spain offering patient’s menus according to their blood
type within the health sector and using the blockchain technology.
Está comprobado que los alimentos que comemos reaccionan químicamente con nuestro tipo de
sangre, y al elegir los alimentos correctos, el estómago puede digerir y absorber los nutrientes
adecuados que necesitamos. Aramark ha creado una nueva unidad de negocio estratégica, para probar
un nuevo concepto de restauración saludable. Queremos proporcionar un servicio de catering al
Hospital privado en Madrid llamado Hospital de Montepríncipe. Los menús se realizarán en función
del tipo de sangre de los pacientes con la intención de que esto ayude a su recuperación. Además, el
hospital será pionero en España dentro del sector sanitario.
Pero este proyecto no estará completo sin la tecnología adecuada de blockchain. La era de la
información cifrada, los contratos cibernéticos, la seguridad y la agilidad, es el futuro. Por ese motivo,
lo implementaremos con el objetivo principal de proteger la información del paciente, expandir la
ventaja competitiva y optimizar los procesos operativos con el ahorro de costes que esto conlleva.
1
El coste total de este proyecto de 7 meses es de 306.222,00 € que se espera recuperar en tan solo 7
meses después de su implementación. Los riesgos del proyecto son muy bajos, teniendo en cuenta la
gran experiencia de Aramark en el sector de la restauración y la profesionalidad del equipo asignado.
19 personas dedicadas el 100% de su tiempo al proyecto serán responsables de la ejecución de los
hitos en el tiempo y forma.
Como resultado, el hospital será pionero en España ofreciendo menús según el tipo de sangre de los
pacientes dentro del sector de la salud y utilizando la tecnología blockchain
Keywords
Index
Executive Summary 1
Keywords 2
Index 2
Introduction 5
Project Charter 6
Business Case 8
Description of Aramark 8
Industry Structure: 9
SWOT Analysis 10
Competitor’s Analysis 10
Overall Strategy 11
Value 11
Vision 11
Mission 12
Culture 12
Identification and Analysis of Main Stakeholders 12
2
Diagnosis of AS-IS Model 13
Diagnosis of TO-BE Model (Future State) 14
SMART Objectives 15
Identification and Definition of High-level Requirements 16
Alternatives Analysis 17
Master Schedule 18
Risk Identification and Assessment 19
Qualitative Analysis of Risks 20
Master / Gross Budget 20
Project Budget 22
Free Cash Flow 23
3
Qualitative Analysis 61
Quantitative Analysis 61
Risk Follow-Up 61
Conclusion 82
Bibliography 83
Appendix 84
Appendix A - Food Service Survey Sample for Client Hospital de Montepríncipe 84
Appendix B - Nutrition Knowledge Test for Chefs and Dietitian 85
Appendix C - Reducing Waste Test 86
Appendix D - Menu Testing Sample on Hospital Patients (Consumer Experience) 86
Appendix E - Risk Management Plan Approval 88
Appendix F - Supplier Selection Criteria Chart 88
Appendix G - Change Request Template
Appendix H - Risk Matrix 93
Appendix I - Stakeholder Register 101
4
Introduction
Our project team realized that there is a gap within the catering industry where no catering company
produces meals based on blood type. We understood this as an opportunity to further educate others
on reasons to incorporate and introduce foods into one’s diet to ensure that they have the most optimal
health. Since we are located in Madrid, Spain, we decided to implement our new service to the city of
Madrid and be innovators in the catering industry. Our client Hospital de Montepríncipe was chosen
since they do not have a large capacity and are under the hospital group called HM Hospitales. Our
rationale for choosing Hospital de Montepríncipe, was that in the future, we will be able to implement
blockchain and our menu creation into the hospitals across spain through the hospital group. It is
known that being healthy and making the right choices every day to optimize your health is important,
and we thought that using this project idea towards patients at hospitals will benefit the most for this
pilot project.
Aramark serves in the catering and food industry and has been present in the European market since
1972 (“History | About Us”, n.d.). The company decided to expand its business in the Spanish market
through taking advantage of the service sector, liberalization, openness to foreign investments and
easy regulatory processes. With the opportunity to expand its business in the healthcare sector and
create a new competitive concept relating to food consumption, made specifically for a person’s blood
type. The chemical reaction of the food we eat to different blood types can have different effects on an
individual’s body since specific blood types carry various components (“Blood Basics,” n.d., “para.
1). Choosing the specific foods based on your blood allows the stomach to digest efficiently, leading
to a healthier life. Aramark recently launched a strategic business unit in Madrid, Spain, called
Aramark, Tu Dieta. This strategic business unit is set to test a fresh idea and new concept of healthy
restoration based on individual’s blood type, that is based on personalization.
Aramark’s strategic business unit provides a catering service to the healthcare private sector. Our
organization has decided to start our services within Hospital de Montepríncipe for the purpose of
offering menus designed to fit patients’ four blood types (A - AB - O - B) to better nourish and heal
them. We will then use blockchain technology as a tool to store hospital patients confidential data
which will be used as a reference for the menu creation.
5
In this report, we will demonstrate the need for blockchain and menu creation within the catering and
healthcare sectors, outline the company’s background and objectives, identify the project management
plan and supporting project plans to ensure that our project will be executed in a timely manner, while
meeting budget and requirement goals.
Project Charter
The project charter outlined below provides information on roles, responsibilities, project objectives,
main stakeholders. This project charter will serve as a reference point for all future plans that will be
created.
Project Charter
Project Description A strategic business unit of Aramark, called ‘Aramark, Tu Dieta, is set to
test a new concept of healthy restoration based on client’s blood type. A
personalized diet system specially designed based on blood type.
Project Scope Scope of the project can be divided into two phases to include the
development of blockchain and the second phase will include the
implementation of blockchain, the supply to hospitals with food and
devise menu options
Project Manager Rim Youssefi, Virginia Martinez Novillo and Jessica Joy Opinaldo
6
Manager Corporate Development, HM Hospitales
Informational Technology: Rim Youssefi, PM of Operations & Hospitality
● Jessica Joy Opinaldo, Project Manager of Aramark Madrid
○ Business Analyst Virginia Martinez Novillo, Project Finance
○ Developer Manager of Aramark Madrid
○ 2 Testers Jessica Joy Opinaldo, IT Project Manager of
Aramark Madrid
Project Schedule
7
Project Sponsor Project Team Member
Date Date
Business Case
Our project team has identified the purpose of the business case and our justification for implementing
such a project, along with the identification of risks, estimated cost of development, business benefits
and savings to be gained.
Description of Aramark
Aramark is a customer service based business that provides food, facilities and uniforms to various
organizations across the world. The organization is leading in educational institutions, destinations,
cultural attractions and municipalities across 19 countries around the world (“History | About Us”,
n.d.).
8
Aramark started a small vending service in 1936 to become a global corporation today. With 270,00
highly qualified employees delivering excellent catering services, all involved to serve more than two
billion meals to customers to ensure that they provide them with the best quality health inspired
menus (“History | About Us”, n.d.). . Aramark found itself to be one of the best catering services food
industries, which provides personalized menus using high quality resources. However the lack of a
standardized ordering process makes it hard for them to keep up with the huge amount of demand and
may sometimes affect the quality of the staff work, as they are available during the whole year 24/7
(“History | About Us”, n.d.).
Industry Structure:
Spain has registered significant geographical differences across regions, health care areas and
hospitals when it comes to efficiency, access, quality and safety variability. The country has scored an
8.5 percent in GDP, which is a relatively low level of expenditure, but in overall the Spanish people
are obtaining quite a good value for money (Begona Abadia-Taira, M. et. al., 2010).
According to the World Health Care Organization (WHO), the health care in Spain is in complete
transition, aiming in providing a better quality, reliability and sustainability in the following areas:
● Patients health status
● Financial access and equity
● Safety and quality of life
● Users satisfaction
Furthermore, people in Spain are finding the importance of remaining healthy, and are constantly
changing their eating habits, striving for efficient diets and wellness programs. Below is a mapped
distribution of the percentages of blood types in Spain (Marian, 2019):
9
SWOT Analysis
In order to identify the problem facing Aramark, we have conducted an internal and external analysis
to identify Aramark’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats to identify a strategy that will
create a unique and competitive value to the market in which they are operating in. the figure below
shows the SWOT matrix used in identifying Aramark‘s positive and negative points:
Strengths: Weakness:
● High skilled and motivated staff ● Not enough investments in new
● Investment in training and learning technologies
programs ● No new innovative programs or health
● Strong brand image and portfolio programs created
● Strong relationship with its
communities
● Product innovation
● Strong distribution network
Threats: Opportunities:
● New trends in customer behaviours ● Liabilities laws in different countries
● New markets are emerging within the ● New technologies developing in other
catering sector countries
● Increase in customer spending ● Creating new educational programs are
other health initiatives
Competitor’s Analysis
In order to identify Aramark’s performance in the market we made an analysis relying on the most
relevant factors that gives value to the company for its market share In this analysis we have
considered the annual revenue of three companies within the same sector, the number of employees,
the number of countries they serve in which we have collected from Aramark website and 2 other
main competitors websites illustrated in the table below:
10
This information is important for us since it describes the annual revenue within three important
organizations that provide similar services that Aramark provides to its consumers. It is clear that
Aramark produces the most annual revenue against the two other organizations, Eurest Services and
Mallorea Catering. Although Aramark is a larger company (based on the number of employees), they
have better reach to its consumers since they reach a large audience in 19 different countries.
Overall Strategy
The ability to attract more external events allows our project team to create a strategic business unit
from Aramark and to implement a new strategy to compliment what exists within the organization.
This new strategic business unit is called Aramark, Tu Dieta and our strategy will be based on the fact
of having separated objectives from the company to take out a niche of their global target and
separated from the usual service process, making the menu standardized for the customer and the
industry. After conducting a research on new technologies development we have decided to invest
money in developing a private blockchain, which will allow us to access the information needed in
less time and in an efficient way, avoiding bottlenecks that could occur during the communication will
exchanging delicate information between two entities, a secure and effective way to process data
needed for the project implementation. Taking advantage of the new trend of blood type nutrition we
have decided to work together within the healthcare sector using the blockchain strategic plan to
create personalized menus to the Monte Príncipe hospital patients according to their blood type while
considering special cases where we may face some allergies and diseases that will completely drive us
to personalize the menus twice.
Value
Aramark, Tu Dieta provides a diet to the private healthcare sector throughout a high quality catering
service. We hand in hand with hospitals design a personalized menu for each individual’s blood type.
We commit to provide the best quality of service for our clients while prioritizing our client’s well
being.
Vision
We will continue to ensure to hire and train our staff with the skills and attitude to ensure we provide
you the best quality life. We are committed to create an enriching and nourishing ritual for
communities to make healthier choices.
11
Mission
Culture
● Our high qualified staff is committed to provide the best quality meals for our patients
● We share the same interest of our customers, patients well being every person’s life and
health matters
● We should all eat right for our type
Javier Reguera, Control and The head of control and new projects of
New Projects of HM High High HM Hospitals must be kept informed and
Hospitals managed closely as his role needs to be
12
informed of any new requirements and the
process of the project
The process flow below coordinates with the current state of the Hospital de Monte Príncipe in
Madrid. Currently, if the patient is admitted to the hospital, a nurse inputs the patients information
into the hospital’s database, such as, patient name, description of issue, allergies, blood type and
allergies. Once the patient has surgery or an operation, they will receive a meal based on what the
hospital provides to its patients. If the patient is able to physically eat, a nurse will provide the patient
with the meal of the day, which includes breakfast, lunch, a snack and dinner.
13
Diagnosis of TO-BE Model (Future State)
In the future, Tu Dieta in Madrid will be able to provide patients with more food options according to
their blood type (allergies and dietary constraints are also a factor). Once the patient is admitted into
the hospital, their information, such as patient name, patient room, dietary constraints, blood type,
description of issue will be documented into the hospital’s blockchain which will be stored by Tu
Dieta Madrid. The head chef at the hospital (employed by Tu Dieta Madrid), will receive this
information and formulate a specific menu catering towards the patients blood type.
14
SMART Objectives
By using the SMART objectives model, Tu Dieta will be able to reflect the importance of efficacy and
feedback.
The hospital and Tu Dieta will evaluate and assess the progress throughout the
Measurable project lifecycle in order to ensure timelines, budget and scope are met. Timelines
will be assessed through reflecting back on the project schedule management plan;
15
the budget will be overseen by the financial manager and project cost management
plan and the scope will be assessed through the project scope management plan.
The reflection of these documents will ensure that Tu Dieta will implement in a
timely and effective manner with no error.
Our goal will be fulfilled through the resources provided by the hospital, such as
the kitchen, kitchen supplies and food delivery. Aramark will provide kitchen staff
and food supply to the hospital based on the needs of the patient information
Achievable
(blood type, allergies and dietary restrictions. Each project manager has a specific
role (Operations, Finance and IT) to ensure that each responsibility is fulfilled in
their respective department
With this plan, project planning, execution and implementation will last six
Time-bound
months, with a contingency of eight months.
16
Tu Dieta, Madrid and Hospital de Monte Príncipe
Madrid must ensure staff have proper training to
4 High Operations, Vendor
its staff on the new project and the importance of
this new change
Alternatives Analysis
The following alternative options have been considered to address the business problem. These
alternatives were not selected for a number of reasons which are explained below:
Patients at the hospital will not be provided ● Same meals for breakfast, lunch, snack and
with meals based on their blood type to dinner for each patient
optimize their health ● Education on healthy lifestyle change
would not be imposed to patients
● No partnership with hospitals of Madrid
17
Master Schedule
The following are the major project milestones identified at this time. As the project planning moves
forward and the schedule is developed, the milestones and their target completion dates will be
modified, adjusted, and finalized as necessary to establish the baseline schedule.
18
● Implement the blockchain technology
Supply hospital with food and kitchen staff
Phase II 09/04/2019
● Devise menu options
● Lessons learned
● Create project closeout and client closeout
Closeout/Project
tracker 10/06/2019
Completion
● Create final report
Our assessment of the risks of the project are the possible threats within the project that could totally
or partially impede the development of the project. Three risks have been identified within the project
each one with a different nature. The enumeration and definition are below:
● Food Contamination: The daily treatment of food within the product life cycle has the risk of
contamination, either because the product arrives in poor condition to the kitchen, or because
the treatment of the food is not adequate. Both cases are not very likely to happen since the
processes of quality control are very strict within the company and by the Spanish regulations
as well. However, the impact could be very high taking into account that the catering is
serving sick patients.
● Blockchain not functioning: Since the main tool of the product life cycle is Blockchain
technology and it is one of the objectives within the project, we have taken into consideration
the possibility of malfunction of it.
● Breach of patient information / data: Despite the fact that blockchain technology is, by
definition, impossible to encrypt, we have taken into account the possible filtering of patient
information as a threat.
19
Qualitative Analysis of Risks
The two tables show the categories, probability, impact on the project and final quantification of the
risks as threats. This qualitative analysis assesses the priority of the risks within the project and the
nature of them:
As is shown in the second table, the most important risk would be if the Blockchain is not possible to
implement. Also, it will affect to the project scope, timing, cost and quality and therefore this is the
main task that the project management team should take into account. The contingency plan if this
happens would be to maintain the existing technology of the hospital. But we must not forget a risk
that although it is not very probable, it has a high impact. The food contamination could lead in the
death of a patient and the repercussions would be very serious for the firm. The contingency plan for
this is to take out an insurance. The rest of the risks are medium or low in terms of priority but also
should be mentioned.
This project has a very clear distribution into three types of costs: labour force, blockchain
implementation and material such as uniforms for the kitchen staff.
Enterprise environmental factors that may affect the development of the project could be external such
as an increase labour force cost because of an increase in taxes, exchange rates change and inflation
but are not included on the budget. In relation to the labour cost, we have divided into three groups
based on the WBS. The labour cost includes not only the salary with paid vacation, but also the taxes
that the company will have to face. The cost of implementing blockchain will be developed by one
Business Analyst, one Developer and two testers. This team will report to Jessica Joy directly and it is
expected to last the first four months with a full-time contract.
20
The team of chefs consists of two chefs and one nutritionist. The contract is a full time during the last
two months of the project. This is followed by the staff team which is composed of nine members
who will be hired the month number six within the project and with a part time contract. The objective
during that month is basically to training them. All of them have an hour rate of 6,25€ (cost for the
company). This figure is understood as “training concept” and not as the final salary of the employees,
so it is expected that once the service begins, after the phase of this project, the salary increase will be
20% and the cost for the company will be 25% higher approximately. The last labour force taking into
consideration is the Project Management team formed by tree Jessica Joy Opinaldo, Rim Youssefi and
Virginia Martínez Novillo with a junior category and this cost includes the relocation and subsistence.
The organizational structure will look like this:
For the salary quantifications we have taking into account the following grades with the according
salaries (company cost):
Business A. B 30.00
Developer B 30.00
Tester C 25.00
Chef D 20.00
Nutritionist D 20.00
Staff E 16.00
21
According to the table and adding the uniforms for the kitchen employees the result of the work
package cost estimate is 134,740.00€.
The contingency reserve considered is 15% over the work package. We consider it a fair percentage
taking into account that six months project of a new service implementation.
Also, a management reserve has to be accounted with a 5 percent, therefore, the total budget for the
whole project is 162,216.00€. Taking into account that is a pioneer service within the company and
Aramark has millions of dollars profit every year, this amount is not high at all. If it works, the spread
of this service in different countries will give Aramark a new segmentation customer.
Project Budget
Subtotal 239,360.00 €
1.4.1 Blockchain Execution:
Manager 3 640 36.00 € 69,120.00
Business A. 1 640 30.00 € 19,200.00
Developer 1 640 30.00 € 19,200.00
Tester 2 640 25.00 € 32,000.00
1.4.2 Menus creation Execution:
Manager 3 320 36.00 € 34,560.00
Chef 2 320 20.00 € 12,800.00
Nutritionist 1 320 20.00 € 6,400.00
Staff 9 320 16.00 € 46,080.00
Subtotal 8,640.00 €
1.6 Closing 3.0 80 36.00 € 8,640.00
22
COST BASELINE 292,908.00 €
Our project team measured how much revenue would be generated for account for capital
expenditures:
Above is the free cash flow graph that represents the total cost, income and profits. In order to
determine the free cash flow, we had to determine the cost of each menu per blood type:
23
Operations unitary cost per day
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
Breakfast 1.80 4.50 3.90 3.00 13.20
Lunch 3.90 9.75 8.45 6.50 28.60
Snack 1.50 3.75 3.25 2.50 11.00
Dinner 3.90 9.75 8.45 6.50 28.60
Total 11.10 27.75 24.05 18.50 81.40
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
3,633.4
TOTAL 932.40 166.50 2,164.50 370.00 0
POPULATION
0.42 0.03 0.45 0.10 1.00
DISTRIBUTION
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
Breakfast 5.40 13.50 11.70 9.00 39.60
24
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
Total 2,797.20 499.50 6,493.50 1,110.00 10,900.20
POPULATION
0.42 0.03 0.45 0.10 1
DISTRIBUTION
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
Breakfast 3.60 9.00 7.80 6.00 26.40
Lunch 7.80 19.50 16.90 13.00 57.20
Snack 3.00 7.50 6.50 5.00 22.00
Dinner 7.80 19.50 16.90 13.00 57.20
Total 22.20 55.50 48.10 37.00 162.80
Blood Type
Menu
A+,A- AB 0 B Total
Breakfast 300% 300% 300% 300%
Lunch 300% 300% 300% 300%
Snack 300% 300% 300% 300%
Dinner 300% 300% 300% 300%
Total 300%
25
The above charts determines the operations unitary cost, income, profit and profit margins according
to each meal of the day (breakfast, lunch, snack and dinner) per each blood type (A, B, AB and O).
Our scope management plan outlines and ensure that the project requirements are created and are
successfully completed. The processes defined in the plan are to be verified and tested throughout the
project lifecycle.
During the planning phase of scope management, documents pertaining to defining the scope such as
the project scope statement, requirements traceability matrix and project charter, clearly define what is
in-scope for the project lifecycle. Specific work performed to deliver the blockchain technology and
menu creation for our client, MontePríncipe in Madrid will be reflected in the project charter. As
project managers, we will be able to plan the scope through having the initial meeting with our client
to understand the gaps within MontePríncipe Hospital and what Aramark Spain can offer.
● Project Charter: our project charter defines the project’s purpose of Aramark head office
creating a strategic business unit (SBU) called Aramark, Tu Dieta in Madrid, Spain to test a
new concept of healthy restoration based on the patient’s blood type at the hospital of
MontePríncipe. The personalized diet system will specifically designed based on blood type
through our new blockchain system to be implemented into the hospital.
● Quality Management Plan: our project scope will be managed under the influence of Aramark
and MontePríncipe quality policies, methodologies and standards. As project managers, we
will ensure that our scope coincides with the principles of our organization, as well as our
client to ensure there is no scope creep or defects we may face in the future.
● Enterprise Environmental Factors and Organizational Process Assets: during our scope
planning phase, our organization has considered the marketplace conditions, policies and
procedures and historical information regarding similar projects that have been performed in
the past.
Controlling Scope
During the planning phase of scope management, documents pertaining to defining the scope such as
the project scope statement, requirements traceability matrix and project charter, clearly define what is
in-scope for the project lifecycle. Specific work performed to deliver the blockchain technology and
menu creation for our client, MontePríncipe in Madrid will be reflected in the project charter. As
26
project managers, we will be able to plan the scope through having the initial meeting with our client
to understand the gaps within MontePríncipe Hospital and what Aramark Spain can offer.
● Project Charter: our project charter defines the project’s purpose of Aramark head office
creating a strategic business unit (SBU) called Aramark, Tu Dieta in Madrid, Spain to test a
new concept of healthy restoration based on the patient’s blood type at the hospital of
MontePríncipe. The personalized diet system will specifically designed based on blood type
through our new blockchain system to be implemented into the hospital.
● Quality Management Plan: our project scope will be managed under the influence of Aramark
and MontePríncipe quality policies, methodologies and standards. As project managers, we
will ensure that our scope coincides with the principles of our organization, as well as our
client to ensure there is no scope creep or defects we may face in the future.
● Enterprise Environmental Factors and Organizational Process Assets: during our scope
planning phase, our organization has considered the marketplace conditions, policies and
procedures and historical information regarding similar projects that have been performed in
the past.
According to the requirements traceability matrix, we have developed a way to monitor that the
process and requirements are occurring as expected. We have to observe, verify, audit and document
the project life-cycle.
Requirement
Audits to
Name and Frequency Acceptance Criteria
perform
Description
Blockchain Tester experts are The two testers ● User is able to input record
implementation responsible of will audit the types into blockchain
supervising the work performed ● A list of blocks with a
implementation in the middle of timestamp are created
on time and the ● User restrictions are enabled
manner implementation and participant and validator
and at the end of access is restricted, unless
it authorized
Twice
27
Data protection The project Before Unauthorized users are unable to
regulation administrator and blockchain participate or access blocks
against data the IT project implementation User restrictions are enabled
breaches within manager will Once
internal or audit the
external sources fulfillment of
data protection
according to the
law
Nurse training The training will After blockchain Nurses are able to input record types
for blockchain consist of a final implementation into blockchain
use testing where the Once
nurses will
perform a real
simulation of the
breakfast, lunch,
snack and dinner
menus
Comply with The administrator Right after 100% of regulations have to be
Spain’s and EU manager will menus creation performed
review the
regulations in
Aramark Spain
food and
standards and
agriculture policies and legal
industries regulations
regarding
food quality
protection
28
Monitor and The administrator Before a Users are able to complete deliverable
control cost, manager will payment is either sheet and each project manager is
human review the cost pay or receive. responsible for submitting to Person in
resources, checklist Every week Charge every 2 weeks
schedule and IT PM and (Fridays) Project Cost Estimate Checklist has
budget Operations PM been approved
are responsible Project Milestones Checklist has been
for the approved
scheduling of the
staff. They will
report that the
scheduling have
been
accomplished
correctly and the
PM administrator
will check the
budget and report
all to Aramark
CEO Spain
Demand the The food order fulfill everyday Users are able to receive food supply
food needed for template has to before 20.00 Food inventory matches the amount of
creating the be done by the food provided from Aramark to
menus Operations PM MontePríncipe
with food for the
next day
The chefs and The menus will Satisfaction Users are able to identify each
dietician create be audited by the survey test after blood-type diet is matched with the
menus designed patients with a delivery of the correct food types
depending on final survey of menus calendar
each blood type satisfaction
chemical
component
29
Testing and One testing with Once after the Users are able to identify each
tasting menus on the four meals of menus are blood-type diet is matched with the
people with the the day with created correct food types
4 blood types people of the four
(Staff) different blood
type from the
hospital
Staff training Random audits Once after menu Users are able to download the menus
and involvement from Operations creation and types from the blockchain system
in the process PM with during 1 week. And also are able to be provided with
inspections Inspections for list of specifics
auditing the right on patient information, such as,
perform every 2 blood-type, patient name and so on
weeks
Chefs and Random audits Every 2 weeks Users are able to provide meals to
kitchen staff are from Operations approx. patients through Supply Inventory
able to perform PM with Checklist and according to the menu
work in the inspections calendar provided
hospital kitchen
30
Scope Description In-Scope
Out-of-Scope
● Planning
● Requirements Elicitation
● Creation/Prototyping
● Testing
● Implementation
● Staff Training
Operations
31
● Staff Training
Acceptance Criteria The project will be accepted when it is agreed by the working team, project
sponsor, Hospital de Montepríncipe representative that the deliverables
within the project meets their needs and the deliverables are approved.
Traceability Matrix
32
Person in Requirement Name
Date Rec'd Source Acceptance Criteria
charge and Description
Data protection
Information regulation against data • Unauthorized users are unable to
Ongoing;
Technology J.Opinaldo breaches within participate or access blocks
weekly
(IT) internal or external • User restrictions are enabled
sources
Information
08/05/2019 to Nurse training for • Users are able to input record types
Technology J.Opinaldo
17/05/2019 blockchain use into blockchain
(IT)
33
• Project Cost Estimate Checklist has
Project
08/01/2019 to Ensure budget and been approved
administratio V.Martinez
08/06/2019 schedule are met • Project Milestones Checklist has
n
been approved
34
Chefs and kitchen staff
• Users are able to provide meals to
are able to perform
08/07/2019 Operations R.Youssefi patients through Supply Inventory
work in the hospital
Checklist
kitchen
After identifying the project lifecycle of a seven month duration, we have identified a start and end
date for each activity and milestone to ensure our timeline is met at the agreed date. In the schedule
management plan, we have used Microsoft Project, a software used to manage projects and develop
plans. We have assigned the project resources to existing tasks throughout what we will monitor and
control through the project lifecycle.
Project Milestones
In the table below, all milestones are described in its phase and what is the target date for each:
● Business Case
● Project Charter
● Licenses
Planning: Kick-Off Once project plan review and completion are complete, 09/10/2019
Meeting kick-off meeting commences to ensure all stakeholders
questions are answered
35
Execution: Deliver Ensure that requirements elicitation, requirements 17/01/2020
blockchain to Hospital approval, programming and coding and testing have been
de MontePríncipe completed
Execution: Deliver Ensure that chefs and hospitality staff are trained on health 17/02/2020
menus to patients at and safety and that menus have been tested on selected
Hospital de patients for approval
MontePríncipe
Monitoring and Ensure that during this milestone that both blockchain and 20/02/2020
Controlling: Testing menu testing have been completed
Completed
Activity List
36
1.4 Execution 1.4.1 Blockchain
1.4.1.1 Communicate expectations and predicted outcomes
1.4.1.2 Requirements elicitations
1.4.1.3 Requirements Approval
1.4.1.4 Programming and codifying
1.4.1.5 Add report type
1.4.1.6 Password protection and data encryption
1.4.1.7 Add hospital data into technology
1.4.1.8 Deliver to Hospital de Montepríncipe
1.4.1.9 Nurse training
1.4.1.10 Validate nurse knowledge
1.4.1.11 Provide specific nurses with blockchain authorization
37
Project Schedule
Target
Phase Activities Start Date Completion
Date
38
● Provide specific nurses blockchain
authorization
In the cost management plan, our project team highlights the activities within the project scope, as
well as the cost of each activity during each phase. The importance of the project budget will allow
our project team to continue estimating and identifying the cost of risks and to finally define the total
budget of the project. Moreover, to ensure the best monitoring and controlling of the project budget
we have calculated a cost baseline of our business performance taking into account the possibility of
lack of money, and unidentified work or risks.
39
Activities: Estimation of Cost
40
1.4.1.8 Deliver to Hospital de
Montepríncipe
1.4.1.9 Nurse training
1.4.1.10 Validate nurse knowledge
1.4.1.11 Provide specific nurses with
blockchain authorization
There are external environmental factors that may affect the development of this project, such as:
The contingency reserve for the entire project is 10 percent of the project budget: 26.268,00€. This
percentage takes into account for a new service to be implemented after six months. Also, the
41
contingency reserve will be used if a potential risk arises. A management reserve of 5 percent has also
been added to the budget: 13.314,00€. These percentages have been calculated from a qualitative
analysis of the possible risks of the project as a whole and according to the size of the project, the
budget, the duration and the resource list.
Project Budget
The total project budget totals 306.222,00€ with a project cost baseline 292.908,00€ as outlined
below:
Subtotal 239,360.00 €
1.4.1 Blockchain Execution:
Manager 3 640 36.00 € 69,120.00
Business A. 1 640 30.00 € 19,200.00
Developer 1 640 30.00 € 19,200.00
Tester 2 640 25.00 € 32,000.00
1.4.2 Menus creation Execution:
Manager 3 320 36.00 € 34,560.00
Chef 2 320 20.00 € 12,800.00
Nutritionist 1 320 20.00 € 6,400.00
Staff 9 320 16.00 € 46,080.00
Subtotal 8,640.00 €
1.6 Closing 3.0 80 36.00 € 8,640.00
10.0
Contingency Reserve % 26,628.00 €
42
5.0
Management Reserve % 13,314.00 €
Throughout the project lifecycle, project cost control is put in place to ensure that the budget meets
each phase in accordance to the above project budget. The project cost control will be monitored after
each milestone. The table below describes how the project budget will be controlled:
Final Report
Delivery
43
Quality Management Plan
In the quality management plan, our project team has developed a list of objectives and requirements
needed to ensure the best quality service and monitoring initiatives. We have defined a set of policies
and standards that are considered crucial to the growth of Aramark’s business and success. We are
committed to achieve excellence through food quality and service to meet customers’ expectations.
We use the following international standard for quality codes:
● Our Quality Management system, accredited to ISO 9001:2001
● OHSAS 18001:2007 (occupational safety and health)
● Our continued commitment and ongoing improvement of Quality system
● Insurance of service responsiveness, courtesy and on time delivrance to fulfill and satisfy our
clients’ needs
You will find below a more detailed plan on who is taking the decision of managing quality, when and
how the quality will be ensured within our company’s activities; and the roles and responsibilities of
the main managers of quality insurance.
The table below describes the policies and standards that Aramark, Tu Dieta sets out in order to
achieve the highest quality of our food and services:
Food, Food Safety Aramark guarantees food safety and full compliance by respecting the
& Regulations European Union and Spain food and regulation standards with full
transparency
People & Society Aramark strives to ensure and enhance preference and consistency to delight
individuals and families by valuing what they value and by offering products
and services that always meet or exceed their expectations
44
Employees ● Aramark strives to engage all our employees with commitment across
our value chain and at all levels of our organization to build the Tu
Dieta mindset
● At Aramark we adhere to regularly training our people on their
important responsibilities to main a safe and healthy workplace and
service environment
● Aramark ensures that every employee has the right to question any
job that causes concern about their personal safety of others and the
environment
Defects Aramark strives for zero defects and little to no waste by constantly looking
for opportunity to improve the inventory process of food supply and
continuously improving the approach to deliver in a competitive way
Quality Management ● At Aramark, we ensure that our processes, services and products go
through an extensive inspection regularly
● Aramark must provide employees with food safety and sanitation
training and are ServeSafe certified
● Aramark ensures that we are in accordance to the ISO 9001:2001
standard
● Aramark strives to meet the international requirement OHSAS
18001:2007 (occupational safety and health)
45
● When using any information or template from a website, references
must be added to the document
Once the Quality Management Plan (QMP) is defined by the three project managers (PM):
● PM Administrator (V.Martínez)
● Operations Manager (R.Youssefi)
● Informational Technology Manager (J.Opinaldo)
It will be signed and approved by Aramark Spain President, Pablo Alcalá, as sponsor of the project.
In this manner, each PM is responsible in first place of the quality assurance of their tasks and as
Administrator, V.Martinez is in charge of collecting, saving and auditing that all the standards and
quality policies are being accomplished.
Also, Administration PM will arrange the surveys after deliverables as part of the quality control.
These surveys and testing will be taken into account and reviewed by CEO Spain and if necessary for
Aramark headquarters possible inspection.
Virginia Martinez Project Manager Direct feedback with Aramark head office
Communication and reporting to the sponsor
Quality management plan creation and
responsible
Quality management plan and control & audit
Direct supervision to the managers
Jessica Joy Opinaldo IT Manager Collect the documents, checklists and templates
included in the quality management plan
Keep and file documents for possible audits,
meetings and inspections
Team Supervisor
46
Rim Youssefi Operations Manager Collect the documents, checklists and templates
included in the quality management plan
Keep and file documents for possible audits,
meetings and inspections
Team Supervisor
The following table outlines who is responsible in each quality stage (creation, assurance and control),
who is responsible and when these stages are monitored:
Quality Creation
What? Quality Management Plan (QMP) to Review and approves QMP with his
be signed by every member of the signature as per the Compliance Agreement
team as per the Compliance
Agreement
Quality Assurance
What? Each PM must supervise their teams Collect documents, checklists and
according to the Policies and templates, including the QMP.
Standards of Aramark and the QMP All documents are to be saved for potential
audits, meetings and inspections
Quality Control
47
When? Post-Implementation
What? Aramark will collect all documents, checklists and templates, including the
QMP and create a lessons learned based on the previously stated documents
Managing quality will ensure the patient satisfaction and therefore, Hospital de MontePríncipe project
acceptance.
We have defined the key deliverables that have priority over the rest. We have selected them from the
WBS because the quality has to be hardly controlled, monitored and inspected and they are part of the
critical path within the project life-cycle. Also they might need to be improved at the certain point.
Change request is the basic tool for suggesting not only improvements, but also any issue that some
members of the project might find. With those conditions, we have developed the following table:
WBS Code -
Process of Controlling
Deliverable
1.4.1.9 Nurse This training will be done directly by the IT PM. The entire data collection
training process will be explained. After they will try themselves once each
48
The chefs and dietitian will report the progress of the menu creation
1.4.2 Menu creation providing the calendar for each blood type every week within the four weeks
of this phase
1.4.2.3 Supply The Operations PM will define the daily food order template that will be sent
chain to Aramark Spain for next day delivery.
1.4.2.6 Staff The chefs will lead the training for the 9 staff of the kitchen. Once it is done,
training the Operations PM will test the training once.
Quality Assurance
The quality assurance comprises those activities that monitor and verify that the processes used to
manage and create the deliverables are followed and are effective. The basic tools to manage quality
within the project and the frequency to do so are the following:
Meeting Meeting arrangement will take place for the project Every two weeks
performance. Led by the project manager and
followed by the managers
Every manager with their team will have team Once a month
meetings putting common ideas, issues and
questions
Weekly
49
Training will be identified and linked to job
description
Survey The patients tested will also receive a survey of the Once
service and the menu before delivering it
We have defined the key deliverables that have priority over the rest. We have selected them from the
WBS because the quality has to be hardly controlled, monitored and inspected and they are part of the
critical path within the project life-cycle. Also they might need to be improved at the certain point.
The following Deliverables Chart below contains information regarding the audits to perform, the
frequency, the acceptance criteria and the quality control (Y/N).
Deliverable
Quality
Name and Audits to Perform Frequency Acceptance Criteria
Control
Description
50
User is able to input record
The two testers
Tester experts are types into blockchain
will audit the
responsible of A list of blocks with a YES
work performed in
Blockchain supervising the timestamp are created
the middle of the
implementation implementation User restrictions are enabled Testing
implementation
on time and and participant and validator phase
and at the end of it
manner access is restricted, unless
Twice
authorized
The project
Data protection administrator and
regulation the IT project Unauthorized users are
Before blockchain
against data manager will audit unable to participate or
implementation YES
breaches within the fulfillment of access blocks
Once
internal or data protection User restrictions are enabled
external sources according to the
law
Comply with
Spain’s and EU The administrator
regulations in manager will
food and review the
Right after menus 100% of regulations have to
agriculture Aramark Spain YES
creation be performed
industries standards and
regarding policies and legal
food quality regulations
protection
51
The administrator
manager will
review the cost
checklist
IT PM and
Users are able to complete
Operations PM
deliverable sheet and each
are responsible for
Monitor and project manager is
scheduling of the Before a payment
control cost, responsible for submitting to
staff. They will is either pay or
human Person in Charge every 2
report that the receive. NO
resources, weeks
scheduling have Every week
schedule and Project Cost Estimate
been (Fridays)
budget Checklist has been approved
accomplished
Project Milestones Checklist
correctly and the
has been approved
PM administrator
will check the
budget and report
all to Aramark
CEO Spain
52
One testing with
Testing and the four meals of
Users are able to identify
tasting menus the day with
Once after the each blood-type diet is
on people with people of the four YES
menus are created matched with the correct
the 4 blood different blood
food types
types (Staff) type from the
hospital
In this part of the research paper we are going to list the tools we used for data gathering,
implementation and decision making; knowing that we used two main ways of data collection and
analysis.
Quantitative data which are considered as exploratory credible research that helps determine
objectives. Qualitative data which deals directly with quality in a descriptive way, and that is
considered as conclusive research within experimental and descriptive methods mostly gathered
through observations as they are immeasurable.
The following figure represents the tools used for data collection implemented in our business:
53
Data Gathering: Internal Quality Management Standards
Regarding Clients data collection in this case; Hospital de Montepríncipe, we designed a food service
survey in order to measure their satisfaction within catering service regarding hygiene and food safety
management (See Appendix A - Food Service Survey Sample for Client Hospital de Montepríncipe
and Appendix B - Nutrition Knowledge Test for Chefs and Dietitian).
Concerning our staff we have managed to design questionnaires for our staff members and chefs and
dietitian separately as they do not have the same professional level aspects to be tested on. We have
designed a questionnaire on reducing waste knowledge (See Appendix B - Nutrition Knowledge Test
for Chefs and Dietitian) for the staff members and nutrition knowledge for the chefs and dietitian (See
Appendix C - Reducing Waste Test), for the purpose of ensuring all staff members attend appropriate
food hygiene courses and understand its standards in order to create a culture of safety.
After collecting data for each specific requirement the results will be shown in histograms and
diagrams in order to define the next step of the improvement of the quality process.
54
The scoring on each exam paper for the staff members the chefs and dietitian should be above 5 to
pass otherwise they are obliged to retake the test or be replaced.
For the first deliverable which will be the blockchain, we will be testing the capability of nurses using
the technology to enter patient data to ensure we are having reliable data to rely on while creating
menus for each blood type. We have implemented an online test regarding all basic techniques used in
blockchain technology to make sure the nurses understand the following:
On the other hand, for the second phase, we will be selecting eight samples on whom we will test the
menus in a period of two weeks to see the reaction of food on their metabolism. As a quality
inspection and management tool we based our observation study on patients state in order to prepare
the right meal for their blood type taking into consideration patients with allergies in the second phase
of the experiment (See Appendix D - Menu Testing Sample on Hospital Patients (Consumer
Experience)) .
After the tests ends the results will help us define the level of quality for each deliverable, the nurses
must pass the test with a result superior to 5 otherwise another test will take place. In case of the menu
testing experiment on the samples throughout the 2 phases showed any negative effects, a quality food
55
inspection and data review will be held to identify the problem, as this diet is not suppose to
negatively affect the patient’s health for the main reason that this healthy diet is applicable without
any risk on all patients.
Management of Non-Conformities
Throughout the project lifecycle, our team will continuously ensure that the best quality is produced.
In the case where there are non-conformities we will produce the following through utilizing the Plan,
Do, Check and Act Cycle (PDCA). In the following table, each stage will describe the questions used
to manage any non-conformities and how we will carry those actions:
Stage Evaluation
By using the PDCA cycle, we can control and continuously improve our processes and the way we
carry out our work throughout the project timeline.
The risk management plan contains internal and external risks which are divided into four categories:
legal, project management, technology and operations. Our project team assessed these risks and
analyzed its probability of impact on the project. We have created responses and follow ups to
56
conduct qualitative and quantitative analysis to each risk evaluated using the following five mitigation
plans:
1. Prevention: mitigating the risk from the beginning through regular monitoring of the project
and ensuring that all objectives are met on time and on scope.
2. Transfer: this plan type refers to when there is a threat to the project. In this case, we will
transfer the risk over to a third party to manage the risk and absorb the impact if a threat
occurs.
3. Business Continuity: this plan type refers to if there is a change to the project objectives or the
business cannot perform under normal conditions
4. Escalate: this plan type is used when a specific higher executive must be informed of this risk
and the organization will deal with this risk as it is high ranking
5. Mitigation: this plan type ensures that if there is a negative project risk, it can be turned into
an opportunity and provide positive results
In the table below, we have identified various risk items pertaining to a specific risk category
(operational risk, information technology risk, project management risk, legal risk, operations risk and
stakeholder risk).
57
Chain permissions management and privacy: authorization may be given to too
Information
many staff members and information may be retrieved and provided to the
Technology
wrong users or to third parties
Project Management A member of the team decides to abandon the project
Information Strategic Risk: Aramark needs to evaluate whether or not we want to be the
Technology first to deploy this technology or wait until this technology matures
Data confidentiality risk: Although blockchain can only allow authorized
Information
access to view information, certain metadata may be available to network
Technology
participants
Legal A patient dies due to contamination of food
Stakeholder Wrong identification of stakeholders
Change in food diet or menu or food type from a stakeholder once the
Stakeholder
operations phase has started
Workers’ Compensation Insurance - accidents can have devastating
Operations
consequences on staff
Operations Chemical contamination to our suppliers warehouse
A competitor convince the hospital to be the catering and the hospital
Project Management
terminates the contract with Aramark
Lack of communication within the project regarding project development
Project Management
within the teams
With the risks listed above, we can further identify how we can assess each risk, what the potential
impact in the project is, the probability of occurrence, how we will respond the risk and include a
contingency for any risks that may happen.
58
Probability and Impact Analysis
Risk Response
If a risk occurs, we have various plans in place to ensure that each risk item has a specific response to
be implemented. We have five plan types in place (prevention plan, transfer plan, business continuity
59
plan, alert plan and mitigation plan), to ensure that we maintain high quality results, while ensuring
that the risks are clearly identified and resolved in a timely manner.
Aramark’s approach with utilizing the Prevention Plan ensures that the
organization approaches risks regularly. For example, if our suppliers
are unable to deliver foods, we regularly communicate with our
Prevention
suppliers to ensure that the food will be delivered on time and on the
delivery date. If communication is regular, we are able to identify the
risk before it happens and deploy a specific risk response
Our transfer plan ensures that we do not assume any risk during the risk
response period. For our technological risks, the insurance purchased
Transfer
prior to the project start date will allow Aramark to not hold
responsibility while the risk response will be deployed
During any event that the business cannot continue due to change in
project objectives as the business cannot reform under normal
conditions, we will evaluate the circumstances and provide a solution
Business Continuity
when assessment is complete. Aramark will be able to perform under
normal conditions, as there are back-up staff, back-up kitchens and
back-up technology involved.
In the event that a risk is extremely high, we will escalate the risk to our
Project Sponsor, who will then inform the legal department at Aramark.
Escalate
Due to the sensitive nature of some high risks, we will need Aramark as
an organization to deploy a risk response as an entire organization.
60
The risks our project may face are actively assessed (See Appendix H - Risk Matrix) , since the team
and project manager are working with the sponsor on a Monthly basis to ensure the identification of
analysis of whatever risks that could occur. In order to identify the risks, an evaluation of the
environmental factors will be conducted, considering the organization’s culture, project scope and
other key project documents such as; project deliverables, assumptions, constraints, work breakdown
structure (WBS), Cost/Time estimation and resource plan. In the risk analysis we have used
quantitative and qualitative methods, to identify possible project outcomes and come up with effective
response. for our risk management plan for each of the five risk types.
Qualitative Analysis
For the Qualitative analysis we have evaluated the impact of the different risk we have defined for the
project and the degree of impact they could have on the project. For the purpose of reducing levels of
uncertainty and focus on highest priority risks, using the following approach:
Risks that fall within the red and yellow zones will have risk response planning which may include
both a risk mitigation and a risk contingency plan.
Quantitative Analysis
For the Quantitative analysis we have selected events with the highest risks and rated each one based
on risk effects estimation on the project. below are the criteria we have used to classify the identified
risks.
61
Risk Follow-Up
A Meeting risk follow up will be held monthly with the sponsor, project management and project
team to discuss the weekly reported activities and actions in order to ensure the productivity and
effectiveness of the project. In addition, the project change request will be analyzed for the purpose to
identify possible impact on the project.
The following is an Agenda for the people that have approved risk management plan and the risk
follow up and response (See Appendix E - Risk Management Plan Approval). The Risk Management
Plan Approval template ensures that all stakeholders involved during the occurrence of the risk had
been clearly identified and take full responsibility. This template ensures that there is a follow up in
place after the identification of the risk to ensure that the risk was mobilized and controlled.
In both the communication and stakeholder plans, our project team identified possible communication
mediums to be carried out to all our stakeholders, which include potential participants according to
their interest, when and to which frequency they will be taking place. The information communication
matrix represents all details pertaining to the communication methods within our stakeholders. Each
stakeholder is expected to refer to the communications matrix to understand who is mandatory to
attend each meeting, conference or face-to-face. Nevertheless there is always a possibility of
communication failure, that is why we have come up with an issue log to be filled when needed
according to its importance.
1. Stakeholder Identification: this table outlines the specified stakeholder, their communication
needs, the delivery method and their responsibility
2. Stakeholder Engagement Approach: this table outlines the specified stakeholder, their purpose
and how to approach these stakeholders
Stakeholder Identification
62
Stakeholder Communication Method Responsibility
Need
Menu Project
Suppliers Food items checklist
components manager
Hospital de Project
Regular updates Status Reports
Montepríncipe manager
Project Project
Weekly updates Emails and meetings
Management manager
Communication/
milestone
Presentations during meetings Project team
updates
Procurement
Support and
Emails and conference calls Project team
assistance
Communication
including of
project value and Presentation at scheduled meetings Project team
Support and
Presentation at scheduled meetings Project team
assistance
Government
Inspection and Project
Inspectors/Ministry Site checks
audit manager
Inspectors
63
Stakeholder Engagement Approach
64
Request for information /
documents about future seek feedback
Government Ensure the application of all Risk key approach to help auditor
Inspectors/Ministry quality, regulatory and compliance work on the key concerning areas and
Inspectors standards minimize the audit risks
The stakeholder analysis matrix below outlines our important stakeholders through level of influence
and level of interest. We have determined that the highly influential and highly interested stakeholders
are our:
● Sponsor
● CEO Aramark
● Food Suppliers
● Project Management, and
● Procurement
65
Communication Matrix
The communications matrix below, outlines all communication mediums, when they will be
performed, the frequency and which stakeholders are involved in these mediums:
Communication Matrix
66
during inventory, menu creation
or any topics that the chefs
would like to discuss with
employees
Th change management
Project Manager
meeting is only held when there
Stakeholders
is a change request. If the
Change Either Operations
meeting is held, then the project In-person /
Management As needed or Technical
team needs to assess if the Face-to-face
Meetings Teams or both
scope change is necessary and
(depending on
if there are budget and/or
scope change)
timeline changes as well
Within this section, the plan determines if the planned communications steps are taking place in
reality. This monitoring and controlling activity will ensure that the messages are delivered to the
right member of the team, in the right way and also on time.
One of the tools available for every member of the project is the “Issue Log”. It contains records of
the stakeholder’s engagement issues during the project life-cycle. The responsible for right fulfilment
of this document is the project manager and it is as follows:
ID
Status
Priority
67
Issue Description
Department Involved
Estimated Resolution Date
Escalation Required? (Y/N)
Impact
Actions
Date Identified
Logged By
Actual Resolution/Completion Date
Final Resolution and Follow-up Actions
This template will also include the failure of communication methods that are being used. Therefore,
the project manager will review if there is a failure and the consequence will follow.
The criteria that determines the importance of an issue is defined in the next table:
Also, management from each team (IT, Operations, Procurement and etc.) have the expert judgement
in communication and soft skills to lead the members of their teams. Moreover, stakeholder
engagement plan must be followed very close to this plan. The main method to control
communication is through face-to-face meetings or through conference call, as they are the most
effective. During those meetings; arranged depending on what has been outlined in the
communication matrix, the project may create a separate project management project status meeting
to assess work performance. The work performance indicators of the project will also give us an idea
if the project is communicating properly.
Finally, the documented lessons learned from previous projects or the lessons learned register
produced from this project, will also determine the right monitoring within the project.
It is important to remember that the following documents must be updated from the project manager:
68
● Issue Log
● Lessons Learnt Register
● Stakeholder register (See Appendix I - Stakeholder Register)
Contractual Strategy
Aramark, Tu Dieta is committed in providing our client with the best quality, while meeting the
objectives. While risks may occur, Aramark, Tu Dieta has signed a contract with an insurance
company to ensure that if there is risk within our blockchain technology provided to Hospital de
Montepríncipe, we have a risk transfer policy in place.
Our client, Hospital de Montepríncipe understands the risks that may occur during testing and
deployment of our blockchain portion of the project. The client understands that we have a risk
transfer policy in place to transfer the risk from Aramark, Tu Dieta, to our insurance company: Marsh
& McLennan, in partnership with IBM.
Within the risk transfer policy, we have a signed agreement between our project manager, project
sponsor, COO International from Aramark head office and the president of HM Hospitales. We have
purchased an insurance policy that provides Aramark with coverage on:
The table below describes the exact employee responsible during the risk transfer, the responsibility
they hold and justification:
69
Name and Role Organization Responsibility & Justification
Virginia Martinez
Aramark, Tu The project manager must be involved, as Virginia has
Novillo, Project
Dieta prepared the insurance agreement with March &
Manager
McLennan at the start of the project and has spoken with
Aramark’s legal team. Virginia will work with Pablo,
the project sponsor to ensure that the contract with the
insurance company can be effectively immediately
Dr. Juan Abarca Juan understands the risk involved with blockchain
Cidón, President of HM Hospitales technology and understands the risk transfer policy as it
HM Hospitales will no longer be Aramark’s responsibility.
70
Make or Buy Analysis
Our table below describes the contracts that we possess, and whether we will create these contracts or
lend them to a third party:
Technology Team Our Aramark team has the subject matter experts
to ensure that the blockchain being created will
be fully tested and implemented properly
71
Criteria for the selection of suppliers
We have identified the criteria for how Aramark, Tu Dieta will select its suppliers to maintain the
highest quality of products and to ensure the suppliers chosen adhere to the quality standards (See
Appendix F - Supplier Selection Criteria Chart) and values that we hold as an organization:
In the event that a risk occurs, the table below outlines how the risk will be managed with the two
contracts below:
72
contract
A signed clause of
Food contamination health and safety Mitigation
policy
After selecting our supplier through assessing the criteria for supplier selection and selecting our
suppliers, we have created control and procurement performance review to ensure that each party has
met their contractual obligation.
Important Notes:
73
Procurement
Manager
Name:
Procurement
Manager
Signature:
Date:
The Procurement Manager must submit this document to the Director of Procurement Aramark,
Tu Dieta to receive approval of this document. Ensuring that the contractual terms are agreed
upon, and to monitor any defects, lack of communication and to monitor any fallouts will be
tracked on this supplier performance analysis
Below is our project team’s supplier contract that describes the terms and conditions:
Supplier Contract
74
This agreement is dated as of ______________________________ by and between Aramark, Tu Dieta hereinafter CONTRACTOR and
____________________________ hereinafter called VENDOR.
The VENDOR and CONTRACTOR, in consideration of the mutual covenants hereinafter set forth, agrees as follows:
ARTICLE 1. PRODUCTS
VENDOR shall provide all products as specified or indicated in the Contract Documents. VENDOR shall supply and deliver food
products to ARAMARK TU DIETA to the following address _______________________ (Hospital Address) ________________________
ARTICLE 2. CONTRACT TIME
The food deliveries shall be in accordance with this Agreement, and are to be completed as specified in the contract.
ARTICLE 3. CONTRACT PRICE
ARAMARK TU DIETA shall pay the VENDOR for delivery of food products in accordance with CONTRACTOR’S bid, which is
attached hereto. ARAMARK TU DIETA shall pay VENDOR net 7 days from date of delivery unless other terms of payment are
agreed upon.
ARTICLE 4. INVOICE PROCEDURES
Invoices for payment with appropriate supporting documents shall be sent to the following address:
Calle de la Senda del Infante, 28, 28035 Madrid, SPAIN
ARTICLE 5. CONTRACTOR’S REPRESENTATIONS
In order to induce ARAMARK TU DEITA to enter into this Agreement, CONTRACTOR makes the following representations:
5.1 VENDOR has examined and carefully studied the Contract Documents and all other related data identified in the Bidding
Documents.
5.2 VENDOR is familiar with and is satisfied as to all federal, state and local laws and regulations that may affect cost, progress,
performance and furnishing of the products.
ARTICLE 6. CONTRACT DOCUMENTS
The Contract Documents, which comprise the entire agreement between ARAMARK TU DIETA and the VENDOR concerning the
work, consist of the following:
There are no Contract Documents other than those listed above in this Article 6. The Contract Documents may only be amended,
modified or supplemented by written agreement between both parties.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, ARAMARK TU DIETA and VENDOR have signed this Agreement. One counterpart each has been delivered
to ARAMARK TU DIETA and VENDOR. This Agreement will be effective NOVEMBER 1, 2020
75
Restrictions and Assumptions
Below are the restrictions during the procurement management phase, as well as, assumptions that are
accounted for when considering our suppliers and what needs to be done in order for the process to be
seamless.
Restrictions Assumptions
Procurement Matrix
76
Deliverable Cost Method of Payment Tolerance
25% advanced/75% once the
Menu Creation 1,500.67 150.07
delivery is confirmed
25% advanced/75% once the
Business Case
1,500.00 delivery/milestone is 150.00
Approval
confirmed
Beginning of the training
Data Protection 1,500.67 150.07
phase
Technology
1,000.00 Beginning 100.00
Protection
The purpose of our change management plan is to include details and information that will entail what
must be done during a change request or if any changes occur that are outside of the scope defined in
the beginning of the project. We have outlined the processes of how to submit a change request, as
well as, including information on who is responsible for handling these such requests.
The change request template that must be filled out by the Project Manager and submitted to the
Project Sponsor with the working team’s approval that the work can be completed. The change
77
request template must outline all the details and aspects that may be changed, the timeline and etc.
(See Appendix G - Change Request Template).
Below are the tables that describes each project team members responsibility within the project
78
79
Change Request Process
At Aramark, we strive to ensure that our clients are satisfied or beyond satisfied with the catering
service that we offer. In the case that there is a complaint, we have a claims and complaints protocol
that our claims management team adheres to. It is divided into different categories, depending on
whether the complaint is received from our internal partners or external clients. Our internal partners
are our shareholders and employees and our external partners are our clients and the receiving
end-user.
Internal Stakeholders
80
Shareholders Employees
We are committed to ensuring our shareholders Aramark is committed in ensuring its employees
are satisfied with the work we do at Aramark. have a safe space to be open about various
situations in the workplace or if there is a
If our shareholder has a complaint within the complaint. We encourage our employees to speak
organization, we adhere to the Shareholder’s up, so we can provide a solution in a timely and
Complaint Management Policy. All complaints efficient manner.
must be submitted to the specific Claims &
Complaints Management representative for legal Our employees must go through the following
advisory. steps depending on the complaint type:
External Stakeholders
81
Clients Receiving end-user
At Aramark, we are committed in ensuring our We are committed to ensuring the end-users of
clients are satisfied with its workplace and the our products from our clients are satisfied with
policies we adhere to. Our procedure for handling what we do at Aramark.
client complaints are as follows:
If the receiving end-user has a complaint, they
1. Receive complaint from client directly must first go to the client where they initially
from the People Manager at our Aramark received the service and submit a claim there or
location go to our website:
2. The Regional Manager of Aramark will aramark.com/other/contact-us/customer-service
assess the complaint for General Support. The website will populate a
3. All complaints must have a solution form that the receiving end-user must fill out to
within 7 business days include details of the complaint, their name,
4. Corrective actions will be provided email, Aramark location, zip/postal code and a
5. A follow-up will be conducted to ensure representative will be in contact with this client
that the complaint was fulfilled type within 2 business days. Resolution of the
complaint is dependent on the actual complaint
itself.
Once the change request has been identified, the following flow chart describes the process of how the
change request is submitted and assessed:
82
Conclusion
Our project team has demonstrated the use of the project management book of knowledge within all
phases of our project. Aramark, Tu Dieta, a strategic business unit stemmed from Aramark, strived to
resolve the technological and consumer healthcare problems in hospitals. We aim to provide a
significant reliability on resources while achieving a sustainable sector development for a better
quality of life.
Throughout the present plan, we have assumed a series of hypotheses under which the project is
developed. Under these assumptions the project has a good profitability and is viable.
Every business plan arises from an idea that arises from a need on the part of an agent. Once it has
been detected, a prior feasibility study must be carried out.
83
But this document does not contain such a process. The idea has arisen a priori and has proceeded to
make the management project thesis. It is, from now on, where it can be analyzed if in real life it
would be interesting to implement it.
With this we want to transmit that it is the person who reads this document who must really decide
whether to undertake this project or not.
Here are some hypotheses listed which have not been entered in detail due to difficulty:
Blockchain technology has been introduced as a fundamental pillar of the project. The implementation
of the technology has been estimated in time and cost after a superficial analysis of the market. Due to
the novelty of this service, it is not easy to find data about it. Also, this project has very particular
characteristics, so it is almost impossible to have obtained information from any other comparable
project.
The project is implemented in Spain, specifically in Madrid by an American company. A priori this
may give rise to doubts as the market study has not been carried out extensively. The hypothesis about
the decision of the location of the hospital has been like a pilot for the multinational because we know
the Spanish health market, and that will be transferred to other countries once it has been finished in
the Hospital de Monteprincipe.
Bibliography
https://www.hematology.org/Patients/Basics/
84
Project Management Institute. (2004). A guide to the project management body of knowledge
http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/128830/e94549.pdf
https://www.babymed.com/pregnancy/blood-type-and-rh-rhesus-status-countries
Marian, J. (2019). Blood type distribution by country in Europe. [online] Jakubmarian.com. Retrieved
from: https://jakubmarian.com/blood-type-distribution-by-country-in-europe/
Appendix
85
2- What do you usually base your choices on while selecting food for your patients?
3- Are you satisfied with the amount of food served?
❍ Yes ❍ No
4- Are you satisfied with the appearance of food served?
❍ Yes ❍ No
5- Are you satisfied with the temperature of food?
❍ Yes ❍ No
6- Are you satisfied with the taste of food served?
❍ Yes ❍ No
7- Are you satisfied with the time of meals serving?
❍ Yes ❍ No
8- From 1 to 5 what is your level of satisfaction within our service?
(5= excellent / 1= poor)
❍ 1 ❍ 2 ❍ 3 ❍ 4 ❍ 5
86
5. Which food has the highest calories?
6. Which food has the highest unsaturated fat?
7. Which food has more added salt?
8. List the food limitations for each blood type?
● Blood type A
● Blood type B
● Blood type AB
● Blood type O
❍ Cartoon
❍ Waste basket
❍ Old bucket
❍ Plastic bag
❍ Tin/Can
❍Other………………………………………..
Phase 1
87
Week 1 Week 2
Sample
Blood Type Meal Patient’s Meal Patient’s
Comments Comments
Component State Component State
Type A
Type B
Type AB
Type O
Phase 2
Week 1 Week 2
Sample Blood
Type Meal Patient’s Meal Patient’s
Comments Comments
Component State Component State
Type A with
allergies/chronic
conditions
Type B with
allergies/chronic
conditions
Type O with
allergies/chronic
conditions
88
Appendix E - Risk Management Plan Approval
Adherence to instructions
Timeliness
Completeness
Overall response
Average score
Company Information
Financial viability
Organisation structure
89
Experience with similar companies
Service department
References
Partnerships
Average score
Project understanding
Average score
Requirements
Average score
Technology is sustainable
Product roadmap
Average score
Vendor demonstration
Resources availability
Proper training
Certificate
Support
90
Average score
Fee Summary
Vegetables / Fruits
Seafood
Average score
Scorecard
Requirements min 8
Total score
91
Requirements min 8
Total score
Scorecard
Requirements min 8
Total score
92
Appendix G - Change Request Template
93
Appendix H - Risk Matrix
4 16
Date March 22th
93
4 16
Date March 22th
Nutrition information regarding allergen and Chefs and Periodically, While creating the
OPERATIONS 5 2 10 Prevention Plan
dietary disclosures dietitian Menus
Chain permissions management and privacy:
To mitigate: to appoint the less
authorization may be given to too many staff Continuous quality management
IT 5 2 10 users as posibble to reduce the PM
members and information may be retrieved and control
likelihood of a breach
provided to the wrong users or to third parties
To mitigate: bonus according to
A member of the team decides to abandon the
PM 4 2 8 project outcome achivement PM During the execution
project
and soft skills
Strategic Risk: Aramark needs to evaluate
whether or not we want to be the first to deploy Prevent / Business Continuity Planning Phase. Review at the
IT 4 2 8 PM
this technology or wait until this technology Plan beginning of each new phase
matures
Data confidentiality risk: Although blockchain
can only allow authorized access to view Aramark Legal
IT 4 2 8 Prevention Plan Continuous quality management
information, certain metadata may be available Department
to network participants
Aramark Legal
LEGAL A patient dies due to contamination of food 5 1 6 Prevention Plan Continous quality management
Department
94
4 16
Date March 22th
Staff and
Chemical contamination to our suppliers
OPERATIONS 2 3 6 Escalate operations’ Continously
warehouse
manager
Law
EEF Political law changes 4 1 4 Accept Periodically
departement
95
4 16
Date March 22th
96
Date Project Category
01/28/2019 Implementation of a new service
97
Date Project Category
01/28/2019 Implementation of a new service
98
Date Project Category
01/28/2019 Implementation of a new service
99
Date Project Category
01/28/2019 Implementation of a new service
100
Appendix I - Stakeholder Register
Identification Information Interest Classification Stakeholder Classification
Level of Influence Level of Interest Engagement Phase of Greatest
Name Position Organization Location Role in Project Expectations Requirements Internal / External Defender / Neutral / Opponent
(1 - 10) (1 - 10) (max. 100) Interest
We require support from
That the budget and our Project Sponsor in the
Pablo Alcalá President Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Project Sponsor requirement needs are case that there are change 10 10 100 All Phases Internal Defender
met in a timely manner requests or budget
changes
The project lifecycle must Ensure that any issues are
meet client expectations, resolved and provide
Virginia Martinez Novillo Project Manager Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Project Team 10 10 100 All Phases Internal Defender
while meeting budget, project support to the rest
schedule and objectives of the project team
Ensure that any issues are
The Operations objectives
resolved and provide
Rim Youssefi Operations Manager Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Project Team are met and delivered in a 10 10 100 All Phases Internal Defender
project support to the rest
timely manner
of the project team
Ensure that any issues are
The IT objectives are met
resolved and provide
Jessica Joy Opinaldo IT Manager Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Project Team and delivered in a timely 10 10 100 All Phases Internal Defender
project support to the rest
manner
of the project team
Provide client with the
Aramark must provide
proper amount of food
Gabriela Smith Inventory Manager Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team correct inventory 9 9 81 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
supply needed daily,
informaton
weekly and monthly
Provide client with the Aramark must provide
proper amount of food correct inventory
Bob Spalding Representative Produce Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team 9 9 81 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply needed daily, informaton and must be
weekly and monthly paid in a timely manner
Provide client with the Aramark must provide
proper amount of food correct inventory
Jackie Kern Representative Meat Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team 9 9 81 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply needed daily, informaton and must be
weekly and monthly paid in a timely manner
Provide client with the Aramark must provide
proper amount of food correct inventory
Teni Panossian Representative Fish & Seafood Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team 9 9 81 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply needed daily, informaton and must be
weekly and monthly paid in a timely manner
Provide the project with
Auditing Department, auditing to ensure that
Veronika Dani Lead Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver To get paid 9 8 72 All Phases Internal Defender
Aramark Spain quality is met to the
highest standards
Provide the project with
insight on proper
sanitation requirements
Brenda Osoteo Sanitary Inspector Ministry of Labour Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver To get paid 9 8 72 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
and ensure that our
project team meets these
requirements
Provide client and
Aramark with proper food
Luis Silva Procurement Manager Produce Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team To get paid 8 9 72 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply according to
inventory results
Provide client and
Aramark with proper food
Paulo Tena Procurement Manager Meat Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team To get paid 8 9 72 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply according to
inventory results
Provide client and
Aramark with proper food
Alejandro Aravaca Procurement Manager Fish & Seafood Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team To get paid 8 9 72 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
supply according to
inventory results
Provide Aramark with the
Erika Ocampo Lawyer Produce Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team best contract option To get paid 8 9 72 Initiation Phase External Neutral
available
Provide Aramark with the
Olivia Mace Lawyer Meat Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team best contract option To get paid 8 9 72 Initiation Phase External Neutral
available
Provide Aramark with the
Marianella Natasha Lawyer Fish & Seafood Supplier Madrid, Spain Procurement Team best contract option To get paid 8 9 72 Initiation Phase External Neutral
available
Hospital de
Alvaro Bardem Lawyer Madrid, Spain Client Team 8 8 64 Initiation Phase External Neutral
Montepríncipe
Hospital de
Javier Muñez IT Department Lead Madrid, Spain Client Team 7 7 49 Blockchain Creation Phase External Neutral
Montepríncipe
Competitor Competitor Eurest Services Madrid, Spain Competitor 7 7 49 All Phases External Opponent
Competitor Competitor Mallorca Catering Madrid, Spain Competitor 7 7 49 All Phases External Opponent
Sanitary Department of
Vanessa Cortes Lead Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver 9 5 45 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Spain
Chloe Kim Sanitary Inspector Ministry of Health Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver 9 5 45 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Simon Jones Representative Ministry of Health Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver 8 5 40 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Melissa Kostanecki Certification Unit Lead Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver 8 5 40 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Rasike Suraweera Representative ISO Madrid, Spain Reviewer and Approver 8 5 40 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Lorelie Pena Lawyer Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Legal Team 8 5 40 All Phases Internal Defender
Victoria Chan Accountant Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Finance Team 8 5 40 All Phases Internal Defender
Margarita Velasco Finance Analyst Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Finance Team 8 5 40 All Phases Internal Defender
Hospital de
Lena Abdou Accountant Madrid, Spain Finance Team 8 5 40 All Phases External Neutral
Montepríncipe
101
Identification Information Interest Classification Stakeholder Classification
Level of Influence Level of Interest Engagement Phase of Greatest
Name Position Organization Location Role in Project Expectations Requirements Internal / External Defender / Neutral / Opponent
(1 - 10) (1 - 10) (max. 100) Interest
Hospital de
Robert Nguyen Finance Analyst Madrid, Spain Finance Team 8 5 40 All Phases External Neutral
Montepríncipe
Lola Suarez Test Analyst Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain IT Team 7 5 35 Blockchain Creation Phase Internal Defender
Blanca Cruz Developer Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain IT Team 7 5 35 Blockchain Creation Phase Internal Defender
Jonathan Silvermann Business Analyst Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain IT Team 7 5 35 Blockchain Creation Phase Internal Defender
Eric J. Foss Chief Executive Officer Aramark Global Toronto, Canada Reviewer 4 8 32 Initiation Phase Internal Defender
Chief Executive Officer and Aramark Northern
Frank Gleeson Dublin, Ireland Reviewer 4 8 32 Initiation Phase Internal Defender
Region President Europe
Dr. Juan Abarca Cidón President HM Hospitales Madrid, Spain Approver 5 5 25 Initiation Phase External Neutral
Javier Reguera Control and New Projects HM Hospitales Madrid, Spain Approver 5 5 25 All Phases External Neutral
Financial Management and
Rafael Beltrán HM Hospitales Madrid, Spain Approver 5 5 25 All Phases External Neutral
Corporate Development
Sara Vergara Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Sandra Ramírez Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Julio Gonzalez Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
John Hill Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Desi Velasquez Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Roman Gutierrez Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Bill Stratford Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Vanessa Lopez Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Atta Chang Staff Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Roberta Cruz Dietition Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 3 8 24 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Bob Hemmingway Chef Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 8 8 16 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Joanne Smith Chef Aramark Spain Madrid, Spain Operations Team 8 8 16 Menu Creation Phase Internal Defender
Hospital de
Patients End-Users Madrid, Spain End-User 2 7 14 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Montepríncipe
Hospital de
Nurses End-Users Madrid, Spain End-User 2 7 14 Menu Creation Phase External Neutral
Montepríncipe
Joanne Velasco Insurance Specialist Marsh & McLennan Madrid, Spain Insurance Team 1 5 5 Blockchain Creation Phase External Neutral
102