Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Buildings CM 0220
Buildings CM 0220
43
BY
KATIE COBURN, JOHN FOX, KAILEIGH PEYTON,
KEVIN SCHULTZ, AND AMANDA BOYD WALTERS
Built Original Use Current Use Architectural Style
Circa 1820 Private home Museum Federal in the Palladian style
Significance Designated as a National Historic Landmark in 1976, this stately downtown residence-turned-museum was originally
commissioned by businessman and two-term Cincinnati mayor Martin Baum, though a financial crisis meant he couldn’t complete
the project. Prominent Cincinnati lawyer and winemaker Nicholas Longworth acquired the residence in 1829 and notably hired
African-American artist Robert S. Duncanson to paint the foyer’s still-intact and carefully preserved landscape murals. Iron tycoon
David Sinton later bought the house and passed it to his daughter Anna. She and her husband, Charles P. Taft, half-brother of William
H. Taft (who famously made his presidential nomination acceptance speech from the home’s portico in 1908), filled the home with
what was then one of the world’s most valuable art collections. They donated the home and art to the people of Cincinnati, opening
the museum to the public in 1932.
Next The Taft marks its bicentennial by refurbishing the building’s exterior siding; removing, repairing, and reinstalling windows and
shutters; and overhauling its ventilation system to better regulate temperature and humidity. The historic galleries will be closed
October 2020 through February 2021, but approximately 80 works from the museum’s permanent collection will remain on display in
the Fifth Third Gallery throughout the process.
P H O T O G R A P H : M U S I C R O O M , H O M E O F C H A R L E S A N D A N N A T A F T, A B O U T 1 9 2 5 . C O U R T E S Y O F T H E T A F T M U S E U M O F A R T A R C H I V E S
45
Architectural Style
Federal with touches of
Greek Revival
Significance The
oldest surviving brick
building in Northern
Kentucky was built by
Thomas Carneal, one of
Covington’s founders,
though he never lived
in it. The Greek-style
columns here and on
neighboring homes in
the Licking Riverside
Historic District offered
CARNEAL HOUSE, SECOND STREET, COVINGTON a touch a class in the
frontier era.
Built Original Use Current Use
1815 Private home Same
P H OTO G R A P H S ( TO P ) BY B R I T TA N Y D E X T E R / ( M I D D L E ) BY PA I S L E Y S TO N E / ( B OT TO M ) C O U R T E SY K E N TO N C O U N T Y P U B L I C L I B R A R Y / I L LU S T R AT I O N BY C AT S I M S
INGALLS BUILDING, FOURTH AND
VINE STS., DOWNTOWN
Built Original Use Current Use
1903 Office tower Converting to hotel
P H OTO G R A P H S ( TO P ) BY C I N C I N N AT I M U S E U M C E N T E R /G E T T Y I M AG E S / ( B OT TO M ) BY PA I S L E Y S TO N E
47
Significance At 49 stories and 574 feet tall, Carew Tower reigned as Cincinnati’s tallest building until 2011,
when Great American Tower was completed. Registered as a National Historic Landmark, it was the first
large-scale mixed-use commercial development of its kind in the U.S., known as a “city within a city.”
Next According to USA Today, owners submitted plans in 2017 to convert part of the building into condo
units. Carew management declined to comment on the status of future development.
Significance Despite
spectacular exterior and
interior design work,
TIMES-STAR BUILDING, EIGHTH Union Terminal was a
AND BROADWAY STS., DOWNTOWN little late to the heyday
of passenger train travel
Built Original Use Current Use and a little too far from
1933 Newspaper presses Hamilton County downtown to spur devel-
and offices courts and offices opment. Its current life
as home to five muse-
ums and an OMNIMAX
Architectural Style Art Deco
movie theater, though,
Significance This building was commissioned is Cincinnati’s best
example of “adaptive
by the Taft family to house Cincinnati’s third daily
newspaper, The Times-Star. Its decorative details, reuse”—boosted by a
from ornate front doors and lobby to stylized carv- 2014 sales tax levy that
funded most of the $228
ings of animals and historic figures, reward close
million upgrade.
UNION TERMINAL, WEST END
observation. The pyramid roof would later inspire
Procter & Gamble’s twin tower design.
Next Rehabbed exhibit
Next Hamilton County has considered selling the Built Original Use Current Use Architectural Style space will continue to
building. Could a developer swoop in and convert 1933 Train station Cincinnati Art Deco come back online
it to residential? Stay tuned. Museum Center throughout this year.
I L LU S T R AT I O N BY C AT S I M S / P H OTO G R A P H C O U R T E SY C I N C I N N AT I M U S E U M C E N T E R
URT PLATTE, FOUNDER
of Over-the-Rhine-based
A RENAISSANCE
Platte Architecture + Design,
has a soft spot for the historic
neighborhood. As an undergraduate archi-
MAN
tecture student at Miami University in the
1980s, his first project was reimagining a
whole block of OTR along Vine Street. “So
Over-the-Rhine was pretty dear to my
heart,” he says in the conference room of
Architect Kurt Platte embraces the design and funding his sleekly modernist offices near Findlay
challenges inherent in Over-the-Rhine historic renova- Market. “But it sure didn’t look like the re-
tions. — S T E V E N RO SE N
naissance that would save Over-the-Rhine
was going to happen in my lifetime.”
The renaissance is in fact happening, and
now entering a busy new decade. Platte and
P H O T O G R A P H B Y A A R O N M . C O N W AY
49
P H OTO G R A P H S C O U R T E SY P L AT T E A R C H I T E C T U R E + D E S I G N
BUNGALOW, VERNE AVENUE, OAKLEY
Built Original Use Current Use Architectural Style
1924 Private home Same Craftsman Bungalow
Significance These
simple one-and-a-half
story houses sprang
up as starter homes in
Norwood, Oakley, Pleas-
ant Ridge, Bellevue, and
other neighborhoods
seeing explosive growth
in the early 20th century.
Most have a first floor
exterior of brick or stone,
topped by wood shingles,
clapboard, or siding.
P H OTO G R A P H S ( TO P ) BY B R I T TA N Y D E X T E R / ( M I D D L E ) C O U R T E SY S U S A N R I S S OV E R / ( B OT TO M ) BY J E N K AWA N A R I
51
Covington-
Newport
Townhouse, Greer
Street, Covington
Built Original Use Current Use
1850s–1890s Single-family home Single-family or
multifamily dwelling
Next Many were split into multifamily units throughout the 1900s but are
now being renovated and converted back into single-family dwellings.
P H OTO G R A P H BY D E V Y N G L I S TA / I L LU S T R AT I O N BY C AT S I M S
DESIGNS ON
THE FUTURE
DAAP architecture students are taught to think outside of the computer and to keep
their options open. — L E Y L A SHOKO OH E
RCHITECTS FOCUS ON
more than just the physical
buildings we inhabit. They
consider human interac-
tions with and within each space and
how a space fits in context with the rest
of the street, city, and world. Within the
University of Cincinnati’s College of
Design, Architecture, Art, and Planning
(DAAP), the School of Architecture and
Interior Design (SAID) takes a—par-
don the pun—building block approach
to training the field’s next generation.
“Our focus, especially at the under-
graduate level, [really goes] back to ba-
sics—critical thinking, design thinking,
problem-solving—that are much more
universal components,” says Melanie
Swick, DAAP’s undergraduate archi-
tecture program coordinator and an as-
sistant professor. “Then when you’re in
a particular project and looking to solve
some of the basic challenges, you have
the tools to do that.”
Those basic tools are built into fresh-
man year “foundations” courses and el-
emental design labs that the rest of un-
dergraduate coursework is predicated
upon. “All first year, everything is done
by hand,” says Sam Sepaniak, a second-
year architecture student. “It makes
sense, because it teaches you a different
way to design, rather than being trapped
in the computer, which I like a lot.”
DAAP’s bachelor of science in ar-
chitecture program features an intense,
four-year curriculum, with three re-
P H O T O G R A P H B Y A A R O N M . C O N W AY
53
MANAGING
quired semester-long cooperative » Beth Johnson, who joined the City of Cincinnati
education experiences. The co-op it- as urban conservator in 2016, has a window to the
CHANGE
self—which sends students to spend mistakes of the past. Literally. Her office overlooks
a semester working 35 hours a week Queensgate, once the site of Kenyon-Barr, a his-
in paid positions—is a UC inven- torically African-American neighborhood that
was emptied and razed in the 1960s under the
tion, dating back to 1906. Students Beth Johnson juggles the past, guise of urban renewal. We spoke with Johnson
get their first assignment in the
the present, and the future to about the nature of her work and how it impacts
spring of their sophomore year, then the architecture that defines our city today.
alternate semesters working and do- keep Cincinnati’s architectural
ing coursework thereafter. The real- fabric intact. CAN YOU GIVE ME A THUMBNAIL EXPLANATION OF WHAT
THE HISTORIC CONSERVATION OFFICE DOES? Every
world experience and exposure to — L I N DA VAC C A R I E L L O
historic district and historic landmark has conservation
prospective employers make co-ops guidelines that help the architect or designer know what’s
attractive for students considering appropriate. Our staff works with designers, architects,
DAAP, which in 2012 was ranked the owners, and developers to make sure that changes they
No. 3 design school in the world by make follow those guidelines.
Business Insider. “It was a huge drive WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONSERVATION AND PRESERVATION? Conservation is about managing change
for me that UC had co-ops because [through] adaptive reuse or rehabilitation. Preservation is about keeping it as it is.
I feel like nowadays you can have the
grades and the projects and every- FOR EXAMPLE? The Harriet Beecher Stowe House is more a matter of preservation—they’re trying to represent
thing, but what makes you stand out what the house was like when Stowe was there. A good example of conservation is Music Hall, a rehabilitation
project where there were changes to the building to make it a better use for the current tenants.
to [prospective] employers is your
experience,” says Sepaniak. YOU CAME HERE AFTER SERVING AS DEPUTY HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER FOR AUSTIN, TEXAS. WERE THERE
Preparing students for the real ANY SURPRISES, ARCHITECTURALLY SPEAKING, WHEN YOU TOOK THIS JOB? I grew up in Dayton and had worked
world in-house is a delicate balanc- in Covington. When I came back to the area, I considered this my home. But I do remember when I first came to
ing act. Hand-design skills are im- interview for the job in Covington, I was just overwhelmed by the amount of Italianate architecture. It was just
overwhelming the amount of [historic] fabric that exists on both sides of the river.
portant, but so is learning how to use
software like AutoCAD, Revit, and THE MOST CONTENTIOUS RECENT ISSUE WAS CERTAINLY THE DEMOLITION OF THE DENNISON HOTEL DOWNTOWN.
Rhino, while remembering the field’s THAT WAS WHEN YOU WERE NEW ON THE JOB. It was
fundamental purpose is putting roofs within the first month of me starting. So, you know,
over our collective heads.“The obvi- baptism by fire. In historic preservation you don’t
always win every case, but what I learned was that the
ous changes [in this field] are digital historic preservationists here are amazing.
fabrication, technology, how work is
produced,” says Ed Mitchell, associ- IN AREAS LIKE OVER-THE-RHINE, WHERE REHABBING
ate professor and director of SAID. OLD PROPERTIES AND NEW INFILL CONSTRUCTION ARE
“We don’t see ourselves as just tech- BOTH GOING ON, WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS WHEN
PROPOSALS COME TO YOU? Our guidelines address
nical people. We’re trying to create things like window placement, materials, setbacks,
themes and narratives that guide de- and verticality, because OTR buildings tend to be taller
sign decisions. That’s a really diffi- than they are wide. Basically, what elements should be
cult thing to learn, but a fundamental incorporated into the building. We don’t expect new
skill to an architect.” buildings to be built in an Italianate style. We don’t want
to create a false sense of history. We look at compat-
Architecture principles bleed ibility. We want people to be able to look at a building
into other design fields, and an in- and say it fits in and supports the historic district.
creasingly expansive educational
approach—a new architectural en- IN THE DAYTON STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT IN THE WEST
END, SOMEONE IS ATTEMPTING TO TURN A CHURCH
gineering degree in UC’s College of
INTO A CLIMBING GYM. WHAT’S THE CONSERVATION-
Engineering and Applied Science, for IST’S VIEW? Churches are really hard to reuse, and
example—helps broaden the hori- part of the challenge is figuring out how to program
zon of post-graduate career options. them. We’ve had some successes in Over-the-Rhine
“Some DAAP architect graduates go with The Transept and Taft’s Ale House. But you have to
into landscape design or experien- be creative. When the people working on the climbing
gym came to me, I said, Yes, let’s see how we can make this work. I really hope that they’re successful. Churches
tial design and pop-up shops,” says are landmarks in these communities. The steeples are part of the skyline.
Sepaniak. “People design sets for
Coachella and music festivals. There AS YOU LEARN ABOUT CINCINNATI’S HISTORY, ARE THERE THINGS WE’VE LOST IN THE PAST THAT MAKE YOU
are lots of different opportunities for THINK, WE CAN’T LET THAT HAPPEN AGAIN? Every day I look over there [at Queensgate]. That’s a whole neigh-
architects these days.” borhood [Kenyon-Barr] lost, and we’ll never get it back. And I know that’s still having repercussions generations
later on the people who lived there.
I L LU S T R AT I O N BY L A R S L E E TA R U
Bavarian Brewing Company /
Kenton County Government
Center, Covington
Built Original Use Current Use
1903–1909, 2019 Brewery Kenton County offices
Significance Covington’s Bavarian Brewing Company was a big player in the beer business for 100
years. Its remaining castle-like structure features brick corbeling, a crenelated parapet wall, and a tow-
er. Kenton County stepped in when the owner wanted to demolish the building, which housed a nightclub
in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Now it’s attached to the new Kenton County Government Center by a
glass-walled connector and ramps. While preserving a historic building wasn’t the point of the project,
Kenton County Judge/Executive Kris Knochelmann says, “It was a nice benefit.”
Next Creating a community gathering place. “The Riedlin-Schott Room will hold 150 people, and it will
be a community space,” says Knochelmann, praising Ried Schott, whose family once owned the brewery,
for his $250,000 contribution to help showcase Bavarian’s history.
P H OTO G R A P H S ( TO P ) BY D E V Y N G L I STA / ( B OT TO M ) CO U R T E SY K E N TO N CO U N T Y P U B L I C L I B R A RY
55
CINCINNATI SHAKESPEARE
COMPANY, 12TH AND ELM STS.,
OVER-THE-RHINE
Built Original Use Current Use
2017 Theater Same
Architectural Style
One of a kind
P H O T O G R A P H S ( T O P ) C O U R T E S Y C I N C I N N AT I S H A K E S P E A R E C O M PA N Y / I L L U S T R AT I O N B Y C AT S I M S / ( B O T T O M L E F T ) B Y D E V Y N G L I S TA / ( B O T T O M R I G H T ) B Y PA I S L E Y S T O N E