Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HBO Chapter 9 - Performance Management and Rewards
HBO Chapter 9 - Performance Management and Rewards
How individuals and groups do their jobs is the main concern of those managing
organizations. It is easy to predict what will happen to organizations when members are
not performing effectively and efficiently. The task of management is to make sure that
every member is doing what is expected of them. How management will go about
doing this task is the aim of performance management. Since the principal means
designed to motivate employees to perform is the reward system, it will be included in
the discussions that will follow.
“Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for
human masters, since you know that you will receive an inheritance from the Lord as a
reward. It is the Lord Christ you are serving.” Colossians 3:23-24
Apart from economic incentives, the other means used to improve employee
performance are:
1. Goal setting
2. Streamlined organizational structure
3. Better technology
4. New arrangements of working schedules
5. High involvement of employees
6. Better motivation of employees
A key element of the HR strategic planning is the staffing function which implements the
provision of qualified people to the identified job openings.
STAFFING
Effective performance begins with getting the right people, and then providing them
with the right environment. To achieve this, the staffing function of the organization must be
well implemented.
Staffing refers to the HR planning, acquisition, and development aimed at providing the
talent necessary for organizational success. The staffing process consists of the following:
1. Job analysis
2. Recruitment
3. Selection
4. Socialization
Job Analysis
The process of staffing starts with an understanding of the positions or jobs for which
individuals are needed in the organization. Job analysis is a technical procedure used
to define the duties, responsibilities, and accountabilities of a job.
The job description contains information concerned with the job. The information
include job duties and responsibilities, equipment and materials used, working
conditions and hazards, supervision, work schedules, standards of performance, and
relationships to other jobs.
To meet the job requirements specified in the job description, the job specification is
derived. In a typical job specification, requirements about the following are indicated:
1. Education and experience;
2. Technical knowledge;
3. Physical aptitudes and abilities;
4. Interpersonal and communication skills;
5. Analytical aptitudes and abilities; and
6. Creative abilities.
Recruitment
After job analysis, the next step in the staffing process is the drawing of people to apply
for the various positions identified. This step is called recruitment and it may be defined
as a human resource management practice designed to locate and attract job
applicants for particular positions.
Internal Recruitment. It is a process for attracting job applicants from those currently
working for the firm.
The computerized career progression system (CCPS) is one that stores extensive
amounts of information about employees of a company. It is useful means of
recruiting people currently employed by the organization. The system’s computer
file contains information on employees such as job history, education, strengths and
weakness, leadership development needs, developmental needs, training, and
special skills.
The computer may also provide information on job title, location, skills requirements,
and potential successors to the position.
The advantage of CCPS is that candidates can be found quickly. A broad spectrum
of candidates can be identified and it will not be limited to candidates working in
the department where the vacancy exists.
The disadvantages of CCPS is that the skill inventory contained in the computer
database is limited only to objective or factual information, such as educational
degrees, certifications, training courses taken, and languages spoken. Information
of a more subjective nature (like interpersonal skills, judgment, integrity) is excluded.
Yet, for many jobs, this type of information is crucial.
There are also some disadvantages attributed to job posting. These are the
following:
1. This method takes time in filling vacant positions.
2. The system may prevent supervisors from hiring the resort to other moves to
make sure that their favorites will get the jobs.
3. Some employees may move from one job to another without any clear
direction.
4. Employees who did not get the job may become alienated from the
organization.
Private employment agencies are those that provide organizations for a fee,
with clerical, blue collar, technical, and lower level managerial personnel. Their
services are especially useful when many individuals are expected to apply for a
job or when qualified candidates are hard to find.
Executive search firms are employment agencies used to recruit middle and top
level managers. These firms can locate successful executives working elsewhere
who are not even actively seeking a new job.
Selection
After recruitment, the next step in the staffing process is selection. This involves assessing
and choosing among job candidates. The selection process involves the following
steps:
1. Completing the application form;
2. Conducting an interview;
3. Completing any necessary tests;
4. Background investigation;
5. Physical and medical examination; and
6. A decision to hire or not.
At each step, applicants are screened out by the organization, or some applicants
accept other job offers and drop from the list of applicants.
Socialization
The final step in the staffing process is socialization, and it involves orienting new
employees to the organization and its work units, especially the work units where the
newly hired employee will be working. The purpose of socialization is to enable new
employees to quickly become productive members of the organization.
In socialization, the new employees are provided with information about the following:
Training
Training is the process of changing employee behavior, attitudes, or opinions through
some type of guided experience. Training the individual employee occurs not only initially but
anytime improved skills are needed to meet changing job requirements.
There are many ways to conduct training programs and they may be classified as follows:
1. On-the-job training; and
2. Off-the-job training.
On-the-job training. This training method is conducted while employees perform job-
related tasks. It is the most direct approach to training.
Internships are opportunities for students to gain real world experience. They are
often offered during summer breaks and may be with or without payment.
Off-the-job training. This type of training deals with work skills in setting away from their
ordinary workplace.
Career may be defined as the pattern of work-related experiences that span the
course of a person’s life.
Career stages. This item refers to the distinct stages that individuals go through in their
careers, typically including establishment, advancement, maintenance, and retirement.
The establishment stage is one of the apprenticeship where the young employee enters
an organization who may be technically able but often without an understanding of the
organization’s demands and expectations. As a consequence, they work fairly closely with
more experienced people.
In the advancement stage, the employee seeks growth and increased responsibility
through the continued development and utilization of his skills. This stage calls for the
employee to work as an independent contributor of ideas in a chosen area. He is expected to
rely much less on direction from others. Advancement may be pursued through internal
career paths within the organization or through external career paths that involve taking
advantage of opportunities that require a change of employer.
During the maintenance stage, the employee may experience continued growth of
performance and accomplishments, or he may encounter career stability. Sometimes, a
further change in employers is necessary to sustain advancement, but often the employee
loses career flexibility. This may be a result of personal considerations such as:
1. Limited interest in learning new skills;
2. Organizational considerations, such as a basic lack of opportunity; and
3. Family considerations that make it difficult to change jobs or to take additional work
responsibilities.
Many people experience career plateau during the maintenance stage. A career
plateau is a situation in which, for either organizational or personal reason, the probability of
moving up the career ladder is low.
Career plateau are of three types:
1. Structural plateau – which marks the end of promotions and the affected employee,,
will now have to leave the organization to find new opportunities and challenges.
2. Content plateau – which occurs when a person has learned a job well and is bored
with day-to-day activities.
3. Life plateau – which occurs when an employee experiences a loss of identity and self-
esteem when there is no longer success in his work area.
The retirement stage is that stage when formal preparation for retirement is made. The
individual learns to accept a reduced role and less responsibility. Depending on the individual,
this can be either a positive or a highly upsetting stage of one’s career.
PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL
Performance appraisal is a key aspect of performance management. It may be
defined as the process of evaluating the performance of employees, sharing the information
with them, and searching for ways to improve their performance.
Traits. Many organizations use traits as criteria in appraising employee performance. This
is true even if it is a very weak means. It is weak because it has little connection with the
actual performance of the job. The traits commonly used as basis for performance
appraisal include:
1. Good attitude
2. Showing confidence
3. Being dependable
4. Looking busy
5. Possessing a wealth of experience
The Process of Performance Appraisal
Performance appraisal is a process in an organization whereby each employee is
evaluated to determine how he or she is performing. It consists of the following steps:
1. Establishment of performance standards
2. Mutually set measurable goals
3. Measure actual performance
4. Compare actual performance with standards
5. Discuss the appraisal with the employee
6. If necessary, initiate corrective action.
When goals are set with the active participation of the employees, appraising employee
performance will be an easy task.
Measuring performance is the third step in the appraisal process. To determine what actual
performance is, it is necessary to acquire information about it. Information may be derived
from the following sources:
1. Personal observation
2. Statistical reports
3. Oral reports
4. Written reports
The essay method provides an excellent opportunity to point out the unique
characteristic of the employee being appraised. The disadvantages, however, are
the following:
it is very time consuming;
the quality of the appraisal may be influenced by the appraiser’s writing skill
and composition style;
it tends to be subjective and may not focus on relevant aspects of job
performance.
The advantage of checklist method is that it reduces some bias since the
rater and the scorer are different. The disadvantage is where there are many
job categories; a checklist of items must be prepared for each job categories
that is costly in terms of materials and time consumed.
The adjective rating scale, also known as graphic rating scale, is a
performance appraisal method that lists a number of traits and a range of
performance for each. The traits listed are assumed to be necessary to
successful job performance. Examples of traits are quality of work, quantity of
work, job knowledge, and dependability. Each trait is accompanied by a five
or seven-point rating scale.
The advantage of adjective rating scale is that it is practical and cost little to
develop. The disadvantages, however, are as follows:
o It does not clearly indicate what a person must do to achieve a given
rating.
o It does not provide a good mechanism for providing specific,
nonthreatening feedback.
o Accurate ratings are not likely to be achieved because the points on
the rating scale are not clearly defined.
The greatest advantage of BARS is its ability to direct and monitor behavior. The
behavioral anchors let employees know what types of behavior are expected of
them which give appraisers the opportunity to provide behaviorally based
feedback.
The weakness of BARS is the difficulty of selecting the one behavior on the scale that
is most indicative of the employee’s performance level. Sometimes, an employee
may exhibit behaviors at both ends of the scale, so the rater would not know which
rating to assign.
3. Objectives. The third approach to appraisal makes use of objectives. This approach,
also known as management by objectives (MBO), is a process of joint goal setting
between a supervisor and a subordinate. It is also a process of converting
organizational objectives into individual objectives. MBO consists of four steps: goal
setting, action planning, self-control, and periodic reviews.
In goal setting, the individual objectives are set based on the organization’s overall
objectives. These goals are agreed upon and then become the standards by which the
employee’s results will be evaluated.
o Halo Error. This is a rating error that occurs when a rater assigns ratings on the basis of an
overall impression (positive or negative) of the person being rated. For example, a
teacher who topped the board examination for electrical engineers is regarded as
outstanding in the aspect of professional qualification. If that impression spills over the
other aspects of evaluation, a halo error is committed.
o Leniency Error. This is a rater’s tendency to give relatively high ratings to virtually
everyone. The opposite of this is strictness error where the raters tend to give everyone a
low rating. Most often, leniency errors happen when peers asses one another.
o Central Tendency Error. This occurs when a rater lump everyone together around the
average, or middle, category. The idea is that there are no very good or very poor
performers on the dimension being rated. As a result, no true performance
discrimination is made.
o Recency Error. This is a biased rating that develops by allowing the individual’s most
recent behavior to speak for his or her overall performance on a particular dimension.
The result is a false picture of the individual’s job performance during the entire period.
o Personal Bias Error. This occurs when a rater allows specific biases, such as racial, age,
and gender, to enter into performance appraisals. For example, a rater may
intentionally give higher rating to a member of a certain fraternity than to a non-
member.
REWARDS
After staffing, training, career planning and development, and performance appraisal,
a final requirement is necessary to ensure effective performance. The requirement refers to the
design and implementation of reward systems.
1. Intrinsic or Extrinsic
Intrinsic rewards are those that the worker receives from the job itself, such as pride in
one’s work, a feeling of accomplishment, or being part of a team. These rewards are
self-regulated as the worker is not dependent on an outsider, such as the manager, to
provide for them. Managing intrinsic work rewards present the additional challenge of
designing a work setting so that employees can, in effect, reward themselves for a job
well done.
Extrinsic rewards are those that the workers get from the employer, usually money, a
promotion, or benefits.
2. Financial or Nonfinancial
Financial rewards are those that enhance an employee’s financial well-being directly
through wages, bonuses, profit sharing, and the like.
3. Performance-based or Membership-based
Performance-based rewards are those given using performance as basis. These rewards
take the form of commissions piecework pay plans, incentive systems, group bonuses,
or other forms of merit pay.
Membership-based rewards refer to those that are given to all employees regardless of
performance. This type includes cost-of-living increases, benefits, and salary increase
attributable to labor-market conditions, seniority or time in rank, credentials such as a
college degree, or future potential such as new MBA degree from a prestigious
university.