You are on page 1of 16

MORTGAGE BROKING

Operating a Mortgage Broking


Business
BY PETER ANDREWS, MBA, CPA, B.ECONOMICS, B.ARTS
Former lecturer at Macquarie University

M
ortgage brokers are becoming the number one choice for
consumers who are seeking a home loan or to refinance their
existing loan. They work with clients to determine their
borrowing needs and ability, select a loan suited to their circumstances
and manage the process through to settlement. This requires a
relationship with a mortgage aggregator to provide access to lenders as
well as a close working knowledge of the lending products the aggregator
is able to provide.
Working as a mortgage broker, however, involves more than technical
knowledge and competence. Successful mortgage brokers have a solid
marketing program. They are also prepared to learn from others in the
industry.

Peter Andrews is a specialist trainer in


Financial Planning.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION TO MORTGAGE BROKING ...................................................2
After an early career in corporate finance THE FUNCTIONS OF A MORTGAGE BROKER .........................................................2
and banking, Peter became a lecturer at THE ADVANTAGES OF USING A MORTGAGE BROKER .............................................2
Macquarie University. THE ROLE OF AGGREGATORS ............................................................................3
REQUIREMENTS TO BE A MORTGAGE BROKER .....................................................3
He has also taught in the Graduate
School of Management at the University
MORTGAGE BROKER TRAINING REQUIREMENTS ...................................................4
of Sydney and the School of Banking and HOW MORTGAGE BROKERS ARE PAID ................................................................4
Finance at the University of New South MORTGAGE LENDING BASICS........................................................................4
Wales.
BASIC TERMINOLOGY ......................................................................................4
Peter has a Bachelor of Arts and a
LOAN TO VALUE RATIO....................................................................................5
Bachelor of Economics from the LENDERS MORTGAGE INSURANCE......................................................................5
University of Sydney and a Master of ASSISTANCE TO FIRST HOME BUYERS .................................................................6
Business Administration from the
University of Florida. He is also a MORTGAGE LOAN PRODUCTS.......................................................................6
Certified Practicing Accountant. OTHER FORMS OF CONSUMER CREDIT .........................................................8
OTHER FINANCIAL SERVICES .......................................................................10
COMPARISON INTEREST RATES ...................................................................11
GROWING A MORTGAGE BROKING BUSINESS ............................................12
MARKET SEGMENTATION ..............................................................................12
DEVELOP STRATEGIES ....................................................................................13
PREPARE A POSITION STATEMENT ...................................................................13
PERFORM SITUATION ANALYSIS ......................................................................13
PROVIDE QUALITY SERVICE .............................................................................14
OBTAIN REFERRALS ......................................................................................14
REACHING OUT TO NEW CLIENTS ...................................................................14
APPROACHING CENTRES OF INFLUENCE ............................................................15
LEARNING FROM OTHER BROKERS ..................................................................15
SECURITY OF CLIENT RECORDS ....................................................................16
ACCESS TO CLIENT RECORDS ...........................................................................16
DISCLOSURE OF CLIENT INFORMATION ..............................................................16
ENVIRONMENT SUSTAINABILITY .................................................................16

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB3 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
2 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
2

INTRODUCTION TO MORTGAGE THE FUNCTIONS OF A MORTGAGE


BROKER
BROKING
The functions of a mortgage broker may be summarised
Mortgage brokers began around twenty years ago and as:
are now involved in setting up 43% of home loans.
Membership of the peak professional body, the  find a lender;
Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia, was  complete the loan application; and
12,553 in June 2014, with 5,740 separate mortgage
broking businesses.1  submit the loan application to the bank or other
loan provider, and wait for them to approve it.
The industry thrived in the pre-GFC period through the
growth of securitisation. However, as Figure 1 indicates, These services are provided without cost to the
the securitised debt market has only been half its pre- borrower. As a general rule, a mortgage broker receives
GFC level in recent years, and this has made it more a once-only upfront fee from the loan provider on
difficult for mortgage brokers to compete with the settlement of the loan and an ongoing ‘trail’ income (on
major banks. average 0.20% p.a.) until the loan is repaid in full.

Figure 1: Australian Residential Mortgage-backed Once the loan has settled, the broker has little more to
Securities, May 2004 – April 20142 do with it, with the borrower’s on-going relationship
with the lender.
250.0
200.0 THE ADVANTAGES OF USING A
150.0 MORTGAGE BROKER
100.0 Five arguments can be put forward for using a qualified
mortgage broker when trying to obtain property
50.0 finance:
0.0
1. Choice
Sep-2007
Jan-2006

Jul-2008

Jan-2011

Sep-2012
Jul-2013
Nov-2006

Nov-2011
May-2004

May-2009
Mar-2005

Mar-2010

The biggest advantage of a broker over a bank or other


lender is choice. A client sitting in front of a broker is
sitting in front of 10+ banks and 50+ products as against
visiting a banker who has access to only one of the
In its submission to the Financial System Inquiry (the bank’s products. This is more likely to lead to the most
Murray Committee) the Mortgage and Finance suitable lending product being chosen. Also, now that
Association of Australia advocated the taking of steps to the banks are more cautious because of the responsible
revive the market for residential mortgage-backed lending provisions (discussed in a later chapter), there
securities to enable mortgage brokers to compete more may be increased likelihood of a successful outcome
effectively with the major banks once again. Its with more specialised lending proposals such as loans
argument for this approach was that this would bring for borrowers with a low credit rating. This is because
about a return to more innovative lending for housing mortgage brokers often become specialised in different
that would, amongst other things, assist first-time market segments, and in doing this they can predict the
homebuyers. probability of a successful outcome.

However, even with the reduced level of loan Prospective borrowers should therefore recognise what
securitisation, the mortgage broking industry is making services they need first and then look for an
progress. For example, between 2009 and 2014, experienced mortgage broker who can assist.
industry revenue grew by an average of 4.1% a year. 3

1 Source: IBIS World report, June 2014


2 Source: RBA
3 Source: IBIS World report, June 2014

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
3 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
3
2. Experience THE ROLE OF AGGREGATORS
Mortgage brokers often own their own businesses and Mortgage brokers need to have access to a wide variety
are committed to their clients in the long term, with of lenders and products. While many brokers maintain
many years of industry experience. This contrasts with direct accreditations with lenders, the major lenders
bank staff, who may not be experienced with property often have volume and compliance standards that a
lending, and may be promoted away from their broker might have difficulty in achieving by themselves.
customers. For this reason, most brokers will use the services of an
aggregator (a wholesaler for the finance industry) in
3. Specialisation
order to have access to major lenders and maintain
Bank staff handling property loans normally do not have their accreditations. There are over fifty mortgage
specialised training and experience in one area. aggregators operating in Australia.
Mortgage brokers can be chosen according to their
specialisation, such as investment property loans. The aggregators come in various forms from discount
Another example of specialisation being important is ‘warehouses’ to fully branded franchise groups. All of
the area of lending to borrowers with a poor credit the aggregators offer additional services other than just
history. Specialised mortgage brokers can provide maintaining access to lenders. Some of the extra
assistance that may not be available through a bank by services could possibly include: loan comparison
making a more careful credit appraisal and a more software, compliance support, Credit Licence support,
successful packaging of the lending proposal. providing leads, customer relationship, administration,
training, mentoring and many other services. Most
Other areas of specialisation include ‘low doc’ loans for aggregators also provide access to other non-finance
the self-employed and ‘SMSF loans’ (investment loans products services that their members can provide for
for self-managed superannuation funds). their clients in return for commissions or fees. Examples
of these products are commercial finance and insurance
4. Follow Up products.
Following up the progress of a loan application is time
A list of aggregators affiliated with the Mortgage and
consuming and frustrating. A good mortgage broker will
Finance Association of Australia may be found at:
have a system for chasing the proposal up, keeping the
borrower informed and saving time. http://www.mfaa.com.au/default.asp?artID=2028

5. Personal Banker REQUIREMENTS TO BE A MORTGAGE


A mortgage broker is like ‘the perfect personal banker.’ BROKER
This is because it is their own business and they are in
for the long haul. If they are successful in building a Australian Credit License
relationship with their client, after facilitating a The National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009
borrower’s home loan they may then be available for (NCCP Act) requires a mortgage broker to either hold an
investment loans or specialised business finance and, Australian Credit Licence (ACL) or be authorised under a
possible once again, further housing finance as their licence (normally by the aggregator or the groups they
clients upgrade. work with).

This contrasts to the situation with banks, with staff Before ASIC grants a credit licence, the applicant must
changes making it difficult to have continuing demonstrate adequate arrangements to:
relationships.
 supervise and monitor the activities of any
representatives and ensure that any breaches are
identified and remedied; and
 ensure that any representatives are adequately
trained, and are competent, to engage in the credit
activities covered by the credit licence.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
4 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
4
An ACL holder must show its ACL number on prescribed Another useful source of articles and video interviews is
documents.4 Regulation 13 of the Regulations issued Australian Broker Online, which may be found at:
under the NCCP Act prescribes the following
http://www.brokernews.com.au
documents:
 The documents required by Chapter 3 of the NCCP MORTGAGE BROKER TRAINING
Act (Credit Guides, Quotes, and Proposal Disclosure
Documents). REQUIREMENTS
 Printed advertisements that relate to the provision ASIC requires credit licensees to conduct formal training
of regulated credit. programs for their brokers. They must also have a
written policy regarding training, as well as maintain a
 Documents required to be created, produced, given training register detailing the training undertaken by
or published under the National Credit Code5 (e.g. each representative.6
NCC notices, credit contracts, mortgages,
guarantees).
HOW MORTGAGE BROKERS ARE PAID
 Documents lodged with ASIC that relate to the
provision of regulated credit. Mortgage brokers are not paid directly by their clients.

Training Requirement Instead they receive commissions from the credit


provider they have selected in the form of:
Brokers and their representatives are required by ASIC
to have completed a Certificate 4 in Financial Services –  A front-end fee (i.e. a once-off payment when the
Mortgage Finance. loan is taken out; and
 A ‘trail commission’, i.e. an annual fee from the
Membership of a Professional Association credit provider,
Although it is not a formal requirement, some credit
providers such as banks require mortgage brokers and Typical fees in these forms are:
their representatives to be a member of a mortgage  Upfront fee: between 0.55% to 0.70% of the loan
industry professional association. amount
 Trail fee: from 0.00% to 0.275% of the loan amount
There are two mortgage industry professional
associations: Having fees paid by the credit provider may appear
 the Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia convenient as far as the client is concerned, but it may
(MFAA); and give rise to what lawyers call a ‘conflict of interest’ in
that it may cause brokers to lean towards the credit
 the Finance Brokers Association of Australia (FBAA) provider that pays the highest fees. Although brokers
(The MFAA requires a Diploma in Financial Services are required to disclose how they are remunerated,
(Mortgage Management) for membership.) they are not required to disclose the fees they receive
from different credit providers. Disclosure of fees from
Industry Knowledge individual credit providers is, however, a ‘best practice’
for brokers to follow.
Although not specifically required by ASIC, a broker
needs knowledge of the industry. Some of this can be
obtained by talking to aggregators and other brokers. MORTGAGE LENDING BASICS
Also, anyone intending to move into mortgage broking BASIC TERMINOLOGY
needs to conduct research. This means reading as much
as possible about mortgages, sales, and finance. A good There is some basic terminology that you should fix in
starting point is the numerous publications such as Your your mind at the outset in case you become confused
Mortgage Magazine, Mortgage Professional Australia, later on.
and Australian Broker that are available from most
newsagents. The word “mortgage” actually means “pledge”. With a
mortgage the borrower pledges to give the property to

4 NCCP Act, s.51.


5 Schedule 1 of the NCCP Act. 6 ASIC Regulatory Guide 204.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
5 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
5
the borrower if the borrower cannot pay back the loan LENDERS MORTGAGE INSURANCE
in full.
An LVR of 80% is generally considered to be the ‘safe’
Now consider the distinction between “mortgagor”
limit, with lenders requiring Lenders Mortgage
and “mortgagee”. In English, the suffix (i.e. word
Insurance (LMI) above that limit. This protects the
extension) "or" is used to denote the person who
lender in the event of default, and with it in place some
performs an action; while the suffix "ee" is used to
lenders are prepared to accept LVRs as high as 95%.
denote the recipient of that action. Since the
buyer/borrower is pledging the property, he/she is
LMI is paid by the borrower. The premium is
"mortgaging" the property and in known as the
determined upfront, but there is no need to pay it that
"mortgagor". The lender is the recipient of the pledge,
way. The premium may, as an alternative, be
and therefore is the "mortgagee".
‘capitalised’. Capitalising the LMI premium essentially
means adding it to the total loan amount, and paying it
An easy way to remember the difference between the
off in regular instalments with the home loan. Most
"mortgagor" and the “mortgagee” is:
borrowers opt for the capitalisation option, which is
The "o" in "mortgagor" comes from the "o" in commonly put forward as costing no more than a cups
"borrower". The "e" in "mortgagee" comes from the "e" of coffee or so a week.
in "lender":
Example – Lender’s Mortgage Insurance
Likewise, although you may not be concerned
with lease finance, there is a similar distinction
(LMI)7
between “lessor” and “lessee”. A lessor is a person Newlyweds Tim and Erica are battling to save a deposit
or organization that owns an asset, such as real estate, for their home, and currently spend approximately 32%
and a lessee is a person or organization that makes of their combined monthly salary on rent.
instalment payments to use the asset. In real estate
rentals, the lessor is the landlord and the lessee is the Paying rent is putting a real strain on their ability to
renter. save a deposit and after speaking with their mortgage
broker, Tim and Erica learn they can secure a mortgage
So in the case of real estate transactions involving real for up to 95% of the value of the property they hope to
estate, both the mortgagor and the lessor have buy if they take out Lenders Mortgage Insurance.
ownership of the property.
Tim and Erica have saved $20,000 for a deposit and
LOAN TO VALUE RATIO additional funds to comfortably meet the other
commitments associated with their mortgage – such as
A term that you will need to be used to when you look
solicitor and application fees. They have learnt they can
at home lending products is the Loan to Value Ratio
secure a mortgage with an LVR of 95% if they take out
(LVR). This is the amount of the loan divided by the
Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI). However, it took
value of the property being acquired. As such it
them long enough to save their deposit of $20,000.
represents the maximum percentage that the bank is
Having to save $12,426 for the required LMI will take
prepared to lend.
too long.

Example - Loan to value ratio (LVR) Keen to help Tim and Erica to buy the property they
have set their hearts on, their mortgage broker advises
Matthew is buying a house for $1,000,000. With careful
that they can capitalise their LMI – which means adding
saving, he and his wife have accumulated $200,000.
the cost of the premium to their mortgage.
They will therefore require a loan of $800,000.
Buying their new home for $400,000 with a home loan
Their LVR will be:
of $380,000 the monthly repayments on their 30-year
$800,000/$1,000,000 = 80% mortgage (rate 6.82%) comes to approximately $2,482.

7 Based on an example from Gemworth.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
6 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
6
The Lenders Mortgage Insurance premium on their New products are introduced from time to time, and
$380,000 home loan comes to approximately $12,426. features of existing products may change. Mortgage
If Tim and Erica capitalise their Lenders Mortgage brokers need to be alert to any information regarding
Insurance premium, it will increase their monthly change from product providers, with information being
mortgage repayments by $81, taking the total monthly disseminated through such means as team meetings
mortgage repayment to $2,563. and seminars. Also, if necessary, training programs
should be put in place to ensure that changes are
ASSISTANCE TO FIRST HOME BUYERS properly understood.

Government grants and stamp duty exemptions can Brokers should also be prepared to discuss the different
provide first home buyers with significant concessions. products with theirs clients and point out their different
features so that an informed choice can be made.
1. The First Home Owners Grant
The First Home Owners Grant (FHOG) is given in the Variable home loan interest rates
form of cash to add to the borrower’s deposit and it
is usually paid at the time of property settlement. Most Australian home loans are variable rate loans,
Eligible applicants are Australian citizens or with interest rates fluctuating approximately in parallel
permanent residents buying their first home. A with the Reserve Bank of Australia’s ‘cash rate’. The
means test is not applied. Reserve Bank uses the cash rate as a blunt instrument
to try to control inflation – when inflation is becoming
The Australian government provides a base amount too high (typically when the economy is doing well) the
of $7,000, but various states impose a cap on cost cash rate goes up; when the economy is perceived as
price above which the FHOG is not payable. For being weaker (inflation usually is lower) the cash rate
example, in NSW, first homeowners purchasing a often comes down.
first home above $650,000 cost price will not
receive the first home owners’ grant. If variable interest rates increase, loan repayments
State governments have their own rules on increase. This, however, creates an addition burden on
qualification for the grants and also the amount for borrower. When an interest rate increase is unusually
the grant. In NSW, the state government provides a large, banks may be prepared to lengthen the term to
bonus $8,000 (additional to the base $7,000) to maturity, thereby lessening the term to maturity by
make total first home buyers grant equal to lowering repayments.
$15,000, but to qualify the property being
purchased must be a brand new property. More If, instead, interest rates decrease, loan repayments are
states have, or plan to soon introduce, similar usually allowed to remain the same, although
policy. borrowers may be able to negotiate lower repayments

2. Stamp Duty Exemption Pros:  If interest rates drop, repayments also


Stamp duty exemption may apply, depending on the drop
state. For example, NSW provides eligible
purchasers with exemptions from transfer duty on Cons:  If interest rates rise, repayments also rise
new homes valued up to $550,000 and concessions
for new homes valued between $550,000 and
$650,000. Fixed home loan interest rates

The exemption is normally applied for by the lending A fixed rate loan is a loan that has a fixed interest rate
institution, with the amount being debited to the and therefore fixed loan repayments. The time period
applicant’s loan account. of these loans can vary, but lenders can usually ‘lock in’
their repayments for between 1-5 years. Although the
As with the FHOG, a means test is not applied. fixed rate period may be, say, 3 years, the total length
of the loan itself may be 25 or 30 years. At the end of
MORTGAGE LOAN PRODUCTS the fixed loan period the lender can decide whether to
fix the loan again for another period at the current
Although there are differences between the individual market rates or convert the loan to a variable interest
products of different lenders, including in some cases rate for the remaining term of the loan.
the names of the products, there are still core
characteristics that allow the products to be discussed
in general terms.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
7 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
7
In general, if lenders expect the cash rate to rise, the The authorities have also been concerned about the
fixed rate will usually be higher than the variable rate; volume of investment loans. In May 2015, APRA wrote
on the other hand, if they expect the cash rate to fall, to the banks on the matter and suggested that their
the fixed rate will tend to be lower than the current annual growth in investment loans should be limited to
variable rate. 10%. The 10% figure was put forward as guidance
rather than a regulatory requirement, but this is
Lenders may offer fixed terms between 1 and 15 years, another reason why the banks will make less money
although most fixed term loans are for less than 5 available for investing in real estate.
years.
Introductory loans
Pros:  Repayments do not rise if the official
With an introductory loan, the interest rate is usually
interest rate rises
low to attract borrowers. Also known as a honeymoon
 Provides peace of mind for borrowers rate, this rate generally lasts only for around 12 months
concerned about rate rises before it rises. Rates can be fixed or capped. Most
 Allows more precise budgeting revert to the standard rates at the end of the
Cons:  Repayments do not fall if rates fall honeymoon period.
 Financial penalties may apply if there is
any early return to variable rate, or early Pros:  These loans usually provide the lowest
repayment of the loan repayment rates
 Payments are usually lower during the
Interest-only home Loans introductory period
Only interest is paid during an interest only period – Cons:  Payments usually increase after the
usually one to five years. Principal repayments are then introductory period
paid with interest payments over the remaining term of
the loan.
Split rate (principal and interest) loans
Pros:  Lower repayments initially, more money
to renovate/improve the property A split rate loan is a loan that has one portion of the
loan fixed and one portion variable. The borrower can
 Cuts the cost of buying a residential select how much to allocate to each.
investment property in the short-term,
thereby allowing the borrower to make Pros:  Provides some protection against rising
which could allow you to make greater interest rates. This gives a blend of
contributions to their principal place of repayment flexibility and interest rate
residence security
Cons:  If interest rates rise, repayments also rise Cons:  Repayments will still increase if interest
 There will be sudden increase in rates rise
repayments at the end of the interest
only period when the loan converts to
principal and interest repayments Home equity loans (line of credit)
A home equity loan is a line of credit secured by a
Interest only loans are used primarily for property mortgage over the owner’s property. Borrowers can
investment, the argument for them being that there is draw down up to their approved limit, reduce the
likely to have been realisable capital gain by the end of amount outstanding and then redraw if they want to –
the interest-free period. APRA and the Reserve Bank, the only commitment is to make interest payments.
however, are concerned that the percentage of
homeowners taking them out is increasing. Their Funds drawn from the facility can be used for lifestyle
argument against them is that by the end of the and investment purposes.
interest-free period homeowner borrowers will not only
have the burden of principal repayments, but higher Pros:  Borrowers can use the money for
interest rates as well. whatever purpose they choose.
 Interest rates are lower than for many

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
8 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
8
other forms of credit Non-conforming loans
Cons:  No formal commitment to reduce debt People with poor credit ratings often have trouble
over time sourcing a home loan. Many lenders now offer what are
known as “non-conforming loans” – also known as
credit-impaired loans’ – for people in this type of
Low-doc loans situation. While lenders are willing to overlook prior
credit problems, they will want to see some evidence of
Low doc (or ‘lo doc’) home loans are designed for ability to repay the loan. A larger deposit than is
borrowers, chiefly the self-employed, who fail to qualify required for traditional loans will generally be required
for a normal home loan because they may not have all as well.
the necessary paper work for proof of income, such as
payslips. Instead, the borrower is typically able to sign a Pros:  Overlooks poor credit rating
declaration of income with no or little proof. For this
reason they may also be known as self-declared income Cons:  A higher interest rate than traditional
loans.
loans
 A larger deposit is likely to be required
The Financial Ombudsman Service has indicated that a
mortgage broker’s responsible lending obligations are
Reverse mortgages
not met if a client’s self declaration is relied on without
making further inquiries. A reverse mortgage allows people to borrow money
using the equity in their home as security without a
Additional documentation that may be required need to make while they live in the home. The loan can
includes one or more of the following: be taken as a lump sum, a regular income stream, a line
of credit or a combination of these options.
 Proof of ABN and/or GST registration
 Business Activity Statements (BAS) The loan must be repaid in full (including interest and
fees) when the borrower sells their home or dies or, in
 Business account transaction statements
most cases, move into aged care.
 Accountant’s letter
This type of loan is increasing in popularity with retirees
 Personal tax return.
who no longer have a sufficient income stream to
maintain their lifestyle.
Pros:
 Simple income declaration form

Pros:  Borrowers are able to maintain their
 No tax return or financial records lifestyle
required
 Cons:  Interest rates are generally higher than
average home loans
 Fully serviceable loan options, redraws,
line of credit, variable or fixed rates
  The loan may affect pension eligibility
 The borrower may not have enough
 Principal & Interest or Interest-only money left for aged care or other future
loans

 needs
Cons:  Generally a higher interest rate because
the risk to the lender is greater OTHER FORMS OF CONSUMER
 More limitations in terms of the CREDIT
maximum Loan to Valuation Ratio (LVR),
available loan features and package Different types of credit are better suited to some
discounts situations than others, and choosing the appropriate
form of credit can help the borrower to minimise
 Misused by some credit providers with
interest payments and manage money better. A
false income details and falsely
personal loan, for example, with fixed repayments and
declaration low credit borrowers to be
a set term is better suited to large purchases than, say,
self employed
a credit card.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
9 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
9
Credit Cards Personal Loans
Credit cards are an ongoing ‘line of credit’ that can be These loans are useful for buying one-off big-ticket
used for purchases and cash advances. The full amount items such as a computer, a car or even a holiday as
borrowed can be paid each month or, after a part well as for consolidating multiple debts into one regular
payment that can be a small fraction of the amount repayment. They are for amounts ranging from just a
owing, be carried over to the next month, with interest few thousand dollars up to $50,000 or more. They are
charged on the amount outstanding. repayable over one to seven years, usually with fixed
monthly repayments, which make them easy to budget
Credit cards tend to come in two varieties: ‘No frills’ for.
cards and those offering reward programs. Basic, ‘no
frills’ cards often have a low rate of interest, making The interest rates, fees and charges on personal loans
them ideal for card users who continually carry an can vary considerably between lenders. Loans with a
outstanding debt. lower rate may come at the cost of higher fees.

The convenience of credit cards comes at a price. In When comparisons are made between loans, they
addition to paying interest of up to 20% or more on any should be based on the ‘comparison’ rate.8 A
outstanding balance, the following charges may apply: comparison rate is a tool to help consumers identify the
true cost of a loan. It is a rate that includes both the
 Annual card fees – these may be waived if annual
interest rate and fees and charges relating to a loan,
card spending exceeds a certain limit. On cards
reduced to a single percentage figure.
with a low credit limit, a high annual fee can really
boost the overall cost. For example, on a credit
For example, a loan with an interest rate of 8.75% and
card with a limit of $1,000, an annual fee of $30 is
an initial application fee of $65 might have a
the equivalent of an extra 3% in interest.
comparison rate of 8.93%. A loan with a higher interest
 Reward program fees. rate but no fees and charges may turn out to be
cheaper.
 Late payments fees.
 Cash advance fees – cash advances involve a one- Line of Credit
off fee, e.g. 1.75% of the amount, as well as
A new type of personal loan - a line of credit, combines
interest on the outstanding balance.
flexibility with the potential to save on interest.
 Some merchants may impose a surcharge for
accepting payment with a credit card. The Instead of drawing all the funds on day one, just the
merchant should advise, but it is always wise to amount needed can be drawdown - usually via ATM or
enquire before making a purchase, especially on cheque book.
larger-ticket items.
They have been available in the past in the form of
Some credit cards offer a zero interest rate on balances housing loan redraw facilities, but some banks are now
transferred over from an existing card. These offers can offering unsecured lines of credit. The main advantage
sound tempting, but the ongoing interest rate applied is a lower rate of interest, and the loan may be made
to new purchases should be looked at. If it is far higher without account keeping charges. However, there may
than the rate being paid on the consumer’s current be an ‘establishment fee’, but it may be less than $100.
card, a zero rate card may not be such a good deal. Also to be considered is that the term is much longer
than the term of a personal loan. That may seem like an
The key to managing credit card debt is to pay off the advantage, but it may lead to much slower debt
outstanding balance at the end of each month. That reduction unless strong discipline is exercised.
way, the comparatively high interest rates can be
avoided. The Nielsen survey referred to earlier found
that almost two-thirds (63%) of Australian consumers Example – Different forms of consumer credit
repay their credit card bill in full each month. However, compared 9
one-quarter (24%) of Australians repay less than that. Let’s say for example that you want to buy new
With some only paying the minimum repayment each furniture costing $3,000. What it will cost you using
month

8 This is a National Credit Code requirement.


9 The example is from CitiBank

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
10 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
10
three different types of credit is shown below. The Because the lease payments do not provide for full
personal loan is the cheapest option for this type of recovery of the purchase cost of the equipment, they
purchase because it combines a relatively low rate are usually lower than the equivalent payments on a
with a short term. personal loan.
Type of Interest Monthly repayments Time Total
credit rate taken to interest At the end of the lease period, the consumer has three
repay charge options:
credit
i. acquire ownership by paying the residual value;
Credit 15% Minimum repayment 26 years $4,456
card of 2% of outstanding ii. hand the item back to the finance provider; or
balance
iii. begin a new lease with an upgraded model of
Personal 10% $63 monthly 5 years $824 the equipment.
loan
The lack of ownership that goes with a lease may not be
Home 7.25% An extra $23 a 20 years $2,691 a problem if payments are made on time, but it can
loan month when $3,000
redraw is added to an certainly be a problem if there is a default on lease
existing mortgage of payments. That is because the finance provider, as
$200,000 payable owner of the equipment, can retake possession
over 20 years. immediately.

The first lesson on the responsible use of credit is


therefore to choose a suitable form of credit for the
OTHER FINANCIAL SERVICES
purpose, with credit card debt being the least suitable Although mortgage brokers are normally associated in
for any term that goes beyond the end-of-month the public’s mind with lending, they may also provide
balance. financial planning services. Considering that most
Australians:
Consumer Leases
 do not have adequate life insurance; and
Leasing is an option that can be a useful alternative to a
personal loan, and the financing costs can be roughly  do not exercise their right to choose their own
equivalent. With a lease, the finance provider owns the superannuation fund, this may be a useful service to
equipment, with the consumer paying a regular lease clients.
payment – for instance monthly – for use of the
equipment. They need to operate under another license to operate
as a financial planner – an Australian Financial Services
ASIC has warned that this can be an expensive form of They also need more information. In particular they
finance for smaller consumer items such as TV sets and need to determine the client’s risk profile – broadly
home computers, with other alternatives such as a no whether they have a conservative, balanced or
interest loan being a better alternative. aggressive risk profile. A clients risk profile is found by
using a specially designed questionnaire.
However, with large ticket items such as motor vehicles,
a lease may be obtained for a financing cost equivalent Mortgage brokers who offer financial planning services
to a personal loan, with many advantages. usually bring the matter up once the client’s credit
application has been forwarded to the credit provider.
The main advantage for many consumers is that, unlike That provides the time between completion of the
personal loans, the consumer does not have to make an credit application and the loan settlement, which may
up-front payment such as a deposit. A lease is therefore be up to four weeks, to provide financial advice to the
a ‘100%’ from of finance. The lease payments, which client.
are constant for the period of the lease, take into
account the finance cost and the depreciation of the
equipment. At the end of the lease period there is a
residual value, which is roughly equivalent to – although
usually slightly more than – the value of the vehicle.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
11 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
11
There are two advantages in doing this. The first and
most obvious is that it provides an opportunity to earn HANDLING CLIENTS
extra income without the need to prospect for financial A later chapter will discuss various aspects of a
planning clients. The second advantage is that, since mortgage broker’s handling of clients, but a matter that
financial planning clients normally meet their planner is worth considering now is the way client’s should be
for an “annual review”, it maintains client contact and handled. In particular, should a broker attempt to be an
provides an opportunity for more mortgage broking expert on all matters, or should the client be referred to
business. members of a “team” or some members – consisting of
other members of staff or even external advisers – or
COMPARISON INTEREST RATES even referred to a more suitable source of finance?

When a comparison is made between finance offered It can be hard to admit that we are not a source of all
by different providers, the comparison should be knowledge and advice, but that is something
between all the features if the finance, including professionals such as accountants and lawyers do every
interest rates and charges. Even a small difference in day. They let clients know when they have to research a
the interest rate can make a big difference to matter, and when required they refer clients to
payments over time. professionals who have greater expertise. That is
something that mortgage brokers need to learn to do if
It is difficult to compare loans that have different they are going to be proper professionals. It is also a
interest rates and fees. To overcome this, lenders are matter of acting in the best interest of clients, which is
required to must give a comparison rate when they what the duty of care is about.
advertise a rate or a weekly payment for loans. The
comparison rate includes the interest rate, plus most This is indicated in the following example.
fees and charges.
Example – Acting in the interests of clients
A comparison rate is made up of the following:
“Reminiscing about the duty of care mortgage brokers
 the amount of the loan;
owed their clients, a retired mortgage broker asked his
 the term of the loan; audience to consider two matters.
 the repayment frequency;
Firstly what industry did they consider they were in? The
 the interest rate; and audience suggested the loan industry. He replied that
they were in the property industry, which he broke down
 the fees and charges connected with the loan.
into:
Example – Comparison interest rates  the home buying industry;

Interest rate Fees & Comparison rate


 the investment property industry; and
charges10  the commercial property industry.
Home 8% 0.5% 8.5%
loan A He then asked them to consider their “mindset”, when
Home 8.25% 0.1% 8.35% they made property loans. He suggested that three
loan B were possible:
In this example, home loan A has a lower interest rate but it has
higher fees and charges. When a comparison is made between the
1. The Novice: I know nothing! Whatever kind of loan
comparison rates, which lenders are required to provide, home loan B you want for whatever kind of property you want is
will cost less than home loan A because it has lower fees and charges. fine by me. I will do what I can to get you the loan,
otherwise leave me out of it.
2. The Protector: I care about your success and would
rather turn down a loan than have you buy a bad
property on my watch. I only have some
fundamental knowledge on property investing but I
have access to a team of experts that I trust that I
can refer you to (and not just because they are
paying me to do so).
10 Fees and charges are usually expressed in dollar terms.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
12 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
12
3. The Expert: I will not only organise your loan I will Once as many characteristics as possible have been
make sure you invest wisely, because I know plenty listed, they should be grouped together to provide a
about property investing. picture of the types of clients the business has, what
motivates them and how they came to be a client. If it
He stressed that the mindset that was most consistent appears that there is more than one type of client, a
with the duty of care was the “Protector mindset”, with desirable approach to take is to choose the business’s
the worst one being “the Expert” mindset. He stated his “ideal” client.
case in the following words:
For David Maistre, an American expert on professional
‘The Novice is not a lot of help, but at least you are
relationships, choosing the ideal client is a matter of
under no illusions that you are on your own and that
choosing the type of client the firm prefers to work
may lead you to finding someone who can help you
with. Maister refers to such clients as a “I like these
invest wisely.
people” type of client.12 By working with ideal clients,
brokers are more likely to have the level of concern that
The Expert is the most dangerous because they are
is an essential quality of professionalism. They are also
promoting themselves as a property expert and odds
more likely to develop the communication with clients
are that they aren’t.
that leads to “engagement” – that is, a longer-term
The Protector admits they are not an expert on property relationship that comes from personal connection. The
investing and only have a basic knowledge, but they “picture” of the ideal client then becomes the basis of a
have sourced a trusted team they can refer you to and marketing plan designed to attract and capture more of
they do have your best interests at heart. the same clients.
He conclude his talk with the following challenge:
Who are your own “ideal” clients. Look at your own
“Are you a protector, an expert, or a novice? And when ethnic and social background, the types of people you
it comes to your clients, do you really care?”11 grew up with and the types of people you went to
school with. Considerations such as this should lead you
to the types of people you prefer to deal with. Likewise,
GROWING A MORTGAGE BROKING it may be that you are the sort of professional that they
BUSINESS prefer to deal with.

Although there is a range of mortgage lending products Maistre indicates that as well as assisting in the
that is common to most mortgage brokers, a common formation of relationships, the development of a target
recommendation for mortgage brokers is to select a market segment leads to efficiencies in marketing. He
target market segment to concentrate on. The selection calls this the “Raspberry Jam Rule”:
may not be made at the outset – it may take time and
“…the wider you spread it, the thinner it gets”.13
industry experience for a broker to decide on his/her
preferred segment. However, industry writers suggest In other words, marketing is more effective and more
that this is the best approach to take. cost-efficient if it is focussed on a target market.

Market segmentation may also lead to specialisation in


MARKET SEGMENTATION
different types of loans. A few come to mind:
For a broker who is already in business, market
 first homebuyer loans
segmenting does not need to be difficult. In fact, it’s
often as simple as sitting down and starting to write out  refinance loans
a list of similar characteristics of the business’s clients:
 low-doc loans
age, marital status, first home buyers, investors, how
they heard about the business, size of deal, why they  credit-impaired loans
chose the broker over another broker.
 construction loans

Some brokers try to do everything. When someone


comes to them for a particular loan, they will say that

12
Maister, D. (1997), True Professionalism, Free Press, New York,
page 24.
11 Michael Sloane, ‘What is the Duty of Care’, The Adviser, 5 Feb. 13 Maister, D. (1997), Managing the Professional Service Firm , Free
2014. Press, New York, page 121.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
13 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
13
they can do it, and then find out how. In contrast, “High performing people cutting through complexity to
brokers who concentrate on a market segment find a deliver clear solutions that our clients value”.15
niche that they feel comfortable in and then dominate
it. A position statement describes the benefits derived
from using the firm’s services and invites a response. It
Correctly applied, market segmentation is about a
says why you should be using us instead of our
company understanding the needs of its clients and
competitors. It also assists in the development of a
therefore understanding how its clients decide between
marketing strategy.
one product and another.

Segmentation also attracts business. As an American PERFORM SITUATION ANALYSIS


textbook on mortgage broking puts it: Once a target market has been established and at least
“The most successful brokers find a niche they feel preliminary thought has been given to appropriate
comfortable with, and then dominate that niche. If strategies, the business should put itself through a
someone in your town is regarded as the expert in situation analysis. This begins with description of the
financing homes of over $1 million, then the people target market and the practice’s experience with that
buying these homes, the builders building them, and the market.
Realtors selling them will all come to this broker so that A SWOT analysis should then be carried out. This
the deal goes through.”14 involves drawing up separate lists of the Strengths,
Segmentation, however, should not prevent a broking Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats facing the
firm from straying out of their preferred niche at times, business. Strengths and weaknesses cover factors
even if specialist help is required. Nor should it prevent internal to the company, while opportunities and
broking firms from directing clients to firms that threats cover external factors.
provide more specialist expertise. The list of opportunities and threats should be
attempted first. This is because a list of the
DEVELOP STRATEGIES opportunities and threats highlights the strengths that
may be made use of (and perhaps further
When the most desirable market segment has been
strengthened) and the weaknesses that need to be
identified and its important characteristics are known,
corrected. For example, the main competitor may have
attention can be turned to the more difficult task of
set up effective web pages for selling its products or
developing strategies. For example, a business that
services. That may identify a weakness that requires
positions itself as providing a streamlined form of
early attention.
service is likely to adopt this as a strategy for reaching
the target market. Examples of other strategies that
SWOT analysis is illustrated in Figure 2 (over the page).
might be adopted include having a wide product range
and being able to match client requirements with the
most appropriate loan.

Ideally, strategies should be based on strengths that are


difficult for competitors to replicate.

PREPARE A POSITION STATEMENT


A position statement describes one or more benefits
that will be received if the firm’s products or services
are utilised rather than those of its competitors.

As an example of the difference between a mission


statement and a position statement, first consider the
mission statement of the international accounting firm
KPMG:

14 Ameen Kamadia, So You Want to Be a Mortgage Broker, Kamrock


Publishing, Houston, Texas (2005), p.100. 15 From KPMG website.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
14 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
14
Figure 2: SWOT analysis 16 A basic requirement for excellence in quality of service
is that the client’s expectations must be exceeded.
Strengths Opportunities
Excellence in quality of service assists in retaining
Your specialist marketing A developing medium such as
expertise the internet existing clients as well as the extension of existing client
A new, innovative product or Mergers, joint ventures or business. It also leads to referrals. In a survey on the
service strategic alliances reasons for referrals conducted by Maister, only 10%
Location of your business Moving into new market were due to the quality of technical work. The
Quality processes and segments
procedures A new international market remaining 90% of referrals were due to the quality of
Any other aspect of your A market vacated by an service.18
business that adds value to your ineffective competitor
product or service
OBTAIN REFERRALS
Weaknesses Threats Quality of service leads to referrals, but they generally
Lack of expertise A new competitor do not happen on their own. As important as quality of
Products or services not Price wars with competitors service is, referrals are more likely to happen if they are
differentiated from Competitor product/service asked for.
competitors’ offerings innovation
Location of your business Competitors have superior As a relatively passive approach, a line about referrals
Damaged reputation access to channels of
distribution
can be included in all letters to clients. It is, however,
Taxation introduced on product possible to take more positive control of the word-of-
or service mouth process. A broker who has developed a sound
relationship with ideal clients, and obviously enjoys that
relationship, can let them know that he/she wants
PROVIDE QUALITY SERVICE other clients just like them. Each ideal client can then
be asked to suggest people they know through work,
Identifying a target market and developing appropriate social networks, etc. Some brokers go further by
strategies, however, do not lead to success on their schooling their ideal clients in what to say when they
own. An essential final ingredient is a caring attitude spread word of mouth about them.
that leads to quality of service. David Maistre, who was
referred to earlier, points out that when people A point to remember is that clients who are truly
approach a professional such as a mortgage broker, satisfied are likely to be eager to provide referrals
they usually do so over a matter of high value with, because this is a way of benefiting social contacts and
long-term consequences or significant risk. They family. Asking then to provide referrals does more than
therefore feel vulnerable and, as Maister points out, prompt them. It provides them with permission to go
“almost by definition in a state of anxiety and ahead.
nervousness”, so “they need to be confident they are in
good hands”.17 They need, in other words, to be assured The needs of referrals should be obtained promptly,
that the broker will put their interests first from the with relevant organization products being presented to
beginning of the relationship. the client. Mostly, this is a matter of finding out why
they were referred to you. If you cannot assist, you
This means demonstrating a caring attitude from the should be able to suggest someone who can, even if
beginning of the relationship. The demonstration begins that means referring them to another mortgage broking
with simple courtesies, such as the way telephones are business. Remember your name was mentioned as
answered. It then extends to the way a prospect is someone who would be able to help meet a need, so
treated when a meeting takes place. In particular, the you should be as helpful and courteous as possible.
broker must demonstrate a sincere interest in clients
and their problems. This leads to client relationships.
REACHING OUT TO NEW CLIENTS
Once a client relationship has been established, a
broker is judged by the quality of service being As well gaining referrals from clients, the business
provided. This exists apart from technical competence should have an active networking program so that
and covers the client’s whole experience with the firm. further business is gained through networking. This
involves reaching out to a market segment made up of
the practice’s ideal clients.
16
From Deena Katz, Deena Katz’s Complete Guide to Practice
Management (2009), page 39.
17 Maister, D. (1997), Managing the Professional Service Firm, page
73. 18 Maister (1997), Managing the Professional Service Firm, page 81.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
15 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
15
David Maister lists different marketing techniques in evidence of a caring attitude, not only to clients but also
different tiers with diminishing order of effectiveness, to the COI. This means finding ways to add value to
as illustrated in Figure 3.19 their business at no cost to them. They might, for
example, be provided with relevant articles or
Figure 3: Marketing techniques
information, websites, or relevant knowledge that the
adviser discovers in the normal course of business.
The first tier: These are all more effective Another way of helping COIs is to invite them to a
Seminars (small-scale) techniques that are worth
attempting because workshop, seminar or function where they can make
Speeches at client industry competence is demonstrated valuable new contacts themselves. They should also be
meetings rather than asserted. They also provided with referrals. An adviser cannot expect
Articles in client-oriented all involve giving something to
referrals from a COI without providing them in turn.
(trade) press the prospective client, but no
one tactic will work alone. While recognising COIs as being potentially powerful as
Proprietary research on
matters of interest to sources of referrals, Maister relegates them to his
prospective clients (this also second tier of marketing techniques because of the
provides useful material for time required to develop the relationship.20 He sees it as
speeches and articles)
a matter of long-term courtship that is valuable, but not
likely to provide results within the timeframe of a
The second tier: While these may be powerful, marketing plan.
Community/civic activities the time investment is higher –
the payoff may take many
Networking with potential
referral sources such as
patient years LEARNING FROM OTHER BROKERS
“centres of influence” (see
A final point about growing a mortgage broking
below)
business is that the main competition for mortgage
Newsletters brokers is not other mortgage brokers. Mortgage
brokers only have 45% of the total home lending
“Clutching at straws”: market.21 They therefore have room to expand.
These are all more directed to
Publicity, brochures, seminars a very wide target market and It is with the banks and other lenders. Mortgage
(ballroom scale), direct mail, are limited in their effect
brokers should therefore be prepared to help each
cold calls, sponsorship of
sporting/cultural events, other.
advertising, video brochures.
An Australian broker has made the following
suggestions:
APPROACHING CENTRES OF INFLUENCE  “Ask/demand your aggregator to get the most
successful broker to speak at your next PD day –
The term “Centre of Influence” or COI is used often in
this could be the most successful broker in terms of
business networking, especially in the financial services
settlements, or most successful with social media,
sector.
or referrals and so forth – doesn’t just have to be
A COI is a person who is in a position or business that volume
tends to have great influence with prospects in a target
 Organise a broker forum of 4 to 8 like-minded
market. These people are “movers and shakers” in
brokers in your area that meets monthly to talk
complimentary but non-competing area. For mortgage
about their business challenges and experiences
brokers, COIs are likely to be other professionals such as
solicitors and real estate agents who have developed a  Publish your experiences, tips and advice in a
loyal client case and have influence in the target blog/article. I’d very much welcome contribution to
market. They also understand the unique needs of the my site (blog) but equally I know the broker
members of the target market, what their preferences industry magazines would love to receive some
are, and how they can be approached. content too
Other COIs may be professionals such as accountants,  Approach colleagues’ you respect and beg them to
solicitors and financial planners. share their knowledge (e.g. article or
Centres of influence need to be “wooed” in the same
way that clients need to be wooed. An essential start is 20 Maister (1997), Managing the Professional Service Firm, page
128.
19 Maister (1997) Managing the Professional Service Firm, page 122. 21 Source: Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615
16 3. MORTGAGE BROKING
16
presentation).22 Financial institutions also consider the impact of their
work practices on the environment. Westpac, for
example, claims to have reduced greenhouse gas
SECURITY OF CLIENT RECORDS emissions by 40% since 1996. It has also sought to
The privacy legislation, which is reviewed in the reduce water and paper consumption. It also has
following article, places obligations on mortgage energy plans for each worksite and reports its emissions
brokers in relation to the security of client records. performance in its Annual Report.
Normal guidelines are set out below. Businesses are not on their own in environmental
sustainability issues. In particular, an important source
ACCESS TO CLIENT RECORDS of information and assistance is provided by
environmental protection agencies in all states and
As all client information is confidential, all client records territories:
will be stored in a secure environment at all times.
 The NSW Environment Protection Authority
Only authorised staff will have controlled access to
client information/records.  The Victorian Environment Protection Authority

Client records are the property of the organisation, but  The Queensland Department of Environment and
clients may have supervised access to their own records Heritage Protection
following written a request, either by mail or  The Tasmanian Environment Protection Authority
electronically, and authorisation by the general
manager, independent living services.  The Western Australian Environment Protection
Authority
DISCLOSURE OF CLIENT INFORMATION  The Northern Territory Environment Protection
Authority
Information contained in a client's record will only be
disclosed with the written consent of the client, parent
or legal guardian specifying the information that is to be
released, except for non-identifying data required by
funding bodies and by government departments for
planning purposes.
The organisation is obliged to disclose information
about a client, with or without the client's consent,
where prescribed as a legal requirement (e.g. breaches
of legislation and criminal activities such as fraud.)

ENVIRONMENT SUSTAINABILITY
Environment sustainability is a growing issue with most
businesses, including mortgage broking and other
businesses operating in the financial services sector.
The pressure is from client and community expectations
rather than legislation.23

Lenders, for example, consider the environmental


impact of their lending and have lists of activities they
will not support through their lending activities. They
also consider the environmental impact of their
suppliers and seek to operate green offices.

22 Blog by Stuart Wemyss, 17 July 2014.


23
Legislative pressure ceased with the repeal of The Energy
Efficiency Opportunities (EEO) Act 2006. The EOO Act, which
required larger businesses to identify and report on
environmental issues, was repealed in 2014.

Copyright 2014 © Mentor Education Group Pty Ltd


MB2 – Operating a Mortgage Broking Business PA 010615

You might also like