Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Background: Workplace stress can affect job Results: Thirty-three nurses participated in
satisfaction, increase staff turnover and hos- 11 focus groups. Respondents identified
pital costs, and reduce quality of patient potential barriers to program adherence,
care. Highly resilient nurses adapt to stress incentives for adherence, preferred qualifica-
and use a variety of skills to cope effectively. tions of instructors, and intensive care unit-
Objective: To gain data on a mindfulness- specific issues to be addressed.
based cognitive therapy resilience interven- Conclusions: The mindfulness-based cogni-
tion for intensive care unit nurses to see if tive therapy pilot intervention was modified
the intervention program would be feasible to incorporate thematic categories that the
and acceptable. focus groups reported as relevant to inten-
Methods: Focus-group interviews were con- sive care unit nurses. Institutions that wish
ducted by videoconference with critical care to design a resilience program for intensive
nurses who were members of the American care unit nurses to reduce burnout syndrome
Association of Critical-Care Nurses. The need an understanding of the barriers and
interview questions assessed the feasibility concerns relevant to their local intensive
and acceptability of a mindfulness-based care unit nurses.
cognitive therapy program to reduce burn- Keywords: resilience, mindfulness, cognitive-
out syndrome in intensive care unit nurses. behavioral therapy, focus groups
subsequent risk for anxiety, depression, and Rachel Hodapp, Department of Medicine, University of
Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado.
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).1 If left
unaddressed, workplace stress can adversely David Conrad, Department of Pediatrics, University of
Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado.
affect job satisfaction, increase turnover and
Sona Dimidjian, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience,
hospital costs, and ultimately reduce quality University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, Colorado.
of patient care.1 Barbara O. Rothbaum, Department of Psychiatry, Emory
Nurses in specialty areas such as the inten- University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
sive care unit (ICU) are predisposed to work- Marc Moss, Department of Medicine, University of Colorado
place stress. The ICU is a fast paced, tension- School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado.
charged environment in which nurses are
directly and indirectly exposed to traumatic This research was funded by National Institutes of Health
events and morally challenging decisions.2 grant number R34AT009181.
359
MEALER ET AL W W W.A ACNACCONLINE .COM
ICU environment likely contribute to the high the differences between the groups were iden-
prevalence of burnout syndrome, PTSD, anxi- tified in 4 domains: (1) worldview, (2) social
ety, and depression in critical care nurses.3,4 network, (3) cognitive flexibility, and (4) self-
Some critical care nurses appear unaffected care/balance. Highly resilient ICU nurses used
by the adversities and challenges of the ICU positive coping skills to address workplace
and thrive in that workplace environment. stress and continue working in the ICU envi-
Nurses with high levels of psychological resil- ronment. These positive coping skills were
ience are significantly less likely to develop used to develop a pilot, multimodal resilience
burnout, psychological distress (eg, PTSD, anx- training program for ICU nurses.
iety, and depression), and problems with daily
functioning (personally and professionally) Multimodal Resilience Training
in response to workplace stress.4 Program
Resilience is defined as adapting or bounc- The multimodal resilience training program
ing back after being exposed to stressful situ- included mindfulness practice, aerobic exercise,
ations or adversity.5 Resilience encompasses event-triggered cognitive-behavioral therapy,
3 components: (1) recovery, (2) sustainability, and expressive writing (written exposure ther-
and (3) growth.6,7 Recovery involves a return apy [WET]). Twenty-nine ICU nurses were
to baseline functioning after extreme stress; randomly assigned to be part of an 8-week
sustainability is the capacity to continue func- resilience program or part of a control group.
tioning without disruption; and growth is the The results of the study indicated that the
ability to enhance adaptation beyond original resilience intervention was both feasible and
levels of functioning.6 Resilience is not a clearly acceptable to ICU nurses. Although the study
delineated or a static construct; individual lev- was not able to determine the effectiveness of
els of resilience may vary based on context, the intervention, significant differences were
which includes organizational and/or environ- found between the 2 groups in PTSD symp-
mental issues (eg, the type of patients being toms and resilience scores.11 Continued
cared for in a unit).6 Importantly, resilience research is needed to understand which inter-
can be learned. ventions are most effective at enhancing resil-
ience and whether the interventions are
Background feasible and acceptable to ICU nurses, who
Resilience resources can be innate or learned are often restricted by the demands of their
through experiences, and role models become work schedule.
stronger or weaker due to prior experiences.5
Resilience resources can be grouped into such Written Exposure Therapy
categories as self and ego-related resources, Written exposure therapy may build resil-
personality, worldviews, spiritual or cultural- ience and subsequently reduce psychological
based beliefs, social or interpersonal resources, distress. By writing and therefore confront-
and cognitive and behavioral coping skills.6,8 ing traumatic experiences, an individual is
Cognitive-behavioral skills and approaches forced to reflect on the negative experience,
often are used to enhance resilience in adults6 reconstruct meaning of the event, and engage
and include cognitive flexibility/reframing, in transformative actions. The earliest study
physical exercise, positive emotions and of expressive writing involved college students
optimism, spirituality, strong social support who wrote for 15 to 20 minutes on 3 to 5
system, active coping skills, and commitment consecutive days about their most traumatic
to a mission or cause.5,9 To our knowledge, experience.12 Writing was associated with
no large randomized controlled trials have improved grades, fewer visits to the infir-
been conducted to determine the effectiveness mary, and better adjustment to college. Since
of resilience training in critical care nursing. then, more than 200 similarly structured
In a national qualitative study, ICU nurses randomized trials have been conducted that
were divided into two groups: (1) highly resil- addressed common illnesses or common
ient and (2) met diagnostic criteria for PTSD stressors such as workplace issues and trau-
and thus not highly resilient.10 The nurses matic events.13-17 These randomized trials
were interviewed about resilient coping skills. and several subsequent meta-analyses dem-
Twenty-seven interviews were conducted onstrate that writing generally improves
before thematic saturation was reached and psychological health.
360
VO L U M E 2 8 • N U MB E R 4 • WINTER 2017 RE SILIE NCE P ROGRA M FOR CRIT ICA L CA RE NURSE S
361
MEALER ET AL W W W.A ACNACCONLINE .COM
Table: Concerns About an 8-Week MBCT Resilience Program, as Identified by Focus Groups
Barriers to Incentives for Preferred qualifications Didactic content should
adherence adherence (of MBCT instructors) address ICU-specific triggers:
Abbreviations: FTE, full-time employee; ICU, intensive care unit; MBCT, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy; PTSD, posttraumatic stress disorder.
and agreed on by the research team. A sum- interviews until thematic saturation was
mary report of the findings was shared with obtained, a response rate was not needed.
the research team for concurrence as an Thirty-two of the 33 nurses who participated
additional validity check. were female; 29 were white, 1 African Ameri-
can, and 2 identified as Hispanic (1 partici-
Results pant did not identify race/ethnicity). The work
Participants units included medical, surgical, neuro-trauma,
Forty-five nurses agreed to participate in burn-trauma, critical care, and progressive
the focus groups. However, 12 nurses did not care. Each interview lasted between 45 and
call in for their scheduled interviews, leaving 60 minutes.
a final cohort of 33 nurses in 11 focus groups The qualitative data analysis revealed 4
who completed the qualitative telephone inter- overarching themes: (1) barriers to MBCT
view. The AACN has more than 100 000 mem- adherence, (2) incentives for adherence, (3)
bers who were eligible to receive the electronic preferred qualifications of instructors, and
advertisement but, because we conducted (4) didactic content (see Table).
362
VO L U M E 2 8 • N U MB E R 4 • WINTER 2017 RE SILIE NCE P ROGRA M FOR CRIT ICA L CA RE NURSE S
363
MEALER ET AL W W W.A ACNACCONLINE .COM
potential triggers of burnout syndrome: with critical care experience; a stipend is pro-
mandatory overtime, staffing issues, rapid vided for participation in the intervention;
turnover of patients, patients who do not and didactic content related only to depres-
require critical care monitoring, team mem- sion has been replaced with ICU-specific
bers who do not restock supply carts, lack content related to burnout, PTSD, anxiety,
of experienced ICU nurses, coworker apathy, and depression. Intensive care unit nurses
and family member demands. Administrative who enroll in the subsequent MBCT pilot
issues contributing to burnout syndrome intervention will be able to provide local
included not providing the appropriate training contextual feedback that can be incorporated
for new technical procedures being imple- into further iterations to the intervention.
mented in the ICU, an environment not
conducive to learning, overall disconnect Limitations
with the bedside nursing issues, pettiness, This focus-group study had several limita-
coworker arguments and/or interdepartmen- tions. We did not ask the participants if they
tal and intradepartmental conflict, and feel- had experience with resilient coping skills or
ing as though administration is trying to fill MBCT. Prior experience with these inter-
full-time positions without regard to how ventions may have influenced the responses
new employees would fit in with the team. given, although the interview responses were
Triggers that were most related to PTSD, constructive and supportive of the need for
anxiety, and depression included the lack of resilience interventions for critical care nurses.
debriefing after patient deaths, the noise of In addition, participants self-selected to par-
monitor alarms, guilt associated with deliver- ticipate in the focus-group interviews and,
ing “bad care,” and emotional injuries. Exem- although the methodology did include pur-
plars from the didactic content theme included, posive sampling, selection bias limits the
“When patients are not doing well and they generalizability of the results. Participant
may be getting close to death, a physician is demographics were not collected, which may
on call and is not present and the family stares limit generalizability to other populations of
daggers at the nurses because they think the nurses. Finally, the results are limited to the
nurses are not doing enough to save their loved design and delivery of an 8-week MBCT
one;” and “I feel as though the administra- resilience intervention, which would not be
tion is just trying to fill their FTE [full-time generalizable to resilience programs of vary-
equivalent] with bodies.” ing time commitments and procedures.
Discussion Conclusions
Focus-group qualitative interviews were Understanding if a resilience program is
conducted to understand feasibility and accept- feasible and acceptable to ICU nurses is criti-
ability design issues of an 8-week face-to-face cal when designing interventions that are
MBCT resilience program for critical care efficacious and effective. For example, if
nurses to reduce burnout syndrome. The the- critical care nurses are unable to attend ses-
matic categories identified included barriers sions because of their work schedules or
to adherence, incentives for adherence, pre- personal commitments, potentially efficacious
ferred qualifications of instructors, and interventions will be dismissed prematurely.
didactic content. Therefore, careful planning and method con-
No single design for the delivery of the siderations are necessary when designing a
intervention was accepted, suggesting that clinical trial or implementing an institutional
institutions that wish to incorporate a resil- resilience intervention.
ience program would need to understand The results of this study will be used to
the barriers and concerns relevant to their refine a pilot MBCT resilience intervention
local ICU nurse clinicians. to reduce burnout syndrome in ICU nurses.
Participants enrolled in the pilot MBCT resil-
Intervention Modifications ience intervention will be interviewed after
Based on the results of the focus-group the 8-week program to identify additional
study, we modified the intervention as follows: modifications that may need to be considered
the MBCT program now has 2 instructors before conducting a larger trial powered to
for the course—a psychotherapist and a nurse determine efficacy and effectiveness.
364
VO L U M E 2 8 • N U MB E R 4 • WINTER 2017 RE SILIE NCE P ROGRA M FOR CRIT ICA L CA RE NURSE S
As health care organizations and leaders 10. Mealer M, Jones J, Moss M. A qualitative study of resil-
ience and posttraumatic stress disorder in United States
continue to gain an understanding of the ICU nurses. Intensive Care Med. 2012;38(9): 1445-1451.
role of resilience in mitigating the symptoms 11. Mealer M, Conrad C, Evans J, et al. Feasibility and
of workplace stress—burnout, PTSD, anxiety, acceptability of a resilience training program for intensive
care unit nurses. Am J Crit Care. 2014;23(6):e97-e105.
and depression—further research is needed 12. Pennebaker JW. Putting stress into words: health, lin-
to continue addressing feasibility and accept- guistic, and therapeutic implications. Behav Res Ther.
1993;31(6):539-548.
ability issues of resilience training programs in 13. Craft MA, David GC, Paulson RM. Expressive writing
the unique and demanding ICU environment. in early breast cancer survivors. J Adv Nurs. 2013;
69(2):305-315.
14. Harvey AG, Farrell C. The efficacy of a Pennebaker-like
REFERENCES writing intervention for poor sleepers. Behav Sleep
1. Moss M, Good VS, Gozal D, Kleinpell R, Sessler CN. A Med. 2003;1(2):115-124.
Critical Care Societies Collaborative statement: burnout 15. Junghaenel DU, Schwartz JE, Broderick JE. Differential
syndrome in critical care health-care professionals. Am efficacy of written emotional disclosure for subgroups
J Respir Crit Care Med. 2016;194(1):106-113. of fibromyalgia patients. Br J Health Psychol. 2008;
2. Mealer ML, Shelton A, Berg B, Rothbaum B, Moss M. 13(pt 1):57-60.
Increased prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder 16. Mackenzie CS, Wiprzycka UJ, Hasher L, Goldstein D.
symptoms in critical care nurses. Am J Respir Crit Care Does expressive writing reduce stress and improve
Med. 2007;175(7):693-697. health for family caregivers of older adults? Geron-
3. Mealer M, Burnham EL, Goode CJ, Rothbaum B, Moss tologist. 2007;47(3):296-306.
M. The prevalence and impact of post traumatic stress 17. Smyth JM, Stone AA, Hurewitz A, Kaell A. Effects of
disorder and burnout syndrome in nurses. Depress writing about stressful experiences on symptom reduc-
Anxiety. 2009;26(12):1118-1126. tion in patients with asthma or rheumatoid arthritis: a
4. Mealer M, Jones J, Newman J, McFann KK, Rothbaum randomized trial. JAMA. 1999;281(14):1304-1309.
B, Moss M. The presence of resilience is associated 18. Sloan DM, Marx BP, Bovin MJ, Feinstein BA, Gallagher
with a healthier psychological profile in intensive care MW. Written exposure as an intervention for PTSD: a
unit (ICU) nurses: results of a national survey. Int J randomized clinical trial with motor vehicle accident
Nurs Stud. 2012;49(3):292-299. survivors. Behav Res Ther. 2012;50(10):627-635.
5. Southwick SM, Pietrzak RH, Tsai J, Krystal JH, Charney 19. Lau MA, Segal ZV. Mindfulness-based cognitive ther-
D. Resilience: an update. PTSD Res Q. 2015;25(4):1-4. apy as a relapse prevention approach to depression.
https://www.ptsd.va.gov/professional/newsletters In: Witkiewitz KA, Marlatt GA, eds. Therapist’s Guide to
/research-quarterly/V25N4.pdf. Accessed September Evidence-Based Relapse Prevention. London, England:
25, 2017. Academic Press; 2007:73-90.
6. Schetter CD, Dolbier C. Resilience in the context of 20. Dimidjian S, Segal ZV. Prospects for a clinical science
chronic stress and health in adults. Soc Personal of mindfulness-based Intervention. Am Psychol. 2015;
Psychol Compass. 2011;5(9):634-652. 70(7):593-620.
7. Zautra AJ, Arewasikporn A, Davis MC. Resilience: pro- 21. Goyal M, Singh S, Sibinga EM, et al. Meditation pro-
moting well-being through recovery, sustainability, and grams for psychological stress and well-being: a sys-
growth. Res Hum Dev. 2010;7(3):221-238. tematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Intern Med.
8. Bonanno GA, Westphal M, Mancini AD. Resilience to 2014;174(3):357-368.
loss and potential trauma. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 22. Hofmann SG, Sawyer AT, Witt AA, Oh D. The effect of
2010;7:511-535. mindfulness-based therapy on anxiety and depression:
9. Iacoviello BM, Charney DS. Psychosocial facets of resil- a meta-analytic review. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2010;
ience: implications for preventing posttrauma psychopa- 78(2):169-183.
thology, treating trauma survivors, and enhancing 23. Segal ZV, Williams MG, Teasdale JD, Kabat-Zinn J.
community resilience. Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2014 Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy for Depression.
Oct 1:5. doi:10.3402/ejpt.v5.23970. New York, NY: Guilford Press; 2013.
365
Copyright of AACN Advanced Critical Care is the property of American Association of
Critical-Care Nurses and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted
to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may
print, download, or email articles for individual use.