* Cae |
| Creating Your
Brand's Contract
‘A Brand Contract isa lst ofall promises the brand makes to cus-
tomers. Such a contracts executed intemal, butitis defined and
validated externally by the marketplace. Brand Contracts can and
should change over time. New promises can be added, pther
‘promises can be updated, and irelevant promises can be deleted,
‘A.Brand Contracts a critical piece ofthe BrandPicture (see
the illustration on the facing page) because it helps to further
define marketplace perceptions and expectations and forces man
‘agers to be honest with themseles. In ation to positive promises
tw customers, a Brand Contract can contain negative promises or
attributes. It is important ro build on the strong brand promises
and mitigate the negative ones.
For example, one of our clients had a reputation for putting
customers calling for information on old for what seemed an ete
nity (as defined bythe marketplace), Whether the client believed
‘tor not, ths had become a “promite” that customers had come
toexpect,
‘To develop a successful Brand Contract, a company has to frst
understand its brand’s current set of promises as defined by the
‘marketplace. Next, it must determine f this contrat is the one it
perceived the brand to have, Then it has to take action to ether
{improve the Brand Contract or strengthen the positive promises
already in place.
Critical to the success of a Brand Contract is that, before the
contracts made and its positive promises publi sated, your orga-
nization determines how best make them a realy. For example,
5jold problem by ont
« cient just mentioned sdeessed dhe ori
eee itso eal center. The att center Wowk
Mae ei tgewer dhe phone and either find someone to talk to
Jame dae uni thir seconds orgie a ime when a company
“wo no longer Per
fepresentative would call back. Thus “en hold”
[thea to be a negative promise or expectation,
Developing a Brand Contract should be aligned with the brand
image research trom Step Two and be derived directly from it (see
Figure 8.1)
‘The Importance of Upholding Contracts
Ina recent Wall Stet Journal article, a writer told Of his experiences
with AT&T's One Rate service. He talked about the brochure and
its promises: No more roaming charges. No more peak hour extra
Charges. One low rate, such as a thousand minutes for $119. Ifyou
‘cannot get a signal, ATRT promises to find a carrier that can. AT&T
‘Gaims you will ike the service 0 mauch that you will use your cel
Islar phone to make all your long distance calls, both from home
and on the road.
‘These wonderful promises (all laid out clearly in the brochure)
definitely hit cellular phone users’ hot buttons. The future is here
and One Rate is it
Figure 3.1, The Brand Image and Customer Expectations
+ Consists ofthe
End experience
{orth by the brand. {
+ The expectations
+ Tear by saying,
|| andoreanieaton
|| Zest”
wt
Dut the writer went on to talk about his frustrations
One Rate plan. The service was inconsistent and did moj nt be
Conain arens within some of the biggest cities in the coun in
times his calls came to a “screeching halt” because the pose!”
con
ee
gether. He was disappointed in the service and frustrated bes”
the promise he thought the brand was making was being bea
‘The implications of this for AT&T go beyond one cuss
dissatisfaction with One Rate. The AT&T brand is on other et?
ee
service, among others, and a bad experience with one prods
a
a
offerings.
Implicit Brand Contracts
A Brand Contract has to be market driven. That is, ic must reflee
what customers really chink and what the company is realy pe-
pared to do. By looking at a company’s current performance, ve
fan sce the contract that the company implicitly offers today and
‘what it must do to improve the contract in the future. The Brand
Contract is a set of promises that you believe will keep current cus
Comers satisfied even as it attracts a new clientele
‘Here is the implicit Brand Contract that Starbucks would prob-
ably develop, based on its current performance, ifit went dhrough
this process of writing a contract.
Starbucks" Implicit Brand Contract
Starbucks promises to do the following:
1. Provide the highest quality coffee available on the market today
2. Offer customers a wide variety of coffee options as well as com
plementary food and beverage items
3, Haye an atmosphere that is warm,
appropriate for having a conversation wid
reading a book
4, Recognize that visiting Starbucks is as much about the see"
ence of drinking coffee as itis about the coffee itself
friendly, homelike, and
ch a good friend oF78 Baw Asser Mawoeseer
6. Provide customers thes
eral thousand Starbueks worldwide
17. Stay current with the times
9 Educate customers on the diferent types of coffee offered
(A few ways that Starbucks currently supports such a contract
include hiring people who have an outgoing personaly, cdecae
ing consumers through brochures and literature about sre differ
cnt pes of coffee; continuing to offer new products that add
the experience (such as compact dses); and providing the seme
‘ype of employee training regardless of location,
As another example, the evolution of Kinko's implicit Brand
Contract over the last fifteen years has been interesting to follow,
Jn the beginning, Kinko's strategy and positioning revolved pri,
marily around serving the needs of university students, wth
‘Kinko's locations at or near most major universitc,
‘A Kinko's Brand Contract back then would probably have
included the follossing:
Kinko's “Ola” Implicit Brand Contract
Kinko's promises to do the following:
2. Provide customers with friendly service
2 Be open twenty-four hours a day
5. Have convenient, sensible locations
+ Hire knowledgeable employees working ateach tore who can _
help students and others troubleshoot any problems
Have a computer station waiting for customers who need one
6, Provide a variety of services, from copying to binding to pro-
ducing business cards
From a customer perspective, Kinko's contract probably also
included a few negative promises such as these:
csr Your Baa 's Commence 15
7. Charge premium prices for every piece of paper sold
8, Have long lines at the cash register and to get on a computer
9, Have some poorly trained employees
Later Kinko's reached out o the athome and small business
communities, Consequently it encountered many challenges us
‘ied to expand and develop a deeper and more meaningfal con
‘ract with its customers, Kinko's had to migrate from its positon
a8 college campus copy shop to one asa small business partner
‘Todo that ithad to upgrade its implicit Brand Contract to meet
the growing needs of smaller businesses as they become more
sophisticated
‘Why? First, competitors such as Mailboxes, Ete, have come into
the market and tried to replicate Kinko's unique points of eiffer-
entiation, Therefore, Kinko's must be concemed with keeping its
‘current core business intact.
Second, many customers have become more sophisticated than
‘Kinko's employees. This was not the ease ten years ago, but expec.
tations of service and expertise are much higher than they used to
bbe. Third, as Kinko's has grown the service provided by employees
hhas declined and become less consistent.
Kinko's also faces another problem. Strong franchises gain
‘their strength by having customers experience the same level of
Service and satisfaction at any oftheir establishments regardless
‘of location, and a good Brand Contract must reflect this. This may
not be the ease for Kinko's anymore.
For instance, there are two Kinko's within a few blocks of each
ther niear my office in downtown Chicago, One of them I would
‘rust with any client presentation; the other I would not,
Four Principles for Developing a Brand Contract
Sohow does one get started in developing a Brand Contract? Fore
‘tunately, your Brand Contract can be derived from the same
esearch that you conduct in determining your brand's image
‘Again, be sure to conduct this research relative to a few key com
ppetitors so that you can make comparisons between your brand
and theirs. Beyond that, ifyou keep four guiding principtes in
‘mind the process should be straightforward.S) moo Ars
7
1. Understand the Brand Contract
from Your Customers’ Perspective
‘The research questions you should ask when developing your
‘Brand Contract complemenc those you ask when determining your
brand's image. These questions ean include the following:
+ In making a purchase inthis category, what were the
benefits you expected to receive?
*+ What are the mostimportant aspects of service that @
provider must be sure to offer?
+ Did Brand X meet your benefit expectations? Why? Why not?
*+ What promises docs Brand X make? Positive promises?
‘Negative promises? What impact do these promises have
‘on your perceptions ofthe brand?
+ How did you arrive at your perceptions of promises?
+ Do other brands make different promises or set different
expectations than Brand X?
“ait with sigh
Contract
{bo not let me
nave when
* Once you purchased Brand X, how well did the actual brand
experience match with your expectations?
* What could have'been done differently to make your
purchase and brand experience an even better one?
+ How well did Brand X match up to the promises you expected
bbefore the purchase, during use of the actual product or
service, and afterward?
viliy’s Band
32.4
——-
ned proce
sone na ete oc
en ety com
sore money
+ Help me mana
‘+ When you think about Brand X, what other promises could
you imagine it making?
Figure
‘The Key to making this process work isto have it be driven by
customers and key purchase influencers, not internal managers
‘You need to expect negative promises and not think about this
exercise defensively. Think of it asa critical
Jong.-term brand satisfaction,
mt Soni
cleric ebay
Prce te commod
path to maximizing
‘Your Brand Contract can and should shift over time and most
likely will have nuances that vary with the customer set. For exam
ple, ifyou own a utility ora telecommunication brand the contract
‘vill be very different for commercial versus residential customers
age ny ovetead by ansing%°
ergy efiency
elise gasand
se eter understand ny energy SUC.
“Basinesesreqlre
nize wy
(see Figure 8.2)
C
fe
+ Conduct an energy 3
|BD Boo Aer Muwcnant
2. Transat the Brand Contract into Standards
‘The etal tantation from
rine whether you have in
promise come true
‘When Fred Smith and his senior management tach trans
formed the brand identity of Federal Expres to tavah eee
few yeas ago, they had tao prima
beeves Fit tney wanted
wince thelr brand seommimene the dake ee
promises that the company had perfected oes he on ses
they wanted to update the look fhe company dre nee nes
‘and colors, mer a
To ntroduce this initiate to FedEx employes ss th
sath story
s0cs Smith and hs eam rented out alge petoee emg a,
plajet attend special meeting
a packed wh rows emplog,
agement eam sted he ee
old Federal Expres silane and
tal them way goodbye to forever asittove off he ee
Feats airplane entered with ts new logo new colo and nek
sn inovatie look
After the unveiling, the management team talked about
{he promises FedEx makes to its customers everyday and how those
promises differentiate FedEx from its competition and keep it
number one in customer satisfaction and loyalty, Management
went on to explain that the redesign symbolized the company's
commitment to continuous improvement and to meeting the
demanding high-quality service needs of ts loyal and expanding
Employees went back to their offices motivated and with
enewed vigor. Upon arrival back at headquarters, they discovered,
‘hat everything had been changed to reflect the new brand. From,
the signage outside to the business cards and stationery on each,
desk to the screen saver on everyone's computer, everything that
‘had been Federal Express that morning was now FedEx.
‘The implicit message ofthis quick conversion was that FedEx
‘sina business in which speed and timeliness mean everything to
«sstomers, FedEx’ ability to keep its promises to customers (your
package will be there by 10:80 tomorrow morning”), and even,
Promises to standards helps you deter:
place what it takes to make the brand
there ont morning. The hangar
es. In dramatic fashion, the ma
ing by showing employees the
cammcYoun bee's Cosract
delight osomers by delering» package eer han expected
asbeen key to erpng the mane vo coal Ped as one
of he ronges Brand Cantace he seen,
Trporanty a promise means acon A promis of veright
delivery mean developing a fives datbuion and transport:
ton inasrserre fra baxinet that promises action "when i
sol potnly has tobe tere overnight
"Te MeDonalis Brand Contit promt customers that hey
vil getthe ame experience in each ad very McDonalds estar
fal That mean hat Over adn hare side
2 common tof guidelines, quality contol, and standares
Thralow MeDenaiy to upholé eprom geal nsec
MeDorali's promise ot hating the best rench is let nest
in new yer eco thar ate tei es ase even beter
TBM Consulting’ Brond Contract
In the early to mig-1990s, “Solutions for a Small Planet" was born
out ofan effort to reconnect all of IBM under one positioning
‘umbrella. Iallowed forthe (apparently) seamless introduction of
IBM's cusines, which today i the fastest growing part of the com-
‘pany. Lou Gerstner, CEO atthe time, helped IBM recognize that it
Sin aservice business as mach asa product business (in fact, one-
third of revenues today comes from services) and that new service
offerings would only help to build the TBM brand
TBM Consulting was being tested as one of many new service
offerings, aimed at helping IBM expand and become recognized
asa global solution provider. Part of the project miy company con-
ducted was aimed at helping IBM Consulting define the promises
‘twould have-to make in the marketplace to be successful
Many inside TBM believed the marketplace would not find IBM.
10 be credible in offering consulting services; one early internal
bypothesis was that the consulting services business should be
called Watson & Associates (after founder Thomas Watson) to se
arate “Big Blue” from the new offering, The marketplace rejected
‘Watson & Associates because it believed the power of the IBM
‘brand was too strong to not leverage in any new service offering,
Many executives and ClOs in outside firms thought IBM Com.
sulting could be a great success because ofthe inherent exper
‘However, this part of the marketplace believed that IBM CorNRE eee a
baw Ase Macrae
‘would need fo make and keep several brand promises to he cred
ble, including these
+ Any recommendation made by the IBM Consulting Group
vill Include two non-1BM recommendations or solutions to
establish objecivig: (Many executives wondered if IBM would
use the Consulting Group to sell more hardware and softwate;
some said thac the firs time IBM Consulting recommended an
IBMonly solution as the only solauon would be the last time
they would use IBM Consulting}
* IDM vill investin methodologies forts consultants to employ
fon engagements.
* IBM will hire some new people from proven and established
‘consulting firms forthe Consulting Group. (The market
Dlace also needed evidence that retraining of current IBM.
Employees, now to be called consultant, was taking place )
* The IM Consulting Group wall prove that the value it
provides is above and beyond the free advice customers
had been receiving for years
* IBM will eam how to market its consulting sils to new
buyers. (Potential clients generally learn about consulting
firms through seminars, speeches, articles, books, and word.
‘oF mouth)
The IBM Consulting Group activate is Brand Contract through
‘any new initiatives. Fist, ithired numerous outsiders fom other
Consulting firms to lead projecs and bring the credibility needed.
{launch this successfully. Second, it brought in an outsider from,
tone of the top consulting firms in the world to run the business
because the consulting business model was very different from that
of the hardware business model
Third, it spent months developing unique methodologies
Fourth, it hired my company to train over 3,000 consultants work
‘wide on core consulting skills and to share findings from our
slobal branding project. Fifth, itset up new career atks and com.
pensation packages that more closely align with the consulting
Industry, as opposed to traditional IBM career tacks. And sixth, tt
spent. fot of time marketing its new offering and expertise in the
way the market demanded,
t
cunmscYou Buses Cowmacr 85
at cng ane spor om nor
sonngrene ene the organization aes fons oa
Siig conung ect of isnt utomeregnents 2d
ie aga poms Se mvc 0
tes hein Catlcngereups nor neo ey oa
fein wor and brand ieeonynons ih ately
Neal conulungand many ssid cen
Ho ers thceecond ging pnp you mst be ab
coat promises neato. You may have make changes
Syournianestreivestia operons ad aw tne or
tag cones mat pre sour prong bce
the Selene of appre when ousy you re he Destin
ws yathavetohnow tow dehoe sere rom a estomer pet
tpeche and en nowhow oimpementitsod mesure youre
“Rive tw easomer saisacon lel Figure 33 show an ex
fleafbow brand sodas taunts Brand Conactand
{henced opersionalie these promises.
3. Fulfill the “Good” Promises of Your Brand Contract
or Risk Damaging the Brand
‘This principle is inuitive, but does deserve some attention. Star
bbucks’ promises are in place every day. Itis important that cus-
‘tomers experiences are similar and sausjing each time they visita
Starbucks. Such consistency leads to lol ct. ers. When Star
‘bucks announced a price increase in 1999, it had eninimal impact,
fon sales and the brand overall because, as mentioned in Chapter
‘One, powerful brands are able to overcome negative news more
readily Similarly, when Starbucks comes out with a new product,
like frappuceino a few years ago, there is instant acceptance
because the company has credibility and people assume that the
{quality of the product will be high before they even ty it.
Butas Starbucks increases its outlets and distribution channels,
Itrisks losing control over the promises of its Brand Contract. I
consistently hear complains about the taste of Starbucks coffee on,
United Airlines. I's probably better than coffee on any other ai
line, but because it's Starbucks the expectations are inherently
higherisan ¥oun Bauso's Cosmet #7
Countless companies do not treat their brand and its contract
asseriously as they should, For instance, Avon may be taking a risk
by opening up aspa in Manhattan hecatse it undermines the foun:
dation of what the company was built upon: one-on-one relation
ships with each customer in her home, natn Avon's “home.”
‘As mentioned earlier Volvo's move from safety to performance
afew years ago was not consistent with it Brand Contract, which
resulted in a downturn in sales. And can ATA become an airline
for business professionals after years of the jingle, "With ATA,
you're on vacation”?
‘When my company helps develop @ Brand Contract, we always
suk the client o think about a few contract stipulations that do not
exis today but that they would like tose inthe future. This forces
‘an organization to think about the future and connect back to the
Brand Vision. Obviously, future promises need to be worked on
today if they are to come to life in afew years.
fd te things that are important to them.
+ Mate all nen and features entertaining end
jor Newspaper
z
Bran contact
ins, an editorial on how nes,
sitet reader
+ Make reporter columns and etal
+ Provide balanced perspective nates,
‘alfa to reader they haves
Personal connection othe wer
+ Enhance swe sndinformatn to make
‘meaningful connections wo read
depth than nigh broads ev
+ Cover local new not onl forte sate but for
thought proveking
+ Provide competetive acute, a imely
compe
+ Gary nteratonal and natonl ews in more
4. Uncover and Address the "Bad” Promises ofthe Brand
‘TOI, one of the largest cable providers in the country and a recent
Acquisition by AT&T, underwent a major overhaul ofits identity
and services a few years ago. The TCI brand had so many negative
connotations that the company had to do something for fear of
losing its business tothe satelite industry.
‘Three ofthe worst brand promises customers articulated about
‘Tet were there:
|
ia}
‘Connects me tothe wor
* You will waita Tong time to get from TCI’ impersonal
telephone automation system to a human being,
+ You will have to miss 2 day of work f you need to have a
service cal; you never know when a service person will
show up.
‘+ Someone will have to come out to your home to fix any
problem you have with your cable
Tnformation relevant tome
Figure 3.3. Moving from Brand Associations to a Brand Contract ata Maj
Wide coverage! local atonal, international
‘TCL improved its Brand Contract by directly addressing these
three issues, as well asa fev others that had less of an impact on.
the brand, TCI now answers phone ealls onthe first ring, has tec:
nicians that can generally sole your problem over the phone, and88. Brawn Asser MANAGEMENT
m toa
¢ call dow
is able to narrow the window of time for a servic
couple of hours.
Summary ses
The Brand Contract concept is simple: understand the Lee
your brand makes, identify those that ere important to y* ee
tomers, and identify the promises that your brand can m: el
well as shortcomings or areas for improvement. Then develop
contract that states all of this. The result will be a customer-driven,
operationally achievable contract and a valuable brand in the
marketplace. ~
Developing a Brand Contract is Step Three in the brand asset
management process and the second part of Phase 2, developing
2 BrandPicture. Once a Brand Contracts established, we can move
on to defining a brand-based model of the customer, which is the
subject of Step Four.f emuring
E urRenuea
‘On Brand
F Haag +
q trandtased
Investment
Crafting a Brand-Based
Customer Model
Developing a customer model isthe third and final pat of the
BrandPicture (se the illustration onthe facing page) The intent
here isto provide a comprehensive understanding of customer
beliefs and behaviors that bear on the brand, the product or ser
vice, the category, and the competitors. The custemer model con-
Siders former, present, and potential customers and encompasses
the range of beliefs and behaviors that such customers hold, not
just the prevalent opinion,
Consider the following tale ofa company that knew its cus
{omers well. and then lost touch with them
Case Study The Sein Story
Sv: an Areian onthe worl fins. Remember the Collet, he
‘ashe Stingray? Sehrion was among te ete brands fo sever deca,
‘Years gp ereyone new abut Scrnn, what tod fo and te igh
qualiyoisbiglee
But in 195, Scion fd fo Chapter 1 ant alms wen vay or
od. hat gpd?
Tn is early as, around shun esa, Sch so forthe
fest mode of tarspraton mone could buy twas hh presi brand
that cape the nations terion before the car as vented and ook ver
thetranspoaton mae Back then, a Scovinn cst §127—more than
sexe ey ca,
aso the 140 and 19505, hen ater pation ket
tafe chin dynasty The rand wa til pegs, buts lesureerates han made of wane Shs pata anon
Ada "da mshi pic a aa eae
inte 1 Soon mpd ea ain a aed a
es raging won ais a. Tis hued sc
se Sinn wath aby 197, ws nara ain
Dios yea Attn, was et otha Ca ol aed
vote al Anerin age
Ine 1705S abt ure
Sines ead atc orate
Deethen tessi temat ale
{nthe ea howe Sin sae ole fos on beth is
Sea ane acts al mountable wees
‘etc masapert eens wee psig fala hat ie
‘any an woud dep lich rds Lag alia
Seen ee st haps anda caying ant ncommending ater nde
Seon sg septa
song bul nas sis Maly and Tek,
became rs he ehcad wi,
Nos oie magnet the
en pe es, thu ppl
ws el ono sperm sae geen was
wheat tthe enpany The alee Vary
“or sig asmoura hs aa a con ty
Seta cass nd
ses raid hig, one
‘eds ul wan, juryedon tte,
olsen
‘Te cangay renal,
Grp, ahs nei
‘She
‘wai ihe wen efor was tae
‘cli having onan Tk an eal
fib tess ie pe aha,
haat bet ot,
Nsbmune tea Selvin um qaupnand ahs,
ra Gates Gans, al many ppt ct a
“NG bsc The a neath eae lcd ha
pawobasee Custonen Mooi, 93
tt
tatu tothe pate ant le Pai
‘Srmjena ig cmt ree me
‘etc asin
Sherecocme
A Customer Model Answers Three Questions
Developing a customer model is done to provide answers to three
important questions relative 1 the brand:
1. How do customer choose one brand over another when mak:
ings purchase
2, Hw does your rand sack. up guns compeding brands?
3. What opportunites ext for brand growth and expansion?
Finding the answers enables a company to beter postion and
extend is brand and to exer greater influence on tne purchase
decision, thus leveraging she per ofthe brand more eorpletly,
Table. shows an energy cusomer’ teedel Remeneak
The answers aio provide might ior future management of
the brand, including beter understanding of consussery nor
ceptions of individual brands and brand categonen For mares,
‘Table 4.1, Energy Customer Model Framenock
—_ SEE: Enerey Customer Model Framework
Rocha precy Cmpeornas Nas and wu
Pignonic proce Ree abou ee about danger
Purehase drivers peer Beliefs about environ.
and tei rte formeasurng ena mpet
‘Purchase process. Sort Beliefs about gas
soem Keowledgeot dete
cries Mme cheese ou ic
bareislaa a earact of deregulation
Management as
Core sence
cof pureliase criteria
expectations
Speci needs
and antsQuestion 1: How Do Customers Choose a Brand?
Addressing this one question shot :
brad bling on nterercateren coe gan so
your brand instead of a competitor’ sof the eaegen,
: Petitors, regardless of the cate
Thlsnvobes answering thre further queigng fe ESO
‘+ What bind of purchase
do customers use?
+ How do they rate your brand,
brands, by hose criteria?
*+ Who at the customer decides
Who else influences the deci
important to each?
Process and purchase criteria
85 opposed to competitors’
to make brand-based purchases?
sions? Which criteria are
Finding Out Your Customer's Purchase Criteria
Regarles of indus, customers uly we pchae ctr such
“sie ale etency comenines meee age
omer sevice, personal selatonsha ie
Lonsipsength,rlaonsip eng dependably payer
credit polices, past experiences, pees recommendater cieee
i beni ece,oaon ad wal
fost customers donate brand es top eitetion, probably
because the brand astames alot ofthe factorajust eed oh os
depen consistency, and length of ne muses When
wesurvoyed customers actos categorie they eted nine ater
mostoien. In order, they are the folowing
1. High quality and reliability
2 Consistent performance
Ccuarnns a Buse Basen Coonan Moo, 95
8. Familiariy
4, Availability and convenience
5, Pricesalue relationship
6. Fiewith customer personality
7. Abilityto solve a customer problem
8. Customer service
9. Advertsing
Implicit i this lis t another characteristic: trust—which is
‘often synonymous with the definition of the brand. The essence of
a good brand is that people trust it. Trust implies that customers
know exactly what they are going to get when they make the pur
chase, and thatitis on terms they are comfortable wit. Itmay also
‘imply experience with the brand. Especially on the top three pur-
‘chase criteria—high quality and reliably, consistent performance
and familiaity—trust cuts across each.
Rating Brand-Based Purchase Criteria
Once you have determined the broad list of customer purchase
decision-making criteria, the next step is to ask both your and com-
petiton’ customers how your brand s performing relative to them.
‘Todo this, ask customers to rank the alternatives on a scale of
11405. This forces customers to think through the criteria relatively
as opposed to absolutely, and to differentiate between brands,
[At the end of this process, you will know how your brand
stacks up against the competition. It will also tell you where to
focus attention to improve your brand's performance and, ult
rately, strengthen the impact the brand has on the overall pur-
chase decision. :
For example, Table 4.2 compares brand purchase criteria for
1 major retail catalogue brand whose top two competitors are
Sears and Wal-Mart. The criteria ae listed in descending order of
importance.
‘The catalogue retailer has scores of 4 or 5 on four ofthe seven
attributes. Ithas the advantage of a major Internet retail busines,
‘which gave ita higher convenience score than WalMart and Sears,
‘who have not established major Internet service yet (although both
Jhave recently announced theie respective Internet strategies)36 Bee AsserAtawcient
Purchase
Giteron
Dice
Accessbiliy/convenicnce
Brands available
Customer service
Paymentand cet policies
Producelection
Pas experience wih retailer
Nae Becton > poor SS
‘The catalogue company’s strate
fgranteasy credit to customers. I
‘volume will ead to high profits,
ay is to charge higher prices but
Is theory is thatthe resulting high
ven if easy credit creates some bad
Saini tahe future, though, if service stays poor the company may
Eng more difculcojusiy higher prices, regardless of easy
credit
‘The biggest advantage
Products it sells and the numt
rand can drive sales and influence the
purchase decision.
Learning customer purchase cri
the areas companies should
land more
‘tiportaatly, i allows senior management to idendf
iy gaps be-
cuarnnc a Beano Basen Gustosex Monet. 97
aknesses and
tween the market's perceptions of strengths and weak
theirs,
Find Out Who Makes the Purchase Decision
aio mportanio ecogoze the deen roles hat dion
tmaersand desion influencers hav ia choosing one br
“eet brand managers think bout everoneinvobed in the
‘rand decision, They understand who the players are and ty to
Bure ost how o sell heir brand to each, For instance, most peo-
Ble bring another person with them to choose new cat The
Ereit ear you we probably the sme one our spouse uses, and
whatever computer iin your offie is probably the same one In
the office next don
Belton celeading manufacturer of hearing iin the worl
now that nany actos inhibit the sale of hearing td, nce
Sng the signa of wearing one, vanity denial of having a probion,
and denial of geting older. ln overcoming thew ifibors the
number one enabler to sling a hearing aid may ber spouse,
Chilo dose iend. Many potential purchaser wal ree ty
the heasing aid han hear one more complaint fom slave oon
Belione knows, dherefre, that be succenlul Rimes guai haa
sells rand to bot the potent byerand de ea
Similar inthe basinest busing
world there are numerous
influencers but usually only one decisi
ion maker. IBM recognizes
and the head of purchasing
Hallmark unabashedly markets to the recipients as well a the
‘buyers of its catds, Ie tries to convince the
Maang the recipient will ois tur it over to see fi iv'a Haan
‘Marketing or truth? Regardless, Hallmark's strategy shove thar
‘sone ofthe best at managing its brand as an ance
Lngiating the key purchase ereria exercise with the decision:
tmaking process enables you to better understand hey youcan
Fears Yur brand to maximize is potential wo influcnee sete
your category.
purchaser that the first58 Raw Ase Mawacauet
Question 2: How Does Your Brand
Against the Competition? Stack Up
in our category?
+ Whatare the stren
chs and weaknesses o
‘How does our brar nd comes f competitive brands?
ind compare on specific values and hence
Identify Your Competitors
‘ant to your customers
This competitive asessment requires you to look at competitors
and competitive brands from the customer's point of view One,
‘omers may define your competitive set much differently than you
‘would, Whether a customer cites a direct or indirect competion or
branded or nonbranded competitor, itis in your best interest to
think about your competitor set in the same way your customers de.
In the Schwinn example, for instance, the competitive sets for
sansportation, children’s recreation, adult exercise, and outdoor
sportare very different.
Nontraditional Competitors
‘ou are in the shipping business and assure FedEx, DEL, UPS,
and the Post Office are your most important competitors, talk to
your customers, They may mention, for example, e-mail. In other
-ategories, nontraditional competitors might include these:
* Por automobile manufacturers and dealers: AutoNation
+ For Xerox: Kinko's outsourcing copier service
* For Endust, Pledge, Bounty, and Hoover: maid services
* For the San Diego Zoo: Disneyland and Sea World
corre a Bran Baste Grown Mose 9)
Don’t forget the simpler alternatives to your offering. Note, for
example, that Coca-Cola says ite number one competitor is tap
‘water, not Peps
Compare Your Brand to Competing Brands -
‘The failure to understand one's competition is ultimately the fail
lure to know one's customers: who they are, how they think, and
hhow the brand can be adapted to meet their needs. Once you
lunderstand that your brand faces bath traditional and nontradi
tional competitors, you can study the benefits they provide, their
strengths and weaknesses, and their future directions,
Figures 4.1 and 4.2 are competition matrices that show how
2 brand can be compared to competitor brands. Your brand image,
‘Brand Contract, and the purchase criteria allow you to map your
company’s brand against others. As the figures show, you can map
the competition from a number of different perspectives, The
‘maps enable you to envision the strategies and approaches needed
to maximize your brand’s potential. Competitor mapping helps
when you are trying to do the following:
+ Prioritize segments to pursue
* Determine how best to position your brand relative
to competitive brands
Figure.
—
~~ L a
cnn ei \ (sie) re)
Financial Services Competitor Map
Innovative —
Desired tomorrow,
|eompetiors/\ | companies | }
\ 7 Cen otay
\ 4 (awe SY
ational competion)
Tena =
12 Rae Aer Manse
+ Decermine the right messages to convey considering:
the compenton, your chosen positoning. and the
segment yea wl purmue
{Question 5: What Opportunities Exist for
wer potential oppor:
sendibility for our
are discussed x derail
Asmverng these questions jumostars che efort to determine
Seandanes of vour brand. This in rurn aliows you to offer a
sctugos through rour brand, thus improving fs image, enhancing
‘Se Beazd Contac and farher inereasin a
caurmmc a Buse Rasta Costosen Mone:
ications Competitor Map
Figure 4.2, Telecommunications
eS ee
companys
oe 9 CompaavE |
5 O compass sss i
i mS Comey |
a OCompany D 1
1
Degas fcatoninon
and concems about haggling, credit rerms, and the cost of new
cars. Saturn was created (0 address these problem areas by inven’-
ing “a diferent car, a different car company.”
eToys also meets 2 need that no one had satisfactorily
addressed before. Parents no longer have the time to shop in
crowded stores with long lines and kids on their arms wanting
everything they see. eToys helps. Itis convenient; it offers all the
toys and books available at Toys ‘R’ Us through the Web.
parking lots, no ines, no pressure from kids seeing a storefil of
6 tos.
Similar for consumers who don't have the time to go grocery
Peapod lets chem do it omline. This successhu! service
"8 constumers to choose the desired color oftheir bananas
ve their groceries delivered to their home for a premium,
at Bell Telephone (CBT) knew the Interne: opporn
ovring and lucrative and wanted to figure out a prot
enter the category by leveraging its strong brand
talking with small and at-home business owners, CBT
I atone great
Deing able to use the phone and the Internet
same phone line. So CBT developed In
h allows small business owners to decid
coming call or not. This dev
he same amie over
ternet Call Manage:
le if they want to take
ice wses.acaller ID, which displarsDucat
Band A) Bente
se | mete) SC
rand | Brande
i
#
i