Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Surf 99010 Fu
Surf 99010 Fu
Abstract
1 Introduction
0.09% Ti. The yield and tensile strength are 430 and 460 MPa respectively,
Young's modulus 72 GPa, and Poisson's ratio 0.33.
SECTION
A-A'
6=16
All dimensions in mm
Figure 1: Dimensions of cold expanded specimens.
the central hole towards the edge of the disc, to a distance of about 3.5mm from
the edge of the discs. Since the beam size was Ixlmm, residual stresses within
0.5mm of the hole edge could not be measured. Measurements were made of
surface hoop residual stresses, and no radial residual stress measurements were
made.
Surface hoop residual stresses are shown in Figure 2 for the mandrel exit and
entrance faces, at 8=0 and 0=90°. The most compressive residual stress (-
350MPa) was found about 1mm from the hole edge on the mandrel exit face at
the position of the split in the sleeve (6=0°). The least compressive hoop residual
stress (about -lOOMPa) was measured on the mandrel entrance face along a
radial line at 90 degrees to the position of the split in the sleeve.
The results in Figure 2 show that there is a significant difference in the hoop
residual stresses on the surface of the mandrel entrance and exit faces. Residual
stresses on the mandrel exit face were more compressive and differences
between stresses on the mandrel exit and entrance faces were more pronounced
at 90° than at 0°. For example, the largest difference between residual stresses on
the two faces is 200 MPa and 100 MPa at 90° and 0° respectively. The hoop
residual stresses also vary as a function of position around the hole and are more
compressive at 0° than at 90°.
position. In the new method, angular variations in strain are measured. This
requires that strain gauges at different locations are used, and a Fourier analysis
of the angular strain distribution undertaken. The detailed theoretical analysis is
given in^.
The Garcia-Sachs method was used to measure residual stresses in the cold
expanded discs used for the X-ray measurements. To use the Garcia-Sachs
method five strain gauges were bonded at 8=0, 45, 90, 135, and 180° on the edge
of the discs, as shown in Figure 1. The strain gauges were orientated on the edge
of the disc to measure hoop strains during boring. Cold expanded holes were
bored out incrementally using a boring machine. A number of specimens were
tested and a feed rate of 1 mm/sec was selected as it gave the greatest
repeatability. In performing the machining, a sharp tool and a slow cutting speed
with copious amounts of coolant were employed to minimise the possibility of
generating further residual stresses in the exposed surface during metal removal.
For each increment of boring the strains at each of the strain gauges were
measured. Cuts were made in increments of about 0.05 mm and readings were
taken typically every 0.2 mm increasing to up to 0.5 mm at about 6 mm from the
hole edge. A micrometer was used to measure the hole diameter corresponding
to each strain reading.
To determine the residual stresses from the measured strains, first a Fourier
analysis was performed on the strains. Equation (Al) describing the measured
strain increments, r((r,8), is given in the appendix. The analysis of strain was
restricted to the first five Fourier terms of the cosine coefficients, rj^ for n=0 to
4. The residual stresses corresponding to each of the coefficients were
determined using equations (A3) to (A5), given in the appendix for the first three
coefficients. Equations for the remaining two terms are similar to Equation (A5),
and are expressed in a general form in equation (A6). The complete residual
stress distribution for the hoop, aee(r,9), radial, cr,-r(r,8) and shear stresses, Tre(r,6)
was found by summing the residual stress terms using equation (A2).
Results for the measured hoop, radial and shear residual stresses are shown in
Figure 3. Hoop residual stresses at 9=0, 90 and 180° are shown in Figure 3a, and
radial residual stresses are shown Figure 3b for the same angles. Also shown in
Figure 3a are measured shear residual stresses at 9=90°. The maximum
compressive hoop residual stress occurred at 8=0°, and at about 0.5mm from the
edge of the hole. It is also evident that there was a significant variation of hoop
residual stresses with angular position adjacent to the hole. For example at the
hole edge the hoop residual stress varied from about -420MPa at 9=0° to
-140MPa at 9=180°. This variation becomes less significant with increasing
distance away from the hole, so that at about 5.5mm from the centre of the hole
the residual stresses were essentially axisymmetric.
As might be expected the radial stresses, shown in Figure 3b, also exhibited a
dependence on angular position. Radial stresses were entirely compressive over
the measured range and reached a maximum at about 5.5mm from the centre of a
hole. The largest compressive radial residual stress of-120MPa was found at 0°
and the least compressive stress of-80MPa at 180°.
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
100 : (a)
-100
Garcia-Sachs
"3 -200
measurements
-500
4 5 6 7
Distance from hole centre, r [mm]
100
(b) Garcia-Sachs measurements
__o__ errr ',6=0° Q_a rr,' 8=180°
50
. . v • <*„ , 9=90° ..-*.. T^Q , 8=90°
a =- 0
^ T .^. .^-'V ?' T
^
-50
C v
•2 1 -100
-150
4 5 6 7
Distance from hole centre, r [mm]
Figure 3: Residual stresses measured using the new Garcia-Sachs
method, (a) Hoop, (b)Radial and Shear
The shear residual stresses were relatively small, as shown in Figure 3b for
8=90°. Although not shown a similar distribution was found at 45°. At 9=0° and
180° shear residual stresses were approximately equal to zero, and are not
included in the figure.
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
• Experimental
FE models
— Combined
Kinematic
Isotropic
2
Strain, f [%]
Figure 4: Stress-strain behaviour for Al 2650 and FE hardening models.
The stress-strain curves for these models are also shown in Figure 4. The
combined hardening model allows both expansion and translation of the yield
surface and gives the best representation of the material response. The material
parameters for this model were identified iteratively.
An axisymmetric FE model was employed, similar to that used by Pavier et
ar\ The analysis included a simulation of the mandrel being pulled through the
hole containing the sleeve. Since an axisymmetric model was used, the
simulation did not include the opening of the sleeve. The mandrel and sleeve
were simulated as a rigid surface moving in the z direction as indicated in Figure
1. The rigid surface included the dimensions of mandrel plus sleeve to provide a
4 % radial expansion of the aluminium plate. The disc was modelled using 80
by 50 (in the radial and axial directions respectively) first order, 4 noded
axisymmetric elements. Contact elements were placed between the rigid surface
simulating the moving mandrel and the disc. The boundary conditions were
applied to the mandrel in 240 steps to complete an axial displacement that
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
allowed the mandrel to be pulled through the hole. A means of constraining the
disc from moving in the z direction during the simulation of cold expansion was
provided by non-linear springs placed around the hole periphery. Reid and co-
workers^ also used this method for constraining the disc.
-100
Garcia-Sachs
-200 measurement
cq
o 8 = 90"
-300 FE results
Q. — Combined
O -400 Kinematic
O
SB Isotropic
-500
3 4 5 6 7 8
Distance from hole centre, r [mm]
Figure 5: Hoop residual stresses measured using the new Garcia-Sachs
method compared to FE axisymmetric simulations.
-100
CQ -200
3
s
i -300
Typical error bar on
o
o -400 iX-ray measurement
33
-500
3 4 5 6 7 1
Distance from hole centre, r [mm]
Figure 6: Hoop residual stresses measured using X-ray diffraction
compared to FE axisymmetric simulations.
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
3.2 Results
The residual stresses resulting from a 4% cold expansion are very similar those
obtained for aluminium alloy 2024 by Pavier et al*. Reversed yielding, as a
result of unloading during the cold expansion process, was obtained adjacent to
the hole edge. This is the region where there is a significant influence of the
material hardening model. Predicted hoop residual stresses, averaged through
the thickness, are shown in figure 5. Results for each of the three different
material models are shown. The most compressive residual stress was found
using the isotropic model, while the least compressive residual stress was
obtained using the combined hardening material model.
As reported in previous studies^ the predicted residual stresses varied
through the thickness of the plate. The least compressive residual stresses were
found close to the mandrel entrance face, irrespective of the material model used.
In Figure 6, the FE hoop residual stresses at the mandrel entrance and exit faces
are shown. These results were obtained from averaged nodal values for through
thickness depths up to 0.1 mm from the mandrel entrance and exit faces. The
depth of O.lmm is intended to represent the maximum depth of penetration for
the X-ray measurement method.
At the mandrel entrance face the predicted near surface hoop residual stress
was approximately constant at about -lOOMPa, while at the mandrel exit face the
near surface residual stress wass much more compressive and similar to the
predicted residual stress averaged through the thickness.
4 Discussion
100
& 0
3
-100
-200
735
-300
a
o Garcia-Sachs Conventional Sachs
o -400 —o__ 8=0° —+— 8=0°
a
..^.. 8=90° ..^..8=90°
-500
The results obtained from measurements using X-ray and the Garcia-Sachs
methods confirm earlier surface residual stress measurements*. The most
compressive hoop residual stresses were obtained at cold expanded holes using
the split-sleeve process at 0° and the least compressive at 180°. Furthermore, the
residual stresses were shown to be a function of angular location, distance
through the thickness and radial distance from the hole edge. The results
presented here indicate that split-sleeve cold expansion of holes induces an
asymmetric residual stress field. Importantly, the conventional Sachs method is
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
not able to resolve residual stress variation around a hole. Results obtained in
earlier investigations ^, using the conventional technique to obtain the angular
distribution, are incorrect. In contrast, the new Garcia-Sachs method can be used
to calculate the angular variation of hoop, radial and shear stresses.
Concluding remarks
Acknowledgements
Appendix
Relevant equations used in the Garcia-Sachs method are given below, together
with relevant notation.
Notation:
a Radius at which the boring process is started.
b Radius at which strains are measured.
rjfj (r, 0) - A£0^ (r, 0) Measured strain at radius b.
M =E Elastic constant for plane stress.
M = r- Elastic constant for plane strain.
\-v
»<>(r)sin(/i0) (Al)
H=0 H=0
The corresponding stresses are also described using Fourier equations, where
Transactions on Engineering Sciences vol 25, © 1999 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3533
cr»(r,0)= £aJ'''>(r)cosM+ £c
H=0 M=0
(A2)
W=0 77=0
The coefficients for the first three terms in the Fourier equations for the stresses
are as follows:
_(o)_M62-r\(
(A3)
dr
(A4)
T"
en ' = ( o
-/F
cr ' =cr): /4-r- '+ —
wy 2
(A6)
n dc
References
12. Link, R. E., and Sanford, R. J., "Residual Strains Surrounding split-Sleeve
Cold expanded holes in 7075-T651 Aluminum", Journal of Aircraft, Vol.
27, No 7, 1990.
13. Garcia-Granada,A.A., Pavier,M.J., and Smith, D.J., "A new procedure based
on Sachs' boring for measuring non-axisymmetric residual stresses" In Press,
Journal of Mechanical Sciences.
14. Noyan. I.C., Cohen, J.B., "Residual Stress-Measurment by Diffraction and
Interpretation", MRE, Springer-Verlag, 1987.
15. Chen,P.C.T., "The Bauschinger and hardening effect on residual stresses in
an autofrettaged thick-walled cylinder" Journal of Pressure Vessel
Technology, Vol. 108, pp. 108-112, 1986.
16. Ball,D.L., "Elastic-plastic stress analysis of cold expanded fastener holes"
Fatigue and Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures, Vol.18, No.l
1995, pp. 47-63, 1994.
17. Bauschinger, J., "Ueber die Veranderungen der Elastizitatsgreze und der
Festigkeit des Eisens und Stahls durch Strecken, Quetschen, Erwarmen
Abkuhlen und durch Oftmals Wiederholte Belastung" Mitt: Mech-Tech Lab.,
XIII Munchen, Germany, 1886.
18. Reid, L., Marrese, V., and Easterbrook, E.T., "Residual stress analysis of
cold expanded bushings" Procedings of the 19th Symposium of the
Internatinal Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue, Edinburgh, 18-20 June
1997,pp.871-882, 1997.