Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Assignment On
Labour dissatisfaction in ready-made Garments:
way to overcome.
Submitted to Submitted by
Laily Akter Kamrul Mozahid
ID: 17122409
Lecturer Department of
Economics Session : 2016-2017
Department of Economics
Jatiya Kabi Kazi Nazrul Islam University,
Trishal, Mymensingh.
Page |2
Preface
The objective of this paper is to identify the causes behind labour dissatisfaction in
ready garment’s sector .The situation access to readymade garments sectors, the
life style of labour in RMG sector in Bangladesh, lack of proper education, skill,
labour unrest, lack of facilities in readymade garments sector. Many researchers
have investigated the garments industry in Bangladesh .There is no regular weekly
day off, job security, social security, gratuity or provident fund for the workers.
Absence of reward, lack of training facilities and rare compensation are growing
dissatisfaction among them. Garments workers are not given any fringe benefits,
including accommodation allowance, health care, emergency funds, or
transportation, even though they are legally entitled to some of these benefits, such
as maternity leave. As why, it’s an essential issue in these times to solve this facts.
Keywords:
______________________Column Break________________________
Page |3
Introduction:
The textile or the readymade garment industry of Bangladesh is one the highly
recognised industries in the world. The textile industry relates to the manufacturing
of cloth, yarn and the consequent designs or the distribution and production of
cloth. Like other 3rd world countries Bangladesh is a developing country. Her
economic development depends firstly on agriculture and secondly on industry.
Although Bangladesh is not developed in industry, it has been enriched in Garment
industries in the recent past years. In the field of Industrialization garment industry
is a promising step. It has given the opportunity of employment to millions of
unemployed, especially innumerable uneducated women of the country. It is
making significant contribution in the field of our export income. The RMG
industry has become one of the life lines of Bangladesh economy, sharing a major
part of the country’s export earnings. The industry started its journey in the late
70’s and since then it continued to play a key role in the growth of the economy,
and has emerged as the largest export earning sector of the country. This industry
has contributed in socioeconomic prospects, creating a huge number employment
opportunities mostly for the poor illiterate female workforce of the country. Thus,
the RMG sector has played a vital role in empowering women by providing
employment.
Literature Review
Many researchers have investigated the working conditions in the Bangladesh
garments industry. In fact, working conditions in the RMG sector are below
standard and do not meet the ILO standards. Labour standards and rights are
commonly ignored in the RMG factories in Bangladesh. Work areas are often over
crowded with limited workspaces, causing occupational hazards such as
musculoskeletal disorders and contagious diseases. Injuries, fatalities, disablement
and death from fire and building collapses are frequent in the RMG sector. The
absence of labour standards monitoring system and ineffective building codes,
poor enforcement and outdated labour laws, and a lack of awareness of labour
rights among workers are the major problems in this sector. In his study in 2012,
Md Nasir Uddin has identified following factors which relate safety issue which
are the important cause of the accident.
Adequate doors as well as adequate staircases are not provided to aid quick
exit.
Lack of proper exit route to reach the place of safety Parked vehicles, goods
and rubbish on the outside of the building obstruct exits to the open air.
Md. Nasir studied 101 workers (samples) from 4 garments and found that 34.65%
of the respondents feel their job place is unsafe and insecure for them. They have
anxiety for electrical faults, fire accidents, building collapse, stampede, etc. On the
other hand 65.35% respondents feel their job place safe and secure for them. So it
is clear that garment workers received alarm for accident of Rana plaza tragedy
and Tazrin garment accident in RMG sector in Bangladesh. The of hazards in the
Page |5
Absar (2008) said in her study on "Living Conditions of Women Workers in the
RMG Sector in Bangladesh"that Bangladesh presently exports Ready-Made
Garment (RMG) to about 30 countries around the world. More women, whether
pushed by poverty or pulled by opportunity, work outside home particularly in the
RMG sector. The exodus of women to work in urban areas, leaving homes and
families, is a relatively recent development. Despite the employment opportunities
at the garment factories, women workers in Bangladesh suffer from abject poverty.
Most of them earn less than a dollar (US) a day.
Ali, Begum, Salehin and Farid (2008) made a study on "Livelihood Pattern of
Rural Women Garment Workers at Dhaka City”. The study revealed that 63.33
percent respondent's livelihood pattern has improved after involving in garment
factory. Some diseases like eye trouble, headache, ear ache etc. to be more
prevalent among the women garment workers due to their involvement in garment
factories. Incidence of physical weakness among the garment workers was very
high. Women are exploited easily due to lack of technical knowledge and training.
The employers do not pay any heed to this exploitation.
Literature review shows that no comprehensive work has been done on this topic.
So for fulfilling the research gap the study is conducted.
Page |6
Methodology
This research seeks to analyse and investigate the current status and examine
working conditions in the Bangladesh ready-made garment’s sector. An extensive
literature survey has been undertaken in order to review the historical perspective,
growth and development of the garments industry, working conditions and
environment, labour standards and labour rights issues, as well as this lack of
Social compliance. Therefore, we can find the reasons for labour dissatisfaction.
Sources of data:
The primary source: Primary data have been collected through interview of the
owners of garments factories, workers, labor union leaders and stuff.
For doing the job, we took the help of different websites. We also went a
Readymade garments which locate nearby. We also talk with some readymade
garments workers. Also we get data from different foreign journals.
2. To obtain more knowledge about the RMG sector and find out the solutions
about labour dissatisfaction.
3. To find out the ways how readymade garment’s worker’s get their legal
rights and lead a better life.
Page |7
We find out that, Bangladesh is earning 78% of its export earnings from the RMG
sector. From the last part of 2014 to till today there has been labor unrest
consecutively in this sector. Almost 4.2 million workers are working in this sector.
Sometimes the workers came out in the streets of Dhaka city and damaged vehicles
and set fire on the garments factories. It is happening so violently that many of the
roads of the city had to be kept close for quite a few hours.
Page |8
"The average expected age of RMG worker is 36.4," the report said, adding that
longer working hours, no job security, owners' unwillingness to hire older workers
and negative effects on health are other reasons for leaving the RMG sector before
reaching the regular age of retirement. The report also revealed that the proportion
of women workers in surveyed RMG enterprises declined between 2010 and 2018.
The data collected by the study from 260 enterprises revealed that women
accounted for 60.5 per cent of their workers in 2018, a decline from 63.4 percent in
2010.The report further revealed that most RMG workers are satisfied with their
current employers and jobs. Women workers report higher levels of satisfaction
than men. Factors underlying job satisfaction include the timely payment of
salaries and overtime, particularly among women workers. Other frequently cited
reasons are also financial, including a festival bonus, regular weekly leave, the
payment of minimum wages, and a regular attendance bonus.
Page |9
Bellows table indicates that one fourth of the workers responded to mechanical
hazards in their workplaces.
Ergonomic 3 67.5
hazards 4
7
Psychosocial 1 32.6
hazards 6
8
Thirty five per cent of the garment workers agreed that they had to experience
physical hazards such as noise, vibration, electricity, temperature and lighting in
their working places. High noise levels are found in some parts of garment
industries. For example, if the factory has associated weaving sheds, these
machines are likely to produce noise levels well in excess of what is considered
safe. Similarly, if many of the sewing machines are old or mounted incorrectly,
they are likely to produce high noise levels. The health effects of noisy
environment and presence of vibration are temporary and permanent hearing
loss and vibration disease called vibration white finger. This condition results
from persistent microscopic damage to nerves and tiny blood vessels in the
hands and fingers as a result of long-term exposure to vibration.
So, there are many difficulties on environmental section in readymade garments
sector in Bangladesh.
P a g e | 11
Working hours:
Though the wages are low, the working hours are very long. The RMG factories
claim to operate one eight-hour shift six days a week. Workers are virtually
compelled to work after 8 o‟clock. Sometimes they work until 3 o‟clock in the
morning and report back to start work again five hours later at 8 o‟clock. They are
asked to work whole months at a time the Factory Act, which stipulates that no
employee should work more than ten days consecutively without a break.
While these garments workers’ total monthly take-home pay is not the lowest in
the manufacturing sector, they have to work very long hours for it; overtime is
imposed and in some cases not rewarded, making the hourly returns to their labour
extremely low. Rates of overtime payment are not fixed. Workers are paid very
badly for these long hours, usually only half as much for overtime work as
for normal hours, unless there are high profits from orders, or high demands to fill
new work orders. To use the working hours efficiently, some employers set
production targets for the workers. Workers are given a quota to fulfill. When they
are unable to fulfill their quota during work hours, they have to stay behind and
work without pay. In a field survey undertaken by Bangladesh Institute of Labour
Studies, 72 respondents (60%) stated that payment of overtime was not regular, 28
respondents (23%) complained that overtime was not paid at all, and only sixteen
respondents (13%) showed satisfaction regarding the payment of overtime and the
remaining 4% remained silent on the matter.
So, it is clear from above description that working hours are very long in
readymade garments sector in Bangladesh. It is one of the reason why labour
doesn’t satisfy in this sector.
P a g e | 12
In examining the expenditure pattern of RMG workers, it was presumed that, the
total household expenditures of upper grade workers would be higher as they earn
more. However, it was interesting to note that, on the contrary, the total standard
deviation between the different grades of workers is BDT 1,208, including BDT 601
for expenditures related to food items, and BDT 1,128 for those related to non-food
items (Table 3). While upper-grade workers, such as those in Grade III, spend the
maximum, those working in some of the lowest grades as in VII, do not necessarily
spend the lowest amount. The relative standard deviation of expenses on food items
(BDT 601), and non-food cost (BDT 1,128) indicates that, consumption patterns of
workers of different grades are almost the same. Such low variation in household
expenditure portrays that workers’ income levels, irrespective of their grades, do not
allow them to spend beyond their bare minimum. Perhaps a large part of these workers
maintain a subsistence level of living, which limits the capacity to spend differently in
accordance with the needs of their families.
Grade wise monthly income:
Wage structure of RMG sector especially for the women is very lower than that of
other country in the world. Higher wages are positively related to better working
environment and better compliance. Government is monitoring implementation of
new wage structure in the RMG units and requested firms to implement it . The
government may set up a committee, in collaboration with entrepreneurs and
workers, to oversee faithful and appropriate implementation of the new wage
structure on a sustained basis.
The working environment is the most important factor for sustaining and
improving the efficiency of the worker. . Unhealthy and unhappy workers doing
their jobs under conditions of physical and mental stress are inefficient
producers, unlike machines, which are relatively indifferent to their
surroundings. The physical working conditions depend on many factors,
temperature, ventilation, lighting and sanitation, nature of the floor and stairs
and equipment installed. So the working environment is not only conducive to
better health and safety but also to worker wellbeing. Ensuring workers’ health
and safety, ergonomics and friendly environment in the workplace not only
meet human rights but also save lives.
About one third of sample entrepreneurs are of the opinion that laws and
regulations guiding the operation of RMG industry should be improved.
Bangladesh required more flexible working hours, with provisions for work during
the night shift, recruitment of young workers as apprentices etc. Others mentioned
about enforcement of more strict laws for improvement of worker’s health and
safety standards in the workplace, change in the building codes for improving
working conditions, and for ensuring compliance with factory laws etc. The issues
and concerns as regards various acts of the new Labor Law such as same age
pattern for men and women workers, working hours, punishment for failing to
P a g e | 20
Conclusion:
Bangladesh is a developing country with high growth opportunity. It has huge
opportunity in its garment & textile industry. The country is a part of
Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) which enabled the country to become
the second largest exporter to the European Union. If the country can overcome
these constraints, it could do much better in the garment industry. Once
Bangladesh can ensure best and high quality products along with better . labor
condition, then it can be the market leader for exporting the RMG in the world.
The key point of this study is that the worker’s life status is improving now but
not the optimum level. If the productivity is increased & ensure strong training
opportunities for these workers then the factory can provide them more
facilities.it is noticeable that Standard working conditions, better wages,
minimum working hours, incentives and respect for equality can change into
better and more satisfied workers and a lower turnover of staff. In the RMG
sector workers constantly feel that they have been largely deprived of the rights
and benefits in the existing labour laws, especially the rights and benefits
related to issue of appointment letters, job security, provident fund, gratuity and
working hours. Also, the level of wages is the most significant source of
dissatisfaction for workers in the RMG industry. RMG owner often deny that
they have the power to improve the wages or conditions of workers. Moreover,
prospects of promotion in the RMG industry of Bangladesh are uncommon. In
most cases, garments workers remain in the same job throughout their working
lives. There is limited opportunity for training facilities in the EPZ sector for
high officials, but in the private sector it is restricted. So, at the end we can say
that workers in RMG sector will be more active when they overcome this
circumstances and productivity in RMG sector also increase.
________________________End_______________________
P a g e | 21
References:
1) Ahmad M. (1989). “Readymade Garments Industry in Bangladesh”, Bangladesh Journal of
Political Economy, Volume 20, No. 2, pp. 94-95.
2) Absar, S.S. (2001). “Problems Surrounding Wages; The Readymade Garments Sectors in
Bangladesh”, Journal LMD Labour and Management in Development, Volume 2, p. 7.
3) Ali, R.N., Begum, F.,Salehin, M.M. and Farid, K S. (2008). Livelihood pattern of rural
women garment workers at Dhaka city,J. Bangladesh Agril. Univ. 6(2): 449–456.
4) Absar, Syeda Sharmin. (2004). Living Conditions of Women Workers in the RMG Sector in
Bangladesh. Australia: Australian National University (sharabsar@yahoo.com).
5) “ Staying engaged: A Sustainability Compact for continuous improvements in labour rights
and factory safety in the Ready-Made Garment and Knitwear Industry in Bangladesh,” Joint
Statement, Geneva, July 8, 2013.
6) Morshed, M.M. (2007). “A study on Labour rights implementing in Ready-made garments
(RMG) industry in Bangladesh”, Bridging the gap between theory and practice, Theses
collection, Centre for Asia Pacific Social Transformation Studies, (CAPSTRANS),
University of Wollongong, 2007, http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?
7) Priyo (2010). Present status of workers’ rights at RMG sector,
http://priyo.com/blog/business/26070.html, viewed on 05/06/2010
8) Paul-Majumder, P. 2003. Health Status of the Garment Workers in Bangladesh. Agrambagh,
Motijheel, Dhaka: Bangladesh at Associates.
9) Mohammad Ashraful Hasan, Vol. 6 No. 2 (2019): May - August Issue , Minimum Wage in
Readymade Garments Industry in Bangladesh.
Minimum Wage in Readymade Garments Industry in Bangladesh | American Journal of
Trade and Policy (abc.us.org).
10) “Female Workers in Ready Made Garments of Bangladesh: Problems, Sustainable Human
Resource Development and Remedial Measures”. IJIMB_7garments_3rd.pdf (crimbbd.org).
11)Recent developments in ‘labor rights’ and ‘safety at workplace’ of Bangladesh RMG
industries, Recent developments in ‘labor rights’ and ‘safety at workplace’ of Bangladesh RMG
industries (textiletoday.com.bd).
12) Sexual harassment of RMG workers, Sexual harassment of RMG workers | The Daily Star.
14)http://dspace.bracu.ac.bd/bitstream/handle/10361/2087/Labor%20Unrest%20in%20Banglade
sh%20RMG%20Sector.pdf?sequence.