Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
OF
NEPAL INVESTMENT BANK LIMITED
Submitted By:
Sumitra Shrestha
TU Reg. No: 7-2-478-59-2003
Roll No: 1221/064
Exam Roll No: 392720
Shanker Dev Campus
Submitted To:
DEPARTMENT OF RESEARCH
FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY
KATHMANDU, NEPAL
September, 2012
RECOMMENDATION
Submitted By
SUMITRA SHRESTHA
Entitled
has been prepared as approved by this department in the prescribed format of the Faculty
of Management, Tribhuvan University. This thesis is forwarded for examination.
Dr. Narayan Krishna Pradhan Prof. Bisheshwor Man Shrestha Asso. Prof. Prakash Singh Pradhan
SUMITRA SHRESTHA
Entitled
And found that the thesis to be original work if the student and written according to the
prescribed format. We recommended the thesis to be accepted as partial fulfillment of the
requirement for Master Degree in Business Studies (M.B.S.)
I hereby declare that the work reported in this thesis entitled "Customer Satisfaction of
Nepal Investment Bank Limited" submitted to Shanker Dev Campus, Faculty of
Management, Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu Nepal, is my original work done in the
form of partial fulfillment of requirement for the Master's Degree in Business Studies
(M.B.S.) under the supervision of Dr. Narayan Krishna Pradhan of Shanker Dev
Campus, Putalisadak, Kathmandu, Nepal.
…………………………..
SUMITRA SHRESTHA
Researcher
Putalisadak, Kathmandu
I also my gratitude to all staff of Human Resource Department of Nepal Investment Bank
Limited, Head office Durbar Marg, Kathmandu, Nepal. Whose support me all kind of
banking data, annual bank report and support for taking photographs.
I would like to express my genuine appreciation to the library staff of Shanker Dev
Campus and Tribhuvan University who provided the reference and reading materials
during the thesis period.
I also want to give thanks for the all staff members who kind help, support and
coordination of the research work of Kumari Bank Limited, Chabahil Branch
Kathmandu.
I would like to give my special thanks to my dear husband Ashim Babu Shrestha who
constant encouragement, guidance and moral support, which is truly a wonderful source
of inspiration to complete this thesis successfully. And I also thanks for all my family
members, my parents, brothers, sisters, and all my friends for their assistance, timely
encouragement in every step of this thesis work.
Finally, before I end this writing, I would like to expand my words of appreciation to
those who are directly and indirectly involved in the completion of this thesis.
Thank You!
………………………….
SUMITRA SHRESTHA
Shanker Dev Campus
Putalisadak, Kathmandu
September, 2012
% Percentage
& And
ABBS Any Branch Banking Service
AD Anno Domine
ADB Agriculture Development Bank
AGM Annual General Meeting
ALICO American Life Insurance Corporation
ATM Automatic Teller Machine
BOK Bank of Kathmandu
BS Bikram Sambat
CEO Chief Executive Officer
CRM Customer Relationship Management
E-banking Electronic Banking
EBL Everest Bank Limited
ESA E-zee Student Account
GT Guarantee
HBL Himalayan Bank Limited
i.e. That is
IDC Industrial Development Center
IT Information Technology
KBL Kumari Bank Limited
LC Letter of Credit
Ltd. Limited
MBS Master of Business Studies
NBL Nepal Bank Limited
NCC Nepal Credit and Commerce Bank Limited
NEPSE Nepal Stock Exchange
NIBL Nepal Investment Bank Limited
NIDC Nepal Industrial Development Corporation
No. Number
NRB Nepal Rastra Bank
NRS Nepali Rupees
POS Point of Sale
PSA Premium Saving Account
RBB Rastiya Banijya Bank
SCBL Standard Chartered Bank Limited
SMS Short Message Service
SSL Secure Sockets Layer
SWOT Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threat
T.U. Tribhuvan University
TR Trust Receipt
WWW World Wide Web
RECOMMENDATION ....................................................................................................... i
VIVA-VOCE SHEET ......................................................................................................... ii
DECLARATION ............................................................................................................... iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................................................................................. iv
ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................ v
TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................... viii
LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... ix
BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................. 64
APPENDIX: I ................................................................................................................... 65
APPENDIX: II .................................................................................................................. 69
Table: 6 Staff understands the problem and Queries of the clients .................................. 46
Table: 8 Reason for the choice of NIBL (Business/ corporate house-in percent) ............ 49
Table: 11 Convenience of the location for the automatic teller machine ......................... 52
Table: 12 Recommendation for the ATM location other than those that already exists .. 52
Companies have recognize that the new global economy has years of continual sales
growth followed by two decades of flattened sales curves have indicated sharp
competitors that their focus must change.
Competitors that are prospering in the new global economy recognize that measuring the
customer satisfaction is the key. Only by doing so they can hold on the customers they
have and understand how to better attract new customers. The competitors who will be
successful recognize that customer satisfaction is a critical strategic weapon that can
bring increased market share and increased profit.
Too many companies rely on outdated and unreliable measures of customer satisfaction.
They listen to sales describing their customers’ states of mind. They track and count the
frequency of complaints. And they watch aging accounts receivable reports, recognizing
that unhappy customers pay as late as possible. While these approaches are not
completely without value, they are no substitute for a valid. Well designed customer
satisfaction-surveying program.
It’s no surprise to find that market leaders differ from the rest of the industry in that
they’re designed to hear the voice of the customer and achieve customer satisfaction:
There was a contract made between Rastriya Banijya Bank. Rastriya Beema Sanstha and
foreign investor Credit Agricola Indosuez forms France. In the contract it was stated that
for the 10 years from the starting of the bank. Mr. Credit Agricola Indosuez would handle
the management.
As it’s determined what needs to be measured and how the data related to loyalty and
repurchase, it becomes important to examine the mind-set of customers the instant they
are required to make a pre-purchase (or repurchase) decision. Surveying these decisions
leads to measures of customer loyalty. In general, the customer’s pre-purchase mind-set
will fall in to one of three categories, rejection (will avoid purchasing if at all possible),
acceptance (satisfied, but will shop for a better deal) and or preference (delighted and
may even purchase at a higher price).
Customer satisfaction means serving people with their requirements and making them
satisfy. So if the customers are not satisfied, it can be said that the bank cannot be
satisfied. Being one of the service industry banks should believes that we are always
there to provide you better service whenever they need and how ever they want.
Customers are always right in this industry so bank should believe that not for the profit
for the better satisfaction we are here.
Source for the research questions for this study are:
Primary Data:
i. Interview
ii. Visiting and viewing the bank
Similar to other countries in the world, goldsmiths, merchants, and money lenders are
considered the ancient bankers of Nepal. The establishment of Tejarath Adda in B.S.
1933 which provided loan services to the public but did not accept deposits was the
platform for the institutional development of modern banking in Nepal.
The modern banking era started in Nepal in the true sense after Nepal Bank Limited, the
first commercial bank was incorporated in B.S 1994 with joint ownership of the
government and the general public. Nepal Rastra Bank was set up as the Central Bank in
2013 B.S. under the Nepal Rastra Bank Act 2012 B.S after 19 years since the
establishment of the first commercial bank. After the establishment of NRB, Nepal
experienced a systematic development of the financial system. In order to enhance the
integrated and speedy development of the country made possible only through
competitive banking services, Rastra Banijya Bank, a fully state owned commercial bank
was incepted in the year 1966.
The banking scenario of Nepal has come a long way since the establishment of the first
commercial bank. The ranges of the functions have increased so are their number. There
are now 31 commercial banks, 87 development banks, and 79 finance companies as per
the statistics of NRB published on 2011 July. Out of 87 development banks only 12
Financial system contains two components viz. depository and non-depository financial
institutions. Commercial banks and finance companies are the examples of the depository
institutions where as Employee Provident Fund, Development Banks, Insurance
Companies, etc. are the examples of non-depository financial institutions. The study in
this report is concerned with the depository financial institutions i.e. NIBL Financial
institutions play an important role in the proper functioning of the economy. These
institutions act as an intermediary between the individuals who lend and borrow financial
instruments. These institutions make the flow of investment easier.
Banking in modern sense started with the inception of Nepal bank limited (NBL) on
1994/7/30 B.S. Nepal bank limited had a Herculean responsibility of attracting people
toward banking sector from pre-dominant moneylenders net and of expanding banking
services. Being a commercial bank, it was natural that NBL paid more attention to profit
generating business and preferred opening branches at urban centers.
Integrated and speedy development of the country is possible only when competitive
banking service reaches nooks and corners of the country. Keeping this in mind,
government set up Rastriya Banijya Bank (RBB) in B.S.2022/10/10 as a fully
government owned commercial bank.
As the name suggests, commercial banks are to carry out commercial transaction only.
But commercial banks had to carry out the functions of all types of financial institutions.
Hence, industrial development center (IDC) was set up in 2013 B.S. for industrial
development. In 2016 B.S. IDC was converted to Nepal Industrial Development
Corporation (NIDC). Similarly, Agricultural Development Bank (ADB) was established
in 2024/10/07 B.S. to provide finance for agricultural produces so that introducing
modern agricultural techniques could enhance agricultural productivity. Moreover,
security exchange center was renamed Nepal stock exchange in 1990. NEPSE opened its
trading floor on January 13, 1994.
With the establishment of RBB and ADB, banking service spread to both the urban and
rural areas. NRB also gave incentive to NBL to expand their branches to rural areas. This
helped the common people reduce their burden of paying higher rate of interest to
moneylenders and absolved them from kowtowing before moneylenders. It is natural
expectations of customers which keep on increasing. Once they got banking services,
they were expecting improvement and efficiency. However, excess political and
bureaucratic interference and absence of modern managerial concept in these institutions
The very marketing concept of Nabil Bank forced the other bank in operation to be more
customers oriented and led the influx of commercial banks. Having observed the success
of Nabil Bank based on marketing concept and also because of liberal economic policy
adopted by the successive governments, following commercial banks came into being.
The Share holding structure comprises of
i. A group of companies 50 percent of capital
ii. Rastriya Banijya Bank holding 15 percent of the capital
iii. Rastriya Beema Sansthan holding 15 percent of the capital
iv. General public holding 20 percent of the capital.
There was a contract made between Rastriya Banijya Bank. Rastriya Beema Sanstha and
foreign investor Credit Agricola Indosuez forms France. In the contract it was stated that
for the 10 years from the starting of the bank. Mr. Credit Agricola Indosuez would handle
the management.
The name of the bank has been changed to Nepal Investment Bank Ltd. upon approval of
bank’s Annual General Meeting. NIBL, which is managed by a team of experienced
bankers and professionals having proven track records, can offer customer what they are
looking for. It is sure that the customer choice of the bank will be guided, among other
things, by its reliability and professionalism. The later is reflected by the fact that the
Banker of the London-based Financial Times Group has awarded “THE BANK OF THE
YEAR” 2003, 2005, 2008 and 2010 as well. This very prestigious award is the first
occasion that a 100 percent Nepali managed bank has won this award.
Figure: 1
Share Holding Structure of NIBL
Organized Institutions
20%
Rastriya Banijya Bank
50%
Rastriya Beema
15% Sansthan
15% General Public
The bank is listed as a company in the Nepal Stock Exchange. A team of experienced
bankers manages the bank and professionals headed are Mr. Jyoti Prakash Pandey who is
the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Bank. The bank has worldwide network that
enables the performance of international trade and business with efficiently and promptly.
Hence the bank’s slogan “THE NEPALI BANK WITH THE GLOBAL CONNECTION”
can be regarded very true.
MISSION:
i. Local expertise rendering world-class service
ii. Techno savvy
iii. Customer oriented quality service
iv. Diversified innovative products and services
v. Visionary and professional management in partnership with competent and
committed staff
vi. Sound financial health with good profitability
Bank accepts deposits from its customers through various types of deposits. Personal
customers generally have saving, current, fixed and call accounts with the bank while
business customers generally have call and current accounts.
Bank generally does not provide interest in current account whereas interest in saving,
fixed and call accounts depend upon nature of deposit and bank policies.
B. Business Account:
1. NPR Account of Company (Registered in Nepal)
2. Account of Clubs, societies and association (NPR)
3. Proprietorship Account (NPR)
4. Account of Partnership (NPR)
FIXED ACCOUNT:
NIBL has a policy to accept fixed deposit for only 1 & 2 years. In this account, NIBL is
providing two types of interest that is a prime for big clients and interest for other client
called interest for others.
For 1 year and above interest
Prime: 5 percent others: 4.50 percent
CURRENT ACCOUNT:
Current account facility is provided for any firm that has been established under company
Act 2054 B.S. partnership Act 2020 B.S. And Sole proprietorship Act 2014 B.S.
Features:
Minimum balance: Rs. 1000
Visa Electron Debit Card (if sole proprietorship)
Unlimited withdrawal
Tele-Banking
Features of e- banking:
Enquiry: this feature of e-banking you enquire about the following information
Account information: to see general information of account balance, rate of interest
Account statement: give information on transaction details.
Tax statement: give information on taxes that have been both calculated and posted.
Interest statement: shows the amount on which the interest has been calculated and the
interest that has been either calculated or posted.
Client details: give the information client’s contact information details.
LC outstanding: this option allows user to see Letter of credit (LC) outstanding report
and LC Statement.
GT outstanding: this option allows user to see guarantee (GT) outstanding report.
TR outstanding: this option allows user to see trust receipt (TR) outstanding report
User history: this option allows you to see user’s activity history.
Request: using this feature following requests can be made to the bank:
Cheque paid: place an order for desired number of cheque pads.
L/C opening: fill the L/C opening from to expedite L/C opening process.
Draft Application: send a request for draft.
Telex Transfer: send a request for draft
Cashier’s cheque: send a request for cashier’s cheque
Advantages of e-banking:
1. Real time banking: Nepal Investment Bank Ltd. e-banking service is anytime,
anywhere, real time and online banking
2. Security: Nepal Investment Bank Ltd. E-banking service brings together a
combination of industry-approved security technologies to protect data for the Bank
and for you. If features password-controlled system entry a VeriSign-issued Digital
ID for the bank’s server, Secure Sockets Layer (SSL)
3. Time out feature: once you have logged into the e-banking a session can last as
long as 10 minutes. After the time has elapsed, the system will logout requiring you
to sign on again. This feature id for your safety and protection. If you were to leave
your computer for any reason while still logged into the e-banking, this feature will
allow only a short period of time to elapse for an unwanted person to access your
account information.
4. Easy to setup your banking account: if you are an existing Nepal Investment
Bank Ltd. Customer with any account, simply visit our nearest branch and fill the
form for e-banking services. This information is necessary to set up your account
and assign you a username and temporary password. If you do not currently have
any account at NIBL you must first establish an account relationship with us. For
that, you must stop into any branch office to open an account
ATM Services:
NIBL provides ATM services to their customer, which is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a
week, and 365 days in a year. This service provided by the bank help the customer draw
fast cash from the various ATM machines that have been placed in various parts of the
country. The bank earns income through issue and renewals of ATM cards for its
customers. There are 69 total ATM around the Nepal provided by the bank. Largest ATM
networks and Nearest ATM networks in Commercial Bank in Nepal.
Bank plays a major role in the creation of credit by providing loans and advances to the
customers. NIBL provides various types of loans such as:
i. Loan to company/firm
ii. Loans against cash (account) Pledge
iii. Loans against Pledge and shares.
iv. Loans against security of authorization to deduct own or third party’s
account
v. Housing loan
vi. Vehicle loan
vii. Working capital
viii. Overdraft
ix. Export credit
x. Trust receipt
The bank has recently introduced home loan as its new product under which employed or
self-employed persons or pensioners within the age bracket of 25 to 65 years with regular
and stable source of income and adequate saving are qualified. In case of home loan, it
requires the proposed site to be accessible with at least 9 feet motor able road and should
fall under the bank's criteria for collateral mortgage. The primary focuses of this product
are the professionals like doctors, engineers, lawyers, and chartered accountants as well
as self employed businessman. The bank provides Home loan for three basic purposes,
viz.
i. Purchase
ii. Construction
iii. Extension
The bank provides loan for almost every vehicles, especially for personal use, and
vehicles brand but the bank has special scheme for Hyundai and Perouda cars under
which they provide loan to the customer in a comparatively lower interest rate. The bank
finances maximum up to 70 and 80 percentage of the total cost in home and hire purchase
loan respectively.
NIBL has tied up with major organizations across the country to facilitate payment of
bills for Utilities (Schools, Insurance, Telephone, Internet and Mobile).
2. Shuvatara School
3. Maria Montessori
4. Ullens School
2. Kaasthamandap Vidyalaya
8. KU-High School
PREMIER BANKING:
Services
An executive lounge in the main office first floor to cater all your banking needs.
Service of tea, coffee, cold drinks.
A dedicated account officer exclusively for the cell.
Free consultancy services of professional’s experts on insurance, taxation, travel, & tours
and legal matters through prior of utility bills.
Free services for the payment of utility bills.
Benefits:
i. Issuance of drafts and traveler cheque for free of charge
ii. No key deposit for lockers
iii. Free issuance of visa gold credit card & visa electron Debit card
iv. Any branch banking services (ABBS) for free
v. Celebration of your birthday with a card and cake
Through Payment:
Customer can pay their mobile bills from ATMs by going to the utilities options and
specifying the amount.
To be availed this service the customer needs to fill a form available in front desk.
Through e-banking:
Mobile bill can be send using our utility payment facility in e-banking services. All you
need to do is sign in and pay from anywhere at any time.
Call deposit:
This is the facility provided by NIBL under NRB supervision for large corporation like
Nepal Telecom, Nepal Electricity Authority and Nepal Oil Corporation and so on.
Generally overnight interest is given on this account.
Any branch banking service:
NIBL provide any branch banking services where customers can conduct their business
or make transactions from any of the branches of NIBL with a charge of RS. 250 on per
transaction despite of where they have opened their account.
NIBL Remit:
NIBL Remit is one of its latest products, which facilitates transfer of fund from almost all
over the world, especially from all the parts of the Middle East, in most of the major
currencies. The funds can be transferred through the correspondent bank arrangement
with various financial institutions in Middle East to facilitate efficient fund transfer.
Furthermore, funds can also be transferred within the country to the following cities in
Nepal directly, and the bank provides service of transferring funds to other cities on
Nepal, via its total correspondents or branches.
Apart from these services there are some other innovative measures too: accidental death
insurance is one example of it. It covers individual account holders. The insurance benefit
payable to the nominee of the account holder is a lump sum equivalent to four- time the
PSA Scheme (Premium Saving Account Scheme) provides incentives for all account
holders with balance of more than 50,000. PSA holders are served through a special
counter in all branches. The participants of this scheme can receive Himalayan Bank
Gold Card, ATM card along with tele-banking facility, free of charge. The customers
under this scheme are given preference in providing self-deposit lockers. They also enjoy
20 percent wavier in rental on the small size lockers. Interest on all accounts as such is
calculated on daily basis. PSA holders maintaining average balance of over 100,000 are
eligible to take part in lucky draw under a premium prize and several other prizes are
given every month.
The bank currently offers following types of deposits schemes to the customers:
1. Current account
2. Saving account
3. Short term deposit account. (7 days to 90 days)
4. Fixed term deposit. (Above 90 days)
The bank accepts and maintains these types of deposit accounts in the following
currencies.
1. Nepali Rupees
2. US Dollars
3. Pound Sterling
4. Deutsche Mark
5. Japanese Yen
6. Swiss France
Any customer complying with the general rule for account opening and fulfilling the
document requirement can open an account.
To provide more prompt and efficient services to customers, Himalayan Bank has been
pioneering in instituting tele-banking services. Dialing a pre-specified telephone number
client can have information on:
STRENGTHS:
i. Global and national network
ii. Pioneer of various new services like any branch banking
iii. Bank has overall good reputation
iv. Convenient location
v. Ample parking space
vi. 365 days banking with extended hours for services.
vii. Attraction to middle level client with minimum deposit of NPR. 2500
viii. Only bank in the vicinity with accepting VISA debit cards
ix. Training given from time to time
WEAKNESSES:
i. Backward in advertising and promoting the bank
ii. Slow credit processing
iii. Differentiation of clients
iv. Low interest rate s compared to new banks
v. Mismatch in the number of staffs in various departments
vi. Inefficient employee appraisal system
vii. Inter department communication problem
viii. Relatively newer and inexperience front line staffs
ix. Lack of human resource
OPPORTUNITIES:
i. Bank surrounded by middle level retail stores, wholesales and distribution
outlets for a strong middle class client based.
ii. Bank surrounded by training institution and agencies for international colleges
abroad providing scope for TC, Draft transaction.
iii. Scope for extension in the operation area
iv. Bringing new services and technology
v. Consumer financing
vi. Exploring new market
vii. Recruitment of specialized banking expert
THREAT:
i. Competition as most of the bank has their point of representation in this vicinity.
ii. High maintenance cost of the bank
iii. Government instability
iv. No support (deposit) from foreign banks.
v. Global economy downturn
vi. Over saturation of the financial sector
Wagle (2000) in his thesis entitled- “A Study on the Trends of Saving, Investment and
Capital Formation in Nepal” has indicated that capital fund has significant and positive
relation with both deposit and loans. That means increase or decrease in capital fund
increases deposits as well as loans. However the degrees of relationship were different.
But relation of capital with profit was positive and insignificant. That indicated less of
increase or decrease in profit is due to capital fund or capital fund is least responsible in
changing profit. Banks seem to be more dependent on the deposits in the form of savings
which leads to higher end use of funds and higher profits. A bank can achieve such
3.1 Introduction:
During the preparation different methods have been used for data collection which
basically includes collection of primary data as well as secondary data to some extent.
Personal interview and consultation with concerned staffs and customers are made for the
reliability and practicality of the data by making different types of questions i.e. open
ended, yes/no, choosing the best one from sampling method around 100 customers.
Nepal Rastra Bank (NRB), yearly AGM, different brochures published from the bank.
For the proper analysis of the study and the company’s customer service procedures,
secondary data were collected from past records of NIBL. Collected data are entered into
appropriate tables for easy interpretations of the study.
Primary data is acquired through the set of questionnaire filled by the regular customers
of the NIBL. The general conception and opinion as per the researcher’s observation has
obtaining data.
The study conducted and presented has come out to be a descriptive one. Information is
derived from the secondary data like past record of bank its official website, brochures
etc. so the overall study can be viewed as a blend of descriptive, explanatory as well as
quantitative and qualitative study.
The research purpose and question of this study indicate that this is primary descriptive
but also explanatory and partly explanatory. Before conduction of research, research
design makes easy to identify the problem to report writing with help of collection,
analysis and interpretation of data.
All the secondary data obtained from various sources are complied, processed and
tabulated in the time series as per need and objectives. Various data and information are
collected from the magazines and other published and unpublished reports and document
from various sources.
i. Primary Data
On this part of data collection, structured questionnaire method has been used. Different
types of customer like walking customer, who visits the bank just for the purpose of
deposit and withdrawal of money, who come bank regular for the purpose of operating
their account for the business purpose. Customers were given the schedule of
questionnaire to fill up during the period of transaction.
4.1 Introduction:
To explore the research question, explorative approach and observatory approach has
been used. Different facts and figure are also represented in different types of charts and
diagram like bar and pie diagram.
Unofficial interview with the customer have been made in all the braches of NIBL to
identify their perception about the bank and whether they are satisfied with services
provided by the bank.
The study had made an attempt to assess the mind of the customers and understand what
their choice of a bank depends on, what a bank can do to attract new customers and retain
its existing customers.
Most of the data collection procedure was by the distributions and the collection of the
form of the structured questionnaire to the sample respondents. 100 respondent were
selected randomly from all the branches and are been presented in tabular form.
Secondary data were collected from the bank and from the annual report of NIBL. For
primary data, field visit were also made to the respondents (specially corporate or
business clients of the bank) with the help of appointments fixed by the staffs in
marketing department of the bank. According to convenience and judgmental approach
respondents were selected for detail questions, together with a small interview session. In
addition, head and staffs of almost all the departments were interviewed for further
analysis and data collection.
What this table indicates that out of the 100 people sampled, maximum of 32 percent
deposit holders were in the saving account and the minimum were the of 3 percent were
in the other (call deposits etc). This is because saving account holder can also be availing
the locker facilities of the bank or other deposits services.
Table: 1
a) Saving account 32 32
b) E-zee saving account 20 20
c) Current account 26 25
d) Fixed account 12 12
e) Lockers 7 7
35
a) Saving account
30
b) E-zee saving
25 account
c) Current account
20
d) Fixed account
15
e) Lockers
10
f) Other please
5 specify
Total
0
No. %
a) Overdraft 30 30
d) Letter Of Credit 11 11
f) Consumer Finance 10 10
g) Outstanding Loan 3 3
Figure: 3
Uses of facilities by the credit clients
As indicated in the table, every respondent voted positively as far as ATMs is concerned.
That is 100percent of the clients were aware of the ATM services provided by the bank.
Close behind 96percent is aware of the visa-electron debit card. Note: NIBL is the bank
that has been offering debit card, which is even valid to India. The respondents were least
aware of the credit card offering by the bank. The reason; credit card service has recently
been initiated in the bank (less than 1 year). Beside that, unlike debit cards that bank has
not been aggressively pursuing market for credit card holders, limiting its supply, mainly
because of the additional risk associated with the credit cards.
Since, the respondents were aware of the most of the service and products offering by the
bank, the conclusion from this table NIBL has done good job of marketing itself.
Table: 3
Yes 90 90
No 10 10
Most of the respondents were convenience that the debit card has replaced the need to go
to the banks to make withdrawal and deposits of their money from the bank. From their
concern it saves time. And it is more convenient to withdrawal money from the ATM
machines anywhere in need. But there are respondent that even denied that Debit card
replaced the need to reach the banks. The reasons: they feel that debit card is not secure.
And there is frequent breakdown of ATM machine and sometimes even it shows the false
balance, which has even not been withdrawal by the clients.
Figure: 4
Debit card replaced the need to go to The Bank
NO
YES
Excellent 30 30
Good 42 42
Satisfactory 15 15
Fair 10 10
Poor 3 3
This has always been the main stream for any organization to cope with this competing
environment behavior of staff. As indicated in the figure that most of the respondents has
chosen the good category for the behavior of the staffs of the bank. This is because the
staffs that are recruited in NIBL are highly trained in their respective fields to provide the
best services to their clients.
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Table: 6
Always 27 27
Sometimes 46 46
Rarely 20 20
Never 7 7
Most of the clients are satisfied with the staff understanding. But there are some who are
not satisfied with the understanding of the staffs. The reason for this is: high pressure,
over load jobs and due to frustration of the staffs towards the management and the some
of the clients of NIBL.
50
40
30 Always
Sometimes
20 Rarely
Never
10
0
Percent %
Table: 7
Safety 15 15
Interest rate 5 5
Accessibility 15 15
Creditability 10 10
Better Facilities 15 15
Services 5 5
20
18
Safety
16
Interest rate
14 Accessibility
12 Creditability
10 Better Facilities
8 Visa-Electron Debit Card
6 Attitude of the staffs
4 Services
Others please specify
2
0
As we can see on the figure (15 percent) has lead the chart because most of the client
choose to deposit their money for safety. Then in interest rate, accessibility, etc. visa
electron debit card has also been the main stream of the client to choose the bank. Due to
low cost associated with the NIBL debit card and provides better facilities. Customers are
forced to choose NIBL.
Safety 10 10
Interest rate 5 5
Accessibility 10 10
Creditability 20 20
Better Facilities 15 15
Visa-Electron Debit Card 10 10
Attitude of the staffs 15 15
Services 10 10
Others Please Specify 5 5
Total 100 100
Source: Field Survey
As evident in the diagram, business and corporate clients are most concerned with the
credit availability and the willingness of the bank to extend credit. That is in turn
followed by the financial strength of the bank, that is, its creditability. Safety is the
another important concern. These clients appear to be least concerned with accessibility.
One probable reason could be: the banks often welcome business clients, who bring in
new business.
SCBL 14 14
NABIL 13 13
HBL 20 20
EBL 6 16
BOK 10 10
NBL 11 11
NBB 10 10
NCC 7 7
KBL 9 9
As per this table, NIBL faces the most competition with Himalayan Bank Limited (HBL);
which is closely followed by Standard Chartered Bank Limited and Nabil bank limited.
Other banks such as bank of Katmandu, Nepal Bangladesh Bank, Nepal Bank Limited,
Kumari Bank Limited are the almost in the same way when it comes to completion with
Nepal Investment Bank. The reason why NIBL face most completion from SCBL,
NABIL, and HBL is because these banks have been firmly established in the Nepalese
financial market with a strong reputation as good bank. Moreover these banks are joint
venture banks with successful banks operating abroad. NIBL on the other hand is an all
Nepali management bank. Plus, when compared to those banks, NIBL has recently been
established. However, NIBL has grown steadily in terms of its strength and growth. In
Table: 10
Location 20 20
Better facilities 15 15
Interest rates 18 18
Creditability 22 22
Attitude of staffs 15 15
As evident in the table, client seems to place a prime importance on the creditability of
the bank. This is consistent with the results in the previous table. That is SCBL, NIBL
and HBL have a considerable strong reputation as being trustworthy and reliable.
Location of the bank and accessibility to services appear to be the second most important
concern for clients. Not explicit in the table but implied by a lot of the clients in the third
reason; according to 20 percent of the clients a reason why they are dealing with other
banks is because of earlier relations and obligation. More specially, they were dealing
with the other banks prior to NIBL and just because they established new relations with
NIBL after take over by the new management. Moreover, some of the clients also cited
that multiple relations with different banks are a means of risks diversification.
No 36 36
Yes 64 64
The bank currently has ATM in many locations like Durbar Marg, Thamel, Pulchok,
Putalisadak, New road, Boudha, Battisputali, Kapan, Thali, Lazimpat, Battisputali,
Maharajgunj and in Bhatbhatini in the Kathmandu valley. The respondents were also
asked to indicate if they thought the choice of the bank in the selection of location for the
ATMs were convenient. Similarly 64 percent of the respondents voted ‘yes’ and 36 voted
‘no’. Many respondents gave recommendation, as the bank must have the provision of
giving the facilities of ATMs even in New Road and in many other places.
Table: 12
Recommendation for the ATM location other than those that already exists
New Road 44 44
Patan 18 18
New Baneshwor 25 25
Maharajgunj 13 13
NOTE: In the coming year NIBL plans on opening 1000 P-O-S terminals in
different part of the valley.
Table: 13
Travel service 22 22
Insurance 15 15
100
Travel service
80
Income tax
60 consultation
Insurance
40
Payments of utility
20 bills
Total
0
No.
This question was specially asked on the behalf of the Bank. Out of 100 clients 45
percent would want the bank to pay the utility bills (electricity, water, telephone etc.) on
their behalf in return for a minimal service fee. Although the bank has not ventured into
this area, it has begun the payment of NTC mobile bills.
Close behind in insurance 15 percent of the respondents would like the bank to provide
insurance service. For it E-ZEE account holders the bank has already been providing
accidental insurance of Rs.50,000.
In addition to these services, around 35 percent of the clients have requested for the
internet banking; 45 percent for education loans (most of the respondent in this category
was students) and 20 percent had requested for the credit card.
% N % N % N % N % N
Greet/smile 56 30 39 21 4 2 1 1 100 54
Thank you 37 20 26 14 19 10 18 10 100 54
Approach 56 30 35 19 9 5 0 0 100 54
Competency 46 25 47 25 3 2 4 2 100 54
Speed 56 30 26 14 9 5 9 5 100 54
Space & 67 36 29 14 4 2 0 2 100 54
service
Information 46 25 33 15 11 6 10 5 100 54
Overall 46 25 39 21 15 8 0 0 100 54
customer
service
Source: Field Survey
According to our research we found that maximum respondents (customers) are very
satisfied with the services provided by the Head office. 18 percent of the respondent said
that thanks giving should be improved in the Head office. Maximum of 67 percent
respondent were satisfied with the spaces and services provided by the Head office
Durbar Marg Branch.
% N % N % N % N % N
Greet/smile 16 5 5 16 29 9 3 1 100 31
Thank you 23 7 52 13 29 9 6 2 100 31
Approach 29 9 42 14 19 6 6 2 100 31
Competency 23 7 45 17 19 6 3 1 100 31
Speed 26 8 55 10 26 8 16 5 100 31
Space & 35 11 32 12 23 7 3 1 100 31
service
Information 23 7 39 12 35 11 3 1 100 31
Overall 29 9 39 12 29 9 3 1 100 31
customer
service
Source: Field Survey
From our research, it shows that the customers of Putalisadak branch are satisfied with
the service provided by the bank. The table shows that 16 percent of the respondents said
that the processing speed of the staffs is to be improved. Whereas 35 percent of the
respondents were satisfied with the space and service of the bank and bank staffs.
To Illustrate:
Let’s say Mr. X is holding an account in Pokhara branch of NIBL. Now he has to
withdraw the amount from Putalisadak branch of NIBL, then the bank will charge Rs.
100 per transaction. So NIBL should not charge service charge as it says ABBS (Any
Branch Banking Service).
5.1 Summary:
After the Nepali management took over, a major issue was manpower shortage. During
the French management the focus was narrow and limited which called for skilled, but
few employees. Larger numbers of work-people were required to match the growth
intended. At same time, the new management had to ensure that it did not sideline, or
rather, displease the existing employees. In a period of one and half year the increase in
the number has been on the line of more than hundred. Specially, earlier there were 30-35
employees, while now there are around to 300 employees.
The operating cost of NIBL is higher than that of other competitive (excluding SCBL,
NABIL and HBL) the main reason for this is, “we are service oriented”. This explains
another mission of NIBL for the coming year. NIBL is focusing on to achieve a 15
minutes time frame so that the customer does not have to wait longer. This goal is
centered on the idea that the shorter time the customer spends in the bank will make their
attitude positive towards the services of the bank. To achieve this very goal, the bank has
spent a lot of its financial resources in expanding branches (NIBL has total of 41
branches including the head office) and 69 ATM Networks to bring the customer closer
to the bank.
5.2 Conclusion:
When the Nepali management had taken over, the interest rates offered on different
deposits accounts were higher than those offered by the competing banks. The interest
rates on the bank deposits have decreased lately. In spite of this, the bank client’s base
has grown steadily with every passing year.
During the French tenure in the bank, the management approach was largely
conservative, and that is providing to be an asset for the new management currently. The
reason, due to its conservative and cautious approach, the bank level of Non Performing
Assets (NPA) was very low.
The bank is willing to take high risks; NIBL has taken wider and varied approach.
Consumer base approach by providing new and sophisticated product/services expanding
its braches specifically for the ease of customers as a result of which its competitive
position among all the banks in the country has accelerated to a top spot compared to
eleventh spot it occupied during the French management. Most spectacularly all this has
been achieved in a span of less than three to four years.
The management team of NIBL has much to do with its success. With experience and
qualified team member at the various levels of hierarchy, not just at the top, NIBL has
been able to ensure that decision is efficient, effective and in a timely manner. This in
turn ensures consumers do not have to do what they dislike the most wait! This has been
an important concern for the management because they realize that in a lot of other banks
in the country, a customer is often made to wait for a considerably long time before any
decisions are to finalize. For instance, in NIBL costumers rarely have to stand on long
queues to get their requirement serviced as implemented 15 minute banking.
The other reason for NIBL’s achievement is because of its intense focus on growth and
service. New products and services regarding from Debit card, Credit card, Loan against
Gold & Silver, NTC’s mobile bill payments, have been implemented.
NIBL has largest ATM network in Nepal, having added 9 more ATM, there are 69 banks
ATM networks. ATM machines are located at convenient place to their customer suitable
for every one. Further more, NIBL has provided POS (Point of Sale) terminals in
NIBL has been very aggressive in innovating and offering new product and services in
card market. Visa debit card has also been the main stream of the client to choose the
bank. Due to low cost associated with NIBL debit card and provides better facilities,
customer are choosing NIBL. NIBL has expanded 41 branches network located at
convenient places by providing good service in ever steps of banking procedures to their
customer.
According to our research and analysis, it is cleary identified that the bank is been
performing towards the customer satisfaction and contributing to the inflow of new
customer, ensuring retention of the old customers and subsequently bringing about new
business, higher growth and profits.
5.3 Recommendations:
Based on the analysis conducted and the results from the questionnaire, the following
recommendation appears to be:
i. The bank possesses over 1500 lockers, but there are comparatively few lockers
holders currently. Service income from lockers can be significant source of
revenue provided if it is marketed properly. So aggressive advertising for locker
system should be implemented.
ii. Consume finance can be a major source of income. So the bank should give
proper attention to these sectors. Particularly on vehicle loans and hire purchase
loan.
iii. Bank should come up with innovative and better schemes as to attract new
corporate and business houses.
1. Books:
Engel, J.F. and Blackwell, R. (1990) Consumer Behavior, New Dilli: The
Dryden Press Inc.
Gitman, L. JH. (1995) Principle of Management, New York: Happer and Row
Publishers.
Kotler, P. (1983) Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning and Control,
New Dili: Prentice - Hall of India.
Vaidya, S. (1999) Money & Banking, New Dilhi: Printice Hall
Wolf, H.K. & Pant P.R. (2002) Social Sciences Research and Thesis Writing,
Kathmandu, Buddha Academic Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
2. Unpublished Thesis:
Pokharel, A. (2010) A Report Study on Performance Evaluation and Customer
Satisfaction of Nabil Bank Limited (A Case Study of Lalitpur Branch). An
Unpublished Master Degree Thesis, Faculty of Management, Shanker Dev
Campus, T.U.
Manandhar, B. (2007) A Report Study on Customer's Attitude Towards Nepal
Bangaladesh Bank Limited). An Unpublished Master Degree Thesis, Faculty
of Management, Shanker Dev Campus, T.U.
Shrestha, S. (2009) A Report Study on Electronic Customer Relationship
Management in Banks (A Case Study of Kumari Bank Ltd. and Nepal
Investment Bank Ltd.). An Unpublished Master Degree Thesis, Faculty of
Management, Shanker Dev Campus, T.U.
Khatry, B.K. (2012) A Report Study on Customer Relationship Management
in Nepalese Banking Sector. (A Case Study of Everest Bank Ltd. and Nepal
Bangladesh Bank Ltd.). An Unpublished Master Degree Thesis, Faculty of
Management, Shanker Dev Campus, T.U.
Dahal, H. P. (2006) A Report Study on Performance Evaluation of Chaudhari
Group for Costomer Satisfiction in Instant Noodle. An Unpublished Master
Degree Thesis, Faculty of Management, Nepal Commerce Campus, T.U.
3. Reports:
Annual Report of Nepal Investment Bank Limited 2010
Annual Report of Nepal Investment Bank Limited 2011
4. Web Sites:
www.nibl.com.np
www.nrb.org.np
Questionnaire
Name: _______________________
1. What are the facilities you are availing from the NIBL? (Please tick more than one if
applicable)
For Deposit Clients:
a) Saving account
b) Lotus saving account
c) Current account
d) Fixed account
e) Lockers
f) Call deposit
g) Other please specify
5) If yow were to rate the behavior of the staff towards the customers which category
would you choose?
Excellent Good Satisfactory Fair Poor
6) To what extent do you think the staff understands your problem and queries?
Always Sometimes Rarely Never
7) Why did you choose NIBL? (Please tick more than one if applicable)
a) Safety
b) Interest rate
c) Accessibility
9) So what are the reasons for dealing with the other banks?
a) Safety
b) Interest rates
c) Accessibility
d) Creditability
e) Better Facilities
f) Visa-Electron Debit card
g) Attitude of the staffs
h) Services
i) Others please specify _________________________
10) Apart from good services what kind of other services do you want from NIBL?
a) Education
b) Credit cards
c) Mobile banking
d) Others please specify __________________________
12) Which other locations would you recommend for the set up of the ATM’s?
a) ___________________________________
b) ___________________________________
c) ___________________________________
13) Do you want the bank to provide you with these additional services?
a) Travel services (Ticketing/ hotels booking/ foreign currency arrangement)
b) Income tax consultations (personals)
c) Insurance (life & Non-life)
d) Payments of utility bills.
9 SCBL
14
7 NABIL
HBL
10 13 EBL
BOK
NBL
11
NBB
20
10 NCC
6 KBL
20 Better facilities
Interest rates
22
Creditability
15 Attitude of staffs
18
Travelservice
22
Insurance
18