Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FOR
GATE SCHOLARSHIP
2020-2021
DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE
Conservation involves making interventions at various scales and levels of intensity which
are determined by the physical condition, causes of deterioration and anticipated future
environment of the cultural property under treatment.
DEGREE OF INTERVENTIONS
Interventions practically always involve some loss of a ‘value’ in cultural property, but are
justified in order to preserve the objects for the future. As a result a conservation architect
is expected to provide minimum interventions so as to protect the value of the structure.
i. Prevention of deterioration
ii. Preservation of the existing state
iii. Consolidation of the fabric
iv. Restoration
v. Rehabilitation
vi. Reproduction
vii. Reconstruction
Introduction
Location: Agra, Uttar Pradesh, India
Built by: Mughal emperor Shah Jahan to house the tomb of his wife Mumtaz Mahal
The tomb is lies in the centre of 17-hectare complex, which also includes a mosque and a guest
house, and an extended formal Mughal garden which is bounded by a crenelated wall on 3
sides.
The Taj Mahal was designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1983 for being "the jewel of
Muslim art in India and one of the universally admired masterpieces of the world's heritage".
It is regarded by many as the best example of Mughal architecture and a symbol of India's rich
history. The Taj Mahal attracts 7–8 million visitors a year and in 2007, it was declared a winner
of the New 7 Wonders of the World (2000–2007) initiative.
Problems faced
For the several years because of the air pollution, the Taj Mahal is undergoing discoloration
and the white marble structure is turning pale yellow. The major reasons behind the pollution
includes the following:
Air Pollution: Agra and its neighbouring areas have a high rate of pollution caused because of
the automobile discharge, burning of municipal waste, cow dung and other forms of waste.
These wastes releases huge amounts of particulate matter into the atmosphere causing
severe environmental damage.
Acid Rains: Gases like Sulphur-dioxide emitted by foundries, chemical industries and refineries
combine with Oxygen with the help of moisture in the atmosphere and result in Acid Rain. This
has a corroding effect on the marble of the Taj Mahal making is pale yellow.
Natural Causes: The Taj Mahal was built in 1632 being 388 years old, the structure undergoes
some discolouring over the period of time. Marble does not exist in a pure form as a result,
there are other mineral components present in the marble of Taj Mahal. Without proper
preservation, such mineral combination could led to oxidization. Oxidization causes chemical
reaction along the outer layers leading to the browning of these minerals, resulting in black
and brown marks on the marble structure. Other than that, the structure undergoes
weathering due to thundershowers and rain which slowly leads to development of cracks and
chipping along the outer surface.
River Pollution: The pollution in the Yamuna has also resulted in the growth of insects which
leaves excretions which further leaves yellow stains on the structure. The polluted river has
also eroded the banks near the foundation of the monument. Yamuna has been polluted
due to various factors which also includes being a dumping ground for industrial and
domestic waste. About 60% of the total waste is dumbed in the river in New Delhi. Though
various treatment plants have been established to stop the chemicals from Industries the
results have been very low as several factories continue to discharge chromium, arsenic and
cadmium. Other reasons for increasing water pollution includes poor drainage system,
saturated landfills, and human settlements around the river.
Other issues: Deforestation for urban growth has led to a shift in climate of Agra. Agra lies in
a semi-arid zone, and the temperatures can reach around 48 degrees Celsius in the area. Due
to the absence of trees, the heat waves that regularly move along the plains of North India
are moving swiftly to wreak any physical resistance which stands on its way. Hot wind along
with dust has a highly abrasive effect on the Taj Mahal for the past two decades. According
to the reports of Archaeological Survey of India, sand accumulated in the reclaimed riverbed
can erode the marble surface during sandstorms.
Preservation of Taj Mahal
Government initiatives: The government has announced the formation of a committee under
the Chairpersonship of Secretary, M/o Environment, Forest and Climate Change, C. K. Mishra
including experts from NEERI, IITs and experts from various organizations to look into the
issue of industrial pollution. To deal with the water pollution in the Yamuna, the government
is planning to cleaning of the Yamuna falls under the Namami Ganga project since it is a
tributary of the Ganga and several projects are already being taken up to make the river
pollution free. The government on its part has come up with 36 projects worth Rs. 4000 Crores
on the river Yamuna. It showed that 11 projects already started in Delhi on the river Yamuna
and the tender for the 12th project will be finalised soon. Aiming to reduce the heat wave,
the government has taken measures to be taken up includes afforestation along the Yamuna,
construction of rubber dam, solid waste management, developing a 35 KM long garden along
the water front of Yamuna in Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Delhi.
The court further directed the following to monitor the air pollution in Taj Trapezium zone. Taj
Trapezium refers to an area of 10,400 sq. km. trapezium shaped area around Taj Mahal covering
five districts in the region of Agra.
The setting up of hydro cracker unit and various other devices by the Mathura Refinery.
The setting up of 50 bed hospital and two mobile dispensaries by the Mathura Refinery to
provide medical aid to the people living in TTZ.
Construction of Agra bypass to divert all the traffic which passes through the city of Agra.
Additional amount of Rs. 99.54 crores sanctioned by the Planning Commission to be utilized
by the State Government for the construction of electricity supply projects to ensure 100 per
cent uninterrupted electricity to the TTZ.
The construction of Gokul Barrage, water supply work of Gokul Barrage, roads around Gokul
Barrage, Agra Barrage and water supply of Agra barrage, have also been undertaken on a time
schedule basis to supply drinking water to the residents of Agra and to bring life into river
Yamuna which is next to the Taj (Court order dated May 10, 1996 and August 30, 1996).
The Court suggested to the Planning Commission by order dated September 4, 1996 to
consider sanctioning separate allocation for the city of Agra and the creation of separate cell
under the control of Central Government to safeguard and preserve the Taj, the city of Agra
and other national heritage monuments in the TT.
All emporia and shops functioning within the Taj premises have been directed to be closed.
Directions were issued to the Government of India to decide the issue, pertaining to
declaration of Agra as heritage city, within two months.
Steps taken by ASI: The preservation, conservation and restoration work of Taj Mahal is done
by the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI). Its experts have been applying Fuller’s earth packs
(Multani Mitti) on the Taj since 1994. The marble mausoleum had been given this treatment
several times in the past, including in 2001-02, 2008-09, 2012 and 2014. Before 2014, this
mud pack was applied on minarets, the passage and the level from which the main dome rises
as said by MK Bhatnagar, of the science branch of ASI, Agra. In 2017, the main onion dome
was treated with mud as well. Certain measures are taken so as to prevent the mud from
drying up soon, use of polythene sheets which is wrapped around the paste along with green
nets to prevent sunlight is done. When the layer of dried clay starts falling, the walls are
washed with distilled water.
Fuller’s earth packs are quite
effective, non-abrasive
and non-corrosive. They
remove sticky pollutant
deposits on the walls and
crevices of the monument.
Once cleaned, the surface
doesn’t require treatment for
6-7 years. This method has
been successfully used in the
UK and Italy as said by MK
Bhatnagar.
AJANTA CAVES, AURANGABADH
Introduction
Location: Aurangabad District, Maharashtra, India
The caves consist of 36 identifiable foundations, some of them discovered after the original
numbering of the caves from 1 through 29. The later-identified caves have been suffixed with
the letters of the alphabet, such as 15A, identified between originally numbered caves 15 and
16. The cave numbering is a convention of convenience, and does not reflect the
chronological order of their construction.
The site is a protected monument in the care of the Archaeological Survey of India, and since
1983, the Ajanta Caves have been a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
During the course of copying the paintings, various artists applied varnish with an aim of
brightening the colours and protection the paintings against dampness. After a period of time
it was observed that the varnish had flaked off from all parts carrying with it the paint. In 1919
A. Foucher a Buddhist scholar quoted that varnish and smoke has resulted in darkening the
colours of the paintings.
Based on the above, the Italians devised a scientific method of treatment for the
Paintings. For the removal of the old dark varnish, the Italians tried alcohol, either alone, or
with turpentine. L. Cecconi also favoured the use of much diluted caustic soda, alcohol and
few drops of hydrochloric acid. Cecconi’s method also consisted
of liberal use of shellac in alcohol, or gum dammar in turpentine
as fixatives of pigment. Where the colour was seen to be
peeling off, a very dilute solution of gum dammar was applied
until the pigments were fixed. Finally, the surface was gently
pressed down with a spatula.
Major structural conservation measures, in the form of improvement of drainage and other
protective measures were also executed during that period. Five drains to cope up with a
run off of 4 inches per hour of rain water, with a slope to develop a velocity of 4 to 6 ft. per
second were constructed on the top of the cave. A zinc drain was also inserted in the inner
aisle of cave no 1 to drain out water from the important paintings of Padmpani & Vajrpani.
Steps were also taken to preserve the paintings from biological impacts caused by micro-
organisms and bacteria that were carried in from visitors. The dampness caused because of
rain is also studied and various methods were implemented to prevent it from damaging the
paintings. Many more studies were made to understand the temperature and humidity in
the caves and also illumination of Mural paintings.
As for today, before any new preservation and conservation work, a detailed study about all
past conservation techniques and treatments that were carried out is done before drafting a
new plan.
THE GREAT STUPA AT SANCHI
Introduction
Location: Madhya Pradesh, India
The Great Stupa at Sanchi consists of a simple hemispherical brick structure built over the
relics of the Buddha. It was crowned by the chhatri, a parasol-like structure symbolising high
rank, which was intended to honour and shelter the relics. In the 1st century BCE, four
elaborately carved toranas (ornamental gateways) and a balustrade encircling the entire
structure were added. The Sanchi Stupa built during Mauryan period was made of bricks.
During the 1st phase of conservation and preservation, various wrongful attempts were
undertaken which further led to displacement of several smaller stupas around the main
stupa to accommodate the construction of a road leading up to the main monument. The
restored southern gateway’s lintels were placed front-to-back. These mistakes were never
reversed for the fear of damaging these structures further.
The 2nd phase of preservation was under the supervision of Mr. Cook, State Engineer at Bhopal
in 1904. During the restoration work pillars and coping stones (the highest stone in any
architectural structure) of the main railing around the Great Sanchi Stupa were destroyed or
removed along with the inscriptions of the names of the donors on them.
The Bhopal state funded the next phase of restoration and preservation project of the Sanchi
site undertaken by John Marshall, the Director General of Archaeology in India, between 1912
and 1919. He spent this time undoing the terrible damages that had reduced most of the
stupas to a rubble at the site. A small on-site museum was instituted by Marshall at the foot
of the hill. It was devoted to the care and preservation of antiquities that lay scattered around
the site. The Bhopal Durbar extended full support in this matter as the Begum of Bhopal
entirely financed the construction of this museum.
In a survey conducted by ASI in 1995-96, a leak was noticed in the Stupa during the rainy
season. After thorough inspection it was noticed that a tree trunk had got in to the crevices
of the middle part of the Harmika part and binding material of the stupa was dead.
Recess pointing along with grouting was done to conceal the gaps which has been created in
course of time after 1912-1919 conservation work at Stupa no.-1. The ancient technique of
making Lime plaster was studied and a
mixture was made by also adding Bel,
Gurh, Menthi and Udath dal etc. This
lime plaster was used to seal all the
pockets which were resulting in water
leakage during rainy season. All weep
holes were cleaned properly, so that the
percolated water will come out easily.
The cement mortar which was used for
mending the railings of the
Figure 2. Reliefs on the ground railing of Stupa II at Sanchi. Source:
pradakshina patha was carefully "The Monuments of Sanchi", John Marshall and Alfred Foucher, 1902.
removed and was replaced with
epoxy and stone dust.
NAGESHWAR TEMPLE, PUNE
Introduction
Location: Nagesh Peth, Pune, Maharashtra, India
The main shrine of the temple is a typical Yadava structure. Several renovations and additions
have been made the temple over the years. The major one being in Peshwa period. The Sabha
Mandap is built in the Peshwa period by a moneylender Aba Shelukar.
The temple complex is a Cluster of various temples which includes the Main temple,
surrounding shrines, a Shiva temple, Lord Vishnu temple, Lord Hanumana temple and Lord
Dattatreya’s temple. The temple is now surrounded with an urban fabric but still stands out
with its unique values.
It is declared as a protected monument by State ASI. Hence there was a need to preserve and
conserve this cultural property.
Alternatives available for proposed action through a combination of repairs, redesign were
examined each of the intervention areas. Finalization of selected options to prepare a flexible
and phased program of implementation was decided as the functioning of the Temple with
all its rituals was not stopped during the period of execution.
The first step towards the Preservation effort started with stopping further deterioration. This
included removing vegetation growth on the structure and peripheral walls. The second step
was to take action to reconstruct areas which were in an unsafe and dilapidated condition.
These included the side structures, Shikhara of the main temple and adjacent smaller shrines.
The sabhamandap of the main temple had tilted due to deterioration in the structural
members and lack of proper anchoring. The same was pulled and anchored in position with
additional structural arrangement. The wooden framed structure of the main temple was
strengthened and deteriorated wooden sections were replaced.
The next step was to reinstate areas which had undesired interventions by way of extra
construction, painting over original walls, etc. to its original status, excavating the filled
up water body (kund), steel grills and fabricated doors, etc. There were several examples of
wall paintings, wood carvings and iconography which had been covered up or badly damaged.
The same have been reinstated in its original state using same material. The wooden false
ceiling which was damaged was reinstated using original material itself.
Introduction
Location: Sadashiv Peth, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Use: Originally built as a residence for Peshwa Bajirao II, later converted into an Education
centre for learning Sanskrit by British and is currently used as a Palace open to public and also
consists of Post office and other Municipal Offices.
The area of the Wada is a total of 20,000 sq. ft. The structure is divided into three parts
around three courtyards which are divided according to the use as public, semi-private and
private area of the residence. The structure is famous for its fine entrance and the wooden
balcony known as meghadambari with carved woodwork.
Preservation and repairs done in the Wada
The preservation and restoration work was carried out in 3 stages. The 1st step was to restore
the third courtyard and then the second one. The open area of the first courtyard was cleared
from new temporary interventions. The damaged flooring of the passage around the second
and third courtyard were replaced using the similar kind of basalt stone as used in the original
structure.
The wooden flooring on the 1st floor was repaired and the decayed wooden columns were
replaced by new portions of Burma teak wood joined with help of metal plates and was later
polished by linseed oil.