You are on page 1of 13

Macionis, Niki (2004) Understanding the Film-Induced Tourist.

In Frost, Warwick, Croy, Glen


and Beeton, Sue (editors). International Tourism and Media Conference Proceedings.
24th-26th November 2004. Melbourne: Tourism Research Unit, Monash University. 86-
97.
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

Understanding the Film-Induced Tourist


Niki Macionis
Griffith Business School, Griffith University, Australia
N.Macionis@griffith.edu.au
Abstract
This paper introduces a new conceptual approach to understanding the potential and actual
motivations of the film-induced tourist. It could be said that this newly defined tourism niche
refers to a post-modern experience of a place that has been depicted in some form of media
representation. That is, an experience that is highly personalised and unique to each individual
based on their own interpretation and consumption of media images. The Push and Pull Factor
theory of motivation presents an appropriate theoretical framework in which to examine film-
induced tourism, from a consumer perspective. It is proposed that a distinction will be made
between the three concepts of Place (location attributes, landscapes, scenery), Personality (cast,
characters, celebrity) and Performance (plot, theme, genre), and whether different or distinct
motivations drive or induce travel behaviour. Further, it is proposed to then develop a continuum
of film-induced tourism motivation which might range from the specific film-induced tourist to the
general film-induced tourist to the serendipitous film tourist. This paper will provide examples,
sourced from previous literature on film-induced tourism, to illustrate this conceptual approach to
understanding the film-induced tourist.
Keywords: film-induced tourism, motivation, push and pull factors, continuum.

Introduction (3) investigating the impacts of film


tourism on host communities; and
Major motion picture films can provide the
(4) exploring the connections between
places, objects and subjects for the gaze of
destination image formation and
many people, and for some, films may
management.
induce them to travel specifically to the
However, an understanding of the consumer
locations where they were filmed (Riley,
and the consumer experience is limited.
Baker & Van Doren, 1998). Although most
Therefore, further research is warranted to
motion picture films are not produced with
identify, characterise and understand both
the prime intent of inducing people to visit
the potential and actual motivations of the
locations, it has been stated that this medium
film tourist.
can enhance the awareness, appeal and
profitability of locations through the power In particular, research is needed from the
of imagery and the fantasy of the story consumer perspective to specifically
(Butler, 1990; Riley & Van Doren, 1992; examine the effects of film on tourist
Couldrey, 1998; Beeton, 2001; Croy & behaviour. That is, does film actually induce
Walker, 2004). These cinematic images may tourism? To what extent can film encourage
influence consumer decision making or entice the viewer to become a tourist to
processes in terms of motivating visitation to the destination depicted or seen in a film? If
film locations, however, this relationship is so, what factors in film prompt site-specific
complex and little understood. tourism? Is it attributes of place such as the
Understanding the relationship between scenery, or is it personality based attributes
tourism behaviour and popular media, such displayed in the film through
as film, is becoming more crucial as characterisation (or celebrity association), or
destinations strive to differentiate is it performance oriented storylines that
themselves in a crowded marketplace. motivate the viewer?
While there have been several studies The purpose of this paper is to contribute to
examining the relationship between film and the literature by introducing a new
tourism, they have tended to focus on: conceptual approach to understanding the
potential and actual motivations of the film-
(1) defining the film tourist activity and
induced tourist. For this approach, the Push
product;
and Pull Factor theory of motivation (Dann,
(2) analysing specific manifestations of
1977) presents an appropriate theoretical
film tourism;
framework in which to examine film-

86
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

induced tourism. It is proposed that a tourism activities while at a destination) to


distinction will be made between the three the serendipitous film tourist (those who just
concepts of Place, Personality and happen to be in a destination portrayed in a
Performance, and whether different or film. Their presence is not related to film or
distinct motivations drive or induce travel media portrayal, and they may or may not
behaviour. participate in film tourism activities). (See
There may be a wide range of consumer Figure 1). This paper will provide examples,
drivers which would allow for plotting sourced from previous literature on film-
tourist types on a continuum, ranging from induced tourism, to illustrate these three
the specific film-induced tourist (those who concepts. It will also review some of the
actively seek out places that they have seen literature as it relates to the nature of the
in film) to the general film-induced tourist film tourism experience.
(those who are not specifically drawn to a
film location but who participate in film

Increasing interest in film

Serendipitous General Specific


Film Tourist Film Tourist Film Tourist
• those who just • those who are not specifically • those who actively
happen to be in a drawn to a film location but seek out places that
destination who participate in film they have seen in film
portrayed in a tourism activities while at a
film destination
Figure 1: Continuum of Film-Induced Motivation

Through the proposed categorisation unique to each individual based on their own
approach of media portrayal of Place, interpretation and consumption of media
Personality and Performance, it might images.
indeed be possible to introduce to the It seems that there are different contexts or
literature a film tourist typology based on perspectives from which to define this term.
push and pull motivation factors. In doing In its most straightforward and logical
this, a continuum of film created motivation context, film-induced tourism has been
will provide an analysis and breakdown of defined as “tourist visits to a destination or
specific film tourists compared to general attraction as a result of the destination
film tourists, based on specifically identified featured on the cinema screen, video or
motivations. As the model is introduced here television” (Busby & Klug, 2001:316).
in its simplest linear form, it suggests that Iwashita furthers this by stating that film,
there is an increasing interest in film as the television and literature can influence the
individual becomes a more specifically travel preferences and destination choices of
motivated film-induced tourist. This model individuals by exposing them to the
shall be further developed and discussed attributes and attractions of destinations
throughout this paper. (Iwashita, 2003).
Defining Film-Induced Tourism Following this type of supply or production
A range of useful definitions has been driven approach, film-induced tourism has
provided in previous studies, and there also also been discussed in a cultural, heritage
appears to be a variety of ways to refer to and historical framework (see Busby &
this phenomenon, including: Media Induced Klug, 2001). Feature films are often made at
Tourism; Movie Induced Tourism; Film- significant and identifiable historic or
induced Tourism; the Cinematographic heritage sites (such as castles or manors) and
Tourist; and the Media Pilgrim on a Media gain increased popularity as tourism
Pilgrimage. One universal theme, however, destinations after the film has been released.
suggests that this newly defined tourism In fact, it has been suggested that some of
niche refers to a post-modern experience of these special sites actually only become
a place that has been depicted in some form popular tourist attractions because of the
of media representation. That is, an film produced on site (Busby & Klug, 2001).
experience that is highly personalised and It is also important to note that film-induced

87
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

tourism does not simply occur at identifiable individuals are usually aware or conscious of
film locations; that is, the sites where feature their plans.
films have been made, but it also exists in The importance of motivation in tourism is
purpose built, commercialised sites (with obvious. It acts as a trigger that sets off all
entry fees) such as Movie World, QLD, the events involved in travel (Parrinello,
Australia; Universal Studios, Los Angeles, 1993). Tourism motivation can be defined as
USA; or Granada Studio Tours, Manchester, “a meaningful state of mind which
UK. adequately disposes an actor [individual] to
Other researchers have defined this tourism travel, and which is subsequently
niche from the consumer perspective interpretable by others as a valid explanation
highlighting the behavioural aspects of the for such a decision” (Dann, 1981: 205).
film tourist. This approach is usually set Dann (1977) suggests that there are basically
within Urry’s (1990) framework of the two factors or stages in a decision to travel:
‘tourist gaze’ in terms of film constructing a ‘push factors’ and ‘pull factors’. According
gaze for an individual to observe. In this to Dann, “pull factors are those which attract
case, people may be induced to visit the a tourist to a given resort or destination (eg.
places they have gazed upon the cinema sunshine, beaches) and whose value is seen
screen. Riley, et al state that it is when to reside in the object of travel; and push
“people seek the sights/sites they have seen factors refer to the tourist as subject and
on the silver screen, it is then that they, deals with the factors predisposing him to
indeed, become movie induced tourists” travel (eg. escape, nostalgia)” (1977:186).
(1998: 920). Consequently, Dann hypothesised that the
Major feature films have also been referred motivation for travel is based on these twin
to as ‘hallmark events’ in terms of the concepts, although, push motivations are
potential impact they might have on a generally accepted as the dominant factors.
destination (Ritchie, 1984), or special Crompton (1979) advances the ‘push’ and
tourism events or as tourism promotion ‘pull’ framework of motivation and builds
(Riley & Van Doren, 1992; Croy & Walker, on it to include nine specific motives which
2004). In fact, it was Riley and Van Doren include:
(1992) who characterised movies as a non-
marketer controlled category of hallmark • Escape from a perceived mundane
event. Although it is recognised that films environment;
are not produced with the purpose of • Exploration and evaluation of self;
inducing tourism visitation, it is commonly • Relaxation;
accepted that feature films, seen by mass • Prestige;
audiences, can indeed enhance the • Regression (to adolescent or child-like
awareness of the locations in the film, as behaviour);
well as the appeal of these tourist • Enhancement of kinship relations;
destinations (Riley & Van Doren, 1992). • Social interaction;
Motivation • Novelty; and
• Education (p. 408).
The study of motivation in consumer Further, Crompton (1979) argued that push
research involves two fundamental factors may be useful not only in examining
challenges including understanding the the initial arousal or ‘push’ to go on a
interrelationships between motives and holiday, but may also have “directive
specific behaviour; and developing a list of potential to direct the tourist towards a
motives comprehensive enough to capture particular destination” (p. 412).
the diverse range of motivating forces that
stimulate and shape behaviour (Funk, Iso-Ahola (1987) also identifies two main
Ridinger & Moorman, 2004). Having said types of ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors including:
that, motivation has been defined as the personal and interpersonal factors. In his
driving force within an individual that escape–seeking dichotomy, he argues that
impels them to action. It is also recognised people are motivated to seek leisure
as but one of many variables which may activities in order to leave behind personal
contribute to explaining tourism behaviour and interpersonal problems of everyday life
(Crompton, 1979). Motivations may not be and obtain personal and interpersonal
easily formulated or expressed, however, rewards from participation in these leisure
activities (Witt & Wright, 1992). Escaping is

88
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

“the desire to leave the everyday factor) and the decision to travel to a
environment behind and oneself”, while destination.
seeking is “the desire to obtain intrinsic The approach suggested in this paper also
rewards through travel in a contrasting hopes to discover which intrinsic
environment” (1987: 261). Although Iso- motivational factors prompt film site-
Ahola notes that in relation to other leisure specific travel behaviour. It is anticipated
behaviours, tourism is more likely to be that there are a diverse range of push factors
triggered by the escape motive. According to associated with visiting film sites including:
Crompton and McKay (1997), these fantasy; escape; status and prestige; search
dimensions are similar generic categories to for self concept or identity; ego
the push (escape) and pull (seeking) forces enhancement; as well as a sense of partaking
proposed by Dann (1977). These in a vicarious experience.
motivations (escape, fantasy, romance,
Some of these types of motivations may be
novelty, self-identity and entertainment) are
more prevalent at different points on the
similar to those identified as fulfilling the
continuum. For instance, as an individual
needs that movie-going fulfills in consumers
becomes a more specifically motivated film-
(Mowen, 2000).
induced tourist, who actively seeks out
Specifically in relation to film-induced places seen in film, it is proposed that there
tourism, it is argued that this push and pull could be an increase in self-actualisation
theory of motivation is the most appropriate motivations, as these tourists place greater
framework in which to investigate film significance on visiting film sites for
tourism motivation. Indeed, Riley and Van personal reward. Whereas a ‘general film
Doren (1992) have examined film tourism as tourist’ is perhaps more strongly motivated
a form of promotion and motivation through by the novelty of visiting a film tourism site
push and pull factors. Pull factors in tourism or participating in a film tourism destination
motivation theory attract the tourist to a and a ‘serendipitous film tourist’ may simply
destination while push factors, on the other be visiting a film tourism site or
hand, refer to the tourist and the internal participating in a film tourism activity in the
drive leading to action (Dann, 1977). Thus, course of social interaction with family or
it is considered possible to track film’s role friends (See Figure 2).
as an information source, or pull factor, and
its influence on tourist motivation (as a push

Increasing interest in film

Serendipitous General Specific


Film Tourist Film Tourist Film Tourist
• those who just • those who are not specifically • those who actively
happen to be in a drawn to a film location but seek out places that
destination who participate in film they have seen in film
portrayed in a tourism activities while at a
film destination
Motivations include: Motivations include: Motivations include:
• social interaction • novelty • self-actualisation
• novelty • education • pilgrimage
• nostalgia • self-identity
• fantasy
• romance
• nostalgia
Increasing self-actualisation motivations

Figure 2: Continuum of Film-Induced Motivation

Therefore, it is argued that the push and pull the two factors have been viewed as relating
framework provides a simple and intuitive to two distinct decisions, it has been
approach for explaining the motivations suggested that they should not be viewed as
underlying film tourist behaviour. Although operating entirely independent of each other

89
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

(Klenosky, 2002). For instance, people may Performance and Personality, and whether
travel because they are pushed by their own different or distinct motivations drive or
internal forces (motivations) and induce travel behaviour. These three
simultaneously pulled by the external forces concepts can be categorised this way:
of the destination attributes. The discussion (1) Place: location, scenery, destination
will now turn to examine the possible range attributes;
of push and pull factors in film-induced (2) Performance: storylines or plot, themes,
tourism, in the following section. genres; and
Push and Pull Factors in Film- (3) Personality: cast, celebrity, characters.
Induced Tourism This could prove a useful categorisation for
investigating film tourism motivations as it
Pull Factors have generally been will highlight the specific media
characterised in terms of the features, representations and attributes that are
attractions or attributes of a destination, such important to film tourists. That is, what is
as sunshine or scenery, that lead or pull an the tourist experience as it relates to a
individual to choose one destination over motivation to visit a site-specific
another, once the decision to travel has been destination? What do these tourists want to
made (Klenosky, 2002). It must be realised do when they arrive at a film location? What
that the pull of a particular destination is important to tourists in fulfilling a given
attribute can be driven by multiple motivation? For example, is it the
motivational forces. For example, going to a spectacular destination attributes of Place
beach holiday destination may be motivated that inspires or contributes to travel to a
by various internal push factors such as: famous site seen on film or is it the romantic
(1) to fulfill socialisation needs with family love storyline attributes of Performance that
and friends; induces travel to fulfil a motivation of
(2) to satisfy escape needs with rest and escape and romance through vicarious
recreation; or experience? For others, it may be the
(3) to fulfill sunlust desires to get a suntan. pilgrimage motivating factor to visit a film
Recognising that there are likely to be a location that has showcased their favourite
range of motivations among individual film star or Personality. Thus, this “3 P”
tourists visiting a specific film site, it is categorisation will set a framework for
proposed that a distinction will be made investigating the specific attributes of film
between the three concepts of Place, tourism motivation. (See Table 1).

Table 1: Push and Pull Motivation in Film Induced Tourism


Pull Factors (Film) Push Factors (Internal
Drive)
Place Personality Performance
Location attributes Cast Plot Ego enhancement
Scenery Characters Theme Status/Prestige
Landscapes Celebrity (stars) Genre Fantasy/Escape
Weather Vicarious Experience
Cultural origin Search for self identity
Social origin
Activity origin

Place popularised or signified as a tourist


Let us first examine Place as a possible pull destination by those popular cultural
factor in film-induced tourism assuming that products which are widely distributed by the
it involves film location attributes, such as ordinary majority” (2003: 215).
spectacular scenery or unique landscapes The concept of place relates to an area that
that are immediately identifiable and has a distinctive internal structure, to which
attractive to a viewer. There is no doubt that meaning is attributed and evokes certain
the development and promotion of a place responses from individuals (Busby & Klug,
can be dramatically influenced by film and 2001). It is through film that such place
other popular forms of media. Iwashita has meaning can be created, altered and
defined popular media-induced tourism, as reinforced. Santos (2004:136) suggests that
involving “places which have been the messages and representations created by

90
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

movies, magazines, television and books Magnolias. The first telling a moving story
cross over to provide an ongoing socio- of historic and heroic baseball lore, the other
cultural discussion of destinations that captured the drama of a group of women
serves to construct a dominant frame. The living in a picturesque southern community.
development of such promotional collateral Visitation to the farm where this baseball
as Movie Maps, which identify film sites and movie was filmed increased significantly
locations, is testament to the pulling power from 7500 visitors in 1989, to 35,000
that films have on destinations. visitors in 1991. Similarly, there were
Many studies have demonstrated that films reports of up to 40 per cent increased
are effective as motivational pull factors and tourism to the site of filming Steel
can successfully induce film place specific Magnolias in Natchitoches, LA (Riley and
visitation (Riley & Van Doren, 1992; Tooke Van Doren, 1992).
& Baker, 1996; Couldrey, 1998; Beeton, People are not only drawn to the places that
2001; Kim & Richardson, 2003). Many of form the settings and landscapes for feature
these destinations have transformed their films, but they may also be drawn to
film sites into tourism attractions, which are particular stories and genres, that is the
then considered worthwhile places to visit drama of the plot, the elements of the theme
(eg. Lord of the Rings - New Zealand). and the experiences of the people in the film.
Taking a somewhat different perspective, It may be that some people make very strong
Croy and Walker (2004) examine the use of connections with the performance aspects of
fictional media in rural areas to assist in the film and are determined to put themselves in
development of a positive tourism the physical place that has formed the
destination identity, or sense of place. Their backdrop to the drama. This can be
research demonstrates a growing recognition illustrated especially well by the popular
and appreciation by regional tourism Australian television series, Seachange,
organisations in New Zealand of the role of which first screened in 1998. The storyline
fictional media in diversifying and of this series revolved around an over-
developing their regional economic base. worked city lawyer who decides to give up
For example, images of the Waitakere the fast life for the slower and quieter
region of Auckland where the film The lifestyle of a small seaside town. This
Piano was shot, have been used for tourism concept or storyline proved extremely
promotional purposes such as Tourism New relevant, intriguing and popular with
Zealand’s 100% Pure New Zealand audiences, and sparked an increase in
campaign. As a result, the Karekare Beach visitation to Barwon Heads where the series
site still receives visitors from around the was filmed (see Beeton, 2001). Clearly,
world because of the sites seen in the film, tourists were pulled to this destination
and the ongoing use of this imagery (Croy & because they could relate to the situation of
Walker, 2004). In this example, it could be the characters in the show. In this case,
argued that it is this physical place of the tourists were drawn to this destination via
moving image that has pulled the tourist to the concept of making a ‘seachange’ rather
it. than the destination itself.
Performance Another aspect of the performance based
attribute in film-induced tourism can be seen
Next, we shall examine Performance as a in action or adventure films where the
pull factor based on storyline, plot or adventurous and dangerous storylines are the
thematic content of film which may, for main attracting feature. For instance, there
example, induce travel to fulfill a motivation are accounts of increases in adventure
of escape and romance through vicarious tourism in non-specific locations after film
experience. releases such as Deliverance, Vertical Limit,
In the case of film induced tourism, Riley All the Rivers Run Wild, Cliffhanger (Riley
and Van Doren (1992) provide two & Van Doren, 1992; Busby & Klug, 2001;
examples of films which pull the visitor Croy & Walker, 2004). This phenomenon
based on the thematic content of the film could be attributed to the power of these film
(storyline/performance) rather than any genres and storylines.
specific physical environmental attractions In his examination of historic films, Frost
of place. These include the successful 1989 (2004), states that the touristic interest
feature films Field of Dreams and Steel generated from films such as High Noon and

91
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

Ned Kelly is the strong historical story-based enticed to put that destination on their
attributes rather than being visually (or holiday list. Moreover, can this explain why
location) based. He suggests that while films many North American fans of the character
such as these may be set in attractive Mick Dundee in Crocodile Dundee sought
locations, this is not the prime pull factor for out the Australian outback as a tourism
tourists, rather they are pulled by the destination? Or was it equally because the
performance aspects of historic storylines. actor Paul Hogan, with his celebrity status,
Riley and Van Doren (1992) also provide a appealed so much?
television example with Dallas which was An example of how popular culture or media
the long running American drama located at may influence tourism behaviour, via the
the fictitious ‘Southfork Ranch’. Riley and attributes of a personality, is discussed by
Van Doren state that international visitors, in Pearce, Morrison and Moscardo (2003) in
particular, visit this site to relive the relation to the role of famous individuals
expectation of the American Dream of (icons) or celebrities who have become
“wealth, cowboys and western lifestyles” famous in their fields, as the basis for
(1990: 272). Thus, it is not so much the marketing tourism destinations. They
physical site of the ‘Ranch’ as the place examine the use of famous icons or
motivator, but the performance motivations celebrities such as the 1950s rock legend
to vicariously experience the lifestyles and Buddy Holly in Texas; the legendary pioneer
values of the characters depicted in the Buffalo Bill in Wyoming; outlaw Ned Kelly
series. in Victoria; and the revered Scottish poet
Personality Robert Burns in Scotland, as tourism
attracting products. They argue that, without
Finally, another possible Pull Factor in film- appropriate marketing, the appeal in visiting
induced tourism may be a pilgrimage sites, shrines or museums dedicated to such
motivating factor to visit a film location that heroes may be limited to people with active
has showcased a favourite film star or literary, artistic or musical tastes and
Personality. In this discussion of personality motivations, or those who are absolute fans.
attributes of film, it is film characters as well In other words, appealing only to the
as the actors/stars who portray them that is specifically media induced tourist niche
of interest. market rather than the incidental tourist
There is no denying the pulling power of travelling on a general itinerary.
Hollywood, the star system and celebrities.
Authenticity
These facets of the entertainment industry
are all profoundly cultural enterprises and Hall (2003) states that authenticity is one of
our fascination with these aspects of media the key motivational factors for tourists, and
reflect our involvement in the meaning film tourism, for instance, is one medium
transfer they set out to accomplish that allows people to live out their fantasies
(McCracken, 1990). Film stars, actors and of their favourite movies or actors in
celebrities are very powerful ingredients of sometimes mythical places. If visitors seek
mass media and they are able to draw an imaginary place and its association with
powerful meanings from the roles they fictional characters, questions of authenticity
assume in their movie or television arise in an unfamiliar form. That is to say
characterisations. Indeed, this is recognised that visitors “attach personal meanings to
in the public relations, advertising and such places and authenticity thus becomes a
celebrity endorsement literature. subjective experience, a combination of the
developers’ intentions, the consumers’
Till and Shimp state that “feelings towards a
interpretations and the interactions among
celebrity are expected to transfer to any
them” (Herbert, 2001: 317). He goes on to
endorsed brand through their power status
suggest that individual motivations vary and
and the recurring association” (1998:68).
that authenticity is not necessarily the major
This is precisely why tourism destination
concern of tourists, with affective qualities
marketing organisations put so many
of place often being more important
resources into utilising celebrities to
(Herbert, 2001).
promote their regions. Therefore, it could be
assumed that if a fan associates Monte Carlo In examining the influence place,
with a famous film character such as James personality and performance, as pull factors
Bond, they may indeed be ‘pulled’ or and issues of authenticity, the concept of
literary tourism provides useful examples of

92
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

destinations that have featured in famous Couldrey (1998) further argues that such
historical and contemporary novels or poetry locations are significant as more than just
(Curtis, 1985; Squire, 1993, 1996; Herbert, ‘simulacra’, and that one can assume that
1996, 2001; Fawcett & Cormack, 2001; visitors to these sites know they are based in
Smith, 2003). fiction. He says the basis for the Coronation
Literary tourism is defined as visitation to Street set’s significance is that it is the place
“places celebrated for associations with where the program is filmed, and therefore
books or authors” (Squire, 1993:104). Squire the actual place that one has seen on
(1996) argues that literary tourism is television, and thus one of the main
premised upon a desire to experience a motivations in going there.
version of the past (or imagined present) and Conversely to this, visitors to Nottingham’s
to make connections between past and Sherwood Forest have an image of place
present, fact and fiction. She states that derived largely from Robin Hood feature
literary tourism trades in images and films (which have actually always been shot
expectations of people, places and particular elsewhere). This combined with the doubtful
historic periods. In a sense, this special historical basis of the legend, may be
interest niche of literary tourism has been a thought to detract from the visitor
precursor to film induced tourism, with experience at the site. However, it seems
many similar, and indeed identical, product that visitors to Nottingham either do not care
characteristics as well as consumer traits. whether the legend was authentic or expect
For example, in relation to place, tourists are Robin Hood to be a myth (Shackley, 2001:
drawn to the places or sites that have a 315).
connection with famous authors, such as In his work on Granada Studio Tours, home
their homes and surrounds. There is much of the external set of the long running British
evidence of this occurring, for example: television soap, Coronation Street, Couldrey
Bronte Country or Hardy’s Country where a (1998: 102) refers to the set as a ‘ritual
region has become characterised by a place’ and that the visitors are in fact “media
famous author (Butler, 1990: 49). In such pilgrims fulfilling a motivation to gaze” and
cases, and in the absence of visual portrayal, experience this site. He believes that visiting
it is not so much the destination itself (or the Coronation Street set is a type of
physical attributes of the destination) that are pilgrimage in that it is a journey to a central
important pull factors, but the association site which focuses on underlying values.
with authors and their fictional worlds. Moreover, when visitors enter the set, an
The interesting aspect to draw from these intrinsically significant connection is made
types of classifications is that they can be between the media world and the real world.
broadly identified as ‘real life’ versus As such, it would seem that authenticity (or
‘imaginary’ places and often this distinction lack thereof) is another important
not clear cut. Herbert (1996) suggests that consideration in conceptualising a film
visitors to literary sites probably do not tourist continuum (see Figure 3). It might be
make any distinction between the two argued that the need for an authentic tourism
worlds. Squire’s research revealed that experience, in the traditional sense, is not as
tourists visiting Hill Top Farm of Beatrix important for the specific film tourist as it
Potter’s Peter Rabbit fame, experienced might be for the general tourist. While
great levels of nostalgia for childhood, as authenticity tends to be an important
well as experiencing notions of a sense of consideration for the traditional tourism
place or English rurality. This raises issues experience, the specific film tourist could be
of authenticity and the fantasy/reality said to accept (if not expect) hyper-real
spectrum which are particularly relevant to experiences in which model and reality are
film-induced tourism. confused (Herbert, 2001).
With specific reference to film tourism,
Couldrey (1998) says that film and
television locations are examples of
Baudrillard’s theory of ‘hyperreality’ in the
sense that ‘hyperreality’ represents
“simulacra in which ‘model’ and ‘reality’
are confused in a world where access to
unmediated reality is impossible” (p. 95).

93
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

Increasing interest in film

Serendipitous General Specific


Film Tourist Film Tourist Film Tourist
• those who just • those who are not • those who actively
happen to be in specifically drawn to a film seek out places that
a destination location but who they have seen in
portrayed in a participate in film tourism film
film activities while at a
destination
Motivations include: Motivations include: Motivations include:
• social • novelty • self-actualisation
interaction • education • pilgrimage
• novelty • nostalgia • self-identity
• fantasy
• romance
• nostalgia
Increasing self-actualisation motivations

Decreasing importance of authenticity

Figure 3: Continuum of Film-Induced Motivation

Internal drivers identification with locations through movie


storylines which allow greater personal
In terms of investigating push factors or
meaning to the beholders of the gaze. This
internal drivers of film-induced tourism, it is
notion of ‘vicarious experience’ can be
anticipated that there are a range of possible
understood through the concept of empathy
motivations that come into play. Such push
(Kim & Richardson, 2003). This suggests a
factors might include; ego-enhancement;
visceral feeling about someone else’s life
fantasy or escape; status/prestige; search for
which allows an individual to participate in
self-identity; or vicarious experience. These
the ‘posture, motions and sensations’ of
push factors can often be strongly related to
someone or something else.
the previously discussed pull factors. For
example, search for self-identity by acting In certain types of place-oriented films,
out the experiences of a favourite actor in a audiences can learn about the destination by
specific location or circumstance. Tourists participating in the place related experiences
may be drawn to film sites for more personal of the characters (Kim & Richardson, 2003).
motivations such as reliving nostalgic They state that it is not unreasonable to
memories from childhood, for example, as in consider vicarious experiences with a
the generational favourite, The Sound of destination featured in a film as another type
Music, which then becomes a sentimental of destination experience. Although
journey, or visiting Notting Hill for romantic according to Griffin (2002), tourism, in
notions. essence, is sensual, emotive and driven by a
desire to experience a place and that the
A critical internal driver, or push motivation,
sights, sounds, ambience and people are
in film-induced tourism is the ‘tourist gaze’
integral to that experience, therefore
in terms of film constructing a gaze for an
vicarious experiences can simulate some
individual to observe (Urry, 1990). The
aspects, but not the totality.
character of the gaze is central to tourism
and there are distinct objects to be gazed Couldry (1998) also suggests a push
upon because they are famous for being motivation of pilgrimage to ritual sites (ie.
famous (eg. Uluru, Grand Canyon). Sites film or television locations) and labels film
made famous from film or celebrity tourism tourists as ‘media pilgrims’ who are
could be avenues for pilgrimage to visit the fulfilling the motivation to ‘gaze’ on sites
site to gaze. they have seen on screen. Beeton (2002) also
suggests that film tourism is about tourists
In terms of the gaze, Riley and Van Doren
looking for the sites, people, experiences and
(1998) also suggest that film tourists may be
even the fantasies portrayed by films. This
motivated by vicarious involvement and

94
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

introduces the intangible elements of the self-identity, status and prestige and the
individual tourist experience based on crucial element of the vicarious experience.
individual motivating factors, such as Having suggested this, as Klenosky (2002)
fantasy. Indeed, Riley and Van Doren has pointed out, push and pull factors should
emphasised that the attractions seen in films not be viewed as operating entirely
“are not only associated with the allure of independently of each other. That is to say,
picturesque physical environments, but also people may travel because they are pushed
for reasons of pilgrimage, escape and by their own internal forces (motivations)
nostalgia” (1992: 268). and simultaneously pulled by the external
As the Continuum of Film-Induced forces of the destination attributes. In the
Motivation is further developed (see Figure case of the specific film tourist, it could be
4), the internal drivers or the push factors assumed that pull factors are also becoming
demonstrate their increasing importance as more important as the tourist moves along
the tourist moves along the continuum. It is the continuum. It is at this end of the
at the most specific film tourist end of the continuum that these absolute film-induced
continuum that the push factors are at their tourists must physically be at the sites of
most significant, in terms of fulfilling a their favourite films, to stand in the footsteps
range of self-actualisation type of of their movie heroes and relive the special
motivations including ego-enhancement, film moments.

Increasing interest in film

Serendipitous General Specific


Film Tourist Film Tourist Film Tourist
• those who just • those who are not • those who actively
happen to be in specifically drawn to a seek out places that
a destination film location but who they have seen in
portrayed in a participate in film tourism film
film activities while at a
destination
Motivations include: Motivations include: Motivations include:
• social • escape • ego-enhancement
interaction • novelty • self-actualisation
• novelty • education • pilgrimage
• nostalgia • self-identity
• vicarious experience
• fantasy
• status/prestige
• romance
• nostalgia
Increasing self-actualisation motivations

Decreasing importance of authenticity

Increasing importance of Push Factors

Figure 4: Continuum of Film-Induced Motivation

Conclusion proposed that a Continuum of Film-Induced


Motivation is an appropriate way to examine
The proposed approach aims to advance
the role of film in the travel decision
prior work by suggesting that the nature of
process. More speculatively, the present
the Film Tourism experience will influence
research suggests a holistic picture of
any such classification scheme, in that some
complex motives for film-induced tourist
film-induced tourists may be motivated by
behaviour.
the externally driven pull factors derived
from the screen, while others may be It is evident that the moving image has great
motivated by internal drivers. Thus, it is power to alter, create and reinforce specific
destination images, and there is no doubt

95
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

that film has become a dominant source of Busby, G. and J. Klug (2001). "Movie Induced
information and images. Film also has the Tourism: The Challenge of Measurement and
power to influence consumer behaviour by Other Issues." Journal of Vacation Marketing
creating motivations within individuals 7(4): 316-332.
Butler, R. (1990). "The Influence of the Media in
which can induce them to act in certain Shaping International Tourist Patterns."
ways. This paper has contributed to the Tourism Recreation Research 15(2): 46-53.
literature by introducing a new conceptual Couldry, N. (1998). "The View from Inside the
approach to understanding the potential and 'Simulacrum': Visitors' Tales from the Set of
actual motivations of the film-induced Coronation Street." Leisure Studies 17: 94-
tourist. For this approach, it has been argued 107.
that the Push and Pull Factors of motivation Crompton, J. L. (1979). "Motivations for Pleasure
present an appropriate theoretical framework Travel." Annals of Tourism Research 10/11:
in which to examine film-induced tourism. 408-423.
Croy, W. G. and R. Walker (2003) Rural Tourism
The three concepts of Place, Personality and and Film: Issues for Strategic Regional
Performance have been introduced as a Development. In D. Hall, L. Roberts, and M.
framework for investigating whether Mitchell (editors). New Directions In Rural
different or distinct motivations drive or Tourism. Aldershot: Ashgate. 115-133.
induce travel behaviour. Curtis, J. (1985). "The Most Famous Fence in the
Furthering this approach in investigating the World: Fact and Fiction in Mark Twain's
Hannibal." Landscape 28(1): 8-14.
potential and actual motivations of the film-
Dann, G. M. S. (1977). "Anomie, Ego-
induced tourist, through a motivation-based Enhancement in Tourism." Annals of Tourism
research design, will provide a new Research 4(4): 184-194.
dimension in understanding the film-induced Dann, G. M. S. (1981). "Tourist Motivation: An
tourist. There may be a wide range of Appraisal." Annals of Tourism Research 8(2):
consumer drivers which would allow for 187-219.
plotting tourist types on a continuum of Echtner, C. and B. Ritchie (1991). "The Meaning
film-induced motivation, ranging from the and Measurement of Destination Image."
specific film-induced tourist to the general Journal of Tourism Studies 2(2): 2-12.
Fawcett, C. and P. Cormack (2001). "Guarding
film-induced tourist to the serendipitous film
Authenticity at Literary Tourism Sites."
tourist. It will ultimately bring to light some Annals of Tourism Research 28(3): 686-701.
clarity of the role of film as a contributor to Frost, W. (2004). “Historic Films and Destination
the motivation to travel to a destination. Image in Australia and the American West: A
References Comparative Study of Ned Kelly and High
Noon”. CAUTHE Conference Proceedings.
Allen, L. (2004). “Hotels Find a Friend in Nemo” Feb, CD ROM. Brisbane, Australia.
The Weekend Australian Financial Review. Funk, D.C., R. Ridinger. and A. Moorman.
January 23-24: 16 (2004). “Exploring Origins of Involvement:
Baloglu, S. and K. McClearly (1999). "A Model Understanding the Relationship Between
of Destination Image Formation." Annals of Consumer Motives and Involvement with
Tourism Research 26(1): 868-897. Professional Sport Teams”. Leisure Sciences.
Beeton, S. (2000). It's a Wrap: What Happens 26: 35-61.
After the Film Crew Leaves? An Examination Griffin, T. (2002). An Optimistic Perspective on
of Community Responses to Film-induced Tourism's Sustainability. Sustainable
Tourism. TTRA National Conference Lights! Tourism. R. Harris, T. Griffin and P. William.
Camera! Action!, Burbank, California. UK, Butterworth Heinmann.
Beeton, S. (2001). "Smiling for the Camera: the Hall, C. M. (2003). Tourism Issues, Agenda
Influence of Film Audiences on a Budget Setting and the Media, e-review of Tourism
Tourism Destination." Tourism, Culture and Research. 2004.
Communication 3(1): 15-25. Herbert, D. (1996). "Artistic and Literary Places
Beeton, S. (2002). A (de)Marketing Approach to in France as Tourist Attractions." Tourism
Enhancing Capabilities for Film-induced Management 17(2): 77-85.
Tourism. ANZAM Conference Proceedings. Herbert, D. (2001). "Literary Places, Tourism and
Dec, CD ROM. the Heritage Experience." Annals of Tourism
Bordelon, B. and F. Dimanche (2003). Images of Research 28(2): 312-333.
New Orleans: The Relationship Between Hirschman, E. and C. Thompson (1997). "Why
Motion Pictures and Tourists' Expectations of Media Matter: Toward a Richer
a Travel Destination. Targetted Research: Understanding of Consumers' Relationships
The Gateway to Accountability, St.Louis. with Advertising and Mass Media." Journal
USA, Travel & Tourism Research Assoc 34th of Advertising 26(1): 43-60.
Annual Conf.

96
International Tourism and Media Conference 2004

Hunt, J. (1995). "Image as a Factor in Tourism Squire, S. (1993). "The Cultural Values of
Development." Journal of Travel Research Literary Tourism." Annals of Tourism
13(1): 18-23. Research 21: 103-120.
Iso-Ahola, S. (1987). "Towards a Social Squire, S. (1996). "Literary Tourism and
Psychology Theory of Tourist Motivation." Sustainable Tourism: Promoting 'Anne of
Annals of Tourism Research 9: 256-262. Green Gables' in Prince Edward Island."
Iwashita, C. (2003). "Media Construction of Journal of Sustainable Tourism 4(3): 119-
Britain as a Destination for Japanese Tourists: 134.
Social Constructionism and Tourism." Swarbrooke, J. and S. Horner (1999). Consumer
Tourism and Hospitality Research 4(4): 331- Behaviour in Tourism. Great Britain,
340. Butterworth-Heinmann.
Kim, H. and S. Richardson (2003). "Motion Till, B. and T. Shimp. (1998). “Endorsers in
Picture Impacts on Destination Images." Advertising: The Case of Negative Celebrity
Annals of Tourism Research 30(1): 216-237. Information” Journal of Advertising. 27(1):
Klenosky, D. (2002). “The Pull of Tourism 67-81.
Destinations: A Means-End Investigation” Tooke, N and M. Baker (1996). “Seeing is
Journal of Travel Research. 40: 385-395. Believing: The Effect of Film on Visitor
McCracken, G. (1990). “Who is the Celebrity Numbers to Screened Locations” Tourism
Endorser? Cultural Foundations of the Management 17(2): 87-94.
Endorsement Process” Journal of Consumer Um, S. and J. L. Crompton (1990). "Attitude
Research. 16: 310-320. Determinants in Tourism Destination
McQuail, D (1988). Mass Communication Choice." Annals of Tourism Research 17:
Theory: An Introduction. USA. Sage 432-448.
Publications. Witt, C. and P. Wright (1992). Tourist
Mowen, J.C. (2000). The 3M Model of Motivation: Life After Maslow. Choice and
Motivation and Personality: Theory and Demand in Tourism. P. Johnson and B.
Empirical Applications of Consumer Thomas. New York, Mansell.
Behaviour. USA. Kluwer Academic
Publshers.
Parrinello, G. (1993). "Motivation and
Anticipation in Post Industrial Tourism."
Annals of Tourism Research 20: 239-249.
Pearce, P., A. Morrison,. and G. Moscardo
(2003). "Individuals as Tourist Icons: A
Developmental and Marketing Analysis."
Journal of Hospitality and Leisure Marketing
10(1/2): 63-85.
Riley, R. and C. Van Doren (1992). "Movies as
Tourism Promotion: A Push Factor in a Pull
Location." Tourism Management 13 (3): 267-
274.
Riley, R., D. Baker, & C. Van Doren. (1998).
"Movie Induced Tourism." Annals of Tourism
Research 25(4): 919-935.
Ritchie, B. (1984). "Assessing the Impact of
Hallmark Events: Conceptual and Research
Issues." Journal of Travel Research 23(1): 2-
11.
Santos, C. (2004). "Framing Portugal:
Representational Dynamics." Annals of
Tourism Research 31(1): 122-138.
Schofield, P. (1996). "Cinematographic Images of
a City: Alternative Heritage Tourism in
Manchester." Tourism Management 17(5):
333-340.
Shackley, M. (2001). “The Legend of Robin
Hood: Myth, Inauthenticity and Tourism
Development in Nottingham, England”. Hosts
and Guests Revisited: Tourism Issues of the
21st Century. V. Smith and M. Brent. New
York, Cognizant Communications.
Smith, K. (2003). "Literary Enthusiasts as
Visitors and Volunteers." International
Journal of Tourism Research 5: 83-95.

97

You might also like