Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 Tahun 2013 | 9
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
1
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Hasan Sadikin General Hospital – Faculty of
Medicine Padjajaran University, Bandung.
2
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Ciptomangunkusumo General Hospital –
Faculty of Medicine, University of Indonesia, Jakarta
ABSTRACT
Objective: to compare the effectiveness of Tendon and Nerve Gliding Technique (TNGT) exercise
with ultrasound diathermy.
Methods: Twenty Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS) hands meet the inclusion criteria and divided into
2 groups: TNGT exercise and Ultrasound group. The subjects’ characteristics in the two groups are
homogenous.
Results: The statistical analysis results using Friedman test on pain/paresthesia complaint and hand
functional status in each group is significant. Using the ANOVA, results of pain/paresthesia complaint
between two groups shows a significant difference in the 4th measurement and results of functional
status between two groups show a significant difference in the 9th measurement.
Conclusions: Our study emphasized the TNGT exercise combined with splinting will be a good
alternative treatment for CTS beside ultrasound diathermy combined with splinting, since TNGT
exercise group has the same effectiveness with ultrasound diathermy group in decreasing VAS and has
better effectiveness in improvement of FSS.
Splinting is the popular method among sensory disturbance; health service with limited
the conservative treatments of CTS.9-11 facilities; and time consuming problem).
Immobilization of the wrist in a neutral position
with a splint maximizes carpal tunnel space and Material and Methods
minimizes pressure on the median nerve.2, 12 In Subject
addition to splinting, clinical guidelines include A total of 20 patients (all women) from Hasan
home stretching programs.13-15 Tendon and Sadikin General Hospital, with clinical and
nerve gliding technique (TNGT) exercises have electrophysiology evidence of CTS with the
been used for the postoperative management average age 50,80±4,71 (mean±SD) years old.
of CTS,16 while several studies in the literature All patients have to sign informed consent. No
has used TNGT exercises in conservative statistical difference was observed between
management of CTS. The value of these groups. Patients were divided into 2 groups
exercises in conservative management of CTS through randomized assignment method. 10
is still unclear.17, 18 There was limited evidence hands from 10 patients constituted the exercise
that TNGT exercise improves outcomes, and group; these patients were treated with a splint
few studies have attempted to determine the and TNGT exercise. A custom made neutral volar
effective combination of splinting and TNGT splint was given to the patients in both groups
exercise for CTS.19, 20 patients to immobilize the wrist in a neutral
Ultrasound diathermy has the potential position.9 The splint has to be used all night and
rule to induce biophysical effect inside the during the day as much as possible for 3 weeks.
nerve tissue. Thermal effect that produces The ultrasound diathermy group
from ultrasound can increase blood flow, local comprised 10 hands from 10 patients; these
metabolism and tissue regeneration and also patients were treated with splint and ultrasound
reducing edema, inflammation and pain.4, 8, 21 diathermy (Table 1). Criteria for inclusion in the
There are conflicting results on the efficacy of study were age of 18 years or older, unilateral,
therapeutic ultrasound in the treatment of CTS, idiopathic CTS, and mild to moderate pain and/
and only a few studies reported the benefit of or paresthesia in median nerve distribution area
ultrasound in CTS treatment.2, 4, 8, 22 lasting more than 3 months. Exclusion criteria
The purpose of this study is to compare were underlying metabolic disorder (diabetes
the effectiveness of TNGT exercise with mellitus or thyroid disease), rheumatoid arthritis,
ultrasound diathermy, in order to elucidate the pregnancy, history of steroid injection to carpal
appropriate treatment for CTS patients with tunnel, severe thenar atrophy, and history of
special circumstances (e.g contraindication splint use. Electrophysiological confirmation of
with diathermy modality therapy such cancer, the CTS diagnosis was described elsewhere.23, 24
This study was approved by the weeks treatment program. A 100 mm horizontal
Institutional Review Board of Hasan Sadikin VAS was used, with one end labeled no pain and
General Hospital. Informed consent was signed the other unbearable pain. The functional status
by all patients in the study. There were no scale has eight questions. The answers were
supplementations given to the patient before rated from 1 point (mildest pain or no difficulty
and after treatment. with activity) to 5 points (most severe pain or
cannot perform activity at all).
Exercise group
In addition to TNGT exercises, splint application Statistical analysis
was required for the exercise group. During The mean and standard deviations were
tendon gliding exercise, the fingers were placed calculated for all subjects in each group for
in five discrete positions. Those were straight, each parameter. The Friedman test was used to
hook, fist, table top, and straight fist.25 Median compare treatment values within the groups.
nerve gliding exercises were carried out by ANOVA was used to compare the differences
putting the hand and wrist in six different of the values between the groups. A p value
positions.16 Each position was maintained for of less than 0.05 was considered statistically
5 sec. The exercise was applied as five sessions significant. The statistical analysis of the data
per day and repeated 10 times at each session. was done with SPSS (version 16.0 for Windows,
The patient is in a sitting position that varied SPSS Inc.).
according to the patient’s ability to relax the
proximal musculature. The head was placed in RESULTS
the midline and the shoulder in neutral position;
the forearm was placed on a table, and the Before the treatment Tinel and Phalen tests,
elbow was positioned at 90 degrees of flexion. positive findings were recorded in all 20 hands
The patients were instructed to do the exercises for both groups. After 3 weeks treatment
as described in the information sheets they negative Tinel test results were observed in
received; they were required to keep diaries 1 hand in the exercise group and in 1 hand in
of their exercises. We checked how often and the ultrasound diathermy group. After 3 weeks
regularly the patients performed the exercises at treatment negative Phalen test results were
home by asking them to bring the diaries and observed in 1 hand in the exercise group and in
come to hospital 3 times a week for 3 weeks. none of the hands in the ultrasound diathermy
group. At the examination performed during 3
Ultrasound diathermy group weeks of the treatment, there was statistically
We offered therapeutic ultrasound diathermy significant improvement in parameters within
which consist of treatment using ultrasound both groups using Friedman test. There was
diathermy machine from Enraff Nonius Sono- a significant improvement in VAS score for
plus 1.5 watt/cm2 with frequency 3 MHz, and pain during the treatment follow up within
probe diameter 3cm.26 Splint application was both groups (Figure 1). Also, there was
also required for this group. The ultrasound dia- significant improvement in FSS score for hand
thermytherapy lasted for 5 minutes per session, function during the treatment follow-up within
3 times a week, for 3 weeks. both groups (p ≤ 0.01) (Figure 2). By using
ANOVA, we found the improvement in VAS
Outcome measurement for exercise group was slightly greater than
The outcome measurement methods, including ultrasound diathermy group, but this difference
Tinel and Phalen test specific for CTS, visual was not statistically significant (Table 2). The
analogue scale (VAS) for pain, and Functional improvement in FSS for exercise group was
Status Scale (FSS) for hand function,27 were better than ultrasound diathermy group, and this
carried out for all patients 3 times/week for 3 difference was statistically significant.
12 | IndoJPMR Vol.2 Tahun 2013
Table 2. Comparison Between Ultrasound Group vs. Tendon Nerve Gliding Exercise Group Exercise
Group in Outcome Measurement After 3 Weeks Treatment
Data presented in mean±SD; VAS: Visual Analogue Scale; FSS: Functional Status Scale;
* significant different p<0.05
Figure 1. Change of Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) Score for Tendon Nerve Gliding Technique (TNGT)
Exercise Group and Ultrasound Group at Each of Measurement Time During 3 Weeks.
Figure 2. Change of Functional Status Scale (FSS) Score for Tendon Nerve Gliding Technique (TNGT) Exercise
group and Ultrasound Group at Each of Measurement Time During 3 Weeks.
functional improvement, especially in grip support, advice and fruitful discussion for the
strength.34 data analysis.
The other reason why FSS score showed
better score in exercise group compare with
ultrasound diathermy group, might due to REFERENCES
TNGT exercise was done every day by patients
at home, and made the patients get to be used 1. Tanaka S, Wild DK, Seligman PJ, Behrens
to move their hand. When the patients had to V, Cameron L, Putz-Anderson V. The US
perform some activities according to the FSS, prevalence of self-reported carpal tunnel
the exercise group would be easier to set their syndrome: 1988 National Health Interview
hand in motion. Survey data. Am J Public Health. 1994
Due to our small sample size, we recognize Nov;84(11):1846-8.
that the results of this study must be interpreted 2. Gerritsen AA, de Krom MC, Struijs MA,
with caution. In addition, splinting application Scholten RJ, de Vet HC, Bouter LM.
alone was not taken into consideration. Despite Conservative treatment options for carpal
these limitations, the present study emphasized tunnel syndrome: a systematic review of
the TNGT exercise combined with splinting will randomised controlled trials. J Neurol.
be a good alternative treatment for CTS beside 2002 Mar;249(3):272-80.
ultrasound diathermy combined with splinting, 3. Shum C, Parisien M, Strauch RJ,
since TNGT exercise group has the same Rosenwasser MP. The role of flexor
effectiveness with ultrasound diathermy group tenosynovectomy in the operative treatment
in decreasing VAS and has better effectiveness of carpal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint
in improvement of FSS. This suggests that the Surg Am. 2002 Feb;84-A(2):221-5.
TNGT exercise could be used for CTS patients 4. Bakhtiary AH, Rashidy-Pour A. Ultrasound
with specific circumstance; patients in living and laser therapy in the treatment of carpal
with limited health facilities, patients with tunnel syndrome. Aust J Physiother.
diathermy’s contraindication and patient with 2004;50(3):147-51.
low compliance due to difficulty to access health 5. Marshall S, Tardif G, Ashworth N. Local
service and time consuming treatment. corticosteroid injection for carpal tunnel
syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
CONCLUSIONS 2007(2):CD001554.
6. Werner RA, Franzblau A, Gell N.
This study found that TNGT exercise in Randomized controlled trial of nocturnal
combination with splinting could be a better splinting for active workers with symptoms
CTS management alternative to beside of carpal tunnel syndrome. Arch Phys Med
ultrasound diathermy in combination with Rehabil. 2005 Jan;86(1):1-7.
splinting. Both groups were able to decrease 7. Giannini F, Passero S, Cioni R,
VAS, while TNGT group showed to be effective Paradiso C, Battistini N, Giordano N,
in resulting FSS improvement. Thus, TNGT et al. Electrophysiologic evaluation of
exercise could be used for CTS patients with local steroid injection in carpal tunnel
specific circumstance; patients with limited syndrome. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1991
health facilities, diathermy’s contraindication Sep;72(10):738-42.
and low compliance due to limitation to access 8. Ebenbichler GR, Resch KL, Nicolakis
health service and time consuming treatment. P, Wiesinger GF, Uhl F, Ghanem AH,
et al. Ultrasound treatment for treating
Acknowledgements The author would the carpal tunnel syndrome: randomised
like to express their gratitude to Dr. Farida “sham” controlled trial. BMJ. 1998 Mar
Arisanti SpRM and Dr. Evi Yulianti SpRM 7;316(7133):731-5.
for helping in the data collection of this study. 9. Burke DT, Burke MM, Stewart GW,
Also to Dr Marina Moeliono SpRM, for her Cambre A. Splinting for carpal tunnel
IndoJPMR Vol.2 Tahun 2013 | 15