You are on page 1of 7

388 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
LETTERS

Acute rotatory vertigo caused by


a small haemorrhage of the
vestibular cortex
Central rotatory vertigo is in most cases
caused by a lesion of the cerebellum or brain
stem. We describe a patient with acute
rotatory vertigo following a small haemor-
rhage in the left medial temporal gyrus, which
probably injured the vestibular cortex.
Case history
A 53 year old woman suddenly experienced
leftwards directed rotatory vertigo in the yaw
plane and nausea without vomiting. She felt
unsteady and had short lasting slurring of her
speech. She had no hearing loss or tinnitus.
On examination, she could stand unaided but
tended to fall after a short while, without a
directional preponderance. Gait was severely Figure 1 Transverse T2 weighted, fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) image (left)
unsteady and she could not walk unaided. The and sagittal T1 weighted spin echo image (right). Both show a small popcorn shaped area of
rotatory vertigo was worse when she was sit- increased signal intensity demarcated by a rim of decreased signal intensity (haemosiderin),
ting upright than when lying down in bed. located in the left medial temporal gyrus. The combination of recent blood products and older
Vertigo was also increased by head move- haemorrhagic residues is consistent with the diagnosis of a cavernous haemangioma.
ments.
Examination of the cranial nerves showed
no abnormalities; specifically there was no Primate studies have shown a well defined superior temporal gyrus, the long insular and
nystagmus or hearing loss and the eye move- vestibular cortical system.1 In all likelihood, a transverse temporal gyrus, and the medial
ments were normal. Neurological examina- similar system probably also exists in hu- temporal gyrus.
tion of the limbs (motor and sensory function, mans, including, as in primates, several corti-
coordination, and reflexes) was normal. Elec- cal areas.1 2 However, one has to be careful in J Boiten
troencephalography showed no abnormali- extrapolating results from primates to Department of Neurology, St Anna Hospital, PO
ties, supporting a non-epileptic cause of the humans,2 so human studies are important to Box 90, NL-5660 AB Geldrop, Netherlands
vertigo. further elucidate the existence and location of
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on the human vestibular cortical system. J Wilmink
sagittal T1 weighted and transverse T2 The vestibular cortical system seems to be Department of Radiology, University Hospital
weighted spin echo and FLAIR images distributed among several multisensory areas Maastricht, Maastricht, Netherlands
showed a small (2.0 × 1.5 cm) haemorrhage in the parietal and temporal cortex, and is
in the left medial temporal gyrus, adjacent to integrated in a larger network for spatial H Kingma
the superior temporal sulcus (fig 1). There attention and sensory-motor control. The Department of ORL and Head and Neck Surgery,
were no lesions of the brain stem or cerebel- parieto-insular cortex is postulated to be the University Hospital Maastricht
lum. The appearance of the temporal lesion core region within the vestibular cortical sys-
was consistent with haemorrhage from a tem; representation is bilateral, with a right Competing interests: none declared
small cavernous haemangioma. hemispheric dominance.3 Recent research
Vestibular function was evaluated by elec- seems to indicate that there might be no spe- Correspondence to: Dr Jelis Boiten;
tronystagmography (gaze, saccade, smooth cific vestibular cortex, contrary to the visual jelis.boiten@st-anna.nl
pursuit, optokinetic, torsion swing, velocity and auditory systems. Electrophysiological
step, and caloric tests; search for spontaneous recordings of vestibular cortical neurones, References
nystagmus), and by video-oculography (ocu- positron emission tomography, and fMRI 1 Guldin WO, Grüsser O-J. Is there a vestibular
lar counter rolling induced by lateroflexion brain activation studies during caloric and cortex? Trends Neurosci 1998;21:254–9.
and eccentric rotation). No abnormalities galvanic stimulation all confirm the multisen- 2 Leigh RJ. Human vestibular cortex. Ann
were found. Additional testing included the sory character of cortical areas that receive a Neurol 1994;35:383–4.
Romberg test, galvanically induced body sway, substantial vestibular input.4–6 One can under- 3 Brandt T. Vertigo. Its multisensory syndromes,
and the subjective visual vertical. On Romberg stand this when one realises that during 2nd ed. London: Springer-Verlag, 1999.
testing there was abnormally increased body motion not only the labyrinths but also the 4 Bottini G, Sterzi R, Paulesu E, et al.
sway (especially with the eyes closed). The visual and proprioceptive systems will be Identification of the central vestibular
patient could stand long enough with the eyes stimulated. This could make a unimodal projections in man: a positron emission
closed to measure the galvanically induced vestibular cortex unnecessary.3 tomography activation study. Exp Brain Res
body sway, which had normal excitability. The We are aware of one other reported patient 1994;99:164–9.
subjective visual vertical showed a 6° right- with rotatory vertigo and a cortical lesion on 5 Bucher SF, Dieterich M, Wiesmann M, et al.
wards (clockwise) tilt and a reduced accuracy MRI.7 That patient, however, had two cortical Cerebral functional magnetic resonance
(SD 4.7°). The neurological symptoms and lesions: the main lesion was an infarct located imaging of vestibular, auditory, and
signs gradually disappeared over a few weeks. in the right posterior insula involving the long nociceptive areas during galvanic stimulation.
insular and transverse temporal gyrus; the Ann Neurol 1998;44:120–5.
Comment other lesion was in the right parietal cortex. 6 Brandt T, Bartenstein P, Janek A, et al.
Our patient is of interest for two reasons. We believe that our patient is the first reported Reciprocal inhibitory visual-vestibular
interaction: visual motion stimulation
First, she demonstrates that acute rotatory case of rotatory vertigo resulting from a lesion
deactivates the parieto-insular vestibular
vertigo may be caused by a lesion of the (haemorrhage) of the medial temporal gyrus,
cortex. Brain 1998;121:1749–58.
cerebral cortex, supporting the existence of a adjacent to the superior temporal sulcus.
7 Brandt T, Bötzel K, Yousry T, et al. Rotational
cortical area in humans with a substantial Functional brain studies have shown that the vertigo in embolic stroke of the vestibular and
vestibular input. Second, she could be consid- human vestibular cortical system may be auditory cortices. Neurology 1995;45:42–4.
ered as an “experiment of nature”: a small located in the superior temporal region poste- 8 Penfield W. Vestibular sensation and the
lesion confined to a particular brain structure, rior to the auditory area, probably in the cerebral cortex. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol
enabling precise localisation of an area in the superior temporal gyrus.8 9 The results of 1967;6:691–8.
cortex that seems to be very much engaged functional brain studies, the previously re- 9 Friberg L, Olsen TS, Roland PE, et al. Focal
with the vestibular system. ported patient,7 and our own patient indicate increase of blood flow in the cerebral cortex
The exact location of the vestibular cortex that the human vestibular cortical system is of man during vestibular stimulation. Brain
in humans has not yet been established. located in several adjacent cortical areas: the 1985;108:609–23.

www.jnnp.com
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394 389

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
Coexistent Lewy body disease in chronic care facility. He developed more tions as an initial symptom despite the
behavioural problems, declining vision, and marked pathology affecting the primary
a case of “visual variant of persistent visual hallucinations and delu- visual and visual association cortices. Our
Alzheimer’s disease” sions. He was unable to recognise family patient also had clinical features suggesting
members by sight or sound. He died at 71 corticobasal degeneration.4 Although there
Posterior cortical atrophy or the “visual
years of age. are reports of prominent visuospatial impair-
variant” of Alzheimer’s disease is a clinical
His past medical history was only signifi- ment or Balint’s syndrome in clinically diag-
syndrome with visual agnosia, some or all the
cant for a total thyroidectomy for cancer, for nosed and pathologically diagnosed cortico-
components of Balint’s syndrome, transcorti-
which he was on thyroid replacement. There basal degeneration,5 visual hallucinations are
cal sensory aphasia, and Gerstmann’s was no family history of any neurodegenera-
syndrome.1 Although pathologically hetero- almost non-existent in corticobasal degenera-
tive disorder. tion.6 This suggests that visual hallucinations
geneous, several necropsy studies on patients At necropsy examination, standard brain
with posterior cortical atrophy have shown and parkinsonism in the setting of cognitive
fixation and dissection was undertaken. Tis- impairment reflect underlying Lewy body dis-
Alzheimer’s disease pathology.1 We report a sue sections were cut and stained with
patient who presented with the features of ease rather than corticobasal degeneration.6
haematoxylin and eosin, Bielchowsky silver Our case supports this contention. We suggest
posterior cortical atrophy who later developed stain, and immunohistochemically with anti-
mild parkinsonism, visual hallucinations, and that underlying Lewy body disease should be
bodies to tau (Endogen-AT8), amyloid pro- considered in any case of posterior cortical
delusions. Neuropathological evaluation re- tein, and synuclein (Zimed-LB509).
vealed combined Alzheimer’s disease and atrophy associated with parkinsonism and
The brain weighed 1136 g. Focal, asym- particularly visual hallucinations.
Lewy body disease. metrical (left greater than right) parieto-
Case report occipital cortical atrophy and mild pallor of Acknowledgements
A right handed retired diesel mechanic, with the substantia nigra were observed. The basal
ganglia, thalamus, and cerebellum appeared Supported by grants AG 16574 and AG 07216 from
12 years of formal education, was referred for the National Institute on Aging. We extend our
evaluation of an “unusual dementia.” His dif- normal. Microscopically, moderate to frequent
diffuse and neuritic plaques and frequent appreciation to the family for participating in
ficulties started at the age of 58 with the research on aging and dementia.
insidious onset of visuospatial dysfunction. neurofibrillary tangles were seen in limbic
Initially he was not able to fill out bank structures. Accentuated neuronal loss and D F Tang-Wai, K A Josephs, B F Boeve,
increased neurofibrillary tangle density were
deposit slips or write numbers correctly. He R C Petersen
had been an avid reader but had to re-read noted in the parieto-occipital lobes. The find-
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester,
material in order to comprehend it, and ings satisfied criteria for Alzheimer’s disease Minnesota, USA
unsuccessfully used a card to keep his eyes by Braak and Braak staging (stage VI/VI)2 and
focused when reading. He was not able to by the National Institute on Aging and J E Parisi
locate the refrigerator door handle until he Reagan Institute working group on diagnostic Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology,
criteria for the neuropathological assessment Mayo Clinic
groped over the surface to find it.
His wife revealed that when he was 61 he of Alzheimer’s disease (high likelihood).2 In
addition, synuclein positive Lewy bodies, pale D W Dickson
was having difficulties working as a me- Neuropathology Laboratory, Mayo Clinic
chanic. Also, he could not see other cars and bodies, and Lewy neurites were found in the
obstacles while driving, and he stopped substantia nigra, amygdala, entorhinal cortex, Competing interests: none declared
driving at the age of 63 after being involved in and cingulate gyrus; however, the substantia
nigra was less affected than the limbic struc- Correspondence to: Dr Bradley F Boeve;
two motor vehicle accidents. He developed
tures, where synuclein pathology was severe. bboeve@mayo.edu
progressive difficulties with performing calcu-
These findings are consistent with a diagnosis
lations, writing, receptive language, and re-
of transitional Lewy body disease.3
References
cent memory. Despite the cognitive difficul- 1 Zakzanis KK, Boulos MI. Posterior cortical
ties, he retained insight in his disorder. Comment atrophy. Neurologist 2001;7:341–9.
When he was 62, his wife noted that he The clinical syndrome of posterior cortical 2 Working Group. The National Institute on
moved in a stiff manner, did not swing his left Aging, and Reagan Institute working group on
atrophy is characterised by prominent dys- diagnostic criteria for the neuropathologic
arm, and acted “like a little old man.” At age function of the neuronal networks in the
67, he developed well formed visual hallucina- assessment of Alzheimer’s disease. Consensus
biparietal and occipital cortices and does not recommendations for the postmortem
tions (he would see bugs, spiders, and people) imply an underlying pathology; neuropatho- diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. Neurobiol
and paranoid delusions (he expressed con- logical examination in most cases shows neu- Aging 1997;18:S1–2.
cern that people were tearing away his home). rofibrillary tangles and neuritic plaques char- 3 McKeith I, Galasko D, Kosaka K, et al.
He developed personality changes and at acteristic of Alzheimer’s disease, but with a Consensus guidelines for the clinical and
times was confrontational. He became en- higher concentration of the pathology located pathological diagnosis of dementia with Lewy
tirely dependent on his wife for all of his in the primary visual cortex and visual associ- bodies: report of the CDLB international
activities of daily living. No features of REM workshop. Neurology 1996;47:1113–24.
ation areas.1 The predominant features of pos- 4 Boeve B, Parisi J, Dickson D, et al.
sleep behaviour disorder were ever noted by terior cortical atrophy are followed by demen- Demographic and clinical findings in 20 cases
the family. tia more typical of Alzheimer’s disease.1 Visual of pathologically-diagnosed corticobasal
The initial neurological evaluation at the hallucinations and parkinsonism are dis- degeneration. Move Disord 2000;15:228.
Mayo Clinic when he was 67 revealed a com- tinctly uncommon but are recognised fea- 5 Tang-Wai D, Boeve B, Josephs K, et al.
plete Balint’s syndrome, a partial Gerstmann’s tures, in addition to fluctuations in cognition Pathologically-proven corticobasal
syndrome, and impairment on visuospatial that are considered characteristic of dementia degeneration presenting with prominent
tasks and recall. On language examination he with Lewy bodies.3 Pathologically, the latter is parieto-occipital cortical dysfunction.
had paraphasic errors and neologisms. He also characterised by the presence of Lewy body Neurobiol Aging 2002;23:S165.
showed bradykinesia, a slow wide based gait 6 Geda Y, Boeve B, Parisi J, et al.
disease, with limbic or neocortical Lewy Neuropsychiatric features in 20 cases of
with reduced arm swing bilaterally, mild gen- bodies.3 pathologically-diagnosed corticobasal
eralised rigidity, postural but not resting Our case presented with the typical features degeneration. Move Disord 2000;15:229.
tremor, and right limb apraxia. He had limited of posterior cortical atrophy, and findings of
upgaze but preserved downward and horizon- Alzheimer’s disease and Lewy body disease
tal gaze. Visual acuity was 20/80 and 20/100 in were revealed on neuropathological examina- Reversible callosal disconnection
the right and left eye, respectively. There was tion. To our knowledge, there have been no syndrome in internal
no alien limb phenomenon, dystonia, or myo- previous pathological reports of cases of hydrocephalus
clonus. posterior cortical atrophy with coexisting
Neuropsychological testing showed impair- Lewy body disease. The visual hallucinations A 74 year old woman was referred to the
ment in verbal skills and verbal memory and and parkinsonism in our patient were consist- neurological department for evaluation of
the inability to complete the visual tasks. ent with dementia with Lewy bodies, and progressive gait disturbance. On admission
Magnetic resonance imaging and single pho- there was evidence of transitional Lewy body she complained of alienation and loss of con-
ton emission computed tomography of the disease at necropsy. The other major features trol of her left arm for six months. There were
brain showed, respectively, marked asym- of posterior cortical atrophy would be consist- no spontaneous movements without the
metrical (left more than right) parietal- ent with the prominent Alzheimer’s pathology patient’s intention, but she had always to rely
occipital cortical atrophy and hypoperfusion. in occipito-parietal cortices. on visual cues. For example, when she was
Towards the end of his life, he became Interestingly, few patients with posterior cooking, eating, or doing exercises with her
wheelchair bound and was transferred to a cortical atrophy experience visual hallucina- home trainer she had to watch her left arm to

www.jnnp.com
390 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
be sure of its movement. On examination she were normal and there was no spatial neglect. examiner on one finger either of the left or the
was alert, fully oriented, and cooperative. There was no apraxia of the left hand for ges- right hand. Then she was asked to point to the
Snout and palmomental reflexes were posi- tures neither on command nor for imitation. location of touch with the contralateral hand.
tive. There was no visual, somatosensory, or Also, there was no agraphia or tactile anomia The accuracy was impaired for both directions
auditory extinction. Motor examination re- of the left hand. She could perform bimanual but especially for right to left pointing.
vealed a mild left sided facial droop and a left tasks without evidence of intermanual con- However, she was correct when asked to point
sided pronator drift but strength was full and flict. She did not exhibit grasp reflex in either to the location of touch on the face or trunk.
symmetric and there was no lack of spontane- upper limb, and there was no compulsive Magnetic resonance imaging showed inter-
ous movement in the left upper limb. The manipulation of objects. nal hydrocephalus (fig 1A) and an old lacunar
plantar response was extensor on the left. Gait There was, however, an inability of one ischaemic lesion in the right anterior limb of
was slow, unsteady, and wide based. The steps hand to imitate the posture of the opposite the internal capsule. Transcallosal inhibition
were short with reduced step height. Neuro- hand when visual cues were removed. Fur- was assessed by transcranial magnetic stimu-
psychological assessment showed fluent thermore, there was an inability to distin- lation (TMS) as described previously2 and
speech without dysarthria. Comprehension guish the left hand from an examiner’s hand showed a deficient inhibition particularly
and reading were intact. Performance in when these were placed in the patient’s right from left to right (upper panels “left A” in fig
verbal and non-verbal fluency tasks was hand behind the back, which is known as 1B). Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pressure was
diminished, and colour-word interference “strange hand” sign (or “signe de la main normal during lumbar puncture. After re-
was slightly increased. Long term memory étrangère”).1 Additionally, an inability to cross moval of 50 cc CSF the alienation of the left
was slightly deficient for verbal and non- locate touch of the fingers was found: the arm, the “signe de la main étrangère” and the
verbal material. Visuo-constructive abilities patient was blindfolded and touched by the impaired cross replication of hand postures

Figure 1 (A) Magnetic resonance image (T2 weighted) showing internal hydrocephalus with thinning of the corpus callosum. (B) Recordings
of the rectified tonic electromyographic (EMG) activity of the first dorsal interosseous muscle (ID1) after ipsilateral focal transcranial magnetic
stimulation (TMS) are shown. Traces of three trials are superimposed over each other. The recording and stimulus sides as well as the latencies
and durations of the transcallosal inhibitory responses (TI) are indicated. Upper panels A: the findings before lumbar puncture are shown. TI is
normal after TMS of the right hemisphere (normal values (mean (SD)): latency 35.8 (7.2); duration 24.8 (5.4)), but missing on the left (arrow).
Lower panels B: results after withdrawal of 50 cc cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). TI could be revealed on both sides. The latencies after the lumbar
puncture differed clearly and were prolonged after TMS of the left hemisphere.

www.jnnp.com
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394 391

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
completely disappeared. There was also gait 3 Bogen JE. The callosal syndromes. In: not effective. There was no family history of
improvement, and for a walking distance of Heilman KM, Valenstein E, eds. Clinical migraine or other severe headaches.
20 m the number of required steps decreased neuropsychology. 2nd edn. New York: A video recording of several attacks made
Oxford University Press, 1985:295–338.
by five and the time needed by 10 seconds. In by her parents showed the child lying still
4 Goldenberg G, Laimgruber K, Hermsdörfer J.
accord with the clinical finding there was a Imitation of gestures by disconnected while crying intensely. Her right upper and
neurophysiological restoration of the deficient hemispheres. Neuropsychologia lower eyelids were swollen and tear produc-
transcallosal function, which now showed a 2001;39:1432–43. tion and rhinorrhoea were seen on the right
normal inhibition of the tonic EMG activity side. It seemed that she was in continuous
(lower panels in fig 1B). Trigeminal autonomic pain, with superimposed paroxysms of very
Within three weeks the alienation of the intense pain, lasting seconds, during which
left hand and the gait disturbance reappeared. cephalalgia-tic-like syndrome she rocked back and forth (the video record-
When readmitted to our department identical associated with a pontine ing is available at the JNNP website:
callosal dysfunction could be ascertained. tumour in a one year old girl www.jnnp.com).These attacks occurred spont-
After shunt implantation there was perma- aneously at any time of day or night with no
nent recovery of callosal dysfunction and gait The so called trigeminal autonomic cephalal- particular regularity or trigger points. Mag-
disturbance. gias (TAC) include episodic and chronic netic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain
Various callosal disconnection signs may paroxysmal hemicrania (CPH), short lasting revealed a tumour in the pons, extending to
follow a structural lesion of the corpus unilateral neuralgiform headache with con- the medulla oblongata and cervical myelum
callosum. Among others, there is the sign of junctival injection and tearing (SUNCT), and (fig 1A), with a syrinx in the cervical myelum.
impaired cross replication of hand postures cluster headache (CH).1 Combinations of On the transverse slide, the tumour extended
when visual cues are removed,3 4 the inability cluster headache and chronic paroxysmal to the cerebropontine cistern on the right side
to cross locate touch of the fingers when hemicrania with trigeminal neuralgia have (fig 1B). Repeated physical examinations after
blindfolded,4 and the “signe de la main also been described and have been called six weeks showed hyperreflexia of the right
étrangère” (the sign of the foreign hand) cluster-tic syndrome2 or CPH-tic syndrome.3 arm and leg and positive Babinski reflexes on
describing a failure to recognise self owner- In order to diagnose TACs, it is essential to both sides. After debulking the tumour, the
ship of the left hand when visual cues are record the case history carefully. Only rarely attacks resolved completely and neurological
removed.1 have intracranial lesions such as aneurysms examination normalised. Pathological exam-
We describe a callosal disconnection syn- or tumours been observed in association with ination of the tumour revealed a pilocytic
drome with a “signe de la main étrangère”, an TACs. In the majority of cases, no brain abnor- astrocytoma. The patient has remained
impaired cross replication of hand postures, malities are found using conventional imag- headache-free following neurosurgery during
and an inability to cross locate touch of the ing. two years of follow up. Neurological examina-
fingers in a patient with internal hydrocepha- We describe a three year old girl who tion has remained normal during this period.
lus that completely disappeared after remov- suffered attacks of severe right sided temporal
pain and autonomic disturbances and in Comment
ing CSF indicating a functional impairment of
the corpus callosum. The finding is substanti- addition neuralgic shooting pains associated The diagnosis of primary headaches associ-
ated by electrophysiological studies: the trans- with a pilocytic astrocytoma in the pons and ated with autonomic symptoms, such as clus-
callosal motor inhibition before CSF tapping medulla oblongata, extending to the upper ter headache or chronic paroxysmal hemicra-
showed a deficient callosal function that nor- cervical cord. The attacks disappeared once nia, is based on the patients’ history, because
malised after CSF removal. Before CSF tap- the tumour had been debulked. diagnostic tests are not available. As shown
ping there was also a functional asymmetry in here, a video recording of the attacks may be
Case report very helpful when patients are unable to
that the transcallosal information transfer
from left to right was more deficient than A three year old girl presented with a history describe the attacks in detail themselves. In
from right to left (fig 1). The origin of this of extremely painful right sided temporal this case the autonomic symptoms during the
asymmetry is not clear, but may be attribut- headache attacks since the age of one year. headache and the sudden additional shooting
able to an additional involvement of adjacent During these attacks she would grab her right pains were recognised by the parents and the
white matter on one side. Together with the ear and cry intensely. Her eyelids were slightly physician after studying these video record-
restoration of transcallosal dysfunction after swollen, with rhinorrhoea on the right side. ings. Although the attacks lasted 12 to 24
CSF tapping, this asymmetry was largely The attacks usually lasted 12 to 24 hours and hours, the combined headaches best resem-
reversible too. occurred weekly, sometimes waking her up at bled a combination of a TAC-like syndrome in
In summary, the restoration of electro- night. During the attacks, the patient wanted association with trigeminal neuralgia or idio-
physiologically assessed transcallosal inhibi- to be in a darkened room, but she did not feel pathic stabbing headache (ISH). It is difficult
tion in parallel with the recovery of the clini- nauseous and did not vomit. Initially, neuro- to distinguish trigeminal neuralgia from ISH
cal symptoms and signs of our patient suggest logical examination revealed no abnormali- in this case, as both headaches only last
a reversible, partial interhemispheric somato- ties. Aspirin or other simple analgesics were seconds, may occur many times per day, and
sensory disconnection syndrome attributable
to a functional impairment of the corpus cal-
losum.
To our best knowledge this is the first report
that underlines that dysfunction of the corpus
callosum in internal hydrocephalus may not
only cause electrophysiological2 but also clini-
cal signs of callosal disconnection.
Competing interests: none declared.
T Nyffeler, R Bühler, P Höllinger,
C W Hess
Department of Neurology, University Hospital,
University of Berne, Freiburgstrasse 10, 3010
Berne, Switzerland

Correspondence to: Dr T Nyffeler;


thomas.nyffeler@gmx.ch

References
1 Brion S, Jedynak CP. Troubles du transfert
interhemispherique. A propos de trois
observations de tumeurs du corps calleux. Le
signe de la main étrangère. Rev Neurol
1972;126:257–66.
2 Rösler KM, Nirkko AC, Hess CW.
Electrophysiological assessment of functional Figure 1 (A) T1 weighted sagittal magnetic resonance image (MRI) scan of the brain after
corpus callosum integrity in internal gadolinium contrast, showing a space occupying lesion in the pons, extending to the medulla
hydrocephalus. Muscle Nerve oblongata. Below the tumour a syrinx is present in the cervical myelum. (B) T2 weighted
1995;18:787–8. transverse MRI scan, showing extension of the tumour to the right cerebropontine angle.

www.jnnp.com
392 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
may be located in the first division of the a case report. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry in these subjects may be purely coincidental
trigeminal nerve. ISH is often described in 2001;70:244–6. but, because of the short delay between
association with other primary headaches and 6 Kuritzky A. Cluster headache-like pain surgery and presentation, it is difficult to
usually responds to indomethacin, in contrast caused by an upper cervical meningioma.
escape the conclusion that the cardiac surgery
Cephalalgia 1984;4:185–6.
to trigeminal neuralgia.1 We cannot conclude precipitated the condition or exacerbated
with certainty that the stabs in this case are subclinical disease. During cardiac surgery
ISH, because indomethacin was not used. there is damage to the atrophic thymic
The attacks were found to be associated A video recording of the remnants that are present in the anterior
with a pilocytic astrocytoma in the pons that patient during a headache mediastinal fat. The thymus contains muscle-
extended to the medulla oblongata on the attack is available on the like cells, called myoid cells, which express
same side as the attacks. Similar cases have journal website whole AChR molecules.3 Release of thymic
suggested involvement of vascular or neoplas- (www.jnnp.com). The AChR could increase an existing subclinical
tic intracranial lesions in TACs.1 4 5 A causal recording shows the patient sitting still with a antibody response, or allow AChR to be
relation between the symptoms and the swollen eyelid on the right side. A few presented de novo to the immune system; the
lesions was not easily established in all cases, moments later she suddenly starts to cry lack of postoperative difficulties, which are
but involvement of the intracranial lesions intensely, while grabbing to her right eye commonly encountered in undiagnosed MG,
with trigeminal structures was suggested. and right ear. During this episode, she moves suggests that the second hypothesis is most
One patient with an upper cervical meningi- back and forth, and pronounced lacrymation probable. The AChR is very immunogenic; for
oma had cluster headache attacks, possibly is seen in her right eye. instance, in mice, intraperitoneal injection of
caused by direct compression of the C1–C3 purified murine AChR without adjuvants can
rootlets or the trigeminal nucleus.6 Further- result in the typical antibodies and clinical
more, cluster-tic syndrome has been reported expression of the disease.4
in association with intracranial pathology.2 In Autoimmune myasthenia gravis Further studies should investigate the pres-
this case, direct compression of the trigeminal after cardiac surgery ence of muscle weakness and positive titres of
root by the basilar artery entering deep into acetylcholine receptor antibodies after cardiac
the cerebellopontine cistern was suggested as Autoimmune myasthenia gravis (MG) is a surgery, and could compare with similar
a cause of the pain. It is not clear how the heterogenous disorder. In young women, the measurements after other forms of major sur-
lesion in our case caused paroxysmal symp- thymus gland is often hyperplastic, and the gery in this age group. Equally, as other
toms, but disappearance of the symptoms patients respond well to thymectomy. How- autoantigens are also expressed in the
after debulking suggests a causal relation. ever, in the increasing number of patients over thymus,5 the presence of other autoantibodies
the age of 40 years, predominantly men, or signs of other autoimmune diseases should
J A van Vliet, M D Ferrari, J Haan, thymic hyperplasia is uncommon, and there be sought.
L A E M Laan are no clear aetiological clues.1 Competing interests: none declared.
Department of Neurology, Leiden University We diagnosed MG in three male patients
Medical Centre, PO Box 9600, 2300 RC Leiden, who had undergone cardiac surgery between C Scoppetta, P Onorati, F Eusebi
Netherlands three and ten weeks before developing symp- Dipartimento di Fisiologia umana e Farmacologia,
toms. Table 1 summarises their main features. Università di Roma “La Sapienza”, Piazzale Aldo
JHC Voormolen The patients presented with ocular, bulbar, and Moro 5, 00185, Rome, Italy
Department of Neurosurgery, Leiden University mild generalised weakness (Osserman classifi-
Medical Centre C Scoppetta, P Onorati, F Eusebi, M Fini
Competing interests: none declared
cation grade I to IIb). None of them was taking
Dipartimento di Scienze internistiche, Ospedale
antiarrhythmic agents or other drugs impair- San Raffaele Pisana, Tosinvest Sanità, Rome, Italy
Correspondence to: Dr Laan; ing neuromuscular transmission and none of
l.a.e.m.laan.neurology@lumc.nl them had had any thyroid or other auto- A Evoli
immune disorder. Two showed typical decre- Istituto di Neurologia, Università Cattolica, Rome,
References mental responses to repetitive stimulation on Italy
1 Matharu MS, Goadsby PJ. Trigeminal EMG, and all three had positive levels of
autonomic cephalalgias. J Neurol Neurosurg A Vincent
antibodies to acetylcholine receptors, which are
Psychiatry 2002;72(suppl II):ii19–26. Department of Clinical Neurology, University of
diagnostic for MG.1 None had had postopera- Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 Ochoa JJ, Alberca R, Canadillas F, et al.
Cluster-tic syndrome and basilar artery tive recovery difficulties that might have
ectasia: a case report. Headache suggested pre-existing MG. All three patients Correspondence to: Professor C Scoppetta;
1993;33:512–13. were treated with cholinesterase inhibitors, ciriaco.scoppetta@uniroma1.it
3 Caminero AB, Pareja JA, Dobato JL. Chronic two also required corticosteroids (for the plan
paroxysmal hemicrania-tic syndrome. of treatment, see Sanders and Scoppetta2), and References
Cephalalgia 1998;18:159–61. one required plasma exchange. The patients 1 Vincent A, Palace J, Hilton-Jones D.
4 Cid CG, Berciano J, Pascual J. Retro-ocular have now been followed up for up to seven Myasthenia gravis. Lancet 2001;357:2122–
headache with autonomic features resembling 8.
years and all still require some medication and
“continuous” cluster headache in lateral 2 Sanders DB, Scoppetta C. The treatment of
medullary infarction. J Neurol Neurosurg have positive AChR antibodies. patients with myasthenia gravis. Neurol Clin
Psychiatry 2000;69:134. The development of MG within a few weeks 1994;12:343–68.
5 ter Berg JW, Goadsby PJ. Significance of of cardiac surgery is intriguing, and has not 3 Schluep, M, Willcox NH, Vincent A, et al.
atypical presentation of symptomatic SUNCT: been reported before. The presentation of MG Acetylcholine receptors in human myoid cells

Table 1 Clinical and laboratory features of three patients with autoimmune myasthenia
Time since AChR
Sex, age at surgery to Presenting features; antibodies Follow up and
the onset onset of (Osserman group at normal value evolution AchR-ab
of MG Heart surgery MG onset) Clinical diagnosis <0.8 nmol Treatment and responce present titre

M, 57 Triple 3 weeks Ptosis, double vision;Responce to im 1.9 nmol Cholinesterase inhibitors: 6 years, fluctuating
aorto-coronaric (I) neostigmine and oral good ocular MG
bypass pyridostigmine 3.0 nmol
M, 58 Double 10 weeks Dysarthria, dysphagia Decrement on 8.0 nmol Cholinesterase inhibitors: 7 years, fluctuating
aorto-coronaric and arm weakness; repetitive stimulation, mild generalised MG
bypass (IIb) response to iv Prednisone and plasma 3.5 nmol
edrophonium exchange: good
M, 65 Triple 10 weeks Double vision, Decrement on 12.0 nmol Cholinesterase inhibitors: 8 months, mild
aorto-coronaric dysphagia and repetitive stimulation, mild generalised MG
bypass dysarthria; (IIb) response to im prednisone: good 1.1 nmol
neostigmine and oral
pyridostigmine

www.jnnp.com
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394 393

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
in situ: an immunohistological study. Ann observed clinically or recorded electrically has
Neurol 1987;22:212–22. been reported in a variety of disorders,
4 Jermy A, Beeson D, Vincent A. Pathogenic including Eaton–Lambert syndrome, botu-
anti-(mouse) acetylcholine receptor induced in
lism, and transverse myelitis, and even in
BALB/C mice without adjuvant. Eur J Immunol
1993;23:973–6. patients with intracranial mass lesions.5 The
5 Klein L, Kyewski B. “Promiscuous” expression partial response to anticholinesterase drugs in
of tissue antigens in the thymus: a key to T-cell our case reinforces the view that it is unwise
tolerance and autoimmunity? J Mol Med to base the diagnosis of myasthenia gravis
2000;78:4:83–94. purely on a positive pharmacological test.
C Rodolico, P Girlanda, C Nicolosi,
Chiari I malformation mimicking G Vita
myasthenia gravis Department of Neurosciences, Psychiatry and
Anaesthesiology, Policlinico Universitario, Via C
Chiari I malformation is accompanied by a Valeria, Messina 98125, Italy
variety of symptoms and signs suggesting
brain stem, cerebellar, or cervical spinal cord M Bonsignore, G Tortorella
lesions. The most common symptoms include Department of Paediatrics and Paediatric Surgery
Sciences, Policlinico Universitario, Messina
headache, neck pain, sensory loss, and
ataxia.1 Dysphagia occurs in 5–15% of the Competing interests: none declared.
patients and it may be the only presenting Figure 1 Brain and cervical spine magnetic
symptom.2 Progressive dysphagia caused by resonance imaging: herniation of the Correspondence to: Dr Carmelo Rodolico;
Chiari I malformation, mimicking amyo- cerebellar tonsils through the foramen crodolico@unime.it
trophic lateral sclerosis, has been reported in magnum.
this journal in 1996 and 2002.2 3 Dysphonia References
may occur rarely, but it has not been described 1 Paul KS, Lye RH, Strang FA, et al.
Arnold–Chiari malformation. Review of 71
as an early symptom.2 Pain and stiffness in the C2–C3 vertebral level (fig 1). No syrinx or cases. J Neurosurg 1983;58:183–7.
posterior neck is a common feature, but severe hydrocephalus was demonstrated. A diagno- 2 Ikusaka, Iwata M, Sasaki S, et al.
neck extensor weakness leading to dropped sis of Chiari I malformation was made. Progressive dysphagia due to adult Chiari I
head syndrome has not so far been reported in A posterior fossa craniectomy was under- malformation mimicking amyotrophic lateral
Chiari I malformation. taken. The anaesthesia and operative proce- sclerosis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
dure were uncomplicated. Two days after the 1996;60:357–8.
Case report operation, the dysphagia and dysphonia im- 3 Paulig M, Prosiegel M. Misdiagnosis of
proved and one month later there had been a amyotrophic lateral sclerosis in a patient with
A 13 year old girl was admitted to our depart-
dysphagia due to Chiari I malformation. J
ment of neurology four weeks after adenoid- remarkable improvement in the neck extensor Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2002;72:270.
ectomy under general anaesthesia, because of muscle weakness. 4 Bunc G, Vorsic M. Presentation of a
progressive difficulty in lifting her chin off her previously asymptomatic Chiari I malformation
chest, together with dysphagia and dyspho- Comment by a flexion injury of the neck. J Neurotrauma
nia. There was no pain or stiffness in the pos- Dropped head may be a part of a generalised 2001;18:645–8.
terior neck. Computed tomography of the neuromuscular disorder, such as myasthenia, 5 Moorthy G, Behrens MM, Drachman DB, et
head was reported as normal. There was mild polymyositis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, al. Ocular pseudomyasthenia or ocular
myasthenia “plus”: a warning to clinicians.
fluctuation of the dysphagia and dysphonia adult onset nemaline myopathy, or chronic
Neurology 1989;39:1150–4.
during the day, with worsening of the inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy.
dysphonia after prolonged conversation or Our patient had a dropped head “plus”
after reading in a loud voice. There was no syndrome secondary to Chiari I malforma- Expanding cerebral cysts
sleep disturbance. tion. Strangely, the neck pain and stiffness (lacunae): a treatable cause of
Neurological examination revealed an in- were not referred. This case report suggests
crease in the deep tendon reflexes in all four that one should suspect Chiari I malformation progressive midbrain syndrome
limbs. Routine serum biochemistry and blood in patients with neck extensor muscle weak- A progressive motor defect presenting in
count were unremarkable. ness, especially if this is associated with lower adulthood is an ominous sign, being often
On the basis of the history and clinical data, cranial nerve impairment. We postulate that associated with either neoplasia or neurode-
myasthenia gravis was suspected, so electro- the symptomatology in this girl may have generative diseases. Notable if very rare
physiological testing was undertaken to in- been the result of brain stem dysfunction sec- exceptions to this poor prognosis are cerebral
vestigate the neuromuscular junction. Percu- ondary to the compression caused by the expanding lacunae or, as they are sometimes
taneous 3 Hz repetitive nerve stimulation of malformation. Dysfunction of the lower cra- called, benign intraparenchymal brain cysts.1
the right accessory nerve along with record- nial nerves and the higher cervicospinal roots These are intraparenchymal cavities without
ings obtained from surface electrodes over the by a retrograde effect of the compression may an epithelial lining, filled with cerebrospinal
trapezius muscle did not show significant be the pathogenic explanatory mechanism. fluid (CSF), located in the thalamo-
variations in compound muscle action poten- The rapid disappearance of the symptoms mesencephalic arterial territory.1 2 Their ex-
tial amplitude under baseline conditions, or after posterior fossa decompression supports panding nature is demonstrated by their pro-
when the test was repeated three minutes this hypothesis. Fluctuations of dysphonia gressive clinical course and by the frequent
after maximal voluntary effort for 30 seconds. and dysphagia may, on the other hand, reflect complication of aqueduct stenosis and triven-
Single fibre electromyography of the right variations in intracranial pressure. Recently, a tricular hydrocephalus.2–4
extensor digitorum communis muscle during presentation of a previously asymptomatic We present a case of progressive midbrain
voluntary activity failed to show any abnor- Chiari I malformation was reported following syndrome associated with expanding cysts,
mally increased jitter or neuromuscular block, a flexion injury to the neck by a trivial car which was successfully treated by neuroen-
and the mean jitter value was in the normal accident.4 In our patient, it is possible that doscopy.
range. Serum antiacetylcholine receptor anti- slight cervical trauma during anaesthesia for
bodies were absent. Standard concentric nee- her adenoidectomy may have brought to light Case report
dle electromyography of proximal and distal the underlying congenital abnormality. A 43 year old woman with an unremarkable
muscles in all four limbs was normal. The cer- Moorty et al have reported eight cases, clinical history presented in 1996 with pro-
vical paraspinal muscles were not investi- initially diagnosed as ocular myasthenia on gressive resting tremor and weakness of the
gated. Motor and sensory conduction veloci- the basis of clinical features and response of left arm. The tremor persisted during posture
ties were normal. A neostigmine test resulted anticholinesterase agents, in which an intrac- maintenance and action. Within a year the
in mild improvement in the dysphonia. ranial mass lesion instead of or in addition to motor problems extended to the left leg. Brain
One week later, the patient experienced a myasthenia gravis was later found.5 Patients magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed
worsening of dysphagia and dysphonia and with dropped head and lower cranial nerve large (10 to 20 mm) well defined lesions with
she started to complain of gait disturbances, involvement, although presenting with a signal intensities identical to CSF occupying
with instability in walking. Magnetic reso- clinical history strongly suggestive of most of the right thalamo-mesencephalic
nance imaging of the brain and cervical spine myasthenia, should be carefully evaluated and region. There was no contrast enhancement
showed herniation of the cerebellar tonsils the diagnosis of Chiari I malformation consid- either in the lesions or in the surrounding tis-
through the foramen magnum, reaching ered. A response to anticholinesterase agents sue. The ventricular spaces were only mildly

www.jnnp.com
394 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003;74:388–394

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.74.3.388 on 1 March 2003. Downloaded from http://jnnp.bmj.com/ on May 1, 2021 by guest. Protected by copyright.
enlarged. A search for cystic lesions elsewhere
in the body was negative.
In the following year disturbance in posture
and diplopia in the right lateral gaze became
apparent. The tremor resolved spontaneously,
but the left hemiparesis worsened. She was
referred for neurosurgical evaluation.
At admission, objective findings were a left
hemiparesis (leg worse than arm), hemirigid-
ity, severely reduced automatic movements
and left bradykinesia, brisk tendon jerks on
the left, diplopia on rightward gaze, and Pari-
naud syndrome. The patient was alert and
oriented, with intact gross cognition.
A preoperative brain MRI showed multiple
large cystic lesions occupying the right para-
median ponto-mesencephalic region and
smaller lesions in the right thalamus (fig 1,
panels A and B). CSF flow sequences revealed
aqueductal stenosis and slight triventricular
hydrocephalus.

Surgical procedure
The patient underwent a surgical endoscopic
procedure. A flexible 2.5 mm neuroendoscope
(Storz) was inserted through a burr hole, and
the third ventricle was incannulated with a
3.9 peel away. The floor of the ventricle poste-
rior to the mammillary bodies appeared Figure 1 Preoperative sagittal (A) and coronal (B) T1 weighted magnetic resonance (MR)
severely deformed by a large cystic mass that images (gadolinium enhanced). Large multilobulated cystic lesions occupy the right
did not allow access to the aqueduct. The ponto-mesencephalic region, squeezing the aqueduct and causing mild triventricular
cystic mass was coagulated and opened into hydrocephalus. Postoperative sagittal (C) and coronal (D) T1 weighted MR images. There is a
the third ventricle. A fragment of the cyst wall slight reduction in volume of the lesions, with partial resolution of the hydrocephalus.
was taken for pathology, which showed
normal neuroglia with few amilaceaous bod-
ies, no epithelial lining, and no signs of old or obscure. Clinical presentation is characterised type of lesion has the advantage of a good risk
recent haemorrhage. by signs of triventricular hydrocephalus from to benefit ratio. As the term “lacuna” is
Once opened, the inside of the cyst revealed aqueduct obstruction, and by various extrapy- usually associated with a small static vascular
a multilobular structure. The flux of fluid ramidal signs, ataxia, and abnormalities of lesion, and the term “benign cyst” overlooks
towards the ventricle was very apparent, indi- oculomotion. In our patient the tremor disap- the expanding nature of the lesion, we
cating multiple intercommunicating lesions peared when the motor defects worsened, and suggest that these lesions should be called
under moderate pressure. The last surgical reappeared after their resolution. This obser- “benign expanding cerebral cysts.”
procedure was a third ventriculo- vation could be explained by the progression P L Longatti, A Fiorindi, A Carteri
cisternostomy 3.5 mm anterior to the mam- of the cystic lesions towards the ventral thala- Neurosurgical Unit, Treviso Hospital, Treviso, Italy
millary bodies. mus causing the functional equivalent of a
After the operation there was a transitory reversible thalamotomy, the “benefit” of F Caroli
disturbance of convergence and limitation of which reversed upon decompression of the Istituto Regina Elena, Rome, Italy
lateral eye deviation, which resolved sponta- cysts. A Martinuzzi
neously on day 3. The expanding nature of the lesions and the E Medea Scientific Institute, Conegliano Research
progressive clinical worsening justify surgical Centre, via Costa Alta 37, 31015 Conegliano (TV),
Follow up management. Treatment of the hydrocephalus Italy
At three months the patient showed a (shunting, cisternostomy) has seldom been Competing interest: none declared
remarkable improvement in motor perform- rewarding.2–5 Opening and draining the cysts,
while carrying a higher morbidity risk, seems Correspondence to: Dr Andrea Martinuzzi;
ance but there was reappearance of a modest andrea.martinuzzi@cn.lnf.it
resting tremor in the left hand. MRI docu- to give a better clinical outcome, although the
mented a mild reduction in cyst volume and cyst volume is not significantly modified by References
moderate reduction in ventricular size (fig 1, the procedures.1 5 In our case, the use of an 1 Wilkins RH, Burger PC. Benign
panels C and D). At 18 months the patient was endoscopic approach to both the hydrocepha- intraparenchymal brain cysts without an
lus and the opening of the cysts minimised epithelial lining. J Neurosurg
neurologically normal except for the mild 1988;68:378–82.
resting tremor of the left hand. She had operative risks and led to an excellent clinical
2 Poirier J, Barbizet J, Gaston A, et al.
resumed all her premorbid activities, includ- result. The values of endoscopic neurosurgery Démence thalamique. Lacunes expansives du
ing dancing. in expanding cerebral lacunae has been territoire thalamo-mésencéphalique
emphasised by others.4 paramédian. Hydrocéphalie par sténose de
Comment While the neuropathology of the lesions l’aqueduc de Sylvius. Rev Neurol (Paris)
A progressive disorder of cognition and and their location supports the interpretation 1983;139:349–58.
3 Mascalchi M, Salvi P, Godano U, et al.
hydrocephalus caused by expanding cerebral that the cystic spaces are dilated Virchow–
Expanding lacunae causing triventricular
lacunae in the thalamus and midbrain was Robin spaces, the precise mechanism leading hydrocephalus. J Neurosurg
first described in 1983.2 These lesions consist to the dilatation remains unknown. The 1999;91:669–74.
of multiple grape-like CSF filled cavities, usu- absence of vasculitis or systemic hypertension 4 Schroeder HWS, Gaab MR, Warzok RW.
ally located bilaterally in the rostral brain in all reported cases reinforces the hypothesis Endoscopic treatment of an unusual multicystic
stem. Their incidence is extremely rare (seven of a localised disturbance in vascular perme- lesion of the brainstem: case report. Br J
Neurosurg 1996;10:193–6.
cases reported thus far),1–5 and apparently not ability and interstitial fluid reabsorption.5 5 Homeyer P, Cornu P, Lacomblez L, et al. A
related to any risk factor. Differential diagno- In conclusion we draw attention to this very special form of cerebral lacunae: expanding
sis includes parasitic and neoplastic cystic unusual neuropathological entity. An endo- lacunae. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
lesions. However, their pathogenesis remains scopic microneurosurgical approach to this 1996;61:200–2.

www.jnnp.com

You might also like