Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/319863853
CITATIONS READS
4 1,716
3 authors:
Hamid Housni
National School of Management Tangier Morocco
2 PUBLICATIONS 4 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Abdelouhab Salahddine on 16 September 2018.
Research Article
Received date: 25 November 2016; Accepted date: 25 April 2017; Published date: 22 June 2017
Copyright © 2017. Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni. Distributed under
Creative Commons CC-BY 4.0
Abstract
Small and medium enterprises, which are the key element to the development of the
economy of a country like Morocco, are involved in varied activities related to trade,
agriculture, crafts, tourism… It is clear that they require funds to start their activity first and
then work on improving it. However, SMEs face some difficulties related to financial needs
due to the quantitative and qualitative rationing imposed by the traditional financial system
against them. Therefore, SMEs look for financial means that meet their specific liquidity
needs, such as participatory banking which could be a credible alternative to classical
financing of SME.Therefore, this article is dedicated to the presentation of different
theoretical reflections and the results of the first exploratory study based on the interviews
with business account managers in several Moroccan banks about the issue of the specificity
of SMEs and their financing by conventional banks.
Cite this Article as: Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017)," SME Financing
in Morocco: Issues and Alternatives", Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice, Vol. 2017 (2017),
Article ID 420530, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice 2
__________________________________________________________________________
the credit rationing in order to alleviate the Small and Medium Enterprises: A
risk of SMEs. Specific and Compellable Business
The present article aims at investigating SMEs represent 95% of all businesses in
the problems facing SMEs in the process of Morocco, according to the statistics of the
financing their activities by traditional SMEs’ confederation. There is no one
banks in the Moroccan territory, and precise definition of an SME. It varies
clarifying the extent to which the according to the field of activity and
participatory bank could be a credible application.
alternative to the solution of these
problems. The first research studies underlined the
size-effect to distinguish between the
Our paper is also devoted to the study of different structurings of the organization
the relationship between classical banks (Aston, 1970). But the idea of categorizing
and SMEs, characterized by an companies on the basis of quantitative
informational asymmetry which limits the factors (company size, turn-over, share
access of these companies to bank capital, added-value…) has been
financing. In order to understand the questioned by the existence of qualitative
specificities of banking practice in the SME criteria which allow the identification of
financing process, we carried out an the SME compared to other types of
exploratory study on the informational organizational structures.
asymmetries management measures and
their impact on SME financing conditions, Moreover, there are other factors which
and the credit rationing determinants affirm that the SME is not a large company
applied by the different Moroccan banks. in miniature, does not use the same
We have limited the study to the city of management tools and does not have the
Oujda in Morocco by targeting a single same organizational strategic and
business account manager of each bank (8 environmental characteristics. Indeed, the
different banks) who is directly involved in SMEs are specific (Julien et Marchesnay,
the processing of SME credit files. 1988).
Moreover, the paper suggests the devices Nevertheless, another current, namely that
of improvement of this relationship and the of diversity, stipulates that SMEs are
financing of SMEs at the national level. heterogeneous and it is impossible to
englobe them within the same single model
The present paper is organized as follows; due to the high diversity of SME
the first section will deal with the configurations.
specificities of an SME and its development
constraints in Morocco. Then, the second Furthermore, the thesis of the specificity of
section analyses the heart of the financial SMEs has been modulated by the synthesis
matter of Moroccan based SMEs by current, which indicates that the specific
presenting the complications that these characteristics of SMEs are flexible (Julien
companies go through to obtain the and Marchensay, 1987; D’Amboise, 1993)
necessary financial resources for their
activity and exposing the different Starting from the nineties, the idea of
improvement mechanisms of the denaturation of the SME emerged to allow
relationship conventional bank /SME, by raising questions on its identity not in
focusing on the dialogue maintained by the relation to a classification in terms of size,
literature and the results of the semi- growth in comparison to a large company
structured interviews carried out. Finally, but in terms of its own properties (Torres,
we will introduce the participatory bank as 1997).
a financial alternative for SMEs in Morocco.
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
3 Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice
__________________________________________________________________________
______________
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice 4
__________________________________________________________________________
SME Financing by Conventional Banks in Gasse and D’Amours (2000), this risk
Morocco assessment creates interest conflicts
between banks and SMEs. While SMEs try
The leaders of SMEs prefer to finance their to control profitability with a fixed risk
activities by internal sources rather than level, banks tend to control risk by focusing
external ones, which is explained by the on profitability. Both sides stick to the
differences in bankruptcy costs, control achievement of the objectives and reach
and fiscal disparities according to the the desired profits (Sarasvathy and al,
pecking order theory (Myers and Majluf, 1998).
1984). When the SME’s needs exceed its
internal capacity, the enterprise applies for The bank–SME relation is considered as an
loans first from the conventional financial agency relation transfused by oppositions
institutions, and then it issues shares. and issues related to latent information,
which increases the risk and cost of SME
Moreover, the signal theory, according to credits (Joseph and Sinkey, 1998).
Ross (1977), stipulates that the more the However, the financing of SMEs is
company’s level of debt is high, the more it considered by traditional bank as being
exhibits a signal of good quality and it more dangerous than that of big
undertakes profitable projects of companies.
investment.
This is affirmed by the central office of
As a result, bank loans dominate in balance sheets of “La Banque de France”,
financing small and medium size which reveals that the risk of failure
businesses. The financial statement proved decreases with the size of the company.
that a small business does not have When establishing an SME financing
sufficient reputation to have direct access contract, the firm worries are directed
to market. At a Moroccan level, SME access towards the profit of the capital returns
to capital and debt markets is limited by while the bank concentrates its concern on
strict conditions demanded by these the solvency of the borrower.
markets. In this respect, SMEs have
recourse to banks to get financed and to The asymmetry of information covers two
contribute to the creation of information types of situation the bank faces. Firstly,
about their solvency in order to gain more when an SME applies for funding, the bank
notoriety. is unable to distinguish between "good"
and "bad"2 projects; this phenomenon is
However, Moroccan SMEs face many called “the adverse selection” developed by
constraints which destabilize the process of Stiglitz and Weiss (1981). According to
granting bank loans. On the basis of the Akerlof’s study (1970), it was concluded
results of the interviews, we found that, on that starting from a certain interest rate,
the one hand, the regulation affects the the effect of adverse selection becomes
policy of distributing credits to SMEs, since stronger and stronger and the balance of
the bank is obliged to respect the key rate the credit market is no longer done through
demanded by the central bank and to take prices (i.e. Interest rate) but through
into account affected or risky sectors of quantities. Thus, SMEs face a rationing of
activity. On the other hand, the bank loans based on the risk level of their
insufficiency of means of SME risks project, and this is because of the
assessment by banks influence the decision opportunistic behaviour of the leader and
of the bank due to the strong information the short-term based management strategy
asymmetry and the incapacity of these of the SME. The business account managers
enterprises to create sharable and interviewed confirmed that most SME
transparent information. leaders try to hide information about the
financial and organizational structure of
Moreover, According to the agency theory their business, which makes the task of the
by Jensen and Meckling (1976) and to 2
The projects which are risky.
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
5 Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice
__________________________________________________________________________
bank more difficult, since it cannot assess treatment process of SME funding
the quality of the company and its projects. applications.
Secondly, after establishing the contract, Furthermore, the literature has highlighted
the bank may have to face the phenomenon some instruments which allow the
of moral hazard, in other words, the hidden reduction of the informational asymmetry
behaviour. This involves a yield diversion risk characterizing the lenders –
by the SME leader. This asymmetry borrowers’ relations. Among the
situation creates an excessive cost of mechanisms implemented by Moroccan
controlling the activity of the company. It is banks to manage SME financing, the
the kind of monitoring that occurs when demand of high guarantees to incite the
the debt is not paid thoroughly (Yan, 1997). SME leader to launch safer projects in
In fact, the interest rate represents an order to preserve the guarantees made
inciting mechanism, that is to say, when the available to banks (Williamson, 1983) and
firm gets a loan at a high rate, it prefers to also to reduce the loss of funds granted to
invest in a more risky project and it companies.
changes its attitude into an opportunistic
behaviour (Williamson, 1986). But, Nevertheless, SMEs do not have solid
according to the outcomes of interviews guarantees and waive the credit contract
conducted, we have found that this even if the project proves to be safe, as
phenomenon is not present in the banking pointed by Stiglitz and Weiss (1981) who
practice, as the financing of the contract is show that the demand of higher guarantees
set up by a notary where the purpose and can incite the SME leader to undertake
details of the funded project are clearly riskier projects to compensate for the
identified. So, the purpose of the loan is opportunity cost of obtaining the
strongly controlled by the bank and the company‘s assets. According to the survey
project changes can be made only after the conducted, the nature of the guarantees
bank's agreement. requested by the bank generally depends
on the amount and the nature of the loan,
In Morocco, in 2015, more than 7.700 but also on the banking relationship, the
companies went bankrupt3. This number extent to which the bank holds private
keeps on increasing every year by 15%. information about its client -SME. However,
This is due not only to the chilliness of when the SME's project is deemed viable,
conventional banks to finance SMEs feasible and profitable but the company
because of information asymmetry, but doesn’t have the actual guarantees
also to fiscal reasons and the delays in sufficient to cover the amount of credit
payment deadlines opted for by the SMEs. requested, the bank recommends the
project to be guaranteed by the guarantee
In this respect, we can conclude that SMEs fund (between 50% and 80% of the credit
are the most exposed entrepreneurial amount).
structures to the credit rationing
phenomenon. In fact, many are the In addition, the funding of an SME by a
determinants of the decision to grant credit conventional bank for a long period allows
to SMEs, each bank has a specific the acquisition of an important
evaluation form that allows it to analyze informational capital which leads to cost
the quality of the project and the company. reduction of the monitoring of the activity
In accordance with the results of the study, linked to the requested credit. Customer
it turned out that the evaluation of financial relationship development ends up at
statements (Balance sheet ratios, internal gathering information about the history of
rate of return, turnover…) and the analysis refunds and improving the portfolio quality
of the company’s sector of activity remain of the SME by gradually eliminating risky
the major decisive elements in the businesses.
3
According to a study by the firm specializes In this sense, SMEs enjoy a reputation
in business information - INFORISK capital and master an ease of access to
______________
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice 6
__________________________________________________________________________
loans under the best conditions (Diamond, assisted by viable and feasible skills in
1989). accounting and finance which can analyze
different business summary financial
On the basis of interviews, the customer statements in order to make the adequate
relationship is one of the most important and appropriate information available to
determinants in the processing of loan conventional banks. Needless to mention
applications by SMEs. The strength of the that the profile of the SME’s manager-
relationship between the bank and the SME owner has a strong impact on access to
induces the generation of up-to-date bank financing (Cavalluzzo et al., 2005,
private information about the company, Han, 2008). This was confirmed by the
future projects and its environment. This results of the interviews, as the majority of
reduces the asymmetry of information and, the case managers interviewed expressed
consequently, increases the chance of the importance of analyzing the quality of
granting credit for SMEs. The customer the manager of the SME and its associates.
relationship also represents a reliable
signal of the borrower's creditworthiness In short, the bank is obliged to develop its
and the credibility of the summary specific expertise in the acquisition /
statements presented. production of information. However this
knowledge is not perfect when monitoring
According to the several empirical studies, costs are high or the establishment of
there is a negative link between the sophisticated evaluation procedures is
customer relationships and the credit cost4. ineffective.
In other words, customer relationship
incites banks to focus on the refinancing Participatory Banks: A Credible
conditions of SMEs, taking into account Alternative for SME Financing
their solvency and the reduction of the loan
cost. The presented solutions, however, do not
solve the problems of SME in the starting
In fact, in contracts of loan grant for SMEs, up or growing stage since they do not have
Moroccan banks demand strict clauses to an attractive debt history to conventional
minimize risks and opportunistic banks and represent a significant risk to
behaviours. These clauses may involve the financial institutions. Thus, the economic
level of indebtedness, the use of financing conditions and the obstacles facing SMEs
the issuance of periodic financial reports, when applying for funding to conventional
the payment of dividends, the increase of banks have pushed them to consider
executives’ salaries, etc. Indeed, the inciting another made of financing: participatory
effect of excessive clauses, on the one hand, banking.5
dissuades the leader of the SME to try
actions or strategies which are hostile to A participatory bank is defined as a
the bank interests, and on the other hand, financial intermediary essentially based on
commits the bank to monitor the borrower the principle of participation in losses and
and exploit the available information profits (PLS). For this reason it is called
effectively. “participatory” because investors entrust
their money to an entrepreneur, sharing
Otherwise, there are other variables which profits following a pre –determined
can alleviate the problem of SME financing, proportion, and assuming the losses
for instance, the training of the owner – together. It is a translation of the famous
manager to improve his capacity to rule “Al Ghonm Bel Ghorm”.
convince the financial institution to grant
him a loan. He can, alternatively, be Furthermore, the principles of Islamic
finance are encouraging these banks to
4
invest in projects of small-size businesses,
Petersen et Rajan (1994) et Berger et Udell
(1995), Leeth, Scott et Dunkelberg (1987)
5
Finaldi et Rossi (2001) Islamic banks
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
7 Journal of Innovation & Business Best Practice
__________________________________________________________________________
As a whole, the Moroccan SMEs generally 3. Bouët, A. and Gouaux, D., (1999), « La
have a structure which calls for a lot of politique commerciale et asymétrie
efforts in terms of managing and financing d'information: une explication alternative
the activity, and in this respect, the des restrictions », Revue Economique, 50
participatory financial institution targets (2) ,211-231
the financial and structural back-up in
favour of these companies. 4. Chatti, M. A., (2010), « Analyse
comparative entre la finance islamique et le
Conclusion capital-risque », Etudes en économie
islamique, 4 (1), 65-95
Having analysed the different theoretical
aspects dealing with SME financing by 5. Cherif, M., (1999), « Asymétrie
conventional banks, we deduce how d'information et financement des pme
information plays an important role in the innovantes par le capital-risque », Revue
relationship between the SME and the d'économie financière, (54), 163-178.
______________
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530
View publication stats
11. Iqbal, Z., and Mirakhor, A., (2013), 21. Torres, O., (1997), « Pour une approche
“Economic development and Islamic contingente de la spécificité de la PME »,
finance”, World Bank Publications, 348. Revue internationale P.M.E. : économie et
gestion de la PME, 10 (2), 9-43.
12. Joseph, F., & Sinkey, J. (1998).,
“Commercial Bank Financial Management 22. Trabelsi, A., (2006), « les déterminants
in the Financial-services Industry”, Business de la structure du capital et les
& Economics, Prentice Hall, p: 920. particularités du financement dans les PME
: Une étude sur données françaises »,
13. Jullien, H. and Paranque, B., (1995), Université Paris IX Dauphine Edogest,
« Financement des entreprises et évolution thesis, 332.
du système financier », Revue
internationale P.M.E. : économie et gestion 23. Williamson, S.D., (1986), « Costly
de la petite et moyenne entreprise, 8 (3-4), monitoring, financial intermediation and
43-66. equilibrium credit rationing », Journal of
Monetary Economics, 18(4), 158-179.
14. Mourji. F., (2001), « Evaluation du
secteur des petites et moyennes
entreprises au Maroc dans le cadre du
programme empretec Maroc», Research
conducted for the UNCTAD secretariat
Amina Hachimi, Abdelouhab Salahddine And Hamid Housni (2017), Journal of Innovation & Business Best
Practice, DOI: 10.5171/2017.420530