Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I’ve Learned
From the
Pandemic Year
REVIEW
* * * * * * * *
WSJ
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL WEEKEND
SATURDAY/SUNDAY, MARCH 20 - 21, 2021 ~ VOL. CCLXXVII NO. 65
WSJ.com
Divisive
HHHH $5.00
What’s
News Meetings
World-Wide Test U.S.
H igh-level talks be-
tween the Biden ad-
Ties to
Beijing
ministration and Beijing
that veered into acrimony
put the U.S.-China rivalry
in sharp relief, complicat-
ing efforts by the two Deepening distrust on
powers to erect guardrails
and keep tensions from several issues signals a
spiraling further. A1 tough task for powers
LUDOVIC MARIN/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
U.S. NEWS
THE NUMBERS | By Jo Craven McGinty
T
approaches to Covid-19 on
and Missis- league Austan Goolsbee used image of the decline attri- either side of the border. Chicago Fed study. “We find hat result might seem
sippi were among the first cellphone data to track cus- buted to the closures. similar results to what they surprising, but accord-
states to fully reopen busi- tomer visits to 2.25 million “We repeated that kind of Visits to stores in Quad Cities find when we look at a dif- ing to an election
nesses this year, ending businesses in commuter analysis thousands of times Iowa (no shutdown policy) ferent, but related, data set postmortem prepared by the
shutdown orders intended to zones across the U.S. last year across all sorts of counties, Illinois (shutdown policy) of cellphone activity.” Republican strategist An-
curb the spread of Covid-19. from January through May. businesses and metro areas,” Beauty Electronics They also found mobility thony Fabrizio, a majority of
But research suggests the Examining commuter Dr. Syverson said. “What all 0% measures didn’t fully capture voters in 10 battleground
dormant economies won’t zones allowed researchers to these results have shown is the drop in spending caused states in 2020 “prioritized
–20
immediately blossom—unless compare consumer behavior the primary driver of busi- by lockdown restrictions. stopping the spread of coro-
consumers also lose their in neighboring jurisdictions ness activity is how comfort- –40 Shutdowns were responsi- navirus over reopening the
fear of the coronavirus. with the same exposure to able or uncomfortable people ble for 16% of the drop in economy.”
About 42 million Ameri- Covid-19, but different shel- feel going out to businesses –60 visits to nonessential busi- The analysis—which was
cans, or 12% of the popula- ter-in-place policies. If shut- given what’s going on with nesses, the study found, but obtained by Politico—found
tion, have been fully vacci- downs were responsible for the pandemic.” –80 24% of the drop in restau- that 57% of voters in five
nated against Covid-19, last year’s economic col- The findings were pub- rant revenue and 45% of the states Mr. Trump won in
Note: Change from March 1 to May 16, 2020
according to the Centers for lapse, jurisdictions that re- lished in the peer-reviewed Source: National Bureau of Economic Research,
drop in nonrestaurant small- 2016 and 2020 and 60% of
Disease Control and Preven- mained open should have Journal of Public Economics University of Chicago business revenue. voters in five states that
tion. fared better than neighbor- in January. When the re- The researchers also supported him only in 2016
“The state of the pan- ing areas that shut down. searchers followed up later, but spent twice as much. tested whether responses to favored limiting Covid-19
demic, not any orders the using 2020 data from May 18 However, a separate study by stay-at-home orders varied over reopening the economy.
I
government imposes about nstead, researchers through Aug. 16 and from economists at the Federal by political affiliation and Still, researchers at the
the pandemic, is what drives found a 60% decrease in Oct. 5 through Jan. 3, the re- Reserve Bank of Chicago ex- found that the effect was Chicago Fed and the Univer-
people,” said Chad Syverson, consumer traffic, on av- sults were nearly identical. plicitly tracked revenue and nearly identical across dif- sity of Chicago didn’t dis-
an economist at the Univer- erage, with only 10% attrib- It’s important to note the spending as well as mobility ferent kinds of counties. count the value of stay-at-
sity of Chicago who has utable to shelter-in-place or- researchers assumed the and found something similar. “An early narrative was home orders as a public-
studied the phenomenon. “If ders—meaning all businesses number of consumer visits That study linked county- that stay-at-home orders health response. Lifting
the pandemic improves, peo- within the same commuting corresponded to the amount level stay-at-home orders to would be ineffective in areas them prematurely might in-
ple will go out at a higher zone lost traffic, but the de- of economic activity, which cellphone records and con- that supported former Presi- crease transmissions of the
rate. The orders themselves cline was 10% greater in ar- wouldn’t detect whether sumer spending from dent Trump,” Dr. Alexander virus without causing the
are icing on cake.” eas that locked down. people shopped half as often March 1 to April 17, 2020. said. “However, we find very economy to spring to life.
U.S. WATCH
Dining, Hotels, Gyms Gain Steam NEW YORK IDAHO
BY SARAH CHANEY CAMBON Spending Thaw Rep. Reed Accused Covid Outbreak
AND GWYNN GUILFORD Of Misconduct Closes Legislature
Americans are booking travel, eating out and spending more on personal services
Restaurant and hotel book- as the U.S. economic recovery from the pandemic picks up. A former lobbyist said that The Idaho Legislature voted
ings are up. Airplane tickets Rep. Tom Reed (R., N.Y.) made Friday to shut down for several
are selling fast. Consumers Credit- and debit-card spending, change vs. average for January and February, 2020 unwanted sexual advances to weeks because of an outbreak of
spent more on gyms, salons Airbnb, her in 2017, according to pub- Covid-19.
and spas in recent weeks than 50% 50% lished comments, an account Lawmakers in the House and
Vrbo*
they have since the coronavi- that the congressman denied. Senate made the move to recess
rus pandemic began. 25 25 Nicolette Davis, a second lieu- until April 6 with significant unfin-
The U.S. economic recovery Online tenant in the U.S. Army who at ished business, including setting
is picking up steam as Ameri- 0 travel 0 the time worked as an insurance budgets and pushing through a
cans increase their spending, platforms Salons and spas lobbyist, said Mr. Reed put his huge income tax cut.
particularly on in-person ser- –25 –25 hand on her back, unhooked her At least six of the 70 House
vices that were battered by Lodging, bra and touched her leg during a members tested positive for the
the coronavirus pandemic. accommo- fundraising trip, according to an illness in the past week, and
–50 –50
dation†
The rising number of account she gave to the Wash- there are fears a highly conta-
Covid-19 vaccinations, falling –75 Air travel –75 ington Post. gious variant of Covid-19 is in
business restrictions, ample Gyms‡ Lt. Davis didn’t respond to a the Statehouse in Boise.
household savings and injec- –100 –100
request for comment. —Associated Press
tions of federal stimulus funds Mr. Reed said that “this ac-
into the economy are fueling March Jan March Jan count of my actions is not accu- NASA
2020 ’21 2020 ’21
the surge, economists say. rate.”
“I’d rather travel than do Mr. Reed has said he is seri- Ex-Senator Is Picked
almost anything,” said Betsy Seated diners from online, phone and walk-in reservations on OpenTable,
change vs. same day in 2019, seven-day average
ously considering running for To Lead Agency
Cole, 81 years old, who booked governor in 2022.
a flight to Boston to see family Miami Las Vegas Dallas Pittsburgh Washington, A former mayor of Corning, President Biden announced he
and friends in late spring and D.C. N.Y., Mr. Reed has represented would nominate Bill Nelson, a for-
hopes to visit the British Vir- 0% western New York in Congress mer U.S. senator from Florida who
gin Islands for a sailing trip for more than a decade since flew on the space shuttle right be-
CURRENT
later this year. She also –25 U.S. AVG. being elected in 2010. He is a fore the Challenger accident, to
booked two international trips member of the powerful Ways lead the National Aeronautics and
for next year. She looks for- and Means Committee. Space Administration.
ward to camping in the Sahara –50 He is co-chairman of the If confirmed by the Senate, Mr.
and riding a camel in Morocco, Problem Solvers Caucus, a bipar- Nelson would become NASA’s 14th
as well as enjoying time on the tisan group of 56 House mem- administrator, succeeding another
water in the Greek Isles. –75 bers who work to come up with former member of Congress, Jim
Ms. Cole, of Naples, Fla., compromise solutions for major Bridenstine, a Republican from
said she is finally comfortable –100
policy debates. Oklahoma.
with the prospect of traveling —Kristina Peterson —Associated Press
again after avoiding crowds, March ’21 March ’21 March ’21 March ’21 March ’21
2020 2020 2020 2020 2020
CORRECTIONS AMPLIFICATIONS
restaurants and trips through-
out the pandemic. She said *Airbnb/Vrbo line includes HomeAway, which Expedia Group rolled into Vrbo in June 2020. †Excluding Airbnb/Vrbo.
she is more at ease now that ‡Gym data reflect the two-week moving average, due to biweekly payment plans.
she is fully vaccinated and Sources: Earnest Research (credit- and debit-card spending); OpenTable (reservations)
many others are as well. “I Shares of Mitsubishi Mo- and they were labeled prop-
want to get going,” she said. activity has put restaurant at- More than 13% of the over- while shelling out money on tors Corp. rose around 45% erly in all editions.
Economists surveyed by tendance 8% above where it all population has been fully goods. The splurge on goods year-to-date through Thurs-
The Wall Street Journal this was in 2019. vaccinated, including almost continues, with U.S. ports now day. A Page One article about As of Jan. 21, 438 of AMC
month raised their average Spending on gyms, salons 40% of Americans age 65 and suffering backlogs of ships auto makers incorrectly said Entertainment Holdings Inc.’s
forecast for 2021 economic and spas recently climbed to above, according to the U.S. carrying tens of thousands of the estimate was for Mitsubi- U.S. theaters and 86 of its in-
growth to 5.95%, measured the highest levels since the Centers for Disease Control containers and long delays un- shi Corp., and a graphic didn’t ternational theaters were
from the fourth quarter of last pandemic first hit the U.S., and Prevention. Airfare spend- loading freight. make clear that a reference to open. A Business & Finance ar-
year to the same period this forcing many to shut down ing among consumers over the Stronger spending on ser- Mitsubishi was actually Mit- ticle on Jan. 26 about the
year, from a 4.87% projection and scaring away clients fear- age of 75—who are more likely vices is already helping spur subishi Motors. company incorrectly said that
in February’s survey. The ful of infection, according to to be vaccinated—is up signifi- the labor-market recovery. many of AMC’s theaters were
higher figure would mark the data from Earnest Research, cantly from June, according to Hiring accelerated in February, In a U.S. News graphic on closed.
fastest such pace in nearly which tracks trends in credit- BofA Global Research analysis with most of the gains in lei- Friday, one of the charts con-
four decades. and debit-card purchases. of Bank of America card data. sure and hospitality busi- tained data by calendar year
“You’re looking at the big- Travel-related businesses Household savings totaled nesses, and economists project for migrants detained at the Notice to readers
gest surge in economic growth are among the big beneficia- $3.9 trillion in January, up the U.S. economy will regain Mexican border, categorized Wall Street Journal staff
that most people who are ries. Spending on vacation from $1.4 trillion in February millions of jobs this year. by individuals, families and members are working re-
working today have ever expe- rental sites Airbnb and Vrbo 2020, before the pandemic hit The recovery will take time unaccompanied children. In motely during the pandemic.
rienced in their working lives,” surged in the week ended the U.S. economy. though. There were 9.5 million some editions, that chart was For the foreseeable future,
said Tim Quinlan, senior econ- March 3, and is well above fewer jobs last month than in labeled incorrectly as fiscal please send reader comments
omist at Wells Fargo Securi- pre-pandemic levels, according February 2020, the month be- years. The data for the other only by email or phone, using
ties. He expects consumer de- to Earnest Research. The num- fore the pandemic hit, and em- charts contained within the the contacts below, not via
mand and trillions of dollars ber of transactions for air
Service businesses ployment is still down 6% graphic are for fiscal years, U.S. Mail.
in built-up savings to propel travel, lodging and on online reliant on downtown compared with pre-pandemic
economic growth “in a manner travel platforms has climbed levels, according to the Labor
that’s going to take people’s sharply in recent weeks, and is
office workers still Department.
Readers can alert The Wall Street Journal to any errors in news articles by
emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling 888-410-2667.
breaths away.” now at the highest level since face challenges. Service businesses reliant
The pickup is arriving the pandemic began, the firm’s on downtown office workers
sooner than many economists data show. still face challenges as people THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
had expected at the start of the Some of this spending continue to work remotely. (USPS 664-880) (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
(Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935) (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
year, before Congress and the might be for future travel, but The $1.9 trillion federal At Compass Coffee, a Wash-
Editorial and publication headquarters: 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036
White House approved a $1.9 much is happening already. stimulus legislative package ap- ington, D.C., coffee roaster
Published daily except Sundays and general legal holidays.
trillion stimulus package. In U.S. hotel occupancy hit a 20- proved this month is expected with bricks-and-mortar coffee Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
the Journal’s March survey, re- week high of 49% in the week to further drive up savings. shops, employment is a frac- Postmaster: Send address changes to The Wall Street Journal,
spondents upped their average ended March 6, led by small Higher-income Americans, tion of where it was before the 200 Burnett Rd., Chicopee, MA 01020.
forecasts of economic growth and medium-size hotels, ac- who have amassed the bulk of pandemic struck. All Advertising published in The Wall Street Journal is subject to the applicable rate card, copies of
in the first quarter to an annu- cording to STR, a research the savings during the pan- “We really depended on lots which are available from the Advertising Services Department, Dow Jones & Co. Inc., 1211 Avenue
of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036. The Journal reserves the right not to accept an advertiser’s
alized rate of 4.9%, from 2.8% firm specializing in the hospi- demic, often splurge more on of people coming off the order. Only publication of an advertisement shall constitute final acceptance of the advertiser’s
in February’s survey. tality sector. Occupancy is still services. They weren’t willing Metro every day to grab a cup order.
Much of the jump in spend- down nearly 30% from 2019. or able to do much over the of coffee,” said Michael Haft, Letters to the Editor: Fax: 212-416-2891; email: wsj.ltrs@wsj.com
ing is for services that involve Randy Vasquez, director of past year, a BofA Global Re- co-founder of Compass. “With- Need assistance with your subscription?
By web: customercenter.wsj.com; By email: wsjsupport@wsj.com
proximity to other people. The guest services at the Inn of search analysis notes, suggest- out people returning to of- By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625)
weekly average of the number the Five Graces in Santa Fe, ing there is a lot of pent-up fices, it’s just very hard.” Reprints & licensing:
of seated diners tracked on N.M., said bookings started to demand among wealthier The outlook is brightening By email: customreprints@dowjones.com; By phone: 1-800-843-0008
restaurant reservation plat- suddenly pick up in March af- households. though. Compass rebooted WSJ back issues and framed pages: wsjshop.com
form OpenTable is up mark- ter a slow winter. “I don’t The incipient boom in service at two downtown cof- Our newspapers are 100% sourced from sustainably certified mills.
edly from mid-December, but know what happened, in all travel-and-leisure spending fee shops earlier this month
still down 33% from 2019. In honesty. I think it’s the vacci- comes after a year in which and plans to reopen the re- GOT A TIP FOR US? SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
Miami, the recent upsurge in nation,” he said. consumers shunned services maining locations by summer.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | A3
U.S. NEWS
Biden Decries
Atlanta Attack
During Visit
BY CATHERINE LUCEY Hyun Jung Grant, 51; Suncha
AND CAMERON MCWHIRTER Kim, 69; and Yong Ae Yue, 63,
died in the attacks, according
ATLANTA—President Biden to the Fulton County Medical
mourned the victims of the At- Examiner’s Office.
lanta spa shootings on a trip Atlanta police said earlier
to the city, declaring “hate can this week that several of the
have no safe harbor in Amer- victims at the Atlanta shoot-
ica” and pointing out that ings were Korean nationals,
BITA HONARVAR/REUTERS
most of those killed were and it took time to make ap-
women of Asian descent amid propriate next-of-kin notifica-
a rise in crimes against Asian- tions before releasing the
Americans. names. The Korean consulate in
Mr. Biden and Vice Presi- Atlanta said Friday afternoon
dent Kamala Harris gave som- that three of the victims were
ber remarks during a visit that U.S. citizens and one was a Ko- A friend of one of the murder victims prepares to place flowers at the site of Tuesday’s mass shooting in Acworth, Ga.
was initially intended to cele- rean citizen with a green card.
brate the $1.9 trillion Covid-19 Robert Aaron Long, 21, ing in Acworth have been The president noted that compulsion to visit spas for experiencing as a result of
relief package, which passed from suburban Atlanta, faces identified by the Cherokee the investigation into the kill- sexual activity. Atlanta police Aaron’s inexcusable actions.”
two months after a pair of vic- multiple charges including County Sheriff’s Office as De- ings is still under way. “What- have said that they are also in- On Friday, Mr. Biden said
tories in Georgia runoffs gave eight counts of murder in the laina Ashley Yaun, 33; Paul An- ever the motivation, we know vestigating whether his ac- Congress should move quickly
Democrats control of the Sen- killings of those four, as well dre Michels, 54; Xiaojie Tan, this: Too many Asian-Ameri- tions constituted hate crimes. to pass Covid-19-related hate-
ate. The trip was planned be- as with the shooting of four 49; and Daoyou Feng, 44. cans have been walking up and Mr. Long had been an active crime legislation, which would
fore a gunman killed eight other people at a spa in Ac- On Friday, Mr. Biden and Ms. down the streets and worry- member of Crabapple First speed governmental response
people at three area spas ear- worth, Ga., which occurred Harris met with Asian-Ameri- ing,” he said. “They’ve been Baptist Church in suburban to the rise of hate crimes ex-
lier this week. shortly before the shootings in can leaders in a state that has attacked, blamed, scapegoated Atlanta. The church released a acerbated during the pan-
Atlanta officials on Friday Atlanta. Mr. Long was cap- become a focal point in a na- and harassed.” statement saying Mr. Long’s demic, following the viral out-
released the names of four tured by police several hours tional conversation about vio- Law-enforcement officials actions were antithetical to break in China.
women killed in shootings at later as he was driving south lence against Asian-Americans, have said that Mr. Long told Christian belief and church —Tarini Parti and
two of the spas on Tuesday: of Atlanta toward Florida. as well as a partisan battle- them he shot the victims leaders “deeply regret the fear Valerie Bauerlein
Soon Chung Park, 74 years old; The four killed at the shoot- ground over voter access. based on what he called his and pain Asian-Americans are contributed to this article.
U.S. NEWS
JUSTIN LANE/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
eral Letitia James, investigators Mr. Cuomo has said he tially complained about Mr.
have recently interviewed at never touched anyone inap- Cuomo to his chief of staff, Jill
least three former aides to the propriately. He has said Ms. DesRosiers, on June 10. Later
governor, Charlotte Bennett, Boylan’s claims are untrue. He that month, she discussed the
Lindsey Boylan and Ana Liss. has apologized if his work- harassment accusations with Ju-
The women have accused Mr. place behavior made anyone dith Mogul, the governor’s spe-
Cuomo of either sexual harass- uncomfortable. cial counsel. The conduct de-
ment or inappropriate behavior The governor said in a press scribed to both Ms. Mogul and
while they worked for the state. call Wednesday that he New York state Attorney General Letitia James is overseeing the Cuomo investigation. Ms. DesRosiers “obviously falls
They and their representa- wouldn’t talk about the allega- within the definition of sexual
tives said that in the inter- tions while Ms. James’s inquiry harassment in the employee
views investigators asked and an impeachment investiga- Governor Faces McGrath, is the fifth current or McGrath referred questions to handbook,” said Ms. Westerman.
about Mr. Cuomo’s behavior, tion being undertaken by the former aide to the governor to Ms. Wang. According to Ms. Wester-
how complaints were handled state Assembly are pending. New Accusations accuse him of sexual harass- Rich Azzopardi, a senior ad- man, Ms. Bennett told investi-
and about subsequent actions Rich Azzopardi, the gover- ment or inappropriate behavior viser to the governor, referred gators that she had been trans-
by senior aides in the gover- nor’s senior adviser, referred to in the workplace. In an inter- questions to Rita Glavin, an at- ferred to a new role after
nor’s administration which Mr. Cuomo’s statement Wednes- A female employee who view with the New York Times torney for Mr. Cuomo. Ms. speaking to Ms. DesRosiers and
some of the women say they day and declined further com- works in New York Gov. Andrew published Friday, Ms. McGrath Glavin didn’t immediately re- when she voiced fears about re-
saw as retaliation. ment. The Governor’s Office of Cuomo’s Executive Chamber said the governor’s behavior spond to requests for comment. taliation, Ms. Mogul said the of-
“We have been assured the Employee Relations didn’t re- said he kissed her on the fore- amounted to sexual harass- Mr. Cuomo has previously fice didn’t need to investigate
investigation is going to look spond to a request to comment. head, called her beautiful in Ital- ment. apologized for workplace behav- her complaint because the gov-
at all of the issues,” said Debra Ms. Boylan discussed the ian and looked down her shirt Ms. McGrath’s lawyer, Mari- ior that made anyone uncom- ernor was just mentoring her.
Katz, Ms. Bennett’s attorney. release of her personnel re- as she sat across from him in ann Wang, confirmed to The fortable but has said he never Ms. Bennett left the Cuomo
Ms. Bennett’s legal team cords during an interview with his office in separate instances Wall Street Journal that Ms. touched anyone inappropriately. administration in November.
said officials in the governor’s Ms. James’s investigators last over the past three years. McGrath had made the allega- —Khadeeja Safdar Ms. Westerman said Ms. Ben-
Executive Chamber didn’t fol- Saturday, Ms. Boylan’s attor- The woman, Alyssa tions against Mr. Cuomo. Ms. and Deanna Paul nett told investigators that be-
low procedures set up under ney, Jill Basinger, said in an fore she resigned, Ms. Mogul
New York state law after Ms. email. Several media outlets asked if there was any other
Bennett complained to Mr. referenced Ms. Boylan’s per- the attorney general and I was reported by the New York ing,” Ms. Basinger said. position she wanted.
Cuomo’s chief of staff that the sonnel records in their report- want them to do their review.” Times, wasn’t released publicly Ms. Liss said investigators Ms. Mogul in a statement
governor had asked questions ing after she said on Twitter In December, a circle of Mr. after several former officials re- in the attorney general probe Friday said, “This characteriza-
about her sex life during a in December that Mr. Cuomo Cuomo’s close advisers drafted fused to sign it, the people said. asked about a phone call she tion of our conversations is not
June 5 meeting in his office. sexually harassed her. She left a letter containing references Ms. Basinger didn’t answer received in December from Mr. true. As I have previously stated
A New York law, signed by the administration in 2018. to the personnel records and when asked if investigators Azzopardi after Ms. Boylan’s the documents will reflect that
Mr. Cuomo in 2018, as well as Wednesday, Mr. Cuomo said circulated it to former officials brought up the letter in their Twitter posts. I acted consistently with the in-
the handbook for employees of during the press call that the for signatures, according to interview with Ms. Boylan. Ms. Liss, who hadn’t worked formation provided at the time,
state agencies mandate any release of Ms. Boylan’s person- people familiar with the mat- “We are pleased with the for the administration since the requirements of the law,
sexual-harassment complaint nel records was “one of the is- ter and a draft reviewed by scope of the investigation and 2015, has said she viewed the and Charlotte’s wishes.”
be investigated by the Gover- sues that is going to be re- The Wall Street Journal. the thoughtfulness and thor- call as intimidation. Mr. Azzop- Ms. DesRosiers wasn’t
nor’s Office for Employee Rela- viewed by the Assembly and The letter, whose existence oughness of their question- ardi has said calls by the gover- available to comment.
cluded in a partisan stew. directed at her Democratic coun- fenses. In a Supreme Court case the First Step Act, which was ocrats cannot count on national
Rural broadband, a top-line terpart, Chairman Tom Carper of dealing with crack cocaine pos- championed by Trump as a way momentum to have a decisive
item that typically draws signifi- Delaware, who has already met session, Biden’s solicitor general to curb mass incarceration. impact on state legislative elec-
cant Republican backing, is ex- with Biden at the White House to this week notified the court that tions,” wrote Democratic Legisla-
pected to be part of any infra- discuss infrastructure. it would no longer try to block a DEMOCRATS TRY TO RESET in tive Campaign Committee Presi-
structure package. Bipartisan Other areas ripe for coopera- reduced sentence for the defen- the states, where their ambitious dent Jessica Post in a strategy
coronavirus aid packages have in- tion on their own include re- dant, as the Trump administra- plan to “flip everything” in state memo where she criticized Dem-
cluded funds for it, as did the search and development credits tion was trying to do. legislature races ended in disas- ocratic donors for their lack of
American Rescue Plan that for small businesses, carbon-cap- Ironically, the Biden adminis- ter in November, as they failed to focus on downballot races.
passed with only Democratic ture technology, along with nuts- tration’s stance is a broader in- flip a single state legislative body While the redistricting process
Capito, the top Republican on reconciliation process to preclude 2022 cycle under redrawn maps.
BIPARTISAN PARTS, partisan the Senate Environment and Pub- the need for Republican support.
whole? Bipartisan groups in Con- lic Works Committee, is also ea- MINOR MEMOS: Rep. Adam
gress are pushing a flurry of big- ger to include funding for an over- THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT is Schiff fundraises off Republicans
ticket infrastructure plans ready haul of the nation’s aging drinking shifting back to Obama-era pros- fundraising off the Dr. Seuss pub-
for inclusion in President Biden’s water and wastewater infrastruc- ecution strategies on drug crimes lishing controversy…“Green” jokes
second major legislative effort. But ture in a larger package. “These after Trump Attorneys General abound as St. Patrick’s Day, the
like with the Covid-19 aid law carefully negotiated, bipartisan Jeff Sessions and Bill Barr in- Environmental Protection Agency
signed by Biden last week that provisions are the perfect jump- structed prosecutors to pursue administrator’s swearing-in and
garnered no GOP votes, some bi- ing-off point to address these the harshest possible sentences Surface-transportation improvements and highway funds are the start of stimulus check de-
partisan ingredients may be in- challenges,” she said in remarks for crimes, including drug of- among the infrastructure ideas ripe for bipartisan cooperation. posits coincided on Wednesday.
make a similar change in mid- schools indicated that reducing us in our overall reopening
CDC Shifts dle and high schools.
“This obviously opens up a
the distancing requirements to
3 feet likely wouldn’t negatively
plans,” Michael Casserly, execu-
tive director of the Council of
Massachusetts Mutual world of possibilities for bring- affect student or staff safety in the Great City Schools, said in
U.S. NEWS
Visa confirmed the probe in a regulatory filing. The company’s share price fell more than 6% Friday.
A6 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * ****** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
France Faces Third Pandemic Lockdown
President Macron’s cron’s approach to the latest
lockdown. He rejected calls
handling of the Covid from city officials to shutter
crisis is frustrating Paris in the depths of winter
when the weather was frigid
many residents and virus variants were start-
ing to spread countrywide.
BY STACY MEICHTRY Now, Paris’s hospital system
AND MATTHEW DALTON is on the brink, forcing author-
ities to transfer patients to ar-
PARIS—Spring was once a eas with fewer cases. Nation-
time for strolls along the River wide, intensive-care units are
Seine and people-watching 83% full.
from sun-dappled terraces. In waiting until spring to
On Friday, however, Paris impose a lockdown, Mr. Ma-
awoke to what has now be- cron has also delayed the pos-
come an entirely different rite sibility of reopening France’s
of spring: a pandemic-induced economy. Officials said they
lockdown. expected the lockdown to
This four-week closure is less shave 0.2% off France’s gross
severe than the original one domestic product this year.
that paralyzed France a year That is a bitter pill for busi-
ago. It is limited to Paris and 15 nesses that have been closed
IAN LANGSDON/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
other areas that have been hit since November. When France
hard by the spread of Covid-19 came out of its second lock-
variants. Parisians are allowed down in mid-December, Mr.
to venture 10 kilometers from Macron stipulated that restau-
their homes with a permission rants and bars were to remain
slip, as opposed to last year closed to reduce social contact.
when the limit was 1 kilometer. The same rule applied to muse-
But France’s third lockdown ums, concert halls and other
is perhaps its most demoraliz- venues where people gather.
ing. The country has looked The restrictions are limited to Paris and 15 other areas of France that have been hit hard by the spread of the coronavirus variants. “What matters most for the
abroad with envy as vaccines economy is the lack of prog-
were developed in record time Cyril Dunn, a 54-year-old falls throughout France and told a group of reporters the ter Jean Castex said France ress toward lifting restric-
and deployed with such speed leather-goods artisan. “There the rest of the Continent. As vaccine was quasi-ineffective would resume use of Astra- tions,” said Andrew Kenning-
across the U.S. and the U.K. are still vulnerable people who of Friday, only 8% of France’s for people older than 65, with- Zeneca’s vaccine after the EU’s ham, chief Europe economist
that France began to wonder if haven’t been vaccinated.” population had received a sin- out providing evidence to back health agency said it was safe at Capital Economics, who had
it too was on the cusp of eco- President Emmanuel Ma- gle dose of a vaccine, and only up his claim. His government and effective. expected a large increase in
nomic renewal. cron’s management of the cri- 3% had been fully vaccinated. then reversed course in early The zigzagging has deepened France’s economic output in
Instead Paris cafes and bis- sis has been particularly vex- Mr. Macron has also fueled March—clearing it for use in confusion in a country that has the second quarter. “We had
tros are indefinitely closed. ing to many. The former skepticism of a vaccine devel- older people—only to suspend a history of vaccine hesitancy. anticipated that by now gov-
The Louvre is sealed off. The investment banker has been oped by Oxford University and the vaccine’s use this week fol- “I don’t understand why they ernments would be preparing
Eiffel Tower is deserted. And steadfast in sticking with the AstraZeneca PLC that many lowing reports that people who stopped,” said Eric Vigor, a 52- to ease restrictions, or would
vaccines lines are very long. European Union’s decision to European health authorities had received it in other parts year-old banker. “If I could get even be doing so.”
“My sister lives in New collectively procure vaccine deem crucial for turning the of Europe developed rare blood vaccinated, I would.” For now, Parisians are
York—she was vaccinated and supplies—an approach that tide of the pandemic. clots, and some had died. Frustrations are running learning to curb their spring-
she’s younger than me,” said has led to inoculation short- In late January, Mr. Macron On Thursday, Prime Minis- particularly high over Mr. Ma- time enthusiasm.
North Korean
Let’s walk Extradited
together. To U.S. From
It makes things better. Malaysia
BY ANDREW JEONG
AND CHESTER TAY
WORLD NEWS
POOL/REUTERS
918,000 barrels a day from Iran officials said recently. and tested its strategy to com-
in March, which would be the Combined with rising oil partmentalize the countries’ re-
highest volume since a full U.S. prices, the developments have lationship into what Mr.
oil embargo was imposed diminished pressure for Tehran Blinken said are competitive,
against Tehran two years ago, and Caracas to negotiate with collaborative and adversarial Secretary of State Antony Blinken, left, and national security adviser Jake Sullivan Friday in Alaska.
says commodities-data company Washington, these people said. components.
Kpler. That trend is confirmed A State Department spokes- To that end, in the week be- said Allison Sherlock, a China of miscalculation and conflicts that sentiment in responding to
by other shipping trackers, woman dismissed the idea fore the talks, the Biden admin- analyst at the consultancy Eur- over hot spots like control of Mr. Blinken on Thursday. “The
some of which see those sales at that the Biden administration istration rallied support among asia Group. critical technologies and United States does not have the
one million barrels a day. would ease sanctions without allies in Asia and imposed sanc- Friday in their last meeting, China’s claims against Taiwan qualification to say that it
“If it sells one million bar- action by Tehran to comply tions on senior Chinese legisla- Messrs. Blinken and Sullivan and Japan and in the South wants to speak to China from a
rels a day at current prices, with the nuclear deal, known tors—moves that contributed and Mr. Yang and Chinese For- China Sea. position of strength,” Mr. Yang
Iran has no incentive to nego- as the Joint Comprehensive to Beijing’s anger as the talks eign Minister Wang Yi gathered A new target is electric-vehi- said. He accused the U.S. of be-
tiate,” said Sara Vakhshouri, Plan of Action, or JCPOA. opened. In his opening re- with a smaller group of aides to cle maker Tesla Inc. China’s ing condescending and waved
president of Washington- “Our current Iran-related marks, Mr. Blinken launched try to set up a way to manage government is restricting use his finger at Mr. Blinken and
based SVB Energy Interna- sanctions remain in effect un- into China’s cyberattacks, its difficulties ahead, officials said. of Tesla vehicles by members of Mr. Sullivan.
tional and an expert on Iran’s less and until they are lifted as threats against Taiwan and oth- An early test comes next the Chinese military and em- Mr. Yang’s remarks drew
oil industry. part of a diplomatic process, ers, and its clampdowns in Xin- week at a virtual conference on ployees in sensitive posts in plaudits in China, where they
President Biden’s adminis- and we will of course address jiang and Hong Kong as government and business, cit- were circulated on social and
tration has sought to engage any effort at sanctions eva- “threatening the rules-based ing national-security concerns mainstream media.
with Iran to return to a 2015
nuclear deal that was exited
sion,” she said.
Since November, Iranian oil
order that maintains global sta-
bility.”
Both governments over data collected by the cars,
according to people familiar
U.S. officials accused Mr.
Yang of grandstanding for a do-
by former President Donald traders say they have been ap- Mr. Yang in turn criticized have a reason to with the effort. mestic audience and said
Trump. Tehran has rebuffed
overtures so far.
proached for new sales by
Asian buyers seeking to take
the U.S. for undermining global
stability by using force around
limit costly Both governments face
pressing domestic issues, giv-
Messrs. Blinken and Sullivan
continued to engage their Chi-
China’s oil purchases from advantage of discounted prices the world, and he said the U.S. confrontation. ing them reason to try to limit nese interlocutors on sub-
Venezuela, where the U.S. has because purchasers feel sanc- doesn’t serve as a model to costly confrontation. President stance.
been trying to use sanctions to tions pressure will ease under others. He listed the U.S.’s Biden has placed priority on “We will still have business
pressure the Maduro regime the Biden administration. problems with racism and de- reining in the pandemic and to conduct,” Karine Jean-Pierre,
into holding credible demo- Iranian officials and traders clining domestic confidence in climate change that U.S. cli- shoring up the recovery. Chi- the White House’s principal
cratic elections, also are grow- have become increasingly ad- U.S. democracy. mate envoy John Kerry and his nese President Xi Jinping is ex- deputy press secretary, told re-
ing, according to London fi- ept at evading sanctions, car- Although U.S. officials Chinese counterpart, Xie Zhen- pected to seek a third term as porters. “America’s approach
nancial data provider Refinitiv. rying out covert transfers in played down the public spar- hua, are due to attend. Climate Communist Party leader next will be undergirded by confi-
Roughly 85% of about 17 the Persian Gulf and in South ring in front of reporters, it ex- change is an issue the Biden year and can ill-afford a full- dence in our dealing with Bei-
million barrels of crude oil ex- Asia to conceal the origin of posed a deepening distrust be- administration has identified blown crisis with the U.S. jing.”
ports so far scheduled out of their cargo and finding new tween the two governments for potential cooperation with Still, he and other Chinese A key part of the Biden
Venezuela for March are des- ways to get paid by using non- that is likely to make coopera- Beijing, as are the pandemic officials have in recent months strategy to compete with Bei-
tined for Chinese ports, ac- banking platforms such as tion more difficult. and the global economy. played up perceptions that “the jing—working with U.S. allies—
cording to Infodio, an investi- cryptocurrencies. “Anyone who was hoping Beyond that, foreign-policy East is rising and the West is also angers Beijing, which sees
gative journalism group On Monday, Iranian First there would be a significant de- specialists said, the acrimony declining,” citing the Commu- the alliances as central to U.S.’s
specializing in monitoring cor- Vice President Eshaq Jahangiri escalation—largely people in shows shifting perceptions that nist Party’s perceived superior- effort to constrain China’s as-
ruption in Venezuela. said Iran’s oil exports increased the business community—can each has about the balance of ity in governance. cent and limit its influence.
Rising oil shipments to in recent months, though he see that’s not going to be possi- power between the two na- Mr. Yang, a member of the —Liyan Qi and Alex Leary
China, said Iranian and Venezu- didn’t provide details. ble, at least in the near term,” tions, increasing the likelihood party’s ruling body, channeled contributed to this article.
ADVERTISEMENT
STRATEGY
Taught by Michael A. Roberto, Bryant University
1 Strategy Is Making Choices 7 Anticipating Your Rival’s Response
TIME O 2 How Apple Raises 8 Why Did Disney Buy Pixar?
ED F Competitive Barriers 9 The Diversification Discount
IT 3 The Danger of Straddling 10 Forward and Backward Integration
FE
LIM
70%
4 What Trader Joe’s Doesn’t Do 11 Mergers and Acquisitions—
R
R
O
DE
RI
L
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR
Taught by Clinton O. Longenecker, The University of Toledo
37 Achieving Results in 42 Winning with Teamwork
Your Organization 43 Coaching—From Gridiron
38 The Value of Great Leadership to Boardroom
39 Emotional Intelligence 44 Understanding Power Relationships
in the Workplace 45 Handling Workplace Conflict
40 The Art of Effective Communications 46 Ethics and the Bathsheba Syndrome
41 The Motivation-Performance 47 Leading Real Organizational Change
Connection 48 Lifelong Learning for Career Success
MARKETING
Taught by Ryan Hamilton, Emory University
of Business Management 52
53
54
55
Positioning Your Offering
Identifying Sources of Sales Growth
Deriving Value from Your Customers
Creating Great Customer
That Work
59 The Promise and Perils
of Social Media
60 Innovative Marketing
What does it take to reach lasting success in business? It all comes down to a solid grasp of Experiences Research Techniques
the fundamentals taught to MBA students in some of the world’s most prestigious business
schools. Critical Business Skills for Success, our comprehensive 60-lecture course taught by Critical Business Skills for Success
five renowned business professors, brings the MBA experience right to you. Course no. 5800 | 60 lectures (30 minutes/lecture)
Here in one place is your accessible introduction to the five disciplines that everyone—
entry-level employees and CEOs alike—needs to master in order to reap rewards in SAVE UP TO $475
today’s complex marketplace: strategy, operations management, finance and accounting,
organizational behavior, and marketing. In exploring each skill, you’ll learn about
everything from key terms and methodologies to research-backed strategies and case studies DVD $624.95 NOW $149.95
involving some of the world’s most powerful companies. These 60 lessons comprise an all- Instant Video $529.95 NOW $99.95
in-one introduction to business management skills you need to succeed. +$20 Shipping & Processing (DVD only) and Lifetime Satisfaction Guarantee
Catalog Code: 193166
Offer expires 04/03/21 For over 30 years, The Great Courses has brought the world’s foremost educators
TGC
./9
to millions who want to go deeper into the subjects that matter most. No exams.
No homework. Just a world of knowledge available anytime, anywhere. Download
or stream to your laptop or PC, or use our free apps for iPad, iPhone, Android,
1-800-832-2412 Kindle Fire, or Roku. Over 800 courses available at www.TheGreatCourses.com.
A8 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
J
dian justice system—a system tially violated international ack DeBoer called himself a “re- me if I made more and more money.”
that Meng Wanzhou, the chief sanctions. Huawei and Ms. covering ego-holic.” In his late When things fell apart in the early
financial officer of Chinese tele- Meng have denied wrongdoing. 30s, he was obsessed with seeing 1970s, one creditor threatened to kill
his name in print and becoming the Mr. DeBoer unless he paid by the fol-
nation’s No. 1 apartment builder. lowing Friday. He was so depressed he
Then he found himself overex- spent two days in bed and began a
tended. In the early 1970s as interest painful self-examination. At the end of
For more information: rates surged, he was on the brink of it, “I was finished using money and
In Memoriam wsj.com/inmemoriam bankruptcy and had to renegotiate
payment schedules with creditors. Mr.
success as a way to stand out in the
minds of others,” he wrote later.
DeBoer ditched the quest for glory He was careful in choosing partners.
(
+
and, inspired by desperation, came up At a meeting in New York, an invest-
(
&
+
with a better strategy. ment banker munched on cookies with-
%.
&
-
%.'
In 1976, he opened the first Resi- out passing the plate. Mr. DeBoer
/
dence Inn. It was in Wichita, Kan., and struck the banker off his list.
&
.-
&
%
catered to people who might need a After making a fortune in hotels, Mr.
&
&
-'
-
9
room for a few weeks or months. Mr. DeBoer and his wife took a four-month
-
-
.
&
(
/ DeBoer built a chain and sold it to world tour, visiting three dozen coun-
/- .
/ /
' Marriott Corp. in 1987. He later tries in their Gulfstream jet in 1988.
?%
founded, nurtured and sold the Sum- where his parents founded a real-estate They sailed down the Amazon River
.$ %
$
/$
67:7
&
+
merfield, Candlewood and Value Place brokerage and insurance firm. and saw a fire dance in Papua New
%--
%+
chains. At age 10, he started loading his Guinea.
1
( & ,
His vision established the extended- wagon with pansies and selling them The chaos and poverty they saw in
-.' & % %' stay lodging category, which now ac- door to door. He discovered he could Myanmar left the deepest impression.
"
- -
' .$-% ,
counts for about 10% of U.S. hotel make more money by buying larger “We have no hope,” a tour guide told
/ &-
% & rooms, according to hotel data-tracking quantities and selling them to other them. Over the next three decades, the
%
--
firm STR. Extended-stay hotels tend to young merchants. DeBoers revisited the country 11 times,
/
?%
%
/
be much more profitable because they funded World Vision healthcare pro-
H
/
+
-'
%
-
<
have smaller staffs and don’t necessar- e studied business at what is grams there and sponsored fellowships
-/ +
%-. %'
ily have pools and other amenities. now Michigan State University. to nurture leaders.
+
-
-' Guest rooms can be cleaned once a After graduating in 1952, he There was nothing heroic about his
%
&
,
&
)% week. served as a military police officer at an giving, he wrote: It didn’t reduce his
!"
#
$
%
& &
' ( 67E2
“You make your own bed—or not,” Army base in North Carolina. In 1953, standard of living. “My hero is the sin-
)% *$+
, &
&
-' 5 he noted. he married Marilyn Sanders, who had gle mom who shares her already
-
- .
/ '
'% (
(%
67E8 Mr. DeBoer died March 12 at his worked as a secretary in his parents’ crowded home with a friend who has
'
" 0 +
1
)
>
(%
)(>"
(
& %
home in Wichita. He was 90 and had firm. nowhere else to stay,” he wrote.
'+
/
& /
& *' #
$
,- &9
.
.
)
+
been under treatment for cancer. After his discharge from the Army, Mr. DeBoer remained frugal. Mimi
#
$
) / %
-
%
?
&
+
He often gave talks about business he returned to Kalamazoo and began Oliver, one of his granddaughters and
%% -
&
$
+
lessons he had learned the hard way, selling single-family homes, then business partners, recalled a lunch at a
(
1
'+ $/
&
+
-
%
$
233433 ' '
%%
compiled in his 2011 book, “Risk Only started building them and graduated to restaurant offering free pie. Mr. DeBoer
" %$
/.
%
-' -%
)
Money.” At the office, he made daily developing apartment buildings around was told that his first choice, banana
&
& -
%
)("
#
“howdy rounds” to greet every em- the country. He learned to fly and cream, wasn’t part of the offer and
' & &' / +
5- .+
& )(> F338 / .'
G-
(
%' % ployee. The license plate on his Mer- bought airplanes to shuttle between his would cost 79 cents. Though he wasn’t
%+
'
+
&
- & $
433
&
cedes convertible read: CAN DO. His projects. Sometimes he wrote checks to very fond of pumpkin pie, he went with
) 6748
0 @F
/
+
-
& H2 standard breakfast was two Oreo cook- suppliers while flying on autopilot. that to qualify for the free offer.
1' & 1
% (
. 83 333
%'
+
ies and a glass of orange juice. Seeing his name in print was a thrill.
& 1'
1(1" 6783 % %
?
&
5. /
%
&
& -%
Jack Peter DeBoer was born Jan. 15, In high school, he had never qualified Read in-depth profiles at
- (- -
/
/$
%
5. )
/
9 +
-&-
% )
/ 1931, and grew up in Kalamazoo, Mich., for the in-crowd. “I loved making WSJ.com/news/types/obituaries
&' -
&
.
' &
.
&
%'
%
0. * + / /
$
% +
-
5-
' .
+
.D .' (% &
& -
'
0 &
<+
' & C O L BY C H A N D L E R LIESBETH STOEFFLER
-
& 6747 /
# & 0-
.
6: 6783 , 1
%
-%%' )
1925 — 2021 1959 — 2021
1 ++
/ .
+
<+
'
$
;88 &
<+
' & & #
.
#
$
% %
$
'%-
/
# & 0-
/
-%
.
&
0
&
- '
& &.
<# %
.
.
& -
-
.
& %&
%
+
-
/
Kodak CEO Pushed Marathons Tested
%
+
, #
-%
-
0.= +
/ *
' /
' &'
.
-
0-
.+
/ .
.
&
+
+ /&
& +
83
For a New Focus Her New Lungs
/$
& %
-
C A
)&& >
= >
.
'
0. / +
-/+
678:
.
&' % -%% -+
olby Chandler After he retired, his suc- t age 18, Liesbeth Sto- At first, sitting up was a
+
/ *
' (( & >
%-. -++
.'
/
> whacked a wooden cessor, Kay Whitmore, kept effler moved from her major strain. Beginning
& > ?= % /
" #
$
)' crate with a machete cutting costs as Fuji Photo native Austria to New what she called her “second
-
&
&
#
$
/
(
&
/
.
*' #
$
in 1989 to show Eastman Film Co. and private-label York for an au pair job. life,” she rebuilt her
@3 )
+
&
0."
%
/ + Kodak Co.’s managers how filmmakers ate into Kodak’s Starting with almost no strength with weights and a
/ A$=
#
$
determined he was to cut core business, destined for English, she learned com- Peloton stationary bike. In
+
'
& %
#
$
&'
G-
-
& I/
'
/
costs. He had good reason technological oblivion in any puter-graphics skills and 2013 she ran the New York
(
-
0
'
$
.- D ) for frustration during his case. In 1993, the board worked her way into a posi- City Marathon in five hours
67:3 &
'
-
) &
' ' &
reign as chief executive, ousted Mr. Whitmore and tion as a vice president at and 20 minutes. She fin-
&
?
#
-%%
' .
from 1983 to 1990. recruited George Fisher. He the fund-management firm ished dozens of other races
+
B /
-
+
&
' '
& +
& Long before he took sold the pharmaceuticals now known as AllianceBern- and climbed mountains.
0. /-
&'
.
%-.
+
% & +
charge, Kodak’s dominance business and focused on stein. After 10 years, her lungs
&
+ & )
+- -
&-
$ ) of the film industry had left film and digital imaging. She skied, ran marathons failed again. Despite a sec-
&9
&
' &
=
' it bloated, complacent and Kodak continued to and drank martinis with ond transplant, her condi-
%
& )
C - C
/ .
. & &
#
&
$
-
& & F3F6 slow in reacting to changes shrink and now has a mar- friends. In her late 30s, af- tion deteriorated. Doctors
#
/-
+
&
in markets and technology. ket value of around $630 ter finding herself increas- warned in September 2020
%
D ? , (
A- '
Mr. Chandler, a Kodak million, down from $16 bil- ingly short of breath and she might have only days or
&
&
/ >
%-. .
+
.$
+
&
&'
///
lifer who grew up on a lion in 1989. prone to coughing fits, she weeks to live. Ms. Stoeffler
Maine dairy farm and stud- Mr. Chandler, who died was diagnosed with cystic survived nearly six months
ied business at the Massa- March 4 at the age of 95, fibrosis. By 2008, it was with the help of a BPAP
chusetts Institute of Tech- wasn’t bitter. If given the clear she needed a double- breathing device.
IN MEMORIAM nology, repeatedly
restructured and in 1988
opportunity of returning to
his old job, he told the
lung transplant. After more
than a year on the wait list,
In her final months, she
rented an apartment over-
EVERY WEDNESDAY AND SATURDAY paid $5.1 billion for Sterling Rochester Business Journal she got her new lungs at looking Central Park. She
For more information visit: wsj.com/InMemoriam Drug Inc., a pharmaceutical in 2004, “I would jump at New York-Presbyterian/Co- died March 4 at the age of
© 2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. company. Investors only the chance.” lumbia University Medical 61.
grew more impatient. —James R. Hagerty Center in July 2009. —James R. Hagerty
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | A9
for interviews. A spokesman & Whitney, which declined to ordered immediate specialized
said a priority has been reduc- comment on Engine Alliance’s inspections even while some
ing the risk of fan-blade fail- behalf. An Airbus spokesman FAA officials didn’t believe
ures that can lead to engine said the plane maker takes into such drastic action was neces-
covers detaching midair. The account past incidents and ac- sary, said people familiar with
FAA spokesman said design cidents to enhance safety. the agency’s response.
changes to a “critical piece of Boeing engineers have been The move effectively took
structure must be carefully working on a plan to more than 50 Boeing 777s—all
evaluated and tested” to ensure strengthen 737 engine covers, operated by United—out of
they provide the same level of essentially to soften the shock service for months, until in-
safety or better without intro- of a fan-blade failure and keep spections have been com-
ducing unintended risks. parts attached to the plane pleted.
Boeing spokesman Bradley even when the blades fly for- Tom Haueter, a former
CHRISTOPHER BEHNAM
Akubuiro said it “has taken ward, people familiar with the NTSB director of aviation
steps to move forward” with work said. safety, said: “They grounded
the FAA to improve engine cov- In March 2020, FAA Admin- the fleet—that’s about as ag-
ers and is giving its technical istrator Steve Dickson told the gressive as you can get.”
teams time they need to ensure NTSB the agency was working —Chieko Tsuneoka, Benjamin
design changes provide their with the plane maker to Katz and Doug Cameron
expected performance and Christopher Behnam, left, with failed engine in 2018. Right, debris from Flight 328 last month. strengthen the 737 engine cov- contributed to this article.
in May. They will mate, lay eggs what some might consider the rescheduling isn’t an option, anyone,” Ms. Heiman says. to some young trees, scientists
Cicadas on tree branches, then die. Af-
ter a few hectic weeks in a
cicadas’ noisy racket is a “song
of love,” made by courting
she added, so the party will go
on. She plans to have someone
“Given the whole pandemic and
everything everyone’s been
say. On the plus side, their un-
derground tunnels aerate soil,
swath of 15 states, from Geor- males—one that couples will rake the bug bodies before the through, we just figured it’s re- their remains nourish trees and
Turn Party gia to New York, only piles of
smelly carcasses and their
keep hearing on their 17th,
34th and 51st anniversaries.
big day.
Her son, Alexander Leifer,
ally not such a big deal.”
Cicadas are harmless except
they are a food source for many
animals. Some humans eat
groups of the periodical kind— emailed her, “you could make food plate or in your hair,” she Heiman says they embraced the memorable for sure,” Ms. Mat-
makes its appearance after hid- the cicadas part of the celebra- says. idea. It helps that the professor tox says. “But I just want to
ing underground since 2004. tion. I have often said that a ci- Dr. Raupp told her the cica- says there shouldn’t be many make sure it’s memorable in a
They’ll tunnel to daylight once cada wedding is very romantic.” das should fade after the first cicadas by their July 3 event. They’re back: Brood X cicadas, good way, not like a disastrous
the soil hits 64 degrees, mostly He later elaborated that week of June. Moving inside or “A few cicadas never hurt last seen in 2004. Fyre Festival event.”
A10 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
counted for $867.5 million, or about
79%, of revenues via the television
deal with CBS and Turner Sports.
Holzman said that the NCAA’s
core purpose isn’t to make its
championship events profitable but
“to provide a great atmosphere for
our fans and our student athletes.”
She added, “If there are increased
ticket sales and there are other as-
pects that come in that is an obvi-
ous benefit.”
Lumping the women’s basketball
tournament in with every other
championship “speaks to the nego-
tiation tactics” that “have never
been about women’s sports,” said
Lindsey Darvin, an assistant profes-
sor sports management at SUNY-
Cortland who studies gender equity
in sports.
The NCAA declined to say how
much revenue the women’s tourna-
ment generates, only that it is not
self-sustaining. Operating costs for
women’s March Madness are con-
siderably lower, as first- and sec-
ond-round games are typically held
on the campuses of higher-seeded
teams rather than neutral sites and
brackets are drawn up to minimize
cross-country travel.
“I don’t see how it’s possible that
they’re not turning a profit, espe-
cially with how much they’re doing
to cut costs,” said Darvin, a former
But the Event Remains Undervalued mittee, said that interest carried
over into the postseason. “We’re
setting records in terms of atten-
dance at all the rounds,” she said.
“Our last Final Four in Tampa was
As an economic opportunity, the women’s bracket is an afterthought in the NCAA’s overall picture record setting and we were hoping
to do so in San Antonio in the Ala-
modome because it’s so big.”
BY LAINE HIGGINS According to NCAA vice presi- Due to pandemic restric-
C
dent for women’s basketball Lynn tions, however, attendance at
onnecticut will aim to Holzman, conversations about the 2021 Final Four will be
win its seventh title in changing the March Madness bonus capped at 17% capacity, about
the past decade when equation to include women’s results 5,000 people.
the women’s NCAA tour- “have not gotten to the level” of the Ratings for the 2019
nament gets under way NCAA Board of Governors or the Di- women’s Final Four rivaled
in San Antonio on Sunday. Yet even vision I Board of Directors, which those of the top men’s regu-
if the No. 1 seeded Huskies cut have the power to effect such a lar season games during the
down the nets, neither the univer- change. 2021-21 season. Over 3.6 mil-
sity nor its athletic conference, the The NCAA annually doles out lion viewers tuned into the
Big East, will see a single additional money to conferences from its “Di- 2019 championship game be-
cent from the NCAA to reward their vision I Basketball Performance tween Baylor and Notre
tournament run. Fund” based on the results from the Dame, a 24% increase from
Women’s college basketball is men’s tournament, with teams earn- 2016, at the height of
growing in popularity, with TV rat- ing one “unit” for every tournament UConn’s dominance.
ings and ticket sales improving rap- game appearance until the Final These upward viewership
idly. As an economic opportunity, it Four. The total number of units trends helped persuade exec-
is still mostly an afterthought in the each athletic conference accrues utives at ESPN to broadcast
NCAA’s overall picture. during March Madness generates all 63 games of women’s
March Madness for the men is a payments over six-year rolling peri- March Madness nationally
multibillion-dollar gusher for the ods. The payment for the most re- for the first time in 2020, a
FROM TOP: ERIC GAY/ASSOCIATED PRESS; ISAAC BREKKEN/ASSOCIATED PRESS
NCAA, thanks to its recently ex- cent tournament in 2019 stood at move that ultimately was
tended $19.6 billion, 22-year deal about $280,000 per unit. pushed back one year by the
TV deal. Teams and conferences A run to the men’s Final Four in Connecticut players, top, after winning the 2010 tournament in San Antonio. coronavirus pandemic. The extra
benefit from that bounty. A team’s 2021 could generate an addi- Stanford’s Tara VanDerveer, above, celebrates a 2021 Pac-12 tournament title. games are part of the existing 24-
Cinderella run can pad its confer- tional $1.1 million payday for the sport contract and it’s unclear if the
ence’s financial coffers for years. conference every season until 2027. weight room in Indianapolis. In a “We have intentionally organized network’s move resulted in addi-
The broadcast revenue generated A team could win the women’s title statement, the NCAA attributed the basketball under one umbrella with tional payments to the NCAA. ESPN
by the women’s tournament, how- for years in a row, as UConn did differences to “limited space” in San the goal of consistency and collabo- deferred comment to the NCAA,
ever, is just a slice of NCAA’s deal from 2013 to 2016, and never see an Antonio’s 514,000 square foot con- ration. When we fall short of these who would not say whether the in-
with ESPN for championships in 24 additional penny. vention center. expectations, that’s on me,” he said. creased exposure would yield addi-
other men’s and women’s sports, The difference between the two On Friday, NCAA officials said The equation for allocating tional revenue for the women’s
which runs through 2023-24 and is tournaments received attention in they had spoken with the women’s riches from the NCAA tourna- tournament.
worth about $500 million over 14 another way on Thursday, when coaches Thursday night, taken their ment was adopted decades ago and, “The leadership isn’t pushing for
years. The women’s basketball tour- sports performance coach Ali Kersh- feedback, and pledged that the according to an NCAA spokesper- this,” said Darvin. “The NCAA as an
nament doesn’t turn a profit, nor ner from Stanford tweeted the dis- weight room issue would be ad- son, is still used because the bulk of overall leadership organization and
does the NCAA factor its results parity in training equipment given to dressed by Saturday morning. the organization’s revenue comes those that are part of these [televi-
into its annual financial distribu- the women in San Antonio—10 yoga Dan Gavitt, the NCAA’s senior vice from the men’s Division I basketball sion] negotiations are holding the
tions to schools as it does for the mats and 16 dumbbells no heavier president for basketball, said he was tournament. Of the $1.1 billion the women back.”
men. There appear to be no plans than 30 pounds per team—and the sorry and that the association would NCAA brought in during the 2019 —Louise Radnofsky contributed to
to change that. men, who have access to a sprawling also try to do better. fiscal year, March Madness ac- this article.
Weather
30s
V
Shown are today’s noon positions of weather systems and precipitation. Temperature bands are highs for the day.
Vancouver
d t
Edmonton
Calgaryy
40s
30s <0
0s
Big Shot for a First-Time Champ
10s
Winnipeg
Seattle 50s 40s 20s BY RACHEL BACHMAN
Portland
Por
P tl d l
Helena Montreal 30s
Ottawa
g
Billings Bismarckk
A g t
Augusta 40s YOU HAVE TO GO BACK to
Eugene Boise 60s 1996 to find the last major-
30s p /St
pls / . Paul
Mpls./St. Pau T t
Toronto A ban
Albany
b t
Boston 50s
50s oux Falls
Sioux ff l
Buffalo rtford
Hartford 60s college football team to win
k
Milwaukee t
Detroit
40s Pierre 50s New Yorkk
ew Y 70s
its first-ever national title. It
Reno es Moines Chicago
Des
Salt
alt Lake
L ke City
C
City
Che
h y
Cheyenne
Ch g
Clevel d
Cl
Cleveland
Phil d lphi
Philadelphia
was the Florida Gators. The
80s
Sacramento Omaha h Indianapolis Pittsburgh hottest technology that year
Denver Charle
h l t
Charleston hington
hi gton D.C.
Washington DC 90s
San
an Francisco
C d
Colorado Topeka Kansas Springfield
p i fi ld was the flip phone.
City h
Richmond d 100+
But it takes going back
JOHN J. KIM/ZUMA PRESS
Las p g
Springs St.. Louis
L
Lou L
Lou ill
Louisville
h
Wichita
Ve
Vegas 50s Raleighl ighh
Los A
Ange l
Angeles 70s
only two years to find the
60s Santaa Fe Charlotte
C h l tt
Memphis
Memphi p h ill
Nashville most recent first-time na-
Alb
b q q
Albuquerque Oklahoma City C b
bi
Columbia Warm Rain
San Diego 80s Phoenix
Ph i Little Rock Atlanta
Atl t tional champion in major
T c
Tucson Jack
Jackson Birmingham
h men’s college basketball: Vir-
El Paso Ft. Worth
th Dallas
D ll
60s Cold T-storms
Jacksonville
Jack ill ginia in 2019. That was also
-0s A ti
Austin bil
Mobile
70s Houston
t Stationary Snow
the last time the tournament
0s Orlando
l d
New
ew Orleans
Tampa was held, after last year’s was Illinois celebrates after winning the 2021 Big Ten tournament.
10s an Antonio
San
20s Honolulu
l 70s Miami
Showers Flurries canceled due to the coronavi-
Anchorage
A h g 80s 80s rus pandemic. football and basketball cham- draft, while men’s basketball
30s 70s Ice This year’s NCAA tourna- pions is partly a numbers players need be only one year
ment, which tipped off Thurs- game. Top-division college out of college and at least 19
U.S. Forecasts City Hi
Today
Lo W
Tomorrow
Hi Lo W City Hi
Today
Lo W
Tomorrow
Hi Lo W
day, stands a good chance of football has about 130 teams years old to be drafted into
s...sunny; pc... partly cloudy; c...cloudy; sh...showers;
Omaha 61 45 s 63 47 c Frankfurt 43 30 pc 49 33 pc producing another first-time from which a winner can the NBA.
t...t’storms; r...rain; sf...snow flurries; sn...snow; i...ice champion. Of the four No. 1 emerge, while Division I This year is a departure
Orlando 69 54 pc 75 56 c Geneva 43 27 pc 48 34 pc
Today Tomorrow Havana 78 61 pc 79 59 pc
City Hi Lo W Hi Lo W
Philadelphia 56 35 s 60 38 s seeds, three have never won men’s college basketball has from recent years because pe-
Phoenix 83 56 s 77 53 s Hong Kong 81 70 pc 79 62 pc
Anchorage 22 3 c 19 2 pc Pittsburgh 56 30 s 62 32 s Istanbul 53 42 c 48 44 sh it all: Baylor, Gonzaga and Illi- about 350 teams. rennial basketball contenders
Atlanta 57 43 s 63 47 pc Portland, Maine 51 29 s 54 30 s Jakarta 91 76 r 90 75 t nois. The other 1-seed, Michi- Squad sizes also help ex- such as Kentucky and Duke
Austin 70 42 s 75 56 s Portland, Ore. 52 39 sh 51 42 r Jerusalem 70 54 s 77 68 pc gan, won its only title in plain football’s steady stream didn’t make the tournament.
Baltimore 57 31 s 63 36 s Sacramento 61 40 s 67 40 s Johannesburg 77 59 pc 72 57 t
Boise 52 32 c 53 36 s St. Louis 59 41 s 66 44 s London 51 43 c 53 39 c
1989. of familiar winners. With ros- “Teams like Baylor and
Boston 55 36 s 58 37 s Salt Lake City 49 34 sh 47 32 s Madrid 54 29 pc 61 31 s Since 1991, the NCAA tour- ter sizes of more than 100, Gonzaga have learned that, in
Burlington 51 29 s 58 35 s San Francisco 59 46 pc 60 47 s Manila 95 80 pc 95 80 t nament has produced eight football programs need waves order to compete with the
Charlotte 56 38 pc 62 41 s Santa Fe 70 38 s 64 31 pc Melbourne 79 65 pc 74 63 sh
Chicago 56 38 s 64 45 s Seattle 52 39 sh 46 40 r Mexico City 74 49 pc 74 51 pc
first-time champions. That’s of standout recruits to change ‘one-and-done’ cultures at
Cleveland 53 35 s 60 40 s Sioux Falls 57 43 pc 57 37 pc Milan 52 33 sh 50 31 pc nearly triple the three first- their fortunes. Kentucky and Duke, college
Dallas 67 47 s 71 55 s Wash., D.C. 57 38 s 61 39 s Moscow 31 22 pc 34 29 pc timers that college football Basketball’s rosters of basketball’s equivalent of Ala-
Denver 62 34 pc 42 28 pc Mumbai 90 76 pc 93 79 pc
has crowned in the same about 15 players mean that bama football, they must cul-
Detroit
Honolulu
56 31 s
79 69 pc 79 69 sh
62 34 s
International Paris
Rio de Janeiro
49
87
36 s
74 s
52 36 pc
87 75 s span. picking up a couple of stars tivate rosters of older players
Houston 69 47 s 71 58 s Today Tomorrow Riyadh 88 59 s 90 67 s Before the Gators in ’96, could move the needle from via the transfer route, red-
Indianapolis 57 35 s 63 40 s City Hi Lo W Hi Lo W Rome 53 40 c 56 38 c
Kansas City 60 46 s 66 48 pc Amsterdam 46 41 pc 47 38 pc San Juan 85 74 pc 85 73 pc
Florida State won its first being a doormat to landing in shirting their players or al-
Las Vegas 71 51 s 64 46 s Athens 62 54 r 64 54 c Seoul 55 39 c 52 35 pc football title in 1993 and the 68-team NCAA tourna- lowing mistake-prone under-
Little Rock 63 39 s 66 44 s Baghdad 78 55 pc 82 59 s Shanghai 57 47 sh 57 40 pc Washington shared its first ment—or from making the classmen to grow over the
Los Angeles 70 50 pc 71 50 s Bangkok 98 81 pc 98 78 s Singapore 89 77 r 89 78 pc with Miami in 1991, according field to making the Final Four. course of two or three sea-
Miami 79 64 pc 81 63 sh Beijing 57 39 pc 52 35 pc Sydney 72 68 r 71 68 r
Milwaukee 53 38 s 57 44 pc Berlin 39 34 pc 46 28 sf Taipei City 82 66 s 68 57 sh to an NCAA list of past cham- Pro draft rules also rein- sons,” said Fran Fraschilla,
Minneapolis 57 44 s 60 44 sh Brussels 46 37 pc 49 36 pc Tokyo 63 58 pc 68 57 r pions. (UW also claims a 1960 force the status quo. Football ESPN analyst and a former
Nashville 64 36 s 67 42 s Buenos Aires 70 62 r 74 62 s Toronto 57 32 s 55 35 s title from college football’s players must be three years Division I basketball coach.
New Orleans 65 53 c 70 55 s Dubai 90 74 s 87 74 s Vancouver 49 39 sh 46 39 r
New York City 54 39 s 58 41 s Dublin 52 42 c 52 42 pc Warsaw 36 25 c 37 25 sf messy poll era.) out of high school before —Laine Higgins
Oklahoma City 65 42 s 68 50 c Edinburgh 55 40 c 53 39 pc Zurich 38 21 pc 41 30 pc The difference between they’re eligible for the NFL contributed to this article.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | A11
OPINION
THE WEEKEND INTERVIEW with Alex Gorsky | By Allysia Finley
household name in the best way fection. T-cells provide backup if a marketplace, the real competition
for developing its single-shot Covid virus penetrates the antibodies’ here is the coronavirus.”
vaccine, which the Food and Drug frontline defense and help enlist Merck recently agreed to pro-
Administration approved for emer- white blood cells into action. Anti- duce J&J vaccines in its factories.
gency use last month. The vaccine bodies can fade after a few months, vaccine as if it were a cold. countries. In January Merck stopped develop-
is increasing the U.S. supply of but T-cells stick around longer and In 2007 a promising Merck HIV The company has enrolled more ment of its two Covid-19 vaccine
shots at a critical time and will en- have something of a photographic vaccine, which used the adenovi- than 150,000 patients in vaccine candidates after early clinical trials
able a billion people world-wide to memory. Some people who were rus-5, or Ad5, failed to prevent in- trials for these diseases, and last showed weak immune responses.
be vaccinated this year. infected with SARS in 2002-04 fection in the later stages of a clin- summer the European Medicines Merck’s vaccines used different vi-
were found to have T-cells that re- ical trial. Worse, data indicated Agency approved its Ebola vaccine. rus vectors than J&J’s, but one had
membered the virus a decade later. that people who tested positive for Mr. Gorsky says the trials for other shown success against Ebola.
The vaccine revolution J&J’s vaccine was found to be Ad5 antibodies were more suscep- diseases have made the company J&J’s vaccine is the third to ob-
72% effective at preventing moder- tible to HIV infection than people confident that its vaccine platform tain FDA approval, but preliminary
didn’t happen on its own. ate to severe Covid symptoms who received a placebo, a phenom- is safe, even among people who results from trials on AstraZeneca
It’s a product of decades of (meaning two or more symptoms enon known as vaccine-induced en- have pre-existing immunity to its and Novavax suggest they are also
that don’t require hospitalization) hancement. A 2008 article in the Ad26 vector. highly effective. All these Covid-19
planning and investment. in U.S. trials. That’s less than the Journal of Experimental Medicine Conducting trials in the develop- vaccines use innovative technolo-
95% of the Moderna and Pfizer-Bi- was titled “The failed HIV Merck ing world also gave the company’s gies that have been developed and
oNTech vaccines, which received vaccine study: a step back or a scientists confidence and knowl- tested over decades on other dis-
J&J’s road to the vaccine—from emergency-use authorization ear- launching point for future vaccine edge to run global trials for its eases. AstraZeneca’s vaccine is
failure to life-saving success, from lier, and which are followed by a development?” Covid vaccine. Most participants in similar to J&J’s, but uses a chim-
I
investment write-off to break- booster a few weeks after the initial J&J’s Covid vaccine trial lived out- panzee adenovirus as a vector. The
through—is a little-known story shot. But the trials aren’t directly t was the latter. Merck’s HIV- side the U.S.—12.7% in South Af- Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna vac-
about science, business risk and in- comparable. For one thing, J&J’s vaccine failure prodded more rica, 17.3% in Brazil and 23.3% in cines inject the virus’s genetic code
novation. There are also lessons for trial occurred later, in the fall and study of other adenoviruses five other Latin American coun- via mRNA, which instructs human
those who think capitalism is early winter, when more virus vari- like Ad26—the vector for J&J’s tries. Trials in South Africa and cells to produce pseudo-spike pro-
merely about rapacious profit. ants were circulating. Some variants Covid-19 vaccine. The Dutch bio- Brazil showed that J&J’s vaccine teins, which in turn prompts an im-
“We would never be in the posi- with changes to their spike protein, tech company Crucell had been ex- could prevent severe illness and mune response. Novavax’s vaccine
tion where we are today if we had which helps the virus infiltrate hu- perimenting with Ad26 in a vaccine deaths even against new variants. uses re-engineered spike-protein
not invested billions of dollars over man cells, appear to partly elude to prevent malaria and other infec- “When we were debating clinical clones.
A
decades so that we could respond,” the antibody response. tious diseases. Unlike with Ad5, an- trial sites, and we asked could they
Mr. Gorsky, 60, says in an interview T-cells aren’t as easily tricked. tibodies to Ad26 didn’t appear to logistically do this, some of our sci- bout 85% of vaccine candi-
the Monday morning after the FDA One reason scientists are excited sabotage the vaccine. In 2009, J&J entists had personally visited them dates fail in trials, and those
authorized its Covid vaccine. The about J&J’s vaccine is that its one entered into a partnership with and said, ‘They can absolutely do that succeed have historically
U.S. Army veteran had been up shot induces a robust T-cell re- Crucell to develop a vaccine it this, and I can vouch and validate taken 10 to 15 years to develop. It
since 3:30 a.m., getting in one of sponse. This means immunity is hoped could someday prevent in- that they can,’ ” Mr. Gorsky says. seems like an incredible stroke of
his early-morning workouts before likely to last longer—how long re- fection from all influenza strains. “That’s ultimately what put us in a luck and science that we have so
meetings. J&J’s Covid-19 vaccine mains to be seen—and less likely to Two years later, J&J bought Cru- position to be able to do such a many Covid-19 vaccines so soon.
development over the last year has be defeated by new variants. cell for $2.4 billion. high-quality trial at that particular But it’s more than that. Credit
been a sprint, but the process that Mr. Gorsky attributes the strong “At that time we had little to no moment, even in the face of those years of research and investment
led to it has been a decades-long multilayered immune response experience in vaccines,” Mr. Gorsky kinds of challenges.” by drug makers, as well as govern-
marathon. from J&J’s vaccine to its innova- says. But capitalism entails risk: J&J was a couple of months be- ment collaboration during the pan-
Vaccines such as those for polio, tive adenovirus-vector platform, Many Crucell vaccine studies hind some other vaccine manufac- demic, which Mr. Gorsky hopes will
MMR (measles, mumps and ru- AdVac, which it has developed over failed, and “we ended up writing turers, in part because its scien- outlast the pandemic.
bella) and seasonal flu have been a decade. down a very significant portion of tists had to make trade-offs to “I think this is a golden mo-
made from weakened or inacti- Adenoviruses like those that can our initial investment.” Still, Cru- create a single-shot vaccine that ment, not only for Johnson & John-
vated viruses. But patients often cause the common cold—so named cell brought along “two really im- could be mass-produced and rap- son, but the biopharmaceutical in-
produce a weak immune response because they were first isolated in portant technologies that gave idly distributed, including in devel- dustry,” he says. “We
to the inactivated viruses, and human adenoids—are easy to ma- seed to what we’re doing today.” oping countries. A single dose fundamentally believe that having
shots that use weakened viruses nipulate because they have a large One was the AdVac platform. needed to produce a robust im- a market-based, innovation-based,
can make immunocompromised genome. They also don’t integrate The other was the PER.C6 manu- mune reaction, but not a reaction biopharmaceutical as well as a
people sick. The manufacturing their genes into our own. This facturing technology, capable of so strong that it caused severe side medical-technology environment, is
process is also laborious. makes them an ideal tool for vec- mass-producing vaccines quickly effects. critical long term to produce the
Scientists over the past couple tor-vaccines. The problem is that and cheaply. Despite earlier fail- “We developed more than a best overall outcomes for health-
of decades have been studying a many people have pre-existing an- ures, J&J continued to work on dozen different permutations,” Mr. care.”
potentially more efficient and ef- tibodies to adenoviruses from prior vaccines for Ebola, HIV, Zika and Gorsky says, “and then we put
fective method known as a “vector infections, so their immune sys- respiratory syncytial virus, all of them through some initial testing Ms. Finley is a member of the
vaccine”: using genetically engi- tems may try to shoot down the which are prevalent in developing and selected our one candidate Journal’s editorial board.
W
52% while the electricity generated anyone I knew growing up, I started his classroom now reaches far and in the parking lot as he took his
from natural gas increased 72%. ho knew that lockdowns DMing those whose social media wide. The same can be said of my driver’s test. The four of us have
Regardless of your thoughts on would make it easier for in- posts suggested we share interests. pandemic posse, and with a few, I’ve commiserated about our elderly par-
climate change, last month’s storm troverts to make friends? I’ve even reconnected with long- grown unexpectedly close. ents coping with isolation. And when
made painfully clear that climate Even though I barely left my house lost family. The more we compare they dis America for its handling of
catastrophists have an oversize in- over the past year, I’ve made enough memories, the more skeletons in the pandemic, I counter with stories
fluence on public policy. An obses- new ones to fill a small theater. closets we find, and the closer we Lockdowns and technology of Aussie overreach—like the astro-
sive focus on reaching the unattain- My wife used to joke that I should become. physicist who ended up in a hospital
able goal of zero carbon emissions get a T-shirt emblazoned with Grou- If there’s a term for these sorts of gave this introvert an with magnets stuck in his nostrils. He
led to decades of poor decisions that cho Marx’s famous line “Hello, I must friends, I haven’t seen it. I think of unexpected opportunity was trying to invent a gizmo that
prioritized and subsidized unreliable be going.” There was no social situa- them as my pandemic posse. When would sound an alarm if he tried to
energy sources (wind and solar) at tion I didn’t want to cut short. Take everyone is stuck at home, you can to make new friends. touch his face.
the expense of reliable ones (natural the weekly lunches at Los Angeles’s approach folks you barely know. They Sometimes I imagine throwing a
gas, coal and nuclear). Texans now Magic Castle I used to attend before won’t call 911 or even block you on big party for my pandemic posse in a
know that reliable energy is essential the lockdown. Other members who Instagram. At worst, they’ll delete Some live clear across the globe. year or two, when everyone can
to our everyday lives. share my passion for magic hung out your message. At best, they’ll become After everything shut down last travel. I can see it now. Mingling
The catastrophists’ oversize influ- in clusters over leisurely meals. I new friends. March, I cheered myself up by book- guests. Strolling magicians. Austra-
ence has produced a dangerous hy- grabbed something to eat, watched a The novelist Viet Thanh Nguyen ing a vacation in Australia for late in lian wine.
pocrisy. Greens say that wind and show, and fled. recently described online teaching as the year. When that got canceled, my That’s a party I might actually enjoy.
solar can replace natural gas and That was then. Now, every Friday having “less human warmth, but wife and I set up video chats with a
coal to meet our energy needs while for the past 50 weeks, I’ve gotten to more human connection” than in-per- couple in Melbourne we’d met on ear- Mr. Glassner is a former president
reducing carbon emissions. But when know some of those same people at son teaching. Although they aren’t in lier trips and had planned to visit. of Lewis & Clark College and author
“renewables” fail, greens claim they the virtual Magic Castle “lunch.” And the same room, his students show a I’ve since helped their son with a of “The Culture of Fear.”
A12 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Europe’s Gang That Couldn’t Shot Straight How Much Should One’s Intentions Matter?
I
t’s hard to think of a recent fiasco that can EMA’s approval process is more bureaucratic, Paul Bloom is close to the truth of was teaching. As I pored over Augus-
match the European Union’s Covid vaccine requiring input from all EU member states. the matter when he notes that ignor- tine’s account of his youthful pear
ing intent and imposing the harshest stealing, I was struck once again by
rollout. Protectionism, mercantilism, bu- Imagine if the FDA consulted all 50 states.
punishment is intended primarily to its careful (some might say obses-
reaucratic ineptitude, lack of But national governments harm (“When Intentions Don’t Mat- sive) attention to human motivation.
political accountability, crip- A string of vaccine also are allowed to make their ter,” Review, March 13). Calling for a Although Augustine was a middle-
pling safety-ism—it’s all here. bungles threatens health own safety rulings on an “culture of greater kindness” to aged bishop when he wrote the “Con-
The Keystone Kops in Brussels “emergency” basis. The U.K. counter that inclination is exactly fessions,” he reflects at considerable
and European capitals would and the global economy. used this option to approve what our society needs. But we are length on all of the possible inten-
be funny if the consequences the Pfizer and AstraZeneca currently a society without much tions that motivated his adolescent
weren’t so serious. shots quickly despite still be- kindness, and clearly not in the mood indiscretion: Was he hungry? Did he
But hospitalizations and deaths are rising ing an EU member late last year. to grant anyone the benefit of a simply desire to break the law? Did
again in Italy, Germany and France while success- Other governments used this discretion to doubt. Condemnation is insufficient; he desire to please his friends? What
ful vaccinations suppress illness and fatalities in slow-roll vaccines. EU capitals refused to follow cancellation is the preferred solution. kind of pleasure did such lawbreak-
Intention could have been used as ing afford him? In his careful analy-
the U.S., United Kingdom and Israel. To date the the U.K. in granting emergency-use authorization,
a mitigating factor to the level of sis of the intentions that motivated
U.S. has administered 34 doses per 100 residents, apparently for fear of hurting European solidarity. punishment in nearly every example his youthful actions in the orchard,
the U.K. has jabbed 40, and Israel has 111. Most But some governments have been happy to impose cited by Dr. Bloom. Intent isn’t al- Augustine emphasizes the depth and
vaccines require two doses. Compare that to unilateral blocks on the vaccine, as with the Astra- ways so hard to discern. For exam- complexity of human personhood.
about 12 in France, Germany and Italy. Zeneca clot kerfuffle. European regulators live by ple, in the case of the New Yorker Only human beings, Augustine im-
As the pandemic moves into its reopening the maxim “better safe than sorry,” but in this case journalist exposing himself, or the plies, endowed with will and intel-
phase, Europe’s mistakes will cost the rest of the they’re getting the sorry with no added safe. New York Times reporter’s quote, lect, have the ability to intend any-
world economically as the Continent struggles At least now, millions of doses are available for the absence of previous such activ- thing. Dr. Bloom’s account, with its
to exit lockdowns. Europeans who do want them. This wasn’t always ity would be a strong indicator of insistence on disregarding intention
i i i the case, after procurement bungles delayed deliv- lack of intent to harm. And rather in the moral evaluation of an action,
Take the latest fumble first. Various Euro- eries and nearly sparked several trade wars. Brus- than the ultimate punishment of fir- denudes human personhood.
ing, perhaps a timeout to reflect on PAULA MCQUADE, PH.D.
pean regulators and politicians spent this week sels officials last year jumped at the chance to the action would have been more Chicago
claiming the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine—the push common vaccine procurement to bolster the appropriate.
only one currently widely available in the EU— EU’s credibility with European voters. Buying on All of the current major move- It seems to me that we are willing
might be unsafe, only to rethink and now beg behalf of 500 million Europeans also was sup- ments for societal change reflect this to punish the agent of a bad outcome
people to start accepting it. posed to give the bloc more leverage with phar- all-or-nothing attitude. Whether it’s if either of two conditions is met—
This time the concern was that the jab caused maceutical companies. income inequality, racial equity or intent or failure to act responsibly.
blood clotting or problems with blood platelets It’s been chaos. The EU bureaucracy has little environmental change, each is en- Perhaps the definition of bad intent
in some patients. Some people who received the experience with procurement on this scale, and gaged in a war that has no room for can be expansive enough to include
vaccine developed blood clots, but the European it also struggled to strike bloc-wide deals for tolerance. Our elected officials need the moral laziness of irresponsibil-
Medicines Agency (EMA) found the vaccine was ventilators and protective equipment. Brussels to lead by example, and the voting ity—I decided not to take the trouble
public to make this a priority. Per- to understand my responsibilities.
not associated with an increase in the overall officials signed vaccine contracts months after
haps then, with kindness, we will Reserving punishment for bad out-
risk. the U.S. and U.K. did last year—and only after have a better chance at achieving all comes is pragmatic, but there are ex-
Among the 11 million or so vaccinated in the some European governments threatened to orga- of those important societal changes. ceptions where bad intent or failure
U.K., serious clots were less common than would nize their own procurement. JOSEPH P. PETITO to act responsibly are punished in
be expected in the general population. People Washington and London understood that cru- Bethesda, Md. the absence of bad outcomes, for in-
can develop clots for many reasons including cial to mass procurement was throwing large stance, a charge of driving under the
other health conditions and medications. amounts of R&D money at many companies in On the same day that I read Paul influence without any harm having
Covid-19 can also cause clots, so any risk-benefit hopes some would work. Brussels focused on hag- Bloom’s essay, I happened to reread been done (yet).
calculation favors vaccination. gling down the cost per dose. Europeans pay a Book 2 of St. Augustine’s “Confes- ROBERT SULLIVAN
This is of a piece with a distinctly European few dollars less per dose but ended near the back sions” in preparation for a class I Johns Creek, Ga.
safety-ism that has dogged the vaccine program of the shipment line.
since the start. Introduction of the AstraZeneca The EU response—a combination of threat-
jab was held up even after the EMA approved ened export curbs, noisy commercial disputes
it because bureaucrats in Germany claimed with pharma companies, and sour-grapes cavil- Adapting Classics for Modern Young Readers
there was no evidence it works in patients older ing about imaginary efficacy concerns—has While I appreciate Marilyn Green- propose that this would appeal to
than 65. mainly undermined Europe’s credibility on trade wald’s attempt to poke at the current post-World War II readers.
Fewer elderly patients were included in the issues. It also risks stoking vaccine nationalism wave of self-censorship in the form I am most familiar with the Tom
sample during the vaccine’s trial phase, but and trade restrictions elsewhere. of cancel culture, her article on Swift brand. Consider that the first
that’s as far as the truth to this claim went. It i i i Nancy Drew, the Hardy Boys and Tom in the series, “Tom Swift and his
was quickly rebutted—real-world evidence Could things have been different? The Trump Swift is so off base it renders the Motor-Cycle, or Fun Adventures on
available even then from the U.K. showed high Administration’s Operation Warp Speed demon- goal ineffectual (“Dr. Seuss, Meet the the Road” was high tech in 1910, but
Sanitized Sleuths Known as the would hardly be considered so in
efficacy in the older cohort—but not before strated how a large government can use its fiscal
Hardy Boys,” op-ed, March 13). the midcentury “atomic age.” The
French President Emmanuel Macron picked up resources to fund R&D in a crisis. The U.K. and Briefly, the rewrites were primarily first in the next series “Tom Swift
the theme. Israel have shown that small countries can le- intended and executed to drive a new Jr. and his Flying Lab” was high
Such careless talk deterred vulnerable elderly verage regulatory nimbleness to sprint ahead. wave of sales by reinvigorating their tech in 1954 and set against a Cold
Europeans from accepting the vaccine last But somehow the European Union—a continent- appeal to the next generation. The War background. The first in the
month. It also skewed priority lists. Younger wide political bloc composed of smaller nation- assertion that many parents assumed current (2019) series, “Tom Swift
teachers and university professors in Italy re- states—managed to get the worst of both their children were reading the same Inventors’ Academy—The Drone Pur-
ceived jabs ahead of the ill and elderly under a worlds. It’s suffering the lumbering bureaucracy books they had read as children is suit” shows that the publisher
scheme developed when officials claimed the of a large government and the squabbling ineffi- hard to fathom, since the new books hasn’t lost touch with the business
shot wouldn’t work for the old. ciency of a small one. are a fraction of the size of their pre- at hand of selling books.
One problem is that no one seems to be fully Europeans can debate at their leisure whom decessors. The result is a more hip, SHAWN DILLES
current, and relevant product. I chal- Vienna, Va.
in charge of monitoring safety and efficacy. to blame for this and how to keep it from happen-
lenge readers to actually complete
Nominally that’s the EMA’s job, and the agency ing again. The rest of the world can only hope one of the earlier versions and then We need to learn that we don’t
handled it with typical eurocratic aplomb. The they get their vaccination act together soon. need to destroy classic literature to
create the new.
Lady Bird Johnson Reduced RICHARD E. RALSTON
Nasdaq’s Wish Is the U.K.’s Command Littering, Benefitting All Los Angeless
R
eaders will recall the many problems so any new rule would apply to banks, insurers, Judith Martin’s review of Julia
with Nasdaq’s recent proposal to add asset managers and the like. Mr. Rathi suggests Sweig’s “Lady Bird Johnson” (Books, What Would Twain Have
a board diversity provision to its list- a diversity mandate could be shoehorned into March 13) might have mentioned a
significant fact about Mrs. Johnson’s
Called Meghan and Harry?
ing rules for companies. Now comes the existing rules under which the FCA vets the
work: Her antilittering campaign was Regarding Peggy Noonan’s “Why
United Kingdom to see Nasdaq and raise its suitability of senior leaders at regulated firms.
dramatically and visibly effective. I We Care About the Royal Family
woke obligations. He says this would be appropriate based on re- was a boy in the 1960s and didn’t Feud” (Declarations, March 13): Ms.
The Nasdaq plan would encourage compa- search purporting to show diverse boards are care about flower beds, but I looked Noonan is absolutely correct when
nies listed on the exchange to maintain a quota better at risk management, although such re- out the car window while my par- she dismisses as utter nonsense
of board members who are women or ethnic or search is highly debatable. ents drove. America’s roadsides were Meghan Markle’s claim that, “As
sexual minorities. The U.S. stock exchange is Mr. Rathi also argues that more diverse lead- covered with trash. By 1969, after Americans especially what you do
trying to sweeten this unpopular pill by promis- ership would somehow help financial institu- major billboard and TV ad cam- know about the royals is what you
ing it would be optional. A company would ei- tions better serve minority communities. Ex- paigns (“Please, please, don’t be a read in fairy tales.” Apparently the
ther hit the quota or explain to shareholders pect this point to resonate in Washington, litterbug, ‘cause every litter bit duchess has never stood in a super-
why it hadn’t. where the Biden Administration and Jerome hurts”), they were not, and it was market line, where the rest of us
Britain’s financial regulator, the Financial largely due to Lady Bird Johnson. To are accosted with the royals’ doings
Powell’s Federal Reserve say they want to use
my mind this is still the most effec- through weekly tabloid headlines.
Conduct Authority, now wants to go one worse. their regulatory powers over the financial sys- tive first-lady project ever. Only One would be hard pressed to find a
“As part of our regulatory work on diversity and tem to achieve diversity goals. Betty Ford’s drive to lift the stigma source further removed from fairy
inclusion and the listings framework, we will Investors and company managers in the U.S. from treatment of substance abuse tales and happy endings.
be exploring whether we should make similar as well as U.K. are soon likely to discover that comes close. Lady Bird Johnson LISA LANE
requirements part of our premium listing there’s no such thing as a “voluntary” mandate. changed the daily habits of millions Gainesville, Ga.
rules,” FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi said Nasdaq says it will let companies opt out of its of Americans.
Wednesday of the Nasdaq plan. plan—at least until regulators decide to opt ev- DANIEL BERGER It’s ironic that two people who
The FCA primarily regulates financial firms eryone in anyway. Sandy Springs, Ga. fancy themselves as international
ambassadors can’t get along with
their own families.
Andrew Yang Takes On the Unions What Israel’s Covid Vaccine
Success Can Teach America
DONNA BALON
Las Vegas, Nev.
N
ew York City families have become un- three days or fewer a week in-person. The New Regarding Tunku Varadarajan’s I’m not sure we do care about
willing homeschoolers in the last year York Post reported Friday that about 70% of chil- “The Weekend Interview with Nach- what Mark Twain might have called
as the pandemic shutdowns stretch on dren in the New York City school system are still man Ash: How Israel Became the “The Prince and the Squawker.”
and on. Credit mayoral candi- exclusively remote. The Post World Vaccine Leader” (March 13): DAVID J. GROSS
date Andrew Yang for calling The candidate for mayor also reported in January that While it is true that the Kupat Holim St. Augustine, Fla.
out the teachers unions for de- system and its four insurance groups
priving children of opportuni-
dares to challenge the more than one in 10 students
were absent, and in 134 schools would be very hard to replicate in the
ties to learn in-person. school lockdowns. a quarter or more of the stu- U.S. healthcare system, that is really Pepper ...
no excuse for not having a more coor-
“I will confess to being a dents were missing from class.
dinated effort. Almost every large
And Salt
parent that has been frus- Wealthy parents can hire tu-
hospital system in the U.S. now has THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
trated by how slow our schools have been to tors or send children to private schools, but the an integrated electronic medical-re-
open, and I do believe that the UFT has been a learning loss for poor kids will result in dispari- cord system and has the ability to
significant reason why our schools have been ties that could last a lifetime. query databases to identify and reach
slow to open,” Mr. Yang told Politico, referring Mr. Yang also supports charter schools, out to patients based on age and
to New York City’s powerful United Federation which the unions have tried to destroy. “Unfor- chronic conditions.
of Teachers. tunately, I think the main argument [against Putting the onus on patients to
Mr. Yang is right. The UFT endorsed current charters] is a political one, where teachers register for vaccinations is where the
Mayor Bill de Blasio, and its parent union also unions hate charters,” he said in a 2019 inter- system has failed miserably.
gave $350,000 to the mayor’s nonprofit amid view. “Teachers’ unions are a very, very power- JOE WELFELD
Teaneck, N.J.
contract negotiations. Throughout the pan- ful constituency. And so some politicians have
demic, the UFT has driven the classroom clo- said ‘I’m better served by getting behind this
Letters intended for publication should
sures, leaving students and parents hostage to point of view.’” be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
their demands. Mr. Yang is leading in the early polls in this include your city, state and telephone
High schools will finally reopen Monday, fol- year’s mayoral race, and you can bet he’ll now number. All letters are subject to
lowing elementary and middle schools. Yet under be union enemy number one. New York’s par- editing, and unpublished letters cannot “If this doesn’t work
be acknowledged.
the “blended learning” system, students still get ents and children should be grateful. I’ll turn on the heat.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | A13
OPINION
W
you thought he was all out of ammo. big change after Covid, but maybe
e’re seeing some Some thoughts on Mr. Cuomo too it’s connected to this: The state’s
Grade A, first-class, from a long time observing him: budget is being negotiated. The Leg-
brass-knuckle politics He is in politics. He wants to win islature, increasingly under the sway
in the state of New and he wants to be the man in charge of the progressive left, wants sharply
York. Wednesday and he wants everyone to know his higher taxes on income, capital gains,
I
style derives from the project each. John Ashbery’s cryptic poem Such challenges render the “com- attention to the composition of
magine a group of bookish folk loosely known as deconstruction. “Self-Portrait in a Convex Mirror” mon pursuit” implausible in today’s book-prize short lists and the
sitting around having a conver- Conceived in Paris to address sub- doesn’t yield its meaning in the way literary climate. First-rate main- awarding of creative endowments is
sation about literature. Some jects relating to power and privilege a poem by Robert Frost does. But stream critics are still at work, in aware of how this new form of cor-
work in the English departments of in society, and to investigate their with persistence on the reader’s this journal and others, but concepts rection has become a leading driver
nearby universities. One ventures workings in the literary canon, it be- part, and insight from a helpful like taste and judgment have fallen in the way decisions are made.
the idea that “a performative model gan a takeover of English studies in critic, Ashbery’s poem opens onto a beneath the wheels of new watch- Some good may come of it, but be
of subject formation cannot be the 1980s. The reverberations are new aesthetic vista. All hail the words: wariness of “gatekeepers” frank about the fact that gender and
thought apart from its implication in felt today in the “decolonization” of critic, then, whose function, as Eliot (meaning, broadly, editors), for one. racial diversity are now essential
regulatory practices operating curricula—the latest step being the put it, is “the common pursuit of Any “correction,” the reasoning components in all areas of contem-
within discursive regimes that cir- banishing of allegedly “white su- true judgement and the correction goes, should have to do with “his- porary critical judgment. You can
cumscribe the ‘materiality’ of the premacist” ancient classics—and in of taste.” toric underrepresentation.” Here, call it the common pursuit of social
subject through the citationality of the toppling of statues and the re- How appealing it sounds. And the untrammeled imagination pres- justice. Or you could put it another
norms.” naming of schools. how obsolete. What our imaginary ents itself not as a fount of inven- way: Identity approval trumps criti-
What does it mean? Before anyone Until Jacques Derrida, Michel Fou- friends discussing “discursive re- tion but an instrument of oppres- cal approval.
can decide, another participant mus- cault and others revolutionized liter- gimes that circumscribe the ‘materi- sion. If the end is to correct an
cles in: “The foreclosure of the per- ary studies, specialist writing was re- ality’ of the subject” would make of unjust balance of power, the means Mr. Campbell was an editor and
formative in the Victorian novel,” he served for specialized disciplines— these terms can be guessed. Whose must involve the abolition of quaint columnist for the Times Literary
says, “is thus the condition of possi- abstract algebra, for example. But taste, after all? And who holds the concepts such as “taste.” Supplement for many years.
bility of its disciplined re-emergence literature by its nature resists mar-
as the illocutionary hallucination of ginalization. Since the time of Homer,
the performative as a material event
of subjectivity that emerges in a dis-
cursive nexus that can be generally
it has been the common cultural con-
versation. The greatest writers in
English, from Chaucer to Whitman by
Will We Be Ready if GPS Goes Down?
named ‘impersonation.’ ” way of Shakespeare and Dickens, By Diana Furchtgott-Roth national Airport not to hackers but based company, performed
G
have all been popular writers. Only in to competing wireless signals from particularly well in urban areas with
the 20th century did the notion of PS is vital to Americans, but a nearby sewage plant. “It’s scary to its Metropolitan Beacon System, a
Understanding literature literary elitism emerge, and only in hacking it has never been eas- be losing GPS a mile and half from terrestrial network of long-range
the second part of the century did ier. Protecting the civilian the runway,” Thomas Goodwin, a broadcast beacons. In rural and
was once a common critical inquiry begin its evolution to- Global Positioning System, an invisi- member of the Wilmington Pilots maritime areas, the Virginia-based
cultural pursuit. Now ward the kind of writing I quoted. ble utility the federal government Association, told me. Satelles displayed outstanding tim-
Since none but a few can understand pays for, falls to Transportation The Coast Guard collects reports ing and location solutions, delivered
it’s about political power. it, it must be the most elitist literary Secretary Pete Buttigieg. He would of gaps in GPS coverage all over the over the Iridium constellation of 66
genre ever known. do well to use the results of the world. Examples in the last months low-Earth-orbit satellites.
I have been drawn to literary criti- Transportation Department’s Janu- of 2020 include ships in the Medi- The stakes are high. Americans
You might think I’ve made this up. cism since books became central to ary report on technologies that can terranean and the Gulf of Suez, sur- use more than 900 million GPS re-
But while the group members don’t my existence. Critics as unalike as back up GPS and keep the country veyors in Wyoming’s Bull Lake Dam, ceivers. You’ll find them in cell-
exist, the sentences do. They are T.S. Eliot and Virginia Woolf guide moving in a pinch. and a driver in Seattle. phones, commercial trucks and
taken from a book published by Uni- the reader toward a wider apprecia- Three separate laws, most re- buses, and railroads. More than
versity of Michigan Press about “the tion than might otherwise be possi- cently the Frank LoBiondo Coast 100 million cars have navigation
novel.” I withhold the title and au- ble. In many cases, the critical writing Guard Authorization Act of 2018, The Transportation systems. Ships, planes and drones
thor’s name out of charity. These are is as engaging as the work under dis- assign the Transportation Depart- use GPS for navigation. Trucks use
examples of a way of writing common cussion. And it helps to keep the right ment the task of providing a backup Department has ideas GPS not only for location services
in academia. It is solipsistic, “perfor- words in the right order. “If there to GPS. The LoBiondo Act required for a backup, but it needs but also for electronic logging de-
mative”—one of its favorite expres- were better criticism, there would be the secretary to put in place a vices, which show whether drivers
sions—and sealed. No one speaks like better books,” Toni Morrison told the backup system by the end of 2020, money from Congress. have been driving for too long and
this and no one ever will. New Republic in 1981. but no funds were appropriated, so getting sleepy. Emergency respond-
Yet the book in question would It isn’t difficult to see how criti- the department couldn’t proceed. ers use GPS rather than maps to
have been peer-reviewed, like all cism gets a bad reputation. But a Although Congress hasn’t fol- Pokémon Go, the augmented-real- locate accident sites and get peo-
university press publications, and reader may thrill to the formalism of lowed through with the money, the ity game released in 2016, prompted ple to the hospital. You don’t want
was no doubt courteously received Alexander Pope on Monday and DOT’s new report lays out a road armies of teen hackers to spoof the to be waiting for the firetruck or
by the author’s friends. It is a form revel in the informality of Allen map. The department tested 11 tech- GPS on their phones, fudging their ambulance when GPS is hacked or
of writing that has brought exclusiv- Ginsberg on Tuesday, engaging with nologies that could be used in the real locations for advantage. A pro- disrupted.
absence of GPS signals, including gram called iMyFone AnyTo adver- John Deere tractors reduce agri-
terrestrial radio signals, fiber net- tises: “Change GPS Location on iOS cultural costs by pinpointing pre-
works for timing, Iridium satellites Device in 1 Click.” Criminals hijack cise locations to plant seeds, water
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY for encrypted signals, and Wi-Fi and trucks, steal cargo and ship stolen and fertilize. The construction in-
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp
cell signals for localization. This vehicles in containers by jamming dustry uses GPS to do the same
Matt Murray Almar Latour
isn’t a partisan issue. Congress GPS signals to disable tracking de- with nails and studs. Surveyors use
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher should allocate funds now. vices. Truckers interrupt port oper- GPS for measurements that are out
Neal Lipschutz Karen Miller Pensiero DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: GPS depends on satellites, which ations by using GPS jammers to de- of their line of sight, especially in
Deputy Editor in Chief Managing Editor Ramin Beheshti, Chief Technology Officer; can be damaged by electromagnetic feat fleet-tracking systems. waterways. Electric power plants
Jason Anders, Chief News Editor; Louise Story, Chief Kamilah Mitchell-Thomas, Chief People Officer; storms or military attack. Even with When the first computers went rely on the technology to synchro-
News Strategist, Product & Technology Officer Edward Roussel, Chief Innovation Officer; the satellites intact, hacking inci- on the market, no one saw a need nize generators and distribute en-
Thorold Barker, Europe; Elena Cherney, Coverage; Christina Van Tassell, Chief Financial Officer
dents proliferate, using inexpensive, for the now-ubiquitous antivirus ergy to the grid.
Andrew Dowell, Asia; Anthony Galloway, Video &
Audio; Brent Jones, Culture, Training & Outreach;
easily available hardware. software. Similarly, GPS was free Americans depend on GPS too
OPERATING EXECUTIVES:
Alex Martin, Print & Writing; Michael W. Miller, Jason P. Conti, General Counsel; In 2019 the British oil tanker from hacking in its early days, but much for the federal government to
Features & Weekend; Emma Moody, Standards; Frank Filippo, Print Products & Services; Stena Impero was lured into Iranian today it needs protection. “The best wait for it to fail. A reliable backup
Shazna Nessa, Visuals; Matthew Rose,
Kristin Heitmann, Chief Commercial Officer; waters in the Strait of Hormuz way to protect GPS and satellite is needed as soon as possible.
Enterprise; Michael Siconolfi, Investigations;
Stephen Wisnefski, Professional News
Nancy McNeill, Corporate Sales; while its GPS, “spoofed” by the Ira- systems is to focus on protection of
Thomas San Filippo, Customer Service; nians, told navigators it was in in- spectrum, tougher receivers and Ms. Furchtgott-Roth, former dep-
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large Josh Stinchcomb, Advertising Sales;
Paul A. Gigot, Editor of the Editorial Page;
ternational waters. The ship was augmenting sources of positioning, uty assistant secretary for research
Suzi Watford, Chief Marketing Officer;
Daniel Henninger, Deputy Editor, Editorial Page Jonathan Wright, International
captured and its crew imprisoned in navigation and timing,” says retired and technology at the U.S. Trans-
Iran for 10 weeks. Adm. Thad Allen, a former Coast portation Department, is an adjunct
WALL STREET JOURNAL MANAGEMENT:
Joseph B. Vincent, Operations; Professional Information Business: Some GPS interference is unin- Guard commandant. professor of economics at George
Larry L. Hoffman, Production Ingrid Verschuren, Deputy Head tentional. In January the Federal The Transportation Department Washington University.
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS: Aviation Administration traced pi- report concluded that multiple tech-
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 lots’ loss of GPS signal approaching nologies should be used to comple- Holman W. Jenkins, Jr. is away.
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES
North Carolina’s Wilmington Inter- ment GPS. NextNav, a California-
A14 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Spring in bloom
TECHNOLOGY |
EXCHANGE
MANAGEMENT
NASDAQ 13215.24 À 0.8% STOXX 600 423.35 g 0.8%
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
10-YR. TREAS. À 1/32 , yield 1.729%
* * * *
China to
Restrict
Tesla Use
By Military
BY KEITH ZHAI
AND YOKO KUBOTA
Fed to End
Emergency
Capital Break
For Banks
How Tech’s Triopoly Won BY ANDREW ACKERMAN
AND DAVID BENOIT
W
hen the pandemic up- ing on Facebook Inc., spotting a chance to holdings of those assets, both of
ended the economy last juice sales of its sweatpants to people stuck which could ripple through markets.
year, companies took a hard look at their at home. Office-furniture maker Steelcase Inc. built an opera- Analysts have been keying on the
advertising plans. tion to sell directly to workers and advertised aggressively on issue, which is widely viewed on Wall
Oreos maker Mondelez International Amazon.com Inc. Street as carrying potential implica-
Inc. shifted money meant for TV commer- The Big Three of digital advertising—Google, Facebook and tions for markets from bonds to
cials during March Madness basketball Amazon—already dominated that sector going into 2020. The stocks to commodities.
and the Summer Olympics into digital platforms. A hefty pandemic pushed them into command of the entire advertising Some analysts had warned that the
chunk went to Alphabet Inc.’s Google, which offered data on economy. According to a provisional analysis by ad agency exemption’s sunset could add to vola-
what locked-down snack lovers were searching for. GroupM, the three tech titans for the first time collected the tility in the $21 trillion market for U.S.
Athleisure company Vuori Inc. more than tripled its spend- Please turn to page B8 Please turn to page B13
Silicon Valley has a diversity problem, one Inc. and Foursquare Labs Inc., but increas-
that even Tristan Walker’s 4-year-old son ingly, he was seeing its limitations.
could see. “We definitely lost out on compelling tal-
RITA HARPER FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
In 2018, after making a trip to the super- ent,” says Mr. Walker, 36 years old. He de-
market with his father in Palo Alto, Calif., Mr. cided to move his family—and his company—
Walker’s son observed, “Palo Alto is where all to the majority-Black city of Atlanta instead.
the white people are.” In recent years, companies have moved
It was a moment that struck Mr. Walker, their headquarters out of the suburbs and
who is Black, not just as a father—but as a downtown to court younger workers. Now
CEO. As the head of Walker & Co. Brands, a more companies are adding new office foot-
startup making personal-care products for prints as a way to recruit ethnically diverse
people of color, he’d noticed it was sometimes talent, too. Atlanta, in particular, has drawn a
hard to recruit people to come to Silicon Val- number of boldfaced names, many in tech.
ley. The area was expensive, and not particu- Microsoft Corp. is investing $75 million in an
larly diverse. Mr. Walker had been drawn Atlanta facility it says will create 1,500 jobs.
there in 2008 and worked at both Twitter Please turn to page B6 Tristan Walker, above with his elder son, Avery, moved his company and family to Atlanta.
B2 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
THE SCORE
THE BUSINESS WEEK IN 7 STOCKS
–2 Hilton
AMAZON.COM INC. Worldwide FEDEX CORP. JPMORGAN CHASE & CO.
–4 Holdings
Losing Dollars
By Pinching
Pennies
Corporate America keeps costing itself big
by not preparing for trouble
This time a year success: It was able to quadruple
ago, Navin Katyal’s normal production rates of nine
phone wouldn’t stop drugs that were in especially high
ringing. demand. But for its customers, it
The head of was too late to avoid the damage.
Pfizer’s North Ameri- No stockpiles of essential medicines
can hospital unit, or personal protective equipment
which sells 165 medications like an- for medical staff made the early
tibiotics, analgesics and sedatives stages of the pandemic deadlier and
for patients on ventilators, was re- more disruptive than it otherwise
ceiving the same message from his might have been.
thousands of customers as Covid-19 The situation also wreaked finan-
DAN PAGE
BUSINESS NEWS
Amazon
Beefs Up
Amazon Targets TV-Ad Spending
BY SAHIL PATEL
AMAZON/EVERETT COLLECTION
which has had a mixed record tising business, chasing only
luring foreign partners to help Google and Facebook, it is a
it wean its economy off oil. move that could help Amazon
Alphabet Inc.’s Google and secure a commanding position
China’s Alibaba Group Holding in the future of TV ad sales.
Ltd. have recently announced Amazon said adding exclu-
partnerships with Saudi state- sive NFL games will encourage
owned companies to host people to sample its original
cloud centers. Huawei Tech- content. But as pandemic lock- The tech giant has ordered a spinoff of one of its most popular Amazon Prime series, the detective drama ‘Bosch,’ for IMDb TV.
nologies Co. has said it would downs turbocharge the growth
open its largest flagship store of streaming TV, the heir appar- ing agencies’ spending with TV advertising spending U.S. market share of ways. Its 2019 streaming car-
outside China in Riyadh. ent to traditional TV’s $70 bil- Amazon, executives at the firms Internet- Traditional TV streaming media players, riage pact with Disney, for ex-
Amazon’s bet is also notable lion ad market, Amazon also said. The business includes ads connected TV third quarter of 2020* ample, let it package and sell
coming after a feud between has been striving to expand its Amazon sells on its own some Hulu ad inventory for the
founder Jeff Bezos and Saudi offerings for marketers. It has streaming services, such as $80 billion Roku first time, people familiar with
Arabian Crown Prince Moham- struck deals to put IMDb TV, its IMDb TV; ad inventory it sells Projections 38% the matter said.
med bin Salman spilled into free and ad-supported stream- in other apps it carries on its And in recent months, Ama-
public in recent years. Critical ing service, into more homes; Fire TV platform; and ad sales 60 Amazon Fire TV zon has expanded IMDb TV’s
columns written by Saudi dissi- ordered a spinoff of one of its rights for live sports it already 33% distribution to Roku, Google
dent journalist Jamal Khashoggi most popular Amazon Prime se- carries. That includes simul- Chromecast and Android TV de-
in the Washington Post, which ries, the detective drama casts of “Thursday Night Foot- 40
Apple TV vices. IMDb TV will be available
Mr. Bezos bought in 2013 as a “Bosch,” for IMDb TV, along ball” that are part of an ar- 13% on all major streaming devices
personal investment, sowed with commissioning other origi- rangement that precedes the by the end of the first quarter,
frustration in Riyadh. nal content. new deal between Amazon and Chromecast the Amazon executive said.
Its moves have helped ex- the NFL. 20
Mr. Khashoggi was murdered 10% Amazon doesn’t break out its
by Saudi operatives in 2018. pand Amazon’s U.S. ad-sup- Advertisers, meanwhile, are streaming-TV ad revenue,
The U.S. last month declassified ported streaming footprint to buying more in streaming TV, Other which makes it difficult to com-
a report that accused the prince more than 55 million monthly especially on internet-con- 0 pare the tech giant with others.
6%
of approving the killing. Prince active viewers as of January, up nected sets, where U.S. ad 2019 ’20 ’21 ’22 ’23 In streaming TV, Amazon’s
Mohammed has said he took re- from 20 million a year earlier, spending will total nearly $13.41 *For media players that get connected to TVs; doesn’t include smart TVs.
most direct point of comparison
sponsibility for the killing be- said an Amazon executive, who billion this year, up from nearly Sources: eMarketer (ad spending); Parks Associates (media players) is Roku. Amazon has become
cause it happened on his watch, was provided by the company $9.03 billion in 2020, according the second-biggest streaming-
but denied ordering it. on the condition that the execu- to research firm eMarketer. tage in the ad wars. Beyond ex- “IMDb TV right now is TV hardware provider in the
In 2019, Mr. Bezos suggested tive wouldn’t be named. “Marketers who are selling panding its previous, more mostly aggregating other peo- U.S., accounting for 33% of de-
a possible Saudi government Amazon still lags well behind products on Amazon now have limited rights to simulcast ple’s content—in terms of vices in households in the third
link to a leak of embarrassing the streaming-advertising a different avenue to reach con- “Thursday Night Football,” in what’s unique, there is very lit- quarter of 2020, behind Roku at
personal photos, an allegation leader, Walt Disney Co.’s Hulu, sumers outside of Ama- which Amazon sold some of the tle at the moment,” said Susan 38%, according to research firm
Saudi Arabia has denied. The and a more direct distribution zon.com’s e-commerce plat- ad time, and the announced Schiekofer, chief digital invest- Parks Associates. But the gap is
Wall Street Journal reported rival, Roku Inc. But the vast form,” said Sal Candela, spinoff of “Bosch” for IMDb TV, ment officer for the ad-buying greater when it comes to
the brother-in-law of Mr. Be- consumer data it owns as a re- president of U.S. investment at it is considering other IMDb TV giant GroupM, part of WPP PLC. streaming-TV ad revenue: In
zos’ girlfriend Lauren Sanchez sult of its e-commerce business Omnicom Media Group. “It’s offshoots of Prime shows. Amazon has told ad buyers 2020, three top ad-buying firms
leaked the photos. Mr. Sanchez could boost its ambitions in generally more advantageous It also has explored bringing that they would be able to bun- spent twice as much on Roku
has denied that. streaming TV. Amazon’s that they have an opportunity to IMDb TV past seasons of dle inventory from its Twitch than Amazon in streaming TV,
In 2018, before the murder, streaming-TV ad sales grew through video, and the big piece original Prime series like “The video service with other according to senior executives
Amazon was in talks to build faster in 2020 than its more-es- of glass in their living rooms.” Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.” Last streaming-TV ad inventory at those firms. And Hulu is far
data centers in Saudi Arabia tablished ad segments such as One of Amazon’s biggest year, Amazon also established a within Amazon’s ad-buying tool ahead of both, receiving 10
that would have given Amazon search and display, albeit from challenges is offering enough dedicated team within its Ama- later in 2021, people familiar times as much in ad spend as
more access to the Middle East- a much smaller base, according high-quality programming to zon Studios unit to produce with the matter said. Currently, Amazon in the category, the se-
ern market and aided the to a person familiar with the capture more ad spend. original programming for IMDb Twitch inventory is available nior executives said.
prince’s efforts to cultivate new, company’s ad business. Stream- It is trying to turn its Prime TV, with plans to release about separately from supply sources.
non-oil industries. The plan ing TV now comprises roughly Video, its mostly ad-free sub- a dozen titles this year, accord- Amazon has been building Heard on the Street: The NFL
hasn’t yet moved forward. 15% to 20% of two top ad-buy- scription service, to its advan- ing to the Amazon executive. its streaming business in other moves the ball........................ B14
EXCHANGE
TAX REPORT | LAURA SAUNDERS
Families Dig Up
New Tax Breaks
The latest stimulus act includes rebates, credits
and deductions—if you know where to look
KIERSTEN ESSENPREIS
signed by President rebate credits worth $8,400 when
Biden this month they file their 2021 tax return next
contains unprece- year. They’ll also likely get full ex-
dented benefits for tra child credits of $5,200 that
families with children would be clipped if their income
and other dependents—especially were higher, bringing them $13,600
for some who plan carefully. of tax-free income this year from
The new benefits, which apply these new breaks. to the existing child credit of up to head-of-household filers. 50 could reduce their AGI by more
for 2021, are largest for low-income “I have four children, a mortgage $2,000 per child, which this year Dependent-care FSA contribu- than $50,000 by making maximum
families, but they extend well into and two car payments. My wife is a applies to dependents who are un- tions don’t have income limits 401(k) and flexible-spending-ac-
the middle class, with many eligible nurse. We need these benefits, and der 18 at year-end, versus under 17 other than the lower-earning count contributions for 2021.
for more than $10,000 in tax-free I didn’t want to miss out because in other years. spouse’s earned income. So if one If a filer reports self-employment
income for this year. Higher earn- of a Covid withdrawal,” says Mr. Starting July 1, taxpayers may spouse earns, say, $5,000, then the income on Schedule C, business de-
ers can also benefit from some Peterson. receive advance payments of part couple can’t put more into the FSA. ductions could also reduce AGI.
changes, such as expanded tax For those earning above the of these benefits from the IRS. De- Employers must also ensure that
breaks for child-care costs. thresholds for 2021, there are still tails haven’t been announced. plans don’t favor higher earners Revisit FSAs versus child- and
The design of these provisions benefits. The new law more than Workers with employer-spon- too much. dependent-care credits. In prior
creates powerful incentives for doubles the usual $5,000-per- sored dependent-care FSAs can The 2021 child-and-dependent- years many higher-bracket taxpay-
many families to pay close atten- household annual limit on pretax contribute up to $10,500 of pretax care credit has a complex phase- ers with two or more children ben-
tion to their 2021 adjusted gross contributions to employer-spon- income to pay care expenses in down of the rate and phase-out efited from maxing out dependent-
income. Some of this year’s best sored dependent-care Flexible 2021, versus $5,000 normally. The based on income. According to Me- care FSAs and then taking the
benefits phase out above certain in- Spending Accounts this year. It employer must opt into this lissa Labant, an attorney and CPA dependent- and child-care credit
come thresholds: $150,000 for mar- also includes a complex expansion change, but many are expected to. with the accounting firm CLA, the for remaining eligible care ex-
ried couples filing jointly, $112,500 of the child-and-dependent-care The child- and dependent-care credit phases down from 50% to penses. Expenses can be claimed
for head-of-household filers and tax credit. credit has also been expanded so 20% of expenses for most joint fil- only once.
$75,000 for single filers. Here’s information to help max- that up to $8,000 of expenses are ers with incomes between $125,000 The expansion of the 2021 child-
As a result, people who are likely imize the new 2021 tax benefits covered for one dependent (up and $183,000. Above $183,000 the and-dependent-care credit compli-
to earn above the limits may want for families. from $3,000) and up to $16,000 rate is 20% until $400,000, and cates this analysis. However, FSA
to legally reduce this year’s income are covered for two or more (up then the rate drops until the break contributions retain the advantages
to fit within them, and those nor- Understand the third-round stim- from $6,000). is fully phased out at $438,000. of not being subject to payroll
mally earning less may want to ulus payments. For many families taxes or, in many cases, state taxes.
prevent an income spike that could the most generous 2021 benefit is Watch phaseouts. For stimulus Know what income counts—and They can also be used for a wider
cost them dearly. the third-round stimulus payments payments and rebate credits, the what reduces it. The income thresh- range of expenses.
Here’s a real-life example of how or rebate credits up to $1,400 per phase-out is steep. The range is olds are for “modified adjusted Figuring which benefit is most
the limits can drastically affect a household member, even for older $150,000 to $160,000 for married gross income,” but for most filers valuable at what income levels can
family’s finances. Patrick and Laura children and adult dependents. joint filers; $112,500 to $120,000 that means their AGI on Line 11 of be difficult, says Ms. Labant, espe-
Peterson live in Aston, Pa., and The Internal Revenue Service is for head-of-household filers; and Form 1040. Beware: AGI is not re- cially because some states have
have four children, ages 2, 3, 5 and sending payments now, but people $75,000 to $80,000 for single filers. duced by itemized deductions, such care credits as well.
8. Last year Mr. Peterson, a bank who aren’t eligible based on 2019 For this year’s extra child cred- as for mortgage interest or charita- By her rough calculations, many
manager, took a $33,000 taxable or 2020 income and do qualify its, the taxpayer loses $50 of credit ble contributions, or by tax credits. married joint filers with incomes of
Covid withdrawal from his retire- based on 2021 income can get re- per $1,000 of income above the What does reduce AGI? Contri- $150,000 or less will benefit more
ment plan as an emergency cush- bate credits for these amounts next phaseout starting point. Thus a butions to retirement plans such as from the child-care credit, while
ion. That boosted their 2020 in- year through their 2021 tax returns. couple with $200,000 of income, 401(k)s; tax-deductible contribu- those earning above $160,000 typi-
come high enough above $150,000 four children and $5,200 of extra tions to IRAs and SEP IRAs; pretax cally should look first to the FSA.
to disqualify them from six third- Know the other child-related credits would lose $2,500 of credits contributions to health savings ac- But many couples will need to run
round stimulus payments of $1,400 changes this year. The extra child due to the phase-out. For the exist- counts; and pretax contributions to the numbers to find out.
after Mr. Peterson filed their 2020 tax credit is up to $1,600 per child ing child tax credit, the phase-out medical or dependent-care flexible She adds: “Maybe these parents
tax return in early February. under 6 and $1,000 per child under still begins at $400,000 for joint spending accounts, among other have children that can double-check
Because the Petersons’ income 18 at year-end. This is in addition filers and $200,000 for single and things. A married couple under age their math.”
EXIT INTERVIEW | MICHAEL CORBAT WSJ: What do you mean by that? ranking Black men on Wall Street.
Mr. Corbat: When you go through Was that important to you?
W
holders a $900 million payment, talked about is you’ve got to create
and several of them refused to the continuum. It’s not just about
hen Citigroup Inc. send you the money back. What recruiting the new class…but it’s
named Michael was your reaction when you found about retention and at the end,
Corbat chief execu- out? having people in leadership that
tive in 2012, every- Mr. Corbat: I think there’s always people can aspire to. I think one of
one was surprised. frustration with those. In the case the legacies is we’ve publicly and
Including him. of Revlon, it was an error, and consciously pushed ourselves.
He had recently moved to Lon- they are never simple. It’s not sim- We’ve been out there and I think
don for what he believed was his ply that a single person hit a as a result, we’ve moved the firm.
last job, running the bank’s opera- wrong button. It’s a series of And, again, nobody is where they
tions in Europe, the Middle East things that happened along the want to be, but I feel really good
and Africa. He had told his wife, way. As part of that, we are in the about where we are.
Donna, he was a few years away midst of a complete changeover of
from retirement. those systems. And you would al- WSJ: What are you most proud of?
Then CEO Vikram Pandit quit ways go back and say, woulda, Mr. Corbat: I guess I would have to
just after a board meeting. Direc- coulda we gone faster? I think the say Jane’s ascendancy. I was one
tors, anxious about the bank’s re- answer is it would have been re- of the people who hired Jane. I in-
covery from the financial crisis, ally hard if not impossible to move terviewed Jane. I’ve been in and
called on Mr. Corbat, who had de- it faster. around at the decision points, so
veloped a reputation as a fix-it to speak, in terms of most of her
man. The announcement the fol- WSJ: Before CEOs making socially job moves and in terms of prepar-
lowing morning stunned the finan- conscious statements became ing her for this. The fact that we
cial world in its abruptness. commonplace, you spoke up for can do this, and by the way, not do
“I’m kind of the Monday morn- racial equity after a white-nation- this because Jane is a female, but
ing ‘go figure it out’ CEO,” Mr. alist rally in Charlottesville, Va. to do this because Jane is the
STEVEN MOLINA CONTRERAS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Corbat said. What was behind that? most qualified person within our
Mr. Corbat, 60 years old, was Mr. Corbat: The Charlottesville institution and we can put our
never the prototype of a big bank event was, in some ways for me, a hand on our heart and say that. I
CEO. He rarely spoke about him- bit of a watershed moment. We don’t think you’re going to get
self and didn’t draw the spotlight. absolutely condemned it. I remem- anyone within our firm to say oth-
Yet, he is credited with strength- ber having a conversation about erwise or anyone who has spent
ening the nation’s third-biggest putting out a note to our people time with her.
bank, simplifying its operations and, candidly at the time, naively, I
and improving its results even as kind of pushed back. I said, “Re- WSJ: What do you do next?
profits and the share price lagged ally? Did our people really think Mr. Corbat: Donna [his wife] has
behind rivals’ and a series of new that we may be in a different posi- declared “What’s next” to be my
crises emerged, including recent tion than we are on this?” And, gap year. I kind of graduated from
regulatory scrutiny. “We really need to speak out on college on a Friday, I came to work
Unlike his immediate predeces- this?” And the answer was yes. on Monday and I’ve been here ever
sors, Mr. Corbat left on his own And we did it. And I saw the insti- since. The conversations I’ve had
terms. He succeeded in giving his tution come back and really take a and the advice I’ve been given
successor, Jane Fraser, a carefully ‘I’m kind of the Monday morning “go figure it out” CEO,’ Mr. Corbat said. deep breath and feel good. The have been remarkably consistent:
orchestrated transfer of power fact that we took that voice and Take some time off and decom-
when he retired in February after reaffirmed it with our people and press. You’re likely more tired
more than 37 years at the bank, Mr. Corbat: I inherited my position think we were able to tick all our clients was important. than you know you are. I’m really
the only place he ever worked. at a very interesting time. It was those boxes. From that point, if you want to curious to see what I’m going to
Before his final day, Mr. Corbat really coming out of the financial call it the “aha” moment, it was miss most. I have some guesses,
spoke to The Wall Street Journal crisis. We had gone through a tre- WSJ: Was there a moment in selectively with things where we around people, around clients.
about Citigroup’s crises, leadership mendous amount of restructuring, those early days where you ques- felt, one, our voice could make a What are those things I want to
lessons and legacies of his eight- a lot of which I had led, and I tioned what you got yourself into? difference, and, two, we wanted to replicate and where do I want to
year tenure. Questions and an- think the question was could we Mr. Corbat: I went into it eyes reaffirm appropriately who we are spend my time? I have just be-
swers have been edited for clarity restore the pride in the organiza- wide open. I won’t say there were and what we stand for. come a grandfather. I’m young. I
and length. —David Benoit tion. Could we really go back and big surprises. But I think, realisti- love the outdoors. So how do I use
reassert strong customer relation- cally, the challenges that were WSJ: You are being succeeded by this next chapter to create better
WSJ: When you look back at your ships and customer dominance and there weren’t necessarily the ones the first woman to run a Wall balance for my life because for
time as CEO, what will you tell could we gain share? And could we externally that were thought Street bank, and your CFO was Donna and I it’s been full-on for
people you accomplished? do those things responsibly? I about. Mark Mason, among the highest- the last eight years.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | B5
WEEKEND INVESTOR
Financial innova- artist who created it.
tions often feel like “It’s so amazing that even if it
insanity at first. Pay gets traded 10 or 20 times or
bills with a piddly more, I’ll still be getting my fee for
piece of plastic? Get it,” Ms. Bellini says. “That’s totally
cash from a faceless not how the art world has worked
machine rather than until now.”
a bank teller? Stop trying to beat Earlier this month, Mario Gabri-
the market and just own all the ele, an investment analyst and
stocks, including the bad ones? newsletter writer, prepared to turn
Yet credit cards, ATMs and in- his research report on cryptocur-
dex funds went on to make the fi- rency trading platform Coinbase
nancial world easier, safer and Global Inc. into an NFT. “Tokeniz-
more convenient for millions of ing” the report, illustrated by digi-
people. One of the nuttiest-sound- tal artist Jack Butcher (who
ing ideas in years, NFTs, could do earned half the initial proceeds),
the same. quickly raised nearly $36,000 in
You’ve heard of nonfungible to- ether.
kens even if you don’t yet know For that, the 119 backers each
what they are—because the people got tokens they may be able to ex-
buying them sound so crazy. In change for ether, now that Mr. Ga-
February, an NFT representing the briele has opened an auction for
Nyan Cat video meme, which looks access to the NFT of his research.
like a feline Pop-Tart dragging a If buyers of the report pay more
rainbow through outer space, sold than Mr. Gabriele’s supporters al-
for more than $500,000. A video ready put in, then the original
NFT of LeBron James dunking a backers will share in those pro-
basketball sold for $208,000. On ceeds—and in future sales as well.
March 11, an NFT attached to a Mr. Gabriele’s goal, he says, is to
digital collage by the artist known put investment research “within
as Beeple sold at Christie’s for $69 the reach of those who don’t have
million. a multimillion corporate research
Although such prices are baf- THE INTELLIGENT INVESTOR | JASON ZWEIG budget to deploy.”
fling—and may, in fact, be crazy— Because NFTs are so new, using
NFTs could solve problems that them isn’t cheap.
have dogged the art world and
other markets for centuries. Think
of a nonfungible token as a unique
digital serial number that certifies
The Method to the Madness On OpenSea, an online market-
place, the typical NFT changes
hands for the equivalent of $100
to $1,000, says Devin Finzer, the
the authenticity and ownership
history of an associated object.
That information, along with
other data, is recorded on a block-
Of a $69 Million Art Sale firm’s co-founder and chief execu-
tive. But transaction costs on the
cryptocurrency to fund those pur-
chases run roughly $40 to $60. So
chain. This is a ledger, or immuta- small buyers incur giant expenses.
ble record, that resides on a de- ‘NFTs’ could solve an age-old art-world problem. But, yeah, that price is nuts. (OpenSea also charges a 2.5% fee
centralized network of computers of its own.)
world-wide. The blockchain tech- “That’s why the high-value
nology underpins bitcoin and things make a lot of sense for buy-
ethereum, the leading cryptocur- Corot genuine or a forgery? Who lenges remain to be solved. who majored in finance in college ers who can afford them,” says Mr.
rencies. Any of the ledger’s mil- were its previous owners? Has it With NFTs, all the relevant and worked briefly at an invest- Finzer.
lions of users can instantly verify ever been exhibited at a museum knowledge about a work of art ment-advisory firm. Since late Are buyers getting carried
that the information is accurate or previously sold at auction? Was “can be permanently systematized, 2018, she has sold about 300 of away?
and complete. it ever seriously damaged and ex- automated and accessible by any- her paintings this way. “I’m sure that some of this is a
By connecting the blockchain to tensively restored? body,” says Noah Davis, the spe- One of her NFTs, a dazzling dig- bubble,” says Ms. Bellini, the Chi-
art and other creative work, NFTs Until now, buyers often had to cialist in postwar and contempo- ital work titled “Yours Truly #0,” cago-based artist. “Sometimes
bring the objectivity of computer take the answers to such questions rary art at Christie’s in New York is on sale by its current owner, an [buyers] just hear it’s cool and
code to fields that are notorious on faith. An NFT, however, can in- who arranged the $69 million sale account called BitBuzz, for 250 good and they don’t even know
for subjectivity. Artists, writers tegrate reams of information of Beeple’s work. ether. That’s a cryptocurrency, what an NFT is, but they want to
and musicians struggle to find au- about an artwork into an authori- Some people in the art world worth a total of about $450,000. buy anyway, and I think some of
diences and make a living. Cura- tative, permanent digital record. see the explosion in NFTs as “ab- Ms. Bellini, who sold the NFT for those people are going to get
tors, dealers, collectors and art Today, for the most part, NFTs solutely absurd and appalling,” he 50 ether in February 2020, will re- hurt.”
historians bicker nonstop about are linked to digital assets like says. “But I studied the theater of ceive a 5% royalty if it sells—now NFTs bring objectivity to the
the quality and value—and the au- electronic images or audio and the absurd in college, and I don’t and anytime again in the future. objects being sold, but they can’t
thenticity—of major works. video files. People are already ex- think it’s ridiculous at all. I think Typically, when an NFT is bring it to the buyers of the ob-
Consider the French artist Jean- perimenting with tying physical it’s inevitable.” traded on the blockchain, that net- jects, because those are human be-
ings. In the long run, I think NFTs
ALEX NABAUM
Baptiste-Camille Corot, who was objects to blockchain records of NFTs also are giving creative work won’t allow a sale and pur-
jokingly said to have painted 3,000 ownership, which would make people an ownership stake they’ve chase to be completed without for- will make markets better. But
canvases, 10,000 of which were NFTs feasible for material assets— never had before. Consider Josie warding the predetermined royalty nothing will remove bettors from
bought in the U.S. Is a particular although some technical chal- Bellini, an artist based in Chicago to the wallet, or account, of the markets.
You know
the feeling
when you actually
wake up early to
work out?
Rolling over your old 401k can bring you that same sense of satisfaction—without the alarm clock. Our team of
rollover specialists will walk you through the process step by step, and even call your old provider. We do the
heavy lifting so you can focus on feeling accomplished.
Visit tdameritrade.com/rollover to get started today.
A rollover is not your only alternative when dealing with old retirement plans. Please visit tdameritrade.com/rollover for more information on rollover alternatives.
TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC. © 2020 TD Ameritrade.
B6 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
EXCHANGE
Seek Diverse
and San Francisco, and often in cities with a lower cost of living, such as Atlanta. EMPLOYMENT
one it plans to expand to several
More than 10%
hundred employees, the location Major metro areas where tech jobs are increasing the most
8% to 10%
was “an opportunity to make mani-
Cities
COST OF LIVING, 2020 Less than 8%
fest our commitment around diver-
sity,” Laphonza Butler, Airbnb’s
50% of New York City 60 70 80 90 100
North America public policy direc-
tor, said in an interview. The move, Austin
Continued from page B1 she says, is part of Airbnb’s pledge Baltimore
Alphabet Inc.’s Google is investing to have 20% of U.S. employees come In a state with a Orlando Atlanta
more than $25 million there this from underrepresented minorities relatively high
year, expanding its existing three- by 2025. tech-talent Raleigh
Tampa Washington, New York
floor office to a new location where McKinsey research points to a diversity score Miami D.C. City
Dallas
the company will eventually occupy geographic mismatch between Black Charlotte
19 floors. talent and economic opportunity.
“I have two young Black boys,” Less than 9% of Blacks live in the Phoenix San Diego
says Mr. Walker, who moved in West, where most new job creation Cincinnati Philadelphia San Jose
April 2019. “I wanted them to grow in tech has been concentrated. Medium tech-talent Boston
up in an environment where they Nearly 60% live in the South. Bryan diversity score Kansas City San Francisco
can see the richness of the Black ex- Hancock, a McKinsey partner who Chicago Los Angeles
perience.” His older son, he says, leads the company’s work on talent
now attends school with many management, notes that in addition
Portland
Black teachers, Black classmates to new office locations, more re-
Low tech-talent Seattle
and a Black head of school. mote work post-Covid could also Denver
diversity score Salt Lake
A wellspring of the civil-rights open up opportunities for diverse City Detroit
Minneapolis
movement, Atlanta is not only the talent.
birthplace of Martin Luther King “We couldn’t fulfill [Airbnb’s di- Note: Includes areas with an increase of at least 2,000 tech jobs from 2018 to 2019. Tech-talent diversity score estimates the proportion of Black, Hispanic and female students
Jr., it’s also home to 16 Fortune 500 versity goals] just by having our pursuing STEM or STEM-related degrees in 2018. Cost of living includes rent.
companies, including Coca-Cola Co. company headquarters in San Fran- Source: Bhaskar Chakravorti, Digital Planet, The Fletcher School, Tufts University Kara Dapena/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
and Home Depot Inc. It has a thriv- cisco or London,” says Ms. Butler.
ing startup scene, as well as a half- “We needed to consider places that
dozen historically Black colleges looked very different to get the re- “We see diversity as a business Among his clients, more than half “Our largest export is our culture,”
and universities. For tech compa- sults we needed.” imperative,” says Toretha McGuire, now cite diversity as a top criterion says Mr. Wilson, who grew up in
nies seeking to diversify, that’s a Some expansion plans have long BlackRock’s global head of talent when choosing new locations, he Atlanta in an entrepreneurial Black
particular draw: HBCUs graduate been in the pipeline. Others fol- acquisition. The company plans to says: “It’s a real shift from what we family, with parents who owned a
40% of Black STEM graduates, even lowed the death of Mr. Floyd and scale up to 1,000 Atlanta hires. “De- saw 25 years ago, when companies call-center business. “The people
though they educate just 3% of col- the ensuing protests. mographics and available talent relocated primarily to reduce cost who make that culture have to be
lege students, says Mary Schmidt In 2020, Gong, a Bay Area-based definitely played a part in our deci- and head count.” able to live here.”
Campbell, president of Spelman sales-analysis software company, sion,” she says of its expansion. Melonie Parker, Google’s chief di-
College, an Atlanta-based HBCU. was planning to add a second U.S. In the 1990s, when Ángel Cabrera ‘Too Busy to Hate’ versity officer, says the company is
“If I’m looking around, trying to location, one with cheaper real es- attended Atlanta’s Georgia Institute Companies putting down Atlanta mindful of such concerns, and is
think where I can settle and find di- tate and a less competitive talent of Technology as a cognitive-psy- roots say they’re also drawn to the working with community groups to
verse talent, Atlanta is like a neon market. It was ready to announce chology graduate student, the land city’s history of progressivism. The support training local small busi-
light,” she says. The city is 51% Salt Lake City as its destination abutting the campus’s east side was city’s race relations were helped nesses. Google currently has 600
Black; by contrast, around 2% of Sil- when Covid hit, putting that an- surface parking lots, he recalls. early on by politicians like former Atlanta employees and plans to sub-
icon Valley is Black. nouncement on pause. A few Now, it’s home to innovation cen- Mayor William Hartsfield, who stantially increase its hiring, part of
With the broader business boom, ters for investment firm Invesco hired the city’s first Black police of- the commitment it made last sum-
some fear locals will be pushed out. Ltd. and several Fortune 1000 com- ficers in 1948. “He didn’t want to mer to more than double the num-
Residential housing prices were up ‘It’s just a vibe and a panies. “This place is rocking,” says see our city looking like Birming- ber of Black Googlers by 2025 and
19% in the last quarter of 2020 over Mr. Cabrera, who moved back in ham or Little Rock,” says Ingrid invest in locations providing a
the previous year, according to data visual that says, “I can 2019 to serve as university presi- Saunders Jones, a retired Coca-Cola “high quality of life” for such em-
from the National Association of achieve,” ’ says a Black dent. executive who worked as executive ployees.
Realtors. In 2019 alone, metro At- Atlanta has plenty to crow about, assistant from 1979 to 1981 to At- Ms. Parker, who is Black, recalls
lanta grew by more than 75,000 Atlanta executive. he says. As Delta Air Lines Inc.’s lanta’s first Black mayor, Maynard that when she first arrived in Sili-
residents. The metro-area popula- hub, it has the nation’s busiest air- Jackson, whose administration con Valley, she struggled to find a
tion is now about 6 million. Janice port, and with the Centers for Dis- made promoting minority contrac- place to worship and do her hair.
Overbeck, a Keller Williams Realtor, months later, shortly after Mr. ease Control and Prevention head- tors a priority. What makes an employee thrive
says around 40% of the clients she Floyd was killed, Gong scrapped its quartered there, he says, a “Those things differentiated us isn’t just company culture, she
and colleagues see are from out of plans and picked a new destination: burgeoning biotech industry as well. and began changing the trajectory,” says—it’s the environs as well.
state, up from a relative handful Atlanta. Calendly LLC, a Black-founded local she says, helping build a more pros- Atlanta has a higher retention
five years ago. “We were like, time out,” recalls startup offering an online schedul- perous Black middle class. During rate for Black employees than
Atlanta has experienced its own Sandi Kochhar, the company’s head ing tool, just received a $350 million the civil-rights era, the city became Google’s other offices, and internal
racial tensions in the past year. The of HR. “Salt Lake City isn’t really a private-equity investment, valuing it known by the nickname “The City surveys show higher engagement
fatal police shooting of a Black man diverse talent pool from a race per- at $3 billion. Two of Peloton Inter- Too Busy to Hate.” levels for such workers, too, she
in a Wendy’s parking lot in June spective. Is this the decision we active Inc.’s founders graduated Deisha Barnett, who grew up in says.
prompted the resignation of the want to make?” The company began from Georgia Tech, which has made southern New Jersey, vividly recalls In 2016, music-streaming com-
city’s police chief and sparked mass hiring last year for dozens of At- itself an anchor of the startup scene. being struck by Atlanta when she pany Pandora vowed to increase di-
protests. The city had already been lanta roles and increased minority Since 2014, Create-X, its incubator first arrived on a college tour in the versity and make 45% of its U.S.
rocked by a wave of protests the recruitment. Since January 2020, for student ventures, has launched 1990s. “You see a lot of Black peo- workforce people of color by 2020.
previous month, after George Floyd Black employees have gone from 230 startups valued at over $600 ple in nice cars, it’s just a vibe and Two years later, it set up an Atlanta
was killed in Minneapolis police 1.4% to 4.3% of the company’s 370 million; of its most recent founder a visual that says, ‘I can achieve,’ ” office, which today has more than
custody. Atlanta’s mayor, who is U.S. employees. cohort, 21% are Black or Latino. says Ms. Barnett, who attended 200 employees. Given the area’s di-
Black, called for an end to the Asset-management company Atlanta’s demographic profile— Clark Atlanta University and in 2014 versity and rich cultural scene, the
“chaos” of those sometimes-violent BlackRock Inc., which opened an its metro-area Black population is moved back when her husband got move was a “no-brainer,” says Ni-
demonstrations. And a mass Atlanta office in 2018, says the second in size only to New York a job at Google and now works for cole Hughey, vice president of diver-
shooting this past week in the At- move has paid dividends. Around City’s—gives it an edge over cities Atlanta’s chamber of commerce. sity and inclusion at Sirius XM
lanta area that killed eight, six of 26% of its 340 Atlanta-based em- like Pittsburgh and Nashville that “Black excellence is on full display Holdings Inc., which acquired the
them Asian women, thrust the city ployees are Black, the company also have sizable diverse popula- in Atlanta, and has been for a very company in 2019.
into the center of a national says, while 11% are Latino. By con- tions, says Peter Miscovich, a man- long time.” While SiriusXM says it doesn’t
discussion about violence against trast, 5% of the company’s overall aging director of consulting at real- Ryan Wilson, CEO of the Gather- disclose information about the eth-
Asian-Americans. As with many American workforce is Black, and estate services company JLL. Mr. ing Spot, a members-only club for nic breakdown of its employees, Ms.
other major U.S. cities, Atlanta has 6% is Latino, according to the latest Miscovich recently helped an insur- local professionals, says he’s glad to Hughey said the company’s Atlanta
also been experiencing a rise in available company data, out of ance company migrate hundreds of see the city get its due, but worries office is more than 50% employees
violent crime. 7,600 U.S. workers. positions to Atlanta from New York. about its long-term affordability. of color: “It has not let us down.”
PERSONAL BOARD OF DIRECTORS Austin Russell was 2 years As Luminar prepared to go public, certain
shareholders questioned whether Mr. Russell
The trusted advisers of top business leaders old when he memorized the
periodic table of elements. was the right chief executive to take it to
the next level. Those naysayers “believe his youth-
He was 13 when he invented ful brilliance is a hindrance to the company’s long-
Austin Russell
Chief Executive Officer, Luminar Technologies Inc.
an underwater recycling sys-
tem. And he was nearly 17
when he founded a business
term prospects,” says Mr. Heng, founder of invest-
ment firm Crescent Cove, which has poured about
$100 million into Luminar since 2016. He encour-
to help self-driving cars Jun Hong Heng aged Mr. Russell “to disregard his doubters and
avoid collisions. Founder and chief persevere.” Mr. Russell heeded the advice. He ig-
Now, at age 26, he is a bil- investment officer at nored skeptical Luminar shareholders and “made
Crescent Cove Advisors LP sure to not doubt any aspect of myself.”
lionaire. Luminar Technolo-
gies Inc., the company he
founded as a teenager, went Ms. Lynn, an early Luminar investor, was
public in December. Mr. Rus- able to coach Mr. Russell ahead of the com-
sell owned 105 million shares pany’s public-market debut. She persuaded
as of Dec. 2, giving him Mr. Russell to hire a world-class executive team
“that would help him see around corners.” Thanks
nearly one-third of the out-
to her counsel, Mr. Russell recognized that he
standing stock. The hefty should recruit veteran executives who knew more
holding gave him a net than he did. “It’s not just about experience. It’s
worth of $2.4 billion follow- Rebecca Lynn about fit and how creative you can be and how
ing the first day of trading. A co-founder and general well you get along with people,” the Luminar
“When you start with partner at Canvas leader says. “I am somewhat maniacal about get-
nothing and build something Ventures ting the right people.”
of real value, that’s when it
gets interesting,’’ he says. Mr. Woodman was introduced to Mr. Russell
Mr. Russell dropped out of in 2018. The GoPro chief and his wife, Jill
Stanford University after one Woodman, subsequently invested a total of
quarter and accepted a two- $18 million in Luminar. “To be your best self, you
year fellowship from the have to take care of yourself,” he urged the Lumi-
foundation of technology en- nar CEO. Mr. Russell shortened his average work-
week to 80 hours from 120. “Burnout can be real,”
trepreneur Peter Thiel so he he says. “It’s all about finding the right balance.”
could develop Luminar and a Nick Woodman Mr. Woodman also recommended his protégé avoid
high-performance lidar scan- Founder and CEO of getting caught up in endless meetings. So, Mr.
ner. The scanner, Mr. Russell GoPro Inc. Russell ended his regular one-on-one sessions with
said, was the “key to en- every staff member.
abling autonomous vehicles
to become a reality.’’
EVE EDELHEIT FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
EXCHANGE
One of several
contenders in the
internet-from-space
race is U.K.-based
OneWeb, which has
already launched
110 satellites out
of a planned 648.
The New Space Race That Is planned 648. The idea is for 588 to
be active at any one time, says Chris
McLaughlin, OneWeb’s chief of gov-
ernment affairs. He projects that by
by all appearances, is very much
like Starlink’s. While the company
has not announced its satellite de-
sign or launch timetable, it will
Landing in a Backyard Near You the end of this year, the company’s
network will offer internet coverage
to northern latitudes, with full
have to launch half of its intended
network, or approximately 1,600
satellites, by July 2026 to comply
global coverage next year. with its FCC license.
Another competitor is Canadian In the future, there are yet more
Elon Musk and Amazon are dueling to provide homes with satellite internet satellite company Telesat. Unlike potential entrants into the space-
the others, it has more than 50 internet race: China announced it
years of experience building satel- intends to launch its own network
Cybersecurity spe- providers, irrespective of their ge- third of all active satellites orbit- lites, says Chief Executive Dan of 10,000 low-Earth-orbit satellites,
cialist Luke McOmie ography, could mean a shift in us- ing Earth, it’s only the beginning: Goldberg. Telesat doesn’t want to and the EU is contemplating build-
lives entirely off-grid ers, revenue and value away from Starlink has received approval give everyone an antenna, like ing one as well. Hardly a month
on the side of a traditional telecom companies. from the FCC to launch nearly Starlink and OneWeb do. Instead, it goes by in which yet another
mountain in Colo- Nick Buraglio lives just outside 12,000 satellites. would provide connections to startup doesn’t announce an at-
rado, where there’s Champaign, Ill. He has plenty of So many satellites are required ground stations owned by telecom tempt at some slice of the market,
no cell service or wired and wireless broadband op- because each one passes overhead companies, which would then con- including more than a dozen start-
landline broadband internet. Yet tions. Yet, as a professional network very quickly, and is relatively close nect to end users in conventional ups aiming to use small satellites to
he recently gave a talk at a con- engineer, he’s testing Starlink out of to Earth’s surface, up to about ways such as cellular or long-range connect the “Internet of Things.”
vention hosted in Japan on the le- curiosity. 1,200 miles, in what’s known as Wi-Fi networks. Users wouldn’t It’s not clear that all of these
thality of drones. He was live via Unlike established internet pro- “low Earth orbit.” The advantage of have to worry about how they got companies will successfully launch
satellite—his own personal satel- viders that handle installation, this orbit is that signals can travel the internet connection they were their networks, or survive once
lite internet connection, that is. Starlink requires you to do it your- swiftly from Earth to a satellite and enjoying, and could use their they do, says Chris Quilty, a part-
With a constellation of hun- self. But that was “mind-numbingly back, which is why Starlink is able phones and other mobile devices ner at Quilty Analytics, which
dreds of satellites, and speeds easy,” Mr. Buraglio says. He con- to offer service with low “la- instead of specialized equipment. tracks the space industry from a
comparable with U.S. broadband, nected the pizza-size Starlink an- tency”—the time it takes a signal Telesat will start launching its financial perspective. His own
the Starlink service lets Mr. tenna to the provided router, and to make a round trip. The McOmies new constellation of 298 low- analysis of the viability of Starlink,
McOmie do his job despite being power, and then followed along in say they are able to use their Star- Earth-orbit broadband satellites in for example, finds that its money-
in the middle of nowhere. He and the Starlink smartphone app. Since link service to blast opponents si- 2023, and plans to have full cover- making prospects depend heavily
his wife Melanie McOmie are liv- it needs an unobstructed view of multaneously on the demanding, age of the globe by 2024, adds Mr. on slashing the cost of the sophis-
ing the sort of lifestyle that pan- the sky, free of overhanging trees, fast-twitch online first-person Goldberg. One reason its constella- ticated and expensive ground-
demic-weary, deskbound urbanites he decided to mount it perma- shooter “Apex Legends.” tion is smaller than those of its based antennas that it sends to
might envy: raising chickens, nently on his roof. That, along with Traditional telecom and Earth- competitors is that each of its sat- customers. The $499 upfront fee
watching out for mountain lions, running the antenna’s data-and- observing satellites generally ellites is bigger and orbits at a to join Starlink doesn’t cover the
and taking in an expanse of unsul- power cable into his home, was the hover much farther from Earth, in higher (but still low-Earth) alti- $2,000 to $2,500 that Mr. Quilty
lied forest. hardest part. Still, he says, it was what’s known as geosynchronous tude, he says. Should the com- and other analysts estimate is the
The McOmies are part of a beta no more complicated than install- orbit, about 22,000 miles above pany’s plans bear fruit, Telesat’s actual cost for each antenna.
testing program for a new kind of ing a rooftop television antenna the equator. This allows them to satellites will also have high- That said, the FCC in December
internet service from Elon Musk’s back in the day. reach much more of the planet at speed, laser-based interconnec- announced its intention to give
rocket company SpaceX. Their expe- Anyone wishing to reproduce once, but the round-trip signal tions between each other, so they Starlink $885 million to connect
rience has been phenomenal so far, this experience will have to get in time is so long that applications can pass internet traffic between homes in the U.S., if the company
they say. They regularly get down- line, however: The waiting list for like internet telephony, video chat- themselves, in space, before send- meets certain requirements, as
load speeds of 120 megabits per Starlink is now up to a year. ting and most types of gaming are ing it back to Earth closer to its part of the Rural Digital Opportu-
second, and because the antenna The experiences of Starlink beta virtually impossible. intended destination. (Starlink is nity Fund.
gives off a fair amount of heat, users are enabled by the 1,000 or U.K.-based OneWeb, which was also testing laser-based communi- Countless other headaches
they’ve been able to stay connected so satellites that its parent com- founded in 2012 and went bankrupt cation between its satellites.) await Starlink and its competitors.
through most winter weather. They pany has launched. While that in 2020, has recently been re- Amazon’s Project Kuiper, about Among them are the rights to the
did have to clear it after a recent makes SpaceX owner of about a launched by a consortium including which the company has remained wireless spectrum satellites use to
blizzard, however. beam data to Earth. OneWeb,
It’s not clear what kind of speeds SpaceX and another satellite com-
Starlink will offer to millions of munications company argue they
people, versus the more than should be granted senior rights to
10,000 now testing in the U.S., Can-
ada and the U.K. Depending on how
It Came from Outer Space a certain wireless band in the U.S.
This might mean satellites from
many people SpaceX signs up, fu- one of these companies—or their
ture users could have internet future competitors—would have to
speeds that are only a fraction of modify their transmissions when
what’s available during this demo they detect possible interference,
period. And even if Starlink and its says Mr. Quilty.
soon-to-deploy competitors work as Then there is the dreaded Kes-
advertised, there are many other sler syndrome, depicted in the
potential challenges to their viabil- Laser link movie “Gravity,” where orbiting
ity, let alone profitability. They in- space debris leads to a runaway
clude the headaches of shared space pileup. At present, there are
wireless spectrum, and the threat recommendations but few binding
of space debris. rules about how Earth’s low Earth
But with at least three other se- orbit is used.
rious, deep-pocketed contenders in Radio Radio Until the space junk-pocalypse
the internet-from-space race—in- connection connection comes, Brian Jemes, network man-
cluding Amazon, OneWeb and ager at the University of Idaho,
longtime operator Telesat—getting plans to continue enjoying his
fast, reliable internet service from Starlink system. At his home near
any place on Earth with a clear Moscow, Idaho, satellite service
view of the sky could soon seem has been 20 times faster than it
no more miraculous than a cell was with his local ISP, which con-
signal. It also might not be much
Ground nected over long-range Wi-Fi.
more expensive: Current pricing station Mr. Jemes, who spent 18 years
for Starlink is $499 upfront and Antenna connects to at Hewlett-Packard and has been
$99 a month for service. internet building networks for 32 years, is
Internet from space has obvious glad to be part of the Starlink
implications for potentially closing beta. Still, he knows that whether
the rural/urban digital divide, not he continues to enjoy such fast in-
only for Americans but also the ternet speeds will depend on how
rest of the world. It could also en- many satellites Starlink puts into
courage new ways of working and the sky, and how popular the ser-
living, untethered from cable and vice becomes.
MARIO ZUCCA
EXCHANGE
MONDELEZ
ing last year came as every other ing continues to decline.
kind of ad spending shrank, with For Google, Facebook When Mondelez invests in digi-
double-digit declines in TV, news- tal advertising, it gets a 25% better
papers and billboards, according to and Amazon, success in return than with TV ads, the com- Stepping up digital advertising, Mondelez used Instagram to host a game
GroupM. And those online gains the advertising game pany says. It has found that its in which an artist made images from the cream inside an Oreo cookie.
flowed heavily to the tech giants Google and Facebook ads do espe-
rather than to digital media sites breeds more success. cially well, generating 40% higher
and publishers that sell online ads. returns than an average digital ad. nesses, the pandemic provided an Growing Domination
The triopoly increased their The two now account for roughly opportunity like no other.
The big three of digital ads now get
share of the U.S. digital-ad market Meanwhile, many businesses of 60% to 70% of Mondelez’s digital Activewear company Vuori dis-
half of all U.S. ad spending.
from 80% in 2019 to a range ap- all sizes pivoted to e-commerce ad spending, up from less than tributes through stores, but its
proaching 90% in 2020, GroupM selling—and turned to digital ads 50% in 2017, the company says. main focus is selling via catalogs $250 billion
estimates. It’s a surge that comes to support that effort. The tech giants share data that and the web. Facebook is a key
Other
as they face scrutiny and litigation Before the pandemic, a little allows Mondelez to understand its part of its strategy. Besides en-
from various agencies at home and more than 10% of retail purchases customers better, said the snack abling Vuori to monitor the perfor- 200
abroad over their dominance. in the U.S. took place online. That maker’s chief marketing officer, mance of its ads, the platform’s
Google, in announcing plans to jumped to 16% in last year’s sec- Martin Renaud. Google data tools let Vuori upload lists of its 150
tweak its tools that help publish- ond quarter when lockdowns showed Mondelez, for instance, customers and then use Facebook’s
ers and advertisers buy and sell peaked, according to Census data. that people tend to search the in- algorithm to find lookalike audi-
ads, is moving away from target- Though the rate tapered a bit as ternet for healthier snacks in the ences, testing and pivoting in real 100 Amazon
ing ads based on individuals’ the year wore on, the trend morning and for more-indulgent time. Facebook
browsing activity across the web. strongly benefits the tech behe- treats as the day wears on. When the pandemic arrived, 50 Google
But that shift might wind up fur- moths. Vuori CEO Joe Kudla noticed
ther strengthening Google’s grip “The pandemic zapped us two something interesting in the data:
on the online-ad industry, some years into the future on the e-com- On-target copy The prices of Facebook’s ads were 0
experts and rivals say, because it merce side,” said Nicole Perrin, When the pandemic struck, dropping at the same time as peo- 2015 ’16 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20
could boost the value of the data principal analyst at research firm Google provided updated data that ple were clicking at higher rates
Note: Other includes all forms of advertising, not just
flowing through Google properties eMarketer. helped Mondelez craft relevant on Vuori ads for items like its $80 digital; Google shares portion of ad revenue with
such as Search and YouTube. Mondelez, the Chicago-based ads. It switched from showing col- sweatpants. That combination sent partners; 2020 data are estimates as of March 2021.
Amazon this week said it will maker of Oreo, Ritz and other lege-age consumers an ad about its return on ad spending through Source: GroupM
eating lunch in the library to one the roof.
that read: “Made it through an on- Vuori stopped traditional mar-
line class? Treat yourself.” keting such as catalogs and direct versus a year earlier and more
Mondelez has been working mail and shoveled every dollar it than doubled for the year.
with Google and Target Corp. to could into Facebook. It doubled its “This is our future,” Ms. Batiz
figure out how likely someone is April 2020 media spending from said. “I don’t think we will ever go
to buy Oreos or Ritz crackers from what was budgeted, and saw sales back.”
Target stores after being served quadruple. Facebook’s ad prices Steelcase, which makes desks
ads for them on Google’s YouTube. have since recovered, and Vuori and other office furniture, spent
“I can’t go to CNN or other plat- has diversified its ad spending roughly $1 million on advertising
forms and be able to get that intel- somewhat, but it has continued to in 2019, primarily for print and
ligence,” said Jonathan Halvorson, increase its use of Facebook ads. digital ads in business publications
Mondelez’s global vice president of A surfer and yoga practitioner, to target facility managers, archi-
consumer experience. Big advertis- Mr. Kudla seeks to create products tects, developers and company ex-
ers like Mondelez still spend a lot for people with the kind of active ecutives. Most of its revenue came
on TV commercials, and most con- lifestyle he and his friends in En- in direct sales to corporations or
sider TV the best way to reach a cinitas, Calif., have. But for finding from its dealer network, which has
mass audience, rather than any customers, he says, Facebook beats showrooms around the country. Its
particular segment of consumers. his instincts. business of direct selling to con-
As it directs more ad money to “We could identify the age, sumers was minuscule.
the tech giants, Mondelez isn’t demo and behavior, but ultimately
working with as many digital pub- the algorithm is much more pow-
lishers in the U.S. In 2017, Monde- erful in terms of identifying people Straight to the user
lez worked with about 150; it now who demonstrate certain shopping As states’ stay-home orders
works with fewer than 10. behaviors,” Mr. Kudla said. spurred an exodus from offices
For direct-to-consumer busi- Performance-obsessed small ad- last spring, Steelcase’s sales
vertisers such as Vuori are the plunged. The Grand Rapids, Mich.,
reason Facebook revenue never company ramped up its small di-
stopped growing last year, despite rect-to-consumer business, in-
the pandemic’s hit to the economy creasing its staff for that to 25
and then a summer boycott by people from two.
some prominent advertisers over It stopped advertising in busi-
the platform’s handling of hate ness publications and began buy-
speech and misinformation. ing search and social-media ads.
In the three years leading up to Steelcase radically increased its ad
the pandemic, Suzy Batiz, founder budget last year and spent $5 mil-
of the toilet spray company Poo- lion to $6 million on digital ads
Pourri, was focused mainly on targeting people setting up home
building out the network of retail offices. About half of that went to
stores that carried what it calls a Amazon search ads.
“before-you-go” spritz of essential “Everyone focused on Amazon,
oils. whether you needed toilet paper,
Then Covid-19 hit, and one dis- spices, a Cuisinart mixer or an of-
tributor refused to take a multi- fice chair,” said Allan Smith, the
million-dollar order already pro- furniture maker’s vice president of
duced. “That was pretty painful,” global marketing. “We decided to
Ms. Batiz said. “But as one of my shift there as well, and it paid off.”
mentors would say, crisis precedes For every dollar Steelcase spent
transformation.” The company on Amazon ads during the holiday
shifted focus from driving custom- season, it made $30 in sales, the
ers to stores to driving them to its company says. Sales for its busi-
e-commerce site and others’ shop- ness aimed at consumers are up
ping sites. 500%.
That meant cutting all market- Steelcase plans to double its
ing spending that wasn’t digital, Amazon spending this year. Its re-
such as payment for promotions at search indicates the pandemic has
Bed Bath & Beyond stores or for changed work life for good, pre-
promotional events, while stores dicting that about 72% of busi-
VUORI(3)
MARKETS DIGEST
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index Track the Markets: Winners and Losers
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago A look at how selected global stock indexes, bond ETFs, currencies and
32627.97 Trailing P/E ratio 33.12 14.91 3913.10 Trailing P/E ratio * 44.63 18.42 13215.24 Trailing P/E ratio *† 37.27 22.37 commodities performed around the world for the week.
t 234.33 P/E estimate * 21.38 13.27 t 2.36 P/E estimate * 22.42 14.62 s 99.07 P/E estimate *† 27.97 18.97
Stock Currency, Commodity, Exchange-
Dividend yield 1.84 3.40 Dividend yield * 1.49 2.51 or 0.76% Dividend yield *† 0.78 1.18
or 0.71% or 0.06% index vs. U.S. dollar traded in U.S.* traded fund
All-time high:
All-time high Current divisor All-time high Lean hogs 3.12%
14095.47, 02/12/21
33015.37, 03/17/21 0.15198707565833 3974.12, 03/17/21 Sao Paulo Bovespa 1.81
Comex silver 1.59
33000 4100 14400 South African rand 1.56
Corn 1.55
32000 4000 13800 Comex gold 1.27
Mexico peso 1.07
13200 Hang Seng 0.87
31000 3900
DAX 0.82
iShJPMUSEmgBd 0.77
Session high 30000 3800 12600
South Korean won 0.62
DOWN UP
65-day moving average S&P 500 Telecom Svcs 0.54
t
Selected rates
and
Yield toRates
maturity of current bills, Yen, euro vs. dollar; dollar vs. Canada dollar .7999 1.2502 –1.8 Denmark krone .1601 6.2462 2.5
U.S. consumer rates notes and bonds major U.S. trading partners Chile peso .001402 713.30 0.4 Euro area euro 1.1907 .8399 2.6
Colombiapeso .000281 3558.90 4.0 Hungary forint .003238 308.85 4.0
A consumer rate against its 5-year CDs Ecuador US dollar Iceland krona
1 1 unch .007885 126.82 –0.8
benchmark over the past year 2.50% Mexico peso .0488 20.5059 3.1 Norway krone .1172 8.5334 –0.5
Bankrate.com avg†: 0.46% 16%
Euro Uruguay peso .02255 44.3450 4.7 Poland zloty .2580 3.8764 3.8
s
MARKET DATA
Futures Contracts Open
Contract
High hilo Low Settle Chg
Open
interest Open
Contract
High hilo Low Settle Chg
Open
interest Open
Contract
High hilo Low Settle Chg
Open
interest
Metal & Petroleum Futures May 1.9211 1.9700 1.8982 1.9437 .0030 131,784 Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June 99.8350 99.8400 99.8300 99.8350 … 1,181,175
Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. March 135.975 136.100 134.525 134.675 –.850 1,846 Dec 99.7500 99.7550 t 99.7300 99.7450 –.0050 974,091
Contract Open May 147.250 147.250 143.650 144.675 –1.950 18,265 March'23 99.4800 99.5050 99.4450 99.4550 –.0150 1,121,091
April 2.489 2.554 2.456 2.535 .054 71,534
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
May 2.523 2.583 2.490 2.566 .055 264,923
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. June 2.579 2.640 2.551 2.624 .054 102,766 April 118.600 119.225 118.000 118.400 –.175 50,769 Currency Futures
March 4.0565 4.1230 4.0530 4.1235 0.0065 1,978 June 119.800 120.000 118.100 118.675 –.975 140,526
July 2.642 2.698 2.613 2.682 .049 90,693 Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥
May 4.0630 4.1215 4.0105 4.1130 0.0050 145,556
Sept 2.686 .049 101,829
Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. April 95.400 95.725 s 94.125 94.250 –.050 40,129 April .9184 .9209 .9167 .9187 .0010 167
Oct 2.666 2.718 2.634 2.702 .049 131,807 June 100.975 101.100 100.000 100.600 .575 93,636 June .9187 .9215 .9170 .9192 .0010 154,060
March 1742.20 1742.20 1733.60 1741.40 9.20 1,178
April 1733.70 1746.10 1727.10 1741.70 9.20 200,834 Lumber (CME)-110,000 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft. Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD
May 1735.20 1745.60 1729.90 1742.90 9.20 417
Agriculture Futures May 860.00 886.60 857.70 886.60 32.00 2,106 April .8003 .8025 .7971 .8004 .0009 196
July 784.00 809.10 782.00 809.10 32.00 792 June .8007 .8025 .7971 .8004 .0009 160,217
June 1736.30 1748.20 1729.30 1743.90 9.30 214,079 Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb. British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £
Aug 1739.50 1750.00 1731.50 1745.80 9.30 31,170 May 546.25 559.00 545.50 557.75 11.25 682,472 March 16.26 16.26 16.25 16.25 –.01 3,914 April 1.3929 1.3960 1.3834 1.3873 –.0058 507
Oct 1745.00 1751.20 1734.60 1747.60 9.20 9,046 July 530.50 539.50 529.50 538.75 8.50 400,416 April 17.34 17.35 16.99 17.02 –.32 3,413 June 1.3933 1.3963 1.3834 1.3875 –.0058 143,986
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton. Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF
March 2626.60 –31.70 6 May 365.50 369.50 362.00 366.00 –.25 3,257 May 2,542 2,542 2,465 2,493 –49 83,918 June 1.0806 1.0835 1.0755 1.0789 –.0007 39,588
June 2680.50 2685.00 2592.50 2630.90 –31.90 9,591 Dec 343.75 2.50 602 July 2,550 2,550 2,482 2,506 –46 65,368 Sept 1.0830 1.0861 1.0784 1.0816 –.0007 142
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb. Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD
March 1198.90 –17.30 50 May 1391.00 1418.25 1390.00 1416.25 24.00 319,039 March 125.45 125.45 125.45 125.45 –.95 8 April .7742 .7773 .7720 .7750 –.0013 390
April 1211.50 1215.40 1171.30 1200.10 –17.40 40,132 May 129.95 131.40 128.25 129.00 –.95 107,419
Nov 1202.50 1225.25 1202.25 1220.00 13.75 201,242 June .7761 .7775 .7720 .7751 –.0013 128,673
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN
Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton. May 15.81 15.89 15.55 15.76 –.13 382,108
March 26.055 26.055 26.055 26.292 –0.029 1,048 April .04900 .04910 .04856 .04861 –.00009 407
May 398.50 408.40 398.20 407.90 9.70 163,870 July 15.51 15.55 15.27 15.45 –.11 237,029
May 26.150 26.400 25.925 26.321 –0.030 128,425 June .04836 .04884 .04822 .04832 –.00009 117,584
July 398.40 408.00 398.00 407.60 9.30 99,611 Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl. Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per €
April 59.56 61.72 58.94 61.42 1.42 52,233
Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. May 30.90 30.90 30.90 30.90 –.05 2,243
July 30.95 30.95 30.95 30.95 –.05 2,902 April 1.1926 1.1944 1.1883 1.1916 –.0006 1,234
May 53.21 54.11 52.97 53.87 .35 190,161
May 59.65 61.80 59.01 61.44 1.38 434,709 Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June 1.1937 1.1959 1.1896 1.1930 –.0006 630,221
July 50.94 51.95 50.84 51.50 .17 107,588
June 59.54 61.64 58.96 61.31 1.37 330,644 May 85.74 85.78 83.65 84.68 –.77 95,334
July 59.27 61.33 58.75 61.01 1.35 171,535 Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt. Index Futures
Dec 82.70 83.08 81.76 82.51 –.08 67,380
May 13.15 .12 8,246
Dec 58.47 1.08 306,189 Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index
Dec'22 53.82 54.97 53.56 54.64 0.61 136,009 Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. May 117.40 117.55 114.30 115.65 –.90 9,532
May 629.00 t 621.75
635.50 627.00 –3.50 177,541 March 32899 32994 32841 32808 –72 21,814
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. July 120.15 120.30 117.50 118.60 –.70 1,204
July 621.00 t 615.25
626.50 619.25 –2.75 115,598 June 32778 32867 32401 32503 –262 90,483
April 1.7714 1.8324 1.7554 1.8223 .0381 61,862 S&P 500 Index (CME)-$250 x index
May 1.7750 1.8321 1.7570 1.8220 .0361 108,200 Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Interest Rate Futures June 3909.20 3922.40 3897.30 3899.80 –6.20 423
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. May 587.00 590.25 t 580.00 585.50 –1.50 100,251
Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
Ultra Treasury Bonds (CBT) - $100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
April 1.9222 1.9711 1.8973 1.9431 –.0010 56,028 July 592.00 595.50 t 585.75 591.25 –1.00 68,335 March 3923.75 3934.25 3908.00 3912.62 –3.88 476,209
March 182-050 24.0 4,476
June 180-070 182-090 179-190 180-100 23.0 1,154,211 June 3910.75 3923.50 3875.00 3899.80 –6.20 2,556,702
Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Exchange-Traded Borrowing Benchmarks | WSJ.com/bonds March
June 154-100 155-090 153-260
155-190
154-030
2.0 824
3.0 1,186,406
March
June
2621.90
2615.20
2624.90
2630.80
2614.00
2581.40
2613.53
2606.70
1.53
–.50
3,917
47,688
Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Sept 2616.70 –6.40 1
Portfolios Money Rates March 19, 2021 March 132-115 –2.5 34,746 Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
June 131-110 131-215 131-010 131-070 –1.5 3,919,957 March 12818.25 12919.00 12732.75 12808.76 13.26 55,020
Largest 100 exchange-traded funds, 5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 12793.50 12898.25 12681.75 12844.50 64.75 219,658
latest session Key annual interest rates paid to borrow or lend money in U.S. and March 124-045 –.7 12,082 Mini Russell 2000 (CME)-$50 x index
international markets. Rates below are a guide to general levels but June 123-202 123-257 123-150 123-190 –1.0 3,520,309 March 2271.50 2279.80 2250.90 2266.16 .56 117,479
Friday, March 19, 2021 2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 2266.80 2296.00 2238.80 2279.10 17.20 493,978
don’t always represent actual transactions. March 110-137 .6 31,964 Sept 2272.00 2291.60 2236.80 2275.30 17.40 49
Closing Chg YTD
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) Week —52-WEEK— June 110-115 110-131 110-106 110-120 .6 2,313,053 Mini Russell 1000 (CME)-$50 x index
Inflation Latest ago High Low 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg. March 2209.04 –1.36 4,087
ARKInnovationETF ARKK 122.36 1.91 –1.7
CommSvsSPDR XLC 75.41 0.87 11.8 Feb. index Chg From (%) March 99.9325 99.9350 99.9300 99.9325 .0025 117,849 June 2193.80 2214.40 2189.30 2206.10 –.10 9,300
CnsmrDiscSelSector XLY 166.45 0.60 3.5 level Jan. '21 Feb. '20 Switzerland 0.00 0.00 0.50 0.00 April 99.9400 99.9400 s 99.9350 99.9350 180,662 U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
EnSelectSectorSPDR XLE 49.53 0.02 30.7 Britain 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 10 Yr. Del. Int. Rate Swaps (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 91.85 92.19 91.67 91.93 .05 35,837
FinSelSectorSPDR XLF 34.22 –1.16 16.1 U.S. consumer price index Australia 0.10 0.10 0.25 0.10 June 90-190 90-190 89-245 89-250 –7.5 126,613 Sept 91.91 92.12 91.69 91.91 .06 482
HealthCareSelSect XLV 115.07 0.36 1.4 Eurodollar (CME)-$1,000,000; pts of 100%
IndSelSectorSPDR XLI 96.47 –0.76 8.9 All items 263.014 0.55 1.7
Secondary market April 99.8275 99.8300 99.8225 99.8275 … 146,709 Source: FactSet
InvscQQQI QQQ 313.14 0.35 –0.2 Core 270.696 0.35 1.3
InvscS&P500EW RSP 140.56 –0.18 10.2
iShCoreDivGrowth DGRO 47.54 –0.38 6.1
Fannie Mae
iShCoreMSCIEAFE IEFA 72.70 0.25 5.2 International rates 30-year mortgage yields
iShCoreMSCIEM IEMG 65.16 1.04 5.0
30 days 2.581 2.456 3.012 1.751
Bonds | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks
iShCoreMSCITotInt IXUS 70.96 0.42 5.6 Week 52-Week
392.20 –0.19 4.5 Latest ago High Low 60 days 2.627 2.505 3.081 1.804
iShCoreS&P500
iShCoreS&P MC
IVV
IJH 260.91 –0.05 13.5 Notes on data: Global Government Bonds: Mapping Yields
iShCoreS&P SC IJR 111.36 0.22 21.2 Prime rates
iShS&PTotlUSStkMkt ITOT 91.00 0.07 5.5
U.S. prime rate is the base rate on corporate Yields and spreads over or under U.S. Treasurys on benchmark two-year and 10-year government bonds in
iShCoreUSAggBd AGG 113.51 0.08 –4.0 U.S. 3.25 3.25 3.25 3.25 loans posted by at least 70% of the 10 largest
iShSelectDividend DVY 114.11 –0.35 18.6 Canada 2.45 2.45 2.95 2.45
U.S. banks, and is effective March 16, 2020. selected other countries; arrows indicate whether the yield rose(s) or fell (t) in the latest session
iShESGAwareUSA ESGU 89.73 –0.08 4.3
Other prime rates aren’t directly comparable;
iShEdgeMSCIMinUSA USMV 67.78 –0.22 –0.1
Japan 1.475 1.475 1.475 1.475 lending practices vary widely by location. Country/ Yield (%) Spread Under/Over U.S. Treasurys, in basis points
158.59
Complete Money Rates table appears Monday Coupon (%) Maturity, in years Latest(l)-2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 Previous Month ago Year ago Latest Prev Year ago
iShEdgeMSCIUSAMom MTUM 0.94 –1.7
iShEdgeMSCIUSAQual QUAL 119.71 –0.35 3.0 Policy Rates through Friday.
0.125 U.S. 2 0.149 t l 0.159 0.109 0.417
iShGoldTr IAU 16.61 0.48 –8.4 Euro zone 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics; FactSet
iShiBoxx$InvGrCpBd LQD 128.63 0.15 –6.9 1.125 10 1.729 t l 1.730 1.344 1.121
iShiBoxx$HYCpBd HYG 86.06 0.38 –1.4
5.500 Australia 2 0.105 s l 0.102 0.131 0.330 -5.2 -5.5 -15.2
iShJPMUSDEmgBd EMB 109.29 0.29 –5.7
iShMBSETF MBB 108.41 –0.03 –1.6 1.500 10 1.817 s l 1.792 1.443 1.490 8.7 8.1 33.2
iShMSCI ACWI ACWI 94.73 0.07 4.4 A Week in the Life of the DJIA
iShMSCI EAFE EFA 76.43 0.28 4.8 0.000 France 2 -0.633 t l -0.626 -0.619 -0.414 -79.1 -78.3 -89.7
iShMSCI EAFE SC SCZ 72.89 0.58 6.6 A look at how the Dow Jones Industrial Average component stocks 0.000 10 -0.045 t l -0.017 -0.061 0.257 -177.5 -172.9 -90.1
iShMSCIEmgMarkets EEM 54.08 1.24 4.7
iShMSCIJapan EWJ 70.69 0.73 4.6 did in the past week and how much each moved the index. The DJIA
iShNatlMuniBd MUB 115.63 0.06 –1.3 lost 150.67 points, or 0.46%, on the week. A $1 change in the price of 0.000 Germany 2 -0.692 t l -0.675 -0.672 -0.679 -84.9 -83.3 -116.2
iSh1-5YIGCorpBd IGSB 54.61 –0.02 –1.0
any DJIA stock = 6.58-point change in the average. To date, a $1,000 0.000 10 -0.290 t l -0.260 -0.305 -0.192 -202.0 -197.2 -135.0
iShPfd&Incm PFF 37.91 0.61 –1.6
iShRussell1000Gwth IWF 238.68 0.29 –1.0 investment on Dec. 31 in each current DJIA stock component would 0.050 Italy 2 -0.387 t l -0.377 -0.343 0.753 -54.4 -53.4 27.0
iShRussell1000 IWB 221.56 –0.05 4.6 have returned $32,335, or a gain of 7.78%, on the $30,000
iShRussell1000Val IWD 150.96 –0.39 10.4 0.900 10 0.672 t l 0.689 0.622 1.796 -105.8 -102.3 63.9
iShRussell2000Gwth IWO 308.39 1.36 7.6 investment, including reinvested dividends.
iShRussell2000 IWM 226.94 0.75 15.8
0.100 Japan 2 -0.134 s l -0.138 -0.114 -0.140 -29.1 -29.5 -62.2
iShRussell2000Val IWN 164.48 0.31 24.8 The Week’s Action 0.100 10 0.116 s l 0.107 0.106 0.091 -161.4 -160.5 -106.7
iShRussellMid-Cap IWR 74.13 0.16 8.1 Pct Stock price Point chg $1,000 Invested(year-end '20)
iShRussellMCValue IWS 109.91 –0.24 13.4 chg (%) change in average* Company Symbol Close $1,000 0.000 Spain 2 -0.494 t l -0.486 -0.463 -0.127 -65.1 -64.3 -60.9
iShS&P500Growth IVW 63.68 0.28 –0.2
iShS&P500Value IVE 140.58 –0.51 9.8 6.76 15.58 102.51 Amgen AMGN $245.94 $1,078 0.100 10 0.347 t l 0.380 0.351 0.892 -138.4 -133.2 -26.5
iShShortTreaBd SHV 110.52 ... –0.0
iShSilver SLV 24.31 0.87 –1.1 5.86 16.00 105.27 Home Depot HD 289.10 1,095 0.125 U.K. 2 0.098 t l 0.119 -0.011 0.124 -5.9 -3.9 -35.9
iShTIPSBondETF TIP 124.90 0.19 –2.2 4.76 10.10 66.45 McDonald’s MCD 222.44 1,043 4.750 10 0.840 t l 0.877 0.699 0.721 -89.0 -83.5 -43.7
iSh1-3YTreasuryBd SHY 86.27 ... –0.1
iSh7-10YTreasuryBd IEF 113.03 –0.06 –5.8 3.90 2.91 19.15 Merck MRK 77.51 956 Source: Tullett Prebon, Tradeweb ICE U.S. Treasury Close
iSh20+YTreasuryBd TLT 134.75 0.62 –14.6
iShRussellMCGrowth IWP 101.37 0.91 –1.2 2.69 9.56 62.90 UnitedHealth Group UNH 365.58 1,046
iShUSTreasuryBdETF
JPM UltShtIncm
GOVT
JPST
26.14
50.74
0.11 –4.0
0.02 –0.1 2.05 3.79 24.94 3M MMM 188.71 1,089 Corporate Debt
PIMCOEnhShMaturity MINT 101.93 –0.02 –0.1
1.37 0.86 5.66 Intel INTC 63.76 1,287 Prices of firms' bonds reflect factors including investors' economic, sectoral and company-specific
SPDRBloomBar1-3MTB BIL 91.50 ... –0.0
SPDR Gold GLD 163.24 0.42 –8.5 1.10 0.61 4.01 Verizon VZ 56.24 968
expectations
37.89 0.19 5.2
SchwabIntEquity
SchwabUS BrdMkt
SCHF
SCHB 95.91 0.06 5.4 1.01 1.29 8.49 IBM IBM 128.90 1,038 Investment-grade spreads that tightened the most…
SchwabUS Div SCHD 71.98 –0.37 12.2 Spread*, in basis points
SchwabUS LC SCHX 95.05 –0.07 4.5
0.89 0.45 2.96 Coca-Cola KO 50.81 934 Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
SchwabUS LC Grw SCHG 127.85 0.35 –0.4
SchwabUS SC SCHA 102.17 0.64 14.8
0.33 0.16 1.05 Cisco CSCO 48.98 1,103 Southwest Airlines LUV 4.750 0.83 May 4, ’23 68 –21 68
Schwab US TIPs SCHP 60.84 0.18 –2.0 0.28 0.44 2.89 Johnson & Johnson JNJ 160.04 1,023 Lloyds Banking LLOYDS 4.050 0.53 Aug. 16, ’23 37 –12 57
SPDR DJIA Tr DIA 326.01 –0.81 6.6 Delta Airlines, Inc. Retirement Plan … 4.500 3.00 Oct. 20, ’25 268 –11 280
SPDR S&PMdCpTr MDY 475.77 0.02 13.3 0.00 –0.01 –0.07 salesforce.com CRM 212.20 954
SPDR S&P 500 SPY 389.48 –0.19 4.2 Morgan Stanley MS 4.375 3.32 Jan. 22, ’47 87 –11 93
SPDR S&P Div SDY 116.47 –0.42 9.9
–0.10 –0.13 –0.86 Procter & Gamble PG 128.01 926
FedEx FDX 4.100 3.72 Feb. 1, ’45 125 –9 n.a.
TechSelectSector XLK 129.60 –0.30 –0.3 –0.65 –1.01 –6.65 JPMorgan Chase JPM 155.14 1,230 –9
VanEckGoldMiner GDX 33.89 0.80 –5.9 General Electric Capital … 5.875 3.71 Jan. 14, ’38 127 131
VangdInfoTech VGT 351.54 –0.06 –0.6 –0.67 –0.43 –2.83 Dow DOW 63.91 1,165 Apple AAPL 3.450 0.59 May 6, ’24 27 –8 30
VangdSC Val VBR 168.67 0.07 18.6
VangdSC Grwth VBK 277.20 0.99 3.6 –0.69 –1.47 –9.67 Honeywell HON 212.91 1,006 Litton Industries … 7.750 1.73 March 15, ’26 88 –8 n.a.
VangdExtMkt VXF 180.78 0.71 9.8
VangdDivApp VIG 144.10 –0.26 2.1 –0.86 –1.04 –6.84 Apple AAPL 119.99 906 …And spreads that widened the most
VangdFTSEDevMk VEA 49.74 0.34 5.4 –1.26 –0.67 –4.41 Walgreens WBA 52.54 1,330
VangdFTSE EM VWO 52.81 0.99 5.4 New York Life Global Funding NYLIFE 0.850 1.27 Jan. 15, ’26 41 8 38
VangdFTSE Europe VGK 63.21 0.06 4.9 –1.32 –4.61 –30.33 Goldman Sachs GS 344.20 1,310 State Street STT 2.200 2.48 March 3, ’31 76 8 77
VangdFTSEAWxUS VEU 61.40 0.46 5.2
VangdGrowth VUG 252.43 0.16 –0.4 –1.62 –3.71 –24.41 Caterpillar CAT 225.29 1,244 Wells Fargo WFC 3.550 1.40 Sept. 29, ’25 53 7 59
VangdHlthCr VHT 227.42 0.67 1.6
–1.77 John Deere Capital … 2.600 0.53 March 7, ’24 21 6 27
VangdHiDiv VYM 100.32 –0.35 9.6 –2.38 –15.66 Walmart WMT 131.74 918
VangdIntermBd BIV 88.61 –0.05 –4.6
–2.11 –2.96 –19.48 Nike NKE 137.49 974 Morgan Stanley MS 3.950 2.03 April 23, ’27 116 6 114
VangdIntrCorpBd VCIT 92.62 –0.06 –4.7
ENEL Finance International ENELIM 4.250 0.78 Sept. 14, ’23 63 5 54
VangdLC VV 183.13 –0.09 4.2 –2.29 –5.40 –35.53 Microsoft MSFT 230.35 1,038
VangdMC VO 221.64 0.22 7.2 J.M. Smucker SJM 3.500 1.25 March 15, ’25 37 5 n.a.
VangdMC Val VOE 136.31 –0.20 14.6 –3.05 –6.02 –39.61 Walt Disney DIS 191.14 1,055 Bank of America BAC 4.000 1.46 Jan. 22, ’25 59 4 59
VangdMBS VMBS 53.31 –0.04 –1.4
VangdRealEst VNQ 90.49 –1.36 6.5 –4.97 –13.37 –87.97 Boeing BA 255.82 1,195
VangdS&P500ETF VOO 359.23 –0.18 4.5 High-yield issues with the biggest price increases…
VangdST Bond BSV 82.18 –0.02 –0.9 –5.07 –7.97 –52.44 Travelers TRV 149.30 1,070 Bond Price as % of face value
VangdSTCpBd VCSH 82.33 –0.01 –1.1 –5.27 –7.83 –51.52 American Express AXP 140.71 1,168 Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
VangdSC VB 217.39 0.56 11.7
VangdTotalBd BND 84.43 0.08 –4.3 –7.33 –8.18 –53.82 Chevron CVX 103.38 1,241 Sprint S 7.125 1.73 June 15, ’24 116.878 2.27 114.750
VangdTotIntlBd BNDX 57.08 0.18 –2.5
–7.78 –17.46 –114.88 Visa V 206.90 947 Netflix NFLX 5.875 3.00 Nov. 15, ’28 119.500 0.88 119.627
VangdTotIntlStk VXUS 63.42 0.51 5.4
VangdTotalStk VTI 205.26 0.13 5.5 CF Industries CF 4.950 4.22 June 1, ’43 110.498 0.75 111.125
VangdTotlWrld VT 97.24 0.10 5.0 *Based on Composite price. DJIA is calculated on primary-market price. Teva Pharmaceutical Finance … 2.950 3.32 Dec. 18, ’22 99.375 0.67 99.663
VangdValue VTV 130.74 –0.43 9.9 Source: Dow Jones Market Data; FactSet.
United Airlines Holdings UAL 4.875 4.58 Jan. 15, ’25 101.000 0.50 101.030
Springleaf Finance … 7.125 3.93 March 15, ’26 114.330 0.38 114.647
Gap GPS 8.375 1.52 May 15, ’23 114.405 0.31 114.375
Dividend Changes
…And with the biggest price decreases
Dividend announcements from March 19.
L Brands LB 5.250 4.27 Feb. 1, ’28 105.750 –1.10 107.000
Amount Payable / Amount Payable /
Company Symbol Yld % New/Old Frq Record Company Symbol Yld % New/Old Frq Record GrafTech Finance … 4.625 4.53 Dec. 15, ’28 100.625 –0.65 102.000
Continental Resources CLR 5.750 4.33 Jan. 15, ’31 110.800 –0.45 114.020
Increased Foreign
Blue Ridge Bankshares BRBS 2.8 .15 /.1425 Q Apr30 /Apr20 Telecom Italia Capital TITIM 7.721 4.94 June 4, ’38 131.900 –0.35 134.730
Accenture Cl A ACN 1.3 .88 Q May14 /Apr15
CBTX CBTX 1.6 .13 /.10 Q Apr15 /Apr01 Granite REIT GRP.U 4.0 .2015 M Apr15 /Mar31 Sensata Technologies ST 4.875 2.38 Oct. 15, ’23 106.170 –0.33 106.480
Cousins Properties CUZ 3.5 .31 /.30 Q Apr19 /Apr06 Teekay LNG 9% Pfd A TGPpA 8.6 .5625 Q Apr15 /Mar31 Ford Motor Credit ... 4.134 3.33 Aug. 4, ’25 103.225 –0.27 n.a.
Dollar General DG 0.9 .42 /.36 Q Apr20 /Apr06 Teekay LNG Ptrs Pfd. B TGPpB 8.1 .5313 Q Apr15 /Mar31
Horizon Bancorp HBNC 2.7 .13 /.12 Q Apr16 /Apr02 *Estimated spread over 2-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year or 30-year hot-run Treasury; 100 basis points=one percentage pt.; change in spread shown is for Z-spread.
Investar Holding ISTR 1.3 .07 /.065 Q Apr30 /Mar29 KEY: A: annual; M: monthly; Q: quarterly; r: revised; SA: semiannual; Note: Data are for the most active issue of bonds with maturities of two years or more
Williams-Sonoma WSM 1.3 .59 /.53 Q May28 /Apr23 S2:1: stock split and ratio; SO: spin-off. Source: MarketAxess
The Marketplace
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
AUCTIONS
THOMAS PETER/REUTERS
#.#+ !"
#$ The deal marks the first time a Chinese bank has opened up its wealth-management subsidiary to a foreign strategic investor.
BY JING YANG Washington and Beijing, after erate China Merchants Group, sets under management grew
a pact signed in January 2020 is one of the country’s largest 10-fold in the 10 years to
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
agreed to pay $410 million for
promised greater access to
China’s financial sector for
commercial lenders.
wealth-management subsid-
Its end-2019, reaching the equiva-
lent of $16 trillion, according
a stake in a leading Chinese American institutions. iary managed the equivalent to a report by the World Eco-
wealth-management business, Friday’s agreement builds of $377 billion at the end of nomic Forum and Oliver Wy-
as the U.S. financial industry on a partnership agreed in 2020, up 12% from the previ- man.
continues to make inroads in 2019, under which J.P. Morgan ous year, according to the J.P. Morgan Asset Manage-
!"
#$ $ China. Asset Management and the bank’s annual report. ment is also seeking full own-
# % &! '( "" The U.S. banking giant’s as- Chinese bank said they would China Merchants Bank is ership of its fund-management
set-management arm plans to collaborate on product devel- the clear leader among the joint venture in China. The
take a 10% stake in the wealth opment and investor educa- country’s banks for wealth-re- firm has agreed with local
subsidiary of China Merchants tion. “We hope that the strong lated business, analysts at partner Shanghai International
Bank. The deal, which is pend- alliance will contribute to the Citigroup said in January. In a Trust Co. to buy the 51% stake
ing regulatory approval, marks opening up of China’s financial note to clients, they said it de- it doesn’t already own, and is
the first time a Chinese bank industry,” said Liu Hui, execu- rives a higher proportion of awaiting approval from Chi-
has opened up its wealth-man- tive assistant president of revenues from wealth manage- nese regulators. JPMorgan has
agement subsidiary to a for- China Merchants Bank and ment and manages a larger previously obtained majority
eign strategic investor. chairman of the group’s pool of assets for individual control of its local securities
U.S. investment banks, as- wealth subsidiary. investors than any of the other venture and full ownership of
set managers and credit-card Other foreign financial banks they cover. its local futures unit.
BOATING
companies have long coveted a firms have opted to form joint China’s large and rapidly Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
bigger presence in China but ventures with the wealth-man- developing asset-management is applying for full control of
were held back for decades by agement units of Chinese industry holds tremendous op- its securities joint venture in
ownership restrictions on fi- banks instead of investing di- portunities for foreign finan- China. Both it and Morgan
nancial businesses. Wall Street rectly in these subsidiaries. cial institutions, which hope to Stanley obtained majority con-
has emerged as a big winner The Shenzhen-based bank, tap into the country’s rising trol of their securities ven-
in the trade war between part of state-owned conglom- affluence. The industry’s as- tures last year.
After the open-source stan-
dards are released next month,
new independent director, to
Corteva’s board, the company
they can be integrated into mo- Mobile apps or ‘passports’ could be used in addition to paper. said Friday.
bile apps that people could use The moves allow both sides
to verify they have been vacci- exchange clinical data through- security gate service, is testing to avoid a costly and time-con-
nated to gain admission to of- out the world, Dr. Halamka said. a Covid-19 test- or vaccination- suming proxy battle culminat-
fices, restaurants, bars, enter- “The aim…is to provide indi- verification app on some flights ing in a shareholder vote on
tainment venues and other viduals access to their Covid-19 into Hawaii as part of a pilot competing director slates at
public places. vaccination records in a secure, program with the state. the company’s annual meeting
Companies and venues could verifiable and privacy-preserv- International Business Ma- this spring.
choose to request additional ing way,” a Microsoft represen- chines Corp. launched a verifi- Corteva, which was part of
verification, such as a driver’s tative said. cation service for Covid-19 DowDuPont before it was spun
license, or temperature checks. The group isn’t getting paid health data last fall called Digi- out of the industrial conglom-
ANNOUNCEMENTS
“We will have the published for developing the standards, tal Health Pass built on block- erate in 2019, is one of the
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES
standards available next month. which will be freely available chain, the technology behind world’s largest sellers of seeds
It has progressed quite rapidly,” for anyone to use. Healthcare cryptocurrencies. IBM, which is and pesticides, with a market
!
said John Halamka, president of
Mayo Clinic Platform, a division
organizations can update their
existing mobile apps to incorpo-
also part of the VCI coalition,
charges commercial clients, in-
value of around $35 billion.
Based in Delaware, the com-
!
of the nonprofit academic medi- rate the new standards. cluding local governments, for pany is a top supplier to Iowa
cal center, who is helping lead “It absolutely has to be a services such as integrating the soybean producers, Brazilian
the effort. joint effort,” said Bill Patterson, Digital Health Pass into their corn operations and other
The group’s more than 200 Salesforce’s executive vice pres- existing mobile apps. IBM had farmers around the world.
"
members include Microsoft ident and general manager of been building the service before Starboard has said the com-
#!
"
Corp., Oracle Corp., Sales- customer relationship manage- the pandemic and will integrate pany has fallen short on deliv-
$ % force.com Inc. and healthcare ment applications. “This is the the VCI standards after they are ering profits. The hedge fund
providers. It hopes the software
framework will be the dominant
largest vaccination effort in hu-
man history.”
released. IBM declined to say
how much money it has in-
had sought control when it
nominated eight directors to
standard world-wide for verify- The enterprise-software gi- vested in the development of its Corteva’s 12-person board, The
*+ %, $- %" .*. / ,# "0#- 1+. ing Covid-19 vaccinations. ant is contributing tools to the Digital Health Pass. Wall Street Journal reported in
!"#$%&&"
' (!#)
“What’s new and exciting group for interoperable messag- IBM said it has offered feed- January. At the time, Starboard
about [the new standards] is ing, workflow, software integra- back on several standards ef- aimed to get Corteva Chief Ex-
the ability to digitally sign that tion and other capabilities, Mr. forts. Eric Piscini, global vice ecutive Jim Collins replaced.
information so it’s basically Patterson said. Salesforce didn’t president of emerging business Starboard holds a roughly
!" #$# %
&' () * "+ "#$#$' ,$&#-$ .&"!
tamper-proof,” said Paul Meyer, networks, said he expects that 2% stake in the company, ac-
/ "-#$ +$$# 0$"'& 102 "-'$' # co-founder and chief executive mobile apps for Covid-19 health cording to FactSet.
3&+4$' +#. 5 &' 6 ++
#"$$#
of coalition member the Com- data will have to comply with Under Friday’s agreement,
AUCTIONS
mons Project, a nonprofit or-
Healthcare groups multiple standards. Corteva added to its board
!"##$ ganization that develops digital can update existing Salesforce said it is working Starboard-proposed directors
services. on integrating IBM’s Digital David Everitt, Janet Giessel-
The Commons Project plans
apps to incorporate Health Pass into its Work.com man, and Kerry Preete. Cor-
!
"#!
$ #
"#!
to integrate the new software the new standards. platform, designed to help em- teva said it separately planned
%$##
!#! & '('
standards into two free apps ployers with a range of tasks to add Karen Grimes to its
! " # $ %
that are currently available, such as staggering work shifts. board, also immediately.
)
)# # * +
! CommonPass and Common- Alphabet Inc.’s Google isn’t After the company’s 2021
# #) ,
)#-
Health. CommonHealth lets say how much it is investing in directly involved with the VCI annual meeting, Corteva said
people collect, manage and the effort. group, but said it is keeping a three currently serving direc-
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES
share their health data, and Various organizations are al- close eye on efforts to establish tors would step down. Those
CommonPass lets people show ready piloting or planning to in- a software standard, which can directors are Lee Thomas, Rob-
their Covid-19 health status in troduce digital verification then be integrated into its digi- ert Brown and Lois Juliber.
scenarios such as traveling and apps, or “passports.” tal-wallet platform and ac- Corteva’s prospects have im-
THEMARKETPLACE returning to work. On Wednesday, the European cessed on Android mobile de- proved since Starboard first
ADVERTISE TODAY The standards are currently Union said it was introducing a vices. “We stand ready to surfaced. Rallying agricultural
% & (800) 366-3975 going through an approval pro- vaccination “passport” in both engage with public health bod- markets, helped by a surge in
!
"
cess by members of Health digital and paper form for EU ies and other organizations to exports to China, have boosted
© 2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
# $ All Rights Reserved. Level Seven International, or citizens traveling within the understand their requirements,” fortunes for U.S. farmers and
HL7, which helps organizations bloc. Clear, the expedited airline a Google spokeswoman said. suppliers such as Corteva.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | B13
MARKETS
cording to inves- stick known as the supplemen- Treasurys. Banks would only Group Inc. and Apollo Global
CREDIT tors and analysts. tary leverage ratio, or SLR. Yield on the 10-year note on look to sell Treasurys if they Management Inc. The Stock-
MARKETS They feared losing The relief meant they could Friday, according to Tradeweb wanted to get back to their holm-based firm’s planned ac-
the ability to ex- rapidly increase their holdings higher leverage ratios quickly, quisition of suburban Philadel-
clude Treasurys and deposits of Treasurys and reserves Mr. Belton said. phia-based Exeter Property
held at the central bank from without needing more capital Others think investors have Group has helped fuel recent Christian Sinding, CEO of
a key measure of balance- as the Fed pumped money into This month, Mr. Belton fore- overreacted to the prospective gains. EQT expects the deal to private-equity firm EQT
sheet strength would hurt floundering financial markets. cast as much as $200 billion end of the relief. close in the second quarter.
their ability to buy and sell Guy LeBas, chief fixed-in- of Treasurys could be sold by Zoltan Pozsar, a money- EQT oversees 52.5 billion since then, including dividends.
Treasurys. come strategist at Janney banks as a group in the market strategist at Credit euros in assets, equivalent to That compares with 45% for
Yields had dropped to as Montgomery Scott, said there months ahead if the exemption Suisse, said investors were about $62.5 billion, largely fo- Blackstone and 27% for Apollo.
low as 1.671% during Asian and had likely been some selling of was canceled. wrong to assume that the spe- cused on private equity, infra- The $1.87 billion Exeter
European trading hours as for- Treasurys by some banks in “This is still how we are cial exemption has been the structure and increasingly real deal helps explain that differ-
eign investors bought Trea- recent weeks as they prepared thinking about the aggregate glue holding markets together estate. That is a fraction of the ence. The deal builds out
surys after Thursday’s selloff for the end of the exemption. selling pressure on Treasurys, and that the end of it meant size of Blackstone and Apollo. EQT’s real-estate investments,
that sent the yield on the 10- Friday’s news, however, proba- although as this was increas- large U.S. banks would have to But EQT is gathering assets at particularly in logistic and in-
year note to its highest close bly was more important psy- ingly priced in over the past sell Treasurys. a faster pace, accelerating the dustrial spaces in the U.S. The
since January 2020. Yields fall chologically than in terms of few weeks, it’s likely some of “Neither the Fed nor the launch of successor funds and firm also gains $10.2 billion in
when prices rise. But the Fed’s fresh selling pressure. that selling already occurred,” market should fear mayhem if the fees that come with man- new assets and access to more
announcement sent the yield “Market attention has been said Mr. Belton. the exemption expires,” said aging them. than 60 new institutional in-
as high as 1.748% before it wrapped around this other- The effect of the relief was Mr. Pozsar. Almost 80% of EQT funds’ vestors as potential sources of
investments last year were in money for its other funds.
technology, media, telecom The deal “gives us a leading
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
MARK LONG
merce, as well as companies like often from local convenience stores,
Uber whose drivers were suddenly could be particularly good custom-
short of work when the ride-hail- ers. And the overall market is enor-
ing business collapsed. mous: The global grocery business
DoorDash and GrubHub are is worth around $7.6 trillion a year,
also signing supermarket deals. according to UBS. grocery delivery in densely popu- liver groceries, such as Walmart,
Amazon-backed Deliveroo, which The challenge is how to make it lated areas already well served by Food apps are about Tesco, Kroger and Carrefour, trade
profitable. When Deliveroo or Uber convenience stores. below one times projected sales,
Eats delivers a meal for an inde- There are other logistical hur- to learn that competing while delivery apps can fetch any-
Forward price-to-sales ratio pendent restaurant, they typically dles to turning a profit. Orders ar- with supermarkets where from three to seven times.
pocket up to 30% of the order rive quickly on bicycles or motor- One big holdout is worth watch-
Uber Delivery Hero
value in commission and still end bikes, but there is a limit to how is a tough gig. ing. Just Eat Takeaway.com,
Just Eat Takeaway.com Grubhub
up with a loss. As supermarkets much couriers can physically carry. which will become the world’s larg-
7 times run on razor-thin margins, they Baskets of bulky items like bread, est food delivery company by reve-
can afford to hand over only a 15% milk and toilet paper take up properties and source food directly nue outside China when its merger
6 or 20% fee in many markets. So space but are low value. Alcohol is from suppliers, with less buying with Grubhub completes, has
the odds of making grocery part- a smarter bet because of its higher power than the large supermarket steered clear of groceries. Founder
5 nerships profitable are worse than sticker price, which might explain chains it is competing with. It is Jitse Groen has said he doesn’t
with restaurant tie-ups. why Uber recently snapped up also working with third-party think the latest fad is a good use of
4 Takeout platforms can charge booze-delivery service Drizly for manufacturers to create its own investors’ cash. However, the com-
other fees to make the numbers $1.1 billion. products. The profit margins on pany’s tone has shifted on the topic
3 more appealing, such as marking Berlin-based Delivery Hero is these so-called store brands are in recent months. A U-turn may be
up supermarket prices. Ordering trying a different tack and becom- higher than branded goods, but on the way.
2 through a takeout app is up to ing a grocer itself. By the end of this is far from the tech giant’s In the hot and relatively young
20% more expensive on average 2020, the company had set up core skills in apps and logistics. takeout app sector, there should
Walmart Tesco Kroger than buying in a store, according roughly 500 Dmarts—mini food If the new initiative grows to arguably still be gains to be made
1
to Jefferies analysts, and this pre- warehouses where grocery orders account for a sizable chunk of without branching out into such a
0 mium jumps above 100% for small are picked for delivery. In the sales, investors risk paying a tech tricky category as groceries. Even
baskets. The risk for the delivery fourth quarter, the unit where this valuation for a division that is es- with their tech wizardry, food apps
April Jan.
2020 ’21 companies is that consumers will new business sits generated 9% of sentially a mature and capital-in- will find competing with super-
simply walk to their local shop in- total sales. tensive business. Shares in major markets a tough gig.
Source: FactSet stead. Takeout apps typically offer Delivery Hero must now lease supermarket chains that also de- —Carol Ryan
OVERHEARD
Inflation Might Restrain
In a classic case of wanting
The Dollar’s Rebound
FROM TOP: DAVID J. PHILLIP/ASSOCIATED PRESS; ISTOCK
88
POLITICS | HUMOR
REVIEW THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * *
Spill, Stain, Repeat
The canvases of
Helen Frankenthaler
Books C7
TOM
HANKS
show for the effort.
Granted, I had no
Zoom schooling ses-
sions to enforce, no
What zone, but spinning up a clinical labora-
tory was another matter entirely. Look-
ing back, I’m still in disbelief at how
quickly the team was able to safely
I’ve Learned
children to parent, no job to perform overcome massive technical, logistical
remotely. I did work, but at a studio and physical barriers. In just three
with strictly enforced Covid-19 proto- weeks, we secured lab certifications, de-
cols, along with a large crew who had veloped new software and hardware
From the
all been bubbled for the duration of with industry partners, ran the first of
the pandemic. thousands of tests, received philan-
During a time of lockdowns, quaran- thropic funding to support lab opera-
tines and social distancing, solitaire tions, and started two dozen additional
seemed like a harmless enterprise, a research projects, including a new rapid,
salve for the mind and the hands, a
safety valve that meant having some-
thing to do. The deck of cards was
right there on the table, and, without
Pandemic point-of-need Covid test.
Ultimately, we added much needed
testing capacity and assisted local
health officials and community organi-
thinking, my hands would take up that
file of 52 to riff and shuffle and cut. A
game would be dealt—to myself, by
myself—in a line of seven cards with a
growing pile of face-downs. The cards
Year zations in protecting essential frontline
workers and the most vulnerable popu-
lations in an area of more than six mil-
lion people. To widen the impact of our
effort, we made all project-related in-
in my hand were revealed in threes, tellectual property open source and
and the blacks were played on the reds, published a road map to help other
and so on, and an hour or so would nonclinical labs scale up the nation’s
pass. I would play more solitaire later In March 2020, the world realized testing capacity.
in the day or the next morning. that Covid-19 was going to change everything. Throughout the year, I was buoyed
I never cheated to win; winning by the mission-driven, collaborative
wasn’t the point. Getting close was After a year of unprecedented challenges, spirit of our consortium of academia,
good enough, and there was always industry and community. My hope as
another game, so why not deal it out? we asked leaders in business, politics, science we climb out of this pandemic is that
ILLUSTRATIONS TOP: RUTH GWILY; CENTER: BRIAN STAUFFER; 2020 HELEN FRANKENTHALER FOUNDATION, INC./ARTISTS RIGHTS SOCIETY (ARS), NEW YORK (BOOKS)
I might win this time. And what else we build on this cooperation, increase
was there to do?
and the arts to reflect on what the pandemic has funding for the type of fundamental
Actually, there was plenty to do! taught them—about themselves, society science that made our work possible,
Damn! There was a sink to clean out and take a science-first leadership ap-
and a dishwasher to empty. Laundry and the path ahead. proach to stay ahead of future threats
to sort. Rice to put in the cooker with and safeguard our health.
the timer set for breakfast. Letters I
could have written and the typewriter Dr. Doudna is a biochemist at the
and stationery to do it. Books I had University of California, Berkeley,
packed in a suitcase were set on a founder of the Innovative Genomics
reading stack, unread, even though I Institute and recipient of the 2020
was, sort of, always reading one of Nobel Prize in Chemistry for
them. There were floor exercises and co-inventing CRISPR technology.
yoga stretches to do. I have kids to
talk to when they are available. I have
business partners to contact. I have Covid-19 has taught us that life and
friends who are hilarious and interest- health are precarious—that the tiniest
ing. I have scenes to bit of our physical
study and work to pre- world, like a virus, can
pare. I have stories in rob us of vitality, com-
my head—and I tell sto-
I have stories munity, family and pur-
ries for a living—that in my head pose, whether we got
could have been that could sick or not. This pan-
sketched out, noted, demic affected us all,
outlined. I could have have been costing so much, too
re-watched “Chernobyl” sketched out, much. Our time is lim-
on HBO! ited and finite. Solitaire
I did get around to noted, squanders what is pre-
doing many of those outlined. cious. Don’t ever play
things. I lived up to most solitaire again.
of my responsibilities But cribbage? With
and explored a few creative recesses my son, who I rarely can beat? Any-
inside my thick head. But those hands time!
of solitaire were accumulated minutes
BRIAN STAUFFER
wasted by hoping that a red six would Mr. Hanks is an actor, screenwriter,
come up or a king would be turned so I producer and director. He is the
could fill an empty column. What didn’t author of “Uncommon Type: Some
I do instead? Stories.”
Inside
Elites
This short-term mitigation, we were
told, was necessary to buy time to pre-
pare hospitals for any patient surges.
But that reasonable aim was soon
transformed into a lockdown-until-erad-
Influential people in public ication approach that left no end in
health, government and
© SANDRA BOYNTON
sight for most Americans. Going from
the media failed “save the hospitals” to “zero Covid”
represents one of the greatest instances
to rise to the moment. in history of moving the goal post.
Lockdowns proved a huge boon to
America’s corporate media, which
THE COVID-19 pan- primed its captive audience with fear
demic represented a
test of elites in the
U.S., from public-
and partisanship. Everything the cor-
porate press did regarding Covid cov-
erage was inseparable from its years-
Birthday Cakes
health experts to the
corporate media. The
results have been dis-
long obsession with attacking Donald
Trump. Weaponizing Covid in an elec-
tion year superseded any obligation to
Are Essential
appointing. Policy present the facts with needed context
makers who bucked and perspective. The pandemic summons memories of a childhood illness
RON the elites and chal- While it was abundantly clear by and a reminder of the wondrous challenges of parenting.
lenged the narrative May that schools represented low-risk
DESANTIS
have been proven environments for the spread of Covid
right to do so. and that the consequences of prolonged I SPENT MY fourth of her skull replaced by a 3-D printed
To begin with, highly publicized epi- school closures were potentially cata- birthday in the Chil- piece. She is determined to be a pediatric
demiological models were as consequen- strophic, the corporate media did its dren’s Hospital of brain surgeon. She’ll be good at it.
tial as they were wrong. The model pro- best to obscure the data and stoke fear Philadelphia. I re- Looking back at my 40-whatever years
duced by Neil Ferguson of Imperial and panic among parents and teachers. member they had two of making cards and books and music
College London—which forecast millions After all, the media had to take the po- cakes because another and such, it seems I’ve been determined
of Covid-19 deaths in the U.S. without sition opposite Donald Trump. sick child—his name to do in my own life what 7-year-old
mitigation efforts—sparked panic among Had the media presented the data on was Bruce, and he Bruce so kindly did for me: offer lively,
public-health elites and served as the schools in a rational fashion with was turning 7—had distracting reassurance. I’ve been con-
pretext for lockdowns throughout the proper context and perspective, it is SANDRA the same birthday. triving a benevolent world for my child-
U.S. and Great Britain. The lockdowns quite possible that the extended school BOYNTON One cake was frosted self, and for other unsettled children
failed to stop the virus but did a great closures we’ve seen in lockdown states half blue, half pink, (which, on some level, covers pretty
deal of societal damage along the way— would have been untenable and millions the other all yellow. much all of us).
damage that a more targeted approach, of students would be in markedly better I’m guessing that I actually liked hear- But in this past unfathomable year,
seeking to reduce total harms, would shape academically and socially. ing the word “encephalitis” over and seeing so many essential workers
have been able to avoid (and did, in For months we were told to “trust over as the big people around me said it steadily doing their essential work, I’ve
places like Sweden and Florida). the experts,” but far too often over the to each other (and not to me) in the days felt some uneasiness about being, essen-
Similarly, models predicting massive past year those who were most influen- and nights leading up to my 1957 birth- tially, non-essential. Nevertheless, I’ve
shortages of hospital beds helped to tial in our society—in public health, day; it has a cool percussive sound. In a been hyper-productive, if for no more
precipitate the disastrous policy—en- government and media—proved incapa- small echoey room with blue light, they noble reason than preserving my own
acted by states like New York, New Jer- ble of rising to the moment. had put a lot of glue or something in my sanity. (“I don’t have time to think about
sey and Michigan—to send contagious, Florida cut against the grain of elite hair, and there had been a mortality! I have a ‘Find
Covid-positive hospital patients back to opinion and bucked the media narrative. machine with lots of the Hidden Cows’ jigsaw
nursing homes. States like Florida that The result is open schools, compara- squiddy arms with button I’ve been puzzle to draw!”) I’ve wor-
rejected the models and adopted poli- tively low unemployment and per capita ends, which they attached ried sometimes that maybe
cies to protect nursing-home residents Covid mortality below the national aver- to my head. I was fright- contriving my quixotic, upbeat art has
had comparatively lower nursing-home age. We cannot simply undo the harm ened. My mother tried to a benevolent the wrong tone these days.
mortality rates as a result. caused by flawed policies advocated by explain it to me, but they But there was nothing else
The reliance on faulty mod- our elites, but we can resolve needed her to be quiet.
world for I wanted to do.
els was matched by poor pub- Spring-break that we never let this happen She couldn’t be there all unsettled Then, out of the blue, I
lic messaging. Elites sent con- crowds on to our country again. the time; my two older sis- got this message from a
flicting messages about the the beach in ters and my baby sister at
children valued, worried friend: “We
efficacy of cloth masks, the Ft. Lauderdale Mr. DeSantis is the governor home needed her too. And (which is often read ‘Night-Night,
uniformity of risk across age last Sunday. of Florida. I remember my co-birthday pretty much Little Pookie’ at bedtime,
friend Bruce looking out and I think every time
for me, putting his arm all of us). about what it means to get
around me, reassuring me, my trusting little miracle
distracting me. I don’t girl off to bed when it’s not
know why I’ve always had the feeling he ‘gentle winds blowing’ above her, but a
didn’t live. I hope I’m wrong. bitter and frightening gale.”
There are those who, with this kind of This startled me, and offered a kind of
early experience of illness and hospitals, illumination as to the “Why do it?” of
would go into medicine. I’m not one of things. Picturing this gentle, protective
them. I have a friend who is oddly grate- father with his miracle daughter—and
ful for the pandemic because, had his also having watched my own daughters
family not been isolated at home last and their husbands orchestrate a cheer-
April, his 11-year-old daughter would ful normalcy this past year for their
have died. Samantha had been reading in small children—I see and remember what
her room; her father had been in a vir- parents do, and how wondrous and diffi-
tual meeting downstairs. Her sister had cult that can be, and how important it is.
MEDIAPUNCH/ASSOCIATED PRESS
come running, yelling that something This is why we make birthday cakes, and
was really wrong with Sam. Her dad light the candles.
sprinted to find her in a violent seizure,
eyes rolled back; a silent abnormality in Ms. Boynton is a humorist, a songwriter
her brain had sparked a sudden calamity. and the author of more than 70 books,
Rushed to Yale New Haven Hospital and including “Hippos Go Berserk!,” “The
into impossibly complex and skillful sur- Going to Bed Book” and “Chocolate: The
gery, she is now alive and well, with part Consuming Passion.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | C3
Finding Success
Off the Court
Being forced to slow down provided the chance to make
new discoveries and appreciate the beauty of stillness.
Science Needs
demic taught me the lining to the pandemic. It helped me to
NAOMI beauty of stillness. learn that my own happiness has much
OSAKA We are made to be- more to do with success off the court
lieve that the more than on it. Most people who are happy
we do and go and move, the more pro-
ductive we are, but the pandemic
proved that’s not always
in their personal lives tend to be more
successful in their professional ones.
You can’t put a price on
Better Marketing
the case. Just because spending time with fam-
you are always moving ily and friends, and the Many people who love their high-tech smartphones
doesn’t mean you are
Always pandemic has taught us refused to trust scientists when it came to Covid.
moving your life in being on the all not to take that for
a creative and positive move doesn’t granted.
direction. The tragedy of it all is I LEARNED THAT through the air at 500 mph, seated in a
The inability to travel mean you self-evident, but there when faced with a cushioned chair, inside a 100-ton metal
grounded me not only are moving have been positive off- common enemy—an tube, 30,000 feet above the ground—be-
physically but also in my shoots. For me, the pan- enemy of the entire cause of science. We communicate with
character. It allowed me your life demic has allowed me to human species—we practically anyone we’ve ever met, in an
to explore and expand in a positive reset and reassess my regressed to basal, instant, no matter where they are in the
my mind and my heart priorities and evaluate primitive instincts world—because of science. We obtain
and to grow in new ways.
direction. everything. I’m hugely rather than band to- immediate access to all the compiled
Without spending part of ambitious, so I definitely gether to fight. This knowledge of the world, at our finger-
the year at home in rela- want to continue making NEIL was a test run for an tips—because of science. Neither you nor
tive stillness, I could not have made progress on the court. But now I know DEGRASSE alien invasion, and we your mother died in childbirth—because
the realizations about the world that I that my real success will be determined TYSON failed. I had naively of science. Most people used to die at 65
did. For the first time I was able to off the court. The world still has a lot hoped that the same or 45 or younger, but we don’t any-
read and watch the news more often of healing to do, but if we stick to- tribal urges that pit human against hu- more—because of science. And we are
and more in depth and to understand gether with love and kindness, we will man could be harnessed to pit all hu- able to glean accurate insights about
the issues affecting the world. move forward stronger than mans against the killer virus. But that Earth’s past, present and future, espe-
As a tennis player, I haven’t al- Ms. Osaka before. did not happen. cially its climate, our
ways been able to do that. It’s hits a return We have apparently ecosystem and the forces
ironic that, without travel, I in the finals Ms. Osaka is a professional passed through a portal Pseudoscience, we exert upon them—be-
became more globally aware. of the 2021 tennis player and the reigning where pseudoscience, cause of science.
I also discovered that I am Australian champion of the U.S. Open and anti-science, fear of sci- anti-science, In that future,
now very comfortable in my Open. the Australian Open. ence and science-denial fear of Covid-19 would never
all thrive in our culture. have become a pan-
Where systems of cul- science and demic. Everyone would
tural, political and reli- science-denial have understood the
gious belief override the risks of transmission.
objective truths estab-
all thrive And the bastions of anti-
lished by the methods in our culture. maskers, thinking they
and tools of science. cannot spread the virus
If the enterprise of to others, would look as
science were some newfangled, untested silly as a swimming pool with a desig-
way of knowing, one might empathize nated “Peeing Section.”
with these sentiments. But the people Until then, let’s not forget the efforts
who battle against science are the same of lab scientists. Nobody writes stories
ones who, for instance, wield and em- about not dying by not contracting
brace their pocket-sized smartphones, Covid-19. So it’s time to praise the re-
which merge state-of-the-art engineer- searchers who developed vaccines in re-
ing, mathematics, information technol- cord time. If heroes save lives, then they
WILLIAM WEST/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
ogy and space physics. It’s an educator’s are superheroes who have saved the lives
conundrum indeed. of millions—because of science.
So perhaps what I really learned dur-
ing the pandemic year is that science Dr. Tyson is the director of the Hayden
needs better marketing—refined and Planetarium at New York’s American
JAMES YANG
persistent—so that no one will ever Museum of Natural History. His book
again take its discoveries for granted. “Cosmic Queries” was published this
Imagine the ad campaigns: We fly month by National Geographic.
ESTHER
Mean Anxiety town halls purely about rela-
tionships and mental health.
I saw the relief on peoples’
PEREL faces when working from
EVEN WHEN we can’t change frequently reminds me that my home is reframed as work-
our circumstances, we can responses to the pandemic vac- ing with home and when
Turning change our mindset. As the psy- illate between needless risks trust, boundaries, burnout
the chiatrist Viktor Frankl said, and panicking. He helped recal- and flexibility are openly
“Everything can be taken from ibrate my initial 24/7 crisis discussed. The past 12
unknown a man but one thing: the last of management mindset. To- months have been defined
into the human freedoms—to choose gether, we’ve learned to accom- by reckonings—socially,
something one’s attitude in any given set modate prolonged uncertainty medically, institutionally
of circumstances.” Frankl’s con- and to be open to not knowing and, as I see it, empathically.
we look cept of tragic optimism, of mak- where this period will take us. It gives me hope.
forward to ing meaning out of suffering, We’ve actively tried to make it These reckonings require
was influenced by his experi- us to invest in the core facets
exploring ences during the Holocaust. of relational health: empathy,
is the Like my parents, Frankl was a I’ve learned dialogue, commitment, re-
antidote survivor of the camps and likely sponsibility, the sharing of
understood the difficult neces- from Viktor power and resources. In
to fear. sity of staying in touch with some ways, the most impor-
Frankl’s
aliveness, dignity and spiritual tant lesson I learned this
freedom in the face of precarity, concept of year is that cultivating mass
loss and grief. tragic mutual reliance—networks of
I’ve learned this year, from relationships that lift every
revisiting Frankl’s work but optimism, boat by sharing stories, re-
also from watching the chil- of making sources and coping strate-
dren in my life, that freedom gies—is as important as de-
in confinement comes from the
meaning out guish. This is a surreal and health. We stopped living in or- veloping herd immunity.
imagination. Just like a child of suffering. tragic period of human history, der not to die. What therapists Frankl’s tragic optimism isn’t
turns a box into a boat, I’ve but we don’t know what comes have long known—that physical just for the individual. As Jack
imagined that my kitchen is next. Turning the unknown health cannot be separated has written, “collective trauma
my favorite bistro, and not just a source of discovery that tran- into something we look for- from mental or relational requires collective healing.”
the place where I’ve spent ev- scends anxiety. ward to exploring is the anti- health—soon became a visceral That is something we are all
ery waking moment of the last And I’ve guided my patients dote to the fear of death. When truth felt by all. learning together.
year working, commiserating through a parallel process. we stay in touch with that, we Meaningful social connec-
and worrying. Faced with change, the exciting are living, not just surviving. tions are crucial, ever more so Ms. Perel is a therapist,
GETTY IMAGES
My worrying has been as- response is anticipation and A year ago, when confronted in crisis. The pandemic didn’t speaker, author and host of the
suaged by being married to a curiosity. The protective re- with the unknown, our immedi- reveal that relationships mat- podcasts “How’s Work?” and
trauma expert, Jack Saul. He sponse is avoidance and an- ate focus was on physical ter; it just put it in sharper fo- “Where Should We Begin?”
C4 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
The Hyper-Acceleration
Of the Life Sciences
ERIC
TOPOL
cal research move at
this pace. For 21 suc-
cessful vaccine devel-
opment programs in
Now that we know what is achievable,
much of this experience could be used
to expedite the translation of other
post-pandemic research into medical
The Inequalities
the past decade, it took an average of
eight years, and that doesn’t even take
into account the many programs that
care. We yearn for major advances in
the prevention of cancer, Alzheimer’s
disease and many other conditions that
Of American Work
have gone on for decades but have failed take a huge toll in deaths and loss of Knowledge workers who could be productive
to produce a vaccine, including for HIV, quality of life.
CMV, malaria, TB, Zika and Dengue fever. But one essential point deserves em- at home have had a far different experience from retail
For a broader sense of the phasis: The successful and restaurant employees and small-business owners.
achievement with Covid mRNA vaccines that set
vaccines, consider that the Investment such a high bar of efficacy
average time in the life sci- in and safety so early in the I HAVEN’T BEEN out And it makes me a bit guilty to say
ences for translating re- pandemic weren’t con- of the country in that—because for so many it really is a
search into clinical practice fundamental ceived in 2020. The use of more than a year— struggle.
is 17 years. research mRNA was pioneered in the the longest stretch I worry about the inequality of work
To respond to the pan- basic research of Katalin since I was 23. in the U.S., which the pandemic has re-
demic with such remark- paid big Karikó and Drew Weissman On March 4, 2020, vealed so starkly. Knowledge workers
able velocity, the global bio- dividends at at the University of Penn- I had a 10-day teach- like me who sit at home and remain pro-
medical research sylvania three decades ago. ing stint planned at ductive are worlds apart from the reality
community shifted its full
a time This investment in funda- Oxford and in Lon- of the waitress who is unemployed. I am
attention to several key of dire need. mental research paid big CONDOLEEZZA don. I didn’t go. And concerned about student learning loss,
tasks: understanding the vi- dividends at a time of dire RICE I am more than fine particularly among the poorest kids. I
rus, its structural and cellu- need. with it. I have don’t understand why opening schools
lar biology and mutations, and our im- The success of the mRNA platform, learned that I never again want to travel was not deemed essential.
mune response to it; identifying and now in tens of millions of patients, also the way that I once did. In the depths of the pan-
testing repurposed drugs in clinical trials; provides new validation for potential ap- My professional stay-at- A restaurant demic, I found our national dia-
developing potent monoclonal antibodies plications in cancer, autoimmune and home life is working out well. I server logue toxic, as elites scoffed at
that could rapidly inactivate the virus; neurodegenerative diseases. So there is became director of the Hoover at work in small-business owners who
and determining risk factors and best no shortage of what science has brought Institution on Sept. 1, and I Wyomissing, fought to work: “Don’t you un-
practices in patient care that reduced to the fore, from rescuing us from the have only been in the building Pa., Feb. 26. derstand that lockdowns are
mortality and morbidity. And all of this pandemic to offering new potential thera- once. Yet conferences and re- necessary?” Well, yes, but it is
was concurrent with the vaccine pro- peutic solutions for the big unmet medi- search activities continue remotely with easy to say that if you are working from
grams proceeding in high gear. cal needs of the future. better attendance, since travel is no lon- home, your paycheck secure. I hated the
The number of Covid-related research ger an obstacle. Virtual seminars and criticism of religious people who want to
publications posted on preprint servers Dr. Topol is a cardiologist and professor webinars are reaching people who would gather and worship, but I didn’t under-
and in peer-review journals rapidly accu- of molecular medicine at the Scripps never have come to Palo Alto. We are stand why they wouldn’t wear a mask.
mulated to tens of thousands. The most Research Institute in San Diego and the productive and efficient. But Stanford is We were all so judgmental and couldn’t
highly revered life-science journals short- author, most recently, of “Deep Medicine: a ghost town—a university without stu- seem to walk in each other’s shoes.
ened their review process from many How Artificial Intelligence Can Make dents feels weird. But just when I became despondent
months to days. Regulatory review of Healthcare Human Again.” In my personal time, I have learned about our behavior, I saw a story about a
that remote strength training and Pilates teenager delivering food to an elderly
work just fine. So too do neighbor or a nurse deter-
piano lessons on Zoom. I mined to help a wife see her
spent last summer wres- In the husband one last time—on
tling the Chopin F Minor FaceTime. There were many
Ballade to the ground. My
depths of kindnesses to celebrate,
piano teacher retired and the large and small. These were
moved to Pennsylvania, pandemic, signs that we will be OK.
where we will continue to The last year has been
work together “virtually.” I I found unnerving and frustrating
would never have thought our national at times, revealing and af-
to do that before 2020. firming at others. We have
And golf is God’s gift to so- dialogue learned to take the unex-
cial distancing and a rea- toxic. pected in stride. Speaking
son to get outside. of unexpected, my Cleve-
Not all has gone well. I land Browns won a playoff
have attended Zoom funerals for four game this season. Maybe next year—God
people who I loved. I have celebrated willing—I can go and see them play.
Easter with the disembodied heads of
BRIAN STAUFFER
hope is the beginning of the Chasten and I learned the basic only on what they said out retrained? Or will our old ways
be end. Yet some things are com- negotiations of marriage all loud—not nearly enough to of sensing one another be in-
enhanced ing into focus. over again, swapping the chal- lent of a whole discussion, re- fully sense how they were re- tact and even enhanced by the
by the As a country, we have lenges of absence and constant placing the more straightfor- sponding to the course mate- new ones we have been forced
learned some lessons the hard travel for the equal and oppo- ward text messages or phone rial. I became an expert reader to evolve? If all goes according
new ones way: the importance of leader- site challenge of being in each conversations once forced on us of eyebrows, extrapolating to plan, we will know the an-
we have ship and clear public-health other’s presence all the time. by constant travel. Clumsily at whole facial expressions like a swers soon enough.
guidance, the vulnerability of Once we were within earshot at times, we have learned a new, scholar reconstructing ancient
had the workers we have belatedly all times, a short word or facial more finely tuned vocabulary texts from a fragment. Mr. Buttigieg is the U.S.
to evolve? come to call “essential,” and expression became the equiva- for talking to each other. In the evenings, it was the secretary of transportation.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | C5
JAMES YANG
a terribly difficult time? Ad- short months, the pandemic of expansion. With unemploy- package of the postwar era. At
damage. dressing a fast-moving global took 20 million American ment at a 50-year low, wages the Fed, we used all the tools Mr. Powell is Chairman of the
pandemic was mainly the jobs—more than double those had been moving up, especially at our disposal to prevent a fi- U.S. Federal Reserve.
‘Government
is the problem,’
once said
Moving at
President
Ronald Reagan,
seen here
in West Berlin,
‘Ventilator Speed’
June 1987. Converting an auto plant to build critically needed medical
equipment showed GM how fast it could get things done.
REVIEW
BY MARK GERSON
Passover and their sleepiness so that they will
A
see the change and ask questions.”
fter hundreds of years In my own home, we throw marsh-
The Power of
of slavery, it is the Is- mallows to children who ask good
raelites’ final night in questions. Does a child like base-
Egypt. They are ready ball? Put a pack of trading cards
to escape to freedom. under their plate. Is a child mis-
Their leader, Moses, imparts a final chievous? Whoopee cushions are
piece of guidance, one that is also
to serve as a lasting edict: He in-
structs them to tell their children
about this Exodus from Egypt. But
Jewish Continuity kosher for Passover!
Before long, the Seder arrives at
the ten plagues, which God used to
punish Pharaoh for continuing to
there are many different ways to enslave the Israelites. The book of
tell a story, let alone one as rich, Exodus says that the first two
complex and dynamic as the Exo-
Telling the story of the Exodus from Egypt allows plagues, blood and frogs, were “ev-
dus. Moses didn’t offer precise in- Jews to share a spiritual experience across time and space. erywhere in Egypt.” But rather than
structions. So thousands of attempt to get rid of the
years ago, Jews created a plagues, Pharaoh’s magicians
book known as the Haggadah, exacerbated them by creating
which means “telling.” more blood and frogs. Why?
The Haggadah serves as Because Jew-haters are often
the script for the Passover Se- willing to accept increased
der, the ritual meal that Jews suffering if it means inflicting
around the world will cele- greater pain upon Jews. This
brate on the night of March explains why Hitler used his
27. As much as any other dwindling military resources
book, it has been responsible in late 1944 to round up and
for assuring the continuity of kill the Jews of Hungary.
Judaism. The Haggadah does The Haggadah has enabled
this “horizontally,” by creat- the Jews to tell the story of
ing an experience that every the Exodus to their children
Jew in the world shares at the for more than 100 genera-
same time, as well as “verti- tions because it isn’t simply
cally” through history. If a
3rd-century Yemenite or an
18th-century Russian were to If the Haggadah
walk into a Seder in Miami or
Tel Aviv today, they would
were just a
know exactly what was going holiday manual
on and be able to participate. or a dinner
If the Haggadah were just a
holiday manual or a dinner program,
program, it would have disap- it would have
peared a long time ago. In-
stead, it offers a condensed disappeared
compilation of centuries of a long time ago.
wisdom—the Greatest Hits of
Jewish Thought. It is one of
the greatest guides ever writ- meant to be read. Rather, the
ten for living a meaningful, Haggadah involves a combi-
fulfilling and happy life. nation of activities: listening,
Near the beginning of the speaking, being heard and re-
Seder, for instance, the Hag- sponding anew. It is truly a
gadah declares: “All who are conversation, in which the
hungry, let them come and participants converse with
eat; all who are needy, let those at the same table, those
them come and celebrate at Seders all over the world
Passover.” But why would we and those who sat at Seders
issue an invitation when the in the distant past.
event has begun and everyone It is counterintuitive that a
is seated? conversation should guaran-
The answer is that the invi- tee continuity. After all, par-
tation is addressed to those ticipants in a conversation
already present to bring a can’t know where it will end
certain part of themselves. up, let alone how it will
The Hebrew word for “face” is change them. Yet it is the un-
a plural, suggesting that each predictable vehicle of a con-
of us has many faces, many versation that has enabled the
selves. The self being invited endurance of the Passover
to the Seder isn’t the confi- celebration. This is another
dent one, which even occasionally so is the most familiar food of the the best teaching tools in An illustrated herbs tonight! Tell me vital lesson from Passover: The se-
feels invulnerable. Rather, it is the holiday—the matzah. When a signif- the Haggadah is the Four Haggadah more about the Exodus!” cret to stability is structured dyna-
self who, as Deuteronomy says, icant amount of salt is added to Questions, which point made in Spain No, because generic in- mism. No wonder Jews celebrate
“does not live by bread alone” but yeast, the yeast doesn’t rise, and out some of the differ- ca. 1320 struction does not in- Passover, the Festival of Freedom,
needs to alleviate its spiritual and the result is the flat, crackerlike ences between an ordi- depicts spire. As King Solomon at an event called the Seder, which
ethical hunger. bread known as matzah. On the nary meal and the Seder: Pharaoh and advised, each child must means “order.” That miraculous bal-
Because most Jews attend a Se- night before Passover, Jews purge for example, “On all other several of the be educated “according ance, curated by the Haggadah, has
der every year, it offers an occasion their homes of bread and introduce nights we eat any vegeta- ten plagues. to his way.” kept the Jewish people on the same
to contemplate our younger selves. the matzah in its place. It is an op- bles. Why on this night do The Four Questions page generation after generation.
We realize how different we are now portunity to ask: What in my life do we eat only bitter herbs?” The are in fact meant to invite children
from who we were in the past and I want to discard? What do I want Four Questions are traditionally re- to ask more questions of their own. This essay is adapted from
BRIDGEMAN IMAGES
acknowledge that our future self will to preserve, and what do I want to cited by a child and are intended The 13th-century rabbi Zedekiah Mr. Gerson’s new book “The
say the same about our current self. last forever—even after I am gone? to arouse the curiosity of children. ben Abraham noted that the Seder Telling: How Judaism’s Essential
We can create that future self with Thoughts about preservation Yet no child has ever leapt from plate should contain “toasted Book Reveals the Meaning of
the guidance of the Haggadah. and permanence naturally lead to their chair, exclaiming, “Wow! I grains, types of sweets and fruits to Life,” published this month by
One of the mechanisms for doing the subject of education. One of can’t believe we are eating bitter entice the children and drive away St. Martin’s Press.
In-Person Teaching
something important in the hang-
ing around, the idle, casual, totally
random snippets of conversation.
While I am packing up my
books, I send one of my friends a
BY KATIE ROIPHE natural. Conversation stirs. You giddy text about how happy I am:
can feel people thinking. “It’s like a drug.”
SOMETHING EXOTIC HAPPENED to Something mysterious happens. I recognize my 11-year-old’s
me the other day. I got dressed in It is physical. It is an energy you elation on the first day back in
heels and a midnight-blue silk shirt, can fake or aspire to but never ac- brick and mortar after dragging
and left the house to go somewhere. tually have in a Zoom class. You weeks of remote school. The
I was teaching my first in-person can cover your material. You can crazy adrenaline of just regular
class in nearly a year. make an interesting point. But the boring old school. The palpably
I am in an unfamiliar classroom, feeling of a live class can never be healthy feeling of watching kids
because the university moved our reproduced, and the effort of try- in backpacks stream into the
small seminar to a large sterile ing or hoping for it exhausts you, gates. After many remote months,
room to allow for social distancing. depresses you and diminishes you a teenager I know comes home
Instead of being around one big ta- in tiny but cumulative ways. from school and tells her mother
ble with coffee cups and granola bar After a Zoom class I always about every minor interaction she
wrappers crinkling, we sit at desks thought, “Now that wasn’t so ter- had with her teachers, because of
spaced at an unnatural distance. rible.” I was too relieved at the how luxurious all of this feels.
Some of the details of our Covid-era okayness, the perfectly adequate I am careful walking down the
ambience might be objectively off- effort at continuity, to fully allow right away and there aren’t any. stairs not to touch the railing. But
putting: the masks, a giant tub of myself to investigate or inhabit the In class, I can But in the classroom, I can feel when I walk out onto the street, I
unusually rubbery and unpleasant lack. The feeling that Zoom is feel when it is when it is time to push farther into am overwhelmed with gratitude.
hand sanitizer, a huge screen pro- “fine” entailed a surrender to the an idea. I can feel which students Never have I loved teaching the
jecting one student over Zoom from barest bones of education, a terri-
time to elaborate have something to say. I have not un- way I love it in these cold, early
a pink room. ble settling. a point, derstood how much of teaching takes days of the semester. The universe
Yet I feel a little like I have In the book we are discussing, “A place outside of words. I can feel has accomplished this one thing
walked into the greatest party of Room of One’s Own,” Virginia Woolf
take a break, when it is time to elaborate a point, with its deranged plotting: It has
my life. I feel in an instant what is writes of the “profound, subtle and switch modes. take a break, switch modes. made the ordinary classroom glitter.
lost over Zoom: the sense of being subterranean glow, which is the rich And then there are the unofficial
together in the same space, working yellow flame of rational intercourse. minutes—before and after class, dur- Ms. Roiphe is director of the
KOTRYNA ZUKAUSKAITE
something out. No need to hurry. No need to sparkle. couraged, confused? Are they off on ing break. A student who moved to Cultural Reporting and Criticism
How do you pin down the inde- No need to be anybody but oneself.” their own fruitful tangents in their New York from somewhere warm Program at New York University
scribable energy in the room? We Pauses are important. They are heads? I cannot feel that on screen. doesn’t yet have a proper winter and the author, most recently, of
are talking about Virginia Woolf. A filled with information. They offer Pauses are blank on screen, and be- coat; another student talks about her “The Power Notebooks” (Free
quiet student talks. The jumping in is up a mood. Is the class bored, dis- cause they are blank I fill them job in a grocery store. Another tells Press).
BOOKS
Global Odyssey The Modern Angler
The mystery Two top writers
and majesty of on the enduring joys
bird migration C12 of fly fishing C11
READ ONLINE AT WSJ.COM/BOOKSHELF THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | C7
‘A Never-Ending Openness’
A perceptive biographer celebrates the painter Helen Frankenthaler—but also turns her into a feminine cliché
Fierce Poise
By Alexander Nemerov
Penguin Press, 269 pages, $28
BY JED PERL
T
HE ART HISTORIAN
Alexander Nemerov is a
seductive writer. While
his colleagues labor
over bulky manuscripts
weighed down with extensive foot-
notes, Mr. Nemerov, who teaches
at Stanford, approaches his chosen
subject, American art and culture from
the mid-19th to the mid-20th century,
with an essayist’s craft (and maybe
craftiness). He’s a great believer in
the curated fragment, the revelatory
glimpse. He likes to look closely at a
few select objects (often photographs)
and reveal their panoramic impli-
cations. Some of the books that he’s
written over the past 15 or so years
(“Wartime Kiss,” “Summoning Pearl
Harbor,” “Icons of Grief”) amount to
compact zeitgeist readings: “Wartime
Kiss” is subtitled “Visions of the Mo-
ment in the 1940s.” Now, in a book
about the painter Helen Frankenthaler,
he’s at it again, zeroing in on what he
describes as critical moments in her
life and career during the 1950s, when
she established herself as an artist.
I’m sympathetic to what Mr. Nemerov
TONY VACCARO/TONY VACCARO STUDIO
“an intellectual biography.” Uxorious viewed Said as a crusading hero for silver-tongued, American-accented and Edward Said was born in Jerusalem
Oriented breakfasts aside, Mr. Brennan is alto- “getting to the main stage with posi-
gether too true to the terms of his tions [on Israel] that only years before
clad not in a keffiyeh but in Savile
Row—supporters of Israel (says Mr.
in 1935, delivered at home by a Jewish
midwife and named after Edward, the
Toward project, and his commitment to an had been beyond the pale.” An Iranian
examination of Said’s brainy side is scholar likened him to Saladin, the
Brennan) saw him as a “malignant
charlatan” who had made criticism
Prince of Wales. He came to hate his
English name as an adult and wished
(for the most part) fulfilled at of Zionism disturbingly per- that he’d been given an Arab one. His
Controversy the expense of the human
dimension. Although his ac-
missible in polite company.
In truth—and this is
Christian Arab family was prosperous,
and his father—owner of the best sta-
count of Said’s early years said not in advance of a tionery business in Cairo—educated
Places of Mind: is rich with beguiling family punchline—many of Said’s him at elite boys’ schools in Jerusalem
A Life of Edward Said particulars, Mr. Brennan friends were Jewish, as were and, later, in the Egyptian capital.
By Timothy Brennan lays bare much too little his colleagues and mentors, Eventually he was sent to Mount
of his adult subject beyond notably Lionel Trilling at Hermon, a boarding school in rural
FSG, 437 pages, $35
his parsing and distillation Columbia. As an undergrad- Massachusetts. He didn’t find the mi-
of the scholarship Said pro- uate at Princeton, writes Mr.
The Selected Works of duced in prodigious quan- Brennan, his closest compan-
Edward Said, 1966-2006 tities. ions were mostly Jewish and ‘Orientalism’ took aim at
Edited by Moustafa Bayoumi Said’s writings ranged urban, “the children of store
and Andrew Rubin across a wider intellectual owners or professionals.” A
our entire understanding
Vintage, 602 pages, $18 span than that of most Amer- friend from that time does of post-colonial lands.
ican public intellectuals of recall, however, that Said His Palestinian advocacy
BY TUNKU VARADARAJAN the second half of the 20th would cross to the other side
century; and while he was, of the street “if an Orthodox was equally contentious.
NICHOLAS TURPIN/THE INDEPENDENT/SHUTTERSTOCK
T
HE SERENITY of Edward foremost, a professor of liter- Jew was walking towards
Said’s household routine ature at Columbia University, us.” The friend read this
in the last 20 years of his he also wrote about music, “as a symbolic protest, the lieu to his taste, having arrived there
life offered a conspicuous art, history and politics, es- indignation he felt toward (as Mr. Brennan puts it) from “a well-
contrast to the nonstop pecially the unjust treatment those in Palestine hurting appointed home in a world city.” In his
turbulence of his public persona. He (as he saw it) by Israel of the his people.” last year, Said felt slighted that he
lived on Manhattan’s Riverside Drive, Palestinians. For all his bril- Ironically, another sym- wasn’t named “salutatorian,” even
waking every day at 5:00 a.m., working liance, he was also a figure of bolic gesture—this time de- though his grade averages had been
for an hour, then making double constant controversy. The scribed by Said himself as identical to the all-American boy who
espressos for himself and Mariam, his worship and admiration that one “of joy”—would tarnish had the honor conferred on him. Mr.
wife. Said was the only family member he engendered on the literary his reputation nearly five de- Brennan writes that the young Arab
permitted to operate the expensive and political left, as well as in cades later. In 2000, while on took the “affront” as proof that “he
(and presumably temperamental) cof- non-Western academic cir- HE, SAID The author and professor of literature in 1993. a visit to Lebanon’s southern would remain a permanent outsider
fee maker, and the water had to be cles, was counterbalanced by border, he was photographed no matter what he did.”
Evian or Volvic. Caffeinated, he laid the hostility and loathing on the right, es- anti-Crusader warrior, adding that Said hurling a stone in the direction of a dis- Said’s father had escaped to the
table, squeezed orange juice and made pecially over his views on Western co- was the “source of our sanity in tant Israeli guardhouse. In the ensuing United States during World War I to
“an elaborate breakfast” for Mariam lonialism. These were expressed most despair.” Fulsome though this accolade storm of opprobrium, Columbia’s pro- avoid conscription into the Ottoman
before returning to his writing. memorably in “Orientalism” (1978), the seems, it is certainly true that Said vost came under fierce pressure to fire army. He acquired American citizenship
These sweetly incongruous domestic book by which he vaulted to celebrity. “almost single-handedly”—in Mr. Bren- him. Said survived, but Mr. Brennan by enlisting in the U.S. Army instead,
details are culled from Timothy Bren- As Mr. Brennan—a professor of nan’s words—“made the Zionist stance tells us that he went into a prolonged returning to Jerusalem (with a taste for
nan’s “Places of Mind: A Life of Edward humanities at the University of Minne- no longer sacrosanct.” If Palestinians depression, feeling that he had been scrambled eggs, pancakes and maple
Said,” described by the author as sota—writes, many Middle Easterners had in him an urbane spokesman— unjustly maligned. Please turn to page C8
C8 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BOOKS
‘Justice without mercy is cruelty, mercy without justice goes to waste.’ —T H O M A S AQ U I N A S
Philippe Sands
The author, most recently, of ‘The Ratline: The Exalted Life and Mysterious Death of a Nazi Fugitive’
My Traitor’s Heart
By Rian Malan (1990)
1
This powerful account of race
and racism is set in apartheid-
era South Africa. It takes the
form of a memoir, one that
is fearsomely honest and engaging,
in recounting how fear begets
violence. “I ran away because I
hated Afrikaners and loved blacks,”
Rian Malan writes to explain his
flight to America, and “I ran away
because I was an Afrikaner and
feared blacks.” He eventually
returns to South Africa, resumes
his life as a journalist, and writes—
about his family, politics, history
and, ultimately, justice. The prose
is spare and brutal, as Mr. Malan
engages with the politics of identity
and with tales and anecdotes that
range from big politics to his
elderly neighbor—who, he writes,
“announced that she needed new
glasses because she could no
longer tell blacks from whites at
a distance. She had caught herself
waving to blacks on the street,
and that would never do.”
BETTMANN ARCHIVE/GETTY IMAGES
2
“The first moments inside
a Court of Law are like the
first moments at a play—
the eye notes the scene, SLEGS BLANKES A South African park in 1970.
sound begins to reach the ear,
then words. Sense converges later.” The Trial and guilt subsists in an existence effective than in the unlikely to pack a lifetime of belongings as
Sybille Bedford, a highly regarded By Franz Kafka (1925) free from things like charges or but remarkable encounter with she and every other black resident
3
novelist, produced an even more evidence or judgment. There is Gadhafi’s son, who offers of the Chagos Archipelago is
impressive body of nonfiction. “Somebody must have made no trial in “The Trial.” The reader assistance, but only at a price. removed from their home. It is
“The Faces of Justice” follows in a false accusation against is left, at each turn, trying to work “Seif looked at me and with an 1965, and the British colony is
the tradition of writers who cap- Joseph K., for he was out what is happening. impatient tone said, ‘What do you being “closed” for a new U.S.
tured the essence of the Nuremberg arrested one morning want if he is dead?’ . . . ‘We want military base. There is, in this tale,
trials—Janet Flanner, Martha Gell- without having done anything to know when, where and how it a disconnect between the gentle
horn, Rebecca West. But Bedford’s wrong.” The opening line of “The The Return happened,’ I said. ‘We want the tone of the prose and the harsh
reporting is distinguished for its Trial,” cobbled together by Franz By Hisham Matar (2016) body in order to bury it in our background facts, which concern
4
concern with the mundanities of Kafka’s friend Max Brod after the own way, so we can have our a people’s enforced separation
justice handed down by the lower author’s death, is as legendary as The future novelist is 20 funeral, and then we want from home and roots, and all its
courts. She makes visits across it is a puzzle. It has led readers years old when his father, accountability.’ ” The evocation ensuing pain. “One day,” we read,
Europe, observes disputes about down many paths, among them a Libyan diplomat, is of mood induces the sense that “your heart catches a cold, and
process and evidence, documents the belief that the novel is about abducted by the Gadhafi you are there, listening in, ready you don’t have enough strength
the interplay between lawyers the rule of law and fair process. regime. The two never see each to intervene. to bring it back to life. It slowly,
and judges, the mendacities of An unlikely conclusion, considering other again, but the son is haunted steadily dies out.” The author’s
witnesses and defendants, and the that Kafka saw his legal studies as by a need to learn the precise afterword records that the
little ways in which societies vary “an intellectual diet of sawdust” details of the fate that befell his Silence of the Chagos International Court of Justice at
in their ways of dispensing justice. and viewed the formalities of father. This memoir of the son’s By Shenaz Patel The Hague recently ruled that
Bedford’s writing is at once spartan law as objects worthy of ridicule. search is wholly gripping thanks (trans. by Jeffrey Zuckerman, 2019) Chagos belongs to Mauritius,
5
and vivid, devoid of emotion. She “The Trial” is far more reasonably largely to Hisham Matar’s that the forcible removal of 2,000
lays bare the ways in which the seen as an exploration of guilt and extraordinary capacity to transmit Charlesia, the central Chagossians was unlawful, and
most ordinary things in life—a imagination and their effect on a sense of intimacy, which carries character in “Silence of the that the “battle has not yet
stolen box of apples, for example— memory and truth. In Joseph K.’s the reader along with him on his Chagos,” is an inhabitant of been won.” There is hope in
represent the human condition. unlikely situation, innocence is guilt, journey. Nowhere is this more Diego Garcia, given an hour this captivating novel.
And yet, there were many more aca- The pyrotechnics of Said’s polemical sic. Said regarded the opera as an Ori- In a most astute observation—one of
The World, demic criticisms of Said than there
were ad hominem blows. In a memora-
writings—on politics, Islam, Zionism
versus “Palestinianism” (his coinage)—
entalist project and wrote that it “em-
bodies, as it was intended to do, the
many in his intense and rewarding
book—Mr. Brennan may have hit upon
overdressed, gum-chewing, squeaky- and literature across the world. So Israel before others in his own camp,
voiced bobby-soxers.” much so that he is widely hailed as the stressing the sufferings of the Jewish
It has been said of Said, and not patron-saint of “postcolonial studies.” people, not only those of his own, and
always flatteringly, that he was—as (The malign modern strictures against insisting on mutual recognition.”
Mr. Brennan puts it—“an improviser, “cultural appropriation” can also be Said had been conciliatory to Israel
experimenter, and self-inventor.” His traced back to “Orientalism.”) well before the PLO came to be so; and
family’s constant relocations had some- Lewis accused Said of polluting the yet, by the time of the Oslo Accords in
thing to do with this, for sure; and this term Orientalist “beyond salvation,” ORIENTALIST Said touches a raw nerve with Zionists because their 1993—delivering peace between Israel
peripatetic life, writes Mr. Brennan, while also questioning his slipshod themes are his themes, but from the opposing point of view. and the PLO on the South Lawn of the
served as fodder for “malicious arti- approach to the academic sources and White House—he had become hostile
cles” in which Said was alleged to have scholarship that Said sought to deni- theme of empire is almost omnipres- Edited by Moustafa Bayoumi and to conciliation. Oslo, he believed, codi-
mythologized his origins to make him grate in his book. He even accused Said ent. In “Jane Austen and Empire”— Andrew Rubin, both professors of liter- fied Palestinian capitulation and served
appear more authentically Palestinian, of “neglect—or perhaps ignorance— published in his “Culture and Imperial- ature, the first edition was published only to keep a corrupt PLO in power.
thus better suited to champion the of Arab scholarship.” Lewis’s brutal ism” (1993), a collection of essays— in 2000 as “The Edward Said Reader,” He compared the new Palestinian
Palestinian cause. The most bare- review led to a lengthy riposte from Said dwells on how the island of a somewhat sententious title that the Authority to the Vichy regime and
knuckle instance was a piece in Com- Said, published in the same periodical, Antigua is missing from Austen’s editors have done well to discard. likened the Palestinian-administered
mentary magazine titled “ ‘My Beauti- in which he mocks Lewis for the “four “moral geography” in “Mansfield Park,” The book is valuable because it territory to a Bantustan. His sarcasm
ful Old House’ and Other Fabrications years of gestation he needed” to write whose eponymous estate is paid for skews in a literary direction, drawing was merciless. Arafat would hit back
by Edward Said,” published in 1999, his response to “Orientalism” and ac- by the profits from Caribbean slavery. readers away from some of the more at Said, banning his books in the West
which asserted that Said’s links with cuses him of “breathtakingly bad faith.” In “The Imperial Spectacle,” an essay conventionally celebrated Said fare. But Bank and Gaza. All of his books, it
Jerusalem were altogether tenuous. The New York Review of Books gave on the opera “Aida” published in 1987 however seductive we may find his aes- should be said, are available in Israel.
Said saw all such attacks as political Lewis the last word, and this vitriolic in Grand Street magazine, Said argues thetic side—Said was a gifted pianist
defamation. “If the major tribune of the back-and-forth might be described—in that the Verdi opera—and the Cairo who forged a friendship with Daniel Mr. Varadarajan, a Journal
Palestinians had lied about his roots,” jest, yes, but also as a way of conveying opera house that was constructed to Barenboim—we cannot grasp Said contributor, is a fellow at the
writes Mr. Brennan of the articles’ im- the intensity of the combat between showcase it—were a significant part of the man without placing at center American Enterprise Institute
plications, “then all Palestinian claims two proud men—as the Ali vs. Foreman Europe’s imperial assertiveness in stage his adamant and passionate com- and at NYU Law School’s
must be fraudulent.” of the Orientalist world. Egypt. “Aida” wasn’t just about the mu- mitment to the Palestinian question. Classical Liberal Institute.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | C9
BOOKS
‘Why should I let the toad “work” / Squat on my life? / Can’t I use my wit as a pitchfork / And drive the brute off?’ —PH ILIP LARK IN
J
AMES SUZMAN did his doctoral
research on the Ju/’hoansi
“Bushmen” of Namibia. He has kept
in touch with them over the past
25 years and written reports on
the plight of minority peoples in the region.
He also had a stint in the corporate world,
as global head of public affairs for the mining
giant De Beers. So, an anthropologist, a busi-
ness executive and now director of a think
tank, Anthropos Ltd.: Mr. Suzman is well
placed to reflect on what makes the lot of
hunter-gatherers so different from that of
early farmers, let alone workers, managers
and entrepreneurs in modern industrial
societies. In “Work: A Deep History, From the
Stone Age to the Age of Robots,” Mr. Suzman
picks away at the very different ideas that
OLEKSANDR RUPETA/NURPHOTO/GETTY IMAGES
subtle feeling of experience, hers and— taking an interest in the book, I found myself
A Woman ultimately—ours as we encounter this
never-ending openness.” He labors
downtown New York art
world in the years after
wondering whether Mr.
Nemerov would be on a
face,” he writes, was “deeply personal streaming of the avant- recent book about the
and vastly public at the same time.” garde, a process that had photographer Lewis
“Vastly public” is a strange turn of begun a hundred years Hine he refers to him as
Continued from page C7 phrase, but also a revealing one coming earlier, when the growth “Hine.”) It seems that
The immediacy of a child’s experi- from Mr. Nemerov, who is fascinated of literacy and the explo- several generations af-
ence is among the themes that Mr. by the ambience and atmospherics of sion of urban life made ter Frankenthaler and
Nemerov embraces as he works to particular times and places. The drama it possible for the work some of her friends,
describe and define Frankenthaler’s of mid-20th-century New York is very of creative spirits to including Hartigan and
achievement. She doesn’t make it easy. much a part of what he wants to reach larger and larger Mitchell, fought for
For Frankenthaler the confrontation explore in this biography, which is sub- audiences. acceptance in a world
with the canvas involved spontaneous “Of course, these pho- dominated by men
discovery, a pictorial intuition she may tographs were pieces of they’re still being ghet-
have believed was so deep as to elude Thepainterdepictedhereis marketing,” Mr. Nemerov toized—now as separate
definition. Her splashes, flashes, and writes of the 1957 photo but equal, which isn’t
expanses of color are meant as talis-
both an inspired innocent shoot. “Life’s adoration equal at all. A solid
mans. Meaning is the pot of gold at the and a savvy self-marketer, was clear enough: Helen GIRL BEFORE A MIRROR Helen Frankenthaler at the Spring biography of Mitchell,
end of the rainbow. I can’t see that Mr. her every move ‘deeply is young, attractive, go- Fantasia artists’ ball, held at the Astor Hotel in New York, 1950. published a decade ago,
Nemerov sheds much light on the work ing places, and in the carried the mortifying
of this painter who had little or no personal and vastly public.’ business of selling—not the clothes she describes as “the prevailing ways of subtitle “Lady Painter.” A more recent
interest in preparatory processes or de- wears but the art she makes.” There is seeing art over the past fifty years,” book, the widely acclaimed “Ninth
finable structures and symbols. The truth to this, but to devote three or four when “our culture has become terribly Street Women”—featuring Frankentha-
best he can offer are on-the-one-hand, titled “Helen Frankenthaler and 1950s pages to a Life magazine article in a skeptical of romantic art such as hers.” ler, Mitchell, Hartigan, Lee Krasner and
on-the-other-hand formulations. One New York.” Two key moments in Mr. book of barely 200 pages leaves me What culture is he talking about? There Elaine de Kooning—forces artists of
painting with “bursts [that] resemble Nemerov’s book are shaped by Life wondering if Mr. Nemerov is writing has been no time in the past 60 years significantly different gifts, sensibilities
childlike splotches . . . is actually a magazine photographs, which he re- about Helen Frankenthaler or 1950s when Frankenthaler hasn’t been taken and ambitions into a one-size-fits-all
deeply considered picture.” Another is gards as having significant evidentiary New York, about the evolution of ab- seriously by many discriminating artists category. I wonder how Frankenthaler
“arrestingly intimate and grandly de- value. The first is of Frankenthaler and stract painting or the place of abstract and museumgoers. would have reacted to the title of Mr.
clarative,” with a passage suggesting a friend at that Spring Fantasia artists’ painting in popular culture. He would Mr. Nemerov relates his growing Nemerov’s book: “Fierce Poise.” What
“the graffiti of a schoolgirl’s private ball in 1950, where Frankenthaler came probably say that he’s doing a bit of enthusiasm for Frankenthaler’s work to is the point of this jazzed-up finishing-
confession” and also conveying “a bold in a costume modeled on Picasso’s both. Maybe so. I think his focus wob- his discovery that “joy was itself seri- school phrase? When did anybody refer
strapping air of titanic achievement.” “Girl Before a Mirror,” a painting in the bles. He sets out to write the biography ous, that prettiness had its edges, and to a man’s poise, fierce or otherwise?
Mr. Nemerov writes that “Helen knew collection of the Museum of Modern of an artist and ends up with something that guilt, anger, and indignation were
how to take a picture right up to the Art. The second is one of a series of more like the portrait of a careerist. not the only games in town.” He ob- Mr. Perl’s new book, “Authority and
edge of legibility, to leave it just on the photographs that Gordon Parks made He risks confusing painting culture serves that having children of his own Freedom: A Defense of the Arts,” will
verge of literalism and then how to to illustrate the 1957 article “Women with pop culture. That would be a grave made him realize “for the first time be published next winter. Among his
draw it back, letting the emblems re- Artists in Ascendance,” which featured misunderstanding of Frankenthaler’s that life is precious.” Doesn’t he realize many books are “Paris Without End,”
treat into their groves, away from Frankenthaler and some of her friends, work—and her world. In his introduc- that even as he prepares to salute Fran- “New Art City,” “Magicians and Char-
meaning, away from philosophy, away among them Hartigan and Joan Mitch- tion, Mr. Nemerov argues that Franken- kenthaler as a painter he’s turning her latans” and a two-volume biography
from all explanation, until we have a ell. There is no doubt that Life was thaler was out of step with what he into a feminine cliché? Reading this of the sculptor Alexander Calder.
C10 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BOOKS
‘The art of losing isn’t hard to master; / so many things seem filled with the intent / to be lost that their loss is no disaster.’ —ELIZABETH BISHOP
Past Imperfect
MYSTERIES
TOM NOLAN
H
youths” behind the cafe’s plate-
OW MUCH DO glass window, in “linen trousers,
most of us know knee-length skirts, striped PETER SWANSON specializes
about the Algerian sweatshirts, hatless heads,” day- in writing mesmerizing thrillers
War, the bloody dreaming that his eldest son, that subvert readers’ expecta-
conflict that raged Hamid, might grow up to be one tions. The author works his
between the French army and of them. He had come to Bab El particular magic once again
the Algerian Front de Libération Oued to look for an apartment, to with “Every Vow You Break”
Nationale (FLN) between 1954 and escape the mounting tensions of (Morrow, 308 pages, $27.99),
1962, ending more than 130 years his village. But as he watched, the in which a young woman faces
of French colonial rule? The war cafe’s windows blew out, “shat- a tricky dilemma: Should she
has cast a long shadow, but clarity tered by a spectacular explosion.” tell her fiancé, a wealthy investor, about the
has been slow in coming. In Seeing a boy emerge from the one-night dalliance she allowed herself
France, it wasn’t officially called wreckage, “spattered with vanilla during the West Coast bachelorette weekend
a war until 1999; it was labeled ice cream and blood,” Ali fled in he paid for? Or should she keep it a secret
an “operation of public order.” terror and drove back to his and trust he’ll never find out?
Sixty years on, its secrets are village. Six years later he would Bride-to-be Abigail Baskin—the child of
still emerging. Only this month, return to Algiers with his family parents who ran a regional theater—opts for
French President Emmanuel Ma- and board the boat that would secrecy and a hoped-for happy ending. But
cron confirmed that a well-known take them to France, leaving the during the subsequent wedding and honey-
Algerian nationalist lawyer had home where he no longer be- moon, she is unnerved by a sense of unreality,
not committed suicide in 1957, longed for a place he would a feeling that both she and her new husband,
but had in fact been tortured and remain an outsider. Bruce, are somehow imposters: “Who was this
killed by French soldiers. Ms. Zeniter’s extraordinary rich, attentive man? And who was she, that she
Since 1966, the easiest point of achievement is to transform a was marrying him?” Their honeymoon site—
entry to understanding the cru- complicated conflict into a com- a technology-free lodge on
elty of the Algerian War has been pelling family chronicle, rich in THIS WEEK an island off the coast of
Gillo Pontecorvo’s neo-realist film visual detail and lustrous in Maine—displays its own
ALAMY
“The Battle of Algiers,” which language. Her storytelling, splen- Every Vow theatricality. With its few
viscerally portrayed the atrocities MOUNTAIN TOWN Traditional houses in Tizi Ouzou, Algeria. didly translated by Frank Wynne, You Break guests, hushed air, gothic
of that conflict, atrocities commit- carries the reader through differ- By Peter decor and identically clad,
ted by both French soldiers and in other words, as un-Arabic as almost nothing about her Algerian ent generations, cities, cultures Swanson mostly male staff, the venue
FLN rebels, who targeted not only possible.” Naïma and her millen- roots until her late 20s. The idea and mindsets without breaking might as well be a stage set.
the army but also political ene- nial sensibility frame the novel’s that the family’s past affects her its spell. In Algeria, Naïma visits, Soon dramatic things
mies, including Algerians they central subject: the untold story present “seems absurd” to Naïma. almost by accident, her ancestral are happening left and right. Jill, another
judged sympathetic to the French of her grandfather and her father, But as a series of Islamist attacks mountain, where the River Isser honeymooning bride whom Abigail befriends,
cause, whom they called “Harkis.” which unfolds chronologically and strikes France and Belgium, she flows through the rocky Palestro confides that she too has a past affair to
While that film preserved one organically, first in Algeria, then begins to appreciate that history’s gorges “softened by waterfalls, keep secret from her new spouse—but her
chapter of the struggle, it did not in France. She knows that both voice is never fully silenced. by rivulets, by little waves,” and ex-boyfriend has now turned up as a guest at
convey its wider span, and could In the spring of 2016, Naïma “verdant with festoons of green- this ultra-exclusive lodge. Chillingly, the fellow
not show its aftermath. Recently, plans a trip to Algeria. Her jour- ery and mossy cushions.” In that Abigail slept with before her wedding also
nonfiction books have begun In a novel of an ney is not motivated by passion landscape, she recognizes the makes a surprise appearance. Then Jill, after
appearing that unearth the war’s to rebuild ancestral ties: Her gal- “world of myths, dense as rocks,” having missed a morning appointment with
buried secrets. But with her novel
Algerian family’s lery is sending her to Algeria to that her grandmother conjured. Abigail, wanders past her cabin at night, dazed
“The Art of Losing,” the young silences, a young track down the lost drawings of She does not know that those and bleeding, and disappears into the forest.
French writer Alice Zeniter has woman learns history a famous Kabyle painter named gorges were the site of an FLN The next day, the lodge’s staff claim she
used fiction to demystify the Lalla, for an upcoming show. She ambush of French troops in 1956, cannot be found.
war, its evolution and its fallout won’t keep quiet. isn’t eager to go: “What if it’s leading to violent reprisals in her Mr. Swanson, as he demonstrated in last
through an enthralling saga of dangerous?” she worries before- grandfather’s village, speeding year’s “Eight Perfect Murders,” has a talent for
three generations of a family from hand. And yet, she wants to see Ali’s departure, and making gradually, disturbingly shifting his characters’
Algeria’s mountainous Kabylia men were born in a village in the for herself the country that her Naïma’s eventual life possible. But perception of what’s going on. Abigail clings
region who left the country in Kabylie mountains, 50 miles from family, through their secrecy, the story does not require her to as long as she can to the possibility “there was
1962 and moved to France. Algiers. But her father has always have made myth. When she meets know that; Ms. Zeniter lets Naïma still a chance that all the strange things that
Ms. Zeniter begins her story in refused to open up about his Lalla, who left Algeria in 1995, attach her own meaning to what had been happening in the past few days were
the present, with Naïma, a young childhood. “Children are the same he asks Naïma if her family were she sees. Leaving the village, nothing more than coincidence.” But after
woman who works at a Parisian everywhere,” he tells her. Pri- “Harkis.” She answers yes, but Naïma is relieved when the artist several more twists of plot and turns of fate,
art gallery that specializes in vately, he thinks Algeria “has doesn’t yet understand the who is driving her back to Algiers Abigail entertains a more ominous notion: “a
the “non-aligned aesthetics” of nothing to do with him.” Naïma’s weight of the word. Ms. Zeniter tells her, “No one bequeathed fleeting certainty that everything here on this
decolonizing countries. Naïma’s mother backs him up. “I don’t writes, “Naïma’s family has been Algeria to you,” adding without island, every person, every tree, was part of a
mother, Clarisse, is French; her think anyone knows,” she says. orbiting Algeria for so long that judgment, “What is not passed play, and she was the one unwilling participant.”
father, Hamid, is Kabyle. Two of The silence dates back to they no longer really know what on is lost, that’s all there is to it.” “What Movie Are We In?” was a game
her sisters are blond like their the previous generation: Naïma’s they are circling. Memories? A With “The Art of Losing,” Ms. Abigail played as a child with her cinephile
mother; Naïma, with black hair grandfather, Ali, died when she dream? A lie?” Naïma wants a Zeniter shows fiction’s power as father. Mr. Swanson’s shape-shifting saga is
and dark eyes like her father, was only a child. Her doting concrete point of reference. Pre- a hedge against loss of the past: reminiscent, by turns, of such foreboding
looks “like a portrait of her grandmother, Yema, in her tiny, paring for her visit, she turns to the art of regaining. films as “Vertigo,” “Fatal Attraction” and
mother painted with all the wrong kitsch-filled apartment in Nor- Wikipedia and YouTube to fill in “The Wicker Man.” Ultimately, “Every Vow You
colors.” For years, she has tried mandy, speaks too little French to what her family has erased. Ms. Schillinger is the Break” reveals itself to be a violent melodrama,
to be seen as “Europeanized, answer the question “What did Ali In Algiers, standing in a translator, most recently, one which the sure-handed author sees
modern; in a word, reassuring; do during the war?” Naïma learns square in the Bab El Oued of Takis Würger’s “Stella.” through to a satisfying conclusion.
BOOKS
‘Many men go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.’ —H EN RY DAV ID TH O REAU
Trout Water
By Josh Greenberg
Melville House,
162 pages, $24.99
BY BILL HEAVEY
M
ARK KURLANSKY
can’t quite tell you
what he loves about
fly fishing. Mostly,
it’s a way of immers-
NATIONAL GALLERY OF ART, WASHINGTON; ON C7: ROMAN EKKEL/GETTY IMAGES
Ceremonies of Deliverance
‘ON A CERTAIN NIGHT each art since antiquity. For Jewish watches, the man suddenly maker, a savior,” we read. In brawny arms tight around the
year when the dark of winter is families, “The Four Questions” transforms: His hair turns red, strong hues of yellow, orangey- skinny boy, the two of them
passing and the world is warm- offers a beautiful reprise of his rags become silk and the red, black, lilac and bluish- emit rays of happy light.
ing up for the green of spring, tradition; for those unfamiliar, eggs become flaming candles. green, the illustrations place In the forthcoming picture
Jews in all lands gather to cele- it’s an arresting introduction. Mr. Rubin’s picture of this readers ages 4-10 with those book “Saint Spotting: or, How
brate a joyful holiday.” Thus Writer Susan Kusel and moment has a garish, startling first audiences who gathered to Read a Church” (Eerdmans,
begins Lynne Sharon Schwartz’s illustrator Sean Rubin give an quality: Coattails streaming, in Galilee and 44 pages, $17.99),
chronicle of Passover, which old Yiddish story a new setting the juggler appears to be falling Judea. Drawing Chris Raschka uses
this year begins March 27, in in “The Passover Guest” or flying—a floating posture from the Gospels, soft brush strokes and
“The Four Questions” (Levine (Neal Porter, 32 pages, $18.99), that pays homage to Marc Mr. Hendrix uses glowing watercolors to
CHILDREN’S Querido, 40 pages, $17.99), Chagall, who created artwork his own language illumine a gentle game
BOOKS a striking picture book for THIS WEEK for a 1917 version of the story. to impart such that he and his mother
MEGHAN children ages 3 to 10 that was That night, as Muriel and her allegorical lessons liked to play when he
COX GURDON originally published in 1989. The Four Questions parents contemplate an empty as those of the was a boy. They would
Ms. Schwartz’s text is By Lynne Sharon Schwartz table, the strange man appears Good Samaritan, meander through
sensitive and accessible. She Illustrated by Ori Sherman at their door. “I have every- the Wise and churches, looking at
lays out the historical origins thing we need,” he says. Soon Foolish Builders, the iconography, talking
of the Passover Seder, the The Passover Guest their shabby home glows with and the Pearl of about the stories the
thanksgiving meal that recalls By Susan Kusel candlelight. “And the food! Great Price. art conveyed and
the pharonic days of Hebrew Illustrated by Sean Rubin There were mountains of His telling of identifying saints
Our captivity and God’s deliverance tender brisket, oceans of flavor- the story of the from their different
annual of the Jewish people. She Go and Do Likewise! ful soup, and fields of crunchy Prodigal Son is attributes. “Saint Spot-
explains the presence on the By John Hendrix matzah.” As to the identity of especially good. ting” invites readers
roundup Seder table of specific foods the mysterious visitor, let’s just The young man ages 3-8 to come along.
of (bitter herbs, unleavened bread, Saint Spotting say he’s the kind of guest for squanders his Like a guidebook, it
picture salt water), all while answering By Chris Raschka whom there’s always an empty birthright and
EERDMANS
starts with a map and a
books the overarching question: “Why chair at Passover. travels home, list of saints and virtues
is this night different from all In time for Easter, which hungry and ashamed. “As the depicted for children to find.
for other nights?” Ori Sherman’s a picture book about a stranger this year falls on April 4, writer wayward son came over the Mr. Raschka begins with Saint
Passover illustrations are sensational: who brings magical bounty and illustrator John Hendrix top of a hill he had known since Anthony, who was, he writes,
and Vivid, enigmatic tableaux of to the Seder table of an recounts a dozen parables boyhood, he saw his father’s “kind and loved reading, so you
anthropomorphized animals impoverished family. The from the New Testament house again.” Bracing himself will see him holding a book or a
Easter. stand out on black backgrounds events in this adaptation of a in “Go and Do Likewise!” for an angry scene, the young baby (usually Jesus as a baby),
like scenes in stained glass or 1904 short story by I.L. Peretz, (Abrams, 40 pages, $18.99), sinner is amazed to see his or both.” On the next page,
like bright folkloric panels on “Der Kunzen-Macher,” transpire a picture book that in its varied father running toward him. he shows a mother and son
a dark quilt. There are lions, in Washington during the Great lettering and sharp color There’s tremendous energy in looking a painting of a woman
elephants, crocodiles and koalas; Depression. Cherry blossoms contrasts exudes a sense of Mr. Hendrix’s portrayal of the with the implement of her
apes and bullocks, kangaroos are frothing on the trees in the confidence and vigor. “Jesus’s reunion: “His father’s warm martyrdom: “Here is Saint
and geese. Some wear pince- spring of 1933, when a poor girl sandals were always dusty,” embrace was upon him in a Catherine with her wheel,
nez, some gold earrings. As named Muriel notices a curious Mr. Hendrix writes, explaining rush of joy. He grabbed his which was made to kill her as
Georgetown University art fellow juggling eggs on the how the young Nazarene walked son tightly—lifting him off the punishment for teaching the
historian Ori Z. Soltes explains steps of the Lincoln Memorial: with his disciples from town ground and kissing his cheek!” emperor’s wife about Jesus.”
in an afterword, such human- “He looked as threadbare as to town, addressing crowds. In the illustration, the man is (See above.) Abundant yellows
ized animal imagery has the men on the street waiting “He was God’s son, sent to be a still trailing clouds of dust from and golds give warmth to this
appeared in Jewish religious in line for soup.” As Miriam teacher, a storyteller, a miracle his headlong dash, and with his slim and affectionate volume.
C12 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BOOKS
‘A good traveler leaves no tracks.’ —LAO TZ U
BY JULIE ZICKEFOOSE
W
E HUMANS had
until recently be-
come inured to
losing track of
breeding birds for
the duration of their migratory jour-
neys, which we now know can span
tens of thousands of miles. When a
white stork turned up in Klütz, Ger-
many, in the spring of 1822 with an
arrow from Africa dangling from its
neck, an awakening began that migra-
tory birds are up to something much
bigger than suspected. Another 25 such
perforated storks have turned up since,
enough for Germans to coin a name for
them (Pfeilstorche). Long before we put
bands on birds to track their journeys,
these “arrow-storks” told of an annual
DAVID TIPLING
Nonfiction E-Books Nonfiction Combined Fiction E-Books Fiction Combined Hardcover Business
TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST
AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK
The Code Breaker 1 New How to Do the Work 1 New The Four Winds 1 3 Life After Death 1 2 Atomic Habits 1 1
Walter Isaacson/Simon & Schuster Nicole Lepera/Harper Wave Kristin Hannah/St. Martin’s Sister Souljah/Atria James Clear/Avery
How to Do the Workk 2 New The Code Breaker 2 New Spellmaker 2 New Green Eggs and Ham 2 3 Think Again 2 2
Nicole Lepera/Harper Wave Walter Isaacson/Simon & Schuster Charlie N. Holmberg/47North Dr. Seuss/Random House Young Readers Adam Grant/Viking
Business Success Secrets 3 New Everything Will Be Okay 3 New Fast Ice 3 New The Four Winds 3 10 StrengthsFinder 2.0 3 5
Tamara Nall et al./Leaders Dana Perino/Twelve Clive Cussler/Putnam Kristin Hannah/St. Martin’s Tom Rath/Gallup
The Deep Rig 4 — Beyond Order 4 1 Wild Wind 4 New Later 4 — Quantum Marketing 4 —
Patrick M. Byrne/Deep Capture Jordan B. Peterson/Portfolio Kristen Ashley/1001 Dark Nights Stephen King/Hard Case Crime Raja Rajamannar/Harper Leadership
The Boys in the Boat 5 — Atomic Habits 5 5 Heartbreak Bay 5 New The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and... 5 — Dare to Lead 5 4
Daniel James Brown/Penguin James Clear/Avery Rachel Caine/Thomas & Mercer Charlie Mackesy/HarperOne Brené Brown/Random House
The Devil in the White City 6 — The Four Agreements 6 9 Transient Desires 6 New 6
One Fish, Two Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish 4 Extreme Ownership 6 6
Erik Larson/Vintage Don Miguel Ruiz/Amber-Allen Donna Leon/Atlantic Monthly Dr. Seuss/Random House Young Readers Jocko Willink & Leif Babin/St. Martin’s
The Reformation 7 — The Sum of Us 7 — Later 7 1 The Cat In the Hat 7 1 Total Money Makeover 7 8
Diarmaid MacCulloch/Penguin Heather McGhee/One World Stephen King/Hard Case Dr. Seuss/Random House Young Readers Dave Ramsey/Thomas Nelson
Nomadland 8 5 Believe It 8 — The Rose Code 8 New Fast Ice 8 New The Daily Stoic 8 9
Jessica Bruder/Norton Jamie Kern Lima/Gallery Kate Quinn/Morrow Clive Cussler/Putnam Ryan Holiday & Stephen Hanselman/Portfolio
Everything Will Be Okay 9 New Seuss-isms! 9 2 2034 9 New Dr. Seuss’s ABC 9 8 Emotional Intelligence 2.0 9 —
Dana Perino/Twelve Dr. Seuss/Random House Young Readers Elliot Ackerman & James Stavridis/Penguin Press Dr. Seuss/Random House Young Readers Travis Bradberry/TalentSmart
1,000 Vegetarian Recipes 10 — How to Avoid a Climate Disaster 10 3 Timeline 10 — 2034 10 New Who Moved My Cheese? 10 —
Carol Gelles/Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Bill Gates/Knopf Michael Crichton/Ballantine Elliot Ackerman & James Stavridis/Penguin Press Spencer Johnson/Putnam Young Readers
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | C13
PLAY
NEWS QUIZ DANIEL AKST From this week’s NUMBER PUZZLES SOLUTIONS TO LAST
WEEK'S PUZZLES
Wall Street Journal
spaces, and
FROM TOP: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES; ISTOCK
Answers to News Quiz: 1.C, 2.C, 3.D, 4.B, 5.B, 6.C, 7.A, 8.D, 9.A
THE JOURNAL WEEKEND PUZZLES edited by MIKE SHENK
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 51 Name: Suffix
53 Turkey club?
1
19 20 21
22 23 24
54 Crockpot creation 2
56 Coach with 347
25 26 27 28 career wins 3
29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 57 Zest source 4
59 “Wir glauben all
38 39 40 41 42 43 44
an ___ Gott” 5
(Lutheran hymn)
45 46 47 48 49 50 51
6
52 53 54 55
61 Really shining in
a full-court 7
56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 defensive
64 65 66
scheme? 8
62 “Shoot”
67 68 69 70 71 72 73 63 Sporty auto roofs
9
74 75 76 77 78 79 68 Depth: Prefix 10
69 Foil, e.g.
80 81 82 83 84 11
70 Went like the
85 86 87 88
dickens 12
89 90 91 92 93 94 95 71 Squeezed (out)
13
96 97 98 99 100 72 Fell upon
101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109
75 Catchall category: 14
Abbr.
110 111 112 113 114 115 76 Eat like a bird
15
116 117 118 119 120 121 122 78 Cornball Gear Boxes | by Patrick Berry
79 Metallica
123 124 125
drummer Ulrich
Each Row of the grid contains a 7 • Legal document Boxes
126 127 128
series of answers placed end to • Lord Peter Wimsey's creator • Loaded down with gear (8)
81 Big initials in end, clued in order of appearance.
bowling • Humorist Lebowitz • Plays the part of (8)
Answers to clues in the Boxes list
On/Off Switch | by Gary Larson 82 Tick off must be packed into rectangular
8 • What United States • Ever-dependable person or
REVIEW
ICONS
When
FROM TOP: COLLECTION OF ERIC AND LIZZIE HIMMEL, NEW YORK; © ESTATE OF FRANCES MCLAUGHLIN-GILL
Magazines
Were Art
A new exhibition shows how European émigrés
helped to create the stylish look of midcentury
publications like Vogue, Life and Fortune.
A
theatrical lights, and because it was
rtists fleeing fascism shot outdoors and not “in a studio
in Europe came to with a fake backdrop of nature.”
America in the 1930s Brodovitch’s penchant for energetic
and unleashed a sea images is also reflected in the leap-
change in magazine ing trio in one of his photographs
photography and design. Their revo- from the 1930s, titled “Choreartium ery issue of ‘Life’ or ‘Look’ ap- of Fortune, Vogue and Harper’s Ba- ‘Choreartium (Three Men
lutionary handiwork, and the work (Three Men Jumping).” peared, people just tore through it,” zaar. Jumping),’ ca. 1930s, by Alexey
of younger American artists they in- The exhibition includes roughly Mr. Klein said. Innovative graphic Under art editor Alexander Liber- Brodovitch.
spired, is on display in a new exhi- 150 items from 1930 to 1960, when design and images by young Ameri- man, an artist whose family fled the
bition, “Modern Look: Photography magazines were at the peak of their can photographers like Richard Ave- Russian Revolution, Vogue became
and the American Magazine,” at the popularity and influence. “When ev- don and Irving Penn filled the pages known for its expertly constructed under the art direction of German-
Jewish Museum in New York from pages and exquisite photographs. A born Will Burtin, covers on subjects
April 2 through July 11. number of Vogue covers in “Modern from cars to construction have a
The combination of American en- Look” feature the dynamic pairing space-age flavor, conveyed by subtle
trepreneurship with European aes- of Liberman and German-born pho- type and colorful images.
thetics and training yielded a tographer Erwin Blumenfeld. In the In the 1950s, a number of maga-
golden age for U.S. magazines from March 1945 issue, for instance, the zines hoped to spark reactions be-
the late 1930s to the 1950s, said Ma- cover urges readers to “do your part yond admiration. Some photogra-
son Klein, senior curator at the Jew- for the Red Cross”; to the left of the phers strove to project “a sense of
ish Museum and the organizer of words is a thick cross, with Blumen- experience, a sense of perception, a
the show. Some émigré photogra- feld’s photo of a slender woman in-
phers and designers studied at the side the vertical axis. In a photo-
Bauhaus school in Germany, which graph by Liberman protégée
pioneered modernist design. Alexey Frances McLaughlin-Gill, “Nan Mar-
Alexey
Brodovitch, the Russian-born art di- tin, Street Scene, First Avenue, Brodovitch, the
rector of Harper’s Bazaar, painted 1949,” the soignée subject exudes Russian-born art
backdrops for the Ballets Russes in both businesslike purpose—back to
Paris before coming to the U.S. He the camera, she pores over a news- director of
would exhort photographers with a paper—and style, with her triple Harper’s Bazaar,
phrase borrowed from the troupe’s strand of pearls and long black
founder, Serge Diaghilev: “Astonish gloves. would exhort
me!” In time, photographers such as photographers:
Photographers rose to the chal- the Austrian-born Lisette Model
lenge. Martin Munkácsi, a Hungar- chafed against such sumptuous im- ‘Astonish me!’
ian native who became one of Ger- ages, preferring snapshots of people
many’s leading photographers, left whose faces and bodies reflected
the country after Hitler’s rise to the toll of real life. Harper’s Bazaar sense of a subject that you had to
power in 1933. He was quickly published a version of one of her come around to,” Mr. Klein said.
signed by Harper’s Bazaar, which photographs in the exhibit, “Coney Among them was Gordon Parks, who
published his groundbreaking photo Island Bather,” of a woman without aimed to document Black life with
“Lucile Brokaw, Piping Rock Beach, a model’s proportions reveling in images such as “Invisible Man Re-
Long Island, 1933.” It captures a the surf. treat, Harlem, New York,” from 1952.
woman in a bathing suit running Pioneering photography and de- In Robert Frank’s “Street Line/New
full-tilt along the sand. The image sign weren’t solely the purview of York, 1951” a white line bisects an
was radical, Mr. Klein said, because fashion magazines. “Modern Look” empty city street with bustling side-
the model was in motion rather shows that graphic-arts publications walks and a solitary person crossing
and business periodicals also flour- midblock. The ambiguous situation
ished; designers and photographers is deliberate, Mr. Klein says, quoting
‘Nan Martin, Street Scene, “were aware of art being such a cat- Frank’s conviction that the “on-
First Avenue, 1949,’ by Frances alyst to thinking about the future,” looker must have something to see.
McLaughlin-Gill. Mr. Klein said. At Fortune magazine, It is not all said for him.”
Subservience
sassin, gliding along hotel corridors
in Paris, or watching, at ground
level, as a storm of autumn leaves
swirls up outside Marcello’s family
house. Not surprisingly, Francis
Ford Coppola would ask Storaro to
BY PETER COWIE loathing and yet—clothed first in become the cinematographer on
the elegant, sensual prose of Al- “Apocalypse Now” just a few years
WHEN “THE CONFORMIST” opened berto Moravia’s 1951 novel, and then later.
in U.S. theaters 50 years ago this in the exhilarating mise-en-scène of Bertolucci reminds us of the
month, its director, Bernardo Berto- Bernardo Bertolucci—it seizes the physical and plastic nature of Italian
lucci, stood at the apex of his career. spectator and maintains its grip Fascism, using locations in Rome’s
Precocious, prolific, he’d been rec- throughout what is nothing less EUR and Lazio districts that serve
ognized as a poet when still in his than a visual and psychological to dwarf the human characters: the
teens, and at age 21 made a remark- roller-coaster ride worthy of Orson gleaming white Palazzo dei Con-
able feature debut with “The Grim Welles and Josef von Sternberg at gressi in EUR for the asylum where
Reaper” (1962). Ahead would lie their best. An intricate web of flash- Marcello visits his father; the high,
such notable films as “Last Tango in backs is knitted with breathtaking long wall with its chiseled Latin in-
Paris,” “1900” and “The Last Em- skill into a narrative that is both in- scriptions in Piazza Augusto Imper-
peror,” but “The Conformist” is a timate and reflective of is- atore; or the Ponte Sant’Angelo
classic that will outlast all of Berto- sues such as political com- Jean-Louis soul. He may have Pierre Clémenti as Lino, whose where Marcello meets Italo and a
lucci’s other work. mitment, marital fidelity, Trintignant as discovered, as Sam- search for gay love frames the film bust of Mussolini is dragged along
Charming, devious, detached and and the influence of the Marcello Clerici in uel Johnson said in at start and end. the cobbled street.
small-minded, Marcello Clerici (a Catholic Church. the film. 1775, that “patrio- “The Conformist” bristles with With this masterpiece, Bertolucci
superb Jean-Louis Trintignant) The film’s sinister beauty tism is the last ref- great sequences. Marcello confess- captured the mood and the essence
serves the cause of Mussolini’s Italy presents Marcello in all his strutting uge of the scoundrel.” ing complacently to a priest who of Mussolini’s regime as no other
at the expense of friends and lovers glory. Sleek and smooth in his tai- Each of the principal actors em- dwells on his sexual deviancy. Anna filmmaker has before or since. “The
alike. His father, riddled with syphi- lored suits and soft-brimmed fe- bodies an aspect of the Fascist era. and Giulia performing a tango. Mar- Conformist” impressed a new gen-
lis, languishes in an asylum, while dora, he marches like a well-trained Stefania Sandrelli as Giulia, the cello’s school pal Italo, whose blind- eration of directors like Mr. Cop-
his mother lives in a decrepit house runway model through the vast, pretty but small-minded young wife ness is a metaphor for the Fascist pola (“The Conversation”) and Mar-
MARS/MARIANNE/MARAN/KOBAL/SHUTTERSTOCK
with a bevy of small dogs and the echoing marble halls of Mussolini’s of Marcello who accepts each new regime he espouses, holding court at tin Scorsese (“Taxi Driver,” in
lascivious attentions of a Japanese Rome. He radiates indifference, his turn in their fortunes. Dominique an assembly of his blind friends. The particular), and the casting of Gas-
chauffeur. Haunted by a traumatic heart as cold as the ice-blue exteri- Sanda as Anna, the beguiling bisex- stabbing of the professor on a snow- tone Moschin as the ill-fated Don
incident in childhood, Marcello as- ors so brilliantly lighted by the cine- ual who almost seduces Giulia while cold forest road, like Julius Caesar Fanucci in “The Godfather Part II”
pires to a “normal” sex life and a matographer Vittorio Storaro. In the remaining loyal to her husband, the in that classical Rome so beloved of pays tribute to Bertolucci’s ground-
bourgeois marriage. The authentic wake of the fall of Mussolini in July anti-Fascist professor Quadri. Gas- Mussolini. And the coda, when amid breaking film.
political “conformist,” he accepts 1943, however, Marcello sheds his tone Moschin as Manganiello, the the celebrations of Il Duce’s down-
without demur the government’s cultivated image and enters a final professional bodyguard and execu- fall Marcello denounces not just the Mr. Cowie has written more than
mission to assassinate his former scene of debasement unshaven and tioner who has served the Mussolini man who sought to seduce him as a 30 books on the cinema, including
professor, who works for the anti- dishevelled, just another subservi- cause since the early 1920s. Enzo boy, but also his best friend. The biographical studies of Akira
Fascist cause. ent coward who has betrayed not Tarascio as Prof. Quadri, quiet-spo- collapse of the regime counterpoints Kurosawa, Ingmar Bergman, and
It is a tale of treachery and self- just his best friend but also his own ken and shrewdly observant. And Marcello’s moral failure. Francis Ford Coppola.
OFF DUTY
Win the Cold Say You Want
Coffee War A Devolution?
Insulating mugs The new Subaru
that let you stop Legacy feels like
microwaving old times, says
your brew D10 Dan Neil D10
FASHION | FOOD | DESIGN | TRAVEL | GEAR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | D1
A Lucky
TED TURNER RESERVES (SHEEP); PETER FRANK EDWARDS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (DRINK); SEBASTIAN ROZO/THE ROAMING ROZO’S (DRY TORTUGAS NATIONAL PARK); STEPHANIE MEYERS (VINEYARD)
Spring
Break
Ready to bust out, but still leery of
crowds? Fortunately, these unsung
spots in the Sun Belt offer truly serene
getaways with plenty of charm
SUNNY SIDE UP Clockwise from top left: A desert bighorn sheep on Armendaris Ranch, a Ted Turner Reserve near Truth or Consequences, N.M., where the sun shines 290 days a year; a
bourbon-spiked ice tea at the Cloister resort on Sea Island, one of Georgia’s 15 sun-soaked barrier islands; Fort Jefferson in the Dry Tortugas National Park, Fla..; a barn at Scharffenberger
Cellars in Anderson Valley, an under-the-radar wine region in Northern California that counts 216 sunny days per year on average.
BY ADAM H. GRAHAM ble lakes, restorative hot springs, sugary alternative to Santa Fe’s folk art scene. Time your
W
beaches and acres of pristine parkland—all visit during a Second Saturday Art Hop to chat up
HATEVER YOU want to call places where you can giddily thaw out and locals at galleries like Desert Archaic, Rio Bravo
the last three months— jump-start your summer. Keep in mind, how- Fine Arts and Main Street Gallery.
Snovid-21, Snowmageddon— ever, that while the pandemic is ongoing, the Staying There Look for the green neon sign
the winter of our global dis- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention still hanging over the town’s 17-room Sierra Grande
content is officially over. advises against all travel as the surest way to Lodge and Spa, one of four Ted Turner Reserves
While the prospect of a sun-drenched spring prevent the spread of Covid-19. But for those in the state. Guests here have access to the
break never felt so deserved, deciding where to determined to proceed cautiously, here are five 156,000-acre Ladder Ranch, 45-minutes south-
go remains a challenge. Very few of us are ready destinations for your well-earned spring break. west, or the 362,885-acre Armendaris Ranch, 20
to plunge back into a swarm of sunbathers. But minutes east. Both offer safari-style game
a drivable warm weather spot with character, Happy Trails drives and encounters with bison, burrowing
natural beauty and minimal crowds? That’s just Truth or Consequences, N.M. owls, roadrunners and endangered tortoises. Af-
the tonic many crave right now. Known locally as T or C, Truth or Consequences is terward, plop down on the balcony for explosive
To find five such vacation spots, we scoured a scruffy cowboy hub (pop. 5,753) built around a pink sunsets, or slip into the soapstone bath
the Sun Belt, that vast swath of territory that bend on the Rio Grande about 160 miles south of filled with 104°F hot spring water (from $160 a
unfurls across 18 states, from Central California Albuquerque. More than a dozen thermal baths night, tedturnerreserves.com).
to North Carolina’s Outer Banks. According to burble around the area, which explains why the
Jonathan Erdman, senior meteorologist for town was originally named Hot Spring before it Seaside Sojourns
IBM’s weather.com, the most populous cities garnered its more colorful moniker in 1950, thanks Georgia’s Barrier Islands
within the region receive an average of over to a publicity stunt for the television game show Of the 15 main barrier islands that line Georgia’s
500 more hours of sunshine a year than those of the same name. Visitors can venture out into 110-mile coastline, Cumberland Island is among
outside the Sun Belt. Little wonder the Sun Belt the rust-colored hills and grasslands on any num- the most scenic and least populated. Much of
harbors the busiest beaches and spring-break ber of hiking trails (sierracountynewmexico.info the landscape—a windswept panorama of sand
party meccas in the contiguous United States, lists a few options) or loiter in town browsing the dunes, wide sand beaches and marshland—is
but it’s also full of under-hyped towns, swimma- cluster of galleries, offering a more contemporary Please turn to page D4
Inside
S
Jacquemus and Altuzarra has average things,” she said. “And
PRING HAS tech- ticked up, she’s noticed lately. you can take the suit and make
nically sprung. Once upon a time, this com- six outfits out of it.” One day
Many Americans fort-style combo didn’t seem so earlier this month, Ms.
are vaccinated or surprising. In the mid-19th cen- Moscone paired her tuxedo
You’ve done the dowdy leggings thing. Now let spring’s relaxed have vax appoint- tury, lightweight wool suiting trousers with a sweater and
ments in view. With luck, became the male leisurewear of Nike Air Force 1s; the next, she
suiting gently reacquaint you with getting dressed. you’ll soon step into a bright, choice, said Dr. Chris Breward, wore the full suit around town.
bustling life beyond your clut- director of National Museums To avoid comparisons to
tered living room. And the Scotland. Only in the early 20th Talking Heads frontman David
sloppy sweats you’ve been century did suits get stigma- Byrne, who wriggled in an ab-
wallowing in for months? tized by stiff, office associations. surdly roomy suit in the 1984
Leave them behind, even if From the 1860s on, wool concert film, “Stop Making
abandoning their plush, reas- “lounge suits” were considered Sense,” Ms. Moscone insists
suring embrace will challenge ideal for, as Dr. Breward put it, your jacket’s shoulders must fit
you. Suiting—yes, suiting—is “country pursuits” like Saturday “amazingly.” Ms. Fei precisely
here to help you segue from woodland walks, hunting, fish- calibrates her sleeve and pant
athleisure addict to present- ing and even sprawling on the lengths, but doesn’t mind a bil-
able person. beach. “They were much more lowing blazer. “I’ve definitely
Designers realize that, after informal garments.” Eventually worn suits that are too big,” she
a year in loungewear, women the style was controversially ap- said. “But as long as they’re
are loath to abandon comfort. propriated by such trailblazing comfortable, it still feels like the
So this spring, brands from women as Marlene Dietrich, pic- right fit.” Ms. Morrison, the
Stella McCartney and the Row tured here posing in a subver- stylist, said showing a scintilla
to Brunello Cucinelli and Max sively untrim suit in the 1930s. of skin can soften the look.
Mara strategically proposed Some modern adherents are “Maybe you don’t wear any-
louche suits so relaxed, they thing underneath and your clav-
might as well be PJs. “An over- icle shows.” She suggested more
size suit is…the perfect transi- modest women roll up the
tion from what we’ve been ‘These suits are the sleeves or tuck the trousers into
forced to wear in the last year,” perfect transition a boot for “a little more shape at
said New York stylist Emma the bottom.”
Jade Morrison. “They’re just as
from what we’ve Carolina Cucinelli, the co-
easy to wear as a sweatsuit.” been forced to wear president of Italian luxury label
Treat them unpreciously, she in the last year.’ Brunello Cucinelli, conceded
urges: Try one with a T-shirt that an oversize suit could in-
and sneakers for errands or a timidate the uninitiated. But she
brisk walk (as her client model encourages them to think out-
Emily Ratajkowski does). bringing slouchy suits back to side of the box. Avoid stodgy
Lily Snyder, 37, a New York their casual roots. JiaJia Fei, a formality by choosing a cheerful
art adviser, succumbed to 34-year-old digital strategist in color like peach, an unexpected
sweats during the pandemic, but Brooklyn, bikes to work in her cargo trouser (like the Cucinelli
is excited to reacquaint herself bright, monochromatic versions. ones below) or by using a bright
with her wardrobe of generous To walk her “giant” dog in Los sneaker and hoodie to “break
suits by labels like Paul Smith Angeles, Cassandra Grey, the up” the suit’s perceived stuffi-
and Bottega Veneta. Ms. Snyder founder and CEO of beauty re- ness. Accessorize irreverently,
appreciates that some women tailer Violet Grey, wears one of counsels Ms. Morrison, espe-
don’t want to be constricted by her eight loose suits from cially when it comes to foot-
dresses or blistered by high- brands like the Row with cream wear. “Anything that has a bit of
heels again. “But my [suits] Air Jordans and a sweatshirt. “If humor behind it works really
aren’t binding. They make me you just buy a few suits, you can well,” she said. Converse sneak-
feel great…like my true and best make a whole uniform and ers, beat-up loafers, chunky san-
self.” She often wears her ample never have to worry about dals and clogs all supply ade-
ensembles with a collared shirt, clothes again,” said Ms. Grey, 43, quate flippancy. But don’t
platform shoes and cuff links. who sometimes wears hers with overthink it, Ms. Morrison cau-
“Style and comfort don’t a men’s button-down or even tioned. “Just throw it on. The
GETTY IMAGES
need to be mutually exclusive just a bra. less you style it, the more natu-
anymore,” said Lisa Aiken, the Wardrobes anchored in tai- ral and inherently comfortable
New York-based buying and loring are New York designer it’s going to look.” And feel, for
BLACK-TIE EXPRESS In the 1930s, Marlene Dietrich exuded confidence in a slouchy precursor fashion director of e-commerce Marina Moscone’s specialty. that matter. You won’t even
to spring 2021’s roomy two-pieces. Matching berets are no longer de rigueur. site Moda Operandi. Interest in “People want to collect a great miss those sweats.
SUITABLE FOR LOUNGING / GENEROUSLY TAILORED SETS THAT ARE POLISHED ENOUGH FOR THE OFFICE AND COMFY ENOUGH FOR RECLINING
Blue and Breezy Elongated in Eggshell Saturday Sprezzatura Ample and Affordable The Big Beige
Jacket, $1,590, Pants, $765, Marina Moscone Jacket, $2,250, saksfifthav- Jacket, $4,495, Pants, $1,675, Jacket, $250, Pants, $135, Jacket, $1,650, Pants, $895,
maxmara.com enue.com; Pants, $990, marinamoscone.com Brunello Cucinelli, 212-334-1010 cosstores.com stellamccartney.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | D3
After a pandemic year that’s popularized casual comfort, broad, baggy jeans—like those Ralph Lauren
memorably wore in 2005—have finally replaced stifling skinny-leg denim
BY JACOB GALLAGHER ing home a lot and wanting to be
O
comfortable,” customers have
VER THE past month, shifted toward a fuller-cut jean that
a particular photo of “isn’t always reminding you of its
Ralph Lauren has presence on your body.” 3sixteen’s
been popping up per- CS, or “Classic Straight” fit, which
sistently on my so- boasts a roughly 8-inch hem width,
cial-media feeds. It shows the is selling briskly.
Americana idol taking his bow after That said, as the wider-jean re-
his company’s women’s fashion naissance unfolds, some men are
show in New York in 2005. His ca- adopting looser cuts for sentimental
sual outfit (pictured, right) is ordi- reasons, too. In a phone interview,
nary for a designer performing a Mr. Mackintosh of New York happily
curtain call, except for one thing: declared that he was wearing a pair
The silver-haired Mr. Lauren is of vintage pleated Polo Ralph Lauren Pleat-Front Throwback
wearing supersize jeans. His mildly jeans—“something I absolutely re-
washed-out, barrel-cut denims member from the ’80s. I had them in A vintage-inspired chino
make him look like a 1920s prospec- the ’80s.” (A more recent version of version. Polo Ralph Lauren
tor or an ’80s b-boy about to pop those jeans—see “Broad Ways,” Jeans, $188, ralphlauren.com
and lock his way down the runway. left—are currently the widest denim
They’re not quite as wide as JNCOs, style in Ralph Lauren’s collections.)
the infamous ’90s jeans whose vast The “highly nostalgic” jeans trans-
hems could accommodate a Subway port Mr. Mackintosh back to his
footlong, but they’re still some youth.
spectacularly roomy jeans. And
about 15 years after that photo was
taken, the wide look is surging
again. He questions why he
Labels as haughty as Balenciaga long squeezed into
and Bottega Veneta are selling
gigundo tube-legged jeans for $595
skinnies. Wearing roomy
and $980 respectively. For frugal jeans is like exhaling
denim-heads, Wrangler’s online after years of sucking in.
shop offers 38 styles of “Relaxed”
men’s jeans starting at $20. On
Levi’s web store, the “Loose” selec-
tion of nine styles includes the Noah Zagor, the senior mens-
“Stay Loose,” a very ’90s-esque wear strategist at WGSN, a trend-
baggy jean (pictured, left). forecasting agency, said pop cul-
Janine Chilton-Faust, the global ture is also fueling the surge of
VP of men’s design at Levi’s, ex- exaggerated jeans. While rail-thin Cropped and Cuffed
plained that this flowier style, re- indie rock stars like the Strokes
leased just last year, was inspired helped fuel the skinny-jean look in A light-wash, high-fashion
by contemporary “skate kids’’ who the early aughts, currently promi- take. Loewe Jeans, $690,
were purchasing wider vintage nent musicians like Billie Eilish matchesfashion.com
jeans—often in a waist size larger and Bad Bunny favor billowy, anti-
than their own for extra roomi- fit clothes. “We look to people like
ness. This generation is “really that for inspiration,” said Mr.
gravitating toward the looser, bag- Zagor, and the trend trickles down.
gier fits,” she said. But Ms. Chil- Still, wide can get too wide. Mr.
ton-Faust noted that an older cus- Mackintosh explained that, while
tomer is also “coming back” to dabbling with breakdancing in his
larger denim silhouettes like the youth, he wore “gigantic” jeans.
Stay Loose. Those overly theatrical swishy
This return of looser legs could MR. BIG SHOT Designer Ralph Lauren steps out on the runway in an pants are a memory he’d like to
be read as a long-gestating back- improbably oversize pair of jeans after his fashion show in New York in forget—they’re not creeping back
lash to skinny jeans which, with 2005. into his closet anytime soon. Levi’s
hems as narrow as 5 inches, de- Ms. Chilton-Faust noted that the
fined the denim market for the impresario Kanye West, who were a trend, but they didn’t suit brand is not simply hitting refresh
past two decades—Mr. Lauren’s nearly always paired calf-hugging his “hefty” stature, and he always on its most floor-sweeping denim
defiance notwithstanding. In the jeans with his signature Yeezy struggled to find slim-cut jeans that cuts of the past. The proportions
recent past, Laird Mackintosh, 48, Boost sneakers. fit him right. In the past year he’s and taper of Levi’s straight-leg
a New York City actor, wore jeans Like many, Mr. Ferrer now ques- discovered his “perfect” jeans: jeans are still fairly conservative,
so slender that, when he SAT, tions why he squeezed into skinnies boot-cut Levi’s 517s that swing eas- clocking around 8 or so inches
they’d cling stubbornly to his for so long: Pulling on the comfort- ily around his legs. wide at the hem, so “you are able
calves, forcing him to tug them able straight-legged Levi’s 501s and It can’t be discounted that the to wear them without looking too
down for comfort. Roi Ferrer, 32, a 550s he wears now is like finally ex- pandemic year heightened comfort crazy,” she said. The reality is that Roomy and Retro
technician at a Los Angeles phar- haling after years of sucking it all considerations for many shoppers. denim as billowy as Mr. Lauren’s
maceutical company, remained in. Kevin Ibanez, 29, a nursing as- Andrew Chen, who co-owns might make for an amusing social- A hemp-infused pair that
GETTY IMAGES
loyal to ultra-lean jeans through sistant in San Diego, likewise comes 3sixteen, a New York City denim media meme, but those sail-sized takes style cues from ’90s.
most of the 2010s. He said he was up short when trying to explain his brand that has sold jeans for over a jeans won’t be blowing into stores Jeans, $98, levi.com
influenced by rapper and fashion years in skinny jeans. Sure, they decade, noted that “with people be- anytime soon.
D4 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
P
said, gave him the confidence tion has gotten the jab. travel resumes many people
ETER VOLNY, that “I’m vaccinated and I’m Many countries—including will want to dip their toe in What’s a vaccine What if I am
a retired adver- not scared of anything.” most of Western Europe—still gradually, said Joe Branca- passport? inoculated but my
tising executive, After a year of isolation aren’t open to U.S. tourists. telli, who runs the road war- The race is on to come up kids aren’t?
typically flies and oppressively endless Cases are rising in some ar- rior site joesentme.com. Here, with a standardized, all-pur- That’s a tough one. There’s
more than Zoom sessions, many of the eas; most of Italy, for exam- some things to keep in mind pose mobile app that will let currently no approved vaccine
100,000 airline miles annually newly vaxxed feel the same ple, just retreated into lock- as we get on the road again: you summon your health for those under 16 years old.
with his wife, and has even way. But it’s not a get-out-of- down after a variant reared data, from vaccinations to For some travel suppliers, in-
been to offbeat places like jail-card quite yet: In Mr. its head. You’ll still need to Where can I go? tests, in one tap. “It’s the cluding a few cruise lines, mi-
practice social distancing and In most places, the rules ha- proverbial Wild West out nors traveling with a parent
wear masks for the foresee- ven’t changed. Only a few there,” said Henry Harte- or guardian may be exempt
It might be wise to laminate that CDC able future, especially when countries are letting U.S. visi- veldt, travel industry analyst from vaccine requirements if
card you get when leaving the vax site so you are in public with people tors bypass testing and quar- at Atmosphere Research. they have a negative test.
you don’t know. antine rules if they have been
it won’t disintegrate in your wallet. Moreover, the CDC, which vaccinated; among them are
recently eased restrictions on Belize, Iceland, the Seychelles What’s Up, Doc?
small gatherings, continues to and Georgia. More countries
North Korea and Tajikistan in Volny’s case, with the excep- counsel against travel, even should join the list later this Two physicians specializing in epidemiology
his quest to visit every coun- tion of Greece this fall, his for the vaccinated. That’s be- year. Thailand, for example, and infectious diseases on when—or if—the
try on earth. Fully vaccinated journeys can’t happen until cause there’s still a risk of has said it will lift its manda-
vaccine will reboot travel, and their own
at last, he’s determined to 2022. And that gets to the getting and spreading tory quarantine restrictions
make up for the lost pan- paradox of the vaccine rollout Covid-19 while away from in the third quarter of this personal vacation plans for the coming year
demic year. “We are decidedly and hopes for a travel reboot: home, the agency said. But year for travelers with proof
sick of being homebound,” he Most of the world isn’t ready the advice could change, ac- of vaccination. Even if your
said. On the calendar: a five- to roll back testing and quar- cording to a spokesman for destination still requires a re-
week Greek idyll, an African antine rules for travelers just the agency “as more people cent negative test, being vac-
safari and a trek to the jun- yet. We’re still in a pandemic, are vaccinated and we learn cinated greatly reduces the
gles of Suriname and Guyana. after all, and only a small per- more about how vaccines odds you’ll test positive and
Home Sale
restrictions for fully vacci- mistic about the near fu-
nated people will be lifted ture. Soon, as more of the
soon. And ‘safe’ is a rela- population gets immunized,
tive word. Everyone has we will see the CDC loosen
Now–3/29 different risk assessments.
Your risk isn’t zero, even if
its travel restriction guid-
ance. Given that the vac-
Up to 15% off and free 1–3 day shipping you do get the vaccine.” cines could be available to
Where he’s going this year most or all American
Home Design Shop New York 212 343-4190 Tennessee to visit family; adults in a few months
Home Design at the D&D Building 212 688-3620
the Galápagos Islands to this will likely be sooner
celebrate his 50th birthday. than later.”
Home Design Shop Los Angeles 310 620-2680
. Where he’s going this
Shop online and find other retailers at knoll.com DR. DAVID ARONOFF year Washington state to
Director, Division of Infec- see his mother; Illinois,
tious Diseases, Department Michigan, Minnesota and
of Medicine, Vanderbilt Wisconsin to tour colleges
University Medical Center with his daughter.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * NY Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 | D7
A Garden Sculpture
nent perch from which to greet ev- effect as moonlight, which I like be-
eryone who walks up the path to my cause moonlight does something to
front door. Seasonal plantings at his our senses that makes us feel closer
feet draw the eye: In early spring he to nature,” Mr. Pringle said.
traverses a sea of Spanish bluebells, “I don’t think I can moonlight my
MOST MORNINGS when my friend studying in a garden bed. nasty war horse statue. and in summertime he floats on a horse,” I said. “He’s sitting out in the
Jennifer arrives for our daily 7 a.m. “Not him,” Jennifer said. “That For one thing, the cast-metal silvery cloud of artemisia. open at the back of the garden.”
run, we try to hide our feelings horse you’ve hidden for some reason horse is roughly the size of a real I phoned San Francisco landscape “That’s OK, you can still create
about how cranky getting up so behind an orange tree.” pony—a good 4 feet long and 3 feet architect Scott Lewis for advice. magic in the garden with the right
early to exercise makes us. Ah, the horse. We inherited two tall—and weighs nearly as much. “How do I make this horse look choice of bulb,” Mr. Pringle said. “I
But sometimes emotions spill out. statues from my father-in-law, who For another, a previous owner had like he’s at home in my small back- really like to use an amber-colored
“Your statue looks terrible there!” rescued them in the 1960s from a painted him the same strong red as yard?” I asked him. bulb on sculptures, because they
she said recently, pointing to a dark scrap-metal yard in Osaka, Japan. the Golden Gate Bridge. Third, his Mr. Lewis, who is often called create a darker, rich color.”
corner of my front garden in the It’s always been easier to find a size and saddle are toddler magnets, on to integrate clients’ sculptures The best part? On a recent jog
freezing predawn light. home for the knockoff of the famous so he was lagged into the ground into their gardens, said it is impor- with Jennifer, I found that describ-
“No, he doesn’t!” I protested, 19th-century statue of Japanese with cables to prevent catastrophe. tant to think about how a statue ing all the possible ways to show-
rushing over to protectively hug my scholar Ninomiya Sontoku than the “Why don’t you put him in a place will look from every angle. “Think case the war horse really distracted
bronze, 3-foot-tall scholar who was knockoff of the Chinese Tang Dy- where he’ll look like he’s running of a garden sculpture like art me from how much I hate running.
STEPHEN KENT JOHNSON FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, FLORAL STYLING BY LINDSEY TAYLOR, PROP STYLING BY CARLA GONZALEZ-HART; SALMAN TOOR, FOUR FRIENDS, 2019. COLLECTION OF CHRISTIE ZHOU. © SALMAN TOOR. IMAGE COURTESY THE ARTIST AND LUHRING AUGUSTINE, NEW YORK
FLOWER SCHOOL
Green
Party
Floral designer
Lindsey Taylor
cuts loose in a
bouquet that
riffs on dancing
THE ARRANGEMENT
ALAMY
TIMBER! The symmetrical furniture placement elevates the room’s design, said Portland, Ore., designer Max Humphrey of the rustic lobby of Lake McDonald Lodge, in Glacier National Park.
BY KATHRYN O’SHEA-EVANS This memorable space was singled clock all hail from the early 20th cen-
W
MY FAVORITE ROOM out by Max Humphrey, a Portland, Ore., tury. The symmetry of the furniture
Western
HEN LAND specula- designer who’s carved out a similarly placement also elevates the space.
tor John Lewis built distinctive American style, showcased in Mr. Humphrey warns anyone at-
Lake McDonald his new book “Modern Americana” tempting the look at home to stop short
Lodge, in 1914, his (Gibbs Smith). His nostalgia-tinged aes- of painting their walls orange. While the
Done Best
goal was bold: Entice thetic integrates the classic Yankee ver- color appears subtle here, with the un-
U.S. travelers liable to grand-tour nacular—plaid, gingham, quilts—with stripped logs and warm wood creating a
through Europe to visit the American reserve, and he argues that, despite its tone-on-tone effect, orange can jar if
Northwest instead. In Glacier National opulence, the famous lodge’s lobby also paired with highly contrasting color. He
Park, his chosen site, the spectacular demonstrates restraint. Placing lots of also cautions against overdoing rustic-
Montana Rocky Mountains easily ap- log furniture in a room of tree columns ity. Instead of wall-to-wall logginess,
A designer with his own style of American proximated the Alps. But Mr. Lewis’s and stick-style railings “can come off as consider combining rough-hewed furni-
hostelry also had to equal the luxe ac- matchy-matchy or Disneyland,” he said. ture—say, the woven chairs here—with
decorating finds inspiration in a national commodations overseas. His formula: Instead, the décor mixes a variety of modern furniture, like a Saarinen tulip
park lodge erected in Montana’s Rocky Mix the grandeur of a Swiss chalet with styles from the same era, a classic deco- table. Below, more of why the lodge de-
frontier rusticity, as illustrated by the rating trick. The Mission sofas and ta- sign succeeds so well, and what might
Mountains over 100 years ago hotel’s three-story open lobby (above). bles, Craftsmen carpet and Art Deco work at home.
Jake Cohen
The author of ‘Jew-ish’ dishes on
maximalist entertaining, go-to utensils
and those infernal sprinkle-bomb cakes
P
UMPKIN-SPICE BABKA. Shakshuka alla vodka.
Challah panzanella. According to Jake Cohen,
these recipes qualify as “Jew-ish.” This
month, Mr. Cohen, 27, a food writer and gre-
garious social media star with a devoted fol-
lowing on Instagram and TikTok, unleashes the notion on
the world in “Jew-ish: A Cookbook: Reinvented Recipes
From a Modern Mensch” (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt).
Published just in time for Passover, it’s Mr. Cohen’s per-
sonal, uniquely millennial interpretation of Jewish cuisine,
including the Ashkenazi dishes he grew up with, the Per- COUNTER CULTURE
sian- and Iraqi-Jewish recipes that he learned from his in- From top: essential
laws, and the foods that simply capture his imagination. cooking tools; a fruit
Some of the recipes might seem unorthodox, but they re- basket hand-crocheted for
flect a larger reality: Many secular Jews connect most mean- Mr. Cohen and his husband
ingfully to their heritage through food. The tone is as ear- by a family friend; essential
nest as it is tongue-in-cheek. (Don’t miss the author photo, a pantry items, including
yearbook-style portrait of Mr. Cohen flanked by challahs.) the tart spice sumac,
For Mr. Cohen, a habit of hosting Friday-night dinner with alternative sweeteners
his husband gave rise to an eclectic repertoire of recipes and and ingredients for
rituals. He writes: “It was about taking a moment at the end impromptu cookie batches.
THINK OF THIS as mole in minutes: tender remarkable depth to the sauce. Pasilla
pieces of seared steak simmered in a smoky chiles—the dried form of chilaca peppers—
sauce made with toasted pasilla chiles, bring their own fruity complexity. “You
charred tomatoes and a grating of Mexican get the slow-cooked flavors from the
chocolate. “It’s something you find at merca- chiles and chocolate,” Ms. Davila said.
dos all around Mexico,” said chef Diana Da- “But this is quick.”
The Chef vila of her second Slow Food Fast recipe. She recommends rounding out this meaty
Diana Davila At her restaurant, Mi Tocaya Antojería main with a serving of roast vegetables such
in Chicago, Ms. Davila features classic as fennel or carrots, or whatever you have on
Her Restaurant dishes and regional favorites you don’t of- hand. Black beans make a nice complement,
Mi Tocaya Antojería, ten see on menus stateside. Here, Mexican too. Served with warm tortillas, it adds up to
Chicago chocolate, aromatic with cinnamon, brings a sumptuous meal. —Kitty Greenwald
What She’s Total Time 25 minutes to just cover. Let chiles sit tightens slightly, about 3
Known For Serves 4 until they are pliable and minutes. Stir in tomato pu-
Authentic Mexican soft, about 10 minutes. rée and stock and bring liq-
cooking—traditional 2 pounds beef tenderloin, 2. Meanwhile, set a medium uid to a boil. Reduce heat to
dishes and regional cut into 2-inch pieces heavy pan over medium-high maintain a simmer, and cook
classics as well as Kosher salt and freshly heat and add tomatoes. Dry- until sauce reduces, about 10
her own creations— ground black pepper roast tomatoes, turning as minutes. Stir in grated choc-
served with warmth 4 pasilla chiles, toasted and needed, until they blacken in olate and continue simmer-
and hospitality stemmed spots all over, about 5 min- ing to meld flavors, about 2
2 plum tomatoes utes. Use a blender or food minutes. Turn off heat and
3 tablespoons sunflower oil processor to purée tomatoes cover sauce to keep warm.
1 cup chicken stock until smooth. 5. Set a large skillet over
1/
2 ounce Mexican chocolate, 3. Remove chiles from soak- high heat. Once hot, add
finely grated ing liquid and reserve liquid. meat and sear until browned
1 teaspoon epazote Purée chiles to form a on exterior and rare within,
(optional) smooth paste, adding about 3 minutes. Bring
Warm corn tortillas, to splashes of reserved soaking sauce back to a gentle sim-
serve liquid as necessary. mer and add seared meat.
4. Transfer chile purée to a Simmer meat until medium-
1. Season beef with salt and medium pan set over me- rare to medium, 3-5 minutes.
pepper and set aside. Place dium-high heat. Stir in 2 ta- Garnish with epazote, if us-
chiles in a bowl and pour blespoons oil and season ing, and serve with black PLAY WITH FIRE Toasting the chiles and charring the tomatoes before
enough hot water over them with salt. Cook purée until it beans and tortillas. they go into the sauce concentrates their flavor and lends smoky depth.
D10 | Saturday/Sunday, March 20 - 21, 2021 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
The Wall Street Journal is not compensated by retailers listed in its articles as outlets for products. Listed retailers frequently are not the sole retail outlets.