Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Research Proposal
Submitted by:
Benjamin Gane Jr.
Mark Jun Reyes
Angelica Marie Sanchez
Tahinay, Ma. Sussenette
BSN III-D
Version 1.0
[ 2020/10/06 ]
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Content Page
I Introduction 3
Hypothesis Formulation 5
Research Framework 5
Definition of Terms 9
Conceptual Literature 11
Research Literature 12
III. Methodology 13
Recruitment Process 16
Budgetary Requirements 22
References 23
2
I. Introduction
1. Background and Rationale
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and Acquired
immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) remain a worldwide epidemic. HIV is a
condition which erodes people's immune system thereby weakening protection
against infections and medical complications; and may be acquired through
unprotected sexual intercourse, blood transfusion, sharing of infected needles
during drug use, or needlestick injury (WHO 2020). As of December 2019,
there are a total of 71,077 people diagnosed as people living with HIV
(PLHIV) in the Philippines, and only about 60% of whom are on antiretroviral
therapy (DOH-Epidemiology Bureau, 2019). There are multitude of
underlying factors that fuel the increase of HIV cases in the Philippines.
Among others, stigma and discrimination remains unexplored and potentially
threatens the efforts in curbing this fastest-growing epidemic.Stigma and
discrimination may prevent PLHIV and other key populations of men who
have sex with men (MSM), transgender people (TG), and people who inject
drugs and their sexual partnersfrom seeking preventive and medical
management.Antiretroviral therapy (ART) is a biomedical approach of
providing long-term medications to suppress the viral load count of a PLHIV
and virtually limits their chances of infecting others and enabling them to live
as normally as possible. However, approximately 40% among those diagnosed
with HIV not on ART (DOH-Epidemiology Bureau, 2018). This is a challenge
for health providers in augmenting the continuous increase in the number of
new HIV cases in the country.
Stigma and discrimination play significant roles for the hesitancy in
seeking treatment smong PLHIV. HIV-related stigma is defined as negative
attitude and judgements to the person who acquired and at risk for HIV.
According to the study conducted among Sub-Saharan Africa, Southeast Asia
and Northeast Asia (Gray et. al., 2019), stigma is the main barrier in seeking
health care services, compounded by the lack of knowledge about the disease
and accessibility of HIV screening and treatment. Furthermore, (Coleman J.D.
et al. 2016), acknowledged that the HIV-related stigma influenced by religious
belief also aggravates the barrier for the promotion of HIV screening and
treatment among key populations. Understanding the underlying factors may
3
help for the development of a plan of action to lessen the refusal and
encourage key populations to have sexual health screening and ART
treatment. In addition, (Hatzenbehler et al, 2013) emphasizes that Stigma and
its extensiveness, affecting many realms of life such as social interactions and
adaptive strategy of a person and attitudes among public health.
HIV-stigma and discrimination are the most common adversities that
limits key population from seeking sexual health care screening and treatment
.Furthermore, Key population are the most at risk for aquiring HIV/AIDS and
STI and composed of sex workers, transgender persons, men who have sex
with men, people who use drugs. Rresearch as evidence in Iloilo City focusing
on the HIV-related stigma and discrimination that may improve the quality
of healthcare services are lacking.
This research aims to explain the effects of stigma and discrimination
on the key population to the intake of sexual health screening in Iloilo City.
This study also aims to describe the factors affecting the key populations' (i.e.
men who have sex with men, sex workers, transgender persons, and people
who use drugs) sexual health because of stigma and discrimination in Iloilo
City.
4
3. Aims and Objectives of the Study
This is to explain and describe the effects of stigma and discrimination
on the intake of sexual health screening among key population in Iloilo City.
The result of this research will improve better quality of healthcare services by
investigating the effect of these barriers in seeking healthcare assistance.
Identifying factors impacting the frequency of sexual health screening and
ART treatment among key population may contribute in the development of
scheme that will help in improving the interventions and quality of
services.This study also targeted to construct and produce recommendations
for the management in terms of stigma and dicrimination to increase the
number of key populations that undergo sexual health screening and ART
treatment.
4. Hypothesis Formulation
H0:
The stigma and discrimination has no effects on the refusal to the intake of
sexual health screening among key population in Iloilo City.
H1:
The stigma and discrimination has led to increase the refusal to the intake of
sexual health screening among key population in Iloilo City.
H2:
The stigma and discrimination has led to decrease the refusal to the intake of
sexual health screening among key population in Iloilo City.
5. Research Framework
HIV-related stigma and discrimination is present worldwide and it is
the currents issue that giving the key population the reason to halt in accessing
healthcare screening and ART treatment. According to (Stangl et al., 2019)
HIV-related stigma and discrimination has greatly affect the psychological
well-being and perceptions of every individuals. And this varies according to
the sociocultural norms, religious beliefs, environmental factors, and even
policies and laws are the major hindrance for the key population in the
5
accessibility to seek health care assistance. On the other hand , these factors
will lead to another stigma experience which is self-stigma related to the
feeling of social exclusion. Thus, it will impede on the HIV/ AIDS,STI
screening and treatment and may pilot for the severity of the disease. This
framework tend to explain the association between the stigma and
discrimination and the halt on the intake of sexual health checks among key
population. In Addition,to the Potential role such as socioeconomic status,
poor health services, stress and anxiety, poor coping mechanism, attitude of
every individual, and mistrust for the health care professionals will also
become barriers among the key population to their sexual health intake. As
this study aims to explain the assocoation of stigma and discrimination to the
intake oh sexual health screening and ART treatment among Key population.
This may help for the recommendation of the improvement and development
of intervention to encourage the key population to seek help from medical
professionals. As well as giving the healthcare providers knowledge about the
effect of stigma and discrimination.
6
Conceptual framework adapted from :
https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-018-6156
-4
Channel 1 connects to the knowledge and awareness ( factor 1 as F1)
that contributes and affects HIV/AIDS STI screening and treatment.
Knowledge and awareness will help and change the perspective and reduced
self-stigma (factor 2 as F2) and reduced (factor 3 as F3) that will contribute to
the reduction of stigma and discrimination (factor 4 as F4) to increased
socialization (factor 5 as F5) to improved the HIV/AIDS STI cases in Iloilo
City.
7
knowledge about the importance of screening and treatment might encourage them
to be tested and treated. counselling and orienting them that health care providers are
there to help them during the screening and treatment procedures.
Stigma and discrimination are present worldwide. In order to get rid of these,
counselling and orientation is a must regarding the effects of these factors on the
key-population and how these factors alter their HIV/AIDS STI screening and
treatment..
-Counselling strategies will help key-population interact and socialize with other
people and will be able to help them verbalize their feelings and needs. These may
assist healthcare professionals develop and improve quality of services that will
persuade key-population to be tested and treated.
6. Definition of Terms
Stigma-defined as negative attitude and judgements to the person who
acquired and at risk for HIV. It could be a contributing factor on the mental
status and well being of people with HIV or PLHIV. (UNAIDS)
Discrimination- defined as sexism and treating other people differently
because of HIV/AIDS, STI. (Marriam Webster)
Key population- consist of men who have sex with men, sex workers,
transgender persons, and people who use drugs these people are higly at risk to
aquire HIV/AIDS and STI (UNAIDS 2016)
Antiretroviral Therapy-combination of drugs used to subdue the HIV virus
and stop the progression and growth of HIV disease(WHO).
Human Immunodeficiency Virus- condition which erodes people's immune
system, Thus, weakens protection against infections and diseases. This may
acquire through unprotected sexual intercourse,blood transfusion,needlestick
injury (WHO 2020)
8
Acquired ImmunoDeficiency Syndrome-primarily caused by HIV and the
most advanced HIV case.(WHO 2020)
Sexually Transmitted Infections-obtaining from sexual intercourse cause by
such, parasites, bacteria and viruses (WHO2020)
Treatment- Procedure or therapy used to treat certain conditions or diseases.
(Merriam Webster)
Accessibility- the act of obtaining treatment for HIV (Merriam Webster)
MSM- men who have sex with men
PWID- people who inject Drugs (UNAIDS)
TGW-”Transgender woman” denoting or realating to a person whose sense of
personal identity and gender does not correspond with their birth sex (Oxford
dictionary)
FSW-Female sex workers (UNAIDS)
MSW-Male sex workers (UNAIDS)
9
consent if they will allow us to make them as our research respondents. . This
study will be focusing on identifying and assessing the factors that can affect
the intake of sexual health checks of key populations in Iloilo City. On the
contrary, this research is designed to have a thorough knowledge about the
effects of stigmas towards the frequency of health checks of key populations
in Iloilo City. The study aims t o give the key population the idea of what
programs and policies that will protect them. Besides, this research will
considered every aspects and factors that has an impact of stigma to the intake
of sexual health screening,
Religious belief, social and cultural norms, violence,socioeconomic
status, poor health services, mistrust for health care services and providers are
factors that will threaten the result of the study. But as the research title itself
we are focusing on the HIV-related stigma and discrimination to the intake of
sexual health checks among key population. Manageability of the extraneous
variable will be controlled using the tangible and specific inclusion criteria to
guarantee that confounders will not intervene to the outcome of the study.
The timing of the study and the field work for actual surveys will be
affected as well as the selection of the respondents for this research may be
limited to online surveys and analysis of data. While restricted public transport
and community quarantined are present due to the Covid19 pandemic. This
study will not conduct an experimental research as we cannot manipulate the
effects of stigma and discrimination among key population. To all intents and
purposes this study cannot provide the specific names of every respondents as
this research will be maintaining anonymity and confidentiality.
10
,United States and UK. Those countries stated a layered disgrace that PLWHA
had lived through stigmatized communities . In many cases, these people are just
the victim of judgement that the society created. In order to break the cycle of
discrimination against these people we should change our unlawful behavior so
that we can improve our situation and create a opportunity that can lead to a
productive and lawful lives.
Local Literature
Human Immunodeficiency Virus or HIV became globally pervasive
and the Philippines turned out to have a national contingency epidemic. The
bureaucrats were given notice by Dr.Rossana Ditangco about the extensive
outbreak and she stated that ’’we can’t control the rapid rise of HIV infection”.
According to the latest data, Philippines became the highest in ASIA Pacific
region on UNAIDS 2017 report. HIV malady in the, country grew rapidly from
2010-2016 , with new identified HIV infections carrier aged 15 to 24 year old as
men who had been performed a sexual intercourse with the same sex. Hence,
Paulyn Jean Rosell Ubial states that healthendow scheme that can increase the
finding in having an antiretroviral treatment for those individuals with HIV. In
addition, to have a safe space and environment for this people, the health
department also offered a quicked response like testing and other health service
that can lessen the effect of any health related risk factors .Therefore, government
officials must have plan to address this kind of concerned so that it could lessen
the stigma and we can’t risk this people aside from that, school must also offer
sex education in order to enlighten the students about having a proper and safe
sex. Moreover by this it could eliminate the shame and we can step up into a
brighter tomorrow.
11
discrimination. These barriers will keep the key population away from getting
tested and treated. And PLHIV are usually interiorized the stigma and
discrimination they experienced and start to develop self stigma.
HIV-related stigma and discrimination has been affecting the intake of
sexual health screening among key population. This is considered a notable issue
that must be pursued to develop the interventions needed to decrease the number
of HIV-related cases. In evaluating the effects of HIV-related stigma and
discriminaton we must have concrete data that will assist in formulation of
interventions and recommendations to highlight in order to encourage key
populations to seek medical assistance. Moreover, The argument for the
inquisitive aspects of investigation will be the most interesting part in the study
that will give insights to the readers of what this study aims to produce.
III. Methodology
1. Rationale of the Study Designs
Quantitative research i s an approach which underpins the numerical
data analysis that helps rule out the effects of HIV and STI-related stigma and
discrimination that impedes the key population from being tested and treated.
The cross-sectional quantitative approach through an online survey that will
gather and analyze data regarding the effects and nature of HIV and
STI-related stigma and discrimination. The stigma index questionnaire
adapted to (Siane et al. 2020) will aid in data gathering from key population
consisting MSM, PWID, FSW/MSW and Transgender woman. The data
gathered from this research will establish information to understand the nature
and effects of Stigma and discrimination among key population in Iloilo City.
This investigation will contribute to the development and improvement of
health services to encourage key populations to seek medical assistance.
Descriptive-correlational design will be used to establish the
relationship among stigma and discrimination and intake of screening..
12
The online survey questionnaire with the target sample size of 380
participants and will be conducting and disseminated in Iloilo city particularly
among key populations that is at risk for acquiring such HIV and STI’s
The following agencies will help distribute the said questionnaires:
➔ Western Visayas Medical Center
➔ Family planning organization of the Philippines (FPOP) Iloilo
➔ The Medical City- Iloilo IREACT UNIT
➔ St. Pauls’ Hospital - Mother Candide Health Center
Study Activities:
Online survey- facilities and centers will help in decimating the online
surveys. The survey questionnaire will be confidential and respondents have the
choice to withdraw and refuse the offer to be part of the investigation and it will be
distributed on an online platform specifically messenger. Thus, Survey monkey will
be used in calculating the total respondents needed.The data will be
password-protected and the researchers are the one that can access the data and
responses.
Table 01. Summary of Required Sample Size per Key Population Members
13
Key (N) (n) Minimum Confidence
Populations Estimated Population Sample target of Interval (CI) and
Size (UNAIDS, Size survey Margin of Error
2019) required respondents (%)
14
Adapted by: “Assessment of sexualized drug use and risk for HIV and STI among
Filipino cisgender men who have sex with men in the Philippines: An exploratory
mixed-method approach (Olete 2019)
Inclusion Criteria:
● 18 years old and above
● Member of key population
● Native ilonggos
Exclusion Criteria
● People who are unable to sign informed consent ( minor amd
people who diagnosed with mental illness and under the influence of
drug during the survey)
● Filipino who are not living in Iloilo city are considered excluded for
this research.
Exclusion of minors :
Respondents should fit into the appropriate age limit of 18 years old
and above. As this could be against the Republic Act of 6809
mandated for the majority commences at the age of 18 years. Minors
are still under their parents authority.
15
4. Recruitment Process
Informed Consent: Via private messages through messenger app: This
App is persuasive and one of the most used apps of filipinos citizens online
survey will commence a month before the actual data gathering.
Introduction of the research:
Explaining and informing the respondents about the aims and purpose of the
said investigation will be included in the survey that can be read by the
possible participants of the investigation.
Filtering: Inclusion and exclusion criteria must meet according to the process
protocol (see figure 1).
Survey forms: The possible respondents for the investigation will answer the
online survey using 10 closed-ended questions maximum for 15 minutes .
16
Data Gathering Approach Outcomes/Data Collected
2. Perception towards HIV and Most People think that a person with
other STI’s HIV and STI is disgusting.
a.Strongly Agree
b.Agree
c.Neither
d.Disagree
E.Strongly Disagree
3. HIV and STI stigma index People seem afraid of me once they
have learned that I have HIV and STI.
a.Strongly Agree
b.Agree
c.Neither
d.Disagree
E.Strongly Disagree
17
4. Attitude towards HIV and STI I need to get tested for HIV and other
testing STIs every three months if I were
sexually active .
a.Strongly Agree
b.Agree
c.Neither
d.Disagree
e.Strongly Disagree
5. Sexual health profile: When was the last time you had
unprotected sex?
18
Data application and storage ensure by the following process:
➔ Quantitative data will be collected using a secured online survey and
saved into a password-protected device.
➔ The personal identifiers of respondents are securely-protected and not
gonna be revealed in a research paper.
➔ All data collected will be gathered for research purposes only.
➔ Quantitative data collection and gathering using online surveys with 10
closed-ended questions in a maximum of 15 minutes.
Outcome:
Primary outcome of this study is to explain the relationship of stigma
and discrimination index to the frequency of sexual health checks among key
population in Iloilo city.
Secondary outcome of this research is to explain and describe the
effects of HIV-STI-related stigma and discrimination to the frequency of
sexual health checks among key ppulation (MSM,PWID,TRANS,FSW/MSW)
that will help to target contructions and recommendations for the management
in terms of stoping stigma and discriination that will encourage an increase
number of key population that will undergo treatment and screening.
Data Analysis:
The outcome of this investigation will deploy quantitative data
analysis. Cross-sectional data will be outlined using a frequency distribution
table to group and cluster accordingly for numerical analysis.
Statistical Technique:
Gathered data from online surveys will be analyzed using Descriptive
and inferential statistics for summarization of the characteristics of the data set
19
that will test the hypothesis . Chi-square test will be used to establish the
association of variables between stigma and discriminaton and intake of
screening and how it affects their possibilities to be treated and tested.
20
Confidentiality:
All data gathered and collected from the participants will be stored using a
password-protected device and only the researcher can access the said
responses and data gathered. All participants' identifiers are blocked and will
not be able to be revealed to the final research paper as against the Data
Privacy Act of 2012 (Olete 2019). Google forms will be used for the collection
of data and personal information will not be included in the form except for
the data required for the investigations analysis.
Vulnerable subjects:
MSM- has experienced HIV-STI-related stigma and discriination and has the
highest risk for acquiring HIV,AIDS and STI.
PWID- they’re named as addict (Olete 2019) and at risk for HIV for sharing
needles and engaging unprotected sex.
TGW- considered as gender bias, that's why being marked as immoral to the
eyes of people and religion. Religion considered only 2 genders (male and
female)
FSW/MSW- are not exception to the stigma and discrimination as it is named
by the public as “pokpok” considered as sinful for having multiple sex partner
accpording to the community.
The vulnerability of the subjects are being considered and respected by this
research. The data cannot be obtain in Non-vulnerable subjects as research
focuses on group of people that has higher risk for acquiring HIV-STI stigma
and discrimination.
21
Budgetary Requirements
7,976
References:
Stigma reduction in relation to HIV test uptake in low- and middle-income countries:
a realist review (Thapa et al 2019)
https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-018-6156
-4
22
fbclid=IwAR2FjPB2PANwyHOTyBR9sQ7g1PE8G5Mc6Our0hLiob4Mso5E
5-Xs3uKarx0
Validation of a modified Berger HIV stigma scale for use among patients with
hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection (Saine et al 2020)
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0228471
Validation of a modified Berger HIV stigma scale for use among patients with
hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection (February 5, 2020)
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0228471
Why I Can’t, Won’t or Don’t Test for HIV: Insights from Australian Migrants Born in
Sub-Saharan Africa, Southeast Asia and Northeast Asia (Gray et. al., 2019)
https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph16061034
23
Appendix: Curriculum Vitae of Research Team and Adviser
EVALUATION OF THESIS TITLE DEFENSE (LAST PAGE)
24
25
26
27