You are on page 1of 123

San Beda University

College of Arts and Sciences


Department of Economics

Managerial Economics
MNGRECO

C. B. Mendoza, Jr.
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Nature and scope of
Managerial Economics
Analytical Framework
and Application

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Analytical Framework: Theory of the Firm
Overview

The Theory of the Firm try to provide a


framework of Analysis that will explain
the behavior of the Firm relative to:
1. Industry and Market Structure
2. Conduct
3. Performance

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Analytical Framework: Theory of the Firm
Structure
This refers to the construction, formation and
the makeup of an industrial organization. It also
describes the kind of environment in which an
organization or market operates.

• Economic of Demand and Supply


• Industry chain economics

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Analytical Framework: Theory of the Firm
Conduct
This describes the behavior or comportment of
buyers and sellers to the structure of a market.
It also refers to the way buyers and sellers
interact with each other and the way they
behave.
• Strategies and Tactics
• Future Plans

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Analytical Framework: Theory of the Firm
Performance
This refers to the achievement or
accomplishment or results of a particular
market or industry.
Performance variables that are considered in
the market include product quantity, product
quality, and production efficiency.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Nature and scope of
Managerial Economics
The Theory of the Firm

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
The Nature of the Firm
• What is a business firm?
• An organization, owned and operated by private individuals,
that specializes in production
• The firm must deal with a variety of individuals and
organizations
• Sells its output to customers
• Receives revenue from them in return
• Where does the revenue go?
• Much of it goes to input suppliers
• The total of all of these payments makes up the firm’s costs of
production
• When costs are deducted from revenue, what remains is the firm’s
profit
• Profit = Revenue – Costs

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
The Nature of the Firm
• Every firm must deal with the
government
• Pays taxes to the government
• Must obey government laws and
regulations
• Receive valuable services from the
government
• Public capital
• Legal systems
• Financial systems
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the Firm

Internal (Goals of the Firm)


• Production Analysis
• Cost Analysis

External (Competitivness)
• Market and Industry Analysis

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the Firm
The Nature of the Firm
Figure 1: The Firm and Its Environment

Owners

Initial Financing Profit After Taxes

Input Costs Taxes


Input The Firm
Government
Suppliers (Management)
Inputs Government Services
Government Regulations
Output Revenue

Customers

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the Firm
The Nature of the Firm

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Understanding Business Cycles
Peak
Peak

Trough

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Understanding the Goals of the
Firm
• To earn Profit
• To increase its own value as an
economic activity
• To improve the quality of life in the
community

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the Firm

❖ Earning Profit
• It is the difference between the income an entrepreneur
receives from the sale of his goods and services and the
expenses he incurs to produce them; (income – expenses).
❖ Increasing its own Value as an Economic
Activity
• A firm always strives for its growth and stability in the
economy
❖ Improving the Quality of Life in the
Community
• A business entity provides job or employment
opportunities to the economy.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
• Expected Value Maximization
• Owner-managers maximize short-run profits.
• Primary goal is long-term expected value
maximization.
• Constraints and the Theory of the Firm
• Resource constraints.
• Social constraints
• Limitations of the Theory of the Firm
• Alternative theory adds perspective.
• Competition forces efficiency.
• Hostile takeovers threaten inefficient managers.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Decision-making Model
❖ The decision making of every manager is
considered as the heart and soul of any
enterprise.
❖ Its success and failures depends on how the
manager makes a sound decision when it comes
to utilizing his available resources (capital,
technology, human etc.) on the business.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Contextualizing Competitiveness

• An idea that initially was about


being the best - to cooperating to
produce the best

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Porter’s competitiveness

• Michael Porter’s concept is instructive:


• It is about long run productivity of a location as
a place to do business
• Good for firms
• Jobs and higher living standards for workers
(not low wages and weak currencies)

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
What Kind of Prosperity?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The key determinant of
competitiveness

• Endowments, including natural


resources, geographical location,
population, and land area, create a
foundation for prosperity, but true
prosperity arises from productivity in
the use of endowments

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Framework of competitiveness

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Porter diamond:
quality of business environment

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
The Nature of the Firm
Figure 1: The Firm and Its Environment

Owners

Initial Financing Profit After Taxes

Input Costs Taxes


Input The Firm
Government
Suppliers (Management)
Inputs Government Services
Government Regulations
Output Revenue

Customers

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
Meaning of Production

❖ Production is a process by which


goods and services are made
available to the consumer.
Production process simply means
the physical relationship between
inputs (labor, materials, capital, etc)
used and the resulting output.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
Thinking About Production
• Production naturally brings to mind inputs
and outputs
• Inputs include resources
• Labor
• Capital
• Land
• Raw materials
• Other goods and services provided by other
firms
• Way in which these inputs may be
combined to produce output is the firm’s
technology
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
Thinking About Production
• A firm’s technology is treated as a
given
• Constraint on its production, which is
spelled out by the firm’s production
function
• For each different combination of inputs,
the production function tells us the
maximum quantity of output a firm can
produce over some period of time

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the
Firm
Profit Measurement

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Role of the Profit
❖ Risk-Bearing Theory of Profit
❖ Temporary Disequilibrium Theory of
Profit
❖ Monopoly Theory of Profit
❖ Innovation Theory of Profit
❖ Managerial Efficiency Theory of Profit

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Measurement
• Business Versus Economic Profit
• Business (accounting) profit reflects
explicit costs and revenues.
• Economic profit.
• Profit above a risk-adjusted normal return.
• Considers cash and noncash items.
• Variability of Business Profits
• Business profits vary widely.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Why Do Profits Vary Among
Firms?
• Disequilibrium Profit Theories
• Rapid growth in revenues.
• Rapid decline in costs.
• Compensatory Profit Theories
• Better, faster, or cheaper than
the competition is profitable.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
❖ The Shareholder Wealth-Maximization Model of
the Firm
❖ Goals in Public Sector and Non-Profitable
Enterprises
❖ Non-Profitable Objectives
❖ Understanding the Markets
❖ Consumer – Producer Rivalry
❖ Consumer – Consumer Rivalry
❖ Producer – Producer Rivalry
❖ Government and the Market

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
Goals in Public Sector and Non-Profitable Enterprises

❖ The following points highlight the seven crucial


objectives of public sectors in a mixed economy.
1. Transformation of the Economy
2. Redistribution of Income and Wealth
3. Source of Capital Formation
4. Development of Socio-Economic Infrastructure
5. Achievement of Balanced Regional Development
6. Reduction of Concentration of Wealth and
Economic Power in Private Hands
7. Attainment of the Planned Resource Allocation

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
Non-Profitable Objectives

❖ The shareholder wealth maximization theory


presumed that the firm should try to maximize
the return to shareholders, as measured by the
total of capital gains and dividends, for a certain
level of risk.
❖ On the other hand, the firm should minimize the
risk to shareholders for a given rate of return

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
The Shareholder Wealth-Maximization Model of the Firm

❖ The shareholder wealth maximization theory


presumed that the firm should try to maximize
the return to shareholders, as measured by the
total of capital gains and dividends, for a certain
level of risk.
❖ On the other hand, the firm should minimize the
risk to shareholders for a given rate of return

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
• Goal of firms
➢ In all market models, we assume that the goal of
firms if profit maximization
➢ Profits = Revenues – Cost
➢ Profits act as a signal (of success) in a market
economy
➢ It is the standards by which firms are judged
➢ If an industry is profitable, many enter until the
profits are competed away to its
optimal/sustainable level

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profit Maximization
• Why are profits/is profitability important? –
➢ Affects stock prices
➢ Affects how investors view a company in terms of
attractiveness
➢ Affects investor decisions
➢ But achieving profitability is a constant
challenge
➢ Managers face many market uncertainties, lack
of information, poor strategies

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Assume Profit Maximization

• What about?
• Stakeholders
• Social concerns
• Environmental concerns

• Do these concerns influence profits?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Short or long run profit
maximization?
• This is a false choice
• Maximize the value of the firm
• The value of the firm is equal to the present
value of the future stream of profits
• Emphasis on short or long term will depend
on:
• Time value of money (cost of funds)
• Market structure
• Uncertainty

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Economic Forces that Promote
Long-Run Profitability

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Maximizing the Value of a Firm

• Value of a firm
• Price for which it can be sold
• Equal to net present value of expected
future profit
• Risk premium
• Accounts for risk of not knowing future
profits
• The larger the risk, the higher the risk
premium, & the lower the firm’s value

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Maximizing the Value of a Firm

• Maximize firm’s value by maximizing


profit in each time period
• Cost & revenue conditions must be
independent across time periods

• Value of a firm =
1 2 T T
T
+ + ... + =
(1 + r ) (1 + r ) 2
(1 + r )
T
t =1 (1 + r ) t

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Profits Possible Profit Streams

Limit Pricing

0 Time
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Economic Profits

• Economic profits are not accounting


profits
• Economic profits are equal to
revenues minus economic costs
• All economic costs are measured in
terms of opportunity costs
• Choices represent foregone opportunities

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Economic Cost of Resources

• Opportunity cost of using any


resource is:
• What firm owners must give up to use the
resource
• Market-supplied resources
• Owned by others & hired, rented, or
leased
• Owner-supplied resources
• Owned & used by the firm

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Total Economic Cost

• Total Economic Cost


• Sum of opportunity costs of both market-
supplied resources & owner-supplied
resources
• Explicit Costs
• Monetary payments to owners of market-
supplied resources
• Implicit Costs
• Nonmonetary opportunity costs of using
owner-supplied resources
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Types of Implicit Costs

• Opportunity cost of cash provided by


owners
• Equity capital
• Opportunity cost of using land or
capital owned by the firm
• Opportunity cost of owner’s time
spent managing or working for the
firm

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Economic Cost of Using
Resources
E
xplic
itC
os
ts
o f
M
ar
ket
-Supplie
d Res
o ur
c e
s
Th
e mone
taryp a
ymentsto
res
our
c e own
er
s

+
Im
plic
itC
os
ts
o f
Owner-
S upplie
d Reso
u rc
es
Th
eretu
rnsforgone b
ynottak
in
g
th
eow n
ers’r
e sourc
estom a
rket

Total Economic Cost


= The total opportunity costs of
both kinds of resources

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Economic Profit vs.
Accounting Profit
Economic profit = Total revenue – Total economic cost
Economic profit = Total revenue – Explicit costs –
Implicit costs
Accounting profit ? = Total revenue – Explicit costs

• Accounting profit does not subtract implicit costs


from total revenue
• Firm owners must cover all costs of all resources
used by the firm
• Objective is to maximize economic profit

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Brady’s Explicit Costs
Total operating costs and expenses $ 100,000
Interest expense 14,000
Non-recurring expenses 8,000
Income taxes 16,000
Total Explicit Costs $138,000

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Opportunity Cost of Brady’s Capital

Personal Savings $ 50,000


Annual rate of return 12%
Opportunity cost of equity capital $ 6,000

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Implicit Cost of Brady’s Owner
Supplied Resources

Opportunity cost of equity capital $ 6,000


Opportunity cost of own salary 45,000
Opportunity cost of building 24,000
Total opportunity cost of own resources $ 75,000

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Total Opportunity Cost of All
Resources

Opportunity cost of owners resources $75,000


Opportunity cost of explicit expenses 138,000
Total opportunity cost $213,000

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Brady’s Total Accounting Profit

Total revenue $ 210,000


Total explicit cost 138,000
Net income $ 72,000

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Brady’s Economic Profit

Total revenue $ 210,000


Total economic cost 213,000
Economic profit $ (3,000)

Based on his profit in 2007, did Terry Brady increase his wealth by
quitting his job at Mattoon High and opening Brady Advantage?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Infinite Annuity

• R = constant dollar annual return


• I = risk adjusted expected rate of
return
• V = present value of future returns

R
V =
i
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Present Value and the Discount
Rate
Economic Profit
Discount 0% 16% 10%
rate
Year
1 $700,000 $603,448 $636,364
2 $800,000 $94,530 $661,157
3 $500,000 $320,329 $375,657
Total $2,000,000 $1,518,307 $1,673,178

Present value is negatively related to the discount rate.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Some Common Mistakes
Managers Make
• Never increase output simply to reduce
average costs
• Pursuit of market share usually reduces
profit
• Focusing on profit margin won’t
maximize total profit
• Maximizing total revenue reduces profit
• Cost-plus pricing formulas don’t produce
profit-maximizing prices
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Separation of Ownership &
Control
• Principal-agent problem
• Conflict that arises when goals of
management (agent) do not match goals of
owner (principal)
• Ex. Mortgage brokers
• Moral Hazard
• When either party to an agreement has
incentive not to abide by all its provisions &
one party cannot cost effectively monitor the
agreement
• Ex. Preexisting conditions

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Corporate Control Mechanisms

• Require managers to hold stipulated


amount of firm’s equity
• Increase percentage of outsiders
serving on board of directors
• Finance corporate investments with
debt instead of equity

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Price-Takers vs. Price-Setters

• Price-taking firm
• Cannot set price of its product
• Price is determined strictly by market
forces of demand & supply
• Price-setting firm
• Can set price of its product
• Has a degree of market power, which is
ability to raise price without losing all
sales
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
The Theory of the
Firm
Market and Industry
Analysis

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
What is a Market?

• A market is any arrangement through


which buyers & sellers exchange
goods & services
• Markets reduce transaction costs
• Costs of making a transaction other than
the price of the good or service

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Market Structures

• Market characteristics that determine


the economic environment in which a
firm operates
• Number & size of firms in market
• Degree of product differentiation
• Likelihood of new firms entering market

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of Production
The Nature of the Firm
Figure 1: The Firm and Its Environment

Owners

Initial Financing Profit After Taxes

Input Costs Taxes


Input The Firm
Government
Suppliers (Management)
Inputs Government Services
Government Regulations
Output Revenue

Customers

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Industry Analysis
Why Industry Analysis?
o Analysis means taking a closer look at the
composition, features and behavior of firms
in an industry.
o How firms behave.
o What leads to them to behave as such
What is Industry Analysis for?
o Investment decision-making
o Corporate planning

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Industry Analysis
Investment decision-making

o Strong Linkages: Backward or forward


o Attractive: Profitable and growing
market demand
o Government support
o Infrastructural support
o Financial sector support

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Industry Analysis
Corporate Planning
o Corporate planning is a total system of
planning which involves the determination
of the objectives for the company as a whole
o Formulation of strategies for the attainment
of these objectives (all this being done
against the background of SWOT analysis)
o Conversion of strategies into tactical plans
(or operational plans)
o Implementation of tactical plans and a
review of the progress of tactical plans
against the corporate planning objectives.
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
SCP Analysis
o Theories of the firm try to explain supply relative to:
1. Structure
2. Conduct
3. Performance
o SCP Analysis is Pioneered by Harvard Economist
Edward Mason, 1930’s and his doctoral student
Joseph Bain in the 50s.
o Became popular in the 1980’s when used by Michael
Porter (Competitive Strategy) as a business tool to
strive and compete in the market.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
SCP Analysis

o Look at the structure of the industry and how it is


organized into different markets
o Firm’s conduct is determined by the nature of the
structure
o Given the behavior, analyze performance
o Used to understand formulation of competition policy

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Framework of Analysis

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Structure

Performance Conduct

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure
• Theories of the firm are organized around
the different kinds of market forms in which
firms can operate.
• In this course, the market forms are
grouped this way:
• Perfect competition
• Monopoly
• Monopolistic competition, and
• Oligopoly

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure

Markets
❖ Are institutions and mechanisms used for
the buying and selling of goods and services
❖ Vary in structure in terms of the number of
participants
❖ Market structure affect the ability of a firm to
influence the price for its product/s and
exert market power
❖ Managers respond differently to different
market types where their businesses operate

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure
• Market types influence the strategic
decisions that managers make (price of
the product and productivity)
• Type of Market Structure
➢ Number of sellers and buyers
➢ Barriers to entry
➢ Product differentiation
➢ Cost structures
➢ Vertical integration

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure

• Perfect Competition
Market Structure
Many
Firms • These market structure
can be arranged along
Many
• Monopolistic
Competition
a continuum where at
Firms the top (Perfect
Competition) there are
Few • Oligopoly a large number of
Firms firms in the market,
and at the
Single • Monopoly bottom(Monopoly),
Firm there is only 1 firm
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure

Each of these markets are


characterized by the following:
❖ No. of firms competing with one another that
influences the firm’s control over its price
❖ Whether products are differentiated or
undifferentiated (or homogenous)
❖ Whether entry into/exit from the market by
other firms is easy or difficult
❖ The amount of information available to market
participants

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure

❖ Perfect competition and monopoly


are 2 market types are Extreme
cases and Hypothetical
❖ In the real world, these markets
don’t exist/rare cases
❖ In the real world, markets are a
combination of these 2 extreme
models

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Market Structure
Why is market analysis important?
❖ Managers need to know the market structure
where their firms operate
❖ Market structure could indicate to managers
the strategic variables that they can use to face
its competition (or exert market power)
❖ Market power is the ability to influence price
and develop other competitive strategies that
allow them to earn large profits over longer
periods of time

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition
o A market form with these characteristics:
1. Large number of firms or sellers.
2. No one is powerful enough to influence the price
3. Homogeneous product.
4. Easy entry and exit of firms- No artificial
restraints on price, supply and demand
5. Mobility of goods and resources, ease of entry
and exit
6. Complete knowledge of market conditions
o Some economists add to this list that consumers and
firms also have cheap, accurate information about
prices.
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition
• What the assumptions boil down to is that
each firm in perfect competition is a price
taker.

• NO FIRM HAS ANY CONTROL OVER


MARKET PRICE.

• This means that the demand curve the firm


sees for its product is infinitely elastic.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition
• Infinitely elastic demand curve of
a perfectly competitive producer of
copra in Sariaya, Quezon:
price
P0 is the current
market price.

P0

quantity
(hundred dried coconut kernels)

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition
Warning!
• The market demand curve is still
negatively sloped:
MARKET FIRM
price S price

P0 P0

D
quantity quantity
(million dried coconut kernels) (hundred dried coconut kernels)

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition

• In competitive markets, market price


is determined by supply and demand.

• If a firm were to raise its price above


market price it would lose all its sales.
It would never be silly enough to
charge less because it can sell all it
wants at the going market price.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition
Market Structure: Perfect Competition
No of Firms Large number
❑ Recall our concern--Behavior
Product None of firm vs outcomes for entire
differentiation market/industry
❑ In a perfectly comp market, no
Market Entry Easy
single firm has any influence
on the price of the product
Information Complete ❑ Firms are price takers (i.e. firm
Buyers and cannot influence the price (its
sellers have own price, the market price)
equal access to but can sell any amount of its
information output at the price established
by the market/all players)

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Other Market Forms Defined

• MONOPOLY: a market with only one seller of


a product for which there are no close
substitutes.
• MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION: a market
with many firms, easy entry, and product
differentiation. (Each firm produces a
slightly different version of the product.)
• OLIGOPOLY: a market with a small number
of firms.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition

Market Structure: Imperfect Competition


❖ Firms have some degree of market power

❖ Market power
The ability of the firm to influence the prices of its
products and develop other competitive strategies that
enable it earns large profits over longer periods of time.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition

Market Structure: Monopoly


No of Firms Single firm ❑ A single firm only producer
❑ Product produced is that
Product None where there is no close
differentiation substitute or is very highly
differentiated. Thus,
Market Entry Blocked Consumers are willing to pay
more for this product
Information Imperfect
❑ Barriers to industry entry exist:
structural, legal, or regulatory
- keeping other firms from
easily producing same item at
same cost
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition

Market Structure: Monopoly


No of Firms Single firm ❑ Monopolist has market power
to influence price and earn
Product None larger profits.
differentiation
❑ Monopolist cannot sell any
Market Entry Blocked
amount of output at a given
market price as in perfect
Information Imperfect competition. Thus if he raises
the price, less output will be
sold; if he lowers the price,
more output will be sold

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition

Market Structure: Oligopoly


No of Firms Small number of ❑ In oligopolistic markets – a
large firms smaller number of larger firms
Product Firms may produce dominate so they exert a larger
differentiation similar or highly
degree of market power, but
how they use it is limited by the
differentiated action and reaction of their
products competition
❑ Barriers to entry:
Market Entry Difficult Structural/legal/regulatory
Significant barriers characteristics of a firm and its
to market that keep other firms
new entry from easily producing the same
Information Imperfect
or similar products at the same
costs.
information

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition
Market Structure: Monopolistic Competition
No of Firms Large number of small ❑ Firms produce
firms
Product Differentiated
differentiated products
differentiation Each firm produces a so they exert a degree
good or service that, in of market power, but
some significant way, is there are many firms
different
competing too, thus
Market Entry Highly competitive/
Relatively easy for new
limiting their ability to
firms to enter the earn above average
market profits
Information Imperfect information

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Imperfect Competition
Characterist PC MC O M
ics
Number of Large Large Small Single Firm
firms number number Number
competing
Nature of Undifferentia Differentiated Undifferentia Unique
the product ted ted or
differentiated
Entry
Information Complete Relatively Asymmetric Asymmetric
Availability good
Firm’s None Some Some Substantial
control over
price

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Determining structure

❖ Profitability and market share


❖ Degree of concentration and the Number
of rivals
❖ Conditions of entry
➢ barriers preventing potential entrants from
becoming actual competitors

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Determining market share

❖ Market Share = share of the biggest


firm as a proportion of market size
❖ Market share is usually an indicator
of market power.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Determining market size

Sales Value in 2005


Manufacture of
bakery products P42.6 Billion

Source: Annual Survey of Establishments 2005, NSO

Department of Economics 10
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Determining Concentration

❖4 firm concentration ratio


❖ Herfindahl Index (H-Index)

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
4-firm concentration

❖ The 4 firm CR takes into account the


market share of the 4 largest firms in the
industry
❖ CR = Summation of market share of top
four firms

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
4-firm concentration

❖A value close to 0 indicates that the


largest 4 firms supply only a small share
of the market. A value of 100% indicates
a single supplier.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
4-firm concentration

Restaurants, cafes and fast food centers


Industry Total Sales in 2005 (000’s) = P58,003,588
Jollibee Foods Corp. & Subd. 15,885,739
Golden Arches Dev. Corp. 9,332,864
Chowking Food Corp. 5,398,709
Greenwich fried chicken 2,918,342
Corp.
58%
Share of Top Four
Source: Top 7,000 Corporations, 2006-2007 Phil. Business Profiles & Perspectives, Inc.
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
4-firm concentration

❖ The H-Index takes into account the


number of firms in an industry and
their size differences
❖H = Summation of (market of share
of firms)2

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Herfindahl Index (H-Index)

❖ The H-Index tends towards 1.0 when


there are few firms and/or greater
degree of inequality in market share
❖ The H-Index tends towards 0 when
there is a greater degree of quality in
market shares.

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Herfindahl Index (H-Index)

H-Index: Guide notes


Structure Range of H-Index
Pure Monopoly 1.0
Dominant Firm 0.5-1.0
Oligopoly 0.2-0.5
Monopolisitc Competition 0.1-0.2
Pure Competition Close to 0.0
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Herfindahl Index (H-Index)

Share of top
Industry Description H-Index # of Firms
4 firms
Restaurants, cafes
0.12 58% 140
and fast food centers

Source of basic
Department data: Top 7,000 Corp. 2006-2007 Phil. Bus. Profiles & Perspectives
of Economics 18
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Herfindahl Index (H-Index)

H-Index: Retailing
Industry Share of top Number
Description H-Index 4 firms, in % of Firms
Dept Stores 0.15 92 11
Bookstores 0.20 58 3
Supermarkets 0.11 59 4
Drugstores 0.51 75 2
Groceries 0.24 69 2
Appliances 0.06 41 3

Source: NSO
Department of Economics 19
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Relationships

Structure Conduct Performance


Perfect Price taker Low margins
Competition Cost leadership Efficient markets
Price maker High margins
Monopoly High entry barriers Inefficient markets
Limited differentiation Quality issues
Advertising
Wide product ranges
Oligopoly Mutually dependent
behavior

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Industry characteristics

Number Individual Firm Market Product Entry


Structure characteristic
of sellers share barriers
Perfect
Competition Many Insignificant Homogeneous Low

Partially
Monopoly One 100% market share differentiated High

Monopolistic Few players each with Highly


competition Few small market share differentiated Low

Few players each with Highly


Oligopoly Few large market share differentiated High

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Structure

Performanc
e Conduct

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Conduct or Strategy
Elements Description

Pricing Key variable in industry conduct


Do firms concentrate on a narrow range of
Product
products or are they wiling to diversify into new
strategy
areas of production?
Can we expect that a different structure will
Research &
produce more or less R &D activity to enhance the
innovation
prospects of economic growth

Advertising What are the determinants of advertising spending?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Structure

Perform
ance
Conduct

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Performance

Elements Description
Profitability How profitable firms depends largely on their pricing behavior
How cost efficient and how allocative efficient firms are depends
Efficiency
partly on their pricing behavior & on other aspects of conduct
Economic How successful firms are in increasing real output over time
growth depends upon various conduct goals like R&D?
Full Do different kinds of market behavior make the attainment of full
employment employment easier?
Does a different market structure lead to a different distribution of
Equity
income?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Performance

❖ Production and allocative


efficiency: Consistent high
growth, profits
❖ Progress
❖ Full employment
❖ Equity
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Public Policy

❖ Evaluate social implications of strategies


❖ Enhance contestability
❖ Promote social welfare
❖ Ensure stability of policy

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Impact of regulation of Public policy

❖ Taxes and subsidies


❖ Regulation
❖ Price controls
❖ Antitrust
❖ International trade rules
❖ Information and education
❖ Public ownership

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Re-evaluation

❖ Current environment standards?


❖ Lessons from the past?
❖ Are conclusions from quantitative
analysis consistent with qualitative
analysis?
❖ Advice from players?
❖ Tips from others?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Relationships

Structure Conduct Performance


Perfect Price taker Low margins
Competition Cost leadership Efficient markets
Price maker High margins
Monopoly High entry barriers Inefficient markets
Limited differentiation Quality issues
Advertising
Wide product ranges
Oligopoly Mutually dependent
behavior

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
SCP Framework

Basic Demand Basic Supply


Conditions Conditions

CONDUCT
Pricing behavior
Product strategy
Research & innovation
Advertising

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Basic conditions
• SUPPY DEMAND
• Raw Materials • Price/income
• Technology elasticity
• Unionization • Substitutes
• Product • Rate of growth
durability • Cyclical & seasonal
• Value/weight character
• Business • Purchase method
attitudes • Marketing type
• Public Policies
Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Industry Characteristics

Number Individual Firm Market Product Entry


Structure characteristic
of sellers share barriers
Perfect
Competition Many Insignificant Homogeneous Low

Partially
Monopoly One 100% market share differentiated High

Monopolistic Few players each with Highly


competition Few small market share differentiated Low

Few players each with Highly


Oligopoly Few large market share differentiated High

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Conduct / Strategy
Elements Description

Pricing Key variable in industry conduct

Do firms concentrate on a narrow range of products


Product
or are they wiling to diversify into new areas of
strategy
production?

Can we expect that a different structure will produce


Research &
more or less R &D activity to enhance the prospects
innovation
of economic growth

Advertising What are the determinants of advertising spending?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Performance
Elements Description
Profitability How profitable firms depends largely on their pricing
behavior
How cost efficient and how allocative efficient firms
Efficiency
are depends partly on their pricing behavior & on
other aspects of conduct
Economic How successful firms are in increasing real
growth output over time depends upon various
conduct goals like R&D?
Full Do different kinds of market behavior make the
employment attainment of full employment easier?

Does a different market structure lead to a different


Equity
distribution of income?

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics
Theory of the Firm
Perfect Competition

Elements Implication or Performance


Profitability Zero economic profits but with positive normal
profits
Efficiency Resource allocation is determined by market
signals
Economic Economy is driven by industries that strive to
growth compete
Employment levels will grow according to
Full
growth of the industries and macro policy
employment moves
Known to allocate wealth equitably but can
Equity
suffer from market failures due to
externalities

Department of Economics
50 Years of Excellence in Economics

You might also like