Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. CCC 0268–2605/99/110805–07 $17.50
806 C. DE STEFANO ET AL.
very concentrated solutions of CH3Sn3 (from 210 purification. Hydrochloric acid and sodium hydro-
up to 830 mmol dmÿ3), reported the formation of xide stock solutions were standardized against
mixed chloro–hydroxo complexes CH3SnClx sodium carbonate and potassium hydrogenphtha-
(OH)y3 with x decreasing in the more dilute late, respectively. Concentrations of NaOH and
solutions. Analogous behaviour was found by strong acids were also checked by cross-titrations.
Tobias13,14 and more recently by De Stefano et All solutions were prepared with analytical-grade
al.3 in studying the interactions of (CH3)2Sn2 in water (R = 18 M
cmÿ1), using grade A glassware.
chloride solutions. Investigations on the hydrolysis
products of ethyl-, butyl- and octyl-tin trichlorides
have been performed by Luijten,15 who reported
Apparatus
their properties and preparation in the solid state. Measurements were performed using an apparatus
Some potentiometric studies on hydrolysis16–18 and consisting of a model 713 Metrohm potentiometer,
complex formation with sulphide19 of ethyl tin(IV) equipped with a combination glass electrode (Ross
trichloride in mixed water/methanol solution, have model, 8102, from Orion) and a model 654
been performed by Devaud and co-workers, in the Metrohm motorized burette. The estimated accu-
concentration range of the organometallic com- racy was 0.2 mV and 0.003 cm3 for emf. and
pound, around 6–60 mmol dmÿ3. Results obtained titrant volume readings, respectively. Titrations
by these authors are partially in contrast with were performed automatically using a suitable
findings for methyltin trichloride (Van der Kelen), computer program which allows evaluation of
probably owing to the different solvent and equilibrium potential values and determination of
concentration ranges used. Results of 1H-and the amount of titrant to be added when the emf. was
119
Sn-NMR and 119Sn Mossbauer spectroscopy stable within 0.1 mV for 3 min. The measurement
studies on the hydrolysis of methyl-and butyl-tin cells (25 or 50 cm3) were thermostatted at the
trichloride (0.5 mol dmÿ3) have been reported by required temperature with an uncertainty of
Blunden and co-workers.20,21 0.1 °C. All titrations were carried out with
From literature data it can be affirmed that, in magnetic stirring, and bubbling purified and pre-
general, investigations on the hydrolysis of mono- saturated N2 through the solution in order to
organotin(IV) derivatives have been performed by exclude O2 and CO2 from it.
using high concentrations of monoalkytin trichlor-
ide. As a consequence, the formation of mixed
hydroxo–chloride polynuclear complexes cannot be
Procedure
avoided, and the determination of hydrolysis A solution (25 cm3) containing (CH3)SnCl3 (1, 2, 5
constants of simple species, most importantly in and 10 mmol dmÿ3) in NaCl or NaNO3 as back-
dilute solutions such as natural fluids, becomes ground salts to adjust the ionic strength to different
quite difficult. values (in turn, 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75 and
In order to define a general scheme for the 1.0 mol dmÿ3) was titrated with standard NaOH
speciation of organotin(IV) compounds in aqueous solution up to pH 11 (80 to 110 points). For each
solution, we report here some results on the experiment, independent titrations of acidic solu-
hydrolysis of methyltin trichloride in NaNO3 and tions (hydrochloric or nitric acids) with standard
NaCl media in the ionic strength range 0 I/ NaOH, in the same ionic strength conditions as the
mol dmÿ3 1, at different temperatures (15 T/ °C systems to be investigated, were carried out in order
45). to determine the formal electrode potential (E °)
and the acidic junction potential (Ej = ja [H]). The
reliability of the calibration in the alkaline range
was checked by calculating pKW values.
EXPERIMENTAL
Calculations
Chemicals The non-linear least-squares computer program
Monomethyltin(IV) cation was used in the form of ESAB2M22 was used for the refinement of all
the trichloride salt (Aldrich; purity = 98%). All the parameters of an acid–base titration (E °, KW,
other reagents were of analytical grade (from Fluka coefficient of junction potential, ja, analytical
or Merck), with purity always >99.5%. Sodium concentration of reagents). For calculation of
nitrate and sodium chloride were used without hydrolysis and complex formation constants, to-
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)
HYDROLYSIS OF METHYLTIN(IV) TRICHLORIDE 807
gether with parameters for dependence on ionic Table 1 Equilibrium constants for the hydrolysis of
strength, BSTAC23 and STACO24 computer pro- CH3Sn3 at 25 °C and I = 0 mol dmÿ3
grams were used. Concentrations, and hydrolysis
and formation constants, are given on the molar Reaction logb S.D.
scale. The LIANA25 program was used to test the M H2O = M(OH) H
3 2
ÿ1.5 0.5a
dependence of logK on ionic strength and tempera- M3 2 H2O = M(OH)2 2H ÿ3.36 0.05
ture by different equations; the ES4ECI26 program M3 3 H2O = M(OH)30 3H ÿ8.99 0.04
was used to draw the distribution diagrams. The M3 4 H2O = M(OH)4ÿ 4H ÿ20.27 0.06
hydrolysis reactions may written as Eqns [1] and 2 M3 5 H2O = M2(OH)5 5H ÿ7.61 0.08
[2]; Throughout the paper we indicate, for simpli- M3 OHÿ = M(OH)2 13.5a
city, aquo–chloro and aquo–chloro–hydroxo com- M3 2OHÿ = M(OH)2 22.64b
plexes as (CH3)Sn3 and [(CH3)Sn]p(OH)q(3pÿq), M3 3OHÿ = M(OH)30 33.01b
respectively. M3 4OHÿ = M(OH)4ÿ 35.73b
2M3 5OHÿ = M2(OH)5 62.38b
pCH3 Sn3 qH2 O
CH3 Snp
OHq
3pÿq
a
Estimated value.
qH
pq 1 b
pKW = 14.00 0.01.
Hydrolysed species
Dependence of formation constants The monomethyltin(IV) cation undergoes strong
on ionic strength hydrolysis, even at very low pH values. The first
hydrolysis step cannot be studied quantitatively
Dependence on ionic strength was taken into since the species CH3Sn(OH)2 is neutralized to
account by using a Debye–Hückel type equation give the free cations at [H]/[CH3Sn3] 1 ratios,
(Eqn [3])26,27 and in these conditions quite small errors in
log K log T K ÿ z I 1=2
2 3I 1=2 ÿ1 CI analytical concentrations produce unacceptable
errors in the determination of hydrolysis constants.
DI 3=2 EI 2 3 Three other hydrolysis steps are observed, giving
with the species CH3Sn(OH)2, CH3Sn(OH)30 and
X X CH3Sn(OH)4ÿ, in the pH range 2–10.5. Between
z
charges2 reactants ÿ
charges2 products the second and third hydrolysis steps there is
experimental evidence for the formation of a
(K = formation constant; TK = formation constant at polymeric species (CH3Sn)p(OH)q(3pÿq). Least-
infinite dilution; z = charge; C, D and E = empirical squares calculations were consistent with the
parameters). The parameter E can be neglected at I formation of the hydrolytic product CH3Sn(OH)2.5,
<1 mol dmÿ3. Results of a series of investiga- which can be expressed as (CH3Sn)2(OH)5,
tions27,28 showed that, when all interactions are (CH3Sn)4(OH)102, etc. The comparison between
taken into account, the empirical parameters of Eqn different fits does not give significant differences
[3] are given by Eqn [4]: and therefore we decided in favour of the simplest
C 0:1p 0:23z ; D ÿ0:10z 4 species. Therefore the speciation scheme for the
hydrolysis of CH3Sn3 includes four mononuclear
with species CH3Sn(OH)q(3ÿq) (q = 1–4), and the poly-
X X
p
molesreactants ÿ
molesproducts nuclear species (CH3Sn)2(OH)5. Calculations
performed at low ionic strength values, and the
The activity of water was taken into account by extrapolation to zero of equilibrium constants
the simple relationship log aw = ÿ0.015 I. Both determined at higher ionic strength, allowed us to
STACO and BSTAC computer programs can deal obtain logbpq values in pure water, reported in
with measurements at different ionic strengths and Table 1. As already mentioned, the hydrolysis
can refine the empirical parameters of Eqn [3] in constant for the species CH3Sn(OH)2 cannot be
addition to formation constants. determined but it can be estimated to be
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)
808 C. DE STEFANO ET AL.
Ca
p qb z* NaNO3 NaCl
1 2 6 1.83 1.63
1 3 6 1.52 2.08
1 4 4 1.35 2.00
2 5 12 3.37 2.99
a
With D = ÿ0.1 z*; E = 0.
b
Refer to Eqn [1].
Figure 1 Distribution diagram vs pH for the hydrolysis of cations and with their hydrolysed species. In the pH
CH3Sn3+ (M) [cM = 10ÿ3 mol dmÿ3, I = 0.5 mol dmÿ3 range 2–3 we were able to calculate the formation
(NaNO3)]. Species: 1, (CH3)Sn(OH)2+; 2, (CH3)Sn(OH)2+;
3, [(CH3)Sn]2(OH)5+; 4, (CH3)Sn(OH)30; 5, (CH3)Sn(OH)4ÿ.
constant of the species (CH3)Sn(OH)Cl, whose
formation percentages are quite high at I
0.5 mol dmÿ3 (NaCl). It is likely that also for
pH >3, other Clÿ mixed species are formed, but
logb11 = ÿ1.5 0.5; this is a rough estimate which only semiquantitative values can be obtained for the
can be calculated by using the predictive equation formation constants. Therefore we prefer to give
log K1 0.4 log K2 ÿ 1, obtained from literature ‘apparent’ hydrolysis constants in NaCl, which can
data for hydrolysis of di- and tri-valent cations. be used in the speciation studies as well as
Equilibrium constants reported in Table 1 demon- ‘effective’ formation constants coupled with ion-
strate quantitatively the strong tendency of mono- pair formation constants for Clÿ species. In Fig. 2
methyltin(IV) to hydrolyse. A comparison (see also we report logb13 ns I1/2 in both aqueous NaNO3 and
discussion) can be made with iron(III): hydrolysis NaCl solutions. In Table 2, we report empirical
constants of that cation are significantly lower than parameters (Eq. [1]) for the dependence on ionic
those of CH3Sn3. In Fig 1 we report the speciation strength of hydrolysis constants. In Table 3, we
diagram in NaNO3 (I = 0.5 mol dmÿ3). For pH >2 report thermodynamic parameters for the formation
monomethyltin(IV) is fully hydrolysed (only a of the mixed species CH3Sn(OH)Cl. The pro-
small percentage of free cation is present) and in the blems of determining the formation of mixed OH–
pH range 5–9, which is of interest for natural fluids, Cl species, and of calculating the relative formation
the main species are CH3Sn(OH)30 and constants, are quite difficult since many species can
(CH3Sn)2(OH)5, in the experimental condition be taken into account. Moreover, when anionic
C(CH3Sn3) = 1 mmol dmÿ3. hydroxo species, such as CH3Sn(OH)4ÿ, are formed
one must take into account also the possibility of
interaction with the cation of the background salt
(Na in this case). As a general rule, we attribute a
Ionic strength and medium effects lowering of formation or hydrolysis constants, with
Potentiometric measurements performed in NaNO3 respect to the values determined in a non-interact-
and NaCl, at different ionic strengths, show quite ing medium (such as nitrate or perchlorate), to the
different behaviour, in particular at low pH values. interaction between the cation under study and the
This can be explained by the tendency of the anion of the background salt; on the contrary, a rise
chloride ion to form ion pairs with alkyltin(IV) is observed when the hydroxo species forms ion
Table 3 Thermodynamic parameters for the formation of the mixed species CH3Sn(OH)Cl at 25 °C and
I = 0 mol dmÿ3
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)
HYDROLYSIS OF METHYLTIN(IV) TRICHLORIDE 809
Figure 2 Dependence on ionic strength of logb13 in NaCl and Figure 3 Values of logbpqOH vs 1/T (T/K): &, logb12OH;
NaNO3 aqueous solution at 25°C. *, logb13OH; ~, logb14OH; !, logb25OH.
pairs with the anion (or cation) of the salt. As an ture, as shown in Fig. 3, where the variation of
example, if we indicate by K and K* the hydrolysis logbpqOH is reported ns 1/T (T = absolute tempera-
constant of the species M(OH), K is calculated by ture/K). From the dependence on temperature one
considering the formation of the species M(OH)Cl can obtain DH ° values (Eqn [5]), where
[M(OH)2 Clÿ = M(OH)Cl] and K* by neglect-
ing this interaction, in which case log K* = log pq OH log pq OH
H F
T 52:23 5
log K log (1 KCl[Cl]). When dealing with mul-
F
T
1=T ÿ
1=
tiple simultaneous equilibria, the equation becomes
much more complicated but the trend is the same. = reference temperature = 298.15 K. As logbpqOH
(In this paper we calculated the formation constants values are affected by fairly large uncertainties, and
for the species M(OH)Cl alone, and we consid- the temperature range is quite small, DH ° values
ered the apparent hydrolysis constants which (Table 4) must be considered only as indicative. As
account for other interactions. However, in mixed one can see, logbpqOHn s 1/T is linear and therefore
electrolytes, such as seawater, where dications and we can write for the different species the simple
dianions are present in high concentration, the equations [5a]–[5d].
formation of such mixed species may be relevant.)
The dependence on ionic strength reported in Fig. 2 log 12 OH 24:6 ÿ 7:9
0:4F
T 104
5a
indicates that logb13(NaCl) > logb13(NaNO3), and
therefore it is expected that a weak species log 13 OH 33:0 ÿ 15:6
0:6F
T 104
5b
CH3Sn(OH)3Clÿ is formed.
log 14 OH 35:7 ÿ 16:2
0:6F
T 104
5c
Temperature dependence of
hydrolysis constants log 25 OH 62:4 ÿ 20:6
0:9F
T 104
5d
Hydrolysis constants strongly depend on tempera-
Table 4 Thermodynamic parameters for the formation of hydrolysed species of CH3Sn3 at 25 °C and
I = 0 mol dmÿ3
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)
810 C. DE STEFANO ET AL.
REFERENCES
DISCUSSION
1. G. Arena, A. Gianguzza, L. Pellerito, R. Purrello and E.
The main characteristic of the (CH3)Sn3–H2O Rizzarelli, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 713 (1989).
system is the very strong tendency of monomethyl- 2. V. Cucinotta, A. Gianguzza, G. Maccarrone, L. Pellerito, R.
tin(IV) to form hydrolysed species over a wide Purrello and E. Rizzarelli, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans.
range (see Fig. 1). This cation also shows the ability 2299 (1992).
to give polynuclear species of the type 3. C. De Stefano, C. Foti, A. Gianguzza, M. Martino, L.
Pellerito and S. Sammartano, J. Chem. Eng. Data 41 511
[M(OH)y3ÿy]n with 2 <y <3, such as those
(1996).
observed for other trivalent cations. Iron(III) forms 4. V. Cannizzaro, C. Foti, A. Gianguzza and F. Marrone, Ann.
the species Fe12(OH)342 (y = 2.83)28,29 and alumi- Chim. (Rome) 88 45 (1998).
nium(III) forms Al13(OH)32 (y = 2.46).30 For chro- 5. S. J. Blunden, P. A. Cusack and R. Hill, The Industrial Use
mium(II), recent experimental results (P. G. of Tin Chemicals, Royal Society of Chemistry, London,
Daniele and S. Sammartano, unpublished results) 1985.
indicate the formation of polynuclear species with y 6. Y. Arakawa and O. Wada, in: Metal Ions in Biological
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)
HYDROLYSIS OF METHYLTIN(IV) TRICHLORIDE 811
Systems, Sigel, H. and Sigel, A. (eds), Marcel Dekker, New 22. C. De Stefano, P. Princi, C. Rigano and S. Sammartano,
York, basel, 1993, p. 101. Ann. Chim. (Rome) 77 643 (1987).
7. M. Gielen and N. Sprecher, Organomet. Chem. Rev. 1 455 23. C. De Stefano, P. Mineo, C. Rigano and S. Sammartano,
(1966). Ann. Chim. (Rome) 83 243 (1993).
8. H. Kriegsmann and S. Pauly, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 330 275 24. C. De Stefano, C. Foti, O. Giuffrè, P. Mineo, C. Rigano and
(1964).
S. Sammartano, Ann. Chim. (Rome) 86 257 (1996).
9. H. N. Farrer, M. M. McGrady and R. S. Tobias, J. Am.
25. C. De Stefano, S. Sammartano, P. Mineo and C. Rigano, in:
Chem. Soc. 20 5019 (1965).
10. E. V. Van den Berghe and G. P. Van der Kelen, Bull. Soc. Marine Chemistry — An Environmental Analytical Chem-
Chim. Belg. 74 479 (1965). istry Approach, Gianguzza, A. Pellizzetti, E. and Sammar-
11. A. Cassol, L. Magon and R. Barbieri, J. Chromatogr. 19 57 tano, S. (eds), Kluwer Academic Publishers, Amsterdam,
(1965). 1997, p. 71.
12. A. Cassol, Gazz. Chim. Ital. 96 1764 (1966). 26. C. De Stefano, P. Mineo, C. Rigano and S. Sammartano,
13. R. S. Tobias, Organometal Chem. Rev. 1 93 (1966). Ann. Chim. (Rome) 83 243 (1993).
14. R. S. Tobias and M. Yasuda, Can. J. Chem. 42 781 (1964). 27. P. G. Daniele, A. De Robertis, C. De Stefano and S.
15. J. G. A. Luijten, Rec. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 85 873 (1966). Sammartano, in Miscellany of Scientific Papers offered to
16. M. Devaud, J. Chim. Phys. 66 302 (1969). Enric Casassas, Alegret, S., Arias, J. J., Barcelò, D., Casal,
17. M. Devaud, J. Chim. Phys. 67 270 (1970). J. and Router, G. (eds), Barcelona, Spain, 1991, p. 121.
18. M. Devaud, J. Chim. Phys. 69 460 (1972).
28. P. G. Daniele, C. Rigano, S. Sammartano and V. Zelano,
19. M. C. Langlois and M. Devaud, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 5/6,
Talanta 41 1577 (1994).
789 (1974).
20. S. J. Blunden, P. J. Smith and D. G. Gillies, Inorg. Chim. 29. L. Ciavatta and M. Grimaldi, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 37 163
Acta 60 105 (1982). (1975).
21. S. J. Blunden and R. Hill, Inorg. Chim. Acta 177 219 30. C. F. Baes and R. E. Mesmer, The Hydrolysis of Cations,
(1990). Wiley, New York, 1976.
Copyright # 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Appl. Organometal. Chem. 13, 805–811 (1999)