Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original article
Specialist in Orthognatodontics; Associated Professor of Orthodontics, Department of Dental Sciences,“Sapienza” University of Rome
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Objectives: The lingual dysfunctions play a considerable role in the pathogenesis of
Received 6 February 2011 dentoskeletal dysmorphisms. The treatment of dento-maxillofacial dysgnathia implies
Accepted 31 August 2011 a functional rehabilitation to re-harmonize the stomatognathic system. This study
aims to demonstrate the importance of a rehabilitation protocol of functional orofacial
Keywords: parameters at the end of a surgical-orthodontic treatment in order to achieve long-term
Dento-maxillofacial dysgnathia success.
Myofunctional therapy Materials and methods: After orthognathic surgery, facial expression exercises and jaw exer-
Post-surgical re-education cises are prescribed to promote the recovery of neuromuscular function. At the end of
Retainers treatment, a sample of 30 dysgnathic patients underwent a functional evaluation of the oro-
Speech therapy facial district to identify any lingual or articulatory dysfunctions. The information gathered
led to an individual re-education program that consisted of an active myofunctional-
logopedic approach integrated with appliances used as retention.
Results: 19 patients needed myofunctional therapy to re-educate deglutition and tongue
posture. Articulatory disorders were found in 7 patients originally suffering from Class III
and/or open-bite skeletal disharmony; 5 of these completed rehabilitation with speech
therapy. After rehabilitation the functional parameters were completely normalized in
12 patients; in 5 cases, partial improvements were obtained, while in 2 cases the therapy was
ineffective.
Conclusions: In a patient undergoing post-surgical reconsolidation of his/her functional equi-
librium even an uncontrolled speech defect may lead to an instable result. Only through an
interdisciplinary approach it is possible to intercept and re-educate all the functions that
are not compliant with the structural changes and to eliminate a tendency to relapse of the
dysgnathia.
© 2011 Società Italiana di Ortodonzia SIDO. Published by Elsevier Srl. All rights reserved.
∗
Corresponding author. Department of Dental Sciences, Viale Regina Elena 287/A - 00161 Rome, Italy.
E-mail address: alessandro.silvestri@uniroma1.it (A. Silvestri).
1723-7785/$ – see front matter © 2011 Società Italiana di Ortodonzia SIDO. Published by Elsevier Srl. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pio.2011.08.002
58 progress in orthodontics 1 3 ( 2 0 1 2 ) 57–68
Fig. 2 – Abnormal posture of the tongue with frontal (A) and lateral interposition (B).
cannot be the cause of malocclusions. According to Marchesan will be demonstrated through the analysis of a sample of
et al. [16] and to Campiotto [17] the majority of dysgnathic 30 patients.
patients do not need a re-education because usually altered
functions would fit the new shape satisfactorily not requir-
ing a specific approach. On the other hand, D’Agostino [18]
2. Materials and methods
states that all his cases necessitate a re-education because in
his opinion this kind of patients have functional abnormal-
A sample of 30 adult patients suffering from dento-
ities that surgery itself is not able to solve. Cimmino et al.
maxillofacial dysgnathia subjected to orthognathic surgery in
[19] reported that after orthognathic surgery the functional
the years 2008-2009 was analyzed. Only patients with “good”
adaptation does not occur spontaneously but a re-education is
and “excellent” treatment results were selected, which con-
needed to correct functional attitudes otherwise irreversible.
firmed that the structural pathology was resolved. Complex
In our experience it is very important to guide the func-
malformations with specific involvement of the neuromus-
tional recovery of the stomatognatic apparatus in dysgnathic
cular system, such as hemifacial microsomia and cleft lip
patients undergoing orthodontic treatment and maxillofacial
and palate, were excluded from the sample. Table I shows a
surgery.
schematic layout of the “diagnosis” and “therapy” for each
The present study, therefore, aims to highlight the impor-
case. Based on the original dysgnathia, we identified three
tance of neuromuscular re-education in order to achieve
groups consisting of 8 patients with Class II skeletal rela-
long-term success in the treatment of dento-maxillofacial
tionships, 11 patients with Class III skeletal relationships
dysgnathia. The present study will also illustrate the
and 11 patients with dentoskeletal open-bite associated or
main post-surgical rehabilitation strategies adopted at the
not with an alteration on the sagittal plane (2 patients with
Orthodontic Service of the Department of Dental Sciences
Class I skeletal relationships, 2 patients with Class II skeletal
at the “Sapienza” University of Rome. The role that this
relationships and 7 patients with Class III skeletal relation-
approach should assume as part of the treatment plan
ships). In total therefore, there were 10 subjects with Class II
skeletal relationships, 18 subjects with Class III skeletal rela-
tionships and 2 subjects with Class I skeletal relationships.
All patients underwent pre-surgical orthodontics and orthog-
nathic surgery.
Due to rigid internal fixation, an intermaxillary block was
not required at the end of surgery and all patients left the
operating room free to open and close the mouth sponta-
neously. Post-surgical treatment started about 15 days after
orthognathic surgery. The muscles must regain a physiological
condition of tone and synergy, and the patient must grad-
ually become aware of the proprioceptive changes in both
dento-periodontal and musculo-skeletal districts. To acceler-
ate these processes all patients were instructed to perform
exercises of facial expression and simple jaw exercises. The
first consisted in alternating forced smiles with lip protru-
sions and in inflating lips and cheeks. These exercises, to
be carried out for at least 6-8 weeks [20], were aimed at
Fig. 3 – Typical lower tongue resting position in Class III extending scars and thereby strengthening muscles and lip
dysgnathia. contraction. Jaw exercises had to be performed in front of
60
Table I – *Caption: AG (Agenesis); CL (dento-skeletal class); MC (Maxillary contraction); DB (Deep-bite); ID (Intermaxillary disjunction); TMD (temporomandibular
disorder); RCF (Result of condyle fracture); ELN (Envelop Lingual Nocturn of Bonnet); EX (Dental extraction); GP (Genioplasty); IN (Dental inclusion); MLD (Mandibular
laterodeviation); LF (Long-face); LFI (Le Fort I osteotomy); OB (Open-bite); PO (Presurgical orthodontics); BSSO (Bilateral sagital split osteotomy); RG (Class III retainer with
lingual grid); RP (Rhinoplasty); SR (Splinted retainer); SF (Short-face); ST (Speech therapy); MFT (Myofunctional therapy for lingual posture and deglutition).
1 S. M. 32 M CL*II; DB* EX* 1.4,2.4 + PO* + BSSO*-GP* EXCELLENT NORMAL BACKWARD ----- NORMAL SR* ----- -----
2 B. A. 17 F CL II; DB; IN* 1.3,2.3,3.3,4.3 EX 1.3,2.3,3.3,4.3 + PO + BSSO-GP EXCELLENT ATYPICAL NORMAL /r/ UNBALANCED SR YES YES
3 E. F. 25 M CL II; DB; SF* EX 1.8,2.8,3.8,4.8 + PO + BSSO GOOD NORMAL NORMAL ----- UNBALANCED SR ----- -----
4 M. A. 26 M CL II PO + BSSO-GP EXCELLENT NORMAL NORMAL ----- NORMAL SR ----- -----
5 L. A. 26 F CL II; MC* PO + LFI*-BSSO GOOD NORMAL BACKWARD ----- NORMAL SR ----- -----
6 A. M. 26 F CL II; TMD* PO + LFI-BSSO GOOD ATYPICAL NORMAL ----- UNBALANCED SR YES -----
a mirror 2 times a day for 5 minutes and they consisted in underwent a functional assessment of the orofacial district
active mouth opening and closing movements on the right in order to identify any dysfunction and to assess its extent.
and left side, and slight protrusions to gently move the To standardize the assessment, carried out by clinical meth-
mandibular structure. TMJ was also monitored at this stage, ods, the data were collected in a specially designed folder
to ensure that no dysfunction occurred. The post-surgical (Fig. 4). In its implementation, reference was made to the
orthodontic phase usually lasted 4-6 months, at the end of orthodontic and functional assessment folder currently in use
which fixed appliances were removed and removable reten- at our Orthodontic Unit for growing patients with orthodon-
tion appliances were applied. At the end of the treatment, a tic relevancy. This folder was re-adapted to the anatomical
comprehensive re-assessment of the cases was carried out: and functional characteristics of adult dysgnathic patients. A
the radiographic and photographic records from the start to brief anamnesis was followed by an analysis of the orofacial
the end of the treatment were compared and the therapeu- muscles focused on the anatomical and functional character-
tic phases analyzed so that an appraisal of the aesthetic and istics of the lips and tongue in static and in dynamic phase.
structural results of the treatment (poor, fair, good, excel- Data collection was completed by an assessment of the pho-
lent) could be performed. While the goal of this treatment netics carried out by a speech therapist. In Table I under the
was the global morpho-functional re-harmonization of the heading “orofacial post-treatment assessment” there are data
stomatognathic apparatus, a thorough assessment of the neu- concerning “deglutition”, “tongue posture”, “articulation dis-
romuscular component was also necessary. The position of orders” and “perioral muscles”. The indications provided by
the tongue, deglutition and speech also had to be re-assessed the examination made it possible to obtain, where neces-
carefully so that functional reconditioning with the structural sary, an individual re-education program by integrating two
changes made could be completed. Therefore, a post-surgical different strategies: on one hand an active myofunctional-
orofacial evaluation and rehabilitation program was carried logopedic approach in which the patient actively participated
out in collaboration with the Phoniatrics Operations Unit of in correcting tongue posture and improper functions,
the Department of Sense Organs at the “Sapienza” University and on the other a passive approach, with the help of
of Rome. The protocol was applied to the sample of 30 adult re-educational aids.
patients. At the end of the post-surgical orthodontic phase the During the months of April-May 2011, the 19 patients sub-
patients, free from the interference of orthodontic brackets, jected to myofunctional and speech therapy were re-checked
62 progress in orthodontics 1 3 ( 2 0 1 2 ) 57–68
Table II – ELN (Envelop Lingual Nocturn of Bonnet); RG (Class III retainer with lingual grid); SR (Splinted retainer); ST
(Speech therapy); MFT (Myofunctional therapy for lingual posture and deglutition).
using the same evaluation criteria adopted after the surgical- possible to use the “proprioceptive neuromuscular facilita-
orthodontic treatment to verify the functional status and the tion” (PNF) technique [4,5,22]. This is a method where the
possible permanence of lingual function abnormalities. The neuromuscular response evoked by stimulating various kinds
results of this last assessment are reported in Table II. of proprioceptors (for example, deep pressure on the edge or
The re-education of tongue posture and deglutition consisted back of the tongue) would exclude a conscious understand-
of a preliminary phase aimed at “restoring proprioception,” ing of posture practice [4,22] (Fig. 5). The exercises used in the
which follows a phase of myofunctional re-education, more PNF method favor proprioception, since they increase sensi-
properly characterized by “muscle exercises” and “functional tivity of the mucous membrane and the tongue tone, making
recovery” [4]. In order to develop oral proprioception of the
new oral space, the patient was asked to slide the tip of the
tongue over the palate in all directions, and to differentiate
between smooth areas and wrinkled areas [21]. This is impor-
tant for the identification of the incisive papilla that can be
facilitated by pressing it down with a blunt instrument or
the tip of the index finger [6] The next exercise required the
mouth to be opened, the tip of the tongue in contact with
the papilla, and the back of the tongue raised and flattened
against the palate. This position has to be maintained for
5 seconds before removing the tongue from the palate, with
the tongue tip still on the papilla. In this way, apart from
encouraging proprioception, the second tongue movement
is traced during deglutition (“pharyngeal phase”). Therefore,
after achieving a satisfactory result, the sequence of move-
ments will be completed by bringing the dental arches in
occlusion and swallowing the saliva. Alternatively, especially Fig. 5 – Deep pressure on the sides of the tongue with
in subjects with spastic or hypotonic tongue muscles, it is a blunt instrument.
progress in orthodontics 1 3 ( 2 0 1 2 ) 57–68 63
Fig. 6 – Exercise with a single elastic for tongue posture. Fig. 7 – Deglutition using a straw placed horizontally at the
intercanine level.
Fig. 10 – Class III retainer with lingual grid and control arch for the lower front group (A,B).
progress in orthodontics 1 3 ( 2 0 1 2 ) 57–68 65
retainer was applied (in 16 patients), which consists of an upper therapy, based on conscious learning, the ELN takes advantage
plate in resin fitted with a retro-incisive lingual grid and a of a mechanism that starts from the patient’s unconscious and
buccal retraction arch for the lower frontal group (Fig. 10). The nocturnal sensory-motor to reach the cognitive awareness
plate should not cover the entire arch but must be horseshoe [28].
shaped and reduced to the minimum size necessary to incor-
porate the metal supports; the objective is to reduce the size
of the oral functional space and not prevent reciprocal tactile 3. Results
stimulation between the tongue and palate. The vestibular
retraction arch originates from the plate and continues to the An evaluation of the sample of 30 cases is reported in Table I
lower frontal group, only touching lightly the surface of the where it can be noted that after the structural anomalies were
incisors and canines so that it does not cause any retrusive resolved, disrupted functions were present in many patients.
action that might interfere with the neuromuscular function In patients treated to resolve the progenism, the tongue
of the TMJ. The therapeutic action of the grid is effective generally continues to be hypotonic and low; the open-bite
mainly for the time it is applied [26], preventing tongue move- group shows a more evident tendency to interpose the tongue
ment in the front portion of the lower arch and redirecting it between the arches while in the Class II subjects lingual capa-
to the top plate; furthermore, it prevents lingual interposition bilities are less involved. 19 out of the 30 patients required
between the arches during deglutition. It is shaped so as to an additional phase of myofunctional therapy to restore
re-educate the tongue to a more backward position, guiding it proper tongue tone and posture, a physiological deglutition,
with a slight incline towards the premaxilla. For this reason, and possibly to complete the re-education of facial muscles
it should not be too far back, but inserted behind the plate, started immediately after surgery. Most patients belonged
immediately behind the upper incisors. In this manner, to the open-bite group (9 of 11) and the Class III group
together with the restrictive effect, the plate with grid will (7 out of 11). Pronunciation disorders were detected in 7 cases
also serve to re-educate tongue position. In order to obtain and mainly concerned patients with prior Class III and/or
a re-educational effect only on the tongue, the use of Bonnet open-bite. In the latter group there is a prevalence of distorted
Envelop Lingual Nocturn (ENL) is indicated. In our sample, we sibilants, in association with the interdental articulation of
applied this device to 6 patients (2 with simple open-bite, 2 dento-alveolar consonants. After myofunctional treatment,
with Class II open-bite and 2 with Class III open-bite). The aim 5 patients completed the re-education process, undergoing
of this device is to create an obstacle-free environment that speech therapy sessions; in 2 cases, the articulatory disorder
helps the tongue to find its posture and normal function also regressed after an initial myofunctional approach.
in those patients that have stopped growing. The ELN is made The check carried out after the rehabilitation period
of a thin intraoral resin shell which stimulates the active (Table II) revealed that the functional parameters of the
ascent of the tongue through a lower lingual ramp up to a hole oro-facial district were completely normalized in 12 out of the
in the opening near the palatine folds [27,28] (Fig. 11). The 19 patients. Only in 2 cases the therapy was ineffective
side flanges prevent the tongue from interposing between the (case n◦ 18 and n◦ 27), while in 5 cases we obtained a par-
arches, both in the front and posterior regions. The ELN does tial improvement with persistence of atypical swallowing
not a simply exercise a restrictive action but it creates also (2 cases), abnormal tongue posture (1 case) or altered
a normal architecture around the tongue, by uninstalling the phonemes (2 cases). About the patients who originally had
primary deglutition program and reinstalling the secondary a speech disorder we observed a complete resolution in
deglutition program from the very start of the therapy. The 4 cases, a partial resolution with correction of dento-alveolar
device is applied at night and a few minutes during the phonemes and persistence of abnormal sibilant phonemes in
day (3 minutes 3 times a day) [27]. Contrary to myofunctional 1 case, no improvement in 2 cases.
66 progress in orthodontics 1 3 ( 2 0 1 2 ) 57–68
6. Garliner D. Myofunctional therapy. Philadelphia: Saunders; 25. De Filippis Cippone A. Nuovo manuale di logopedia. Trento:
1976. Edizioni Erickson; 1998.
7. Moyers RE. Postnatal development of the orofacial 26. Testa M, Comparelli U, Kratzenberg G. Tecniche ortodontiche,
musculature. In: Proceedings of the conference patterns guida alla costruzione e all’utilizzo di dispositivi terapeutici.
of orofacial growth and development, ASHA report 6. Milano: Masson; 2003.
Washington DC: American Speech and Hearing Association; 27. Buraglio C, Volpato B, Antonioli M. L’ELN di Bruno Bonnet:
1971 p. 38–47. indicazioni, modalità di utilizzo clinico e risultati nel
8. Chateau M. Equilibrio ortodontico. In: Atti del raduno SIDO. trattamento di soggetti a fine crescita. Ortognatodonzia Italiana
Spoleto; 1970. 2002;11:73–81.
9. Lanteri C. Ortognatodonzia. Milano: Masson; 2002. 28. Bonnet B. Correction de la posture linguale par l’enveloppe
10. De Santis M. Voce e linguaggio. Padova: Piccin; 1986. linguale nocturne (E.L.N.). Le Chirurgien Dentiste da France
11. Montagna F, Lambini N, Piras V, Denotti G. L’ortodonzia e i suoi 1994;719:31–4.
dispositivi, apparecchi mobili e fissi rimovibili nella pratica clinica. 29. Del Mondo S, Villari P, Laino A. Ruolo della logopedia nel
Milano: Elsevier Masson; 2007. trattamento post-chirurgico della sindrome progenica. In:
12. Böhme G. Applied phoniatry. V. Speech defects due to Savastano C, Bertelé G, editors. Fase Terapeutica post-chirurgica
abnormalities of jaw and dentition. HNO 1977;25: del paziente disgnatico, Monografia SIDOP. Napoli: G. De Nicola
131–6. Editore; 2004. p. 73–81.
13. Bloomer HH. Speech defects associated with dental 30. Cozza P, Fidato R, Germani C, Santoro G, Siciliani G.
malocclusions and related anomalies. In: Travis LE, editor. La deglutizione atipica. Mondo Ortod 1992;17:
Handbook of speech pathology and audiology. New York: 141–59.
Appleton Century Crofts; 1971. p. 715–66. 31. Fournier M. La rééducation fonctionelle chez l’enfant et son
14. Giannì E. La nuova ortognatodonzia, 1. Padova: Piccin; 1980. controle par l’orthodontiste. Rev Orthop Dento-Faciale
15. Proffit WR. Equilibrium theory revisited: factors influencing 1994;28:473–85.
position of the teeth. Angle Orthod 1978;48:175–86. 32. Goodstein DB, Cooper D, Wallace L. The effect on speech of
16. Marchesan IQ, Bianchini EMG. A fonoaudiologia e a cirurgia surgery for correction of mandibular prognathism. Oral Surg
ortognática. In: Araújo A, editor. Cirurgia ortognática. Med Rehab 1974;37:846–9.
São Paulo: Santos; 1999. p. 353–61. 33. Dalston RM, Vig PS. Effects of orthognatic surgery on speech:
17. Campiotto AR. Fonoaudiologia. In: Souza LCM, Silveira ME, a prospective study. Am J Orthod 1984;86:291–8.
Capellette M, Garducci M, Lino AP, editors. Cirurgia ortognatica 34. Lee ASY, Whitehill TL, Ciocca V, Samman N. Acoustic and
e ortodontia. São Paulo: Santos; 1998. p. 19–30. perceptual analysis of the sibilant sound /s/before and after
18. D’Agostino L. Características fonoaudiológicas nas orthognathic surgery. J Oral Maxillofac
defor-midades maxilomandibulares. In: Psillakis JM, Surgjavascript:AL get(this, ‘jour’, ‘J Oral Maxillofac Surg’)
Zanini AS, Mélega JM, Costa EA, Cruz RL, editors. Cirurgia 2002;60:364–73.
craniomaxilofacial: osteotomias estéticas da face. Rio de Janeiro: 35. Altmann EBC. Myofunctional therapy and orthognathic
Medsi; 1987. p. 317–23. surgery. Int J Orofacial Myology 1987;13:2–12.
19. Cimmino C, Della Pietra G, Savastano G. Lo studio fonetico 36. Campiotto AR, Freitas LP, Lima RA. Cirurgia ortognatica
come proposta di studio funzionale in chirurgia ortognatica. e fonoaudiologia. In: Lopes Filho E, editor. Tratado de
Ortognatodonzia Italiana 1998;7:323–8. fonoaudiologia. Sao Paulo: Roca; 1987.
20. Ronchi P. Dismorfie dento-facciali, trattamento 37. McNamara JA, Carlson DS, Yellich GM, Hendricksen RP.
ortodontico-chirurgico. Milano: Quintessenza Edizioni; 2004. Musculosketal adaption following orthognathic surgery. In:
21. Chauvois A, Fournier M, Girardin M. Rieducazione delle funzioni Carlson DS, McNamara JA, editors. Muscle adaptation
nel trattamento ortodontico. Verona: Ed. CISCO; 1994. in the craniofacial region, Monograph No 8, Craniofacial
22. Falk ML, Wells M, Toth S. A subcortical approach to swallow Growth Series. Ann Arbor: Center for Human
pattern therapy. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 1976;70: Growth and Development, University of Michigan;
419–27. 1978.
23. Garliner D. Importanza di una corretta deglutizione. 38. Carlson DS, Ellis E, Dechow PC, Nemeth PA. Short-term
San Benedetto del Tronto: Ed. Futura; 1996. stability and muscle adaptation after mandibular
24. Yamaguchi H. Oral myofunctional therapy: essential for advancement surgery with and without suprahyoid myotomy
surgical orthodontic treatment. In: Hanson ML, Mason RM, in juvenile macaca mulatta. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol
editors. Orofacial myology: international perspectives. 1989;68:135–49.
Springfield, Illinois: CC Thomas Publisher; 2003. p. 392–416. 39. Langlade M. Diagnostic orthodontique. Paris: Maloine; 1981.