Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/0103-6440201601531
Marginal and internal adaptation is critical for the success of indirect restorations. New
imaging systems make it possible to evaluate these parameters with precision and non-
destructively. This study evaluated the marginal and internal adaptation of zirconia copings
fabricated with two different systems using both silicone replica and microcomputed
tomography (micro-CT) assessment methods. A metal master model, representing a
preparation for an all-ceramic full crown, was digitally scanned and polycrystalline
zirconia copings were fabricated with either Ceramill Zi (Amann-Girrbach) or inCoris Zi
(Dentslpy-Sirona), n=10. For each coping, marginal and internal gaps were evaluated by
silicone replica and micro-CT assessment methods. Four assessment points of each replica
cross-section and micro-CT image were evaluated using imaging software: marginal gap
(MG), axial wall (AW), axio-occlusal angle (AO) and mid-occlusal wall (MO). Data were
statistically analyzed by factorial ANOVA and Tukey test (α=0.05). There was no statistically
significant difference between the methods for MG and AW. For AO, there were significant
differences between methods for Amann copings, while for Dentsply-Sirona copings similar
values were observed. For MO, both methods presented statistically significant differences.
A positive correlation was observed determined by the two assessment methods for MG
values. In conclusion, the assessment method influenced the evaluation of marginal and
internal adaptation of zirconia copings. Micro-CT showed lower marginal and internal
gap values when compared to the silicone replica technique, although the difference
was not always statistically significant. Marginal gap and axial wall assessment points Key Words: marginal fit, dental
showed the lower gap values, regardless of ceramic system and assessment method used. prosthesis, zirconia, CAD/CAM.
the silicone film can be measured in multiple reference following characteristics: supragingival circumferential
points both at the margin and internal walls. This method chamfer finish line, 2.0-mm occlusal reduction, 1.5-mm
is considered easy to perform, is relatively inexpensive axial reduction, axial convergence angle of 6o and rounded
(11), and is accepted as a reliable method to evaluate internal line angles.
marginal and internal adaptation (18); on the other hand, The master models were scanned by two different
the difficulty in identifying the margins of the restoration, systems for fabrication of the zirconia copings (n=10):
possible tearing of the silicone film upon removal of the Ceramill Map400 (Amann Girrbach AG. Koblach, Austria)
crown, as well as sectioning plane error and few reference and Cerec inLab (Dentsply Sirona, York, PA, USA). Copings
points are considered drawbacks of the silicone replica 0.5 mm thick at the margins and 0.8 mm at the axial and
technique (13,14). occlusal walls were machined from zirconia blocks (Ceramill
Recently, microcomputed tomography (micro-CT) Zi and inCoris Zi, respectively), with 20 μm-thick marginal
imaging has also been used as a non-destructive method spacer and 70-μm-thick internal spacer. After milling,
to evaluate marginal and internal fit of indirect restorations copings were sintered. Marginal and internal adaptation
(19-21). This technique allows a two and three-dimensional of each coping was measured using the silicone replica
assessment of marginal and internal adaptation of technique (18,23,24) and micro-CT imaging (19,25-27).
restorations in several directions and sections, making it To produce the silicone replica, each coping was
possible to assess a great number of reference points and filled with a light-body PVS material (HydroXtreme light
easy identification of critical distances non-destructively body, Coltene Whaledent, Cuyahoga Falls, OH, USA) and
(13,21). positioned on the master model. Firm finger pressure
There is no consensus on which is the best non- simulating a definitive cementation procedure was applied
destructive method to evaluate marginal and internal and after 5 min the coping was removed from the master
adaptation of indirect restorations. Only few studies model. To remove the light-body material from the coping
comparing different methods for the assessment of and determine its thickness, which corresponds to the
marginal and internal adaptation of indirect restorations marginal and internal gap, a regular-body PVS material
R. S. Cunali et al.
are available (14). All the studies mentioned in the review with contrasting color (HydroXtreme regular body, Coltene
(14) have compared the replica technique with the cross- Whaledent) was placed into the coping to produce the
section technique. Only one study (22) comparing the replica. After polymerization, the replica was cut with
silicone replica technique to micro-CT was found, but a sharp scalpel blade in buccolingual and mesiodistal
the methodology used to measure the pre-cementation directions to obtain four cross-sections.
space is different from the present study. Both techniques The four cross-sections of each replica were placed
(micro-CT imaging and optical density image analysis) on a scanner (C3180 HP Photosmart, HP) for digitization.
used imaging of polyvinylsiloxane (PVS) impressions. The high-resolution images (1200 dpi) were saved as jpg
The authors determined the silicone thickness using a files and a single operator determined the thickness of the
photometric technique. Based on the Beer–Lambert Law, light-body PVS material using image analyzing software
proportionality between a known thickness (standardized (ImageJ, US National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MA,
thickness specimens fabricated from the same impression USA). Four assessment points of each cross section of the
material) and the amount of light transmitted through the replica were evaluated (Fig. 1) (23):
impression material could be assumed (22). Marginal gap (MG): perpendicular distance at the
Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare margin from the prepared master model to the internal
micro-CT and silicone replica techniques for the evaluation surface of the coping;
of marginal and internal adaptation of zirconia copings Axial wall (AW): distance at the mid-axial wall between
fabricated with two different ceramic systems. The null the internal surface of the coping and the prepared tooth;
hypotheses were: (1) there will be no difference in marginal Axial-occlusal angle (AO): distance at the region
and internal adaptation of zirconia copings fabricated of the axial-occlusal edge between the prepared tooth
with different ceramic systems, and (2) there will be no and internal surface of the coping, represented by the
difference in marginal and internal adaptation of zirconia intersection of two straight lines, parallel to the axial wall
copings assessed by the two methods. and occlusal plane;
Mid-occlusal wall (MO): distance at the center of the
Material and Methods occlusal region between the prepared tooth and internal
Two identical metal master models were used, one surface of the coping.
for each ceramic system, representing a preparation for For each replica, four measurements were obtained for
an all-ceramic full crown on a lower first molar, with the each assessment point. The mean value for each assessment
468
Braz Dent J 28(4) 2017
point was calculated and considered for statistical analysis. axis of the preparation and the image pixel size was 13 μm.
The same master models and copings were cleaned with Volumes were reconstructed using the NRecon software
alcohol and then submitted to micro-CT analysis. Each (Skyscan), employing the Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK)
coping was adapted to the master model, placed in the algorithm, beam hardening of 100%, and ring artifact
micro-CT chamber and scanned (SkyScan 1172, Skyscan, correction of 16. CTAnalyser software (Skyscan, Aartselaar)
Kontich. Belgium). For standardization purposes, micro- was used to obtain cross-section images of the central
CT images for the two ceramic materials were acquired region of all copings in both buccolingual and mesiodistal
at the same time. The micro-CT has an X-ray source directions, and the files were saved in bmp format.
with cone-beam geometry and small spot size (5 μm), in The measures for the four assessment points of the
order to reduce dispersion. An 11-megapixel camera with 2D micro-CT images were also performed using an image
CCD (charged coupled device) was used as detector. The analyzing software (ImageJ, US National Institutes of
following scanning parameters were used: Al+Cu filter, 100 Health). For each buccolingual and mesiodistal cross-
uA current, accelerating voltage of 100 kV, exposure time section images, four measurements were obtained for each
of 4000 ms per frame, and rotation step at 0.4º with 180º assessment point (Fig. 2). The mean value was calculated
rotation. The X-ray was irradiated perpendicular to the long and considered for statistical analysis.
The replica cross-sections were made visually, midway
between buccolingual and mesiodistal distances. The same
criterion was used for the selection of micro-CT images, in
an attempt to align the cross-sections and standardize the
measurements for the two assessment methods. Figures 1
Figure 4. Correlation plot between marginal and internal gap values determined by micro-CT and replica techniques.
Table 1. Means and standard deviation for marginal and internal fit (μm) evaluated by micro-CT and replica technique for the two ceramic systems
Points
Ceramic system Assessment method
Marginal gap Axial wall Axial-occlusal angle Mid-occlusal wall
Replica 77.90±12.21 a 83.63±14.43 a 162.65±39.88 b 187.35±53.89 b
Amann
Micro-CT 68.73±8.86 a 81.00±15.84 a 110.83±14.08 a 126.53±18.12 a
In each column, values followed by same letter are statistically similar (p>0.05).
470
Braz Dent J 28(4) 2017
CAM systems. According to the results, the first test marginal and internal fit of ceramic restorations (28,29).
hypothesis was accepted, i.e., there was no difference The results of these studies indicated that luting space
in marginal and internal adaptation of zirconia copings settings might influence the marginal fit. Programming
fabricated with different ceramic systems, was accepted, a small spacer thickness may result in premature contact
while the second test hypothesis was rejected, i.e, there points between the prepared tooth and the internal surface
was a difference in marginal and internal adaptation of of the crown (20,29), preventing the overflow of excess
zirconia copings evaluated by the two methods. In the cement and increasing marginal gap (28).
present study lower values of marginal and internal gap Different gap widths depending on the location
were observed for micro-CT in comparison to the replica (assessment point) may be related to the quality of the
technique for the two ceramic systems tested. acquisition and processing of the CAD/CAM technology
Recently, micro-CT has been widely applied in dentistry, (15). Increase on the internal gap may result in rounded
and is commonly used for implant planning, evaluation edges produced by the finite resolution of the scan of CAD/
of root canal preparation, forensic investigations and CAM systems. Furthermore, the overshoot phenomenon,
marginal adaptation of ceramic crowns. It is a non- which simulates virtual peaks near the edges, can also be
destructive method of analysis that allows the evaluation responsible for higher values of internal gap (19).
of marginal and internal fit of indirect restorations In the present study, mean values for marginal gap
through high-resolution images, permitting 2D and 3D varied from 68.73 to 77.90 μm, with no statistically
visualization from any angle or position. By this technique, significant difference between ceramic systems and
marginal and internal adaptation can be evaluated on x assessment methods. All values were lower than 120 μm,
and y axes, enabling a more realistic perception of the considered the clinically acceptable limit for marginal gap
thicknesses of 20 µm and 70 µm were predetermined, material. Micro-CT images were then obtained from the
respectively, for the margins and for the internal axial silicone specimens and standards. The quantitative optical
and occlusal walls. In a previous study (20), gap widths analysis method used the same standardized thickness
obtained for the 60 µm-spacer group for axial and occlusal specimens and measured the cement space thickness by
walls were approximately 113 and 152% higher than the transilluminating the pre-cementation space impressions.
programmed spacer thickness. The present study used a Also, the results from the present study cannot be directly
preset internal spacer thickness of 70 µm, but gap values compared to a previous study (22), because there are
were from 22 to 73% higher than the predetermined value significant methodological differences and the values for
for axial and occlusal walls, respectively. marginal and internal adaptation are not reported and
The two evaluated ceramic systems showed similar analyzed in the same way. The distribution of thicknesses
values for marginal and internal fit. This result was in the pre-cementation space replica measured by micro-CT
expected, since the processing method of the copings was reported by volume percentage and more than 90% of
from both systems is similar. It is important to observe the measurements ranged from less than 50 µm to 170 µm.
that zirconia copings were machined in larger dimensions The present study compared two increasingly used
to compensate for sintering contraction, and this may methods for the evaluation of marginal and internal fit
have also influenced the gap values. The success of of prosthetic restorations. Several studies and literature
this compensation depends on the homogeneity of the reviews suggested that micro-CT could be recommended as
pre-sintered block and on the software’s capability of a useful tool for evaluating the adaptation of all-ceramic
estimating the real contraction of the material (16). Thus, restorations (13,19,21). Based on the results of the present
both systems were able to compensate the zirconia sintering study, the authors corroborate this recommendation. Also,
contraction providing clinically acceptable results. Different the results suggest a strong positive correlation between the
results can be expected for multiple fixed prostheses, since marginal and internal gap values determined by micro-CT
other difficulties and distortions on impressions and casts and replica technique (Fig. 3). Therefore, both techniques
may occur, as well as problems with ceramic sintering can be used to determine the fit of indirect restorations.
R. S. Cunali et al.
avaliou a adaptação marginal e interna de copings de zircônia fabricados AA, et al.. Effect of imaging powder and CAD/CAM stone types on the
com dois sistemas diferentes, utilizando as técnicas da réplica em silicone marginal gap of zirconia crowns. J Am Dent Assoc 2015;146:111-120.
e micro-CT. Um modelo-mestre de metal, representando um preparo para 13. Contrepois M, Soenen A, Bartala M, Laviole O. Marginal adaptation of
uma coroa totalmente cerâmica foi digitalizado e copings de zirconia ceramic crowns: a systematic review. J Prosthet Dent 2013;110:447-454
policristalina (Ceramill Zi, Amann Girrbach e inCoris Zi, Dentslpy Sirona, e410.
n=10) foram fabricados. Para cada coping, a adaptação marginal e interna 14. Nawafleh NA, Mack F, Evans J, Mackay J, Hatamleh MM. Accuracy and
foi avaliada pelas técnicas da réplica em silicone e micro-CT. Foram reliability of methods to measure marginal adaptation of crowns and
avaliados quatro pontos de cada seção transversal e imagem de micro-CT: FDPs: a literature review. J Prosthodont 2013;22:419-428.
adaptação marginal (MG), parede axial (AW), ângulo axial-oclusal (AO) e 15. Beuer F, Naumann M, Gernet W, Sorensen JA. Precision of fit: zirconia
parede centro-oclusal (MO) utilizando um software de imagem. Os dados three-unit fixed dental prostheses. Clin Oral Investig 2009;13:343-349.
foram analisados estatisticamente por ANOVA e teste de Tukey (α=0,05). 16. Colpani JT, Borba M, Della Bona A. Evaluation of marginal and internal
Não houve diferença estatisticamente significativa entre as duas técnicas fit of ceramic crown copings. Dent Mater 2013;29:174-180.
para MG e AW. Para AO, houve diferenças significativas entre as técnicas 17. Reich S, Uhlen S, Gozdowski S, Lohbauer U. Measurement of cement
para copings da Amann, enquanto que para copings da Dentsply Sirona thickness under lithium disilicate crowns using an impression material
foram observados valores semelhantes. Para o MO, ambas as técnicas technique. Clin Oral Investig 2011;15:521-526.
apresentaram diferenças estatisticamente significativas. Observou-se uma 18. Rahme HY, Tehini GE, Adib SM, Ardo AS, Rifai KT. In vitro evaluation
correlação positiva entre os valores de adaptação determinados pelas duas of the “replica technique” in the measurement of the fit of Procera
técnicas. O método de avaliação influenciou a avaliação da adaptação crowns. J Contemp Dent Pract 2008;9:25-32.
marginal e interna de copings de zircônia. Pode-se concluir que a micro- 19. Borba M, Cesar PF, Griggs JA, Della Bona A. Adaptation of all-ceramic
CT mostrou menores valores de adaptação marginal e interna quando fixed partial dentures. Dent Mater 2011;27:1119-1126.
comparado com a técnica de réplica em silicone. Os pontos de avaliação 20. Mously HA, Finkelman M, Zandparsa R, Hirayama H. Marginal and
da margem e da parede axial mostraram os menores valores de adaptação, internal adaptation of ceramic crown restorations fabricated with
independente do sistema cerâmico e da técnica de avaliação utilizados. CAD/CAM technology and the heat-press technique. J Prosthet Dent
2014;112:249-256.
21. Seo D, Yi Y, Roh B. The effect of preparation designs on the
References marginal and internal gaps in Cerec3 partial ceramic crowns. J Dent
1. Denissen H, Dozic A, van der Zel J, van Waas M. Marginal fit and short- 2009;37:374-382.
term clinical performance of porcelain-veneered CICERO, CEREC, and
473