Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Huiqun Fu1, Xiufeng Zhang1, Xitai Wang1, Rong Yang1, Jian Li1,
Li Wang1, Ning Zhang1, Guanglin Li2, Tao Liu3, Bingfei Fan3,
and Yoshio Inoue4
Abstract
Prosthetic knee joint (PKJ) is an important apparatus for trans-femoral amputees to regain walking ability. This study has two
objectives: (1) to design a high performance and low-cost passive PKJ and (2) to evaluate the performance of the PKJ. In the
proposed PKJ design, a four-bar linkage was employed as the mechanical structure, and parallel spring and damper were used
as the two connecting rods of the four-bar linkage. With the parallel spring, the length of the connecting rod is variable and a
buffer flexion angle can be generated, which was consistent with that of the human knee joint. The damper was used to
regulate the swing speed of the shank. Through theoretical analysis, modeling, and simulation, key parameters of the
mechanical structure were optimized. Finally, experimental studies were conducted to test the performance of the PKJ,
including fatigue test and gait analysis. The results showed that the designed PKJ is reliable and the gait of PKJ is close to the
healthy subject. Moreover, it is comfortable and showed no adverse effects on the amputee during the walking experiment.
Keywords
Prosthesis, gait analysis, kinematics simulation, swing speed regulation, knee joint, four-bar linkage
Introduction
Walking is a fundamental daily activity for human beings.
For lower limb amputees, the loss of the walking ability
causes a lot of inconveniences in their daily life. Currently, 1
National Research Center for Rehabilitation Technical Aids, Beijing,
the most effective way to regain walking ability is to use China
2
prostheses. In all prosthetics components for a trans- ShenZhen Institutes of Advanced Technology, Chinese Academy of
femoral amputee, prosthetic knee joint (PKJ) is a critical Sciences, Beijing, China
3
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems (Zhejiang
component that can affect the overall performance of walk- University), Hangzhou, China
ing. In past few decades, lots of work has been done to 4
Kochi University of Technology, Kochi, Japan
improve the PKJs. Generally, PKJs can be divided into
passive PKJ and active PKJ according to the power require- Corresponding authors:
ment. There are many active prosthesis proposed in the Xiufeng Zhang, National Research Center for Rehabilitation Technical
Aids, Beijing, China.
literature, such as geared active prosthesis,1 agonist– Email: zhangxiufeng@hit.edu.cn
antagonist active knee prosthesis,2 intelligent mechanical
Tao Liu, State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems
active PKJ with ball screw and servo motor,3 pneumatically (Zhejiang University), Hangzhou 310027, China.
powered knee and ankle joints,4 and a powered knee Email: liutao@zju.edu.cn
Creative Commons CC-BY: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without
further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/
open-access-at-sage).
2 International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems
Damping Cylinder
the four-bar linkage which is composed of ABCD in Figure Foot Connector
1, the parallel spring consist of a rubber mat and a support
cylinder, the rubber mat is a compression spring and the
support cylinder can be regarded as a hydraulic spring,
AD rod is fixed with shank and BC rod is fixed with thigh,
namely shank part and thigh part, respectively. AB and CD
are two support rods fixed between shank and thigh called Figure 2. Model of the designed PKJ with different components
rear connecting rod and front connecting rod, respectively. having different colors. PKJ: prosthetic knee joint.
The parallel spring is used as the posterior support rod of
knee joint to absorb the impulsive force at heel strike and PKJs, features and advantages of the proposed PKJ are
improve the stability of the stance phase of walking. The summarized in Table 1.
damper is installed between BC and AD rods to regulate the
swing speed of the shank during swing phase of walking.
There are several PKJs using the four-bar mechanism in Mechanical design of the PKJ
the literature. A classical four-bar linkage PKJ is presented The model of the designed PKJ is shown in Figure 2. The
in Amador et al.’s study,16 analysis was performed by the PKJ consists of top connector, rotary component, top frame,
standard ISO 10328, the authors focused on the mechanical cylinder connector, fork, nuts, adjustable sleeve, rubber mat,
property, and no extra damper or other adjustable compo- connector pin, support cylinder, bottom frame, damping
nent was designed. Thus, this PKJ has no special features cylinder, foot connector, and so on. The rubber mat is
other than the basic functions, for instance, the swing speed installed in the middle of the AB rod to achieve the flexion
and ICR cannot be regulated. Hence, this PKJ could be less during walking. An additional spring is installed on the pis-
comfortable for amputees in different walking scenarios. ton rod of the damping cylinder to assist the extension of the
Jianan Lu and Yonghua Chen designed a customizable PKJ joint. The damping cylinder regulates the swing speed of the
based on four-bar linkage,17 one connecting rod is made of PKJ and makes a large rotary angle for the joint without
acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS)/nylon blend, glass interfering the cylinder connector between the hinge points
reinforced (nylon), which is hollow and regarded as a bal- B and D. Meanwhile, it makes the elastic rod AB easier to be
ance block, the hollow can be filled with a customizable compressed during the heel-strike. Support cylinder func-
rubber damper. Since the PKJ is a long-term use apparatus, tions as a buffer for flexion and can be regarded as a hydrau-
ABS or nylon is not as strong as the commonly used alu- lic spring. Top connector is connected with the thigh, while
minum alloy, this design would shorten the PKJ’s lifetime. foot connector is connected with the prosthetic shank. In
In the design in Demsar et al.’s study,18 shock absorber and addition, the connections between top frame and bottom
coil spring were added to the four-bar linkage, which pro- frame, top frame and rotary component, rotary component
vides better kinematics of the leg structure, However, the and fork, and support cylinder and bottom frame are all
stability of the support period when walking was not good implemented by rotation shaft and plastic bearings.
because the PKJs cannot lock at stance phase. A variable-
damping control prosthesis was found in Zhao et al.’s
study,14 the PKJ can be locked when its heel contacts with Working principle of the key components
ground, while due to the absence of elastomer, shock will Damping cylinder and support cylinder are the two critical
happen at heel strike. Compared with these four-bar linkage components in the designed PKJ. The first one is used to
4 International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems
(a) (b)
Spring Piston
Check valve
Piston
Valve
Elastomeric energy
Throttle storage unit
valve
Figure 3. (a) Working principle of the damping cylinder. (b) Working principle of the support cylinder.
regulate the swing speed of the shank and the other is used
to realize the knee buckling in the natural gait. The working
principle of the damping cylinder is shown in Figure 3(a),
which controls the telescopic speed of the cylinder to reg-
ulate the swing speed of the joint by adjusting the two
throttle valves. The damping cylinder is composed of some
critical components such as check valves, throttle valves,
piston, piston rod, spring, and so on. The spring is used to
resume after knee buckling.
The working principle of the support cylinder is shown
in Figure 3(b). The piston rod would rebound quickly after
being compressed from the top position by an elastomeric
energy storage unit, so that the buckling of the knee joint is
close to the natural gait. The support cylinder consists of
piston rod, valve, cylinder block, elastomeric unit, and so
on. Considering that the designed knee joint works under
the condition of high- or mid-speed, liquid is used as the
medium between the two cylinder blocks.
Instantaneous Instantaneous O
O Instantaneous
O center center center
D D A D
A
A B
B C C
B C
knee joint. When adding the angle a, the ICR is lower than
Normal four-bar linkage PKJ
the standard which means better flexibility but poor stabi- Intended design
Bending angle (deg)
lity. Therefore, the changes of the length of BC and AD Biological knee
rods in the four-bar linkage have greater influence on the 0
ICR while the changes of other parameters have little influ-
ence, especially the change of the angle b. –20
By establishing constraints, this article calculated the
length of the four rods to make sure that the designed PKJ –40
has both proper stability and flexibility, and its instantaneous
center is posterior to the load line at the heel-strike phase and –60
prior to the load line at the toe-off phase, as shown in Figure 5. Stance phase Swing phase
190.0
185.0
Knee angle (deg)
180.0
175.0
170.0
165.0
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
Time (sec)
70
either be measured in SolidWorks or in ADAMS by estab-
60
lishing an observing force with fixed thigh and shank.
Loading (Kg)
50
Figure 10. Results of finite element analysis. (a) The resultant displacement diagram. (b) The stress nephogram.
Figure 11. (a) Fatigue test workbench for the designed PKJ. (b) The infrared scan result after fatigue test, the temperature of the
weakest point is 31 C. PKJ: prosthetic knee joint.
damage was found after the fatigue test, and the tempera- weight 83 kg). The subject was wearing the designed PKJ
ture of the weakest point is 31 C, which is still within the and had given informed consent to the investigations. Eight
acceptable range. Consequently, the reliability of the markers were pasted on the healthy side and the prosthetic
designed PKJ can satisfy the requirements. leg, respectively. The gait curves of the amputee were
recorded by VICON (Vicon Motion Systems Ltd., Oxford,
UK) including six high-speed cameras. Figure 12 shows the
Gait analysis gait curve of the designed PKJ including two peaks which
The performance of the proposed PKJ was evaluated in gait are close to the gait of the healthy side. Figure 13 shows the
experiments with an amputee (age 40, height 182 cm, and ground reaction force curve of the PKJ with respect to the
8 International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Xu Jianguang at National Research Center
for Rehabilitation Technical Aids for his valuable discussion with
the design and pertinent opinions for the article. We would also
like to thank Liu Ying at National Research Center for Rehabili-
tation Technical Aids for the data collecting and article polishing.
Finally, we would like to thank all the staff who participated in the
project at the National Research Center for Rehabilitation Tech-
nical Aids and for their support for the experiment.
Figure 13. The ground reaction force of the designed PKJ, the
horizontal axis is the frame number at the sample frequency of
Declaration of conflicting interests
1000 Hz. PKJ: prosthetic knee joint. The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
article.
ground corresponding with the gait curve shown in Figure
12. Experimental results show that the gait curve of the
Funding
designed PKJ basically corresponds with the gait curve of
the healthy side and makes comfortable and portable sen- The author(s) received no financial support for the research,
sory with no adverse reactions during walking. authorship, and/or publication of this article.
References
Conclusion 1. Afzal MR, Bin Junaid A, Eizad A, et al. A cost effective
In this article, a four-bar linkage PKJ with a parallel spring design and analysis of an active prosthetic knee for transfe-
and damper was proposed, with the parallel spring, the moral amputees. In: 2014 international conference on
length of the connecting rod is variable, and a buffer flex- robotics and emerging allied technologies in engineering
ion angle can be generated. Thus this design can absorb the (Icreate), Islamabad, Pakistan, 22–24 April 2014, pp.
impulsive force at the heel-strike phase and improve the 270–276. New York: IEEE.
stability of the stance phase. The damper is used to regulate 2. Martinez-Vilialpando EC and Herr H. Agonist-antagonist
the swing speed of the shank by regulating the two throttle active knee prosthesis: a preliminary study in level-ground
valves, so that the PKJ can satisfy the demands of various walking. J Rehabil Res Dev 2009; 46: 361–373
Fu et al. 9
3. Borjian R, Lim J, Khamesee MB, et al. The design of an manufacture, human gait characterization, intelligent control
intelligent mechanical active prosthetic knee. In: Iecon strategies and tests. In: IEEE International Conference on
2008: 34th annual conference of the IEEE industrial electro- Robotics and Automation (ICRA), Anchorage, AK, 03–08
nics society, vols 1-5, Proceedings, Orlando, FL, 10–13 May 2010, pp. 2934–2939. New York: IEEE.
November 2008, pp. 2918–2923. New York: IEEE. 12. Radcliffe CW. Four-bar linkage prosthetic knee mechanisms:
4. Sup F, Bohara A, Goldfarb M, et al. Design and control of a kinematics, alignment and prescription criteria. Prosthet
powered knee and ankle prosthesis. In: Proceedings of the Orthot Int 1994; 18: 159–173.
2007 IEEE international conference on robotics and automa- 13. Kim H-g, Park S, and Han C. Design of a novel knee joint for
tion, Rome, Italy, 10–14 April 2007, pp. 4134–4139. New an exoskeleton with good energy efficiency for load-carrying
York: IEEE. augmentation. J Mech Sci Technol 2014; 28: 4361–4367.
5. Ha KH, Varol HA, Goldfarb M, et al. Myoelectric control of 14. Zhao J, Berns K, de Souza Baptista R, et al. Design of
a powered knee prosthesis for volitional movement during variable-damping control for prosthetic knee based on a
non-weight-bearing activities. In 32nd Annual International simulated biped. In: Proceedings of the 2013 IEEE interna-
Conference of the IEEE Engineering-in-Medicine-and- tional conference on rehabilitation robotics, Seattle, WA,
Biology-Society (EMBC 10), Buenos Aires, Argentina, 24–26 June 2013.
31 August–4 September 2010, pp. 3515–3518. 15. Sun B-y. Multi-objective optimization design of the institu-
6. Otto Bock. Otto Bock Lower limb prosthetics, http://www. tions of the prosthetic knee joint. J Clin Rehabil Tissue Eng
ottobockus.com/prosthetics/lower-limb-prosthetics/ (2016, Res 2012; 16: 4010–4014.
accessed 6 March 2016). 16. Amador BT, Mueller-Karger CM, Torrealba RR, et al. Com-
7. Össur. Össur prosthetic solutions, http://www.ossur.com/pros parison of the contact conditions in the structural analysis of a
thetic-solutions/products (2016, accessed 6 March 2016). polycentric knee prosthesis. PAHCE 2013; 2013:1–6.
8. Endolite. Endolite Knees, http://www.endolite.com/products/ 17. Lu J and Chen Y. Topology optimisation and customisation
category/knees (2016, accessed 6 March 2016). of a prosthetic knee joint design. Int J Comput Integ M 2013;
9. Park J and Choi S-B. A prosthetic knee using magnetorhe- 26: 968–976.
logical fluid damper for above-knee amputees. In: Confer- 18. Demsar I, Supej M, Vidrih Z, et al. Development of prosthetic
ence on active and passive smart structures and integrated knee for alpine skiing. Stroj Vestn-J Mech Eng 2011; 57:
systems (eds WH Liao, G Park and A Erturk), San Diego, 768–777.
CA, 09–12 March 2015. Bellingham: SPIE-Int Soc Optical 19. Choudhary P, Mishra P and Dwivedi VR. A proprioceptive
Engineering. discussion on mechanism used for knee joint from 2000-
10. Stopforth R and Riet Dv. A low cost extendable prosthetic leg 2012: A literature review Control Theory Appl 2013; 30:
for trans-fermoral amputees. In: Eugenio B (ed) Mechatro- 1543–1552.
nics: principles, technologies and applications. Chapter: 6. 20. Lenschow S, Zantop T, Weimann A, et al. Joint kinematics
Hauppauge: Nova Publishers, 2015, pp. 139–165. and in situ forces after single bundle PCL reconstruction: a
11. Torrealba RR, Perez-D’Arpino C, Cappelletto J, et al. graft placed at the center of the femoral attachment does not
Through the development of a biomechatronic knee prosthe- restore normal posterior laxity. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg
sis for transfemoral amputees: mechanical design and 2006; 126: 253–259.