You are on page 1of 8

The way to drive real sustainable profit

to the bottom line


How savvy procurement professionals take true costs away from their business to help their
companies become more profitable.

“Getting a reduction in price is an immediate gain, while buying on


total cost is a long-term proposition. Anyway, most times the savings
suppliers claim from total cost buying are all smoke and mirrors.”
“I’m only evaluated on unit price reduction. Total cost reductions
impact other departments – they get the credit, not me.”
“The purchase price is such a large part of the equation, why go
through the effort of calculating total cost? You can’t measure it
accurately anyway.”

Do these comments sound familiar? It’s a wonder I have any costs at all!” ues above just the purchase price,
Anyone responsible for purchasing one purchasing professional told James and that directly affect profitability.
materials and components from outside Anderson, professor at the Kellogg But the process doesn’t stop there.
suppliers has probably said or thought School of Management at Northwest- They detail how to accurately project
these sentiments more than once. ern University in Chicago, and along – in monetary terms – exactly how
Buying on total cost, or Total Cost with James Narus of Wake Forest Uni- much those value elements deliver
of Ownership (TCO), has become an versity, a pioneer in developing TCO. to the customers’ bottom line results.
industry mantra in the last decade. “The concept has been around since “If you look at the cost of a product
But, despite the ability to deliver signifi- the late 1960s, but has never been you’re producing, 50 to 75 percent of
cant cost reductions and efficiencies, widespread,” Anderson says. “Today, that cost is likely due to what you’re
many companies have found the reality the greater availability of data makes it purchasing,” explains Anderson. “People
to be much less tangible. more attractive as a progressive, practi- are looking at TCO to find ways to cut
Part of the problem has been that cal approach.” large parts of these costs or to get some
many supplier companies have been What Anderson and Narus developed advantage working with their suppliers
trying to claim the benefits of TCO with- to make TCO a reality – and what many or customers. Maintenance, repair and
out doing the hard work necessary to leading companies around the world operating supply providers are also trying
accurately measure results. now practice religiously – was a meth- to get their customers to notice these
“Nearly every supplier coming in the odology, a roadmap if you will, for de- overlooked cost elements to discover
door now claims he will save me money. fining those things that a customer val- the real cost drivers.”
A changing paradigm
Many companies still prefer to work
with supplier salespeople who practice
feature-, friendship-, and price-based
selling. But as the purchasing function
becomes increasingly sophisticated, the
focus has shifted from “buy from the
seller that I like who has a good product
and competitive price,” to “buy from the
seller who presents the best total solu-
tion and terms that maximize the eco-
nomic benefit to my company. And,
who can back up those benefits with
real numbers so I can prove it to
manage­ment.”
And while individual purchasing decision
influencers each have their own needs
and priorities, buyers – and certainly
purchasing committees – are becoming
more aware of the total impact of their
decision on the company’s bottom line.
A 2007 study by Strategic Account
Management (SAMA) found that cus­tom­ Price is only the easy-to-see part of the picture. The key element here is obtaining objective numbers that
accurately project cost savings.
ers rank Total Cost of Ownership nearly
two times as critical as price. Purchas-
ers are beginning to realize that price is But this approach can be self defeating. People use the term ”TCO”, but do they
just one sub-component of TCO. As suppliers become squeezed on price, really understand what it means and
One of the most common metrics for quality can go down, increasing warranty how to apply it? Total Cost of Ownership
evaluating a company’s financial success costs. Or, a supplier is making so little off includes three sub-areas: Acquisition,
is gross profit margin, the difference a customer’s business that their orders operation and end of life (disposal). All
between net sales and cost of goods get pushed back, making delivery of crit- need to be considered to make the right
sold (variable expenses). The assumption ical components or materials impossible business decisions. Although acquisition
is that the easiest way to reduce cost of to forecast. (Interestingly, in a 2008 is often the focus, this is only a small
goods sold (and increase gross profit survey, readers of Purchasing magazine part of a product´s total cost.
margin) is to reduce the purchase price rated “availability” ahead of “price” in
Cost
of the materials and components you the criteria they use to select suppliers.)
buy. And, that is the strategy many pur- Also, component price reductions
chasing departments have followed. may not be sustainable – chances are at
Operation

Acquisition End of life

Time

Customer priorities (according to customers)


A 2008 study by the Strategic Account Management
Association (SAMA) reveals that plant managers are
recognizing the importance of a TCO purchasing
approach.

2
some point in the not too distant future,
“A 5% annual total cost reduction
the supplier will be forced to return
prices to their original level. program is 2.5 times more valuable
Think for a moment about how attrac- than a 5% price reduction over a
tive your business is to a supplier who 5 year period. Why? Because price
also offers valuable knowledge and reductions are one-time benefits
resources to help you solve problems. that only last for a set period of time,
When the “supplier/customer” relation- whereas TCO is ongoing, incremental
ship is seen as a true partnership, the and sustainable… Contracted prices
supplier will be motivated to spend are beneficial for only a set period of
these limited resources with partners, time – but once your staff is taught
not customers who haggle over price. how to maintain pumps, they will
In place of “squeezing” suppliers for always be maintained better.”
lower material or component prices,
companies are now looking to partner Todd Snelgrove, 2009 Annual PMAC
with a select few suppliers who have The Purchasing Management Asso-
the expertise to look at the complete ciation of Canada (PMAC) National
picture; suppliers who can see how their Convention.
products or services impact their cus- “In today’s global business environ-
tomer’s operations, and make specific ment, customers are perceiving
recommendations for improvement. same happens when the supplier isn’t more and more products as com-
The value of these improvements can able to capture sufficient value to justify modities. Therefore, it is vital for a
add substantially to the bottom line its creation…. In reality, when the buyer company to be able to prove why its
– much more than the relatively small and supplier join forces to create value products and services are able to
gains from price concessions. together, the pie is bigger and there is deliver REAL VALUE. One of the
“Companies are in business to create more to go around for both parties. most important tasks we have today
value for their customers and, in doing Unfortunately, the spirit of joint effort throughout the SKF Group is to
so, capture a share of that value in for joint benefits is rarely the buyer- create, deliver and document the
terms of profits,” says Kamran Kashani, seller modus operandi. But companies value that our products and solutions
Professor of Business Programs, are beginning to see the benefits. SKF
bring to our customers.”
International Institute for Management is one example of a company that is
Development (IMD). “If no value is cre- able to demonstrate that when they
Tom Johnstone,
ated, or what is created is perceived to partner with willing customers, the
President and CEO, SKF Group,
be less than value capture, the buyer- relationship is a profitable one for both
and, as such, and a lasting one too.” from Value Merchants.
supplier relationship breaks down. The

In the recent 2009 report from AberdeenGroup, a leading consultant in the procurement field, “identifying
cost savings” was cited as the number one driver of chief procurement officers.

“An interesting dynamic emerges


when you compare the perceptions
of most business customers and
the reality. Lowest unit price is
often assumed to be desirable. In
fact, firms that are convinced to
buy on value exhibit higher repeat
purchase rates, which suggest
that they are far more satisfied
with the results.”

Mr. Marco Bertini,


Assistant Professor of Marketing,
London Business School.

3
The language that “They say, ‘We’re probably worth The big challenge is developing a meth-
management understands €40,000.’ That works for a while, but odology to calculate these types of costs
Consider the example of a manufacturing more and more customers are trying to that both the customer and supplier agree
company with €100 million a year in find out what’s real and based more on provides accurate results. “You must be
sales that has a net profit margin of fact than guess work.” able to prove to your customers that,
10 percent, or €10 million. A supplier based on their own customized oper­
comes in and demonstrates that through ating parameters, they’ll save money by
TCO strategies, they can save the com-
Measuring bottom line results implementing these things,” says
pany €100,000 in variable costs (lower Purchasing magazine noted in a story Underhill.
repair costs, less machine downtime, on MRO (maintenance, repair and oper­ Underhill says that in some compa-
energy savings, less material wastage, ations) buying that nies the primary driver being measured
etc.). While not appearing to be a large most purchasing today is simple reduction in price, such
amount on its own, consider that it operations – and as switching from brand A to brand B
would take a one percent increase in MRO suppliers and reduced freight costs. However,
gross sales, or €1 million, to net the – routinely track customers are finally realizing that this
same bottom line gain. And, unlike price such metrics as is not enough. Many companies are now
reductions, these savings generally are price, inventory not allowing brand/supplier switching to
sustainable year to year. levels and process count for price reductions in purchasing
It is results like these that are attracting improvements. departments, realizing that simply
the attention of purchasing profession- But many suppliers also provide services switching to a lower priced supplier may
als and CFOs alike. Purchasing profes- that can help significantly reduce costs actually not save money when the total
sionals are starting to learn that the for purchasing. Identifying and moni- cost is con­sidered.
best way to justify their benefit to the toring these savings, however, is not TCO makes visible a wealth of other,
company is to express it in the language always easy. more hidden savings. One of the main cost
that management understands: money. “When I work with clients, the first drivers commonly not measured on large
To offer a total cost solution, a supplier thing I want them to understand is that supply contracts, for instance, is the tech-
must be able to show concrete results these costs exist,” says Underhill. “I take nical support provided at the local level.
on a customer’s financial profit and loss something from their operation that is “Every time a supplier solves a prob-
statement in four typical places: real to them – a steam leak, bearings, lem or finds a better solution for a given
stock-outs – and walk them through problem or application, it should be
1 Revenues. Can downtime be reduced, where the costs are and what a poten- documented,” Underhill says. “But this
production rates increased or time to tial solution could look like.” is very rarely done or measured in any
market for new products reduced? way by the sales team. Therefore, the
2 Expenditures. Can scrap or rejects be corporate offices don’t know what’s
reduced, thus impacting raw material actually happening down in the field in
costs? Can repairs be reduced, thus terms of savings. They can’t measure it,
“SKF’s suppliers have an important
impacting the cost of replacement and the field doesn’t know how to
role to play in our demand chain,
parts? Can energy usage be reduced, measure it.”
reflecting our high quality brand
lowering manufacturing costs? As a result of this lack of documented
image. SKF Demand Chain has a
3 Personnel. Can maintenance time be savings, the company may consider
goal to develop a world class supplier
reduced, thus freeing up employees buying from a lower price supplier in the
base. That means identifying and
to do other things? future – a supplier who would actually
developing suppliers that add the
4 Assets. Can cost of ownership of a most value to our operation in terms cost the company more in total cost.
machine or plant be reduced? If ma- of quality, cost, delivery, innovation Finally, the sooner that measure-
chine speed can be increased without and management capabilities. We ments are added to the equation, the
increasing wear, can capital expendi- have a very rigorous process that better. “The greatest value improve-
tures on additional machines be helps to determine who can truly ment potential exists at the need defini-
reduced? help us lower our Total Cost of Owner­- tion and specification stage, when ear-
ship, and that the benefits will be lier supply and supplier involvement can
The key element here is obtaining objec- sustainable over a long period of reveal major savings opportunities,”
tive numbers that accurately project time, so that SKF will continue to explain P. Fraser Johnson and Michiel R.
cost savings. Tim Underhill, a former be a best in class supplier to our Leenders in their article, “Minding the
professor from Texas A&M University customers.” Supply Savings Gaps”
and now a consultant in TCO says,
“TCO is not effective unless it is used Bo-Inge Stensson, Senior Vice
properly, however, and this takes time, President, SKF Group Demand Chain.
patience and persistence. A lot of people
grab a number out of the air,” he says.

4
SKF Documented Solutions operating parameters, we can save them Buy a

Program money by implementing the strategies


bearing

Almost 20 years ago, SKF developed a we recommend,” says Todd Snelgrove, an


ge Ins
tal
l

Mo lubr
Ch

g
SKF Global Manager, Value.

tin
programme based on the realization that

un icati
un

tin on
mo

ga
The SKF Documented Solutions Pro-

Dis

nd
factors beyond the quality and design
attributes of a bearing had a major gram is web-based software that calcu-

Prepare
Stop
impact on the life expectancy of that lates the expected value of a solution,
bearing. These factors include the whether in gearboxes, pumps, motors,
maintenance the bearing receives, the fans, machine tolls, conveyors, cranes,

Connitor
Mo

Ba itionng

nt
me
sic
d i
or industry specific machinery. The pro-

gn
environment the bearing operates in Ru n

Ali
n Ru

and how the bearing is installed. gram allows you to see how offerings
In implementing a programme to pro- from the five SKF technology platforms Re-lubrication

vide customer support in these critical – bearings and units, lubrication sys-
tems, mechatronics, seals, and services Bearing life cycle
areas, SKF was able to see the bottom
line savings the customer received. Ma- – can benefit your unique situation. Factors that contribute to the life
chine uptime was increased, resulting in With SKF’s Documented Solutions expectancy of a bearing were iden-
higher production levels. More efficient Program, to which customers have ac- tified, support provided, and bottom
bearings were installed, resulting in cess as part of the partner relationship, line savings documented.
lower energy costs. Better installation total cost reductions are shown in areas
techniques were taught, reducing the such as reducing energy, lubrication, in-
manpower require­ments for a plant. ventory, warranty costs, manpower, ma-
Machines lasted longer, reducing annual chine life, reliability, output and quality, 10 signs to look for in a real
capital expenditures. downsizing equipment, and over 250 TCO supplier
Based on this experience in over other factors.
19,000 businesses all over the world, in “Customers need to visually see that 1 A process to find cost-cutting
a variety of industries, SKF developed the price premium for some SKF prod- opportunities.
its own “SKF Documented Solutions ucts or services is really an investment 2 A team that is able to imple-
Program” software to help its custom- in their bottom line and that it will have ment a program to achieve
ers predict – then measure – the real a payback and return on investment promised savings, including
world, annual savings they could realize that is difficult to find anywhere else in a Value Manager to drive the
from using SKF products and services. their operations,” says Snelgrove. latest TCO initiatives.
Because of the large quantity of data 3 A tool that can measure the
that has been collected, SKF is in a To find out how SKF can take cost out expected and actual impact
unique position to be able to quickly and of your business, contact of cost-saving initiatives.
accurately project the monetary return todd.c.snelgrove@skf.com, or your local 4 A corporate culture that
on specific initiatives. SKF representative. embraces value initiatives,
“We can prove to potential customers not a marketing gimmick.
that, based on their own customized 5 The willingness to enter into
agreements where pay is
based on true value created.
6 An ongoing pipeline of innova-
Maximizing value with
tive, problem-solving solutions.
specific targets
7 A well-used reference of best
The SKF Client Needs practices by industry and
Analysis program com- application.
pares a company’s own 8 A log of solutions applied and
operating information to the results, including financial
a global best practices impact.
library to identify areas 9 A proven record of buying by
with the most potential value, not by price.
for improvement. Specific 10 Value propositions presented
solutions for the targets with HARD dollar impact, not
identified by the analysis soft benefits with no impact
can then be generated on operating profit.
using the SKF Docu-
mented Solutions
Program.

5
Customer Case Reduced repair time Reduced water consumption
By utilizing SKF’s maintenance tools, training By using the SKF Dry Lubrication system,
Histories and techniques, one customer saved 362 a juice producer eliminated the need to
maintenance man-hours annually and in- spray thousands of litres of water and
The SKF Documented Solutions creased machine life by 10 percent, with soluble lubricant on one conveyor, saving
over one million yen in savings. 15,700 euros in one year.
Program has helped thousands
of companies around the world Reduced machine repair costs Increased machine speed
achieve significant savings by By using SKF repair and refurbishment By upgrading to solution bearings and
1) reducing operating costs and, services, one company saved 700,000 euros implementing proper maintenance prac-
2) increasing productivity: in annual costs. tices, one manufacturer was able to
increase annual production 4 percent
Reduced energy Reduced warranty cost and save 19 million rubles.
By installing the correct seals, replacing By using quality SKF parts in their products
old bearings with new SKF Energy Effi- along with proper installation procedures Increased quality
cient (E2 design) bearings and the proper and tools, one OEM manufacturer reduced By installing SKF Super precision bearings,
type and amount of lubrication, plus insti- warranty costs by 11 percent, or 4 million variation was reduced, increasing quality
tuting proper installation, alignment, and rupees. by 1 percent while saving 3.25 million yen.
maintenance practices, one company
saved 247,500 US dollars annually. Reduced inventory expense Increased manpower efficiency
Working in conjunction with their SKF author- By accurately planning maintenance activi-
Reduced design costs
ized distributor, one company was able to ties and taking proactive action based on
By using advanced SKF design simulation implement more accurate planning, reducing machine life information obtained from
software to model design changes, one inventory levels by 400,000 Canadian dollars. SKF condition monitoring solutions, man-
OEM saved 146,000 euros. power availability was increased by 9 per-
Reduced lubricant usage cent, saving 875,000 rand.
Reduced unplanned downtime
By using SKF lubrication systems to make
Through the use of SKF condition moni- sure the right amount of grease and oil is Increased product benefits
toring technology and services, one com- delivered to the right place at the right time, By adding an SKF solution product to an
pany increased production by 12 percent lubricant usage was reduced by 18 percent, application, one OEM was able to claim
in the first year of implementation, saving with an annual savings of 450,000 British superior product benefits to its customer,
one million euros. pounds. in lubricant and disposal costs. leading to a 3 percent net profit improve-
ment, or 870,000 euros.
Reduced scrap Increased uptime
By installing new greased-for-life bearings, By using proper bearing mounting processes,
one food producer reduced scrap, and the and SKF tools and training, along with high
associated grease con­tamination problem, quality SKF Explorer performance class
by 18 percent, resulting in 745,000 bearings, one com­pany saved over 569,000
Argentinean pesos of annual savings. Australian dollars annually.

Why SKF? International company Research and development


SKF has 100 manufacturing sites worl­d­ With multiple facilities in various parts of
wide and sales companies in 70 countries. the world, SKF engineers are continuously
An effective partner in achieving Having a global perspective means we have at work developing more advanced solutions.
Total Cost of Ownership purchasing a strict adherence to global standards. In fact, SKF applies for, on average, at least
benefits must have the products, one patent every other day.
services, tools, knowledge and ca- Five areas of product expertise
SKF isn’t simply a bearing company. We are ISO standards
pabilities to take a comprehensive
also leaders in seals, lubricants, mecha­ SKF established new ISO standards for
approach to your entire operation. tronics and services. No other company bearings with the development of the SKF
SKF has proven itself up to the brings this combination of expertise to the Explorer performance class.
challenge time and again, in a di- marketplace. The combination of these
verse range of industries, on every technologies results in highly effective
continent of the globe. Consider solutions that generate greater profitability
for our customers.
these credentials:

6
Six Sigma Racing technical partnerships SKF Remanufacturing/Refurbishing
Using the Six Sigma methodology and In the high pressure environment of high- Services
tools enables SKF to reduce costs and performance motorsports, SKF has proven Comprehensive services are available for
improve the services and products that itself to be a valuable partner to some of the many products (bearings, bearing units
we provide to our customers, including top names. SKF has a 60+ year relationship and spindles) that optimize product life­
the reduction of waste (time, resources, with Scuderia Ferrari, the longest running cycles and reduce operation costs for
materials). Increased production and technical partnership on the Formula One cir- customers.
improved product quality. shorter lead cuit. We have a long-standing involvement in
times, reduced returns under warranty NASCAR and a technical supplier relation- SKF Certified Rebuilder Programme
and better availability are also benefits ship with Richard Childress Racing. SKF has Certifying repair shops in the correct
offered as a result of using this approach a product development relationship with rebuild methods help end-users achieve
to continuous improvement. Ducati in the Moto GP world championship. enhanced equipment performance and
increased profitability.
Industry-focused solutions Sharing and growing knowledge
SKF has always been a customer-driven By offering training for SKF employees (SKF SKF Nova Consulting
company and that means our R&D com- College), SKF distributor partners (SKF Dis- This global consulting practice offers spe-
mitment is focused on specific industries. tributor College), and end-user customers cific competence in the bearing industry.
Our goal is to anticipate the needs of our alike (Reliability Maintenance Institute), SKF It helps customers become more success-
customers and develop solutions shows its commitment to increasing value ful by identifying and addressing oppor-
accordingly. by sharing knowledge. tunities and challenges arising from mar-
ket developments, technology shifts and
Engineering support Environment efficiency demands.
SKF offers a complete range of engineering Green initiatives are a global, corporate
consultancy services, including advanced commitment, and a driving force in every- Field experts
modeling technologies (i.e. BEAST, thing we do. SKF was among the first inter- SKF’s broad range of knowledge is in part
ORPHEUS). national companies to receive worldwide due to our many field experts such as
certification to the environmental standard Professor Stathis Ionnides, winner of the
Engineers ISO 14001. Tribology Trust’s Gold Medal, internation-
SKF has the industry’s largest dedicated ally recognized as the highest honour in
staff of engineers (10,000 total), including SKF Energy Efficiency Solutions tribology research and application – an
field service and application engineers We have introduced a new family of prod- area of science focusing on the study of
that work hand-in-hand with customers. ucts that bring potential for energy savings friction, wear and lubrication. Ioannides
in virtually every industrial sector. is also the main developer of the ISO
Product distribution standard for calculations of bearing life,
Our customer service is only as good as SKF Maintenance Products used today by all bearing companies in
our local presence. That’s why SKF has a Realizing that better maintenance meant the world since 2007.
network of 15,000 distributors and dealers, lower total costs, SKF introduced a line of
each extensively trained to help your oper­ products over 30 years ago that bring Developing knowledge
ations perform smoothly. The SKF author- greater efficiency and productivity across Initiatives such as the SKF University
ized distributor network is the largest of all industries. Technology Centre for Steels and Heat
its kind globally. Treatment at Cambridge University, led
SKF Condition Monitoring Technologies by the world expert in bainitic steels,
SKF Logistics Services Preventing and eliminating unplanned Professor Harry Bhadeshia, extends
SKF has the industry’s broadest global downtime can save companies significant research capabilities to students and
logistics network. operating expense. SKF is the world’s largest fosters new developments.
manufacturer of condition monitoring
Acquisitions equipment, with a range of hardware and World leader
SKF continues to acquire leading compa- software products – plus services – to help SKF is the undisputed technology leader
nies to expand its knowledge in its five companies realize greater overall equipment in ball and roller bearings, with the SKF
competency areas. effectiveness. brand ranked number one in surveys
worldwide.
SKF Asset Management Services
SKF Client Needs Analysis, Root Cause Failure
Analysis and Reliability-Centered Mainte-
nance are just a few of the many services
available from SKF to help organizations
realize optimum performance from their
asset management initiatives.

7
Works cited
Anderson, James C., and James A. Narus:
“Business Market Management: Understanding, Creating, and Delivering Value,”
Prentice Hall.

Anderson, James C., Nirmala Kumar, and James A. Narus:


“Value Merchants: Demonstrating and documenting Superior Value in Business Markets,”
Harvard Business School Press, 2007.

Bartolini, Andrew:
“The CPO’s Agenda 2009, Smart Strategies for Tough Times,”
AberdeenGroup, April 2009.
“Buyers: Keep it simple when tracking savings.”
Purchasing, 15 January 2004.

Johnson, P. Fraser and Michiel R. Leenders:


“Minding the Supply Savings Gaps.”
MITSloan Management Review, Winter 2010.

Stoller, Jacob:
“Bearings: Looking beyond unit price.”
Purchasing B2B, June 2008.

Studebacker, Paul:
“Monetizing Maintenance.”
PlantServices.com 25 September 2007.

2008 Distribution Performance Survey, Purchasing 2008.

2010 Strategic Survey, State College, Pa.: Institute for the Study of Business Markets (ISBM).

The Power of Knowledge Engineering

Seals
Bearings Lubrication Drawing on five areas of competence and application-specific expertise amassed over more than 100
and units systems years, SKF brings innovative solutions to OEMs and production facilities in every major industry world-
wide. These five competence areas include bearings and units, seals, lubrication systems, mechatronics
(combining mechanics and electronics into intelligent systems), and a wide range of services, from 3-D
Mechatronics Services
computer modelling to advanced condition monitoring and reliability and asset management systems.
A global presence provides SKF customers uniform quality standards and worldwide product availability.

® SKF and Reliability Maintenance Institute are registered trademarks of the SKF Group.
™ SKF Explorer is a trademark of the SKF Group.
© SKF Group 2010
The contents of this publication are the copyright of the publisher and may not be reproduced (even extracts) unless prior written permission
is granted. Every care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this publication but no liability can be accepted
for any loss or damage whether direct, indirect or consequential arising out of the use of the information contained herein.
PUB GC/S8 10090 EN · March 2010
Printed in Sweden on environmentally friendly paper.
Certain image(s) used under license from Shutterstock.com

skf.com

You might also like