Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Connected devices
In 2019, despite the fact that connected drug delivery de-
vices are available and that adherence monitoring is pos-
sible and could drive demand, the adoption rate of these
products is slow. According to Merck’s David Braun, this is
due to a number of factors including complicated user in-
terfaces, high product costs, lack of patient awareness/pro-
Dr. Giana Carli Lorenzini, Postdoctoral Research Fellow in the Department of
motion in the health system and lack of a proper ecosystem Design Sciences at Lund University.
If the insurance company sees patients adhere to a drug and feelings of seniors. They’re sharing their medication use
better, then will they be more willing to pay for it because it through pictures from home. “Now I’m looking at cases that
boosts outcomes? were successfully developed and what they did to make an
He advised attendees that they shouldn’t underestimate inclusive design,” she says.
their data strategy because the data is powerful, beyond
sending reminders.Connected devices will be part of daily Smart packaging
life but there’s a lot the industry needs to do, including being Where does the smart package fit into the digital healthcare
faster to market and adopting technology from the consum- ecosystem? Dr. Alex Cole, Chief Scientist Aurora/Strategic
er electronics industry. “The opportunity is there. It’s not just Marketing Analyst at CPI, said, “The whole thing only works
an opportunity but a responsibility.” if you know the patient is taking the medication. It’s the glue
that holds it together. The package or device doesn’t have to be
Three types of patients connected but you have to get that info into the ecosystem.”
Dr. Giana Carli Lorenzini, Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Everything about pharmaceutical and device packaging is
the Department of Design Sciences at Lund University, dis- so controlled, from fill levels to storage conditions. But there
cussed the three types of patients: isn’t any environmental monitoring or traceability with the
• The pre-user who’s just been diagnosed and may be patient. He recounted a story in which a nurse accidentally
prone to making “naïve mistakes” with treatment left a fridge thermometer on top of the fridge, and continued
• The experienced user, who’s already adapted to a routine to record a 21°C reading all day. Even though the drugs were
and packaging safely inside the fridge, the products had to be thrown out.
• The user-advocate, involved in patient advocacy groups With smart packaging (and/or connected packaging) and
and looking beyond their own care to the community of more integrated healthcare ecosystems, Dr. Cole said that
patients at large opportunities include lower product wastage all the way to
While it’s not a reason not to update a package or device, it’s the patient, improved adherence, more informed patients,
important to consider that when changes are made, the expe- reductions in dispensing errors and reductions in accessi-
rienced user may revert and make mistakes. She is continu- bility issues. He mentioned smart blister packaging, such as
ing research, working on a post-doc, studying the routines Med-ic Smart Blister from Information Mediary Corp and
Pharmapack 2019 Highlights Connected Devices, Adherence Packaging, continued
Dr. Cole pointed to the need for packaging such as Schreiner Medipharm’s
Stevanato Group’s Cartridge-based wearable device was selected as the Best smart blister package, which generates data in real time when a patient pushes
Innovation in Drug Delivery Device in the Pharmapack Awards. a tablet from a cavity.
Schreiner Medipharm’s smart blister package, which gener- ducing technologies that are flexible, capable of high volume
ates data in real time when a patient pushes a tablet from a production and printable on very thin substrates so that they
cavity, which may include medication type, extraction time can be embedded in compact designs.
and specific cavity.
As Braun had mentioned, Dr. Cole said that adoption rates Disposable electronics?
are still slow. “We need this massive collaborative approach The elephant in the room when it comes to these high-tech-
and we need all the partners to see the benefits.” CPI is work- yet-single-use packaging designs is that we cannot continue to
ing with universities and patient groups, pharmaceutical pump electronics into the waste stream. Dr. Cole said that they
companies and government bodies, looking atways to im- are also investigating options to recycle these components,
prove offerings and adoption. and potentially use the connectivity of the designs themselves
CPI, which develops printable electronics, is looking at to reach the patient and help guide them in terms of how pa-
ways to use electronics to overcome some challenges by pro- tients should properly recycle or dispose of the packaging.
Healthcare Industry Cannot
Ignore Environmental Impact
Recycling or reusing medical devices? It’s coming. A presentation at Pharmapack
highlighted green guides and carbon footprint opportunities.
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
Healthcare Industry Cannot Ignore Environmental Impact
felt guilty throwing the product away each month. ated packaging units)… and that’s just for respiratory products.
“We have to work as an industry-wide consortium on this. Breaking down LCA numbers for Relvar 92/22 by device, pro-
The medicine is king but if we can work together and iden- duction, API, distribution, use and end of life, he showed how
tify materials and processes that do have CO2 benefits, we the device and pack breakdown enable better understanding
could make a big difference,” Anderson noted. “We’ve never of CO2 impact and where changes can be made. The figures in-
accounted for actual CO2 savings. You save money when you cluded the energy to manufacture the package and device itself.
save CO2, either by enhanced process or materials.” By making processes more efficient, such as enhancements
Positive impacts can come from unlikely sources. A logis- that speed up lines, companies can reduce environmental
tics company scraped barnacles off their boats, making the impact. One key consideration is that pharmaceutical com-
vessels more efficient and using less fuel. Seemingly little panies typically don’t make the devices, they design them or
things can add up. buy them from suppliers, so they must work with suppliers
Anderson described a sustainability spectrum that compa- early on to engineer out costs.
nies fall on, ranging from reactive to mature. On the initial
reactive side, companies are doing what they can to “stay le- CO2 numbers
gal,” progressing through stages until they are differentiating Anderson pointed out that the CO2 numbers themselves
their products and businesses, building trust and ultimately don’t mean much until you begin to compare them to others.
changing the marketplace. The carbon footprint of a Big Mac is approximately 4,000 g of
CO2 equivalent gases per serving, where a vaccine’s is under
Opportunity: metered dose inhalers 1,500 and an MDI’s is under 500. He said the awareness is im-
Anderson discussed the major opportunity that healthcare portant and he thinks we should start the discussion around
product manufacturers have to make an impact. Take the in- waste with end users.
haler market. It’s projected to be worth $43 billion by 2025, with
the market split between metered dose inhalers (MDI) at 60%, The green impact of non-adherence
dry powder inhalers (DPI) at 30% and smart mist inhalers/neb- It’s wasteful when patients don’t take their medication as
ulizers at 10%. Globally, volumes of single-use doses and multi- prescribed. The pharma industry as a whole has to do more
dose devices globally are in the billions (with billions of associ- to make patients realize they are part of the total solution,
Healthcare Industry Cannot Ignore Environmental Impact, continued
Propellants
Propellants are another area that governmental bodies are
targeting. In fact, the UK parliament released a document on
Carbon footprint breakdown by component.
reducing F-gases that said the National Health System (NHS)
should set a target that by 2022 at least 50% of prescribed in-
halers are low GWP [Global Warming Potential], and that the
government should ensure that by 2020, at least 50% of MDIs
are recycled. With Brexit, it’s only one nation but the NHS in
the UK is a huge market. Anderson was concerned at the lack
of fanfare as he stumbled on this information, asking, “Is any-
one beside GSK looking at this? This is news to people… even
among producers of MDIs. They have to be made aware.”
Green guides
Anderson stressed the importance of having a green guide
at every company, which enables informed discussions be-
tween business groups along with mutual cooperation to-
ward the goal. The benefits, he said, are as much commercial
Huhtamaki won a Pharmapack award for Push Tab®, a flexible blister that as they are environmental because saving CO2 saves money.
eliminates PVC.
Healthcare Industry Cannot Ignore Environmental Impact, continued
The guide should set clear expectations of requirements for the Cycle” is GSK’s recycling and recovery scheme for all
primary, secondary and tertiary packaging and help design- respiratory inhalers, in which the company provides a con-
ers rapidly asses the environmental impact of designs, with venient way for patients to recycle their inhalers.
prevention being most favorable. The company reports that by the end of 2017, over 1.2 million
inhalers had been recycled and recovered. This has saved carbon
He presented the 7 Rs of GSK’s waste hierarchy: dioxide emissions equivalent to taking 5,199 cars off UK roads.
• Reduce – Reduce the mass of materials, complexity and At this point, Anderson noted, this is perhaps only 1.3% of
the life cycle footprint of packaging inhalers, “but the opportunity is there. This is what we have
• Remove – Remove unnecessary materials or those with to do if it can’t go into waste stream.”
environmental concerns
• Reuse – Reuse the component (a hurdle in pharmaceu- Key takeaways
ticals) • Poor adherence is never “green.”
• Recycle– Design for recyclability • Design and specify inhalers (and packaging) to be op-
• Renew – Increase the use of materials and energy from timized. This means maximizing shelf life while mini-
renewable sources mizing materials. Use an LCA to understand the carbon
• Reward – Improve the environmental impact of the sup- footprint of each component and look at ways to refill
ply chain, accounting for patient, customer and consum- where possible and make electronics reusable.
er needs at lower cost • Engage your suppliers in this effort.
• Respect – Use responsible suppliers • Use new “greener” propellants wherever possible.
As devices become implanted with small electronics, the
Inhaler recovery need for assessment is even greater. Anderson concluded,
GSK is putting its money where its mouth is when it comes “With connected devices, what is going to happen when all
to recycling. The company saw that their inhalers were the these end up in the waste stream? No one’s talking about it,
second biggest contributor to their global footprint, just af- we’ve got to talk about it.”
ter the transportation aspects involved in producing and
supplying products globally. around the world. “Complete
The Shift from Hospitals
to Home Care Continues to
Shape Packaging
The future role of patient adherence tracking, flexible packaging options and
sustainability continue to challenge the healthcare industry.
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
The Shift from Hospitals to Home Care Continues to Shape Packaging
ing up production and consistent product sizes. Busimi said we have to talk about ways we can recycle, or better still, re-
that ready-to-use options and industry standardization and duce. The healthcare industry cannot continue to add plas-
can help, so that projects benefit from some “modular” ma- tic to the environment the way it was in decades past, both
chinery or packaging aspects versus bespoke… everything. for environment and the court of public opinion. More and
Marie-Liesse Le Corfec, Global Portfolio Marketing Head, more, pharmaceutical manufacturers are asking for packag-
Prefilled Systems at BD, said that we need more industry col- ing with reduced environmental footprints.
laboration and partnerships, in addition to the flexibility to Another key part of this, as David Braun, Global Head of
run products on different packaging sizes. As pharmaceuti- Medical Device Business Solutions at Merck, noted, is deter-
cal companies must get products to market faster to help pa- mining the value-add of packaging. Consumers are increas-
tients, packaging, device and machinery suppliers can help ingly eschewing packaging waste, at times even opting for
pharma companies by offering drug companies the informa- “packaging-free” food stores. Medical packaging must deliver
tion packages they need in streamlined ways, including val- value, and that value must be communicated to the patient.
idation and testing data. It’s almost as if the packaging com- In his presentation at Pharmapack, Braun spoke of the great
munity can aid in being a “delivery device” to help pharma opportunity that connected devices present if implemented
companies deliver drugs to the market. correctly, and that healthcare can learn from the fast-mov-
ing consumer electronics industry.
Sustainability Ultimately, panelists said that patient desires and inde-
Sustainability questions still lurk, though the topic is be- pendence were the driving forces for change, or for keep-
coming much more popular. While the pharma and med de- ing things the same. Le Corfec mentioned that an existing
vice industries are slow to adopt any changes, much less sus- device was on the table during an evaluation and the pa-
tainability initiatives, the panelists all agreed there is much tient remarked that that was what they wanted. Just because
room for improvement. a device has been around for years doesn’t mean it’s not
Ger Standhardt is Executive Director of HCPC Europe, valuable or needs to be changed. “We have to listen to the
which recently developed a research database to create an patient,” she said.
overview for members of the available research in the field
of patient-friendly and adherence packaging. He said that
UK Wants 50% of Metered Dose
Inhalers Recycled… By 2020
A speaker at Pharmapack Europe found a lofty goal in a UK document about reducing
F-gases. Do the device manufacturers know about it?
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
UK Wants 50% of Metered Dose Inhalers Recycled… By 2020
The Lorax Compliance COO addressed the issue Feb. 6 at Pharmapack, saying
that businesses in this sector may not be aware of the full extent of environmen-
tal Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) legislation and the changes that will
be implemented from the E.U.’s Circular Economy package.
“The pharmaceutical industry has many regulatory hoops to jump through,
so it’s perhaps understandable that environmental reporting has been as less
of a priority,” said Carvell. “Nevertheless, many pharmaceutical companies are
highly globalized and export and import into numerous markets. As more E.U.
countries focus on improving their packaging collection, sorting and separat-
ing capabilities, this industry, like many others, will need to prepare for these
changes and consider how they will impact their operations.”
Carvell explained the recent legislation changes in both the E.U. and international-
ly, including Germany’s VerpackG scheme, which requires businesses to register to a
dual reporting system, and carries a maximum fine of €200,000 for non-compliance.
During Pharmapack Europe 2019, Lorax
Compliance COO Michelle Carvell urged
“The industry should expect further reforms over the next two years in line with
the pharmaceutical industry to prioritize the E.U.’s 2018 Circular Economy package,” she said. “Planning for these changes is
its environmental reporting obligations for
packaging or risk high financial penalties not something to leave until the last minute. The VerpackG scheme, for example,
caught many businesses unawares when it was implemented January 1, 2019. A
number of other EPR programs are changing and if businesses that are unable to
source the necessary data they will automatically be subject to higher default fees.”
Case Study: The Emotional Side of
Pediatric Infusion
At Pharmapack 2019, a human factors study highlighted anxiety and
other delivery issues, offering insights into the real-world challenges of
managing pediatric drug delivery.
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
Case Study: The Emotional Side of Pediatric Infusion
But that sense of confidence and control does not neces- lenges, and the skill that comes along with it… there’s an
sarily carry over to pediatric patients and the parents who emotional component to delivery.”
perform the infusions. The pediatric study was narrowed One parent remarked that their sadness comes from twice
to children under 12 years of age, and yielded some unique weekly infusion, including her child’s reaction to the needle
challenges. poke. Though the infusions are “only twice a week,” they ex-
plained that their child’s bad days are really bad.
The emotional toll Parents may experience a range of negative emotions in-
Parents who must infuse reported much anxiety and dis- cluding a fear of infusing, concerns over finding a vein and
tress. Kalbermatten said, “Infusion is one of the largest chal- causing their child pain. “These emotions turn into barriers
and translate into real adherence issues,” he noted.
Observing the process in and pressed the bandage post-infusion while the mother’s
Preparation for infusion requires multiple items and steps, hands were full of supplies. Did the father wash his hands?
and that means many points for contamination. After film- What if that third hand is unavailable while the primary care-
ing parents infuse their children, the team discovered many giver deals with removal and disposal?
real-world issues—and differences between actions and what The team also noted that disposal can be tricky. There are
they say they do—that could potentially be addressed with tools available, but patients and caregivers don’t always have
packaging advancements such as: the right one at home. They may have an insulin sharps con-
• Juggling supplies to keep them off the surface. tainer that does the job but is not ideal.
• Taking a phone out mid-preparation to scan the bottle The question Franzese posited is whether there is anything
for an app, introducing an opportunity for bacteria from drug and device manufacturers can do to help parents pre-
the phone to hands. pare and infuse, and reduce possible contamination. Addi-
• In one parent’s case, priming the system with saline solu- tionally, what can be done to reduce anxiety for the child?
tion first, so that if something went wrong, they would Ultimately, the study offered insights into users—the dos-
only waste saline and not the drug itself. “Even the ex- ing environment, the emotional state and emotional needs
pert hadn’t seen that before,” said Franzese. of the patient and caregiver—that can be shared with drug
One child expressed that he feels scared of the process, and manufacturers and supplier stakeholders to help inform fu-
prefers a routine in which all family members sit in the room ture device and packaging decisions.
during the infusion at home. In the video, the father stepped
Should My Device Be Connected?
Live from Pharmapack Europe, a device design consultant shared an approach for
deciding on connectivity and packaging upgrades, along with the real question you
should be asking yourself when making the call.
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
Should My Device Be Connected?
For Team Consulting, the company gathers a multi-disci- How do you integrate connectivity? You may be able cre-
plinary team and works through a matrix with opportunities ate a sleeve for the device so that existing devices (and
across the top and categories of devices on the Y-axis. They manufacturing lines) remain as is. The benefit is that a
populate the matrix, noting how each type of device could sleeve is reusable and cuts down on the cost of treatment,
meet the benefit. but you are relying on the user to add it on. You have to
To bolster patient adherence for example, a dumb device ask yourself what the user is getting in return for that add-
may receive a packaging redesign so that the package steps ed step. Value-added functions for the patient may include
the user through the package. A smart device may prompt easy communication with phone/app for convenience or
the user through the use of an LCD screen, while a connect- smart reordering.
ed device could share data with the healthcare provider so You may also consider a bolt-on in the manufacturing
that the user is prompted with an email or phone call. process, removing a piece of casing. In this case, you are
For each part of the matrix, they ask how well a solution meets not asking the user to perform the extra step, but every
the particular stakeholder need, noting risks or technology con- time they throw out the device, they throw out the elec-
straints. They ask if the outcome could be achieved with a dumb tronics with it.
solution. Ultimately, the best answer may be a suite of solutions
and not one single design update or choice to connect.
If the connectivity is fully Integrated (i.e. you change the alent in the consumer electronics industry for good rea-
moldings), the risk is that you likely have to revalidate your son. As Driver noted, “There’s quite a lot of opportunity
product and production line. there. You don’t have to interact with a user interface.
Driver offered attendees several other tips including: You ask a question more or less when you think of it, so
• Create a quick and dirty prototype, the earlier the better. this may reduce cognitive load for the user.”
Companies such as Nordic Semiconductors, Texas In- • Right now, voice commands are mostly about making a
struments and Diolan make development boards which request. But the industry may be moving toward systems
can be used for quick prototyping. providing the user with prompts.
• When testing early, get feedback from a set of stakehold- • A successful app or device will likely strike a balance of
ers (not only the users). functionality and utility (not just novelty), and will not
• Deciding what to sense is really key—more data means more make the user do things they don’t want to do.
storage space, a greater power budget and greater cost.
• Be selective about what you communicate to the user. For Key takeaway
example, an Apple watch offers a very pared down view of The human factor cannot be overlooked. If the user is los-
activity for the day. There’s a lot of data in the background, ing privacy to use a connected device, they need some oth-
but the user is seeing a simple and appealing set of three er benefit to motivate them to engage with the system. “And
colorful circles and trying to close the gap (see image). feeling better might not be enough,” Driver said. “We have to
• Don’t overlook voice control. This feature is quite prev- shift patient behavior with good design.”
New Pharmapack Awards Include
Patient-Centric and Eco Designs
Phillips-Medisize, Stevanato, Schott AG, Aptar Pharma, Stiplastics and Huhtamaki
were awarded in the Exhibitor Innovation Category while Pierre Fabre Cosmetic, UCB
Pharma and Vemedia were awarded in the Health Products Category.
By Keren Sookne, Director of Editorial Content
New Pharmapack Awards Include Patient-Centric and Eco Designs
Each year, innovative companies submit new packaging and drug delivery
designs for Pharmapack Award consideration. The awards recognize new
products set to shape the future of the industry. As Pharmapack Brand Director
Silvia Forroova explained, the committee only considers developments that
emerged since the previous year’s conference, ensuring that the awards
highlight the latest in packaging advances.
New in 2019,the Health Product Category has 2 special recognitions:
• Patient-Centric Design Award in Partnership with HCPC Europe
• Eco-Design Award in Partnership with Adelphe
New Pharmapack Awards Include Patient-Centric and Eco Designs, continued
Exhibitor Category
Connected Health Platform by Phillips-Medisize pabilities, robust cybersecurity and streamlined regulatory documentation.
Its advanced analytics package is designed for connected drug delivery devices, biosensors
and regulated Mobile Medical Applications (SaMD/MMA). Ultimately, connected health solu-
tions may help patients improve medication adherence and manage chronic conditions.
Best Innovation in Packaging Material & Component Best Innovation in Packaging Material & Component
SCHOTT’s new syriQ BioPure® prefillable glass syringes were de- Aptar Pharma QuickStart™ is an innovative way to deliver inject-
signed specifically for the biologics market, keeping sensitive drugs able development solutions to pharmaceutical customers, demon-
stable, easing administration and shortening time to market. Im- strably accelerating bench-to-market time. Designed specifically
proved drug stability is reached through enhanced manufacturing for R&D labs, biotech companies, start-ups and universities, Quick-
processes, which lead to ultra low tungsten level and low adhesive Start™ provides everything needed for the small volume filling of
residuals resulting in reduced risk of potential interactions with oth- high-value formulations.
er materials. QuickStart™ combines best-in-class components from Aptar Phar-
Additionally, a homogeneous silicone layer ensures a consistent glid- ma, Schott and EMA, enabling innovators to benefit from multiple
ing performance, which is essential to ease administration for the pa- configurations shipped from a single source, and available to order
tient. Functionality is achieved through tighter dimensional tolerances through a convenient e-commerce portal. These components satisfy
and a verified compatibility with safety devices. The syringes are made all regulatory requirements, allowing developers to access commer-
of FIOLAX® borosilicate glass and are available in more than 48 pre-val- cial scale quality at development stage costs, meaning performance
idated configurations. at project outset can be maintained at scale up.