Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contents
Part 1: Student Evaluation and Justification of UDL Approaches ........................................................... 1
Part 2: Three Lesson Plans Reflecting UDL.............................................................................................. 4
Part 3: Critical Reflection on Lesson plans .............................................................................................. 8
Part 4: Stakeholder Report For School Colleagues and Fellow Teachers ............................................ 10
Appendix – Selected Resources used in lessons ................................................................................... 12
References ............................................................................................................................................ 14
0
Part 1: Student Evaluation and Justification of UDL Approaches
(835 words including intext citations)
Sky is a student facing challenges. She exhibiting some elements of a behaviour disorder
(Johnson-Harris & Mundschenk, 2014) and is having problems with academic achievement
and interpersonal relations. Her experience of schooling is falling well short of the goal of
Universal Design for Learning (UDL), to “create a love of learning and the ability to learn”
(Gordon, Meyer & Rose, 2014, p. 8). The UDL framework is applied to three geography
lessons in this report, to “embrace and enhance the natural variability of learners” such as
Sky (Glass, Meyer & Rose, 2013, p. 98).
UDL arose from the fields of architectural design and neuroscience (Gordon, Meyer & Rose,
2014), and is based on a number of key principles that are particularly pertinent to Sky’s
situation, including the necessity of emotional engagement in learning and the need for a
combination of curriculum, pedagogy and assessment that is responsive to the diversity
inherent in any cohort of students (Gordon et al., 2014). UDL delivers benefit to all students,
not just those with identified disabilities or disorders (Lieberman, 2017; Courey et al., 2012)
but also gifted and talented students (Dalton et al., 2019), those whose disability has not
been recognised (Courey et al, 2012) and at-risk students, such as Sky.
Although it has been argued that technology and UDL are “not inextricably intertwined”
(Courey et al., 2012, p. 11) and that “sound pedagogy” is the true foundation, purposeful
integration of technology is a common feature of UDL (Hashey & Stahl, 2014; Wilson et al.,
2011) and features in these lessons. Digital technologies create rich opportunities for UDL in
geography, with spatial technologies and digital mapping facilitating exploration of real
world scenarios, which is a core element of quality geography teaching (Kidman, 2012).
1
Taken together, Sky’s behaviours may indicate a behaviour disorder, however responsibility
for any diagnosis lies with psychology professionals, and it is hoped that she is receiving this
type of support given her history of school exclusion. Her school work, when completed, is
“just below” class level, which diminishes the likelihood of a learning disability. Sky’s limited
capacity to follow instructions and her propensity to tear up her work indicate the need for
more self-regulation and improved executive functions, and deficits in these are commonly
associated with classroom misbehaviour (Romer et al., 2011). The UDL Guidelines address
these skills specifically, through the pillars of ‘engagement’ and ‘action and expression’
(CAST, 2018).
Sky’s inability to regulate her emotions is not just affecting her social connectedness, it may
indicate increased risk, or be symptomatic of, mental health disorder (Silk et al., 2003). It is
likely to be having an adverse effect on her learning; UDL principles suggest “engagement
with learning is gained through social processes” (Gordon, Meyer & Rose, 2014, p. 12) and
the ‘affective’ domain, relating to engagement, is “all-important” (p. 90). Sky is in need of
support that enables her to achieve “interest, purpose, motivation, and, most importantly,
strong self-regulation” to achieve learning expertise (p. 90) and as a protective factor for
mental health (Silk et al., 2003).
Research suggests Sky’s family situation is likely to be inhibiting her capacity to learn,
including: her parents’ lack of engagement with her schooling (Barnard, 2004; Fan & Chen,
2001); her disrupted homelife (Jensen, 2013; Legault, 2006); and possible neglect or family
poverty (Kieran & Anderson, 2019; Jensen, 2013). Further, these types of socioeconomic
and cultural challenges may be fostering unconscious, but relatively common, biases on the
part of Sky’s teachers, which can be a “threat to (their) learning” (Kieran & Anderson, 2019,
p. 1203). UDL may be helpful; as a universal framework it may offer a protective effect.
Sky’s behaviours have resulted in regular school exclusion, which has been found to have a
negative effect on academic performance and lead to social alienation (Crosby, 2018;
Beauchamp, 2012). Research indicates that students with behaviour disorders and those
from a low socioeconomic background are over-represented in students being excluded
from school, and that this disciplinary strategy rarely achieves an improvement in school
behaviours (Beauchamp, 2012). UDL lessons can be expected to improve Sky’s behaviours
2
(Gordon, Meyer & Rose, 2014) and diminish the need for the school to rely on this form of
discipline, which is likely to be exacerbating Sky’s challenges.
Teachers will need to collaborative across faculties, and employ formative assessment to
ensure these lessons and others are meeting Sky’s needs; the level of disruptive behaviours
will form a key indicator of her engagement and the success of this program (De Nobile et
al., 2017).
3
Part 2: Three Lesson Plans Reflecting UDL
ASSIGNMENT 3: LESSON PLAN: Differentiating Learning Using the UDL principles: Unit of work/ topic: Land Management (Year 8 Geography)
Regular Outcomes/ Lesson goals: Students will: Explain the purpose of land management; Identify different types of land degradation; Identify how land management practices have
changed over time; Identify different causes of land degradation; Propose solutions to environmental challenges, using a local, contemporary case study
Life Skills Outcomes for individual: .
Strengths, Multiple means of REPRESENTATION Multiple means of EXPRESSION Multiple means of ENGAGEMENT
Interests, (various ways of acquiring information and (alternative ways of demonstrating what (tap into interests, provide challenges, increase
Needs: knowledge) students know) motivation)
SKY
LESSON 1: • Social learning to encourage connectedness • Range of activity formats to maintain • All lessons clearly outline learning goals
• Range of information delivery modes interest and attention • Students self-select difficulty level of
(Please see including visual: aerial photos of case study • Creative expression in ‘Emu Passport’ worksheet
lesson details site and verbal instruction workbook • Topics linked to background knowledge
on following • Structured and supported social learning • Visual acuity and background knowledge in including sustainability
pages, with mode for worksheet activity class discussion of aerial photos activity • Participation at multiple points e.g. year of
UDL features • Collaborative learning in worksheet activity • Research and numeracy skills applied in the aerial photo
highlighted) and class discussion about aerial photos worksheet activity • Emu activity links the three lessons,
employing fun activities and independent
research
LESSON 2: • Range of information delivery modes • Expression includes dancing and creative • Real world application of land management
including video case study writing in Emu TikTok in video
• Scaffolded worksheet and class discussion • Opportunity for verbal contributions and • Students encouraged to share social media
supports learning in zone of proximal critical thinking in worksheet activity and knowledge and expression and perform a
development land management case study discussion dance
• Structured social learning for worksheet • Students draw on knowledge from Science, • Students draw on self-regulation to work
activity Maths and prior Geography for worksheet independently on challenging task
and the homework on conservation of Emus (worksheet)
LESSON 3: • Use of a range of real-world resources • Students have opportunity to autonomously • Students grouped with learners of similar
including digital, to deliver information select their mode of participation in Media capacity for supportive and challenging
about case study Review: can be verbal, visual or written collaborative activity
• Teacher’s mind map of class discussion • Expression includes drawing and creative • Discussion about the credibility of the media
contributions combines visual with written writing in Emu-stagram sources is an opportunity for critical
to record learning thinking, and acknowledges different views
and bias
4
Lesson 1
Topic area: Land Management and Stage of Learner: Year 8 Syllabus Pages: 63/64
Protection
Syllabus Outcomes Assessment Students learn about Students learn to
- describes processes and Formative - Definition and different - Explain the purpose of
influences that form and assessment: forms of land management land management
transform places and review of and degradation - Identify different types of
environments GE4-2 worksheets and - Australian land uses and land degradation
- discusses management of verbal challenges - Identify how land
places and environments for contributions to - Example of changes in land management practices
their sustainability GE4-5 class Think-Pair- management over time have changed over time
Share activity
Cross Curriculum themes & General capabilities Explicit subject specific concepts and skills
- Sustainability - Interpret aerial photography use over time
- Civics and citizenship - Classify different land types
- Numeracy
- Science
5
Lesson 2
Topic area: Land Management and Stage of Learner: Year 8 Syllabus Pages: 63/64
Protection
Syllabus Outcomes Assessment Students learn about Students learn to
- describes processes and Lesson assessment: - Responsibility for land - Identify different causes
influences that form and Formative assessment management of land degradation
transform places and achieved through - Causes of land - Propose solutions to
environments GE4-2 evaluation of student degradation and environmental
- discusses management of worksheets and class associated human challenges
places and environments for discussion activities
their sustainability GE4-5 - Chart types
Cross Curriculum themes & General capabilities Explicit subject specific concepts and skills
- Numeracy, Science - Analyse visual representations of Geographical
- Sustainability phenomena
- Work and Enterprise - Communicate geographical information
6
Lesson 3
Topic area: Land Management and Stage of Learner: Year 8 Syllabus Pages: 63/64
Protection
Syllabus Outcomes Assessment Students learn about Students learn to
- describes processes and Lesson assessment: - Challenges in land - Critically evaluate
influences that form and Formative assessment management media
transform places and achieved through - Communication of Land - Communicate
environments GE4-2 assessment of responses Management Challenges evaluation to
- discusses management of to Media Review and - Evaluating media sources classmates
places and environments for Traffic Light Exit Slip
their sustainability GE4-5
Cross Curriculum themes & General capabilities Explicit subject specific concepts and skills
- Literacy - Critical review of Geographical communication
- Ethical understanding
- Sustainability
7
Part 3: Critical Reflection on Lesson plans
(467 words including intext citations)
This set of lessons with UDL principles features a range of “built-in academic and behavioral
supports” (Johnson-Harris & Mundschenk, 2014, p. 169) that will enhance Sky’s opportunity
to meet her learning goals. Teachers delivering these lessons will need to retain high levels
of awareness of Sky’s emotional wellbeing, limited self-regulation and disengagement.
The UDL principle of multiple means of engagement, includes “motivation, building on the
interests of the students” (Nisbet, 2019), and is vital for Sky, who has multiple indicators of
lack of academic motivation (Legualt, 2006). Employing Sky’s particular interest in creative
expression, including drawing, creative writing and even dance, are potential solutions here.
These lessons address Sky’s need for social learning through instances of groupwork in
varied formats. This may also support Sky’s engagement via “collaboration and community”
(CAST, 2018). Future lessons could offer opportunities for Sky and other students to learn
from, and cooperate with, a diverse range of learners “on a less formal level” (Foreman &
Arthur-Kelly, 2014, p. 265).
The UDL principle of multiple means of representation enables students to “choose the
methods by which they take in information” (Nisbet, 2019), and these lessons support Sky,
who is often tired and disengaged, by varying information delivery and providing
reinforcement across multiple formats.
The lessons combine direct instruction with student-led inquiry and class discussion, giving
students several access points for their learning. In particular the lessons make use of real-
world sources, such as media articles or a report by the National Parks and Wildlife Service,
which is a feature of UDL principles to incorporate “relevance and authenticity” (Courey et
al., 2012, p. 20). Teachers may need a greater understanding of Sky’s optimal means of
representation.
The UDL principle of multiple means of action and expression encourages teachers to offer
students a range of ways to “show what they’ve learned” (Nisbet, 2019) and these lessons
offer several opportunities for students to select their response format (written or verbal),
or the depth of their written response.
8
One notable extension outside of traditional Geography pedagogy is the use of creative arts
including dance, which is designed to engage Sky’s natural interests. Glass et al. argue that
“the arts push us to recognise and consider multiple, flexible ways in which people learn and
interact with the world” (2013, p. 107), and it is argued this is a key principle of the
geography syllabus (NESA, 2019). The lessons also make use of scaffolded resources, which
recognises the UDL method of “graduated levels of support” (CAST, 2018).
The lessons link geography concepts to the students’ personal interests and activity in social
media, which may also encourage critical thinking (Bigum & Rowan, 2015) however teachers
will need to seek further opportunities to allow students’ to “apply deep understandings of
key disciplinary concepts and principles to real-world problems” (Masters, 2016 p. 6).
9
Part 4: Stakeholder Report
For School Colleagues and Fellow Teachers
(404 words including intext citations)
Sky is a student with untapped potential but a number of issues are preventing her from
achieving full success in her learning. Her interest in music and art offers opportunities for
re-engagement however the school needs to urgently address Sky’s unsatisfactory levels of
academic motivation and social connectedness. Her problematic behaviours may indicate
the presence of a behavioural disorder, and have resulted in several instances of
suspension. That, and her lack of self-regulation, may be either risk factors or indicators of
psychological disorders (Havinghurst et al., 2015) and thus require expert attention, if this is
not already been provided.
Sky’s appears to lack adequate family support for her education, as indicated by her
tiredness and lack of appropriate uniform and equipment. It would be desirable for the
school to locate additional support to ensure Sky has access to uniform and materials, either
through targeted funding or charitable programs. It would also be desirable to recruit a
mentor from the field of art or music to act as a prosocial role model. Research indicates
that these types of relationships can act as a protective factor for adolescent mental health
(Murray & Malmgren, 2005) and are especially important to students facing behavioural
challenges like Sky (Osher et al., 2010).
The level of Sky’s social alienation is a concern, and is associated with adverse academic
outcomes and risk factors for poor mental health (Havinghurst et al., 2015; Arnett, 2014).
The social learning activities incorporated into the above UDL framework may assist in this
regard but other interventions could include a more intensive program of social emotional
learning, in accordance with the NSW Wellbeing framework (NSW Department of Education
and Communities, 2015).
UDL research suggests that to support Sky’s engagement, the school could allocate her a
school-based task or “job with meaning” (Rapp, 2014, p. 29). Such activities have been
found to provide “a sense of community... and feelings of empowerment”, both of which
would be beneficial for Sky given her circumstances (p. 29). This role should be developed in
consultation with Sky to give her the opportunity for self-determination, though her existing
10
interest in art and music suggest some responsibility for organising or creating resources for
the school’s music and art events would be appropriate.
It is hoped that a new approach to learning, utilising the Universal Design for Learning
framework, will re-engage Sky in her learning and support her to improve her behaviour and
school relationships.
11
Appendix – Selected Resources used in lessons
Emu Passport:
12
13
References
Arnett, J. (2014). Adolescence and Emerging Adulthood. Pearson Education Limited. Harlow,
Essex, United Kingdom.
CAST (2018). Universal Design for Learning Guidelines version 2.2. Retrieved from
http://udlguidelines.cast.org
Comber, B. (2016). Poverty, place and pedagogy in education: research stories from front-
line workers. Australian Educational Researcher, 43, 393–417. DOI 10.1007/s13384-
016-0212-9
Courey, S., Tappe, P., Siker, J., & LePage, P. (2013). Improved Lesson Planning With Universal
Design for Learning (UDL). Teacher Education and Special Education, 36(1), 7–27.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0888406412446178
Crosby, S., Day, A., Somers, C. & Baroni, B. (2018) Avoiding school suspension: Assessment
of a trauma-informed intervention with court involved, female students. Preventing
School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 62(3), 229-237, DOI:
10.1080/1045988X.2018.1431873
14
Dalton, E., Lyner-Cleophas, M., Ferguson, B. & McKenzie, J. (2019). Inclusion, Universal
Design and Universal Design for Learning in Higher Education: South Africa and the
United States. African Journal of Disability, 8.
doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.uws.edu.au/10.4102/ajod.v8i0.519
De Nobile, J., Lyons, G., & Arthur-Kelly, M. (2017). Positive learning environments: Creating
and maintaining productive classrooms. South Melbourne, Australia. Cengage
Learning
Fan, X. & Chen, M. (2001). Parental Involvement and Students’ Academic Achievement: A
Meta-Analysis. Educational Psychology Review, 13(1), 1-22. DOI: 1040-
726X/01/0300-0001$19.50/0
Foreman, P. & Arthur-Kelly, M. (2014) Inclusion in Action. Cengage Learning Australia, South
Melbourne Australia.
Glass, D., Meyer, A. & Rose, D. (2013). Universal Design for Learning and the Arts. Harvard
Educational Review, 83(1), 98-119, 266, 270, 272. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.uws.edu.au/
login?url=https://search-proquest-
com.ezproxy.uws.edu.au/docview/1326778711?accountid=36155
Gordon, D., Meyer, A. & Rose, D. (2014) Universal Design for Learning: Theory and Practice.
CAST Professional Publishing, Wakefield MA, USA. Retrieved from:
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib
/uwsau/detail.action?docID=4603679.
Hashey, A. I., & Stahl, S. (2014). Making Online Learning Accessible for Students with
Disabilities. Teaching Exceptional Children, 46(5), 70–78.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0040059914528329
Havighurst, S., Kehoe, C. & Harley, A. (2015). Tuning in to teens: Improving parental
responses to anger and reducing youth externalizing behavior problems. Journal of
Adolescence, 42, 148-158. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.adolescence.2015.04.005
15
Jensen, E. (2013). How Poverty Affects Classroom Engagement, Educational Leadership,
70(8), 24-30. Retrieved from: http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-
leadership/may13/vol70/num08/How-Poverty-Affects-Classroom-Engagement.aspx
Kieran, L., & Anderson, C. (2019). Connecting Universal Design for Learning With Culturally
Responsive Teaching. Education and Urban Society, 51(9), 1202–1216.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124518785012
Legault, L., Green-Demers, I. & Pelletier, L. (2006) Why Do High School Students Lack
Motivation in the Classroom? Toward an Understanding of Academic Amotivation
and the Role of Social Support. Journal of Educational Psychology, 98(3), 567–582
DOI: 10.1037/0022-0663.98.3.567
Lieberman, L. (2017) The Need for Universal Design for Learning, Journal of Physical
Education, Recreation & Dance, 88(3), 5-7, DOI: 10.1080/07303084.2016.1271257
Masters, G. (2016). Five challenges in Australian school education. Policy Insights, (5).
Australian Council for Educational Research. Retrieved from:
https://research.acer.edu.au/policyinsights/5/
NSW Department of Education and Communities. (2015) The Wellbeing Framework For
Schools. Retrieved from: https://education.nsw.gov.au/student-wellbeing/whole-
school-approach/wellbeing-framework-for-schools
16
NSW Education Standards Authority (2019 [2015]). Geography K-10 Syllabus. Sydney,
Australia.
Nisbet, J. (2019). Universal Design for Learning: Principles and Examples for 2019. The
Prodigy Blog. Retrieved from: https://www.prodigygame.com/blog/universal-design-
for-learning/
Osher, D., Bear, G., Sprague, J. & Doyle, W. (2010). How Can We Improve School Discipline?
Rapp, W. (2014). Universal Design for Learning in Action: 100 Ways to Teach All Learners.
Brookes Publishing. Baltimore, USA.
Romer, D., Betancourt, L.M., Brodsky, N.L., Giannetta, J.M., Yang, W. and Hurt, H. (2011),
Does adolescent risk taking imply weak executive function? A prospective study of
relations between working memory performance, impulsivity, and risk taking in early
adolescence. Developmental Science, 14, 1119-1133. doi:10.1111/j.1467-
7687.2011.01061.x
Silk, J., Steinberg, L. & Sheffield Morris, A. (2003). Adolescents' Emotion Regulation in Daily
Life: Links to Depressive Symptoms and Problem Behavior. Child Development, 74(6),
1869-1880. DOI: https://www.jstor.org/stable/3696309
Wakefield, M. (2020). Key questions to consider when planning lessons. In Universal design
for learning: theory and practice. Eds: Meyer, A., Rose, D.H., & Gordon, D. Retrieved
from http://www.cast.org/our-work/publications/2020/udl-guidelines-key-
questions-planning-lessons.html
Wilson, K., Boyd, C., Chen, L. & Jamal, S. (2011). Improving student performance in a first-
year geography course: Examining the importance of computer-assisted formative
assessment, Computers & Education, 57, 1493–1500.
doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2011.02.011
17